Podcast Search

The Talk Show

453: ‘What’s in Louie’s Wallet’, With Louie Mantia

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00I think you and I, Louie, even had a back and forth around the holidays last year that maybe I'd have you back on.

0:00:06You were on last summer.

0:00:07We talked about liquid glass writ large.

0:00:10And then I think we thought about having you on around the holidays just to have a holiday party on the show for Alan Dye leaving Apple.

0:00:17I like the idea of like just a little party for that.

0:00:21Yeah.

0:00:21We were all celebrating a little bit, I think.

0:00:23Yeah.

0:00:24Yeah.

0:00:24We had maybe I should have had an episode.

0:00:27I could have had five or six people on and we could have danced on his Apple employee badge grave.

0:00:32Wow.

0:00:33Do you think actually, yeah, do you think he had to turn in his badge?

0:00:37Oh, yeah, of course.

0:00:38Right.

0:00:38I guess.

0:00:39I mean, I don't know.

0:00:40I've never.

0:00:40I don't know.

0:00:41Some people keep their badges afterwards, but I kind of wonder now that I think about it, even a bad spirit.

0:00:45I wonder if they.

0:00:46Yeah.

0:00:46Now that I think about it, maybe he didn't.

0:00:48I don't know.

0:00:48I don't know.

0:00:49I am curious at his level what it was like because it is so I honestly, it really is.

0:00:59I can't think of the precedent for anybody else at that level leaving the company.

0:01:06The last time I think it happened was Scott Forstall, but that was 100 percent different circumstances.

0:01:12Forstall didn't leave for a competitor.

0:01:14He was more or less asked to resign or back.

0:01:16Well, you know, I mean, I'm sure I'm sure.

0:01:18But I mean, and this is a long time ago when I left.

0:01:21But when I left, I thought I was doing the right thing.

0:01:24I'm like putting in my two weeks and they're like, all right, well, you're done today.

0:01:26You know, it's like you don't get to stick around, you know.

0:01:29Yeah.

0:01:29Hold on a second.

0:01:30Let's come back to that.

0:01:31I actually have a question for you.

0:01:32We'll get back to that.

0:01:33But with Alan Dye leaving for Meta and obviously negotiating his deal with Meta in secret, right,

0:01:41behind the rest of Apple's executive team's back.

0:01:44And then I think even Apple's public statement, they didn't quite come out and say, I mean,

0:01:52of course not, right?

0:01:53The Apple PR statement isn't going to say, well, this really blindsided us, you know?

0:01:58Yes, yes.

0:01:59They're not going to admit to anything like that.

0:02:01Right, but I do think, though, that they, in PR speak, made it clear what the circumstances

0:02:08were, right?

0:02:09There was no, we wish Alan well and thank him for his time.

0:02:12No, there was definitely.

0:02:13Yeah.

0:02:13Well, yeah.

0:02:14When other executives have moved on, they usually just like say, I mean, I don't know.

0:02:19Was Alan Dye an executive?

0:02:20I forget what his actual position was.

0:02:21Oh, he was on, he was, I don't think he was on the main bios page.

0:02:26Yeah.

0:02:27He wasn't on like the leadership page.

0:02:28Or is he though?

0:02:29Because I think Stephen LeMay is now.

0:02:30He might've been.

0:02:32He actually, actually, if we go back.

0:02:34Yeah.

0:02:35Actually, I can, I can recall a headshot of him.

0:02:37So maybe.

0:02:37Oh yeah.

0:02:38He definitely had the headshot.

0:02:39And so he, whatever his title.

0:02:41Yeah, he was on there.

0:02:41Right.

0:02:42Okay.

0:02:42He was never a senior vice president, but he was a vice president of design.

0:02:48Yeah.

0:02:49And it's just, it just doesn't happen.

0:02:52Honestly, forced all leaving was one thing and that doesn't happen.

0:02:56That hasn't happened since either.

0:02:58Not like that.

0:02:59That an executive has been forced out and nobody leaves Apple for competitors.

0:03:04It just hasn't happened for so long.

0:03:07It is so, it's just, it remains curious to me.

0:03:10I wonder what the, what the upswing on that was for him.

0:03:14I mean, besides the money, which obviously is, has got to be it.

0:03:17Or maybe he was just really tired of Apple's shit.

0:03:19I have no idea what motivated it.

0:03:21Yeah.

0:03:21I don't know.

0:03:22There's.

0:03:22We kind of have no story there at all, right?

0:03:25No, not really.

0:03:27Other than the fact.

0:03:28So one theory that has been expressed, and again, there would be a, you know, very limited

0:03:35number of people who know this, but one theory that people have that I don't think is ridiculous

0:03:42is that the wheels were already in motion around a year ago.

0:03:48Let's say.

0:03:49I forget when German first started reporting that John Ternus was the intended successor

0:03:55to Tim Cook without a timeline for Tim Cook actually stepping down.

0:03:59But going backwards from when it was publicly announced, clearly by the end of last year,

0:04:04this was known inside, at least Tim Cook and John Ternus knew and the board.

0:04:09And perhaps I would guess most of the executive team, like the Monday morning group that I

0:04:18believe still holds to the same tradition that Steve Jobs held, where every Monday morning

0:04:23there's like the senior leaders of the company have a all morning.

0:04:26A senior staff meeting.

0:04:28Where they just go over everything that the company's doing, like what happened last week

0:04:33and what's happening this week and what's coming up.

0:04:36I would guess all of those people knew by last year that Tim Cook intended to step down and

0:04:41that the Ternus was going to be named the successor.

0:04:44And anyway, there's some speculation that maybe Ternus didn't like Alan Dye and Dye knew it

0:04:51and got out while the getting was good.

0:04:53You know, like, ooh, it sounds to me like this is bad for me.

0:04:57I mean, if you want to leave on your own terms versus someone else's terms.

0:05:00I mean, if you don't want to be kicked out like a Scott Forrest All situation, I guess

0:05:03you, I guess you bounce first.

0:05:05Right.

0:05:06And it's again, singularly through Mark Gurman, at least publicly, but I've heard this as well

0:05:12too, that Ternus, Jobs obviously was intimately comfortable and spent enormous amounts of

0:05:19time with the design team, software and hardware, that he was in, he wanted to be shown prototypes

0:05:26of software.

0:05:27You know this, right?

0:05:28Icons.

0:05:29Yeah.

0:05:29Every, and he could freaking, we've got, we've got 60 minutes with Steve Jobs and he wants

0:05:36to talk about one button, right?

0:05:38Yeah.

0:05:38I mean, he was, he was definitely involved in a way that I don't think Tim Cook ever was.

0:05:43Right.

0:05:43Right.

0:05:43I mean, I don't think that was, that was never Tim's job.

0:05:45Right.

0:05:46And when it comes to hardware, he, Jobs would go to the hardware design team on a regular,

0:05:52on the reg, whether it was scheduled or unscheduled.

0:05:55I got the feeling it was both, that there'd be scheduled meetings and sometimes Jobs would

0:05:58be like, you know what?

0:05:59I'm going to go down there and see what they're up to.

0:06:01That is the case.

0:06:02Yeah.

0:06:03And by all accounts, Tim Cook has done the opposite and has just sort of stayed away.

0:06:08And I think to his credit that he doesn't consider himself a designer or an arbiter of design

0:06:13taste.

0:06:14And so he's not going to impose himself on the team, but that apparently John Ternus is

0:06:19more interested and has been spending time with the design team and stuff like that.

0:06:24So it's possible.

0:06:24And so that is basically one theory that Alan Dye got wind that Ternus was going to be the

0:06:31new boss and that he and Ternus didn't get along.

0:06:34Maybe, maybe they just actually flat out did not get along over the years and had arguments

0:06:38in the past.

0:06:38And he's like, well, if he's going to be the new CEO, maybe I had to get out.

0:06:41The only, I don't know anything about that.

0:06:44And I think the people who do, it's a very small circle and nobody, including Gurman, has

0:06:49reported on any kind of backstory like that, any kind of personality clash or difference in

0:06:55taste.

0:06:55But if that were the case, then I don't think Apple would have been as apparently blindsided

0:07:01as they were by his departure.

0:07:02Right.

0:07:03So I kind of think, no, is it possible though that just, I mean, I think I said this like

0:07:08a year ago, but he's, he's, he never really seemed like he was a computer person, right?

0:07:14Alan Dye was not really like, he was not like a person that ever seemed to have a love for

0:07:19it or, or anything of the sort.

0:07:22So it kind of makes me wonder if just, I mean, not that Meta is any less of a technology company

0:07:27or anything, but I mean, I wonder if he's just more willing to bounce than other people

0:07:31that, I mean, they're, you know, like the replacement, like Steve LeMay, it's hard to

0:07:35call him a replacement because he's been there for so much longer, but you know what I mean?

0:07:39But, but I mean, that guy clearly loves these things, right?

0:07:43That guy clearly loves these devices.

0:07:45So I, that, that's a person that's like a, an Apple lifer, right?

0:07:48Whereas like Alan Dye never seemed like he was going to be an Apple lifer.

0:07:51Anyway, he was going to leave at some point, right?

0:07:54I, I would think so.

0:07:56He, he came from a background in branding and the fashion world that he worked.

0:08:02He was like design director at Levi's.

0:08:03Which by the way, I mean, has anyone ever unearthed any of his portfolio before?

0:08:08Do we actually have any evidence like visually of like anything he's done?

0:08:12I'm so, I'm, I remain so curious about this and I've still never seen like any of his work

0:08:17prior to Apple.

0:08:17I've never seen anything like that either.

0:08:21And in hindsight, sort of suspect, I mean, he was obviously good at something.

0:08:27And I think that I've expressed this opinion before.

0:08:30Again, this is my own, I could be way off and I could be selling his own design, either talent

0:08:35directly with his hands on the mouse or his talent as an art director, which is a very different

0:08:41thing, right?

0:08:42You can be a fantastic Stanley Kubrick love to hold the camera and actually,

0:08:47was his own cinematographer for an off most of the shots in most of his movies.

0:08:51To my knowledge, Steven Spielberg isn't.

0:08:54And Steven Spielberg is never the guy holding the camera, except back in 1972.

0:08:59That's fine, right?

0:09:01Steven Spielberg is.

0:09:03Oh, it's totally true.

0:09:04Fantastic.

0:09:05Arguably the best director.

0:09:06You know, if you drew the card to defend somebody as the best director of movies ever and you got

0:09:12the card that said Steven Spielberg, you'd be like, oh, I might win.

0:09:15I can make this argument.

0:09:16You don't have to have your hand on the mouse to be a good designer.

0:09:20No, I know.

0:09:20And this is, I think this is true with Steve Jobs and his roles too, right?

0:09:23I mean, like Steve, like we were just talking about like how Steve and Tim differed in their

0:09:27involvement on, on these sort of teams.

0:09:30I think Steve probably didn't have like his hand on the mouse designing anything, but I

0:09:34think that he was way more interested in being involved in that process than Tim was.

0:09:39And I think that there is varying levels of involvement that can make you good for a particular

0:09:43job.

0:09:44But I mean, and, and I guess Alan Dye had some, I don't, I have no idea the kind of guy that

0:09:50he is, but people did follow him, right?

0:09:52He left and like some of his, some of the team came with.

0:09:55Yeah.

0:09:56There was, I don't know all the names and I don't want to throw people under the bus,

0:09:59but there was, for example, a guy named Billy Sorrentino who was sort of, I think his Dye's

0:10:04right-hand man.

0:10:05And it still might be at now that they've both gone to meta.

0:10:08Billy Sorrentino had been at Wired magazine for a while.

0:10:12And I know that there were, I know that there were people at Apple who called Dye and his

0:10:18team fucking quote unquote fucking magazine designers.

0:10:22Cause it wasn't just about Billy Sorrentino and I heard when all this went down, I heard

0:10:27some, Hey, don't use this because it might be able to come back to me about stories from

0:10:34people who, who were at Wired and worked under Billy Sorrentino and the stories were not good

0:10:39to say the least, but there's a talent like there, but nobody's, I know what you're getting

0:10:45at though, Louie.

0:10:45It's like, nobody's ever said, Hey, when Alan Dye was at Levi's, that's when they had

0:10:50these ads.

0:10:51And here's like a bunch of ads.

0:10:53Here's a bunch of ads from, I don't know what year it was.

0:10:55Let's say 2006.

0:10:56And it's like, Oh, those are, and you're like, damn, those were fucking good ads.

0:11:01Right?

0:11:01Yeah.

0:11:02This is not like, I don't know if you know this, but there was like this revelation I

0:11:06had like years ago where I was like, Oh, Scott Forsall used to work on like Microsoft

0:11:11office stuff.

0:11:12Oh, that's interesting.

0:11:12Wait, Scott Forsall invented word art.

0:11:15There was like that sort of thing.

0:11:16I was like, that blew my mind, but I don't think there's a moment like that for Alan Dye.

0:11:20I can't, I don't think there's anything I can point to and be like, Oh, he was, Oh, there

0:11:23was that team that he was involved.

0:11:24I don't have, I got enough.

0:11:25I've never seen anything that it was like, had his name attached to it.

0:11:29That was like, Oh, that was great.

0:11:31I can see how this happened.

0:11:32My opinion.

0:11:33Director or like the person, the designer involved.

0:11:36Right.

0:11:36I've never seen it.

0:11:37My impression is that he just has an extraordinary talent for this sounds pejorative, but it is

0:11:45a skill for sucking up to the people.

0:11:49You're talking politics.

0:11:50Yeah.

0:11:50The politics.

0:11:51And I think he, and it's, yeah.

0:11:53And I think he was exceedingly good at the internal politics at Apple.

0:11:57And I've heard that specifically from the sort of people, like when he left and I reported,

0:12:03I, you know, couldn't use anybody's names, but talking about people who were still there,

0:12:07who it was like, they were saying that it's like a party here that he and the people he,

0:12:12who left are gone.

0:12:15that it was the word politics came up all the time and that they really were frustrated.

0:12:21And there was the sense that no, and you know this, when you work at a big company, including

0:12:25Apple, and even when they're, the company is known for shipping good design, that ideally

0:12:32when there's an argument about which way to go a or B, a or B and you say B and they're

0:12:38like, well, what about B or C B or C and you at Apple, the process is you keep going for

0:12:44letters and letters and you get back to double A versus double B, double A versus double B.

0:12:48And, but you, ideally, you feel like if you lost an argument, you lost two, even if it wasn't

0:12:54your preferred choice, another good design.

0:12:56You don't feel like you lost two.

0:12:58Yeah, because you went down that path.

0:13:00I mean, right, right.

0:13:01I mean, yeah, because you're comparing against good versus better, right?

0:13:05I mean, that's the idea.

0:13:07And more and more under Alan Dye, especially in the years after Johnny Ive left, where I really

0:13:13feel like a lot of the UI stuff went off the rails.

0:13:15It just felt like bad UI, just bad designs were going, getting pushed through.

0:13:21And there, I know for a fact that the company is just chock-a-block full of really good, talented

0:13:28designers, always has been.

0:13:29Many of them have been there for a long time.

0:13:31Not just Stephen LeMay, but lots of other people who know Stephen LeMay very well.

0:13:35And that they just kept seeing really bad ideas.

0:13:38And, you know, you work at Apple, you keep your mouth shut.

0:13:40That's part of the culture of working at Apple.

0:13:42I think it's, yeah, well, because I think it is a politics game.

0:13:45I think there's some people that may be like Alan Dye.

0:13:47I don't know.

0:13:48But they're like, it isn't just the best design wins.

0:13:52It is the best design with the best presentation wins, right?

0:13:55There has to be a good argument for it.

0:13:56I've seen people argue like bad design, like shipping bad design, but their arguments for

0:14:03it sound so plausible and good that it can go through anyway.

0:14:08And so I think it's very possible that maybe what happened in general, like last year with

0:14:13the 26th release was just like that, right?

0:14:16Maybe even to some extent, like iOS 7, maybe there was like some aspect of these kinds of

0:14:21shifts that we've seen Apple go in where it's like they were presented with, oh, this is better

0:14:26because X, Y, or Z.

0:14:27And at no point there was anyone properly defending the other side.

0:14:31It's very possible that that happened.

0:14:33Yeah.

0:14:33And I think, so I think the backstory, I'd love to hear more about it, but I do think it's

0:14:38very complex.

0:14:38And I think a lot of it involves, it is complex when the talented political operators are winning.

0:14:47It's very difficult for the talented designers who don't feel they're very good or, and never

0:14:54felt the need to develop political skills because they felt like, hey, I'll just do good design

0:14:58work.

0:14:59Yeah.

0:14:59Or they just don't want to.

0:15:00They have no aspirations to be, I mean, there's tons of great designers I knew at Apple that

0:15:04had no, they had no managerial aspirations.

0:15:08They didn't want to do that sort of stuff.

0:15:10They wanted to be the person that was like hands-on actually designing it.

0:15:13Right.

0:15:13Yeah.

0:15:13Yeah.

0:15:14And I do.

0:15:16I mean, the only way that works, the only way that works is if you have, if you work for

0:15:19a manager, a director that you believe in, that you trust.

0:15:22Right.

0:15:22But at the moment when you start working for someone whose vision you don't trust.

0:15:26And I would, I would say like, that is the fundamental thing that was like so good about

0:15:30the Steve Jobs era in particular was that I think there was like this, it was kind of this

0:15:35unwritten thing that everyone at Apple was there because they trusted Steve's vision.

0:15:39Ultimately, that's why you're there and everyone knew that when they were producing something

0:15:43that they were producing it for his taste, that he was like batting pretty high averages.

0:15:48Right.

0:15:49And we were like willing to like seed our own personal feelings for ultimately what he was

0:15:54pitching and that because he had the vision for it.

0:15:57And I think that post Steve Jobs, I think it's really hard for anyone at Apple.

0:16:00Obviously it's not Tim and that's fine.

0:16:02And maybe it's Ternis, I don't know, but was it Alan Dye that ever had the vision that

0:16:07was anything like Steve?

0:16:08I don't mean that it was the same vision.

0:16:09I mean, did he have a vision that other employees could believe in?

0:16:12I think the answer is no.

0:16:13I think the complete opposite.

0:16:15And I, and I think that is the fundamental problem is that Apple doesn't have the vision

0:16:19to have like all of the people that were under there working toward the common goal they believe

0:16:24in.

0:16:24Right.

0:16:24And I, cause I think that's what makes it a good product.

0:16:26Yeah.

0:16:27Somebody sent me a note, somebody who's ex Apple now for a couple of years and just basically

0:16:33saying and, and offered to give me a fuller description, which I, I have not taken them

0:16:39up on yet, but basically that it, and we'll get to this too, but in my recent writings about

0:16:46Apple and ads and calling back to the Steve Jobs era and a couple of very pointed quotes

0:16:52from Steve Jobs about like when they introduced iCloud email and it's here, it's free email and

0:16:58you can even get it on the web and there's no ads.

0:17:01And his explanation was because we, we use this stuff too.

0:17:04And we put ourselves in the customer's shoes and we're like, how many ads do we want in

0:17:08our email?

0:17:08And the answer is none.

0:17:09Yeah.

0:17:10It was the same as the sticker argument that you, you know, you posted about the other

0:17:13day.

0:17:13It's like, we, we want to open a box and we want to look at our computer and not have

0:17:16stickers on it.

0:17:16Right.

0:17:16I mean, it makes sense.

0:17:17Right.

0:17:17And somebody, this person said that under Steve, Apple was very, this is going to sound like

0:17:24this duh, John, but very top down, right?

0:17:27Steve thought of things or wanted things.

0:17:31And then the company coming down from him.

0:17:34There was direction from the top.

0:17:36And that under Tim, it is very bottom up where at the bottom level ideas can surface and then

0:17:44they rise through.

0:17:46And it's still not a very hierarchical company.

0:17:50It may not be any more hierarchical than it was under Steve Jobs, that there's not a lot

0:17:55of layers of management above the actual engineers writing code and designers deciding on pixels

0:18:02between them and Tim Cook, but it's a more of a bottom up surfacing.

0:18:07And I think liquid glass kind of the whole thing or all of the UI stuff, even before last

0:18:13year in liquid glass, a lot of the UI stuff just sort of came from the bottom up where it's

0:18:18like somebody's like, well, what if we have a thing like this?

0:18:20And what if we have a thing like this?

0:18:22And even some of the, I think some of the really cool UI stuff that shipped while Alan

0:18:28Dye was there, I think the dynamic island is so fun and cool.

0:18:33And what, it's just a way to make not just lemonade out of lemons, but really delicious

0:18:41lemonade.

0:18:42Yeah, it doesn't, it doesn't seem like that came from a direction from above.

0:18:46It seemed like that thing, and I could be totally wrong here, but like, it seemed like

0:18:49that thing came from like someone experimenting and finding something that was kind of cool.

0:18:55And it wasn't like, hey, we need to solve this problem.

0:18:57Maybe we should do this.

0:18:58And then had a team of people working for it.

0:19:00I don't think it came from it.

0:19:02I mean, like, I just conjecture.

0:19:03I have no idea.

0:19:04No, no, it was really was like one guy on the design team.

0:19:08And he's on Twitter and a little public, I forget his name, I could look it up for the

0:19:13show notes.

0:19:13I don't, I'm always a little, even when somebody is a little public about their work at Apple

0:19:18on Twitter and stuff, I'm still a little, always a little gun shy to draw attention to

0:19:22them.

0:19:23But just, it was somebody who on the software design team who came up with this.

0:19:27And when the, I forget which iPhone was the first one that instead of having a notch anchored

0:19:33to the top, had the, the pill underneath, which is when they introduced somewhere around 13

0:19:41or so.

0:19:41Yeah.

0:19:42Or like the iPhone 14 or 15 or whatever.

0:19:44But anyway, after that iPhone event in September, I was out there for the event in the Steve Jobs

0:19:50theater to watch the introduction.

0:19:52And then you roll out, you turn around and you go back and the back behind the Steve Jobs

0:19:58theater and underneath the atrium is the hands-on area.

0:20:01And I often don't really, or usually my go-to way of dealing with that incredible scrum.

0:20:10And it is a scrum and it is just so many more people than are really fit in there.

0:20:15But everybody's hectic and people are on deadlines and I'm not.

0:20:19When people are trying to get video footage and photographs and some of these people are

0:20:23trying to get entire videos out the door ASAP because they want to beat the competition.

0:20:29And I often spend that time, I do want to see some things with my eyes, but then I also

0:20:35know that I'm going to get briefings, smaller briefings later and it'll be a long day for

0:20:40me and I'll get to see these things on my own soon enough anyway.

0:20:43Right.

0:20:44You're not pressed to post your reels on Instagram or your shorts on YouTube or anything.

0:20:49So why don't I take the opportunity to look around and see which people are there?

0:20:54And I often run it, either Apple people or other people in the media.

0:20:58And I ran into, at that event, Alan Dye and his team.

0:21:03And I've met Alan Dye officially through PR briefings in the years before that.

0:21:09He knew who I was, I knew who he is, and he was there with other people from his team,

0:21:13including the guy who made the Dynamic Island.

0:21:15And he was just like, hey, what do you think?

0:21:17And I was like, I love the Dynamic Island.

0:21:19And he introduced me to the guy.

0:21:20He's like, him.

0:21:21And very generous, Alan Dye was at this moment.

0:21:24And was effusive with praise for the guy on his team who he thought should get the credit

0:21:29for it.

0:21:29It was all great.

0:21:30And I got to say to the whole team how much I loved it and that I thought it was so fun

0:21:34and clever and useful.

0:21:36All the things.

0:21:37Looks good.

0:21:38Looks useful.

0:21:39Makes great lemonade out of the lemon of having a black pill-shaped thing in the middle of the

0:21:45screen.

0:21:45It's like, all of a sudden, it seems like there's a reason for it.

0:21:48I love it.

0:21:48It was all good.

0:21:49So in terms of, hey, another thing people have said to me, if Alan Dye is so bad, how in

0:21:54the world did he stay there so long?

0:21:55He wasn't all bad, right?

0:21:57I mean, and he could get along and he was personable.

0:21:59My personal interactions with him were always pleasant.

0:22:02He's extraordinarily tall, I will say.

0:22:05Yeah.

0:22:08He's six foot six.

0:22:09That is tall.

0:22:11I kind of imagine that there is an element, I mean, I'm not going to say that he is a complete

0:22:19fraud or anything.

0:22:19I'm sure he is good at some things too, right?

0:22:21I'll say it.

0:22:22He is sort of a fraud.

0:22:23But I mean, it's just, but I think what we're talking about is that maybe he's good

0:22:28at politics or maybe he's good at the management of a team.

0:22:31I don't know.

0:22:32And I don't know how much of like the direction was him, like the visual direction of it.

0:22:36I don't really know.

0:22:37And I don't think any of us really know.

0:22:39But is it, I guess, at that moment when he introduced you to the designer for Dynamic

0:22:46Island, I feel so bad that we don't know his name, but he is, I guess, relinquishing some

0:22:52of that praise from coming from him.

0:22:55He didn't invent it.

0:22:56He was actively admitting that it was like someone else that was doing this.

0:22:59I'm kind of curious.

0:23:00I don't really know of that happening, by the way, any other time in Apple history where there

0:23:05was like someone higher up pointed to a specific designer.

0:23:08I mean, I know that that was like in the Steve Jobs theater and it wasn't public, but the person

0:23:12you're talking about, I know, I know they're on Twitter.

0:23:14I know what you're talking about, but I always, I don't know.

0:23:17I guess I'm curious just like why, why in that moment did, did someone get the spotlight?

0:23:22Because you know how it is.

0:23:23Apple is notoriously, we don't talk about who makes stuff here for various reasons, including

0:23:28poaching or whatever.

0:23:29All right.

0:23:30So I looked it up.

0:23:30It is Chan Karuna Mooney, who I hope I'm pronouncing his surname correctly, but I've met Chan and

0:23:38Chan, his first name is, I'm quite certain, Chan Karuna Mooney.

0:23:42He's still there.

0:23:43And, and he chimed in.

0:23:45Last time I saw him chime in was after this entire kerfluffle.

0:23:49He chimed in just to say good things that he looked forward to.

0:23:53I think it's his third most recent tweet, December 5th, 2020.

0:23:57Oh no, the other ones are, this is actually his most recent tweet.

0:23:59He just piped in on December 5th, just to say, after this kerfluffle broke and Stephen

0:24:06LeMay was named the leader of software design the next day, he just wrote, Steve's been my

0:24:12manager for my entire 15 year career so far at Apple, and I could not be more excited for

0:24:17this new era.

0:24:18So no bad words about Alan Dye, of course, but a full throated public support for Steve

0:24:24LeMay's promotion.

0:24:25Oh, well wishes for Alan Dye either.

0:24:27Yeah, sounds like none, there were none.

0:24:30Right, right.

0:24:31I will put a link to that tweet in the show notes, and then anybody can look up Chan's

0:24:37Twitter feed, which he hasn't tweeted since.

0:24:39So it just shows how, how important it was for him, he felt, to publicly support that Steve

0:24:46LeMay's promotion.

0:24:47Yeah, I think, I do think too, there is a culture of, they always say with the Beatles, when you're

0:24:56like, hey, who wrote, all the songs are Lennon-McCartney, credit.

0:24:59Right.

0:24:59But you're like, well, which one really wrote it?

0:25:01And you're like, well, who sang it, right?

0:25:03And the way I heard somebody say it once was, whoever read it, spit it, for the Beatles.

0:25:08And there is a culture of that at Apple with keynotes, where the people you see on screen

0:25:15now, but are on stage in old days, were usually the people who were most responsible for the

0:25:20thing that they were introducing.

0:25:22Yeah, more recently, I think that is true.

0:25:23Yeah.

0:25:24I think it's always been true.

0:25:25I just think that there's more people now.

0:25:27And in the old days, when it was a stage show, it would just be Steve, right?

0:25:31It's all ultimately.

0:25:32Right.

0:25:32Well, yeah.

0:25:33Or it'd be Steve or another SVP or something.

0:25:35And the SVP might have been the SVP responsible, but they were like, maybe so high up that they

0:25:40weren't necessarily directly responsible.

0:25:42Right.

0:25:42And in the video era, I think it is, to me, it's one of the nicer parts of the mixed bag

0:25:49of stage live versus tape.

0:25:52Yes, yeah, totally.

0:25:52I mean, the stage stuff where they have like, or not the video stuff you're talking about,

0:25:57when they have like the one person that introduces features or stuff about the platform, yes,

0:26:01I think that person is generally like, but when you see the individual WWDC videos, I think

0:26:06that person is super the person that worked on it.

0:26:09You know what I mean?

0:26:10Like the person's introducing a very specific thing, how to implement it in your app.

0:26:14I'm like, that's the person.

0:26:15Right.

0:26:15Yeah, I think that's true.

0:26:17And I think the fact that Alan Dye got to introduce Liquid Glass, you know, that he was

0:26:22responsible for it, but it's not Liquid Glass specifically.

0:26:25I mean, I don't want to rehash the whole thing, but it was Liquid Glass on the Mac that

0:26:31is so bad.

0:26:33And I actually, honestly, I didn't even hesitate last year to upgrade my phone to iOS 26.

0:26:40By this time last year, by the end of July, I was already full time on iOS 26.

0:26:44And I actually like it better overall.

0:26:47But I always keep another phone on the old OS, like a year old phone on the old OS, so

0:26:53I can compare differences.

0:26:54And when I would go back to the iOS 18, I'd be like, I don't like this.

0:26:59Yeah, well, there is some part of that that I think is true, that the sooner you adopt

0:27:03any of these things, the more you become accustomed to them.

0:27:06And the more, I don't know, the less horribly repulsive it is.

0:27:09I mean, do you have 27 installed on any of your devices?

0:27:12I do.

0:27:13I've had 27 on my phone since June.

0:27:16You're living with it.

0:27:17You mean like your day-to-day phone, your normal phone?

0:27:19Yeah.

0:27:20Yeah, I mean, same.

0:27:21I got it on both my Mac and my phone.

0:27:23And sometimes I feel like when people talk about 27, I'm curious, or 26 for that matter,

0:27:30like critically, I wonder if they were living on it or if they were just seeing it in screenshots.

0:27:34I'm not trying to defend anything, right?

0:27:36I just like there is a difference between when you live on it and when you're looking at it

0:27:40like statically.

0:27:41Oh, I totally agree.

0:27:42You really do.

0:27:43And it's just, I don't know, if you are making a movie, you've kind of got to watch the dailies

0:27:48to see what it looks like on the screen.

0:27:52And it's like, well, what does this look like in the video or the film that we captured of

0:27:57these actors in the setting?

0:27:58Don't just look at a couple of still images and don't just read the screenplay.

0:28:03It's, you got to see the actual footage to feel, oh, this actually, I was just watching

0:28:10from the side of the stage and it looked good to me, but I look at this footage and boy,

0:28:15this seems really flat.

0:28:16It does not seem emotionally resonating at all.

0:28:18I think seeing things in context, like properly, is like critically important.

0:28:22And I don't know, if you're going to talk about this stuff, anyone, like I think you deserve,

0:28:27you owe it to yourself to make sure that you're actually using it.

0:28:31But I got to tell you, John, that note you said, like that you keep an old phone around

0:28:35so you can see like previous OS stuff.

0:28:36I went, I went like rummaging through like all my old phones to try to find an old device

0:28:40that was like running iOS six still just like double check on some things I was thinking.

0:28:45And I got no complaints about iOS six.

0:28:48I really don't.

0:28:48I think that it was like pretty great.

0:28:50But there is this one thing that is really funny when you start using these old devices.

0:28:54It's, oh my God, John, animations were so much slower.

0:28:57Everything feels so much slower, even if it's not computationally working harder, if it's

0:29:03just, or it's like straining the thing, it's like everything really does feel slower.

0:29:06And I feel, I keep feeling like there was some part of like older iOS stuff that was almost

0:29:12hindered by the fact that it was slower, not that it like looked a certain way.

0:29:16Every year we kind of get like smoother animations and everything.

0:29:19And like, yeah, we get a lot of smoother stuff with liquid glass, but I can't help think what

0:29:24if that was like just a richer design?

0:29:25Is the richer design what killed it?

0:29:27Or is the fact that we kept getting more smooth things like, I don't know.

0:29:32I mean, before we leave the topic of the leadership change of this, I'll just say, because I do,

0:29:38I don't know that if I've, how publicly I've made this, but I do not hold it against Alan

0:29:43Dye or the people who left with him that their background isn't in UI design or human computer

0:29:50interaction or something like that.

0:29:51I'm a big believer in being multidisciplinary.

0:29:55I'm a big believer in being a polymath and that you could spend your life designing stuff

0:30:02for printed magazines, but have had a lifelong interest in computer user interface.

0:30:09Because if you did spend your life, pretty much if you spend your life, there are very few

0:30:15designers left who aren't using computers to do their design work.

0:30:19Right.

0:30:19What field?

0:30:20I don't know.

0:30:21I mean, maybe there's still some old architects who are using paper and pencil and stuff.

0:30:26But for the most part, pretty much if you're a writer, you're using a computer now.

0:30:30You're at least using it.

0:30:31Yeah.

0:30:32Right.

0:30:32But there aren't many writers left on typewriters.

0:30:34So you could have informed, you could be a magazine designer who has spent your life really,

0:30:41really interested.

0:30:42In theory, I agree with you.

0:30:42Right?

0:30:43But you still have to be able to prove it.

0:30:45In theory.

0:30:45In theory.

0:30:45Yes.

0:30:46Yeah.

0:30:46Well, I mean, the thing you're saying is just you believe that someone could have like this

0:30:49lifelong interest in this thing.

0:30:51And yes, I mean, that's true.

0:30:52But an interest in the thing and like a deeper knowledge of the thing are entirely different.

0:30:56I mean, I don't care if someone hasn't done UI design their whole life.

0:31:00I mean, I, I mean, I got into that when I was a kid, but I'm not deeply, I was not designing

0:31:06old, old stuff.

0:31:07Right.

0:31:08So, but I, but I know about it.

0:31:10I mean, I, I never used system seven or anything, but that doesn't mean that I, I'm not aware

0:31:15of these things.

0:31:16So I, I guess, I don't know.

0:31:17You're a child, Louie.

0:31:19Just a child.

0:31:20I know.

0:31:20But I just, but I, I, I really feel that, that, that's, that some people, maybe Ellen

0:31:26and I, I don't know, but, but some people that were designing stuff for modern, modern

0:31:30Mac OS, we're not familiar with, it's not the mistakes, but the lessons we learned along

0:31:36the way.

0:31:36We learned so much over the years and to see some of those lessons kind of be undone and

0:31:41then have to be relearned again.

0:31:43I'm just like, what are we doing here?

0:31:44I think developers feel it every year.

0:31:46Right.

0:31:46So, I mean, there is this kind of, I don't know.

0:31:48I just want to, I do think what you say is theoretically true, but I think that there

0:31:52must be like a deep, not just, but it has to be, there has to be a greater knowledge

0:31:57here.

0:31:57Yeah.

0:31:58Yeah.

0:31:58He, he, if, if some, or somebody else, somebody else who'd spent their life designing for print

0:32:05magazines or designing motion graphics for movies and TV shows and became, had a lifelong interest

0:32:12in software user interface design and interviewed for a high level position at a company like

0:32:17Apple or somebody else who's a leader in the field.

0:32:19You would still expect that person to be able to come in and wow you with, wow, that's

0:32:24amazing that you spent your life doing motion graphics for motion pictures.

0:32:27And you know, all of this stuff about user interface design, and you've got all this really

0:32:31informed opinions about it.

0:32:33You can't just come in and be like, yeah, I've always wanted to do it.

0:32:36Okay.

0:32:36Yeah.

0:32:37So this is kind of like a new designer syndrome thing.

0:32:39And I, there's part of it that I'm kind of curious about, like Alan Dye's earlier years

0:32:43at Apple, not as like package designers stuff, but like more like UI designer, like when he

0:32:47was thrust into that world, like where maybe he was interested in, or maybe he was handpicked

0:32:51to do this for some reason we're not aware of.

0:32:53But like there, there is this new designer problem where like you, you kind of want to come in and

0:32:58you want to fuck everything up.

0:32:59And I don't, I don't mean it like in a negative way necessarily.

0:33:01I just mean like, you want to redo everything you want to, you want to redesign something

0:33:05you want to touch something up.

0:33:06You want to like, it's not like a leave your mark thing.

0:33:08It's like, you just want to like have your perspective, like reflected in the thing that

0:33:12you're working on.

0:33:12I mean, like I did this at Apple, I did this at square.

0:33:15I am not immune to this.

0:33:16I do this myself, but I think there's like this thing that I've, I've learned.

0:33:21And I think other designers have learned, which is when that feeling arises, like it's good

0:33:24to like, just sit with it for a little bit before you go and start changing everything.

0:33:30And I'm, I'm kind of curious if Alan Dye had any period of time where that happened

0:33:34for him, where it was just like, all right, before I go and change anything, maybe I should

0:33:37like first listen to people.

0:33:39I don't think so.

0:33:39Try to understand this.

0:33:40Right.

0:33:41I know.

0:33:41I know.

0:33:41And that's kind of like the crux of it for me, I think.

0:33:44I don't think there was like a deep, long interest.

0:33:46Maybe there was a long interest of it, but there wasn't a deep knowledge.

0:33:49There wasn't necessarily like a lot of advisement.

0:33:51He wasn't listening to advisors or something like, or, or like he didn't try to understand

0:33:55it before he went and did stuff.

0:33:57You know what I mean?

0:33:58So, so then we ended up making mistakes all over again.

0:34:01Yeah.

0:34:01The, the best, one of the best little back and forth is a direct comparison, which I think

0:34:07is totally fair.

0:34:08And then a little bit of inside information that I got from somebody who used to work

0:34:13at Apple until a couple of years ago.

0:34:14And this person didn't say to me, I left because I couldn't get along with Alan Dye and hated

0:34:18his team, but frustration with them and their inability to, to just, just not that they disagreed,

0:34:27but it's like, you're talking on different levels, but I compared Alan Dye's introduction of liquid

0:34:32glass on camera for the keynote last year.

0:34:36And the words he used with Steve jobs, his introduction of Aqua back in 2001 or whatever year it was at

0:34:44Mac world.

0:34:45And the difference in the language they used was just so dramatic that the Alan Dye thing

0:34:50was like, Oh, just a bunch of bullshit.

0:34:52Just our, our ideas of openness and, and it expresses the integrity of the materials and

0:34:59all this bullshit.

0:35:00And Steve jobs spoke about Aqua in two ways.

0:35:03One, he literally said, I, it looks so cool.

0:35:06You want to lick it or something like that, which was true that it looked like candy, but

0:35:10then he also on stage at Mac world expo used the phrase, the key window, which is like UI design

0:35:18lingo for the, the window that has input focus, like which window when you hit command W closes,

0:35:24that's the key window.

0:35:26And that he was talking about the fact that the Aqua controls made emphasize the difference

0:35:32between a foreground window and the front most window, like the window, the buttons and the

0:35:37controls were colorful in the front most window and they went clear in the background.

0:35:41And he used the phrase key window.

0:35:43And this friend of mine who left Apple was said something to the effect of the, when I posted

0:35:48that was like, I can't put, you know, I'm not surprised, but I, it really struck me that

0:35:52to hear Steve jobs, use a phrase that I use in my work all the time, like key window.

0:35:57And when I would talk to Alan die and his team, I would purposefully avoid using words like that

0:36:04because I learned very quickly that when I did, I could see their eyes glaze over like a blah,

0:36:09blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.

0:36:10It's like the old far side cartoon about what does a dog hear?

0:36:14And it's like, you know, this is like a dog owner who's like, oh, I got, I can't believe

0:36:18you pissed all over the carpet.

0:36:20I guess the far side didn't use pissed.

0:36:21Rufus, you're a bad dog.

0:36:24Don't ever do that again, Rufus.

0:36:25And what does the dog actually hear?

0:36:27Blah, blah, blah, Rufus, blah, blah, blah, blah, Rufus.

0:36:30That's it.

0:36:30Right.

0:36:30That's what Alan die and his team heard when people were talking about key windows and

0:36:34controls that don't show which window has the input focus.

0:36:37And that's how we wound up with things like split screen and the iPad where you couldn't

0:36:42tell which side of the goddamn iPad had input focus.

0:36:46Yes.

0:36:47You could not tell.

0:36:47I know we talked about that.

0:36:50I think at the time you and I, where it's like, there was like, like older black and white

0:36:55only versions of Mac OS could differentiate between the window based on like the window

0:36:59texture.

0:36:59And it was like, we only had two colors and we were able to differentiate, but yeah, side

0:37:04by side iPad, it was hard to tell what was in focus.

0:37:07But even if you look at the original, like 2001, like Cheetah, you know, original release

0:37:12of like OS 10, like it wasn't just the Aqua controls, the like the red, yellow, green that

0:37:16were like dimensional and colorful.

0:37:18You know, remember like the actual title bar was opaque, but for the non active windows,

0:37:24they were like slightly translucent.

0:37:26So you could see the desktop picture, sorry, desktop picture behind it.

0:37:30Yeah.

0:37:30Yeah.

0:37:30So like there, there was like, there was a multiple levels of reinforcement there about

0:37:34what it was.

0:37:35And not to mention, of course, like the menu bar said the app's name that was currently

0:37:39in focus.

0:37:40Right.

0:37:40Right.

0:37:41So like when, when iPad that didn't have like necessarily menu bar stuff, I mean, like, I

0:37:46think that like, that really hurt it.

0:37:47Yeah.

0:37:48There were multiple visual cues and they all, it wasn't like one thing or the other.

0:37:54It wasn't just the app's name in the menu bar and it wasn't just the red, yellow, and

0:37:59green buttons.

0:37:59And it wasn't just whether the stripes were more prominent than in the foreground or background.

0:38:05It was all of those things together.

0:38:08And it created a windowing system where there was this emphasis and the people involved with

0:38:14it all the way up to Steve Jobs knew and embraced the lingo about things like the key

0:38:19window and, and stuff like that.

0:38:21And clearly that didn't just get lost.

0:38:25It got blown away at some point, even though the institutional knowledge wasn't gone.

0:38:30And that there are people like Steve LeMay who clearly know all of these things and had

0:38:35been losing battles here and there.

0:38:39Not all of them.

0:38:39Right.

0:38:40Which is why nothing was the worst, you know, and arguably, and it's one of the worst things

0:38:46that one of the, you know, like how did this happen is that I still think you could say,

0:38:51certainly with iOS on the phone, that I would argue that not just that I prefer it personally,

0:38:58but that I could really make the case that it is just a better designed design system than Android

0:39:03or any of the custom Android flavors that Samsung and other high level makers make for the phone.

0:39:10And I would definitely argue even goddamn Tahoe, macOS 26 Tahoe, the worst user interface on any macOS version ever,

0:39:19ever, all the way back to system one in 1984 is a better user interface than any version of Microsoft Windows ever.

0:39:28Now there are aspects of versions of Windows that I would say, oh, that part of Windows like 95 or NT or something like that,

0:39:36like the clarity of the front most, the key window or something like that.

0:39:41Look at that.

0:39:41Even goddamn Windows 95 had better blank than Tahoe.

0:39:46Right, right.

0:39:47But overall as a design system, I would still take macOS Tahoe without question.

0:39:51I'm recording to you right now using a machine here in my little podcast basement that's running Tahoe.

0:39:57I'm looking at it and there are things that make me queasy, but it's still better.

0:40:01It's not horrible.

0:40:01And that's the thing that's the worst.

0:40:03That's where I think, how did this happen above Alan Dye's head?

0:40:07Where I think that people like Jaws and Federighi and whoever else is up at that level,

0:40:13all the way up to Tim Cook could honestly look around and say, well, our UI design is still better than any other company out there.

0:40:20So what's the frigging problem?

0:40:22But the margin is different, I think.

0:40:24I think that at the, yeah, how do I say this?

0:40:28It always felt like years and years ago, it always kind of felt to me that the gap between something like macOS and Windows was pretty significant.

0:40:37And I think it has narrowed.

0:40:39I think it has narrowed.

0:40:40I mean, I still think that what you're saying is true, that modern macOS, I would still take it over like other platforms.

0:40:46Modern iOS, I would take it over other platforms.

0:40:48But I think that the gap has narrowed.

0:40:51And it used to be Apple was so ahead in a bunch of these areas, specifically like UI design.

0:40:56And I think it slid partially because maybe someone didn't quite understand all the lessons that were already learned.

0:41:04Yeah.

0:41:05Oh, I think that's the fundamental crux of it.

0:41:08Let's come back to it.

0:41:09Let me take a break here and thank our first sponsor of the show.

0:41:12And it is our good friends at Notion.

0:41:15With the recent launch of custom agents, Notion became the collaborative AI workspace where teams and agents work side by side.

0:41:24And now their new developer platform is turning that workspace into infrastructure that developers can build on.

0:41:32The developer platform includes new primitives that allow teams to sync any data source into Notion,

0:41:39build any tool for your Notion agents and orchestrate any agent in Notion.

0:41:44One of them is the command line interface tool.

0:41:47I love that it's 2026 and I get to talk about like leading consumer big name apps.

0:41:58And the big new selling point is that they have a command line tool because of the integration with AI.

0:42:03But it's useful to nerdy people who listen to the talk show in all sorts of ways.

0:42:08But Notion now has a command line tool.

0:42:10They gave it a cool name, which I really like, NTN, Notion.

0:42:14Just take out all the vowels.

0:42:15But it's useful in all sorts of ways.

0:42:18You don't even have to use AI to make good use of it because it can query your whole Notion database and get things out of it.

0:42:24So you can integrate everything in Notion with anything else that is scriptable through the command line.

0:42:30But obviously, the reason they made it was for the integration with AI agents.

0:42:34And you can do things you can have with workers.

0:42:37You can have Notion-hosted sandboxes that run custom code, that run database syncs, agent tools, and webhook triggers.

0:42:45And it's safe and protected because it's running in Notion's runtime instead of standing it up on your own.

0:42:51There's all sorts of other things you can do.

0:42:53But it's not just like, hey, all right, now we have a command line tool and you're on your own.

0:42:58Go figure it out on your own.

0:42:59Notion's whole system of agents and workers is integrated in the system.

0:43:05And it's got some guardrails and some guided steps, if it were, to help you through creating this and working with it in a way that you feel like, oh, yeah, I can figure out how to make this happen.

0:43:17And it's really, really easy to use.

0:43:19The command line interface authenticates in one line and the workers deploy without provisioning infrastructure.

0:43:27So with a cloud-based Xero infrastructure path, you can just write your code to do the things that you want and deploy and you're done.

0:43:36And you can use this to integrate and get into your Notion database or your team's Notion database data from any source, anything you can get into JSON.

0:43:47And then you can pipe that through the command line interface tool and set up a worker to do this automatically and just sort of automatically have an agent in the background that populates some kind of changing data source and have it integrated into your Notion database.

0:44:01Learn more about Notion's developer platform today at Notion.com slash talk show.

0:44:09That's all lowercase letters.

0:44:11They want me to emphasize the lowercase need, Notion.com slash talk show to try Notion's developer platform today.

0:44:19And when you use that link, you're supporting our show, Notion.com slash talk show.

0:44:25What did I say we were going to come back to?

0:44:28Now I've forgotten.

0:44:29Oh, I know what it is.

0:44:31But forgetting the things that have happened before.

0:44:34Yes.

0:44:36I think one of the other ways that Apple lost its way in user interface design and the reason why it bottomed out, I really do believe this.

0:44:48I'm excited.

0:44:49We'll get to the optimism with Golden Gate.

0:44:51I think we'll turn this conversation into that.

0:44:54But the reason I think Mac OS 26 Tahoe is the bottoming out isn't just – and I thought this at first too.

0:45:02Well, of course iPhone comes first because iPhone's the biggest, most popular – it's the biggest platform in every way.

0:45:09It's got the most users.

0:45:10It makes the most money for the company.

0:45:13Everybody – of course iPhone comes first.

0:45:17There's no argument about it.

0:45:18And maybe 10 years ago, like certainly when iOS 7 happened, it was iPhone first and then iPad the year later and then macOS got an iOS 7 flavored UI design like two years later.

0:45:31It would be like let's do iPhone first and then we'll do other devices after that.

0:45:37And Apple has gotten under Craig Federighi to a, hey, we do all of these things at the same time now.

0:45:45And that's the whole point of the changing the version numbers to the year is every year there's going to be a new version of each operating system and we're going to do things like this.

0:45:55And I think it was easy to think, well, something as major as the rethinking of the whole user interface as liquid glass, nobody could do it across all of the platforms in one fell swoop, even Apple at their best.

0:46:13But if they're going to say even the Mac gets an update with this look the same year as iOS, of course it's kind of half-assed because they put all of the effort into the iPhone first and then the iPad kind of inherits that by being just a big iPhone in a lot of ways second.

0:46:32And the Mac is more complicated and didn't get as much attention and so of course it's worse.

0:46:39And I think there's some truth to that.

0:46:41Yeah, there was like a little backseat situation at the time.

0:46:44It was just like Mac OS did take the design backseat.

0:46:48Yeah, but I think a bigger, and it's not unrelated, but I think a bigger reason is that it doesn't really matter that the iPhone is more popular and makes more money, even though it does from Apple's, there's a, certainly from Tim Cook's perspective, that matters and it gets more attention.

0:47:07But even if the Mac were the bigger business and the Mac generated more money and the iPhone in some hypothetical alternate world where human nature would have to be different, but where people are less interested in a cell phone than they are in laptops and laptops are the more popular thing.

0:47:27God, that would kind of would, and I feel like that species would be a better species than us.

0:47:34We're obviously weak, we're weak that we can't resist these goddamn computers in our pockets.

0:47:40But the real difference is, and the more important difference, is that a desktop graphical user interface like Mac OS or Windows is more complex and complicated than a phone interface where it's one screen at a time and you don't have overlapping windows.

0:47:58There is no, so distinctions like key windows get lost on iOS because there is only one key window at a time.

0:48:05And then you start thinking like, yeah, but then there's like popovers and popovers to me on iOS have often looked bad, right?

0:48:12And it's because it's not, especially in the iOS 7 later era, in the old days, like iOS 6, if there was a layering, it looked pretty cool and you could tell where the layers are.

0:48:24And maybe there was never any confusion, but there have been years where like the way a popover looks is so white on a white background.

0:48:32Yeah, it was a huge contrast problem.

0:48:34We didn't have enough shadow.

0:48:36Well, because we weren't using all the tools we had accessible to us, right?

0:48:39You're talking about like that pre iOS 7 situation.

0:48:41There was like this kind of translucent border.

0:48:44There was like a heavier shadow.

0:48:46There was like a blue like header for the popover and it had a little gloss treatment.

0:48:50There was like this clearly defined spot that was the popover, whereas I think all of the stuff in iOS 7 and then it kind of like, I mean, it got better over time, but it started with iOS 7 for it's like all of that stuff had significantly less contrast that the text was way too light, right?

0:49:06They went so far in one direction that they reduced all of the distinction by reducing all of the tools we had available to us to differentiate.

0:49:16Yep, I totally agree.

0:49:18And so when they lost their way even with iOS, with layering and texture and using tools, just basic design concepts like borders and textures and the fake 3D depth and transparency and shadow to emphasize the difference in layering as opposed to de-emphasize it.

0:49:40If that happened even on the phone, of course, the Mac suffered even more where there are more layers because there's windows that overlap with each other and in each window is all the layered complexity of a single screen on iOS, right?

0:49:57Right, right.

0:49:58And so it's just more complicated.

0:50:00You do more things.

0:50:01You're capable of more things.

0:50:02I mean, there are people who I know and it's such a different – whatever their communication and computing needs are so different than mine, I appreciate it and I think it really speaks to the utility of an iPhone.

0:50:19But I can't imagine being the sort of person for whom the iPhone is my main computer for work.

0:50:24No, I can't imagine that either.

0:50:26I mean, I've got to be honest with you, John.

0:50:28Like I opened up Numbers yesterday on my phone just like maybe for the first time in my life.

0:50:34Like I opened it up and I was like – and I opened like a spreadsheet that's stored in iCloud, right?

0:50:39So like it was great because I can use the same spreadsheet that I've already been working with on my Mac and I went to check on some data and I actually went to go check – like to edit it and it took me an embarrassing amount of time just to find a button that would actually let me edit the table.

0:50:55Because on Mac OS, right, you click on the table and you're able to edit it immediately by interacting with it.

0:51:02But on the phone, I think they're doing like this thing where they're trying to prevent you from accidentally editing the table just by like scrolling or something.

0:51:09I don't know because your touch interface – like we have hover and click on Mac OS, but we don't really have a hover state like on iOS.

0:51:17So there's no way to know if I'm intentionally interacting to edit or whatever.

0:51:20Anyway, there's an edit button, an explicit edit button like on iOS.

0:51:24And it's interesting is like kind of like the way that you're saying like Mac OS is like inherently more complicated.

0:51:30There's a lot of like formatting stuff that I'm sure is possible on iOS in some way like with Numbers.

0:51:36But like it's very clear that like I could not make that spreadsheet on my iOS-like device.

0:51:42There's no way I would want to make it.

0:51:43I could edit it, sure.

0:51:45But like I can't imagine it being like my primary device for work.

0:51:48I don't know how people could do that.

0:51:50Yeah.

0:51:50Well, if all you really do is talk on the phone and send text messages.

0:51:55Send emails.

0:51:55Yeah.

0:51:56Then it could – yeah, sure.

0:51:59I'm sure that's a lot of executives' lives like across different companies, right?

0:52:04It's like that's the kind of work that they do is like that, yeah.

0:52:07Yeah.

0:52:08People who travel a lot.

0:52:09I know like real estate agent type people who are like showing buildings and they're just on their feet and they're talking to people and sending text messages and they're taking pictures.

0:52:18And they can do all this stuff on their phone and it's kind of amazing that there are so many people who really can but I can't.

0:52:24It feels to me like I'm trying to see the whole world by looking through a drinking straw.

0:52:30Like it's – yeah, no, it is like that.

0:52:32I mean like macOS has so much more complexity for all of its apps but it also has apps that iOS could never have anyway.

0:52:39So if you need that app, as many times as Adobe has tried to put Photoshop on an iPad, I'm like, I can't take that seriously.

0:52:45I can't do that.

0:52:47I'm sorry.

0:52:47A spreadsheet is such an interesting example too because there are things – there are things you don't even think about using a spreadsheet.

0:52:54And I'm not like a huge spreadsheet jockey but I have a couple of spreadsheets I use all the time.

0:52:59I keep the Daring Fireballs weekly sponsorships in a numbers spreadsheet and have for, I don't know, like 15, 20 years.

0:53:07I don't know, a long time.

0:53:08And every once in a while I'll be like out of the house and I need to check on who is next week's sponsor.

0:53:13And I'll open up that spreadsheet in numbers on the phone and I'm like scroll, scroll, scroll, scroll.

0:53:20And it's like, oh, my God, I can't believe – I'm glad I can access it on the phone but I would never, ever use it as my main interface.

0:53:26But think about things you can do in a spreadsheet that all spreadsheets back to the dawn of time.

0:53:31You can like click the mouse on a cell and drag down and now you're selecting multiple cells.

0:53:37Or you can like double click in a cell and now you're selecting text in that cell.

0:53:43Well, and the screen real estate limits you too, right?

0:53:46Sorry.

0:53:48Go ahead.

0:53:48Yeah.

0:53:48Well, let's say I spelled Louie wrong.

0:53:50I spelled it L-E-W-I-E.

0:53:52And I'm like, oh, that's not how Louie –

0:53:54That's obviously the wrong way to spell it.

0:53:55Right.

0:53:56That's the wrong way to spell it.

0:53:57Or if you spelled John without the H.

0:54:00And it's in a spreadsheet cell.

0:54:03How do you correct that?

0:54:05How do you not – I don't want to select multiple cells.

0:54:07I want to drag to select just the vowels in the middle of Louie.

0:54:11Yeah.

0:54:12We've kind of like – yeah.

0:54:13On iOS, like there's like a flattened level of like kind of interactions that you're allowed to have.

0:54:18Whereas like you're more versatile when you're on the Mac.

0:54:20You've got like all your fingers on keyboards.

0:54:22You've got like your mouse.

0:54:23You've got like multiple types of clicking.

0:54:24You've got hovering, right?

0:54:26You've got all of these available input methods.

0:54:28But like on the phone, you really just have your finger like –

0:54:31Right.

0:54:31But if I misspelled your first name in a cell in a spreadsheet, I wouldn't even have to think about how to select the text to change it.

0:54:39I would – by the time I even thought about it, the cursor would be there.

0:54:43You mean on macOS.

0:54:43On macOS.

0:54:45And I'd already be doing it.

0:54:46Yeah, of course.

0:54:46On the phone, I would feel like now I have to somehow perform surgery with my hands in mittens.

0:54:54Yeah, you're trying to be super careful.

0:54:57You're trying to make sure you click in the cell.

0:54:58Then you have to – then you're trying to select the text and you don't want to scroll the view while you're selecting the text.

0:55:03I mean, yeah, no.

0:55:04And I might literally think, why don't I just make a note to myself to fix this when I get back to my Mac?

0:55:09Yeah, right, right, right.

0:55:09Just send a message to yourself to fix it.

0:55:11But where I'm going with this is when the iPhone was created, it was created by Forstall – at least on the software side.

0:55:19The whole team was a bunch of people who'd come from macOS 10.

0:55:23I don't think there was a single person involved who didn't come from macOS 10.

0:55:29Whether they were designers or just engineers, they'd all been working on the Mac.

0:55:34But they had the good taste to not do – I know this sounds like a joke, but if you never saw it.

0:55:41But the original version of Windows – I think they called it Windows Phone.

0:55:45I don't know.

0:55:46But the – or Mobile Windows – Windows Mobile.

0:55:50Windows Mobile.

0:55:50It had a start menu just like Windows 95.

0:55:55And it was like they just ported Windows 95 to fit on a two-inch phone screen.

0:56:00Well, the same was true – the same was true with like – do you remember like Windows tablet PCs like way back in the day, like 2001, 2002, like era sort of stuff?

0:56:08It was the same way that like tablet PCs like were running Windows.

0:56:12They were running like proper Windows like with – like you had like a stylus to go around and click on the start button that was there.

0:56:19And it was the same thing.

0:56:20It's like they could only think about adapting what they had.

0:56:22And yeah, iPhone never did that, did they?

0:56:24Right.

0:56:24And they sort of – instead of starting with all of Mac OS X and sort of taking things out here and there, clearly what they did to create the original iPhone software interface is start with a blank slate and start adding stuff back.

0:56:39Well, we obviously need text controls.

0:56:42We obviously need buttons, right?

0:56:44We need tap buttons.

0:56:45How are we going to do this?

0:56:47And they built it back up and they ended up shipping a thing that didn't even have cut, copy, and paste until version 3, right?

0:56:55There was no way to copy text for two years of the iPhone.

0:56:59And trust me, I was like trying to do some blogging and stuff from my iPhone at the time.

0:57:04And I was like, oh.

0:57:05And I knew they were going to get to it sooner rather than later.

0:57:07I mean it was –

0:57:08Of course.

0:57:08But it's one thing or the other.

0:57:10And I didn't get super mad about it because if you added all of Mac OS X to the iPhone from the start and just did the least amount possible to make it fit on the three-and-a-half-inch screen and try to make some of the controls big enough to be tappable, it would have been horrible and fiddly.

0:57:27And it would not have been the hit that it was.

0:57:30But the iOS interface was always designed, though, by people who had this background in the more complex system, Mac OS X.

0:57:39Right, right.

0:57:40They were distilling it down to essentials.

0:57:43But I think actually Steve outlined the rough strategy for that like pretty – in the iPhone introduction video, I probably don't remember exactly what he said.

0:57:53But it was like – you remember the way he introduced it was he said, iPhone runs OS X.

0:57:59And at the time, I think every nerd was like thinking that was like a crazy, fun, wild thing to think about because their brains were probably thinking, oh my god, there's like a dock, there's a desktop.

0:58:07And it's like that's not what happened.

0:58:08I mean there is a dock.

0:58:09But it's not the same kind of dock, right?

0:58:11It doesn't have the same rules.

0:58:12Is there a hidden way I can run real Photoshop?

0:58:15Right, right.

0:58:16But what Steve meant and what he clarified a little bit later, right, was like that Mac OS X had all the technologies they needed, right?

0:58:26And so it was more about it runs that same – it forked to the OS in a way that we could use all the same technologies we already built to stuff we had under the hood.

0:58:36But we could build new UI explicitly for the phone rather than start with the interface.

0:58:42And it was – but it was all made by people who knew those principles.

0:58:47And they knew everything that was missing, everything that was imprecise about iOS, they were well aware of and did it deliberately.

0:58:57And what happened as the iPhone became preeminent and mobile computing became preeminent and these post-iOS 7 – whatever you think of iOS 7, it clearly obliterated the entire – not just the way phones' interfaces were designed.

0:59:19All software was designed.

0:59:21And websites, everything.

0:59:23I mean, we're still – I mean, how many years ago was that?

0:59:27It's at least 15 years, 11 years, 12 – I don't know.

0:59:31But all these years later, everything still – basically, everything from websites to desktop apps to Windows to the way even Linux and stuff looks is all downwind of the radical change Johnny Ive and his team posed on iOS 7.

0:59:48But something happened in the intervening years, though, where that became the primary way that some designers looked at software, was starting with the phone and mobile.

1:00:00And I think that's true of Alan Dye and his team.

1:00:03And then that's all – they had only this limited, primitive, conceptual attitude towards user interface design and then tried to bring that to the Mac, which demands precision and all of these other concepts.

1:00:20And –

1:00:22This is exemplified perfectly in system preferences, right?

1:00:24System settings, sorry.

1:00:25Yeah.

1:00:25Like, it's clearly like this thing that was iOS first and then when they moved it – when they moved that design over to Mac OS, it was like absolutely not any better, right?

1:00:35It was like in every measurable way, it was like harder to use.

1:00:40And it's the list on the left isn't even alphabetical.

1:00:44There's no way to – so all the spatial awareness that you had done like on a 2D axis, like X and Y, like that you could understand.

1:00:52You had like bigger icons, you could dive into a category and kind of forget the rest, right?

1:00:56Suddenly you were like seeing like this source list that was way too long.

1:01:00I mean the system settings source list is like obnoxiously long and there's categories within categories and like it's kind of – I think there's a reason that like the search field has become like the main criticism for that, right?

1:01:12It's like if it doesn't work, then actually you fundamentally failed because people rely on that search field because the source list is obnoxiously like hard to manage, right?

1:01:21But that is like a perfect example I think of the iOS first thinking that came over to Mac OS and it's like, man, you don't get it.

1:01:28Mac OS actually has to be different in this way.

1:01:30Like I understand like a 2D axis, like just only up and down makes sense like on iPhone because we don't want to have – we already have a grid of icons that's on the home screen, right?

1:01:40So we don't need another grid of icons.

1:01:41It's obviously easier to implement, right?

1:01:43It's simpler.

1:01:43Yeah.

1:01:44But it's so much has been lost.

1:01:46I have not revisited that.

1:01:48I've been meaning to the whole system settings thing.

1:01:51And I don't think – again, it is sort of emblematic of it.

1:01:54The new system settings in Mac OS, which we've been with for at least four or five years now I think, it's not a disaster, but it's worse in every way than what came before it.

1:02:04And one of the things that's lost is the fact that in the old system preferences, each pref panel really was technically – they were apps.

1:02:14They were just apps that instead of having the .app bundle name, they had the –

1:02:18Yeah, pref pane or whatever.

1:02:19Pref pane.

1:02:19And you could – if I walked over to your desk and you happened to be in system preferences, as soon as I got to your desk, I'd know, oh, you're in the Wi-Fi preference panel.

1:02:32Why?

1:02:32What's wrong with the Wi-Fi?

1:02:33Because it looked – it had a look that was like, oh, that's the Wi-Fi panel.

1:02:37You're in the mouse or trackpad control panel, and it just had a look that was as distinctive as like a really good personal app.

1:02:47You knew which pref panel you're in.

1:02:48Whereas all of the pref panels now just look like a series of white rows with the green – or the blue, I guess it is, the blue switch on the right side.

1:02:58And it's like you're in the severance office, and it's – of course, every hallway looks the same, and every door looks the same, and every room looks the same.

1:03:10So what room are you in?

1:03:11I don't know.

1:03:12They all look the frigging same.

1:03:13They're all – how am I supposed to know?

1:03:15This is all an effort in general to kind of make everything look the same intentionally for familiarity.

1:03:22But what it does is it robs every app, every pref painter, whatever, of its distinction to know one thing from the other.

1:03:29I mean, we don't need to talk about GarageBand, but GarageBand on macOS having – you know what I mean?

1:03:33Like the little wood panel on the side and the darker interface and even Aperture from days of your Aperture was like a fully graphite interface, not just the controls or whatever, not just the window controls, but like the toolbar.

1:03:44Everything was like a graphite interface.

1:03:45But both of these apps could exist simultaneously, and you understood they were on the same platform because they shared some sensibility to them, but they looked entirely different and made you feel like you were just operating in a different tool.

1:03:55You are, right?

1:03:57But if every tool starts to look the same, then I guess even though things feel more familiar, I actually understand less, if that makes sense.

1:04:06I don't really know the difference between one thing and another thing like when they all look the same, right?

1:04:11But to go back to the thing you said, you said like maybe Alan Dye and his team like were designing like iOS first, and so when they were bringing those things over to macOS, I will say there was like this early moment, I think it was like with the original iPad.

1:04:25I was working at the Icon Factory at the time, and we were designing Twitterific, and one of the things that was totally eye-opening was seeing how we needed to make an iPhone version, an iPad version, and a macOS version of the same app.

1:04:39I mean, it was like the first time we had like truly universal app across multiple platforms, right?

1:04:43I will say that the iPhone existing in its way, like being like mostly a hierarchical list of panes you navigate from, super helped us design what should have been the macOS app.

1:04:57And I don't think it's impossible to go that route where you start with iPhone or at least factor it into your equation, but when macOS apps are so complex, and we're talking about apps like Final Cut, I mean, come on, no one's going to ever do that on a phone, even if they had it, right?

1:05:12It's like, that's not a task for a phone.

1:05:14I don't know why there's iMovie for iPhone.

1:05:16I'm sorry, I don't understand.

1:05:17Actually, that's four.

1:05:18But for certain complicated tasks, right, where there is a need to have a bunch of UI, I actually, like I said this last year too, I think there's a need to see UI and have it be clear and distinctive for what it is.

1:05:30So I think that starting with iOS in that way, I think can really be like detrimental to your app, right?

1:05:37It can solve hierarchical problems.

1:05:40It can help you solve flow problems.

1:05:42But like, I think these are different platforms with different needs for user interfaces, and you can't treat one like it can be just simply ported to the other.

1:05:51Yeah, so that brings us to this year, and I am in such a better mood about the state of Apple's UI this year than I was a year ago when you were on the show, Louis, because I do think it's almost every single UI change in iOS 27, and especially macOS 27 Golden Gate, compared to the 26 versions, is for the better.

1:06:16And is it enough?

1:06:18Does it address all of my complaints?

1:06:20Definitely not, because it's starting, especially on the Mac, starting from such a problematic place.

1:06:26But every change is for the better, and it's specifically with just basic—

1:06:31I mean, the bar was so low, John.

1:06:33Yeah, but it's not just like style.

1:06:36It is—and it's about the fundamental principles of design.

1:06:42We got our sidebar fixed.

1:06:43Yeah.

1:06:44Right?

1:06:45I mean, that is a fundamental thing that I think was, like, absolutely a misinterpretation of that UI element.

1:06:51I don't think it should have ever been floating.

1:06:53It should have never been, like, this separate thing.

1:06:55It makes more sense if it's fully, like, fully edge-to-edge there, right?

1:07:00Yeah.

1:07:00But, yeah.

1:07:03I mean, we get those things, and that's not necessarily just a style thing.

1:07:06I think that's a clarity thing.

1:07:07I think that's a UI thing.

1:07:09Are you—nobody else—I mentioned it a couple weeks ago on Daring Fireball, and it's one of those things that was so low on my list for Tahoe.

1:07:15because I had other complaints that I didn't, but I'm still—I'm bummed that one thing Golden Gate doesn't address is that when you click on a menu in the Mac menu bar, like the view menu or the edit menu, it still is like a capsule-shaped highlight of the menu name, like file or edit, and not a round rect.

1:07:37It just doesn't—and the way that it's disconnected from the menu that shows up beneath it, it makes no sense to me.

1:07:44The menu name should definitely be connected physically to the menu because that's—

1:07:51You know, I'm glad you bring that up because there was something else I noticed on iOS.

1:07:55I don't know.

1:07:55You said—I think you have iOS 27 installed.

1:07:58But if you go to the keyboard and you tap a key on the keyboard, you no longer get that fly-out shape from the—what is that?

1:08:05That was like this—those options came from that key.

1:08:10There was a relationship to it, right?

1:08:12And it's like now it's just like—it's like a rounded rectangle with a rounded rectangle on top of it.

1:08:17It's the same thing you're describing with Mac menu bar, right?

1:08:19Where you're saying there's a relationship from this thing to this thing, but actually the relationship, as indicated, is not there anymore like it used to be.

1:08:26I've been meaning to write about that one, too.

1:08:28It is one of the small things I don't like about iOS 27.

1:08:31It's crazy.

1:08:32It's—so you hold down like the S—you tap S and you get a big S above it, which tells you—and it's told you since the original iPhone, hey, that's the key that the keyboard thinks your fat finger pressed.

1:08:46And you can kind of—it's a really clever solution to the problem of your finger covers the button so you can't see the highlight of the actual button.

1:08:56And in—for some reason that I cannot freaking explain, in iOS 27, those—it's still—you still get a pop-up that tells you—the keyboard thinks you tapped S, but the pop-up isn't connected to the actual S that your fat finger is on.

1:09:11Why? I don't know.

1:09:13Why? I have no idea.

1:09:14No, it drives me absolutely up a wall.

1:09:17And I remember when I posted about it, there was somebody that was like, oh, it's just a beta.

1:09:21I was like, you know what? No, I'm sorry.

1:09:22They've not fixed this in four versions.

1:09:24This is not—this was a deliberate choice.

1:09:26They made this choice, and they're standing by it, and I think it's absolutely wrong.

1:09:31There's just—there's hundreds of little things like that in macOS that go back to the dawn of macOS that please parts of my brain to no end because they are connected or that they make sense in the world of macOS.

1:09:45That you click the file menu, and a menu drops down underneath the word file, and the word file gets a highlight because you've clicked it, and it's showing the file menu, and then the menu shows underneath.

1:09:59And that menu that shows underneath should be connected to the word file in the menu in the way that, like, when you have a folder, a physical manila paper folder with tabs, the tab is connected to the folder.

1:10:13It doesn't just magically float above it.

1:10:16I got another one for you, John.

1:10:18You wouldn't want it to.

1:10:18All right.

1:10:19You're going to make me mad.

1:10:20Now, when you do a contextual click, like, you right-click on something, like, almost anything in the OS, you get, like, this Ask Siri that's above, like, the first item now, right?

1:10:29Ah, yeah.

1:10:31It drives me absolutely nuts.

1:10:33But the thing that's crazy to me is that, like, forever, forever, John, like, whenever you, like, right-clicked, assuming there was enough space, the first item would be directly to the bottom right of where your cursor currently is.

1:10:45But now, and that still is true because, like, for example, if you, like, click on a file, like, open is still the first thing, and it's in that same position that it always was.

1:10:52But now the menu is actually taller to compensate for the fact that they're trying to say, like, ah, we know that your muscle memory is still here, but the muscle memory is a little bit fucked because they actually increase the size of it.

1:11:05So your brain is trying to understand that now this weird Ask Siri thing that maybe you will never even ever use in your life is suddenly, like, this little tumor that's growing on the top of, like, the menu command.

1:11:17It's absolutely maddening, man.

1:11:18Yeah, I have noticed that.

1:11:21And when I pointed it out to a friend weeks ago, I wondered if that was one of the things they might reconsider over the summer, and it doesn't really seem like they've reconsidered anything over the summer.

1:11:31I mean, they've fixed bugs and stuff, but, yeah, you described it very well.

1:11:35Where in macOS 27 now, when you control-click on anything in the OS, and there's now this permanent Ask Siri sort of, it's not a menu item, it's like a text field that you can type, you click on it.

1:11:52It's kind of like a text field.

1:11:54Right.

1:11:54And the idea is, if you click on a file, like, it just says myfile.txt, and you control-click on it and ask Siri, it's like you're providing the file as input to Siri.

1:12:10You could say to Siri, summarize this text file.

1:12:14And it knows which text file because you control-clicked on it, and then you type that command.

1:12:20And they did.

1:12:22It's sort of like what used to be position one, if that's the top item.

1:12:27And presumably, and it's true and most good, it's part of the principles of user interface design.

1:12:33But the most important items are often at the top.

1:12:36That's why undo is always at the top of the edit menu, right?

1:12:40It's undo and redo and then cut, copy, paste, because those are, like, the most common edit menu commands.

1:12:46So they're at the top.

1:12:47So top, the first position is still the first position, and it's still the command that used to be there in 26 and macOS 18 or 15 or whatever.

1:12:56It's like they added a new position zero for Siri.

1:13:00That's exactly, that's the correct way of describing it.

1:13:02Or, like, position zero or position negative one.

1:13:06Yeah, no, it's, yeah.

1:13:07And so it's there.

1:13:09But it does, what happens, and the friend who, I explained this to a friend who really complained about this because it really was screwing with him.

1:13:16And he was like, oh.

1:13:18And I showed, like, last year, this year, a comparison and how, oh, if you just didn't even look and just moved your mouse the same way,

1:13:25it would still get to the same command.

1:13:27But he was like, oh, that makes some sense.

1:13:30But then he was like, but I'm still angry because I look at it and I see the top position and that's, I don't care where it is.

1:13:35And that's true, right?

1:13:36That's the problem with the design is we are visual creatures.

1:13:41Yeah, we're seeing the bounds of that rectangle.

1:13:43I've remarked about this, I mean, several times with Photoshop, which is its own, like, beast.

1:13:47But Photoshop, I keep adding all this generative AI bullshit, John, it's pissing me off.

1:13:52It's like a creative tool and whatever.

1:13:54Anyway, but that's besides the point.

1:13:55But they keep adding new menu commands.

1:13:57And when they add menu commands, they often add it to the top or the bottom instead of somewhere in the middle.

1:14:03And, like, my muscle memory is close is at the bottom or open is at the top.

1:14:07You know what I'm saying?

1:14:08Reveal in Finder is at the top.

1:14:09But, like, suddenly when it's enabled content credentials as the latest feature, it's like, man, you can't just inject this.

1:14:16The proper place for this Ask Siri thing, to be honest, if you're going to have it, is maybe five items down or something.

1:14:22It's not at the end.

1:14:23It's not at the top.

1:14:24Right?

1:14:25It's got to be somewhere there in the middle.

1:14:26Yeah.

1:14:28I don't know what the solution is to this.

1:14:30I have to say that in my tinkering, I've got the Golden Gate installed on a secondary Mac I use.

1:14:37I have never once used the Siri command in a contextual menu.

1:14:41And it might just be I need to, oh, because it's not my main Mac.

1:14:46I'm not developing that habit.

1:14:49You're not trying to.

1:14:50But it's like, I don't know if I ever really want that contextual menu for this.

1:14:54I don't know.

1:14:55I can't quite understand what I would ever need it for.

1:14:59I mean, I guess this is for people that don't know where everything is and they're like, oh, I can just ask Siri to do that thing.

1:15:05But then are those the sort of people who use contextual menus at all?

1:15:09No, that's a great question, John.

1:15:10That's a great question.

1:15:11I mean, like, is the person that doesn't know that Move to Trash is there or something?

1:15:15Is that person going to, like, type in Move to Trash in the Ask Siri?

1:15:18I doubt it.

1:15:19I don't think I'm using contextual menus, to your point.

1:15:21I don't know who it's for exactly.

1:15:23Yeah, I kind of feel like it's a nice idea.

1:15:25I could see trying it.

1:15:27But I feel like in practice, it's all I've really heard are complaints like yours, that it's just screwing with people's visual muscle memory because it's taken over the top spot.

1:15:38And I think the sort of people who'd use contextual menus are the sort of people who don't have a problem dragging the file into the Siri window.

1:15:45That's right.

1:15:46If they wanted to do it, if it's a file.

1:15:48And I don't know what else you could contextual, you know, and every other thing you can right click on to ask Siri about, there are other ways to get that thing into Siri.

1:15:59And I don't think, I don't know, I'll keep an open mind about it.

1:16:04I don't think it's the worst thing in the world, but I kind of feel like, eh, this is a place they didn't need to put it.

1:16:09Because I kind of feel like, hey, there are a couple of ways on the Mac to bring up Siri, right?

1:16:15There's now there's an app, you can click on the dock to get it.

1:16:18There's command space, right?

1:16:20They've taken this very convenient keyboard shortcut, right?

1:16:24So you can always command space to bring it up.

1:16:27You can, I think you can still put it in a menu bar, but just command space and the dock icon alone are two super prominent ways to do it.

1:16:36And that's where I go to ask Siri AI questions on Mac OS 27.

1:16:41I either use command space or I go to the dock menu.

1:16:44I go there.

1:16:45I think about it spatially.

1:16:46I don't need it everywhere, which is what putting it in the context menu is, right?

1:16:51Right.

1:16:51Yeah.

1:16:53So I don't know.

1:16:54I am.

1:16:54But it's like, I mean, the thing that I guess, like the reason I brought it up was, you know, you talked about like the relationship of like the menu title to like all of the list of menu items.

1:17:03And to me, it's like the same thing is happening here.

1:17:06I feel like there was a relationship of like the cursor to the menu, right?

1:17:10The contextual menu that happened.

1:17:11And now it's like, it's weird because when you right click now, it's just like that there's something above your cursor and there never used to be something there before because it always felt like it was coming out of that cursor trajectory.

1:17:22It's like they've messed with a thing that shouldn't be messed with.

1:17:24Imagine if they put a Siri prompt field at the top of every window, right?

1:17:30And it's like, oh, they haven't moved the red, yellow and green buttons.

1:17:34They've just added something on top of them.

1:17:36And it's like, do we need it?

1:17:38How about this one?

1:17:38How about this one?

1:17:39What if instead of a Siri icon in the dock, it's actually a Siri field in the dock.

1:17:42You can type directly in the dock.

1:17:44Yeah.

1:17:44Yeah.

1:17:45I don't think you need all that.

1:17:46And it's an innovative.

1:17:47I don't want to piss on trying a new thing.

1:17:50I just feel like, let's keep the contextual menu simple.

1:17:55And it's a menu and you select things from it.

1:17:56You don't need to type into it.

1:17:58And for the people that really do want it, I really just like knock it down like four spots and I think we'd be fine.

1:18:03Yeah.

1:18:04Make it like, yeah, I could see that too where there's like a top.

1:18:07Why is it right there?

1:18:09Top four or five items for the most common elements.

1:18:12And then it gets the secondary spot is where you could ask Siri.

1:18:16And then everything else in the context menu goes below that.

1:18:19I could see that too.

1:18:20It would be better than making it.

1:18:22I would not even mention it.

1:18:23I would not even be here talking about it at all if that's where it was.

1:18:27All right.

1:18:27Let me take a break here and thank our next sponsor.

1:18:29It is Even Realities.

1:18:31They've sponsored the show before.

1:18:33If you recall, they make AI smart glasses that look like premium eyewear.

1:18:40They do not look like smart glasses at all.

1:18:43They do not have cameras built into them for one thing, which definitely helps make them look more like normal glasses.

1:18:49They are smart glasses with a screen built into one of the lenses or both of the lenses, actually, with a screen that is in one of the lenses.

1:18:59But you don't look like you're wearing smart glasses.

1:19:02You look like you're wearing normal glasses.

1:19:04And in fact, they have two different styles and they have multiple colors.

1:19:06And when I they sent me a pair and the pair that I picked actually looks fairly similar to the style of eyeglasses I normally wear.

1:19:16And my wife and son literally did not notice that I was watching.

1:19:19I was like walking around the house with them.

1:19:20And I'm like, what are they going to say?

1:19:22What are they going to say?

1:19:22And they didn't say a damn thing.

1:19:24It's really that much.

1:19:25They look like regular glasses.

1:19:26They have a bunch of great features.

1:19:30And the screen, it's like a green projected thing.

1:19:35And when you see stuff on screen projected in your field of vision, it does not look to somebody looking at you.

1:19:42They don't see what you see in the glasses.

1:19:44It is something you see.

1:19:46They don't see it.

1:19:46But it is super bright.

1:19:48You can use them outdoors.

1:19:50Super clear.

1:19:51A whole bunch of features they have.

1:19:54One of them is teleprompt where you can load it up.

1:19:58If you need to give a speech or a talk or a presentation or something like that, you can load up the whole talk you want to give in the teleprompt app for your even realities.

1:20:07And then when you engage it, you see the script like a teleprompter in your field of vision.

1:20:12And the people looking at you do not see that you're looking at a teleprompter script.

1:20:16They just see you looking straight ahead in what looks like normal glasses.

1:20:21They have AI features where you can record meetings through the glasses while you're wearing them.

1:20:27They have, for the developers who are listening, the even G2 glasses just launched Terminal, which is a new feature that keeps your AI coding agent in view when you want it.

1:20:37So you can be out and about, bring up Terminal, and then check in and give commands to CloudCode or Codex or whatever your agent of choice is.

1:20:45It's like any terminal.

1:20:47It's sort of agnostic towards which one you're using.

1:20:49But you can direct your AI coding agent from your glasses right in your field of view.

1:20:56It's kind of amazing.

1:20:56To learn more about even G2.

1:20:59And they have other stuff, too.

1:21:01They have sunglass clips that you can put over it.

1:21:03They have a ring that you can wear that is a smart ring that tracks your fitness and stuff like that, but also serves as an input device for selecting items in your vision with the glasses.

1:21:14It's like a touch-sensitive part of the ring that you can wear.

1:21:18Where do you go to find out more?

1:21:19Go to evenrealities.com and see how everyday smart glasses keep helpful information, insights, so you can stay productive and hands-free throughout the day.

1:21:31And for listeners of the talk show, use promo code talkshow at evenrealities.com.

1:21:37No special URL, just evenrealities.com, but then at the promo code talkshow gets you 10% off the even ring one and or the even clip.

1:21:49The clip is the sunglasses clip that snaps on top of the glasses and add them to your even G2 order.

1:21:56That's evenrealities.com, promo code talkshow.

1:22:01All right, we've got to talk about icons, Louis.

1:22:03Oh, well, thank God.

1:22:04You wrote a piece that I love, and I was like, oh, now I've definitely got to get Louis back on the show because you wrote a piece defending, is it fair to say, defending the mandatory squircle?

1:22:15Presenting alternative arguments.

1:22:17I don't know.

1:22:18I don't know if I'm defending it.

1:22:19I'm just saying it's not all that bad.

1:22:21And it's, you convinced me.

1:22:24You did.

1:22:25The icon, the squircle has never been my biggest.

1:22:28And I did, a lot of the complaints about it, I did link to.

1:22:34And there is something that is lost with the custom shapes.

1:22:38I love the argument that you could just look at the silhouette of the classic numbers where you see these bar charts in 3D or like the podium for Keynote.

1:22:49You just see it as a black and white silhouette, and you're like, oh, I know what app that is.

1:22:53That's Keynote.

1:22:54And now the silhouette for every icon is the exact same shape, the exact same squircle.

1:23:00But your title for your post was The Shape of Apps, is that it?

1:23:04That's right, The Shape of Apps.

1:23:06And it is.

1:23:07I see the argument that if you see an icon in this shape, what is that icon?

1:23:12That shape means that's an app.

1:23:14Yep.

1:23:15I mean, I think that's what it is.

1:23:18I think that's what it's been on iPhone for a while.

1:23:22I mean, I know this shape has literally changed a couple times now in a technical sense.

1:23:26But a rounded square, in some sense, has been The Shape of Apps for almost 20 years now.

1:23:32And I think that the other thing your piece really convinced me of, and it was very thoughtful.

1:23:38I linked to it a couple weeks ago.

1:23:40I will link to it again in the show notes for this episode.

1:23:43But the other thing, and you make clear, is focusing just on the mandatory squircle shape is losing the forest for the trees.

1:23:51There is something wrong with the state of icon design overall, and it's not the shape.

1:23:57It is the sort of, hey, there's so much artistry that you can do, even if you don't have control over the overall shape.

1:24:06Within that shape, you can do...

1:24:08So much, you can do other things that you couldn't do before, right?

1:24:12Right.

1:24:12There's new opportunities to be had.

1:24:14It's no excuse for icons that are indistinguishable and bland and don't look like they were...

1:24:19That's what I think.

1:24:20I think that's exactly right.

1:24:22I think the idea that we can no longer distinguish these, I think, is not a good argument.

1:24:26I think we can absolutely distinguish these, and I think there's evidence that it can be done.

1:24:30But I think that what we're seeing, and maybe what some people react to negatively, is that there are a ton of people that are not making maybe good enough efforts to distinguish themselves.

1:24:42I mean, the classic example is photos in Slack, right?

1:24:45At a glance, these two icons right next to each other is like, well, whose fault is that?

1:24:48Well, I don't know, both of them?

1:24:50But it's not...

1:24:51Let's just say it.

1:24:53If these were silhouettes, that would not make this problem any better, right?

1:24:56It would be the same exact problem.

1:24:58So it's not that there's an external silhouette or isn't, right?

1:25:02I mean, the problem is that they are too similar to each other.

1:25:04So I think there's plenty of opportunities to differentiate.

1:25:08And I would say the poster child for like, okay, this has got to be...

1:25:14It's got to get better from here, is the app icons for all of the creator suite from Apple.

1:25:21And I feel like we can just let it fly because it's Apple, so we don't have to worry about hurting anybody's feelings.

1:25:28Not that I really worry about hurting anybody at Slack's feelings, but, you know, it's Apple.

1:25:32So of course we can let it fly.

1:25:34But some of the icons, none of the icons for Creator Studio are good.

1:25:39Yeah, they're all okay, aren't they?

1:25:42Well, they're all suffering from a problem that's one step deep from the squircle.

1:25:46If every app has a squircle, fine.

1:25:47And there's good reason to make a family of apps look like they belong to each other.

1:25:53I totally support that in general endeavor, right?

1:25:56That's a great idea.

1:25:56However, there is some, I guess, it's not clear to me why Numbers needs to be like so similar to Final Cut Pro.

1:26:05I understand that they're in the same creator suite.

1:26:08I don't understand why they're in the same suite, but they are.

1:26:12And having the same constraints between the two, constraints that the rest of app icons don't have.

1:26:18That thing I don't particularly understand.

1:26:19Because you brought up the Numbers icon from before, right, with its unique silhouette.

1:26:23And I don't think it was a particularly great icon because it was always in a perspective that matched no other icon on the platform.

1:26:30I just want to say that.

1:26:32Beautifully rendered, right?

1:26:33Beautifully rendered.

1:26:34But it never matched the perspective of any other app.

1:26:36And that was like one of that particular icon's downfalls.

1:26:40But to the other end, you have an app like Final Cut Pro, which I think has always been throughout its entire history, except maybe perhaps Apple Creator Studio.

1:26:49Every version of Final Cut Pro's icon prior to now was like the exemplary icon for macOS.

1:26:56It's like, it was always like, oh, that's, it's like, it's like iMovie, but it's more pro.

1:27:01And it had like these little digital numbers on like the clapboard, right?

1:27:04But it was still that same clapboard shape at the angle, like for older macOS 10 versions.

1:27:09But then like when, when we did get more of that kind of like Yosemite, like flavor where the silhouettes, like the unique silhouettes of old macOS 10, but color scheme of iOS, it got like this beautiful little rainbow situation.

1:27:22It was like this white clapboard.

1:27:23It looks super Apple, right?

1:27:24And then I think when, even when we got to like Big Sur, when it was like the icons are outside of the bounce, like the top of the clapboard was, it's like the top of the clapboard was the top cut of, it's like they cut off the top of the thing.

1:27:38And actually just rotated the squircle upwards.

1:27:40And it was like really clever.

1:27:42And every single one of these was exemplary of like how to make a great macOS 10 app icon.

1:27:47And yeah, the creator suite ones, they're not, they're doing something different with those.

1:27:53I don't know what that is.

1:27:54Well, it's not good.

1:27:56Some of the other stuff that's going on and I, maybe you can understand.

1:28:01I don't know.

1:28:02It, it, the other thing, and I guess I, I, I do think maybe part of the squircle mandatory nature plays into this is that the way icons are rendered now is, is complicated in a way that it, it never was before.

1:28:18It used to just be basically, they were a picture.

1:28:20And well, I will say they're, they're complicated in different reasons.

1:28:23I mean, yeah, it is, it was just a picture.

1:28:25Right.

1:28:26But icon design was always like having multiple sizes that were all hinted.

1:28:32Right.

1:28:32Right.

1:28:32I mean, you could theoretically have an entirely different icon for every size, right?

1:28:37128 and 32 by 32 and 16 by 16 and all the two X versions of them, you could have completely different assets.

1:28:44And so there was like, I'm sure an element of that, that was complicated because a lot of developers were automating that by like automatically scaling down.

1:28:52Like there are a thousand 24 image to the 16 by 16 without any care to it.

1:28:56So there was complexity, but in, in, in that rendering, but I think what you're referring to is the liquid glass is like this recipe.

1:29:02Formula situation.

1:29:03That's like, let's take, let's take all of these SVG shapes.

1:29:07Let's take these effects and let's render them on the fly.

1:29:10And that is happening at all icon sizes for everything.

1:29:13And early enough in like Mac OS 26, I got to tell you as a person that, you know, I mean, a pair key, we're drawing icons like all day, every day.

1:29:22And like we were delivering icons to our clients last year, post the announcement, but pre-release and the rendering would differ.

1:29:32In different areas in the doc was different from in finder because not everyone was getting the memo or something.

1:29:37Not everyone, like all the rendering was not being done simultaneously.

1:29:40It was done one way on iOS and another way on Mac OS.

1:29:43The colors were not the same when it was an image.

1:29:45It was exactly the same, John.

1:29:47It could be exactly the same.

1:29:48And we knew that was going to be the case.

1:29:50I think they definitely, whatever this rendering pipeline is, it looks much better this year than last year.

1:29:59It certainly does.

1:30:00It's sharper.

1:30:02There's the fact that it's layered.

1:30:05The fact that this is even going on now, it's like, oh, I can kind of see what Apple is doing here because that's kind of cool.

1:30:11And I can see the layering and the specular highlights.

1:30:13Whereas last year, I didn't even realize it was going on.

1:30:17And it was.

1:30:17I was just like, these icons all just look flat and blurry.

1:30:20And I really wouldn't have believed that there were visual effects being applied to them.

1:30:27There were, but it certainly didn't look like it.

1:30:29I mean, it's interesting now.

1:30:31Some of them are so subdued from what they were last year that I would straight up argue that this is more an evolution of the original iOS 7 style than an evolution of yesterday's style.

1:30:41And I think the visual kind of clarity around specular highlights and stuff, I think, especially for the app icon edges, that was stuff we were trying to do years ago.

1:30:52Like pre-Liquid Glass, pre-iOS 7, we were trying to apply specular highlights.

1:30:56And the thing was, like, all of these were always different app to app, right?

1:31:00Because everyone was kind of hand doing it, just like themselves, like trying to figure out what level of opacity it should be.

1:31:05And now all of those specular highlights are the same.

1:31:08And even with all of these different parameters inside of an app icon, at least there is some, I guess, formula, some format everyone has access to.

1:31:16And just the defaults of them will make them look like they belong with all the other ones.

1:31:20Yeah.

1:31:21It has to bother you to some degree.

1:31:23But the point that, like, you ship an icon that you think looks perfect this year.

1:31:27And it just comes through the imaging pipeline that's perfect.

1:31:31Yeah.

1:31:31And then come next June, when macOS 28 and iOS 28 comes out, that same icon, without you having changed anything, or let's say through Parakeet, an app you delivered to a client and it's out there in the world, it will render differently.

1:31:46Yes.

1:31:47It drives me nuts, man.

1:31:48And this is the thing, like, I'm, this is my, this is my personal issue with it.

1:31:53Because I understand that this is affecting very few people.

1:31:56Maybe developers notice and maybe they care.

1:31:59But, like, I am one of, I think, few people that are just absolutely just horrified at the idea that year after year, Apple could change that formula a little bit or change the definitions of that formula.

1:32:11Where an icon that I delivered last year looks different this year.

1:32:14And, and it's like, I already did it.

1:32:17I already, I contacted one of our clients from last year that I made, like, an original liquid glass icon for.

1:32:22And I just, I just delivered a new 27 one that just was like, well, if this is how it looks, this is how I think it should look now with that same thing.

1:32:29Because it's closer to my intent, right?

1:32:31But, no, it's, yeah, it's, it's, it's a little stumbling block that I feel like developers feel year after year, right?

1:32:37And we've always felt, I mean, even pre-liquid glass, I mean, if you go look release after release of macOS 10, you'll see the icons do subtly change year after year.

1:32:46And if developers did the same thing, then they could kind of keep up with it in the same way they did with their software in general.

1:32:52If you keep updating your app, so it looks and feels like it's the current iOS or the current OS, then it will, it'll feel like it belongs.

1:32:58But, I mean, I guess now Apple's like, we're doing that for you.

1:33:02And if you, if you're not on top of it, I mean, then I guess you're just, but here's, here's the part that, that really I'm, I'm struggling to quite understand is an app icon that now I make for iOS 27.

1:33:15Now, not the old one that is converted to the new style.

1:33:18That's maybe its own situation I have to deal with.

1:33:21But if I design an icon now for OS 27 and it gets built for OS 26, I have to now consider that, John.

1:33:29I have to consider like how that is being rendered on older platforms, even though it's the same exact file being delivered.

1:33:36And I kind of think it's always been true.

1:33:42It's just the nature of software that you're never really done or most cases, it's hard to say you're done.

1:33:48You've got to kind of keep updating for the new technologies in the operating system underneath it, even if you're not adding major features to the app itself.

1:33:58But I feel like Apple has just sort of reached a new level of presumption about how everybody who makes software for their platforms is constantly, nothing has ever settled in any way in any of it.

1:34:14We can't just ship it and be done with it anymore.

1:34:17I mean, to some extent, it's always been true.

1:34:19It is always been true that you kind of have you never finished, like you said.

1:34:23But it would be nice if you were more finished.

1:34:25And maybe this situation where they force it into a squircle, like where you put it on the gray background, like when that happens, I guess we are living in a situation now where that does look a little bit better and more at home.

1:34:38Like for the apps that are older, that are aging, that are not necessarily being updated.

1:34:43At least those are looking like they're in line with everything else.

1:34:46So it is presumptuous from Apple that everyone's constantly maintaining these apps.

1:34:52But for now, if they don't, then those older apps don't look necessarily out of line.

1:34:58Right.

1:34:59And I guess they're not going to reverse it, but it's, I don't know.

1:35:03It just speaks to me that it's a little bit myopic about the way Apple works internally, where Apple has a team of people working on every different app.

1:35:13Right.

1:35:14All the time.

1:35:14And I know that there's certain smaller apps, especially on the Mac, in the corners of macOS, where it's just one person.

1:35:21Like that don't get really touched.

1:35:22Yeah.

1:35:22Right.

1:35:23And somebody's responsible for updating the chess app.

1:35:27Right.

1:35:28Yeah.

1:35:29It's like one guy, and he's listening, and he's like, yeah, team.

1:35:33Ha ha.

1:35:33Right.

1:35:34Yeah.

1:35:34But there is somebody who is responsible for, hey, when we change the look of macOS 28 next year, this is.

1:35:42We have to do some small things here.

1:35:44Yeah.

1:35:44This is what you're going to have to do to update it.

1:35:47And out in the real world, that's not true.

1:35:51Yeah.

1:35:52I mean, yeah.

1:35:53When you have like indie development companies that have like just seven apps or something, they're not necessarily working on those seven apps all at the same time.

1:36:01They don't necessarily have the team to support that sort of thing.

1:36:04They're kind of like shifting their focus to newer releases.

1:36:06And so by the time they actually get around to like refreshing things, it might be like a year from now.

1:36:11And by then, Apple will have released a new version.

1:36:14Right.

1:36:14And maybe the formula, again, has changed.

1:36:16And hopefully, you know, I know, you know, if you're indie and you're a small team, there's only so much you can do even in an ideal world.

1:36:22But a lot of indie developers would like to have a couple of apps going at the same time and maybe come out with new apps once in a while.

1:36:30And if you have to constantly keep everything in your existing app and redo it and redo the paint every year, you're never going to be able to find the time to move on to make a new thing.

1:36:44Right.

1:36:44I think this is exactly the pain that developers feel, that they are constantly just maintaining their app for Apple, for Apple's benefit, not for their users' benefit, but for the benefit of Apple to like keep chugging along on their UI churn, which is silly because I think all of these individual companies have their own aspirations, right?

1:37:02They're the only thing that they want to focus on and because they constantly, and it's real money, John.

1:37:06I mean, it's not just like the amount of time that they have to spend engineering that app.

1:37:10I mean, like if people need a new app icon, I mean, they do have to spend money on that probably.

1:37:15And when they, and it's like, if that becomes an every year expense for them, I'm sure some people are like, hmm, do I want this thing or do I want a new icon?

1:37:23They're constantly comparing everything against that.

1:37:25And I think that just doesn't work for Apple's benefit, but maybe that's why Apple did what they did.

1:37:31Like with last year's release, like putting it all in a squircle is just like saying, we know not everyone will continue updating this.

1:37:37So let's try to make something that works backwards and forwards from now on.

1:37:41All right.

1:37:41I got one more complaint for you.

1:37:43One thing I do not like, I do not like the visual interface to Siri when you, not the app, but when you hold the side button on the phone or do command space on the app.

1:37:54Oh, that little blobby thing that comes down from the dynamic island that's like that black translucent inky sort of situation.

1:38:01Yeah.

1:38:02Yeah.

1:38:02I don't like it.

1:38:03And I've tried to get, I've tried to love it after a month or six weeks or however long it's been.

1:38:09And it's, it's not doing it for me.

1:38:11It's funny to me that like every year or two, they just rebrand Siri entirely.

1:38:15It used to like be this chromatic thing.

1:38:17Like it was like this pink and green and blue situation.

1:38:20And I mean, originally Siri was just like that purple microphone situation.

1:38:25They, they keep doing it.

1:38:26And I had to look, but I think SF symbols has icons for each generation of Siri, which is so funny to me.

1:38:33Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

1:38:33It's like, it's like, cause they, cause they need to be able to reference different versions of Siri.

1:38:37If you have the AI stuff turned on or not, I guess for previous versions of iOS and macOS.

1:38:42But man, I just, I gotta be honest with you, John.

1:38:46I have stopped using Siri for almost everything these days.

1:38:51I don't, I don't really use it.

1:38:52I don't, I, I don't even use it to set timers anymore.

1:38:56I like, I, for, for a long time, the benchmark to me was like, can I at least just set a timer?

1:38:59That's actually all I want to do.

1:39:01I'm never like looking for information.

1:39:02I'm never looking for it to play music.

1:39:04I am actually faster and more reliable choosing a song from my library manually on my Mac than it is to make sure that it's playing the correct thing when I say it out loud.

1:39:13So I just kind of gave up on it, you know, but like setting timers, John, I got myself a kitchen timer and I hit a button and it starts.

1:39:20And that is it.

1:39:21I actually don't understand what I need Siri for if I'm being completely honest.

1:39:26So I guess the visual change doesn't bother me because I'm not even looking at it anymore.

1:39:30Sometimes I use it just to pull down and launch apps, right?

1:39:35Cause it is also the launcher.

1:39:36And on Mac OS, I use launch bar for command space.

1:39:41And so I have my own launcher, but on the phone, you don't get to add a third.

1:39:45On the phone, you don't get a choice there.

1:39:47I mean, yeah, I was going to say on the Mac, I'm just using tiny start right now, which is great.

1:39:51And I love it.

1:39:52And it's, it's kind of the same thing as I, it's just a specifically an app launcher.

1:39:55Cause I don't want to search my whole computer.

1:39:58When I invoke that command, if I want to search different apps, I will go in that app and search that thing.

1:40:03I don't need this global search solution, but you're right about the pull down thing, but can actually that I don't like on iOS.

1:40:10iOS now just pulling down, pulls down this whole field from the top of the screen, John, it used to go to the lock screen.

1:40:18And now I have to go to the top left for that.

1:40:20That is a muscle memory problem right there.

1:40:21Yeah.

1:40:22And it's like, you pull it down and you can kind of see it slowly come down.

1:40:26But then if you want to make it go away, you would think, well, then you can slowly push it up.

1:40:30And no, it just, you can flick up to make it go away, but it doesn't animate.

1:40:35It just sort of disappears.

1:40:37And I've had problems where I like when I do use Siri and I, and I, and it's searching for something.

1:40:41Yeah, you can't, you can't easily dismiss it all the time.

1:40:44I can't, I can't understand how to dismiss it, I guess.

1:40:47Yeah.

1:40:48That was another one where after seeing it at WWDC in early June, I thought, well, they'll probably really, really put some attention on that UI over the summer.

1:40:56And it seems like, no, we may not need to wait till next year.

1:41:00I don't know.

1:41:01All right.

1:41:02Let me take a final break here and thank our third and final sponsor of the episode.

1:41:07our good friends at Squarespace, Squarespace, the all-in-one website platform where you can build an entire website, a web business, anything you need to do on the web, you could do it at Squarespace.

1:41:22Everything from registering the domain name to building the look and feel, and you can use the traditional drag-and-drop WYSIWYG tools.

1:41:31You can use their AI tools and just sort of give commands to the AI tool to tell it how you want the website to look.

1:41:38And, of course, you can pick from Squarespace's incredibly deep portfolio of templates to start from and then customize those templates to your heart's desire.

1:41:51One of the things I often say about Squarespace is they are so common, they are out there, and so many sites run on Squarespace that you have, as a user, have no idea, like how many restaurants, websites you go to.

1:42:03And they're, in fact, Squarespace sites.

1:42:06And you would have no idea because Squarespace, it's not the sort of thing where, oh, you have a Squarespace site, it's going to look like one of these three things, and that's how all Squarespace sites look.

1:42:17No, Squarespace's design flexibility is so rich and thorough that if you have a very distinctive, unique brand, your site will have that distinctive, unique brand that's all yours and, like, no Squarespace.

1:42:30Oh, that's a telltale sign of a Squarespace site.

1:42:32There really isn't anything like that.

1:42:34Features to emphasize or just mention they've got great analytics and a really, really, both good information in the analytics and a really good dashboard user interface that really makes the information you get easy to comprehend and see at a glance and kind of see, oh, traffic is up or traffic is down or, oh, I'm getting tons of traffic from Instagram for some reason or whatever.

1:42:59You can see it all in the analytics.

1:43:01Where do you go to find out more?

1:43:03It's so easy.

1:43:04Go to squarespace.com slash talk show.

1:43:08That's been the URL for so many years, squarespace.com slash talk show.

1:43:13And whether you use that code or not, everybody gets 30 days free, free trial, no limits, no watermarks, 30 days to build a website exactly the way you want before you have to pay.

1:43:25But when you do pay, use that code talk show and you get 10% off your entire order.

1:43:31Pre-pay for a whole year.

1:43:32Save 10% on a year by using squarespace.com slash talk show.

1:43:38All right, the last topic for the show, and I told you we'd come back to it.

1:43:42I can't believe I remembered it.

1:43:43I'm excited.

1:43:44But the one thing I haven't talked about on the show yet that's in the news is the Apple lawsuit against OpenAI for trade secret infringement.

1:43:53Yep.

1:43:54And you used to, and one of the things they're saying is that they were, that the ex-Apple people now at OpenAI were, A, instructing the Apple people to bring parts.

1:44:04That's wild to me.

1:44:05It's true.

1:44:05That's wild.

1:44:07There was a quote, they didn't say who said it, but that one Apple employee wrote in a message, I didn't even know we were allowed to do that.

1:44:16And it turns out, of course, they were not allowed to do that.

1:44:19Of course.

1:44:20Yeah.

1:44:22And that they were also giving them instructions on what to do when they gave notice that they were leaving Apple to.

1:44:30Right.

1:44:31And this is the sort of thing, that's the sort of aspect of this lawsuit where we, A, we've only heard Apple's side of it yet.

1:44:37We have still seen nothing other than a PR sentence from OpenAI responding to it.

1:44:43Which statements have not been great, in my opinion, because the one was like, we have no interest in other companies.

1:44:49And they did a take two, right?

1:44:51Yeah.

1:44:52Yeah.

1:44:53And like my analogy, it's still, I crack myself up with it, is if I think you stole my wallet and I find a police officer and I think, that guy right there, he stole my wallet.

1:45:03It's in his pocket.

1:45:04And you just say, I have no interest in other people's wallets.

1:45:07Right.

1:45:07Right.

1:45:08And that is not saying.

1:45:09Like, let's be honest.

1:45:11I think, I am always interested in the trade secrets of all the others.

1:45:16Of course, of course you would be, right?

1:45:18If you knew that stuff, that would be great information, right?

1:45:20There's a reason that that's not okay, right?

1:45:23So the idea that you're not interested in it, I think it's just like this.

1:45:27I don't know what argument you're trying to make, but it's not working.

1:45:31I didn't even think of that.

1:45:33All I've been thinking of is that the unambiguous way the statement to make is, we did not steal anybody's trade secrets.

1:45:39We did not do that, right, is the statement, right?

1:45:42We're not interested in that.

1:45:43It's like, bullshit.

1:45:44You make a good point, though, where it's like, and again, I'm not interested in stealing anybody's wallet, but I am curious what Louis Mantia has in his wallet.

1:45:54I bet you've got some really fun stuff in there, you know, like some really clever cards.

1:45:58I am curious.

1:45:59I'm not interested in stealing your wallet, Louis, but I have to admit, I am curious what is in it.

1:46:05Yeah.

1:46:05I mean, it's like, well, I don't know if you're a person that ever watched My Cousin Vinny.

1:46:10It's one of my favorite movies.

1:46:11Oh, I love that movie.

1:46:12I haven't seen that in a while.

1:46:13There's a moment where Vinny says something like, if only I could get a look at Trotter's file sort of thing.

1:46:18It's like, of course you would want that information and he gets it because that's by law what you're able to do here.

1:46:23So the idea is he thought it was like wrong, right?

1:46:25And I think that's the correct implication that actually maybe it's wrong that I would get to like spy on this other person's information.

1:46:31In that specific case, he was totally allowed to have that information and he ends up getting it by what he thinks is sweet talking, but it's actually just the law.

1:46:38It's like the idea that open eye would not be like, oh God, if only we would know about that.

1:46:43Of course they would love to know.

1:46:44But there's a reason that you don't do that is because you don't want to break the law.

1:46:49I don't know.

1:46:49You can just say that you didn't do it.

1:46:51But if you say you weren't interested, I'm not buying it.

1:46:54Right.

1:46:55Well, this is where I want to circle back to what you said about what you used to work at Apple and then you left.

1:47:01And what was it like when you left?

1:47:02What was the security procedure?

1:47:04What was the two weeks notice scenario?

1:47:07I mean, it's all, God, it was so long ago.

1:47:10But I mean, as far as I remember, the way that it went was I thought I was going to give my two weeks and just continue finishing up whatever projects I was working on and see myself out.

1:47:22But at the end of the two weeks, but in reality, giving that notice is just is to Apple just saying, OK, well, this guy's done.

1:47:29Why would we continue giving him more secrets?

1:47:31Right.

1:47:32Because like, what are you going to do?

1:47:34You're going to make sure that I don't ever interact with anyone that might be sharing potentially information that is not something I need to know or something I could walk away with.

1:47:44They're like to make sure that happens.

1:47:47Right.

1:47:47You have to section me off in like my own little office and my own little spot where it's like I never interact with anybody.

1:47:53Right.

1:47:53And I have access to no files.

1:47:55At that point, you might as well be gone.

1:47:57So I I'm a little I'm a little curious about like how any of this has changed or anyone's strategies that they may have.

1:48:05I mean, I'm sure there are people that are just like they don't give notice until they're actually ready to go rather than giving a two weeks notice like and not expecting that they're going to be shut out the door.

1:48:15But no, I mean, I tidied up my things and I and I left pretty immediately after that.

1:48:20And it wasn't like a it wasn't like a bad blood thing.

1:48:23It was just like a security thing, you know?

1:48:25Yeah.

1:48:26And that's what I'm glad you said that because it's not no bad blood.

1:48:30But it's not punishment.

1:48:31Good luck.

1:48:31Right.

1:48:32And a lot of Apple people.

1:48:34I mean, you know them.

1:48:35I know them.

1:48:35I mean, anybody who knows anybody at Apple knows somebody who's been at Apple, left Apple, done something else and then come back to Apple.

1:48:43I know people who come back to Apple twice.

1:48:45I don't think I know anybody who's I know people on their third stint.

1:48:50I don't know if I know anybody on their fourth yet, but I'll bet there are some.

1:48:54And it's perfectly acceptable.

1:48:55You can leave on good terms and go away for a couple of years and then come back on good terms.

1:49:01And everybody is an adult and everybody understands that that's how careers work.

1:49:07But when it's with this scenario in particular, with IO and Love From and OpenAI, there is bad blood.

1:49:16Yeah, it seems that way.

1:49:18Yeah, there's no – I kind of knew it before – more than kind of.

1:49:23I knew it to some degree because I know people who are at IO who used to be at Apple.

1:49:30And I didn't know it was this bad though.

1:49:33And I certainly didn't hear anything that would be – I was as surprised as anybody when Apple announced this lawsuit.

1:49:39I had no idea this was coming.

1:49:40But I knew that it was – if you were an employee who Apple – your manager would like to retain because you were good at your job and got along with people and you say,

1:49:56I'm leaving because I'm going to go somewhere else.

1:49:59Well, then it's like, ah, that's too bad.

1:50:01But it's a shame.

1:50:02And like you said, you leave on good terms.

1:50:03If you said, I'm leaving and I'm going to IO, that's a problem.

1:50:09It has been.

1:50:09Yeah, and there is a difference between – of course, I think everyone knows this.

1:50:13There's a difference between I'm thinking about leaving and I'm leaving, right?

1:50:17Yeah.

1:50:17And I'm thinking about leaving might prompt some discussions about retaining you.

1:50:21But if you've made the decision already, I think they're like, all right, get out of here then.

1:50:25Yeah.

1:50:26And so it's definitely been the case where for a while or from the beginning – and we know it's actually Apple confirmed it.

1:50:33I think Gurman had reported that it was like upwards of 400 employees have left – former Apple employees are now employed at OpenAI.

1:50:39That's crazy to me.

1:50:40And Apple put that in the legal complaint that they filed that it's – I forget if they said about 400 or over 400.

1:50:48But even Apple says 400.

1:50:51And that's a lot of people for a company that hasn't shipped a single hardware thing yet.

1:50:55Yes.

1:50:55It really is.

1:50:56And it just speaks to how much money that OpenAI has raised because I was like,

1:51:03That doesn't even make any sense.

1:51:04But I got to say, man, like even with 400 people, like if what Apple is like suggesting is true here,

1:51:10if like their accusations are true, that like there were trade secrets and everything that migrated their way over to OpenAI or IO or whatever,

1:51:17like I can't believe even with 400 people they managed to get some people to do that.

1:51:23I can't quite believe it because how do you work at Apple and not understand the security implications of your job?

1:51:30Yeah, I don't know.

1:51:32I actually don't understand how anyone can go, this seems fine.

1:51:37This seems like something I could get away with or it seems fine.

1:51:39I don't know how you think either.

1:51:42I don't know either.

1:51:43And there's this guy, Chang Liu, who is unfortunately named in the lawsuit and is at the center of it.

1:51:51And one scenario would be the, none of this is a good case, but the best case from Apple's perspective is that he's just emblematic of a type of behavior that is widespread amongst the employees who have left Apple for OpenAI.

1:52:09And that after he left, he had kept an Apple laptop for a couple of weeks and was still using it to log in.

1:52:15And he had figured out some kind of way that even after he was no longer an Apple employee, his credentials for file sharing, which probably went through Box, which is what Apple uses for remote file sharing.

1:52:27But they didn't name Box in particular, but somehow he could still log in and still get files as an Apple employee, even though he wasn't an Apple employee.

1:52:36What is going on over there, like at Apple in that respect?

1:52:39Like, how did that not get shut off sooner?

1:52:41Yeah, I don't know.

1:52:43And that Apple has records of all this, that obviously there's logs of who logged in with what credentials to the file sharing.

1:52:50And it's all there.

1:52:52Like, presumably of all the allegations in this suit, those are the ones that Apple's definitely got dead to rights.

1:52:58Now, is it one guy who was an idiot?

1:53:01You know, you got to wonder, like, if he's such an idiot, how did he get a job at either company?

1:53:06But again, the security implication of it, I feel like people have their own ideas about, like, what security at Apple is like.

1:53:12But I'll tell you that, like, yeah, you sign confidentiality agreements and you generally understand not to share things.

1:53:18And I think that people at Apple, generally speaking, are more cautious in general than they need to be.

1:53:25I have known people that work at Apple and they are, like, super, super tight-lipped about anything that they work on, even in the most general sense, because I think they fear some wrath or whatever.

1:53:38But it's wild to me, I guess, that you could be working there and not have that understanding.

1:53:43Even if you had a different understanding of, like, how much, I don't think it's logging into a file server to download files on your Apple laptop after you terminate your employment level.

1:53:54Right.

1:53:55Right.

1:53:56And even before you terminate, you know, and there's some allegations in there that they were coaching employees on how to, okay, if you're going to take this job, before you tell Apple you're quitting, do this and this and get these files first and copy them to a personal device.

1:54:10And then tell Apple you're leaving for open AI because as soon as you tell them you're leaving for open AI or just tell them you're leaving and don't even tell them where you're going because if you do tell them you're coming here, they are immediately going to call security and you will be immediately walked out of the building with a box with whatever was in your office in your hands immediately because that's what they're doing for open AI.

1:54:31So we're going to coach you on how to prepare for this.

1:54:35And there was something about coaching them to prepare for the Apple's global security team, approaching them about questions about their whatever.

1:54:44And if some of that stuff sounds like, hey, that sounds fishy that they're coaching them this.

1:54:49But Marco Armand on ATP said, and I was thinking the same thing, but I have to give him credit because he put it on a podcast first, is it's sort of like when you teach kids about their basic civil liberties here in the United States.

1:55:00And that when a police officer comes to your house and knocks on the door and says, we'd like to come in, you can just say, no, thank you.

1:55:07And they cannot come into your house.

1:55:09Allegedly.

1:55:10Well, that's the way it should work.

1:55:14Now, whether they actually won't come in, who knows, but you're in your rights to say no.

1:55:21And for example, an important one, too, is if you have stuff in the trunk of your car and you get pulled over on the highway, the police, you don't have to give them any permission to search the trunk of your car.

1:55:34They have to have probable cause.

1:55:35And you can teaching kids that they have these rights is that's a good thing.

1:55:40And that we have these rights is a good thing.

1:55:42And so there is a scenario where OpenAI and former Apple employees at OpenAI telling soon-to-be-ex Apple employees, here's what to expect and what we think you should do and what you should know.

1:55:56And that if after you leave and you're no longer an Apple employee, if Apple Global Security says we'd like you to come in for an interview, you can just tell them no.

1:56:04You should, because why would you want to?

1:56:06You're not an Apple employee anymore.

1:56:07And if they have questions about what you've done, that's their problem, not yours.

1:56:12That's totally fair.

1:56:13That is absolutely fair.

1:56:15And that's not suspicious behavior.

1:56:16It just looks bad if you're looking at it in the perspective of the other things Apple is alleging in there.

1:56:21They're like, I don't know.

1:56:23That whole part of the complaint made me roll my eyes where they're like, Tang Tan, a former VP at Apple, had a document of what Apple managers know about employees who, when they leave, and was using it to coach people.

1:56:36Well, that's not a trade secret.

1:56:37There are allegations of serious trade secret theft in this lawsuit.

1:56:41But Apple's, here's what they do when employees give their notice that they're leaving.

1:56:46That's not a trade secret.

1:56:48Well, I think this was also mentioned on ATP, too, about what do you retain when you leave, and how do you section off that part of your brain so that you don't keep it?

1:56:58I mean, of course, any documents, any very specific methods of doing something are likely proprietary.

1:57:05But any expertise that you learned through working there, that's yours to keep.

1:57:10I mean, everyone benefits from that expertise whenever you get a new job.

1:57:14Apple benefits from that expertise.

1:57:15I think this was outlined on ATP also.

1:57:18But I mean, I admit there's part of this that I struggle with to understand also.

1:57:23You're right.

1:57:24There are very serious things in this that are more tangible.

1:57:27But there's also this question, I guess, about, I don't know, who owns what about this sort of stuff?

1:57:33If it's just a method, right, then I don't think you own that method, necessarily.

1:57:37I would have to know what the method is to know for sure.

1:57:40But I walked away from Apple learning things.

1:57:42I learned things that then I applied to my work elsewhere.

1:57:46I don't think these are Apple trade secrets to use a raster marquee tool rather than a vector shape if I'm drawing a circle.

1:57:52I don't think that's a trade secret, but I don't know, man.

1:57:56I don't know how you know how to separate that stuff in your brain because, and especially when you work for multiple companies, you start holding, like, the secrets in your brain.

1:58:04And I'm not saying it's impossible to know whose secrets are what and where you heard it.

1:58:09But over time, that stuff starts to get a little fuzzy.

1:58:12It's not totally all around a possibility for me that someone could leave Apple, go to work for another company, and inadvertently do something, share some piece of information.

1:58:22that they didn't necessarily think was actually proprietary.

1:58:26You know what I mean?

1:58:28It's possible that someone learned something that they assumed was, like, just general on-the-job knowledge and not this is something Apple specifically has patented the fuck out of.

1:58:39Who knows?

1:58:39Yeah.

1:58:40Yeah.

1:58:41I do think that a lot of people, and I don't know the specifics of it.

1:58:45I've never worked at Apple.

1:58:46I'm almost certainly never going to work at Apple.

1:58:48And so I've never, and I've, even though I have a lot of friends who work there and have worked there, I've never said to somebody who works at Apple, hey, can I play with your laptop, your work laptop?

1:58:59I mean, see how it's set up and what software the company installs.

1:59:04I don't know.

1:59:05But I do think people who are used to a lot of typical corporate IT put stuff on your computer that locks it down, and they're like, I can't believe anybody at Apple would be trying these things.

1:59:17Of course it's all locked down.

1:59:18I think they vastly underestimate how unlike that being an Apple employee is, that your computer is mostly running macOS, and yes, you have to log into a work VPN to connect to work things, and the VPN logs your activity.

1:59:34But there's not a lot of, or any real software that locks you out of things on your device.

1:59:40It's much more, because the idea is that you're an Apple employee.

1:59:44You love macOS and iOS the way they're supposed to be for users, and you get to use them in that way, and you're not using a sort of handcuffed version of these platforms like you are in a lot of corporate environments.

1:59:58So I think it is easier to forget that it is a work machine, and you are going to hand it in, and after you hand it in, they can look at it forensically and see everything you were doing on it.

2:00:12And they do encourage.

2:00:14In some cases, I think you almost can't get by without logging into your personal iCloud account on your work machine.

2:00:22When it's like, oh, what's your personal iCloud?

2:00:24And then your iCloud gets like a magic work folder in iCloud Drive that has some of the work-related documents.

2:00:32And then when you're no longer an employee, they take that flag off your iCloud account, and then you don't have the magic folder in iCloud Drive anymore.

2:00:41But you are supposed to or almost have to log in with your personal iCloud on a work machine.

2:00:48And therefore, you can be having these conversations in iMessage on your work machine, and iMessage is end-to-end encrypted between you and, let's say, the person at OpenAI you're communicating with about your future job.

2:01:05But the end isn't you.

2:01:08The end is your work MacBook Pro.

2:01:11And then when you hand that work MacBook Pro in, all of a sudden, Apple does have one.

2:01:17They haven't broken the end-to-end encryption of iMessage.

2:01:21They just have one of the ends.

2:01:22I mean, I guess it depends on if they have login capabilities, admin login capabilities to look at that data.

2:01:27You know what I mean?

2:01:28No.

2:01:28Yeah.

2:01:29If they don't, then they don't.

2:01:31No.

2:01:31I don't think there's as much funny business.

2:01:34I don't think there's as much running in the background on an Apple work machine.

2:01:37No, I mean, I can only speak to what was the – yeah, I can only speak to what happened 15 years ago for me.

2:01:42But as far as I know, no, there wasn't anything.

2:01:45I don't like – I think there was – I think some – maybe I'm naive, but I don't think so.

2:01:51But maybe there were some naive people that thought they were constantly being spied on because that's kind of like how other workplace environments work.

2:01:57But from my experience, the laptop, the computer I brought home with me, it was a work laptop and it had access to work things through VPN stuff.

2:02:05But I don't think there was like any specific software.

2:02:08I used it as if it was a normal Mac.

2:02:10And yes, I absolutely wasn't signed into my personal accounts on this device.

2:02:14And I was using it interchangeably for personal stuff and for work stuff.

2:02:18It's not like – do you know what I mean?

2:02:20It's just a computer, man.

2:02:21Yeah, but once they – you know, global security at Apple has the computer in the hand, then they've got it all.

2:02:28And it is just a computer.

2:02:29I mean, yeah, I guess unless you wipe it all, right?

2:02:31I think there's a lot less – and I think it's good.

2:02:34I think it's a good thing and it's part of what makes Apple Apple that there is a large – even as big as the companies have gotten and as their headcount has grown,

2:02:41there's a large amount of trust between Apple and the employees as while you're an active employee that they trust you to do the right thing.

2:02:50By and large, Apple employees do.

2:02:51And like you said, if anything, by and large, they over-index on it and they're too careful and don't even talk about things they could talk about.

2:02:58Do you think any of this – any of what's going on right now will change that dynamic at Apple?

2:03:05Right now, they're like super open and trusting.

2:03:08Both sides are fairly trusting.

2:03:09Do you think this creates an amount of distrust?

2:03:13No, but I do think that's – I don't think so.

2:03:16I don't think as a policy, but I do think that's part of the reason they filed the suit is as a sort of, hey, while we're at 400 people who've left here for there, let's keep it from growing to 800 because we can make it a big pain in your ass.

2:03:31It's going to – we're going to scrutinize – if you do leave us for them, we're going to scrutinize everything you've done and you better have all your I's crossed and – or T's crossed and I's dotted, et cetera, et cetera.

2:03:45I don't know.

2:03:45I think that's part of it.

2:03:46And I guess the other thing that I know it's like, well, what does Apple want out of this?

2:03:51I do think – I think they just want to send a message that just says enough and I think they do.

2:03:56I don't think they're trying to say we're going to prosecute you or pursue you illegally, but they do want to discourage Apple employees from leaving.

2:04:04They don't want them to leave.

2:04:05Of course not, if they're good employees.

2:04:08And I think it is particularly personal with Johnny Ive and Tang Tan and the other higher-ups.

2:04:16Is it like – are these people not having – I mean, maybe they are having discussions.

2:04:20I mean, I've heard people say it's Apple's job to retain their talent and I agree with that sentiment.

2:04:25Yeah.

2:04:25Of course, of course.

2:04:27And how much they're getting paid, whatever.

2:04:30It's like all of that stuff is negotiable, right?

2:04:32So like I have no idea, I have no insight here about like did these people, if they wanted to go, were they going because they believed in the possibility of whatever OpenAI and IO are creating and Johnny Ive are creating?

2:04:46Was that the exciting part or was it more they didn't like working at Apple?

2:04:51Like did they bother to ask about compensation to retain their talent?

2:04:55I don't know because like I said, like there is a difference between saying like I am thinking about going and I am going, right?

2:05:01And I think that you can't – if someone says I'm going, like retaining your talent at that point I think is a little hard, right?

2:05:09I think that once someone's made the decision, I think it's like, well, all right, we can try to convince you otherwise, but your decision is probably already made.

2:05:15Yeah.

2:05:17Well, I think maybe part of it – and I guess with 400 people, there's 400 stories and I'm sure they're all over the place.

2:05:26And some of them are hardware and some of them are software.

2:05:28And Apple's hardware and software are in very different places.

2:05:31I think they're – and I think this is almost everybody – I haven't even seen anybody really disagree with it, that it kind of makes sense amongst any personal details about John Ternus and his personality.

2:05:45But just the basic idea that their hardware story is in such a good place across the board that it kind of makes sense that the senior vice president of hardware engineering is the guy who got the promotion to be CEO, right?

2:05:56The hardware is the best part of the company and therefore the hardware guy is the new CEO.

2:06:02And there's some fundamental like, yeah, I guess at some part it makes some sense.

2:06:07Wait, so that's why Alan Dye left?

2:06:08Because he wasn't going to get the CEO job?

2:06:11No.

2:06:11He was like, all right, if that's not a CEO, he came out.

2:06:13No, I don't think so.

2:06:14I've seen people suggest that, but there's no way that he was running.

2:06:17But as good as Apple's hardware has been, and the Apple Silicon has been great for the Mac, if you're a designer who wants to make novel new shapes and form factors and use new material, it hasn't been a great time.

2:06:32I think it's been a great time as a user because the hardware hasn't been making changes for change's sake.

2:06:38They're like, you know what?

2:06:38These laptops are – this is a great design for a laptop.

2:06:41So the M2 version and the M3 version and the M4 version all kind of look the same, and at some point they made space black look actually black instead of slightly darker gray.

2:06:52So what, like the innovation in MacBook Pro design is that the dark one got darker?

2:06:56Yeah, yeah.

2:06:57I'm not complaining overall.

2:07:00No, no, no.

2:07:00I love that they're not making unnecessary changes.

2:07:03But if you're a designer, it's kind of boring, right?

2:07:06It's a little stifling.

2:07:07No, I'm sure.

2:07:07I'm sure.

2:07:08I mean, if you're a creative person and you're looking to be creatively fulfilled, I'm sure you're always looking for, like, new problems to solve, right?

2:07:14I've said this before.

2:07:15I think we're at a point in computing history.

2:07:18We've been there for a little while now where actually there's no more problems to solve.

2:07:22Almost everything that we have done, we've solved, we've refined to hell already.

2:07:26And the only way to improve is to break it a little bit with one version so that you can fix it in another.

2:07:33It's not real, like, we, I don't know, people call it rearranging deck tears on the Titanic, right?

2:07:38You've moved things around for the sake of moving it around, and it's maybe all for naught anyway because it's all syncing.

2:07:43But I guess I don't really understand why someone would want to leave Apple in particular.

2:07:48I mean, if you want to be creatively fulfilled elsewhere, I really want to know.

2:07:53I have no speculation, I have no interest, I have no understanding of this, but what possibly compels people that were all of those seasoned software and hardware people at Apple to find whatever they're doing at OpenAI, like IO, to be vastly more creatively fulfilling?

2:08:08I have no idea what that pull is.

2:08:12Yeah, I don't know either, except that I think there's a lot of people who really did like and love Johnny Ive and really appreciate his sort of earnest artist approach to technology.

2:08:24And that it has always been rare.

2:08:26I mean, he is.

2:08:27Johnny Ive is an earnest artist.

2:08:30I mean, I think as far as hardware design, of course, I agree with you that I think there's a lot there.

2:08:35But like software design, I don't know if that's ever been there.

2:08:37I mean, I said this about Johnny or about Alan at the beginning of the episode that like, was Alan like actually a person that ever really loved computers?

2:08:45I can't say that I can recall any moment where it seemed to me that Johnny ever loved computers either, right?

2:08:55He's always been like a person that cared way more about like how the thing felt, how it looked, how it sat, how it was held in your hand, how it interacted with you.

2:09:05But it was never about the thing on the screen, right?

2:09:10Yeah, I don't know.

2:09:12Less so than most other people who design computers, right?

2:09:15I do think he likes computers, but I think he was more interested in the people first and the fact that computers were so such a big part of everybody's life.

2:09:26And I think he could see and was correct.

2:09:28I think anybody at Apple could see in the 90s, like when he and Steve Jobs, when Steve Jobs discovered him sitting there being ignored in the design studio that like, hey, people are only going to use computers even more and more as time goes on.

2:09:44And it's such a big part of people's lives that if you just want, even if you just want to design things and Johnny Ive has, he's designing cars now and he's taking, you know, everybody's designed chairs.

2:09:56Everybody who's a designer like Johnny Ive is designed a chair and you want to design anything.

2:10:01And Love From designed a new, it's called a rostrum.

2:10:05It's like the big podium for either Sotheby's or the other big auction house in London.

2:10:09Okay, so I do understand this, John.

2:10:11Like, I understand the idea that like you could design more things than just computers.

2:10:15I mean, a lot of the reason that, you know, I-

2:10:17But computers are the thing that people use, right?

2:10:19Well, yeah, right.

2:10:20I can understand, of course, wanting to do other things.

2:10:23And of course, like computers are where people are, but I kind of am still kind of curious, I guess, why there is so much of a push to try to develop a thing to replace a phone or a computer, right?

2:10:33Whether it's glasses, whether it's VR headsets, whether it's some wearable tech, whatever it is.

2:10:40But I have to say, it's like none of these seem to ever catch on as a mainstream thing.

2:10:45And I think that's because actually the phone and the computer are actually very good as they are.

2:10:50Yep.

2:10:51And like if you want to have a new computer or a new phone, I think I'm there.

2:10:55I'm there to like experiment with that.

2:10:57Like if Nintendo comes out and they have a new phone, I'm intrigued.

2:10:59I want to know what that's like, right?

2:11:01But if you're trying to develop something that is not either of these things because you believe that those things have already dominated the space, that you're trying to make this third thing, I don't think the third thing has ever proven to work.

2:11:13I think the iPad is not even really a third thing.

2:11:16The iPad is just an iPhone that's bigger, right?

2:11:18I do too.

2:11:19And I think at its best, that's what it is.

2:11:22Right.

2:11:23I think that in any kind of new field, there's often this weird, there's this initial period where a new thing is new and it's novel and everybody's trying to figure out the best way to make it.

2:11:34And there's a lot of innovation and a lot of dead ends are pursued, but they're exciting because you don't know it's a dead end until you get to the dead end.

2:11:41And it was exciting up until then.

2:11:43I mean, and the whole iPod is a great example of that.

2:11:46The whole iPod, in fact, turned out, the idea of an iPod turned out to be a dead end effectively.

2:11:52And I know that there's sort of a resurgence right now where people are buying old iPods.

2:11:56I mean, I think they're cool.

2:11:57I got a fucking iPod hi-fi on my desk right now in front of me.

2:12:02It's awesome.

2:12:03And, like, being able to put an iPod in there and just, like, scroll wheel my way, it's awesome.

2:12:06It's great, dude.

2:12:07You know who loved the iPod hi-fi?

2:12:09Steve Jobs.

2:12:10I know.

2:12:10It's great.

2:12:11Absolutely loved it.

2:12:12I got two of them.

2:12:13It's a long story, and I can't say exactly who told me this, but somebody who had a meeting in Steve Jobs' suite at, obviously, the old Infinite Loop office, but was going to have a meeting in a conference room outside Steve Jobs' personal office towards the end of, not at the very end,

2:12:32but towards the end of the late 2000s, and got to look inside his office.

2:12:37And for whatever, I don't think it was always there, but it was, like, after the iPod hi-fi was discontinued, there were 20 of them, he said, just stacked in his office.

2:12:47I do.

2:12:48I do feel like they're precious now.

2:12:50I'm very careful about that.

2:12:52He had this meeting where the nature of the meeting was such that he could not bring it up, and he'd never had a meeting directly with Steve Jobs before.

2:13:01I'm sorry.

2:13:02I think that's the first thing I bring up.

2:13:03I don't care what the topic of conversation is.

2:13:05I got to bring it up.

2:13:06That's so fun.

2:13:07All we could think, and he told me the story, and all we could think of is that Jobs loved

2:13:12it, didn't want to discontinue it, but the sales were bad, and he was like, all right, all right,

2:13:16we'll discontinue it, but bring me 20 of them.

2:13:19Yeah.

2:13:20And they're like, where do you want them?

2:13:21And he's like, just put them in my office for now.

2:13:24And this is when my friend saw them, but Steve Jobs loved the iPod Hi-Fi and had a stash

2:13:30of them in his office.

2:13:31I love that.

2:13:31That's the best.

2:13:32I don't have 20.

2:13:33I don't think I have room for 20, but I'm happy with the two iPods.

2:13:37But the whole thing was a dead end, ultimately.

2:13:38The iPod was a dead end, yes, yes, yes.

2:13:40Right?

2:13:40But while it was pursued, it was incredibly exciting.

2:13:44Okay, but like, is the iPod really, I mean, I know the click wheel iPod is long gone,

2:13:50right, but I think there is, look, I don't have kids, right, but I still am, like, I'm

2:13:58at a loss about what device kids are supposed to have, like, when they're not, quote, quote,

2:14:04old enough for, like, an iPhone, like, with cellular capability.

2:14:08I feel like the iPod Touch was the solution for that, and it was awesome.

2:14:12Like, it is a perfect solution.

2:14:13I mean, like, when I had an iPod, I was a child, right?

2:14:17I had an iPod as a child because I wanted to listen to music.

2:14:20And I had, like, a cell phone maybe later.

2:14:22You know what I mean?

2:14:23I didn't, so I...

2:14:25The iPhone is so good that it's even killing the notion of devices that you'd want for,

2:14:32and children is a perfect market where you might want to give them a standalone camera.

2:14:36I mean, it's true.

2:14:38Or a standalone music player, and you don't want to have not only a cell plan, but you just

2:14:43don't want them on the internet at all or something like that.

2:14:45But the iPhone is so good compared to every other standalone device, like a voice recorder

2:14:52or a camera or a music player that it kills it, and then you end up with kids with phones

2:14:59at an early age, and it's, well, what are you going to do?

2:15:01I mean, it's interesting.

2:15:01But anyway...

2:15:01But, well, I mean, why did they get rid of the iPod Touch?

2:15:03Do we fully understand that whole situation?

2:15:05Is it just not big enough of a market?

2:15:08Yeah, basically.

2:15:09That's crazy.

2:15:09I think it just wasn't selling enough.

2:15:11It is crazy.

2:15:12But it just really was.

2:15:13And as much as you can imagine that there were use cases for it, I think what effectively really

2:15:19happened, and it coincides with when it disappeared and when they started slowing the annual, it

2:15:25would only get updated every couple of years, and then it went away, is it happened at the

2:15:29point where all the parents were buying their second or third iPhone for themselves, and so

2:15:37they had old iPhones to give to the kids.

2:15:39And so I think what really killed the iPod, I think the main market for the iPod Touch, I think the

2:15:45main market was always kids, and the kids were getting hand-me-down iPhones, and so it just

2:15:50killed the market.

2:15:51But anyway, I would just say this.

2:15:53I think OpenA's eyes and Love From and I.O.'s appeal from Apple employees, I think it's

2:16:00different from hardware and software.

2:16:01I think from a hardware perspective, Apple's hardware is great, but they're not doing new

2:16:08things.

2:16:08They're shipping new laptops that look like the old laptops, and even the iPhone Air, which

2:16:14is the coolest new iPhone Apple has made in a long time, it's still just thinner, right?

2:16:19That's an engineering challenge, but it's not like they totally reinvented it, whereas

2:16:25under Steve Jobs 20 years ago, they were coming out with wacky new devices all the time, right?

2:16:32I don't know if that's a Steve Jobs thing or if that's just like a maturity of the industry

2:16:35thing.

2:16:36No, I think it was a Steve Jobs thing, and it gets back to that point I made like an hour

2:16:40or two ago about it being top-down back then and bottom-up now.

2:16:43And what comes bottom-up now is never, let's make an all-new device just for fun and see

2:16:51if it works.

2:16:52Like the EyeSight camera, right?

2:16:56Remember the cool FireWire EyeSight camera?

2:16:58It is, I forget where mine is, it's in my office somewhere.

2:17:02It's one of the best just things to look at and hold that I've ever had in my life.

2:17:06Yeah, it's just an incredible object.

2:17:09But we couldn't have that today.

2:17:12I mean, I guess you could because the Pro Display XDR still doesn't really have a camera on it,

2:17:17which is crazy.

2:17:18But I mean, it's possible that like, I mean, I don't know.

2:17:21Apple still makes HomePods instead of iPod HiFis, right?

2:17:26I don't know.

2:17:27I mean, they still do other devices, right?

2:17:30They have a bigger device lineup than they ever have.

2:17:33Yeah, but if you want to make all new devices, I feel like Johnny Ive has a better pitch for

2:17:38the hardware side than Apple has had lately.

2:17:40Well, yeah, maybe people see the definition of where Apple is and they're like, well, we

2:17:45know the bounds of where this ends.

2:17:48We know that we're not going to change too much of this product lineup and we know we're

2:17:52not going to make new products all that often.

2:17:54So maybe we need to go somewhere else.

2:17:56I get it.

2:17:57And I think on the software side, it was a largely frustration with, hey, Apple's software

2:18:03UI direction went to shit and I don't want to ship shit.

2:18:07I want to ship great UI software.

2:18:09So I want to go somewhere else to do it.

2:18:11And there really is just this dearth of competitors in the industry, not just in California, if you

2:18:21have to work in person, but just in anywhere in the world where, okay, I'm going to leave

2:18:26Apple and I want to go somewhere else where I'm going to do what I think is Apple at

2:18:31its, whatever era you personally think was the best era of Apple software UI design, where's

2:18:36the company now that's doing that work?

2:18:38I can't think of who that company is.

2:18:39I don't think, is there a company that's doing that?

2:18:42I mean, but I got to be honest with you, John.

2:18:43I don't think there is.

2:18:44Like when you ask that kind of question, I can't not think about Scott Forstall leaving

2:18:51Apple, whether it was like, and just being like, you know what?

2:18:54No, I'm done.

2:18:55I'm not doing that stuff.

2:18:56I'm going to go produce musicals or something instead, like whatever he does.

2:18:59I think that's a better situation for some of these people that are just like, well, maybe

2:19:03there isn't this anymore.

2:19:05I mean, we've seen it with people that are getting disillusioned from the tech industry

2:19:08in general.

2:19:08Just maybe this is not the place for me anymore.

2:19:11And I think there were people on the software side who just want to do exciting new top

2:19:16notch work that people will look at 20 years from now.

2:19:19I'm like, oh, remember that?

2:19:20That was awesome.

2:19:21Yeah.

2:19:22And it's love from IO, Johnny Ive, whatever else maybe made the pitch that you can do

2:19:28that here and you're not going to look at, you're not going to do that.

2:19:31Yeah.

2:19:31In so far as like making money, sure.

2:19:34As a job.

2:19:34Sure.

2:19:35I mean, I kind of wish that a bunch of those people just went and started their own individual

2:19:39companies and became independent developers or independent designers in some way and just

2:19:44expand it out.

2:19:44Because now they're all working under a new roof, but it's all under one roof again with

2:19:49one singular vision.

2:19:50And maybe that vision is good and maybe the product that comes out of it or products that

2:19:54come out of it are great.

2:19:55But you said it earlier that there's so many talented people that work at Apple.

2:19:59There are, there were.

2:20:00And I think all of them are capable of so much more than kind of the box they work within.

2:20:06And if the box I think is constraining, then I think maybe do something else, right?

2:20:13Instead of doing just that.

2:20:14I mean, if what you're looking for is making better software the way that it used to be, maybe

2:20:19that is the place.

2:20:20Maybe it's true.

2:20:20Yeah.

2:20:21So to close it up, my fear is that if people at OpenAI and systematically stole trade secrets

2:20:33to the degree that Apple is claiming that maybe they did, that this is the tip of the iceberg,

2:20:38and that this lawsuit could be so devastating to OpenAI's hardware endeavor that it never

2:20:44gets off the ground and it doesn't happen, I think that would be terrible.

2:20:46Man, catastrophic for like all of those.

2:20:50people that work so hard on it.

2:20:52Right.

2:20:52And I, and I know that I think here I'll disagree with John Syracuse who's like, ah, well, they'll

2:20:58just settle it.

2:20:58I don't think Apple has any interest in settling this lawsuit.

2:21:01Zero.

2:21:01If they have, if they have good evidence, I don't see any reason why they would.

2:21:05And if they, even if they don't have good evidence, but they think that evidence is there, there

2:21:10is no amount of money that OpenAI or any kind, well, how about if OpenAI came with an open

2:21:15checkbook and said, how many zeros do we need to add on a check?

2:21:18We'll give you billions of dollars, billions to settle this lawsuit.

2:21:22And you write the statement you would like us to say, to apologize.

2:21:27Apple's already got all the money in the world.

2:21:29That's not really-

2:21:30They've got all the money in the world and they don't care.

2:21:32They want the discovery.

2:21:33It's a principle thing, I think, at this point.

2:21:35And of like a retribution thing, to be honest.

2:21:38And I think that they would rather pursue this and see what else they can find.

2:21:43And there is, if you just think about it from a common sense level, there is sort of a, it's

2:21:52not just that Apple doesn't need more money, it's that you can only offer so much money.

2:21:57Yeah.

2:21:57You can offer too little.

2:21:58And then it's like, Apple's like, are you kidding me?

2:22:00That's too little.

2:22:02But if you offer a ridiculous sum of money, like I'll just say, it would be ridiculous

2:22:06if OpenAI said, we'll offer you $10 billion to settle this lawsuit, right?

2:22:13Which I would guess would be way more than any other similar settlement for this.

2:22:18It would immediately make, not just Apple, but anybody observing this thinking, wait a minute,

2:22:24what does OpenAI have to hide?

2:22:26$10 billion worth of a mistake or something that they're trying to cover up happening?

2:22:29Oh, a million percent, yeah.

2:22:31So even if Apple, or there are people at Apple who are like, well, if they just give

2:22:35us enough money, we'll just take it.

2:22:36Because this is a distraction for us too.

2:22:39But at a certain point, even those people at Apple who are like, I don't know if this is

2:22:43a good idea.

2:22:43If OpenAI offered enough money, they would be like, wait a minute, that's suspicious.

2:22:47Yeah.

2:22:48Right?

2:22:48Maybe we should pursue the discovery to see what else is there.

2:22:53So I don't think there is anything, anything that OpenAI can possibly do to settle this lawsuit

2:23:00before Apple is thoroughly satisfied that discovery reveals everything there is to be discovered in

2:23:08terms of iMessages and emails and any other activity or planning within OpenAI regarding

2:23:14how to get trade secrets out of ex-Apple employees.

2:23:19And my hope is that that discovery doesn't really reveal that much more than what this initial lawsuit says.

2:23:27That there was a rogue employee who was an idiot about sharing some stuff from it.

2:23:31And that's it.

2:23:32Yep.

2:23:32Crazy if true.

2:23:34I mean, this is all totally fine.

2:23:35And then there is a reasonable settlement and it goes on.

2:23:38And years from now, we just say, I remember that one time when there was six months where

2:23:41Apple was suing them.

2:23:42But if there is a lot of there there, Apple is going to shut this whole thing down.

2:23:48Yep.

2:23:48And I think that would be a travesty because it's the first company that I'm vaguely interested

2:23:53in what they do with a new consumer electronics computing device.

2:23:56And if it never even sees the light of day, I think that would be tragic.

2:23:59Yeah.

2:24:00Anyway, that's my take.

2:24:03Louie, it's been great having you back on the show.

2:24:05Thanks for having me.

2:24:06You've been very generous with your time.

2:24:08And it's always a pleasure talking to you.

2:24:10If there are this year, if there's any reason to dance on somebody leaving Apple at the end

2:24:15of the year, I will have you back on.

2:24:17Yeah.

2:24:17And I will invite you to the party.

2:24:19What else?

2:24:20What do you want to promote?

2:24:21We've got what's the domain name for Parakeet, your design?

2:24:24Yeah.

2:24:25So I run Parakeet.

2:24:26That's Parakeet.co.

2:24:28We make icons.

2:24:30That's what I do.

2:24:31I do it every day.

2:24:32And yeah, I live and breathe that.

2:24:33So I guess if anyone wants icons, or even if you just want to look at icons, that's where

2:24:38I would go.

2:24:39Yeah.

2:24:40And your excellent blog, which again, I'm going to get the domain name.

2:24:44I'll just say it.

2:24:44It's l-m-n-t dot me.

2:24:46It's Louie Mantia without the vowels.

2:24:48L-m-n-t dot what's the dot?

2:24:53Me.

2:24:53Dot me.

2:24:54Dot me.

2:24:54Yeah.

2:24:55That's really clever.

2:24:56Sort of similar to the Notion command line tool just being NTN.

2:24:59Ah, right.

2:25:00Just take out the vowels.