Podcast Search

The Talk Show

454: ‘Getting the Snack Right’, With Chance Miller

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00How are you doing, Chance?

0:00:01I'm excellent.

0:00:02How's the summer treating you?

0:00:04Not bad.

0:00:04It's when you texted me this morning asking if I could do the show,

0:00:08I was thinking, like, it's been kind of slow these past few weeks.

0:00:12We're in kind of the the doldrums.

0:00:14We don't have beta five.

0:00:17We're just kind of sitting on our hands, it feels like.

0:00:20Yeah, it's funny.

0:00:20I was on the that uh TBPN show, the the one that the open

0:00:26AI bought, and you know, it's like a YouTube thing.

0:00:29And they asked if the summer was busier than usual, and I kind of

0:00:33had to put on my well, I'm talking to people in the great in

0:00:37the greater tech world, it is a very busy summer because the AI thing

0:00:40is a mania that is continuing.

0:00:42In the Apple specific world, no, I would say.

0:00:48I mean, there is the added drama of the open AI lawsuit, which I

0:00:52do want to get to, but you know, that that isn't really a steady

0:00:58turn, right?

0:01:00I mean, that's the thing that's gonna play out for years and years, barring

0:01:03any surprising settlements.

0:01:04So you can dissect it for a few months at first, and then you

0:01:09have to wait.

0:01:10Yeah, it's like the Epic Games thing.

0:01:11We spent I think first time I was on the show, maybe we talked

0:01:15about Epic Games, and it's like, oh my god.

0:01:18I know it's it is a very odd measure of time, but I had

0:01:22a lot less gray hair when the epic thing started.

0:01:26And it's you know as slow as other things move, you know, and we

0:01:31all want everything that we're unhappy with to move faster.

0:01:34Nothing moves slower than the legal process.

0:01:37Nope.

0:01:37We'll get to that.

0:01:38But you did mention it's a good opening topic that uh even iOS 27

0:01:43is slow.

0:01:44And my friend Will Haynes, who I sort of, it's not like a commercial

0:01:50project, but if he he's he hit me, him and Craig Hockenberry from uh

0:01:55the icon factory are do Kotoba, which is a dictionary app for iOS.

0:01:59You could just KOTO, I'll put it in the show notes.

0:02:03But it's not in the App Store because it uses APIs that you're not

0:02:08allowed to use in an App Store app.

0:02:10So you if you want to use it, you have to like get it

0:02:12for it's open source, you get it from GitHub.

0:02:14Anyway, he's a friend.

0:02:15But for years and years and years, Will has at Will, I'll put and

0:02:19I'll put a link to this in the show notes too.

0:02:21His iOS version history, where he tracks the betas for I it I'm looking,

0:02:30it goes all the way back to iPhone OS, iPhone OS 2.0 and just

0:02:36tracks how many betas there were for each release.

0:02:41And it's uh like iOS 20, it it's so it's interesting, like the the

0:02:47point zero releases are obviously very different than the point one, point two point

0:02:52three releases because this is the big summer beta.

0:02:56It looks like Apple's only a little bit behind, but it feels to me

0:03:01like a lot behind.

0:03:01So right now, as we record, and again, there is no better way to

0:03:06guarantee that beta five will come out than me and you recording this.

0:03:10As you started talking, as you pointed to Will's website, it came out.

0:03:13Beta 5 is now.

0:03:14Did it really?

0:03:15Yes.

0:03:16As we're listening, that's late breaking news.

0:03:19Well, that's fantastic that it came out while we're recording.

0:03:23I actually made it happen.

0:03:25I jinxed it so hard that it came out.

0:03:28All right.

0:03:29Well, it it looks to me like beta five came out like third week

0:03:35of July last summer, and beta five came out for iOS 18 two summers

0:03:41ago, around the same week.

0:03:43So it looks like they're maybe like three weeks behind for a beta five.

0:03:49You know, I I don't know what the holdup is because overall, uh maybe

0:03:52that's the thing is that iOS 27's been pretty stable, but I also think

0:03:56iOS, I've been using them on my iPhone.

0:03:59I think beta four, the one that we've been stuck with since the very

0:04:02beginning of um July has been the worst of all of them.

0:04:07Yeah, I think so.

0:04:08I'm I don't know if you have it, but the most frustrating bug is

0:04:11you search for an app in Spotlight and none of the app icons show

0:04:15up, so it's just a bunch of blank.

0:04:16So you type like I in, wanting to get into get to Instagram.

0:04:21All the icons are blank.

0:04:22It's like app roulette.

0:04:23You just tap one and hope that the one you're tapping is Instagram, 'cause

0:04:26it's blank, you don't know what it is.

0:04:27So a lot of little things in beta four, I think.

0:04:31But it's impossible to know what the holdup is 'cause there are so many

0:04:35like factors at play with these, like maybe s like some of the engineering

0:04:39team like these teams are so small.

0:04:40If half the engineering teams just out of the office for a few days

0:04:44or they're focused on something else, then like yeah, you just push it a

0:04:47week.

0:04:47They're surprisingly flexible, I think, despite the fact that they are usually pretty consistent.

0:04:52What's your experience been like with the beta of 27?

0:04:56All in all, really good, I think.

0:04:59It's the obvious like Siri AI has been twofold.

0:05:04I think the new stuff that it can do with personal context, digging into

0:05:08everything on your phone, mail mail messages, reminders, wallet, all of that stuff has

0:05:13been remarkably reliable.

0:05:15But where I've started to have more problems, and it's weird because it started

0:05:18in the later betas, is where trying trying to do things that old the

0:05:24old version of Siri could do right nine point nine out of 10 times.

0:05:28So setting a timer, adding a reminder, adding something to your shopping list, controlling

0:05:29a home kit scene.

0:05:36At some point between like beta three and beta four, maybe there seemed to

0:05:41be a regression in how reliable those things were.

0:05:44And we heard about it some at the tech talk that you and I

0:05:47and many other members of the press went to at WWDC, where there's like

0:05:51that intermediary layer trying to determine which direction a request needs to go.

0:05:59And one example I've been using is like I'll say, add something to my

0:06:03shopping list, and it'll come back and say, you don't have a shopping list.

0:06:07Would you like me to create one?

0:06:09I do have a shopping list and it's there.

0:06:12And then so one time I said, okay, create the shopping list.

0:06:15And it said, I don't have the ability to create lists and reminders.

0:06:19It's like that that side of things is really buggy for me.

0:06:25I had one the other day where I needed to set a reminder to,

0:06:33well, I mean, I it's I'll just username.

0:06:36But we have a friend, we we got caught in a rainstorm, and a

0:06:39friend named Andrea let us borrow me and my wife's some umbrellas to get

0:06:45home in a thunderstorm, walk home.

0:06:47And I wanted to set a reminder to return her umbrellas.

0:06:52And I said, remind me to return the umbrellas to Andrea.

0:06:56And Siri AI on the phone said, was that Andrea?

0:07:02Andrea, you know, spelling the name different ways.

0:07:05Andre or it was like four different things.

0:07:09And I just said Andrea.

0:07:11And then it just asked again, was that Andrea, Andrea, Andre, or whatever?

0:07:17And I said, and I just took a different one.

0:07:19I just said, Andrea.

0:07:14It doesn't matter to me.

0:07:22Like whatever it said, I would know what it meant, right?

0:07:25It could spell, it could say Andrew.

0:07:27Yeah.

0:07:27And I would, I would know exactly what it meant.

0:07:29Umbrella to somebody whose name is vaguely start, you know, starts with A and

0:07:33D.

0:07:34And I went through this, it was like obviously caught in an infinite loop.

0:07:37And at the last one, I just said, you pick.

0:07:42And uh it actually that actually worked.

0:07:45And it did pick the wrong name, but it actually it actually worked.

0:07:49It made a decision.

0:07:50Yes.

0:07:51Which I thought was kind of interesting.

0:07:53Because I did I thought that you I thought this was stuck in some

0:07:56kind of loop.

0:07:57And I'm just un I'm unsure even of the ways that it breaks down

0:08:03now because it's so clearly ground up a new system, right?

0:08:08Like that that to me, that loop I got stuck in was all new.

0:08:12I don't remember that ever happening with Syria before.

0:08:15I remember it mishearing me.

0:08:16I remember saying I can't do that.

0:08:18I remember, you know, all sorts of other frustrations, but never repeatedly asking me

0:08:25Andrea Andrea Andre or whatever, and me saying one of them and then it

0:08:32just repeating the exact same question again.

0:08:34And being able to say you pick and having it work, that actually is

0:08:38kind of clever.

0:08:39I think one of the things they've done, and maybe they've toned it down

0:08:41a bit through the betas, but at least in beta one and two, the

0:08:46dictation model for Siri interactions seemed to be like hypersensitive.

0:08:49It did not ever want to assume what you were saying, and it thought

0:08:53if if there was like a 50% chance that it misheard you, it was

0:08:56going to ask you to clarify.

0:08:58Because my example of a very similar situation is I ask it for years,

0:09:03almost every day, what time do the Reds play tonight?

0:09:06Because I watched the Cincinnati Reds.

0:09:08And usually it's like some games are at seven 7:10, 6:40.

0:09:12Like just so I just want to know exactly what time does it start.

0:09:15In iOS 27, it started saying, Did you mean the Cincinnati Reds or the

0:09:20Boston Red Sox?

0:09:23And I would say I meant the Reds.

0:09:24And it would say Reds or Red Sox.

0:09:26And you have to put the Cincinnati in there for it to be confident

0:09:29enough just to tell me the score or tell me the time.

0:09:31Tell me the time.

0:09:32Yeah, or tell you which team.

0:09:33Yeah.

0:09:33Yeah.

0:09:34So one step or two steps forward, one step back overall.

0:09:39It is, you know, there's some.

0:09:42I know some people want to argue about comparing it to the frontier, which

0:09:48is, you know, it is a big part of today's tech news, is what

0:09:53the very latest fable and uh you know, whatever the chat GPT version numbers

0:09:58are capable of, which is so far beyond what we're talking about with Siri.

0:10:06Not even that saying that Siri is dumb, it's just that we're talking about

0:10:08just getting basic stuff right.

0:10:10It's just really is it's not even apples to oranges because they're both fruit.

0:10:15It is like comparing a whole meal to a snack, right?

0:10:18It's like, let's just get the snack right.

0:10:21I don't know.

0:10:21It is and it's good overall, but it it and it's definitely progress, but

0:10:26it is still sort of uh confusing at times.

0:10:30And to me, the baseline isn't like, hey, what ad super advanced stuff can

0:10:35you make?

0:10:35Can you have this make an entire app for you?

0:10:38Can it look at the source code for an entire Xcode project or a

0:10:42website and do stuff?

0:10:43Like Siri AI doesn't even try to do stuff like that.

0:10:46Put that aside.

0:10:47And to me, the baseline for what it should be able to do is

0:10:51if you hired a college intern, right?

0:10:54And if you have chance hired a college intern and you said, hey, I

0:10:58don't, I actually don't know.

0:10:59Do you live in the Cincinnati area?

0:11:02I live in Michigan.

0:11:03I grew up in Louisville, Kentucky, and everybody in Louisville is a Reds fan.

0:11:07So right.

0:11:08Right.

0:11:08But that's a very quick thing that a human being would learn about you,

0:11:13that your favorite team is the Cincinnati Reds.

0:11:15And if you just said to your human assistant, hey, every day tell me,

0:11:20you know, if I ask you, you know, just know I I, you know,

0:11:22because the times vary, you know, I don't know.

0:11:24Maybe they're playing out in California and it's going to be on at 10,

0:11:2610:30 at night.

0:11:27Yeah.

0:11:28And you said, what time are the Reds on tonight?

0:11:31to a human being.

0:11:32They would never in a million years ask you, you mean the Red Sox

0:11:36or the Cincinnati Reds?

0:11:38Like, that's just baseline.

0:11:40Yeah.

0:11:40And it's still kind of frustrating that Siri isn't getting to that baseline.

0:11:44Like the first time, sure.

0:11:47But that seems like something that it should be able to remember about you.

0:11:50Yeah.

0:11:51Part of the overall my time with iOS 27, there's is a like a

0:11:57psychological element, especially with the personal context stuff, because we've spent the last however

0:12:03many years thinking, well, if I ask Siri this, it's gonna bomb.

0:12:06It's not gonna like I'm not even gonna bother trying to ask it because

0:12:08I know it's gonna get it wrong.

0:12:10And throughout iOS 27, it's been like a mental training to be like, maybe

0:12:15I could ask it that and it'll get it right.

0:12:17And then you start doing that, it accurately responds to enough of your questions

0:12:21that you start to learn that it actually is quite a bit better than

0:12:25it used to be.

0:12:26But it's been bad for so long that at least for me personally, it's

0:12:30like I don't trust it yet.

0:12:29Or I didn't trust it at first.

0:12:34So in beta one and beta two, I wasn't using it as much as

0:12:37I could have because that mental model of thinking it was terrible took a

0:12:41while to overcome.

0:12:42And I think that's going to be a thing when it ships to everybody

0:12:44in September.

0:12:45Like there's not going to be a resounding response from iPhone users saying, wow,

0:12:50Siri is good.

0:12:50It's going to be like a trickle as people try things and learn that

0:12:53it's finally mostly quite a bit better.

0:12:56Yeah.

0:12:57I talked about that on a recent episode with Quinn Nelson, and we both

0:13:00have the same problem where it's the hardest part of testing it is remembering

0:13:03to use it.

0:13:04Yes.

0:13:05In the flow of daily life.

0:13:07Like when I'm actually actively thinking about it, you know, and like I'll install

0:13:12beta five when we're done recording this today, and I'll be thinking about it

0:13:15the rest of the day.

0:13:16But like just out and about in daily life, it just does not often

0:13:21does not occur to me.

0:13:22And I'll search for something the other way.

0:13:23And then afterwards I'll think, ah, I should have used Siri AI.

0:13:26And then I'll go and do it, not in the flow, you know, and

0:13:30just see, ah, and it even would have worked.

0:13:32But I I don't think of it.

0:13:34There is some learned behavior not to bother trying that is that they need

0:13:39to overcome.

0:13:41What else have you been using the apps, the actual Siri apps?

0:13:46I've used it on iPhone quite a bit.

0:13:49I I've kind of tried to replace my use of ChatGPT or Claude, just

0:13:53trying the Siri app.

0:13:54On Mac, not at all really.

0:13:59I don't think it's well enough integrated into Mac OS to really be useful.

0:14:03Yeah.

0:14:03And I think I think overall, because so part of German's reporting up to

0:14:09WWDC was like, will they, won't they make a standalone Siri app?

0:14:13And up until March or April, he was like, well, they're testing the models

0:14:14with a dedicated app, but they're probably not going to release it.

0:14:20And then it was like, okay, maybe they will release it then.

0:14:23Yes, they're releasing it.

0:14:24And I think that kind of shows him the quality of the app across

0:14:27iPhone and Mac, especially where it's very basic.

0:14:32I heard something, I mean, and you know, this is me dipping my toes

0:14:36ever so gently into the rumor game.

0:14:38I heard something at while I was out in California at WWDC that I

0:14:43don't want to go into detail much, but basically that part of the code

0:14:53and the project at Apple changed kind of remarkably close to WWDC.

0:15:00You know, that I don't know what I don't even remember exactly what month,

0:15:04but something like March or April that like it's like, hey, why don't we

0:15:11do it an app and somebody put one together and they're like, yeah, now

0:15:15you're in charge of Siri, and because this is a good idea, you know

0:15:19that um I'm not trying to make excuses for Mark German, um, but that

0:15:24I actually really do think in this case that actually was a a fairly

0:15:29significant change internally and I think so.

0:15:32And and to the surprise and possible consternation of people at Apple who were

0:15:38working on whatever they were going to use as the visual presentation layer at

0:15:42that point.

0:15:43Um, and I think it's a good idea, but I agree with you.

0:15:47It it just feels very thin, and nowhere does it feel thinner than on

0:15:51the Mac.

0:15:52You know, it just is like because and I can't use it day to

0:15:56day because I am still on my main work Mac still using Sequoia, so

0:15:59I don't get it.

0:16:02And I think often, but I am using it on my iPhone, and it

0:16:06I am going to it before I go to Chat GPT.

0:16:08And it is it is succeeding for so many of the things I've used

0:16:13Chat GPT for, and I don't miss it.

0:16:16It is slower.

0:16:17I notice when I go back to Chat GPT, like, oh man, chat GPT

0:16:22is a lot faster to respond.

0:16:23This feels like Chat GPT when I first started using Chat GPT two years

0:16:28ago.

0:16:28But I, you know, uh it's it's not too slow, it's just you know,

0:16:33and and if you're not used to if you're currently using chat GPT a

0:16:37lot or or Cloud or whatever else that's fast, you might look at the

0:16:43results of this and be like, I'm I'm not switching to this, it's slow.

0:16:46Whether you think the results are good or not, why why use the slow

0:16:49thing?

0:16:49But for all the people out there who haven't been using one on a

0:16:52regular basis, it's pretty good.

0:16:54And you know, you can trigger it from the side button on the lock

0:16:57screen.

0:16:57You don't have to unlock your phone, it is a huge convenience factor.

0:17:01Um, but when I'm at my Mac, and I often think, ah, I kind

0:17:05of wish I could use Siri AI on my Mac so I could continue

0:17:09testing it this summer.

0:17:10And then I do use Chat GPT classic, and I notice all the ways

0:17:16like the ways that it will attach itself to a BB edit window or

0:17:20to the current note in Apple notes, and I think I do not want

0:17:24to give this up.

0:17:25Like, yep.

0:17:26Same reason I don't want to, I'm not gonna switch to their stupid ass

0:17:29uh Chat GPT's super app that doesn't, you know, the super app that misses

0:17:34the best features of Chat GPT Classic.

0:17:37Uh, I'm gonna hold on to ChatGPT Classic as long as they will continue

0:17:41to let it be used, and it's not even the speed thing, it's the

0:17:44integration thing.

0:17:45It just doesn't.

0:17:44I don't know.

0:17:47But you know, hopefully, I I don't expect a lot between now and the

0:17:51fall when Mac OS 27 Golden Gate actually ships, but hopefully it is a

0:17:58you know major point of development after 27.0, you know.

0:18:04I don't know.

0:18:05I do applaud them for making the chat just a standalone chatbot app because

0:18:10it felt like if they weren't if the reason for not doing it felt

0:18:15like pride more than anything because they said all along they didn't want to

0:18:18make a chatbot app, but people want a chatbot app.

0:18:20I want a chatbot app app because typing to it is honestly the most

0:18:26natural way to interact with it, especially if you're just researching something.

0:18:30Yeah.

0:18:30And to like silo it all off, however, they were gonna do it without

0:18:33an app, I don't think would have made sense.

0:18:36Yeah, I do think, you know, so I do give them credit for that,

0:18:39you know.

0:18:40Uh turning, you know, doing effectively an about face, you know, and they've definitely

0:18:45managed to do it without saying that they're doing an about face, which I

0:18:51don't blame them for, and I would do if I were them in in

0:18:55charge of the messaging too.

0:18:57But I'm glad they did.

0:18:59And I I just feel it is the common sense of hey, chat is

0:19:05actually just a good interface.

0:19:08You know, it is why human beings spend so much time in text messaging

0:19:15with each other.

0:19:16It is a it is actually and it it's a thing that has stuck.

0:19:22It it's you know, I would say I started using what looks like a

0:19:26modern chat style interface back in the instant, we used to call it instant

0:19:30messaging days of iChat and the apps of that era.

0:19:35And it's effectively unchanged since then.

0:19:38It's just gotten technically better with syncing between devices and being always on instead

0:19:43of having to actually log in and being end-to-end encrypted with services like iMessage

0:19:48and WhatsApp and Signal.

0:19:50Um, but it's it's just a good interface that people get, you know, they

0:19:55understand it and it's simple.

0:19:58And you know, the the time-oriented nature of hey, uh new bubbles are at

0:20:04the bottom and you go keep scrolling up to go old, you know, to

0:20:09go back in time, it people understand it.

0:20:11And you're on this side and the person or thing, if in the case

0:20:16of a chat bot is on the right, it just works.

0:20:19And so I feel like if they had not done it and presented something

0:20:25else as the visual layer of it, it would almost certainly be worse and

0:20:30just for the sake of being different.

0:20:32And putting aside the technical limitations of the old Siri, it was just frustrating

0:20:38up until now that you couldn't go back.

0:20:40Like if you knew that yesterday you had had an interaction with Siri that

0:20:44answered a question and you've already forgotten the answer, not being able to go

0:20:49back and look at it and having to start all over again was super

0:20:52frustrating.

0:20:53And if you look at it from Apple's perspective and sort of not growth

0:20:58hacking, Apple doesn't need to growth hack anything, but if you want people to

0:21:02know that you're trying again and that Siri is different and better now, the

0:21:05best way to do it is to slap a Siri icon on their home

0:21:07screen for the first time.

0:21:08Yeah, yeah.

0:21:09They update iOS 27 and it's there.

0:21:11Yeah, I agree.

0:21:13You know, I think the other thing that maybe they tied themselves in knots

0:21:16wasn't um all these other companies that everybody is saying is ahead of us

0:21:22and that we're hopelessly behind, they're all doing chatbots.

0:21:25So we don't want to say we're doing a chatbot because then it looks

0:21:28like even more like we're catching up.

0:21:30So let's just say we don't think chatbots are a great interface, blah, blah,

0:21:33blah, blah, blah.

0:21:34I think the other thing they got they maybe tied themselves in knots over

0:21:37was the idea that having a chat transcript is a privacy problem.

0:21:44You know, that you might want to say things to Siri and not have

0:21:49a record of them.

0:21:51And I think they overthought that.

0:21:53I I think it is great that Apple thinks of privacy way at a

0:21:58way higher priority than I would say any of its peer companies.

0:22:02But in this case, what is the privacy violation?

0:22:06Like I've been thinking about it, you know, on that privacy front as I've

0:22:09used ChatGPT for years.

0:22:11Like I don't even trust OpenAI nearly as much as I trust Apple, but

0:22:15I do trust that my actual chat transcripts with ChatGPT aren't nobody else is

0:22:20going to read them, and nobody else has access to my devices.

0:22:23So how would they read them?

0:22:25And if somebody does get access to my devices, I've got bigger problems than

0:22:30them reading my Chat GPT transcripts, right?

0:22:34And I guess I haven't even looked.

0:22:36I'm presuming that if you don't want Siri transcripts, I'm sure there's a setting

0:22:40to turn it off.

0:22:41But I think the settings are the same as messages, which is delete after

0:22:4630 days, delete after 60 days, something like that.

0:22:48Yeah, something like that.

0:22:50Yeah.

0:22:50Which I, you know, it's great.

0:22:51I haven't said to save forever.

0:22:52What do I care?

0:22:53Honestly, you know, I feel like the security layer is that my phone is

0:22:56locked and people don't know my passcode, and I don't tell people my passcode.

0:23:00And you know, it's being too private, right?

0:23:03That's what I think.

0:22:59If you're if they were worried about that.

0:23:05And I think maybe they've just sort of realized, hey, what is the point

0:23:09of this?

0:23:09You know?

0:23:10What what is the point of worrying about the privacy here?

0:23:13We can do this and keep it private, you know.

0:23:14And and I would honestly say uh my personal chats in iMessage are way

0:23:21more have way more stuff that I would not want somebody else to read

0:23:24than my Siri interactions.

0:23:26So if you know, if you're allowed to keep an Apple encourages, I mean,

0:23:31they don't make it as easy as possible to search your old stuff, but

0:23:34it's there, why not?

0:23:36I saw an example on Threads or somewhere of somebody.

0:23:41I think people are gonna realize how much stuff is in their messages history

0:23:44because this person was used to Siri and iOS 27.

0:23:46They said, What's my social security number?

0:23:48Yeah.

0:23:49And it went and it found it in an old messages thread, like with

0:23:51their partner or something.

0:23:53Because you're exactly right.

0:23:54People will send and save just about anything in messages and they forget that

0:23:59it's there.

0:24:00You can surface that for better or for worse for some people.

0:24:03Yeah.

0:24:04And I guess if it uncovers something, you know, I mean, you'd have to

0:24:08ask for it for it to be uncovered, but if you discover, ooh, I

0:24:11wish that wasn't there, you know, you can delete an old text message, I

0:24:17think.

0:24:17Yeah.

0:24:17You know, I think that if you delete if it uncovers it and you

0:24:20tap it and it shows up, you can delete it and it's only deleted

0:24:24for you.

0:24:24Obviously, it's not deleted at the other end on the person you were corresponding

0:24:28with, but I think it deletes to all of your devices.

0:24:30I don't know.

0:24:31I mean, it's always been there.

0:24:32And and it it it is funny to think from a privacy angle that

0:24:36that because iMessage search has is still so bad, yeah.

0:24:40Um that people forget how much is in their archive.

0:24:44Um I've noticed that too.

0:24:47I guess at the last point on that point is that at WWDC, Apple

0:24:51made a big deal out of the fact that they have rewritten the search

0:24:55backend for mail, and say and kind of admitted, hey, mail search just kind

0:25:01of sucked for a long time, and you know, we knew it and we

0:25:04fixed it.

0:25:05And I think it is better.

0:25:07Um I I really do.

0:25:09I mean, I'm mostly amusing it on my iPhone because my main Mac is

0:25:13still running Sequoia.

0:25:15But it does seem like search is better, faster.

0:25:18And when I know I'm looking for a thing that is in my email,

0:25:22it does seem to find it.

0:25:24Um, the search in the messages app though is not updated.

0:25:29Um, and I asked about that.

0:25:32We had a briefing about the sort of snow leopard.

0:25:36Did you get that briefing?

0:25:37I think sort of yeah, yeah.

0:25:38It was sort of like here's how this is like they even said snow

0:25:42leopard, you know.

0:25:43I think they said iOS 12, which I didn't recall as a bug fix,

0:25:48let's fix underlying stuff year, but it and you know, I don't know.

0:25:52I don't really remember iOS 12 specifically.

0:25:54But I asked, hey, you guys said mail search is better, is messages search

0:25:59better too, and it got one of those Apple great Apple non-answer answers, which

0:26:05was like a smile, which said a lot, and a that would be something

0:26:11for us to look at in the future.

0:26:13Yeah, which is interesting because it seems like Siri AI for the personal context

0:26:18stuff, the hierarchy of where it's going to look for answers to your personal

0:26:22context, like messages is near the top.

0:26:24It might be number two to mail, but somehow they're they're doing it without

0:26:29having actually re-architected the actual search for users in the messages app.

0:26:35Yeah, well, and that is the the thing, and maybe because it is computationally

0:26:39expensive somehow, because it does take a while.

0:26:43But I have personally found this would be my tip for people listening.

0:26:48If you are looking for something in your messages, and the actual traditional search

0:26:54in the search bar in the messages app isn't helping you or is giving

0:26:58you so many results it's not helpful.

0:27:00Ask Siri AI and tell it to search in messages.

0:27:04You know, uh search messages for the time chance told me his social security

0:27:09number.

0:27:10And you know, which you've never done, or at least have not done yet.

0:27:14Yeah.

0:27:14But that works way better than searching the old fashioned way in the search

0:27:21field.

0:27:21And I can't can't really blame them for not making the search field a

0:27:25front end to Siri, because I I think that is it just is more

0:27:29expensive.

0:27:29I don't know if it's expensive locally.

0:27:31I don't know if it's going out to private cloud compute, but whatever it's

0:27:35doing, it takes long enough that you can tell it's um, but it it

0:27:38actually works.

0:27:39So it is sort of it is sort of weird that the built-in search

0:27:44is kind of crappy, but you can fix it by doing what seems like

0:27:49a very complicated or or should be an unnecessary workaround of going to Siri,

0:27:54but it actually does work.

0:27:56That's it's which is kind of unusual.

0:27:59All right, let me take a break here and thank our first sponsor.

0:28:03It is our good friends at Squarespace.

0:28:06Squarespace, man, what a long time great sponsor Squarespace has been for the talk

0:28:12show.

0:28:13Uh, it is the all-in-one platform for building your website or your presence on

0:28:14the web.

0:28:21And it is truly soup to nuts.

0:28:24I I say this every time that I talk about them on the show

0:28:27because they sponsored that I can't think of any aspect of having a website

0:28:31that Squarespace can't handle.

0:28:33Now, if you already have a domain name, that's fine.

0:28:36You can use it at Squarespace.

0:28:38But if you don't even have a domain name, you can register it at

0:28:42Squarespace.

0:28:43If you already have like a brand for whatever it is, like a business

0:28:48or if it's a restaurant or whatever, that you already have a brand, you

0:28:53can bring your brand and apply it to the design in Squarespace.

0:28:57If you don't, you can use Squarespace's design tools and the AI design tools

0:29:02if you want to make a start from scratch and have a whole template

0:29:07and branding and design right there in Squarespace.

0:29:10You can pick and choose which parts you do on Squarespace and which parts

0:29:14you uh bring in elsewhere.

0:29:16Um if you know CSS, HTML and JavaScript and stuff like that, you can

0:29:20get to the code in Squarespace and modify it however you want.

0:29:24And if you don't even know the difference between JavaScript and HTML and CSS,

0:29:28you don't have to worry about it and you never have to see it.

0:29:31It is both totally visual if you want it to be, or very low-level

0:29:35roll up your sleeves if you want it to be.

0:29:38Um it's just about everything.

0:29:41And like I always say, even if it's not for you, dear listener of

0:29:45the talk show, I just know that you, the nerds who listen to this

0:29:50show, are the people that everybody in your life comes to when they need

0:29:54things like a website for their business, like a consulting business or a, or

0:29:58like I said, like a friend who has a restaurant or something like that,

0:30:01or any kind of business.

0:30:03Uh they come to you and they're like, I need help.

0:29:59I need a website.

0:30:05Send them to Squarespace and give them the code for the show and it'll

0:30:08help help out this show.

0:30:10Where do you send them?

0:30:11Send them to squarespace.com slash talkshow.

0:30:15Squarespace.com slash talkshow and that code talk show T-A-L-K-S-H-O-W save you or your friend

0:30:23or whoever you send it to 10% off their first purchase which could be

0:30:27for up to an entire year at Squarespace.

0:30:30So squarespace.com slash talk show.

0:30:36What else?

0:30:37Did you the other breaking news that happened I knew about this because I

0:30:41was embargoed on it, but uh the embargo is apparently up.

0:30:45Live baseball and Vision Pro coming later this month.

0:30:48Yes.

0:30:49I was hoping we could talk about this.

0:30:51Yes.

0:30:52I'm very excited.

0:30:54They it is uh the first uh Friday night baseball with uh uh what's

0:30:59the word not interactive uh immersive immersive video and it is a game between

0:31:05my beloved New York Yankees and I think I might be an exhibition game

0:31:10with a uh a triple A team uh called the Boston Red Sox yeah

0:31:14excellent yep yeah exactly exactly right lots of Red Sox mentioned so far this

0:31:20episode unfortunately yeah four games total I think it's it's Red Sox Yankees Angels

0:31:25Pirates Padres Giants Giants Dodgers so if you're Jason Snell, you get your Giants

0:31:31in there twice, even though yeah yeah abysmal abysmal baseball team, but you can

0:31:36watch it immersively.

0:31:38I feel like it is not a coincidence that the first one though is

0:31:41Red Sox Yankees.

0:31:42Probably, and again, I am biased at least halfway.

0:31:45I mean, but everybody involved in that rivalry is biased only halfway.

0:31:50I think the best rivalry in baseball, possibly in U.S.

0:31:55professional sports, two teams that truly despise each other.

0:31:58Yep.

0:31:59Very, very exciting.

0:32:01And I think like a lot of things, and I don't know, maybe it's

0:32:04just the way, you know, because they're going as fast as they can, and

0:32:08whatever the hiccup has been to getting, you know, doing this in Vision Pro

0:32:14for live sports.

0:32:16Um even though they have Friday night, you know, we all I at least

0:32:20I thought, well, they have Friday night baseball rights.

0:32:22I kind of thought they'd get this going sooner than they did.

0:32:26And here it's you know, only starting at the end of August, so they've

0:32:29only they're only gonna have four games before the end of the season.

0:32:32But that's better than nothing, and maybe, you know, uh, you know, it's as

0:32:37fast as they could do it.

0:32:38And why wait till next year?

0:32:39Let's let's start this year.

0:32:41I mean, I remember the original Vision Pro demo at WWDC in what that

0:32:48have been 2024, I guess.

0:32:50One of the things in like that sizzle reel was I think it was

0:32:53a Red Sox game.

0:32:54Yes.

0:32:55You were sitting, I think, behind the dugout or in the dugout, or the

0:32:58dugout.

0:32:58Yeah, and that's on the first baseline, right?

0:33:01Yeah, I remember it.

0:33:02That is cool.

0:33:03And they did the NBA thing earlier this year with like the four or

0:33:07five Lakers games.

0:33:09Yeah.

0:33:09But that was it was really cool once you got to watch it, but

0:33:12that one had like the blackouts and the rights restrictions.

0:33:15Like you couldn't actually watch it live unless you lived in Los Angeles.

0:33:19So this is better from that perspective because if you have Friday night baseball,

0:33:23you can just watch it and you can watch it live, which is gonna

0:33:26be really cool.

0:33:27Yeah.

0:33:28They've got a Friday night uh game with the Reds at the Brewers on

0:33:29September 11, but alas, no uh no goggle icon next to that one.

0:33:38Um but this is very cool.

0:33:41I I I do I suspect that it's going to be like I I

0:33:47don't know.

0:33:48I'm reading the description here that it's sort of uh like I think it's

0:33:52gonna be like the the basketball games where they jump you around with your

0:33:56viewpoint, you know, that you don't get to you don't get to like pick

0:33:59a seat, you know, from the like let's say they put three seats and

0:34:03camera up three locations and you get to control it.

0:34:07I think they're gonna move you around.

0:34:09But uh I know my my dithering colleague Ben Thompson is particularly uh uh

0:34:14adamant that you should be able to stay in the same seat and you

0:34:18know control it yourself.

0:34:20But I'm just excited.

0:34:21I I don't want to complain of this that feels like uh looking at

0:34:23gift horse in the mouth.

0:34:25Yeah, I mean, this is this should be super cool.

0:34:27Um I mean, I would I really would watch triple A teams play immersively

0:34:31just to see it.

0:34:32The fact that it is Yankees, Red Sox, and uh if the season ended

0:34:36today, both teams would be wild card teams, I believe.

0:34:39Yep.

0:34:40Um, you know, it it's it should be, you know, what 18 days from

0:34:44now should be high both a high stakes game and a in a rivalry

0:34:48that's always feels high stakes.

0:34:50So awesome, awesome news.

0:34:52Yankees fans have it nice because they also did the stadium tour, the Yankee

0:34:57Stadium tour in immersive video.

0:34:59And that I mean, I don't like the Yankees, but that was a that

0:35:01was a fantastic immersive video kind of example.

0:35:04So yeah, it was.

0:35:06Uh, you know, I don't like the Dodgers, but I would love the same.

0:35:08I would love the same thing at the Dodgers at Dodgers Stadium.

0:35:11Yeah, I I would even take it at uh that rat infested shithole Fenway

0:35:16Park.

0:35:16I mean, honestly, you know, especially if they showed all the rats and stuff

0:35:19like that.

0:35:14That'd be great.

0:35:21Uh uh Vision Pro still alive.

0:35:26I love it.

0:35:27It still makes me laugh.

0:35:28It really does.

0:35:29Uh I guess we could parlay this into the next subject uh as a

0:35:33bit or segue.

0:35:34Um it still when I think about it, makes me laugh that they raised

0:35:40the price of Vision Pro by like the most token amount possible.

0:35:46Like it can't possibly be commensurate to the RAM in the device compared to

0:35:53it.

0:35:53It really to me was like somebody, you know, and I don't blame them.

0:35:58And again, I think I would have done the same thing where they were

0:36:00like, hey, we don't need to raise the prices, we're hardly selling any units.

0:36:04The RAM is just a it actually is a drop in the bucket compared

0:36:08to the overall four thousand dollar price tag of this thing.

0:36:11We don't need to raise the price.

0:36:13But I think they were like, yeah, but if we don't raise the price,

0:36:16people are gonna think that the product is dead, right?

0:36:19There's so many rumors that this is a dud that we're walking away.

0:36:22We want to make let people know we're you know, this is still a

0:36:26uh active product with a future ahead of it.

0:36:29If we don't raise the prices, you know, it looks bad.

0:36:33And so they raise the price like I don't know, five dollars or something.

0:36:37And the other thing I was thinking, like, are they still do you think

0:36:40they're still actively they can't still be actively making that many Vision Pros, like

0:36:45presumably they've made enough to satisfy demand right now.

0:36:49I would think so.

0:36:50I remember, and it it with the home with the original home pod, there

0:36:55was some uh sleuthing based on like the copyright dates on the boxes and

0:36:59the serial numbers.

0:37:03But you know, and again, Apple never confirmed it, but that there was some

0:37:06sleuthing that strongly suggested that there was only ever one production run of the

0:37:12original home pod.

0:37:13And you know, then when they stopped, it was and it's a kind of

0:37:18an unusual product line because they it wasn't dead, obviously, right?

0:37:23You can go to an Apple store now and buy a second generation home

0:37:26pod.

0:37:26But they had that in the works, but it wasn't ready to go and

0:37:30it wasn't out yet.

0:37:31But they I guess they ran out of original home pods, didn't want to

0:37:35make more of them, and so they had this uncomfortable we're not going, we

0:37:39you know, the home pod is no longer for sale, but it is not

0:37:42dead.

0:37:43And lo and behold, the new one did come out later.

0:37:47Um, and I can't help but think that Vision Pro is kind of like

0:37:50that, right?

0:37:50That yeah, they they made a bunch of them with the M5 or whatever

0:37:54the hell chip they updated it to, and it's you know, I I don't

0:37:58think they had to make many.

0:37:59So I whatever they you know again, the new prices of RAM probably you're

0:38:04right, chance probably aren't raising the price.

0:38:06I think it's really just a sign of life.

0:38:09And that same thing applies to the Apple TV, probably too.

0:38:11Like they're not I don't think they're still making new Apple TVs, like that

0:38:16they probably have what they need to satisfy that, and it's still got a

0:38:19$70 or something absurd, like $70 price increase, which oh yeah, it was crazy

0:38:25as a percentage, it was you know, and people aren't talking about it.

0:38:29I you know, we can get to the rumors, it's one of the other

0:38:32topics we can get to um, you know, on the show.

0:38:36But uh I I'm not hearing a lot of rumors about uh new Apple

0:38:41TV, but it feels like man, like if this isn't a price increase for

0:38:46new ones that are coming in September or October, boy, it makes no sense

0:38:51at all why they raised the price this much.

0:38:53Like Gurman's latest reporting on the Apple TV is I think he it's the

0:39:00same hedging that it's been for a while now, but ready to ship as

0:39:03early as September or October, I think he said.

0:39:06So maybe but all that's gonna be new is it's gonna have a faster

0:39:09chip.

0:39:09It's not anything dramatically different.

0:39:12Right.

0:39:13Uh which uh, you know, what could be different?

0:39:16I don't know.

0:39:16I mean, I the only thing I can think of that could be dramatically

0:39:19different is it wouldn't you wouldn't know it by looking at the hardware, but

0:39:23if they have a significant home uh, you know, this is your what do

0:39:28they call it, your home hub base station hub, your home hub.

0:39:33If it can suddenly do more interesting and useful things in the home hub,

0:39:38maybe.

0:39:39Uh, but any, you know.

0:39:43The segue would be to the ram crisis and the what the hell is

0:39:49going on.

0:39:49Okay.

0:39:50Right?

0:39:51Great way to put it.

0:39:52Um and I do feel like we just had last week, the week before,

0:39:59I forget, you know, I guess maybe it was eight days ago, but whenever

0:40:02Apple released their earnings, it's Tim Cook's last earnings.

0:40:06Was Tim Koch's last earnings as CEO.

0:40:10We are recording this on August 10th.

0:40:12I think it's gonna come out tonight.

0:40:13So, you know, August 10th.

0:40:14Um, we're 21 days out from uh John Turnus taking over as CEO on

0:40:21the first of September.

0:40:22Uh it is the very end of Tim Cook's tenure as CEO.

0:40:27He very obviously, both both just observing and taking his public statements at their

0:40:35at his word, wanted to hand things make this the best and easiest and

0:40:42most seamless transition ever.

0:40:44No drama, right?

0:40:45And there it really hasn't been, right?

0:40:47There's no German doesn't have any reports of any, you know, kind of upset

0:40:51within the executive ranks or anything like that.

0:40:54It seems like there was no drama, or if there was drama internally, it

0:40:58was entirely self-contained, you know.

0:41:00No drama internally, broad public support.

0:41:05I haven't seen anybody on the technical side, people who are just fans of

0:41:09the company or the investor side who is like, hey, what the fuck is

0:41:13up with this John Turnus, you know.

0:41:15You know, and he's left the Turnus with record, uh, record another record quarter.

0:41:22Everything is good except for the Ram thing.

0:41:25Yeah.

0:41:26And there's nothing Tim Cook can do about it, right?

0:41:28And if there's nothing Tim Cook can do about it, there's nothing anybody can

0:41:31do about it because if anybody could navigate the situation, it would be him.

0:41:36Yeah.

0:41:38The latest I'd link to a thing today that both the New York Times,

0:41:41it seems and it seems to me like can't be a coincidence that the

0:41:44New York Times and the Wall Street Journal both had fairly similar reports about

0:41:50Apple sort of uh lobbying the the federal government here in the US to

0:41:57get permission or a blessing.

0:41:59It's it's unclear whether they would need a legal exception or just like a

0:42:05blessing, like, hey, this is okay because it's technically legal, but we don't want

0:42:11to cross a political line to use Chinese-made RAM, even if only for devices

0:42:14that are sold within mainland China itself.

0:42:21But Apple tried that back in 2022 for other reasons before this crisis, I

0:42:25guess for cost savings or just to, you know, they like to have as

0:42:29many suppliers as possible.

0:42:30And the this is for multiple reasons, sort of a political red line, and

0:42:36one of the ever more increasingly rare things that is bipartisan here in the

0:42:42U.S.

0:42:43That both Democrats and Republicans alike are sort of like, hey, Chinese-made RAM is

0:42:48a bad idea.

0:42:49And it's not for a security, as far as I know, it's not a

0:42:52security thing that, hey, if you put Chinese RAM in a device, somehow the

0:42:57Chinese have a backdoor to devices.

0:43:00Because RAM doesn't have communication ability.

0:43:03That does not have RAM works.

0:43:05It's really, I as I understand it, just a hey, we don't RAM is

0:43:10such a crucial component.

0:43:12We don't want to give China any kind of leg up in the long-term

0:43:18supply chain for RAM in the world.

0:43:21This it's a bad idea.

0:43:23And in other areas of computing and components where China does have this position,

0:43:31it has played out poorly for the West geopolitically.

0:43:36And so let's not give them RAM too, basically.

0:43:39And Apple apparently the reports today are that Apple is still, because of this

0:43:43crisis, trying to take a second crack at getting permission slash blessing to use

0:43:48Chinese-made RAM and even in China.

0:43:51And both the Times and Wall Street Journal reports, they didn't have any names,

0:43:56but they seem to suggest that politically speaking, uh, the answer is still no.

0:44:02And more interestingly, both suggested that even if they Apple did get the permission,

0:44:07it actually wouldn't help them very much because apparently the Chinese made RAM is

0:44:11all sold out through the end of 2026 anyway.

0:44:14I don't get if if that part of it's true.

0:44:18Apple's original strategy was let's get permission from Trump or the Trump administration.

0:44:23Right.

0:44:24And then they would do it despite the fact that they would get blowback

0:44:27from both parties.

0:44:29Or were they hoping that if Trump said yes, the Republicans would fall in

0:44:33line and they'd support it, but the Democrats would push back against it still,

0:44:37and Apple can live with that.

0:44:39But now if they're gonna go through all of that those hurdles and headwinds

0:44:42and whatever, and it's not solved the problem.

0:44:45I don't like what what's the point?

0:44:48Yeah, I don't know either, right?

0:44:50You know, and again, part of this crisis is it's not just oh, and

0:44:55again, Apple did have to raise or they said they had to, but I

0:44:59you know, I I think in some sense they did have to, and other

0:45:04than by taking a severe hit on their own margins.

0:45:08They needed to raise prices.

0:45:10They raised prices on all products other than what, the iPhone and Apple Watch,

0:45:15I think.

0:45:16AirPods, yeah.

0:45:17And AirPods, which possibly aren't affected, right?

0:45:20I don't know.

0:45:21I mean, they have some kind of memory in them, but maybe actually are

0:45:24not affected by this particular crisis, AirPods.

0:45:27Um, presumably they didn't raise the iPhone and watch prices because they're just waiting

0:45:32till the actual new devices uh in a month.

0:45:36Um and you know, uh, I guess I don't know.

0:45:41It it is kind of curious strategy-wise, because then I would if that's what

0:45:47they're doing, and there was a room.

0:45:48Do you see that?

0:45:49There was a rumor over the weekend that maybe they were going to raise

0:45:51prices on the iPhone 17 and 17 Pro today, which didn't happen, or at

0:45:56least hasn't happened while we're recording yet.

0:45:58Maybe we can make that happen right now.

0:46:01Yeah.

0:46:01Because strategically you could think, well, why not raise the prices now?

0:46:05And then we uh when they announce the iPhone 18 Pro and the But

0:46:10maybe everything is so out the door because they're gonna do this iPhone folding

0:46:16ultra that's even before this was going to have supposedly going to have a

0:46:23very high price because these folding screens are so expensive and all the other

0:46:26competing folding phones are like close to $2,000 or more than $2,000.

0:46:33And so whatever they raise the price of the iPhone 18 Pro 2, it'll

0:46:37look good compared to that.

0:46:38Yeah, I don't know.

0:46:39I think that if they're going to raise iPhone prices, they should have and

0:46:43probably would have just done it when they did everything last month.

0:46:46Because if you if you look at it from a public reception point of

0:46:50view, I think lumping it all in together and doing it all at once

0:46:54is better and getting through that one cycle than doing all that, letting the

0:46:58chatter about that die down, and then six weeks later say, actually, we're also

0:47:02gonna make the iPhones.

0:47:03Yeah, the current iPhones, not even the new iPhones, the current iPhones, 100, 200

0:47:08more expensive.

0:47:09Yeah.

0:47:10Uh so but I guess the other wild card on that iPhone pricing thing

0:47:14is okay.

0:47:15So we're expecting iPhone 18 Pro and the iPhone Ultra slash folding, whatever they're

0:47:20gonna call it.

0:47:21But I don't know, I don't know.

0:47:22I'm I it it just makes sense they would call it Ultra.

0:47:25But yeah, I don't want to imply that I've heard anything, and that's just

0:47:27a guess.

0:47:28But everybody's sort of centered on the same guess.

0:47:30Um are they going to raise price and the rumor is that the regular

0:47:36no adjective iPhone 18 is not going to come out till next March or

0:47:41so alongside the 18E and possibly a second generation iPhone Air, um, that they're

0:47:51just permanently going to a hey, the E and the regular phones will come

0:47:56out early the next year, and only the high-end pro and ultra phones will

0:48:01come out in September.

0:48:03But will they raise the prices on the iPhone 17 in September a month

0:48:08from now in September?

0:48:10Yeah.

0:48:11I don't know.

0:48:13Well, historically, if you think about it on the old cycle, so when they

0:48:17when they announced the iPhone 17 lineup last September, they kept selling the 16

0:48:22but knocked it down 100 or 200.

0:48:26So if this cycle alongside the 18 Pro introduction, typically they would introduce the

0:48:33base 18 and then the base 17 would stay around and go down a

0:48:36hundred to two hundred dollars.

0:48:39So if you're looking at it from that schedule, just keeping the prices the

0:48:44same this year is technically better than most years for the for that base

0:48:4817 phone.

0:48:49Right.

0:48:49But it does create if the 18 Pro and Pro Max are 200, 300

0:48:55more expensive, the gap between the base 17 and the flagship 18 Pro.

0:49:01Like that's gonna be a well, like a $700 gap at that point.

0:49:05So I think they could just raise the prices for the 17 and get

0:49:09away with it.

0:49:10That's what I I sort of think that they'll do, you know, because I

0:49:13don't think they want to make the 17 look more appealing compared to a

0:49:18brand new 18 Pro, right?

0:49:20Like if somebody is out there and just you know, a normal or closer

0:49:24to normal human being who doesn't follow 9 to 5 Mac on a regular

0:49:29basis and is just vaguely waiting until September or October, and then sees that

0:49:34the iPhone 18 Pro has a whoa, that is more expensive.

0:49:38And then hey, the iPhone 17 is like six hundred dollars less or whatever,

0:49:42seven hundred dollars less.

0:49:44I'll just get that.

0:49:45I've been waiting and I'll just get that.

0:49:47I don't think that's what Apple wants.

0:49:49So I think that they would raise the prices then to sort of keep

0:49:52you know, establish the new pricing tiers of these 100 gaps between 100 to

0:50:00200 gaps between phones.

0:50:03But I don't know.

0:50:04I mean, I feel like everything's off the table at this point.

0:50:06You know, it's just it's just all uncharted territory.

0:50:10What else?

0:50:10It I guess the the other weird thing about the RAM crisis is just

0:50:15that it's not just a normal supply-demand thing, like oh, now they're more expensive

0:50:20and you pay the higher price and you could just get as much of

0:50:23it as you want.

0:50:24It's it just feels like no matter what you're willing to pay, there's it's

0:50:28like they're sold out, right?

0:50:29It's yeah, the the rumor, I don't think it's confirmed, but I get the

0:50:33big three non Chinese RAM companies, Micron, Samsung, and I think it's SK Heinex

0:50:39in there.

0:50:40Yes, something like that.

0:50:41Yeah, supposedly they've sold out their future comp they're completely sold out of their

0:50:47production runs for 2027, right?

0:50:51Yeah.

0:50:52Now, presumably Apple is part of that.

0:50:55Right.

0:50:56That the yeah, I mean, it's almost certain to some degree.

0:50:59Now, are they like, uh, you know, I guess we're good.

0:51:02But I, you know, a big part of the earnings call last week with

0:51:06Tim Cook was that part of the reason they're facing a crunch is that

0:51:12Mac and iPhone sales are significantly up year over year, right?

0:51:16That they do lock in orders to some degree based on their projected sales.

0:51:23And Tim Cook said something more or less, you know, and we we projected

0:51:27strong sales.

0:51:28We weren't thinking sales would be weak, and they are strong, and that's why

0:51:32we're caught flat.

0:51:33It was we thought sales would be good, but they are really, really good.

0:51:37It was like 22% up for the Mac and 29 for the iPhone, or

0:51:40maybe the other way around, but you know, somewhere around 25% up year over

0:51:44year for Mac and iPhone, and they just did not lock in that kind

0:51:49of RAM, and there is no RAM to buy at any price to fill

0:51:54the need.

0:51:54It's unprecedented.

0:51:57He called it a demand forecast issue, I think was his term.

0:52:00And if there was ever a bad year to really mispredict how many phones

0:52:06and Macs you thought you were gonna sell, it's this year.

0:52:09Because any other year, they just go and say, Okay, we need 30% more

0:52:12RAM for the iPhone, 30% more RAM, and they get it.

0:52:14Like they say jump, the suppliers say, Okay, how high?

0:52:17That is not the case this year, and it's really coming back to bite

0:52:20them.

0:52:20Yeah.

0:52:21And what was the story?

0:52:22Did you see the story about the um it's it's affecting the TSMC production

0:52:27of the chips?

0:52:29Yes.

0:52:30As I recall, it is basically, you know, they have to, because of the

0:52:35system on a chip, everything's integrated.

0:52:38You can't just do can't print the wafers and then stick the RAM on

0:52:46when it's done.

0:52:46It has to be there at a at a production level.

0:52:44Yes.

0:52:50And it's it is halting production of the actual chips because they don't have

0:52:54the RAM part to put on the system on that chip.

0:52:56Yeah, it was from Tim Culpen who and he so the A20 Pro, the

0:53:00chip for this year's phones, is going to use TSMC's wafer level multi-chip module

0:53:06or WMCM.

0:53:08And like you said, that's where the RAM is integrated and packaged alongside the

0:53:13chip itself.

0:53:13And what Culpin said was they have $1 billion in A20 Pro chips sitting

0:53:20there that they can't do anything with because they don't have the RAM to

0:53:23go along with those chips yet.

0:53:25And his kind of takeaway was the iPhone 18 Pro could be, probably will

0:53:32be super hard to find when it comes out.

0:53:34It will be announced and released on schedule like we anticipate, but it'll be

0:53:39the hardest iPhone to get at launch in a while.

0:53:43Because again, it goes back to if any other year they had decided to

0:53:46implement this new wafer level multi-chip module technology, it'd be fine because they have

0:53:51plenty of RAM.

0:53:52But they picked this year, and this is the year that the RAM Mageddon

0:53:56is happening.

0:53:57Yeah.

0:53:57And it's been a couple of years since there was a new iPhone that

0:54:01was literally hard to buy.

0:54:03Um I know with the iPhone 10, it it like didn't even come out

0:54:10till November.

0:54:11So it was like they did the September announcement and announced it alongside the

0:54:15iPhone 8, and we got to see it in the media, but then it

0:54:18didn't come out.

0:54:19And even the review units didn't come out until November because they don't like

0:54:24giving review units more than 10 days before products come out.

0:54:28You know, so that in some sense was a supply issue where there was

0:54:32literally zero supply.

0:54:34But I guess I I can't remember the last time there was like, hey,

0:54:40you know, some people who got their pre-orders in right when the pre-orders opened

0:54:45are gonna get their iPhone 18 Pro on launch day, but an awful lot

0:54:50of people are gonna, you know, and presumably right when the pre-order, if this

0:54:54is true, when the pre-orders open, people, you know, I don't know, half an

0:55:00hour too late, or people who are just later in the day, or people

0:55:03I don't know how how severe this will be, but people who like ordering

0:55:09at a time of day when the pre-orders launch, who in the last handful

0:55:13of years would still get their new iPhone on launch day, are gonna see

0:55:18like two to three weeks or four to six weeks, or who knows, you

0:55:22know, what it's going to say.

0:55:24We don't quite know, but I kind of believe it.

0:55:27You know, it's not just that Tim Culpen is a pretty good reporter, it

0:55:31just feels like this crisis is industry-wide, and there's literally it's just outside Apple's

0:55:37control.

0:55:37What are they gonna do?

0:55:39Yeah, every year.

0:55:40I think it's it's it's probably you who you say you wake up on

0:55:43well past when pre-orders start every iPhone launch day.

0:55:45Yeah, and you still get one on it, still comes on launch day for

0:55:48you, even though you ordered it at two in the afternoon or whatever.

0:55:50You might have to set an alarm that day to order my time.

0:55:55But the last time I can remember this, anything like this wasn't even at

0:56:00an iPhone launch window.

0:56:02I want to say it was the iPhone 12 Pro going into the holiday

0:56:07season of 2020, where Apple had they like issued an actual state, like an

0:56:13update to investors saying we can't make enough phones because the factories in China

0:56:14are shut down because of COVID.

0:56:22That's the last time I can remember.

0:56:23And that wasn't when the 12 was released.

0:56:26That was two months later because when they released the phones, the factories were

0:56:30up and running, and then COVID got worse.

0:56:34Yeah, I do I vaguely remember that.

0:56:35I'll try to find that and put it in the show notes.

0:56:37Um and again, overall, though, I remember thinking earlier in 2020, like, oh, who

0:56:43knows?

0:56:44Maybe there won't even be a new iPhone this year.

0:56:45Like this is so, you know, 2020 was a bananas year, especially around April,

0:56:50May, into June.

0:56:52Uh, and overall, Apple navigated that uh almost remarkably well.

0:56:58Um it's uh I don't know, but this, you know, and again, if this

0:57:04turns out not to be that big a deal, you know, if it's like,

0:57:07oh, whatever happened to like we, you know, it's come December and it, you

0:57:12know, the iPhone 18 Pro availability is more or less like 17 Pro and

0:57:1616 Pro were the last few years.

0:57:18We'll be like, hey, what about that report over the summer that they were

0:57:21gonna be back ordered?

0:57:21I wouldn't be surprised if any company can pull it off and still manage

0:57:25to keep up with it.

0:57:26It's Apple, but I don't know.

0:57:28I feel like this this could be the year to really set the alarm

0:57:32for for pre order day.

0:57:34It wasn't the 12 Pro, it was the 14 Pro.

0:57:37Uh in 20.

0:57:38It's I can't imagine COVID shutting down things in 2022.

0:57:44That's such a no that it affected that many launch cycles for Apple is

0:57:48hard to remember.

0:57:50I don't know.

0:57:50All right.

0:57:51So, well, I'll I'll look for that in the show notes.

0:57:54All right, let me take another break here and thank our next sponsor.

0:57:57It is our good friends at Factor.

0:58:00Factor makes chef crafted uh dietitian designed, ready-to-eat meals so that you don't have

0:58:09to choose between real food and convenience.

0:58:13These are not meal kits where you get a box full of ingredients that

0:58:17you need to put together.

0:58:18Meal kits are great.

0:58:20I like those too.

0:58:21But factor, you get whole meals, entire meals that are fresh and they are

0:58:27shipped cold, you know, with like dry ice in the box.

0:58:30Um, but the whole meal is sort of self-contained in a little container.

0:58:34You put it in a microwave, cook it according to the instructions, and you

0:58:37know, within not like 30 minutes, but like, you know, three or four minutes

0:58:42of taking it out of the refrigerator and putting it in a microwave, you've

0:58:46got entire meal uh right there, and it is really good food.

0:58:50They have over a hundred and seventy-five band ingredients, things that factor doesn't not

0:58:58put in their meals.

0:58:59Every factor meal is designed around what supports a healthier lifestyle and nothing that

0:59:06doesn't.

0:59:06These are fresh ingredients, good ingredients.

0:59:09Um, and they're all almost all ready in two minutes of microwave time with

0:59:15no prep and no cleanup.

0:59:16It's all self-contained.

0:59:18So even on days when you're super busy or you're in a rush for

0:59:21breakfast, and breakfast are some of my very favorite meals from Factor.

0:59:25Um, eating well is still achievable.

0:59:28And every week when you sign up for Factor, they have over a hundred

0:59:33menu items to choose from.

0:59:34And it varies, it's not the same hundred ones every every week, but there

0:59:38are over a hundred every week.

0:59:41And it's not overwhelming because they're grouped into categories like breakfast or proteins or

0:59:44something like that.

0:59:48So you can kind of zero in on the ones you want, but there

0:59:51is a huge number of great options that you will find.

0:59:55Some of the newest ones that they wanted me to tell you about salmon

0:59:59burgers.

0:59:59They have shredded pork, collared greens, and more.

1:00:03Plus add-ons that they're really, really excited about, like pumpkin flavored cheesecakes.

1:00:08Ooh, and uh protein shakes.

1:00:1197% of the users of factor agree that it helps them live a healthier

1:00:16life.

1:00:16That's a poll result that they did amongst their users.

1:00:19Really, really good.

1:00:20I love the breakfast stuff best.

1:00:22All of it's good.

1:00:23I love it for lunch.

1:00:24I love the breakfast stuff.

1:00:26Uh, really, really good.

1:00:27It's so much easier than actually making something or leaving to go get something.

1:00:32Um it's really good.

1:00:34I I really like the food from Factor.

1:00:36It's it's it's just good.

1:00:39So let's eat real.

1:00:41Head to factor meals.com slash talk show 50 off.

1:00:47And the 50 there is five zero.

1:00:49That's factor meals.com slash talkshow 50 off and use that code talk show50 off

1:00:57to get guess what?

1:00:5950% off and one free breakfast item per box for one year while supplies

1:01:04last until October 31st, 2026.

1:01:08That's code talkshow 50 off at factor meals.com slash talkshow 50 off at factor

1:01:15meals.com.

1:01:16See website for more details.

1:01:20Do you want to want to put your lawyer hat on?

1:01:22I'll put my tie on.

1:01:23Let's do it.

1:01:25Uh so uh Apple filed the lawsuit against uh OpenAI and I.O.

1:01:35Um, I guess at the beginning of July?

1:01:38I forget.

1:01:39Uh and OpenAI's only response was some pretty weird PR statements of we don't

1:01:45have any interest in other people's IP uh or trade secrets.

1:01:50And then Apple filed before OpenAI filed a legal response.

1:01:57OpenAI uh Apple like got a second shot in.

1:02:00They filed their request for a preliminary injunction.

1:02:05Um then in immediate response published, I think, a very ill-considered blog post that

1:02:13was kind of confusing, even.

1:02:16But then their law firm uh filed their request to dismiss the website.

1:02:24And that was a good read, and they have very good lawyers, and that's

1:02:28where we stand.

1:02:29So Apple is saying they need to pre they want an emergency preliminary injunction

1:02:33before the trial date, I think is October 1st, or the first trial.

1:02:37They're saying this is so severe, and we're our trade secrets or will be

1:02:42so hurt forever if they're allowed to proceed that we need an injunction against

1:02:46them right now.

1:02:48And OpenAI is like their lawsuit is such nonsense that it should just be

1:02:52dismissed out of hand.

1:02:54I think that catches us up on the high level.

1:02:57Yeah.

1:02:58The Apple request for a preliminary injunction, like what they say is the harm

1:03:03is happening now, and every day that passes without an injunction allows OpenAI to

1:03:07embed their knowledge of Apple's stolen information into its hardware development efforts.

1:03:12And then as part of that, in a separate filing, they also filed a

1:03:16motion to expedite discovery.

1:03:19And they want OpenAI to hand over the documents sooner.

1:03:22They want to be able to depose OpenAI employees and executives sooner.

1:03:27So they're not like I know at the start of the show we said

1:03:32legal cases kind of take a while and they drag out, but Apple's trying

1:03:35to hit the ground running on this one.

1:03:36Right.

1:03:37Right.

1:03:38And you know, everything does move slowly in the legal world.

1:03:42And so we're, you know, this happened, you know, at the very end of

1:03:45July, and the trial date is set for October 1st.

1:03:49So really it's just August and September in between what's already the trial date.

1:03:54But, you know, uh at least for the discovery, I could certainly see Apple's

1:03:59desire for that.

1:04:00Like, I do not think I mean, and the way uh lawyering works is

1:04:08you, you know, you say, you know, uh a hundred percent, I say zero

1:04:16percent, you know, and somewhere in the middle, if there's going to be some

1:04:22kind of settlement, it's somewhere in the middle.

1:04:25But the, you know, as the lawyer, you you start with asking for everything,

1:04:30or the other side asking for the other everything, right?

1:04:35So who's clo who's going to get closer to what they're asking for?

1:04:40Uh I I don't see Apple getting the preliminary injunction, and I'm not quite

1:04:46sure what that would mean, even.

1:04:48I honestly don't know what they're looking to to shut down.

1:04:53It's unclear.

1:04:54Like, are they saying that Tang Tan's uh employee badge should stop working and

1:04:58he can't come to work in the meantime until the trial?

1:05:01I I I really don't know.

1:05:03The request for expedited discovery, though, I could see being granted.

1:05:07You know, that okay, let's get the let's get this process started and an

1:05:12agreed upon framework for what each side is going to have to disclose to

1:05:17the other.

1:05:18In the filing for the preliminary injunction, Apple outlined the five things that it

1:05:24at it once, which is stop accessing or using Apple's confidential information, halt ongoing

1:05:29user disclosure, preserve evidence, allow forensic inspections of devices, and allow Apple to search

1:05:35OpenAI system for Apple confidential information.

1:05:39And Apple said that OpenAI agreed to the first three of those.

1:05:43So stop using the information, stop the disclosure and preserve the evidence, but it

1:05:48would not allow the forensic inspection or let Apple search through all of its

1:05:53systems.

1:05:54Right.

1:05:55And translating that into normal talk, it's because they're saying we don't have any

1:05:59of your trade secrets.

1:06:01So yes, we will stop using the things that we don't have.

1:06:05And then the parts that are let us come in and look to see

1:06:08that you really don't have them, they're like, no.

1:06:10Yeah.

1:06:11If they don't, right?

1:06:13In one scenario where they literally do not think they have any Apple trade

1:06:17system uh secrets on their devices or their networking systems, I still don't blame

1:06:23them in that scenario for saying, no, we're not letting you come in here

1:06:26and inspect this.

1:06:27We didn't do anything, right?

1:06:29You know, it's w if you if if I tell you, chance, uh uh,

1:06:36you know, give me, you know, give me back the wallet you stole from

1:06:39me, and you have not stolen my wallet, you're not gonna let me come

1:06:43into your house and like search for my wallet.

1:06:45Because you didn't you you didn't steal it.

1:06:48You know.

1:06:48So I I you know, there is no, hey, if they have nothing to

1:06:52hide, why don't they do this?

1:06:53I don't blame them.

1:06:54You know, it's like, and if they did, if they're worried, because they do

1:06:58think, hey, maybe we did some sketchy things here, well then obviously they don't

1:07:02they don't either way they don't want to concede those points.

1:07:05And I think Apple knew I uh there's no way that they were gonna

1:07:08get agreement on those last two points.

1:07:10Either way.

1:07:11Yep.

1:07:12You know, I I guess the three possibilities is open AI really thinks they

1:07:16did there's no there there and they didn't do any of this.

1:07:19Apple AI uh open AI knows that they've got some uh some sketchy stuff

1:07:24that hey that doesn't look good, or somewhere in the middle where they're like,

1:07:27ooh, we don't we're not sure, maybe.

1:07:30Any one of those three, there's no way that they're going to want to

1:07:33to give Apple discovery.

1:07:35Right?

1:07:36Part of it goes back to like I know this got talked about some

1:07:40when the lawsuit was first filed, but part of it goes back to what

1:07:44Apple wants from the lawsuit period and also the multiple people named in the

1:07:48lawsuit, because I think that Tang Tan probably could have kept getting away with

1:07:54what he was doing for a much longer period of time.

1:07:58But on the other side, the Chang Luction, they got they were doing something

1:08:07so obscene and so obtuse and so easy to trace that that's what threw

1:08:12them onto through Apple onto that scent.

1:08:15Yeah.

1:08:16And that's sort of my high-level takeaway, too, right?

1:08:19There's there's uh what they're they they've named uh three people, Apple.

1:08:24They've named OpenAI as a whole, Tang Tan in particular, and this guy Chang

1:08:29Lu, uh an electrical engineer who left Apple for OpenAI at the beginning of

1:08:352026.

1:08:37I think with this guy, Chang Lu, they've got uh I think he's got

1:08:43some problems.

1:08:44He's dead to rights.

1:08:46Right.

1:08:46And Apple even got their thing out, like OpenAI is trying to hang their

1:08:51hat on this.

1:08:53It is an unusual uh use of iCloud drive that Apple has.

1:08:59Um I've written about it a bit at Daring Fireball and heard much about

1:09:04it after I started writing about it from people who used to work at

1:09:07Apple.

1:09:08So uh, you know, Apple has this unique, I'm sure there's no other company

1:09:13even close to Apple size who uses iCloud Drive like this.

1:09:16And part of it is they are using some magic secret sauce.

1:09:20But long story short, that if you work at Apple, they encourage you but

1:09:25don't require you to use your personal iCloud account, your Apple account ID on

1:09:33your work devices, and then you are still iMessageable with your regular phone number.

1:09:41It's everything is more convenient.

1:09:43If you can imagine all the ways that you're as a non-Apple employee, that

1:09:47your life would be weird if you had to use a second device with

1:09:51an entirely second separate Apple ID.

1:09:54You know, that's what they're trying at one level, that's really what they're trying

1:09:58to avoid.

1:09:58And that they, I don't know, some number of years ago, they added a

1:10:01feature where if you agree to use your personal iCloud account with Apple with

1:10:07your work, they flag your account and you get a special Apple.

1:10:11I think the folder is literally named Apple Work at the top level of

1:10:14your iCloud drive.

1:10:16And then the contents of that folder are where you might share work-related documents

1:10:22with your colleagues.

1:10:23And you can use features like you know, the way that the iWork apps

1:10:28like numbers have collaboration.

1:10:30Like I one of the readers who emailed me was like, you know, you

1:10:33know, I know it sounds a little silly, but you know, one of the

1:10:36reasons people use Google Docs is you can have a spreadsheet and two people

1:10:39can edit it at the same time.

1:10:41And we added this feature to numbers, you know, and it's really cool and

1:10:46it works.

1:10:46And we couldn't use it at work.

1:10:48And instead, you know, even though we made this cool feature, we've still had

1:10:54to do the old-fashioned thing where we're back and forth emailing or iMessaging each

1:10:58other, saved copies of document name, final revision two date dot numbers, and then

1:11:08somebody else would get it and be like final, final, final revision one.

1:11:12Yeah, uh and you're like, which one is it?

1:11:15Final, final, final or final, final revision four.

1:11:19Which one's the final?

1:11:20And yeah, and you know, at some level, you're like, oh yeah, it would

1:11:24make sense if they could just use iCloud.

1:11:26And then you run into, but yeah, but what happens when you stop working

1:11:29at Apple?

1:11:29Right.

1:11:30What happens if some of your documents aren't in the um the Apple work

1:11:38folder?

1:11:39But anyway, it's as pertains to this lawsuit, Apple got out ahead of OpenAI's

1:11:45motion to dismiss and said, as pertains to Chang Lu, yes, there was some

1:11:49of that with iCloud Drive, but all the stuff we're talking about had nothing

1:11:54to do with iCloud Drive and everything to do with the third-party cloud storage

1:11:58provider, who nobody neither side has named yet, but I'm almost certain is Box.

1:12:03Yes, absolutely almost 99% sure, yeah.

1:12:06Right.

1:12:07Um and Apple said, you know, pretty I would say as clear as they

1:12:12could state it, that uh the stuff they're talking about has nothing to do

1:12:16with iCloud Drive.

1:12:17So any of the i Apple open AI's lawyers saying, hey, you know, to

1:12:23prove a trade secret, you have to protect it.

1:12:25And the way Apple handles this iCloud Drive stuff with their employees is so

1:12:30sloppy that they're not even protected.

1:12:32And it raises the question of whether these even qualify as trade secrets.

1:12:35It's all out the door or a moot point as far as Apple's concerned,

1:12:38because it was related to Box.

1:12:41And they had, I read the the dep, or not deposition, but the statement

1:12:45that from a hired forensic expert who looked at the logs and showed the

1:12:49dates that Chang Lu had accessed, presumably box, you know, and it was, you

1:12:55know, at least 37 files or something like that, um, or 39 files from

1:13:01and he left the company, left Apple in January, and he accessed them in

1:13:05February and March and all the way until like April 27th.

1:13:09That seems to me to be uh not good.

1:13:14The Tang Tan stuff is like some of it strikes me as kind of

1:13:18word of mouth like game of telephone, some of the things he was doing.

1:13:23And I think if Apple had only known about what Tang Tan was doing,

1:13:28I don't know if any of this actually happens.

1:13:31I don't think that's enough to take on a whole company because they're not

1:13:34just taking on Tang Tan and Chang Lu, which is how they usually approach

1:13:38these trade secrets cases.

1:13:39Like we've seen them go after different people before for taking things with them

1:13:43when they leave, leaking information while they're there.

1:13:46There were a few of them linked to who like left Apple's self-driving car

1:13:51project to go work for a Chinese self-driving car project and they took some

1:13:55files with them.

1:13:56Apple didn't go after the company that those people went to.

1:13:58Apple went after the individual person.

1:14:00Right.

1:14:01Which is what makes this case so different.

1:14:03And why I think it is primarily Chang Lu, but since they're going after

1:14:08OpenAI, they can kind of lump it all together.

1:14:10Right.

1:14:11I think one scenario is that this uh that Chang Lu was doing this

1:14:16on his own, you know, and and if he had asked his supervisor or

1:14:22who I don't know who, you know, who's, you know, if he'd reported directly

1:14:26to Tang Tan or if there was somebody in between them.

1:14:29But if he had asked, you know, should I go go back to my

1:14:33I still have I still have access to my Apple box account?

1:14:36Should I get the documents for Blanc?

1:14:38They would have been like, oh my god, no.

1:14:40You know, no.

1:14:41Let's, you know, let's talk to you know, legal and and figure out the

1:14:46right way to let Apple know that they accidentally still have you access, you

1:14:51know, but whatever you do, don't touch that.

1:14:53You know, they might have said that, or they might have they might have

1:14:57just said, you know, real cutesy style, like, hmm, yeah, I don't know.

1:15:02That's assuming OpenAI has any sort of checks and balances in place internally.

1:15:07And I don't think they're utilized, yeah.

1:15:11Right.

1:15:11We have no idea, you know, and I don't want to imply one way

1:15:14or the other.

1:15:15Um, and is was is Chang Lu the exception?

1:15:19Whether he had any uh uh other people within OpenAI and I.O.

1:15:25who knew what he was doing, uh you know, is he the one person

1:15:28who had access to these documents and did this?

1:15:31Uh or was he one of several and he's just the one that Apple

1:15:37has evidence against.

1:15:38And that's obviously that's what Apple is saying, they need the broad discovery to

1:15:42find out.

1:15:43I don't know, but I would say of the people and things that are

1:15:47in Apple's accusations, he seems like he's in trouble.

1:15:52When it comes to Tang Tan, who is I forget his title at IO,

1:15:57but he's effectively that in head of a head of the hardware initiative, and

1:16:00he was a senior or not a senior vice president, but a vice president

1:16:03of iPhone hardware at Apple until he left a few years ago.

1:16:08Obviously, still had had always had and clearly still has a good relationship with

1:16:13Johnny Ive, given that he worked with him when Johnny Ive was at Apple,

1:16:17and Johnny Ive hired him amongst other people in Johnny's inner circle at Apple

1:16:23at I.O.

1:16:25He's named in the lawsuit, but as I read it, nothing that Apple has

1:16:30revealed as evidence is unlawful from Tang Tan.

1:16:34You can say that it looks bad, and if it goes to a jury,

1:16:39you know, it this is not a criminal suit, it's a civil suit.

1:16:44And so it's not you know, is Tang Tan going to jail?

1:16:48Nobody's accusing him of that.

1:16:50And so you go to a civil suit and it's sort of what does

1:16:53the jury think?

1:16:54And does some of this stuff look bad?

1:16:57Yeah, but is it unlawful?

1:16:59I don't think anything that they've alleged is unlawful.

1:17:02Even the part if you really read what Apple puts in quotes in their

1:17:07um their motions, um, like the part about asking people coming in for job

1:17:12interviews to bring parts, the parts that are in quotes, nothing says bring prototypes

1:17:18or individual in development secret parts.

1:17:23It could just be it could be you know, bring parts in released devices

1:17:27that you have worked on.

1:17:28And I'm sure company policy at Apple is you can't bring that, right?

1:17:32Like if you worked on the volume buttons for the iPhone 17 Pro, I

1:17:39don't know, you know, that's a simplistic example.

1:17:42But if you did the volume buttons for the iPhone 17 Pro, you could,

1:17:46you know, it's obviously not illegal to show Tang Tan the volume buttons from

1:17:50the iPhone 17 Pro, because you could stop by an Apple store and buy

1:17:55an iPhone and show them to them, or or you know, if it's a

1:17:59an internal part like a uh logic board or something, you could use a

1:18:03screwdriver and take the iPhone apart and show it to them, right?

1:18:06And I'm so sure if they just have extra parts laying around so you

1:18:09don't have to dissemble a phone that it's against company policy, and that you

1:18:14know, if you just use a part that was laying around the office, you

1:18:19might get fired for taking it off campus to show at a job interview

1:18:24at any company, let alone open AI.

1:18:26But again, is it un is it unlawful?

1:18:29No, there's all sorts of things you get fired for at Apple that are

1:18:32not unlawful.

1:18:33Uh you know, if if it comes out that you're Joe Apple employee and

1:18:38you've been telling Mark German anything that Mark Garmin reports, you're going to get

1:18:43fired.

1:18:44That's a hundred percent certainty.

1:18:46Did you break the law?

1:18:48No, yeah, you're not, you know.

1:18:50I mean, I now can you are you if you told him things that

1:18:55you had signed uh uh non-disclosure agreement, I guess you're on the hook for

1:19:00a civil judgment, but you're not gonna go to jail, right?

1:19:04Tang tan doesn't work for Apple anymore, right?

1:19:07So I don't think it's unlawful.

1:19:08It just looks bad, right?

1:19:10And and like the whole thing, Apple is making a big deal out of

1:19:12like Tang Tan held on to a checklist of what Apple managers do when

1:19:18you say, Hey, I'm giving my notice.

1:19:22Uh I'm gonna go work at OpenAI, and they're like, Oh, you don't need

1:19:25two weeks.

1:19:26We're gonna call security and you're gonna be you're gonna be marched out now,

1:19:30and we're gonna ask you for this, that, the other thing, and we're gonna

1:19:33have an interview with you.

1:19:35Again, that's not illegal.

1:19:36Apple might wish that people who don't work at Apple didn't have that checklist,

1:19:41but it's not illegal to have it, you know.

1:19:43So I don't think there's anything Apple has alleged to date that is unlawful

1:19:48that Tang Tan has done.

1:19:49Yeah.

1:19:50It's a harder case to prove than it is for Chang Lu, anyway.

1:19:54Yeah the burden is on Apple to do to do that and convince a

1:19:57jury of that.

1:19:58Right.

1:20:00Possibility A is they just, you know, and again, it's multiple people, and I've

1:20:04even heard this from people at Apple that per at a personal level, John

1:20:08Turnus and Tang Tan never liked each other.

1:20:10And not just not just that they were rivals coming up through the hardware

1:20:14ranks for what was eventually uh Turnus' pro promotion to senior vice president of

1:20:22hardware, and now promotion from SVP of hardware all the way to the you

1:20:27know the CEO office.

1:20:29Um, but that they didn't like each other even even at beyond the way

1:20:33that maybe two up and comers in a company are just not going to

1:20:37like each other for competitive reasons, that they just didn't like each other, period.

1:20:40Um I've heard that.

1:20:42That could factor into this, obviously, you know.

1:20:44And maybe too, if they did like each other, you know, that maybe Tang

1:20:49Tan isn't mentioned in the lawsuit, right?

1:20:51I don't know, who knows?

1:20:53The example that would prove that point would be the Johnny Ive element of

1:20:56it all.

1:20:56He's not named in the lawsuit, and presumably that's because Apple still has respect

1:20:59for five in a way that they don't for Tang Tan.

1:21:03Tang Tan.

1:21:04Yeah.

1:21:04Or that they literally don't have any evidence at all.

1:21:06Yeah.

1:21:07You know, that that Johnny Ives, you know, is not involved in these job

1:21:11interviews that Apple has obviously gotten some details about.

1:21:14And and if they do find evidence that he is, maybe they name him.

1:21:18Who knows?

1:21:18Maybe they're, you know, we don't know.

1:21:20I mean, this is it's it's it could be one or the other.

1:21:23It could be that they like him and have respect for him and definitely

1:21:26were trying to keep are tr are trying to keep him out of it

1:21:29by name.

1:21:30Or it could be that they just don't have any evidence, and so therefore

1:21:34they didn't name him.

1:21:35But if they do find evidence, they would.

1:21:37I don't we don't know.

1:21:38That's uh to be determined.

1:21:41The the third thing, so there's Chang Lu, and I think that they've got

1:21:44him on some stuff.

1:21:45And I suspect that uh it uh Mr.

1:21:48Liu is just going to be cut loose by open AI.

1:21:51And if he's the only person involved, then that's maybe the end of the

1:21:55matter, you know, like, oh well, he did some bad stuff and we're gonna

1:21:59part ways with him.

1:22:00And but we've made sure that everything he brought in and everything he's touched

1:22:05at open AI, you know, is expunged from our systems.

1:22:09Tang tan, I'd to date, again, there might be evidence against him.

1:22:13Maybe Apple has evidence and they put it didn't put it into motion and

1:22:16they're waiting to see what uh open AI does comes up, you know, comes

1:22:20back within disclosure.

1:22:22And then Apple can say, hey, but we already know about these text messages

1:22:26from Tang 10, and they're not in what you've not disclosed.

1:22:29What's it called?

1:22:30Uh discovery.

1:22:31Right.

1:22:31That hey, your discovery is obviously incomplete because we know about this.

1:22:29Like Apple's under no obligation to have already put in their current motions everything

1:22:40they know.

1:22:41I sort of suspect they have, because if they really are looking to get

1:22:45a preliminary injunction, they've put everything they've got into it, but who knows.

1:22:49The other factor that's in the Apples thing is this bit, which they don't

1:22:54they don't name the company, the supplier, but they claim that there is a

1:22:59supplier that knows that Apple has worked with for a proprietary finish to I

1:23:05think and I think they say it's a metal.

1:23:07Yes.

1:23:08So presumably either steel or aluminum or titanium.

1:23:12Um it doesn't really matter, but there's some proprietary finish to a metal with

1:23:18a supplier that Apple considers a trade secret that they've spent money to develop

1:23:23and that that they have a proprietary agreement with this supplier.

1:23:27And that open AI went to this supplier and said, Hey, you can tell

1:23:30us and how to do this, and we can use this finish too.

1:23:33And we have Apple's permission to do it.

1:23:36Apple doesn't reveal the name of the supplier, and without even the name of

1:23:40the supplier, they don't reveal like here's text messages we know that they exchanged.

1:23:44We Apple hasn't said how they know that this happened.

1:23:47Presumably they've talked to the supplier, and the supplier was like, Hey, somebody this

1:23:51guy who I thought this guy left Apple and whoever it is, and he

1:23:55came and said, you know, was talking about this finishing thing, and Apple was

1:23:59like, Yeah, he left, you know, last year.

1:24:01Uh tell us more.

1:24:02I don't know.

1:24:03But to me, that is the wild card in this whole thing.

1:24:07Because that that's a pretty I I think prima facie.

1:24:12I forget, I don't know if that's how you pronounce it, but on the

1:24:14face of it, that's a theft of a trade secret.

1:24:17And you know, uh it's it's pretty much the definition of what Apple is

1:24:21accusing them of.

1:24:22But Apple hasn't revealed the details of it.

1:24:24And obviously, for this to come when this comes to trial, they will have

1:24:28to.

1:24:28That's to me the wild card in this whole thing.

1:24:31I think it's interesting that going back to the John Turnus bit a little

1:24:36bit.

1:24:37If John Turnus wasn't behind this lawsuit, would Apple have chosen right now to

1:24:43start slinging mud at OpenAI?

1:24:45Like the whole that whole the timing of it is so weird for a

1:24:50company that's been so meticulously planning this transition that you wouldn't just start this

1:24:55without not just buy-in from Turnus, but Turnus being emphatically behind it and thinking

1:25:02there was more to it than just dragging people's names through the mud.

1:25:05That's why with Tang Tan, like I'm a bit more inclined to think Apple

1:25:11has maybe more than they've talked about.

1:25:13And I think Apple's lawyers probably have a reason for particularly emphasizing this need

1:25:18to know document so much, like for just a single document, they're really the

1:25:23filings make a real big and put a real big emphasis on it.

1:25:26Yeah.

1:25:27I think we're entirely right that Cheng Lu is number one.

1:25:30This material supplier thing is clear as day, probably.

1:25:33And I think Apple even says Cheng Lu was mostly behind that too.

1:25:39And then the Tang Tan thing is the weakest argument, but I think there's

1:25:46enough to it that Apple that they wouldn't do it, yeah, if they didn't

1:25:50think there was a there.

1:25:51I don't know.

1:25:52Maybe maybe they're more spiteful than we're than we think.

1:25:56I do think it's got to be the case that Turnus, not that he's

1:25:59single-handedly behind it, but that he endorses this lawsuit.

1:26:03Because if he didn't, I don't again, Cook's desire to leave Turnus the neatest

1:26:11plate possible coming into the job.

1:26:14Even if Cook was like, John, I really think we should do this.

1:26:18And Turnus was like, ah, I don't want to.

1:26:20I I just don't want to, I don't want to, I don't want to

1:26:22start my tenure with this ugliness.

1:26:25I think Cook would say, Okay, you know, you've heard my piece, but we'll

1:26:29do it your way, and you know, but you know, keep your eye on

1:26:33this, you know.

1:26:33I but I think Cook would actually defer to Turnus because obviously all but

1:26:39these I I don't think we'll hear anything more from Apple until September when

1:26:43Turnis is CEO.

1:26:44So the only the very opening salvos happened under Cook's tenure.

1:26:49And it's clearly such a this transition is exactly, you know, it is Cook's

1:26:55baby, the transition.

1:26:57It is not like the Cook said, Hey, maybe I'll stay on, and the

1:27:01board is like, no, you're out, and we've picked this guy, Turnus, you know,

1:27:05and Cook is like, well, let me quick hurry and file this lawsuit.

1:27:09You know, that's that is clearly not the situation.

1:27:12So either Cook and Turnus are both fully on board with it, or Turnus

1:27:18is fully on board and Cook is like, sure, I'll go, we'll go your

1:27:21way.

1:27:21Yeah, but I suspect it's both of them.

1:27:23But it's one way or the other, it's got to be Turnus.

1:27:25There's no scenario where Cook is on board with it and Turnus is not,

1:27:29and Cook is like, well, screw you, we're going ahead with it.

1:27:32The other factor, though, I have to say it before we move on, is

1:27:35the other factor that could be the whole point of this is that Apple

1:27:39has no real intention of getting an injunction.

1:27:41They know there's not much more.

1:27:42They've got this Chang Lu guy.

1:27:44I mean, the poor guy might get fired and whatever.

1:27:47Um, but it's not going to really have any long-term effect on whatever open

1:27:52AI is already working on with the people who were already there.

1:27:56But that the entire point of this is to stop employees from Apple from

1:28:01leaving Apple for Open AI.

1:28:03Because if there are others, and I don't know, you know, obviously that's the

1:28:07sort of thing where you'd have to be insane to be a little birdie,

1:28:10even if you trust me to say, yeah, I'm still at Apple, and I

1:28:13was thinking about leaving for open AI, but now I'm thinking, I don't know.

1:28:17You know, but if there are other employees who at Apple who were on

1:28:22the fence and thinking, ah, some of the best people I used to work

1:28:25with here are there, and they seem pretty happy.

1:28:27Maybe I should go too, and they're still hiring.

1:28:30This might make, I think that the intention, the not that as a side

1:28:34effect, but maybe the primary intention of this whole thing is to give those

1:28:38people second thoughts of, oh, do I want to get involved in this and

1:28:42have Apple, you know, if you leave Apple to go work at Google or

1:28:47or whatever, you know, they're like, okay, you know, it's been nice working with

1:28:50you, have a good time, you know.

1:28:52You know, Sayanara.

1:28:54Uh I think when you say I'm leaving and I'm going to IO and

1:28:57open AI, you're looking for a forensic exam of your digital life on the

1:29:03way out the door.

1:29:05And a sort of hey, the old open door of sometimes people leave Apple,

1:29:12they go somewhere else to a startup for a couple years, and then after

1:29:15a couple years they come back to Apple.

1:29:17Like that door closes if you're going to open AI.

1:29:20You know.

1:29:21And I think that that might give people pause, and that might be the

1:29:25entire intent.

1:29:26Yeah.

1:29:26You know.

1:29:27I mean, in the filing, I I was surprised they revealed this number, but

1:29:30they said I think it's more than 400 former Apple employees are at Open

1:29:29AI now.

1:29:35Which I expected that number to be high.

1:29:37I don't know if I expected it to be that high.

1:29:40High.

1:29:41I I agree, because that is an aw, that's just a very, very large

1:29:44number.

1:29:45And I I'm trying to think off the top of my head how many

1:29:48I know.

1:29:49I don't know.

1:29:50I I could probably count them on one hand.

1:29:52But definitely on two hands.

1:29:54Um and I thought that was unusual, but now it makes if it is,

1:29:59you know, I mean, there's no nobody's disputing the 400 number.

1:30:02And it's like, oh, well, if it is 400, well then no wonder I

1:30:05know 567.

1:30:06Right.

1:30:06Or I've heard of 567 because it's 400 people.

1:30:09And I can't even think of who is in second place in terms of

1:30:14having the most highest number of ex-Apple employees currently employed.

1:30:19Probably Qualcomm with the chip team that left Apple Silicon some number of years

1:30:26ago.

1:30:26And there was, you know, some uh legal uh elbow throwing over the legality

1:30:32of what they what knowledge those people were leaving with, right?

1:30:35That there were some of the people from Johnny Sarugi's team involved in the

1:30:38creation of Apple Silicon, not just Apple Silicon, like the M series chips, yeah,

1:30:42but like the whole lowercase Apple Silicon from the chips that they've been making

1:30:47under Johnny Surugi's division ever since the PA semi acquisition in 2010 or whatever

1:30:53year that was, or 2007.

1:30:55Um, that they left for Qualcomm, but it's not 400.

1:30:58I think it's more like 40, right?

1:31:00I think it's I think it's a team that could kind of fit on

1:31:03a bus, not 400.

1:31:04And I would guess that that's second place.

1:31:07I I I'd I've just never heard of anything like this.

1:31:10And I think that could just be the explanation that there isn't anything ever

1:31:14there's never been anything like this.

1:31:16And Apple is some combination of angry and concerned about it.

1:31:23And the combination of anger and worry is let's just file this lawsuit and

1:31:28see if that helps put a stop to it.

1:31:32I think Apple employees leave for Google all the time, but Google employees also

1:31:35leave for Apple all the time.

1:31:37That's kind of an open door both ways.

1:31:39I haven't I haven't heard of anybody leaving open AI for Apple.

1:31:42I can't imagine that's a very common pathway.

1:31:46No, and at this point, and again, I don't know, at a personal level,

1:31:50maybe there's some people who are still, you know, it's it's like, hey, no

1:31:53hard feelings, even if you went to, I'm sure for some people, and it

1:31:56a measure of their actual friendships and the technical acumen, you know, like hey,

1:32:01you're so good, we'll take you back, you know, because we'd love to have

1:32:04you back.

1:32:04Um, you know, but I can't help but think that for the average employee

1:32:09who's made this switch, the door might be closed at least for a number

1:32:13of years.

1:32:13Yeah, just because this is been escalated to a level that it hasn't before.

1:32:18And again, there's no I I can't think of any precedent for it, really.

1:32:22So we shall see.

1:32:23All right, let me take a break here and thank our third and final

1:32:26sponsor of this episode.

1:32:28Notion.

1:32:29Notion AI is a workspace designed to strengthen human teamwork, not replace it.

1:32:39Like, I think a lot of people just, you know, to s whether your

1:32:43anxiety over the AI moment is high or low, I think everybody is sort

1:32:47of feeling it in general of hey, what is going on uh with AI

1:32:51replacing human action, human activity, human work, or human jobs or something like that?

1:32:57Notion is designing AI workspaces that are designed to strengthen human teamwork and human

1:32:59work, not replace it.

1:33:06It is augmenting humans, not replacing them.

1:33:10You know, like what can you do in Notion?

1:33:14I I, for one, don't want a future where you know a company is

1:33:20just one founder and a big company, and it's like instead of having Umpa

1:33:23Lumpas, you've just got like a thousand AI agents out there, right?

1:33:28Like it's human beings who make awesome things.

1:33:31Notion is all on board with trying to make sure that that's the way

1:33:36it continues to work.

1:33:37It is the AI workplace where your team's knowledge, projects, and agents all come

1:33:42together in one place.

1:33:44Teams using Notion, human beings using Notion.

1:33:47Um, they move faster, they cut friction and costs by consolidating tools to stay

1:33:54aligned.

1:33:55In Notion, your documents, your meetings, your projects, and more all live in one

1:34:01connected system where AI has the context that it needs.

1:34:05So you don't have to use a meeting recording tool and then a shared

1:34:09note tool for the docs.

1:34:11It's all in Notion and it all works together.

1:34:14They have over a hundred million users.

1:34:16It is trusted by 98% of the Forbes Cloud 100, and 95% of the

1:34:22top 50 AI companies use Notion, including OpenAI, Cursor, Lovable, and more.

1:34:29Learn more about how Notion can support your business at Notion.com/slash talkshow.

1:34:36That's all lowercase letters.

1:34:38Notion.com/slash talkshow to try Notion today.

1:34:42And when you use that link, you're helping support the talk show.

1:34:44One last topic.

1:34:47And it's I think it was the last time I saw you in person,

1:34:50chance was uh the Siri AI in the EU situation.

1:34:54Yes.

1:34:57Situation.

1:34:59So the only thing that's happened, there's two things that have happened over the

1:35:02summer.

1:35:03There was a thing, I don't think I wrote about it where Tim Cook

1:35:06met with somebody, somebody I have some woman whose name I don't remember from

1:35:09the EU in a private meeting.

1:35:12And uh, you know, there it's what they said, I don't know.

1:35:15We don't know that they were like, well, we you know, it was a

1:35:19it was a it was a nice discussion or something.

1:35:22But nothing came out of it.

1:35:24And I haven't heard anything like, oh, you know, we straightened that out, and

1:35:28you know, now we we have a path forward.

1:35:31Um as Apple left it at WWDC, they said they were pretty clear, almost

1:35:37almost using words as strong as this, that they did not see a path

1:35:41forward to launch Siri AI in in the EU under the current interpretation of

1:35:46the DMA from them.

1:35:48Um you know, and that they have this idea of the the what do

1:35:53they call it?

1:35:54The uh trusted systems agent.

1:35:57Yeah, the TSA.

1:35:59They should have thought of a better name, you know.

1:36:01But anyway, the trusted systems agent.

1:36:04Uh, but that it would be an enormous engineering effort.

1:36:07I think they said something to the effect of that it would be the

1:36:10biggest, as they as they envision it, it would be the biggest engineering effort

1:36:14for compliance with the DMA that they've undertaken to date, you know, more than

1:36:19the alternate app stores, more than the system for alternative web rendering engines, uh,

1:36:26more than the whatever stuff is in the system for taking payments from other

1:36:29processes, you know.

1:36:32Um it would be a bigger engineering effort to build this trusted system agent.

1:36:38And the EU that was pretty clear that they would have to build it

1:36:43first before the EU would say whether that makes it compliant.

1:36:47That they could spend a year and a half and a lot of engineering

1:36:50talent and resources and time building it, and then have the EU pass it

1:36:55around to the competitors and say, What do you guys think of this?

1:36:57And then come back to Apple and say, nope, that that's not compliant.

1:37:01And Apple's stance is we're not going to do it unless we know that

1:37:05the plan we've shown them is uh, you know, that we have a framework

1:37:09for what would be compliant.

1:37:11That was the biggest sticking point for Apple, I think.

1:37:13It's not just that they wouldn't say no, they or not just that they

1:37:15wouldn't say yes, that they wouldn't say no either.

1:37:18Like if the EU had come back and say, we like this trusted system

1:37:22agent thing, but you also need to do X, Y, and Z.

1:37:27They didn't even do that.

1:37:28It was build it and find out.

1:37:30Yeah, we and we don't talk about plans, we only talk about actual proposals.

1:37:35Um yeah, that they they really, you know, according to Apple.

1:37:39And I think, again, there's some dispute over how detailed the trusted system agent

1:37:43proposal is, but I think both sides, this is one of those things where

1:37:46at the the the Venn diagram does overlap that both sides agree that they

1:37:51did not, they did not give them any kind of well, you at least

1:37:54knew need X, Y, and Z.

1:37:57Apple said they didn't show it to us, so we don't know what to

1:37:59build.

1:38:00And the EU basically said, we don't do that.

1:38:02We don't tell them, you know, what to do.

1:38:05Now, the other news though, over the summer that I wrote about was that

1:38:09they did give guidance, quote unquote guidance to Google for AI interoperability on Android.

1:38:18And it is, I described it as breathtaking in terms of the scope of

1:38:24what they're saying Google needs to offer to third parties to comply.

1:38:30Um, you know, down to the fact that they need to allow third party

1:38:34agents to provide code that would run on the digital signal processor of the

1:38:40device to process the the wake words.

1:38:43Hey Dingus, you know, like if me and you do a startup with Dingus

1:38:48AI and you say to your Android phone, hey Dingus, you know, what what

1:38:52time am I recording the talk show with chance?

1:38:56They they don't want, you know, the the EU.

1:38:59I mean, it's this is what they're saying they have to do is the

1:39:02third party has to have code that runs on the digital signal processor.

1:39:06Um and they say it would be done securely, and it's not just any

1:39:10Joe app in the Play Store could do this, it would be some kind

1:39:13of vetting system.

1:39:15But it's just uh breathtaking in terms of the level that it's effectively being

1:39:20able to write low-level system software for Android and that they have to allow

1:39:25others to do it.

1:39:26Google did took the opposite standpoint.

1:39:29I'll just say this.

1:39:30Google did the, well, we're gonna ship our thing first and see if it's

1:39:33compliant later.

1:39:34And Apple has taken the we're gonna find out if it's compliant before we

1:39:38ship it in the EU first.

1:39:40And I think Google is now finding that uh perhaps would think maybe we

1:39:44should have done it the way Apple did it.

1:39:46Yeah.

1:39:47I mean, the bullet point in your story about the Google stuff that you

1:39:49describe as madness, but that Google must allow concurrent access to always-on hot word

1:39:55detection.

1:39:56So if you have Claude, ChatGPT, Grok, and Meta AI installed, all of them,

1:39:59in addition to Gemini must be permitted to have always on audio detection concurrently.

1:40:07Right.

1:40:07How?

1:40:09I don't know.

1:40:10And you know, it's and how many different words are they allowed to use?

1:40:15You know, and again, that's part of the argument of innovation is well, what

1:40:18if you have a very broad idea of the ways that you could wake

1:40:22up the device and you know, uh who knows?

1:40:26The other thing in the guidance, you know, as a requirement in addition to

1:40:30this digital signal processing code, um, even if we concede, like, oh, I don't

1:40:37understand what they mean by digital signal processing code.

1:40:40Yes, it's very low level, but it's completely isolated.

1:40:43This could be done safely, blah, blah, blah.

1:40:45In the guidance is also that these third-party agents have to be allowed to

1:40:48run as just regular apps in the background, unfettered by Google in terms of

1:40:54like, hey, you get 30 seconds an hour or something, you know, that there's

1:40:58some kind of limit on what they can do in the background.

1:41:01It's it more or less comes out and says that the that these agents

1:41:05have to be able to do whatever they want in the background whenever they

1:41:08want, because Google is the one who's allowed to set the limits on what

1:41:13Gemini does in the background.

1:41:15Um, and you know, I I've never heard I haven't heard anybody say, hey,

1:41:19I upgraded my Android phone to one that has Gemini built in and now

1:41:23the battery life is trash.

1:41:24I have there's no reports of that whatsoever.

1:41:27Google obviously is balancing whatever Gemini does in the background with the battery life

1:41:32concerns of you know, actual users.

1:41:37But if you know, if they're if they actually comply with this in the

1:41:41EU, every single third party who does participate in this, it would be up

1:41:46to them whether they take battery life and RAM into consideration with what they

1:41:52do in the background.

1:41:54I mean, it's effectively PC rules on an on a phone.

1:41:59And I know that there are people out there, every time this comes up,

1:42:02you can see, you know, some of them and some people feel very strongly

1:42:05that they wish all phones worked like Macs and Windows, where third parties could

1:42:10run code that runs in the background.

1:42:11And they, you know, when I defend the the or argue that this is

1:42:15madness, they'll say, but yeah, don't you but don't you say the Mac is

1:42:18your favorite platform and don't you run third-party things that run in the background?

1:42:22And yes, I do.

1:42:23That's not my phone, and they're different things, you know.

1:42:27And there's a reason why phones are so much more popular than PCs ever

1:42:31were.

1:42:32Um and anyway, if this guidance to Google is any indication of what guidance

1:42:38to Apple would be if Apple were to just ship Siri AI in the

1:42:43EU and then find out from the guidance what they need to add to

1:42:47comply, I can't see how Apple would ever agree to this.

1:42:52Any of it.

1:42:53No, I mean, the way Apple described the trusted system agent thing was like

1:42:57it was an intermediary that would allow assistants to access the same features as

1:43:02Siri AI and Apple Intelligence.

1:43:06What the EU is telling Google to do here, we don't know a lot

1:43:09about trusted system agent, but based on that description from Apple, there's no way

1:43:14half three quarters of this stuff would work if that's Apple's only as far

1:43:19as they're willing to go.

1:43:21Right.

1:43:22And so for example, like I I I know that I we don't know

1:43:28what they would want.

1:43:28I don't think they know what they want.

1:43:29I don't think they're technically competent enough to really uh form opinions.

1:43:34I think they take their advice from competitors.

1:43:38But like for example, it's not just, hey, Apple would have to open up

1:43:43Siri AI to third, you know, to open AI to Chat GPT or to

1:43:48Claude or to Groc or to uh you know an up and coming AI

1:43:54system agent, and they would have to get the same access to the semantic

1:44:00index in iOS and Mac O, or I guess iOS because Mac OS isn't

1:44:04a gatekeeping platform, but uh the semantic index, they'd have to have the same

1:44:08in uh access to the entire semantic index that Siri AI has.

1:44:13Um, that alone I'd see as a red flag, right?

1:44:18And I I think the trusted system agent, I think you agree too, with

1:44:22something like the way that like, hey, when third-party apps try to access your

1:44:26photo library, they have to go through a system prompt that gives you the

1:44:31user the ability to say, I only want to give this app access to

1:44:35this, this, these four photos, tap, tap, tap, tap, right?

1:44:38Yeah, these four photos uh Instagram now has access to, but not my whole

1:44:43library.

1:44:44And it yes, if I want to give it my access to my whole

1:44:47library, I can opt into that too, but I have to confirm it and

1:44:51then it can have it.

1:44:52I think that per the EU, you don't have to do that with Siri

1:44:56AI.

1:44:57Like when Siri AI goes to read your Apple notes, it's not, hey, do

1:45:01you want to give Siri AI access to these three Apple notes?

1:45:04You know, or do you want to give it all?

1:45:05It just has access to them because Apple trusts its own Siri in a

1:45:10way that it's never going to trust third parties.

1:45:12But I think to comply, Apple would have to allow the third parties the

1:45:17unfettered no confirmation prompt access to this stuff.

1:45:22And I'm not entirely sure to think why they wouldn't have to permit the

1:45:27third parties to build their own semantic indexes, right?

1:45:31What's to say that that Claude Anthropic wouldn't say, we don't like the way

1:45:36Apple built their semantic index, it doesn't work the way Claude does.

1:45:39We want to have access to all the users' email, all of their iMessage

1:45:44history, all of their Apple notes, all of their calendars, all of their contacts,

1:45:48everything else that is exposed to Apple's semantic index so that we can read

1:45:53all of this stuff and build our own semantic index, which is what we

1:45:56need to do to use this.

1:45:58To me, I honestly reading what they said to Google, I think that they

1:46:02would that that that's what the EU would say to Apple, that they would

1:46:05have to give third-party AI agents access to every single thing on your devices,

1:46:11iOS devices that Siri has access to just to build the semantic index.

1:46:24Right.

1:46:25And you know, it's not just that Apple is being a competitive dick and

1:46:28saying, hey, we've got you know, we are the ones who make this, and

1:46:32you know the users only get to use our system, which is part of

1:46:36it that you know, they are the ones who built the iPhone, and so

1:46:38they get to build the system components of the iPhone.

1:46:41But there is also a brand promise to users, which is that when you

1:46:45buy an iPhone, everything the iPhone is uh capable of doing, even when you

1:46:51install third-party stuff from the App Store, is stuff that Apple says is okay.

1:46:56Right?

1:46:56That is a brand promise that you can, you know, and it goes to

1:47:00the heart of why Apple, you know, the part of Apple's argument for the

1:46:59exclusivity of the App Store is distribution.

1:47:07That people just say, I don't know how to do this.

1:47:10I just trust Apple.

1:47:11That's why I bought an iPhone.

1:47:13And everything I can do on my iPhone, I can't mess up.

1:47:16And it's, you know, whatever I, you know, and if there is anything that

1:47:20I should be careful about, I can feel assured that I will be prompted

1:47:25and have to give permission for.

1:47:27Um so honestly, all of that is to say that I on my honest

1:47:33guess is that unless the EU and the European Commission comes back, has a

1:47:38come to Jesus moment and says, all right, we're we're going to rethink our

1:47:42policies on what the DMA requires.

1:47:45If they stick to what they're currently saying the DMA requires, I don't think

1:47:49Siri AI is ever coming to the EU.

1:47:52I I mean, and I know that sounds that sounds crazy, but there are

1:47:57feet, you know, iPhone mirroring still hasn't come to the EU.

1:48:00And that's now an old feature.

1:48:01It's like two years old, right?

1:48:03And I don't see any future where it is coming.

1:48:06And that's much smaller than Siri AI overall.

1:48:10But I I really don't see it happening.

1:48:13And that creates an incredible, it goes back to again to what we were

1:48:17talking in the first half of the show.

1:48:19I mean, Siri AI is not groundbreaking in terms of its intelligence, but it

1:48:23is totally groundbreaking in the utility of Siri on your device.

1:48:28It is useful, it works.

1:48:30It is it it the hardest part of using it is remembering that it's

1:48:33actually good.

1:48:34And I don't think it's ever coming to the EU.

1:48:37And which makes EU iOS devices a second class experience in the world.

1:48:42Yeah.

1:48:43At WWDC, me and you were in the same briefing about this with Greg

1:48:48Joswiak and some other Apple people.

1:48:44Yeah.

1:48:50And leaving that, my impression was one, Apple is unhappy about this whole situation.

1:48:57They're unhappy that they can't ship this feature, and they're unhappy at the lack

1:49:00of cooperation from the European Union on trying to ship it, trying to work

1:49:05together on a plan.

1:49:07Then they kind of went silent.

1:49:09Like there was the report of the talk with the EU digital person that

1:49:13went well, apparently.

1:49:15But now I'm imagining that Apple has seen this list of requests from the

1:49:19EC to Google, and inside they're just like, oh, we dodged a bullet with

1:49:25this one.

1:49:25Thank God we didn't build this system out just for them to come back

1:49:28with all of this crap.

1:49:29It's like, yeah.

1:49:30I left that briefing optimistic that they would probably you could tell the Apple

1:49:36wanted to come together with the EU and figure something out.

1:49:40But now I'm less optimistic.

1:49:42I think you're right that it's probably just not gonna happen.

1:49:45Right.

1:49:45And I do think that some of the initial coverage was too focused on

1:49:50the fact that Apple was like, and again, it goes back to the way

1:49:53that lawyers just ask for everything at the start, and then they find out

1:49:57if they need to dial it back.

1:49:58And Apple was like, and in addition to if you if you'll look at

1:50:03our TSA proposal and give us a thumbs up or tell us to add

1:50:07a couple of items, and maybe we can come to, okay, we said A,

1:50:11B, and C, you say A B C plus D and E, and we'll

1:50:15say, how about just A, B, C and D?

1:50:18And you'll say, okay, that's good.

1:50:20Build that, and then they can go ahead.

1:50:22In addition to that, they were like, and how about you just let us

1:50:25ship Siri AI now while we build this, as it is?

1:50:29And the EU is like, no, that, you know.

1:50:32And too many people focused on that as Apple asking for a complete permanent

1:50:36complete exemption.

1:50:37That was just Apple shooting for the moon.

1:50:40I don't think Apple really had any hopes that the EU is going to

1:50:43say, sure, go ahead and ship that while you build it.

1:50:47Because from the EU's perspective, it doesn't make any sense.

1:50:52I mean to say, sure, you can ship what you have now that's non-compliant

1:50:57while you build the compliant thing.

1:50:59Because if they were to grant that exemption, it wouldn't exactly inspire Apple to

1:51:04build the TSA system speedily.

1:51:07Right.

1:51:08Right?

1:51:08You know what I mean?

1:51:10Well, and in the court of public perception, too.

1:51:12If Apple shipped Serie AI as it exists today, and then in a year,

1:51:16they couldn't come to an agreement with the EU, and the EU's like you

1:51:20gotta take it away.

1:51:21Apple can point to the EU and say, look at what these people are

1:51:24making us do.

1:51:25Right.

1:51:25And they never say that you'll have to take it away.

1:51:28Like the EU's options to Google in their guidance to Google for Android doesn't

1:51:33include or just remove Gemini in the EU.

1:51:36Yeah.

1:51:36It's entirely predicated on the idea that they're just going to build a system

1:51:40that allows third parties to build equivalent systems.

1:51:44But I and I don't even know at this point if Google can comply

1:51:48by removing Gemini, because what happens to the people who don't update their devices,

1:51:53right?

1:51:53That they can't guarantee that everybody who's already got Gemini.

1:51:57I mean, I guess because Gemini has a cloud component that they can kind

1:52:01of revoke the functionality remotely, even if you don't update your device.

1:52:06But I think now that, you know, it it's much harder to, and there's

1:52:10the perception of, hey, we s you bought a Samsung phone that did this,

1:52:14and now you've, you know, it updated overnight, and now you've lost all these

1:52:14cool features that you were using.

1:52:21Is generally users don't react well to that sort of update.

1:52:26Um, in a way that you never had it in the first place might

1:52:31frustrate users who pay attention, but the typical users don't even know what they're

1:52:34missing.

1:52:35Exactly.

1:52:36But I I really do think, I mean, that's why I continue to take

1:52:40uh uh outsized interest in the whole story, because I I really, you know,

1:52:48A, even just for the next two, three years, I think this creates this

1:52:52profound difference in the iOS experiences between people who live in the EU and

1:52:58people who live elsewhere in the world, anywhere else in the world.

1:53:01But then it that divide will keep forking as the years go by, right?

1:53:06Like where things will be 10 years ago, 10 years from now could be

1:53:09profoundly different.

1:53:10And I don't think the European Commission understands it.

1:53:14I really don't.

1:53:15And I do think, again, I might be pro or American biased, you know,

1:53:20but I really do think that the people in the European Commission have an

1:53:24outsized assumption about the influence and importance of the European Union, and that they

1:53:30just assume that oh, they can they can bluff all they want, but they'll

1:53:35come and comply because the EU is so important.

1:53:38And I think the truth is no, that the rather than comply with these

1:53:42ex extraordinary demands, these come, you know, Apple and Google and the others will

1:53:47really just sort of they're not gonna walk away from the EU, but they're

1:53:51going to landlock EU users without new features going forward.

1:53:56It just is unfortunate for the EU users, and that at a certain point,

1:54:02if what you're trying to do isn't working, what you're trying to do to

1:54:05help consumers in your market isn't working, then you need to step back and

1:54:09reassess and say, okay, why isn't why aren't Apple and Google jumping through these

1:54:14hoops like we're asking them to?

1:54:16Right.

1:54:17If your intent is purely to make the experience better for consumers.

1:54:21Right.

1:54:21And I think Jaws, I'm I'm paraphrasing to some degree, but I and Jaws'

1:54:26remarks in that briefing were on the record.

1:54:28Um, but it basically he concluded with, we're asking the EU, who is this

1:54:33for?

1:54:34You know, and I really do think it comes down to that.

1:54:37And it's that question of who is this for?

1:54:40How in the world is this benefiting the citizenry of the EU?

1:54:43And I don't think it is.

1:54:45It's it's like they're they're too caught up in some kind of ideal that

1:54:49isn't going to come to pass, where the companies like Apple and Google run

1:54:55these platforms like open source public uh utilities when they are not.

1:55:03And they're caught up in the ideal at the expense of every practical actual

1:55:09experience of the people who use these products.

1:55:12And that there are no other products that do comply, right?

1:55:16It's not like, oh, Apple's going to, they may not like it, but they'll

1:55:19eat the shit sandwich and comply because otherwise people are gonna buy the Nokia

1:55:25phone and the the whatever else, you know, the Blackberry or whatever.

1:55:30Well, those companies don't exist anymore.

1:55:31You know, those platforms don't exist.

1:55:33There are no alternatives, you know, and you could say, well, that's the problem,

1:55:37you know, that it's a duopoly, but that the the DMA doesn't change that,

1:55:41you know.

1:55:42You have to deal with the real world, not the ideal one that you

1:55:45wish we had, where there was an open phone that these companies had to

1:55:49compete with and that users loved and sold in quantities and that they would

1:55:54abandon their iPhones for.

1:55:56Those phones don't exist.

1:55:57So I don't know.

1:55:59Uh, but it's curious to me.

1:56:01And I and you know, and it's not curious at all that we haven't

1:56:04heard anything in August because everybody in the EU takes off for from like

1:56:07the end of July till September.

1:56:10So all right.

1:56:12That's all I got, uh, Chance.

1:56:14Anything else you wanted to talk about?

1:56:15Anything else happened while we were recording?

1:56:17I don't believe so.

1:56:18I think we're in the clear.

1:56:20All right.

1:56:21We only broke one piece of news.

1:56:24Uh everybody who wants to follow Chance's uh find reporting and writing and your

1:56:30whole team of colleagues at nine to five Mac.com.

1:56:34Uh anything else you want to promote?

1:56:36You got a podcast, the nine to five podcasts?

1:56:38Yeah, I got two podcasts if you want to check them out.

1:56:40Nine to five Mac Nine to Five Mac daily, which is five days a

1:56:44week.

1:56:44And then nine to five Mac happy hour, which is one time a week.

1:56:48Both those on 9 to 5 Mac.com.

1:56:51I could I could deal with the happy hour.

1:56:53I don't know daily.

1:56:54I salute I salute everybody who does the daily podcast.

1:56:57Uh my thanks to our sponsors, uh, I think going backwards in time, Notion,

1:57:04Factor, and Squarespace.

1:57:06So thanks to them.

1:57:06Thanks to you, Chance.

1:57:07Great show.

1:57:08Yes, thank you.