Podcast Search

The Talk Show

455: ‘I’m Thinking X, Not X’, With Andru Edwards

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00Andrew, welcome back to the talk show.

0:00:02I think you were here a year ago.

0:00:03I think before the Apple event Was it was it that long ago?

0:00:06I think so.

0:00:07But now I've had you here after an Apple event.

0:00:09But you're fresh off an airplane and I have to tell you of amongst

0:00:13numerous things that I've written in the last month, the one that has gotten

0:00:17the most among the most reader feedback was a footnote where I pointed out

0:00:24about I is it just me or is there this trend trend where no

0:00:28matter what time of day you fly, everybody keeps the windows all the way

0:00:31shut and it's you're I read that.

0:00:35And you're flying in the dark and I kinda I get it early in

0:00:39the morning.

0:00:39I totally get it.

0:00:40I do it.

0:00:40I fight a window.

0:00:41But in the middle of the day, I want the sunlight.

0:00:44I don't.

0:00:44I it throws me off being in a a dark aluminum tube at the

0:00:49i it's hard enough to adjust the time zones.

0:00:52But like when it's twelve noon and you're taken off from the East Coast,

0:00:56it should not be dark.

0:00:57Are you what are your thoughts on this?

0:00:59I'm hit by feedback.

0:01:00You might not like this, but I think you have a decision you have

0:01:03a decision to make, okay?

0:01:04You can be an aisle guy or you can be the window guy in

0:01:07charge of the window We all know window seat gets the window, aisle guy

0:01:11has the easy access, and the middle seat gets both armrests.

0:01:14Right?

0:01:15So if you are gonna be an aisle guy, you just have to put

0:01:18up with whatever the window person's up to.

0:01:20Me personally, I kind of I like the window because I no matter how

0:01:26long my flight is, unless it's international, I'm moving.

0:01:28I'm not going to the restroom.

0:01:29I'm not moving.

0:01:30I just I'm just locking in and I'm gonna take my laptop out, maybe

0:01:33my vision Pro, I'm gonna do some work.

0:01:35So basically I use the window as needed for what I'm trying to do

0:01:39for work.

0:01:40So if my laptop doesn't need a window and it's better while I'm to

0:01:43close that down, I'm closing it.

0:01:44Yep.

0:01:45So what I don't like though, hopefully you're not one of these guys.

0:01:49Are you one of the guys that the people that reach over from the

0:01:53middle or the try to activate the window?

0:01:56I had one of those a couple of weeks ago.

0:01:58I wasn't shocked No.

0:02:00No.

0:02:00Sometimes you take what you can get if you book last minute, but the

0:02:03even so you get what you get.

0:02:04You get your real estate and the window seat gets the window.

0:02:07No, that's ridiculous.

0:02:09That's as bad as if they reached over and like took food off your

0:02:11tray or

0:02:13Exactly.

0:02:14Exactly.

0:02:16Took the drink off your off your tray and were like, You're not drinking

0:02:19this, are you?

0:02:20I mean that's a little presumptuous.

0:02:21No, and I th I know it's like a weird cultural change though.

0:02:24I feel like everybody and again I'm not a d a doomer about screens

0:02:29and everybody's addicted to screens and everybody's down about how much time they spend

0:02:33on devices.

0:02:34I get it.

0:02:34I know and I think about it too and I'm trying to be m

0:02:37mindful about it and trying to adapt and not get into habits about it

0:02:43or break some habits about it.

0:02:45But I do think it's definitely a reflection of that.

0:02:48It absolutely is.

0:02:49And that people are not amazed by being thirty eight thousand feet in the

0:02:54air and getting to see this magnificent earth.

0:02:58I mean you really do.

0:02:59I'm an aisle guy, but I've next choice is a window.

0:03:02I've sat in a window.

0:03:03And there's always some point on a long flight where you just look out

0:03:06the window and you're like wow, look at that.

0:03:09And nobody is amazed by that.

0:03:10What they are amazed by is the dumbass movie they're watching on their laptop.

0:03:16And when you're watching a movie, you don't want the window open, you want

0:03:20you don't want the reflections.

0:03:22And so you need that contrast.

0:03:24Yeah.

0:03:25So I don't know.

0:03:26But it is I got so much email about it, mostly from people who

0:03:29are like, Yeah, I'm annoyed by this, but but nobody everybody sees there's nothing

0:03:34to be done about it.

0:03:35So most people are were in agreement with you.

0:03:37And I remember from years ago when it was a lot rarer to have

0:03:43a laptop on a flight, right?

0:03:45And I remember like when I first started flying with a laptop twenty twenty

0:03:49some years ago, it's y you had to I don't know, like a a

0:03:54power book of the time would get like two point five hours of battery

0:03:57life.

0:03:58So if you're on a five hour flight, you could board, you could read

0:04:02for a bit, you could wait for the food cart to come down the

0:04:06aisle, and then take your laptop out and hurry up and do some work,

0:04:10and then your laptop would be dead by the time you got to like

0:04:14the Rocky Mountains and then you'd put it away and read for the rest

0:04:18of the flight and you know, you didn't have to worry about it.

0:04:21'Cause you didn't have you didn't like a power or a laptop back then.

0:04:24Oh yeah, you definitely didn't you didn't have outlets, you didn't have anything.

0:04:28And it just seemed at the time, sure, I'll close my window because I

0:04:32don't want the glare on my screen.

0:04:34But it doesn't me closing my window isn't gonna make the whole cabin dark

0:04:38because most other people aren't doing that.

0:04:40And now everybody's in the same boat and everybody with a window seat is

0:04:44thinking, Well I'm gonna close the window.

0:04:45And the other thing that I think has happened is that there's a certain

0:04:49tipping point culturally where even people who aren't acting out of their own self

0:04:54interest become because they don't want the glare on their screen and their window

0:04:58seat.

0:04:58And they kind of get the vibe like, uh-huh, everybody has their windows closed.

0:05:02I guess I'm supposed to keep mine closed too, right?

0:05:05There's like a tipping point where it used to be the default was, well,

0:05:09of course you want this open because you have a window seat.

0:05:11You wanna look out the window as you're f amazingly thirty some thousand feet

0:05:15up in the air.

0:05:16And now it's like the cultural norm, just the vibe in the cabin is,

0:05:21huh, seems like everybody has a closer is keeping it closed.

0:05:23I better keep mine closed too.

0:05:25Even if I want to look high.

0:05:26'Cause I often the other thing too, I've seen this is I've seen people

0:05:29next to me and it they go to open it and I think, Ah,

0:05:32that's good.

0:05:32I'm glad he's opening that window or she or whoever and they open it

0:05:35and they take a peek and then they close it.

0:05:39I have seen that.

0:05:40I have done that myself.

0:05:42But yep.

0:05:42So I travel a lot.

0:05:43I just got off but you mentioned I got off a plane today.

0:05:45I just got off my my forty-sixth flight of twenty twenty-six so far.

0:05:50And what I have noticed though over the past like two years, or maybe

0:05:55even post COVID, when we get on the plane, all the windows are already

0:05:59closed.

0:06:00Yeah, I feel like before all the windows used to be open.

0:06:04So I'm also wondering if it's like people get on a plane and they're

0:06:08just oh it's supposed to be like this.

0:06:09It's supposed to be like it's supposed to be all closed.

0:06:12And if you got on a plane and all the windows were open, would

0:06:15people close them or just leave them alone?

0:06:17Yeah, that's a thing I've noticed too and it's something I've gone to Disney

0:06:20World a lot and I've actually was just in Vegas a couple of weeks

0:06:23ago and it's like there are certain like Vegas is in August is like

0:06:27this where i they want it closed because it they want to keep the

0:06:30cabin as cool as possible in the desert sun.

0:06:33But now it doesn't really matter where you are or what time of year,

0:06:36it seems like you board the plane and the windows are closed by default.

0:06:38And I just shut down.

0:06:40Yeah.

0:06:40And uh anyway.

0:06:41Forty six flights.

0:06:42Man, oh man, I would that would That's something.

0:06:46I know, and we still got more to come.

0:06:47It's about to ramp up.

0:06:49It is it's been a just a busy couple of days.

0:06:52We we saw each other at the Apple event, which is I guess two

0:06:55weeks ago now.

0:06:56And it was funny, and I told you when I asked you to be

0:06:59on the show that I've been thinking about it ever since is uh and

0:07:02let's so let's just talk about it.

0:07:03Let's talk about that Apple event.

0:07:05Yeah, yeah, let's do it.

0:07:06Um it was I saw you in I actually saw you in Steve Jobs

0:07:10theater too.

0:07:10I think I was moving down the the aisle trying to get a seat.

0:07:14Yep.

0:07:14But then I ran into you.

0:07:16They did a weird or they they mix it up every year, but they

0:07:18had like a a br what they call it?

0:07:21Briefings and something else content.

0:07:24A whole different build.

0:07:25I mean it's a build yeah, content center.

0:07:27It's content it's a building apparently that they use.

0:07:30This is an Apple building in the area about twenty minutes from Apple Park.

0:07:34And they said twenty minutes.

0:07:36They said right, they said twenty minutes.

0:07:38See I will be a I'll be a whiny baby on the podcast in

0:07:42a way that I wouldn't in my writing.

0:07:45But they said it was about twenty minutes away.

0:07:47I the couple of times I took the shuttle, it was I don't know,

0:07:51thirty thirty plus minutes.

0:07:53Closer closer to I was looking and they were like, Don't please don't share

0:07:57the location, which is fine.

0:07:58You agree to this stuff.

0:07:59It's it's not a secret, but they don't want you to tell people the

0:08:04exact address.

0:08:05But I mean you can look on your Yeah.

0:08:08You can look on your phone and see where you are.

0:08:10And we were almost all the way to Menlo Park, and I'm not super

0:08:15familiar with every single area in the valley, but i it it that's not

0:08:21close to Cupertino.

0:08:23No, it's not.

0:08:24It's not.

0:08:25It was strange 'cause like you said, they didn't wanna they didn't want to

0:08:27tell you the exact address.

0:08:29And when I was so I left there and I wanted to come back

0:08:35And where I was much closer to that than going back to Apple Park

0:08:40and they were like, Oh no, we can't tell you the address, you have

0:08:42to go all the way back to Apple Park and take a shutter.

0:08:44I'm like a two minute Uber away.

0:08:46Right.

0:08:46Nope, you gotta go all the I gotta go thirty minutes there and thirty

0:08:49minutes back and orders.

0:08:50I was like, this is this only Apple would do this.

0:08:52This is insane.

0:08:52That's like a video.

0:08:53I had one right.

0:08:54It's like the level it's like the level got reset and it's like yeah,

0:08:57I know where I was, I was so close to the end of the

0:08:58level and they're like the level over.

0:09:00You gotta go all the way back to the basers.

0:09:03And it's like ah, god damn it, this part I already beat this part.

0:09:06I know.

0:09:07Terrible.

0:09:07One thing I noticed about you, by the way, at a c at the

0:09:10last few Apple events that I've observed and seen you, you don't take the

0:09:14same strategy that us video people do, which is we try to sit as

0:09:19far back as possible in Steve Jobs theater so that when it ends, we

0:09:24can just get up and turn around and get right to the devices.

0:09:28And you seem to

0:09:30almost be more Into taking in the whole scene as opposed to let me

0:09:37get to the devices and check them out right away.

0:09:40Yeah.

0:09:40Yeah that's that accurate?

0:09:41Yeah, no, that's very true.

0:09:43This time I sat in the front row center.

0:09:47I I should pull I didn't publ I don't know where to publish the

0:09:49photos, but I I have some good photos.

0:09:51I was right above the main camera.

0:09:54It's sorta like there's theater seating where they put all the media people and

0:09:59then there's sort of a halfway through you know this, I'm trying to describe

0:10:03it for the audience.

0:10:04About halfway into the theater, there's like a fifty yard line and the seating

0:10:09in front of that is different and better.

0:10:12It's and it's closer to the stage.

0:10:14But in between the two seating areas is sort of a well where there's

0:10:19this whole A V professional rig with big cameras and all sorts of audio

0:10:25stuff and probably the lighting controls.

0:10:27I was right above them.

0:10:29It's and it's sort of the seating is raised.

0:10:32The part where us in the media get in the back sort of goes

0:10:36up and that front part is more flat.

0:10:39And that's And uh so I just went all the way down until an

0:10:42usher said that with my color badge for the media I couldn't go anymore.

0:10:46And I looked over to the side and there was still there was a

0:10:49seat right in the middle and I sat there.

0:10:50I was actually right in front of Austin Mann, the photographer, and he I

0:10:54think he was jealous 'cause he wanted to s sit one real closer.

0:10:58But he likes to sit in the middle too.

0:11:00Who else was I next to?

0:11:01Chance Miller, who was just uh on the talk show last month from nine

0:11:05to five Mac, a few other people But yeah, that's my strategy.

0:11:08And I I and I do I think you and I were talking to

0:11:12some people on Threads who had just been invited for the first time.

0:11:17And that's one of my little tidbits of advice.

0:11:20Not like tons of people ask me for advice on how to attend these

0:11:23things.

0:11:23But one of my things to if you've never been there is to consider

0:11:28that.

0:11:28That if you might rush in when they open the theater and want to

0:11:32get as close as possible, which is sort of what I do now.

0:11:35But it it's considered.

0:11:37But then you have to realize that when the keynote is over, it will

0:11:40be several minutes before you get out of the theater.

0:11:42And in the meantime, the hands on area will be filled up.

0:11:46It's filling up quickly.

0:11:48Yes.

0:11:48And if what you want to do is capture capture B roll footage or

0:11:51just get some hands on time as much as possible, you want to sit

0:11:55in the back.

0:11:58That's always my strategy.

0:11:59Or back as possible.

0:12:00Yeah.

0:12:01Yeah.

0:12:01That's where you were seated.

0:12:03At the aisle too.

0:12:04You had an aisle seat.

0:12:05That's right.

0:12:06That's right.

0:12:06I was right there.

0:12:07I was ready to go.

0:12:07I'm giving up your secrets.

0:12:11No, it's definitely true.

0:12:13What do you w there was a discussion this is t before we talk

0:12:16about the event itself.

0:12:17It was sort of a meta discussion.

0:12:18Mark German had tweeted and German does not get invited to Apple events for

0:12:24being

0:12:27Well nobody explains it's Apple, so they don't but one can surmise the reasons.

0:12:33But Gurman tweeted, Apple's new focus on influencers for events and product quote reviews,

0:12:40sort of dick quotes around reviews People who say nothing but positive things and

0:12:45never ask a legitimate question of Apple executives in exchange for free devices, travel

0:12:51and more is a serious issue.

0:12:52This echo chamber will lead to mediocrity.

0:12:55I I I've t actually talked to Mark privately about that.

0:12:59Surprising to some.

0:13:00Mark and I get along in person pretty well.

0:13:02I know what he's getting at there.

0:13:05The list of people who were invited to Apple events is always it's always

0:13:11been evolving, right?

0:13:12And the media is always evolving.

0:13:15But it's it's uh there is a different crowd that uh it not YouTubers,

0:13:22it is video is just is now no longer new.

0:13:27I mean the one of the funniest things I saw in all of the

0:13:30post keynote thing was I'm already forgetting his name.

0:13:33Who's the flips in front of Turnus?

0:13:35I show speed.

0:13:36I show speed.

0:13:37So I show speed is an influencer.

0:13:40And he's this perfect type of guy who I'm talking about.

0:13:43He's twenty-one years old.

0:13:44He's got uh I don't know, twenty zillion followers on YouTube and social media,

0:13:50and he does a lot of live streaming and he posted a video where

0:13:54he went up to Marquez Brownley to and I guess they'd never met before

0:14:00and was telling Marquez, Hey man I grew up watching your videos.

0:14:05I and I'm like, Oh, this is great.

0:14:08Marquez is getting what I've gotten years ago.

0:14:11They're grew up peace.

0:14:14Yes.

0:14:15Which was also funny.

0:14:17But the idea that Marquez Brownley is now the veteran who newcomers to Apple

0:14:23Keynotes are coming up to and saying, Oh, I grew up enjoying your coverage

0:14:28of these things.

0:14:29Oh, I loved watching that.

0:14:31It is funny.

0:14:31That is funny.

0:14:33I think it's an interesting discussion, but I do think there's misconceptions, I guess,

0:14:40when it comes to the approach.

0:14:42So obviously these Apple events, like event is almost like a key word.

0:14:48These are events.

0:14:49Apple is putting on an event.

0:14:52And unlike WWDC, which is also an event, but really geared towards developers, this

0:14:57is the one.

0:14:58This is their big one of the year that the the average person is

0:15:01going to care about and want to know about.

0:15:04And so it's it would be a silly strategy not to take advantage of

0:15:12it's like advertising, right?

0:15:13And today's advertising just It just happens to be influencers have a lot of

0:15:17attention.

0:15:18Like you said, like iShow Speed is on we're never allowed to live stream

0:15:22these things.

0:15:22But iShow Speed was in their live streaming all over the place.

0:15:25He has some special permission.

0:15:27And when you look at his numbers when he was live streaming It's it's

0:15:31almost a million people watching this man just walk around.

0:15:35So I know I saw that.

0:15:37How would you not how do you not say to yourself, and and by

0:15:40the way, he's someone who every year would do a live stream about the

0:15:43new iPhone just on his own, right?

0:15:45He because he's just interested in it.

0:15:47So why would you not say to yourself, you know what?

0:15:50If we're gonna bring in celebrities that love our brand, let's bring this guy

0:15:54in.

0:15:54There were some other celebrities there too.

0:15:56Kiki Palmer was there.

0:15:58Kid Cuddy was there.

0:15:59There was people there who are not reporters, who are just like taste makers

0:16:04or seen as or well-followed celebrities.

0:16:08Now, that being said, I feel like the word influencer gets kind of it

0:16:13kind of annoys me because it mixes people up like me, who I'm literally

0:16:17there to do my job,

0:16:19to report on what Apple is doing and share that with people who are

0:16:23interested in that versus the influencer who's, hey, I'm just people just find me

0:16:29interesting and I just do stuff and people watch me.

0:16:31That's not me.

0:16:32But I think what most people don't realize is it's not like everybody that

0:16:37goes and sits in Steve Jobs theater goes home with an iPhone that day

0:16:40for free.

0:16:41Right.

0:16:42Most people do not leave with an iPhone, whether it's that day or after.

0:16:48It's actually a a small subset of people that do.

0:16:51And the majority of people who do are doing it because it's our job

0:16:55to cover it and we wouldn't be able to do our job properly if

0:16:58if Apple didn't do that.

0:17:00So when I read Mark's comment there, it was like I see what he

0:17:05means but I also it's like I disagreed with half of it because I

0:17:09think it it told the wrong story to the average person who just would

0:17:12read his tweet and what they would glean from it, I thought was not

0:17:16actually accurate.

0:17:17Yeah, I think so too.

0:17:18And I don't think uh knowing Mark, it is not because Mark is

0:17:26jealous, right?

0:17:27Mark knows the score with Apple.

0:17:29I mean I think if they said, Okay, sure.

0:17:31You know what?

0:17:32And I've seen him at Apple events.

0:17:35The last time I remember seeing him at one was it might not be

0:17:38the last one he was at, but I just remember very vividly it was

0:17:41the one for the iPhone ten.

0:17:43So that would be twenty seventeen, I believe.

0:17:47And the night before he had leaked shocker leaked had a leak that they

0:17:54were gonna call it in print iPhone space capital X.

0:18:01I was like, Oh god, another fucking X.

0:18:04'Cause I after all these years of people calling it Mac OS X, are

0:18:09they gonna when it was stood for Mac OS ten, are they gonna call

0:18:13call it the iPhone with an X thinking it's ten and wanting you to

0:18:19say ten and the whole world's gonna say iPhone X.

0:18:22And Gurman said they were gonna call it ten.

0:18:25And I said, ah I think if it's an X they actually maybe they

0:18:27think X is cool and they're gonna tell you to say X.

0:18:31It's just a spitball, you know, and I guess I guess wrong all the

0:18:34time.

0:18:34There's one that I guess wrong right there.

0:18:36And I remember I ran into German in the lobby, the right but not

0:18:42the upstairs lobby at Steve.

0:18:43Jobs Theater after they let us down, but in that uh what turns into

0:18:47the hands on area afterwards behind the seats.

0:18:50And I say and you know, we said low and I just said I

0:18:54I'm thinking X not ten and he just said, Nope, ten.

0:18:57He knew it.

0:18:57Somebody had told him.

0:18:58I was like, Ah shit, why'd I shoot my mouth off?

0:19:01I knew so I knew before they even announced it, with his certainty, the

0:19:06just the way that he said it.

0:19:07But it for years since then he's he has not gotten invitations.

0:19:11And if he ever did again, they would just invite him and act as

0:19:14though there was no reason that he hadn't invited for so it would just

0:19:18land in his own.

0:19:19That's not why he's saying that.

0:19:21And there are I don't know, I was told by people who who who

0:19:26were involved.

0:19:27I met some people, I forget where what countries or there there's more people,

0:19:31it seems, from international countries that are going could invited to this event.

0:19:37This one in particular.

0:19:38WWDC two, but this one in particular.

0:19:41And that some of them or all of them had been put up by

0:19:45Apple in a hotel and maybe their flights were paid or some of them.

0:19:49Um Uh that's normal.

0:19:51Yeah.

0:19:51In the Indian international.

0:19:54It is.

0:19:55And uh German seems to have picked up on this and others too.

0:20:00And I it's like a sensitive thing for me they don't pay for anything.

0:20:05They get like I said like I wrote, like I we get cookies and

0:20:08coffee, right?

0:20:09Or they had apple tar trees.

0:20:11Yeah.

0:20:12And then there's some foods.

0:20:13It's very nice.

0:20:14The food over at the visitor center where they have they coordinate off for

0:20:18the press and have Wi Fi.

0:20:20They give us free Wi Fi, right?

0:20:21We get that.

0:20:22But it's the idea it's it does not it the the domestic press does

0:20:28not get air airfare or uber fare or any fare.

0:20:33Right, correct.

0:20:34You just don't.

0:20:35And it's that's just the way it is for international.

0:20:38I don't know.

0:20:39Seems very normal.

0:20:40And I guess if somebody wanted me to cover something halfway around the world,

0:20:44maybe I would take I would disclose it i if I took it.

0:20:48But I get it.

0:20:49I think it's just a sign though of the I don't think it's related

0:20:52to coverage.

0:20:53And like you said, people don't walk out with free iPhones or even review

0:20:57unit iPhones.

0:20:58And Apple is very secretive about how many review units go out.

0:21:03But you can see on embargo lift day how many there are that come

0:21:07out and it's not that many.

0:21:09It still isn't it is and I the other thing too is there's always

0:21:17been just I don't know celebrities.

0:21:20I mean that's sort of what influencers are.

0:21:22Like influencers i in it's definitely not you, right?

0:21:26But

0:21:27those exactly yes.

0:21:28Is more along the lines of a next generation self-made come up through where

0:21:35the modern mediums mediums plural for young people like him 21 years old coming

0:21:42up are not TV right it's not broadcast TV, it's social media, it's YouTube,

0:21:49it it's TikTok, it's whatever you can livestream on.

0:21:52It's these internet first things.

0:21:55But their fame and their audience is like for people of older generations, what

0:22:02you had to be on TV to be that famous before.

0:22:05Nobody in print was that famous, right?

0:22:08Walt Mossberg is probably the legend of of legends almost certainly in the the

0:22:14field of what we do.

0:22:16And Walt Mossberg is not as famous as iShow Speed, whose name I forgot

0:22:22five minutes ago.

0:22:22But not at all.

0:22:23It's just the nature of print versus visual mediums and the new visual mediums

0:22:28are that.

0:22:29And so of course a a company that is looking to stay at the

0:22:34forefront of attention has got to adapt to that in the same way and

0:22:40I've I I think I'm aging gracefully in this way.

0:22:44There was a time when I was the

0:22:48new the odd person in the green room in the media at Apple events

0:22:53because I was a blogger.

0:22:55Uh blogging, yes.

0:22:56Right.

0:22:57And that was the word like influencer, like well, you're just a blogger.

0:23:00For a site that I owned, it wasn't a site with any kind of

0:23:04roots and print.

0:23:05I didn't have colleagues.

0:23:06And it was unusual.

0:23:08And there were some people in the media who I c you know, they

0:23:13nobody said anything shitty to me, but there were people who I could tell

0:23:16didn't, saw that I was younger and didn't want to talk to me.

0:23:20But I'll tell you who did.

0:23:21You know who did talk to me?

0:23:22Walt Mossberg.

0:23:24Exactly.

0:23:24Walt.

0:23:25The first time I was in it was in Moscone.

0:23:28I don't know if it was a Macworld or if it was a WWDC,

0:23:32but it was the first time where in addition to a press pass I

0:23:36had a briefing after the keynote and they're like, Go over there and then

0:23:40you wait and it was over on the side of Moscone and I felt

0:23:44a little out of place.

0:23:45I was like, I don't even know if I'm the right place.

0:23:47And it's like, oh no, you're in the right place.

0:23:48And it's well what do I do now?

0:23:49And they're like you just wait and then it'll come get you.

0:23:51And I'm like, all right.

0:23:53And Walt Mossberg was there.

0:23:54I was like, holy shit, Walt Mossberg's here.

0:23:56And Walt was probably waiting.

0:23:57Oh well in fact I know he was.

0:23:58He was waiting to talk to Steve.

0:24:00Jobs.

0:24:01I was not waiting to talk to Steve Jobs.

0:24:03Wow.

0:24:04But Walt was, I'm sure, and Walt came up to me and or I

0:24:08introduced myself first, but he knew who I was and he just ah, I

0:24:12love your work.

0:24:13I think you're doing a great job.

0:24:14And it we talked for a bit and was just so gracious.

0:24:19He didn't have to be like that.

0:24:20And there were other people who definitely weren't, but I w always remember that.

0:24:23It's just a I don't know.

0:24:25It sounds like such a Uh Kinard.

0:24:29But the it's a change it's the media landscape is always changing.

0:24:32And it would be ridiculous if Apple didn't.

0:24:36Well I mean it's but it's also not it's not supposed to be just

0:24:41a press conference.

0:24:42That's really the thing.

0:24:43Apple's not trying to put on a press conference.

0:24:45They're trying to put on a pop culture event that everybody if you don't

0:24:49hear from it or if you don't care, if you don't care about consumer

0:24:52electronics, you are gonna hear about it from the red carpet when John Turnis

0:24:56is there.

0:24:57You're gonna hear about it from celebrities who are there.

0:25:00They wanna make sure everybody or as many people as possible know that something

0:25:05just happened today.

0:25:07Yeah, and that's the hard thing.

0:25:09And I would like to write about it some year.

0:25:12I don't about this year already, but uh it's it's so hard to keep

0:25:15up for me at least at the pace that I'm able to write stuff.

0:25:19It's so hard to write about the actual announcements uh i and t to

0:25:25write about the event separately in a way that I would like to sort

0:25:29of describe what it's like.

0:25:31And that's why I'm glad to have a podcast where I can talk about

0:25:34it.

0:25:34But it is and I there is this whole other debate about hey, should

0:25:39Apple go back to live on stage keynotes?

0:25:42And Meta just had a very good one.

0:25:44I did watch you at your suggestion, but I wanted to talk about it

0:25:48with Ben Thompson on Dithering for what's going to be tomorrow's episode two.

0:25:53And it's what Meta did is exactly what a people some people are w

0:25:58hope Apple would do, which is go back to a traditional here's a stage,

0:26:03here's the CEO of the company in live in front of a couple hundred

0:26:07people in the media and some employees who were gonna do the clapping and

0:26:12talk about things and do demos with products in your hand or on your

0:26:16face if their glasses in front of the people mixed in with pre recorded

0:26:21videos that you showed to people.

0:26:23Which Steve Jobs always did, right?

0:26:25And I Steve always did a fun thing and I always like he always

0:26:29did it.

0:26:29He would be like, Hey, we shot a we made a commercial about this

0:26:32or we made a video about this.

0:26:34Would you like to see it?

0:26:35Remember that?

0:26:36He'd always say, Would you like to see it?

0:26:37And everybody would Yeah, and then and then people would clap and he'd be

0:26:41like, Oh, okay, well then play the video.

0:26:43Was there any chance that he was not going to play the video?

0:26:46But he would ask.

0:26:47He would always ask.

0:26:49And then they'd play a video.

0:26:51You know, and that's where we got to know Johnny Ive as outsiders, right?

0:26:55Because Johnny Ive does not like I think once or twice he did appear

0:26:58on stage or was in a stunt where he took a phone call from

0:27:02Steve or something.

0:27:03But for the most part Johnny Ive wasn't comfortable, didn't want to be on

0:27:06stage live and would do those often parodied voiceover things talking about the design.

0:27:14And pronouncing aluminium.

0:27:17But the thing that gets lost though is people say, I wish Apple would

0:27:19go back to that.

0:27:20These pre recorded things are boring.

0:27:23And I get it if you think they're boring, but Apple I know what

0:27:26Apple and I know you know that Apple and I know that YouTube changed

0:27:29the way they count the views, but a lot of fucking people watch their

0:27:33videos.

0:27:34Right?

0:27:35Yeah.

0:27:35And I think it's who are the people saying is boring?

0:27:38It's probably people like us who would rather see demos, right?

0:27:42But the average person is what Apple's doing is giving you a show.

0:27:45They're giving you a a a an entertaining commercial.

0:27:48Right.

0:27:49But visually stimulating.

0:27:51Yep.

0:27:51And but the thing that is so hard to get across, because nobody really

0:27:55writes about it.

0:27:55And you can see it if you watch the day of and the hands-on.

0:27:59But the whole thing is a a live event, right?

0:28:03It is like the premiere of a movie and there's hundreds of people there.

0:28:08And there's a buzz in the air and there's jostling and a crowd.

0:28:14And it is a thing, right?

0:28:17It is electric.

0:28:18And that is partly the way it's always been, but it's also sort of

0:28:23different now, and it's a bigger deal, right?

0:28:26I did not know who iShow Speed was before this happened.

0:28:29I really didn't but now that I find out that there was a guy

0:28:33in the hands on area doing backflips with a million people watching him as

0:28:37he did it at the same time.

0:28:39I'm like that feels right.

0:28:41It feels like an area where yes, I don't know who all these people

0:28:45are.

0:28:46I don't some of them are speaking Chinese.

0:28:49Obviously don't know who they are.

0:28:51But some of them you can see sometimes, see people who are live streaming.

0:28:54And again, they obviously have some kind of special special dispensation from Apple to

0:28:58do that, right?

0:28:59I'm not allowed to live stream.

0:29:01You're not I mean I could do it, but then I maybe I then

0:29:04I don't stop getting invited.

0:29:05But some people are permitted to and you can just kind of tell whoever

0:29:09they are if they're permitted to.

0:29:10There's a lot of people watching this live right it is a cultivated thing

0:29:16and it does it gets the buzz generating right the live event aspect of

0:29:23it and it's just it's hard for people outside who aren't there to sort

0:29:28of understand what that's like.

0:29:31I did think we might see some sort of hybrid this time, just because

0:29:38we've got a new CEO.

0:29:40Maybe he wants to do something a little different.

0:29:42And the the guess I had was if they're wanting to introduce a foldable.

0:29:47You know how they always do all those those cool transitions when they're doing

0:29:50their show.

0:29:52Unfold Unfolding into the theater, like on the screen and he's walking out and

0:29:57I care and he's holding it.

0:29:58Like the way Steve Jobs would hold it back in the day holding it

0:30:01in his hand, everybody taking photos as he's and here we are, we're back

0:30:03live.

0:30:04Would have been interesting to see because I almost did feel like

0:30:10Turnus has an amazing personality, very different from Tim Cook, but it also felt

0:30:16like he's just playing he's just playing Tim Cook's role in in this video.

0:30:21That it didn't feel like his.

0:30:23It just felt like he stepped into someone else's place as opposed to having

0:30:28his own

0:30:30methodology of doing it.

0:30:33Yeah.

0:30:33And I don't know how much of that is just well, they're part of

0:30:37the seamless most seamless CEO transition ever is making every change one little click

0:30:46at a time and nothing's I mean, this is what I think is that

0:30:50there Tim Cook was on board with this John Turnus now that he is

0:30:54the CEO is on board with this I do think it is

0:31:00definitely Turnus's call.

0:31:02Like I know uh Cook is now chairman of the board and that's an

0:31:06unusual and unprecedented situation for a new CEO of Apple.

0:31:10But this whole th everything is unprecedented, right?

0:31:13The the modern history of Apple started Starts with Steve Jobs coming back to

0:31:17the company, right?

0:31:18And I'm interested in the that prehistoric period from the eighties and the nineties

0:31:25before that.

0:31:26And I do think that some of that

0:31:29DNA is still in the company.

0:31:31But in terms of it's like an A you know B C A D,

0:31:36like year zero of modern Apple is December nineteen ninety six when they made

0:31:42the deal to buy next.

0:31:44And nineteen ninety s right.

0:31:47It's it's not it just isn't worth

0:31:50trying to draw a line through that period, right?

0:31:54And so you've really just got Steve Jobs and then Steve Jobs got sick

0:31:59and he was going to be the chairman if he had been able to

0:32:02stay ahead of the cancer after he stepped down as CEO.

0:32:06But he didn't.

0:32:06He was gone I think it was August when he m said, I can't

0:32:10that day has come, can't do this anymore and by end of October he

0:32:14was dead.

0:32:15So there hasn't been the opportunity for the ex CEO to remain as chairman

0:32:20of the board before.

0:32:21But I do g I g very much have the impression that Tim Cook

0:32:23knows that if you're CEO, you've got to be left alone to be the

0:32:26CEO You cannot have the chairman breathing down your neck.

0:32:30No.

0:32:30And I think Tim Cook has plenty of stuff to keep him busy, right?

0:32:33Somebody joked, somebody observed, I forget what country they were from.

0:32:37So it was like Australia or something, but like somebody from like the Prime

0:32:40Minister of Australia or some other country was there and Tim Cook was showing

0:32:44them around campus like last Saturday and they're like, The guy just got the

0:32:48job and he's already working weekends.

0:32:50Oh, that's funny.

0:32:51Wow.

0:32:51I mean good.

0:32:52Let him handle those things though.

0:32:53That's fine.

0:32:54But I could see that.

0:32:55Like, did this current Apple keynote format evolve to fit Tim Cook's style?

0:33:00I think yes.

0:33:02Right?

0:33:03And so is it going to evolve to fit Turnus' style?

0:33:08Yes, I think.

0:33:09So I do think it will change.

0:33:11But I don't think I I don't think changing it significantly out of the

0:33:15get go was ever considered.

0:33:17And especially for the iPhone event, right?

0:33:20This next month

0:33:22right?

0:33:22Do you I everybody anticipates an October event or announcements of some sort.

0:33:28You never know what they'll do for these October things.

0:33:30Will it

0:33:43Yeah, or like the Neo event in March which was awesome.

0:33:47Really one of the best events they had, like a one off event in

0:33:50a weird warehouse space that they just took over and built a thing.

0:33:54And Turnus spoke at that one, right?

0:33:57Although I don't think they broadcast that, right?

0:33:59That but something like that, but maybe broadcast his actual remarks, right?

0:34:06Right.

0:34:07I would love to see them do something like that.

0:34:09And I kind of think they want to too right?

0:34:12And so the one they're least likely to screw with is going to be

0:34:16the September iPhone event, right?

0:34:18That it's it's like their Oscar.

0:34:21Right.

0:34:21And it's yeah, it's if you go back on YouTube and look at like

0:34:24the nineteen seventy seven Oscars and I don't know, Johnny Carson's hosting or Bob

0:34:28Hope or somebody like that, you're like, Holy shit, this does like for me,

0:34:32I was like I don't know, four years old at the time.

0:34:34And it's like it brings back some vibes 'cause I remember like being a

0:34:38little kid and not even knowing what these award shows are, but my mom

0:34:41and dad would be watching them or whatever, and it's like, Oh my god,

0:34:43this is amazing.

0:34:44And it is different.

0:34:45It's nothing like the modern day Oscars.

0:34:48But that's there was no year in between where it was like, oh wow,

0:34:51they totally changed how they did the Oscars.

0:34:53It just evolved over time.

0:34:55Yeah.

0:34:56And I think the iPhone event will be like that.

0:34:58And the other thing about the the invitees is I've heard and maybe I

0:35:02heard it from you.

0:35:04I don't know.

0:35:05But what I've heard is that they've made room to invite a broader range

0:35:12of influencers and media people by inviting fewer employees to sit in the theater

0:35:20for the keynote.

0:35:21That was me.

0:35:22Yeah, that was so it was yeah.

0:35:23So basically for this event in particular for whatever reason, Maybe just because it's

0:35:28their first foldable.

0:35:29It's I mean when again I was talking about this to other people, really

0:35:32this is the only the second time in the history of the iPhone that

0:35:35we're really seeing a new way to use an iPhone, right?

0:35:39It was the home button era and then it was the iPhone ten with

0:35:42the gesture era and this is only the second time, so the second change.

0:35:46So it was a bigger deal than typical and they wanted to get more

0:35:51media slash influencers slash celebrities in there.

0:35:54So the only way to do that would be to lessen the number of

0:35:59Apple employees, right?

0:36:01Because you can't they're not gonna magically grow the size of the Steve Jobs

0:36:05Theater, which different from W W D C where they're doing it outside and

0:36:10you could just throw some more chairs out there somewhere.

0:36:13Right.

0:36:13You have th a couple thousand people, it seems like thousands, right.

0:36:16This is Yeah.

0:36:17I don't know.

0:36:17What is the Steve Jobs theater?

0:36:19I looked it back up when they announced it.

0:36:21Apple Newsroom said a thousand people.

0:36:24And I don't I take it that's roughly.

0:36:26And they've re-jiggered the seating slightly since it opened, but I'm gonna say a

0:36:30thousand people, give or take.

0:36:32Okay, so if you typically would have twenty five percent Apple employees and seventy

0:36:36five percent media, maybe you lessen that to fifteen percent Apple employees or something.

0:36:40Yeah, I don't know what more attention.

0:36:42Yeah.

0:36:43And I could tell there was a lot of new people there, a lot

0:36:46of new faces.

0:36:47Yeah, and so that's my bigger takeaway from and where I think German is

0:36:51wrong is I don't think there's any decrease in the number of whatever your

0:36:57your idea of who the r right people are to be invited, people who

0:37:01if they get time to talk to Apple executives on or off the record

0:37:05will ask hard questions or interesting and probing questions.

0:37:10People who really are are going to say more than wow a real a

0:37:14new iPhone.

0:37:15Right?

0:37:16People who are going to actually evaluate it with a critical eye.

0:37:20I don't think they've ever I don't think they've turned the dial down on

0:37:24that type of invitees in order to make room for cheerleaders or people who

0:37:32are just enthusiastic.

0:37:34I think they've added that without decreasing the other mix by taking away seats

0:37:39that previously went to Apple employees.

0:37:41Yes, I think that's I think that's accurate.

0:37:43And I think in Okay the the truth is I think if they had

0:37:49it to do all over again, they would at least double the size of

0:37:52Steve Jobs Theater.

0:37:53Right?

0:37:54A thousand seats seems big.

0:37:55And it's I just linked yesterday as we record to that fourteen or sixteen

0:38:01year old recording of the the Antenna Gate press conference, which was in Apple's

0:38:07old town hall.

0:38:08Town hall held, I think, a hundred and twenty five people.

0:38:12Somebody told me the h the the seed count once.

0:38:15And I think it used to only hold a hundred and it was like

0:38:19around that time, like when the iPhone became after the iPhone shipped and it's

0:38:26it's becoming a big hit and uh things it was starting to head in

0:38:31this direction where it would be hard to f hard to make the cut

0:38:34for a thousand seat place.

0:38:36They redid the seats in the town hall and they made them like what

0:38:41when airlines do.

0:38:42Like when they're like, We're gonna add two more rows we're gonna add two

0:38:45more rows to the cabin and it's like, ah Christ.

0:38:48And it's like all of a sudden there's no room for your knees in

0:38:51your seat.

0:38:52And at that AntenneGate press conference it's part of it was that was so

0:38:58unusual and literally put together the day before.

0:39:02I re I wrote it was on a Friday and it was a Thursday

0:39:07and somebody from Apple PR called me to see say, Hey, I think we're

0:39:11gonna do an event tomorrow.

0:39:13I think they even told me what it was about, which is that just

0:39:15tells you how unusual it is.

0:39:17Okay.

0:39:18About this antenna situation.

0:39:21Could you make it?

0:39:22And I was like, I'll try, you know, and I booked a flight and

0:39:25literally at like eleven thirty A.

0:39:27M.

0:39:27East Coast time I had no idea and by three I'm at the airport

0:39:31getting on a flight to SFO.

0:39:33But the the town hall if you look at that video, it was only

0:39:36like maybe two thirds or three quarters full.

0:39:38There were like at least a quarter of the seats were empty.

0:39:41That would not happen today.

0:39:42No, not at all.

0:39:43Twenty twenty two days after the release of the iPhone eighteen pro, or let's

0:39:48say the duo right?

0:39:49'Cause the duo is the better compare, the one that everybody's excited.

0:39:53Twenty two days after the duo comes out, they have to hold an emergency

0:39:57press conference because there are reports that if you hold it wrong, it loses

0:40:02cell reception, there would not be uh seventy five people at that event.

0:40:10That would be that would be full.

0:40:11I mean that's the biggest story.

0:40:13And so I think coming from app old Apple campus where the hundred to

0:40:18hundred twenty five seat theater is like, Oh, that's too small and they made

0:40:22the Johnny Ivan, the architects are like, We'll make this grand Steve Jobs theater

0:40:26and it'll be a thousand seats and I think they thought that'll be a

0:40:29lot.

0:40:30I think g d given the iPhone event, it's at least that event every

0:40:35year.

0:40:36If they could have a bigger room, they could they would take it.

0:40:39But they don't have a bigger room.

0:40:41So it's a thousand and that's it.

0:40:43And so I think conversely, I think the weird thing is as Apple's own

0:40:47headcount of employees has grown and continues to grow and there's more people who

0:40:52work at Apple than ever, it's easier I think for them to say we're

0:40:57gonna have fewer employees there because it was already at the point where only

0:41:00a tiny sliver of Apple employees could possibly get in there.

0:41:04Right.

0:41:05Oh right.

0:41:06Certainly.

0:41:06Right, of course.

0:41:07Right.

0:41:07If you're not one of the executives who's uh in the keynotes sometimes and

0:41:12gets to sit in the first few rows, you're probably not gonna get to

0:41:15watch live.

0:41:16And you're just watching a video anyway, really.

0:41:18Right.

0:41:19And it's not to take anything away from them, but if the point is

0:41:22getting atten like the point of this event is to get attention on things.

0:41:26Yeah.

0:41:26Doesn't help.

0:41:27As someone like maybe you worked on you're one of the people who worked

0:41:30on moving the variable aperture, right?

0:41:32You're one of the just the team that worked on the variable aperture.

0:41:36It's cool to be able to be there and see the reception of it,

0:41:39but you yourself are not accomplishing the ultimate goal of getting attention on the

0:41:44event on the devices, so you're spendable in that sense.

0:41:50The other thing that was weird, have you ever been I presume you have,

0:41:52'cause it's been open for a bit.

0:41:54They have that weird not weird, but unusual new building, the observatory.

0:41:59Which is over there.

0:42:00It's close to the Steve Jobs Theater by tr by it's supposed to be.

0:42:05And they've had press things in there.

0:42:08And then I was wondering f w you I told earlier in the show

0:42:11when I was talking about the place where they took us to in a

0:42:13shuttle over in Menlo Park half an hour away.

0:42:17Why didn't they do this over in the observatory?

0:42:19But it turns out the observatory was where they after the hands on area

0:42:23where they took all of the sort of celebrity types.

0:42:27They did use the observatory, but it wasn't for the media.

0:42:31It was

0:42:33for social type things.

0:42:35And last year they used the observatory as a hands on area for is

0:42:40seventeen.

0:42:41But camera in particular, I remember.

0:42:44Yes.

0:42:45I think it was a mixture of this is my guess.

0:42:48Way more people this year being invited, so the observatory will be more cramped.

0:42:52And secondly, they were setting up for an evening event which they've never done

0:42:56before and maybe they didn't want us to see.

0:42:59Yeah, yeah.

0:42:59What was going on?

0:43:00Let's just get these guys over there and leave 'em there all day.

0:43:04I know.

0:43:04If but if it keeps going in this direction, by next year they're gonna

0:43:07uh uh put hoods over our heads and blindfold us.

0:43:10Right.

0:43:11And we're gonna wake up and they're gonna tell us we uh we can't

0:43:14tell you what state you're in.

0:43:16All right, let me take a break and then we can talk about the

0:43:18actual stuff that they announce.

0:43:20And I'm gonna talk to you about our good friends at Notion.

0:43:24Hey, are you worried you listener of the show?

0:43:28Is it is it occurred to you uh do you have just a little

0:43:32bit of uneasiness about hey, is are companies making AI products trying to replace

0:43:37human beings?

0:43:38Some companies are talking like that.

0:43:41Notion definitely is not.

0:43:43Teamwork is something that is fundamental to what Notion is meant to to work

0:43:49with.

0:43:50It's for actual people on teams.

0:43:52And yes, there's AI in Notion right now.

0:43:56But it is not about like helping a one person company whose employees, quote

0:44:04unquote, are an army of uh AI agents.

0:44:08That's not Notion.

0:44:09If that's the way that is an interesting area of AI, that's not notions

0:44:14game.

0:44:14Notions game is companies and teams full of actual people who are trying to

0:44:20use software to collaborate and Notion is a great tool for that.

0:44:24It is the AI workspace where your teams, knowledge, projects, and agents all come

0:44:31together in one place.

0:44:33Teams using Notion, move faster, cut friction and costs by consolidating tools and stay

0:44:42aligned.

0:44:43In Notion, your documents, your meetings, your projects, all of that stuff lives in

0:44:48one place in a connected system where the people on your team have access

0:44:53to them and can query them and search for them and ask questions about

0:44:57them.

0:44:58And the AI that you're using can do stuff like that too.

0:45:01But it really is about teamwork.

0:45:04Learn more about how Notion can support your business at Notion.com slash talkshow.

0:45:12That's all lowercase letters.

0:45:15Notion, N-O-T-I-O-N, Notion.com slash talk show to try Notion to get today.

0:45:23And when you used that link, you are supporting our show.

0:45:26Notion.com slash talk show.

0:45:30What do you think about the actual announcements?

0:45:32What's your takeaway two weeks later?

0:45:35It's well it's interesting because with the announcement of the iPhone Duo,

0:45:44you kind of that's where all the attention shifts to.

0:45:48So I think a lot of the other announcements that were made kind of

0:45:53got quickly overshadowed by that one.

0:45:57But I think everything everything was solid.

0:46:00We had the AirPod, which

0:46:04the one thing that confuses me is why do they even have the two

0:46:07different models that are only separated by twenty dollars?

0:46:10I so they did that with the AirPods four and they did it again

0:46:14with AirPods Five.

0:46:15So A, if they did it again, I guess the answer is people buy

0:46:19the cheaper one too?

0:46:20I I

0:46:22and that they somehow are convinced that if they only offered the one with

0:46:26the charging case that the some of the people who buy the cheaper one

0:46:31wouldn't the extra twenty bucks.

0:46:33I tried to ask in my briefing and I got one of those like

0:46:37a like uh I could see the look in their eyes that was like,

0:46:41We're not gonna answer that one.

0:46:42When they had if the words coming out of their mouth was different people

0:46:45have different needs and where they're both great products, blah blah blah.

0:46:49But it really this is something where I I feel like I would like

0:46:53to be in the Apple store and every time somebody tries to buy the

0:46:56AirPods five For $129.

0:47:00I want to shake them and say, here, I'll just give you twenty bucks.

0:47:03Here.

0:47:03Take twenty dollars and buy the other one.

0:47:05I swear to God.

0:47:07Pay it forward.

0:47:08Yeah.

0:47:09Because it's such a better product.

0:47:12Right.

0:47:12You're getting an hour more battery.

0:47:14You're getting the charging case that can go wireless.

0:47:17Yep.

0:47:17And you're getting the volume on the stems, right?

0:47:21You can squeeze the stems on the entry model, but you can't raise and

0:47:25lower the volume.

0:47:25And that's crazy to me.

0:47:27I mean, I forgot that there are AirPods that don't have volume on the

0:47:31stem.

0:47:32I mean that's how how long I've been using the AirPods Pro and it's

0:47:35so great.

0:47:36Like why what how do you lower the volume otherwise?

0:47:38What do you need to talk to C I mean I don't no matter

0:47:40how good Siri gets, I don't tell Siri to raise and lower the volume.

0:47:43That seems stupid.

0:47:44I just put my finger there.

0:47:45Yeah, I take your phone like an animal.

0:47:47Yeah, so I don't get the volume button.

0:47:49I d but it somebody must be buying it because they did it two

0:47:52generations in a row.

0:47:53I don't know.

0:47:54Right, right.

0:47:54But the cool the the best part of that announcement, I mean obviously they

0:47:57sound great, but noise cancellation came to the entry level.

0:48:03And so what we really saw there was a price drop, if you think

0:48:07about it, versus what you had to pay on AirPods four to get that

0:48:11feature versus AirPods Five, especially in the current day and age with how the

0:48:15pricing of technology items, like this is a real price drop, right?

0:48:19You get this feature for much less than you did just the day before

0:48:23on the AirPods 4.

0:48:24So I thought that was I thought that was great.

0:48:26Apple Watch, I'm just going order of what I thought was exciting.

0:48:29I'm not trying to take over.

0:48:30Yeah yeah.

0:48:31Uh but Apple Watch.

0:48:33I it I didn't see As aside from the audio intelligence feature, which I

0:48:37think is the most controversial thing they did.

0:48:40And interesting.

0:48:42Right.

0:48:42And it's and it's not out yet even in beta.

0:48:45So it's all we you and I with review units and access to the

0:48:50betas that are develop we still can't talk about it.

0:48:53We don't have it, yes.

0:48:54I did I was happy to see the return of the ceramic finish.

0:48:58I was a big fan of that.

0:48:59Yeah, that's nice.

0:48:59What was it?

0:49:00Series three ver three through five, I think it was.

0:49:02Back then called the Apple Watch Edition, which they did not bring back that

0:49:05name.

0:49:06I forgot that.

0:49:06Weird name anyway.

0:49:07Yeah.

0:49:08But so but it almost felt like we have to do something unique and

0:49:11different this time because there's not much change to the hardware itself.

0:49:16So that that's one thing that they did.

0:49:18I thought the finishes this year are really good.

0:49:20The gold looked really good.

0:49:21The bronze I thought was really nice on the aluminum.

0:49:23Putting ceramic shield two on the aluminum watches to me, Ceramic Shield two was

0:49:29like the the unsung hero of the iPhone 17 line.

0:49:32Like after, I don't know, a week or so of babying iPhones for years,

0:49:39I would always have these micro scratches on there.

0:49:41And the 17 Pro after a year today.

0:49:45It's as if it was just taken out of the box.

0:49:47So if you ever bang your Apple Watch on a door jam as you're

0:49:51walking by or whatever and get micro scratches on it, I think that problem

0:49:55is solved this year.

0:49:56So that's very nice.

0:49:57But I am interested to see how it the audio intelligence is going to

0:50:02be received by the general public, especially with

0:50:08the

0:50:09at least the online backlash of meta's glasses.

0:50:13Yeah.

0:50:13And the the whole feeling of surveillance that people are worried about?

0:50:19Yeah.

0:50:20Is that a general population worry or is that an online echo chamber worry?

0:50:25I'm just curious where that goes.

0:50:27How do you feel about those features though?

0:50:29I'm okay with them.

0:50:30And I did just I had a short piece on Daring Fireball that I

0:50:34could probably just summarize.

0:50:35But I think I'm glad to see Apple doing it, and it seems thoughtful,

0:50:40and they didn't spell this out.

0:50:42But then when I had a follow-up call with Apple, the product marketing people

0:50:47for the review unit of the watch, I asked about it.

0:50:50And it was my formulation, but they said that that is a good point

0:50:54and we do think of it that way, which is that my question to

0:50:57them was, Well, how come these features you have to have the watch to

0:51:01do?

0:51:02Why can't my phone i putting aside the larger question of are these good

0:51:06ideas and are people comfortable with them anyway.

0:51:09Why can't the phone do this?

0:51:11The phone has microphones.

0:51:12The phone, if anything, probably has better microphones than the watch.

0:51:16Phone has a better processor, bigger battery.

0:51:19Why doesn't the phone list listen to for these things.

0:51:22And then I thought about it, and it's that the watch is a trusted

0:51:27device once it's on your wrist and unlocked, and it remains trusted until you

0:51:32take it off.

0:51:33Right?

0:51:33You put it on in the morning.

0:51:35You either type in your code or you unlock it with your watch and

0:51:39now the the watch is unlocked until you take it off.

0:51:44Whereas your phone is only in a trusted state when the screen's on, right?

0:51:49And it's like you forget that with face ID.

0:51:52And we could talk about it we'll talk about that with t with the

0:51:54duo in a bit, but the lack of face ID.

0:51:58But with the phone, it's all day, every day.

0:52:01It is going you don't really think about it because I I don't think

0:52:04about it, even though I'm talking about it right here.

0:52:06But it's like I forget about it.

0:52:08Is it's face ID for me is so seamless that I don't think of

0:52:13my phone as being locked and unlocked and locked and unlocked and locked and

0:52:16unlocked.

0:52:17But it is.

0:52:17Dozens and dozens of times a day it goes from locked and totally locked

0:52:24out of anybody who picks it up can't do anything to I look at

0:52:28it and as soon as I look at it it's unlocked and now it'll

0:52:31show me private information.

0:52:33And so the phone really isn't a good device to be listening to conversations.

0:52:37In my example, just not even being creepy, but like I leave my phone

0:52:41in our kitchen all the time.

0:52:43I that's a place where I just I have a spot on the counter

0:52:46and there's chargers and conversations take place in the kitchen when I'm not in

0:52:52the kitchen.

0:52:53My phone should not be recording and transcribing those conversations, right?

0:52:58They're almost certainly innocuous.

0:53:00It's my wife and son here or whoever else might be a guest in

0:53:03the house.

0:53:04But I'm not there.

0:53:05So it shouldn't listening.

0:53:06Definitely.

0:53:07I think everybody I don't want it to be listening.

0:53:10Or what if I am a creeper, I shouldn't kind of surreptitiously or leave

0:53:16or hide my phone in a room and have it listen and transcribe or

0:53:22summarize conversations when I'm not there.

0:53:25Right.

0:53:26And your watch won't do that either because for you to leave your watch

0:53:30in a room or put it in a desk drawer or whatever and try

0:53:33to do that, if the watch is off your wrist, it won't do any

0:53:37of these things.

0:53:38It's only when it's on your wrist.

0:53:40So I think that's a little bit more thoughtful than people are who whose

0:53:44knee jerk reaction is, Oh, this is creepy and perverted and whatever are thinking.

0:53:49And that's the point.

0:53:51My comparison is to air tags, right?

0:53:53Everybody when Apple announced AirTags is like, oh, I don't know if anybody should

0:53:56make this this device.

0:53:58That technology was coming one way or the other.

0:54:01And it would be better it was better for Apple to come out with

0:54:03a privacy minded version than for some other company to come out with one

0:54:08that didn't have any of the privacy controls.

0:54:10And AI transcription listening devices are they're here already, but they're going to be

0:54:17everywhere soon.

0:54:18And so and whether that's good or bad, it's irrelevant.

0:54:22They are coming, whether Apple shipped them or not, or and whether Apple could

0:54:26cancel the watch features and say, you know what, we heard, we listened, we're

0:54:30gonna postpone these features for a year and maybe they they save for a

0:54:34year and it never comes back.

0:54:35They're still coming.

0:54:36They're just gonna come from other companies.

0:54:38And I think that's gonna be worse.

0:54:40That's

0:54:41Apple being able to kind of lead the way and set the example of

0:54:45here's the proper way to do this.

0:54:46And that was a good point you made because even if I can unlock

0:54:50my phone and I can hand it to you, unlocked, and then you can

0:54:55continue using it, I can't unlock my watch and then hand it to you.

0:55:00No.

0:55:00Even if I wanted to.

0:55:02The second it comes off.

0:55:03Right.

0:55:03The second it comes off your wrist, it is no it locks itself.

0:55:06So I have to unlock it for you and put it there's no way

0:55:09to transfer it in the unlocked state from one person to another

0:55:14which goes along with the point you just made that it really is the

0:55:18when it comes to a trusted state of any device that you have, that

0:55:22that would be the one that you would know.

0:55:26It's on that person.

0:55:28Yeah.

0:55:29And it's like people aren't thinking about this, but the watch has had the

0:55:32voice memos app for years.

0:55:34I don't even know how many years.

0:55:36Right?

0:55:37And you could like if you have the ultra, you can just like set

0:55:39it to the action button, right?

0:55:41And you could just have the action button start a recording.

0:55:44And so anybody, especially if they're wearing long sleeves and can cover the watch,

0:55:49their watch might be voice memoing right now.

0:55:52Right.

0:55:52And the phone too.

0:55:53The phone is had it for and it does a transcription of everything and

0:55:56you can put your phone face down.

0:55:57Right.

0:55:58So

0:56:00you know, in the media nobody carries dedicated voice recorders anymore.

0:56:04Whenever there's like an on the record briefing or a meeting or something like

0:56:07that.

0:56:08Everybody just puts their phones out and points 'em towards the person who's being

0:56:12recorded and it's just a tabletop full of r reporters' phones all recording.

0:56:17Exactly.

0:56:18You have no idea if somebody's If it's not on the tabletop or it's

0:56:22face down and you can't see the screen, you have no idea whose phone

0:56:25is recording.

0:56:26And and that's not putting all of everybody's concerns to rest, right?

0:56:30But I'm saying the idea that they've introduced the ability for the watch to

0:56:35record and transcribe is that's the wrong way to think about it.

0:56:39That's been here for years.

0:56:40These new features.

0:56:42And I they're parsing Apple is parsing words a little, but I see the

0:56:47point.

0:56:47And I do think And I think they could have done a better job

0:56:50explaining it technically.

0:56:51When they say with the live rewind, what's it is that what it's called?

0:56:55Yeah.

0:56:56Fifteen second one.

0:56:57Right.

0:56:58And they say that it doesn't record.

0:57:00But it's like, well, if it doesn't record, how in the world does it

0:57:03go back fifteen seconds to get a transcript?

0:57:05And I think that the techni I think I don't know this, nobody at

0:57:09Apple has confirmed it, but I think it's effectively in a buffer and it's

0:57:13never it never touches permanent storage in the device.

0:57:18Correct.

0:57:18And that buffer is in the secure enclave.

0:57:22Exclave.

0:57:22Exclave.

0:57:23Yeah, or whatever they call it.

0:57:28Because the s the secure enclave is on is in an area that can

0:57:33be accessed.

0:57:33So the exclave is like it's totally outside of everything.

0:57:37Yeah.

0:57:37Yeah.

0:57:38So it never touches permanent storage, even a bite of it.

0:57:42And it's only in what's effectively RAM, like if the watch powers down, it's

0:57:47gone.

0:57:47And there's only fifteen seconds worth of buffer space for it in the secure

0:57:51exclave.

0:57:52And because it's a secure exclave, no app on the system or rogue app

0:57:58could be like if you figured out a way to a super common way

0:58:03to for these exploits is you send somebody an iMessage that's malformed and it's

0:58:09got like an image that triggers a bug in the the JPEG parser and

0:58:14now you've overwritten memory.

0:58:16And I know that Apple has spent years sandboxing the image, but that that

0:58:19has been a traditional path to a zero day.

0:58:22You send somebody a bad I formatted I message, corrupts memory.

0:58:27Nothing that could happen there can ever poke through the secure exclave.

0:58:31Yes.

0:58:31So correct it still can't get the last fifteen seconds of audio.

0:58:35Even though if it could get it, which it can't, it would only be

0:58:38fifteen seconds anyway.

0:58:39So it really is kind of secure.

0:58:42It's that feature in particular, to me, uh once you really think about it,

0:58:47I can't see any reason to object to it other than the fact that

0:58:50I feel like fifteen seconds is probably too short.

0:58:53So it's sort of not that people worried that it's a privacy invasion, it's

0:58:58that I'm not quite sure that the times when I n might need that.

0:59:02'Cause you g I'd have to add for me at least three or four

0:59:05seconds of remembering, oh, I could I can double click this on my watch.

0:59:09I've already seconds by remembering to go back, so I'm only getting ten or

0:59:13eleven seconds.

0:59:14Right.

0:59:15And I asked them too, is it fifteen seconds of because it's meant for

0:59:19spoken word.

0:59:19So I was like, is it the last fifteen meg seconds of spoken word

0:59:23that I heard?

0:59:23Or is it fifteen seconds of real time?

0:59:25So in other words, if you said something to me 14 seconds ago, will

0:59:29I only hear one second of that and then fifteen seconds and then fourteen

0:59:32seconds of dead air?

0:59:33And the answer was yes.

0:59:34It was it's just fifteen seconds of time passing.

0:59:37So it really isn't just saving anything.

0:59:40Right.

0:59:40Right.

0:59:41Right.

0:59:41That is a good that's a very good question.

0:59:42I didn't think about that.

0:59:43Somebody who's talking slowly and pausing between answers.

0:59:47You don't have thirty seconds of time for fifteen seconds of text.

0:59:50You get fifteen seconds, period.

0:59:52And the other thing with the other feature, the what are they calling the

0:59:55one with the transcripts?

0:59:57I forget the name, but someone that summarizes it summari it listens and summarizes

1:00:02the portion of the day that you have it enabled.

1:00:06Right.

1:00:06And but it will also not summarize what it considers to be sensitive conversation.

1:00:15Whatever that means.

1:00:15They didn't Yeah, and it's like I am I'm the the the Joanna Stern

1:00:21in me that's trying to think of the most absurd way to test features

1:00:27is already thinking like what kind of pretend conversation could I have to see

1:00:33if it'll summarize it that is completely inappropriate or will it record if I

1:00:38pretend to talk about a medical crisis, is that what it considers to But

1:00:44I don't know if it's wouldn't you want if you're talking to a doctor?

1:00:47Like that the one thing I've heard from multiple people is they would love

1:00:51to have this for times that they go to talk to a doctor and

1:00:53it's like even if you're not having a crisis per se, it's like what

1:00:57the hell was my doctor saying about the it was like the they were

1:01:00talking about my blood work and they said some number was not a problem

1:01:04and I don't need medication but it was like just above the point where

1:01:08maybe they would prescribe medication and I forget what the number was.

1:01:12And it's like I would love to get a a transcript of that so

1:01:15I could remember exactly what it was.

1:01:17And yes, you can just call your doctor and say that, but I who

1:01:19does that, right right.

1:01:22So I don't know.

1:01:23And what if you and I have a conversation where we pretend to be

1:01:26talking about robbing a bank?

1:01:28Right.

1:01:28Or or if you and I are having an argument.

1:01:30Is that what it would be like what's sensitive?

1:01:32It's Yeah.

1:01:34We have to see it in action because I really do wonder

1:01:37if you're meeting with your doctor, you want accurate I don't know how much

1:01:41of a I want a summary, but I want a transcript.

1:01:44And it's like giving you a transcript.

1:01:46So

1:01:47Yeah, how detailed is that summary?

1:01:49Where does it c how yeah, exactly.

1:01:51How useful is the summary when you can't refer to well, let me see

1:01:56what exactly the doctor said when they were talking about this section.

1:02:00So I'm curious.

1:02:01Yeah, and so I I think it's a great idea.

1:02:04I think Apple is in a good position to be the ones to sort

1:02:08of start introducing features like this into daily life and make people comfortable with

1:02:13it.

1:02:14I d my my concerns aren't that this is not private.

1:02:19I think it is I think Apple is it's as far as I can

1:02:22tell, they have thought through all the actual privacy issues.

1:02:25So I think it actually is private.

1:02:27But that doesn't mean most people will perceive it as private, right?

1:02:32It's the perception that matters.

1:02:35And honestly, that just going back to the Antena Gate thing, that was honestly

1:02:40the whole thing with in hindsight.

1:02:41Clearly that was the problem with the antenna gate.

1:02:44The iPhone four did not have a fundamental flaw with the antenna.

1:02:48It had a minor flaw with the antenna.

1:02:50And it it really was only evident in a situation with low signal strength

1:02:57to begin with.

1:02:58Low signal strength plus quote unquote holding it the wrong way and it would

1:03:03drop from low but usable to lost signal.

1:03:08But it was the perception that had them call us call call me from

1:03:13across the country to hold a press conference to address it, because the perception

1:03:17was they just released a fancy new phone and it can't make a phone

1:03:20call.

1:03:21And that perception matters.

1:03:24And if Apple released a new feature that transcribes meetings throughout your day or

1:03:30conversations throughout your day and gives you a useful AI summary of them at

1:03:34the end of the day, and it really is private and thoughtful.

1:03:38But the perception is anybody wearing an Apple Watch is listening to you and

1:03:42recording everything you say to them while they're wearing the watch.

1:03:45That's a problem.

1:03:46That is a problem.

1:03:47But again, you already kind of solved for that with the fact that voice

1:03:52recording has been something on the watch and the phone for years and this

1:03:58is doing less than that.

1:03:59This is just summarizing.

1:04:01And so it's not recorded.

1:04:03It's weird, but there was no backlash when the voice recorder was added.

1:04:07But the backlash

1:04:09because of AI.

1:04:10Right.

1:04:10You can have a five year old Apple Watch right now that is way

1:04:14more privacy invasive than the brand new series twelve with this feature once the

1:04:18feature comes out.

1:04:19But the other thing too is one of those things is every Apple Watch

1:04:22from more than three or four feet away looks the same, right?

1:04:25It or at least looks like the the same generation.

1:04:28It looks like an Apple Watch.

1:04:29So if everybody starts thinking I don't think it's gonna happen, and I think

1:04:33cameras are different, and I think that's why came out with the glasses that

1:04:37don't have cameras, period.

1:04:39I think as as much as people stood up at attention with this whole

1:04:44feature when it was announced in the keynote, the fact that it's just recording

1:04:48audio doesn't trigger the same reaction in people that cameras do, right?

1:04:54Right.

1:04:54Right.

1:04:55But I also think there's the Apple has the I don't wanna say I

1:05:00think it's well earned.

1:05:01Their reputation of privacy is well earned.

1:05:04But I think

1:05:05there's a sense within the company

1:05:09that they think everybody knows this.

1:05:14Yes.

1:05:14Whereas Andrew.

1:05:16Yes.

1:05:16You know what I'm saying?

1:05:17If we just say, hey, we have this feature and it's private, we don't

1:05:20have to say anything more than that.

1:05:21We just put the Apple logo with the little lock and thing at the

1:05:24top and right.

1:05:25But I think a lot of people just don't believe big tech.

1:05:30And they think ever they think your iPhone listens to you all day and

1:05:34puts ads in front of you and that that's the perception.

1:05:38Whether it's true or not, that's perception.

1:05:39So you have to go in with, okay, here's what the average person thinks.

1:05:43We need to be more explanatory.

1:05:45Almost the way Steve Jobs said a long time ago about privacy.

1:05:48Tell people what you're doing tell and then tell them again and then tell

1:05:50'em again.

1:05:51Right?

1:05:51Be super clear about it.

1:05:53Yeah.

1:05:53Versus we've earned this reputation, we don't say much about it.

1:05:57Yeah, and I think part of that I don't think it's cockiness, but I

1:06:00do think it is the fact that it people at Apple, some of the

1:06:05people in the product marketing who I talk to about the watch, I've been

1:06:08talking to since the first watch.

1:06:10It's not just that they've been at Apple that long, but I know people

1:06:13who've been working on Apple Watch now for twelve generations.

1:06:17And they get used to it and they know the focus the hyper vigilant

1:06:22focus they have on privacy at the company.

1:06:25And they know that everybody else they work with at Apple has that same

1:06:30hyper vigilant focus on privacy.

1:06:34And everybody knows that people at other companies have less of a focus on

1:06:39privacy, right?

1:06:40And but I think what app people at Apple from being in st in

1:06:45Apple for so long and thinking and knowing in their bones that Apple is

1:06:49a different company with a different priority of or different order of priorities compared

1:06:55to other companies, they completely lose track of what you were saying, which is

1:06:59that in the real world, regular people they know the difference between Apple and

1:07:03Meta and Google and Amazon, but they think they're all in cahoots together and

1:07:08that the same people who are at Google today are probably working at Apple

1:07:12next year and then they're working at Meta the year after that and then

1:07:15they're working at Amazon and then they're back to Google and they're just they're

1:07:19all the same and they all do the same things and they're all listening.

1:07:23They that's ha that is how people think.

1:07:25It really is.

1:07:27If they think your Facebook app or your Instagram app is showing you ads

1:07:32based on something you just talked about, your iPhone is right.

1:07:35It's your iPhone that's listening to you.

1:07:38Yes.

1:07:38And so they just see it as it's one big

1:07:43industry that's just slurping up all your data.

1:07:46Yeah and it's the industry.

1:07:48Right.

1:07:48At the same time, Apple probably better than any other company.

1:07:52It probably is part of what makes Apple Apple and makes Apple

1:07:56more worthy of attention in my book is that they're more aware.

1:08:01They're not just aware in a scornful way, like, oh, you're a dummy, so

1:08:07we're gonna make a product for you as a dummy.

1:08:10They they it's with respect that they're like, You're we're gonna treat you as

1:08:15an intelligent person and we just but we know that you don't know anything

1:08:19about how computers work and you shouldn't need to.

1:08:23You've got your own life and your own interest and if you would like

1:08:25to learn about how computers work, that's great.

1:08:27We that's everybody here at Apple did.

1:08:30But if your interest is somewhere else you shouldn't have to know how this

1:08:34works, but we're still gonna make a product that respects your intelligence and is

1:08:40design will do all the hard work at their best with their best products

1:08:44and they pull it off.

1:08:45But they even with their worst products that don't it's what they were trying

1:08:49for is to present to the user an experience that doesn't make them understand

1:08:53how it works.

1:08:55But at the same time that Apple is aware of that, they don't really

1:08:58think about it from the other side that if they don't understand how it

1:09:00works that you cannot e explain in technical detail how it's not possible for

1:09:07Instagram to listen to you because the secure I think it's this time the

1:09:12secure enclave makes sure that the green light goes on if the microphone is

1:09:17on.

1:09:17There's no

1:09:19your battery will be destroyed if everything that you Yes.

1:09:24I've had this conversation with extended family members multiple times.

1:09:27And they enjoy it.

1:09:28And I think I explain it to them well.

1:09:30And they it's the best sense they've ever gotten of what I do and

1:09:34maybe what what has given me a career.

1:09:37But like I've said, the scariest part isn't Like when they talk, and again,

1:09:42it comes up at family gatherings.

1:09:43I'm guessing it's happened to you.

1:09:45I'm just about anybody who listens to this show or watches any of your

1:09:50videos, is you know your family members think the phones listen to you.

1:09:53And what I've said is As creepy as that would be if your phone

1:09:57was just listening to the conversations you were having about it and then using

1:10:00the transcription of those conversations to then serve you ads, that would be incredibly

1:10:06inefficient.

1:10:07And what they're actually doing is so complicated.

1:10:10That it's actually creepier, but it's not listening to you.

1:10:14It isn't listening to you.

1:10:16But by what right.

1:10:18By what you do when you go to the website where you buy root

1:10:24beer.

1:10:25You love some edgy little independent brand of root beer and you go there

1:10:29and you buy it, but they put pixels on the site from a thousand

1:10:33partners, including Facebook.

1:10:36And then Facebook picks it up from that and then And that they know

1:10:40that people who like root beer and who also watch this movie, there is

1:10:44a c for whatever reason, people who are interested in rewatching the Matrix trilogy

1:10:50over and over again and who buy craft cane sugar root beer

1:10:55also really I don't they don't they have no idea why, but there is

1:10:59a very strong correlation to wanting to buy uh Japanese blue jeans.

1:11:03And they're gonna show you an ad for Japanese blue jeans.

1:11:06And sometimes something weird like that's gonna happen.

1:11:09You're like, I don't know how this happened.

1:11:11I just told m my wife that I was thinking about getting these goddamn

1:11:14Japanese blue jeans.

1:11:15And th the son of a the thing must be listening to me.

1:11:18And it's not.

1:11:19It's actually creepier and more complex, but it's not listening to you.

1:11:23And you can explain to them that it is technically impossible to turn the

1:11:27microphone on without that light coming on and if y and that if y

1:11:30even somebody who opened the phone and tried to disconnect the light, the microphone

1:11:35would stop working.

1:11:36It really is uh it's cryptographically uh guaranteed.

1:11:40It's like the Farside cartoon where the guy's yelling at his dog to saying

1:11:44and all the dog hears is blah blah blah blah ginger, blah blah blah

1:11:48blah ginger.

1:11:49All they hear when you explain it is blah blah blah blah iPhone blah

1:11:53blah blah blah listening.

1:11:56That's it.

1:11:56Or or what they hear is oh you are brainwashed by your own industry.

1:12:02We really know how they're obviously listening to us, right?

1:12:04So I think we're wrong.

1:12:05We oh, you're just gullible.

1:12:07Yeah.

1:12:07So what I have found works in that regard is by saying that what

1:12:11they actually do is creepier.

1:12:14If you understood it and that I barely understand it, but that it is

1:12:18creepier, that's what resonates.

1:12:20'Cause I'm not saying, hey, the whole tech industry is on your side and

1:12:24doesn't creepy things.

1:12:26Right.

1:12:26You're saying it's actually worse than what you think.

1:12:28Yeah.

1:12:29Right.

1:12:29And if you talk to people who work in the ad tech industry, they

1:12:33honest to God, if they could have recordings of what you talk about all

1:12:37day, they wouldn't.

1:12:38They're like, We don't need that.

1:12:39Do you know how much work that would be?

1:12:40You know how much space that would take up?

1:12:42Why would we want that?

1:12:44We don't need that.

1:12:45It would be the least efficient way to serve you targeted ads.

1:12:49It's it but that's the world Apple's up against.

1:12:52Apple doesn't do it, but that's the world people people are in.

1:12:57The other thing I want us before we move on from Apple Watch, the

1:13:01other thing that I'm wondering about with these features is I'm just honestly wondering

1:13:05how well they'll work at a technical level.

1:13:08Because I do think Siri AI is very good on the phone and on

1:13:13the Mac.

1:13:14And I do think that w their plan they announced at WWDC totally works.

1:13:19I think it is a step change forward.

1:13:21They have cut up to baseline modern L L M.

1:13:27That's the bar.

1:13:28Right?

1:13:28It's not anywhere close to the frontier.

1:13:30It is not gonna blow anything away that you're if you're used to the

1:13:34leading edge models from ChatGPT and Claude and they never said it was, right?

1:13:39It does what they said and it is baseline competent and can answer amazingly

1:13:45interesting questions based on your email and your iMessages and your Apple notes and

1:13:51whatever other apps publish their data in a way that can be indexed.

1:13:55And you can just ask questions like, hey, what was the serial number of

1:13:58my iPhone series iPhone 16 that I bought two years ago because I want

1:14:02to get the refund from Apple's AI refund thing and it'll just tell you

1:14:05your serial number if it's in your email.

1:14:07That stuff works.

1:14:09I don't think Siri just regular Siri works very well on Apple Watch.

1:14:13Any I still don't think it does.

1:14:15It is slow.

1:14:16I don't think you can have conversations.

1:14:20It does not seem to me to be a good AI device just for

1:14:24regular Siri, and yet now they're saying in it which so it the watch

1:14:29still hasn't, in my experience.

1:14:33And they're saying it's gonna give me daily summaries of every conversation I've had

1:14:36that is that it but only the interesting ones.

1:14:39Right.

1:14:40So it puts your summaries into the Siri AI app.

1:14:45So you can open your phone and see.

1:14:47So I guess I'm I didn't ask this question, but I'm curious.

1:14:50Is the phone doing any of this work?

1:14:53Or is it just

1:14:56I think the phone must be doing the transcription, but they don't talk about

1:14:59that.

1:14:59They don't explain it.

1:15:00I think they should.

1:15:01I think they should draw a diagram honest to God, Ed Like the diagrams

1:15:04from W D C, right?

1:15:06Yeah, like dub dub dub D C or the way that like I remember

1:15:10Phil Schiller doing one with one of the iPhone cameras where they talked about

1:15:13the focus pixels on the sensor.

1:15:15And he was like this might be a lot of detail for this type

1:15:18of event, but I love this stuff and I think you want to know

1:15:20it.

1:15:20And uh He spent like two minutes talking about a a new sensor technology

1:15:24that let them get a sharper image.

1:15:27I give us some diagrams of how this works.

1:15:29But I don't know.

1:15:30I'm just show me when it I'll believe it when I see it that

1:15:33this works well.

1:15:34Right, right.

1:15:35That's a good point.

1:15:36I do agree.

1:15:36Siri i is so much better, but I have you not seen any regressions

1:15:41in any i any areas?

1:15:43Like in recent weeks?

1:15:46Yeah, like I guess for me the two regressions is if you ask it

1:15:51something that old Siri was good at, turn this light on, right?

1:15:55Uh old Siri would turn it on within a second or half a second.

1:15:59And new Siri has to it's almost like are you setting this to the

1:16:02cloud?

1:16:02Like what are you doing?

1:16:04Private cloud compute.

1:16:05Yeah.

1:16:05And the other one was a specific use case that I would use often

1:16:09is if I know I have a password in my password manager app, say

1:16:15Google Password or Samsung, whatever.

1:16:17Old Siri, I can say what's my Google password?

1:16:19Because I want to copy and paste it into a website or try to

1:16:21log it.

1:16:22What's my Google password?

1:16:22It'll and it'll open the passwords app to the Google password.

1:16:26So I can literally just tap and copy it instantly.

1:16:29And now it's like, oh I don't know what that is.

1:16:30Why are you asking me?

1:16:31Uh this is something that Old Cree was an expert at.

1:16:34Right.

1:16:35Right, because they probably put passwords on a list of, hey, don't touch this

1:16:39app, right?

1:16:39It's sort of like the whole problem with the journal app.

1:16:42I I'm fascinated by the journal app even though every single step of the

1:16:46way and every single word I've ever typed into the Apple journal app, I've

1:16:50thought this is a bad idea to put anything I care about into this

1:16:54app because this is not a good app.

1:16:57But I like the idea of it.

1:16:58I like the presentation of your journal entries as sort of a personal social

1:17:02feed rather than a three panel thing like the actual notes app.

1:17:08But Apple Journal is not indexed by the new Siri AI thing because it's

1:17:13like, oh, that's because it's

1:17:15maybe that's what some people want.

1:17:17I would like everything I put in the app to be indexed by Siri,

1:17:21right?

1:17:21I everything on my phone.

1:17:22There's nothing on my phone that I don't want Siri to index.

1:17:26I would like it to see the passwords.

1:17:29But I think they don't want to s I think it's 'cause they don't

1:17:31spook people.

1:17:32They don't want to spook they're like, oh, Siri never looks inside your journal.

1:17:35Maybe it will eventually, right?

1:17:37And right now it doesn't have access to health right?

1:17:39That's the big new thing coming out and the health update that's in beta

1:17:44right now is re re architecting the health app.

1:17:48And maybe it's like they're double crossing the T's and double dotting the I's

1:17:52just to make sure

1:17:54that everything Siri does related to your information and health is by the book.

1:17:59When that when you say, Hey, what's the door code for my garage?

1:18:04I forget, and it's gonna say your blood pressure was one forty one over

1:18:08and it's like what that's not what are you talking about?

1:18:10How are you s you're not supposed to say that out loud?

1:18:13I don't know.

1:18:14But it's I just don't want to see new series not able to do

1:18:17stuff that old series could do.

1:18:19The bad series can do this.

1:18:20The slowness is a real thing and I think it's because you say stuff

1:18:23and it's like, oh I know you're talking to me.

1:18:25And it's like it does so much more process.

1:18:28So when you do ask it a complex thing and it does take a

1:18:31few seconds to chew on it and you're like, I'll give you a few

1:18:35seconds to find the serial number to a phone I bought two years ago.

1:18:38Sure.

1:18:38Right.

1:18:39But when you say turn the lights on in the kitchen

1:18:42you don't you shouldn't need to Exactly.

1:18:44What are we waiting for?

1:18:45And I think what's happening I don't know, I'd have to guess.

1:18:49I don't know I just feel like it doesn't even determine that it's a

1:18:53simple request until it's done something more complex to make sure it's not more

1:18:59complex.

1:19:00But then the truth is now it takes five seconds to turn the lights

1:19:03on and off.

1:19:04And that's always I think old Siri was still slow compared to Alexa.

1:19:08We actually had an Alexa in our kitchen for years just because it was

1:19:13instant, right?

1:19:14And I'd I put I always every year I always had the I think

1:19:17I still do actually.

1:19:17I think I put the Alexa I plug it back in when we have

1:19:19Christmas trees.

1:19:21Because b my wife likes to have multiple Christmas trees throughout the house and

1:19:24plug them in with an Alexa power adapter and you tell Alexa to turn

1:19:30them off and it is like hitting a light switch.

1:19:33It is before the word is out of your mouth, they're on or they're

1:19:36off.

1:19:37And which is exactly what you want.

1:19:39And with Siri, yeah, not so much.

1:19:41But overall it's good.

1:19:42I think there I also I was wondering if this is what you're talking

1:19:45about.

1:19:46I also think that as the beta has turned into release and now the

1:19:50world is using it, it seems a little worse than it did over summer.

1:19:55I bet that could totally just be my own personal anecdot.

1:19:59I asked a question, I forget what it was.

1:20:01It is so good to and I know people who are you you have

1:20:04all their email and Gmail uh and ask Gemini have been getting this for

1:20:09for years or a while.

1:20:11But asking Siri for something in my email, thousands and thousands of messages is

1:20:17so much better than any search of my email I've ever had.

1:20:21It's even better than the search it i in Gmail itself when you type

1:20:26just a query because you can say what it was about.

1:20:29Who's the person who told me the weird story about the the whatever I

1:20:35don't know.

1:20:36They told me a story that they saw somebody on the BART train with

1:20:40a weird color iPhone and then they're like, Oh, that was so and so

1:20:43who told you a story in twenty fourteen about the this and it's like,

1:20:47There's the email.

1:20:48That's amazing.

1:20:49It really is.

1:20:50But I you know, it's weird.

1:20:51I don't he feel like part of the hey, now it meets the bar

1:20:55for what people expect is the fact that in the real world it doesn't

1:20:59seem like people are amazed, right?

1:21:01It just feels like people aren't complaining.

1:21:04Which is I think the best that Apple could hope for.

1:21:08But I think I've also heard you talk about this too, where it's like

1:21:11you're s you've been so trained to not ask Siri to do certain things

1:21:18that you forget to try

1:21:21doing it again because now we'll actually do it.

1:21:23And we've been using this since again beta over the summer.

1:21:27Everyone else has only had access to this for what a few weeks.

1:21:31So there they are where we were a few months back where

1:21:36they're used to it.

1:21:37I really mean it.

1:21:38They need an ad campaign that is the the gist of it is seriously,

1:21:43try Siri again.

1:21:45I s they really do.

1:21:46And they're up the last of us again and this time she can actually

1:21:50do series commercials that they are not gonna do that.

1:21:53They're definitely not going to bring her back.

1:21:56They don't remind people of that.

1:21:57But what do you let's uh talk about the iPhone eighteen pro before before

1:22:02moving on.

1:22:03All right.

1:22:05I saw one of the videos you had where you asked your audience what

1:22:08people want next most in the next phone.

1:22:12And I was totally unsurprised by the Clear number one answer, which was which

1:22:19was battery life.

1:22:20So and it was I actually did this poll two separate times.

1:22:23I did a general poll just I didn't say iPhone, I just said what

1:22:26your next phone, so whoever whatever phone you use, what would convince you to

1:22:30upgrade and it was fifty I think it was like fifty-two percent of people

1:22:33said battery.

1:22:34And then the day before the iPhone event, I said, what would you want

1:22:37to hear Apple announced tomorrow that would make you want to upgrade?

1:22:41And again, it was over fifty percent.

1:22:43Battery.

1:22:44And I actually was surprised personally because I assumed if it's my audience, they

1:22:49were gonna want some more whizbang, interesting, flashy feature.

1:22:55But no, it was like just give me as much battery life as possible

1:22:59and I'm all in.

1:23:00And that's what Apple did.

1:23:01That's what Apple did this year.

1:23:03Yep.

1:23:04And it is the simplest

1:23:08bore boringest to talk about spec to improve.

1:23:12It's like, oh, now the battery lasts longer.

1:23:14And everybody goes, yeah, that's good.

1:23:16Right.

1:23:16And it's like, but tell me about that variable aperture.

1:23:18How do the blades move?

1:23:20How are they not fragile?

1:23:21Right?

1:23:21How is that and what we want to ask all these other questions about

1:23:24all these other things.

1:23:26And in some ways I even want to talk about the colors more.

1:23:29Yeah.

1:23:29And y what people care about is battery life.

1:23:32And that's what they did.

1:23:33If you look at their stats, it's weird because they came up with a

1:23:38new battery.

1:23:39I don't claim a use case number.

1:23:41Typical use case number.

1:23:42And yeah.

1:23:44But they just invented it this year.

1:23:46And I it's good for the future because their typical use case test, whatever

1:23:52that involves, next year we'll be able to compare year over year and two

1:23:56years from now.

1:23:57But this year when you go to Apple dot com slash iPhone slash compare,

1:24:03that typical use case number doesn't show up because there's nothing to compare it

1:24:07against because there's no they didn't have that they didn't go back and run

1:24:12that test with old iPhones.

1:24:13Including simple to do.

1:24:15Right.

1:24:16Including ones that they're still selling that are still current, like the iPhone uh

1:24:21seventeen regular and the iPhone seventeen E and the iPhone Air.

1:24:25But they do they have video and they call it video streaming or something,

1:24:30which I guess is do you have the video already on the phone or

1:24:33are you d watching a Netflix video that is network pulling the video and

1:24:39streaming it.

1:24:40But it's a slight hit to battery life.

1:24:42The iPhone 18 Pro is 15% longer.

1:24:47It's like I forget the exact numbers, but it's like forty versus thirty five

1:24:53hours.

1:24:53Something like that.

1:24:54But it both of them work out to fifteen percent longer and then the

1:24:58iPhone eighteen that that's the Pro Max.

1:25:0115% longer and the pro is ten percent longer, but ten percent longer on

1:25:07the eighteen.

1:25:07This is my favorite stat of the year, single favorite stat

1:25:1118 pro regular now has longer battery life than last year's seventeen Pro Max.

1:25:18Ten percent improvement was a Right, which is huge literally huge if you don't

1:25:23like the Pro Max phones.

1:25:24It was hard to kill a pro max battery seventeen pro max last year.

1:25:28So Yeah.

1:25:29Yep.

1:25:29And that for my review, I spent most of my time with the 18

1:25:33Pro Max Burgundy.

1:25:35I named it Ron Burgundy in my pocket.

1:25:39Just to I was like, oh, I haven't used I haven't used one of

1:25:41these for a couple of years.

1:25:42I should spend a week with an eighteen Pro Max.

1:25:45It is huge.

1:25:46I do not like it in my pocket.

1:25:48I do not like it in my hand.

1:25:50And the battery life

1:25:53never ever f and this is while testing it and purposefully shooting more photos

1:25:57and videos and stuff than usual and the battery never drops below fifty percent.

1:26:03Yeah.

1:26:05I'm out shooting videos with this thing like during the review period trying to,

1:26:10you know, test and it's like I didn't pay attention to the days where

1:26:13I was trying to keep it on the charger to get Siri to finish

1:26:16indexing everything, right?

1:26:18'Cause it goes faster if you have it plugged in.

1:26:20On the days where I'm using it normally, like I'm shocked that I'm ending

1:26:24the day in the thirties thirty percentage area with battery life because I'm literally

1:26:29morning till night using I'm traveling.

1:26:31I don't have access to plugging it in.

1:26:33I'm not plugging it in on purpose.

1:26:34I'm shooting 4K video.

1:26:36I'm shooting a bunch of pictures and it's just not dying.

1:26:39Yeah, that's the spec you were looking for.

1:26:42This is your year.

1:26:44I have a my main iPhone profile, whatever you want to call it, when

1:26:49my bet you know, and then I can back it up to iCloud and

1:26:51set up a new phone and restore from the backup and get all the

1:26:54apps and everything set up the way it was on my other phone.

1:26:57I think it's several years now I've had a shortcuts automation where when my

1:27:02battery life hits I even forget the number if it's thirty or thirty five.

1:27:07I I think I de D uh used to be thirty five and now

1:27:09it's thirty 'cause it I was like, I don't even need this.

1:27:12But it hits thirty percent and then it turns on automatically low power mode.

1:27:17Yellow thing in control center.

1:27:20And with my personal iPhone seventeen pro

1:27:24most days I like watching TV at right before bed, it's around eleven thirty,

1:27:30midnight, I'm ready to go to bed and I look and the battery is

1:27:34yellow Because it that that's kicked in and turned on.

1:27:38But it's it's at thirty percent or twenty five, thirty percent.

1:27:42Almost never in a whole year, no matter what I do, does it go

1:27:45below twenty percent, no matter how busy I am in a day.

1:27:49With and then ever since after I published my review with a week where

1:27:53I s mostly use the eighteen pro Max, I've switched to the eighteen pro

1:27:57review unit.

1:27:58It doesn't trigger the shortcut.

1:28:00It's it doesn't reach thirty or thirty five percent.

1:28:04Any day.

1:28:05I don't think it's it clicked once.

1:28:07It's 10% by Apple Specs, but it seems, I don't know, even better than

1:28:10that.

1:28:11It's yeah, and this is a thing that everybody cares about.

1:28:16Every single iPhone.

1:28:17There are very few things that everybody cares about.

1:28:19There are, oddly enough, people who do not care about the camera 'cause they

1:28:23don't never take pictures.

1:28:24There are people there there were people who did not care about the retina

1:28:28screen.

1:28:28They're like, I don't really care.

1:28:29I don't see the difference.

1:28:30And it's maybe that's crazy the eye doctor.

1:28:33But the one thing everybody cares about is if their iPhone dies and it

1:28:37doesn't work because the battery's at zero, they care.

1:28:40And

1:28:41it is a boring stat.

1:28:43And if you improve ten to fifteen percent every year, it compounds and within

1:28:49four years it's fifty percent more battery life.

1:28:52And that's huge.

1:28:53And if most people only upgrade every four years, they're getting a phone that

1:28:59starts with fifty percent longer battery life and their old phone that they'd used

1:29:04for four or five years probably had a worn out battery anyway.

1:29:07And so if there's no other difference that they notice, what they notice is

1:29:12my phone was dying every day by the time I went to bed and

1:29:15now my phone has tons of battery life every day.

1:29:18And it's a huge upgrade.

1:29:20And that's all they care about.

1:29:21Yeah, for them.

1:29:22But yeah, especially like you said, people hold them to the phones multiple years.

1:29:25Which leaves me totally unrelated, but I always thought it was funny how people

1:29:28like us in the who would upgrade annually complain how lightning has been around

1:29:33for so long, ten years this lightning port is going away.

1:29:36Whereas the average person probably only owned two iPhones that had a lightning fork

1:29:40because they you know what I mean?

1:29:41So to them it was like 'cause I remember the backlash.

1:29:43Why does Apple always change the port from every they always change the ports?

1:29:47Yeah, two iPhones ago it was this and now it's right.

1:29:50It's so funny.

1:29:51It's just the different echo chambers that we're in.

1:29:56The other thing that I do think that that's battery life focus has shown,

1:30:00and it is kind of true, and I think it plays into the fact

1:30:04that the iPhone Air has not sold well by anybody's measure.

1:30:09There's apps that keep track of which phones people use and and they don't

1:30:14advertise it.

1:30:15It's I hope that with the iPhone Air two that's supposedly coming in spring

1:30:20that they do advertise it and that adding a second camera will give it

1:30:25I because I think it is a absolutely terrific device.

1:30:28And I do think in my testing with it, battery life is very good.

1:30:33And it is lasts all day for me.

1:30:35Maybe not where thirty percent doesn't kick in, right?

1:30:38It's like yeah, it's more like you kind of use the whole battery to

1:30:41get through the day with the air.

1:30:43But it's so nice.

1:30:44But I just think common people who don't know anything about technology know that

1:30:49the battery has to be smaller.

1:30:51Right?

1:30:51It does.

1:30:52It's just common sense.

1:30:53Of course.

1:30:53Right?

1:30:54It's like if you pick up a flashlight, like just the a basic run-of-the-mill

1:30:59drugstore flashlight.

1:31:00As soon as you pick it up, you know if it has the D

1:31:03cell batteries in it or not, because it is it's too light.

1:31:07You pick up the air and you pick up an iPhone Pro, either size,

1:31:11and you just know there's

1:31:14one.

1:31:15And that is what people think.

1:31:16They think, Well, I want this.

1:31:17And for years, in that era when Johnny Ive was there and they were

1:31:21making the iPhones thinner and thinner every year, leading up to I think the

1:31:25thinnest ever was like iPhone 6 up until the air, which is now the

1:31:30thinnest.

1:31:30And now the duo, which will be the thinnest when it's unfolded.

1:31:34And and there was the other gate, which is I think was actually more

1:31:39of a significant gate scandal than antenna gate, bend gate, right?

1:31:45Bend gate.

1:31:45Oh god.

1:31:46Right?

1:31:46With I think it was the iPhone six.

1:31:48Where if you put it in your butt pocket and sat on it, the

1:31:51whole phone would bend.

1:31:52And everybody was like, we've been screaming at you for years, just make the

1:31:56goddamn things thicker by putting a bigger battery in 'em, because we want a

1:32:00bigger battery anyway, and we'll take the the hit to weight and thickness to

1:32:05have a better battery.

1:32:06And and eventually Apple did listen, they started making the iPhones thicker instead of

1:32:12thinner as they added cameras and camera bumps and other things and But I

1:32:17think that the basic evolution and the forking of the lines and the pro

1:32:22and non pro have shown that it really is true.

1:32:27The people outside Apple who were yelling, just make it thicker and heavier and

1:32:32put a bigger battery in it.

1:32:33That's why it's so many people buy iPhone Pro models.

1:32:36It really is.

1:32:38Yeah.

1:32:38Right?

1:32:39It is.

1:32:39It's even compared not just talking iPhone Air, which is ridiculously thin and is

1:32:44sort of conspicuously lightweight.

1:32:46I mean just compared to, hey, should I buy an iPhone Seventeen or a

1:32:52seventeen pro last year.

1:32:53I'm gonna get the one that looks like it has a bigger battery.

1:32:56And if you look at the tech specs, it says it has more battery

1:32:59life.

1:33:00And I think there's a lot of people who don't care too much and

1:33:02they're like, Oh, the camera's better and the screen's better and you get a

1:33:04promotion display and they're like, shut up.

1:33:06I just want the battery and I'll pay the ridiculous price for this.

1:33:09Right.

1:33:10Right.

1:33:10Battery, battery, battery.

1:33:12Yeah.

1:33:13That's it.

1:33:14They could have shut up.

1:33:15They absolutely could have just said the battery is long life is longer.

1:33:18And then John Turnis could have dropped the mic and walked off the stage.

1:33:21And all these people then tech press would be like, Oh my God, this

1:33:25is ridiculous.

1:33:26I can't believe this guy, you know, bring back Tim Cook.

1:33:28And out in the real world people would be like, Yeah, I'll buy that.

1:33:31Cheering.

1:33:31They mean cheering.

1:33:32Yeah.

1:33:34But I mean there there are other things about this phone though, like the

1:33:37A twenty, which is sits between an M3 and an M4 in some benchmarks,

1:33:42which is just absurd to carry around in your pocket, right?

1:33:47And then the variable aperture camera which I don't know

1:33:52maybe you have a different opinion.

1:33:53I don't know that the variable aperture is such a huge deal.

1:33:57I think it's more the huger deal is that the main camera now takes

1:34:02in even more light

1:34:05and they're okay with doing that because they can now adjust the amount of

1:34:10light that comes in.

1:34:11Because it would be too much it I don't think it would be appropriate

1:34:15for that to be the main camera if you couldn't reduce the amount of

1:34:20light that goes into it for the situations that require it.

1:34:23So I think really the main feature is when that thing is wide open,

1:34:28the amount of light that can get into the camera is such a big

1:34:31improvement versus last year.

1:34:3350% more, which yeah results in just better photography overall.

1:34:37Yeah, the way I I I remember at some point I learned how the

1:34:40F stop numbers work and why they're on such a weird scale where going

1:34:47from F two point eight to f four point oh is one stop and

1:34:52then the next stop is f eight and it's like what?

1:34:55And then you go from F one point eight to F one point four

1:35:00and you're like, Whoa, well that's almost nothing, right?

1:35:02And you're like, No, no, no, that's full stop.

1:35:04And it's like, Oh that's double?

1:35:06Oh, F one point eight to one point four?

1:35:08And then you're like, Well, what about the F one point two?

1:35:11That's now that's just a little and you're like, No, no, that's a five

1:35:14thousand dollar lens from Canon.

1:35:15Right.

1:35:16The F one point two.

1:35:17And it's and I've an idiot.

1:35:19I fucking bought it a long time ago.

1:35:21And I did love it.

1:35:22But it the goddamn thing was As heavy as a brick, the fifty millimeter

1:35:26F one point two lens.

1:35:27It wasn't five.

1:35:28It was like I don't know, fifteen hundred or two thousand dollars.

1:35:31But it was a full stop difference from F one point four, which is

1:35:35double the light.

1:35:36And it's like, oh well, forget about the scale.

1:35:38Fifty percent more light.

1:35:39I understand that.

1:35:41And I also understand why they never made a non variable aperture lens that

1:35:46was F one point four eight because it's too much that's too open when

1:35:50you're out in the sunshine, right?

1:35:52Not that you couldn't get a an image, but you wouldn't, right?

1:35:57It's and it's it's sharper.

1:35:59And everybody knows that lenses aren't

1:36:03well photographed.

1:36:04All the way opened up.

1:36:05Yeah.

1:36:05They're they're not at their sharpest.

1:36:07So I think it's a win for low light.

1:36:09I think I'm with you though.

1:36:11I don't think it's huge deal, but I think it's one of those things

1:36:16that three, four years ago or from now, three, four years from now, with

1:36:21the third, fourth generation of variable aperture, it will be more of a big

1:36:25deal where you'll be like, oh, it has a broad a slightly bigger range

1:36:30from the most open to the most closed.

1:36:33There'll be sensor improvements in those intervening years.

1:36:37And then all of a sudden, optically you will get more of a bokeh

1:36:42effect when it's wide open.

1:36:44And And y you'll get the advantages that photographers have always loved about having

1:36:49aperture control.

1:36:49You'll see them m more visibly.

1:36:51Yeah.

1:36:52You can already, depending on how you frame it in the lighting though, when

1:36:55you do use the manual aperture and open it up, you do get more

1:36:59of a blurred background.

1:37:01I know Austin Mann's video had a really nice section in his in his

1:37:05review he had a video and he just used some trees wherever he was,

1:37:08whatever ranch he was on in Colorado.

1:37:10And it was such a perfect illustration 'cause he went and it was sort

1:37:14of like the Steve Jobs style, not just telling you once but repeating it

1:37:17like open, closed, open, closed, blurry, focused, blurry, focused.

1:37:24Uh it's already making me think that the end for portrait mode is sh

1:37:30ought to be coming soon, right?

1:37:32Because portrait mode in mobile photography was always using computational photography to completely simulate

1:37:41the optical effect of focal distance.

1:37:44And now we're actually getting real focal distance through the variable aperture.

1:37:48So why is there a mode that lets you do portrait mode?

1:37:52Well, there's the mo I don't think they should have taken it out this

1:37:55year for these phones because what the effect you get from portrait mode is

1:38:00way stronger than what you get from the actual aperture because it's just not

1:38:06that noticeable this year.

1:38:07But you can notice it enough that I think three, four, five years from

1:38:11now, I think that the what the iPhone will be capable of blurring the

1:38:16background for a nearby subject will be such that you probably shouldn't ever use

1:38:23portrait mode starting three or four years from now.

1:38:26I I kind of disagree because one thing I really like

1:38:33if portrait mode

1:38:36looks natural, which Apple really tries to make it do.

1:38:39And it's improved a lot in the ten years since it came out.

1:38:42One thing I really like about that and photographic styles is that they're non

1:38:46destructive.

1:38:47So I can go in and say, you know what, I actually wanted here,

1:38:50I mean we're on an audio podcast, but I have a a blurry photo

1:38:54behind me on the wall.

1:38:56But if this was a portrait mode photo, I could tap on that and

1:38:59then that would go into focus versus my face.

1:39:02And when you're doing the the real version, right?

1:39:05You're just burning it in.

1:39:06You can't switch focus.

1:39:08And I feel I think people like the fact that they can just decide

1:39:11later, Oh, I took this photo, it wasn't exactly what I want, but I

1:39:15can just tap here or there and I can fix it in post.

1:39:18Yeah.

1:39:19And you would lose that if you didn't have portrait mode anymore.

1:39:21Yeah, or maybe it go t it changes from being a mode in the

1:39:24camera to something you only put in post, right?

1:39:27So you just shoot normally and then do it.

1:39:29And you're right, because that is one of the things.

1:39:31Photographic styles i i is a the whole thing is why it's su it's

1:39:35a great system is that it's non destructive and any f style you've applied

1:39:40and I always use black and white as my example because it's the most

1:39:44striking, right?

1:39:45Yeah.

1:39:45You could talk about the difference between what's the difference between amber and gold?

1:39:49And it's like, uh you can kind of see it when you've when you

1:39:52switch between the two, you can uh I don't know why you know, they

1:39:55both look kinda like different shades of gold to me, but but y you

1:39:59say stark black and white, everybody knows what that means.

1:40:02And if you shot in the old days on black and white film and

1:40:05you're like, God damn it, I wish I kind of wish I I love

1:40:08black and white, but I wish I had color for that.

1:40:11Well, tough shit you shot on black and white film.

1:40:14Yeah.

1:40:14Right?

1:40:17Right.

1:40:17And it it's like with certain filters i i that you apply to a

1:40:22JPEG, if you apply a black and white filter and then you save it

1:40:26and you don't keep the original, it's destructive and then you can't go back

1:40:30to color unless you had a copy.

1:40:32The way that photographic styles are only stored as effectively, I think the best

1:40:37way to think of it is they're like recipes and they're always applied dynamically

1:40:41to the original.

1:40:42And the original is always there.

1:40:44And you don't need to make copies to keep the original.

1:40:47You can always revert to the way it looked.

1:40:50So you could just set your iPhone camera app to shoot in black and

1:40:53white so you see black and white as you're shooting.

1:40:56And then if you think, ah, these should have been in color, you just

1:40:59go into the photos afterwards and change them to a color photographic style.

1:41:04Yeah.

1:41:04Aperture isn't like that, right?

1:41:06The f actual aperture on the iPhone eighteen pro main camera is a real

1:41:11you know, and they love to show it now, you know, and it is

1:41:13cool to look at.

1:41:15It is a real aperture.

1:41:16You can't if you shot an image at F one point four eight you

1:41:20can't suddenly go to F four to get more of it in focus.

1:41:24It's right.

1:41:26Unless you're shooting in portrait mode as well.

1:41:29So that's a good point.

1:41:30I hear you there.

1:41:31Well but no, 'cause it's still even in portrait mode, you still can't uh

1:41:36portrait mode might put more fake out of focus in but there's still the

1:41:42simulated.

1:41:43Right, exactly.

1:41:45It's the beginning and I expect over the coming years they'll add the aperture

1:41:50to the other lenses too.

1:41:52I don't know which one first, probably telephoto and then ultra wide last.

1:41:56You know, and they're always working on the sensors.

1:41:58But I don't think think uh to me this is the big this is

1:42:02the last

1:42:03and uh they might surprise me.

1:42:05I'll be happy to be surprised, but I can't think of anything else that

1:42:08they can add to the camera now that's been missing at a technical level.

1:42:12It's just incremental improvements to it going forward.

1:42:16Um I guess is how willing are they to

1:42:20if you look at l a lot of the Chinese smartphone cameras, they have

1:42:23one inch sensors and they really are pretty good and striking.

1:42:26Like is Apple willing to I know a lot of people think the camera

1:42:29mesa or whatever we call it, the plateau.

1:42:32The iconic plateau.

1:42:33Yeah, is wildly large, but it can get bigger and y you can get

1:42:37better natural photography without all of the pol post processing tricks.

1:42:41Right.

1:42:43I don't know how the I don't know how those Chinese phones do it

1:42:46with the bigger sensors, but if there's something they can do to vastly increase

1:42:50the size of the sensor, that would be the single best optical thing that

1:42:53they could possibly do.

1:42:55But I think they're just gonna increase the size incrementally.

1:42:58But and there's stuff they could do with the what do they call it?

1:43:00Telescopic where it you can kinda put the sensors in sideways.

1:43:04I mean there's stuff I'm sure they're working on to make just the pure

1:43:08optical part of the f camera better before they do the computational magic.

1:43:14But it's great.

1:43:15Uh what do you think of the new styles in the photographic styles?

1:43:20The film and the glow and the Face whatever.

1:43:23Yeah, I like them.

1:43:24I think for me I don't like that one.

1:43:26But I can see I know it's a popular thing.

1:43:29But I'm not sure.

1:43:29But I know why people want it and I don't judge them for it.

1:43:32Yes I do.

1:43:33It's easy I think it's interesting.

1:43:35I like the different styles, I like the combos, I like being able to

1:43:39get the film look.

1:43:40For me personally, I always I'm entertained by the notion of adding grain because

1:43:45I don't know if people liked grain before, I guess.

1:43:47It's almost like people like that sound of vinyl, like how vinyl has that

1:43:50yeah.

1:43:51That crack but it's that crack that wasn't in the studio when they were

1:43:54making it me.

1:43:55It's just like a feeling, a nostalgic feeling.

1:43:57And so for me personally, I like I don't need that, but I like

1:44:02everything they do with photographic styles this year, with the exception of announcing that

1:44:07it would also be on the older phones and then removing that announcement from

1:44:10the press release later.

1:44:11Because are you telling me the A nineteen pro can't do these new photographic

1:44:17styles?

1:44:18That was a weird thing.

1:44:19Yeah.

1:44:19And I don't know how much publicity it got.

1:44:21Maybe I missed it.

1:44:22And I thought that the people were crazy when they were saying this, that

1:44:25they were saying, Oh no, they said it's coming to the sixteen pro and

1:44:28seventeen pro, and are all the seventeens.

1:44:31And I'm like, no, that's never how they do it.

1:44:33Whenever they come out with a new generation of photographic styles, they always lock

1:44:36it to the new phones, whether that's technically necessary or just what I call

1:44:41marketing spite that they do.

1:44:43And then they're like, No, it's in a footnote and I looked and it

1:44:45was in the footnote and I was like, Holy shit.

1:44:47I was like, I gotta ask Apple about this.

1:44:49And then like the next day I went to ask Apple about it and

1:44:52I went back to the newsroom post and I'm like, I wanna make sure

1:44:55I get this right before I ask.

1:44:57And then I couldn't find it.

1:44:58And then I was like Yeah, and I was like what the hell a

1:45:01and I oh you know what somebody else asked and somebody else realized oh

1:45:05that was a mistake.

1:45:06I don't though, was it a mistake that they were going were they going

1:45:10to do it or did whoever just wrote the footnote hear it wrong?

1:45:15I don't think they were ever going to do it.

1:45:16And it certainly wasn't in any iOS twenty seven betas.

1:45:21So I don't think there was ever any code that did it.

1:45:25But Is it do I believe that the A nineteen pro chip in the

1:45:29last year's phones is incapable of doing this?

1:45:32No.

1:45:33Uh it is to some degree marketing spite, but that's that's they're in the

1:45:39business of selling phones.

1:45:40So of course.

1:45:40And you had an article about this though.

1:45:42You were playing with the photographic styles and it seemed like you really liked

1:45:45it.

1:45:46And you even liked grain.

1:45:48I do li I've always liked grain.

1:45:49I liked shooting film.

1:45:50When I did shoot film for people who are old like me and did,

1:45:54I loved Kodak Tri X black and white film.

1:45:58Four I think it was four hundred ISO.

1:46:00Very grainy black and white film.

1:46:02I used to own a the original Rico GR digital GRD back around 2005

1:46:09or 6, that the little pocket digital camera.

1:46:13And the whole claim to fame was that Rico got better low light photography

1:46:19out of that little camera not by having an amazing sensor that reduced noise,

1:46:24but by having a sensor that they programmed their JPEG interpolation off it to

1:46:30sort of embrace the noise.

1:46:32That's the one camera I've owned that I actually wore out.

1:46:35It actually cause it was a pocket camera, the motor that made the lens

1:46:41extend eventually just sort of it didn't just break completely it just started making

1:46:45a sad noise and then sort of stopped coming out and I was like,

1:46:50Well I forget how many thousands of photos I took with that camera, but

1:46:53it was like, Oh, I've gotten my money's out of this.

1:46:55So yeah, I am a n a grain man.

1:46:58But even as somebody who enjoys film grain and film simulated film grain and

1:47:04d and definitely does not like the over processed

1:47:07noise reduction that modern smartphone looks Yeah.

1:47:13I think that the default level of grain that they apply is way too

1:47:17much.

1:47:18And I kinda wish the the grain in particular, not just so there's the

1:47:21halation effect, that red glowiness that I think is too strong at a hundred,

1:47:26even though a hundred's the default for film.

1:47:29The grain does is just on or off.

1:47:31And I kind of wish the grain was it doesn't have to be zero

1:47:35to a hundred.

1:47:35It could just be like small, medium, light.

1:47:39I don't know.

1:47:40But I kind of feel like, man, I'd I would I'd like a little

1:47:43of this.

1:47:44You know, it's sort of like I don't know, it's like I would like

1:47:47a little bit of salt on my fries, but all I can do is

1:47:50like somebody just comes in some prankster has taken unscrewed the cap from the

1:47:54salt shaker, right?

1:47:55Right.

1:47:56I just wanted a little grain.

1:47:57I didn't want all of this.

1:47:58But I like it overall.

1:48:00And again, it's non-destructive.

1:48:02So if you're ever looking at a photo and you're like, Jesus, this just

1:48:05this looks like noise to me not cr not attractive grain.

1:48:08You just turn it right off.

1:48:10I don't know I like it.

1:48:11And I like it.

1:48:12And I do think that overall that the pictures I get off the phone

1:48:15using the built in camera app look better than they ever have.

1:48:18And I think they've really do they've it it's a lot.

1:48:21They're asking a lot of one app to embrace people who literally just tap

1:48:26camera, tap shutter, that's and to people who kind of want it to be

1:48:31a semi pro camera app.

1:48:33I kind of still feel like they should have two apps, a regular camera

1:48:36that is more point and shoot and an Apple Pro camera that I love

1:48:41the Halide Guys, I love the not boring camera app, but I kind of

1:48:44feel like Apple should have something that's more in that range.

1:48:47And hopefully it wouldn't put them out of business but would take some of

1:48:51the complexity out of the built in camera app.

1:48:54I think they did it though, like 'cause now you can decide how much

1:48:58pro controls you want in the camera.

1:49:00Yeah.

1:49:00And it would be strange because they also have final cut camera.

1:49:02So that would actually be a third camera app.

1:49:04Yeah.

1:49:05So But final Cut Camera is just video.

1:49:07Just for video, yes.

1:49:08So then they need like a professional photo, a professional video and then the

1:49:11regular it's that's just not the how they're gonna do it.

1:49:13But the fact that you can

1:49:15choose which pro controls you want on the screen now.

1:49:19So if you don't want any, just remove 'em.

1:49:21Or if we want everything, you can do that too.

1:49:24I think that was I think that was the right call, the way to

1:49:26do it.

1:49:26Yeah.

1:49:26And I think for anybody listening who hasn't really played with it, I think

1:49:29the way to think about it is you really if there's one or two

1:49:32that you use, pull them out of there and put them in the permanent

1:49:36list at the top or if you pivot the camera to the side.

1:49:39Don't keep opening that drawer and poking at 'em.

1:49:42That drawer is not something you should be going to a lot.

1:49:44Right.

1:49:45If you and if you use a couple of 'em, drag a couple of

1:49:48'em out.

1:49:48There's room for a bunch of 'em over there, but they should be one

1:49:51tap away and not in the drawer.

1:49:55And the reason they're not one tap away by default is that the default

1:49:59list of them is meant to be simple.

1:50:01It's just f flash and format or something like that.

1:50:05No, it's good.

1:50:06It's good year.

1:50:07What about the colors of the iPhone eighteen pro?

1:50:09Last question.

1:50:10They were never gonna do it, but I felt like cosmic orange should have

1:50:13just been a permanent addition to like when you went outside last year or

1:50:19this in the year of seventeen it was orange phones everywhere.

1:50:23People really enjoyed having finally a bright non-gray take on a pro iPhone, right?

1:50:31Because I felt like everything was just a shade of gray before.

1:50:34There was like that deep purple that was almost black.

1:50:36There was the blues that were kind of gray and the wrong gl this

1:50:39was like a a bold and now we're back to dark.

1:50:44Did you take notice of how many people attending the event in Cupertino had

1:50:49the Orange seventeen Pro or Pro Max.

1:50:52Like the hands on the hands on area, the new phones from Apple in

1:50:57the hands on area were on the tables or on those sticks that they

1:51:00have for the ones on display.

1:51:03And all the other ones were in our hands, and I would say two

1:51:06thirds of them were orange.

1:51:08It was unbelievable.

1:51:10Yeah.

1:51:11It was there were more orange iPhone seventeen pros in the media and attendees

1:51:17hands than there were in the hands-on area last year.

1:51:21Oh, it was all orange.

1:51:23It was unbelievable.

1:51:25And that's another one where the same way that I said that I think

1:51:28Apple was wrong about people's tolerance for thicker phones if it's to make the

1:51:34battery bigger.

1:51:35That yeah, they really will buy a thicker phone heavier phone if it makes

1:51:39the battery last uh noticeably longer.

1:51:42I whatever idea Apple had that people didn't want to buy brightly colored pro

1:51:48iPhones, I don't know what the hell the I don't know who that is

1:51:52or who won those arguments.

1:51:54Was clearly wrong, right?

1:51:56I'm willing to say, no, I don't have Tim Cook's number of every single

1:52:00iPhone that was sold and what colors and whatever else actual data is, but

1:52:06just the Actal data of seeing what people in the at the iPhone event

1:52:12last week had bought in the last year.

1:52:15And that's only the people in the press who had a one-year-old iPhone, right?

1:52:18Right.

1:52:18There's plenty of people who go to these events and hats off to them

1:52:22for being in the business and following the phones and still using a three

1:52:27or four year old iPhone personally.

1:52:30But that's just the people who had a seventeen pro.

1:52:33But they were all orange.

1:52:34It was orange, orange, orange.

1:52:35I I and Burgundy isn't doing it for me.

1:52:38It's it and I know what they're thinking, that it is a way to

1:52:43signify that you have the new iPhone and that only lasts a year.

1:52:48But uh But they added a color this year too though, so it's like

1:52:52there's always the the silver one, right?

1:52:55There's always silver.

1:52:56So I just felt like if you're gonna do if you're gonna add a

1:52:59color in, have one of the four be just bold.

1:53:03And then make the others, the other three can be muted.

1:53:06So even if you wanted to do burgundy, the blue is just a very

1:53:09muted blue.

1:53:10Give me a bright teel.

1:53:13I think they and I think they kind of painted themselves in a corner

1:53:16a little bit on blue because last year the dark one was like a

1:53:19very dark blue.

1:53:20That's the one I bought and so what were they gonna do?

1:53:23Come up with a the cosmic blue?

1:53:26That's what they should have done.

1:53:27What cosmic orange is to orange, but I feel like maybe they thought they

1:53:30couldn't they 'cause that's too close to last year's dark blue.

1:53:33I don't know what they were thinking, but d I do not expect a

1:53:37year from now to see all uh all that many burgundy phones in the

1:53:40press hands at the iPhone event.

1:53:42I don't think it's a bad color.

1:53:43I'm sure some people like it, but it's Cosmic Orange is ten years from

1:53:48now, we'll still be talking about Cosmic Orange and the seventeen pro.

1:53:51It's an exciting color.

1:53:54That's what it was.

1:53:56So I I don't know.

1:53:56I think they gotta look and I'm sure they will look at the data,

1:54:00but I think I seventeen the the arn seems so popular that I can't

1:54:04help but think that by next year with a year of data under their

1:54:09belt that maybe we'll see at least one truly exciting color every year starting

1:54:14next year.

1:54:15And then this year's the last year without an exciting color.

1:54:18All right.

1:54:18Let me take a break here and thank our other sponsor of the show.

1:54:21It is our good friends at Factor.

1:54:25Hey, I especially this time of year, I do not have time to be

1:54:29cooking myself meals.

1:54:30I don't I'm very busy and I'm a very poor manager of my own

1:54:36time.

1:54:37But I do like to eat well.

1:54:39And factor meals are the perfect solution to my problem and possibly yours.

1:54:47Real Food.

1:54:50Not meal kits where you get ingredients.

1:54:52Those are great things.

1:54:53I love meal kits too.

1:54:55But you get the meal kits and it's

1:54:57a recipe card and you'd spend twenty minutes or thirty minutes and you cook

1:55:01a meal.

1:55:02No.

1:55:02Factor is entire meals that are already made, already portioned for one person, and

1:55:08you just heat them up in a couple of minutes and you've got a

1:55:13delicious meal ready to go.

1:55:16Not frozen, these are meals that ship to you refrigerated with dry ice to

1:55:21keep them fresh.

1:55:22All fresh ingredients, they have this whole list.

1:55:25The company has this what is it?

1:55:26Seventy five band ingredients.

1:55:29Ingredients like junk food ingredients, non natural ingredients, they've got this whole list probably

1:55:35growing every month of seventy five ingredients that they don't include in any of

1:55:39their meals.

1:55:40When you sign up for a factor meal plan, they have over one hundred

1:55:46nutrient dense menu items every week to choose from.

1:55:50New options, recent additions include things like salmon burgers, shredded pork, collard greens, and

1:55:57more.

1:55:57They've got all sorts of special seasonal stuff too, like pumpkin flavored cheesecake.

1:56:02They've got protein shakes.

1:56:04If you're on a special diet, if you're like all in on the protein

1:56:08or you're trying to cut out carbs or you have an allergy or anything

1:56:13like that.

1:56:14Or if you're a vegan or a vegetarian, they've got options for you.

1:56:17They've got kid friendly options with simpler ingredients and the sort of staples that

1:56:22kids like.

1:56:23Lots of stuff to choose from, lots of great ingredients and it just I

1:56:27love it.

1:56:28Everything tastes good.

1:56:29I really love Factor's food.

1:56:31I just love the way it tastes and I love how lazy it allows

1:56:34me to be that I can just pop it in the microwave for a

1:56:37couple minutes and I've got a hot, delicious meal.

1:56:39Ninety-seven percent of users who sign up for Factor agree that it helps them

1:56:43live a healthier life.

1:56:45Let's eat real.

1:56:47Head to factormeals.com slash talkshow fifty off and use code TOKSHOW50OF to get 50%

1:56:58off and one free breakfast item per box for one year while supplies last

1:57:04until October 31th of 2026.

1:57:08That's code talk show fifty off with a five zero for the fifty.

1:57:12Talk code talk show fifty off at factormeals.com slash talk show fifty off.

1:57:20See website for more details details.

1:57:25I was told I I need to say that.

1:57:27See website for more details.

1:57:29Alright last but not least we got the duo.

1:57:31Right?

1:57:31We t and it's what Apple announced at last.

1:57:34We'll talk about it last.

1:57:35Now we're two weeks out a week past the eighteen reviews.

1:57:40Here's my story about the duo.

1:57:41My like I told we went to a it was my wife's

1:57:45sister's little kid.

1:57:47We had a birthday party last weekend.

1:57:49Whole bunch of family, mostly from My wife's side, some my dad was there,

1:57:54it was great.

1:57:55Three different people, and they know I think my wife had said that John

1:57:59was out in California for the iPhone thing, and they know that every year

1:58:03around back to school time I go out to California for the iPhone thing

1:58:06and they kinda know what nobody reads my reviews, but they know what I

1:58:09do and I don't bother with them.

1:58:11But like last year they wanted to know I remember they want to know

1:58:14do you have the orange iPhone?

1:58:15And I did.

1:58:16One of my review units was the orange phone.

1:58:17They wanted to see it.

1:58:18This year three different people said, Do you have the new iPhone?

1:58:21And I said, I do and I took out the Glacier Blue iPhone eighteen

1:58:26pro and they're like, Unfold it And I'm Oh, I don't have that one.

1:58:31I'm sorry.

1:58:31And then I g by the third person I by I didn't take out

1:58:35the eighteen pro.

1:58:36I was like, Oh no, I don't have the folding one and they're like,

1:58:38You don't Oh.

1:58:41And they're they d that's all they wanted to see.

1:58:43Yeah.

1:58:44That's

1:58:46And I I in some ways I feel that their don't pay attention to

1:58:51tech at all take it was a more accurate summary of the overall news

1:58:56of the month than anything

1:58:59Right probably.

1:59:01They probably saw I should speed and they were like, Hey, let me see

1:59:03if I have that phone I saw, right?

1:59:05No.

1:59:06I should have told my nephews I I saw I should speed.

1:59:10I feel like I I've been having withdrawals.

1:59:13I missed that phone already.

1:59:14So like I have I own every folding smartphone that's been released in the

1:59:23United States, Galaxy one through seven, um, pixel original and then Profold 9 1011

1:59:32Motorolas OnePlus had one.

1:59:34I I've owned them all.

1:59:36And you can just tell there's a difference between a mechanical function, right?

1:59:44Don't get me wrong, it is very impressive that you can fold these glass

1:59:48phones in half and unfold them.

1:59:50It's unbelievable.

1:59:51But when you get to the Apple polish of how they do things, it's

1:59:56just different.

1:59:57It's just another level of the way that they consider

2:00:02how the user is going to interact with this.

2:00:08Not just from the aspect ratio, which was I think very smartly considered, but

2:00:15also the software.

2:00:16Everybody talked about the animation opening and closing, right?

2:00:19You open it And the way that it blurs and then comes back into

2:00:24f into frame is like it's revealing the thing that you're seeing on the

2:00:28outside is matched one for one as what you're gonna see on the inside.

2:00:32No other none.

2:00:34None of the other ones do this.

2:00:36They you have a closed screen and you open it and things move around

2:00:39or they're in a different area or you can have your closed screen and

2:00:42you see it go from black to on.

2:00:44Correct.

2:00:45Yes.

2:00:45And there were even some people like, Hey, since Android is the open platform

2:00:49people have already copied the animation that that Apple made.

2:00:53And it's no, because as you're opening the phone, you just see a black

2:00:56screen on the inside until it decides to light up.

2:00:59That's not a a copy of the feature.

2:01:02Obviously there was a lot of expectation.

2:01:05Everybody thought this was the year they're gonna do it.

2:01:07It was it was the worst kept secret in tech.

2:01:10But the the thing is it was almost like the first iPad where it's

2:01:14like we all knew it's gonna be an icon.

2:01:17It's like what are they gonna do?

2:01:18The tablet.

2:01:18What are they gonna show you?

2:01:19The tablet, the tablet, the tablet.

2:01:20What are they gonna show us?

2:01:22What's gonna make it unique and different?

2:01:25And I felt like they they knocked it out of the park.

2:01:28Obviously there's things that it's not an ultra, right?

2:01:31We all thought Ultra, which never made sense to me because ultra wouldn't Yeah,

2:01:35that's true.

2:01:36That's true.

2:01:36I predicted duo.

2:01:37Yes.

2:01:39If you're not gonna have the best cameras, if you're gonna have the best

2:01:41if you're not gonna have the best everything, ultra makes no sense.

2:01:44You can't call it that, right?

2:01:45So you have to be willing to.

2:01:50It's almost as if

2:01:52this is the folding version of A standard iPhone, not an iPhone Pro, if

2:01:58that makes sense.

2:01:59This is a folding iPhone standard.

2:02:03And there's room if by s for some reason Apple decides later, you know

2:02:06what?

2:02:07Now we're gonna make the iPhone Duo Pro, right?

2:02:10With better cameras and better battery.

2:02:13So if you've been looking for again, like I said earlier on, near the

2:02:18beginning of the show, it's like it's the second time we've had a different

2:02:22way to use an iPhone.

2:02:25The first time was when we went to iPhone ten with the gestures.

2:02:28And this is number two.

2:02:29So it's really interesting that if you've been bored by smartphones, which a lot

2:02:34of people have said, like I just feel like they they're incremental.

2:02:37We don't really have much change.

2:02:38Nothing's happening.

2:02:39We've had foldables for several years, but if you use Apple's software, you're not

2:02:46gonna be able to buy any other device and have all your apps there

2:02:51if you're in the Apple ecosystem or use apps that are only available on

2:02:54the App Store, you're just out of luck.

2:02:56So why would you?

2:02:57Now you get to join in and try something new, try something different, see

2:03:01how it is.

2:03:02And for all intents and purposes, like you get something that is right out

2:03:06of the box.

2:03:08Just so like I said, it's just so well considered.

2:03:10Especially like nanotexture display on the inside.

2:03:13But

2:03:16it was brilliant.

2:03:17But well I would go.

2:03:18And they did keep that secret.

2:03:19No, they did keep and they did keep that nanotexture display secret.

2:03:22Jaws mentioned it in a couple of interviews that he did.

2:03:25I think that he was pretty happy that didn't even though the aspect ratio

2:03:29did.

2:03:30And it's tricky because the nanotexture makes it hard to photograph.

2:03:34And I've seen a a couple of repeatedly on social media where people have

2:03:39from the hands-on area, there's pictures of people with it open.

2:03:42They're like, dude, that screen looks washed out.

2:03:45Yeah, it's like, oh, that's the way it photographs.

2:03:47It that screen is not washed out.

2:03:49Trust me.

2:03:50When you look at it face on, it is gorgeous.

2:03:53I am a nanotexture fan.

2:03:54I talk about it all the time.

2:03:56I love my nanotexture studio display.

2:03:58I love the way the nanotexture iPads look.

2:04:02I keep saying I wish you could get a regular iPhone with a nanotexture

2:04:06display and I even said that to someone at Apple and they said, Oh,

2:04:08that's an interesting idea.

2:04:09And they didn't and then as soon as I I always forget, no, they

2:04:13can't do nanotexture on a regular phone.

2:04:15We were just talking about earlier in the show, the ceramic shield two, and

2:04:18you don't get micro abrasions.

2:04:20If a regular iPhone had a uh nanotexture display, you'd get macro abrasions.

2:04:26I mean that's the nature of the nanotexture.

2:04:30The duo can do nanotexture on the interior display because when you put it

2:04:35in your pocket or you put it in your bag, you fold it.

2:04:38And so it won't shouldn't be scratched 'cause it's folded.

2:04:41Don't put it in your bag unfolded, I would say without ever having used

2:04:46one, because it will get scratched.

2:04:47Or the that to some degree.

2:04:51It looks amazing.

2:04:52It feels amazing to the fingers.

2:04:54It's it does kind of haunt me

2:04:58that I've only gotten brief hands on time with it because it is intriguing.

2:05:02I do I have serious questions about how much I will enjoy using it

2:05:09closed with the squat outer screen.

2:05:12I I I've just thought I don't know how much time you spent with

2:05:15it closed.

2:05:16I spent more time with it closed than open because I opened it and

2:05:19I thought, well, it's like an iPad mini.

2:05:22And it's not it is a different OS, which I'll come back to in

2:05:25a second.

2:05:26But I kind of am familiar with the basic form factor and the dimensions.

2:05:31Whereas closed and using the outer display, that's where everything is weirder to me,

2:05:38right?

2:05:38And it's like you've got all these controls on the side now.

2:05:41It's sort of other people have put this is not an original observation.

2:05:44But basically you get a content area that's the six the the sixteen to

2:05:49nine widescreen area of most iPhones and then the controls go over on the

2:05:54side, right?

2:05:55So like

2:05:57yeah, you've got like an iPhone six or seven shape in the left and

2:06:03then a control bar on the right with the toolbar buttons.

2:06:06And it's just weird.

2:06:07It's weird to have a back button that's n you know, I thought it

2:06:11was weird when they tried I still have my Safari on phone set with

2:06:15the the location bar at the top.

2:06:17Because I I don't know.

2:06:19Yeah, but that's just me being uh fuddy duddy.

2:06:22I think if it's a web browser, the address is at the top and

2:06:25I could never get used to it at the bottom.

2:06:27Although I will say with the week I spent with the Pro Max review

2:06:31unit, I kept it at the bottom.

2:06:32Okay.

2:06:33I can live with it.

2:06:33I could live with it either way.

2:06:34Especially with the bigger Pro Max.

2:06:36You know, I was like, oh, I'll leave it there.

2:06:38Top, bottom, I can get used to.

2:06:40Having the back button on the right of a web browser, that's weird.

2:06:44It's weird.

2:06:45I'm sorry.

2:06:46I'm not saying it's wrong.

2:06:47Your MacDoc.

2:06:49On the right.

2:06:50Always.

2:06:52Okay.

2:06:52I've had it on the right since before Mac OS ten even came out

2:06:55because on classic Mac OS I had a drag thing dock over on the

2:06:59right.

2:06:59So I'm a dock on the right person on the Mac.

2:07:03I was wondering I just keep my dock on the bottom, but I like

2:07:06make it very small.

2:07:07And then I have it set to like almost to the largest magnification if

2:07:11I mouse over it.

2:07:12Yeah, yeah, yeah.

2:07:12I was wondering how you would like it because it seems to be the

2:07:18closest thing you're ever gonna get to the iPhone mini.

2:07:23It doesn't feel like a mini though.

2:07:24It's a mini size area of the screen.

2:07:26It's just too different, right?

2:07:27And that's I wish they made I wish what I wish they made is

2:07:30a mini pro, right?

2:07:32I uh just charge me more for it.

2:07:34I don't care if it's smaller.

2:07:35I would like an iPhone 19 Pro Mini, but they're not gonna make that.

2:07:40Um I so I don't know.

2:07:42But maybe, and I've I've been thinking about it.

2:07:45I it's it may not be for me.

2:07:46It probably isn't for me, I think.

2:07:48If I can't get used to moving my Safari location field from the top

2:07:53to the bottom, I'm probably not gonna get used to a a passport shaped

2:07:58iPhone.

2:07:59But Do you plan to give it a try like Oh absolutely setting it

2:08:03as your main device for however long.

2:08:06How long would you give it a try to see if it would be

2:08:10your main thing?

2:08:11'Cause it sounds like you haven't decided that a foldable is not for you.

2:08:14You're more curious if it is.

2:08:16Well, I again and it it's just to get it over with.

2:08:20I d you know, d I don't have one, I'm guessing you don't have

2:08:23one and I know people don't think through how Apple does this the way

2:08:27you and I do, but in my experience Apple has never given anybody I

2:08:33know a review review unit more than a few days ahead of when they

2:08:39go on pre-order.

2:08:40And if you ask, hey, am I gonna get an iPhone Duo review unit?

2:08:45They they don't answer.

2:08:47They'll say, uh well that's we'll talk that's the I forget how what I

2:08:51don't even know what the Apple answer to that is, but they wouldn't.

2:08:55So there's and when you do get review units, you sign an NDA or

2:09:00I don't know what they call it.

2:09:01It's like an NDA where it's like I agree that I'm not going to

2:09:04post about this until the embargo date on the next week and I'm not

2:09:09gonna post pictures to social media that were taken with the camera until the

2:09:13embargo date and I don't even read it anymore.

2:09:16But but it's all basically you're going to get this and you're going to

2:09:20keep it secret until the embargo.

2:09:21And And in my experience and they don't talk about it beforehand.

2:09:25So I am I'm under no embargo regarding the iPhone Duo right now because

2:09:29I don't have one and they haven't offered me one and I haven't signed

2:09:32anything.

2:09:32But what I would expect is if it they stick to the schedule they

2:09:36have stick for every product that I've ever reviewed before, the review units will

2:09:41come out ro if it goes on pre order on October sixteenth, review units

2:09:47will go to the hands of selected reviewers.

2:09:50On the thirteenth or the fourteenth, like Tuesday or Wednesday of that week.

2:09:54I think it'll be more than that.

2:09:56Like I don't think so.

2:09:58Because this past so the iPhone eighteen Pro that we just got,

2:10:04I left Apple with that on they gave it to me on the Wednesday.

2:10:09Right.

2:10:10And then the embargo pre-orders were Saturday.

2:10:14Embargo wasn't followed on Tuesday, though.

2:10:17Nope, it was Wednesday.

2:10:18Wasn't it?

2:10:19So so we had a week.

2:10:20So we had a week with it though.

2:10:21Yeah.

2:10:22So we had one week.

2:10:23Which was which is as generous as they get.

2:10:25Yes.

2:10:25Yes.

2:10:26Right.

2:10:26And that's

2:10:28they do not let reviewers in my experience and the experience of people who

2:10:32in the racket who I talk to, they never let us have more than

2:10:36a week with a device before customers before the reviews come out.

2:10:41Right.

2:10:41And then the reviews come out like on a Wednesday or a Tuesday, it

2:10:45depends.

2:10:45They change the day of the week.

2:10:47But then customers get it on Friday.

2:10:49That's day when the Apple executives go to Fifth Avenue in New York and

2:10:54there's a big people wait in line and there's on the news and all

2:10:58that happens.

2:10:58But there's that's the cadence.

2:11:00Review units go out in the middle of one week.

2:11:03At the end of that week, three or four days later, it there's pre-orders.

2:11:08Then in the middle of the next week, after six or seven days, the

2:11:11re people who have the review units are allowed to publish their

2:11:16and then three days, two or three days after that, everybody in the world

2:11:20can just go in an Apple store and buy it.

2:11:22Now you're not gonna be able to buy the duo, but because it's gonna

2:11:24be sold out.

2:11:26But the people the people who got the pre orders in within the first

2:11:29ten seconds of them coming online on October sixteenth will have them in their

2:11:34hands.

2:11:34So I would guess it'll be if I look at the calendar, it'll be

2:11:40Tuesday the October thirteenth or Wednesday, October fourteenth, when people who get review units

2:11:46for the duo get them, and that the review embargo will be probably Wednesday

2:11:51the twenty first.

2:11:52And then on the twenty third, two days later, anybody who bought one and

2:11:56gets one on day one will get it.

2:11:57That's what I expect.

2:11:59And I can say that because I haven't agreed to anything and they didn't

2:12:01tell me anything.

2:12:02Right.

2:12:03And then if we record an episode if I record an episode of the

2:12:06talk show that week, I won't be able to talk about it because it'll

2:12:10be under a embargo.

2:12:11My question for you is if we're expecting an event in October from Apple,

2:12:18which most people are, with things like the rumored home pad type type thing

2:12:23that German has reported on for years.

2:12:26A home pod with a screen of some sort that might, you know, be

2:12:29like a family screen device for the kitchen or whatever.

2:12:33I don't what else are we expecting?

2:12:35A new MacBook?

2:12:37Or MacBook Ultra, whatever that rumored touchscreen MacBook.

2:12:41Yeah, I wonder about that.

2:12:42I know German says it's coming and I don't ever want to bet money

2:12:46against what he says, even though he is wrong quite a bit, but I

2:12:49still don't bet against him.

2:12:51Right.

2:12:51I don't know about that.

2:12:53So like one way they could do it would be like 'cause how will

2:12:56they give you the review units if you are lucky enough to get a

2:13:00review unit?

2:13:01And again, I don't know if I am.

2:13:02I kind of hope I am.

2:13:04I kind of would bet that I will be but I never take it

2:13:07for granted.

2:13:08I wouldn't shocked if I don't.

2:13:10I wouldn't be shocked 'cause it's a weird device and maybe it'll only be

2:13:15three people who get it, like the original iPhone.

2:13:17Oh please, for the love of God.

2:13:18No.

2:13:19I don't know.

2:13:20You never know.

2:13:21But the other thing is they don't like shipping secret things by FedEx.

2:13:26They like to hand them to people and just here it's in an Apple

2:13:32employees' hands and now it is in John Gruber's hands and you've signed a

2:13:36thing and now it's your responsibility.

2:13:38They don't like taking secret things and handing it to a FedEx guy and

2:13:42then the FedEx guy puts it on an airplane.

2:13:45They might pre embargo

2:13:47They don't like that.

2:13:48Right, pre embargo.

2:13:49So it could be that they'll just ship them to reviewers, but if they

2:13:53hand them over, where would they do that?

2:13:55Would they request people fly back to California to get them, or will they

2:13:59have an event in New York or something, which they often do.

2:14:03But if they have the event in New York, would it also double as

2:14:06the hey here's this uh home pod with a screen thing?

2:14:11Yeah, I think but then are they gonna give us one of those to

2:14:14review too.

2:14:15I one of the reasons I feel like it kinda had to work out

2:14:18this way is just supply chain stuff.

2:14:19But they in hindsight, they could not have given reviewers both phones two weeks

2:14:24ago because no one would have reviewed the iPhone eighteen pro.

2:14:27They would have said, Oh, it's Burgundy.

2:14:29And then they would have spent the whole week with the duo.

2:14:31And at places like The Verge with multiple staffers, they would have stabbed each

2:14:35other trying to get the duo.

2:14:37That's funny.

2:14:38No, that's true.

2:14:40I see.

2:14:40And so I don't know how they can't give me a home pod with

2:14:43a screen and the duo and expect me to review them in a week.

2:14:46I'm if I can get one review out in a week, right?

2:14:50And that they don't want those reviews distracting from each other, right?

2:14:54Right.

2:14:56I think the home pod with screen, it's obviously a much, much less important.

2:15:03Yeah.

2:15:03More of a low profile device compared to the iPhone Duo, right?

2:15:07And so

2:15:10If I had to guess, if they want to hand these things to us,

2:15:12they would do an event,

2:15:15then they could hand both things over.

2:15:17Or it's gonna be I mean the home pod with a screen seems kind

2:15:21of I'm guessing New York, because California's really only for dub dub and iPhone

2:15:25event.

2:15:26Yep.

2:15:27And they don't like to stay in the same place twice in a row.

2:15:31I don't think it seems like a it's gonna be a cumbersome kind of

2:15:34box for the home pa home pad.

2:15:36It has a home Hold bot has this maybe that's what they're gonna ship

2:15:39to you because that is not as top secret high high level.

2:15:44We'll ship you this.

2:15:45Or uh let me run this by I think about these things.

2:15:48I and again, I don't know why I could just sit there and wait

2:15:51not even worry about it and then just wait and have No, it's part

2:15:54of the phone.

2:15:54Here's what I thought of All right.

2:15:56What if it's a it's another here's the announcement, we're gonna tell you all

2:16:00about it.

2:16:00We're gonna have demos that you can do in the hands on and try

2:16:04it.

2:16:04But this doesn't November and so we'll give you the review unit in two

2:16:09another month where you'll get review units of the home pad, even though the

2:16:13event was in the middle of October.

2:16:15But then you do leave uh some of the people will leave the thing

2:16:18in the middle October with a duo review unit for the next week.

2:16:22Yes.

2:16:22That's that's my guess.

2:16:23Okay.

2:16:24And then either I'm all wet and nothing like this will happen and it

2:16:27will play out at a totally different schedule, or it's gonna come out exactly

2:16:31like this and someone at Apple is gonna say who leaked it to Gruber,

2:16:34but nobody leaked anything to me, including the the duo name.

2:16:39I did not nobody leaked that to me.

2:16:41Right.

2:16:41But that was that was a good that was a good guess.

2:16:44Yeah.

2:16:44Well I'm good sometimes I'm good at thinking how Apple thinks.

2:16:48And the duo thing I think that they like.

2:16:51I think someone like Jaws, who's been there for a long time, remembers the

2:16:55old power book duos.

2:16:57They like the name I forgot.

2:16:58I even forgot.

2:16:59I keep forgetting.

2:16:59I should link to this on Daring Fireball.

2:17:01They use the name duo just a couple of years ago for the duo

2:17:04charging dock.

2:17:05Oh

2:17:07it was a lightning the MagSafe duo charging dock where it folded up into

2:17:11a nice little square and then you unfold it and you had a MagSafe

2:17:14for your phone and a watch charger charger.

2:17:17The yeah, MagSafe Duo charging.

2:17:19They dislike the name Duo.

2:17:20I think Duo sounds good next to Neo and it is it's a two

2:17:25it is pricing scheme though.

2:17:26It is.

2:17:27And Jaws said this in multiple interviews.

2:17:29Jaw said it multiple times in interviews that he gave after the announcement, it's

2:17:34two products.

2:17:35It is.

2:17:35It's like you open it up and it is like a small iPad mini

2:17:38tablet, but running iPhone OS, not iPad OS.

2:17:42And then you fold it up and it is a passport style closed phone

2:17:46that is actually not too thick and is lightweight and not too ridiculous or

2:17:51uh not ridiculous at all to just use in its closed form.

2:17:55Um

2:17:57And if you wanted an iPad mini size device with a one hundred twenty

2:18:00horse promotion display, here it is.

2:18:04Yeah, here it is, right?

2:18:05And that's the way I just go back to it.

2:18:07This and again, I've only d used it in the hands-on area in a

2:18:12little bit in briefing time.

2:18:13I have probably spent less time with it in my hand than you because

2:18:16you spent a lot of time in the content and creation area shooting extra

2:18:20videos.

2:18:21In Utah This is what I first got out of my head to invite

2:18:24you on the show, Andrew.

2:18:25Is I was you're like oh are you leaving?

2:18:27I'm like, I'm outta here.

2:18:28I gotta get the hell out of here.

2:18:29Again, you were just starting to work after a long day, but it was

2:18:33like you were going into the room where they had content areas for you

2:18:37guys to shoot footage.

2:18:39And then you said to me, Yeah, well, you have a YouTube channel, you

2:18:42should make more than one video a year.

2:18:44And I'm looking at you after that it was like I don't know, like

2:18:48six o'clock at night.

2:18:49I mean, and it th the day started at eight AM.

2:18:52I was exhausted and you're like going to where I'm like, Yeah, I'm I'm

2:18:55signing up for that.

2:18:56No way.

2:18:58So I haven't used it that much.

2:18:59But the way I'm thinking about it two weeks later is I'm almost thinking

2:19:03of the duo as more like an iPad mini that folds into a phone

2:19:09you can take with you than as a phone that you can unfold into

2:19:13an iPad mini like thing.

2:19:15That it's like a two thousand dollar iPad mini pro.

2:19:18Yeah.

2:19:18It's pro not With the best camera in the world, but pro because it

2:19:24can fold up and it has this amazing matte screen inside.

2:19:28And from what I saw, I have a lot of questions about how much

2:19:32I'm gonna like the iOS

2:19:35on the outside screen when it's folded with that stuff I talked about with

2:19:39it where it's moved over to the right.

2:19:41But opening it up, I loved it.

2:19:43I th I think I like it.

2:19:44And again, I've only used it for a couple minutes.

2:19:46So I'd with with hold my right to say, oh no, never mind.

2:19:50It's not that good or it's not that different or whatever.

2:19:52But I think I like it better than iPad OS because I love the

2:19:58Mac and you might think, well if you love the Mac so much you

2:20:01probably love iPad OS since last year with the iPad OS twenty six where

2:20:06it got more Mac like with the red, yellow, green buttons and the windows

2:20:09you can drag around.

2:20:10I do think that's better than the iPad OS that came before it for

2:20:14multitasking, but I don't want multitasking on an iPad.

2:20:17My favorite iPad era was like when it was brand new, when it really

2:20:22was more like a big iPhone.

2:20:24And I think that they added split screen to the iPad while it still

2:20:30had a home button.

2:20:32And I think that was the fundamental mistake where they went wrong.

2:20:36And it's not that they were wrong that people wanted to do split screen.

2:20:39It's that it was incompatible with the home button as the fundamental metaphor for

2:20:45m getting around the system because there's only one home button, but now you

2:20:50have two apps on the screen.

2:20:52And like you said, the only other time they've had a big change like

2:20:55this with the iPhone was iPhone 10, where they got rid of the home

2:20:59button and you drag up from the bottom.

2:21:01With the duo, when you do split screen, you just drag up from the

2:21:06bottom like a phone to get rid of one of the two sides.

2:21:10And now you have a home screen underneath and you can just open another

2:21:13app to fill the slide.

2:21:14I think it is actually a better multitask.

2:21:17It's not more complex.

2:21:19It's not m better for experts, but for just simple I want to put

2:21:23two apps on the tablet at the same time.

2:21:25I think it's a better interface than iPad OS.

2:21:28And so I think the fact that it doesn't they didn't say and they're

2:21:32they in fact it definitely doesn't work this way.

2:21:34It's not iOS on the outside and iPad OS on the inside.

2:21:41It is duo OS on both screens.

2:21:44It's different.

2:21:45And I think it's a better for me, a better tablet interface than iPad

2:21:50OS.

2:21:50I think it's a better tablet.

2:21:51I that's my anticipation.

2:21:54So would I spend $2,000 on an iPad?

2:21:57Like maybe.

2:21:58Let me ask you this.

2:21:59This is my one fear.

2:22:02Obviously, what they showed us was apps that are optimized for this device.

2:22:09If you have downloaded a bunch of third-party apps and they're not updated yet

2:22:15for the duo, I don't know if you've seen what how they look.

2:22:19They look almost like how apps used to look when you would launch them

2:22:23on the iPad back in the day and they have that compatibility mode.

2:22:27Are you gonna buy a duo and then most of your apps are looking

2:22:32it makes this look weird.

2:22:33Yeah.

2:22:34Most you're hoping for this full screen experience and like all of a sudden

2:22:37it's just everything's cut off.

2:22:39And if that's the case, I think people are gonna have a hard time

2:22:42accepting two thousand dollars for that.

2:22:45Yeah.

2:22:45And there's two ways of compatibility.

2:22:48Well there's three.

2:22:49The the right way is to recompile the app and adjust it with iPad

2:22:53o or iOS twenty seven point one, the weird twenty seven point one version

2:22:57number that's only for the duo.

2:22:59And it's a race against time for developers working on it now to get

2:23:03it out to within the next what th th four weeks.

2:23:07And I think a lot of the indie apps will get that done, right?

2:23:10Overcast from Marco

2:23:15Then there's apps that aren't adjusted for the Duo or OS twenty-seven point one,

2:23:21but have been recompiled with Xcode twenty seven point zero's SDK.

2:23:27Those look mostly okay.

2:23:30They don't get it's like they they fill the screen, but they don't the

2:23:34right side area.

2:23:35Okay.

2:23:35And there's but you still get the the system status bar like with the

2:23:39the new circular battery thing and the time.

2:23:43And then there's what apps look like if they're still on an older SDK

2:23:47than 27.0.

2:23:49And those are the ones where you get just huge black areas and a

2:23:53tiny little iPhone sized window in the middle that like spans the crease.

2:24:00I don't know like is Slack already on at least on twenty seven point

2:24:05zero?

2:24:05I don't know.

2:24:06Right.

2:24:07Google's apps Google's apps uh notoriously back in the day, every time Apple would

2:24:12change the screen size of the new iPhone, it would be like eleven months

2:24:16before Google's apps didn't have black bars at the top and bottom.

2:24:19Right.

2:24:20And those are super popular apps, right?

2:24:23I don't know what people use the Google app for.

2:24:25Just the app called Google.

2:24:27But every time I look at the top app store list, it's like number

2:24:30six or seven, right?

2:24:31It is a super popular app.

2:24:33Don't you think that, hey Isn't it interesting in hindsight that after all these

2:24:38years Instagram finally came out with an iPad app this year?

2:24:41Mm-hmm.

2:24:42I don't you think that somebody at Apple they're like they got together with

2:24:46the people at Instagram and they're like, Look, you guys don't like us, we

2:24:49don't like you, but let's you're a super popular app.

2:24:53We're not gonna tell you what we're doing, but you're really gonna want to

2:24:58have something like an iPad like layout for the iPhone.

2:25:03Yeah.

2:25:03Right.

2:25:04Yeah.

2:25:05Some kind of Apple-like way of not telling them, but telling them if even

2:25:11if you only care about the iPhone and you want to be spiteful about

2:25:15not having a native iPad app, the y the the time for that spite

2:25:19is over.

2:25:19And that they were like, okay, and you know, and now this year they've

2:25:22got it.

2:25:23So I think Instagram is gonna be there on day one or very soon

2:25:26after.

2:25:26And I think Instagram whatever they think of Apple and whatever Zuckerberg thinks about

2:25:31Apple and the the competition there, they know it just goes back to the

2:25:37type of people who Apple has invited, the influencers, the pure Instagram personality celebrities

2:25:44who got invited to the event.

2:25:46They know what people who use Instagram care about.

2:25:49And that's like new cool things.

2:25:51Yes.

2:25:52So I think like Instagram will be updated, but what about like your bank

2:25:55app and shit like that?

2:25:56Like there's that's gonna be a little iPhone postage stamp in the middle of

2:26:00the duo screen for two years.

2:26:02It is mad.

2:26:03I'm gonna mad about that.

2:26:04I thought it was interesting though they had Netflix because Netflix still has not

2:26:08put on a Vision Pro app and they have Apple TV and they didn't

2:26:12they did not choose to showcase Apple TV.

2:26:14They specifically chose Netflix T.

2:26:16Yeah.

2:26:17And I think that's such a great example.

2:26:19And maybe the Apple actually learned a lesson from Vision Pro and they're like,

2:26:23Oh yeah, maybe we do need developer relationships proper relations with some of these

2:26:25big companies.

2:26:26And yeah, maybe we sh should have gotten Netflix on board with our cinematic

2:26:32viewing experience Vision Pro before we came out with it, rather than assuming that

2:26:37they would just come and do this.

2:26:38So why don't we go and make nice with them and have them build

2:26:42a thing for the duo?

2:26:43And they they were s I think I nobody at Apple told me this,

2:26:47but I kind of think Apple was like, I can't believe we didn't think

2:26:49of that where with the duo folded like a laptop

2:26:55Oh with you're looking at the big screen, but it's folded like a laptop

2:26:59into an L shape to watch a horizontal Netflix video, it ref it renders

2:27:06a reflection of the video on the flat part and it's it is live

2:27:11and as you change the angle of the duo it changes the reflection to

2:27:16reflect the angle.

2:27:17It is it's like an Apple like thing to do.

2:27:20And the Netflix team built it in like a couple of days in secret

2:27:24at Apple Park.

2:27:25So I think that's a great sign that Apple knows the most popular apps

2:27:28and is going to do the developer relations work to make it happen.

2:27:32So I don't think that's gonna keep people from buying it.

2:27:34You know, and I think people will just I think it'll hopefully be the

2:27:38sort of thing where people will just yell at the apps that aren't updated

2:27:42to put press rather than not buy the duo because of it, buy the

2:27:46duo and then yell at your bank for having a shitty app.

2:27:49Yeah.

2:27:50Yeah.

2:27:50I mean, hopefully we're not seeing a bunch of one star.

2:27:53I mean, because a lot of the the best apps out there are just

2:27:55teams of one or two people, right?

2:27:57And it's like Apple really didn't give them a lot of time to to

2:28:01do this.

2:28:01Right.

2:28:02Um

2:28:03but regardless, as a purchaser, I want I I want to take advantage of

2:28:07those screens.

2:28:08I don't especially the the outer screen, which is so small anyway, like I

2:28:11don't want an even smaller weird app experience.

2:28:16So I don't know.

2:28:17Right with a big black bar that doesn't have any content on this.

2:28:20Right.

2:28:20The top twenty or thirty apps, paid free, et cetera, games, these have to

2:28:24be day one ready to go.

2:28:27Yeah.

2:28:28I do what do you think about the theory?

2:28:29People keep bringing it up and now I don't know.

2:28:31I thought no, Apple doesn't do that.

2:28:33But what about the theory that the iPhone Air was sort of not a

2:28:38test, but sort of a proof of concept for making a thinner iPhone to

2:28:43get some of the engineering challenges out of the way before making the duo.

2:28:48Because I have to say, having had the duo in hand, it does feel

2:28:52a lot like an iPhone Air.

2:28:54Yeah.

2:28:55It really does.

2:28:57I don't know h the psychology behind it, but Apple does use

2:29:03like I guess one example would be the the digital crown from the Apple

2:29:08Watch appearing on the Vision Pro, right?

2:29:10Like it's like they will make something and then figure out a cool way

2:29:15to reuse it elsewhere.

2:29:17And so they did titanium fifteen and sixteen.

2:29:21They continue titanium on the air and it was thin, right?

2:29:26It was the thinnest at the time until the duo, the thinnest iPhone ever

2:29:31made, is titanium.

2:29:33It it I don't know again, I don't know if it's like we're just

2:29:36gonna release this air as a trial for this other thing.

2:29:39I think it was more

2:29:41the evolution of the titanium technology and can they keep it cool?

2:29:46Can they have a a battery that runs?

2:29:48Like just making sure and preparing for this.

2:29:52Yeah.

2:29:52All right.

2:29:53Last question.

2:29:54Given that you've used and bought all as you said, all of the Android,

2:30:00to be clear.

2:30:01Well it is used carried and reviewed.

2:30:04Yes.

2:30:04Do you think you're going to be a duo owner?

2:30:07Yes.

2:30:08A hundred percent.

2:30:09A hundred percent.

2:30:10Sounds just what it sounds like.

2:30:11Because I mean, a lot of people that do this job you're different because

2:30:18you're independent, right?

2:30:19You do this because you have a passion for it and you love it.

2:30:22Same here.

2:30:23At the end of the day, the reason I started all of this on

2:30:27day one is because I'm so passionate about new technology and I'm i it

2:30:31excites me and so here it is.

2:30:34Here's a again, a genuinely brand new, different iPhone experience.

2:30:40Of course I'm gonna want to get in there and use it.

2:30:44I did think that, kind of speaking of a question that you just asked

2:30:48about the the air,

2:30:50the iPhone e sim transfer tool that they put in OS twenty seven.

2:30:57The handoff thing.

2:30:58The handoff handoff.

2:30:59Allows you to very easily keep a pro phone when needed, right?

2:31:04And carry a duo with you.

2:31:06So if I need to if I need better cameras or for whatever reason

2:31:12need better battery.

2:31:13I can easily see.

2:31:14I do not think it's a coincidence that feature is debuting alongside the duo.

2:31:18Exactly.

2:31:19'Cause I think with e sims, Apple Apple employees, especially the ones who work

2:31:25on the new iPhones, are used to carrying multiple phones because they get the

2:31:30new phone while it's a prototype and they can't take it out.

2:31:33You know, or they have to put it in a case to make it

2:31:35look like the old one.

2:31:36But with the duo they definitely couldn't, right?

2:31:38You couldn't even put that in a case and walk around.

2:31:40You could only use it at work when you're at areas where everybody around

2:31:44you is allowed to see it.

2:31:46Yeah.

2:31:47And the e sim thing has made it easier to switch between phones.

2:31:51Somebody a friend who's never really only ever switched E sims when he's bought

2:31:56a new iPhone.

2:31:57I got a new iPhone, now I have to switch the e sim.

2:32:00And it was like I don't even know how possible it is to do

2:32:03the just the normal go through Verizon and move the eSIM from one phone

2:32:07to another.

2:32:07And I say, Oh, I do it all the time because of what I

2:32:10do.

2:32:10Takes I I would say about two or three minutes.

2:32:13You have to have both phones.

2:32:14You have to start it on the phone that doesn't have the active event

2:32:18to V SIM and say I want it and it goes through iCloud so

2:32:22it says, oh do you John, your phone number 267, whatever, do you want

2:32:27to transfer that?

2:32:28Yes.

2:32:28And then it says, okay now go to your other phone and confirm it

2:32:31and you have to do a face ID double click on the side button

2:32:33to say yes, I want to move my e sim, and then the first

2:32:37the phone that has it will spin for a bit, and then the other

2:32:41phone spins for a bit, and then it says, Okay, your sim is transferred,

2:32:45and then there's sometimes a couple of minutes where your eye messages are funny

2:32:49and you somebody texts you and they go across as green because the phone

2:32:55it didn't register the new the phone that just got I don't know, one

2:32:59of the two phones hasn't completed the whatever it the handshake to the iMessage

2:33:04server and you get green you get or send green messages for a bit

2:33:09and then within half an hour it's all worked out.

2:33:12And it's not bad.

2:33:15And if you have to use multiple phones for work or for reviews, it's

2:33:18not too bad.

2:33:19But you wouldn't want to switch like that all the time.

2:33:23No.

2:33:23What they're saying, the way they're describing iPhone handoff works You just whichever one

2:33:28you're using is the one that has the phone number.

2:33:31Yes, whichever phone is unlocked, it instantly picks it up.

2:33:34That sounds exactly like what this if you don't love it as your main

2:33:40phone when you want the phone as a phone, or you want the longest

2:33:45battery life, or you really care about the camera.

2:33:47But other times, if you could just take your iPad mini with you, I'm

2:33:52on my iPad mini and I'm doing something or watching a video or something

2:33:55and I just want to fold it up and put it in my pocket

2:33:57and leave to go get lunch and come back and not worry about the

2:34:01phone other phone I left on the chart.

2:34:03This sounds amazing.

2:34:04Yeah.

2:34:05And again the but also sounds very much like oh you want to buy

2:34:09two expensive iPhones from Apple?

2:34:11Yep.

2:34:11You got three thousand dollars worth of iPhones in your pocket.

2:34:14Yeah.

2:34:15Tim Cook up in the chairman's office is nodding his head saying, Yes, yes.

2:34:19And John Turnus is like, Yes, numbers go up in my first year of

2:34:24the job.

2:34:24People are going to say I'm doing a very good job.

2:34:27But how many people already own an iPad and an iPhone?

2:34:32Lots of people, right?

2:34:33And it's like maybe instead of buying an iPad that's iPad that says iPad,

2:34:37you buy an iPhone Duo and maybe instead of buying a new iPhone Pro,

2:34:43you just keep the iPhone fifteen Pro that you already have, right?

2:34:47And that's sure, now it's three years old, but you just keep it and

2:34:51instead of upgrading from the iPhone fifteen Pro, you just keep it.

2:34:55And now you have an iPad Duo, but sometimes you still have your iPhone

2:34:59fifteen Pro with you in your pocket, and thanks to iPhone handoff and the

2:35:04five dollars a month or whatever these bastard carriers are gonna charge us for

2:35:09it, it's still a month is less than what they charge for an iPad

2:35:12with cellular, which is twenty bucks a month.

2:35:15So And what's wrong with ATT that

2:35:19well and Verizon is said they're going to do it, but they haven't said

2:35:23when and they haven't said what it's gonna cost.

2:35:25But I've been on Verizon at least since twenty eleven or something like that.

2:35:29And if there's can charge you for they do.

2:35:32I mean so I'm hoping it's five dollars a month instead of zero, even

2:35:36though I think it should be zero, but given how much I pay already.

2:35:40But I think that's the way to think about it.

2:35:42It's a two thousand dollar iPad mini that you can fold up and take

2:35:45with you, and it's by far and away the best and most fun iPad

2:35:49mini I've ever seen, even though it doesn't iPad OS.

2:35:52But I actually think that might be better anyway.

2:35:55And you can even use a pencil.

2:35:56Yeah.

2:35:57We didn't get to try that, but No, that was weird, right?

2:36:01That was kind of weird that they didn't let you try that.

2:36:03I was like, Hey, is there one set up with a pencil anywhere?

2:36:06And they were like No, no, that's a good idea.

2:36:09That's

2:36:10a good idea.

2:36:12Everything that they don't do for us in the media, that's always, oh, that's

2:36:15a good idea.

2:36:16But I don't know why I don't know why they didn't have a pencil

2:36:18set up, but they didn't I think maybe

2:36:22because it it was buggy still.

2:36:25Seems to me like part of the whole thing with the SDK not coming

2:36:28out till now and everything is that this whole uh initial twenty seven point

2:36:32one release of iOS might be a little buggy.

2:36:34Yeah.

2:36:34I thought they learned their lesson from your article last year though, which is

2:36:37don't announce th things to us that we can't try.

2:36:41Right.

2:36:41And that would be the only thing this year that was like we they

2:36:44announced it, but there was no way for us to actually see it in

2:36:46action.

2:36:46Even in their game.

2:36:47Yeah, but yeah, maybe.

2:36:49Yeah, I didn't see anybody use it with a pencil at all.

2:36:51That was now that I think about it, I didn't see s uh 'cause

2:36:54sometimes there's things that they'll show that but it never leaves an Apple employee's

2:36:58hands but it's not a little bit.

2:37:00They just showed it as a still image of the pencil leaning against it.

2:37:04We never got to see someone actually writing.

2:37:07Yeah.

2:37:08Weirder and weirder.

2:37:09Yeah.

2:37:10And then there's the German report that they uh intended to make a special

2:37:14little golf pencil for it.

2:37:15Uh that would have been cool.

2:37:17That would have been duo sized, but that got cancelled.

2:37:19So maybe that had something to do with it.

2:37:21I don't yeah.

2:37:22Are you excited for the pencil support in it?

2:37:24I'm really a big no.

2:37:26No.

2:37:26I always keep the pencil on top of the iPad and use it like

2:37:29twice a year or something.

2:37:30It's just there.

2:37:31So all right.

2:37:32One more question for you as somebody who has tested a bunch of these

2:37:35folding phones.

2:37:36Yeah.

2:37:37How do you find typing on them?

2:37:39That's the thing that I didn't really do in the hands on area.

2:37:42And I that's the one question the most frequent question from my readers that

2:37:46I can't really answer because it's turns out that the things I decided to

2:37:50try weren't typing.

2:37:53But I don't love typing even on an iPad mini.

2:37:56Yeah, so I don't know what happened to this mode on because I don't

2:38:02unless I have to like set it back up again.

2:38:04The iPad used to allow you to have a little split screen keyboard when

2:38:07typing on it.

2:38:08Yep.

2:38:08And I don't remember seeing that in recent years.

2:38:10But most of the foldable phones have that and it makes it very easy

2:38:13to do.

2:38:14And I think the duo does too, but I think only in the widescreen,

2:38:18right?

2:38:18I don't think you can do it when it's Yeah, when you have that,

2:38:21it's actually it l it looks complicated, but your fingers just know what to

2:38:25do.

2:38:26So I'm going to do that.

2:38:28Yeah, exactly.

2:38:29Yeah.

2:38:31All right.

2:38:31I think we've gone on long enough.

2:38:33But um

2:38:35anything else you want to talk about from the keynote?

2:38:37I think that about wraps it up though.

2:38:39Uh Yeah.

2:38:41All right.

2:38:41Exciting times.

2:38:42Thank you for taking especially given your the incredibly busy travel schedule.

2:38:47Oh, it's alright.

2:38:48And you're probably c coming back east soon too.

2:38:51Yes, I will.

2:38:51I'll be there next week.

2:38:53Yeah, and if there's an event in October, I do hope to see you

2:38:57there.

2:38:57People can find your YouTube channel at YouTube and it's just username at A

2:39:03N D R U Andrew.

2:39:05Right?

2:39:05That's the best place to find you.

2:39:06Anywhere else, what else you wanna promote threads same on threads at Andrew on

2:39:10Threads as well.

2:39:12Andrew.

2:39:12Oh you got a good username there.

2:39:13Yep.

2:39:14A N D R U on both and keep up the good work.

2:39:18Lots of more reviews to come.

2:39:19I thanks to our sponsors.

2:39:20We had Factor where you can buy meals And Notion, the AI for teams.

2:39:26So my thanks to them.

2:39:27My thanks to you, Andrew.

2:39:29Good to see you.

2:39:29Absolutely.

2:39:30Same here