Podcast Search

ATP

711: Hot Dog on an Actuator

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00All right, as you know, it is very important to me to never guess

0:00:05or BS about anything.

0:00:06Mm-hmm.

0:00:07Mm-hmm.

0:00:08So I have some actual data this time.

0:00:10I was uh it kind of bothered me last episode that I didn't have

0:00:14good performance numbers for the M six Mac minis in my transcript machines.

0:00:18Um so now that I well, my the single single Mac mini in my

0:00:22the one of forty eight is an M six.

0:00:24Um and I'm happy to report that now I have actual numbers.

0:00:28So in this role of being my transcript machine, the M six over the

0:00:33M four is about twenty to thirty percent faster.

0:00:38Wow.

0:00:38So that's so I now have actual numbers to say that like it is

0:00:41it hovers between those two.

0:00:43Now keep in mind that these are doing more than just cr transcription.

0:00:46Um they're also now, thanks to Claude, using two different transcription models.

0:00:51Um I'm I'm now falling back to parakeet for languages that Apple's speech transcriber

0:00:56does not support.

0:00:56Um so they're they're doing a lot more, but with that mixed workload over

0:01:02like twelve hours averages, I'm you know, depending on when I look it's between

0:01:07and thirty percent difference.

0:01:08And now here's the question.

0:01:10Uh how does that work out when you divide by price?

0:01:14Oh.

0:01:16Is it in other words, is it still more economical to get more M

0:01:18fours?

0:01:19Well, at the price I paid for them back in the day, yes.

0:01:23But uh even even today's prices, presumably you can get an M4 mini for

0:01:26cheaper than an M six, right?

0:01:28I mean, probably, but it the difference might not be as big as you

0:01:31think.

0:01:31Like used Mac minis always cost more than you think they will because there's

0:01:36always a market for used Mac minis, especially at the low end.

0:01:40Like if you're you know, if you're trying to sell a used Mac mini

0:01:43that's high spec'd that cost you two thousand dollars when you bought it new,

0:01:46you're probably gonna lose some money on that.

0:01:48Whereas if you just are trying to sell a base model that you got

0:01:51a good price on, you're probably not gonna lose that much money.

0:01:54Because the thing like, you know, because it is so important to so many

0:01:58people to just have a Mac and the Mac Mini is usually in m

0:02:02many ways the cheapest way to do that, although the Neo throws a wrench

0:02:05in that plan.

0:02:06But there's always this is why used Mac minis, like when you go on

0:02:09eBay and stuff, they're never that much cheaper than the new ones.

0:02:12Just because everybody wants them.

0:02:15So it's probably better for me to just buy M sixes at this point,

0:02:18but i it would probably be close.

0:02:20And if I compare it to what I was actually paying for these M

0:02:23fours, you know, a year and a half ago or a year ago, like

0:02:26that was a very different situation.

0:02:28Like 'cause almost all of these, like they're Like their their list price was

0:02:31six hundred dollars.

0:02:32I don't think I paid that for a single one.

0:02:34But it was definitely like, you know, around five hundred bucks for most of

0:02:37them, maybe five fifty at the highest.

0:02:41All right.

0:02:41For the final time for twenty twenty six.

0:02:45I am begging you to go to saintju.org slash ATP and send a little

0:02:50bit of money their way.

0:02:50So what are we talking about?

0:02:51So September is Childhood Cancer Awareness Month.

0:02:54And uh this month, September is running at least 32 days because uh we

0:02:59A week from today as we record this, I will be in Memphis, Tennessee

0:03:03on the St.

0:03:03Jude campus and I will be recording our 12-hour podcast a thon that begins

0:03:07at noon Eastern and runs until midnight.

0:03:09And we are doing this in service of St.

0:03:11Jude Children's Research Hospital.

0:03:12Why St.

0:03:13Jude?

0:03:13Because they do whatever they can to make sure that no child dies in

0:03:17the dawn of life.

0:03:19They have done absolutely tremendous work.

0:03:22They are astonishingly good people who care.

0:03:25Everybody there cares cares.

0:03:28How do I know?

0:03:28Because I've been there many times and I've spoken to many different employees in

0:03:32many different parts of the organization and they care.

0:03:36It is astonishing how much everyone cares about their mission.

0:03:39It's really, really, really impressive.

0:03:41So here's the thing.

0:03:42Uh when St.

0:03:43Jude opened in 1962, childhood cancer was largely considered incurable.

0:03:48Since then, St.

0:03:49Jude has help push the overall cancer survival rate into in the US at

0:03:52least from 20% to more than 80%.

0:03:55Percent and Saint Jude won't stop until no child dies from cancer.

0:03:59Uh turning curing childhood cancer is an absolutely astonishing undertaking and Saint Jude needs

0:04:04our help to do it.

0:04:05That's you, the listener.

0:04:06You yes, in the headphones, you.

0:04:08Uh the generosity of donors, like you everywhere supports cutting edge research that saves

0:04:13lives, ensures that families never receive a bill from St.

0:04:15Jude for treatment, travel, housing, or food.

0:04:18Every child deserves a chance to live their best life and celebrate every moment.

0:04:21When you support St.

0:04:22Jude, you can help make s cures possible for kids with cancer.

0:04:27And why wouldn't you want to do that?

0:04:29Uh it it is really astonishing the generosity of the ATP and relay community.

0:04:34Uh I meant to highlight this earlier and I completely forgot to.

0:04:38And as I vamp for time, I can't find the actual thing I'm looking

0:04:41for.

0:04:41But if I recall correctly, the leading donation.

0:04:45Last I looked anyway, a single donation was twenty thousand dollars.

0:04:50And I just want to congratulate that person.

0:04:52Uh I've spoken to that person.

0:04:53I am uh friendly with that person or at at the very least casually

0:04:57acquainted with that person.

0:04:58Um I don't know if they want to be named and that's why I'm

0:05:00being cagey about it, but I hope at that level everyone's friendly with this

0:05:03person.

0:05:05Exactly right.

0:05:05You should be if you're not.

0:05:07You have friends in all of us for sure.

0:05:08Um so yeah, so it is absolutely incredible the generosity of the ATP family,

0:05:13but and relay.

0:05:14But here's the thing.

0:05:15What if you don't have twenty thousand dollars just laying around burning a hole

0:05:17in your pocket?

0:05:18What if you have two dollars laying around burning a hole in your pocket?

0:05:20You know what?

0:05:21We'll take that too.

0:05:22Don't fead.

0:05:22That's freaking great.

0:05:24It really is.

0:05:24You should go to saintju.org slash ATP and you should donate whatever you can

0:05:28because I can tell you, I've seen it with my eyes.

0:05:31This money goes to good things.

0:05:33And who doesn't want to try to eliminate the the sickness, sickness in kids?

0:05:38I almost said eliminate sick kids.

0:05:39That'd be very bad.

0:05:40Thankfully, I caught myself.

0:05:41We're not gonna fix it in post.

0:05:42We're gonna leave it in.

0:05:43Uh but anyway, why wouldn't you want to get rid of childhood cancer?

0:05:46So additionally, and I know that October does end on September thirty second this

0:05:52year, but there are some new devices coming a couple of weeks.

0:05:58We're just gonna keep keep that all in, yep.

0:05:59No, it's all staying in, baby.

0:06:01Not gonna fix anything in post.

0:06:02It's perfect.

0:06:03Uh but yeah, so uh October isn't running as long as we maybe could

0:06:07desire it to because the iPhone Duo isn't shipping until a couple weeks after

0:06:12the campaign ends.

0:06:13But you probably have already figured out, if you're a p prospective iPhone Duo

0:06:18buyer, you probably have already figured out what you're gonna buy.

0:06:20And if you feel guilt about your rampant consumerism, which you probably should, there's

0:06:25a way that you can set yourself right with the universe.

0:06:29You can erase that bad karma and even it out.

0:06:32You know, it's like a carbon offset for karma.

0:06:34And the way you do that is by listening to my dear friend Marco

0:06:37Armin tell you about his offset.

0:06:39Absolutely.

0:06:39Because you know, throughout the history of the world, no one has ever had

0:06:42any problems with using money to absolve you of potential sins or or guilt.

0:06:48Um so if you want to offset your indulgences, figure out the base price

0:06:53of the indulgence family that you've selected.

0:06:55Whether it's an iPhone, uh an Apple Watch, maybe an upcoming, you know, foldable

0:07:00iPhone, uh maybe some kind of foldable computer in you know a month or

0:07:03two or whenever those whenever those launch.

0:07:06You gotta figure out what are you probably gonna spend on that or what

0:07:08did you spend on that?

0:07:09Take the base price, whatever you spend on top of that with everything all

0:07:13in, storage upgrades, tiers of different things available different options, cases, Apple Care, whatever

0:07:18it is.

0:07:19Fifteen hundred dollars say and then and the the base products is an iPhone

0:07:22Pro, that's eleven hundred dollars.

0:07:23So your the offset between those two is four hundred dollars.

0:07:26That is your suggested minimum donation.

0:07:29This will absolve you of all your sins, at least in in this particular

0:07:32area.

0:07:33Um and what I suggest also, if you can, go to level two, which

0:07:37adds on to that whatever you spent on paid AI plans or API costs

0:07:41this month.

0:07:42Level three, even above that, is whatever you spent on paid AI plans and

0:07:46API costs this year.

0:07:49I challenge you, try to find a better way to absolve yourself of rampant

0:07:52consumerism guilt and AI usage guilt than this.

0:07:55You won't find one, I assure you.

0:07:57And there's nothing wrong with the system whatsoever of using this foob's all view

0:08:00of this guilt.

0:08:01So please go today.

0:08:02Consider that as your minimum donation if you can swing it.

0:08:04Thank you very much.

0:08:06John, this is your last opportunity.

0:08:08Well this is everybody that's what I was gonna say.

0:08:09This is everybody's if you've been hearing this uh you know pledge drive thing

0:08:12like oh yeah, I should probably do that.

0:08:14This is it.

0:08:14This is the last chance.

0:08:16You're gonna hear us talk about it again, although we may have talked about

0:08:18Casey being on that podcast account, that'll be in the past tense.

0:08:21And keep in mind, you can donate to St.

0:08:22Jude all year long.

0:08:23Obviously, we try to get people to do it during the pledge drive, but

0:08:26if you miss it, it's like, oh, I can't donate anymore.

0:08:28You can always donate.

0:08:29But please, if you wanted to do it during our pledge drive, this is

0:08:32it.

0:08:32This is the time.

0:08:33If you're hearing this.

0:08:34Stop the podcast.

0:08:36Go donate.

0:08:37S T J U D E dot O-R-G-A-TP.

0:08:40Thank you very much for all of you for listening to us talk about

0:08:44this.

0:08:44It really truly is important to us.

0:08:46It means a lot to all three of us.

0:08:47It obviously means an incredible amount to Steven and the relay community.

0:08:51So thank you very much for p for for going on this journey with

0:08:55us, SaintThu.org slash ATP.

0:08:57John, last episode, which as we sit here now is two days ago, but

0:09:01we already have some follow up.

0:09:02Uh Andy writes, Which mouse pad does John use?

0:09:05I want that new mouse pad feeling.

0:09:07Yeah, I I was thinking about this.

0:09:08I was I was showing my daughter my new mouse pad when I was

0:09:10FaceTiming her with her earlier today and explaining uh what I did.

0:09:13So I'll put a link in the show notes to what I get.

0:09:15I haven't always gotten the same one, but it's usually uh just like a

0:09:20cheap, generic black uh sheet of mouse pad.

0:09:23You know those big ones that like gamers use to cover like their entire

0:09:27desk.

0:09:27I get that and then I cut rectangular pieces out of it to fit

0:09:32in the area where I want the mouse pad because it's not like a

0:09:34regular mouse pad shape.

0:09:35And mouse pads come in like I don't know what I think of is

0:09:38the 80s size, which is too small Uh and now they come in the

0:09:42like the 2000 size, which is cover your entire desk.

0:09:44And there's a one or two in-between sizes that I've toyed with, but they're

0:09:48neite right.

0:09:48And I have I have a uh a metal keyboard tray that my keyboard

0:09:51and mouse are on.

0:09:53And I there's room for the mouse pad part of it, and I want

0:09:56it to basically be the exact depth of my keyboard tray and then as

0:10:00wide as I want it to be.

0:10:01And so I just you know bought this Amazon basics rolled up mousepad because

0:10:06I had run out of my previous role or rather I'd run out of

0:10:08parts that I could cut out of it.

0:10:09Uh and then I just took my old mouse pad, put it on top

0:10:12of it, took a razor blade and cut right angles, and now I have

0:10:15a nice new piece of mouse pad.

0:10:17And when I was showing to my daughter I was like she was like,

0:10:19why don't you cover the whole uh keyboard tray with it.

0:10:22And like previously I couldn't find a sheet that would fit the dimensions of

0:10:26it, but now my current sheet would fit the dimensions and I was thinking

0:10:28about it.

0:10:29I might do that, but I kind of like the idea that the keyboard

0:10:33knows where the keyboard area ends.

0:10:34Like I can never accidentally move the keyboard over too far and encroach on

0:10:38my mouse area because the the mouse pad will stop it.

0:10:41You know what I mean?

0:10:41So maybe I'll I'll think about that.

0:10:43For five years from now when I'm replacing this mouse pad again, I might

0:10:46think about cutting cutting off a piece that is the size of the entire

0:10:49keyboard tray.

0:10:50I would definitely do it if my keyboard was sliding around, but it doesn't

0:10:53the metal grips the little rubber feet pretty well.

0:10:56Now Goldilocks, how do you make sure that you get exact right angles when

0:11:00you're cutting this?

0:11:01Uh you use a uh a metal uh like an L-shaped metal ruler, you

0:11:05know what I mean?

0:11:06Okay.

0:11:06I I had a feeling that anything that is not an exact perpendicular cut

0:11:11would be completely intolerable to why would you do that?

0:11:14It's hard to make right angles.

0:11:15I have a million tools in the house that will, you know, metal squares

0:11:18and stuff that will do that.

0:11:19Um yeah, that's a you can use that as the cutting edge, right?

0:11:21But you can't the nice rounded corners that mouse pads always have no there's

0:11:24only all I do have this I the one I cut from the sheet,

0:11:27one of the rounded corners is on it and the other are all sharp,

0:11:30right?

0:11:31And I put the rounded corner in the corner of my um keyboard tray

0:11:35'cause I don't know.

0:11:36That just it that feels like the right place to put it.

0:11:38But I don't I don't want the rounded corners.

0:11:39I want every uh why I want the whole thing.

0:11:41It's like Tahoe, rounded corners just cut into space.

0:11:44Oh my god gracious.

0:11:46I was I just I was just pointing that out to we were discussing

0:11:48in another Slack with somebody on a recent post about what makes Mac apps

0:11:51Mac apps or whatever.

0:11:52I'm like, this is a good companion piece.

0:11:53Uh maybe I'll put the link in the the notes.

0:11:55I'll give it to Casey in a moment, or I'll in the chat room

0:11:58actually.

0:11:59Um

0:12:00hammering home like in extreme length, the the point that everyone made and we

0:12:05all made on this show back when Tahoe was released, which is that rounded

0:12:08corners cut into the space of content.

0:12:11And people go, all right, sure, whatever.

0:12:12But like this person's like, no, seriously, think about how dumb it is.

0:12:16And just goes on and on at length to say, look at how this

0:12:19screws up every aspect of the infrared interface for no good reason other than

0:12:22round corners look cute.

0:12:25Still bothers me.

0:12:26I mean my mouse pad is around corners and it it has never bothered

0:12:28me once, but that's also because like I'm not going near the corner.

0:12:31Yeah, I mean like you're not trying to display content on your mouse pad.

0:12:34At least not yet.

0:12:35I'm sure that someone has a mouse pad that someone has a mouse pad

0:12:37that has a screen on it.

0:12:38Well I I need to remove my mouse to so that I can really

0:12:41show off the content beneath it.

0:12:42You just got a translucent mouse and then make your hand translucent and you'll

0:12:45be all set.

0:12:45There you go yeah.

0:12:49Did you see that guy who had the transparent desk with the little charging

0:12:52uh coil that follows his uh devices around?

0:12:54Did you see that?

0:12:54No.

0:12:54Oh my god.

0:12:56It was I I saved it for oh god, I gotta find this.

0:12:59Um

0:13:00yeah, he he was riffing on air power of all things, which I feel

0:13:03like is a really obscure clickbait way to do clickbait for YouTube.

0:13:06It's like no one remembers this.

0:13:08This guy I don't know if this kid was born when air power existed.

0:13:11Um you don't have time to watch it now, but it is uh I

0:13:13can't tell if it's real.

0:13:15So there's that.

0:13:16So let's just chalk it up to it.

0:13:17Maybe the whole video is AI.

0:13:18I don't know.

0:13:19I just It almost doesn't matter with this that kind of thing.

0:13:22Like it you're it's just a fun thing to see.

0:13:24Yeah.

0:13:24Yeah.

0:13:25Might all be AI, including the person.

0:13:27Yeah.

0:13:29All right, John, your drive enclosures, you were debating where to put them if

0:13:33I recall correctly from uh a couple of days ago, how you were going

0:13:36to mount them into what?

0:13:38Uh can you tell me what is the situation today?

0:13:41They are now mounted.

0:13:42I used uh Velcro command strips to hold the little brackety things that I

0:13:48got.

0:13:48Like it's like a laptop holder and like these J-shaped hooks, like and I

0:13:52uh Velcro command stripped them to the back of my desk and I slotted

0:13:56the stuff in and ran the cables to them and they're all set now.

0:13:59So it's nice to have all the stuff off my desk.

0:14:01Now I just have a Mac Studio on my desk with cables plugged into

0:14:04every port except for the HDMI port.

0:14:06I even have the headphone port filled with the same thing that was in

0:14:10the headphone jack of my Mac Pro, which is uh one of those L-shaped

0:14:14adapters for headphone um jacks, right?

0:14:18With nothing plugged into it.

0:14:20Oh.

0:14:20And why is that?

0:14:22So it won't ever play anything over the speaker.

0:14:24Wow.

0:14:25I've done this for years.

0:14:26This is like an old school Mac thing of like if you don't want

0:14:28your Mac to make noise and you have external speakers, if you never want

0:14:31the internal speaker to play like off to the side of your desk, if

0:14:33you have like a tower thing, you put one of the headphones adapters in

0:14:36there and then it always thinks it has headphones in.

0:14:38So even like all the inputs, all the outputs of audio get messed up

0:14:42and it's like oh it's it's you know that your speakers are offline or

0:14:45this or that, it's never gonna make a noise.

0:14:47Well is that so uh maybe I don't know maybe 10 ish years ago

0:14:52Apple changed the way the audio devices and Macs work such that the headphones

0:14:55The headphone jack and the speakers are now separate audio devices and you can

0:15:00actually address them separately in the software.

0:15:02Yeah, I think if you have the the bong turned on, which I I

0:15:05do still have turned, I need to turn that off, but you know the

0:15:06start off.

0:15:07The bong turned on that that will still play even with the the headphone

0:15:11jack in.

0:15:11So yeah, I think they are separate.

0:15:13All right.

0:15:14Your weird AirPods five issues.

0:15:16Can you reintroduce that before I uh tell you what Baum Squad has to

0:15:20say about it?

0:15:21Yeah, I I got AirPods Five and I was like I didn't is this

0:15:24something to do with my new phone or my new AirPods?

0:15:26But when I put them in, first of all, it sounded like uh head

0:15:28tracking was on because I would hear the sound like come from my left

0:15:31and then go to my right or whatever.

0:15:33And then they would even out.

0:15:34And I didn't deal with that was.

0:15:35And then the second thing was when I took the uh the AirPods out,

0:15:40I take out my right one, fine.

0:15:42And then when I go to grab my left one, my fingers would brush

0:15:46against the microphone grating on the outside.

0:15:48And the microphone would pick that up as if I'm rubbing my finger on

0:15:51like a lavalier mic or something, and it would make huge static in my

0:15:54ear.

0:15:54I'm like what the hell?

0:15:55Like, because I have I have everything off, like not in any mode, just

0:16:00every all effects are off.

0:16:01So it shouldn't even be using that microphone but every time I did it

0:16:03when I took out the left one, because I take them out one at

0:16:05a time, when I took out the left one, my fingers would hit the

0:16:07little speaker grade and it would make terrible static and I couldn't figure out

0:16:09why.

0:16:10So Bomb Squad writes the AirPods weird sound change when putting in the second

0:16:14AirPod and the microphone being activated when you take out one airpod is almost

0:16:18certainly the same thing.

0:16:19The listening mode, like transparency or noise cancellation setting, is discrete between one AirPod

0:16:25and two AirPod use cases.

0:16:27The fix is to only put in one AirPod, then go into go to

0:16:30your AirPod setting and control center and switch the listen to the listening mode

0:16:34that you want.

0:16:35Do the same with two AirPods in.

0:16:37Now they should be fixed.

0:16:38Have you tried this, John?

0:16:39I did this and it worked.

0:16:40And I think Bomb Squad has the right idea that essentially there's two sets

0:16:46of settings.

0:16:46There there's the settings for when one AirPod is in.

0:16:48It doesn't matter if it's the right or left, I think, but there's one

0:16:51AirPod setting and then there's the two AirPods setting.

0:16:54And for whatever reason, the one AirPod setting was defaulting to transparency mode.

0:16:58And so when I put the AirPods in, if I put them in one

0:17:00at a time, I'd put one in, it would be in transparency mode.

0:17:02And then with this put the second one in, it would go to my

0:17:05two AirPods mode, which was everything off.

0:17:07And so that's why I held heard the weird difference between left and right,

0:17:09you know, when I was putting them in.

0:17:10And same thing.

0:17:11When out, as soon as I take out one AirPod, it's up, you're in

0:17:14one AirPod mode now, and one AirPod mode is configured for transparency.

0:17:17And then I would take out the left one and I would hear the

0:17:18speaker.

0:17:19So many people wrote in to say, Oh, this is because when you have

0:17:23one AirPod in, they always default to transparency mode.

0:17:27And those people are close, but I think that Baum Squad gets it right

0:17:31in that it's not regardless of what the default is, it's like, oh, they

0:17:35always do one uh they always do transparency with one AirPod.

0:17:38They do whatever you set it to with one AirPod.

0:17:40That may be the default, but they're just simply two sets of settings.

0:17:43It's not saying, Oh, they they always default to transparency mode when you have

0:17:46one.

0:17:47They'll they'll one when you put one in and change the settings, that will

0:17:49be the setting forevermore, I think.

0:17:51So that's the situation I would not have guessed this has solved my problem.

0:17:55All right.

0:17:56With regard to uh excising all of the Intel apps from your computer, uh,

0:18:02there's a way to do this that I presume John found.

0:18:04You can go into system settings and then about and then uh intel-based apps

0:18:10and it will tell you all of the Intel-based apps.

0:18:13Uh there's a sh the sheet that comes up that says support ending for

0:18:16Intel-based apps.

0:18:17Intel-bas running on Rosetta will not open in macOS twenty eight.

0:18:20The following apps need to be updated for Apple Silicon.

0:18:22An update may be available on the developer's website, and then there's Learn More

0:18:25link.

0:18:26We will put the Learn More link into the show notes.

0:18:28So a couple things in this.

0:18:29So last episode I was saying I was going to like what used to

0:18:31be called system profiler.

0:18:32I think it's call information now, because that of course lists all your applications

0:18:36and the uh architecture.

0:18:38Um activity monitor will also show running applications in their architecture.

0:18:41There's a bunch of ways to do this.

0:18:43But apparently in Mac OS twenty seven uh they added this like to a

0:18:48much higher level.

0:18:49Like in system settings about, it's right there on the about screen.

0:18:52There's in there's an Intel based app setting.

0:18:55I'm sorry.

0:18:55Oh, it's in general about.

0:18:57Yeah, I think.

0:18:58Sorry, did I miss something yesterday?

0:18:59Yes, you missed general.

0:19:00That's okay.

0:19:00Yeah.

0:19:00Anyway, but the point is it's you don't have to launch a separate app,

0:19:03you don't click on details or more info.

0:19:05It's it's much more prominently placed.

0:19:07And the second thing is as many people have noted, there's text that you

0:19:10just read, and there's also a notification if like the system finds like a

0:19:15printer driver or some other, you know, background thing that is Intel only, it'll

0:19:19pop up a notification in macOS and say, you know, this isn't Rosetta's going

0:19:22away and this won't happen in Mac open in Mac OS twenty eight, blah

0:19:25blah blah.

0:19:25Are we still using printer drivers?

0:19:27Yeah.

0:19:28I've I've found a bunch of them and I'm excising them.

0:19:30But anyway, as many people have pointed out, this is one of the rare

0:19:35occasions when Apple is officially saying there will be a macOS twenty-eight, which is

0:19:41so dumb because everybody knows there's gonna be another version of macOS, just like

0:19:45there's gonna be another version of iOS.

0:19:47But Apple, in its way, is always so cagey if you say, like, well

0:19:51well an iOS N plus one they're like, what are you talking about?

0:19:53There's no iOS N plus one.

0:19:54It's like, okay, but like if you were to make another version of iOS

0:19:58that has the same number as the current one, both one more, like they'll

0:20:01never admit that a future product is going to happen.

0:20:03But here they are within mac os 27 saying that a thing called mac

0:20:07OS twenty eight exists, which most of the time is, you know, I I

0:20:10guess if for the number discontinuity, it would have been a spoiler to know

0:20:13that they were going to jump from 15 to 26 or something.

0:20:16But I this is a very, very rare and strange occurrence where they're not

0:20:20saying in the next major version of Mac OS ever, they're saying Mac OS

0:20:24twenty eight.

0:20:24That's gonna be the name of a product.

0:20:25They might as well have announced it.

0:20:27Very un-app alike.

0:20:28I'm surprised they didn't app store for mentioning a future uh

0:20:32they've supposedly gotten better about that, but I still do because I've been burned

0:20:35too many times.

0:20:36I still do latest version of Mac OS, future version of Mac OS.

0:20:39I never say the name.

0:20:40Oh yeah, me too.

0:20:41It's like it's like it's like, you know, it's like theater superstitions like never

0:20:44say the name of a future OS.

0:20:46Yeah.

0:20:46And well, here's the thing.

0:20:47Like, regardless of whether it's oh it's fine now they say it's fine.

0:20:50They say a lot of things, first of all.

0:20:52And second of all, the price of getting it wrong could be an extra

0:20:54several days or a week of waiting.

0:20:55And is it worth it?

0:20:57No.

0:20:58We are sponsored this week by Granola.

0:21:01So I have an odd job, not the bad guy, but an unique job,

0:21:07wherein I don't really have meetings, but we wanted to make sure that granola

0:21:12was the real thing.

0:21:14And so John and I had a meeting and we talked about ATP membership

0:21:18stuff.

0:21:19And we talked for like something like an hour or hour and a half.

0:21:22And while we were talking, Renola was there listening and capturing meeting notes for

0:21:26us.

0:21:26And a transcript as well.

0:21:28And this worked out really well because one of my big failings when I

0:21:32had a jobby job was that I would oftentimes record the bare minimum amount

0:21:36of action items, particularly for myself, that I would then look back on later

0:21:40and be like, I have no idea what these words mean and I'm who

0:21:44wrote them.

0:21:45I lost the context completely.

0:21:46So Granola is an AI-powered notepad that makes your meeting notes look useful.

0:21:50It captures what happens in your meetings and turns it into clean, structured notes

0:21:54with decisions and action items pulled out and made easy to find.

0:21:57So like I said, action items are pulled out and made easy to find.

0:22:00So at the bottom of the notes that granola gen generated for our meeting,

0:22:04there's next steps.

0:22:05And one of the next steps, I'm verbatim, is uh approve sponsor product in

0:22:10the doc assigned to casey, which is exactly right.

0:22:13That is one of the things that I needed to do.

0:22:16And this is very helpful because not only does it tell me what I

0:22:19need to do, but I can click on that line item and get a

0:22:22trans uh transcription summary.

0:22:24And then if I really want to go back to the actual transcript, I

0:22:27can do that as well.

0:22:29This makes it really hard for me to lose context, which is really, really

0:22:32helpful.

0:22:34So once you try it on a first meeting, it is hard to go

0:22:37without.

0:22:38You can try it totally free.

0:22:40You can head to granola.ai slash ATP.

0:22:43That's G-R-A-N-O-L-A.

0:22:47To get your time back.

0:22:48Go to granola.ai slash ATP and try it on your next call.

0:22:53Thank you to Granola for sponsoring the show.

0:22:59Hal Lee writes the M5 Ultra is the first Apple GPU to beat the

0:23:04AMD 6900 XT, a GPU I once owned, and that was released in December

0:23:102020.

0:23:11It wasn't the top of the line at the time, NVIDIA had faster GPUs.

0:23:16So looking at GeekPinch, the M3 Ultra with whatever this unit is, 232,267, the

0:23:23Radeon RX 6900 XT 237,000 41.

0:23:28And the M5 Ultra.

0:23:31350,305.

0:23:33So congratulations to Apple Silicon for finally besting a six-year-old GPU that you could

0:23:40put in a 2019 Mac Pro.

0:23:41I'm excited.

0:23:43All right.

0:23:43New Mac minis have a some issues, caveats, if you will, about their storage.

0:23:50Joe Rosignal at Mac Rumors writes: NAN storage in the new Mac Mini models

0:23:55with the M6 and M5 Pro chips is soldered to the logic board.

0:23:59Whereas the previous models with the M4 and M4 Pro chips have removable storage

0:24:02that can be upgraded.

0:24:03Uh M Marco.

0:24:05Uh in addition, all new Mac mini configurations with 256 gigs of storage reportedly

0:24:10have a single NAND chip rather than a pair of 128 gig chips.

0:24:14As a result, 256 gig configurations have slower SSD speeds compared to configurations with

0:24:18512 gigs of storage or more that do have dual NAND chips, according to

0:24:23uh some person who was doing some testing with blackmagic's disc speed test benchmark

0:24:29tool.

0:24:30Yeah it looks like a pure doubling like the five twelve has six point

0:24:33four gigs per second compared to three point two and the m4 has two

0:24:36point eight.

0:24:36So even with the single chip, the the M61 is still faster than the

0:24:40M4 one with the quote unquote good uh two one twenty eight's in them

0:24:44or whatever, but it's worth knowing.

0:24:45It doesn't matter for Marco's case, because he all he cares about is the

0:24:48SOC, like he's not constrained by disk size or disk speeds or anything like

0:24:52that, but just FYI, they cheaped out a little bit on the lowest end

0:24:55uh M five with two fifty six gigs, if that matters to you.

0:24:58Yeah and this is fairly common.

0:25:00Apple does this a lot with their lower end products, like almost in almost

0:25:04all of their products, the base storage uses fewer chips and therefore is slower

0:25:09than the upgraded storage.

0:25:10But they they did that and then they reversed it.

0:25:12Remember the first time they did it, everyone made a big stink and then

0:25:14like the next round of computers came back and they didn't do it.

0:25:16We were like, Yay, they've doing that thing, but now they're back.

0:25:19All right.

0:25:20Uh the OS's twenty seven have a re-jiggered screen time situation.

0:25:27Or so we're told.

0:25:28A friend of the show, Stephen Robles, put up a great YouTube video about

0:25:32many things but the end of it, uh we'll put a timestamp link in

0:25:35the show notes.

0:25:35At the end of it, Steven talks about this.

0:25:37It requires every single device, I think in your family, if I understood him

0:25:42right, to be upgraded, updated to a 27 OS.

0:25:45Uh and if you've just got a new device, stolen device protection won't let

0:25:49you remove old devices from the list without waiting five days first.

0:25:53Uh in Steven's case, his mom is in his Apple family, but he doesn't

0:25:56have anything to do with her screen time specifically.

0:25:59However, because she's part of the family, she also has to update to OS

0:26:03twenty-seven before uh before Steven can use any of the new screen time features

0:26:07for anyone in his family.

0:26:09And then also, what happens to older devices that can't go to twenty-seven?

0:26:13Do you never, ever, ever get the new screen time stuff?

0:26:16Like this I get that y you have to draw a line in the

0:26:19sand if you've jiggered like how this data is stored or whatever, but this

0:26:23kind of stinks.

0:26:24Yeah, and the mystery about it is like, I mean, it if if you

0:26:26have old devices, it doesn't stop you from updating to the new screen time

0:26:30features.

0:26:30But then his question was, can I no longer control screen time on those

0:26:34devices?

0:26:35Like they just become uncontrolled and only the twenty seven devices?

0:26:38He was comparing it to like Home Kit.

0:26:40Remember when they did the HomeKit architecture change where you had all these prompts

0:26:42where like, so you want to convert your home to the new home kit

0:26:45architecture or whatever?

0:26:46But that wasn't as restrictive.

0:26:47But this like I mean, so the two things are combining.

0:26:49He was annoyed 'cause he's trying to put out a video like day day

0:26:52and date of the uh iOS twenty seven coming out.

0:26:54And the stolen device protection is like, hey, you just got this device.

0:26:57You don't have enough time in this device for us to let you start

0:27:00removing devices from an Apple ID.

0:27:01Like that's a security thing if someone snatches your phone in an unlock state

0:27:04or whatever, like uh to stop you stop them from like deleting all the

0:27:08devices off of your Apple ID so you don't have any control anymore.

0:27:11So I get why that protection is there, but he can't remove that means

0:27:14he's got to wait five days, which is an eternity in YouTube time.

0:27:17So that was annoying him.

0:27:18And then like having to have you know his mom is part of his

0:27:21like Apple family thing but he he doesn't want to control her screen time,

0:27:24but she has to update.

0:27:25They won't let him he can't see any of the new features.

0:27:28He can't upgrade anything until everybody every device that can be upgraded to twenty

0:27:32seven is updated to twenty seven.

0:27:34And And who knows, maybe those features he won't even care or care about

0:27:37them or like them.

0:27:38But this is just this sort of like I mean, this is a transient

0:27:40problem.

0:27:40This will go away in a few years when everybody's devices are updated and

0:27:43like this will solve itself.

0:27:44It's not a big deal, but it is kind of frustrating for one of

0:27:46the headlining features.

0:27:47Like it got its own section in the like and the WWC keynote about

0:27:51all about the screen time things, they did not emphasize that this is one

0:27:54of those things that you're not going to be able to use unless everybody

0:27:57updates.

0:27:58All right.

0:27:59Uh I was

0:28:02trying to figure out just a day or two back, why was my pie

0:28:06hole did not seem to be working, particularly on my iPhone?

0:28:10I was getting loads of advertisements.

0:28:12And let me tell you, if you haven't done I swear to God.

0:28:17I swear to God, this just happened.

0:28:19I just got a text from Aaron.

0:28:21True story.

0:28:22It literally just happened.

0:28:23It says the following My phone is inundated with ads, with like the raised

0:28:27eyebrow emoji.

0:28:28I could not have planned that better.

0:28:31I hand on heart, that literally just came in as I was trying to

0:28:34talk.

0:28:34Did somebody uh shut your pie hole?

0:28:38You could say that exactly.

0:28:39Oh my god.

0:28:40Uh though I I I'm shook that this just happened.

0:28:44Uh I I I'm like completely blue screen now.

0:28:47Uh so anyway, so sorry, let me try that.

0:28:49We're gonna leave it in.

0:28:49We're gonna leave it in, Marco.

0:28:50It's gonna leave it in.

0:28:51So yeah, I was trying to figure out why the pie hole was not

0:28:55really working.

0:28:55Now Aaron is asking the same question.

0:28:57Um it wasn't working, particularly on my phone.

0:29:00And the most obvious place I saw this is well, if you ever go

0:29:04to any news related website where you have an advertisement every other paragraph.

0:29:07Or any website these days.

0:29:10Go to any website to do anything.

0:29:11Um but I noticed this most especially, it was most concrete when I did

0:29:16Wordle in the morning, because typically, you know, you I will say play Wordle

0:29:20and it'll show you an interstitial and with the pie hole you'll see advertisement.

0:29:24And you wait a couple of seconds and then you can click continue.

0:29:27Um the then you would you would just go and play your wordle.

0:29:32But in this case, I'm seeing like video advertisements.

0:29:34Like what is happening This is driving me baddie.

0:29:38And I was going to bring it up on the show at some point,

0:29:40but I hadn't around to it.

0:29:41I've been very busy recently.

0:29:41We all have very bit been bit very busy recently.

0:29:44Um and all of a sudden I got copied on a tweet or a

0:29:49toot or whatever.

0:29:50Uh which originated with DAS Fuller, D-A-Z-F-U-L-L-E-R.

0:29:54And it reads as follows: In the latest version of iOS, there's something called

0:29:58connectivity assist.

0:29:59We're gonna come back to that in a second.

0:30:00If you're running a pie holer similar, then this seems to be bypassing it

0:30:04by routing the rejected requests over mobile data instead.

0:30:07Even the text below the settings says you should probably turn it off if

0:30:11you're running an ad blocker.

0:30:12So connectivity assist, I was all in for before I knew this.

0:30:17And what connectivity Assist says is, well, if you're trying if the phone is

0:30:20trying to cling to Wi Fi, but just it ain't working, go ahead and

0:30:24just go to mobile data.

0:30:25And they tried this like 10 years ago or something like that, under a

0:30:28different name.

0:30:28I forget what it was called.

0:30:29And it never really worked right.

0:30:30And this was one of the kind of headline features of iOS twenty-seven was

0:30:34your phone is going to do better about releasing Wi-Fi.

0:30:36And I guess this is w the primary way in which it does that.

0:30:40Well, as it turns out, what I think is happening is when it's getting

0:30:44no good response from DNS for a lot of these queries, because the way

0:30:48Pi Hole works is it'll give you like nothing better.

0:30:51I think it responds with like a, I don't know what that is, when

0:30:54when your device does a DNS request for something that it knows is an

0:30:57advertiser.

0:30:58Well, apparently uh the iPhone or whatever iOS device is saying, Hey, all right,

0:31:02I'll go to mobile data instead, which is not at all what you want.

0:31:06And I'll give you one guess what happened when I turned it off.

0:31:09Then all of a sudden it all started working again, just like it had

0:31:11been before iOS 27.

0:31:13Now, for another show, Aaron Vay, who writes, uh is one of the authors

0:31:18of Indigo, which is my preferred um blue sky and mastodon client.

0:31:22Aaron writes: this is not a new feature, it's the Wi-Fi assist from previous

0:31:25versions renamed and turned on by default.

0:31:27I run PyHole in my home network and started seeing ads on my devices.

0:31:30This is why.

0:31:31Think about this.

0:31:31Apple enabled a feature that sees a block while downloading ad stuff, then reaches

0:31:36out through the cellular network to get it.

0:31:38I understand to a degree how Apple landed here.

0:31:41Don't love it though, and let me tell you, I got I was in

0:31:44a much better spot once I turned this off.

0:31:46And now Erin will be too after I can tell her about it.

0:31:50Yeah I think I would still leave this feature on.

0:31:52I mean uh obviously the alternative is like pie holes like solve the problem

0:31:55once for everybody in your house because all the DNS will go through the

0:31:58pie hole and problem solved.

0:31:59But the other alternative is run ad blockers on your individual devices, which is

0:32:03more annoying, but also doesn't run a foul of this situation and I I

0:32:08think I want this because very often like if I'm leaving the house to

0:32:11walk the dog the my I have seen my various past iPhones uh struggle

0:32:16to decide should I cling to the Wi-Fi that I can still get through

0:32:19the wall of the house as I walk down the block or should I

0:32:22switch to cellular?

0:32:23So if I'm doing like a FaceTime call or I'm on like a a

0:32:25regular uh you know, doing anything where I'm like talking to somebody or videoing

0:32:29with somebody while I walk the dog, you can see the part where it's

0:32:31like, I don't know, should I be trying to get that one little bar

0:32:34of Wi-Fi from the house or should I give up and use cellular and

0:32:37like just give up and use cellular.

0:32:38We're going for a walk, but it it struggles.

0:32:40So I I like that feature.

0:32:43I like this previously named Wi Fi assist now called connectivity assist.

0:32:46And if it was interfering with my ad blocking which is not because I

0:32:49don't have a pie hole, I would just switch to using something on device.

0:32:52Like that's how much I want that feature, more than the uh the the

0:32:55hassle of having to run an ad blocker as an individual device, which for

0:32:58me is not much of a block of a big thing.

0:33:00Cause if you use like one blocker, it's on Mac, it's on iPad, it's

0:33:03iOS.

0:33:03If you're an all Apple house, you can get one app and it'll take

0:33:06you pretty far.

0:33:07Yeah, I mean I I totally get why that juice may be worth a

0:33:10squeeze for you, but for me, absolutely turned it off and immediately was so

0:33:14much happier when I did it.

0:33:16All right.

0:33:17Um, this is a little bit of a journey, just like that last topic

0:33:20ended up being, actually.

0:33:21But um there was some news about GM and CarPlay.

0:33:26Um I didn't put this in the show notes, I'm pr I presume John

0:33:29did, but uh, I'm gonna tell you something that I wrote on my blog

0:33:31a couple of days ago.

0:33:32Uh I wrote just shy of a year ago, GM CEO Mary Barra extended

0:33:36this lunacy edict to that they will never do any more car play in

0:33:40their cars, to include all future internal combustion vehicles as well.

0:33:43Unsurprisingly, this did not end well.

0:33:45The backlash was immediate and the data was brutal.

0:33:48Uh surveys at the time found 79% of new car buyers would only consider

0:33:52a vehicle that offered car play and that it was available on 98% of

0:33:54new cars sold.

0:33:55Dealers warned buyers would simply walk to a rival showroom Forgive me, that was

0:33:59a quote from somewhere I don't have my own blog post in front of

0:34:01me at the moment.

0:34:01I'm going off our show notes.

0:34:03Anyway, coming back to my blog post.

0:34:04Well, look who didn't about face after realizing they scored a tremendous own goal.

0:34:08And again, from whatever I source I quoted, this week GM unveiled a new

0:34:13infotainment interface debuting on the 2027 Chevrolet Silverado and GMC CR pickups that folds

0:34:19smartphone integr uh smartphone projection back into the dashboard and runs alongside GM's native

0:34:24system.

0:34:25Well, look at us.

0:34:27Look at us.

0:34:28We knew it.

0:34:29We called it.

0:34:29We told you you were idiots.

0:34:31The internet was aflame in the happy way for once.

0:34:35Uh, about how exciting this was.

0:34:37The GM was finally getting a friggin' grip.

0:34:40That was whatever day the 21st was.

0:34:42That was Monday.

0:34:44Then later that same day, after I posted my blog post later on Monday,

0:34:49reading from Joe Ross Ignol at Mac Rumors, GM wants you to know it

0:34:52still plans to ditch Apple CarPlay in future EVs

0:34:56Joe says.

0:34:57Recent reports claiming that General Motors is reversing course on its controversial plans to

0:35:01ditch CarPlay in its future EVs appear to be incorrect.

0:35:04As noted by Joanna Stern in her New Things YouTube channel, a GM spokesperson

0:35:08has confirmed that its new software interface that shows CarPlayer Android Auto alongside its

0:35:13own native system in 2027 models of pickups is specific to the gas-powered versions

0:35:17of those pickup trucks.

0:35:18GM Previously stated that CarPlane Android Auto would continue to be offered in its

0:35:22new gas-powered vehicles for the foreseeable future.

0:35:24So the 2027 models of those trucks still supporting these platforms is not a

0:35:28change.

0:35:29Of course, boo this man.

0:35:31Not Joe.

0:35:32I guess I should say boo Mary.

0:35:34Uh boo that person.

0:35:36Uh so I did post a Miya culpa on my website earlier today.

0:35:39Uh but I I really, really hate this.

0:35:42And uh just to be clear, on my Mia Culpa, I have been keeping

0:35:45track of the sorts of devices that you can get car play on.

0:35:48So you can get it on most new cars, as we talked about, at

0:35:51all kinds of different price points.

0:35:54I'd forgotten to note, and this has been true for years now, but I'd

0:35:57forgotten to note that several motorcycles have them.

0:35:59Uh I picked out like the Honda Goldwing and the Harley Road Glide as

0:36:02two examples.

0:36:03Those are larger, more luxury bikes, but it's not just them.

0:36:06You can get the get it on boats.

0:36:09The I think it's Mastercraft.

0:36:10Yes, Mastercraft has announced that they will do it on some of their boats.

0:36:14And and you can have CarPlay in your fing shower.

0:36:18That is not a joke.

0:36:20Upbeat Sound Company at UpbeatSound.com, not a sponsor, makes like one of those dinguses

0:36:26that you would put in, I don't know maybe a Rivian uh that you

0:36:29stick to your shower wall and it has speakers on it and you get

0:36:33a CarPlay interface, like a waterproof car water resistant carPlay interface in your shower.

0:36:39This is 100% a true story.

0:36:41It's kind of awesome.

0:36:42Oh it's incredible.

0:36:43I kinda want one.

0:36:44I I kinda want one.

0:36:45But uh I want to be able to text for my shower though.

0:36:47I don't want to be like, keep your eyes on the road and like

0:36:49I'm not going anywhere.

0:36:50Like I should be able to text.

0:36:51Does it work with wet hands?

0:36:52Like because normally I would assume normally touch screens don't.

0:36:56Like you know what I know but the point is if it has like

0:36:58a resistive touch screen, it could be pressure sensitive.

0:37:00Yeah.

0:37:01Whatever it takes, maybe.

0:37:03And by the way, there's a there's this entire family out there of like

0:37:06hundredish dollar little tablets that run car play that are made to be stuck

0:37:10in a car or like a Rivian.

0:37:11And and like I've I've I that's what I use now for testing overcast

0:37:14car play stuff because it's easy and it's on my desk.

0:37:17And they're fine and they're cheap and they work just fine.

0:37:20Yeah, it's bananas.

0:37:21So just to recap, almost every new car, a bunch of new motorcycles boats

0:37:27and showers, but not Rivian and not GM EVs.

0:37:31Great work, guys.

0:37:32Just just stellar work.

0:37:33Really proud of you.

0:37:34Yeah.

0:37:34Well no everyone was getting all excited about this.

0:37:36And like, don't you guys remember this is not a change, but they like

0:37:38you said the follow up story came like moments later.

0:37:41So it's like okay, everyone will be corrected.

0:37:42So I couldn't save you, Casey, but I could have told you if you

0:37:44were told me you're writing that, I would have said, This is not a

0:37:46change, this is just them continuing what they said they were gonna do.

0:37:49You know, and I thought this, but everyone was so excited.

0:37:51I read a few things and I was like, Oh, I guess I'm wrong

0:37:53forgotten.

0:37:53Well, so here's here's the thing about it.

0:37:55All right.

0:37:55So those those are the facts as you've read them.

0:37:58But reading between the lines, as you noted, I think this experiment is currently

0:38:03not going well for GM.

0:38:05So start your timers, right?

0:38:07At a certain point, there'll be a change in leadership or they'll have a

0:38:11change of heart.

0:38:12Like I think this does I think the longer this goes on, the more

0:38:15likely they are to eventually reverse, especially if Tesla ever actually goes through with

0:38:19their supposed plans to add car play.

0:38:21Like I don't just because they're that this is still the status quo does

0:38:26not mean that every day that passes makes everyone realize inside and outside of

0:38:30GM what a stupid move this was.

0:38:32So I think it You know, despite the fact that this is not an

0:38:36actual change, it's not going well for them.

0:38:39No.

0:38:39And the thing that blows my mind is that if you're Rivian, if your

0:38:45primary competitor, at least in people's minds, maybe not like literal competitor, but I

0:38:50feel like almost everyone I know that's even vaguely interested in Rivian in is

0:38:54at least considering cross-shopping Tesla.

0:38:57If you're Rivian, why wouldn't you use this as a differentiator?

0:39:02And one of my earlier blog posts on this subject, because I've been banging

0:39:05this drum for tr uh banging this drum for a while now, is that

0:39:09um the Wasim Ben Said, I think is his name, who is like the

0:39:13CTO uh at Rivian, was on, I want to say it was decoder, it

0:39:16was one of the great Verge podcasts and said, Well it's it takes over

0:39:20your screen.

0:39:20That's why we can't do it.

0:39:22It doesn't though.

0:39:23Like CarPlay CarPlay Ultra does, but regular CarPlay doesn't.

0:39:27It in in my BMW now.

0:39:30It uses most of the screen, but not all of it.

0:39:32In in Erin's Volvo, in her old Volvo, it used like a half the

0:39:36screen.

0:39:36Now it uses the majority of the screen, but not all of it.

0:39:39And so if you're Rivian, why would you not use this as a differentiator?

0:39:43It's friggin' additive.

0:39:45If your infotainment is so frickin' great, then no one will use it.

0:39:49And it's fine.

0:39:50What does it hurt you?

0:39:52Why would you not use that as a differentiator?

0:39:54It blows my mind.

0:39:56And so I there's been rumblings as John said, there's been at least a

0:39:59moderate amount of smoke, which makes you think there's that Tesla is potentially going

0:40:03to juice their, as far as I understand, pretty bad sales these days, because

0:40:07hey, guess what?

0:40:08The CEO is a fing maniac.

0:40:10Um But anyway, they're trying to juice their sales potentially by adding CarPlay.

0:40:15And then I think John is exactly right.

0:40:17The second that happens, Rivian is going to suddenly discover that all of their

0:40:21issues with CarPlay just magically disappear.

0:40:24And I think GM will also do the same thing.

0:40:27But why would you not differentiate?

0:40:29Why would you not do it now?

0:40:30It drives me batty.

0:40:32This is on the long list of things that I get very worked up

0:40:34about that I really shouldn't, but I just don't understand what they're doing it's

0:40:40and again it's add to additive if your infotainment is so freaking spectacular then

0:40:46maybe your owners won't use it maybe what'll happen is all these people like

0:40:50i don't know me who refuse to buy a car without car play will

0:40:54buy the Rivian and then see, you know what?

0:40:56Maybe I don't need this after all.

0:40:58But at least now I've gotten in the door.

0:41:00Like I just don't get what they're doing here for such an admirable company.

0:41:05It's it's it's in so many ways, Rivian to me anyway, seems like Tesla,

0:41:10but not evil.

0:41:11So why wouldn't you do this?

0:41:13I just don't understand it drives me batty.

0:41:16Yeah, and and I think once Tesla does it, like you know, there's I

0:41:19think there's enough smoke behind that, like, that it's probably gonna happen.

0:41:23And you know, you start you see like Apple made a few changes in

0:41:26the latest couple iOS versions that seem like they're aimed at getting Tesla on

0:41:30board with CarPlay.

0:41:31Like it it it looks like it's probably going to happen.

0:41:34The only question is when.

0:41:36Uh but once Tesla caves, I first of all, I think it will be

0:41:41a big deal.

0:41:42I think it will be a big deal to their sales.

0:41:44I think Apple will want to brag about it.

0:41:45Um and and I think that is a huge thing that buyers look for

0:41:49in new cars.

0:41:50And so once Tesla caves, it's only a matter of time before Rivian does.

0:41:54But I think it will take that.

0:41:56Like I don't think Rivian is going to change their mind until and unless

0:41:59Tesla caves.

0:42:00Oh, I agree.

0:42:00Which is so dumb.

0:42:01It's so dumb.

0:42:02And I'll say and I honestly, I love the idea of going back to

0:42:06Rivian in the future.

0:42:07Like, you know, 'cause the only reason I got rid of my Rivian was

0:42:09because it was a service nightmare, 'cause it was such a young company and

0:42:12it had a lot of little bugs that couldn't fix for twelve weeks or

0:42:15whatever it was.

0:42:16But um I would love to go back to Revune in the future.

0:42:19Like I I I still miss things about it.

0:42:23Um and I still really respect what they're doing as a company and their

0:42:27vehicles are very capable.

0:42:28And very appealing to me.

0:42:30Um, but one thing I don't miss is having to put my phone in

0:42:32a stupid dock next to the dashboard and you know, having to operate little

0:42:37tiny phone apps manually with my hands because I because there's no car play

0:42:40and there's and their maps sucked and you know, there's no overcast and there's

0:42:44no other like it everything about the infotainment thing was terrible.

0:42:50Um, and I know I've heard that they have better maps now, which that's

0:42:54great, but what you don't have is any maps.

0:42:58Like you don't you don't give me the ability to use any map app

0:43:00I want.

0:43:00What if I like Waze better than Google Maps or Apple Maps better than

0:43:03Google Maps?

0:43:04Like whatever it is.

0:43:05Like if if what I want is not exactly the one app that you've

0:43:09selected to build a half-assed version of in your infotainment system, then it's a

0:43:14bad experience for me.

0:43:15And what are the odds that you're gonna guess right on everyone's preferences?

0:43:20I said it before, never bet against the smartphone.

0:43:23And the good thing is you don't have to.

0:43:25You can like and every other car company has figured this out.

0:43:28Like just show the phone thing in the window.

0:43:31And that's and it's fine.

0:43:33And no other car company has had any problems just doing that.

0:43:38And the customers love it.

0:43:40So it's only a matter of time before Tesla, you know, needs that needs

0:43:44to to juice their sales that way.

0:43:45'Cause they you know, as you mentioned, they're uh they're always looking for something

0:43:50and 'cause there's they're always getting themselves into trouble.

0:43:53And uh yeah.

0:43:54And and the thing is and I I I so hope that, you know,

0:43:59like I I have one more year on my lease.

0:44:01Next year, next next summer I'm picking a new car.

0:44:05I don't think Rivian's gonna come around by then, but maybe the one after

0:44:09that.

0:44:09I would love to go back to Rivian, like three years after that.

0:44:12Maybe by then they'll have a nice big service network.

0:44:14The R three and the R three X will be out and they'll be

0:44:17super fun and maybe they'll have CarPlay.

0:44:19One can dream.

0:44:20Yep.

0:44:21No, I agree.

0:44:21I could I agree with you completely.

0:44:22And here's the thing.

0:44:23Let's take it as writ that both Tesla and andor And or Rivian infotainment

0:44:30is without equal.

0:44:31I don't care if it's both of them, one of them.

0:44:33It doesn't matter.

0:44:33Let's just let's say Rivian is without equal.

0:44:35Let's say it's better than Tesla.

0:44:36I don't.

0:44:37Let's say it's the best infotainment in any automobile.

0:44:40Let's say that's the case.

0:44:41Do they have overcast support, Marco?

0:44:44No, of course not.

0:44:45Right.

0:44:45And they never will.

0:44:46Because it's never worth it is never gonna be worth either Tesla or me

0:44:51building that.

0:44:52Or Rivian, but yeah, yeah.

0:44:54We're saying the same thing.

0:44:55And there's so many uh like if when I plug in my phone to

0:44:59CarPlay, I don't just see three apps.

0:45:02There's like forty apps on there, right?

0:45:05There's so like Audible has an app, like there's so many, like every map

0:45:09app has one.

0:45:10Like InstaPaper has an app that'll read articles to you.

0:45:13Like there's so like there's stuff you would never even think about.

0:45:16The AI uh providers are now having CarPlay apps.

0:45:19WhatsApp has a car play app.

0:45:20There's so many.

0:45:22There's no way any car maker is ever going to cover them all.

0:45:26And they don't need to.

0:45:28So again, it's that's just a self-created problem.

0:45:31Right.

0:45:31That's the thing, is that even if Rivian's infotainment is miles better than everything

0:45:36else out there.

0:45:37Let's say it's better than CarPlay.

0:45:39But the problem is if I want to go and switch what podcast I'm

0:45:43listening to in Overcast while connected to a Rivian, maybe I'm ignorant and maybe

0:45:48I'm missing the point here, but as far as I know, I would need

0:45:51to pick up my phone and use Overcast.

0:45:54Or if they supported CarPlay, I could pop over to CarPlay for a moment

0:45:59if it's not already up, Do what I need to do in Overcast and

0:46:02then pop back to Rivian's infotainment.

0:46:04Like I just, I don't understand what they're thinking.

0:46:07And as you said, Marco, and it's exactly on the nose, every one of

0:46:11us has a different array of apps that we want to use in the

0:46:16car.

0:46:16I want to use Overcast.

0:46:18I don't use Waze, and I don't typically use Google Maps, so that doesn't.

0:46:22But I want to use Overcast.

0:46:24Marco, well presumably you want to use Overcast, but you also use Waze.

0:46:28And that's fine.

0:46:29That's beauty of CarPlay, is that we don't have to all agree, as you

0:46:33said, on the same six friggin' apps.

0:46:35It's just I don't get it.

0:46:37And it drives me so baddie.

0:46:38It's just such I guess hubris for lack of a better word.

0:46:41I don't know it's just it it's it it it's deciding in Rivian's headquarters

0:46:45that they know better than you.

0:46:47And that's so frustrating.

0:46:49And you know what I've heard a very smart man say from time to

0:46:51time.

0:46:52In fact, as recently as like five minutes ago, don't bet against the smartphone.

0:46:57I love how fired up you get about this.

0:46:59This is you're so anxious.

0:47:01So dumb.

0:47:01It's so dumb.

0:47:02And and the Rivian uh guy, you know, he's he is very he's very

0:47:06calm and soft spoken.

0:47:08He's like, Well, we believe this is a better experience.

0:47:10And and I can add I don't get all fired up like Casey about

0:47:13this.

0:47:13I can very calmly address an idea, I believe it's not.

0:47:16Right.

0:47:17And therefore I believe I'll buy a different car.

0:47:19Exact and that's exactly it.

0:47:20Like I genuinely I think I've said this a couple times on the show.

0:47:23I genuinely, even though I just got a car, I will probably put a

0:47:26deposit down on an R3 because I want the or the R3X specifically, because

0:47:30I just think that would be such an amazing car.

0:47:32It's like little hatchback-y thing that's supposed to be like a little hot rod

0:47:35hatchback like my golf r it looks so cool it looks so freaking cool

0:47:39and having driven a couple of R1 S or I I've driven one or

0:47:43two R1 S's and an R1T and I love the whole vibe of Rivian.

0:47:49Like everything about it I love.

0:47:51Like the the concrete things and the not so concrete things.

0:47:54And I can absolutely see myself driving a Rivian, but I will not freaking

0:47:58do it without car play.

0:48:00So I will probably put a deposit down when they're willing to take them.

0:48:03And if they don't cave on this, which I think Marco's at least a

0:48:06year or two away, then I will ask for my money back or or

0:48:09maybe I will just sacrifice, you know, whatever that money is because I will

0:48:12not buy a car without car play.

0:48:13I just won't do it.

0:48:15John, am I crazy?

0:48:16Yes, but not for this reason.

0:48:18Fair.

0:48:19Very good.

0:48:19My car doesn't have car play either, you know.

0:48:21Yeah, well, it's time for you to get a new car.

0:48:24Um, all right.

0:48:25We are in an in-between-ish area where you could squint and say this is

0:48:29follow-up, maybe this is a topic.

0:48:31I don't we'll see what I end up deciding in the show notes.

0:48:33But we're in that kind of gray zone.

0:48:35And what we're gonna talk about is uh the Apple Watch and it listening

0:48:39to you and we're going to start with some feedback from Steve Riggins, who

0:48:42writes, I'm not sure why Marco is so concerned over the new Siri audio

0:48:45features when voice memos have been sitting there for years.

0:48:48It only automatically records the last 15 seconds as new feature.

0:48:51Only automatically records the last fifty fifteen seconds.

0:48:54Otherwise, it's not as bad as voice memos, which just records audio flat out

0:48:59basically forever.

0:49:00So the main difference between the the proposed or the the announced Siri replay

0:49:06and Siri rewind features is that they're always recording.

0:49:10Voice memos requires the the user to explicitly decide I'm gonna open up the

0:49:17Voice Memos app and have And hit record and I'm recording.

0:49:21That is a different level of thing than something that is always record than

0:49:27a product that just always records all the time without you initiating the recording.

0:49:31Now, there's all sorts of

0:49:34you know, there there's all sorts of opinions and laws about whether it is

0:49:39right to record people around you possibly without their knowledge, or whether somebody can

0:49:43record, can like leave a recording device somewhere and record the people around it

0:49:46with none of their knowledge.

0:49:47There's lots of laws and opinions about that.

0:49:50Um but I think for this particular question, that that distinction almost doesn't matter.

0:49:56It's when when you are deciding I'm I'm taking out my phone and I'm

0:50:01hitting record on this app and I'm making a recording, that is a very

0:50:05different degree of surveillance and recording than a product that is always doing it

0:50:11in the background.

0:50:12So my follow-up to this to Steve's question was so let's think about hey

0:50:16Siri.

0:50:16Sorry, I just did it.

0:50:17Hey Dingus, whatever.

0:50:19Um, which has existed for years and years on phones, right?

0:50:22Um that technically works in a very similar manner, in that you may be

0:50:27wondering especially when they first roll this out, how does it know when I

0:50:30say hey Dingus?

0:50:32Is it always listening?

0:50:33And the answer is yes, it's always listening.

0:50:37And it technically, you know, s setting aside the secure exclave or whatever, it's

0:50:41a similar type of thing where there's some very low power corner of the

0:50:45logic board or potentially chip that has a tiny little buffer that's constantly recording

0:50:51audio through the microphone in a very low power state, and the hey dingus

0:50:55one is saying I'm just gonna be constantly recording a a couple of seconds

0:50:58of audio and I'm just gonna be looking at it saying, Did this eh

0:51:01siri?

0:51:01Did this a hey Siri?

0:51:02Sorry, I can't do this a Siri, did this a that's all that's all

0:51:05it's doing all the time.

0:51:06And they change it to eventually look for just just the word without the

0:51:09hey but that's all it's just it's constantly quote unquote recording as in taking

0:51:14in digital audio taking in audio analog audio, converting it to digital, and it

0:51:18has some buffer of you know the past one or two or three seconds

0:51:22of audio.

0:51:23And it's analyzing that buffer to see is anywhere in this buffer, did anybody

0:51:27say hey dingus at any point?

0:51:29And if it did, it says, Oh, I'm gonna wake up the whole rest

0:51:31of the phone and say, Oh, they I they said the thing.

0:51:34So, and by the way, here's like, you know, the beginning of the audio

0:51:37that they said after that and then piece it all together and blah blah

0:51:39blah.

0:51:40That feature has existed for a really long time.

0:51:42Most people have not uh worried about it because they don't they're just like,

0:51:46oh like a human, you just say hey whatever.

0:51:48Like I mean people do this all the time where

0:51:51Um

0:51:52someone, you know, says something and then says your name at the end of

0:51:55it.

0:51:55That you have this phenomenon where they shout something and they say your name

0:52:00at the end to realize that they were addressing you, and suddenly you hear

0:52:03all the stuff they said before that, whereas if they didn't say your name

0:52:06at the end of it, you would have ignored it as background noise, right?

0:52:08Yep.

0:52:09And so they think, oh, the phone's just like a little person.

0:52:11When I say hey dingus, it wakes up and it's like, well, how?

0:52:14How does it wake up?

0:52:15How does it know you say that said that?

0:52:16How does it know you're drinking you?

0:52:17It doesn't know your intention.

0:52:18It's not reading your mind.

0:52:19It is always recording a tiny bit of audio.

0:52:23But what it does with that audio is it's looking for the the wake

0:52:27word.

0:52:28Okay.

0:52:28Enter the watch which is always recording audio, but it's not just looking for

0:52:34heydengus anymore.

0:52:35First of all, the buffer seems bigger.

0:52:37I don't know how long the how big the hay Siri buffer is or

0:52:40whatever, but this buffer we know is at least 15 seconds.

0:52:44Second, it's not just constantly scanning that buffer looking for a wake word.

0:52:49Instead, it's got that buffer all ready to go.

0:52:52And you know, it's a rolling buffer, so it's throwing away the the the

0:52:55data that's you know it's keeping a 15 second window.

0:52:58It's just letting it kind of sit there.

0:53:00I mean it's probably also scanning it for the wake word, but it's making

0:53:03it sit there, waiting for you to double tap the crown on your watch.

0:53:06And then it goes, Oh, they want to know what was said in the

0:53:09last 15 seconds.

0:53:10Well, luckily I've been recording audio all day and I have the last 15

0:53:14seconds of audio as a matter of fact in this buffer right here.

0:53:16Now that they've tapped that, instead of me just scanning that buffer for the

0:53:19wake word, I'm going to run it through a speech to text thing.

0:53:24I'm going to get some text out of it.

0:53:25I'm gonna summarize it and I'm gonna put it up on the screen in

0:53:27a bubble.

0:53:28That's what this feature does.

0:53:30And well hold on.

0:53:31That's there's a final distinction here.

0:53:33This feature does not summarize it.

0:53:36Oh yeah.

0:53:36The transfer the fifteen second yeah, the fifteen second one just transcribes exactly what

0:53:41was said.

0:53:41Does not do any summarization.

0:53:43I think it does s doesn't it do some sort of like um anonymization

0:53:46or something in it?

0:53:46I f I think it might do some processing on it.

0:53:48I don't think so there's is it I forget is that's replay, not rewind,

0:53:52right?

0:53:53Yeah no, I know you're talking about there's there's the distinction between the one

0:53:55that summarizes versus transcribes.

0:53:56And fifteen seconds is the transcript, but I thought they had also said that

0:53:59in the fifteen seconds transcript they'll try to like blank out people's names or

0:54:01something.

0:54:02But either way, uh what it's doing with the audio is not just scanning

0:54:06it to find something and say, H have I been triggered?

0:54:07Yes, no, and then feeding the audio to the the system to like do

0:54:11a command or whatever, but they're making text out of it.

0:54:14Okay.

0:54:14Whether it is literal transcription or a summary, either way, it I don't think

0:54:17it actually makes that much of a difference, other than like trying to make

0:54:20it digestible, because 15 seconds you can transcribe and that's it's a lot of

0:54:23text, but it's not too much.

0:54:24Whereas if you've been an hour long meeting, the transcript of that is going

0:54:28to be much longer than the summary.

0:54:29Um but yeah, so that that distinction, I think it's mostly because people think

0:54:35of a wake word as being just again, they they think of the phones,

0:54:39you know, they conceptualize the phones the way the way we conceptualize living things

0:54:43as in there, it's just responding to its name.

0:54:45It's not recording me.

0:54:47It's not listening to me.

0:54:48But of course it is listening.

0:54:49Like in the same way that you're not listening until someone yells your name.

0:54:52When you hear your name, your brain wakes up and says, Oh, I was

0:54:55just I was just, you know, blocking out all that background noise of people

0:54:58chattering behind me.

0:54:58But when I hear my name, I'm like, oh, I suddenly pay attention.

0:55:01That's all the phone is doing, right?

0:55:02So that's fine.

0:55:03Versus, oh, you didn't listen to you, but now when you see that that

0:55:06I transcribed the last 15 seconds of speech, you're like, wow, you've really been

0:55:10listening this whole time because here I see the things that were just said

0:55:14in the last fifteen seconds, including what the people at the next table were

0:55:17saying and they didn't even realize they were being recorded.

0:55:19So anyway, I don't wanna belabor this, but that's I wanted to bring up

0:55:22uh Hey Siri at this point because technologic Oh, sorry, both of my phones

0:55:26lit up Technologically speaking.

0:55:29You brought this on yourself.

0:55:30Yeah, I've I've my other phone's going to the Pokemon mines.

0:55:33It's a new as in actually I found a new uh not used orange

0:55:37apple silicone case.

0:55:39It's just what my wife wanted to put my phone in to embarrass it

0:55:42while it goes to the Pokemon line.

0:55:44So they both lit up.

0:55:46Um yeah, we should continue with the feedback because there is more.

0:55:49All right.

0:55:49So Carlo writes, My basic position is simple.

0:55:52If I legitimately hear something, I don't think another person has a privacy right

0:55:55over how well I'm allowed to remember it.

0:55:57If you tell me something, I might remember it perfectly.

0:55:59I might write it down afterward.

0:56:00I might dictate myself a note.

0:56:02None of those things are normally considered privacy violations.

0:56:05So if my watch privately creates a summary to help me remember the same

0:56:08conversation, what exactly changed?

0:56:10The information reached the same person, it wasn't anyone else.

0:56:14Technology just made that person's memory more reliable.

0:56:16It this feels much closer to augmented memory than surveillance.

0:56:19I get this a lot, but I don't know, it just feels really different.

0:56:24There's a difference between surveillance and eavesdropping.

0:56:27Eavesdropping, uh some uh etymologists will let us know where that comes from or

0:56:32whatever, but eavesdropping is like you're around the corner from someone having a conversation

0:56:36and you're listening that's generally frowned upon too.

0:56:38Like it's kind of, you know, like you're sneaky, you're listening in a conversation

0:56:41that you shouldn't be listening, and sometimes you're not around the corner.

0:56:43Maybe you're just like at a restaurant in a booth and you can hear

0:56:46the people in the booth next to you and you're listening to their conversation.

0:56:48That's also kind of frowned upon, socially speaking.

0:56:51But you're that you can do it.

0:56:53But surveillance is different from that in that you don't have to be there

0:56:58or do anything or participate.

0:57:00You can continue exactly ignoring them having your conversation, confident in the fact that

0:57:05your watch is recording everything and will summarize everything the next booth said without

0:57:10you having to concentrate on it or appear to be eavesdropping or anything like

0:57:14that.

0:57:14And that is a violation of the social contract much more so than eavesdrop.

0:57:17Eavesdropping is rude is like you shouldn't be listening to our conversation, but at

0:57:20least people can see that you're because you're not if you if you're having

0:57:23your own conversation or whatever, they're like, Oh, they're if someone would see you

0:57:26and say they're clearly being polite and not listening to the conversation on the

0:57:29next table, but no, you're not being polite.

0:57:31You put a tape recorder down the table and you're recording it, and later

0:57:33you're gonna know it's not the same thing as summarized or whatever, but that's

0:57:37the point.

0:57:37Surveillance is a machine doing a thing that would be too socially unacceptable for

0:57:42you to do, but you just set the machine to do it.

0:57:44And so you can appear not to be violating that social norm when you

0:57:47totally are, which is why it is usually considered more invasive to, for example,

0:57:52plant cameras in your neighbor's house than it is for you to look out

0:57:56your window in through their window.

0:57:58Both of them are bad.

0:57:58You shouldn't be peeping in their windows.

0:58:00But if you went into their house and planted cameras and tape recorders, that

0:58:03would be more of a violation of you looking out your window at their

0:58:06house.

0:58:06Aaron Powell There's also there there's a lot of differences in in degree and

0:58:11situation here.

0:58:12Like if first of all, if you know if for a product like this,

0:58:16it is creating an artifact that you can refer to and that might have

0:58:20some kind of authority.

0:58:21So for instance, if if there's some dispute over what was said, you know,

0:58:28you can you can point to this.

0:58:29You can go put open up your app, you know, your Siri app or

0:58:31wherever these these recordings land, and you can say, no, no, no, look, this

0:58:34is what you said.

0:58:36And that that's a different type that's a different a different nature uh than

0:58:41you know, you just just trying to argue that you they remember something.

0:58:44Although I feel like you could be that pretty easily in court given how

0:58:46poorly these things summarize.

0:58:48Well, sure.

0:58:49But that's a good thing.

0:58:49But also but but again, you are you're creating an artifact that maybe somebody

0:58:53else could have access to.

0:58:54Like you know, when we first discussed this, I I brought up the example

0:58:56of like, you know, a lot of spouses or partners have access to each

0:59:01other's Apple IDs or know each other's passcodes to their devices.

0:59:05And so you could plausibly like if you if you're if you had like

0:59:09a partner or an ex maybe who knew your passcode to your phone and

0:59:14could open it up and read these notes, it is plausible that they could

0:59:18maybe see an action item or a summary of a conversation that could give

0:59:22away something that you would rather they not know.

0:59:24So for instance, what if you are planning to move out?

0:59:28And they see in your Siri app when they're spying on you that you

0:59:32met with a like an apartment listing agent.

0:59:35That they and they it's even if it says something like met with Michelle,

0:59:37what if they know that your friend Michelle is an apartment listing agent?

0:59:40And like there's there's uh so many ways this c this can be a

0:59:45privacy violation unintentionally, um, or or in this case, you know, intentionally, but like

0:59:50when you when you're creating these records of everything around you, it does change

0:59:54things dramatically because you know also in that situation, you as the wearer of

1:00:00this recording device, you m again, you like what we were saying earlier, you

1:00:04might forget that this is a feature.

1:00:05You might not even know this is or you might have turned it on

1:00:07once month ago, forgotten about it, and tr it's been it'd been recording your

1:00:10conversations for months, and or rather it's been taking notes on your conversations for

1:00:14months.

1:00:14Um so even though it is not creating an audio recording that persists, it

1:00:21is still creating artifacts automatically all the time that could have major privacy implications

1:00:27and could backfire on you and the people around you in ways that you

1:00:31would rather they not.

1:00:32Again, think about law enforcement.

1:00:34Like so you know, suppose that this becomes one of those things that the

1:00:37T S TSA agents make you check when you enter the country, or the

1:00:40you know the customs agents.

1:00:42Like w they want to see what you've been talking about with your friends.

1:00:44Have you been saying anything maybe against the president?

1:00:47This sounds ridiculous to only some people out there now, because most of us

1:00:51you could you hear an example like that and you're like, oh yeah, that

1:00:54could happen.

1:00:54That probably will happen.

1:00:56These kinds of scenarios are not ridiculous.

1:00:58So meanwhile,

1:01:00why are they creating this?

1:01:03It it does seem like if what you want is something to take notes

1:01:07on your meetings, there's lots of other solutions for that that will do a

1:01:12better job and will be like, you know, they'll be more thorough.

1:01:16They'll actually have things like searchable transcripts and or recordings in in a i

1:01:20in those kind of contexts that makes a lot more sense.

1:01:22It is more defensible and they'll probably do a better job.

1:01:25So Apple's gonna be here with this kind of very limited, possibly very mediocre

1:01:30version and bring on all this all this you know baggage for what?

1:01:34And then finally I would also say that if you consider it a memory

1:01:39augmentation, that is an interesting approach.

1:01:42That is an interesting theory that you're saying, I'm not recording conversations, I'm just

1:01:47automatically taking durable, you know, automated notes on everything around me all the time.

1:01:53Okay.

1:01:54Isn't that a similar argument to LLMs are just reading things like humans read

1:02:01them and just learning them and then just it can repeat them back perfectly?

1:02:05But that's not a copyright violation.

1:02:06It read it just like I just like you or I would read it.

1:02:09And if I can read a news article and recite it perfectly back to

1:02:12you, I'm that's not a copyright violation.

1:02:15Well, it might be a public performance, but you know, like th there's you

1:02:19can see like when you change the degree or the the nature of something

1:02:24by this much, it does change a lot of the legal questions around it.

1:02:29And there's a lot of precedent for that throughout all of technology and history.

1:02:33Like When you change something this dramatically, the law and the perception and the

1:02:37judgments around it often change.

1:02:40In this case, something that takes constant, persistent, automatic notes of everything is a

1:02:46difference in degree versus me having the right to remember what you said to

1:02:50me.

1:02:51A couple of things on what you said.

1:02:52First, I I hate that LLM analogy because LMs aren't people, but I'm setting

1:02:55that aside.

1:02:56Um the I think what uh another thing I want to push back against,

1:03:00although you keep bringing it up as an example to help people understand it,

1:03:02which makes sense from an emotional perspective, but technically speaking, and I feel like

1:03:06from like the principle of all this, it doesn't matter if anything that has

1:03:11been recorded is sensitive in any way.

1:03:14Like this is not bad because you might say a thing that you don't

1:03:17want people to know, it's bad even if you never say anything.

1:03:19It's the whole like, well if you have nothing to hide, you shouldn't have

1:03:22to worry about it.

1:03:22No, surveillance is surveillance.

1:03:24Even if you never say anything, if nothing is ever recorded that is harmful

1:03:29in any way, Okay, it's still just as bad.

1:03:32It doesn't badness of it based on whether you had said something that is

1:03:35potentially sensitive.

1:03:37Because that that way leads you to okay, well, it's fine as long as

1:03:39you have nothing to hide we'll just record everything.

1:03:41And if you object to the recording, then obviously you have something to hide

1:03:44and it and you're And your argument is like, well, everybody has something to

1:03:46hide, but really it doesn't matter if I have anything to hide.

1:03:49The principle is I should not constantly be recorded.

1:03:52And I think this is getting to the heart of the difference, which is

1:03:54what is surveillance versus taking notes or you know, memorizing or eavesdropping or whatever.

1:04:01Surveillance is constant, ambient, and back referenceable as in it's just running all the

1:04:07time.

1:04:07You just have the camera pointed at your garage and it's just there all

1:04:09the time.

1:04:10It's just recording 24 hours a day, seven days a week.

1:04:13Maybe once in a blue moon, someone will come and try into your garage,

1:04:16but it's recording all the time.

1:04:18That is surveillance.

1:04:19You don't do anything to make it.

1:04:20It's not an intentional move where every morning you wake up and say, Well,

1:04:23time to record the garage in case someone skills.

1:04:25It's just running all the time.

1:04:26That's what surveillance is.

1:04:28It's the difference between sitting down at a meeting at work and starting your

1:04:32note-taking thing.

1:04:33And then you have the meeting and then it summarizes your notes as one

1:04:35of our sponsors does, uh, you know, I think for this episode, and then

1:04:39you're done.

1:04:40That is an intentional act in a particular context where I think everyone is

1:04:43socially acceptable to take notes during meetings, whether you're taking them with a pad

1:04:46and a pencil on your computer or with a note taking app.

1:04:49It is an intentional act that everyone is aware of that's going on in

1:04:52a particular context versus my watch is recording everything all the time.

1:04:57Oh, I can geofence it.

1:04:58But like just because it is ambient, because it is surveillance, once it is

1:05:03off and running, is just filling up your Siri app with like summaries of

1:05:06things that have happened all around you all day because surveillance is not an

1:05:10intentional time-limited act where you say record now stop recording.

1:05:13It is just I've set a camera up pointing at my garage and that's

1:05:16going to be there forever.

1:05:17And I might only look at it when someone breaks into my garage, but

1:05:20it's recording all the time.

1:05:22And surveillance, you know, video surveillance or audio surveillance, there are laws around that

1:05:26because of the nature of surveillance.

1:05:29It is not as simple as, you know, an intentional recording act, although we

1:05:32have laws about that as well.

1:05:33It is like it is it is d different in kind.

1:05:37And again, it doesn't matter if anything ever happens that is important in that

1:05:41video.

1:05:41The act of surveillance is still the act of surveillance, even if nothing ever

1:05:44happens the thing you pointed the camera at.

1:05:46At certain scenarios you can't point your camera.

1:05:48You can't again you can't plant cameras in your neighbor's and say, Well, it's

1:05:51not a problem unless something sensitive happens in their house.

1:05:53Like, no, it's problem that the camera is there at all recording all the

1:05:56time.

1:05:57Uh again, without their without their knowledge or whatever.

1:05:59So Carlos's point is like, well they don't know that I'm and I'm memorizing

1:06:02everything they say and now I'm recording everything they say.

1:06:04And it's like yeah, you've just crept right up to probably existing laws on

1:06:07on eavesdropping and surveillance.

1:06:09And this is turning a thing that was previously a thing on your wrist

1:06:11that would tell you time and do stuff into, hey, you may not know

1:06:14it but we're recording and summarizing every conversation that happens around you.

1:06:18Nick here writes, Apple swears up and down.

1:06:21It's doing all it can to make this private and secure.

1:06:24And I have no reason to believe otherwise.

1:06:26The audio is not actually saved and is instead merely transcribed.

1:06:30That text is automatically deleted unless the user takes an action to save it

1:06:33too.

1:06:34But good luck explaining that to anyone around you after you read back an

1:06:38exact transcript of what they just said.

1:06:40I think normal people will continue to react negatively when you tell them that

1:06:43you've been passively recording them because outside Silicon Valley, that is considered gross and

1:06:47invasive.

1:06:48Let me just uh plus one the very last thing there that Nick said.

1:06:52I have not spent enormous inordinate amounts of time in Silicon Valley, but I've

1:06:57spent more time than most East Coasters, I like to think.

1:07:01And I don't think

1:07:05reality as the rest of the country, I'm saying the East Coast.

1:07:08I don't think the reality is the rest of the country and perhaps the

1:07:11world sees it really exists in Silicon Valley.

1:07:16It's it's very different there.

1:07:19In some ways that's good.

1:07:21In a lot of ways I don't think it's Great.

1:07:24And I think Nick hit the nail on the head that this is considered

1:07:27absolutely gross and invasive everywhere except maybe in the valley.

1:07:31And it is again it is confusing to emphasize again.

1:07:33There's the 15-second transcript and then there's the thing with it summarizes conversations that

1:07:37have happened.

1:07:38And the 15 second transcript is a small time window, throws it away if

1:07:42you don't keep it, blah, blah, you have to double tap the crown, blah

1:07:44blah blah business.

1:07:45But the recap thing is like is just constantly listening to everything and it's

1:07:49not transcribing everything, but it is summarizing the conversations.

1:07:51It is just a condensed, compressed version of constant surveillance.

1:07:54And that's the most dangerous one because you're just living your life, going through

1:07:58your day, and somewhere on your phone it is filling it up with paragraph

1:08:02long summaries of conversations that you had.

1:08:04And that is just a different form of surveillance.

1:08:06It's old school kind.

1:08:07Like if you've been watching um Star City on Apple TV, there's it's like

1:08:11a seventies era Soviet, you know, type of thing.

1:08:14And they have they have they have actual audio listening devices spying on people,

1:08:18right?

1:08:19But it's just too much content.

1:08:20So they have a room full of people who listen to the audio tapes

1:08:23and then summarize them.

1:08:24They're basically doing what the recap feature does and they because it's too long

1:08:27to listen.

1:08:27You know they didn't they didn't they're not transcribing them word for word, right?

1:08:30They're just being like, okay, they listen 15 minutes and they say, This person

1:08:34talked with that person and they argued about shopping, right?

1:08:37It's just a summary, but it's still you watch the show and you're supposed

1:08:41to believe this is oppressive surveillance.

1:08:42He's like, Oh no, no, it's not surveillance The tapes, they throw away the

1:08:45audio tapes.

1:08:46They just have these people summarizing it.

1:08:48So you just get a summary.

1:08:49It's like, yeah, that's still surveillance.

1:08:52And also like everyone thinks their phone is listening to them.

1:08:57That's true.

1:08:57Every I mean it is.

1:08:59It's listening for it's listening for hey dingus.

1:09:01Right, but like you y you've had you as the nerd in in your

1:09:04life, you've had everybody c you know tell you, you know, your phone's listening

1:09:07to you 'cause this one time you can run ads, yeah.

1:09:09Yeah 'cause I 'cause I this one time I mentioned this water filter and

1:09:12then the next day I was seeing ads for water filters all over my

1:09:14phone.

1:09:14They was listening to what I didn't I didn't type in anything, it heard

1:09:17me.

1:09:17Everyone has stories like that.

1:09:19And you know, even and it's already been hard enough as the nerd to

1:09:22try to explain like, well, actually that's not you know, they don't need to

1:09:25be listening to you for that.

1:09:26You know this is like now this this now it's just out the window.

1:09:30It's no yeah your phone's listening to you.

1:09:31It is.

1:09:32Well so here's the thing about that.

1:09:33The reason people would freak out about that is because they like if you

1:09:37explain how it's actually working like, you know, based on their IP address and

1:09:41other things and all sorts of stu like they're like, Oh, well that's boring

1:09:43and I'm not interested in.

1:09:44But as soon as you say, But no, but imagine it didn't work that

1:09:47way, which is actually probably the better way, but imagine instead it was literally

1:09:50listening to you.

1:09:51That bothers them so much more because it is more

1:09:56connected to the human experience of eavesdropping, right?

1:09:58That is more a violation of the human social norm of don't, hey, don't

1:10:02other people's conversations that it's the phone being rude.

1:10:05Whereas when it does it the computer way with IP addresses and cookies and

1:10:09stuff like that, they're like, oh, that's

1:10:12whatever.

1:10:12It doesn't like they there's no social norm uh around like professional persistent tracking

1:10:18cookies and stuff.

1:10:19Like the actual tech, the actual ad tech that does this thing that gives

1:10:22you the ads that are based on the stuff you've been doing online.

1:10:25That ad tech doesn't bother people because it doesn't have an analog in human

1:10:29society.

1:10:30But listening on conversations that you shouldn't be listening to does.

1:10:33And that's why they latch on to the idea that it's listening.

1:10:36And now that it literally is listening, of course it's gonna bother them.

1:10:40Just like it's it's a t uh fact of human nature that just like

1:10:45things that are outside our lived experience seem alien and not as interesting to

1:10:49us.

1:10:49But now that the phones are doing things that are analogous to our own

1:10:53sense experience of living in the world, it makes people angry, which is exactly

1:10:57why they were angry when they thought phones were doing this.

1:10:59And then when you explain what they're doing, they're like, oh, that doesn't.

1:11:02But if it's listening, that does bother me.

1:11:03Well now it's listening.

1:11:05And like and I think what this also what we've seen is like people

1:11:08don't

1:11:09like you know, as Nick here was saying, like good luck explaining these minor

1:11:13differences or these minor technical things to anybody.

1:11:16Like do you think anyone is going to sit through an explanation about well

1:11:21it's not actually storing But it's only fifteen seconds or whatever.

1:11:24You read back what they just said, they're like they hate you now.

1:11:26It's only transcribing.

1:11:28It's like it's taking notes for you and it's super secure and it's it

1:11:32streams the audio from this part of the chip to this part of the

1:11:34phone chip and no one cares.

1:11:37Everyone will just say, oh yeah, so it's recording everything we're saying.

1:11:40Okay, great.

1:11:40None of those technical distinctions matter to any regular people.

1:11:44It's just, okay, yeah, now every Apple watches a recording device.

1:11:48Anonymous writes, I'm a lawyer and I live in Washington.

1:11:50State.

1:11:51Although I'm not a privacy expert, I do think it's interesting to consider the

1:11:54implications of this kind of recording under various state laws.

1:11:57In Washington, for example, we have a statute that expressly makes it against the

1:12:01law to record any, quote, private conversation by any device electronic or otherwise designed

1:12:07to record or transmit such conversation, regardless how the device is powered or actuated

1:12:12without first obtaining the consent of all the persons engaged in the conversation.

1:12:17On its face then, I can't see how anyone wearing an Apple Watch constantly

1:12:20recording others without them knowing wouldn't be violating Washington law.

1:12:23Well it depends on the definition of record.

1:12:26It depend like it depends on the definition of conversation.

1:12:30Like that's how that's how laws like this are tested.

1:12:32It's you you evaluate all the words, like, well, is this a recording?

1:12:36What is it what is a recording of a conversation?

1:12:39Does it does a you know a a loosely transcribed like series of notes

1:12:44about facts in it does that count as a recording?

1:12:47If if you talk to me and I take notes on the conversation, is

1:12:52that a recording?

1:12:54Apple, I'm sure their lawyers reviewed all this and I'm sure their lawyers determined

1:12:57no it's not.

1:12:58Um we are not lawyers, so we are not really qualified to make that

1:13:01kind of determination.

1:13:02But even if it is technically skating by the law, it almost doesn't matter

1:13:09because again, it's it's gonna it's a it's a PR problem.

1:13:12It it's a it's a perception problem.

1:13:14That is going to do far more damage to Apple than you know, i

1:13:19if if some state sues them for violating some edge of a law that

1:13:22they can talk their way out of.

1:13:23The fifteen second one would be pretty easy to you know, win on in

1:13:27court because that is straight up, you know, transcription of what was said.

1:13:32Maybe with a little misogynist, but it's not is a transcription, a recording.

1:13:35Is I don't know.

1:13:36It yeah, yeah.

1:13:37I I think they would say it is like they say electronic device.

1:13:40If electronic device that uh that recorded audio and immediately turned it into speech,

1:13:44uh I think that would pretty be pretty easy to win.

1:13:46But anyway, someone will try it, I guess.

1:13:47Uh the summaries are maybe a little bit harder, but uh that's just like

1:13:51there are I'm sure there's existing laws in the book with pot with particular

1:13:54wording, but uh if people rebel against this and if especially with state laws

1:13:58where there's actually a chance of passing laws on like the federal uh level,

1:14:01you could just add laws that say, Yeah, whatever the Apple Watch is doing,

1:14:04that's now against the law.

1:14:06Another anonymous, a different anonymous, writes, On the topic of audio intelligence, it seems

1:14:10Apple is following a very similar strategy at the genius bar.

1:14:13If you have a genius bar appointment, you're asked to agree that they are

1:14:16not responsible for data loss, followed by an additional agreement page that asks about

1:14:19audio collection for note-taking during the appointment.

1:14:22This happens right at the beginning of every appointment.

1:14:24The audio consent agreement covers the fact that audio is transcribed on the iPad

1:14:27they use, and that transcript is sent to the cloud for processing.

1:14:31This is an example of a social norm that I think we've pretty well

1:14:33established.

1:14:34For decades, I guess, you call a customer support number and they say this

1:14:38call is be recording for training quality purposes and blah blah blah.

1:14:41That's an example of a confined scenario like a meeting at work where everyone

1:14:45agrees, all right, fine.

1:14:46Like I understand why it's being recorded.

1:14:48In fact, it might actually benefit me here.

1:14:50It's similar to if you're having a meeting, you might want it to be

1:14:52recorded.

1:14:53So both sides, you know, you can't argue about what took place or like

1:14:56literal audio recording, there are limited contexts where you say, fine, if you don't

1:15:00agree, hang up with the phone.

1:15:01But if you do agree, we're both here.

1:15:02This is being recorded, and both parties have an interest in it being recorded

1:15:07because you don't want like the customer service person lying about what you said

1:15:09and you want to be able to prove what they said.

1:15:11Obviously they have the recording and you don't.

1:15:13And so it's quite fair.

1:15:14But in some states you can record your end too and blah blah blah.

1:15:17Um but yeah like essentially AI note-taking technologies uses the genius bar.

1:15:22That's a great idea because People there's a lot of conversation happening in the

1:15:25genius bar and it's hard to keep track of what everyone is saying and

1:15:27people are trying to take notes in real time, but also pay attention to

1:15:30the customer.

1:15:31If the customer and the genius bar person agree that we're okay with this,

1:15:35I think again it benefits both of them to have additional data about their

1:15:41interaction so that they get the best service possible.

1:15:44Um that's so different than um by the way, on your walk from the

1:15:48parking lot, we were recording you and we heard your conversation and we already

1:15:51know what you are.

1:15:52We already know what you're coming here to talk to us about.

1:15:54And it's like I'm not okay with that.

1:15:56That is surveillance.

1:15:58Finally, uh, you I believe John noted that MKBHD has a segment in his

1:16:03watch review that discusses exactly this.

1:16:05All right.

1:16:05So here the one of the things that when we first discuss this, I'm

1:16:08like, well, uh, this from a technical perspective and a principled ethical perspective is

1:16:13very, very bad.

1:16:14But it's the type of thing where depending on what the defaults are, again,

1:16:20this hasn't shipped yet, so we don't know how this will be configured out

1:16:22of the box if it ever ships.

1:16:23We'll see.

1:16:24Um but like depending on how this is deployed, maybe this stuff is off

1:16:28by default, right?

1:16:29Um and it's the type of thing where if if it doesn't occur to

1:16:33you, I would love to just record a get summaries of every conversation that

1:16:36happens to me all day and you seek out this feature and turn it

1:16:38on, and if it's off by default, it's so obscure that like I don't

1:16:41think it's a need that people will be seeking out.

1:16:44And basically what it would mean is the you know, the tyranny of the

1:16:46defaults, most people will have no interaction with this feature and it won't even

1:16:50rise to the level that people know about it and won't become a PR

1:16:53problem.

1:16:54But then MKBHD made a video about it.

1:16:56It's like, well, that ship has sailed.

1:16:58Uh because Cause now millions and millions and millions of casual tech enthusiasts know

1:17:02about these features.

1:17:04And his take on it was very similar to ours, which is this is

1:17:07a bad idea, Apple.

1:17:08Why are you doing this?

1:17:09And so now any hope that Apple could s weather this storm with smart

1:17:14defaults and obscurity, I feel like is out the window.

1:17:16Not that like MKBHD is talking to the public, but he's talking to the

1:17:20broadest possible swath of people who care about tech stuff, like literally millions of

1:17:24people.

1:17:25So, and I he's not the only one who has talked about this, but

1:17:28yeah, Apple really I mean, it's great that this didn't point out because Apple

1:17:33now has a chance to think better of it and do something different and

1:17:36maybe say, oh, we're gonna delay this feature while we think about it, but

1:17:40We'll see how this goes, but yeah, he MKBHD is on it.

1:17:44I I just I can't imagine this providing enough utility to be worth all

1:17:51of the reputational damage and downsides.

1:17:53Because uh like we were saying earlier the products that do this, like like

1:17:56our sponsor of this episode, like the products that do this like for business

1:17:59meetings are much more thorough and much more specialized and and you know, intentionally

1:18:05don't strip out a whole bunch of information 'cause that's not the point of

1:18:08them.

1:18:08Um Uh and they have a long history.

1:18:10Like when I was in my jobby job, every meeting we had was recorded,

1:18:13whether it was in WebEx or Zoom or Teams or all the different like

1:18:16every meeting was recorded.

1:18:17Full audio both ends of every meeting.

1:18:19And it was beneficial to everybody.

1:18:21We didn't have any AI note taking or whatever, but it was if you

1:18:23couldn't if you missed the meeting, for example, you couldn't, you could go and

1:18:26play back the recording of the meeting.

1:18:28Incredibly beneficial.

1:18:29Like no one was like, Oh, you're recording meetings.

1:18:31Like that's just that's just the way things work in this office.

1:18:34It's fine.

1:18:35Not surveillance.

1:18:36If I had to guess, honestly, I bet this feature never ships.

1:18:40I bet it kind of gets, you know, delayed, re you know, very similar

1:18:43to the CSAM scanning thing from a few years back.

1:18:45Like I bet it kind of gets like, you know, delayed, rethought, and then

1:18:49oh actually never mind.

1:18:51Like you know, in some form.

1:18:53Yeah, and like the thing is this a lot of the same tech has

1:18:56been used in Apple devices and could be used in the future in Apple

1:18:59devices as an assistive technology for people who can't hear what's being said and

1:19:04basically getting closed captions on people.

1:19:05Like it's a m potential thing of glasses.

1:19:07Like if you can't hear what people are saying, if you just looked at

1:19:09them and can see subtitles of how these as they speak, that's an incredibly

1:19:13valuable assistive technology.

1:19:15Most people would not consider that surveillance because it is just someone using an

1:19:19assistive device to live through the world.

1:19:21It's not recording those tr the the transcripts, it's just putting under their face

1:19:25so you can understand what they're saying when they're talking to you without being

1:19:27able to hear them.

1:19:28Um and obviously they have actual hearing aids for people who just need the

1:19:31sound boosted or whatever.

1:19:32Like as an assistive technology, I think it does have value.

1:19:35And that's why I feel like the the one that could reasonably survive with

1:19:39some tweaks is the 15 second rewind thing.

1:19:41Um I I'm not sure of the utility of that, but like that is

1:19:45less ser that is much more like Hey Dingus, right?

1:19:48It's like it's just a rolling buffer.

1:19:50And if you never listen to the rolling buffer, it all just disappears.

1:19:53Just like the rolling buffer that was listening to Hey Dingus, all that audio

1:19:56is gone like tears in rain, right?

1:19:57Lost, sorry.

1:19:58Uh will be lost.

1:20:00Anyway, um and so those 15 second buffers, if you never double tap the

1:20:03crown, it never shows up.

1:20:04But when you do double tap it, arguably you could say I'm using it

1:20:06as an assistive technology, especially if you can't actually save that 15 seconds and

1:20:10it's just on your watch briefly.

1:20:11But the recap one, that's surveillance.

1:20:15We are sponsored this episode by Claude.

1:20:18Now, literally right now, as I'm recording this ad, I have Claude working in

1:20:22the background using Claude code, and it is going through my server code and

1:20:26it's trying to audit and find all the different ways that might need to

1:20:30be changed when I upd upgraded to a new OS on my servers.

1:20:34It's found tons of little stuff so far.

1:20:36And I can just say, All right, fix it.

1:20:38And it fixes it.

1:20:39And this is saving me hours.

1:20:40It's my users downtime.

1:20:42It's saving frustration and bugs.

1:20:45And earlier it even recommended some changes that are gonna save me money on

1:20:48my server costs.

1:20:49It can do so much.

1:20:50Before that, I met with a new accountant.

1:20:52What did I do?

1:20:53I had Claude Code audit my tax returns for the last couple of years

1:20:57and generate questions that I can bring to my accountant and say, Hey, can

1:21:01we take a look at this?

1:21:02And sure enough, it found real issues that the accountant was very happy to

1:21:05see.

1:21:06There's so much you can do with Claude.

1:21:08Just a couple of days ago, I had Claude help me expand the language

1:21:12set that Overcast transcriptions can apply to.

1:21:14So now Overcast is transcribing in more languages than before and it did this

1:21:18in a way that would have taken me at least a week.

1:21:21And Claude helped me build it in less than a day.

1:21:24Claude is the AI for problem solvers.

1:21:26It's collaborator, understands your entire workflow and thinks with you, not for you.

1:21:31Whether you're debugging code at midnight, building financial models, or strategizing your next business

1:21:35move, Claude extends your thinking to tackle the problems that matter.

1:21:39I do so much with Claude now.

1:21:41It just helps me do things better and faster.

1:21:43It helps me ship code with fewer errors.

1:21:46It helps me run my life and help me with challenges at the restaurant

1:21:50or just look up stupid stuff.

1:21:52Like it's just there's so much you can do with Claude from the serious

1:21:55to the fun to the creative and so much more.

1:21:59Check out Claude today.

1:22:01For problems worth solving, get started with Claude at Claude.ai slash ATP.

1:22:06That's Claude.ai slash ATP and check out Claude Pro, which includes access to all

1:22:11the features mentioned in this ad read.

1:22:13Claude.ai slash ATP.

1:22:16Thank you so much to Claude for sponsoring our show.

1:22:22All right, we have been very busy, and I apologize we haven't had more

1:22:25time for Ask ATP, but this is the benefit of having two shows 48

1:22:29hours apart, is that we can do some Ask ATP.

1:22:32So Elliot writes: What is the highest mileage you have ever got to in

1:22:35a single car?

1:22:36What do you think is the highest mileage that you should go?

1:22:39For me, uh, when I had a 1994 Saturn SL2, uh, I believe that

1:22:45got to like 120,000 miles or thereabouts.

1:22:48Before or after the wheels fell off.

1:22:50Uh that one, first of all, excellent memory.

1:22:52Uh second of all, it was one wheel, thank you very much.

1:22:55And third of all, it was after.

1:22:57Really, if any of the wheels fall off, that's bad by the way.

1:23:00Even if it's just one, I don't feel like it's not that much of

1:23:01a defense.

1:23:02That was not great.

1:23:03Uh so to be fair, that was uh dad's commuter car until it was

1:23:07eventually handed down to me.

1:23:09Um that car bombed up and down the Sawmill River Parkway at truly heinous

1:23:15speeds at like four o'clock in the morning when dad would go to work.

1:23:17Um it was astonishing.

1:23:19He was like the Sabine Schmitz of the sawmill.

1:23:22It was really some else.

1:23:23Um and that reference probably made sense to six people, but that's okay.

1:23:26Uh anyways, uh that car got to like 120,000 miles on one clutch, I

1:23:29should add.

1:23:30Um, and then the Nissan 3Z that we bought with something like 70 or

1:23:3680,000 miles on it from a coworker of my dad's.

1:23:40And I think that had like 110-ish when we got rid of it, when

1:23:44I got rid of it because at that point it was mine.

1:23:46Um, but nothing since then has been anywhere close to that mileage.

1:23:50Um I think the original BMW was like 70,000, 80,000 miles.

1:23:55I could look it up but I'm not gonna do that while we're air.

1:23:57Um, the Volkswagen head's 35-ish thousand.

1:24:00Um, I'm starting life with this BMW at 23,000 or something like that.

1:24:05So we'll see.

1:24:06But I have a feeling that Marco will probably be on par with me

1:24:10and John will shame us both.

1:24:12But let's see.

1:24:13Marco, let's start with you, 'cause I think you're gonna be close.

1:24:16What is your world record holder?

1:24:17Well, your maxima probably had a bunch of miles, didn't it?

1:24:20Yeah.

1:24:20So um growing up, you know, my family cars, we would go past a

1:24:23hundred thousand miles.

1:24:25Um not that far past, um, but you know, maybe a hundred and ten,

1:24:29hundred and twenty.

1:24:30Um my personally owned ones, my Nissan Maxima was the highest at ninety four

1:24:36thousand.

1:24:37So you never crossed a hundred thousand.

1:24:38Wow.

1:24:39I honestly I would have loved to, but at that point there were a

1:24:43whole bunch of repairs the car needed that were not related to the engine.

1:24:46Like a whole there was like I that car, I don't know what happened

1:24:50to it before I owned it, but the weirdest stuff would break on that

1:24:53car.

1:24:54Like I had to replace like the windshield washer fluid tank.

1:24:59Why?

1:24:59I don't know.

1:25:00Like there's it's j I I I had to replace like thousands of dollars

1:25:05worth of really minor little crap all around the car.

1:25:08Yep.

1:25:08What year was it?

1:25:09I'm sorry.

1:25:1096.

1:25:10Oh see.

1:25:11So the 300ZX was ninety-one and it was very much the same at the

1:25:15end of life.

1:25:15It just started falling apart.

1:25:17Yeah and like and I wish like 'Cause you know, it it it was

1:25:19a you know, nineties Japanese car.

1:25:21It it should have been able to go significantly longer than ninety four thousand

1:25:25miles.

1:25:25And it could have if I you know, if I actually like kept up

1:25:29with all these repairs.

1:25:30But I honestly at that point it was costing so much in minor repairs,

1:25:33I was like, you know what, I'm just gonna get a new and that's

1:25:35that's when I replaced it with a new accord.

1:25:37Oh, that's right.

1:25:38I forgot about that step in your journey.

1:25:39Yes.

1:25:40Yeah.

1:25:40It w I mean there was a gap between where I where I didn't

1:25:42have a car for a few months, um, but that didn't last very long.

1:25:45Was the Maxima the Maxima was not a stick, is that right?

1:25:47No, no, it was.

1:25:48It was a ninety six Nissan Maxima SE.

1:25:51Four door sports car.

1:25:52Yep.

1:25:53It was all leather inside with the Bose stereo.

1:25:56It had like every other option you could get on a Maxima SE was

1:25:59all there, but with a stick.

1:26:00That car, I loved that car.

1:26:03It was so good.

1:26:04Oh man, those those were so hot.

1:26:06I swear to you, if you think of like my well, I don't think

1:26:09they make the maxima anymore in heaven for several years, but the most recent

1:26:12maxima that I can think of was like a crossover now.

1:26:14Yeah, right.

1:26:15The most recent maxima I can think of was like very bulbous and gross.

1:26:18It had like a vertical sunroof that didn't or something like that.

1:26:21They they really have not been good for a long time, but like the

1:26:24mid to late nineties and the early aughts, they were so hot.

1:26:29And you could get them with decent power with a five speed, maybe even

1:26:33a six speed toward the end of this being an option.

1:26:35God, they were so hot.

1:26:36Oh my god, I wanted one so bad.

1:26:38And honestly, I would greatly prefer the climate control in this car to the

1:26:42car I have now.

1:26:43Look at all those buttons.

1:26:44Physical controls.

1:26:45Yeah.

1:26:46Imagine that.

1:26:46And like high fan speeds, strong AC.

1:26:49That's I I love the IX in lots of ways.

1:26:52The climate control sucks.

1:26:53Like it's not good.

1:26:55I hear that.

1:26:56Uh we'll come back to the highest mileage we think you should go.

1:26:58But first, John, what how high have you been?

1:27:01I mean, it's I think it's different for cars that I've owned versus cars

1:27:04that I've driven.

1:27:05So I put in I was trying to find pictures of this.

1:27:07It always frustrates me when I can't find any pictures of the exact car.

1:27:10But anyway, you can see on our um Slack channel.

1:27:141980 something, I think ours was 1981, uh Volvo Volvo 240 wagon.

1:27:19That That's what I learned to drive stick on.

1:27:21Oh, these were these were hot in the like they're actually hideously boxy and

1:27:26gross, but I still love them way.

1:27:29Yeah, they're very uh very ungainly, very awkward looking, uh very hard clutch depressed

1:27:34to be stiff for that eighty horsepower engine in there.

1:27:37Um no pickup whatsoever.

1:27:40It had uh it uh the stick shift was uh four gears in an

1:27:43H pattern and uh with a button on the top of the shifter to

1:27:46go into the fifth overdrive gear, like an electronically actuated overdrive.

1:27:50There wasn't like a shift position for it.

1:27:53Uh, and reverse was like a ring to pull up to get into reverse.

1:27:56Anyway, really weird.

1:27:57Um, I was driving this car when it cross 100k, because I would drive

1:28:02this around, you know, with as a teenager with my friends and stuff, we

1:28:05were all in the car and we saw that we were gonna get close

1:28:06to a hundred K.

1:28:07So we drove around the neighborhood and I and I watched the physical odometer

1:28:11roll over to a hundred K while going up the steepest hill in the

1:28:15neighborhood at a very high speed.

1:28:17Um so we t we timed it out just so we would be going

1:28:20up uh the big hill the on a grassy pond.

1:28:22Uh if you know where that is, but you probably don't uh very steep

1:28:25hill that I used to go down on my bicycle and go like forty

1:28:27miles an hour down the hill on a bicycle incredibly dangerous.

1:28:30I don't know why I did this.

1:28:30I'm amazing that I'm still alive.

1:28:32The the same hill, by the way, where the bunch of teenagers who were

1:28:35a couple years younger than me died by going too fast and losing control

1:28:38of their car going over the crest of that hill and hitting a tree.

1:28:41Um lovely.

1:28:42So I was in this car when it crossed a hundred K, but that

1:28:45wasn't the end for this car continued to live on and I believe it

1:28:48crossed one hundredty, one fifty before we got rid of it.

1:28:52By that point it was so rusted through that like we had a you

1:28:54know a a uh plus sign shaped tire iron like wrench thing in the

1:28:59back.

1:28:59Yeah, yeah.

1:29:00And that fell out of the back of the car through a hole in

1:29:03the bottom of the car while someone was driving because it had rusted the

1:29:07bottom of the car had rusted out so much that that just went

1:29:10yeah.

1:29:10And it made a lot of noise and yeah.

1:29:12Um so I think that is the highest mileage car I've ever Driven.

1:29:16And I'm sorry you said that was a Volvo 200 series?

1:29:19Is that two forty, I believe it was.

1:29:20Okay, yeah, but two hundred series though.

1:29:22Yeah, yeah.

1:29:22Uh wagon.

1:29:24And it was beige, but it wasn't the color beige.

1:29:26You see a white one in the in the slack, and you see this

1:29:27beige one, but the our beige one was not that dark.

1:29:30Um this is the right headlights for the the in the like the 8586

1:29:33one they did like the headlights where they wrapped all this around but ours

1:29:35was the one with the little squares like this.

1:29:37So I don't know the exact year.

1:29:38But that was not my car, that was my parents' car.

1:29:40For my cars, usually what would happen is once they got around ninety or

1:29:46a hundred, we'd start thinking about getting a different car.

1:29:48So I think

1:29:51uh well, my first car.

1:29:52Yeah.

1:29:53So I should do that.

1:29:53I forgot all about that.

1:29:54My nineteen ninety two Civic.

1:29:56My very first car, which my parents quote unquote sold to me for like

1:29:59a dollar.

1:30:00Um, when they gave it to me, I think it was pushing up around

1:30:0470 or 80.

1:30:06And then I drove that well into the hundreds.

1:30:08I don't remember it was at when it was dying.

1:30:11I think it was maybe tw 120, 130.

1:30:13And I sold it to a private citizen and the clutch was going and

1:30:17they test drove it.

1:30:18And I'm like please don't slip.

1:30:20Please don't like and it was just like the whole test drive.

1:30:22I'm like, just just need them to give me the money and leave with

1:30:24this car because I knew the clutch was going.

1:30:26Like it 120, 130,000 miles in the first clutch.

1:30:30It'll do it needs a new clutch.

1:30:31Okay.

1:30:32And I could feel that it needed a new clutch, but I didn't pay

1:30:34for a new clutch.

1:30:35And somebody did buy it from me and they probably immediately had to buy

1:30:37new clutch.

1:30:37Sorry to that.

1:30:38Person.

1:30:38Uh, although they didn't give me much money for it.

1:30:40So that is probably the highest mileage champ.

1:30:42And then all the other ones I had, all the civics and accords I've

1:30:44had.

1:30:45Usually once they cross around 100, we're usually thinking of uh swapping them out.

1:30:49Like the 2017 accord we have uh is around 8687 now.

1:30:54And I bet we're gonna keep that a while longer.

1:30:55Maybe we'll sell it to quote unquote sell it to a kid at some

1:30:58point.

1:30:58Um so yeah, I don't have exact numbers, but yeah I d I've never

1:31:01been past one fifty, I think.

1:31:03I think the Volvo around around one fifty is the highest I've gone, and

1:31:06then that wasn't my car, and my 9092 Civic was around 120, 130 before

1:31:10we sold it.

1:31:11So, how high do you think one should go?

1:31:13It sounds like John, you're in the 100,000 range.

1:31:15No, that's not.

1:31:16I would my answer to that is different.

1:31:17How high should you go?

1:31:19Okay.

1:31:19Keep Keep driving it until you don't own the car anymore.

1:31:22Like that's my always my policy, right?

1:31:24Um smileage shouldn't matter because if you still keep wanting to have the car,

1:31:28just keep paying for parts for it.

1:31:29And if paying for parts makes you not want the car, well then you

1:31:31don't want the car anymore.

1:31:32Like that's what it comes down to.

1:31:33So for example, my twenty fourteen accord, which granted is very low mileage, my

1:31:37current strategy is if anything breaks in that car, I'm gonna pay to fix

1:31:40it.

1:31:40And they're gonna say, Well, why would you pay for that?

1:31:42It's you paying for that is more than the car is worth and I'm

1:31:44gonna pay it because I want to keep driving that car.

1:31:47Like that happens to a lot of people.

1:31:49They'll the car is worth fifteen hundred bucks and it's gonna cost you five

1:31:52grand to fix this engine.

1:31:53You sure you wanna fix this engine?

1:31:54Some people say, Hell no, I don't want this car anymore.

1:31:57But for this specific car, I would say, yes, fix it because I still

1:32:01want to drive this car.

1:32:02That's the decision.

1:32:03Like you see all these like Lexus things that go for like a million

1:32:06miles or Volos that have a million, 1.2 million miles on the same engine

1:32:10or whatever.

1:32:11If people keep wanting to drive the car, they just keep putting money into

1:32:14it.

1:32:14And you just you know, it's the car of Theseus.

1:32:17You're replacing the water pump, you're replacing the the head gaskets, you're then you're

1:32:20replacing the head, you're replacing all the pulleys, you're you know, like the the

1:32:23distributor, you all new wires, like you just uh so many parts that are

1:32:26being replaced over time, and of course all the wear items are replaced many

1:32:29times over and you get new shocks and you get new struts and you

1:32:32know but if you want to keep driving the car I'd say there is

1:32:35there is no limit.

1:32:36If the car continues to run and you can get parts for it and

1:32:39you want to keep driving that car, keep driving it.

1:32:42You could say the limit does not exist, John.

1:32:44That's reference.

1:32:45Uh Marco, any thoughts on highest you should go?

1:32:48I think you it it's like replacing your iPhone.

1:32:52If you want to rationalize a new purchase, you can at any time, like

1:32:55in some way like, well, it's gonna keep costing more to maintain.

1:32:59I uh it's g you know, gas is getting expensive.

1:33:01You know, you can always find some reason to rationalize replacing it, but usually

1:33:08just repairing an old car is usually the cheapest way to keep going.

1:33:13Um, especially like if you average it out over the years.

1:33:15Repairing an old car is almost always cheaper than replacing it for a very

1:33:19long time.

1:33:20Um, but it also depends on the car.

1:33:22Like sometimes you can get a lot of miles out of a car before

1:33:26it needs you know the entire engine to be rebuilt, like John was saying.

1:33:29Like sometimes you can you can go well past a hundred.

1:33:32Sometimes you don't get to fifty.

1:33:33Sometimes a pebble creates some bad luck.

1:33:36Like there's there's all sorts of ways that that your car ownership can end.

1:33:41But if if something is reasonably repairable for reasonable prices and you still like

1:33:46the car and it still serves your needs, repair it.

1:33:49That's one of the things you learn from watching car rebuilding channels is any

1:33:53modern engine in a commodity car should easily go hundreds of thousands of miles

1:33:58if you just continue to replace the wear parts, the parts that are always

1:34:01gonna wear out.

1:34:02Certain parts certain parts are always gonna wear out.

1:34:03You do have to replace belts and uh you know hoses and stuff that

1:34:07just you know brought out, but like the the heart of the engine should

1:34:10easily last hundreds of thousands of miles.

1:34:12The exception to that, I remember I said commodity cars.

1:34:15What if you don't have a commodity car?

1:34:16What if you have a fancy car?

1:34:18Those, unfortunately, many of them are lucky to make it to a hundred thousand

1:34:22because they have some fatal flaw where the rod bearings wear out or the

1:34:25timing chain guard has a problem and needs to be replaced.

1:34:28And if you don't, whatever like if whatever the weakness of this exotic weird

1:34:32engine has, if you don't address that weakness preemptively, the engine potentially will not

1:34:38make it to 100,000, which is so not true of like a four-cylinder naturally

1:34:42aspirated Honda engine, like you just d like don't have to do anything to

1:34:46that and it will easily make it to a hundred K as long as

1:34:48you know, again something catastrophic doesn't happen, like damage or whatever.

1:34:51But temperamental cars, you've got your fancy BMW M car, so many of them

1:34:56have something that everyone knows.

1:34:57Oh, these all have this problem.

1:34:59So if if you don't get these things replaced at this number of miles,

1:35:02this engine is toast.

1:35:03Like catastrophic things that will cause, you know, interference in the interference in the

1:35:08engine and just destroy it entirely.

1:35:09That won't with a stupid simple Honda engine because there's nothing in there to

1:35:13go wrong.

1:35:14The performance engines, they're trying to, you know, they're they're not made to be

1:35:19like we have to make sure this lasts 100,000 miles if no one ever

1:35:21pays attention to it.

1:35:22They're like no, we want maximum power and you know efficiency and all these

1:35:25other things about it.

1:35:27And they're not looking towards longevity.

1:35:28So that's one of the weird things about this business: the more exotic or

1:35:32interesting and or exciting the engine.

1:35:35The less likely it is to cruise easily to hundreds of thousands of miles.

1:35:38The um the but the canonical example of this to me is the Porsche

1:35:42IMS bearings, which I forget the specifics about what the IMS bearing is or

1:35:46or where it sits or whatever, but it was on, I think, boxsters and

1:35:49especially nine elevens for like five or five or so years.

1:35:52And it's one of those things that you don't really know when it's gonna

1:35:56go, but if it goes, it's a catastrophic failure, like John was saying.

1:36:01Like you have to throw away the engine and start anew, which is just

1:36:03astonishing.

1:36:04Uh JJ in the chat said the engine of fancy cars are wear items.

1:36:08Yeah, I mean there's always such weird things.

1:36:09Like one of the recent ones, like a particular Porsche engine, speaking of them,

1:36:12where there's the little finger followers that actuate the valves from the camshafts or

1:36:16whatever, and the little finger followers like wear out in a particular way.

1:36:19And once they start to wear it screws with your timing and it's just

1:36:22like and you know it's fixed in the next version of the engine.

1:36:25The the the rod bearings I was thinking with BMW there's so many BMW

1:36:28engines, like these are great, but at 50,000 miles you better replace the rod

1:36:31bearings because the ones they come with are just gonna be toast pretty soon

1:36:33and the whole engine's gonna seize up.

1:36:35It's like that does that doesn't happen with a stupid commodity car engine because

1:36:38they're not made fancy.

1:36:39They don't have the special silicon graphite impregnated rod bearings for extra low friction.

1:36:44It's just no, it's just like the cheapest most reliable thing.

1:36:47Um, so yeah, modern cars should last easily hundreds of thousands of miles if

1:36:52something doesn't go wrong, unless you have a fancy car, in which case all

1:36:56bets are off and you better know the lore about the particular molly yeah.

1:37:02Or just be willing to constantly take it in for service and pay gobs

1:37:05and gobs of money.

1:37:06Vanos, by the way, as you found out, Casey, is also a giant source

1:37:09of of pain in BMWs because their valve timing system and the way it

1:37:12works with oil pressure actuating all those little things is temperamental.

1:37:18That's very gentle of you.

1:37:19I'm I'm very, very impressed.

1:37:21I think they also have the the the the timing chain, plastic timing chain

1:37:24guards that shatter into a million pieces.

1:37:26That was also not what you wanted to happen.

1:37:28Yeah.

1:37:29Tell Aaron's first Volvo.

1:37:31Uh yeah.

1:37:39Yeah, no, the timing chain guard is just like keeping keeping the timing chain

1:37:42from like, you know, like it's wrapping around some pulleys and the guard like

1:37:45pushes it out a little bit and that guard made of plastic that that

1:37:47eventually becomes brittle and breaks.

1:37:49And now you have pieces of plastic being caught between the gears of the

1:37:52timing chain and the As they g it's it's bad news.

1:37:55Uh anyway, uh Mark Bramhill writes Google recently announced the end of support for

1:37:59third-party email addresses, sending and receiving mail through Gmail starting in January.

1:38:03I remember John uses this for routing all of his different accounts into one

1:38:06Gmail or Gmail account.

1:38:08Do you have a plan for what to do when the new year arrives?

1:38:10My email setup depends on this and I don't want to lose my custom

1:38:13domain, make my account a Google Workspace account, or lose my bajillion Gmail filter

1:38:17rules.

1:38:18What do we say for our friend Mark?

1:38:19I didn't

1:38:21sent in probably several months ago, basically based on how long things stay in

1:38:24SKTP.

1:38:25Uh so I looked into it and sure enough, there's like some little Google

1:38:28announcement that says, Yeah, by the way, um, you may have been enjoying the

1:38:32fact that you can be in the Gmail web interface and send mail from

1:38:37from any of your email addresses that you own.

1:38:39In other words it would go through like the SMTP server of whatever your

1:38:43domain is, but you can do that from the Gmail web interface.

1:38:47So for example, I one of the domains I own is hypercritical.co, which is

1:38:50where my website is, and I have email addresses at hypercritical.co, like switchglass at

1:38:55hypercritical.co for like switchglass support for one of my apps.

1:38:58I have I have email addresses for all my app names.

1:39:00Okay.

1:39:00Um and if someone sends an email to that address and says, hey I'm

1:39:04having a problem with switchglass, When I reply, my reply comes from switchglass at

1:39:09hypercritical.co.

1:39:10But I send that reply at from gmail.com because gmail.com lets you configure, hey,

1:39:15when you're switchglass at hypercritical.co, what should I use for the SMTP server?

1:39:18And I point it to the now these days the fastmail server that is

1:39:22my you know, SMTP server and you know anything, blah blah blah.

1:39:26This is separate from receiving email, which is very easier.

1:39:30Again, I've moved everything to Fastmail a while back.

1:39:32Um

1:39:34I receive email for all my various addresses at hypercritical.co and they go to

1:39:38Fastmail.

1:39:38But fastmail is that makes it easy to send a rule that says, oh

1:39:41do you want me also to send a copy of this to your Gmail

1:39:43address and I say yes.

1:39:44So that's still gonna work.

1:39:45You can still receive emails that were really sent to a different address because

1:39:48all that is just forwarding, just fast mail saying, I'll just forward this to

1:39:52this Gmail address.

1:39:53And I receive it and I see it there.

1:39:54It's the responding as a different address.

1:39:57I don't know why Google's getting rid of this other than just being punitive

1:40:00and mean, uh, trying to get you to upgrade to some paid thing or

1:40:03whatever, which by the way, I would do if I wasn't of it destroying

1:40:05my entire life because I don't trust any ability to upgrade this type of

1:40:09stuff and I hear all these horror stories about how free Gmail is better

1:40:11than workspace until they lock your account forever and you lose access to everything,

1:40:14which I know is a problem.

1:40:15Anyway, just fingers

1:40:18workspace you have a chance of getting someone on the phone, but if if

1:40:20Google locks your free Gmail account, you're never getting it back.

1:40:23Anyway, yeah, so what am I gonna do for sending?

1:40:25Here's what I'm personally planning to do.

1:40:27First of all, when people send email to like, you know, switch glass at

1:40:31hypercritical.co, half the time I don't even bother responding from switch, I just respond

1:40:35for my Gmail address.

1:40:36Like I don't pay that much attention.

1:40:38Like they know it's me.

1:40:39It's like a I'm not pretending to be a big company.

1:40:42They send email, they know it's getting to me.

1:40:44When I respond, I respond from my personal email address.

1:40:46It comes from my Gmail.

1:40:47Who cares?

1:40:48Okay.

1:40:49I may probably do that.

1:40:51But if I decide that, oh, for some whatever reason, it's important for me

1:40:54to send an email as switchglass at hypercutel.co, I'll just go to the Fastmail

1:40:58web interface and do it from there.

1:41:00Like that's what I'm gonna do.

1:41:01Like it's not going to affect my life too much because it was just

1:41:04kind of like a nice convenience that I can send email.

1:41:06As my different addresses from the Gmail web interface.

1:41:09But if I can't, most of the time I just won't do it.

1:41:11And if I do want to do it, I'll the Fastmail web interface.

1:41:14Ben Cooper writes: if Apple ever makes a new Mac Pro one day, probably

1:41:19with some or one of their AI super servers chips that will roll out

1:41:23in the next three to five years, will it reuse the twenty nineteen design

1:41:26or have a new one?

1:41:27I kind of feel like it depends on how long it is.

1:41:29Like I've always said when they made this case design in 2019 that they

1:41:32were going to try to get mileage out of it because it was so

1:41:34expensive to develop.

1:41:36And it turns out they did get many years out of it, mostly by

1:41:39just never updating the machines that they sell in that case.

1:41:41So they they sold the Intel one and they sold the M2 one, and

1:41:44that's it.

1:41:45Just just been, you know, it was the Intel it was for the Intels.

1:41:48Maybe they was I forget if they had uh a Xeon Rev in this

1:41:51case, maybe not.

1:41:52Um but yeah, and the M2 was the only Apple Silicon one to it.

1:41:56But they sold that stupid M2 thing for way longer than they should have.

1:42:00They did get a lot of years out of it.

1:42:03Maybe they feel like they recouped their costs on developing it.

1:42:05May they feel like they didn't, which is why the whole thing is canned.

1:42:08Uh if they came up with an X pro Mac Pro next year, they

1:42:11would reuse the case.

1:42:12If they come out with a Mac Pro ten years from now, I think

1:42:15they have a new case.

1:42:16Yeah, I think they would do something new.

1:42:18It may look very similar to what to what you just left behind, but

1:42:22I think it would be new.

1:42:23Marco, any thoughts?

1:42:24I mean, besides my standard disclaimer that I think the Mac Studio is the

1:42:28Mac Pro now and I think if they call if they wanted to call

1:42:32something else the Mac Pro, it would probably just be like the Mac Studio

1:42:37in Space Gray.

1:42:39Or maybe it would be a little bit bigger.

1:42:41They would call it the Mac Ultra.

1:42:42That's what they would call it.

1:42:43Oh, maybe.

1:42:44Because I mean we'll see how they go with the the rumored uh it

1:42:46didn't work out for the phone so far, right?

1:42:48So the phone is the duo and not the ultra, and maybe the twentieth

1:42:50anniversary will be the ultra, but the rumor still is that the touch-based OLED

1:42:54MacBook Pro will be the MacBook Ultra.

1:42:56If they do the MacBook Ultra, clearly in three to five years, if they're

1:42:59gonna make something that is bigger and hotter than the Mac Studio, I feel

1:43:02like they would call Mac Ultra.

1:43:03Or I mean th you know, they're on their kick for like, you know,

1:43:06three letter names ending in oh, we got Neo, we got duo, is there

1:43:09any you know like MacBao?

1:43:11Bow?

1:43:11Quadro.

1:43:12They already did Quadra.

1:43:15Well that's Quadro, not Quadro.

1:43:17Quadro is different.

1:43:18That's something else.

1:43:19Isn't Quadro an NVIDIA trademark?

1:43:22Uh what was that?

1:43:23Wasn't that their their professional GPUs?

1:43:25Yeah, that weren't those the ones that were like for CAD, not games.

1:43:28Right, yeah, exactly.

1:43:29Yeah.

1:43:30All right.

1:43:31Thank you to our sponsors this episode, Claude and Granola, and thanks to our

1:43:35members who support us directly.

1:43:37You can join us at at b.fm slash join.

1:43:39One of the many perks Of membership is ATP overtime our weekly bonus topic.

1:43:45This week in overtime, we're gonna be talking a little bit more about John

1:43:47Turnus's intelligent personal hub remarks during that keynote, and Apple's home AI hub that's

1:43:54rumored.

1:43:54I'm gonna be talking about that.

1:43:55Uh in overtime, you can join or listen atb.fm slash join.

1:43:59Thanks everybody, and we'll talk to you next week.

1:44:05Now the show is over.

1:44:07They didn't even mean to begin.

1:44:09Cause it was accidental.

1:44:11Accidental.

1:44:12Oh it was accidental.

1:44:14Accidental John didn't do any research.

1:44:17Marco and Casey wouldn't let him.

1:44:20Cause it was accidental.

1:44:22Accidental.

1:44:23Oh it was accidental.

1:44:26And you can find the show notes at ATV.fm And if you're into Mastodon,

1:44:34you can follow them at C A S E-Y-L, I S S, so that's

1:44:40K C Liss, M-A-R-C-O, A-R-M, T Marco Armin, S-I-R-A-C, U USA C recuser, it's

1:44:52accidental, accidental.

1:44:55They didn't mean to accidental, accidental, check podcasts so long.

1:45:05I have a problem and AI hasn't solved it.

1:45:08Is this a cowbell joke?

1:45:09What are we doing?

1:45:10No.

1:45:10Uh I wish a cowbell would be the answer, but um what is the

1:45:14was that a fever anyway?

1:45:15I think it was a fever.

1:45:16But anyhow.

1:45:17Um I bought my BMW, you know, a month or so ago, a month

1:45:22and a half ago.

1:45:23And like six-ish months ago, BMW in America cut off the API that some

1:45:32third party individual like open source wrote um uh wrote a home assistant integration

1:45:39for.

1:45:40So with Aaron's car, there's a non-supported or not Volvo supported integration and home

1:45:46assistant that'll let me tell it to like start cooling itself or unlock or

1:45:51lock or whatever the case may be.

1:45:52Um and this is completely unnecessary.

1:45:57Let me start by saying completely unnecessary.

1:45:59I recognize that.

1:46:00I get it.

1:46:01But it's actually kind of nice.

1:46:02So as an example, um, instead of having the Volvo own always start preconditioning

1:46:08itself every morning when Aaron is about to do the school run, I can

1:46:12use Home Assistant to make an automation that says if it's over such and

1:46:17such degrees or below such and such degrees, precondition.

1:46:20If you're in that sweet spot in the middle don't bother.

1:46:24Again, for this entire conversation, I'm just gonna take it as writ.

1:46:27I understand none of this is necessary, it's a hobby, I think it's neat,

1:46:31and I like doing it.

1:46:32I don't think I need any of this for my BMW, I don't have

1:46:35repeatable common uses like that, but it's still nice to have, and it's still

1:46:40nice to be able to see that oh the BMW's charged at eighty percent

1:46:43or twenty percent or whatever the case may be.

1:46:44It's nice to have that in home system.

1:46:46You have to make a new LED for that.

1:46:47I could make a new LED for that.

1:46:49You're exactly right.

1:46:50And I absolutely would, one hundred percent.

1:46:53Now I'm frustrated again because I remember that that was part of the plan

1:46:56and I can't do it.

1:46:57Um and so that to cut to the end of the story, I have

1:47:00not solved this problem.

1:47:01But there is a read-only API that BMW had to make, I think, because

1:47:07of EU rules in the EU, where you can get information about your car,

1:47:12you cannot influence your car.

1:47:13So you couldn't lock it or unlock it.

1:47:15You couldn't pre-condition or whatever, but you could at least know how charged it

1:47:20is, among other things.

1:47:21This API is does not exist in the United States.

1:47:24There is a home assistant uh integration that does work with that API, but

1:47:29when you go to register for it in the US, it just kind of

1:47:32hangs.

1:47:33So I figured I'd like to think think of myself as reasonably smart.

1:47:38I should be able to figure this out.

1:47:40So my fur well, how would you two start to try to get access

1:47:44in home assistant to the BMW APIs?

1:47:47What would be your first step?

1:47:49I'd go right to an LLM for this.

1:47:51Do you have uh an example of a product that does this that you

1:47:56can reverse engineer, like something that exists that you have access to that uses

1:48:00the API?

1:48:01Sure.

1:48:01My iOS app.

1:48:02Oh yeah, well then just why would wire sniff that sucker?

1:48:05That is exactly what I did.

1:48:06Unfortunately, and now I'm talking a little bit out of my comfort zone, but

1:48:10unfortunately it appears that BMW did the thing that they should do, and their

1:48:14certificate pinning.

1:48:16So I can't sniff that traffic.

1:48:19It it it rejects everything.

1:48:20Like I have Charles installed on my phone.

1:48:22Now it could be that it's user error.

1:48:24Maybe I misunderstood how to do this with Charles, but I've done this with

1:48:26other things with Charles that aren't as sophisticated and it's worked Great.

1:48:30And I tried to do this with Charles on the phone.

1:48:32Charles is a wire sniffer and I couldn't get anything useful out of it.

1:48:36I don't know how the certificate pinning works.

1:48:38Does this totally stop you if you're man in the middling it with uh

1:48:41like a proxy?

1:48:42Again, I'm talking outside my comfort zone, but my limited understanding, very limited and

1:48:47probably incorrect understanding of certificate pinning, it it uh it it's probably all wrong.

1:48:51So consider your source here.

1:48:53But my understanding is it basically says it ha the the other end has

1:48:56to match this exact certificate.

1:48:57Can't be a good certificate.

1:48:59It and maybe Marco, you might know about this, but um but it has

1:49:02to match a particular certificate or something along those lines I forget the details.

1:49:06So when 'cause I d I do the same thing in Overcast.

1:49:08I've since day one.

1:49:09And so you c you know using the you know the standard stock IOS

1:49:12APIs there's ways to basically like intercept the negotiation of the of the secure

1:49:18connection before it's actually made and i it you you can be presented with

1:49:22the certificate chain of trust and you can inspect it.

1:49:24And you can you return like yes or no, do I trust this or

1:49:27not?

1:49:27Um or you can you know you can block it, you can cancel it,

1:49:29whatever else.

1:49:30But anyway, you can inspect um you know, is it signed by one of

1:49:34the keys that you with uh that you approve of?

1:49:36Or you can say is it signed by one of the

1:49:38is it an exact certificate that you that you approve of?

1:49:40Or is it signed by an intermediate certificate that you trust?

1:49:44So and that's you know, usually like you ca you can get very, very,

1:49:48you know, picky and low level with this, but the most common approach I

1:49:52think is to pin one of the intermediates.

1:49:54That way you can reissue your certificate and, you know, as long as it's

1:49:56still signed by the same CA or, you know, something like that, then you

1:50:00know, you can you don't have to issue an update to your app for

1:50:02it to work.

1:50:03Thank you.

1:50:03That is that is my a much better explanation than I could have given.

1:50:07Uh but yes, that that matches what I what I was experiencing, which is

1:50:10basically it was trying to man in the middle, and I was I think

1:50:13I might have said Wireshark, but I I meant Charles.

1:50:15I used Charles Proxy to or I I used Charles Proxies to attempt a

1:50:19man in the middle it and even though I told Charles you know I

1:50:22told my phone to trust Charles's certificate, the BMW app rejected it.

1:50:26So my next step would be okay, decompile the app um and see what

1:50:29the source code is doing.

1:50:30Because if you can't see what's happening over the wire, you can see the

1:50:32code that produces the content that goes over the wire.

1:50:34That is what I should have done, but I didn't and and and I

1:50:38should try that.

1:50:39I don't know if it'll matter, but I agree with you that is the

1:50:41next step.

1:50:42I did not that did not occur to me and it should have.

1:50:45Now, in my defense, I was doing this a month or so ago, or

1:50:47shortly after getting the car.

1:50:49And I forget when you were talking about reverse engineering something, but I think

1:50:51it was subsequent to that.

1:50:52But anyway, it doesn't really matter.

1:50:53I should have thought of it and I didn't.

1:50:54So what I thought was, all right, well, I know the app works.

1:51:00What if I what if I used iPhone mirroring?

1:51:05Oh no.

1:51:05I have Does this does this end with like a hot dog on an

1:51:08actuator?

1:51:09Pretty close.

1:51:10Did the water drinking birds on the Simpsons.

1:51:13Exactly it.

1:51:13Exactly.

1:51:15I thought, you know what?

1:51:16I'll have Claude write me and Claude is uh past and potentially future sponsor.

1:51:21Current this episode.

1:51:22Oh, this episode Oh yeah, it is this episode.

1:51:24I'm sorry.

1:51:25I I didn't even think about that.

1:51:26Yes, current sponsor.

1:51:28But anyways um, I thought, let me have Claude write a macOS app that

1:51:35will tickle iPhone mirroring and do what I want it to do in the

1:51:41BMW app via iPhone mirroring.

1:51:44This took a long time.

1:51:47There was a lot of back and forth, but I'll be damned, fellas, it

1:51:52worked perfectly.

1:51:54Oh, that's awesome.

1:51:55Which is incredible.

1:51:57I could get information on my Mac about what was happening on my phone

1:52:03via iPhone mirroring via via the my BMW app, right?

1:52:06It's the same app, presumably you're using for your car, Marco.

1:52:09And it would look at the it would do screen re it would take

1:52:12a picture or you know, look at this the iPhone mirroring screens, which is

1:52:16my iPhone screen.

1:52:17It would figure out what was the state of charge, you know, is it

1:52:20locked, is it unlocked, etc.

1:52:22Then it got to the point that it would lock or unlock the car

1:52:24if I asked it to.

1:52:26Like it was interactive.

1:52:27It was incredible.

1:52:31This is all well and good.

1:52:32I feel like you're you're using the past tense a lot in this in

1:52:35this last sentence.

1:52:36I was gonna say instead of using your phone, I was like you need

1:52:38like a sacrificial phone whose only function in life is to be that phone

1:52:41that gets You are exactly exactly right, John.

1:52:44And I am lucky enough to buy an iPhone every year like a friggin'

1:52:48idiot.

1:52:49I have old phones laying around.

1:52:51And so I thought, you know what I'll do?

1:52:53I'll sacrifice my webcam phone, which is like an iPhone 15, maybe 14, I

1:52:57forget exactly what this is.

1:52:59I'll sacrifice that and no longer use it as a webcam for you know

1:53:02a handful of uh FaceTime social FaceTime calls I do every month.

1:53:06I'll just use my actual phone for those.

1:53:08I'll sacrifice this and I'll put this bad boy attached to my M1 Mac

1:53:12Mini.

1:53:12Job done.

1:53:13This is gonna be frickin' great.

1:53:16I start that process.

1:53:18Everything's going great.

1:53:19I log into my BMW on this sacrificial phone and I connect it to

1:53:23the Mac Mini.

1:53:24I install my little, I don't remember what Claude ended up calling it, but

1:53:27it was probably just as bad a name as I would have come up

1:53:29with, or maybe I told it.

1:53:30Uh but anyways, I I had Claude, you know, right had Claude, you know,

1:53:34help me put it on the m on the Mac Mini.

1:53:36Everything is going great.

1:53:38This is working perfectly.

1:53:39And the next step was going to be all right now let's put this

1:53:42bad boy in home assistant which honestly what I was what I did was

1:53:46I had it dump everything into my my QTT or uh um MQTT uh

1:53:53server which is basically like a a generic bus that a bunch of different

1:53:56things can talk to.

1:53:57Um it's not really that important to the story here, but it would dump

1:54:01everything on MQTT and then uh it's very easy for home assistant to pick

1:54:05up stuff on MQTT.

1:54:07Um So I I have it in MQTT.

1:54:10My next step was going to be to start integrating into Home Assistant using

1:54:13this bus.

1:54:14And I noticed that it was working great

1:54:20until I disconnected via screen sharing.

1:54:23This is a headless Mac Mini.

1:54:25I do everything via Apple screen sharing.

1:54:27The second I disconnect,

1:54:30it locks the Mac Mini.

1:54:32Okay, fine.

1:54:33I'll tell it to have an infinite scr uh screensaver, never ever auto lock

1:54:37yourself.

1:54:38It'll be great.

1:54:39I have some scripts to set that up for you if you want.

1:54:41That's exactly how all of mine run.

1:54:43Right?

1:54:43The second you disconnect screen uh the screen sharing, it locks the Mac mini.

1:54:47All right, fine.

1:54:48I'm talking with Claude about this.

1:54:50Why don't you purchase an HDMI dongle so it thinks there's a physical connection

1:54:55to an actual um uh monitor connected to the device?

1:55:00Well, you know what, Claude?

1:55:01I happen to have one laying around.

1:55:03I plug that in.

1:55:05No good.

1:55:05The second you disconnect screen sharing, it locks the computer.

1:55:09When it locks the computer, it locks uh the iPhone mirroring.

1:55:14I that is where I ended up getting stuck.

1:55:16Ooh, the GLINET comic Q.

1:55:18That is interesting.

1:55:20I wonder if well, but no, but that's but the problem though is that

1:55:23is that if I use the Mac Mini with for normal stuff, like with

1:55:28screenshots screen sharing, then as soon as I disconnect, it's gonna relock everything, right?

1:55:33So there the the solution I could choose is to dis to disavow screen

1:55:37sharing for the purposes of this one computer and only ever g log into

1:55:41it via like the GLI net or use like a more vanilla V and

1:55:44C thing or something like that.

1:55:46Um, and that is a solution, but I don't want this that badly that

1:55:52I wanna re-jigger how I access the Smack Mini because I do that more

1:55:55frequently than than than than you would think.

1:55:58So I ended up throwing up the white flag.

1:56:01But the fact that I was this close, I was so close.

1:56:06I almost got it.

1:56:08And if it wasn't for the fact that there's no way I can figure

1:56:11out to s prevent the Mac Mini from locking itself the second I disconnect.

1:56:16If it wasn't for that, I think I would have had it.

1:56:19And that to me is absolutely astonishing.

1:56:22So it was a really fun journey.

1:56:25I'm glad I tried it but ultimately it didn't work out.

1:56:28Well I think though I think what's interesting about the you know, uh part

1:56:31of the uh the great loss that we've had as we've moved away from

1:56:38a lot of web browser apps and a lot of you know, like kind

1:56:41of more open APIs into now everything has its own custom app and they're

1:56:46all super locked down and they have no one has public APIs anymore and

1:56:49they're all those are all locked down and everything is through API keys and

1:56:54and pinning and stuff like that.

1:56:55And and of course my own app does exactly this and so I can't

1:56:58really s I I can't really talk.

1:56:59But I think one of the things that we've lost in this world is

1:57:03like the ability for for power users and tinkerers and programmers to hack around

1:57:08stuff and make cool stuff.

1:57:09And I think one of the great enabling things about AI is that it

1:57:15basically is like a complete almost like you know like the world's best brute

1:57:20force solution.

1:57:21It's like, okay well, what if we just have this this you know intelligent

1:57:26automated agent just operate a computer and just click through all your BS?

1:57:31You want to have it log into your BS?

1:57:33Okay, it'll do that.

1:57:34You wanna have it read the screen and scrape things because you don't have

1:57:37an API?

1:57:38Okay, it'll do that.

1:57:39And you know, nerds like us can start rigging up things like, you know,

1:57:43remote KVMs or screen shares or iPhone mirroring to actually start doing the same

1:57:47thing to iOS apps too, or just have the iOS app run on your

1:57:51Mac if it can do that.

1:57:52Like I feel like we now are in uh we're we're in an era

1:57:56now where like one of the fun things about AI is that it helps

1:57:59break down those walls that everyone else has put up.

1:58:02Yep.

1:58:02I couldn't.

1:58:04I'll have to uh take a stab at having it like decompile the app.

1:58:07I I I really should have thought about that.

1:58:08I'm

1:58:10but I I I bring this up both because I'm I want to fuss

1:58:13and moan about the fact that I can't um that I can't I can't

1:58:17seemingly do this, although it also didn't occur to me to just run the

1:58:22app natively, which it looks like I might be able to do, which presumably

1:58:27might get me what I want.

1:58:28So you both have saved me, potentially, potentially saved me.

1:58:31Um so instead of running it in iPhone mirroring, I might be able to

1:58:34run it natively on my Apple Silicon Mac Mini.

1:58:36Um, But it it's it's both fascinating to me that this is a potential

1:58:43like Rube Goldberg solution, which I was I felt pretty proud that I came

1:58:46up with this and that Claude was able to basically get it working.

1:58:50It was no fault of Claude that failed.

1:58:52But it's also a bummer that all of this, like you said, Marco, is

1:58:56locked in and there's nothing we can do to get at it.

1:58:58And as much as I have very mixed feelings about the EU's regulatory landscape,

1:59:03it's stuff like this when it's executed right, which the EU doesn't always do,

1:59:08this is when it's when it this is the EU at its best, right?

1:59:11At the very least I could have gotten read-only info out of the BMW

1:59:14if I lived in in I almost said in Britain, but uh if I

1:59:17lived in mainland Europe.

1:59:19Too soon.

1:59:20Too soon.

1:59:22But yeah, no, I I I'm bummed that it didn't work, but I thought

1:59:26it was a really fun experiment in Rube Goldberg machine to try to get

1:59:30it to work.