0:00:09From Relay, this is Upgrade, episode six hundred and forty for October 5th, 2026.
0:00:15Today's show is brought to you by Squarespace and Factor.
0:00:18My name is Mike Hurley.
0:00:19I'm Jason Snell.
0:00:20Hi, Jason.
0:00:21Hi, Mike.
0:00:21How are you?
0:00:21I'm good.
0:00:22We're sitting in a hotel room in Memphis.
0:00:23We're actually too far away from each other to do a high five, so
0:00:26we have to pretend.
0:00:26We could do it like a little finger.
0:00:28We touch we touch fingers.
0:00:29Okay.
0:00:29If you watch the video on YouTube, you got to see that.
0:00:32That was quite a thing.
0:00:33Um we are recording together live in Memphis.
0:00:36It's Saturday.
0:00:37Uh and that actually leads me into my snort talk question.
0:00:40Jason how are you feeling today?
0:00:43I'm feeling great.
0:00:44You feel great?
0:00:44I feel great.
0:00:45Wow, look at you.
0:00:46Yeah.
0:00:46What a show off.
0:00:47I feel terrible.
0:00:49Okay.
0:00:50All right.
0:00:51So we did the podcast with them yesterday.
0:00:53Um, I'm happy you're feeling Did you get a good night's sleep?
0:00:57Uh no.
0:00:58Actually, let's check on in on Jason's sleep score.
0:01:01Okay.
0:01:01Well how's Jason's sleep score?
0:01:02We can do s live sleep score checks.
0:01:04Fifty-three.
0:01:05Okay.
0:01:06Pretty good.
0:01:07That's bad.
0:01:07Actually terrible.
0:01:08Low.
0:01:09Very, very poor.
0:01:11Very poor indeed.
0:01:12My sleep score,
0:01:14seventy eight.
0:01:15Ah.
0:01:15Okay.
0:01:16It says.
0:01:17Great.
0:01:18Well, I didn't
0:01:20got about six hours of sleep.
0:01:21Sleep doesn'thing for how you feel in the day, is what we've learned No,
0:01:24no, I'm on my second diet mountain due and I'm that'll do it.
0:01:28And I'm riding high.
0:01:29That'll do it.
0:01:29Yep.
0:01:30If you'd like to send in a snow talk to help us open a
0:01:32future episode of the show, just go to upgradefeedback.com.
0:01:36Uh we're here in Memphis.
0:01:37Uh we're recording on Saturday.
0:01:39We're talking about the podcast a thon which was yesterday as we were recording
0:01:42this because all month we have been raising uh money for St.
0:01:45Jude because we are still in extended September right now.
0:01:48Yes.
0:01:49Um you actually still have if you're listening to the show on Monday, uh
0:01:53or I think maybe a little bit of Tuesday, there is still time to
0:01:56make a donation to Saint Jude.
0:01:57Uh you go to Saint Jude.org slash relay.
0:02:00Um as we are recording right now, two important things have happened.
0:02:03We passed our fundraising goal of seven hundred thousand dollars for the month.
0:02:07Thank you so much to everybody that's made a donation.
0:02:10We've also passed five point five million dollars lifetime raised for the kids of
0:02:14St.
0:02:14Jude.
0:02:15Um the Podcast at on was a wonderful experience as it always is.
0:02:20We had we had a lot of fun.
0:02:22We had a great time last night.
0:02:23Uh it's available for you to watch uh whenever you want uh over on
0:02:28YouTube.
0:02:28Uh you can, you know, break it up over many, many, many viewing sessions.
0:02:33Yeah, binge yeah, you could do a binge, twelve hour binge, or you could
0:02:36do it uh watch an hour uh for twelve days.
0:02:38An hour a day for twelve days.
0:02:40That is that the recommendation?
0:02:41On the twelfth day of relay, the podcast a thon gave to me.
0:02:47What did it give at the end?
0:02:48You touched some things in some boxes.
0:02:50That happened at the end.
0:02:51Yeah.
0:02:52Something like that.
0:02:52Something like that.
0:02:54So yeah.
0:02:55At this time I touched things in boxes.
0:02:57I didn't
0:02:59I mean I touched the boxes, but that doesn't.
0:03:00That's not the that's not the problem, is it?
0:03:03Uh yeah, we're just we're s just super thankful uh that the relay community
0:03:07continues to come out in the force that it does.
0:03:09You know, like me and Steven were looking at this for many, many, many
0:03:13years in a row, we've been incredibly consistent with the amount of money that
0:03:17has been raised by this community like over the last many years.
0:03:21Um, and we're just super thankful um that you continue to support this organization
0:03:27that means so much to us.
0:03:29So go and check out if you want to make a donation, you can
0:03:32donation any time.
0:03:33If our campaign's stupid though you can put it there.
0:03:35And go check out the podcasters on as well.
0:03:38So it's a good time.
0:03:39Good time had by all.
0:03:41Yes, I think so.
0:03:42Jason, you reviewed Shop Different by Ron Johnson for the Wall Street Journal again.
0:03:49Oh my god, I'm in the presence of a two time Wall Street Journal
0:03:52book reviewer.
0:03:53Yeah.
0:03:53I guess they thought my other review was fine, so they asked Ron Johnson's
0:03:57book.
0:03:57Well obviously more than fine.
0:03:59Why does it just have to be fine?
0:04:00Why can't be they thought it was good.
0:04:02Okay.
0:04:03Acceptable enough to give me a second assignment.
0:04:05That's better.
0:04:06I think that's what all I mean by that.
0:04:08I'll take that.
0:04:08Um yeah, they they um they asked me and I read it.
0:04:13I mean, I read it, I feel like I read it like three months
0:04:15ago now.
0:04:16Yeah, I feel like you wrote this review ages ago.
0:04:20I wrote this review a month ago, but I had already I had to
0:04:22refresh my memory because I'd already read it like three months two months before
0:04:26that or something like that.
0:04:28Um so uh yeah, Ron Johnson has a book I think it's now called
0:04:32Shop Different, where he tells the story, he tells his story, sort of like
0:04:36and how what led him to Apple.
0:04:37And then he tells the story about how he and Steve Jobs and it
0:04:40was very much a kind of collaborative experience because Apple didn't really have a
0:04:44lot of retail experience and Steve Jobs wanted to do retail stores.
0:04:48And Ron Johnson brought kind of a lot of knowledge to that that Steve
0:04:52Jobs didn't have.
0:04:52And there's a lot of great Steve Jobs stories in there about uh Jeron
0:04:57Johnson having ideas and and Steve, you know, being really upset that he was
0:05:01like, I don't want to, that's dumb.
0:05:03And then like Steve would think about it for a little bit and then
0:05:06he would be like, Okay, we're gonna do that.
0:05:08And then the um the anecdote that I really like is um Ron Johnson
0:05:13suggests the name Genius bar and the geniuses for the Apple store.
0:05:18And Steve Jobs says that's the stupidest thing I've ever heard.
0:05:21And like two days later, their general counsel Apple's general counsel, is outside Ron
0:05:27Johnson's door when he gets there in the morning.
0:05:28And he's like uh oh, okay, what is this?
0:05:31And and uh she says to him, What in the world is a genius?
0:05:36Oh.
0:05:37And that's the moment where he was like, oh, guess Steve decided that was
0:05:40a good name.
0:05:42It's interesting because I actually have never really liked the name Genius.
0:05:47Okay.
0:05:47Well I guess Steve.
0:05:49Steve agreed with you un until he didn't.
0:05:51Yeah.
0:05:52I mean it works when you have it, but like it's an odd odd.
0:05:57I think it's very clever and it's
0:05:59the yeah, that's the point of it.
0:06:01Um but uh it also it works.
0:06:03It does work.
0:06:04Like it I don't know why it doesn't mean it just feels too much,
0:06:09but it obviously does the job.
0:06:10It does the job, you know what it means.
0:06:11Yeah, and there's a great moment where um they've gotten pretty far down the
0:06:14line of what the Apple store is gonna be.
0:06:17And then Ron Johnson is at a meeting where Steve Jobs is recounting the
0:06:21uh that they're they're working on the digital hub strategy.
0:06:24So this is gonna be two thousand ish.
0:06:28And And Ron Johnson goes home and he's like, hmm, this is not what
0:06:34we're setting up in the stores.
0:06:36This this idea that the Mac is at the center of all these other
0:06:38devices is not how our stores are laid out at all.
0:06:41And the next morning He's driving the they they he would drive in the
0:06:46morning, um, on some mornings to the warehouse where they had their like staged
0:06:51Apple store that they were basically working out what an Apple store was gonna
0:06:54be like.
0:06:55And and Steve and Ron would be there and the retail team would be
0:06:58there.
0:06:59And as they're going out to the warehouse, um, or before they even head
0:07:05out, he says, We gotta read we gotta change what we're doing.
0:07:08And Steve's like, What are you talking about?
0:07:10And he says, Digital help strategy.
0:07:12It totally changes what should we should be doing.
0:07:13And Steve Jobs' like, God no, you know, we spend so much time, we
0:07:16can't do this.
0:07:17It's fine the way it is, whatever.
0:07:19And then and and he kinda yells at him and then they they drive
0:07:23over and the drive is silent.
0:07:25And Ron's like, Well, this is awkward.
0:07:28And they get there and they get everybody together and Steve says, Well, Ron
0:07:34here says that we've got to throw everything away because digital hub strategy needs
0:07:41to lead to a complete reorg of what we're planning here.
0:07:44And you know, he's right.
0:07:46So listen to Ron, good luck.
0:07:48And he walks away.
0:07:49Wow.
0:07:50And it's one of those moments of like Steve Jobs ha Steve Jobs, you
0:07:54know, we talk about this um
0:07:57idea that people don't like to be surprised.
0:08:00And this is a great example of that.
0:08:02Like Steve Jobs clearly He was very resistant
0:08:07at when given something new.
0:08:09Mm-hmm.
0:08:10Like, mm-mm, I don't know.
0:08:12But it was really, I think, him kind of
0:08:16processing and being cranky, being a cranky guy Yeah, like your instant reaction is
0:08:20no, I don't want to change.
0:08:22Right?
0:08:22Yeah.
0:08:23Yeah.
0:08:23And and I think that is natural.
0:08:25Yeah.
0:08:25And and you're like and you want to have maybe apply some skepticism to
0:08:28it.
0:08:29And he knows how much money's been spent on this.
0:08:31I mean he does how much work they've done on all of this.
0:08:34But then he um but I think one of Steve Jobs's uh special powers
0:08:38was his ability to look at that and then say, Hmm, actually, we should
0:08:43do that.
0:08:43And once he once he gets over the hump, he is the strongest uh
0:08:47proponent of whatever it is.
0:08:49So there's a bunch of uh interesting stuff like that in the book.
0:08:52I think he he wears it, uh Ron Johnson does about going to JCPenney.
0:08:56I think he felt like he had sort of done everything he needed to
0:08:58do at Apple.
0:08:59Um and wanted to try.
0:09:02And he's a believer.
0:09:03One thing you get in the book is he's retail.
0:09:05Like he his whole beginning of the book is like, Oh, I love I
0:09:08love going to department stores and shopping malls.
0:09:10Like it's just his thing, which is like, I mean, so he got to
0:09:14do his thing.
0:09:14But then he gets this opportunity to go to JCPenney.
0:09:17And what I say in the review, it's how I end the Wall Street
0:09:20Journal review, is basically like he had defined one of the great retail organizations
0:09:26of the twenty first century and then like he decided maybe he could, you
0:09:31know He wants to run the show.
0:09:32Revive he wants to run the show and he wants to revive maybe what
0:09:35he in his heart felt was like a classic department store brand of the
0:09:3920th century.
0:09:40And I think that that's kind of the challenge there is that he had
0:09:43actually done the thing, which was make the Apple store.
0:09:45And now he's trying to kind of like do this thing that's the past
0:09:48now and is fading away.
0:09:49And they were very resistant to him but he admits that it was kind
0:09:51of like a bad situation.
0:09:53And uh yeah, I I I don't know.
0:09:55Also it's all intertwined with the Steve Jobs dying because like he literally is
0:09:59told, Steve Jobs says, I'm dying and can you stay until I'm gone?
0:10:04Don't leave now.
0:10:05Can you stay at while as long as I'm still here and Ron Johnson,
0:10:08who's going to be the CEO of JC Penny, is like, yes, it stays
0:10:11for six months.
0:10:12So it's a very emotional.
0:10:14He talks about saying goodbye to Steve on day before he died.
0:10:18Um, there's a lot of that in there too.
0:10:20But um but yeah, he owns the JCPenney stuff and you know a and
0:10:25yet I I walked away from it sort of thinking like it was kinda
0:10:28in his nature.
0:10:29He kinda had to try.
0:10:30But but also he was, I think, chasing this is me, I think chasing
0:10:35an ideal that was already gone, already had been made obsolete.
0:10:39Um, but he was so idealistic about retail and about department stores and all
0:10:43that that he really wanted to give it a go and he had enough
0:10:46cachet because of the Apple stores to take on that role and it just
0:10:49didn't it's like maybe there's even an like an argument that the work he
0:10:53did at the Apple store is part of the reasons the department stores were
0:10:56going away.
0:10:57People were creating new experiences.
0:10:58That part the department store anymore.
0:11:00Yeah.
0:11:01Like it was a sign of the times and that something like JC Penney
0:11:05was not gonna take off again, maybe.
0:11:08Also struck by how Ron Johnson he defined a lot of at least according
0:11:12to the book, but I believe him, um, defined a lot of what the
0:11:15Apple store was in a way that Steve Jobs was maybe not thinking big
0:11:18enough, which is an interesting thing to say about Steve Jobs, because you always
0:11:22think he thinks big, but I think maybe he didn't think big enough.
0:11:26Like
0:11:28Ron Johnson
0:11:30says, this will be your brand.
0:11:32He was like, I don't want to be in shopping malls.
0:11:33And he's like, Do you want to reach people who don't know anything about
0:11:36Apple?
0:11:36That's where they are.
0:11:37And in two thousand, that is where they were.
0:11:40And, you know, saying the size of the store, he's like the si the
0:11:44store needs to be big.
0:11:45It's representation of your brand.
0:11:46Your brand is is your brand big, Steve?
0:11:48And Steve's like, Well, yeah, our brand is big.
0:11:50Is your brand bigger than the gap?
0:11:52Well, yeah it is.
0:11:53Well then your stores need to be bigger than the gap, uh was his
0:11:55argument.
0:11:55And and he sort of had to drag Steve there a little bit.
0:11:59But I believe, I think I mentioned this in the review, but like I
0:12:03really, really believe that the unstated
0:12:07thing about Apple's revival is the retail stores.
0:12:10That if you think back, Apple's brand was not even bad.
0:12:16It was irrelevant in that era because of the rise of Windows PCs.
0:12:20The Mac was this niche product.
0:12:22The iPod wasn't out yet.
0:12:24And when it came out, it wasn't Windows for a couple of years.
0:12:28But at least people who are curious could go into an Apple store and
0:12:31see it.
0:12:31And it by having that retail presence, by having the Apple brand be reachable
0:12:35by people, it allowed them to sell Macs at iPods and ultimately iPhones.
0:12:40And I think even with the exact same product set that they had, I
0:12:45don't think Apple would have been as successful in rehabbing its brand if they
0:12:49weren't present in um first initially American retail stores in the retail environment and
0:12:55then ultimately worldwide.
0:12:56I think it was a huge part.
0:12:58And Steve Jobs cared a lot about the Apple brand, but you could sort
0:13:02of see that from Ron Johnson's perspective, he wasn't thinking clearly about what retail
0:13:07meant for the Apple brand.
0:13:08And then and that's part of the journey they take together.
0:13:11Yeah.
0:13:12Yeah.
0:13:13And and you can kind of see why, because it's not like he had
0:13:16something to compare it to.
0:13:18Like there wasn't a consumer technology company that was owning and operating their own
0:13:23branded store experience.
0:13:25The computer stores in that era.
0:13:26Yeah.
0:13:27Were either Circuit City or Comp USA where there, you know, the where there
0:13:30was there was a store within a store for Apple, but it was d
0:13:33it was kind of dusty and nothing.
0:13:34Or they were like computer stores and they were very
0:13:39dusty and not interesting.
0:13:40And that's that's one of the realizations there is Ron Johnson's like, we want
0:13:43people coming into these stores and not just once every three years, right?
0:13:48We want them coming in frequent all the time.
0:13:51Whenever they're mall.
0:13:52Exactly.
0:13:52You'll pop into the apple store.
0:13:53Exactly.
0:13:54And that was a real leap.
0:13:55Yeah.
0:13:55But that that is ultimately what they did.
0:13:57Yeah.
0:13:58So people can get the book now, they can read your review on the
0:14:01Wall Street Journal, and we will have more about this in future episodes of
0:14:04Design in California as well.
0:14:05Which this will come up again in the future for us.
0:14:09Yep.
0:14:10This episode is brought to you by Squarespace, the all-in-one website platform that is
0:14:15designed to help you stand out and succeed online.
0:14:18Whether you're just getting started or scaling a business, Squarespace will give you everything
0:14:22that you need to claim your domain, showcase your offerings of a professional website,
0:14:26grow your brand and get paid all in one place.
0:14:30With Squarespace, you can offer your services and get paid.
0:14:32From consultations to events and experiences, you can showcase your offerings of a customizable
0:14:37website that is designed to attract clients and grow your business.
0:14:41Think about built-in appointment scheduling, email marketing tools, and so much more.
0:14:46You can keep everything cohesive with on brand invoices and get paid easily with
0:14:51online payments.
0:14:52You can also make smarter business decisions with Squarespace's analytics tools.
0:14:56That'll help you keep track of the stats that matter with intuitive built-in analytics
0:15:01tools that make it super easy for you to review website traffic, learn where
0:15:04to focus your engagement and track revenue from bookings, invoices, or product sales all
0:15:09in one place.
0:15:10They're all in one place.
0:15:11That is what I love about Squarespace.
0:15:13They have everything that you're gonna need and they put it all in a
0:15:15beautiful package.
0:15:16It's very easy to understand and it will grow alongside you and the needs
0:15:20for your website and business.
0:15:22Don't take my word for it though.
0:15:24Go to squarespace.com slash upgrade and you can sign up for a free trial
0:15:28when you're ready to launch and you could build your whole website on this
0:15:31free trial.
0:15:31And then when you're ready to launch it to the world, use the offer
0:15:34code upgrade to save ten percent of your first purchase of a website or
0:15:38domain.
0:15:38That's squarespace.com slash upgrade and the offer code upgrade to get ten percent of
0:15:43your first purchase and show you support for the show.
0:15:46A thanks to Squarespace for their support of this show and all of Relay.
0:15:52So on last week's episode, we had what I thought was a really great
0:15:56aside when we were talking about Apple's progress to making a fitness band, where
0:16:02we questioned why does it take Apple years to get a product to market?
0:16:06Like if they think this is hot, they have the resources they have, why
0:16:10not rush?
0:16:11Why not better structure yourself to deliver products quicker?
0:16:16The next day, Mark Gurman reported John Turnus's plan to do exactly that.
0:16:22So I'm gonna give some information here.
0:16:24We're gonna go through it.
0:16:24So John Turnus is indicating to other executives that he wants the company to
0:16:29accelerate product development, broaden the range of products that the company makes, and become
0:16:34a leaner organization that has a much greater focus on engineering.
0:16:38Doesn't sound like exactly what you would do if you were John Turner?
0:16:41Right.
0:16:41Like it feels like if you've come from that organization, he is taking all
0:16:46of the frustrations that he has had, right?
0:16:48Yeah.
0:16:48Or may have had.
0:16:50Comes in and he's like, Great, now it's my turn.
0:16:53You know, and we're gonna do it the way that we're gonna do it.
0:16:55So as part of this, the company is considering relying also less on the
0:17:00traditional spring and fall release schedules releasing more products throughout the year.
0:17:05So focusing less.
0:17:06I'm sure stuff like iPhones, right, will continue to be where they are.
0:17:10I guess we now have these two spots, but not to just focus everything
0:17:15in that time.
0:17:17Uh I was listening to
0:17:19maybe it was dithering and they were talking about releasing products in the fall.
0:17:25And like if you release something at that time of year, you're indicating the
0:17:29idea that it's gonna be a Christmas product.
0:17:31So it has to have a lot of units.
0:17:33So I was thinking, you know, like we talk about fitness band.
0:17:36Well, if you can't you know, it's gonna take you time to get it
0:17:39up and running, why not just start small?
0:17:41Well then release it in February, right?
0:17:44Scale up for the rest of the year.
0:17:45Like you don't have to release every product in the holiday season, so you
0:17:49sell millions of them.
0:17:50Um so it's interesting thought.
0:17:52Uh Turnus also wants to eliminate some middle management positions to aid faster decision
0:17:58making and keep any engineers in closer contact with key decision makers directly.
0:18:03There are some reports from German that Turnus has for years felt that Apple
0:18:08has hired too many people and feels that they do not produce enough to
0:18:12warrant the size of the organization.
0:18:15Uh we were talking about this a little bit before and and and I
0:18:19hadn't read the full report, I read it this morning.
0:18:22And you had mentioned that you think that Gurman's basically got sources in the
0:18:25HR team.
0:18:26Yeah.
0:18:26And as I was reading through that, I'm like, ah yeah, I see it.
0:18:29It he knows so much about these issues of hiring and and layoffs and
0:18:35recruitment.
0:18:37And
0:18:39I think it's I it always sticks out to me because while Bloomberg is
0:18:42a business publication.
0:18:43Yeah.
0:18:44Um sometimes some of the details that German gets feel like they're I don't
0:18:50know how to say it.
0:18:52They're they're really like
0:18:54What almost what you'd expect in like a tech insider uh in industry newsletter,
0:19:02more than what we tend to look for Bloomberg and Mark German for.
0:19:07It's almost like hey, what's scuttle bud?
0:19:10Who who's hiring and who's getting laid off?
0:19:13And it feels like sports reporting sometimes, right?
0:19:17Where it's like this key player's going to this one and the transfer window.
0:19:21Who are the winners and who are the losers?
0:19:22And I think part of it is just the effect of his sources distorting
0:19:27his reporting a little bit.
0:19:29And again or just being what he has to report.
0:19:32Well, well, this is this is what I mean.
0:19:33I don't distorted factually.
0:19:35I mean if if you go fishing for Apple News and your job is
0:19:40to find Apple News, which Mark Gurman's is, and you come back with a
0:19:44big basket of HR transactions, you're gonna cover the HR transactions even though I
0:19:53look at it and think we probably give more emphasis to his reporting on
0:19:57this subject
0:19:59than we would otherwise because it's coming from him and because of what else
0:20:03he reports.
0:20:04It just feels a little imbalanced to me.
0:20:06But yes, so he's in there saying there were layoffs in this group.
0:20:09And again, I had that uh that thought, which is like this is the
0:20:11kind of thing you see in the newsletter, uh the industry newsletter about oh,
0:20:15group X at company Y had a layoff and group B executive went to
0:20:20group C.
0:20:21And I don't always think that the narratives that get built around that make
0:20:26a lot of sense.
0:20:28It's the function of Apple being so secretive, though, that any information is newsworthy.
0:20:32Of course.
0:20:32And so that's why like yeah, the idea that there were three hundred layoffs
0:20:35in the Siri teams, like you can just report that it's like it's not
0:20:39the exact number, but there you know, oh there's layoffs in the series team,
0:20:42there's layoffs in in Yeah, no.
0:20:43And and and um but it just i i the emphasis of it like
0:20:47I yeah, I texted you when that that came out and I just said,
0:20:50Well, if we if we ever doubted Mark German's sources in the HR department,
0:20:55I think you can't read that story and not read it that way.
0:20:57And that's fine, but it just seems weird because it's much better to get
0:21:01the why is John Turnus motivated to do what he's doing because I think
0:21:06I could argue that there are a bunch of places where Apple is seems
0:21:10to be really understaffed.
0:21:12Although as an outsider it may be that it's not efficiently staffed.
0:21:15It may be that the people that it was easy to hire some kinds
0:21:19of staff and not others.
0:21:20And that may be true because sometimes I do feel like Apple, right?
0:21:24We talked about this with their software all the time.
0:21:26If you're gonna be so ambitious to have all these additional first party apps,
0:21:32all of these things, we were spending time before we got started trying to
0:21:35set up Final Cut Camera.
0:21:36Oh God.
0:21:37And and we just as the last time we tried this An incredible tool.
0:21:42That feels like it is built on a house of cards.
0:21:44Yeah.
0:21:45If one thing goes wrong, everything goes wrong.
0:21:47We failed to connect a third camera, uh exactly as we failed to connect
0:21:51it um a year ago.
0:21:54And
0:21:55different cameras to different phones.
0:21:57It's not like it was the same phone each time, right?
0:22:00Different phones.
0:22:01So
0:22:02that's what that kind of stuff when we talk about it.
0:22:05I feel like either be ambitious and hire staff to behave like how Apple
0:22:10would do this product
0:22:13or don't do it, but instead they a lot of times they, you know,
0:22:16they we've talked about this a lot.
0:22:18They launch it and then it's like they forget it.
0:22:20They retask or it's not enough task to be on it.
0:22:22And they're there and the worst the presence in the market of Apple um
0:22:26deters other people from trying to compete with them.
0:22:28And Apple doesn't really try hard enough.
0:22:30And we'll end we'll end up with this kind of like broken middle ground.
0:22:33Um so there are cases where I would say Apple's hiring practices are really
0:22:37messed up because they're trying to do too much with too little.
0:22:40However, I think that it's also probably true what Mark Erman reports here, that
0:22:45you look at some of this stuff and you think, why?
0:22:50I mean, I you you I understand that at some point a few years
0:22:54ago hiring all these people made sense because we thought we were going to
0:22:57do this, but now we're not.
0:23:00So uh let's not keep them around.
0:23:04If those rules don't make sense, we should just say so and be more
0:23:08efficient there.
0:23:10But uh and and I again I think the flip side of that as
0:23:14in and invest in other areas where we actually think it's And it also
0:23:18feels like particularly as well as just like a general reshuffling, which apparently has
0:23:23been doing a lot more of, it seems like Turnus is keen to remove
0:23:28specific functions, like middle management positions.
0:23:32And And just like looking at this from a business perspective, right?
0:23:36Or from a pu f guess from the personal side first, I never want
0:23:40anyone to lose their job.
0:23:41But
0:23:43I think anyone that's worked in a corporate position, you have, I have.
0:23:48Everybody feels that there are management functions that get in the way of the
0:23:53work being done.
0:23:54Like I think it is a very normal feeling.
0:23:56I know I had it when I worked in the corporate world.
0:23:58I see it now in interacting with corporations you know, companies that we work
0:24:02with, where like you can feel that there's someone that's trying to get something
0:24:06done.
0:24:07There's someone in the middle, and then there's the decision maker.
0:24:10And that person in the middle has their own agenda.
0:24:13Yeah.
0:24:14They have their own targets they need to hit at the times that they
0:24:16need to hit them, or they're not very good at the job.
0:24:18And that can be a blocker to the work being done.
0:24:21And it it often springs from a good impulse, which is I've got somebody
0:24:26who's really good and they need another task and I'm gonna I'm gonna delegate
0:24:29some of the work to them as a manager.
0:24:30Or we have too many people in this organization, one person can't manage them.
0:24:34So that person needs four managers to manage the people in the organization.
0:24:38Like this is very natural this like shrinking and contracting.
0:24:41He will, you know, turn us will maybe get rid of a bunch of
0:24:44these people.
0:24:45In five years' time, they'll bring some in again because it got unruly.
0:24:48It's like a very normal like ebb and flow.
0:24:51Yeah, this happens.
0:24:52We were just talking about this as well like a couple couple of days
0:24:54ago like w in regards to s to something I don't remember what it
0:24:58was, but this idea of like someone comes in, they have a bunch of
0:25:01ideas, uh and then they're like, oh, what about this?
0:25:05And then it doesn't work and a person goes away.
0:25:07New person comes in.
0:25:08Here's an idea, you know, and it's very normal.
0:25:11Yeah, th this this is just a a cycle of it.
0:25:13And when I said when when he was l coming in, I said there's
0:25:19gonna be natural change because there's some stuff that just remains static because It's
0:25:24just the way we've always done it.
0:25:25And Tim Cook isn't interested in getting his hands dirty on that stuff.
0:25:30And now here's a new CEO and he's got his list of things that
0:25:35he doesn't like about how Apple has been run for the last five or
0:25:39ten years.
0:25:40And he gets to decide now.
0:25:42Yeah.
0:25:43I don't know that these are the right decisions.
0:25:45No.
0:25:45I wanted him to clearly be making decisions immediately.
0:25:48Yes.
0:25:49Right.
0:25:49The and like these things take a long time to put into effect.
0:25:53But if if you know, we're this point in and it's like Noir Girl
0:25:57report, Turners is keeping his hand on the wheel, even Keel, no change.
0:26:01It's like okay, is that the right necessarily the right way to do things?
0:26:06Like I I feel like I wanted to see him shake it up.
0:26:09And so more.
0:26:10Turners has indicated that Apple must introduce products more quickly and become more experimental
0:26:16to remain competitive in the Apple intelligence era.
0:26:19Artificial intelligence, sorry.
0:26:21Artificial intelligence.
0:26:22I think I think we're in the United States we're supposed to call this
0:26:25uh something else.
0:26:26Isn't it like super intelligence?
0:26:27Mega intelligence now?
0:26:28Yes.
0:26:29Because AI's not not enough.
0:26:30Machine learning wasn't enough so we have to call it AI.
0:26:33No, AI's not enough, so we have to call it like Superintelligence.
0:26:36To get us closer to A E I, right?
0:26:38'Cause we've got to be up a level now.
0:26:40I yeah.
0:26:40Anyway, this is I I can't tell you how many people texted this to
0:26:44me because we literally talked about it on upgrade last week.
0:26:49S sometimes we have conversations like that's a good conversation and then something happens
0:26:53like, Oh, that was a really good conversation.
0:26:55So yeah, I said to a couple people, like, Yeah you know, friend of
0:26:57the show, John Turnus, he's uh he's out there doing stuff.
0:27:00Yep.
0:27:01That but I mean it it it certainly felt that way to us as
0:27:05observers that that it wasn't good enough.
0:27:07If I and I and I ranted about this last week and I ranted
0:27:10about this about a year ago, but it's the same the short version of
0:27:12the rant is if I on the outside can be like, Well, wait a
0:27:16second.
0:27:16If if it's obvious that Apple needs to do X and Mark German then
0:27:20reports in Bloomberg.
0:27:22Apple's working on X.
0:27:23See it in two years.
0:27:24Something's wrong.
0:27:25Yeah.
0:27:25See it in two years is not an answer.
0:27:28And we talked about the iPod, I which I know it's different era, but
0:27:32like the iPod got done from nothing to a shipping product in 11 months.
0:27:37Yeah.
0:27:37So what are we doing here?
0:27:39And I and if I were John Turnus, 100% this is one of the
0:27:42things that I would come in with is we need not every product needs
0:27:45to be like this, but we need to be to have the skills to
0:27:49fast track a product.
0:27:50If and and what better example, talking about Mark Erman says the artificial intelligence
0:27:56era, whether a product is specifically AI or not,
0:28:00the artificial intelligence era has taught us something which On a software side, let's
0:28:05take software.
0:28:06Apple has this whole approach, which is like, Well what we do is we
0:28:11think of what we're gonna do for the next year.
0:28:13And then we roll that out in June.
0:28:17And then we ship it in September.
0:28:19And then the next June we roll out whatever's gonna happen for the next
0:28:23September.
0:28:24And in the artificial intelligence era, you can't do that.
0:28:28Yeah, you can't do so slow.
0:28:29You can't you can't do it that way.
0:28:31And they they got really comfortable and for a while they could afford to
0:28:34do it that way.
0:28:35Yeah.
0:28:35But you can't.
0:28:36And so if you're gonna come in and be the new boss, whether it's
0:28:39hardware or software, and I would say it's both, you need to say, Look,
0:28:43not everything, I'm not saying there's gonna be a new iOS, you know, version
0:28:49that's like a WW D D C drop but it's every three months, right?
0:28:52Of course it's not.
0:28:53We're not gonna do that.
0:28:54But like if there's a crash thing we have to do, we need to
0:28:56be flexible enough to do that.
0:28:58And if there's crash hardware thing we need to do, we need to have
0:29:01the skills and the capability to do that.
0:29:03And the word experimental here, become more experimental, I think is also code for
0:29:08saying, let's try some stuff.
0:29:10Yeah.
0:29:11And it doesn't all have to be
0:29:15because I think they set the bar so high that they're basically like, unless
0:29:18something clears this incredibly high bar, they just don't do it.
0:29:21And it's a mistake.
0:29:22It's a problem.
0:29:23Like this WWDC cycle has been such a
0:29:29perfect example of the speed of the era of technology that we're in.
0:29:33So when they showed off Siri uh Siri AI at WWDC.
0:29:37It's like, okay, they're you know, chatbots are state of the art, they're doing
0:29:41chatbots.
0:29:43Comes a time that it ships, now everyone's doing agents, right?
0:29:46So we've got Mews, dots.
0:29:48Right.
0:29:49Well, Apple doesn't have that.
0:29:50And and they may, you know, we know they struggle to get here.
0:29:54Yeah.
0:29:54But if you're at Apple,
0:29:57do you say to yourself,
0:30:00We had some agent features.
0:30:03They're not done but we're working on them.
0:30:06We were planning on showing them in June of 2027 and shipping them in
0:30:11mid-September of 2027.
0:30:14And do you look at Muse and say?
0:30:18We're gonna be there.
0:30:20Watch for us in September 2027 in a year's time.
0:30:25Or do you look at it and say, Yeah, we gotta fast track that.
0:30:28We gotta get that out.
0:30:29We got we gotta ship that.
0:30:30That's the priority now is to ship our take if you have one.
0:30:33And if you don't have one, don't you need to you you need to
0:30:36get one.
0:30:36Yeah, get one, but don't don't say we've been here before.
0:30:39Yeah.
0:30:40Don't say you've got it when you haven't got it.
0:30:41Yeah.
0:30:41But it's like again, I don't know that that is the right
0:30:45I don't know that's the right call.
0:30:47I I do think that this is an interesting product type, right?
0:30:51This like age like it's an interesting thing.
0:30:53Yeah.
0:30:54I don't know.
0:30:55I think there's agentic stuff that Apple could do, especially since the again their
0:30:58great advantages that it's on device.
0:31:01I don't want to share all of my personal data with Facebook, right?
0:31:04Like with Meta.
0:31:05I th there is not I can't think of a okay.
0:31:09X maybe.
0:31:11You know, but it's close.
0:31:12There's very few companies that I would l rank rank lower on trust.
0:31:16You want to log into your Gmail and access your iMessage history.
0:31:19Exactly.
0:31:20So I
0:31:22think Meta may actually be the worst because I I do not believe X
0:31:25is competent enough to deal with that.
0:31:27Uh but but meta
0:31:29we've seen.
0:31:30Well they they're competent enough to deal with huge sets of data.
0:31:33They've committed many crimes, yes.
0:31:35So it could be one of those.
0:31:36So so this is It's just an it's it's just an example of the
0:31:41pace.
0:31:42Right?
0:31:43That three months ago, this what this was a fringe thing.
0:31:47Yeah.
0:31:47Open claw and all this kind of stuff.
0:31:49Now it is mass market, number one in the app store.
0:31:54Right.
0:31:54People want to try this thing.
0:31:56And as an example of the hardware thing, Nao Meta's like we're bringing out
0:32:00this little charm where you can talk to your thing and clearly well clear
0:32:04but most likely OpenAI's hardware product will use their agent tool and it's like
0:32:10well now they're gonna have these products and come out quickly, right?
0:32:13It's that speed thing.
0:32:14Right.
0:32:14So what are you gonna do?
0:32:15There's no way that Meta was thinking about this charm two years ago.
0:32:20Of course.
0:32:21Because they hadn't because their strategy for AI then was completely different to where
0:32:24they are now.
0:32:25So it's like it it's all of this isn't it's not saying that any
0:32:29of this makes any sense, but is an example of the speed and pace
0:32:33of technology now.
0:32:35You cannot be as slow as Apple has been.
0:32:38Exactly.
0:32:38They're being methodical, thoughtful, and have introduced products in the right way.
0:32:43But we are in a time of threat to their business.
0:32:47Because something could undermine them.
0:32:51Right.
0:32:52Right.
0:32:52I just don't know.
0:32:53And and again, it doesn't have to be everything.
0:32:56But if you don't have that other gear to shift into,
0:33:01you can't you just can't do it.
0:33:02You need that other gear, you need that other muscle, you need whatever metaphor
0:33:06you like, you need the Capability to choose, to pick your spots and say,
0:33:09Yep, we gotta go on this one.
0:33:11And I I think the example that I would give that is um is
0:33:15the best is if you've been talking internally, and I can't believe they haven't
0:33:20been, that age agent more agenty stuff is where they're going.
0:33:24If you look at like the describe a shortcut.
0:33:28Extensions.
0:33:29You look at the you look at extensions, if you look at the um
0:33:33all of the the shortcut action app stuff,
0:33:40it's hard not to think that they've always been sort of thinking the next
0:33:43step is the is applying models that use all your stuff.
0:33:48So you're working on it and you see this, the next step is saying
0:33:53and having the legitimately uh the legitimacy inside Apple to say,
0:33:59this can't go in iOS twenty-eight.
0:34:01It's gotta go in twenty-seven three or 27-4.
0:34:05And everybody's like, Whoa, are you kidding?
0:34:07Uh and you have to be able to say, No, we have to do
0:34:11this.
0:34:12This is important.
0:34:13Um, and and if we're incapable of doing this, what's wrong with our organization
0:34:18that we need to fix?
0:34:19Because that's and that's at the level of the CEO.
0:34:21Yeah.
0:34:21Or or somebody like Crick Federiki, if it's a software issue.
0:34:24It's like, if we're not structured in a way that allows us to react
0:34:28like this, how do we restructure?
0:34:29You do have to ask that fundamental question because yes you need to that
0:34:33is that's a good way of putting it.
0:34:35I it if the question isn't like if we can't do this, what's wrong
0:34:40with us?
0:34:41No.
0:34:41The question is if we can't do this, how do we do this?
0:34:43It's it Yes.
0:34:45It's gotta just be action.
0:34:46It's not about like, okay, let's have a review of the organization to work
0:34:50out where the flaws are.
0:34:51No, there's not enough time for that.
0:34:53Like you have to move and yes, break the idea of the annual operating
0:34:58cycle.
0:34:59I bring system cycle.
0:35:00And it's like I know so many people will say, Oh, but for years
0:35:04we said uh uh annual releases are too much.
0:35:07Yes, but that was when all of the code was written by humans and
0:35:10it's not anymore.
0:35:11That's also and we know it's not.
0:35:13So like the developers can move at a faster pace.
0:35:16So the operating system should move at a faster pace.
0:35:20And their competition is using those tools and moving at that pace.
0:35:23And you've gotta be able to do it.
0:35:25You just have to you have to be able again, not saying everything, but
0:35:28saying you gotta be able to pick key categories and say, We're gonna move
0:35:32fast on this one.
0:35:33When one of your biggest technology competitors is an app in your store that
0:35:37has been number one for weeks that's doing things that your device should do,
0:35:41maybe you need to think about that.
0:35:43And not just a competitor, like a Arch enemy.
0:35:47Arch enemy.
0:35:47I say mortal enemy, but that wasn't the the arch enemy.
0:35:50Like the the absolute inverse of your values.
0:35:54And you were offering that to people, right?
0:35:56Like you are the conduit for people putting this app on the device.
0:36:01You should be there.
0:36:02And like, especially when Siri AI's power is in the personal context, which is
0:36:09exactly what the agents are looking for.
0:36:11Right.
0:36:12And you've got it because you're Apple and no and and it's on your
0:36:15device and and people you have a better story, but you you have to
0:36:19implement it.
0:36:20And that is the yeah, I I think at the core
0:36:23That is what we're saying is you need to find a way to be
0:36:29better at this.
0:36:30Um, and and I do think it's probably structural, but that's just a guess
0:36:35from the outside.
0:36:36And and I do think it's empowering people on the inside to say, Okay,
0:36:40if this is important, how are we going to do this?
0:36:43Considering how much time we've spent talking about agents now, we've gone in a
0:36:47different direction.
0:36:47I've moved our topic order around in the shop.
0:36:50'Cause there is w we're gonna talk about the home hub, which you think
0:36:53maybe naturally ties in with turners moving faster, but we're talking so much about
0:36:57agents.
0:36:58I want to talk about this.
0:36:59Apple's posted to their developer website an article titled Update Updates to full disk
0:37:05access in Mac OS.
0:37:06I want to read it real quick.
0:37:07It's quite a short update, but I think it's get the context for it.
0:37:12We give developers powerful APIs to build incredible capabilities into their apps for Apple
0:37:17products, backed by a set of controls designed to protect users' private data.
0:37:21Full-disk access largely sidesteps these controls, bac in order to allow backup apps to
0:37:29function properly on the Mac.
0:37:31That's funny to say the Mac.
0:37:33I don't do that often.
0:37:34Anyway, some developers are using full disk access in ways that could put users
0:37:38at risk, exposing everywhere everything on their systems, including files, mail, messages, and even
0:37:44browsing history without users' full knowledge and understanding.
0:37:47For communication apps, this can also compromise the privacy of the people users are
0:37:51communicating with.
0:37:53Going forward, we will introduce additional controls to ensure that users who genuinely wish
0:37:58to grant an app this extra extraordinary level of access can only do so
0:38:03with very explicit user action.
0:38:05Addressing this is critical.
0:38:07As AI agents become increasingly capable and autonomous, the risks associated with this level
0:38:13of access will grow substantially.
0:38:15We are committed to ensuring users clearly understand these risks before granting such access
0:38:20so they can make informed decisions about their own data and privacy.
0:38:25Yeah.
0:38:26Now they I mean what's funny here is that they've done a lot.
0:38:29Like e full disk access
0:38:32they put it in the context here.
0:38:33It's look, this was really for backups.
0:38:36Okay.
0:38:37And they added a few years ago this idea that like if an app
0:38:41looked inside your photos folder, you got a pop-up that said, do you want
0:38:45to let this app look at your photos?
0:38:48Um and similar for some other sensitive areas of your system.
0:38:52So it seems to me that what's going to happen here is that Apple's
0:38:55going to say.
0:38:56We're gonna we need these agents are using uh a feature that was not
0:39:02intended for them to grant to take over everything on your system and look
0:39:08and sort through it.
0:39:09And Apple's like, we're not comfortable with this because this is not granular enough,
0:39:16which I think is fair enough.
0:39:18Um so it's interesting that they feel that they need to do this, but
0:39:23I mean the idea that you've got a program running on your system that
0:39:27can just look anywhere and do anything and run.
0:39:30I mean, I've done this with Claude Code sessions where it says, Oh yeah,
0:39:35I cause it I it went from me approving uh everything to you put
0:39:39it in auto mode and then you suddenly have this moment where they're like,
0:39:41Yeah, I'm running code, um, I'm running tests.
0:39:45It's very convenient, right?
0:39:46But it's like literally it's just running, it's typing things into your terminal now.
0:39:51And
0:39:52it it could tell you or it could not tell you.
0:39:55Well and also it's like, you know, these Muse, we're just talking about Mews.
0:40:00There are stories and of it going and looking inside of people's messages history.
0:40:05Right.
0:40:05Because what happened is in that one journalist story, they didn't grant grant it
0:40:10access to messages, but it had full disk access.
0:40:12So it just read the messages file.
0:40:14Yeah.
0:40:15So um so I get what Apple's doing here, and I think they need
0:40:18to do it.
0:40:18I also share John.
0:40:20Gruber's uh Power User Lament, which is basically like
0:40:24I mean, it's it's very much like uh the conversation we had about why
0:40:27Apple Security does a bunch of stuff to limit, you know, the apps you
0:40:31launch.
0:40:32And I grouse about that all the time, like oh, an unsigned app, and
0:40:35I've got to go here and I've got to go over here and all
0:40:37of that.
0:40:37But they did that because people were getting talked into approving those things by
0:40:42uh phishing attacks.
0:40:44And it was subverting their computers because they were walking them through Apple Security
0:40:48process.
0:40:48So Apple made its security process more complex so that it was harder to
0:40:53try to talk people through it.
0:40:55And the result is that if you want to run an app that's not
0:40:58signed and you're a power user, it's a pain now to do that.
0:41:03But I also understand why.
0:41:05And that's what this feels like to me, is that not too similar to
0:41:10a phishing scam sometimes when the chatbot is talking you through the things that
0:41:14you need to do.
0:41:15Exactly right.
0:41:16And and so I think
0:41:19I think it's the right thing to do because I think there are even
0:41:24in fact I'd say right now that's even sophisticated users are granting too much
0:41:29access
0:41:31to their computer.
0:41:32Well, like I said, I had that moment where I was running something in
0:41:34Claude Code and it was and it suddenly was like, Oh yeah, I compiled
0:41:38this thing and I went out on the internet and got this file and
0:41:41brought it back.
0:41:42And I'm just gonna know what I'm giving access to, but then it does
0:41:46things that I didn't expect it to do.
0:41:48Right.
0:41:48And if you if you set some trip wires, which it sounds like Apple
0:41:52is going to do so that the system, instead of just saying Here's what
0:41:56would you like to use this tool?
0:41:58Grant full access.
0:42:00Right.
0:42:00That's basically where we are.
0:42:01Is Apple feels like there is a barrier beyond which there's just one switch,
0:42:06which is full disk access.
0:42:08And it's like, good luck.
0:42:09And Apple's like
0:42:12we can't do that.
0:42:13Yeah.
0:42:13We can't full is too much.
0:42:15And so you create more tripwires where it's like, it's gonna do this.
0:42:20Are you okay?
0:42:21Are you really okay with that?
0:42:24And And I think I believe Apple when they say ultimately the goal is
0:42:29not to prevent Mac users from doing what they want with their computer.
0:42:33The goal, that's not the goal.
0:42:35The goal is to protect users from people or software doing things on their
0:42:40Mac that they don't understand or intend
0:42:45by warning them that this is a threshold that they're gonna cross over.
0:42:48Yeah.
0:42:49That they're gonna hit this tripwire.
0:42:50I think that's going on here.
0:42:51Yeah, the devil's in the details though, right?
0:42:53I mean you are an an I would say an advocate for removing some
0:42:58privacy permissions, and it seems like they're about to add a lot more.
0:43:03I know, and it bugs me and on And honestly, as a user of
0:43:06something like Clog Code,
0:43:09if
0:43:11I can't give a command and let it spin, but instead have to sit
0:43:16there and go, okay, okay, okay, okay.
0:43:20My experience is going to be worse, right?
0:43:24But I also, just as with the signing of apps, also I am willing
0:43:29to grant Apple some degree of latitude because I understand that in certain circumstances,
0:43:39I am not who they're trying to protect.
0:43:41I am going to be a
0:43:44little bit of a casualty in the sense of a little bit of inconvenience.
0:43:49In return for who knows how many users who got talked into installing malware.
0:43:55And, you know, when I talk to those security people, they say they've largely
0:43:59stopped that.
0:43:59They've largely solved that because they've erected enough barriers that it's too hard to
0:44:04talk somebody into this now.
0:44:06Well, that's great.
0:44:07Yeah.
0:44:08So
0:44:09we don't know how this is gonna
0:44:12end up.
0:44:12And I I do wonder if ultimately there will be A switch you can
0:44:18flip as a power user that will let you do this.
0:44:23But my guess is it will be much harder to do because the goal
0:44:26is not to not let people have power.
0:44:28The goal is to make it behind a barrier
0:44:33that regular people can't be talked into, right?
0:44:37It's this idea of like if somebody calls you on the phone, they can
0:44:41talk you into giving them a code or something that might steal money from
0:44:44the bank.
0:44:45But they probably can't talk you into
0:44:49buying a toy gun and painting it to look like a real gun and
0:44:53then walking into a bank and saying this is a stick-up, right?
0:44:57Somebody's gonna nobody's gonna do that.
0:44:58They're gonna be like, what are you talking about?
0:45:00Are you talking me into being a bank robber?
0:45:02I'm I'm not gonna do that, right?
0:45:04Um, there's a line beyond which nobody is gonna get talked into it, or
0:45:10almost nobody.
0:45:12So That's that seems to me is Apple's job is how do you build
0:45:17a system where if people want to do stuff, they can do it.
0:45:21But it's it's gonna be more inconvenient for us because it maybe it has
0:45:27to be because too many people are getting taken for a ride.
0:45:30And this is super dangerous.
0:45:31I mean, make no mistake, letting a a a coding agent or another active
0:45:37agent rifle through everything you do and have on your hard drive and run
0:45:43code
0:45:45seems bad.
0:45:46Yeah.
0:45:49It's all gonna be again, it's like I find it weird because 'Cause like
0:45:52devils into details.
0:45:54Uh, this post has no detail.
0:45:55It doesn't say what they're gonna do, when it's coming, or how it's gonna
0:45:59be implemented, which is interesting to me.
0:46:01It's like why did they post it now?
0:46:04Like, why are we seeing this now?
0:46:06We've no detail.
0:46:07Yeah.
0:46:08I mean, are they are they concerned that like something's gonna go wrong?
0:46:14I think they're seeing what some of these coding assistants are already doing in
0:46:17terms of a and and that story about Muse looking at the that person's
0:46:22Jason Aiton.
0:46:23Jason Aiton's uh messages file.
0:46:26I think I think they've been working on this already because they're concerned about
0:46:30this with the coding agents and now they feel like it's really getting out
0:46:33of hand and they need to get out in front of it.
0:46:35But that's a guess.
0:46:36And I you know, like you I hope that there are ways around it.
0:46:39I mean, say something like the photos prompt that pops up, you know, and
0:46:43it's like continue giving full access.
0:46:45Like that kind of thing is fine.
0:46:48But I don't want every experience that I have with cowork to be throwing
0:46:53up permissions prompts for me.
0:46:55I know.
0:46:56Right.
0:46:56And so like I just don't know what this is gonna look like.
0:46:58And something that's really interesting is so many people are using the Mac because
0:47:05of this, right?
0:47:06Right.
0:47:07And so what happens to all those Mac minis and closets that are just
0:47:12connected to codecs and because they I feel like Apple knows this is a
0:47:18competitive advantage for them.
0:47:19Yeah.
0:47:20So I I think that's why what they will probably do is erect a
0:47:25barrier that is higher, but that you there's still a switch back there that
0:47:29you can flip.
0:47:30And it may be, um we talked about the idea of doing a developer
0:47:35mode, maybe it's an agent mode, maybe it's something.
0:47:38It might I'm reminded of like when, for lots of stupid reasons, if you
0:47:42wanted to install audio hijack, you used to have to reboot
0:47:46into the recovery mode and then go to a special security setting and then
0:47:52and then check to lower your settings and then put in your password and
0:47:55then reset and then reboot and then install and then reboot again.
0:48:01It may be something like that.
0:48:02The problem here is if somebody's motivated enough to use this stuff, like this
0:48:08is this is that kind of nanny state argument, which is like in the
0:48:13end,
0:48:14if somebody wants to give Meta unfettered access to everything on their hard drive
0:48:20and the ability to write code and run it.
0:48:24At some point, if it's the Mac,
0:48:28you gotta let them, right?
0:48:29You gotta let 'em.
0:48:30Yeah.
0:48:30At some point.
0:48:31Yeah.
0:48:32And I will say, because I know people rush to pay panic about this
0:48:37stuff.
0:48:38Thus far on the Mac, Apple's take has been we will not stop you,
0:48:46but we may make it harder.
0:48:48And and I think that's what they're gonna go for here is they're gonna
0:48:51try to make that
0:48:54convenient switch for running on a Mac Mini in a closet somewhere
0:49:00behind something scary enough that most regular people are not gonna bother.
0:49:05There was something that I found very funny.
0:49:07Uh John Voorhees uh posted about this on Mac Stories, right?
0:49:11So he m he references how Apple says that full disk access was uh
0:49:18for backup apps to function on the desk.
0:49:20Yeah.
0:49:21And I'm just gonna read from Joan.
0:49:23This is nonsense.
0:49:24Looking at my MacBook Pro, only a handful of apps to which I've granted
0:49:28full disk access are backup apps.
0:49:30Others include, and I'll just skip ahead to the funny ones, Pixel Mata Pro,
0:49:34Test Flight, Madden NFL twenty seven arcade edition.
0:49:39And then obviously like things you'd expect, like Hazel and Setup.
0:49:42Well well yeah, but I mean this is the thing, right?
0:49:44Why does Madden have full disk access?
0:49:46And I think the argument would be that it absolutely shouldn't and maybe some
0:49:49of this is on Apple for allowing full disk access to get a little
0:49:53out of hand.
0:49:54That is the Apple arcade version of Madden.
0:49:56I'm sure.
0:49:57Which is it's just it's it's just why
0:50:00so that's part of the problem i is is that.
0:50:04Um also what is it?
0:50:06Something I saw somebody mention that there's actually some data that now full the
0:50:11the backup apps can't because it's kept in like an exclave and therefore is
0:50:16not reachable.
0:50:18So you can't back that stuff up.
0:50:19It's impossible.
0:50:21So we'll see what they do.
0:50:23We'll see what they do.
0:50:24But I think I think their goal is to find
0:50:28I think what they've realized is that full disk access became a catch-all.
0:50:33And it can't be anymore.
0:50:35Like it's gotten worse and worse and worse.
0:50:37And so to John's point, the
0:50:42His list of full disk access apps
0:50:45shows why full disk access has been broadly defined in a way that probably
0:50:50it shouldn't be.
0:50:51That there should be more granular permissions so that
0:50:56Madden doesn't need full disk access, right?
0:50:59Like that shouldn't it shouldn't be necessary.
0:51:01That's happening because I love that it does though.
0:51:03That's happening because there's some reason, or either somebody's taking a shortcut, or there's
0:51:07some reason that some file somewhere, but like it shouldn't ever be that way.
0:51:12So maybe they will address this so that full disk access because I I
0:51:15think what I would say is I think Apple always viewed full disk access
0:51:20as a thing they had to do because of backup.
0:51:22And then it got out of hand.
0:51:24That's my that's my read on that.
0:51:25Yeah.
0:51:27I wonder what the replacement is and how they enforce it.
0:51:32Like if you don't want Muse on the Mac to have full disk access,
0:51:36but you still want to offer full disk access.
0:51:38How do you stop them?
0:51:40By by building barriers that make most people not want to bother,
0:51:49or at the very least
0:51:51make them really, really, really, really, really, really sure that they know and approve
0:51:58of what their agent is doing.
0:52:00Yeah.
0:52:00And and I think those are the two options.
0:52:02Right?
0:52:03Because you can't get in the way of a backup app.
0:52:05Yeah.
0:52:06I know, but it might mean that to install a backup app now is
0:52:09going to be sort of like to install audio hijack where you're gonna have
0:52:13to do a bunch of steps in order to get that backup app.
0:52:17Yeah.
0:52:17I think it's uh an in A a somewhat strange decision to publish this
0:52:24with nothing.
0:52:26Yeah.
0:52:27Cause
0:52:29it is not I don't really think I mean maybe I'm not paying attention
0:52:34to the right places
0:52:36You know, the the the I would say somewhat minor controversies of what Muse
0:52:41is accessing right now, right?
0:52:44I don't really think people were saying, oh Apple.
0:52:47Like I don't really think there was fire on them in which they felt
0:52:49they needed to respond to this, but yet they have decided to do that.
0:52:55And I think of our i as with these things usually, it's just creating
0:53:00more questions than answers.
0:53:03I I look forward to seeing more.
0:53:06And and again, I guess this is between now and WWDC, right?
0:53:11Like you would assume, right?
0:53:13This is a sooner rather than later thing.
0:53:15If they're talking about it just on a Friday or whatever.
0:53:19Yeah, yeah.
0:53:20No, it'll be uh point two, point three.
0:53:23It'll be it'll be in introduced in there and maybe it's like optional to
0:53:26begin with, but this is a warning and then it'll get enforced at a
0:53:30later one.
0:53:30They they do that sort of thing with stuff like this.
0:53:32So yeah, we'll see.
0:53:34Or did i is it that or has um have agents ruined everything for
0:53:39everyone from now on?
0:53:40I don't know.
0:53:41Ye I mean probably.
0:53:43Yeah.
0:53:44But
0:53:45but
0:53:47maybe it'll be worth it in the end.
0:53:49I don't know.
0:53:51This episode is brought to you by Factor.
0:53:54Summer's in full swing.
0:53:55You know what that means.
0:53:56That means travel.
0:53:57We're traveling right now.
0:53:58I know when I travel, my uh my eating routine can get very disrupted.
0:54:03Uh I'm eating all kinds of things.
0:54:06When I get home again, I don't know about you, Jason, when I'm a
0:54:09trip where I've been eating lots of great food, I struggle to get back
0:54:13into my regular routine a little bit because I like continuing to eat the
0:54:18very good and easy food that's available to me.
0:54:22Sure.
0:54:22Wouldn't it be great if there was a healthier option, right?
0:54:24Yeah.
0:54:24For good and easy food.
0:54:27It would be good, Mike.
0:54:28Let me tell you about factor.
0:54:29Oh.
0:54:29Uh they make chef crafted, dietitian designed, ready to eat meals so you don't
0:54:33have to choose between real food and convenience.
0:54:36We've With over 175 banned ingredients, every factor meal is designed around what supports
0:54:41a healthier lifestyle and nothing that doesn't.
0:54:44Factor meals are ready in just two minutes and require no prep and no
0:54:47cleanup, so even on the days where your schedule is completely out of control
0:54:52eating well is still achievable.
0:54:54Every week you'll find over a hundred nutrition sorry, nutrient dense menu items to
0:55:00choose from, and new options like salmon burgers, shredded pork collard greens, and more,
0:55:05plus add-ons you'll crave like pumpkin-flavored cheesecakes and protein shakes.
0:55:0997% of users agree that factor meals help them live a healthier lifestyle, so
0:55:14you can feel confident that you're doing something good for yourself with each and
0:55:18every meal.
0:55:19Jason, I know the uh the Snell household.
0:55:22Still big fans of facta?
0:55:25Yeah, I mean the the you can't argue with the success of the meals
0:55:29coming sometimes and uh them just disappearing out the door.
0:55:33Yeah.
0:55:34Lauren works at the library every day and, you know, w if we don't
0:55:38have leftovers, then what are you doing for lunch?
0:55:41And, you know We got lots of podcast products in the house that are
0:55:44just like whatever.
0:55:45And uh those met with the seal of approval and then we got them
0:55:49for my mom because we were concerned about her nutrition as well.
0:55:52So like it it and I can say for myself that yeah, I'm impressed.
0:55:56I think it's goes down to the quality of the ingredients, but they taste
0:55:59they taste really good.
0:55:59Yeah.
0:56:00Let's eat real.
0:56:02Head to factor meals.com slash upgrade fifty off and use the code upgrade fifty
0:56:07off to get fifty percent off and one free breakfast item per box for
0:56:11one year with supplies while supplies last until October 31st, 2026.
0:56:17That's the code upgrade50Off at F-A-C-T-O-R-M-E-A-L S.com.
0:56:22Upgrade 50 off at factormeals.com.
0:56:25See the website for more details.
0:56:26Our thanks to Factor for their support of this show and all of Relay.
0:56:32New segment time.
0:56:34What's this new segment, Jason?
0:56:36This segment brought to you by Mountain Dew.
0:56:40Last year I opened the Mountain Dew during an ad read and you lost
0:56:45it.
0:56:46I did.
0:56:46Yeah, I did lose it because I was doing an ad read and I
0:56:49hear
0:56:52and I also think you did it accidentally directly into the microphone last time.
0:56:58So this time I thought I would wait and use it as a new
0:57:01segment to interstitial.
0:57:03The entire time during the ad, I'm seeing out the corner of my eye
0:57:07a man fondling about in two.
0:57:10And I had to keep it together.
0:57:11And I did.
0:57:12You did.
0:57:12We should all be proud of me.
0:57:14All right, so we're gonna go back to talking about new products now.
0:57:17Mark German is reporting that Apple is getting ready to debut its home hub
0:57:22on October 13th, just a little over a week away.
0:57:26We have more details.
0:57:28Things are a little bit more concrete now.
0:57:30The display will be roughly a six inch square, can be mounted on the
0:57:35wall or on a speaker base.
0:57:37The wall mounted version needs constant power via USB-C, there's no battery, and it
0:57:42includes the speaker and microphones in the unit.
0:57:45The device itself, in both configurations, will be able to recognize who approaches it
0:57:50or who's speaking, and will use this as the right as the way to
0:57:54give the right answers to questions that are asked and to show information on
0:57:59the screen.
0:58:00It does this by voice detection or facial recognition that's not face ID.
0:58:05So
0:58:07the photos app stuff basically.
0:58:09You know, like we've all seen this of like Jason's at the front.
0:58:12You don't have a video doorbell, do you?
0:58:14No.
0:58:14So we have a video doorbell.
0:58:16If I ring the doorbell
0:58:18for some reason in my own home, it pops up and says, Michael's at
0:58:23the door.
0:58:24Right?
0:58:24Like i or like it would do Adina's at the door.
0:58:27Or uh in twenty seven, the camera stuff is getting smarter and like our
0:58:33home camera or whatever, if it was to be on, it would say like
0:58:37Edina is in the living room or something.
0:58:40It it's you can see that they're they're doing some stuff here.
0:58:43Yeah.
0:58:44And I think that is probably what's going on for this product.
0:58:48Makes sense.
0:58:49Um but because this is less reliable, there will be a setting to require
0:58:53a secondary check via an iPhone for performing some action.
0:58:57So maybe it says like you ask for something, it's like you could say
0:59:01like, oh, to do this, like maybe, I don't know, send a message delete
0:59:05a calendar event, get face ID from your iPhone.
0:59:08I would also hope your Apple Watch could do this.
0:59:10Yeah, this is what I was thinking is is you there are a lot
0:59:12of signals here, right?
0:59:13Beyond face recognition.
0:59:15If the if the iPhone that is connected to that person is in Bluetooth
0:59:18range um, or a watch that is on by you know unlocked biometrically.
0:59:25By the way.
0:59:26The duo.
0:59:28And the watch unlock.
0:59:30Is there another little shooter drop with this maybe at some point?
0:59:35Maybe able to do face ID, facial recognition with the camera, and if you'rearing
0:59:39a watch it will unlock your phone?
0:59:41Maybe, although if you're wearing the watch.
0:59:44I know but it really takes that as a fallback.
0:59:48Okay.
0:59:48A lot has to fail before the watch on at least with the current
0:59:51iPhones
0:59:53with a face ID, there is a pretty significant step process to go through
0:59:59before the watch and lock actually triggers and it makes a big deal about
1:00:04it and I'm I'm I continue as you can tell I'm still in copium.
1:00:08I am continuing to hope for some kind of better experience than just touch
1:00:13ID.
1:00:13But nevertheless, we're gonna talk about it right now.
1:00:16Quote from Mark Gurman.
1:00:17Apple envisions customers placing several of these displays throughout their homes.
1:00:22They could be used to control thermostats, door locks, and other connected products, as
1:00:26well as for video calls, intercom style communication, music playback, and viewing slideshows or
1:00:31photos stored in Apple's iCloud service.
1:00:33Of course, they would like us to have several Chris R.
1:00:37Holmes.
1:00:38Um
1:00:39I left out until now Mark's updated description, and this is actually pretty significantly
1:00:45updated description of the standalone tabletop version.
1:00:50The hub is about as thick as an iPhone, the screen, and its display
1:00:54is surrounded by a quarter inch black bezel reminiscent of older iPads.
1:00:58It has rounded corners, no sharp edges.
1:01:00The device lacks a battery, so it also has to be plugged in at
1:01:03all times.
1:01:03There's no volume or power button.
1:01:05The product comes in Apple's standard grey aluminium finish and includes a USB-C port
1:01:10for power.
1:01:11The screen sits above a metal round base with multiple rings of perforated speaker
1:01:16holes and connects to and connects to it through a polished metal arm.
1:01:22Users can manually tilt the display forward or backwards, and the base has a
1:01:26rubberized bottom to help it stay on a table.
1:01:29Are they making an IMAC G four?
1:01:33Maybe.
1:01:34I think it sounds like it, right?
1:01:36Maybe.
1:01:36And wouldn't that be a very interesting way to debut a product like this
1:01:41is a nostalgia hit.
1:01:43Mm-hmm.
1:01:44Very Very interesting.
1:01:45Very interesting.
1:01:46Especially when you consider the tabletop robot.
1:01:48Yeah.
1:01:48That Mark German says is coming next year and isn't a robot.
1:01:52Another product under development is an upgraded version of the home hub.
1:01:55It pairs a larger nine inch display with a robotic arm that allows the
1:01:59screen to move through space.
1:02:01What an interesting matter.
1:02:06Through space?
1:02:07I don't that didn't hit me so much when I read it the first
1:02:10time.
1:02:11Just like why not just move around, Mark?
1:02:13Yeah into another dimension.
1:02:16The display on the more advanced model was designed to swivel three hundred and
1:02:21sixty degrees.
1:02:21So th do you remember a really long time ago we had a conversation
1:02:26about I think it was a combination of rumors and a research paper of
1:02:29the device being able to turn at you.
1:02:31Yeah.
1:02:32It's this, right?
1:02:33Yeah.
1:02:34Yeah.
1:02:34This is the idea here is that it it the a future one would
1:02:38be like that G four I Mac in its animated Pixar version.
1:02:42Moving through space.
1:02:43Through moving through space and time.
1:02:46As we all do.
1:02:47We all do.
1:02:48From as the home hub world.
1:02:49Yes.
1:02:50And it makes sense too the display's bigger.
1:02:52Like that will be your pro version of this thing, right?
1:02:54Like or or whatever it's gonna be.
1:02:58Super interesting.
1:02:59The operating system for the home hubs, and going back to the one that
1:03:01that hopefully will be unveiled next week, is a mixture of iPad like app
1:03:06designs, so kind of making use of the space.
1:03:08We've watched OS style kind of app icon launcher.
1:03:11Mm-hmm.
1:03:12Has a lot of widgets in the home screen UI.
1:03:15Some clock designs and photo slideshows that are apparently very reminiscent of the new
1:03:20stabby mode shown with the iPhone Duo.
1:03:23This is a real like buffet of features going to this product.
1:03:26Yeah, yeah.
1:03:27And obviously Siri AI all over the place.
1:03:29Of course.
1:03:30Yeah.
1:03:30Of course.
1:03:31Why this thing's been delayed for like seven years.
1:03:33No coincidence that probably the work that went into this and the iPhone Duos
1:03:37standby mode are probably the same or using the same APIs and stuff.
1:03:42'Cause that Apple loves to re reuse pieces of And also just the the
1:03:47this product up and down is kind of an omission of some stuff of
1:03:51like what they needed their AI experience to be and also that my word,
1:03:56do not build another platform.
1:03:58Yeah.
1:03:59We don't need another app store.
1:04:01No.
1:04:02Apparently Apple's gonna have versions of its own apps on there.
1:04:04I don't know what that means for third parties, but I expect widgets.
1:04:10Like I you know, like
1:04:12how is Spotify on this, right?
1:04:14Like how are we getting there?
1:04:16How is YouTube on this?
1:04:19Is it just app mirror like this is there has to be a story
1:04:23there, right?
1:04:24But I don't think the story is home hub OS, home hub app store.
1:04:28Like it I don't think that's what we're we're gonna get.
1:04:32It's possible that there's a since this is rumored to be based on a
1:04:38version of T V OS, I do wonder if maybe the solution to the
1:04:43App Store problem
1:04:45is something weird like a paired app.
1:04:51So follow me here.
1:04:52You say, what about Spotify?
1:04:54Well, if you've got Spotify in your iPhone, I I wonder if a developer
1:04:58will be able to generate something that's very like a T V OS app
1:05:03that is coply.
1:05:04Ex that that is in well and maybe even that is a part of
1:05:09the package.
1:05:10Yeah.
1:05:11That is a binary that gets synced like on an Apple Watch, gets synced
1:05:16to the device.
1:05:18I if you imagine if we take whatever OS this is out of it
1:05:21and just imagine it's Apple TV, what if apps didn't go on your Apple
1:05:25TV through the App Store app on the Apple TV?
1:05:28What if they went on your Apple TV because your Apple TV is connected
1:05:31to an iPhone?
1:05:32And if the iPhone loads the Spotify app and there's an Apple TV Spotify
1:05:35app, Spotify shows up on your Apple TV, right?
1:05:38That they could do that.
1:05:39That's fairly straightforward.
1:05:40They could do that with this, where there's no app store for it.
1:05:44But if you're a div but there's a developer story, and the developer story
1:05:48is everybody, you know, everybody who connects to this thing.
1:05:53Is gonna have an iPhone and the iPhone app will be able to extrude
1:06:00something, a widget, maybe even an app, some kind of experience to the device.
1:06:05Maybe it's projection like CarPlay or maybe it's like a little watch app that
1:06:11just kind of like goes, Yeah.
1:06:13I know you can open the app store on the watch, right?
1:06:16But you can also just But that was a mistake.
1:06:19Yeah, exactly.
1:06:20But but like for the most part, what happens is you download the iPhone
1:06:23app.
1:06:23And then in the watch app, you say, put the watch app on this
1:06:27thing.
1:06:28They they go together, essentially.
1:06:30I could see them doing something like that.
1:06:31So that, for example, Spotify or Netflix or Prime Video or whatever, that that's
1:06:40how they would do it.
1:06:41And and it wouldn't, and it wouldn't surprise me if
1:06:46under the covers it was basically a TV app.
1:06:52Yeah.
1:06:52Yeah.
1:06:53But but what they shouldn't do is make it like
1:06:58a platform where the user is now managing a new set of apps and
1:07:02stuff like that.
1:07:03Like that needs to not be.
1:07:04Or making it even a a a platform that every developer feels they need
1:07:08to have some kind of thing for.
1:07:09Right.
1:07:09Like it's you are basically if you don't exist on TV OS, you probably
1:07:14don't need to be here.
1:07:15I think that's probably true.
1:07:17You know, with some basic exceptions.
1:07:20Maybe if you're a to-do app or something or a calendar app, you might
1:07:23want to have something, but maybe your widgets enough.
1:07:25Maybe your widget isn't this is the thing of like how much of this
1:07:28app is native stuff, how much of it is projecting from somewhere?
1:07:31Like these are the stories we need to know.
1:07:33But it's clear that they seem to be making a lot of decisions that
1:07:38mean that if you do something in another place, you probably can do it
1:07:42here as well.
1:07:43Right?
1:07:43Like if they kinda look like iPad apps.
1:07:45Right.
1:07:46And there's it's like you're not building this unique experience for this thing.
1:07:50It's not like the Apple Watch, say, where where it's different.
1:07:53So an interactive widget would work, a little mini app would work.
1:07:57Um if it's not there on day one, I suspect that that's where they're
1:08:01going with it.
1:08:02And that's that's that's great.
1:08:04Either either way, right?
1:08:04Like how they engineer it isn't the point.
1:08:06The point is if you do have a third party app, you're ultimately gonna
1:08:09want to be on there in some form.
1:08:11Yeah.
1:08:11And they're gonna want you there.
1:08:12They are gonna want you there.
1:08:14But I don't think it's gonna be here's our new platform, right?
1:08:17A completely new app that's unlike anything you've ever done before.
1:08:19It'll either be like a widget or it'll be like a TV app or
1:08:22it'll be like an iPhone app.
1:08:24And again, my gut feeling is it's either gonna project or it's going to
1:08:28be like a little thing that gets synced up to the device.
1:08:30Future of the home is apps.
1:08:32Oh God.
1:08:33You said about the app store on on Watch OS.
1:08:36What what world were we heading towards that like the watch needed to be
1:08:42really signposted as a standalone device.
1:08:45Why why was that well that was a thing we cared about?
1:08:48That was a real weird time, but I think it says something about Apple
1:08:54getting stuck in a rut, right?
1:08:57And I think this is
1:09:00I think it's it's telling about Apple's approach to the app store in general
1:09:04and a lot of the a lot of this is when I talk about
1:09:06change and about Tim and all these other executives that have been there for
1:09:09so long and them leaving being a good thing, even if they did a
1:09:13good job being a good thing.
1:09:15The Apple Watch, which is a long time ago now, but twelve years ago
1:09:18but l it's a good example of this, where the Apple Watch having an
1:09:21app story and an app store is so much about Apple saying, Well, obviously
1:09:27our customers have spoken and every device that we ever make should have an
1:09:30app store.
1:09:32And it shouldn't.
1:09:34But that said, I do use Apple.
1:09:36Watch apps.
1:09:37So there being apps is totally fine and makes a lot of sense.
1:09:42But like
1:09:43just like th this thought that there had to be a browsing experience.
1:09:49Yeah, exactly.
1:09:49And like that was required for it to be considered a standalone device.
1:09:54Right?
1:09:54Like anyone was ever gonna be like, I'm just an Apple Watch user.
1:09:59Yeah.
1:10:00Right.
1:10:00Very strange.
1:10:01No, it's it's it's nonsense.
1:10:02And it's true twelve years later.
1:10:04You still have to do that.
1:10:04They never actually did the last part.
1:10:06Yeah.
1:10:06Right?
1:10:07Which was that you could just take it out of the box.
1:10:09I think it's just a misconception.
1:10:10I think I think they it was just a different part they were playing
1:10:13the hits.
1:10:13It was a different part It was the path that led to there's an
1:10:17app store for the TV, there's app store for iMessage, there's an app store
1:10:20for Vision OS.
1:10:22Also, I'll give you I'll give you a little bit of a hot take
1:10:25here.
1:10:25Love it.
1:10:26Which is
1:10:27I am not a fan of the this would never happen if Steve Jobs
1:10:31were alive stuff, right?
1:10:32But if there's ever a product that Steve Jobs would have said no to,
1:10:35it was the Apple Watch as it was conceived in 2014.
1:10:41Because Nobody said no to anything.
1:10:45The Apple Watch was all things to all people.
1:10:47That first the my my standard joke about the 2014 Apple Watch launch, which
1:10:52was, by the way, my last day at Macworld, um, was what doesn't it
1:10:57do?
1:10:57Yeah.
1:10:58Because it did everything.
1:10:59It it had everything.
1:11:01It it didn't do any of them well, but it did everything.
1:11:04And that was a mistake.
1:11:06Like they couldn't pick or they refused to pick or different people my theory,
1:11:11different people in positions of power couldn't agree on omitting somebody's pet feature.
1:11:17So they put it all in there, including digital touch.
1:11:20And in hindsight, it's like
1:11:24I mean in hindsight, we've learned what the Apple Watch is good and bad.
1:11:29It's it's an i it's an iPhone accessory that can run software synced from
1:11:35your iPhone, but probably not very much of it and not too sophisticated.
1:11:39And it sinks back and and you use it for notifications and health and
1:11:45activity.
1:11:46Yep.
1:11:47Like w and and they might have gotten it wrong back then but they
1:11:51didn't try to simplify.
1:11:54They just did everything.
1:11:55So and but I think it uh it shows you Apple got so much
1:12:00success from the App Store
1:12:02that a lot of people in Apple just got real app store brained.
1:12:06Like everything, you know that people talk about like software brain, how people get
1:12:09this kind of like broken view of the world because they think everything is
1:12:12software and it's not.
1:12:14Apple totally got app store brained, where the solution to everything was an app
1:12:18store.
1:12:19And the future of T V is apps.
1:12:21It just it was an it was an app store for iMessage.
1:12:25I know.
1:12:25Why were they not just apps that could put things in iMessage?
1:12:30Again.
1:12:32Yeah, it's it's I I don't know.
1:12:35I can't remember how I felt about it at the time, right?
1:12:39Whether I thought it was ridiculous or not.
1:12:41I think I was excited about some of the things that it enabled, like
1:12:44the iMessage App Store, but the fact that there's an app there was an
1:12:48app store for iMessage
1:12:51that you got to in the iMessage in underneath the keyboard, there was an
1:12:56app store.
1:12:57There was an app store.
1:12:58He can just lift one up and that's an app store.
1:13:01What am I doing?
1:13:01Forget it, Mike.
1:13:02It's App Store brain.
1:13:03That's just it's believable times.
1:13:05I mean this is this is I mean, you could see it.
1:13:07It's in hindsight, it's very clear.
1:13:08Apple just decided to apply an App Store to everything as if that was
1:13:11the answer.
1:13:12And then what happened is over time the amount of apps submitted to these
1:13:16app stores got smaller and smaller.
1:13:18And then we got television.
1:13:20The future of computing, there are no apps.
1:13:23There are no apps.
1:13:24So this is the thing that we and all our upgradian friends should watch
1:13:31about this home hub.
1:13:32Yes.
1:13:33Is what is the app story, or perhaps what is the not app story?
1:13:40Because
1:13:41you're going to your point you're going to want to do things with this
1:13:45thing that are not supported by Apple's apps.
1:13:49So what happens?
1:13:50But like again, if it's really an Apple ecosystem play and you can take
1:13:56an iPhone or, you know, maybe eventually an iPad or something, and sync it
1:14:00and sync something to it, a widget, a a little app extension,
1:14:06that's all you need.
1:14:08Um
1:14:09but but yeah, this is this is like a real question of how Apple
1:14:13thinks about a device like this, because I don't think it should have an
1:14:18app story.
1:14:18And the reports are that it doesn't have an app story.
1:14:23But if not then what?
1:14:25What what is the answer?
1:14:26Otherwise.
1:14:27I don't know.
1:14:28But it will be really interesting to see.
1:14:30Well, we're not very far away now.
1:14:31Apparently it's next week.
1:14:33So So that's wild.
1:14:35Yeah.
1:14:36Bearing in mind we're recording early.
1:14:37I mean it's very unlikely that before the episode comes out on Monday that
1:14:41they'll start inviting the media.
1:14:43But just just as a note, right?
1:14:44Like we don't know very soon potentially, and we are recording a couple of
1:14:48days in advance.
1:14:49Yeah.
1:14:51This episode is brought to you by Design in California.
1:14:54Oh, it's a podcast that we make.
1:14:56Uh this week's episode of Design in California is the final in our series
1:15:01on Apple's macOS crisis.
1:15:03So at this point, Gil Emilio, Steve Jobs, they just need to finalize their
1:15:07deal, announce it to the world that next is going to be joining Apple
1:15:11and become the foundation of the Mac.
1:15:14But is Steve happy?
1:15:17Is he happy, Jason?
1:15:18What is in the mind of Steve Jobs is so much of what's in
1:15:23this episode.
1:15:24Um Gil Emilio is trying to pin him down on what his job what
1:15:28his role is going to be at Apple.
1:15:29Is he gonna have a role at all?
1:15:31Yep.
1:15:31Gil really wants him to have a role.
1:15:33He doesn't he knows the press will love it if Steve is around, but
1:15:37what would that role be?
1:15:38Yep.
1:15:38And what is in the mind of Steve?
1:15:40Is Steve in fact one of the things we debate, isn't it?
1:15:44Is Steve plotting all along the downfall of Gil Emilio and to take over
1:15:48as CEO of Apple?
1:15:50Or
1:15:52is Steve not thinking about that?
1:15:54Or is he legitimately conflicted about what's going on?
1:15:58And I don't think I have theories, but I don't think there's a clear
1:16:02answer.
1:16:02But it's like if you believe there's a clear answer to that question, oh,
1:16:06of course Steve was plotting it all along.
1:16:09I think we will convince you otherwise.
1:16:11So this is the final episode.
1:16:13This will be the final episode of this series.
1:16:15This is a series that we will continue to come back to with our
1:16:18special guest John Syracuse.
1:16:19So because the plan with John is to tell the story of OS Ten.
1:16:24Of all of it.
1:16:24Yeah.
1:16:25All of it.
1:16:25Mm-hmm.
1:16:25We haven't gotten there yet.
1:16:27Nope.
1:16:27We will though.
1:16:28Maybe next time.
1:16:30Uh who knows?
1:16:31It is impossible to know.
1:16:33We'll tell more of that story next time.
1:16:34We will continue to tell the story.
1:16:36When we actually get to OS 10, who could tell?
1:16:38There's actually still quite a bit to go.
1:16:41So if we're finishing up that series of John, what's next?
1:16:45Well, next week begins our series on the origins of the iPod.
1:16:50Let's start with the history of the MP3 and the digital hub strategy, then
1:16:55talks about the components, the people and the decision making that leads to the
1:17:00first iPod released twenty-five years ago.
1:17:03Some amazing moments in that series including um finding the guy who's gonna build
1:17:09the iPod on a chairlift in Vail.
1:17:12Yep.
1:17:13Uh and also the magical romantic moment.
1:17:18When Johnny Ive met his very best friend, the color white.
1:17:23Yes.
1:17:24Or one of my favorite moments.
1:17:26Uh the creation of the click wheel.
1:17:28Where that came from.
1:17:29Where uh the surprise inspiration of the click.
1:17:31Surprise, inspiration of the clickwheel yes.
1:17:33Brilliant series that starts uh next week.
1:17:37Yes.
1:17:37Um and so you can celebrate the anniversary of this groundbreaking product by listening
1:17:41to Designing California, our wonderful podcast.
1:17:44Members of Designing California next Wednesday get all five episodes in the Origins of
1:17:50iPod series at once and everyone else will get them rolling out over the
1:17:54next five weeks.
1:17:55Um people I also want to mention people have really been enjoying the show
1:17:58on YouTube as well.
1:18:00It's a great production for YouTube.
1:18:02Um, it's it's exactly the same as the audio version from an edit perspective.
1:18:06Obviously, it's me and Jason.
1:18:07We also include some imagery in there.
1:18:10And actually the iPod series, particularly, I think, will be nice uh on YouTube
1:18:15because you made some uh you actually re did some video recording of your
1:18:18original iPod I got my original iPod out at my strong request.
1:18:23Yeah, you you ordered me to do that.
1:18:25And I had to go on eBay and find find firewire firewire charger because
1:18:30I could attach it to a computer via firewire, but it doesn't iPod mode
1:18:34when it's attached to a computer.
1:18:36So I had to I had to do that.
1:18:37And I I have lost my Firewire power adapter.
1:18:40So Um, did that and then shot a bunch of video and shot some
1:18:44pictures and there's a picture of my bo I saw the box.
1:18:47So the box is in there.
1:18:48It's good stuff.
1:18:49Um and and uh some file footage and all sorts of other stuff in
1:18:52there.
1:18:52So people should check it out.
1:18:53And yeah if you're a member, you get all five episodes at once next
1:18:55week.
1:18:56And if not, that's fine.
1:18:58You'll just get 'em over the next five weeks starting next week.
1:19:00But only if you go and let check it out.
1:19:02So if you have yet to check out Design in California, this is us
1:19:06telling you to do it.
1:19:07Do it.
1:19:07You know, like maybe you were like, I don't know if I want to
1:19:09hear about the Mac, right?
1:19:11But maybe you want to hear about the iPod.
1:19:12And I think that once you check out a series of the show you'd
1:19:15be like, you know what, I would like to hear about that other stuff
1:19:17too 'cause this stuff's really interesting.
1:19:19I think if you listen to the show and enjoy the show, you will
1:19:22enjoy Design in California.
1:19:23And we're gonna continue to give you many, many reasons because we're gonna be
1:19:27doing many, many series of this show.
1:19:29Oh yeah.
1:19:30Uh I would hope for a very long time.
1:19:33I hope so.
1:19:33So that's at relay.fm slash designed.
1:19:36Uh where you can also find us on YouTube.
1:19:38There'll be links in the show notes.
1:19:39There's actually links to all of our platforms uh over at relay.fm slash designed.
1:19:44It is time for some ask upgrade questions.
1:19:47Kyle wants to know, what is your favorite Memphis barbecue?
1:19:52Um I haven't been to them all.
1:19:54Mm-hmm.
1:19:54But my go-to is Central.
1:19:56Yeah.
1:19:58We're actually going to go to Central.
1:20:00In a matter of minutes.
1:20:01We're after the show is over, we're going to Central Barbecue.
1:20:04Which we're looking forward to.
1:20:05And And Jason has a menu hack, which he shared of us all last
1:20:09year.
1:20:10Just the good item, the best item on the menu.
1:20:12Oh, and last year I last year, you know, sometimes you have a meal
1:20:14with a group and somebody orders something and you're like, oh, that was the
1:20:17best one.
1:20:18I got that last year.
1:20:19Yeah.
1:20:19And it was the brisket nachos.
1:20:21Yeah.
1:20:22Oh, so good.
1:20:23It was so good.
1:20:24I had it after I had it I think the next day.
1:20:27Mm-hmm.
1:20:28So it was Central the next day.
1:20:30Yeah.
1:20:31So this time I'm very much looking forward to getting on the the Natural
1:20:34Train Review.
1:20:34But yeah, I've only no, I haven't only had central I've eaten other places.
1:20:39It's it's my favorite.
1:20:40It's great.
1:20:40Yeah.
1:20:41It's great central barbecue.
1:20:42There's several locations here, but that's you know, that that's the one that's hit
1:20:46me the best.
1:20:46I'm sure there are others that I will have to go to sometime, but
1:20:50um also where we tend to stay is right by the downtown central.
1:20:54So it's easy to walk over there and you can see it.
1:20:56You can smell it, maybe depending on how the wind's for sure.
1:20:59Mark wants to know, do you think Apple will take the duo format and
1:21:03blow it up to a clamshell like iPad duo somewhere?
1:21:07Anything is possible.
1:21:09Yeah.
1:21:10But I am skeptical.
1:21:13It makes less sense.
1:21:15Well this is the thing is I think innovating and iterating on the iPhone
1:21:19makes sense because the most important reason you do a foldable is because you
1:21:23want to carry it in your pocket.
1:21:25Yep.
1:21:25And then open it up and have it be big.
1:21:27And an iPad, like, I don't know.
1:21:31I mean, I could see some utility, but it's a victory over, you know,
1:21:36the dynamics of the device size than it would be if you were uh
1:21:42you know trying to get a phone that fits in your pocket and also
1:21:45has the biggest screen possible.
1:21:46That's premise of a foldable device, I think, is exactly that.
1:21:50And um I think it breaks down when you start talking about bigger devices
1:21:56because at that point I'm not sure it really makes sense.
1:21:58Yep.
1:21:59Eric writes in and says, The light blue and burgundy combo is a go
1:22:04to color combo this year.
1:22:05I'm seeing it everywhere in fashion and interior design.
1:22:09Do you think that Apple got lucky or specifically picked the colors that seem
1:22:13to be in vogue this year?
1:22:16I don't think luck had anything to do with it.
1:22:18I think I think the people who are making okay, maybe they were lucky.
1:22:23But I I would say I think Apple picks its colors carefully.
1:22:29So I will agree.
1:22:29I've seen the Burgundy and blue.
1:22:31I think the the blue that you see most paired with burgundy is not
1:22:35the blue that Apple chose.
1:22:36It's not glacier.
1:22:37Yeah.
1:22:38It's a bit more Robin's egg.
1:22:40And we can disagree.
1:22:41And when I rant about the colors are, I'm disagreeing about Apple's decisions.
1:22:45But I have no doubt when you look at their watch bands
1:22:49and the device colors that there are a lot of people in Apple that
1:22:53are very concerned about trends in fashion and color and how to reflect those
1:23:00in Apple products.
1:23:02I think the bands and cases
1:23:05are definitely chosen by people who are trying to hit the trends.
1:23:12I don't know
1:23:14if you can get that far ahead with an iPhone.
1:23:17I was gonna say I I think the devices they're trying to do it,
1:23:20but there's two things.
1:23:21One is they are gonna have to make that decision much earlier and trends
1:23:25can change.
1:23:26And the other is
1:23:29there are physical constraints on an iPhone.
1:23:33Yeah.
1:23:33Because they have to be rugged and they use a particular production process
1:23:39and that probably affects or an iPhone or a or a laptop or wh
1:23:44whatever that product is.
1:23:45The color the actual color hue that is available is probably limited by the
1:23:51production process of the iPhone eighteen pro, let's say.
1:23:54Yeah.
1:23:55And so put those two things together and I think it's a tougher thing
1:23:59for them to do.
1:24:00But I do think they try.
1:24:02I just think it's harder to if you can do it, you try it.
1:24:06Yeah.
1:24:06Yeah.
1:24:06And I would say that
1:24:08I don't like the colours this year, but I am not unhappy about it
1:24:14in the strategy.
1:24:16I wouldn't expect to every year like the colours that they offer.
1:24:20That's not how fashion works.
1:24:24I'm happy that they have continued to have
1:24:28to continue to make bold color decisions.
1:24:30I think that burgundy is a bold color decision.
1:24:34I don't like it, but I like that it is it feels to me
1:24:38as strong a decision as Cosmic Orange, just in a different direction.
1:24:41Sure.
1:24:42Right?
1:24:42'Cause it's like that is a that's a big color statement.
1:24:46Uh and I think it's divisive.
1:24:47And I think that's what they should be doing, especially when they offer four.
1:24:51There's four this year, right?
1:24:52Like so you can get silver or black if that's what you want, or
1:24:57you can go with one of the color choices.
1:24:59Richard asks, are you at all concerned that Apple may wait an entire year
1:25:05until OS twenty eight to meaningfully update Siri AI?
1:25:09How would you rate the chances of a major improvement as part of twenty
1:25:13seven point four, for example?
1:25:14So this goes back to what we were talking about earlier with agents, but
1:25:17what about the actual AI experience?
1:25:19I I mean,
1:25:22I am concerned.
1:25:24That is the question.
1:25:25I am concerned.
1:25:27I would like to believe that they've learned and are going to be capable
1:25:30of updating their models midstream
1:25:33and updating functionality that uses their models midstream.
1:25:39But until we see them do it,
1:25:42I'm gonna be concerned about it.
1:25:45But like, there's no reason that you shouldn't be able to put a new
1:25:51model under the covers with an OS update and have it be a better
1:25:55model.
1:25:56If you're working on a better model, the last thing you want to do
1:25:59is get the better model in March and say, Well, this is great.
1:26:02We'll ship it in September.
1:26:04Like you can't do that.
1:26:05You should ship it in March or April.
1:26:08So I am concerned And then separately, like I said, it's also about the
1:26:12implementation of features that are are using those models and not saying, well, we've
1:26:18got a new thing we could do with Siri AI.
1:26:20Let's not do it until next September.
1:26:22I I would I would love like to believe that some of that stuff's
1:26:25gonna get fast tracked because they have been behind and they're still catching up.
1:26:30Yeah.
1:26:30And they may just be catching up forever and they need to move fast.
1:26:33But I'm concerned because, as we said, culturally there There's been a real resistance.
1:26:41Their system isn't built to do it.
1:26:43The resistance to it is not necessarily people.
1:26:46It may be the system.
1:26:48And some people are probably
1:26:51responsible for building that system but it maybe was built for a time when
1:26:55the priorities were different.
1:26:56But regardless, the system needs to change and you know, we'll see.
1:27:01But I am concerned, I would say I I think it's possible, I think
1:27:05it's obvious that they need to I am concerned.
1:27:07Me too.
1:27:08And Mahir asks, what does smoking apple two smell like?
1:27:13So at ten hours and twenty-five minutes in the podcast of time, there is
1:27:18a timestamp link.
1:27:20You will we're sitting around playing a game and there's an Apple two on
1:27:24the desk which had previously, a little while before been playing the Oregon Trail.
1:27:28Yeah.
1:27:28Which is a great segment.
1:27:29Yeah.
1:27:30It's a fun thing to be able to play what was essentially a very
1:27:33thematically appropriate game from original Apple II hardware.
1:27:37Yep.
1:27:37So we're sitting playing a different game, like a word game, and you'll see,
1:27:42if you look at the Apple II, you will see smoke start to emit
1:27:46from around the power cable.
1:27:49We're all laughing and joking.
1:27:50And then I go, Oh and point at the computer because there's smoke coming
1:27:55out of the computer.
1:27:56And the reason I pointed this doesn't come up in the video, I heard
1:27:59something pop.
1:28:00Yeah.
1:28:00And it took caught my attention.
1:28:02Apple's uh Steven's Apple II, his original Apple II, which had an original power
1:28:07supply.
1:28:08Smoke is pouring out of the computer.
1:28:10Yeah.
1:28:11You'll see Steven somewhat gingerly but confidently yank the power cable out of the
1:28:16back of it.
1:28:17Mm-hmm.
1:28:17We start knocking things on the floor because also Casey's original iPod Nano is
1:28:22just lit against the back of it.
1:28:25Uh and and then uh we all start freaking out and trying to blow
1:28:28the smoke away and cut to a break because unfortunately Steven's Apple II uh
1:28:34bit the dust.
1:28:35But it was it was just the power supply.
1:28:37Everything else seems to be fine.
1:28:38He bought a new power supply this morning.
1:28:40Okay.
1:28:40So he he he took a look at it.
1:28:41He said to me today he took it out and shook it and it
1:28:44sounded like a maracca.
1:28:45So some stuff happened inside of that power supply.
1:28:49So to answer me here, it smelled real bad.
1:28:51It smelled really
1:28:53bad.
1:28:54I mean we did we had to take it Stephen took it out on
1:28:56the loading dock.
1:28:57Yes.
1:28:57Because it was still emitting smoke.
1:28:59Smoke for quite a while.
1:29:01Here's what I would tell you it smelled like.
1:29:02It smelled like old smoke.
1:29:04That's what it smelled like.
1:29:05Smoke that was old.
1:29:07Like dust and smoke.
1:29:09Yeah.
1:29:10And it was a white smoke.
1:29:12Like it was Yeah, they they they did not elect a new Pope.
1:29:15No.
1:29:17They did not.
1:29:18That poor computer.
1:29:21Stephen was Well I say it's he was upset about it, right?
1:29:25But got over it much quicker than I thought he would have.
1:29:29I think we all diagnosed it as being a power supply issue pretty quickly.
1:29:32And he's like,
1:29:35Oh no, my Apple II just go on fire, you know?
1:29:38But it was it was confined to the power supply.
1:29:39Which is why which is this big rectangular part, like it's a single part.
1:29:44And it was clear that that's where everything was happening.
1:29:47Yeah.
1:29:47So then he felt okay.
1:29:49Yeah.
1:29:49But that was uh Man, I was really worried they were gonna evacuate us
1:29:53out of that studio and I do not know I'll tell you right now.
1:29:57I have no doubt that there are lots of plans.
1:30:00I don't know what they are in that scenario.
1:30:03It turns out that loading dock is the fastest way out of there.
1:30:06Oh, I know that.
1:30:07I mean, um, what happens if we have to evacuate the street?
1:30:10Oh yeah.
1:30:10Right?
1:30:11Like what happens to the stream?
1:30:12Like I'm sh I have no doubt that there are 'cause there are so
1:30:16many professionals that they have like oh, this is what we do, we unplug
1:30:21this computer, that kind of thing.
1:30:22Like that thing they had for like when the Queen died, they were like,
1:30:26How do we put this plan into motion?
1:30:28Like what if Steven's Apple Two catches on fire and what happens to the
1:30:31podcast?
1:30:32You know, this is where the fire exit is.
1:30:34I know where it is, and I know that in that scenario someone's gonna
1:30:37take us out of there.
1:30:38But like what happens to everything else, you know?
1:30:40Luckily we didn't have to find out.
1:30:42But I was worried we were about to find out.
1:30:44Yeah.
1:30:44You know, uh, but we didn't so you can go and check that out
1:30:48along with the rest of the podcast events on YouTube.
1:30:50If you'd like to send in a question for us to answer in a
1:30:53future episode of the show, or if you have any feedback or follow-up, please
1:30:56go to upgradefeedback.com.
1:30:58I'd like to thank our members who support us with Upgrade Plus.
1:31:01Uh this week I want to ask you about some new Kindles.
1:31:04Okay.
1:31:04You can go to getUpgradePlus.com and get longer ad-free versions of the show each
1:31:08and every week.
1:31:09You can find us on YouTube by searching for upgrade.
1:31:12We are sitting across the table from each other today, so you can see
1:31:15that if you like.
1:31:16Uh thanks to our sponsors, that is Factor and Squarespace for their support of
1:31:20this week's episode.
1:31:21But most of all, thanks to you for listening, and we'll be back next
1:31:25week.
1:31:25Until then, say goodbye, Jason Snell.
1:31:27Touch my finger.
1:31:28We're touching fingers again.
1:31:29Goodbye.