Podcast Search

The Accidental Tech Podcast

34: Made The Dot Smaller

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00I took the bold step the very first time ever done it and marked that review is

0:00:05not helpful I totally mark them as not helpful to have better not helpful I

0:00:12wanna talk about TV from a nap Breaking Bad and this is going to have a point I

0:00:19was watching agents of shield earlier tonight with Aaron sorry well it's ok

0:00:25it's it's got promise but it's not very good at the moment well the reason I

0:00:31bring this up is because there was a portion of the episode and this is not

0:00:37particularly important if you haven't seen it yet but somebody was going

0:00:40behind enemy lines if you will and they had like you know an invisible world

0:00:45almost invisible secret agent earpiece thing and this person was trying to

0:00:50schmooze people they didn't know at a party and so what they did was they had

0:00:55the other agents like up in the magical plane thing telling the person on the

0:01:01field in the field

0:01:02oh well this is someone so he has twin kids and ask him about this now the

0:01:07other thing so this person can schmooze not look like an outsider well they

0:01:11walked away from one of the from this conversation where they had to schmooze

0:01:14and with people that know me and they said something to the effect oh wow it's

0:01:19really awesome having you guys here and really get used to this and then they

0:01:22said and i'm quoting its like Siri if it works and so this is a national TV show

0:01:30and granted america's not the be all end all but I mean this is Apple taking

0:01:34potshots on national television which I thought was a little bit surprising well

0:01:40to be fair Syria has never been that reliable no I mean it's it's not

0:01:43unreasonable I just thought it was surprising that it would that it's

0:01:46become part of the killers right word but it's become something that everyone

0:01:51recognizes as an issue that's the anti trap anything you do that to a lay

0:01:56person seems like it should be like another person talking to you until we

0:02:00get actual real you know whatever the term is strong AI is not going to be

0:02:04like that and

0:02:05and there's gonna be an expectation gap I talked to a thing I want to respond to

0:02:09me like a person it's not going to we all know it's not going to but doesn't

0:02:13matter because once I start talking to like a person to dam up their work like

0:02:16a person and that combined with its reliability of like sometimes it just

0:02:20says sorry I couldn't do it could reach servers not available in order but even

0:02:24a response to you you know it's fun to play with and then you quickly realize

0:02:28it's not like talking to a person and you disappointed and that's never going

0:02:30to go away like Google now series things are getting better and better and you

0:02:36know just be leaps and bounds over where they are today and people will still be

0:02:39like it'll still be jokes about them on late night TV because there are they so

0:02:44stupid you know my dog smarter than syria like it doesn't understand he

0:02:47doesn't understand and it wont doesn't understand it won't understand for you

0:02:51know years decades our lifetime who knows how long it will take to get

0:02:55actual intelligence on the level of human being and the other end of a

0:02:58computer thing and up until that point it's going to be the butt of jokes it's

0:03:04hard to tell it on the agent of shield episode they were making fun of the

0:03:07reliability or the intelligence or bowl right right

0:03:11figures like the reliability that you know that Apple graceland I now we can

0:03:16make this stupid thing reliable the very least and then you're just complaining

0:03:19about all the responses aren't very smart but when it says sorry it's not

0:03:23available right now series now read that it says when when you know the service

0:03:27center response that is something that Apple should be ashamed I now but

0:03:30everything else if you're doing anything that you talk to the talks back you just

0:03:34gonna have to take your lumps but you know as far as as far as popular culture

0:03:39is concerned as far as regular people are concerned he'll even as far as

0:03:43you're concerned it doesn't really matter whether the server failure

0:03:47happens or whether it does the wrong thing or or thinks the wrong thing about

0:03:52what you said either way it's a failure and and all it takes is a few failures

0:03:56where you know after that you just forget about using you stop using it

0:04:01right in so it seems weird to me

0:04:05words are weird is the right word but I can't help but wonder this got me

0:04:09thinking that I can't help but wonder at what point is Apple gonna say enough is

0:04:13enough and not properly fix this and I know that that

0:04:15we've talked about this a lot with light cloud and core data for example and

0:04:21we've talked a lot a lot about this with series as well but at some point you

0:04:26have to think that they're gonna get together and say got guys and girls we

0:04:29really really really have to fix this like it's that time ever coming is Mr

0:04:33waiting for train that's just not going to show up it was kind of a victory for

0:04:37Apple to be mentioned because the worst thing for Apple would be for them to

0:04:39make that same joke about Google now so like syria has the mindshare as that

0:04:43thing on your phone that you talk to and there is value in having that mindshare

0:04:47even if it comes along with you know all that other baggage and everything just

0:04:51because like you know you gonna become the kleenex or whatever of the thing

0:04:56whatever is generous sized random but you know that's that's what they went 2

0:05:00for the joke because they figure most people know that they'll know what we're

0:05:03talking about they'll get the joke whereas you know Google now or any of

0:05:07the other things that you talked to are more reliable yes but again I'm not I

0:05:11don't think the joke was about reliability I think it's like if it

0:05:14worked as in if you could actually a serious things and she would give you

0:05:17answers

0:05:18versus just saying I'm sorry I don't know what that is doing a google search

0:05:22warrant which is what syria does when you try to talk to me like a person I

0:05:26don't know but like I think it's good that the word is in the public

0:05:30consciousness and I think Apple continues to work on the reliability and

0:05:34you know fail for the same reason they fail to make all their online service

0:05:37reliable but is also working on the intelligence part of it is just at this

0:05:41point I think it's the cost of doing business you want to be on the phone

0:05:44market you get out some sort of thing that you talked to does real-time

0:05:47intelligence searches from multiple sources and so it's never going to go

0:05:50away they're going to keep trying to make it better and you know about online

0:05:55services like I wanted to get a fix on line thing like you know that Mak

0:05:58goodnight tools and MobileMe with iCloud the one where they fixed everything

0:06:03I really they just keep trying I guess when I mean and it's it's how you have

0:06:09to start wondering what is it about Apple that makes them quote not good at

0:06:15Webster's like we all say that we all right that we all think that Apple is

0:06:20not good but what's different like what's going to be different

0:06:25a year from now compared to now in that area like what steps are they taking or

0:06:30what steps could they even take to meaningfully change that like what is it

0:06:35about the company that makes them not good at web services and I don't really

0:06:40see from the outside any evidence that meaningful changes happening there it

0:06:45seems like you know as we've discussed before it's it's probably a problem of

0:06:49engineering resources and priorities and up until this time Apple has clearly put

0:06:57some priority on web services but they are still a very small company with

0:07:04their engineering resources and it doesn't really ever seem like that's

0:07:09gonna take a massive turn for the better we're suddenly their web services are

0:07:15going to have tons more staff on them tones more resources and be at a much

0:07:19higher priority the company I don't I don't see that happened

0:07:22yeah I don't know either and and it seems we like most not everything is web

0:07:27objects right I mean I know the iTunes stories but but we have no reason to

0:07:30believe everything else as well I'll text you right and and that I really

0:07:34don't think web objects the technology has anything substantial to do with why

0:07:40Apple is not quote good at web services and then you can pick on any language or

0:07:44platform and say oh well that doesn't scale or that's old or whatever the fact

0:07:48is that's not the problem

0:07:49you know you could with with proper administration of proper coding you can

0:07:53make anything scale you can make anything work the platform is really the

0:07:58problem you know the platform is an end by the way there's nothing saying Apple

0:08:02has to be using with objects maybe they're not using it for part of the

0:08:06stuff using it for just a front end somewhere and using Oracle stuff behind

0:08:10who knows but I I would not I would not put blame on

0:08:15the fact that they occasionally have web object URLs that we're looking at it

0:08:19from the front I don't have a lot to do with it well but the hard thing about

0:08:23web job a web objects is that how do you hire for someone that can do web objects

0:08:27obviously you can teach any competent programmer just about anything but if

0:08:32you want a web objects guru they're like what four of them in the world in there

0:08:36are probably on Apple's payroll ready so to get in and of itself web objects may

0:08:40not be the problem in the sense of it functions in with like he said good

0:08:46coding it'll continue to function but it's hard to hire into that role if you

0:08:50wanted to throw people at the problem which may or may not even be the

0:08:54solution

0:08:54well but really like looking at looking at a major code base for a major web

0:09:00service under heavy traffic that's very high profile I mean really doesn't

0:09:05matter what language is written in like any new hires gonna have to go through a

0:09:09lot of training and a lot of time just becoming familiar with this code base

0:09:13and becoming useful in working with it i mean i i dont think even if it was

0:09:17written in Java which everyone can either knows or can be taught very

0:09:20quickly I don't think that would really make a difference I mean really I think

0:09:24if I'm directs really was the big problems they're having either that's a

0:09:29giant failure of leadership or that's it it's a giant failure of leadership

0:09:37that's it that's like that's the reason if if they're being held back because

0:09:41they're using web objects that's a really stupid reason to be held back and

0:09:45there is no reason to continue it

0:09:47these services are all pretty nu they could if that was really the problem

0:09:51they could rewrite them it wouldn't it would be a big undertaking but it

0:09:54wouldn't be an insurmountable the fact is I don't think that's really the

0:09:58problem and if it is really the problem then I'm still correct it's a problem

0:10:03with something about high-level leadership of priorities rather than

0:10:08this technology can do this

0:10:10objects is actually not now but back in the day was actually a tiny example of

0:10:16couples sort of doing the right thing and I've done this rant several times as

0:10:21many other shows you two should be able to recite it by now

0:10:24like if you're gonna do web services or anything anything online at the scale

0:10:33Apple does it you go into a different realm and what market said about you

0:10:37know you can make any web service killing pop forum is true but once you

0:10:40start getting into Apple scalar Google scale things like that do matter a

0:10:44little bit more than they do you like there's a threshold to reach capacity

0:10:48like okay now a neoplasm won't do and really the platform actually does matter

0:10:54because any tiny inefficiency is multiplied by the millions of service

0:10:57that we have or maybe a particular architecture dictated by a particular

0:11:00platform doesn't allow us to be in a million different data centers around

0:11:04the world in a synchronized manner and all these other things that come into

0:11:07play for like seven people in the world for like maybe

0:11:11Amazon Microsoft Google anybody who's got a worldwide online presence

0:11:16huge service which millions and millions of customers and where the good thing

0:11:21that web objects had going for it is that they didn't make themselves but it

0:11:25was in the house came with us feel like like technology using now ok from nexrad

0:11:30and that's what you have to do it this scale you have to take ownership of your

0:11:35online platform you can't just use sort of off the shelf stuff and by experts

0:11:39and have them put them up to each other once you pass a certain threshold of

0:11:43scale you got to stop yourself and the Sun does microsoft does Google does

0:11:48practically everything themselves right down to their own hardware and

0:11:52everything and Apple seems to do so so much less of it and Apple is it that

0:11:57scale now hundreds of millions of people using iOS devices connecting to a club

0:12:01like there there there there at that scale they can't be the only person

0:12:05doing stuff off the shelf they need to take ownership of their online platform

0:12:08technology and I don't understand the leadership get here too because it's

0:12:11clear that leadership gap doesn't exist for the client side stuff because they

0:12:17the organization that does all this other stuff so clearly when it comes to

0:12:25a top or not but so clearly understand that it needs to take complete ownership

0:12:30of its platform we have to be responsible and making sure we have

0:12:33good tools good compiler good language and we're going to not just do them once

0:12:37and just ok we're done koko's awesome you know project build their we're all

0:12:41set we've got our own tools for great they're gonna be no that's not satisfied

0:12:45with that we need a better compiler we need to ditch project will you make a

0:12:49New Mexico keep making this code better and better we need to switch out our

0:12:53debugger friend we need to have the Objective C runtime you know they just

0:12:58take such incredible ownership of their platform they know they can't just let

0:13:01it sit there and then not relying unlike some other vendor or some other

0:13:05platforms solve their problems and just throw it a bunch of people are here you

0:13:08go here some pieces you know they totally take control of their clients

0:13:11and they need to service that is just as important thing to be doing all those

0:13:15same things whereas the team that has been working on this is the technology

0:13:18that that we're going to use inside Apple to deploy online services you know

0:13:23starting 10 years ago and continually revising it ten years ago the head web

0:13:27objects which even then was kind of weird and aidid and they just didn't

0:13:30like keep it up today to modernize it and like it like it's free pass that by

0:13:35they didn't let that happen on the client side did you know racing ahead

0:13:38especially with exceptions a file system but most other aspects

0:13:43taking ownership of their of their platform there on the server side

0:13:45they're not they're going to third-party vendors and that's an untenable strategy

0:13:49they need to be more like Google and Microsoft and Amazon and have their own

0:13:54platforms with their own in-house technology dedicate those kind of

0:13:57resources to it and I don't understand why one half of the company can do that

0:14:01and the other half can't because it seems like the same leadership well yeah

0:14:05but what do you say that objects is getting better I mean from the outside

0:14:09there's no indication it's getting better but who's to say from that it

0:14:12isn't getting better on the inside and they're just not letting anyone see it

0:14:15the model of the way it works in the model the web of course the whole idea

0:14:19of having you know object transparency just kind of like working like cocoa on

0:14:24the web and all these conveniences like that's not what massive online services

0:14:27about these days anymore they're about infrastructure pieces to manage storage

0:14:31and data in ways that are totally unlike the web objects that in terms of where

0:14:36the state is and

0:14:37you know how it all fits together just look at how like let's look at Google's

0:14:42span are things that they use for the database stuff in there and then all of

0:14:45its predecessors like GFS and what was that some of the ceremony was the thing

0:14:51that the predicted a big table and like all these infrastructure projects that

0:14:56have come and gone and MapReduce and all those things like that Google is

0:14:59constantly revising Apple hasn't gone through that the revolution Google

0:15:02started out its first things and just GFS and MapReduce were already ahead of

0:15:06where Apple as the web objects in terms of doing things that scale and ghouls

0:15:12constantly throwing away it's all 10 replacing with doing it over and over

0:15:15and over again for its service and same thing with Amazon and all the stuff that

0:15:19is using to run its services

0:15:20Apple started with one dot dress which was already like sort of the old model

0:15:25and look at much working for developers to do you know like google has proven

0:15:30that you can make things annoying for developers is certainly using big table

0:15:35is super annoying which is one of the reasons spanner exist for developers but

0:15:38it was like you know scaling is king and even though it's going to be annoying to

0:15:42do the stuff of the application level we scaling is more important and will work

0:15:45at the other things later as Apple was like oh we want this to be all nice and

0:15:49kind of like working with objects or convenient and everything is magically

0:15:52objects and persistent sounds like our data I guess my mind and in that nice

0:15:57and that is nice and everything but that you know you're you aren't your hands

0:16:01tied behind your back in terms of how do you scales 217 data centers with

0:16:04redundant hardware and all these other you know things like will know the day

0:16:09has come when Apple has finally started to join the modern age when they don't

0:16:12have to bring a story down before they introduce new products like there's

0:16:17there's a way to do it like the reason they do that is not so much like a we

0:16:20have to take the store downtown new products they don't have to take the

0:16:23tour ended in parks they have to take the dart story on this my theory they

0:16:27have to take the story down to add new products that appear to customers in

0:16:31deterministic Manor right because they can add new products take mister down

0:16:34but they have no idea when or where they'll appear for people because of

0:16:38their their architecture doesn't allow them to sort of you know have a way to

0:16:42say ok now this is available for the entire world is just like an added and

0:16:45then it sort of trickles out through

0:16:46there whatever system they have going with combined their CD and stuff and

0:16:50they don't want to spoil the surprise so instead of bringing the whole thing down

0:16:54read the whole thing put put all the new stuff in the news wait for the moment my

0:16:57cell K and go bring it back up and then you're sure that nobody sees at halftime

0:17:01accidentally right and you're sure that when you turn on everybody sees the new

0:17:05thing because you had time for to propagate during the you know that's my

0:17:08theory of why is it the store down but that's not how it works you can take to

0:17:13start down when you when you don't want to spoil the surprise do you really

0:17:17think taking the store down is still necessary or do you think they're doing

0:17:20it only for the theatrical element but it's it's because if they didn't they

0:17:24wouldn't have control over when people saw things like they want ever wanted to

0:17:28be visible to it

0:17:29everybody wants as much as possible but only starting in the given point I feel

0:17:34like this against the speculation if they just put up the store now it would

0:17:38either slowly trickle out to people which would be kind of annoying that you

0:17:40want everybody to see when you announce or if you started early

0:17:43some people might see it early you know so I think it's it's about making it so

0:17:49that everyone sees things simultaneously it could be purely for theatrics and

0:17:53then they do not do it all but that I think they would have stopped that by

0:17:56now like this so many things they've done for theatrics that sort of coming

0:17:59on but my guess is that has to do with content propagation and being control

0:18:03when it appears that the first person and getting it to appear to the most

0:18:08people as soon as possible but there's no I mean there's no technical no reason

0:18:14why it has to take that one hot like they don't have to take the store down

0:18:18for an hour and a half to two to update something how long does it take for the

0:18:23new content to propagate through their worldwide network of CDN it depends it

0:18:27depends how they do it I know what I'm saying maybe it maybe actually takes

0:18:30them like two hours to be sure that all the new content is propagated audience

0:18:34but but that's a choice they make an implementation I mean they can they can

0:18:37do it within a few seconds of the 18 2010 and this is just my guess of what

0:18:43they were doing like and you're right it is found for a long time so I can sit

0:18:46down for five seconds then comes back up and down for like an hour during during

0:18:50the keynote practically

0:18:51usually goes down before the keynote and so it's down for like three how are they

0:18:58trying to prevent people

0:18:59only buying the old products while they're announcing the new ones but you

0:19:03can still go into an Apple store and buy you can still buy them like that morning

0:19:07you could say that that can't be the reason I wonder what about the store

0:19:12employees wave you are like if you go in like the keynote is going on Trulia

0:19:16everyone out there knows the keynote is going out you go in like on the October

0:19:1922nd iPad event and you call in a while someone is on stage introducing new iPad

0:19:23you try to buy an old one would think the Apple Store guys gonna go you know

0:19:28they're announcing new ones now I can stop by this here you go you can have it

0:19:31now but just in case like you might want to know maybe you don't know they're

0:19:34announcing new ones right now I wonder if they tell you that I i think you

0:19:37might be overestimating the geekiness and attentiveness of both the staff and

0:19:41the customers in Apple Store

0:19:43be depressed if they don't if they don't even know that it's going on so do you

0:19:49think you know

0:19:51thinking about some more of the sample service before we go up to two different

0:19:54topic do you think Apple's really feeling pain from this from from their

0:20:01stuff being the status quo of working most of the time but not being up to the

0:20:07standards service wise quality wise up time was liability was of Google

0:20:12services Amazon Services Facebook services you know that the other big

0:20:16giant do you think Apple really feeling the pain from that lady you think this

0:20:20is really hurting them because with Google they had to still ridiculously

0:20:25well because a not a lot of other people in their business for doing that

0:20:29be there were scaling way past but everyone was doing and see that's their

0:20:34entire business that's where everything comes from if Google doesn't serve an ad

0:20:39they lose money whereas Apple is selling all this hardware regardless of how of

0:20:44whether I must extend this morning you know it doesn't really hurt them

0:20:47directly and severely where there's one to two inches of downtown here in there

0:20:53like how much do you think how much pain you think there's a feeling it's kinda

0:20:58seems like they're not filling enough to do anything drastic well maybe but let

0:21:03me answer your question by asking you a question do you think Apple is proud

0:21:07did and I think it's pretty clear to me that they're very proud company and i

0:21:11dont I can't imagine to come full circle I can imagine that they liked hearing

0:21:16these potshots taken at them during agents of shield doesn't make sense you

0:21:20know that's the question of the question is it seems like a bomber type question

0:21:24are they in denial

0:21:26if you were to ask them like you know off the record I can report this story

0:21:30evidence that you bump into Tim Cook in an elevator whatever it's like do you

0:21:34think Apple does online stuff as well as you know Google Amazon and Microsoft and

0:21:40that this could explain the leadership gap where they like maybe they have you

0:21:45know they're in denial they think everyone has troubles every once in a

0:21:48while we were kind of you know in the mix were kind of pretty much almost as

0:21:51good as Google and Amazon you know maybe some days where Sunday's better as their

0:21:55ups and downs like or do they really realized that just happened what the gap

0:21:59is you know and the Kappas not if you were to put on a little graph or

0:22:03something like that only a couple of percentage but it's like that last

0:22:06couple of percentage of its like uptime going from like you know three nines 279

0:22:10just astronomically hard so much harder than going from ninety percent of time

0:22:14to 99 you know me in like the last little bits of the part the modern I

0:22:18wonder like that could explain why they haven't sort of gotten religion on this

0:22:23and dedicated themselves to doing the server side taking ownership of the

0:22:27service i'd text during the client side is that they think they think they're

0:22:31they're not that bad like maybe they really actually think we have room for

0:22:36improvement

0:22:37we're not satisfied with where we are but it's not that were closed right and

0:22:40I would say no you're not like it seems like you're close but really those last

0:22:44few inches on the graph make all the difference you're not close there is

0:22:47nobody there is not a single person who has any technical clue who would say do

0:22:51you think a ten-day of any month of any year that Apple does on stuff better

0:22:55than Google like it never it's never happened

0:22:57no one has ever had that opinion as a hundred percent ok Go's better how much

0:23:01better their little better but nobody believes that will better nobody liked

0:23:04and I have a feeling that you have someone on the iTunes Music Store think

0:23:07of course we're better look how many billions of songs we saw look how many

0:23:10apps we give people Google doesn't do stuff like that they're so their store

0:23:13sucks we do so much better you know like because they excel in a few areas like

0:23:17read mostly distribution

0:23:20of static data to people they think we're an online services company and

0:23:23we're awesome and it's just it's just not the same as an attractive thing do

0:23:27you think anyone's ever returned an iPhone because I message was down for 20

0:23:30minutes a month now you read about them not feeling like it would be better if

0:23:34they felt they have more questions than Google they just do because you know

0:23:36there are so many other interesting things you can do with the device that

0:23:38don't matter and you you know you can use Google services for example you can

0:23:43use Google Maps another area where they have little trouble you can use Google

0:23:46now like it's not the whole business is just part of their business and so no

0:23:51one's going to return that thing because series waukee every once in awhile like

0:23:55it doesn't hurt them as much as almost kind of a shame because it hurt them or

0:23:58maybe you know like dropped jobs I think knew they weren't in the Google the

0:24:02stuff better like the MobileMe team and having meetings and trying to do a club

0:24:08like at least he i think he understood we're not good at this we should get

0:24:13better he didn't know how to make that happen apparently but a few short ride

0:24:16so we'll see if there ever comes a time where like I mean I guess Tim Cook maybe

0:24:21did that about maps like apologizing for map so we need to do better and some

0:24:25understanding the master may be just as bad as a data problem and not a server

0:24:29problem I don't know like that the thing about maps of I was like ok well now we

0:24:34just need a better map it's like ok so you have forgotten about the fleet of

0:24:39cars are going to drive over every single road in the entire world take

0:24:42pictures did you forget about that part because you don't get that for free if

0:24:45you just get better map data right

0:24:47Google did that that's a crazy project it's huge and its ongoing right and they

0:24:51don't stop doing it and if you don't have an answer for that you're not gonna

0:24:55have Street View you not gonna have like let me fly 3d through the middle of

0:24:58creeks offices like you're so far from that so how are you ever going to

0:25:01compete it could be that is like walking over never gonna do that we just need

0:25:05maps to say we have maps and they can just continue to use Google Maps are

0:25:09things in Google Maps always gonna be better but that's not an applicant about

0:25:13you know a man and it's not like when I say this is like a ass is a substantial

0:25:18problem the company that probably never change I can imagine to take another

0:25:22example the industry imagine if you know some some Microsoft CEO comes in

0:25:30I guess it's possible some new Microsoft CEO comes in and they say you know what

0:25:35our devices aren't cool everything we make our our our hardware is not cool

0:25:41our software is not cool nobody thinks our stuff for school let's hire somebody

0:25:46in charge of keeping things cool or let's let's just let's increase the

0:25:51funding to our cool department by 50 percent this year like do you think

0:25:55that's really going to change it like it it's not that easy and so I feel like

0:25:59looking at Apple and saying how can they address the server or the Services issue

0:26:04that they their services aren't that good traditionally and continue to be

0:26:08that way I don't think there is an answer I don't think I don't think

0:26:12that's the kind of thing that can change in a large company I think either it's a

0:26:17priority from the start or it's not

0:26:19and the elements that Google has that that enabled them to produce these kind

0:26:26of services that skill very well that prioritize all these things Apple

0:26:29doesn't have those elements and it in the same way that Google's never going

0:26:34to make something client side that has the kind of quality and taste of of an

0:26:39apple client side platforms and software I don't think Apple will ever have what

0:26:45it takes to make good quality services but the good thing in Apple's favor is

0:26:49that the thing that Apple has that measures I think it will seem not to

0:26:52have as it's kind of like it's one of the things he labels intangible and

0:26:56scarecrows cuz it's intentional but it's like it's it's more mysterious whereas

0:27:00the things that Google has our tangible and a great example of it is Google was

0:27:05a company that made web search and index the entire web which is amazing

0:27:07technical field right but they decided they want to have a client-side OS and

0:27:12they did that by making a client-side platform that they conclude took

0:27:17ownership of their own you know don't call it Javed Albuquerque NM their own

0:27:21API their you know their own ideas their own store like they understood if we

0:27:26want to have a client-side mobile platform we need to owner we need to own

0:27:30the technology from top to bottom we're gonna like to find the VMware going to

0:27:33find the language sort of you know Java whatever may decline

0:27:37stuff and we're gonna have the idea they understood that hey we were a

0:27:41server-side company but we want to get into client side and we have we can't do

0:27:44it by like licensing about yourself or someone else we have to take ownership

0:27:47of it so that is a tangible thing and I think that's proof that Apple could if

0:27:51you wanted to say we need to get into service side and we have but also say

0:27:56they had to say it and we need to take ownership of it the same way we take

0:28:00ownership of the inside the thing that's hard to transfer is like tasting culture

0:28:06and coolness that is much harder to do because like there is no coolness

0:28:09Department of Microsoft you can increase funding and 50% something that doesn't

0:28:12exist right that and maybe like I will designers are tangible we just tell them

0:28:17all but like that's hard to do because they don't want to leave that point

0:28:20gonna make something like that wouldn't work because the structure around them

0:28:26is different there like I think the tangible things like a server-side

0:28:31company proved that he can get into client side and take ownership of it I

0:28:33think there's no reason that a client-side company can't prove that it

0:28:36can get into service I don't take ownership of the text I could just

0:28:38didn't do it whereas the the intangibles about coolness and taste and design that

0:28:44is much harder to do like more rarely do you see a company like you know company

0:28:48like saying we're not cool stylish we're gonna put some effort on google has

0:28:52tried to increased style and so as Microsoft but none of them you know

0:28:55they're still there still not reaching the heights at Apple gets in terms of

0:28:59taste and design right they've both made efforts in that area but it seems harder

0:29:02do whereas I would say technology wise but Google has as much control over in a

0:29:08pending whatever the lawsuit is an Oracle but as much control over and like

0:29:12determining its own destiny for all of its core tech all that service id Tech

0:29:17of its clients high-tech hell they want to get back on the link now

0:29:20like they have taken ownership of their text back and so so as Microsoft had

0:29:25ownership and same thing with Amazon you know if they took in during the took

0:29:30ownership of it you know we're not gonna call Android it's going to be whatever

0:29:34the hell the Kindle assets right she s so I think I think it is totally within

0:29:40the realm of possibility too don't you do have to change how the company works

0:29:43like the structure and stuff like that but not in any more radical having

0:29:47Google had to change when

0:29:48you know this episode is brought to you in part by our friends at Squarespace

0:29:54Squarespace is as usual the online platform that makes it fast and easy to

0:30:01create your own professional website or portfolio for a free trial and 10% off

0:30:06the square space.com and use offer code ATP 10 for the show and the month of

0:30:11October could ATP Tennis check out 10 percent off Squarespace so we've been

0:30:16telling you all this time about Squarespace is awesome platform they're

0:30:19constantly improving it you can have new features new designs better support all

0:30:24the time

0:30:24seventy people dedicated to support and growing right here in New York City and

0:30:29Squarespace is awesome just $8 a month and includes a FREE domain name you sign

0:30:33up for a whole year upfront and they're responsive design SEO optimized

0:30:38templates everything that's where space is all set ready to go however what

0:30:43they've also added recently is this entire flexible commerce platform where

0:30:48space commerce is currently available in USA UK Canada Australia Belgium France

0:30:52Germany Holland Netherlands and Spain you can sell any kind of product using a

0:30:57very simple single interface digital goods physical goods whatever you want

0:31:02you can sell this Christmas commerce a partner with our friends at stripe and

0:31:05stripe is awesome and everyone loves them for very good reason

0:31:08strap handles everything so it doesn't charge any fees on top stripe takes 2.9%

0:31:13$0.30 per transaction

0:31:15that's it everything else is included in your Squarespace plan Christmas congress

0:31:19also offers an express checkout mode which bypasses the shopping cart

0:31:22interface if you want to the order management interface lets you track as

0:31:26seen in orders recent customer update emails you can print packing slips all

0:31:30from a single easy to use interface you even in agree with all the regulations

0:31:36so that they handle tax shipping rules everything that you need to know to be

0:31:40able to sell physical or digital goods there PCI compliant everything is secure

0:31:45SSL everything you want in an online store Squarespace Commerce offers so

0:31:51start of Travis Chris base today whether to do in commerce or just a site for

0:31:55yourself or blog or portfolio or a site for your business doesn't involve

0:31:59commerce whatever the case may be

0:32:01you can do it on Squarespace so they take care of the hosting so you don't

0:32:06have to be cancer free trial today with no credit card required a real free

0:32:11trial just goes where space.com start building your site see if you like it if

0:32:15you like it

0:32:16use coupon code ATP 10 at checkout for 10% off thanks a lot to Squarespace for

0:32:21sponsoring ATP there everything you need to create an exceptional website has

0:32:25been making me depressed because I've been wondering websites recently they

0:32:29look like they were designed in 1993 by some sleep aid tons of money like you

0:32:33know home improvement construction companies and their websites they look

0:32:39like they probably spent $15,000 to get some teenager 1994 to make a website

0:32:44Timberland Company and simple things like make appointments are by things

0:32:48like look like like $8 a month in squares Mason for the stripe for like

0:32:53that experience and as always it's cheaper for you it's nice if your

0:32:58customers you make more money it's it's so cheap it's especially good when you

0:33:02look at the prices for the work they're going to like you guys have the money

0:33:04you have all the money in the world you know the prices charged so cheap just

0:33:08get

0:33:08Squarespace but they're so proud of their sites like they invested so much

0:33:12money early on the writers like to tear it down like I was one of those people

0:33:20building the site for people and everything I built was terrible compared

0:33:25to what like any modern web CMS out of the box everything I did back then was

0:33:30horrible and a chargeable so much money does it was all one off but now you

0:33:33don't now you can just go to the big platforms and like I want early all

0:33:38these restaurants / only sites don't get me started they have to be losing more

0:33:42than $8 a month in sales to keep having their stupid flashed some sites to get a

0:33:49clue but they still like you can tell they had they paid someone in the last

0:33:52ten years to do it but it's still gross it's still I can just place just

0:33:56described every time I go I cannot recognize like the stripe form like the

0:33:59fact that it's all clients I dare say so beautiful just like I feel kind of bad

0:34:03because you know I made e-commerce sites too and it used to be such a pain to

0:34:07make e-commerce sites like if we had straight back when we were done in the

0:34:10afternoon

0:34:12has all the features that it's been like months implementing like manually you

0:34:15know if they weren't you know there was no companies that you could like out

0:34:18sources do we do no one knew what they were doing well just like I guess we'll

0:34:22take money from people over the computer it seemed like a crime get away with

0:34:25something but yeah and structurally isn't that old like I like when it came

0:34:30out was the maybe three years ago I mean it's not that old and like I just member

0:34:34even that even like three years ago making money online was still a hassle

0:34:38you basically had like the PayPal API which is a disaster of in every possible

0:34:43way I cannot having run-ins with the PayPal EBI I cannot tell anybody enough

0:34:50how much they should not use PayPal for any of it if you even if you ignore all

0:34:56of the crazy stories about how people like how the paper how locks your

0:34:59account to your money that's bad enough but even when everything's working as

0:35:04intended

0:35:05it's terrible it's absolutely the worst thing in the universe like end for

0:35:11managing recurring subscriptions there's no way to get a list of subscribers

0:35:15still there is still no way to get a list you just have to take it all those

0:35:20messages saying hey new person and keep track of yourself like newsstand only

0:35:24came to that news then that's true I think yeah the new stan has the weird

0:35:31thing we could I don't know anybody like PayPal is the worst like one strike came

0:35:37out a few years ago whenever that was the reason why I made such a splash was

0:35:41like they they're on their page it was like here is like a curl command and

0:35:45here's a block of JSON the equivalent that like here's how you charge

0:35:48somebody's card and it's like these you know four lines or JSON guys one girl

0:35:52come in you're like oh my god that's so much better than anything I've ever seen

0:35:56to this message that there was the Amazon Payments story in the

0:36:05newsweek around like speaking of the death of PayPal PayPal is the Experts

0:36:09Exchange for yes exchange as insert the blankets to pay power and insert the

0:36:17blanket Amazon Payments stripe and all the other companies that finally

0:36:21recognized that despite PayPal being the 800 pound gorilla everybody hates it's

0:36:24terrible

0:36:25indeed the diet all it takes is you know some new services that way out to all as

0:36:32we are to be seen to ALA heard of it but I like the the interest free lending

0:36:36thats keep I think your quarter and you can see you can pay a quarter and yeah

0:36:43it's like it basically I am not sure how it works I think it might be based on a

0:36:48CH or something it but somehow it doesn't use the credit card networks to

0:36:52move money around so they charge only 25 cents but then there's like no fraud

0:36:57protection like it's it works a lot like cash something like that I get it I

0:37:02don't know all the details but somehow they're able to only charged $0.25 for

0:37:08pretty much any size money transfer and a complicated money-laundering scheme

0:37:13that you are you an unwitting participants what was weird is like so I

0:37:17signed up for that a few months ago that that's how we're doing some of our ad

0:37:21payments and liked it it feels wrong because it's so like it feel suspicious

0:37:29to me to only pay 25 cents to move a giant chunk of money somewhere like I i

0:37:34dont know it made me uneasy but you know it it shouldn't it shouldn't though

0:37:38because like it's all the fact that it costs money to transfer money is an

0:37:42artificial constructs artificial constructs based on the old world by now

0:37:46that we have all our computers are connected together like the problem is

0:37:49there's no sort of secure standard for

0:37:53there's no common security standard for transferring money on the corner

0:37:57whatever you know like like really secure and everything is kind of strange

0:38:01game of like Trustin you know parties are sufficiently trustworthy the end and

0:38:07you assume that they're not you know like and then they they communicate over

0:38:10this terrible protocol that it's like a check you know where you just like the

0:38:14account number and routing

0:38:15number and somehow you can send money into people's accounts like the entire

0:38:18banking system has not kept up with current technology it's all kind of a

0:38:22house of cards they were just you know kind of their alright everybody was just

0:38:27not enough blood assists you know things like Paula come in and it does seem like

0:38:32you know what it shouldn't we should be able to transfer money see mostly from

0:38:36account to account why why we need a middleman for that it's because well we

0:38:39don't have any real secure protocols and if we did the NSA would be stopping you

0:38:45know what kind of along same lines as a square cash which I think was under

0:38:49guard sent sent him maybe not somebody sent me hester select right out and

0:38:56basically what's the way it works is you send an email to whoever whomever

0:39:01whatever is supposed to receive the money

0:39:05UCC their email address let the square cash email address and you put the

0:39:11dollar amount subject line and then Square will send an email to the person

0:39:16receiving the cash saying we think somebody's about to pay you hold on they

0:39:21send an email to the person that sent it so they sent it to you saying hey man or

0:39:25girl are you really sure you want to send this money and then what happens is

0:39:30the person receiving the money just inputs their debit card account number

0:39:35and all the money transfer nothing's $0.50 a transfer and I'm sure there's a

0:39:39limit in terms of how much you can send but I don't know what it is so it must

0:39:43be pretty high and that's it it's worth it works flawlessly dollar-something to

0:39:49try it out yet that was pretty neat people that I remember saying that they

0:39:52have a system in Europe that works but this does not surprise me

0:39:54Europe has has all the night Europe is the new Japan already used to be that in

0:39:58Japan they have like flying cars and her boards and then we had nothing at all we

0:40:03have the Azores like da kine Casio keyboards but they have the cool stuff

0:40:06and then their economy tanked but now it's like you know in Europe they have

0:40:09you know socialized medicine

0:40:12and unemployment and switzerland was passing a law that for the minimum

0:40:18monthly income to be the equivalent of $2,800 for all citizens we get so much

0:40:25email from this from people who are like I can't believe how terrible your system

0:40:29in the US's don't you know how much better this is in Europe and the answer

0:40:32is yes we know we are we are very aware of how terrible our system his please

0:40:37you'll have to tell us other I think like i mean they're saying you know they

0:40:39just need some two numbers they could transfer money just like they still

0:40:43don't have the coins actually at the forefront of this technology as sad as

0:40:46it is with their you know crazy thing they have going on there at least they

0:40:50have sort of an attempt to make a secure you know mathematical foundation for

0:40:54distributed middleman list transfers that everyone can be assured are you

0:41:00know happening correctly you know what else you're right and I bring this up

0:41:04only briefly cuz I just watched a video from Mythbusters about this is

0:41:07roundabouts so the Mythbusters which are clearly the the bastion of all things

0:41:12good about science and they never ever flub anything ever they did a test with

0:41:17a four way stop versus around about the roundabout crush the four way stop in

0:41:20terms of throughput and stuff that wasn't me I don't even think that's up

0:41:24for debate i think i think almost every study has always proven that roundabouts

0:41:27really are way better for throughput ya know we have a ton of them around you

0:41:31have them down for you guys ever get Massachusetts the land of the round

0:41:35about them now they're all over the place where they're becoming popular

0:41:39here and it's funny watching everyone tried to navigate them because nobody

0:41:44knows what they're doing

0:41:45John while I'm thinking of it how's the review going do you feel like you have a

0:41:51release date based on the October 22nd iPad everyone's kind of assuming will be

0:41:57Mavericks as well and we gotta get the GMB

0:41:59hours after the election that's right that's right it turned out that Apple

0:42:03Insider story that was pooh-poohing like they had it right it was just they were

0:42:06talking about the people who get like the early see it as soon as I start and

0:42:09went to the Apple website and saw nothing there I'm like oh maybe it's

0:42:13just bogus but it was just you know staged roll out the super duper

0:42:16Appleseed program people got it and then got it so there ya have got to gym

0:42:24boo I had to redo a bunch of screenshots got the things they change just insane

0:42:29like they change functionality to slide like rewrite the entire section because

0:42:33everything I had written about in all the screenshots taken were no longer

0:42:36there and the worst thing about the section had to rewrite is I don't

0:42:39understand one of the things that they changed like they changed the pop-up

0:42:44menus where they are like that what the choices are and understand all the

0:42:48choices except for one and so like right now in my review I have written that I

0:42:52could not figure out what this meant like I tried maybe means this trial no

0:42:57trial I could not figure out of course I asked so many questions but they ignore

0:43:03me so maybe I'll be wrong but having a gem bill is good so I did a lot of work

0:43:08revising things by the end I was getting pissed because it's like you know you

0:43:14know the labels are the tag things or whatever in the Finder public eye color

0:43:20dot next to the fire and rain as you give it like a red lip they change the

0:43:23size of those dots pixel guy just a troll you every single screen shot that

0:43:29have to forget I was like and I like the old times better like they made them

0:43:33like lightly small like I'll come on his own now just like if I had to redo a

0:43:38screenshot cuz they totally change or something works fine but I had to redo

0:43:42the dots mark that's this cruel like the one I tweeted was that one pop-up menu

0:43:47was like two pixels farther away from the label we have to have like some some

0:43:55very high ranking Design Manager on OS ted has to be a listener the show I

0:43:59would just like to say that it and if that is the truth can you imagine even

0:44:04if it's just the whoever's in charge of that particular screen just singing

0:44:07themselves you know what I'm gonna troll John Siracusa moved from the pop-up menu

0:44:11like that when I kind of get a passport because it was misaligned in the

0:44:16pre-release felt like you know what it looks like a bunch of optimism still I

0:44:20can't unless you know their last ages all line up and one of them wasn't the

0:44:23top one was like sticking out more than they were simply correcting like this is

0:44:27something we did a once over every single screening getting one

0:44:31someone Interface Builder like didn't drag little things need to be like you

0:44:34know i mean and so they realigned its like you know I can retake the

0:44:38screenshot like it's just that point I was like really is every screen change

0:44:43in some small way people ask me on twitter is there anything that I let

0:44:46slide like if it's not off like that that I pick the right ones you see that

0:44:53is off I pixel you can't unsee it I'm not gonna leave the previous screenshot

0:44:56and not just because it's purely because it's like hey the top pop up menu is

0:44:59online someone screwed up and Interface Builder I'm gonna fix that one there in

0:45:04every viewer there's at least two or three shots that are not from gym and

0:45:10different ways that only I would notice and I've never been called on it so now

0:45:13I shouldn't say this was not someone's gonna go sit there in like radically

0:45:16different recycling find the one that but rest assured they will be shots in

0:45:20there that were taken not in the GM's the difference in material ways of like

0:45:26you know there that no one will ever notice and I'm ok with that because

0:45:31seriously gonna redo everything when he's the only person on earth who would

0:45:36notice is you are like the person to the graphic designers like I change that

0:45:40that's a different color now that's just you know no not even them like we'll see

0:45:46like it's cumbersome reading especially when like it was just a new screenshots

0:45:50fine but when I had read a whole section because they totally change the

0:45:53functionalities you a tool to the GM's bill to massively changes in personality

0:45:57its and do you think it's ready to be called a gym that's when they started

0:46:04doing this they'd be like here's the GMC Jimmy like what does that mean what does

0:46:08this mean you're seeing us the GMR is this mean that like it will be a ver si

0:46:14released

0:46:14where it says GMC to you because that's the big fear it's like white GMC to that

0:46:21shows that you're misinterpreting the previous title does not mean it was a

0:46:24seat at the gym it meant this is it's like it's like release candidate the

0:46:28terminology of like maybe this is GM's here you go you know and so I really

0:46:34hope they will not be another one this is GMC too and I don't think they're

0:46:36well

0:46:37I think that should be fine I need a price on a date to price in a date I

0:46:42have right now the text number of you says I don't know what the prices

0:46:46because now I can press the button and like publish it and you know I can

0:46:51submit to any bookstore and it would be a valid assuming they don't change the

0:46:55gym right but I also have two morrow different versions based on two

0:46:59different guesses about the price movie so I need a price and date I'm waiting

0:47:03patiently house overcast known as observers also brought to you in part by

0:47:10Audible audible is the leading provider of downloadable audiobooks but over a

0:47:15hundred and fifty thousand titles in virtually every genre their catalogs

0:47:19huge is constantly only a few months ago we were saying a hundred thousand

0:47:23downloads are titles now at a hundred and fifty thousand they're huge and

0:47:27always going if you want to listen to it audible has it you can listen to audio

0:47:31books anytime anywhere they support iPhones iPads computers Kindles even

0:47:36older iPods if you're one of those people still carrying on iPod or if you

0:47:40want to exercise or whatever the case maybe you can even play audio books

0:47:43there are audible offering ATP listeners a free audiobook along with a 30 day

0:47:48trial go to audible podcast dot com slash ATP take advantage of the special

0:47:53offer so John from what I understand you actually have a book recommendation and

0:48:02a new book recommendation because anyone has listened to my past podcast knows

0:48:07that he's talked about the same three books over and over again this is one of

0:48:10them but it's a different context this time it's in the context of an audiobook

0:48:13this book is i i don't realize I refuse but this is the favorite my favorite

0:48:18buyer it ever read it also won a pulitzer prize so it has some pedigree

0:48:21to it and it is also interesting only a book that most people will never ever

0:48:27read on their own in paper form because it's like over a thousand pages and

0:48:32truth be told it's like if you're not into the subject matter that's a lot of

0:48:36pages to read about one person no matter how interesting there were no I am super

0:48:39into this this one person because he is out Robert Moses I knew the CPS and I

0:48:45grew up on Long Island

0:48:47and I went to all the beaches and parks they talk about in here and it's just an

0:48:50amazing experience for me I'm such a crazy now big fan of around to read

0:48:55about how all these things that I enjoyed my youth came to be in there

0:48:59sort of tortured history and the interesting man that was behind them and

0:49:03you know it really is an amazing book but I recognize when I recommend it to

0:49:06people like that like yeah I'm going to read this book over several so get the

0:49:09audiobook and this like everything about this over Marcus if you like to bridge

0:49:13things this is an unabridged audiobook and a thousand page kills prize-winning

0:49:17biography today having a bridge between us like admit to yourself that you're

0:49:24never gonna read it right and instead just uses an audiobook 66 hours like

0:49:29more than two and a half days of cardio he said you're going on like a cross

0:49:34country drive or something this is what you want this I mean think about the

0:49:39value getting for your money for this just unbelievable value enriching your

0:49:45life in a way that you would never do on your own because you have to admit to

0:49:47yourself that you're never going to read this book but you will just stick it in

0:49:50your iPod to listen to it on your drive to and from Europe colleges across the

0:49:55country whatever so highly recommended the power broker realtor prize-winning

0:49:59by Robert Caro a man with an amazing accent your YouTube videos all about

0:50:05long out and Robert Moses two things near and dear to my heart that is

0:50:09awesome

0:50:10Robert Moses himself because he was terrible person but I read the book

0:50:14alright thanks to Michael John Siracusa

0:50:21thanks a lot to audible for sponsoring ATP go to audible podcast dot com slash

0:50:26ATP take advantage of our free 30 day trial

0:50:30thanks a lot audible so it was that your hint that you don't want to know or

0:50:35don't want to share what's going on with overcast there's not a whole lot to

0:50:38share I mean the week went by I am working on it I've been working on it

0:50:44I'm doing a little more with the sync engine today I was running playlist sink

0:50:50and a couple of other preference Inc type of things I mean nothing really

0:50:56exciting

0:50:57optimizations fixes and just moving forward with the feature set adding

0:51:02podcast podcast that's all like still in the works there's still a whole lot

0:51:07missing but that's about it not a gamer in the chat wants you to talk about

0:51:15pricing for the app and and I pricing is interesting but honestly I have not

0:51:23really made a decision yet and there's I'm not just saying that to to be coy I

0:51:28really haven't decided what I'm going to do yet there's a lot of options I really

0:51:32don't think I'm going to do the paid up front

0:51:36thing there's there's a lot of value to that and I could with the new iOS 7

0:51:42receipt validation API I could launch as paid up front

0:51:47see how it goes and then moved to free with a purchase and simply migrate those

0:51:52users over who bought it you can migrate them over and you you basically know if

0:51:57they bought the paid version or not when you make the same app free so you could

0:52:02move from paid to fit within a purchase easily for the first time afterwards

0:52:07before before iOS 7 you could not do that there were no need to thank

0:52:11everybody so I could do that and I i'm I've certainly thought about doing that

0:52:17I'm leaning towards not but the reality is also I'm probably still at least

0:52:24three to four months away from release at least that's why you know i i i said

0:52:30im gonna try it out this year it reality I think like January or February is is

0:52:35more realistic and more likely so all these pricing dynamics could be

0:52:42different then like I might change my mind the business model in the last

0:52:46month I I really don't know so that's about it I guess bTW 14 in the chat ask

0:52:54you a question which I address on another show I don't think I addressed

0:52:57here

0:53:00iTunes Match style subscription to remove ads and give the money to the

0:53:04podcasters basically the readability model collecting money from people and

0:53:08then distributing it to what you listen to

0:53:10there's a number of practical problems to that most of which is what

0:53:16readability faced bitches if you default to collecting money for everyone without

0:53:20them claiming it's kind of weird and there's a lot of issues with the head

0:53:24you could do something I can agree with flatter fighters decent service you know

0:53:28I really my style but but it's a good service and they have good intentions

0:53:32and stuff like that I think the biggest problem with the podcast app or platform

0:53:39collecting money for everybody and distributing it out is that I don't

0:53:44think you could agree I don't think you could get any number of podcasts to

0:53:48really agree on how they want to do that how they want a message that how they

0:53:52want to receive that money a lot of podcasts already collect money directly

0:53:56through themselves and wouldn't want the competition

0:53:58a lot of them it would cause confusion as to who the people should be paying

0:54:02the advertisers but I mean it's not good for advertisers either because like that

0:54:06hybrid thing makes nobody happy like you can even have a broadcast at this

0:54:09listener supported buchanan podcast is ad-supported but when you try to do both

0:54:12it's likely advertisers are pissed the not getting those people who are like

0:54:16paying to skip their ads and so you like your advertising to fewer people and

0:54:21then some people are pissed because they feel like they have to pay for it or

0:54:23should papers they can skip the ads that some people are skipping ads and they're

0:54:26not so it's much cleaner to say look it's free

0:54:29supported by ads or its you pay for it and you know they give you like the

0:54:33magazine top model wears no ads you just pay money like those are such so clean

0:54:37and understandable you don't understand fusion hybrid solutions like especially

0:54:41hybrid solutions that but you impose on people that they haven't chosen to do

0:54:45just exactly and John and it wasn't one last hypocritical episodes were you

0:54:51talked about how advertisers almost always outbid the listeners or

0:54:56indirectly you know that's that's very true like almost always a podcast can

0:55:01make more if you add them through direct payments but anyway there I don't think

0:55:06it's the platform or apps responsibility to let podcasts to to monetize podcasts

0:55:12I think every show is gonna have a different audience with different needs

0:55:15and different priorities and I i think I should just leave it up to the show's

0:55:19and their producers how they want to monetize and where they want to do that

0:55:23also for a practical point of view what didn't instant cast have flattered

0:55:29integration for a while and it cost tons of problems with a preview

0:55:33like anytime you collect money in a nap either not through Apple or if you're

0:55:39collecting money to distribute and some other weird way you know went up in the

0:55:43app you're running a very big risk of being rejected for any update you try to

0:55:47make or being kicked out of the store when you're already in it and that's

0:55:51that's right tiptoeing along the line of what Apple will allow within a purchase

0:55:55rules and it is just ok thank you underscore David Smith it is it is just

0:56:01not worth even risking that and and to build a major feature around depending

0:56:05on that is not wise so not only do I think it wouldn't really get past Apple

0:56:11very reliably but I also don't think it's a very good idea for one particular

0:56:17podcast app or even any group of them to try to create and enforce a new

0:56:22universal podcast monetization model where every shows gonna do something

0:56:26different and even like even the language around collecting the money

0:56:31like I've I talked forever ago on building analyzed about flatter and and

0:56:37joy I think in a couple of things like that where I was saying I don't like

0:56:42that I don't like the idea of having like a tip jar on my site you know like

0:56:48this to socially that's kind of a weird thing to me and I would want to very

0:56:53carefully control any language or implication or pressure around asking

0:56:59people to give me money for something and everyone's gonna have different

0:57:03opinions on what that is for them and what what do what they want to present

0:57:07to people what they want to ask people to give to do and in what context with

0:57:12what language so that there isn't one solution that's going to please

0:57:15everybody who cares about the stuff as much as I do you know another thing that

0:57:20we've got a lot of feedback on and I don't know if there's really anything

0:57:23you can do have to say about this but a lot of people seem to take offense at

0:57:28you saying that the Now Playing screen is the only thing that matters do you

0:57:31have anything that you care about

0:57:34and maybe not I don't know I mean I don't I can see both sides of the story

0:57:38so I don't know I don't have any particularly strong opinions about it

0:57:41but I don't know if you had anything to say yeah I mean I don't take too long in

0:57:45this cause I don't know big too boring but the last episode I i I threw off the

0:57:50comment that I was focusing a lot of my design effort on the Now Playing screen

0:57:54and at the rest of the app could just be like a book a table using it wouldn't

0:57:57matter that much because you know you spend the most time navigating now

0:58:01playing screen and whatever whatever exactly I said there we had a lot of

0:58:05emails from people saying that's wrong as soon as I start playing a show I turn

0:58:10the screen off the phone in my pocket and that's it so I'm interacting more

0:58:13with the rest of the app so what are what I was getting at whether I said it

0:58:18or not who knows if I messed up oh well that's the reality of talking for two

0:58:23hours every week

0:58:25unrehearsed preparation what I what I mean is he now plays for his very

0:58:32frequent interaction with your skipping a section or using the scrubber or

0:58:37playing and pausing casino you to listen to something somewhere else

0:58:41very freaky interaction some of that you can do it the remote but the clicker in

0:58:44some cases some of it you cancel your doing directly so that screams to me

0:58:49like everything else about the app it matters a lot less how it's designed it

0:58:56because of how you desire you're probably going through some kind of list

0:59:01or collection of shows that each within it has a list of episodes or email you

0:59:06have playlist that have that have a list of episodes of them them whenever the

0:59:09cases those are pretty straight forward designs like yeah you can you can tweak

0:59:13in here and there you can add to flourish here in there that you know

0:59:16there's there's a lot of little decisions you can make differently but

0:59:19structurally navigation only the rest of the app is not that hard to design it

0:59:24just isn't it's you know if you want to go that route with with your podcast app

0:59:28feel free but the fact is it doesn't matter how I present a list of episodes

0:59:33in the grand scheme of things I'll try to do as I can but it's not I'm not

0:59:36losing sleep over that the Now Playing screen there's more variability although

0:59:41you wouldn't know it by looking at the apps out there right now but the ability

0:59:45how that can be designed and I think it matters more because maybe you're

0:59:52interacting with it for a split second and putting it back in your pocket but

0:59:55what if you're jogging or what if you're in a car and you can't really look at it

0:59:59safely there a situation like this where it matters how it's designed it matters

1:00:03how it's laid out it matters what's on there and what's not to a level that i

1:00:08think is more nuanced and more important and hearts design for than a list of

1:00:12episodes that's what I meant I think I understood what you meant and what I

1:00:17would have said to my interpretation of what it was that that's where you're

1:00:21concentrating your development effort for the 1.0 because you have to pick

1:00:25something but the one kernel of truth I think was in all the feedback from my

1:00:31perspective is when I think of podcast absolutely no don't use an iPod shuffle

1:00:36that the problem that I would like solved by them that just not solved

1:00:42adequately by most the ones I use is part of the particular way that idea was

1:00:48deciding what I'm going to listen to like when I do it manually

1:00:52it's terrible process of using iTunes iTunes 11 has gotten even worse about

1:00:55this is hunting around for the stupid things dragging them onto my iPod

1:00:59shuffle you know if I'm like a good hunt around for all them and then drag the

1:01:03mall once but unlike after doing two or three trips then I go over the iPod

1:01:06shuffle and all those things are down at the bottom and then I manually drag them

1:01:09up into the order they want and rearrange them and then wait for the

1:01:12sinking right because I have no idea what I want to like okay well today I'm

1:01:17going to do this and then I wasn't that when it comes out and then I'm going to

1:01:20be engine catch up with this podcast and and when I go on this car trip on to

1:01:23these things are so that whole idea of like managing what I'm going to listen

1:01:27to next is the thing that i think is not solved by the current crop land by the

1:01:33current couple I I was broadcast applications and so even though I I

1:01:38would be spending most of my time in the now playing screen features that are

1:01:42important to me are the ones that let me sort of setup my Q no Netflix queue

1:01:48whatever like here's what I'm gonna listen to next make you assist random

1:01:51arbitrariness not like one podcast a higher priority than the other or like

1:01:55there's no automated way to do it

1:01:57manually pick what what I want to listen to my daughter and that's that's what I

1:02:03if I had to pick another part of the UI for your story on that would be the

1:02:06second one because most of the time will be on even now playing screen or the

1:02:10controls on this leads to an arrest ever but to get to that screen at all I have

1:02:15to sort of like you setup makes sense like this i think is that I don't I'm

1:02:22assuming you're not telling us every single feature that you can have the

1:02:25application cause why would you know that's something for people to keep in

1:02:28mind as they don't realize that you're not going to reveal everything up each

1:02:33of those Apple however that you're playing in the future cuz I just not

1:02:36what you do when you're making an application is why would you give your

1:02:38competitors the head start and never mind the teachers that are going to be

1:02:41in version 1.1 and 2.0 and so on and so forth so I will keep that in mind

1:02:46oh yeah I mean that's going to like everything I'm talking about is 1.0 like

1:02:50as soon as I really sit there is hopefully going to be a lot of users and

1:02:55those lot of users are going to give me feedback and are going to use it and

1:02:59with it and expect and are going and I'm gonna see how it works with you know

1:03:02full scale and how the server stuff works and how the have a structure of

1:03:06the app works however usually people are going to go to report problems or

1:03:10suggest improvements that I haven't bought and so all this planning and and

1:03:17all this thinking about the design of making the decisions that's hot as for

1:03:211.0 and it could all change like a month after release it I think about in

1:03:26September 1.0 now compared to you know the final version I don't even want to

1:03:30think about it so long way to go so it's a marathon not a sprint

1:03:35some people have nostalgia and and positive memories and they look back

1:03:40fondly on the stuff they made in the past I am NOT one of those people back

1:03:45on stuff I made like three years ago and was like oh I embarrassed like I I don't

1:03:50even want to think about it I don't want to look at it I i'm just deeply

1:03:54embarrassed by it which is probably unhealthy but he's moving forward at

1:03:59least now

1:04:01good yeah I think so cool thanks to sponsors this week

1:04:08Squarespace and audible and we'll see you next week after our singleton drip

1:04:11indeed now the show is over they didn't even mean to begin it was accidental

1:04:23accidental john Kasay

1:04:30cuz it was accidental and you can be there that's Casey list and a team Marco

1:05:14least we've ever gotten through a little notes documents back at ya now 10 follow

1:05:23up and put in the agency SHIELD item like right before the show and that's

1:05:27when we did this is the first time I've actually got the whole show without even

1:05:32looking at the document that it is exactly two and three cases as long as

1:05:39we stay strong

1:05:40not compromise with negotiate with terrorists here just because we have the

1:05:46majority two out of three people use document the document is official added

1:05:53or not

1:05:54ok so did you see that proposed put out a think that's axonal neutral beam or

1:06:02whatever

1:06:04talk about religious arguments that yes I realize they're actually controversial

1:06:09there there is a chance that we both we all three of us here that's being

1:06:13repaired now it's because it's the IMM er i know i know i understand anyway but

1:06:20like the nickname for the cars beemer that's well that's a religious debate is

1:06:25that the motorcycles are one are bitter or Beamer and the car is or being there

1:06:32and I think the cars access must be Bimmer if you sell it and this is why is

1:06:39devoid saying either of them i don't i don't want to have to deal with it

1:06:42Porsche Jaguar system around through ice and remember they were posted

1:06:54controversy