Podcast Search

Upgrade

644: You Can Put a Few Fingers on It

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:09From Relay this is Upgrade Episode 64.

0:00:13Today's show is brought to you by Squarespace, Celtrios, and Planet Money.

0:00:18My name is Mike Hurley and I'm joined by Jason Snell.

0:00:20Hi, Jason Snell.

0:00:22Hi Mike Hurley, how are you?

0:00:23I'm good.

0:00:23It's a Tuesday.

0:00:24We're all over the place at the moment with timing and everything, but there's

0:00:28Good reasons for all of that.

0:00:29What what what is time?

0:00:31Indeed.

0:00:31Anyway, how how does time work?

0:00:33Time works with orderly segments, which brings me to our Snow Talk question.

0:00:38Savo wants to know, Jason, have you ever been to Ballhalla?

0:00:43Oh, Bahala is the nickname for the home for Chase Center, uh, the home

0:00:49of your WNBA champion Golden State Valkyrie's.

0:00:54Um Man, that game came down to the wire while all the trick-or-treaters were

0:00:59at our house.

0:01:00So I kept on like people are like, they're gonna bring it down.

0:01:03There's only two minutes to go.

0:01:05Trick-or-treat!

0:01:06Ugh, okay, finally.

0:01:08Here's it.

0:01:08Take two.

0:01:09Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

0:01:10Uh Um but they won.

0:01:12It was great, great to see.

0:01:14And um I have been to Chase Center, but I have not been to

0:01:18Balhalla.

0:01:18We thought when the Valkyrie started, we thought, you know, we'll go to a

0:01:21game sometime and we thought the tickets would be available.

0:01:24Tickets are not available, They've sold out every single game they've ever played.

0:01:28And so we have not.

0:01:30I I uh I went um we try to go to a couple of

0:01:33cow women's games a year.

0:01:34Yeah.

0:01:35Those are fun and affordable and you can sit in the first row.

0:01:37But the Valkyries games have been a tough ticket already, and now they're the

0:01:41the champs.

0:01:42So that's exciting.

0:01:43Um but I have been to Chase Center.

0:01:44In fact, Chase Center, I went to a Warriors game when that was my

0:01:47Christmas present one year.

0:01:48Well, no, I'll be let me be specific.

0:01:51Christmas twenty nineteen my Christmas present was Tickets to a Warriors game, which we

0:01:55went to in mid February of twenty twenty.

0:01:59Yeah, so a very long time that was the last sporting event I attended.

0:02:04Yep, yep.

0:02:05Those things get remembered.

0:02:07Yeah.

0:02:07Those things get remembered.

0:02:09So if if we uh broaden it out to Chase Center, I've been there

0:02:12to the actual Valkyries Bahala, I have not.

0:02:15But congratulations to the Valkyries.

0:02:16I wanted to this question is sat in our uh feedback system for a

0:02:20while and I've been waiting for the time to use it and I knew

0:02:23this is the time to use that question.

0:02:24Now's the time.

0:02:25If you would like to send in a snow talk of your own to

0:02:28help us open a future episode of the show, please go to upgradefeedback.com and

0:02:31send in your Snell talk question.

0:02:34The draft happened.

0:02:36The experience happened.

0:02:37We're gonna talk about the ProLed MacBook Pro in a minute, but we need

0:02:41to score the draft.

0:02:42We do.

0:02:43Um it it was okay, I think.

0:02:46I think we did okay in the end.

0:02:47I was worried uh When I initially scored it, I thought it was like,

0:02:51did I win like two to one, one to nothing?

0:02:54What was this?

0:02:55But no.

0:02:56Um, I think we're gonna call it three to two.

0:02:59Yep.

0:02:59I think one of your points is arguable, but I also won the tie

0:03:03break.

0:03:03So it doesn't matter.

0:03:05Yep.

0:03:05So your three correct picks.

0:03:07What I got right.

0:03:08Yep.

0:03:09Dynamic Island on the MacBook Pro.

0:03:12Um significantly lighter.

0:03:14I was afraid to pick three pounds so I picked three point one pounds.

0:03:18It is three pounds.

0:03:19Mm-hmm.

0:03:20Current models remain in the lineup,

0:03:24um, which they do.

0:03:26Yeah, yeah.

0:03:27And what I got wrong is significantly thinner.

0:03:30They are insignificantly thinner and configurable with more than 120 gigs of RAM.

0:03:35Ha ha ha.

0:03:35In this economy, no.

0:03:37Yep.

0:03:38Uh mine was the the arguable one is Apple reveals new touch specific features

0:03:43of macOS.

0:03:44There was a lot of discussion in our Discord.

0:03:45People were arguing on my side.

0:03:47I would not have given myself this point.

0:03:49But if it was down to me maybe winning, I maybe would argue.

0:03:54I think it's arguable.

0:03:56I think in the spirit of the pick, the idea was you were saying

0:04:02Apple's gonna do something new and different with uh touching.

0:04:05Well Gilma was talking about these like you touch it and a wheel would

0:04:08pop up around you.

0:04:10Exactly.

0:04:10Yeah.

0:04:11And and so the arguments, the lawyerly arguments in our Discord about this feature

0:04:16are

0:04:17but you can, you know, but but you can do multi-touch, but you can

0:04:20swipe between apps that you've never been able to do that on the I

0:04:23mean, some of that you had then with the trackpad.

0:04:25But there were some arguments about that.

0:04:26And I said, I don't know.

0:04:28That just feels like implementing touch.

0:04:31Yeah.

0:04:32Not a new feature of Mac OS that features touch.

0:04:36So that was I so yes, I think that if it if if this

0:04:40was the difference between who wins and who loses, it would probably be worth

0:04:44a more detailed argument and appeal to Steven.

0:04:47But I think in terms of how how you and I envisioned this pick,

0:04:53we thought it would be one of these wild Mark German, like they're completely

0:04:56reimagining X.

0:04:57And in fact, I think as we'll get to in a little bit, one

0:05:00of the stories of the um the touch MacBook Pro with uh oh with

0:05:04ProLED display is that they did not reinvent the Mac.

0:05:08And we can talk about that and there was some criticism of it um

0:05:12that I don't think is justified, but we will we can get into that.

0:05:15But but um I think that's why this one doesn't it was they added

0:05:20touch, but they didn't add like touch and then a new Mac thing on

0:05:23top of it that uses touch.

0:05:25It's just they added touch.

0:05:26Yeah.

0:05:26So which is actually quite surprising.

0:05:29I think

0:05:30I don't know what I think about that, but I wanna myself and you'll

0:05:34break it down so we'll find about how about that.

0:05:35Uh Apple details a new hinge system for the MacBook Pro.

0:05:38This one I wasn't sure about.

0:05:40They didn't say what I thought they were gonna say, but then in the

0:05:42press release it talks about how they engineered a new hinge.

0:05:45So yeah.

0:05:46I I mean Turnus mentioned it when he came out, he mentioned a hinge

0:05:49and I'm like, Oh Mike.

0:05:50I thought there was no way they were gonna talk about this.

0:05:53It felt like a lot to me for the reason they did it, but

0:05:56I thought they would talk about it more.

0:05:57It's just that like the current laptops, if you tap their screens, they're moving

0:06:01around.

0:06:01They just go back.

0:06:02And so like you have to do something.

0:06:05Like so I knew they would do something, but then I was nervous about

0:06:08how much they would talk about it.

0:06:10Um Apple claims more than twenty four hours battery life.

0:06:13I did not get, which is a shame.

0:06:14They still claim twenty four, Offit of sixteen.

0:06:17Apple describes the display as tandemoled.

0:06:19It is a tandem OLED display, the second tandemoled Tandemola display and John Turnus

0:06:23appears in a launch video.

0:06:25They did not make kind of like a a launch video for this product,

0:06:28which I'm uh so it was three to two.

0:06:30I take this as an absolute storming victory for me because you were convinced

0:06:35I would get zero points.

0:06:36And so I laugh in your face with two points, but congratulations on remaining

0:06:40uh draft champion.

0:06:41You did really well.

0:06:42I'm proud of you.

0:06:43Thank you so much.

0:06:44I I don't exactly know how to take that.

0:06:46Uh let's talk about the ProLed MacBook Pro.

0:06:48So So you uh were in LA for what looked like from the outside

0:06:54a real influencer event and and I and I wonder what that was like

0:06:58for you.

0:06:58Um but it it really looked like that.

0:07:01It was it was a lot there were a lot of interesting people there.

0:07:04It was also f it felt it felt really LA to me.

0:07:07Like some of the conversations I were hearing were just so

0:07:12um LA.

0:07:14So LA.

0:07:15There's no other way to put it.

0:07:16I don't even know how to say it.

0:07:17Like, who are these people and what are they talking about?

0:07:19It was just very funny um to to to hear that.

0:07:24So um anyway, so yeah, it it uh it was unusual and then it

0:07:29was in an unusual space.

0:07:30It actually reminded me so much of what they did in New York for

0:07:32the Mech McNeil event.

0:07:34It was a I think maybe it had it'd been a studio space because

0:07:38it's LA, but like like kind of a warren of corridors and different kind

0:07:45of freeform areas.

0:07:47And like I kept turning the wrong way to go to this lounge and

0:07:51there was another lounge up here.

0:07:52But like you could go through into a patio and Like it was just

0:07:56kinda it was just a weird scene.

0:07:58Um, but there was places and it was packed.

0:08:00That's the other thing is it was so there were so many people there.

0:08:03Um that when they opened the hands-on area, I just went to the cafe

0:08:07and wrote a story.

0:08:08Yeah.

0:08:08And then went back to the hands on after because uh there was no

0:08:13point in even trying.

0:08:14It seemed like you had a long time anyway, right?

0:08:16So like what yeah, because you're not that kind of like publication where you

0:08:20need to rush to get photos, you can just leave that until later.

0:08:25If you know it's like, Oh, they're not gonna kick me out in ten

0:08:27minutes time, you just come back, right?

0:08:29No, I had I'd uh add another night on the hotel stay because they're

0:08:32like events will go into the evening and so you should plan on leaving

0:08:35the next morning.

0:08:36I'm like all right, I guess I'm here all day and I was there

0:08:39all day.

0:08:40Um I did not stay into the DJ set, which means I did not

0:08:45get to get my picture taken with John Turnus like Federico did.

0:08:48Yes.

0:08:48I did have a moment where I thought, you know what?

0:08:50I am tired and hungry and it's you know, it's already like seven.

0:08:54I'm gonna go back to the hotel.

0:08:56There was a Korean barbecue across the street.

0:08:58I got some bulgogee, um, watched the end of the world series, um, did

0:09:02some work and went to sleep because I had a very early flight home.

0:09:06So yeah.

0:09:07Um it's an interesting product.

0:09:09Um so to get pick up back where we were talking about with the

0:09:12draft and with the touch feature, let's start there.

0:09:14Like okay, let's first let's start with this, which is

0:09:18Touch is super important for the Mac as a whole when you're thinking about

0:09:23what the Mac is as a platform.

0:09:27Touch is not that important on this product.

0:09:29I mean, it's novel, but like I don't think anybody should rush out and

0:09:34buy this thing because it's got a touch screen on it.

0:09:37OLED is the reason.

0:09:38The OLED display is the reason for this product.

0:09:40And the lightness of it is the reason for this product.

0:09:43The touch is

0:09:45interesting.

0:09:46Again, notable from a newsy perspective and a platform perspective.

0:09:50But like I saw I saw some people, and again, the world is full

0:09:54of disingenuous arguments, but I saw some people making the argument of like, why

0:09:58would I spend so much money just to get touch on a Mac laptop?

0:10:01And it's like, well, you wouldn't you wouldn't There was a there was a

0:10:04question as to whether you would, right?

0:10:05Before we saw it.

0:10:06Like what what is this experience gonna be like?

0:10:08And now we've seen it.

0:10:09It's like, no, you actually wouldn't do this.

0:10:11It's just a thing you have.

0:10:12It's like you don't it's not a reason to buy the computer.

0:10:16So this is yes, Apple is Apple was very restrained.

0:10:20Apple brought every kind of touch feature that they have learned about from the

0:10:24iPad and the iPhone and they put it in there.

0:10:27It is multi-touch.

0:10:28There are some cases where you, I mean, and again, their use cases are

0:10:32very specific because they basically they got a somebody who writes a logic plugin

0:10:37to support multi-touch.

0:10:38But the idea there is that that logic plugin, which is skew m skewomorphic,

0:10:42so it's got a bunch of different.

0:10:44You could put a few fingers on it and and make a DJ kind

0:10:48a bunch of DJ effects with it.

0:10:50And like that's something you can't do on the Mac.

0:10:52You can't, it's not like that CSI episode or whatever where those two people

0:10:55are on the one keyboard.

0:10:57It's not like you can just keep plugging in mice and have like four

0:11:00pointers and you're like, oh, I can point at everything now.

0:11:03It doesn't work.

0:11:04There's one pointer.

0:11:05But you can but you can touch

0:11:08the screen with multiple digits and it will actually respond that plugin responds to

0:11:15all of those inputs simultaneously.

0:11:17That is new for the Mac.

0:11:18So that's fun.

0:11:18Yeah.

0:11:19That's fun.

0:11:20But for the most part, you know, you tap a menu, the the the

0:11:24the letting between the leg menu items i they space out a little bit.

0:11:27That's it.

0:11:28They're the affordances are incredibly conservative.

0:11:31They're incredibly minor.

0:11:32It is thorough and careful, but not dramatic.

0:11:37And

0:11:38I I I hear the arguments that some people are making saying they wish

0:11:42it were more dramatic.

0:11:43And I get, I get it, but I I I'm sorry.

0:11:46It feels to me sort of like a I, you know, come on, do

0:11:48something interesting.

0:11:49I want something interesting to write about more than an argument.

0:11:51So here's my argument about why it isn't like that, which is

0:11:55this is just a laptop.

0:11:57This is a conventional laptop.

0:12:00You don't I mean people are like, oh, does it support Apple?

0:12:03Pencil?

0:12:03It's like it's a laptop.

0:12:05I would hate to try to write on it in Apple Pencil.

0:12:09It's like way over there over the keyboard.

0:12:11It doesn't bend fun.

0:12:13Like people are like, oh, it's not a convertible.

0:12:14It's like, it's not.

0:12:16Now, there were never any rumors that it was going to be a a

0:12:18convertible, like a wraparound display or something like that.

0:12:21But here's the thing.

0:12:23It's also not evidence.

0:12:24This conservative approach to touch is not evidence that Apple isn't considering more innovative

0:12:31Touch on macOS.

0:12:32Yeah.

0:12:32Yeah.

0:12:32It but not on this laptop.

0:12:35And here's the thing that Apple doesn't ever do.

0:12:38Apple doesn't ship a suite of touch features that only make sense on a

0:12:43convertible laptop.

0:12:46On a non-convertible laptop.

0:12:48Yep.

0:12:48Because why would you do that?

0:12:50Yep.

0:12:50That product doesn't exist.

0:12:52They save those features for when they do, if they ever do, a convertible

0:12:57laptop.

0:12:57And yeah, you can see if you look at this product that it would

0:13:01be interesting if instead of the great mic endorsed hinge that's on it, there

0:13:06was a different kind of hinge mechanism that maybe la let you turn it

0:13:09around and lay it down and then it's heavy but it's a three-pound like

0:13:14tablet, but it is kind of like you could do Apple Pencil on it,

0:13:18and you could do more intensive touch stuff.

0:13:20But it that's not the product that they're shipping.

0:13:23And this is just a traditional laptop.

0:13:27It's like the people who are who are playing gotcha with the zombie arms

0:13:30thing are also com criticizing that there isn't more to give you zombie arms.

0:13:34It's like Apple's not wrong in that this is a secondary input device.

0:13:39It's it's nice to have it will have some nice benefits.

0:13:42But even then when the people are demoing stuff in LA and they're like,

0:13:46oh look, and there's this three I 3D item and I can kind of

0:13:49turn it a little bit, like

0:13:51a lot of those, I looked at it and I said, yeah

0:13:56you can.

0:13:57But I kept coming back to will you?

0:13:59And how often will you?

0:14:00Because it's up there on your screen and is it gonna be and I

0:14:04can see like there are moments we're having that tactile ability, being able to

0:14:08touch an uh an iOS app in the simulator.

0:14:10Like there there are gonna be moments where it makes sense to touch the

0:14:14screen.

0:14:14And that's why it's a touch screen.

0:14:16Yep.

0:14:16But even in Apple's demos, they were leaning into it, I think, more than

0:14:21was realistic.

0:14:22Cause I think it's just not it's it's again, it's really interesting that they're

0:14:26doing it, but it's not

0:14:30as a it's interesting for the platform more than it is for the product,

0:14:33I guess is what I would say.

0:14:34Yeah, I like there are places where I imagine it would work really nicely

0:14:38for me, but it's not all the time.

0:14:39But it's like I'm spending so much more time in Photoshop, right?

0:14:42Like making YouTube thumbnails for design in California.

0:14:44And something I find really annoying with a mouse sometimes is resizing things and

0:14:49it's so much nicer for me to resize with like a pinch gesture.

0:14:53Like I find that so much more responsive.

0:14:56That's a good one.

0:14:57But it's not gonna be like, well I must buy this MacBook Pro.

0:15:00But it's like if I had that MacBook Pro, I would be like, oh

0:15:03that's the thing that I could do that would be nice.

0:15:05And so here's the thing tandem OLED is not gonna come to the entire

0:15:10m Apple laptop line.

0:15:12Yeah.

0:15:13For a long time if ever.

0:15:14Right?

0:15:14Like a regular.

0:15:16Like we're gonna talk about the iPad Mini later, but that's not a tandem

0:15:18OLED, it's just an OLED.

0:15:20And same as on the iPhone.

0:15:21The iPhone's not a tandem OLED.

0:15:22And there will be an OLED MacBook Pro or MacBook Air at some point

0:15:25and that will happen.

0:15:26But like but here I will say this.

0:15:29I think in the next at the event I said three to five years.

0:15:34It may be sooner.

0:15:36We don't know.

0:15:37But I would be shocked if every Apple laptop shipping in five years wasn't

0:15:42a touch screen.

0:15:43Yeah.

0:15:43I think it's just gonna happen.

0:15:44I I don't think this is a a pro high end only feature.

0:15:48I think this is just a platform nice to have platform feature that will

0:15:51just be assumed in five years.

0:15:53And I think at that point, that's when we might start to see Mac

0:15:56OS start to change a little bit more right?

0:15:59Like if if they're shipping multiple and not like in big ways, but that

0:16:02you know, if they're shipping multiple computers with touch screens, we may start to

0:16:06see some stuff that didn't work before start to creep into the system.

0:16:12I still think it's gonna take a I I think it's hardware that makes

0:16:14you want to use the touch screen more.

0:16:16Sure.

0:16:16For stuff like that to happen.

0:16:17But maybe it's possible.

0:16:18But I do think it's gonna be everywhere.

0:16:20It might be one of these things that they're just not sure about yet,

0:16:22but like once they start shipping it, they're like oh you know what, people

0:16:25are doing this more than we thought they were, kind of thing.

0:16:28Yeah, you know.

0:16:29Could be.

0:16:29Could be.

0:16:30But I think it's just gonna go everywhere because I think it's I mean,

0:16:32it's kind of table stakes for screens now, right?

0:16:34We expect to be able to touch our screens.

0:16:36Yes.

0:16:37And um it's not that big a deal.

0:16:39And and I think that's good that it's big a deal.

0:16:41It's just another the way it works, if I wanted to sum it up,

0:16:44I would say the way that touch on this thing works

0:16:47is

0:16:49the way you expect the things happen the way you expect them to happen

0:16:55when you didn't think about it and tried to touch your max screen.

0:16:59That's how they work.

0:17:00They work the way if you if you reach out and touch your max

0:17:03screen and it doesn't do anything.

0:17:05Ask yourself, what I think was gonna happen there.

0:17:08Yeah.

0:17:09That's what they implemented.

0:17:11They implemented just logical what you thought would happen happens.

0:17:14If you if you flip your finger up on a Safari window it flips

0:17:17up like you're on an iPad.

0:17:18Like it's just not it it doesn't get weird.

0:17:22It just is fine.

0:17:23Okay.

0:17:24So the display isn't just a touch panel though.

0:17:26It's also the ProLED display.

0:17:28Which it is the ProLED display.

0:17:30Look, we're in we're near we're nearly a week removed from this.

0:17:33Um my initial reaction to ProLED is that it is a ridiculous name and

0:17:38you shouldn't put a pun in your in your product like this.

0:17:42Uh I I still don't like the name ProLed, but I've warmed to it

0:17:46in the way that it doesn't make me angry anymore.

0:17:49I'm just kind of like ambivalent to it.

0:17:51I would say it's not much dumber than all of Apple's other branded displays,

0:17:57which if I

0:18:05I wouldn't call this a pun.

0:18:06I think they're it it's there's probably a technical term for it.

0:18:09It's literally two s two syllables run together.

0:18:13It literally is just they didn't want to say pro OLED, so they said

0:18:16pro LED.

0:18:17Yeah, but they didn't say pro OLED.

0:18:19It didn't need to be called the pro OLED.

0:18:21Like they don't call anything else s like Pro.

0:18:23But they would they needed they this is the cute name they came up

0:18:25for.

0:18:25I like look, I I'd say that it would be completely irrelevant if they

0:18:29weren't needing to use it to differentiate between the existing MacBook Pros that are

0:18:34in the product line.

0:18:35Yeah.

0:18:36If they had replaced them, they could have just said it's the new MacBook

0:18:39Pro and then with Pro ProLED display XDR or ProLED XBR display, whatever it

0:18:45is.

0:18:45Yep.

0:18:46And it would have been the it we would have ignored it like we

0:18:51always ignore their branding of their displays, but that is um not what they

0:18:55had to do.

0:18:56And so all of the like model descriptions and the compare thing and all

0:19:01of that all say with pro led.

0:19:03So um it's a mouthful, it's silly, in the end it won't matter.

0:19:07Like they they used to call the MacBook Pro the MacBook Pro with retina

0:19:11display, right?

0:19:12Like that is the the the what we are modeling this on is what

0:19:15they're kinda modeling this on was when they added retina displays to the MacBook

0:19:19Pro, they kept it around at the top end and it was called the

0:19:22MacBook Pro of Retina Display.

0:19:23So they're doing the same here.

0:19:25They could have called this the MacBook Pro with Touch, but you understand why

0:19:29they wouldn't do this.

0:19:30That's why they didn't trying to kind of downplay a little bit.

0:19:33It's like, hey, you can touch it, not you should, right?

0:19:37That's not what the that's not what the point of the product is.

0:19:40And and yeah, it it's not we also didn't call it MacBook Pro with

0:19:45retina display, right?

0:19:46We called it the Retina MacBook Pro.

0:19:47And I think we'll probably call this the touch or the OLED MacBook Pro

0:19:50is probably

0:19:52MacBook Pro is probably OLED MacBook Pro makes the most sense.

0:19:55Yeah.

0:19:55And then in a year or two, they will this will be the only

0:19:57MacBook Pro they sell, and it won't be differentiated by the dumb name anymore.

0:20:02So I may even just call it the ProLED.

0:20:04I might just lean into it.

0:20:05You know, I'm just gonna call it ProLED.

0:20:07It's the ProLED laptop.

0:20:08Uh but the ProLED XDR display, Tandemoled display, I mean the Tandem OLED display

0:20:13on my iPad Pro is the absolute best display that I own of any

0:20:17kind.

0:20:18It is truly stunning when you see HDR content on that thing.

0:20:22Like and it is just the colours and everything is fantastic.

0:20:26Is this also a fantastic display?

0:20:29Oh yeah.

0:20:30Yeah, like real good.

0:20:31Yeah.

0:20:33Like like so good you'll be mad when you have to plug it into

0:20:36a studio display kinda good.

0:20:38Maybe.

0:20:39I don't I don't I only briefly saw that studio display uh X DR

0:20:43that you have.

0:20:44My studio display XDR is great, but it is not to the quality level

0:20:48of my iPad Pro.

0:20:49So you know, like to to me at least.

0:20:51I mean it's like it's this funny thing of like even um like when

0:20:54I had the MacBook Pro and the studio display when I was using like

0:20:58the fourteen inch MacBook Pro, like the M one version, I was really annoyed

0:21:03because that had promotion and it would plug it into my studio display and

0:21:06I wouldn't have promotion.

0:21:08And I imagine that it will be a similar thing here where this is

0:21:11this stunning OLED display with the dynamic island and all that kind of stuff.

0:21:16Then you plug it into the studio display and you're like even the X

0:21:19DR and you're like, I'm not getting everything I could be getting.

0:21:23And you're not getting, you know, and if you've the lid is closed, you're

0:21:26not touching anything either.

0:21:27Um yeah, it it looks again, seeing it in a a controlled environment in

0:21:32LA, um, obviously with the best possible images on it and all of that.

0:21:37But it was very impressive and they did a demo where they did the

0:21:39poor thing, just like with a Neo, where they card out a PC laptop

0:21:42and say, This is the best PC laptop with a tandemoled display.

0:21:46And you will not be surprised to discover that it did not look good

0:21:50compared to Apple's display and take that for what it's worth.

0:21:54I'm sure that the maker of that display would say, Hey, that's not fair.

0:21:58You did this wrong or that that wrong or maybe they would admit, Yeah,

0:22:02you know, the ours is cheaper or whatever but um it did look spectacular.

0:22:07It it it is and again, that's why somebody would buy this thing.

0:22:11People are like, I don't know why anybody would spend that kind of money

0:22:12on it.

0:22:13First off, it's what, four hundred dollars more than the equivalent MacBook Pro, which

0:22:16is already expensive.

0:22:16I get it.

0:22:17But like if you're somebody who is especially doing professional work where you care

0:22:23about color and dynamic range, well, there it is.

0:22:27Or if you're gonna use those Mac laptop.

0:22:29Right.

0:22:29Cause like, you know, a lot of people like you, you know, you use

0:22:31your laptop docked.

0:22:33So it it you're using it less than if you were using it every

0:22:37day.

0:22:38Maybe if you're using it every day, you you may want the best screen

0:22:41available.

0:22:42Yeah.

0:22:42Ergonomics are a real question.

0:22:44I I think Apple has for a while done this because they've been boasting

0:22:47about their screens and now even more they're showing these workstations where there's like

0:22:51a studio display

0:22:53and in front of it there's a laptop with a screen open.

0:22:57Yeah.

0:22:58Because they they're like, no, no, no, no, the right way to do this

0:23:00is to run the lid open because then you can use the OLED display

0:23:05and then you can touch the display.

0:23:07So, you know, I don't know whether that will become a trend and whether

0:23:11I think people should try it if they buy this thing and they want

0:23:13to run it with an external display.

0:23:15You should you should try to see if you can do it so that

0:23:17like it's in front of you.

0:23:19Ergonomically, I would not recommend that.

0:23:22You'll be looking down at that display, which is not good for you.

0:23:25Um I do.

0:23:26Which is why people have the stands, right?

0:23:29So you put your laptop up on a stand.

0:23:31That would be my recommendation for people.

0:23:33But yes, I know.

0:23:34They're gonna recommend it.

0:23:36And I do do this like I you know, when I when I'm at

0:23:38home in Edina's office and I'm editing a podcast, I sometimes would I need

0:23:43the I need my trackpad.

0:23:44She doesn't have a trackpad on her desk, just a mouse.

0:23:47And so it's well I'm gonna open this display but I'll use the display

0:23:50in front of me and I'm using the trackpad and and the mouse so

0:23:53I can do some editing or whatever, but not ideal.

0:23:56So this computer, this laptop, it is part of the MacBook Pro range.

0:24:01It isn't something else as we mentioned.

0:24:04And it features the M5 Pro and M5 Max, which is kind of what

0:24:08we expected, but you you ne you can never be sure until it's there.

0:24:12Um do you have any kind of reflections on that?

0:24:16Mark German was right.

0:24:18Yeah.

0:24:19This whole this whole product is a Mark Gurman was right.

0:24:21And don't don't think I didn't mention that to John Gruber.

0:24:24Um

0:24:26I was talking to somebody else.

0:24:28I think I was talking to Federico and I said, you know, Gurman had

0:24:30this.

0:24:30Gurman had this in like January 2023 or something.

0:24:33He said they're working on a touch screen MacBook Pro.

0:24:36Um

0:24:37And that carried through and happened.

0:24:41And he had the he broke that story about the M6 Pro and Max

0:24:45not happening.

0:24:46And boy, we would be scratching our heads today if we didn't know that

0:24:50tidbit.

0:24:51Yeah.

0:24:51And they had announced these things without new chips in them.

0:24:53Because I guess we didn't mention the the fourteen inch MacBook Pro now starts

0:24:58with an M six that happened since our last episode.

0:25:02The unupdated Updated for now, maybe next year, but the the it doesn't have

0:25:08any of the other benefits.

0:25:09It's like the old design, but it's an M6 instead of an M5 now.

0:25:12But these are M5 Pro and Max.

0:25:15We would be spending lots of minutes talking about the weirdness of that right?

0:25:19Like if Mark hadn't already reported that Apple's gonna basically jump straight to M

0:25:23seven I was thinking while I was in LA, I had a lot of

0:25:26time to think I was there all day, that

0:25:29m Mark Gurman basically did them a favor.

0:25:32And then in fact if Mark German hadn't reported that, they should they would

0:25:35have leaked it to the Wall Street Journal or something.

0:25:37Yeah.

0:25:38Because

0:25:39the last thing you would want is for your product launch to be about

0:25:42Apple killing a uh a chip or blacking a faster chip or something.

0:25:48It just wouldn't make sense, right?

0:25:49Like it just wouldn't make any logical sense.

0:25:52And the expectations just German's report completely eliminated any expectations that they were these

0:25:58were gonna be M sixes.

0:25:59Um and and I'd say it's validation, right?

0:26:01Now we know that's the story he told is like they're gonna skip to

0:26:04the M seven.

0:26:05Because clear clearly these were going to be M six Pro and Max.

0:26:08That was the idea.

0:26:10And I mean I mean maybe not but I I think i it's hard

0:26:14not to look at this and think that must have been what they were

0:26:16planning and then when they made their kind of swerve, according to German, um,

0:26:21this is what you get, which is you get a new laptop with an

0:26:23old chip.

0:26:24So there's no performance story here really to speak of.

0:26:26It's the same laptop chip we already saw.

0:26:29Um next year, maybe M seven.

0:26:32Yeah.

0:26:33Yeah, we'll probably talk about this in the in the following weeks.

0:26:35But yes, Mark is talking about the fact that the next one will be

0:26:38the M seven and s yes, some timing on that will probably be next

0:26:41week.

0:26:41But yeah.

0:26:42Next fall, the following spring.

0:26:44But it makes sense.

0:26:45I mean the M five M five Pro, M5 Max, great chips, and this

0:26:49product is more about the body, right, of the MacBook Pro than it is

0:26:53about the insides in that way.

0:26:56Like, you know, in that we mentioned it already, but it's much lighter.

0:26:59Do you feel that?

0:27:00Like when you pick it up, does does it does it feel meaningfully different?

0:27:04I mean as a um as a user of an M4 Max MacBook Pro.

0:27:09Um, you can tell.

0:27:10I mean, that's that's a lot.

0:27:12That's you know, a lot of weight lost.

0:27:15It's more than 10%.

0:27:17It's it's a it's in a laptop, you pick it up.

0:27:20I mean, obviously you'll get used to it over time, right?

0:27:22Whatever the weight of your laptop Top is but um you pick it up

0:27:26and you know when I picked up the fourteen, when I picked up the

0:27:29sixteen, I was like, This is not as big and bulky as I thought

0:27:33it would be, because it's lighter, even though it's still huge, it's lighter, and

0:27:37the fourteen is at three pounds.

0:27:39That's pretty great.

0:27:40That's pretty great.

0:27:41And I asked Apple, how did you not drop battery life and lose, you

0:27:47know, four tenths of a pound or whatever?

0:27:50And

0:27:53I didn't get a satisfying answer, but I did I think

0:27:58when you go OLED, you drop a bunch of components like the LED backlighting.

0:28:04Um, and they said that that helped a lot and that they also tried

0:28:07on the bottom case, they tried a bunch of stuff to remove weight.

0:28:11Um

0:28:13so

0:28:15uh and I think uh in the end they removed some battery because the

0:28:18OLED uses so much less power.

0:28:20Yeah.

0:28:21So they were able to remove battery.

0:28:22Could be some some kind of chassis chassis change too, right?

0:28:25Like maybe they were able to be more efficient with

0:28:28body design.

0:28:29There there's some stuff that happened in the in the lower area that that

0:28:32um that was part of that.

0:28:34But I think part of it too is that they did end up dropping

0:28:37battery somewhat in order because they knew that the OLED would make it all

0:28:42um more power efficient than right it would normally be.

0:28:46You said about removing the backlight.

0:28:48Well they added another light.

0:28:50The light up logo on the back of the display is back as uh

0:28:53there's a video I put in the show notes that somebody took of John

0:28:56Tannis introducing it to you all and he says there's one other thing that

0:28:59I think you're really gonna like and then he shows it on the video

0:29:02and he says the logo's back.

0:29:05This seems like you know, on the face of it, putting the light up

0:29:10Apple logo back onto the back of the laptop feels like such a small

0:29:13thing but I've been really stuck on this of like

0:29:17it feels quite monumental to me in a way, of John Turnus' apple.

0:29:24Like he is aware of this, like we are aware of this about like

0:29:28how much we used to love those and how iconic it was.

0:29:31And they've decided to bring it back to do the extra engineering work that's

0:29:35required because they've had to put a light in the back of the case

0:29:38because there's no backlight anymore, which is how it was done before.

0:29:42I find this just to be a very encouraging little detail, um of of

0:29:48care to the Mac, uh which I really, really appreciate.

0:29:53Do you have any deep thoughts uh on this?

0:29:58Um

0:30:00I mean my deep my deep thought is

0:30:04first of all, they wouldn't tell me how they did it, but I think

0:30:06it's very clear that there's no light there's no like light leakage back there

0:30:09that they can use like they could for an LED backlight.

0:30:12So

0:30:13w somebody will have to take it apart and find out.

0:30:15They lit it.

0:30:17And so this is Apple making a design and engineering decision that they want

0:30:22their Apple logo to light up.

0:30:24Which, let me tell you, it's great for the Apple brand.

0:30:28Not only is it sort of delightful for the product, but it's Apple brand

0:30:31to walk into a room and there are a bunch of light up Apple

0:30:33logos in there, and the fact that they went away from this is kind

0:30:35of bananas, if you think about it.

0:30:37Yep.

0:30:38Um I I what was that argument?

0:30:41Who won that argument?

0:30:42Why did they listen to Johnny Ive?

0:30:44You change things just to change them.

0:30:45Right and I think it's just that.

0:30:47It's like we've done this for so long, it's time to do something else.

0:30:49And they just didn't.

0:30:51And now we're doing something else again.

0:30:52We're going back to it.

0:30:53Going back to it.

0:30:54But like they put in work here.

0:30:55So I what I would say is I I just think it's delightful because

0:30:58this is an engineering and design decision that certainly added complexity and probably cost

0:31:03to this product.

0:31:04But they did it because they thought it would make the product more fun,

0:31:09better.

0:31:10Like I make the users happy.

0:31:11I love that.

0:31:12Like he knows that people that really care about the MacBook Pro are gonna

0:31:15be happy about this.

0:31:16And we are.

0:31:17We're very happy about this.

0:31:18It's like, yes, that's the kind of stuff.

0:31:21Like, let's do this.

0:31:22Like that's delightful.

0:31:25It's gleeful, right?

0:31:26It's like one of the things that we've loved about them.

0:31:28And it I think that that is becoming more and more evident in a

0:31:32lot of their products again.

0:31:33Little little bits of glee.

0:31:37Like the the way that the duo display opens.

0:31:39It's like I lo you didn't need to do that.

0:31:42I love that you do it though, right?

0:31:43There it's got that animation.

0:31:44It's like brilliant.

0:31:45I'm very happy that you did that.

0:31:47It's like a fun thing to have.

0:31:49So I I I think a lot of this stuff it makes me it

0:31:51makes me very happy.

0:31:52It makes me very um hopeful for for their product design going into the

0:31:56future.

0:31:57Yeah.

0:31:57And just to answer a couple of questions that have come up.

0:32:01Okay.

0:32:01Um there's an accessibility setting to turn it off.

0:32:04Okay.

0:32:05If you don't want to have it light up.

0:32:07At all.

0:32:07And and because you know, you the moment you do something like bring back

0:32:11a fun feature, immediately somebody'll say, I actually don't like that feature.

0:32:14How dare you?

0:32:15So you turn it off.

0:32:18Um if you don't like fun, you can turn it off.

0:32:21That's uh and separately, it seems to adjust automatically along with the f the

0:32:28the the screen.

0:32:29Yeah.

0:32:29Even though I think they are not related.

0:32:31But they seem to have set it so that they adjust.

0:32:34So when the screen is dim, it's dim.

0:32:36And when the screen is bright, it's bright, which is a pretty good proxy

0:32:39for like the environment you're in.

0:32:41That you're probably not in like super darkness with the the screen turned up

0:32:45all the way.

0:32:46Yeah.

0:32:46And if you are, then maybe it blasts out by then.

0:32:49But um anyway, more when we know more, but everything is controlled there.

0:32:53I asked my questions.

0:32:55I literally was told that it's magic.

0:32:57So they won't they won't talk about it.

0:33:00Then we're gonna have to wait for iFix it to see if that's the

0:33:02little gremlin.

0:33:03See if that magic is in there.

0:33:04Chip find find the little elf who lives inside each one and interview him.

0:33:08iFixit.

0:33:10So this is still very much a MacBook Pro.

0:33:13And you know, like it it it it is it's not a huge leap.

0:33:18Um it is not the MacBook Ultra that we had in our minds at

0:33:23certain points when when thinking about what this product could be.

0:33:27There's still stuff missing, you know people that want a cell radio like a

0:33:31cell connection in there, mobile connection, they're not gonna get it, it's not there.

0:33:35It's still very much a MacBook Pro, right?

0:33:37Do you do you find this to be I mean look, we'll have more

0:33:39to say on this when we get the chance to use one, um, maybe

0:33:44review one, but it feels right now like this is very much a MacBook

0:33:48Pro.

0:33:48It is literally the same MacBook Pro that was already out, except with a

0:33:55drastically better screen

0:33:57and it weighs half a pound less.

0:34:00And it's got touch.

0:34:02Yep.

0:34:02Oh, did I mention it's got touch.

0:34:04It does also have that.

0:34:05But it's not i again

0:34:09It's not a rethinking of the MacBook Pro.

0:34:11There is there is an argument to be made.

0:34:13I'm not sure if I would make it, but it it's worth thinking about.

0:34:19Is Apple too restrained when it comes to its It's laptop design.

0:34:24Are they too samey?

0:34:25Have they been too samey for so long?

0:34:27Now, we'll we'll I'm sure we'll talk about this at some point in the

0:34:32future, but I'll I'll do the short version of my take on it now,

0:34:35which is I think there's room for Apple to experiment

0:34:40with Mac

0:34:42stuff, Mac laptops, Mac portable things.

0:34:46I think there's rough,

0:34:48but not by making your high end professional laptop weird.

0:34:53I think that look to the iPhone Duo.

0:34:56If they want to make a convertible or something, they should make a convertible.

0:35:00But the MacBook Pro is a meat and potatoes kind of computer.

0:35:04It's a workhorse.

0:35:06It is a workhorse.

0:35:07They need um they need to offer that.

0:35:11And and I would just say, 'cause Steven Hackett was on MacBreak Weekly last

0:35:15week and we noticed that it was literally ten years to the day that

0:35:21they released those first USB-C laptops that were kind of so disastrous

0:35:28and but with butterfly keyboards and all the rest.

0:35:31Mm-hmm.

0:35:34That's the kind of reinventing the MacBook Pro would be that kind of decision.

0:35:39Because pe they we one of the reasons the MacBook Pro is what it

0:35:43is is because that's what people want.

0:35:45They they have found, they have tinkered, they have refined.

0:35:48That's what people want.

0:35:50If we want Apple to get weird, they should get weird.

0:35:54But not by taking a very important product that people care and turning it

0:36:00into some weird experiment.

0:36:02Instead, do the weird experiment as another product.

0:36:05If they want to make a convertible, I would love for them to go

0:36:07down that path and say, what if we did make an Apple pencil capable

0:36:10fold back thing that's not an iPad, it's a Mac, but it's it'll give

0:36:15get you a touch mode and be kind of iPad-like.

0:36:17And what does that look like?

0:36:18And maybe that's your MacBook Studio, right?

0:36:21Maybe.

0:36:22But um

0:36:24Do that somewhere else, right?

0:36:26Don't do that to the to the MacBook Pro.

0:36:29So more to come on this in the future, uh, I expect.

0:36:32Um get to spend time with them.

0:36:35Um I wanna mention one item of follow up on last week's episode I

0:36:39referenced uh an app that Marco Arment had made called Fine Liner.

0:36:44It is now available.

0:36:45Um I don't really want to talk too much about this.

0:36:47I actually would like to at some point in the future, but not yet,

0:36:50because as we mentioned, it's a

0:36:53Very rare that you will use an app that has spoilers.

0:36:57And like I don't want to spoil what this app does when you first

0:37:02launch it.

0:37:03What I will say is if you have access to a device with an

0:37:08Apple pencil of of any kind, whether that be an iPad or a duo

0:37:12or or whatever.

0:37:14That's the way I recommend you try this device for the first time.

0:37:18Sure, but even if you just have to use your finger, yeah, uh you

0:37:20can do it.

0:37:21It's delightful.

0:37:22I'm just saying if if you have an Apple Pencil, don't download this on

0:37:24your iPhone and use it on your iPhone.

0:37:26Like download it on your iPad and use it on your iPad.

0:37:29I agree.

0:37:29But it's um because it's free, it's worth going through the the the setup.

0:37:34Like this is the funny thing about this app.

0:37:36Usually you get the onboarding experience and like, oh God.

0:37:39Oh my god.

0:37:40Mm-hmm.

0:37:41The onboarding experience in this is the best.

0:37:43It is the best.

0:37:45It's the thing that I love.

0:37:46It is so good.

0:37:46It's unbelievable.

0:37:47So you you gotta go try it.

0:37:49It's a Fineliner.app.

0:37:50Uh I wanted to mention it because I I referenced it last week and

0:37:53it's out now.

0:37:53And I think I really want people to try this because it's Yeah, it's

0:37:56fun.

0:37:57It's fun.

0:37:58It's hilarious.

0:37:59We gotta keep this one in mind for uh the upgradies.

0:38:02I think so.

0:38:04This episode is brought to you by Squarespace, the all-in-one website platform designed to

0:38:10help you stand out and succeed online.

0:38:12Whether you're just getting started or scaling a business, Squarespace will give you all

0:38:16of the tools that you need to claim your domain, showcase your offerings for

0:38:19a professional website, grow your brand, and get paid all in one place.

0:38:24With Squarespace, you can design a beautiful professional online presence that fits your brand

0:38:29or business of cutting-edge design tools.

0:38:31And they have a bunch of different ways that you can start.

0:38:33One of the things that I've done with Squarespace for years is take a

0:38:36look at their beautiful, like um they have like l so many design templates

0:38:40that you can choose from.

0:38:41These like beautiful galleries and you can go through and click through, see what

0:38:44works for you.

0:38:45They also have a new system call Blueprint AI, which is their AI enhanced

0:38:49design partner.

0:38:50You can choose from these professionally designed templates that I mentioned.

0:38:53They're all award-winning.

0:38:55Uh your website is flexible to what you need.

0:38:57So you get started with one of these things.

0:38:59No matter which way you get started, it's just a starting point.

0:39:02Then you can use their intuitive drag and drop editing tools with beautiful styling

0:39:06options and unrivaled visual design effects on-brand content and more to list what you

0:39:12offer to show your site, to show your blog.

0:39:14There's no experience required.

0:39:16And you can truly make something that looks exactly how you want and it's

0:39:19always going to look professional.

0:39:21They they really are the best at this.

0:39:22It's one of the reasons that I've been using Squarespace for various projects for

0:39:26like 20 years at this point.

0:39:28You can also start an online store with Squarespace.

0:39:31Whether you offer services, sell products, or do both, Squarespace gives you everything you

0:39:35need to grow a business and get paid all in one place.

0:39:38You can create that beautifully designed website or online store that showcases your brand

0:39:42and engages with customers.

0:39:44They have easy online payments and built-in tools for inventory management, shipping, and fulfillment

0:39:49so you can simplify your workflow and give customers a truly seamless shopping experience.

0:39:54Head to squarespace.com/slash upgrade and you can sign up for a free trial right

0:39:58now.

0:39:59And when you're ready to launch, use the offer code upgrade and you'll save

0:40:02ten percent of your first purchase of a website or domain.

0:40:05That is squarespace.com slash upgrade and the offer code upgrade.

0:40:09You will get ten percent off your first purchase and show your support for

0:40:12the show.

0:40:12Our thanks to Squarespace for their support of this show and all of Relay.

0:40:19Today is you published your iPad mini review.

0:40:22It's one of the many reasons uh that today's episode came out on Tuesday

0:40:27rather than Monday.

0:40:28There's many of them and this is one of them.

0:40:30So you've had an iPad mini for like a week?

0:40:34Or a few days, something like that.

0:40:36Um I have had an iPad mini since last week, yes.

0:40:39Which d what do you have?

0:40:41Do you have the the nanotexture one?

0:40:43I have the nano I have the most expensive.

0:40:45I have the whatever that would be eleven hundred dollar.

0:40:48It's the nine ninety nine plus a hundred dollar for nanotexture.

0:40:52I it's yeah yeah.

0:40:53I have a I have the pricey one with nanotexture.

0:40:56So it's got all the bells and whistles.

0:40:57You also when talking about this we'll also And all the cores.

0:41:00Oh, we love all the cores.

0:41:01And

0:41:03two neural engines, two dual cool.

0:41:05I do have two neural neural engines.

0:41:07So that's gonna be smoking.

0:41:08Shout out to John Voorhees who actually tested an app that uses the Neural

0:41:11Engine to generate transcripts so he could say, Yep, it's fast.

0:41:14Like, yeah, I'm sure it is.

0:41:15I'll put John's review in the show notes so people can see his uh

0:41:19statistics on that.

0:41:21Um

0:41:22You also last week got the opportunity to sit down with two of the

0:41:28product managers for this product.

0:41:30So friend of the show.

0:41:31Uh friend of the show, Tom Boger Tim Boger, not Tom, Tim.

0:41:34I actually after that it was over, I said say hi to Tim Millet

0:41:39for me.

0:41:40He's like, okay.

0:41:41Yep.

0:41:42Friend of the show.

0:41:42Come back.

0:41:43Tim Tom, come back.

0:41:44And Dave and Dave Pacula, who is the VP of hardware engineering.

0:41:47He's uh he's a rising star on the hardware side.

0:41:49He's a a Turnus adjacent figure.

0:41:53And uh I think I never interviewed him before but Apple's getting him out

0:41:56there.

0:41:57Apple's I sometimes I feel like I'm the training wheels for Apple uh executive

0:42:02interviews.

0:42:02Yep.

0:42:03Like a few.

0:42:04We you know, where it's like we're just, you know, getting you getting ya

0:42:07getting a fan of you, yeah.

0:42:09But yeah.

0:42:09Yeah.

0:42:10So we're gonna talk about some of the quotes there.

0:42:12I'll put both links in the show notes as well.

0:42:14Um we were talking last week about the article that you had written in

0:42:19advance of the iPad Mini being unveiled.

0:42:22Wondering if the iPad Mini was the best iPad was the article that you

0:42:26were writing.

0:42:26Because because it's sort of like people love it and it fits in places

0:42:31and it has a a kind of a reason for being or several reasons

0:42:34for being that put it where some of the other iPads it's like, what

0:42:38is this for?

0:42:39And then the iPad mini is like, well, people love it because it's for

0:42:41all the things that people love it for.

0:42:43And obviously we're gonna jump into all of the details.

0:42:46But kind of just like on a top level, I I was wondering the

0:42:49the additions that Apple have made to the iPad Mini, has it made the

0:42:54the iPad mini even better or has it just brought it to a kind

0:42:58of even keel for what you would expect the iPad mini to have compared

0:43:02to the other iPads that are around it?

0:43:05Well I mean all but the low end iPad are now OLED, right?

0:43:08Mm-hmm.

0:43:08And so this is OLED.

0:43:10Not tandem fancy OLED, but OLED.

0:43:13Right?

0:43:13Does the air have OLED?

0:43:15No, the iPad Air is not OLED.

0:43:16Oh the iPad Air will have OLED, according to Mark Erman.

0:43:19It's all happening, right?

0:43:20But it's low end OLED.

0:43:21So yeah i look, the mini is out of cycle.

0:43:24They're all out of cycle.

0:43:25iPads get updated weird.

0:43:26But in the end, that's that's gonna be table stakes for uh an iPad

0:43:30with this cost, right?

0:43:31'Cause the air will get that too.

0:43:32A lower end OLED display.

0:43:34Okay, so there's one.

0:43:36Um but it's nice and it get lets it be thinner and it lets

0:43:42it it it it it gets to be better.

0:43:45Um and then it's the A20, which again it hasn't been updated in two

0:43:49years.

0:43:50A twenty pro, that is the current iPhone chip.

0:43:53That is I I the way I wanted to put it in perspective for

0:43:57this is um it this thing is so much faster than the MacBook Neo

0:44:02because it's using an A twenty pro instead of an A eighteen pro.

0:44:05It's funny.

0:44:06So MacBook Neo just just doesn't matter what we talk about, the MacBook Neo

0:44:10always finds its way into the conversation.

0:44:12Yeah, well it's an interesting it's an interesting part.

0:44:14But I wrote a speculative piece about what the next generation MacBook Neo would

0:44:18be.

0:44:18And I wrote that it would sort sort of be a bummer if it

0:44:20was based on the A19 and not the A20, because the A20 seems so

0:44:24much more powerful than the A19.

0:44:26And uh look, here's the Lil iPad Mini and it's got the full on

0:44:30A twenty pro.

0:44:30Again, one of the reasons they're overspecking it for today is because um they're

0:44:35not gonna update this next year, right?

0:44:37They're gonna update this in two or three years.

0:44:38It'll be it'll be a while.

0:44:40It's gonna be even longer.

0:44:41Yeah.

0:44:41Maybe even longer.

0:44:43So you this is what you do.

0:44:45You pack in those features now because you know it's gonna have a long

0:44:48shelf life.

0:44:49Um

0:44:51So I I don't know, I mean, my take and my review is basically

0:44:56the the secret to the iPad mini is that it's an iPad.

0:44:59That right and talking to those guys, the versatility they keep coming out.

0:45:04That's got lots of use cases.

0:45:05It's not made for a use case.

0:45:07And I think this is the truth of it, is they don't make it

0:45:10for a use case.

0:45:11There is not a like iPad mini for boats and an iPad mini for

0:45:15airplane pilots and iPad mini for the Wichita linemen.

0:45:18Instead, it's like they make an iPad and in this case OLED lighter, thinner

0:45:26and um uh and nanotexture and dust and water resistance, which means that it's

0:45:33iPad you can take out in the working world, which people already do, with

0:45:38a little more confidence.

0:45:39That's all all what's going on with that product.

0:45:42But what the iPad Mini isn't and has never been from the beginning is

0:45:46not an iPad.

0:45:46It's not like, well, it's an iPad, but you wouldn't do any iPad things

0:45:50on it beyond the basics because it won't work very well.

0:45:52It's like I've edited a video on an iPad mini.

0:45:54I've edited a podcast on an iPad mini.

0:45:56Like John Voorhees ran machine learning models on the iPad mini.

0:46:01Like it's a full iPad.

0:46:03And part of my review argument too is like if you want a unit

0:46:07because I I know people are gonna use it the way they want to

0:46:09use it, but like does it make sense to buy one of these and

0:46:12use it as a uh as an a e reader, basically, as a book

0:46:15reader?

0:46:15The answer is no.

0:46:16Like the most expensive Kindle paper white is a fraction of the cost of

0:46:20this thing.

0:46:21But what this thing is good for is the iPad things.

0:46:24It doesn't just read books.

0:46:26You can go through your email and it'll you can look at the web

0:46:28and you can look at social media and you can edit photos and you

0:46:32can like and you can do literally everything that an iPad can do.

0:46:36And if that has value, then the price starts to make sense.

0:46:41If all it is is like an ebook reader, like it's not a unitasker.

0:46:45It's multitasker in the truest sense it can do lots of stuff because it

0:46:49can do everything an iPad can do.

0:46:51Like everything, right down to like multi-window support and like ev it it'll drive

0:46:57a 4K external display and you can have multiple windows.

0:47:02Like it's an iPad.

0:47:03Yeah.

0:47:04So so that's why it costs what it does.

0:47:07And that's why they loaded it with the features.

0:47:09They're like they they've just decided they're not gonna make that that base iPad

0:47:14is the compromised iPad, right?

0:47:16That's as compromised as they're willing to take the iPad.

0:47:18And they don't the Mini, and I think they've learned lessons of who uses

0:47:22the Mini, they don't think the mini audience is an audience that's searching for

0:47:27the cheapest iPad.

0:47:29They want the smallest iPad because the iPad's really good as a portable device,

0:47:35and a small one fits in a lot of different places that uh literally

0:47:38that other ones don't.

0:47:39But it's not the Barkenbin iPad and it's not spec' that way.

0:47:44So that's that's why OLED, why nanotexture, like all of those things.

0:47:49Yeah, I mean it's like, you know, you're saying about the i is an

0:47:52iPad, it does iPad things and it's not compromised in that way.

0:47:57We now kind of have a sense for Apple making something that is the

0:48:01size of a tablet but is not an iPad, right?

0:48:04Like we we know what that is now with the iPhone duo.

0:48:07Like that is an iPhone.

0:48:09So it does not do all of the things that an iPad can do.

0:48:12The iPad Mini absolutely does.

0:48:15Like it does all of the things.

0:48:18Um and there have been times when the Mini didn't do all of those

0:48:22things, but s you know, like w different multitasking, but that was just because

0:48:26of like it was locked off, but like s many iPads were locked off

0:48:29because of what the chips were inside.

0:48:31Right.

0:48:32But since they kind of got their hands around the much better multitasking tasking

0:48:36system that exists now, you now can do all of that stuff on the

0:48:40mini.

0:48:41I just remember the first mini came out and it was like, Well what's

0:48:43this gonna be?

0:48:44And the answer was it's just a little iPad.

0:48:45Like it did all the things that an iPad did.

0:48:47It was not min iPad light or something.

0:48:50And then the second one was the incredible one where it had like the

0:48:54exact same specs as the I think it was the air at the time.

0:48:58Like they had the same chips in them and everything.

0:48:59So you was just choosing what size do you want.

0:49:02And so many people like me went with the mini to have this really

0:49:05powerful, fantastic dis like screen and like uh the pixel density, which we cared

0:49:11about so much then, and it was little and it was a brilliant iPad.

0:49:14But and then since then it's like, well

0:49:17The iPad sits in this weird spot, right?

0:49:19It's not the cheapest by design.

0:49:21Just because it's smallest doesn't make it cheapest.

0:49:24They put a bunch of additional features in it from a power perspective because

0:49:29of that.

0:49:29So just because it's little is not the cheapest.

0:49:31It kind of sits in the middle of the line and it becomes this

0:49:34product that is like the people that love it really love it and they

0:49:38want it for specific reasons.

0:49:40Uh and so then we end up with a product like this.

0:49:43Now, the dis just to touch on the display a little bit more.

0:49:46Uh Apple told you they built the whole product around the display, right?

0:49:50Yeah, that was the premise.

0:49:51That was the starting point for the product.

0:49:54Everything else came from that.

0:49:55Dave Pakula, I read from the the interview that you had, the VP of

0:49:59Harbor Engineering.

0:50:00We were able to make the product thinner because there's fewer layers than the

0:50:03display stack and the Olay panel itself is thinner.

0:50:06We were able to make the screen go from eight point three to eight

0:50:08point five inches in the same footprint because of the narrower borders of the

0:50:11OLED.

0:50:12Once we flipped the switch and said we're gonna do this thing on OLED,

0:50:15it opened up a tremendous number of opportunities and everything got better because of

0:50:19it.

0:50:20Yeah.

0:50:20So you can see the progression that like I mean there this is an

0:50:23interesting story.

0:50:23We don't hear about this a lot, but it's like they did this interview

0:50:28and they told the story of how they made it.

0:50:29And the the story of how they made it starts with the OLED panel,

0:50:32and then everything starts to follow from that.

0:50:34So it's OLED panel means we can make the screen bigger without obviously I

0:50:38think they didn't want to break like every accessory and stuff, so it's still

0:50:42the same physical size, uh like width-wise, I think.

0:50:46Uh it's a little it's thinner, which is really nice, but it it it

0:50:49it is an eight point five in the eight point three space because the

0:50:54borders are narrower, so the bezels are narrower.

0:50:57And then they started like then you don't have the backlighting, and then they

0:51:00all just kinda like everything else kind of ticks out from there, according to

0:51:03them.

0:51:03That was that was where they started.

0:51:05They didn't start nanotexture or uh let's do weird stuff with the speakers or

0:51:12let's make it dust resistant.

0:51:14They they started with the OLED.

0:51:15That was the premise of the product.

0:51:16Looking at the technical specs, there's very tiny differences, like a a couple of

0:51:24millimeters It's it's immaterial differences, but yes, there are some differences there.

0:51:29But it basically basically they tried to keep it roughly the same size as

0:51:32the old iPad mini, but thinner.

0:51:34Yeah.

0:51:35And with this OLED.

0:51:36And then, you know, um it doesn't do promotion.

0:51:40It's this is such a bummer to me, man.

0:51:42I'm so sad about that.

0:51:44I I I get it and I use multiple promotion devices.

0:51:48My um my MacBook Pro has promotion.

0:51:52My iPhones have promotion.

0:51:55I didn't really notice it.

0:51:57I mean maybe maybe some of that is that it's just a I mean

0:52:00it it's small, it's I I have a nanotexture one, maybe it's just a

0:52:04different look.

0:52:05Mm-hmm But like I didn't even have the moment of scrolling and being like,

0:52:09Oh no, it doesn't it it's fine.

0:52:11It j it just didn't I never felt let down by it.

0:52:14If you're somebody who really, really, really notices, I can see why that would

0:52:17be a bummer.

0:52:18Um I I want to be empathetic, but I can tell you as a

0:52:21user who has spent time with promotion devices My iPad Pro 13 is ProMotion

0:52:272, right?

0:52:27Like and I was using that like migrated from the iPad Pro.

0:52:31I was using it on this iPad Mini.

0:52:33I just didn't even notice it.

0:52:35Maybe, I mean, maybe some of it is that the pixels are also small

0:52:39because it's it's really like an iPad just kind of s shrunk down.

0:52:43Yeah.

0:52:43So everything is smaller.

0:52:44All the widgets are really small.

0:52:46Um, but it just it never ticked a box with me.

0:52:52I never had a moment.

0:52:53I was looking for the moment when I scrolled something and went, oh, disappointment.

0:52:57And I never found it.

0:52:59So that's all I can do is be honest.

0:53:01I I just I I get why people are disappointed theoretically by that but

0:53:06it just didn't

0:53:09it just didn't get rise to the level of noticeability for me.

0:53:13I understand.

0:53:14It frustrates me though.

0:53:16Like it and as a weird thing, it's like the principle of it.

0:53:19It just should get it.

0:53:20It just should have it.

0:53:21Uh but it's it's it is a sh I think it's a shame.

0:53:24But if you feel like the experience is still good, then that is that's

0:53:29great.

0:53:29Uh the nanotexture on a on the iPad mini, I'm assuming, looks really good

0:53:34in the same way that it looks good on everything and works great for

0:53:38the things that you wanted to use an iPad mini for, right?

0:53:41Reading and and watching content and stuff like that, especially outside.

0:53:45Of course.

0:53:45Yeah.

0:53:46Yeah.

0:53:46Having that nanotexture display takes a little getting used to.

0:53:48I mean, I I feel like one of the bluntest things in my review

0:53:51is

0:53:53if you get the nanotexture display, just know you are giving up some of

0:53:59the most impressive feature of an OLED display, which is pure black.

0:54:04Mm-hmm.

0:54:05Because everything's kind of gray.

0:54:06Yes.

0:54:07And as somebody with an iPad Pro 13 with tandem OLED display.

0:54:12Um Those blacks are real black, real deep.

0:54:16And on this iPad mini, I know, not as good a display, but also

0:54:19it's got nanotexture on it and I watch video on it.

0:54:22And like it's nice.

0:54:23It looks really nice, but it's got that sheen, that anti glare sheen, it

0:54:29just does.

0:54:29And so you need to decide, are you the kind of person who buys

0:54:33an iPad and watches TV and movies and darkened rooms?

0:54:37Or are you somebody who's out on the patio, who's out at the beach,

0:54:40whatever on the on the telephone pole.

0:54:43Um these are the decisions you have to make.

0:54:46Usually

0:54:47with Apple with like you pay extra for something, it means you're getting a

0:54:51better product.

0:54:52I don't believe that nanotexture is equal to better.

0:54:55It is just a thing that you can opt for, but there are absolutely

0:54:59times when it makes the screen worse.

0:55:02Like I see it with my duo all the time, right?

0:55:04I'm looking at something, I close it, looking at the same thing and I'm

0:55:08like, this looks so much better to me on this front display.

0:55:12Because it's much more vibrant, the color is much stronger, there's you know, there's

0:55:17more contrast, but I love the way the nanotexture feels.

0:55:21There are times when I think it looks fantastic, but it is not like

0:55:24a universal thing.

0:55:26And so I think that's the same with the with the mini here, right?

0:55:29You gotta want straight up.

0:55:30The difference the difference is you get to choose.

0:55:31Yes.

0:55:32Whether you want to spend that a hundred dollars and it's gotta be on

0:55:35one of the two higher end skews, it can't be on the low end

0:55:37skew.

0:55:37Yeah.

0:55:37So you read it.

0:55:38Spend at least a hundred dollar higher skew and a hundred dollars for the

0:55:41nanotexture if you want the nanotexture.

0:55:43But I think if you know, you know.

0:55:44But I I wanted to warn people like

0:55:47Saying, well, I'll get the nanotexture because I might use it outside, you should

0:55:51think about it.

0:55:52Yeah.

0:55:52Because if you're really use it in those kind of weird lighting conditions, I

0:55:55wouldn't because you're going to lose some of the magic of the of the

0:55:59OLED blacks because it's all gonna be kind of hazed out a little bit.

0:56:03Just that's just how it has to be.

0:56:06All of them, no matter what you get though, with the iPad mini, have

0:56:09the IP sixty seven ratings.

0:56:12Yes.

0:56:12First resistant iPad.

0:56:14I've had to stuff.

0:56:16Uh IP sixty seven essentially means it can take a splash but don't dunk

0:56:21it, right?

0:56:22Is the idea.

0:56:23It means you can it could be submerged in water up to a meter

0:56:26for thirty seconds.

0:56:27Yeah.

0:56:27So it means that you could drop it in the bathtub and then pull

0:56:31it out.

0:56:32And it should be fine.

0:56:34Now, when I talked to Tom Boger about this, he was like, Look, I

0:56:37asked somebody why they were excited about I think at the event, why they

0:56:41were excited about the water resistance, and they're like, I want to take it

0:56:43in the bathtub with me.

0:56:44And he's like, Mm.

0:56:45Like, it's not a waterproof no shower skin.

0:56:48Can I read this quote from Dave Paculi, which I just think is hilarious

0:56:51from your article?

0:56:52Using it in the bathtub was definitely not a grounding recommendation for us.

0:56:56They weren't saying let's make an iPad mini that you can use in the

0:57:00bathtub.

0:57:01But what they did say is if you have it at the pool and

0:57:06your kid drops it in, it should survive.

0:57:09Like iPhones, right?

0:57:10Apple doesn't say, hey, everybody, go swimming with your iPhone in.

0:57:15You probably shouldn't because if there's anything wrong with any of the seals, water

0:57:19ingress ruins your phone.

0:57:20Guess what?

0:57:21Apple's actually not responsible for that.

0:57:23You are.

0:57:24IP sixty-seven is one meter for thirty minutes.

0:57:28Oh, one meter for thirty minutes.

0:57:30Right.

0:57:30Okay.

0:57:30So the idea here is you should be s it's like Gorilla Glass.

0:57:34It's a thing where it's when you drop it, it should But it shouldn't

0:57:37be so bad.

0:57:37And this is like the first iPad that's that they've been able to make

0:57:40that claim.

0:57:41Um and uh and and I get the sense that especially for the iPad,

0:57:46dust is a big part of it too.

0:57:48Basically, this is an iPad that you could feel good taking outdoors.

0:57:52Yeah.

0:57:52That in dusty conditions, dirty conditions, it's not gonna have that dust ingress.

0:57:57Um IP sixty seven also means basically dust won't get in.

0:58:01Um and then for water, like what they said is it's also for a

0:58:05lot of their customers, it's like out in the rain.

0:58:08It's gonna get splashed.

0:58:10Yeah.

0:58:11Stuff like that, that it'll be fine.

0:58:13It'll be fine.

0:58:14So there's uh on the VergeCast they have this run long running joke about

0:58:18Apple's all gonna keep making the iPad mini forever because pilots use it.

0:58:22And I found it really funny, this is a quote from Tom Boger from

0:58:25the pilot who straps it to their leg in a helicopter to a doctor

0:58:28doing some serious stuff of an iPad mini that just fits perfectly in their

0:58:32lab coat to field service technicians.

0:58:34And for them, something like IP sixty seven is huge for them.

0:58:37Uh I don't like thinking about what the doctor's doing where you need it

0:58:41to be water resistant like I don't like thinking about that, like the the

0:58:45the the doctor or a surgeon, but nevertheless Apple seems focused on uh on

0:58:51delivering a product with the iPad mini that is versatile for work and for

0:58:56like being a little computer that is full featured, that can be with the

0:59:00person who's out there doing stuff.

0:59:03And I'm happy that they think of it that way, 'cause I think that

0:59:05is a really nice use for this versatile product.

0:59:10Yeah, I think so.

0:59:10That's the idea here is that um the the and they this came through

0:59:13with it was funny because I wrote that piece that basically said the same

0:59:16thing and then they they came in and said, Look, versatility is the whole

0:59:19thing.

0:59:19It's it it fits in so many different workflows.

0:59:22They didn't invent it for one.

0:59:23The this th this isn't the iPad for pilots.

0:59:26It is, but like they didn't make it for pilots.

0:59:28There isn't like a separate iPad for for for the Wichita linemen, right?

0:59:32Again, it's just one iPad and then you decide what you want to do.

0:59:36He's still on the line, you know, the Wichita.

0:59:38Lyman.

0:59:39He's still on the line.

0:59:40He's working on it.

0:59:41They I I d I don't know what this reason is.

0:59:44Oh, you're gonna you're gonna listen now.

0:59:45Now you have to listen.

0:59:46It's famous song.

0:59:48Okay.

0:59:48Wichita Lyman.

0:59:50Glenn Campbell, I wanna say?

0:59:51Okay.

0:59:52It's actually kind of a great song.

0:59:54All right.

0:59:55The which I'm alignment for the county.

0:59:57Anyway, it's yeah.

0:59:59We already referenced the A twenty chip a little bit, but you know, it

1:00:03just seems like it's powerful enough to do anything that this iPad's gonna need

1:00:06to do for probably quite a long time, right?

1:00:09Yeah.

1:00:10I mean this is this is a modern chip, so that's gonna give this

1:00:13product a lot of life.

1:00:14And in fact, uh not just life uh for buyers of it, but a

1:00:18lot of life for people who are gonna be buying it in three years

1:00:21when they're still selling it.

1:00:23It it's uh yeah, this is their latest.

1:00:26I mean, i i they put they did not make the Mac mini or

1:00:29the iPad mini wait at the back of the line and get last year's

1:00:32chip.

1:00:32Right?

1:00:33They didn't get last year's chip.

1:00:34They got this year's chip.

1:00:36And uh and that's good.

1:00:38That's good.

1:00:39Makes it a again, it's not cheap, but you do get a lot when

1:00:43you get it.

1:00:43As you say, a full featured product at a full featured price.

1:00:47It's kind of nothing that you we can do really.

1:00:49It just is what it is, right?

1:00:51We're gonna talk about earnings and profit margins and all this kind of stuff

1:00:54in a minute.

1:00:55I I don't even really know how to think or talk about the pricing

1:00:59of somebody's products now because it's like I I don't feel like Apple's doing

1:01:03what Apple of Old used to do, right?

1:01:05Um, where it's just like w they're just making this more expensive for the

1:01:08sake of it.

1:01:09It it feels like this product is where it is because of the world

1:01:14that's around it.

1:01:15Like an i it it maybe would have come in at the price that

1:01:18the old iPad mini was if i if if if the world was different.

1:01:25You know?

1:01:27Yeah, I think it would have been more expensive, but it wouldn't be as

1:01:29much more expensive.

1:01:30I think that's the OLED.

1:01:31I think will probably took it over, but maybe we we'll never know.

1:01:35Um but oh and I wanted to give a shout out to the adorable

1:01:39uh folio case that they made for it, which is fine woven.

1:01:42It's actually really nice.

1:01:43What's nice about it?

1:01:44It it I mean the the the fine woven is actually okay.

1:01:48It feels it feels and and it's I don't know, as somebody who's gotten

1:01:52a folio case for my iPad Pro, what it feels like to me is

1:01:55like a little boy dressed up like in a little boy tuxedo and everybody

1:01:59went Oh, you're so cute.

1:02:01You're wearing the big the big boy clothes.

1:02:03The iPad's what it's like.

1:02:04The iPads are going to a wedding and and this the iPad mini is

1:02:08like the page boy.

1:02:11Yeah, exactly.

1:02:15Oh you ke y he keeps the good stuff for the podcast, everybody.

1:02:19And I don't remember that being in your view.

1:02:21Um I'm happy to hear it though.

1:02:23Uh I wanna close on this by reading your conclusion.

1:02:26The reason the iPad mini has earned the love and loyalty of a wide

1:02:29array of users is that it's tall and does everything an iPad can do,

1:02:32and that's winning combination.

1:02:34This new model has a great new screen, is thinner and lighter than ever.

1:02:38It's certainly not cheap, but there's a lot of value packed in there if

1:02:41you've got a plan to take advantage of it.

1:02:43And and I think that that part is echoing what you were mentioning earlier,

1:02:46right?

1:02:46Like don't buy this to be your Kindle.

1:02:48Buy this to be your Kindle when you're comic reader and you're a video

1:02:51player and also something that you use to catch up with the group chats,

1:02:56right?

1:02:57Like it's it's not a single purpose machine.

1:02:59It is a full purpose machine and it is priced fully uh for that.

1:03:05Don't do this if that's what you want is just a simple device 'cause

1:03:09it's this is not a simple device.

1:03:10I mean you can spend the money, but I I I don't value.

1:03:13And I did actually in my review, I said dress it up in the

1:03:16in the fine woven folio case like it's an iPad Pro.

1:03:19We're in a little business suit.

1:03:20Oh we can get the little tuxedo.

1:03:22Little business suit.

1:03:23There's little tuxedo.

1:03:26Yeah, that that cause that makes me think of it being a little child,

1:03:30where a little business suit.

1:03:31I don't know if I would have thought of it the same way.

1:03:33Because I don't often see little children doing business you know?

1:03:36You do see 'em in little tuxedos.

1:03:38I guess you do.

1:03:41This episode is brought to you by Celtrios, the shoot 'em up game with

1:03:45a tiny ship, big weapons, waves of foes, power ups and obstacles.

1:03:49The nights are getting longer and we all want a nice way to wind

1:03:52down when work is over.

1:03:53Celtrios is a fun free game that you've been looking for.

1:03:56There's no ads, no in-app purchases, no subscription, nothing is locked.

1:04:00It's only for Apple platforms.

1:04:01You can get it on your Mac, iPhone, iPad and Apple TV.

1:04:05There are 13 stages of the game and you can start from any of

1:04:09them.

1:04:09Plus, you can resume play later if the app is quit.

1:04:12I like this the the freedom of being able to jump through the levels.

1:04:16Like that is brilliant.

1:04:17Uh and I've played Soutrios many times over the years.

1:04:20They've been a a long-running recurring sponsor, especially of the the video game show

1:04:24that I used to do with Federico.

1:04:25It's a really fun, really well-made game.

1:04:27There is a huge high quality soundtrack for forty-five minutes of music.

1:04:31The game keeps expanding.

1:04:33There have been over a hundred free updates to Soltio so far, and the

1:04:36entire thing was made by an independent developer.

1:04:38You can play solo or grab a friend for two-player.

1:04:41The Mac version supports various inputs.

1:04:43You know, we're talking about having all these different mice earlier on.

1:04:47Well actually you can grab a controller for a second player if you're on

1:04:51uh iOS as well.

1:04:52So there's there's a bunch of different ways you can have multiple people play

1:04:55this game on different platforms.

1:04:57There's tons of other things to love about Certios.

1:04:59You have so many ways to play play with customization to keep it fresh,

1:05:02like ship configuration, dozens of abilities, Mac full screen options, randomizing, and a hard

1:05:07mode.

1:05:08If you like the traditional Schmuck games or you just want a quality game

1:05:11that is fun to play again and again, with none of the usual annoyances

1:05:15that other games have, Celtrios is for you.

1:05:17The Mac version is on Steam for free demo and the iOS and TBOS

1:05:21versions are on the App Store.

1:05:22Go to kevingrant.name slash apps to learn more on of course there'll be a

1:05:27link in the show notes.

1:05:28So you can let them know that you uh heard about it from this

1:05:30show.

1:05:31That is kevingrant.name slash apps or click the link in the show notes.

1:05:35A thanks to Celtrios for their support of this show and relay.

1:05:39Money money money money who has all the money?

1:05:44Money money money, who has all the money?

1:05:48Money, money, money, money, who has all the money?

1:05:54It's that all and it is that time again everybody.

1:05:58We're going to be talking about Apple's fourth quarter results.

1:06:02Uh, this is the end of Apple's fiscal year.

1:06:05Uh Apple's fiscal year ends at the end of is it September, right?

1:06:09It's

1:06:10September.

1:06:11Um so I'm gonna give you the top line numbers and then we're gonna

1:06:14jump into some of the stories uh that are making up this uh which

1:06:18is also John Turnus's first uh first quarterly earnings call, which he he led.

1:06:25He's not the first he's been on but it's the first that he's led.

1:06:27So revenue for the quarter was 114.5 billion.

1:06:32This is up, this is just an unbelievable number.

1:06:34That's up 12% year over year.

1:06:36It is Apple's biggest fourth quarter in history.

1:06:39Uh Jason, can you remind me I just thought this now.

1:06:43This year has been the biggest quarter each time, right?

1:06:47I think so.

1:06:47I think it's been the biggest quar quarter each time, and it's year, obviously,

1:06:51as well.

1:06:51So yeah, it's uh I'm gonna do my annual uh uh results post yep

1:06:56probably later this week.

1:06:57But uh yeah, it's it's it's huge.

1:06:59Yep.

1:07:00Uh so profit is thirty point seven billion dollars, up eleven point eight percent.

1:07:07So basically in line with revenue.

1:07:09Uh iPhone is fifty seven point six billion, which is up twenty-three point seven

1:07:14percent.

1:07:15The iPad is at six point two billion, down ten point four percent.

1:07:20Services are at thirty one point six billion, which is up nine point eight

1:07:24percent.

1:07:25Uh this has returned to quarter to quarter growth after a dip in Q

1:07:29three.

1:07:29So one of the weird things about services, you look at the charts, the

1:07:32wonderful charts over at sixcolours.com, which are even better than ever than now interactive.

1:07:37Oh boy do I love those charts.

1:07:39Um but it used to be that services was just always going up.

1:07:43It wasn't just year over year growth, it was quarter by quarter growth.

1:07:46Last quarter it dipped a little bit but now it's back up again and

1:07:50it looks kind of like in line as if the Q three dip had

1:07:53never happened.

1:07:54It's a very funny thing.

1:07:56Yeah, they say that a lot of this too, um and again they say

1:07:59a lot of things to make the investors feel better.

1:08:02But one of the things they say is is and they they again, this

1:08:05is all legal.

1:08:06They can't lie about it.

1:08:07They said the foreign exchange hits services.

1:08:11That services would have been up by a lot more, But unfavorable foreign exchange

1:08:16headwinds um knock the number down.

1:08:18And that's just like a bottom line with Apple being a global business is

1:08:21depending on the strength of the dollar, um, their results vary.

1:08:26And so they said, like, we're we're we're they're not reporting numbers, they're reporting

1:08:31money.

1:08:31This is their fault, right?

1:08:33They chose to report money and money is variable and so they have to

1:08:37say, Well, the money's up a little bit, but trust us, uh if we

1:08:40held all the money ver uh not variable, it would have been up by

1:08:43more and you just kind of have to take that.

1:08:45But I would say it's it's a um uh if I were a freaking

1:08:50out uh analyst and which I am not I would say that it's um

1:08:54the second consecutive uh deceleration of growth in services.

1:09:00Not that services is not continuing to accelerate, but the rate of acceleration is

1:09:06less.

1:09:07It was up less than 10%, 9.8%, but still.

1:09:10And that's the lowest rate of growth in that category um in three years.

1:09:17So yeah.

1:09:19So Yeah, it's not great, but it's not none of the I mean I

1:09:25know that services is meant to be like this, but none of their other

1:09:28product lines work this way, where it just keeps going up always.

1:09:31Like they go up and down.

1:09:33Just keeps going up.

1:09:34But services should keep going up.

1:09:36That's kind of the point of it.

1:09:37It's like the the reason it exists is that they put brought this in

1:09:40and focused on it this way.

1:09:43Right, because this is you you're selling to your install base, you sell somebody

1:09:46an iPhone and then you sell them services and the services are higher margin

1:09:49and they you know, they accrue Crew beyond the iPhone.

1:09:52They did.

1:09:53There's some details here.

1:09:54Um, they talked a lot about how happy they are that they've got this

1:09:57new thing where they're taking iCloud Plus and in a hundred different countries, they're

1:10:01bundling Apple TV and Apple Arcade with it, as well as remember there's like

1:10:06a limit on how many Apple intelligence things you can do, actions you can

1:10:09do, but and then you it tells you to come back tomorrow.

1:10:13And then they are including in iCloud Plus more of those.

1:10:17Like if you're an iCloud Plus person you get more cleanups in photos or

1:10:22whatever else.

1:10:23And you know, that's a direction for them that they wanted the analyst to

1:10:27know.

1:10:28Is iCloud Plus becoming more of a uh uh a ride-along service for compute

1:10:35that is not just iCloud storage.

1:10:38Like that the the they're they're saying it's more than that.

1:10:41It's we're gonna bundle stuff in and it's gonna include AI stuff.

1:10:44So that's that's where you're gonna see their Apple's not gonna offer like an

1:10:47AI subscription.

1:10:48They're gonna offer iCloud Plus and AI is gonna be a part of it.

1:10:52That's how they're gonna do it.

1:10:53They they revealed that.

1:10:54And they also said Apple one apple care families or Apple Care One families

1:10:58is another area of growth for them.

1:10:59So those those are the areas they're trying to grow in more.

1:11:02I think I mentioned this on on Connected, but Apple have essentially just turned

1:11:06Apple Care into a service now.

1:11:08Like you used to be able to buy a year of Apple Care.

1:11:10You can't do that anymore.

1:11:12Like if you want to buy a year of Apple Care you've now signed

1:11:15up to a renewing subscription every year.

1:11:18Every yeah.

1:11:18It will just k it will just happen.

1:11:20And now they also have, which is because of this, I was like, Well,

1:11:23I may as well do the thing.

1:11:24And I did the Apple Care one thing, right?

1:11:27Where you pay like sixteen pounds a month and I get three devices.

1:11:31It's like that just makes sense for me to do that now with how

1:11:34many devices I have.

1:11:36Yeah.

1:11:36Uh fair.

1:11:37Because I n I needed AppleCare for the duo.

1:11:40Like there was no way I was not doing that.

1:11:42And so it's like, well, I may as well put a couple of things

1:11:46in in into an Applecare subscription.

1:11:48I I think it's it's fine.

1:11:50But yes, I I don't like that they did that though.

1:11:52That like you can't just be like I will buy Apple Care for one

1:11:54year.

1:11:54It's like no you won't you will subscribe to Apple Care uh and and

1:11:58you'll like it.

1:11:58But this is another thing that turned into a service.

1:12:01Uh the final part of the of the products uh kind of uh uh

1:12:05suite here is wearables, home and accessories.

1:12:07Eight point three billion dollars in the quarter that is down seven point nine

1:12:12percent.

1:12:13How was Turnus' performance in his first earnings core, Jason?

1:12:17Um I'd say it was restrained.

1:12:19I think that he was definitely feeling or they all agreed or they instructed

1:12:22him him or whatever it was that he was going to kind of take

1:12:24it easy.

1:12:25And so I would say he was even more tentative than um

1:12:30than than Tim Cook in terms of like not revealing everything.

1:12:34He pretty close to stayed on script and it is all kind of scripted

1:12:38at this point.

1:12:39It's been that way for a while.

1:12:40It's gotten only more locked down over time.

1:12:42Now the analysts ask these questions, but it feels like all the answers are

1:12:45already they're reading them off of cards.

1:12:47I you know, I think there is a little bit of improv there, but

1:12:50the improv is literally if they ask this question, read this answer.

1:12:53Yeah.

1:12:54And if they don't, we don't have to read that answer and we just

1:12:57won't talk about that part.

1:12:59And so then you you get what you get.

1:13:01But um I would say That's so he he didn't want to step in

1:13:06it, although I he did have a very funny moment.

1:13:09His his funny moment was when somebody asked him again to try uh one

1:13:13of these questions where they're like, Let's new CEO to talk about future products

1:13:16and they're like, Hey, this touch Mac book, does that auger changes in the

1:13:20Mac to make them more like the iPad?

1:13:21And the how does it all inter interconnect?

1:13:24And he says, We don't have any fundamentally different changes we're planning right now,

1:13:28nor would we talk about it anyway.

1:13:30I love that answer.

1:13:31Thank you.

1:13:32John.

1:13:32I like that as a news spin on the we don't talk about it.

1:13:37I appreciate it, but we know I'm not gonna if I even if I

1:13:40did I wouldn't tell you, I think is very funny.

1:13:43Yeah.

1:13:43So he's fine.

1:13:44I I think the smartest thing he did is he brought in Sabi Khan,

1:13:48the COO, uh to the QA.

1:13:51And so when 'cause Tim would do that stuff before, right?

1:13:55Yes.

1:13:55Cause Tim Tim was the CEO but also is the the operations guy, essentially.

1:14:00And and John Turnus is not.

1:14:03John Turnus can talk with authority about products, but not necessarily about ops.

1:14:07And I'll also say, like when Steve Jobs was CEO, he wasn't on every

1:14:11call.

1:14:11He he it was a big deal when it was like Steve is joining.

1:14:14Oh what will Steve have to say about it remember that.

1:14:16Like that

1:14:18Steve is on the call.

1:14:19He's busted in.

1:14:20He's got something to say.

1:14:22My transcript started because we used to transcribe what Steve said on the call.

1:14:26Not the rest of the call, just what Steve said on the call and

1:14:29ultimately became a full call transcript.

1:14:30So he had a COO run those meetings.

1:14:32That was Tim Cook.

1:14:33So Tim Cook that's why Tim Cook did like ninety earnings calls.

1:14:36It's like he was doing earnings calls before he was the CEO.

1:14:39So getting Sabi Khan involved.

1:14:41I mean, I don't if John Turnus is gonna go so far as to

1:14:44like not show up for the um for the calls.

1:14:47I think perhaps he will.

1:14:49He could choose not to, but I think he will.

1:14:51But having Sabi Sabi Khan there is a good move.

1:14:53I think Cook has kind of set that as an expectation now, right?

1:14:56That like that like Turner should probably be there.

1:14:59I think so.

1:14:59But having Sabi Khan field it and also just logistically, like if they truly

1:15:05do have a set of cards with answers for various questions on it.

1:15:09Being well versed, having three answers there, Kevin Perrick, the CFO, John Turnus, and

1:15:15Sabi Khan, each of them has less ground to cover.

1:15:21Which I think is good.

1:15:23I think that's good for Apple in terms of like staying on task.

1:15:26But I think it's also good that if you did want to speak something

1:15:30resembling extemporaneously to add a little color here or there that you'd be better

1:15:35off doing that if it was an area you had a great deal of

1:15:38confidence in because it was your beat.

1:15:40And I think Sabi Khan having that visibility is a is a good thing.

1:15:45So I thought that was an interesting move too.

1:15:46But yes it it is increasingly scripted and it only feels more so over

1:15:50time.

1:15:51I I I would love to see maybe as this goes, this group will

1:15:55loosen up, but this was not the time to do that.

1:15:57This was we're gonna lock it down as much as possible.

1:16:01Well and also this is a risky one, right?

1:16:02Like that we're gonna get into it, but th this call had some areas

1:16:06of like uh oh.

1:16:07So like you really don't wanna be flying by the seat of your pants

1:16:10on one of these ones.

1:16:12Absolutely not.

1:16:12Um so uh I'll I'll read from your uh analysis This quarter closed out

1:16:17a remarkable year for the iPhone, putting the iPhone 17 cycle in the books

1:16:21with four straight quarters of twenty-ish percent year-over-year growth.

1:16:25Apple CFO Kevin Parrack said it was the best iPhone year in every single

1:16:30Apple geographic segment.

1:16:32Man, the seventeen.

1:16:34Like I know obviously we're into the eighteen now, but like that the iPhone

1:16:38seventeen line just absolutely crushed like and for you know, we were saying it

1:16:44at the time, it was the best iPhone lineup they ever had when they

1:16:47announced it, and it turns out the world agreed and they've sold loads of

1:16:51them.

1:16:51I think as well, like I don't know if this was purposeful or if

1:16:54it's like luck, 'cause you never really know how people are gonna react, right?

1:16:57You can guess, but people react it very well.

1:17:01But it feels like they're set up well for going into the split strategy,

1:17:05right?

1:17:05Where I know that this quarter isn't the iPhone eighteen quarter, but it's the

1:17:11beginning of pre orders, right?

1:17:13Slip in to the end here.

1:17:15Yeah.

1:17:16There's sale there's iPhone sales, but it's it's a couple of weeks out of

1:17:19out of three months.

1:17:21So it's it's never it's never a huge indicator of the next that's why

1:17:24I said it closes the books on the 17th cycle, really.

1:17:27I mean not entirely because the seventeen is still for sale.

1:17:30Yeah.

1:17:30But you know, you know what I'm saying.

1:17:32It's the this was the big like this was the year of just the

1:17:35iPhone 17s, and this is what the result was.

1:17:37Because the next quarter will include you know, it's gonna include the eighteen, it's

1:17:42gonna include the the pro in full, right, for leading up to the holidays,

1:17:45it's gonna include the duo.

1:17:47But I feel like they've probably set themselves up pretty well that the iPhone

1:17:51seventeen is considered to be a very good phone that people are still going

1:17:54to buy probably.

1:17:56Uh which is helpful in the year where they have fewer iPhones

1:18:01right now that you can buy that are new, right?

1:18:05Because we're going to be getting another to next year.

1:18:09And so it's like, what is that gonna do to the numbers?

1:18:11We still don't know for sure, but it feels like the iPhone seventeen line

1:18:16has probably taken some of the pressure away from that because it was such

1:18:21a successful phone line overall.

1:18:24So they've probably set themselves up pretty well there.

1:18:26But just, you know, going back on what you said, it's incredible, right?

1:18:30The the the the amount of iPhones that they have sold in the last

1:18:3512 months is Truly astounding, like an incredible achievement, what they have managed.

1:18:41And I would say actually one of the nice things about my little interactive

1:18:44charts at Six Colors is if you go and show iPhone revenue over

1:18:51time and look at the four quarter average, especially.

1:18:54If you if you drag it out for like more of iPhone history than

1:18:58by default, what you see, and and revenue change is a great example of

1:19:02this too.

1:19:03If you if you look at that, you can see the moments where the

1:19:05iPod or the iPhone pops.

1:19:07You can see them, right?

1:19:09Like twenty-one, the iPhone popped.

1:19:12They had a great cycle.

1:19:14And then they had a couple of flat years.

1:19:17Um, actually, you know, really twenty-two, twenty, they had four flat years.

1:19:22And then this year blew up again.

1:19:25Um, you know, they had that a little bit in 18, they had it

1:19:27a little bit in fifteen.

1:19:28It it it right, the iPhone doesn't go up, up, up every year.

1:19:32What happens is it's shoots.

1:19:33It shoots up and then it's kind of flattish down a little, but basically

1:19:37flattish at that new level.

1:19:39And then a few years later it shoots up again.

1:19:41This was the pop up year.

1:19:43We'll see where they go from here.

1:19:44The funniest one though is the one right at the beginning of your charts,

1:19:47which is twenty twelve, where it's a hundred and thirty one point four percent

1:19:51year over year.

1:19:52Well, I mean they the previous year they hadn't sold very many iPhones, right?

1:19:56And and then all of a sudden, you know, you go from, you know,

1:19:59ten billion to thirty billion or whatever.

1:20:01And it's yeah.

1:20:02And it's just it's just a very funny thing when you go all the

1:20:04way out on the chart, the chart gets like really like broken in the

1:20:08way that charts can when you have this huge outlier.

1:20:10Um but yeah, you can you're right.

1:20:12If you if you ignore that one, you can see, you know, twenty fifteen

1:20:17twenty twenty one, even twenty eighteen to a to a some degree, these years

1:20:22where the the the revenue change is is is incredible for like the entire

1:20:28year, right?

1:20:29Like you you see it I think you see it more in the revenue

1:20:31change than you see in just the pure revenue.

1:20:34Um because you see the kind of like the longer term.

1:20:37You can see the spikes and then the flat and then the spikes and

1:20:39then the flat and that's your growth.

1:20:41And so like again it's like, all right, so that was twenty fifteen to

1:20:45eighteen, twenty eighteen to twenty one, twenty one to twenty six, it was a

1:20:49bit of a longer period of time.

1:20:51So we're like another three to five years you would expect before this happens

1:20:54again.

1:20:55And Except we don't know.

1:20:57I mean, how will the market change and and new products desirable new products

1:21:01affect this?

1:21:02If the iPhone Duo does really well and if the spring launch of the

1:21:07eighteen perhaps does well, like the numbers could be very different or they could

1:21:12be flattish like they've bit they usually are after a after a big growth

1:21:18year, it's very hard to grow more on top of that.

1:21:20You're more like making the effort to maintain your existing growth and that's probably

1:21:24what will happen next fiscal for iPhone, but who knows?

1:21:27With a duo out there and the change in selling the base phones, it's

1:21:32gonna be a little different.

1:21:34Wildest stat from the the quarterly earnings.

1:21:38Fiscal twenty six was the best ever year for Mac unit sales.

1:21:43They sold more Macs in twenty twenty six than they have sold in any

1:21:47other year.

1:21:48Yeah, purge on Turnus because they don't reveal the unit sales anymore, right?

1:21:51They do revenue.

1:21:52Unless they really want to tell you something.

1:21:54And he said, this is the best Mac.

1:21:55We sold more Macs than we've ever in a in a fiscal year before.

1:21:58And I went and I looked at the annual sales.

1:22:00The annual sales aren't.

1:22:02It's not a record.

1:22:03In Mac revenue.

1:22:05Right.

1:22:06MacBook Neo.

1:22:07Well, so I also think the Mac minis in there.

1:22:09They they called out the Neo and the MacBook Pro.

1:22:12Yeah.

1:22:12I reckon it's the because you know, we saw what happened to the Mac

1:22:15Mini.

1:22:16You just couldn't buy one.

1:22:17And yeah.

1:22:17That makes a difference.

1:22:18But yes, maybe two.

1:22:19It they have sold many more Macs that aren't the usual value of a

1:22:26Mac.

1:22:27Which is why we you don't see it in the charts, which is why

1:22:29it's drives unit sales but doesn't drive as much revenue, which is why even

1:22:34though they didn't say how many they sold, they did say they sold more.

1:22:38Yep.

1:22:38And the revenue number's down a little.

1:22:40A little.

1:22:41But it's not a record revenue year for Mac, but it's a rec re

1:22:45record unit like that's very interesting to me.

1:22:49But a very solid revenue year for the Mac though.

1:22:51Like it it's been a good it's been a very good year for the

1:22:53Mac this year, I think.

1:22:54Um and clearly, uh clearly they have done a very good job there.

1:23:01Yeah, no, it's good.

1:23:03It's good.

1:23:03And Turnus said, you know, the Mac's the reason I'm at Apple.

1:23:07It's reason most of us are at Apple.

1:23:09Like the it's it's a nice little reminder.

1:23:11I think he's gonna play that card a lot of like I'm the new

1:23:14guy, but I'm not new to Apple.

1:23:15I've been here all along and um I think that's a good card for

1:23:19him to play.

1:23:19Keep playing it.

1:23:23You wrote in your uh analysis, if you're wondering why Apple is getting to

1:23:27home in a big way, look no further than the lack cluster performance of

1:23:30the Wearables Home category.

1:23:32And Kevin Parrick blamed a tough compare with the A sixteen iPad, Apple Watch

1:23:38SE3, and AirPods Pro Three.

1:23:40I just can't believe that that's a tough compare.

1:23:42I I just No.

1:23:44I don't think that I mean I'm sorry.

1:23:46Maybe the quarter was worse and those were products you had before, but were

1:23:49they really like stormers?

1:23:51Like I

1:23:53I I I think they're trying real hard to make it not seem bad,

1:23:56but it's not it's just not great.

1:23:58That those those didn't seem like tough compares, and yet they called them tough

1:24:02compares.

1:24:02So okay.

1:24:04It's all right.

1:24:05And again, it's like if that is a tough compare, then you need to

1:24:10do more.

1:24:11Like I don't I mean I'll grant you but the I'll grant you AirPods

1:24:15Pro are a great product.

1:24:16But like the iPhone S or the Apple Watch S E was a tough

1:24:21compare.

1:24:21The A sixteen iPad.

1:24:23Like again, it's like we're just we were just talking about the fact that

1:24:26the MacBook Neo is the cheapest product, means they sold a lot on it,

1:24:31but the revenue didn't go up.

1:24:32Well, right.

1:24:32The A sixteen iPad, the Apple Watch SE three are the cheapest products in

1:24:36their categories.

1:24:37Yeah.

1:24:38So so it shouldn't be a tough compare, I feel like.

1:24:43It's fine.

1:24:44It's just wrong.

1:24:45Yeah I I just again not impressed by that.

1:24:47But I agree with you that's like oh okay.

1:24:50Uh if they care about this product line at all, then products like the

1:24:53home view are the things that they need to be pushing further down.

1:24:57Like if they want this area to rise, they have to do more in

1:25:00it.

1:25:00Then don't This seems to be when they were going great, everybody was like,

1:25:05Why do we even need to do things in the home?

1:25:07And then the home category, home wearables accessory, kind of fell on hard times.

1:25:13And now that seems to have led to some motivation to maybe actually do

1:25:17some home products.

1:25:18So we'll see how that works out for them.

1:25:22One of the most interesting things, the thing I think is getting the most

1:25:25play probably in the business press is margins.

1:25:28Um Um talking about Apple's margins.

1:25:30So gross margin had been creeping up and has now fallen.

1:25:34So it's forty seven point nine percent this quarter, which is incredible.

1:25:38Uh like a forty.

1:25:41It was fifty point one last quarter.

1:25:42So that so it'd been bumping up like tick tick tick tick have been

1:25:45going up and now it's dropped quite a bit.

1:25:48Um similarly, Apple usually sees a bump a bump in profit at this time

1:25:52of year compared to the previous quarter, but that has fallen off a little

1:25:56bit too.

1:25:57So they've actually well the you know, the revenue has been really great.

1:26:00They haven't made as much money.

1:26:02Uh

1:26:04and some of the profit stuff and the margin was actually helped by tariff

1:26:09refunds that they got.

1:26:10So it would have been even worse without been worse.

1:26:13That's right.

1:26:14Uh Parac said they are forecasting a further drop to somewhere between forty five

1:26:20to forty six percent next quarter, which is around twenty twenty three to twenty

1:26:24twenty four levels of margin.

1:26:26Of course, all of this is memory prices.

1:26:29All yeah.

1:26:30All of that.

1:26:31And this is with price increases.

1:26:32Yes.

1:26:33So imagine.

1:26:34Uh this is from John Turnus.

1:26:36For the December quarter we expect even higher memory costs.

1:26:39Looking beyond the December quarter, we see the pricing for memory purchases continuing to

1:26:44increase.

1:26:45And Turnus also said that Apple has increased its purchase obligations for manufacturing by

1:26:50thirty three billion dollars in the last quarter.

1:26:52Yeah.

1:26:52In the last quarter, they they made new supply contracts that put them on

1:26:58the hook for thirty three billion dollars.

1:26:59Over time, presumably, but still that is a new commitment.

1:27:02If you think about like a sports franchise making a free agent commitment, that's

1:27:07what they did here.

1:27:08The free agent in this case, I guess, is memory, uh, and other stuff,

1:27:11but like that's a new thirty-three billion dollar commitment that they made.

1:27:16And that reflects

1:27:18the expense of of the stuff in the market right now and the cost

1:27:23to lock in even those high prices, which is what they're doing right now.

1:27:27So it's a lot.

1:27:29Yeah.

1:27:31Yeah, I don't

1:27:33I mean, no one knows what to do about it, right?

1:27:35They just have to keep pushing on.

1:27:36But what it's gonna mean is that the margins are gonna be less for

1:27:39a while.

1:27:39But And the prices are gonna be higher.

1:27:41And that's just how it's gonna be.

1:27:42That's

1:27:44I think I think I saw some reports about people in Wall Street who

1:27:49are not happy about this.

1:27:50I'm like, I get it, I get it, but

1:27:55I

1:27:58Uh like they're I mean they're in the in Wall Street.

1:28:01They're markets, so let me just put it in terms they'll understand.

1:28:05This can't be a long term problem.

1:28:07This can't be a long term problem.

1:28:09Either demand will ease or supply will grow.

1:28:13There will be a solution to this.

1:28:15It's not going to stay like this forever.

1:28:17No.

1:28:17It's just not because somebody will be motivated to lower RAM prices or the

1:28:22demand that causes the prices to go up will drop.

1:28:25One of those things is going to happen.

1:28:29So you just gotta kind of grit your teeth.

1:28:32Apple, fortunately, Apple does have the margin that it can eat here.

1:28:36And they've shown that there's actually one of the really good questions the analyst

1:28:40asked is, Do you did you see price?

1:28:42Um ala did you see elasticity in the product?

1:28:45Which is basically they're saying

1:28:49when you raise the price, how does that affect demand?

1:28:52Did fewer people want to buy that product because you raised the price?

1:28:56Or did it not matter?

1:28:58And here's the funny thing.

1:29:00Apple is not in supply-demand balance.

1:29:03So they don't know.

1:29:05They or at least I mean they probably have an inkling, but they can't

1:29:08say.

1:29:08Because if you're selling everyone you make, you can't tell whether your price changes

1:29:13have affected your sales because you're still selling everyone you make.

1:29:17You you're you're feeding data in and a And it doesn't change anything because

1:29:23because you've got this other constraint somewhere else.

1:29:25So remains to be seen what the issues are with their pricing because they

1:29:31have these issues.

1:29:32Although I thought it was a funny data point that they're like, well Memory

1:29:35is going to be an issue, but also the the problem that they said

1:29:38last quarter was that the the advanced nodes

1:29:42were holding them back because they could only make so many chips.

1:29:46And the new two nanometer process that's in the A20 Pro and the M6

1:29:51that's on a new line.

1:29:52It's new production line.

1:29:54It's a new node.

1:29:54It's the newest, shiniest of all the nodes.

1:29:57Um, but what that means is now they've got more bandwidth

1:30:02on the older nodes that were impacted, that are making whatever they're making, A

1:30:08nineteens and M fives and stuff.

1:30:12Uh M five Pro and M five Max.

1:30:14All of that stuff.

1:30:16So they said that actually helps them.

1:30:18Going getting this new you wouldn't think like getting on the new process, but

1:30:21getting on the new process means that they have fewer products being made on

1:30:24the older process, which gives them more capacity there.

1:30:27So that's the game they're playing right now.

1:30:29Yeah, I mean

1:30:31I guess that's good, right?

1:30:33But they're they're still in this spot where they're talking about not being able

1:30:37to meet demand, as you mentioned.

1:30:38Yeah.

1:30:39And so what I hope what I hope they don't take from this is

1:30:42well someone put the prices up again.

1:30:43Like I r uh I don't I don't want them to do that.

1:30:46We'll see.

1:30:47Um I know they don't want to do it.

1:30:49Um, but but they don't want to lose margin either, right?

1:30:52That's they're gonna make the decisions they're gonna make.

1:30:54Let's be clear here.

1:30:55They're not in supply demand balance for a bunch of their products.

1:30:59They're still forecasting that next quarter, which is the holiday quarter, will be the

1:31:06biggest quarter in Apple history.

1:31:08Yeah.

1:31:08Even though

1:31:11presumably it could have been a lot bigger if they had had more products

1:31:14in the channel, but they weren't able to do it.

1:31:16But this is in the mid 150 billion.

1:31:18It's 153 to 156 or 153 to 158 billion, depending on their range.

1:31:25Um

1:31:26it was just twenty twenty when they broke a hundred.

1:31:29Yeah.

1:31:30In the holiday quarter.

1:31:31And now they're a hundred and fifty.

1:31:33That is seven years later, but still that's fifty percent more.

1:31:37Right?

1:31:37Like that is a hundred and fifty three billion dollar quarter.

1:31:40Yeah.

1:31:41With supply.

1:31:41So

1:31:43Apple's a very valuable company.

1:31:45Analyzing its finances and its business are very interesting and matter and the ramifications

1:31:49of it for the economy and for like uh are all huge.

1:31:53But

1:31:54At the end of the day, it is also important to remember to quote

1:32:00a great man

1:32:02who's got all the money, it's Apple.

1:32:05Yeah.

1:32:05They really do.

1:32:07I mean, it that that is it's still a money it's like we can

1:32:09analyze it and we can detail it and we can show where there are

1:32:12red flags and where there are issues and the it's not like smooth sailing.

1:32:16In fact, it's actually kind of really weird right now.

1:32:18And yet the machine that throws off money continues to throw off enormous amounts

1:32:24of money.

1:32:25Mm-hmm.

1:32:26People should go check out the charts.

1:32:27There'll be links in the show notes at the six colours.

1:32:30Please do.

1:32:30Charts are bigger and better and badder than ever.

1:32:33Uh and I love it.

1:32:33There is extra charts in there now.

1:32:35Charts that I wanted.

1:32:36Everyone's getting a better time.

1:32:38They're really really, really good charts.

1:32:39Really nice.

1:32:40They're n they're good they're good charts.

1:32:42Yeah, you can uh the regional charts you can like turn off regions now.

1:32:45You can just be like, I don't I wanna see Japan.

1:32:47Why does Jason not put Japan in the chart?

1:32:49You can have Japan if you want.

1:32:50It's put Japan in the chart, will you?

1:32:52Put Japan in the chart.

1:32:53Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1:32:54Put Japan in the chart.

1:32:57If you want.

1:32:57I'm always saying that.

1:32:59So I'm happy that you've finally done it.

1:33:01Japan has entered the chart.

1:33:03I like that.

1:33:05This episode is brought to you by Planet Money.

1:33:08Every big economic story begins with a question.

1:33:10Questions like why do prices go up?

1:33:13Or what the robot chefs mean for the restaurant industry.

1:33:16Planet Money helps you find answers by digging into the places and the people

1:33:20at the center of the story, asking the questions that make the economy easier

1:33:25to understand.

1:33:26Listen to Planet Money wherever you get your podcasts.

1:33:31Let's finish up with some ask upgrade questions.

1:33:36First one comes in from PAL who says, I would love to know how

1:33:39the size of the folded duo feels.

1:33:42It is really out of my budget and preference.

1:33:45It's too thick, too heavy as well.

1:33:47But could you see a world where an iPhone Uno exists, where it's just

1:33:52the front pane of the duo?

1:33:54Maybe slightly thicker than one single pane, maybe slimmer than the duo.

1:33:58It gives me Blackberry size vibes.

1:34:00I think last week I mentioned that the iPhone Duo was really reminding me

1:34:05of something and I couldn't work out what it was.

1:34:07It was a Blackberry.

1:34:09I used to have be a Blackberry user in my corporate days and the

1:34:13way I hold and send messages on the Blackberry so on the duo reminds

1:34:18me of how I would hold and send messages on the duo.

1:34:22Like it is that on the blackberry wide, like the on the Blackberry.

1:34:25On that wide kind of keyboard.

1:34:28Um yeah, I I think if the duo is a wild hit, then I

1:34:33mean maybe never say never, but I think the thing is that the beauty

1:34:36of the duo screen is that if it is in your way, you can

1:34:40always unfold it and get the bigger screen.

1:34:43And so there's opportunity for more.

1:34:45And I think a a thin squat phone is just recreating the mini and

1:34:52people didn't buy it.

1:34:53So unless like Duo Mania sweeps the nation, maybe there's an air that's a

1:34:58different shape or something like that.

1:35:00But like it turns out at least for now that people have told us

1:35:03what they want.

1:35:04B phone buyers have told us what they want.

1:35:06And the smaller phones didn't.

1:35:09So um the magic of the duo is that you can always get to

1:35:12a bigger screen from that screen if you want to.

1:35:16Pizza says, I was expecting a long line of people waiting to play with

1:35:20the duo, but at a couple of Apple stores I went to last weekend,

1:35:23there were many duos sitting unused.

1:35:26Is it possible that demand for an expensive folding phone is still very small?

1:35:32Um I think this is somewhat relative 'cause I feel like at the same

1:35:36time I keep hearing stories of people getting to stores at opening time, right?

1:35:40Like a a and and getting in line and trying to buy these things.

1:35:43Like it's uh I think it's all very relative based on where you are.

1:35:47I don't you know, I just I don't know if you can judge based

1:35:50on there not being aligned to play with a duo demo a floor model

1:35:55at an Apple store, whether that tells us anything at all.

1:35:58Yeah.

1:35:59Yeah.

1:36:01I s I think the product is h in demand and in the kind

1:36:05of like public interest much higher than I had expected.

1:36:10And I'm I'm pleased about that because I think it's worthy of it.

1:36:12It's wonderful little product.

1:36:15Amar says, is it me or is there a worrying lack of forward thinking

1:36:18with the duo?

1:36:19Apple waited eight years and one would have hoped that they could have figured

1:36:22a way around some age-old limitations that come from the form factor, but they

1:36:26did.

1:36:26The cameras are still compromised, the inner screen is still very easy to damage.

1:36:31The phone is thick and heavy.

1:36:32Basically all the shortcomings of existing foldables.

1:36:35Apple jumps into a category and solves industry problems.

1:36:38But that didn't with the duo.

1:36:40What do you think about that?

1:36:41I don't agree.

1:36:42Yeah.

1:36:43I I I think I think you're I think this is envisioning some kind

1:36:47of like perfect world.

1:36:48It's really an unrealistic view of of what's going on here.

1:36:52What Apple did is they're choo they're choosing the right time to step on,

1:36:56and they chose this as the right time to step on.

1:36:58What Amara is saying here is they didn't all the problems.

1:37:01Well, they didn't.

1:37:03There are lots of issues.

1:37:04But what what's the right thing to do?

1:37:05Wait and never release a phone because it'll never be perfect?

1:37:08At some point you have to step on.

1:37:10At some point you have to ship a product.

1:37:11What they decided was the in the interior screen had to be good

1:37:17and that the crease had to be not a distraction.

1:37:21Yeah.

1:37:22And like that, that seems to be what they prioritized is they wanted it

1:37:26to be rugged enough that they could actually say that it works, you know,

1:37:30it doesn't it doesn't deal with water and and uh and and dust badly

1:37:34like early folding phones did and that that inner screen is really good and

1:37:39then they put the software on it.

1:37:42You can't solve every limitation.

1:37:44The cameras are still compromised.

1:37:46The cameras are compromised in many Apple products for lots of reasons.

1:37:49The iPhone Air is a great example of that.

1:37:51Like there are compromises you have to do just physically for it.

1:37:57Um, we'll see how the inner screen is in terms of damage.

1:38:00I I if you're if you're this is a reference to to crack gate

1:38:05or whatever, like I'm sorry, I don't what to tell you.

1:38:08Um that seems to have been a bad hinge.

1:38:12So you tell me.

1:38:13Apple jumps into a category and solves industry problems.

1:38:16Well, there were a lot of reviews that said this is the nicest folding

1:38:18phone they've ever used.

1:38:19So you tell those reviewers.

1:38:21I think they just you gotta choose your moment.

1:38:23It's timing.

1:38:24This is the moment they chose.

1:38:25It is a state of the art folding phone.

1:38:27It is.

1:38:28And the ultimate difference maker and the thing that makes it nice is it's

1:38:33iOS.

1:38:33Like and they did a bunch of stuff to make iOS work really well.

1:38:37Yeah.

1:38:38Including things that other that other companies have not done that will now be

1:38:42copied by them.

1:38:43But like I again like I just I don't understand the argument that says

1:38:46until you can make a camera for a folding phone that is as good

1:38:49as a camera for a non-folding phone, you shouldn't bother making a folding phone.

1:38:52It's like they make a non-folding phone.

1:38:55This is a different use case, and I that I'm okay with that.

1:38:58So I should have mentioned that today's ask upgrade was predominantly spicy takes um

1:39:03about the iPhone Duo.

1:39:05These are the ones that I picked out, and we're finishing on the spiciest.

1:39:09Okay.

1:39:10Mike says, not me, bring back Alan Die.

1:39:13The the duo out of screen is not just a disaster, but is specifically

1:39:19one in a way Die never would have allowed.

1:39:21He believed that everything should be content.

1:39:24Hide all the controls.

1:39:25If you can't turn them into glass.

1:39:27The tiny outer content space and app doc is antithetical to this and the

1:39:32biggest complaint of reviewers.

1:39:34Does the Apple Commentariat owe Dye an apology?

1:39:37I promise this is not Alan Dyes Burner email or his mother.

1:39:42Um

1:39:43No question that ever uses the word commentariat is in my opinion a good

1:39:50one.

1:39:50Or antithetical, frankly.

1:39:52But yes.

1:39:53Um I reject your premise that the duo outer screen is a disaster.

1:39:57Me too.

1:39:58Yeah.

1:39:59It's n it's got issues,

1:40:02but it's not a disaster.

1:40:05And I I is this John Gruber?

1:40:07Yeah.

1:40:08Did John Gruber write this email?

1:40:09Is John Gruber turned around on Alan Die?

1:40:12Joan would never say bring back Alan Die.

1:40:14Never.

1:40:15Never.

1:40:15I I I don't tell you.

1:40:17It it's weird, but um I actually kind of find it delightful.

1:40:21Me too.

1:40:22So it's got issues.

1:40:23I think the fact that they moved where the buttons go and it works

1:40:29is unbelievable.

1:40:30Right.

1:40:31Like that to me is unbelievable.

1:40:32And yes, so many apps are super weird and broken, but that will change.

1:40:37Like the starting point is great.

1:40:39There's a there are a lot of moments of joy I get out of

1:40:41that outside screen.

1:40:42I will say, and I texted you, Mike, and Steven about this.

1:40:46Somebody tried to call me and I had to use the phone app.

1:40:50And I used the phone app closed for the first time.

1:40:52And I had no idea I felt like I was losing my mind.

1:40:56Because like the filter view I think the thing that sent me over the

1:41:00edge was the filter view that they put in that is already a little

1:41:04too complicated, if you ask me, where you have like a hidden button, filter

1:41:08button that'll let you show your un you know unknown calls and stuff like

1:41:12that.

1:41:12And it's pretty subtle.

1:41:14And that button on the standard iPhone is above the list of calls.

1:41:19On the iPhone Duo, it's off in the sidebar.

1:41:22And I just stared at the phone app and I'm like, what do I

1:41:26do?

1:41:27Yeah.

1:41:27Where is the thing that brought me here?

1:41:29Where is the notification that brought me here?

1:41:31I don't understand what I'm even looking at.

1:41:34And it took me forever to figure out, oh, it's the filter thing and

1:41:37it is it over there?

1:41:38It is over there.

1:41:40And I I I just if you haven't spent some time, ponder the phone

1:41:44app on the outdoor the outside screen of the iPhone Duo because it's

1:41:50it did not get the love it needed to get and it exposes a

1:41:54lot of real issues with the iPhone duo that I don't see in other

1:41:57apps, but in that app, it's 'cause I think actually my theory is I

1:42:01think that the iPhone the iOS twenty seven phone app is actually not good.

1:42:05No.

1:42:06And then then they put it on the duo and they made it even

1:42:08worse.

1:42:08And so now it's like it's just mind I love some of the features

1:42:12that they added in twenty seven for phone calls, but the phone app is

1:42:18is not great.

1:42:19Uh say you have in twenty six or twenty seven, you know like the

1:42:21core screening and all that stuff.

1:42:23I like all of that.

1:42:24Like I that's I really like that.

1:42:26Um but now it's like where do those calls go?

1:42:30And they're like, I have a badge and I can't find it.

1:42:33And that's in general.

1:42:35But yes, it's even more perplexing when the screen is even smaller.

1:42:38I just I it has been a long time since I opened a phone

1:42:41to a screen and was completely confused about what I was even supposed to

1:42:48try to do.

1:42:50It's just like, what is happening here?

1:42:52So anyway, that's my so there are issues there to to to Mike, uh

1:42:56from this member of the Commentariat, uh, who I tried never to make it

1:43:00personal to Alan Dye.

1:43:01I'm not sure I believe this premise that Alan Dye would never have shipped

1:43:04the iPhone duo the way it is, but you like so be it.

1:43:07And also I I reject the premise that it's weird, but I don't think

1:43:10it's kind of fun and interesting.

1:43:12You can not like it, but like we don't need to we don't need

1:43:16to overlap these things from anyway.

1:43:18Like Say say hi to your brother Alan Die.

1:43:21Yeah.

1:43:22Is it is this balan by

1:43:25Who is this?

1:43:28Uh this week's episode of Design in California takes you inside the room where

1:43:33Tony Fidel, John Rubinstein, and a surprise executive pitch the iPod to Steve Jobs.

1:43:40This is a this is my I think I may have already said this,

1:43:43but this is the truth now.

1:43:44This is my favorite episode of the series.

1:43:47Um I think we are very lucky that there is enough history that has

1:43:53been recorded to tell the story of what it is like to pitch a

1:43:58product, a design, to Steve Jobs.

1:44:02So it is really fun to hear uh how we go from, hey, we

1:44:07want to show you the iPod design to landing on the design of the

1:44:10iPods.

1:44:11So that is over at relay.fm slash designed.

1:44:13It is the penultimate episode of our story on the history of the iPod

1:44:19as we uh get toward the twenty fifth anniversary of the iPod's release.

1:44:24Um we've had the twenty fifth of its announcement, but the release is just

1:44:27around the corner.

1:44:28If you would like to send in your questions for us to answer you

1:44:31have feedback or follow-up, you can go to upgradefeedback.com and send those in.

1:44:35I want to thank our members who support us with Upgrade Plus.

1:44:38This time we have an upgrade thing to talk about, Jason.

1:44:42I need some assistance on one of our categories.

1:44:44Go to getupgradeplus.com and you can get a longer ad-free version of this show

1:44:49each and every week.

1:44:50If you want to find us on YouTube, go search for the upgrade podcast

1:44:53and we'll be right there.

1:44:55I would like to thank our sponsors of this week's episode.

1:44:57That is the fine folk over at Squarespace, Celtrios, and Planet Money.

1:45:02Uh and I want to thank you for listening.

1:45:03Until next time, say goodbye, Jason Snow.

1:45:06Bye, Mike Curly.