Podcast Search

Upgrade

646: There Are No Clocks

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:09From relay, this is Upgrade Episode 646 for November 16th.

0:00:152026. Today's show is brought to you by Scribe, Squarespace, and Fitbod.

0:00:20My name is Mike Hurley and I am joined by Jason Snell.

0:00:23Hi Jason Snell. Hello, Mike Hurley.

0:00:25I am coming to you live from one thirty Third of the home of the accidental tech podcast.

0:00:31Wonderful stuff. Where which one of those homes are you in?

0:00:35I'm in the most polite and gracious hostful of all those homes.

0:00:40No offense to the other guys, but we all know it's he liss's house.

0:00:46The most the most gracious of all.

0:00:48He's checked on me like three times already.

0:00:51Really? I I expect to see him appear from underneath your desk at some point during today's episode.

0:00:57Uh I have a snow talk question for you that actually relates to what is happening.

0:01:01Uh Brad wants to know, Jason, how did you enjoy your very cold visit to Charlottesville for the Cow UVA game?

0:01:08Side note great meeting you. Yes, hi Brad.

0:01:11It's nice to meet Brad, um, who's a friend of Casey's and was at the tailgate for a while.

0:01:15Uh yeah, uh well, uh as Casey's lovely wife Erin pointed out, it imagine if it was twenty five or thirty degrees warmer,

0:01:26it would have been really nice. It was still very nice, but I was wearing five layers and uh we had hand warmers and stuff because it was chilly and windy.

0:01:36The wind was the worst part. When the sun was out and it was not windy, it was it was a lot nicer.

0:01:40But yeah, they had a big spread and we're just hanging out and talking.

0:01:43And really it's a it's a very fun idea that you basically have a two, three hour social hangout with people that you don't see that often but yeah.

0:01:52Yeah, the hotel game thing.

0:01:54That was the reason. That was the sort of the premise of this.

0:01:56And then we went and saw a football game, which was a bad team playing a worse team.

0:02:01And that was but it was fun being there with those guys and and and having been to a Memphis game with with them as well.

0:02:08We've got two of the three. They're gonna have to come out to El Cal game at some point.

0:02:12Yeah. Yeah. Yep. Yep.

0:02:13Yep. Yep. Yep. Well, very nice.

0:02:15Uh yeah we had fun. Yeah, I was I was jealous.

0:02:18Yeah, it was one of those things I'm sure you felt this too, when like you see your friends together and you're like, Oh, they're my friends.

0:02:24I would like to make them. Mike, a year ago, right now, I was in your office.

0:02:29That's true. Yeah, yeah, yeah.

0:02:31Right. So the shoe is on the other foot, buddy.

0:02:34Yep. And I and I know that uh as well, like you felt this way when I would go see Steven in Memphis and in one year you're like, I'm coming.

0:02:42I'm just coming. We'd love that. I'm just coming to see it because I'm gonna yeah.

0:02:46Oh yeah. The co-kool-aid man's coming.

0:02:49So uh yeah, it's but it's it's fun.

0:02:51They're um they're they're they're wiring things, Mike.

0:02:54Yeah, let's get to this. So if you would like to send in a snow talk question of your own, uh please go to upgradefeedback dot com and you can send that in.

0:03:01So there were two reasons for this trip.

0:03:04The other one that I'm aware of, which uh s for some reason was also tied to an an unlock in the podcast a thon, although it doesn't really appear like anything's happening that's podcast a thon related to what's going on right now.

0:03:17My understanding is Steven is currently rewiring Casey's house.

0:03:22Well Well sort of. So so yeah, the so this trip plan goes back to when the schedule got announced.

0:03:27So like Steven rent the Airbnb that we're in was I think he rented it in in May.

0:03:34Like it's been a long time coming.

0:03:36And then the the whole like Stephen helps Casey, because there was gonna be like a whole like Stephen helps Casey rewire his house, which sort of didn't happen.

0:03:45And then Stephen, you know, you gotta throw some things in the mix.

0:03:49So Steven threw working on Casey's house into the mix of uh things for the podcast a thon.

0:03:57And you know, a lot of those promises you make, you're you make them because you expect you're gonna keep them.

0:04:01And I think Steven's intent was always to help Casey out when we were here.

0:04:07So they're out there, like right now, they'll when I left them, s they had attached uh, you know, a thing to a dremel and they were gonna be dremeling some of the siding of Casey's house out.

0:04:17Uh they were they were during the I was watching a it it it went down yesterday exactly as I expected, which is I'm drinking a beer watching the football game with Casey's wife and his kids,

0:04:26and Casey and Steven are pulling Ethernet through the through the basement, through the crawl space in order to hook up a camera on on the back porch,

0:04:37which when we asked why, um and Aaron was like, Why do we even need a security camera on the back porch?

0:04:43Casey's response was exactly what you would think, which is why not?

0:04:46Because we can. We have to Stephen.

0:04:49I said I well and I said I said I enjoy our backyard camera because of the wildlife more than anything else, right?

0:04:57You can be like, Oh, I s the skunk it was out there or there was the right during uh the start of COVID, we had a visitor who was a fox for like four or five nights.

0:05:05And we're like, Whoa, there's a fox out there.

0:05:07Never seen him since. But there was a fox there for a while.

0:05:10So I hope they see some fun wildlife, if nothing else.

0:05:14And that yeah, that's so they're they're pulling cable.

0:05:16He's got a camera on the front of the house that um Aaron did say.

0:05:19I hope Steven's also gonna address that camera on the front of house because Casey hooked that up and it's really janky.

0:05:25And suffice it to say, yes, that has always been like I think job one of the plan is to properly wire that camera as opposed to whatever kind of weird wiring that Casey did that Aaron considers janky.

0:05:38So so yeah they're they're doing that right now as we record this.

0:05:42And then um I did have a couple of moments where we were talking about, you know, technology stuff as you do.

0:05:47It's a it's a bit of a drive to and from Charlottesville as well.

0:05:50And I I kept having the moment where I would I would realize I was about to say the words home assistant and I would just point at Casey.

0:05:56I'd get Casey, home assistant, and then we would go on, uh, because that was like turning a a light switch on.

0:06:02Speaking of which, I've seen the the legendary Casey Lis light switch.

0:06:07Right. Which has like a series of colored um lights on it that yeah that indicate status.

0:06:15And you know, this is a thing that he's done.

0:06:17It's like the light for the garage door being open, the light that somebody's opened the mailbox, so the mail is out there the light for um like he it's it it's a lot,

0:06:27right? It's a lot. But there was a moment where Stephen and I, he showed it to us and Stephen and I, and then he went off to do something else.

0:06:32And Stephen and I were looking at it. And Stephen turned to me and he said, I kinda want one.

0:06:36I said, Yeah, it's actually pretty good.

0:06:38No way. Wow. He's that's a good thing.

0:06:40Yeah, they don't make him anymore. Well, I mean, it's super subtle.

0:06:43That's the thing that I like about it, is it if you don't know or care what it means, uh nobody cares and it doesn't matter and you know and yeah, I actually think for a lot of smart home tech that's the best approach.

0:06:54That's why I like those um those those switches that are smart switches um instead the Lutron Casita instead of smart bulbs.

0:07:04Because smart bulbs, you're like, oh, don't use the light switch anymore.

0:07:07Now you must use an app. Smart switches, it's just a switch.

0:07:11You can control it via an app, but also you can just Turn the light on by the switch.

0:07:17And that I feel like that's important. So Casey's little ambient weird status light thingy is actually um that's the right way to do that.

0:07:27Now, what is it necessary in life to have all of these things um censored like that?

0:07:32And he does. Like he literally has a power sensor on his washing machine so that he can have the status of if the laundry needs attention.

0:07:42Wow. Like Yeah, I mean that's that's a bit much.

0:07:45But um but you know, ex a little bit extra is what we've come to expect from Casey, so it's okay.

0:07:51I have put a link in the show notes.

0:07:52Obviously Casey has documented this on his website with a color coded chart.

0:07:57Um I it's interesting to me that that someone could internalize these col the color system.

0:08:04I'm sure that says something about Casey as a learner, right?

0:08:07That like he has these colours and it's like he can just look at that and he knows that for example green means the laundry needs attention.

0:08:15So you know the story the story is that um Aaron was saying how they were expecting a package and they got a notification I think that it got delivered and there was nothing at the front door and and they were standing in the in the kitchen and they were a little bit confused.

0:08:28And I think it was I think it was uh Aaron and Michaela and um and then she realized, oh, isn't doesn't Casey have a light to say if somebody put it in the mailbox?

0:08:38And then I think Erin said she asked Michaela, like, do you remember what color the mailbox light is supposed to be?

0:08:44Is it blue? Is it blue? And the light blue the blue light was on.

0:08:47And they're like okay, I think it's in the mailbox.

0:08:48And it was in the mailbox. But that that was a funny moment of like, does anybody else in this house know what the colors mean?

0:08:55Wouldn't this this task maybe be better served by like an a small e ink screen that just literally says the thing on it that needs to be?

0:09:05Sure. I mean e you'd have to refresh it.

0:09:07I mean, yes, there there are there are other ways to do it.

0:09:09And I think that today he might have, if if he didn't have this option, he might have something um like that.

0:09:15Because this is subtle and ignorable, but it's also not necessarily useful to people who don't know the code.

0:09:21Whereas you could have you could have a little uh an e ink screen or even like a little screen somewhere with a status display on it that was I mean, that's that's that's what I do for our um our e ink screen in in the in the kitchen,

0:09:34um I made the point of you can do like subtle things with like here's the weather and here's what our calendar is.

0:09:41But since Lauren is a commuter, um I have it that above a certain threshold of percentage chance of rain that day,

0:09:50it puts a big umbrella icon prominently on that screen.

0:09:56And that is I like that because that's the signal of like all she has to do is look and be like oh it is gonna rain today.

0:10:01I should bring an umbrella, I should bring my raincoat.

0:10:04I like that. So I think that I think that yes, but I I do love this kind of tech and I I like the little lights.

0:10:08You're right. I might not actually choose to use it, but what I like about it is that it's super subtle, it doesn't.

0:10:14Um and you can ignore it if you don't care and nobody's gonna fault you for it.

0:10:20So I like that about it. So the the purpose of what they're doing right now is what?

0:10:25They're just rewiring all these Ethernet and adding in some new hardware?

0:10:29I think it's cameras primarily.

0:10:30Okay. Um they did find I mean it's the same thing that happens.

0:10:33This is why I always am reluctant to do networking stuff, is that you think it's gonna go fine and then you start to unravel it and it turns out that it's not fine.

0:10:44So like they they had they opened up the thing and it was corroded.

0:10:48Oh and there was like power over Ethernet, and then Steven's just cutting it with a he cuts an Ethernet cable with a with a just scissors and there's maybe a spark and he's like,

0:10:58Oh, does is this power over Ethernet or whatever?

0:11:00Like, oh we found the power. Um and then one of the cables that they was part of the cable run just didn't work.

0:11:05So they had to run some new cable.

0:11:06So Casey's, you know, cutting off the end of a cable and tying another cable around it so they can pull it through.

0:11:11And like that's the that's why I always try to not do anything with my network.

0:11:15Because I know the moment like our friend Lex Friedman just did a video on his website about switching from Eero to Ubiquity wireless access points in his house.

0:11:25And if you watch that video, it's that same thing where you get that little pit in your stomach where you're like, it's all supposed to work but then it doesn't work.

0:11:33And then, you know, even when you get it to mostly work, there's like one device that isn't your network.

0:11:38And, you know, and I always feel the pressure of like everybody else who lives in my house is going to be very angry at me because I am the dummy who who broke the network and didn't I'm responsible.

0:11:49And like every time it's just this is why I hate doing networking of any kind is because not because I don't understand it and not because I can't troubleshoot it.

0:11:59It's because I know that something I'm not anticipating is gonna break and I'm gonna have to figure it out and I'm gonna have to fix it and it's super frustrating.

0:12:07So what I'm saying is this is why I I mean I didn't make a stretch goal for the podcast a thon.

0:12:13So I watch the football game and this is why we're up here and they're down there.

0:12:18Uh the upgrade's

0:12:23Speaking of which, speaking of of home networking, the upgrades are not related to it in any way.

0:12:30I have no transition. The upgrade is uh nominations are open.

0:12:34Um we've had some responses so far.

0:12:36Thank you to everybody that has sent in a response.

0:12:39You can go to upgradies dot vote and you can send in your nominations.

0:12:43The nominations are closing on December fourteenth.

0:12:46Uh the episode will be out on December twenty eighth.

0:12:49This is our award show where we along with your help as a listener of this show, uh we m give awards to things that we enjoy throughout the year.

0:12:59This is apps and media and stories.

0:13:01Favorites of the year. Favorites of the year.

0:13:03Yep. So Jason and I will come prepared to that episode with our nominations for each category.

0:13:09Uh and we want you to help out because sometimes the upgradians can help shine a light on things that m that deserve to be uh spoken about, right?

0:13:16So we will always mention mention a bunch of uh of nominees for each category before we make the final award judgment.

0:13:23Uh but also as well the upgradings can help us make a decision.

0:13:27You know, like if Jason and I both can't decide on something, maybe we can use you as a as a tiebreaker.

0:13:32So we want you don't you know, go to upgrades.vote.

0:13:35You can send in your uh uh nominations.

0:13:37You don't have to fill in every category if you don't want to, uh, but we would really appreciate it if there's something you've enjoyed this year uh to let us know about it by um by by sending in your upgradies nominations.

0:13:50Um I'm excited for the upgradies as I always am.

0:13:53Uh um I've already started making my notes, Jason.

0:13:56I don't know about that yet.

0:13:57I I just I realized I realized there were just a couple of things that I popped into my head.

0:14:02And it's I'm gonna forget about these if I don't start writing them down now.

0:14:06So I've started writing them down now.

0:14:07Uh I do actually have a book that I'll be nominating this year even though it didn't this year.

0:14:13Uh, but I'll nominate it anyway.

0:14:15Uh I actually have two, because I've read I've read two books this year if you could imagine such a thing.

0:14:18Uh on that, actually, I will just give a a piece of follow-out.

0:14:22Um, the author of uh Apple in China.

0:14:24Patrick McGee, is my guest on Cortex, uh, this month.

0:14:28And that episode is out now. So if you wanna listen to that, it was fascinating, a fascinating conversation uh about how he put that book together.

0:14:36So There's a great uh video episode of that, is there not?

0:14:39There is actually. Um yeah, I I've been making full video episodes of Cortex uh with your help because you built a tool for us for designing California.

0:14:50Um Uh and I have been using that tool to turn uh our audio episodes into video episodes.

0:14:56Which Yes, you found lots of bugs. You sent me a screenshot that was the most horrifying screenshot I've seen in a long time.

0:15:01Yeah. And I said you gotta send me your file so I can fix all those bugs.

0:15:04Yeah. And then they were fixed and it it output a really great episode.

0:15:09So if people like their video podcasts, they can do that.

0:15:11Yeah, but you can uh go check that out.

0:15:13But yes, please go to upgradeies.fo and send in your nominations for the thirteenth annual upgradies.

0:15:21This episode is brought to you by Scribe.

0:15:24Imagine this. If the one person who knows how your billing process works leaves your company, they leave your team, they're gone.

0:15:32What happens next? Often that knowledge walks out the door with them and nobody realizes how much they relied on it until something goes wrong.

0:15:41That's exactly that this sponsor, Scribe, was built to solve.

0:15:45Scribe is a specialized intelligence platform that automatically documents how your team actually get things done and it's trusted by ninety-four percent of the Fortune 500.

0:15:56That's a lot. Here's how it works.

0:15:58Your team does a task the way they normally would.

0:16:01Scribe will capture the steps as they happen and turn them into visual step-by-step guides in one click.

0:16:06No manual writing, no starting from scratch when someone new joins the team, or it's time to get everyone on the same page.

0:16:13Your team reviews each guide, then shares it right in the tools that they already use.

0:16:17From there, any guide can become an on-screen walkthrough so your team can finish any process of confidence.

0:16:23And privacy is built in. Scribe can automatically redact sensitive data like names, emails, and payment information, and it only captures work in the apps your admins approve.

0:16:34And because AI knows what the world knows now and not how your company works, the workflows scribe captures can give your AI agents the context they're missing.

0:16:44Turn your team's know-how into guides anyone can follow.

0:16:47Go to scibe.how slash upgrade and mention this show.

0:16:53Again, that is scribe dot how slash upgrade.

0:16:55Mention that you heard about it on upgrade.

0:16:57Thanks to Scribe for their support of this show and relay.

0:17:02So you are in a home.

0:17:03You're not in your home, but I think it is time to talk about the home view because it is out now.

0:17:10I have views. You wrote a home.

0:17:12Indeed. You wrote a review uh about the of the home view.

0:17:15How long did you have the home view for?

0:17:17Oh like almost uh like a week and a half.

0:17:20It full it was actually uh you know, I I I knew that you got it a little early and it reminded me because we just did the uh the finale of our iPod series on design in California and you had that for about two weeks and I thought,

0:17:31Oh, it's like you usually don't get things for this long, I feel It was it was a pretty leisurely uh I mean, amid all the other embargoes,

0:17:39that was the thing that killed me is that I I had the home view and I had multiple embargoed products ahead of it in the queue.

0:17:46Yeah. Because its embargo was so much later than the iPad mini and the Mac but Pro that um it was like I I set it up and was using it which is great because I got to I got to use it but there were other things ahead of it but I did

0:18:00I did get to it and manage there was a moment when I was about to head out on my trip where I thought I was gonna literally have to put the tuck the little home view in my backpack or in my suitcase and bring it with me.

0:18:10Um, but I didn't I I finished my review before I left, so I left it at home.

0:18:14I do feel like there was probably a benefit in having it a little bit longer.

0:18:17I mean, I only got mine on Friday right?

0:18:20So I I I I picked up mine when they came out.

0:18:22And I've had very little interaction with it really.

0:18:26And so I think about having that thing live in your home for a longer period of time probably helped you to to put your thoughts together about it a little bit.

0:18:36Sure, because you get not only you're sitting down I mean I literally did sit down at the bar with it in front of me and kinda like do all try to use it to do all the things,

0:18:44but it also just kinda hung out in our kitchen.

0:18:47Yep. And uh it was nice to have that time with it to discover it, you know, its quirks, but also the the some, you know,

0:18:55use cases and how it feels like to have it sitting in your in your house in in your life.

0:19:00Like I was pretty pleased actually just out of pure happenstance.

0:19:02We hosted like a family like an extended family get together at my house yesterday.

0:19:07And so I was cooking lots of party food.

0:19:09So I'm setting timers, turning on music.

0:19:11Like I actually had a a uh uh an overuse day with the home view which was pretty helpful for me because otherwise uh the other days I'm like,

0:19:20Oh hey, look at that picture, you know, like which which is really what I want it for, but I didn't really I haven't really had like the full on uh experience with it.

0:19:27But anyway let's talk about the design.

0:19:29We'll start with that. I knew it was small.

0:19:32It's tiny little guy. But it's smaller than I think it is.

0:19:35Yes. It's very little.

0:19:37Um which is interesting I think.

0:19:40Yeah. I mean it's it's the screen is five inches square.

0:19:43I had somebody be very pedantic and be like, I think you'll know I think you'll find it's seven inch display.

0:19:47It's like, Yes, that's how math works.

0:19:50It's five inches square, meaning that the diagonal is seven inches.

0:19:54Yep. That's how that works. You kind of care more about the physical space that it takes.

0:19:59And so like the five by five by five.

0:20:01Yeah, it's it's just and it's square. But then it's little it's got the the nice little um little um oh I I'm I'm blanking on it.

0:20:09You know, it's the base by a little hinge.

0:20:12Yeah. That feels nice and and allows you to tilt it up and down to sort of like get it where you can see it at a good angle.

0:20:18Very satisfying to move that too.

0:20:20Like it feels good. Yeah it feels good.

0:20:22And then it's got the little base, which is a very Apple kind of like aluminum hole punch in a a base design.

0:20:27But it's it's tiny. Like if you haven't seen one, it's smaller than you think it is.

0:20:31Uh it just I it I trust me, you you probably have a reasonable expectation like we all did about its size and it's smaller than that.

0:20:39Yeah, is a real old one. Like it like in a way that I now I was wondering like will I want one of these for my studio?

0:20:45And the answer to that is is maybe.

0:20:47Like I'm not entirely sure yet.

0:20:49Um, but I know I could put it kind of like on my desk in a way that I hadn't.

0:20:56You know what I mean? Like it's like, oh no, that thing's just gonna fit in.

0:21:00Um one of the things I was actually quite surprised about is that I mean I'm I yeah, I am correct about it as I'm checking on the website.

0:21:09The 'cause I got the pink one um because that fits with my home quite well actually.

0:21:14The USB C cable is color coded to the product.

0:21:20Yes. Because they ship you one in the box and a power adapter, which is lovely because you don't always get that these days.

0:21:26Um and the the cable that they send you is is color coded to the model that you have, which I think is a nice touch because uh it's gonna be on show,

0:21:34right? Like just with the way that these things work.

0:21:37I mean ours is on like a church island, which means you're seeing that cable.

0:21:40Like it it's it's gonna pop out.

0:21:42Um, I know there's lots of jokes about drilling holes and things that lot people keep making.

0:21:46Uh I'm obviously not going to do that because I'm not gonna do if I had a wooden countertop, then sure, maybe, but I have a marble one, a quartz one actually.

0:21:54So no that's not gonna happen. Um but i it's more visible, so I like that it's it's uh it's a it's color coded, so that's nice.

0:22:01But yeah, I I I think that the hardware of it is it feels very fitting for the home.

0:22:08You know, like a lot of companies, they they they use what I've always called smart home fabric as their design, right?

0:22:14It's just like even the original home pod is this and the home pod mini is this, right?

0:22:18They've that weird kind of like lattice fabric that it feels like every smart home product is covered in.

0:22:24This isn't that. It's metal.

0:22:26But I think the kind of adorableness of it being all little, it it makes it fit quite nicely in a home, I think.

0:22:33I agree. I agree. It's it's uh I think they did a good job.

0:22:37I think it's I think it's cute. Yep.

0:22:39And attractive and fits well.

0:22:41I mean, certainly in my kitchen. Fits great.

0:22:43It's nicer than the the previous two screens that were there.

0:22:47Let's talk about the operating system experience.

0:22:50Uh you you call it in your review a peculiar amalgam of numerous other Apple products.

0:22:55And it it really is.

0:22:57It's like it's like a recipe.

0:22:59It's got a dash of this and a sprinkle of that.

0:23:01It is fascinating what they've done with this.

0:23:03Yeah it's perfect for something in the kitchen to be like a recipe.

0:23:05Yeah, it it is. If you if you are like us, so I you know, a a civilian would probably not think like this, but if you're somebody like us who has spent a lot of time knowing about Apple's entire product line and

0:23:19everything they're doing, you can't, I think, not look at the home view and see where they lifted pieces.

0:23:27Like Apple's always been really good at reusing stuff.

0:23:30They always have been. That's how they can do so many different products and so many different operating systems is they reuse pieces.

0:23:37So like widgets are in a lot of different places and Uh i because they were they take that one tech and they use it again.

0:23:44Well there are a lot of widgets here too, but like it's got these faces on it and and and like the ones that are the most pretty and the most refined are very clearly just Apple Watch faces that are on this thing.

0:23:56Just huge but Apple Watch faces.

0:23:58And then they've got some new faces that are more functional but less pretty.

0:24:03Um that are for the home view.

0:24:05But and and to to edit the faces, it's like editing Apple Watch faces.

0:24:10So that's all there. But it's some some of the stuff feels like it's also kind of lifted from standby mode, which itself is probably kind of lifted from Apple Watch,

0:24:19but standby mode on the on the iPhone there's CarPlay apps as well as like regular apps that sort of feel like iPhone apps or iPad apps,

0:24:27but they're different. Um, yeah.

0:24:29So it's just as you use it, you keep pointing at things and being like, Oh, that's like this other Apple product.

0:24:35And I think where the Homeview does fall down is that as clever as they've been,

0:24:43it feels very much like they've been very clever to get this product out and to have it do what they want it to do.

0:24:48But, you know, there are gaps.

0:24:50There are moments where you're like, why does it do it like that?

0:24:53Um an an example that made me laugh out loud that somebody pointed out this weekend is is um you can select text in safari on the home view but you can't do anything with the

0:25:05selection.

0:25:07Okay. Yep. Well it's that that's what it's like.

0:25:12It it it's just like you launch an app and and you there's an app screen, right?

0:25:17There's a home screen, which you can rearrange, but you can't apps, but you can rearrange it like it's an iPhone or an iPad.

0:25:23Um some of those apps are are apps that they're from Apple and they're home view apps.

0:25:29How how do they get made? Nobody knows.

0:25:32HomeView apps. But some of those apps are not their CarPlay apps that just that don't even know about the home view.

0:25:38Even Apple's apps. Some of Apple T V apps are CarPlay apps.

0:25:42Yep. The T V app is a is a CarPlay app, for example.

0:25:45Or news where you can listen to stories but can't check the recipes from Apple News.

0:25:51Right, which totally makes sense.

0:25:53Um Yeah it it it's it's very weird.

0:25:56Al also a thing that I noticed that was fascinating is in using overcast is I can use overcast, right?

0:26:03Like Marco didn't know about the home view, but I can use overcast.

0:26:06Great. Except Except Overcast relies on the concept of the now playing view in CarPlay, for it's now playing, is that there's another for those who don't use CarPlay,

0:26:16there's another app basically in CarPlay called Now Playing that shows you whatever media is playing at the moment.

0:26:23And so it would be, I think, redundant to have now playing view in your car play.

0:26:28I didn't know what was going on here.

0:26:30Now I understand it. So you can navigate you can navigate in overcast and play something, but you can't in Overcast then show the now playing view.

0:26:40And and there's a bug here too, I think, which is there is a live activity that theoretically is showing you the activity of whatever media is playing.

0:26:48But I found that sometimes Overcast would not trigger that.

0:26:54If you if it triggers it, you can tap on it and you get a now playing view, I believe.

0:26:59And that's how it works with music.

0:27:01But there's this funny like in-between state where um Overcast expects there to be the now playing view in CarPlay,

0:27:10and the home view just doesn't have it because it's not really CarPlay.

0:27:14Um and and and I would say it's also just a little disconcerting to have two separate app frameworks that are uh happening in the same place with no indicator of which is which.

0:27:24Uh which is it's just again, like I'm not faulting.

0:27:28Like I think them importing CarPlay in order to get immediate support for audio apps and presumably some uh eventual support for video apps is smart.

0:27:39I think it's clever.

0:27:41But the execution is.

0:27:45I mean, it it they are they had to live down the fact that they're relying on CarPlay and that CarPlay behaves differently.

0:27:50And it it feels to me, I don't know this for a fact, but it feels to me like a product that

0:27:57th maybe there were some assumptions that there was gonna be an app store or some sort of third party app method of using it.

0:28:05And then when that got shut down, they had a moment of like, well then what are we gonna do?

0:28:11And like CarPlay is a really clever fallback.

0:28:14It's really clever hack. But it doesn't erase the fact that it's really weird.

0:28:19Yeah. Yeah. Th the the thing that I have found the weirdest actually is the widgets.

0:28:25Um Um because Yeah, interesting choices.

0:28:29Yeah, you can get widgets on this device and some of the widgets are widgets that are coming from the Apple apps.

0:28:38No, but like Apple has some.

0:28:41They're like, you know, st just standard widgets.

0:28:43And then the rest come from your phone, like how that works on the Mac, right?

0:28:48And we knew this is going to happen and we found out that they're just the small widget type.

0:28:53But the thing I find strange is the widgets look weird because they are physically larger than any place that they currently appear in the small shape.

0:29:02Like they're just bigger. They're huge, yeah.

0:29:04Um because that's just the way that the interface looks.

0:29:07So they some of them are a bit sh sh kind of like spaced out, I'll say.

0:29:11It looks just like a little bit m more than you need.

0:29:14And I'm adding these widgets. So I'm happy that they work actually.

0:29:17I was I was very pleased that like even say a widget smith widget that looks at an album of photos works.

0:29:25I was like, brilliant, because I want that on my home view because I like to have that.

0:29:31But the thing I was originally st struck by is like, Oh, I can't make a stack of widgets.

0:29:36Like there's if you drag a widget on top of another widget, all that happens is the widget moves out of the way.

0:29:42And I'm poking around in the home screen and I'm like, But there is a stack here.

0:29:45There is a stack, yeah. Like A there is a stack that Apple ships it with, like a uh they like a smart stack.

0:29:51And I realized if you create a new widget and the widget option you start with is smart stack, you can just rem edit what's in the smart stack and make your own stack,

0:30:04which is like, okay, I got what I want, but that is absolutely not how this works on other platforms.

0:30:09Yeah, the i it is there there are a lot of things that feel very one point oh about it.

0:30:13Yeah. And I I heard from some people who are like, wait a second.

0:30:16It is the hardware it has been around for two years.

0:30:19So why is the why are you saying that the software is unfinished?

0:30:21Haven't they had two years to finish? And it's like, bless your heart, uh, 'cause I'm in the south.

0:30:26Um Um no, like the story here is that the software is not ready.

0:30:30That's why it didn't ship. And what I'll tell you what didn't happen is when Apple Intelligence kind of failed two years ago, what they didn't keep like a team of elves working on home view for two years,

0:30:39polishing everything and getting it ready to go.

0:30:41No, I'm pretty down and then picked it up two years later and said, okay, what do we need to do to finish this off?

0:30:46And and like the the truth is, same old story.

0:30:49The hardware is great and the software lets it down because the software is kind of like not all there yet.

0:30:54And I think it's got a lot of potential to be more like the Apple Watch in the early days, where like it it feels it reminds me a lot of the Apple Watch in the ear,

0:31:03both in the lack of focus. I think Apple is like unsure what the the five things are that everybody g is going to want out of this.

0:31:09So they built 15 features and are going to wait and see which five kind of bob to the top or four or three or whatever that number is and address the deficiencies that it's got.

0:31:18I hope they do that. But to your point about the the the widgets and it's and it's the widgets in those faces.

0:31:25And this is what I say about the faces seeming kind of primitive, the ones that aren't just watch faces with little complications.

0:31:31There they what I noticed is there are widgets There are there are faces that are modular that have widget spaces in them or that have home spaces in them.

0:31:41And also I'll point out, not together.

0:31:44Like there's you can either have widgets in them or you can have home in them, but you can't have both mixed.

0:31:50And I think part of that is probably because the widgets that are projected from your iPhone aren't gonna show up if it's not you.

0:31:57Yeah. Right? Because they're from your phone.

0:31:59But still, but still, Dill, right?

0:32:02And then the other thing I realized is there are slots that have clocks.

0:32:06Yep. And at least in my exploration, if you delete a slot with a clock, and then you say, Oh no, actually I want to put a clock there, and you add a clock back or add a a widget or something back.

0:32:18There are no clocks.

0:32:20There are no clocks. Not only that, but I don't need to see a little tiny widget of hands of a of a clock.

0:32:27I would really like a digital time.

0:32:29Like there are on the photos widgets.

0:32:31And there are no options for that.

0:32:33There are just these clocks with hands.

0:32:35And you can edit the clock with hands when it's there.

0:32:37But at least my experience was when I deleted the clock slot, I couldn't get a clock back there.

0:32:44I had to make a new face that had the clock there.

0:32:47Okay. This is this is what we're talking about here, right?

0:32:50It is it is a fun piece of hardware that does a bunch of stuff really well and a bunch of stuff not really well.

0:32:56And it's all kind of like not fitting together quite right.

0:33:00And I think this product I I think it's a lot of fun.

0:33:03I think it's got a lot of potential. I think there's so many good things about it.

0:33:07And I think that as a baseline baseline for this product to me, I don't know how you feel about this, but to me, baseline of this product is,

0:33:15is it a home pod with a screen?

0:33:17And does that screen show nice photos from my Apple Photos library?

0:33:22If it can do those two things and then like offer people in my house some control of smart home devices,

0:33:30I'm kinda there. I will also say the smart home stuff.

0:33:33There's a home app and the home app will do everything the home app does anywhere else.

0:33:36That's great. But like I'm really disappointed in the home faces because they're also pretty rudimentary.

0:33:42And the one that really gets me is if you put a dimmable light on a home face, you can't dim it.

0:33:48It can only go off and on. And like, what are we doing?

0:33:52And again, 1.0.

0:33:54It all feels like every time I talk about like think of the potential here, I will have to say, but right now it does this infuriating thing because that is that's where we are.

0:34:04So, like lots of things about it.

0:34:06If you diminish your expectations, if you kind of rein it in, because I do think table stakes for this is can I use it as a voice assistant?

0:34:13And you know, Siri AI is still spotty everywhere, but when it works, it works really well.

0:34:17I did a test where I asked it about a a painting.

0:34:21I uh somebody, I think Lex summarized my review as saying I was trying to get the name of a painting.

0:34:26I don't know. It's a painting I'm extremely familiar with.

0:34:29I'm just gonna boast a little bit. I know.

0:34:31All about Jacques-Louis David, he's my favorite painter.

0:34:33But I thought it would be a funny question to say what's the name of that and we just did the French Revolution series of the rest is history, Mike, right?

0:34:40Yeah, yeah. Um The Terror. So it's what's the name of the painting from the French Revolution with a guy dead in a bathtub.

0:34:48That was my query.

0:34:50And it not only showed Death of Marat by Jacques Louis David.

0:34:54I mean it not only answered it, it showed the painting.

0:34:57And I was like, Well that is the platonic ideal of home pod with a screen is I should be able to shout it out and get an answer and see the answer and like,

0:35:08okay, good job. Serie AI still kind of all over the place.

0:35:11Sometimes it works really well.

0:35:13Sometimes it is slow or it doesn't but like potential there.

0:35:18It it you know, the music playback generally works.

0:35:21I had a quirk with that too. It you can link it to your speakers.

0:35:25So if you don't want to play it on the device, which sounds Okay, but you've got like airplayable speakers, you can do that.

0:35:31And then it's just a controller for that.

0:35:33And it shows pictures of my family that are pleasant along with the time.

0:35:36Like these are these are the table stakes.

0:35:38And I feel like it's it's funny.

0:35:40It's like the table stakes of the home view.

0:35:43It's close to being all there.

0:35:45It's not all there, but it's close to being all there.

0:35:49And then there's like everything outside of it, which is like, what is this product?

0:35:54Is it an fully functional interactive Apple product?

0:35:59And the answer is kind of sometimes, but sometimes not.

0:36:05And that's when it starts to get weirder.

0:36:07And and again, I think it lacks clarity and vision, probably because of its its troubled history.

0:36:18And and I guess one other things that frustrates me about it is I think this this could actually be a really great product, but somebody's gonna need to make some decisions about what it's for and then make those

0:36:32features really good. Yeah.

0:36:33And right now it's more like they did the basics, they sprayed a bunch of stuff in there and sort of like shrugged and shipped it.

0:36:41So what now? Yeah, for me, you know, like we've been talking about this product, a product like this for years, right?

0:36:47Of like as me and you have gone down this road of a bunch of

0:36:52we've been we wanted this product for more than two years now.

0:36:55Literally all I wanted is show me my photos in a really nice way and don't put a bunch of crap on the screen.

0:37:04Right. And don't try to sell me stuff. Exactly that.

0:37:07It does now. I mean, I never really felt the need when I'm originally thinking about this product that it would be something I would ask questions of because Siri was no good at that,

0:37:19right? Yeah. Now it is, and so I am.

0:37:22Yeah. For me, that Death America question, yeah.

0:37:25Like that I I I said it, the platonic ideal.

0:37:28It's like I asked a question and got an answer.

0:37:32And not only that, it showed me the answer.

0:37:35Yep. Like a painting. Here's the painting you're thinking of.

0:37:39Like that, that is, yeah, you're right.

0:37:42That was like what I wanted, what I dreamed about out of this product, but didn't expect I could get.

0:37:49No. And like and then there are some other things that are just, you know, it does what I want, right?

0:37:54And it does it in a nice way. Timers.

0:37:56This device does a really great job with timers.

0:37:58It's very intelligent at the way that it's if you have multiple timers running, which one it's gonna show you at any given time.

0:38:05It makes a decision about that. Like if you set a new time say you have a 10 minute timer running and you set a twenty minute timer.

0:38:11When you set the twenty minute timer, it shows you the twenty minute timer is set, right?

0:38:15Yeah. And if you've named it will

0:38:18change back to the one that's about to go off first, which I think is very clever, right?

0:38:23So then you're kind of aware of what's going on.

0:38:25So like it and then it has like live activities and all that kind of stuff.

0:38:29I I think that all works very well.

0:38:31But yes, it is a I think comparing this to the original Apple Watch is like the perfect comparison for this.

0:38:38I think so too. Because it's like the app situation is incredibly not ideal for anyone,

0:38:46right? Like the th you could make watch apps, but oh boy, it was terrible.

0:38:51Right? Like it it it was not really really worth doing in i with the original watch OS because it was so hard and so limited and it relied so much on the phone that everything was really slow and weird.

0:39:03And then also similarly it's like, hey, it does and the same for the hub view.

0:39:08All these things. You can do all these things.

0:39:10You know, it's a long list of things that it does.

0:39:12But really, people are gonna do like three things.

0:39:15And then you my hope is, like with the Apple Watch, the Apple understands and sees what people do with it and then just make those experiences as good as they can possibly be and also create a

0:39:28better story for developers, whatever that ends up being.

0:39:33Yeah. Like maybe you just continue continue that it's CarPlay, but give some additional function to CarPlay that runs on HomeView.

0:39:41Right. You know, or something. I I yeah.

0:39:44I I don't know what they're gonna do.

0:39:47No. And and I don't know what developers want to do, but 'cause I think I think giving CarPlay as an out is okay.

0:39:54And yeah, maybe you need to give them some tools so that they can clean some stuff up on the home view.

0:39:59I still think the right way forward for this product is probably probably to allow developers of iPhone apps,

0:40:07at least in certain categories, to do the equivalent of of of and I've said this before, to do the equivalent of Apple Watch apps where there's no app store.

0:40:19But if you have, so if Marco wanted to make a proper home view app, and maybe he doesn't because he doesn't need to, or if the developer of Mela,

0:40:27the recipe app, wanted to do a proper, because there's no way to get that on the on the home view right now, a proper app on the home view, that you wouldn't have to like ideally you wouldn't have to write an entirely separate app.

0:40:39There would be some rules about how to adapt an iPhone app to the home view.

0:40:44And then if you had the iPhone, app on your phone, you could say add this app to home view and it would add it and it would just be there.

0:40:53Right. Like no app store on the home view doesn't need an app store.

0:40:56The app situation should be simple, but use the home view for a day and you'll realize that Apple apps and some CarPlay apps is not gonna do it.

0:41:09Like there needs to be more It doesn't need to be as complicated as an iPhone or an iPad.

0:41:15You know, it may be as complicated as an Apple Watch, leaving aside that the Apple Watch also has an app store, because let's forget about that.

0:41:22Pretend it doesn't exist. Everybody else does.

0:41:24You know, they need to do something and and that's what occurs to me is wouldn't it be easier to just let people adapt their iPhone apps very simply if they care enough about the home view to do it?

0:41:34But I don't know. I don't know what the right thing is.

0:41:37You're right. Maybe, maybe it's as simple as adding some new categories of CarPlay apps and saying CarPlay is the framework we're gonna go with here.

0:41:44And here are a few things you can add to make it work better on the home view.

0:41:47But like, does it make sense for a recipe app to use CarPlay?

0:41:51I mean, I'm sure they could do it, but like that's not the right approach.

0:41:54But right now, if you have your recipes in an app, like you just can't do it.

0:41:59I mean, I've gotten emails from people who are like, Oh, I've I built a workaround where you can spin up a web server and export things from Mela and then put it on your web server and then load it.

0:42:06And it's like, okay, great, but like that's not good enough.

0:42:09Like there needs to be a way to do that.

0:42:11And I don't know what it is, because CarPlay doesn't seem to be appropriate at all for that.

0:42:16But I also don't think this device needs an app store.

0:42:19Yeah. What faces are you using?

0:42:21Like I mean, you've mentioned a couple that you've tried, but what what are you actually using on your home view?

0:42:27Photos? Yeah. I mean that's a killer face.

0:42:30I my problem my problem with the photos view is it's all or nothing.

0:42:35It's like you get photos and then maybe there's like a little text complication or something like that.

0:42:40And like I just expected it all to be a little better integrated.

0:42:43Like could I drop a home button on the photos view that if I tap on it brings up a photos face uh or a home face for or or a widget face or something like that.

0:42:54Could I have or could I have sort of like most of the screen is a photo, but then there are a few buttons on the side.

0:42:59Like Like some flexibility.

0:43:02Kind of like the iPad home screen, right?

0:43:04Where you can have the little lock screen widgets and they're a bit chunkier than than uh how they are on the iPhone.

0:43:09Yeah, I I would like that 'cause I do think the photos is the killer app, and yet I had this thought of like, yeah, but if I want to see the weather or if I wanna control my lights,

0:43:17I now have to swipe across to two other faces for that because the home stuff can't be with a widget stuff.

0:43:26So what am I doing then?

0:43:27Um so yeah it is I do have a home and I have like a dashboard with widgets and stuff in it and I have a home uh and the photos.

0:43:35So so I've I've loaded some key items like our thermostat and the lights in the kitchen where the thing is into the home grid.

0:43:43And then I've got some, you know, my weather forecast widget, which again my frustration that it's using the small one.

0:43:49That's the same what it uses in standby when the medium one is nicer, but it's not going to show that.

0:43:54So I'm using the small one there. And then, you know, again the killer is you can have multiple photo widgets that are shuffling.

0:44:01And I love that I'm like shuffling through multiple aspects of my photos library, like, you know, photos of my kids together,

0:44:09photos of my pets photos of the whole family together.

0:44:13I can pick multiple ones and then they all kind of shuffle together and they look great and and it's delightful.

0:44:19So which again is a feature that they lifted from the iPhone and have put on the Apple Watch and now they put on the home view, but it's a killer feature for a product like this.

0:44:29So I mean that's what I'm doing. What are you doing?

0:44:30Yeah I'm all I'm all photos. I mean I set up the smart home face, which I I really think is good, right?

0:44:36'Cause you can kind of just have this big command center.

0:44:39And And I liked that you could just have the cameras there, but I think I may have found an issue.

0:44:45You have a wireless camera.

0:44:46I have a battery powered camera.

0:44:48Yeah, right. The battery of my camera so I had to change it.

0:44:53They changed the batteries periodically.

0:44:55It's Nakara doorbell camera.

0:44:57And I changed the batteries and in the next day it was completely dead.

0:45:01It's like that's weird. And I was like, Oh the I think the home view is keeping that camera constantly streaming even though it's not visible.

0:45:12Because they want to give you the experience of you swipe over and you'll see it straight away.

0:45:17I've changed the batteries this morning and I took that camera off of the kind of smart home face and the battery's looking pretty decent right now.

0:45:27So I think that that's a thing.

0:45:29Now it what I think it should do is understand because home the home app knows that that is a battery powered doorbell.

0:45:38Right. I think that for battery powered doorbells they should do like what they do for the home app, where initially it just shows like this is the last screen that we saw and then refresh.

0:45:51Yeah I would say that's probably a a bug more than anything else.

0:45:54Yeah. But it's an example of this software being unfinished.

0:45:57Yeah I have one Accara camera camera up and running.

0:46:00I have another one that I need to install.

0:46:01Maybe I should have Steven come to the house.

0:46:04Um and Steven, if you're listening, uh come on over.

0:46:08So um I uh and it looks great like those and th and now we're gonna get in December we're gonna get the L G one that is,

0:46:17you know, working with Apple. But it's you're gonna have a a very nice home security camera.

0:46:22And sure, when you've got those and they're wired or at least they're wired to power and they're on your network and you can have a face where it's just like literally looking at your at your front yard.

0:46:33Um that's cool.

0:46:35Um again, I have that thought, which is like I do find it funny that for a lot of this stuff it's it's cool and useful, but it all requires you to maybe you can use Siri to advance them,

0:46:46but basically like it requires you to swipe 'em between the faces.

0:46:49Yeah. And I keep thinking, wouldn't it be nicer if you had some faces that were kind of more of a uh a a a dashboard with like uh I c I know I can tap here on this photo of it's mo mostly photo of my family,

0:47:03but if I tap here it's gonna bring up the home face face that's got the security camera and if I tap here right right like a little launcher inside I don't know I'm just spitballing here but like it feels a little fragmented right now like the the this whole product is like that where it's like

0:47:17okay that's really cool is that what you want is you want to look at your driveway when you uh when you come home?

0:47:23Probably not. You wanna see a picture of your of of your family or something.

0:47:27So it's weird. It's very weird.

0:47:30But but I l I like the basics of it.

0:47:32I do like the basics of it. I like having it in my kitchen.

0:47:35That is a thing that I have learned over the last week and a half is I like it in my kitchen.

0:47:40It's just when you use it, you see all the things that it doesn't do everything you expect it to do.

0:47:46What have you had much uh experience with the user switching?

0:47:52A little bit. We we um we got Lauren set up with it.

0:47:57Uh and I keep thinking about when we go away and we have our house sitter come, you know, having it be in a state where she can actually use it,

0:48:05because then I can say you can use this to adjust the thermostat or whatever.

0:48:10Uh so not a lot. It seemed to work okay where like she swipes up and it says good afternoon Lauren and I swipe up and it says good afternoon Jason and it's doing different stuff.

0:48:21Uh one of the challenges it's kind of hard to to test it because you know if I if I get up next to each other,

0:48:29right? Yeah. If I get up in its face things get weird.

0:48:32So um so I've done a little of that, but not not a lot.

0:48:35It does seem I mean it it seems to have provided me with I n what I need when I'm in front of it.

0:48:40Let's put it that way. And the voice commands I've found to p to work pretty well too.

0:48:44Like if yeah one person asks or the other.

0:48:47Um there was a c couple of points I wanted to to touch on before we finish up here.

0:48:51As a as a media device I quite like this.

0:48:53You know, I am a Sonos house.

0:48:55Um, but it this product does a great job with airplay and also kind of becoming like part of the group, you know?

0:49:02Like you you can and I've done that, right?

0:49:04Like I have uh uh some sonar speakers downstairs and I could very easily just like select, you know, like in the airplay UI,

0:49:12like I want you to play here, here and also the home view becomes part of the the group, right?

0:49:17So they're all playing the audio together.

0:49:19And what I was pleased about I hope this will work this way, but you can never be sure.

0:49:24The next time that I asked for a music, it just automatically played on those same speakers.

0:49:29So like it remembers what you set for it.

0:49:32So because what I didn't want to have to keep doing was say Play this on the down the downstairs group or or whatever.

0:49:38Like I that's I don't I want it to be smarter than that.

0:49:42And I think the default the smart default is you just keep playing where you were last playing.

0:49:46Like I think it makes the most sense to do that.

0:49:49Um Because I think naturally otherwise I would ask it to do something else, right?

0:49:53Like if I if I wanted it to play upstairs, I I would ask it for that, you know?

0:49:58So I think that's I think that's pretty good.

0:50:01One of the downsides that I find with with Siri AI is that things just take longer.

0:50:07Like asking for music, like it takes longer than the old Siri did.

0:50:11And that is just a thing that Siri AI does.

0:50:14And so like I'm not surprised about it.

0:50:17But it is annoying. Right.

0:50:19When you have music in your Apple Music library and you ask to play that music and you know that instead of playing that music, what it's actually doing is going out to the cloud,

0:50:29having that processed, and it's coming back down to the device, then it's going to my music library, and then it's playing it.

0:50:38Now it may not be doing those exact things, but it's doing those steps because it just is taking way too long to play an album that I already have saved.

0:50:47It it feels to me like Apple really did prioritize side of getting it functional over getting it fast.

0:50:52Yeah. And there are places where you're used to uh responses and they seem to have addressed like one the timer thing seems to work better now than it used to be.

0:51:00But I agree, there are still these cases where you're sitting there going, Why am I still waiting for this thing to happen?

0:51:06And I think it can vary based on where you are.

0:51:09I've heard from people who say it's terrible and other people who say it's fine.

0:51:12I think it's based on where you are and what time of day it is and like the load on Apple servers and I like all this stuff.

0:51:19But like it needs to be better and more certainly needs to be more consistent than it's been.

0:51:24Yeah, absolutely. And I think it will get better.

0:51:27I do. Yeah.

0:51:28I I want to say how aggressive it gets with handoff.

0:51:31Okay. Just like every time I approach like I was trying to take a picture of it with my phone and it was like great here handoff time.

0:51:41It pops up a thing. But But I think the handoff stuff it does is really clever, right?

0:51:45Like you can you can give whatever's on your phone to it fairly easily.

0:51:49And you can take whatever's playing on it back to your phone fairly easily.

0:51:53Like again, Apple's recycling features they built for other products.

0:51:58I think it does a really good job of it here.

0:52:00I think it's very aggressive with it to the point where I kept thinking, oh yeah, oh geez, like, oh, you saw my phone is here, and now you want to you, you're you're anticipating I might want to do something there,

0:52:09and I don't always, but I appreciate the idea that I want to very easily say, like, take this video I'm watching on my on my phone and just start playing it yourself.

0:52:21Yeah. And it'll do that. And you can use it as an airplay target.

0:52:24It will play via out via airplay.

0:52:26It will also be an airplay receiver and play video like I had a college football game that I I airplayed to it from my phone.

0:52:33And it's weird because 16 by 9 video is horribly letterboxed.

0:52:37And then if you zoom, it's hilariously centered where that's everything is nar is off off the sides.

0:52:44I don't really recommend either of those things.

0:52:46It's watching widescreen on an old four by three TV, right?

0:52:49Is what that's that's basically it's worse than that.

0:52:52But yes, it's basically that. But I like I think it I think the handoff stuff is actually really fun and that they they they did a pretty good job picking that feature up.

0:53:00Again, out of the heap of Apple features and building it into the product.

0:53:03Yeah, I've I've really liked how easy it is to send things, but I haven't had the experience you've had with it grabbing because my phone is never near the home view,

0:53:15just on the way that my kitchen is arranged.

0:53:17Like I would never have my phone that close.

0:53:20It's like if anything, one of the problems I'm having with the size of the device is where I want to put it.

0:53:27It's like just a little too far away for me to actually tap it based on where I'm standing to cook.

0:53:32So like I may make some changes and then this might become a problem.

0:53:36But for like where I want this thing to be, I never have my phone that close.

0:53:41And I and I wonder if that is like a thing aga Again, it's like, oh, when it goes into the real world, it could it turns out that people they would have it much closer to them than necessarily you would think in testing or whatever.

0:53:53And and but yeah, I I do like how I like how easy it is to send things.

0:53:57Like airplay is very fast, you know like an handoff is very quick and and all of that stuff is is good.

0:54:02I was actually surprised that th there is a Safari app on on the Homeview.

0:54:08I I just figured it was gonna take everything, you know, every web page was gonna have to be a like a a a handoff request you know, but actually you can just go to the web and search for something.

0:54:18Yeah, you can. You can you can just type in URLs.

0:54:20Although it is it is actually really easy to take a web page from your phone and then just kinda hold it up to the home view and it opens it.

0:54:27Which is exactly why I thought they just wouldn't put Safari on it.

0:54:29Like I I just was like, oh you know, No, it it's um I I it's a great escape hatch, the having Safari on it.

0:54:36It really but it does, I mean, it is one of the weird things about This product, right?

0:54:41Is like if I had to boil down everything that we've said up to now, what I would say is the question is what the home view is.

0:54:50Is it another Apple platform device fully functional, like an iPad or an iPhone?

0:54:59Or is it not?

0:55:00Is it a kind of a an appliance that Apple makes, like AirPods or a or a home pod?

0:55:08And the answer right now is floor wax and dessert topping, right?

0:55:13Like it is both of those things at once.

0:55:17And I think that's uncanny about it.

0:55:20Um, it may be inevitable.

0:55:22Like it's got a touch screen.

0:55:25It can't I mean, we would be complaining about it if it was just an Apple Watch, right?

0:55:30Like we would be complaining about it if you couldn't do more with it.

0:55:33But part of the problem is that once you go down that path and you put Safari on it, it's implying like a level of sophistication for a device that maybe the device doesn't need or maybe doesn't deserve or

0:55:47hasn't been built to to fulfill.

0:55:49And I think this is why I come back to saying I underst like the like the Apple Watch in the beginning.

0:55:57I want to feel like this product has a vision that like people at Apple know exactly what they want this product to be.

0:56:04And it and like with the original Apple Watch, they don't I don't think they do.

0:56:09I think they wanted to try a bunch of different stuff.

0:56:11And I get it. Yep. And I think the van advantage of that, you roll all this stuff together and then you see what happens when you ship it.

0:56:19And we know from Mark German that like they're already building or have built another thing that sits that's b got a bigger screen and the arm moves itself around and stuff that they're gonna do next time.

0:56:30So like I think they're all in on this category.

0:56:33And that one of the things that's gonna be interesting, because software is so much more malleable than hardware, is Apple watching how people use this thing and then hopefully investing in the software and solving some of these issues because it is a tweener.

0:56:46It is neither fish nor fowl.

0:56:48It is the floor wax and the dessert topping.

0:56:50Like it is not its own thing as much as an a like I said, an amalgam of other things.

0:56:58And I think for it to be truly great, it needs to be its own thing.

0:57:01And we need to know like this is what the home view does and doesn't do.

0:57:04And right now it's like, what doesn't it do?

0:57:07What, you know, it kind of does everything except for the things it doesn't do.

0:57:10And that's I like I'm fascinated by it.

0:57:12I love that it I love that it clears the bar for like it will stay in my kitchen.

0:57:17But I also kinda love that beyond that it's just kind of weird and has a lot of potential, but it's mostly unfulfilled.

0:57:26And I don't know. It I think it's fun.

0:57:28I think it's very funny that the with between this and the iPhone duo, Apple has made two of the weirder and more interesting products it's done in the last decade.

0:57:36Yep. Which is exactly what I wanted.

0:57:39And I think it was what we were both hoping for, maybe with change.

0:57:42That yeah, I think Apple have been held back by the feeling that they have to ship fully formed ideas.

0:57:51Like it has to be absolutely one hundred percent flawless.

0:57:55We've done not only the table stakes, but we've completed them all.

0:57:59Right? Like everything's done. And I think that that has held them back from taking some bets and some risks.

0:58:05Yeah. Ship this thing and see what happens and see and and and your customers are going to help tell you how they're using it and what they want from it.

0:58:13And and I'll also say from an organizational standpoint, I mean, having a product that's shipping with software that's shipping certainly is gonna put the pressure on you as a developer inside Apple to make the product better right?

0:58:27Like it's a lot it's one thing to say, oh well, you know, we're working on the home pod software or the the home view software for 1.0 and we'll see how that goes.

0:58:35And it's another thing that it's out there and there's something wrong with it.

0:58:38And people are like really angry that it doesn't do this thing and it and you're responsible for it.

0:58:43Now, you know, somebody's gotta it's a it's a product that they're standing by.

0:58:48Somebody's gonna have to address these issues.

0:58:49That's how these products advance.

0:58:51Like and that will make the next one better too.

0:58:54Which is also good, but it will hopefully make this one a lot better.

0:58:58This episode is brought to you by Squarespace, the all-in-one website platform that is designed to help you stand out and succeed online.

0:59:06Whether you're just starting out or scaling a business Squarespace will give you everything you need to claim your domain, showcase your offerings of a professional website,

0:59:14grow your brand, and get paid all in one place.

0:59:17With Squarespace, it's incredibly easy to start an online store, whether you offer services, products, or both.

0:59:23Squarespace will give you everything you need to grow your business and get paid all in one place.

0:59:28You can create a beautifully designed website or online store that showcases your brand and engages with your customers, with easy online payments and built-in tools shipping and fulfillment,

0:59:38you can simplify your workflow and give customers a seamless shopping experience.

0:59:43You can then also connect with your customers through email campaigns.

0:59:47Squarespace has all of the tools that you need to engage your clients, promote your services, or grow your business.

0:59:52They're built right in. You can set up email automations to stay connected, nurture leads, and save time, while seamlessly integrating your offerings with a beautifully designed template that will drive bookings and sales.

1:00:03You can schedule emails that reach your audience at the perfect time and keep your business top of mind and drive long-term growth.

1:00:10Uh I've played around with these Squarespace email tools a bit and I've been very impressed.

1:00:14I'm impressed with how easy they make it to customize again, like with all of Squarespace's stuff.

1:00:18You can make it look and feel wherever you want.

1:00:20But they have all of the simple things you need and a lot of the more complex stuff as well, like the automation based stuff.

1:00:26Um it's very fully featured.

1:00:28It's very uh fairly priced.

1:00:30Like I I've I found their offering to be really, really great.

1:00:33Um, like I have with all the Squarespace's stuff.

1:00:36Go to squarespace.com slash upgrade and you can sign up for a free trial today when you're ready to launch.

1:00:41Use the offer code upgrade and you'll get ten percent of your first purchase of a website or domain.

1:00:46That is squarespace.com slash upgrade and the offer code upgrade, you'll get ten percent of your first purchase and show your support for the show.

1:00:52A thanks to Squarespace for their support of this show and all of Relay.

1:00:57So today as we're recording, which is uh Monday the sixteenth, um Apple uh gave some information, uh statements to the New York Times saying that they got they got they got a story,

1:01:09they planted a story in the New York Times This is what happened.

1:01:11Like this is good publicity for them.

1:01:13I can't I I'm impressed that they made this announcement uh in the way the way they did.

1:01:18Yeah. Yeah. But even the New York Times is is not necessarily the place that I would do this if but it's the way I wanted to do it.

1:01:25Anyway, yeah on Monday, Apple will add a video this is reading from the New York Times piece.

1:01:29On Monday, Apple will add a video podcast section to Apple TV, initially just for testing with developers.

1:01:34That means twenty seven point three beta two, which is probably out by the time this episode comes out.

1:01:39Yep. They will soon be free to all users, even if they don't pay for Apple streaming service and will appear on over one billion devices that have the Apple TV app,

1:01:47including Roku's and Smart TVs.

1:01:49Apple also plans to increase the number of video podcasts on its regular podcast app, where it introduced video nine months ago, but it has been working to bring some of the biggest shows on board.

1:02:00So, Apple is bringing Apple video video podcast Apple podcasts that have video into the Apple TV app.

1:02:10I'm presuming everywhere, but definitely definitely on other devices.

1:02:16Uh yeah, I no I think I th I think that's well, first off, the idea is that if you've got this video content, people may mu may not look for it in podcasts.

1:02:25It's the same reason that, you know, you think about video for YouTube and you think about video for Netflix.

1:02:31They're like, Well, Apple's video app is the TV app, it's not the podcast app.

1:02:35People think so if you're coming from podcasts you're like, oh, these podcasts have video now.

1:02:39But if you're want to watch something, maybe you're seeing it in the TV app.

1:02:43So that's one, I think it makes sense.

1:02:44So they'll be in both places. But two, is the TV app is the thing that Apple has put on other platforms.

1:02:50So if they want to put this feature out there, you know, I'm sure they could negotiate to get the Apple Podcasts app with video in different places,

1:02:59but the easiest thing to do is just up update the TV app that's everywhere, that's on TVs and third party streamers and all of those things.

1:03:09Just update it with access to your podcast library of the podcasts that are doing HLS video, which is what this is about.

1:03:18So this is interesting to me though, right?

1:03:20Like yes, HLS video is the thing.

1:03:21It is a video standard, it is a streaming video standard.

1:03:24It means that Apple doesn't host the video, they use a video server partner.

1:03:28You c it's an interesting way to switch between audio and video.

1:03:31It's just serving what's needed at any one time, as opposed to say Spotify, where you upload the video to them and then Spotify just use the audio from the video file that you've uploaded directly to them to serve the audio or video.

1:03:44There's slight distinctions that maybe only podcasters care about, but that's the way the technology works.

1:03:49I'm struck by this Apple plans to increase the number of video podcasts.

1:03:54Like what does that mean? They're trying to make deals, right?

1:03:57They're they're trying to go to people who've who've got that's what it is.

1:04:00It's like they've got their people kind of aggressively going, like what can we do to get you to do HLS video?

1:04:06That that that's I think that's what this is is how how do we get you to do this?

1:04:10Cause like all those workflows are putting it on YouTube or putting it on Spotify.

1:04:14HLS video, you can't just like put it on Apple.

1:04:17You've got to actually go find a place to put it and connect it up and all of those things.

1:04:22It's more complicated than that.

1:04:24Which is an issue we're having.

1:04:26Like w we want to offer video and Apple Podcasts, but the partners the partners that we use are dragging their feet on how it's to be supported and we also need a little bit of

1:04:40extra help because we have our own uh CMS at relay.

1:04:44But like we have a solution but it requires work not from us and that is proving to be complicated.

1:04:52We ha we have the videos, but to get them connected is is a problem.

1:04:56Yeah. Um so I think that that's one of their challenges here.

1:04:59But this is this is that statement of plans to increase the number like they are they've got people in their podcast team that are trying very hard to evangelize HLS video and work with providers and kind of smooth it all

1:05:13over. And we've had some tangential kind of like conversations with them that have been pretty positive, but the bottom line is that our current provider uh isn't doing this uh even though they've been announced.

1:05:24They're supposed to be, but it yeah, so I don't know what we're all doing.

1:05:27Yeah. We're gonna work something out. But and like especially now this is happening, it's giving even more of a reason.

1:05:32The thing is that I'm just a little bit I I just not sure about this strategy, if I'm being honest.

1:05:40I I'm not sure why they're choosing to do it this way, rather than just having a podcast app.

1:05:48Like why does it need to be an Apple TV?

1:05:50'Cause they don't control those other platforms and they have an app on those platforms that they presumably control to a certain degree what goes in them.

1:05:57Yeah. And so y you know, you'd have to make a new deal with Roku and a new deal with Amazon.

1:06:02Yeah, I suppose. Yeah. Right?

1:06:04Like it's 'cause it's not necessarily like a free or I mean you could do that, but like Also, like, some of these embedded TVs, I'm sure like they're never gonna update.

1:06:14So your TV app is on them.

1:06:16Is your podcast app ever gonna appear there?

1:06:19And also there's the logical part of it, which is just what is a podcast now?

1:06:23Well if you're viewing it as as I want to find video content, I I think there's a whole audience that's not coming from the direction of I want to watch a podcast.

1:06:33They're coming from I'm in the TV app.

1:06:36What video is here? And that's weird, but I think that's where we are.

1:06:40So I like I get it. Is it duplicative?

1:06:43It is, right? Is it a little weird?

1:06:45It is. But I I see functional reasons why they would do it in terms of where the TV app has been established and they can just kind of like get more video content into the TV app.

1:06:56But also, y you know, it's a little bit of meeting people where they live.

1:07:00Like if if do you think of the podcast app as the place for video content or do you think of the T V app as a place for video content?

1:07:07The customer experience to me is strange, right?

1:07:09It's like and I'm intrigued. Obviously we'll have some answers to this very soon.

1:07:12But it's like how do you how do you watch a podcast, you know, like you watch it on your phone in the TV app now?

1:07:19Like what what is happening here? And well I think you could you could choose you could choose what to do.

1:07:23But I I think the way I would think of it too is a little bit like Apple doesn't seem to be interested in making exclusive deals, right?

1:07:29Like Spotify did like like uh Netflix has done, where they've taken podcasts and sort of like said, No, now your video podcast lives on Netflix.

1:07:38Um Apple's not, I think, interested in doing that, but they do see a benefit in, and I'm sure the podcasters do too, in saying,

1:07:46you know, if you bring whatever Conan O'Brien needs a friend to Apple TV podcasts,

1:07:54we're gonna have promotion for you in the Apple TV app.

1:07:57Well uh and and right now if you go to Apple Podcasts pretty much the only shows they are promoting are shows that have video.

1:08:07Like they are they are being very concerted with this 'cause it's something that they care about.

1:08:11They know that podcasters want to be featured on those tiles at the top.

1:08:15So they're able to say, Well, we are at the moment prioritizing video.

1:08:20And like you can see that if you just go into the app.

1:08:22So like this is the strategy. I think to me though, it's just the overall the overall business strategy of video podcasts,

1:08:34I am I'm intrigued to see how this goes again.

1:08:37Like this is not the first time this has happened.

1:08:41A lot I feel like a lot of people are reacting to YouTube and then also reacting to Netflix, right?

1:08:47Yes. I am not convinced that Netflix will stomach this strategy in the long term.

1:08:53Because I agree. One, that is Netflix's entire MO.

1:08:57They have an idea that they can try like gaming was in a was one for them, right?

1:09:01We're all in on gaming and then actually we're not.

1:09:04We're gonna sling a bunch of Yeah, we're not we're not gonna pay attention to that anymore.

1:09:08I don't think that Netflix's current strategy in podcasts is the right one.

1:09:13Now I will note they made a hire recently, a guy called Steve Wilson, who used to Be just a Apple Podcast guy is now running Netflix podcasts.

1:09:22And I wonder if there will be a change in strategy there.

1:09:24Because I think at the moment Netflix's podcast strategy is uninspired.

1:09:28Like I I don't think that they're doing Right.

1:09:31I I just don't really think they're doing something that makes a lot of sense for Netflix, like why you would go to Netflix to watch this podcast.

1:09:38Right. Um and so I mean I'm intrigued to see it.

1:09:40They do anything different, but I just I don't I I'm just not convinced that P That people want that content on Netflix,

1:09:48but they do want it on YouTube.

1:09:50Like that is kind of my gut feeling.

1:09:53It's like a podcast feels more at home on YouTube than it does on Netflix.

1:09:58And I'm I I'm not convinced that people open Netflix and they're like, Oh, I'll watch a podcast.

1:10:03We know this because we know about how Apple and Netflix have gone back and forth.

1:10:06There is some degree of delusion slash arrogance slash confidence at Netflix, which is Netflix,

1:10:16like every other streamer is like, we want to be in the TV app on Apple TV because we wanna be in there, you know, mixing it up where like you don't just see that there's a new slow horses,

1:10:26you see that there's new show on Paramount Plus.

1:10:28There's this new thing on HBO Max.

1:10:30And Netflix's attitude has always been, no, we don't want other things.

1:10:36We want you to have to come to us.

1:10:38And then we control everything you see and all the content you see is ours.

1:10:44And they're they're they're slowly changing, but they're changing in the way where they're gonna start probably like bundling other services content in inside the Netflix app.

1:10:55But they the the goal is you never leave the Netflix app.

1:10:59And so I think their podcast strategy is basically an extension of that, which is right now for popular podcasts,

1:11:08you have to leave the Netflix app.

1:11:10And what if we made it so you didn't ever leave the Netflix app for that either?

1:11:14And it's just it's also very similar to the Spotify strategy, which has gone through several different iterations.

1:11:22And while Spotify has picked up a lot of market share.

1:11:27I'm not sure I would call that strategy a huge success.

1:11:31Well no, one of the ways you can see that Spotify's strategy has not been successful for them is there are some Spotify shows that are now doing video on Netflix.

1:11:38Uh-huh. So that's clearly that's two strategies that haven't worked.

1:11:42And they had a bunch of exclusives that they're never mind, never mind.

1:11:45It's not an exclusive. It's everywhere because we need a larger listenership for this.

1:11:48Yeah. So I mean they're playing their own games.

1:11:50I think that's the bottom line is like what Netflix is doing is self-serving to Netflix, it doesn't and it may not work, right?

1:11:55Because the premise is self-serving to Netflix and maybe that's not meeting the audience where they are.

1:12:00Maybe it is, maybe it isn't. Certainly like Spotify, the premise is that it gives you more time on Netflix means it's time you're not spending elsewhere.

1:12:08And if you're Netflix user, it's more time you're not it's making Netflix maybe more valuable to you without them having to make as many expensive scripted TV shows.

1:12:18Yeah maybe there's a strategy there.

1:12:20I'm unclear on that. But yes, everybody's scared I think everybody's scared of YouTube, right?

1:12:24Oh everybody's terrified of YouTube. Yeah, they're terrified of them.

1:12:28Because it's it t YouTube has no none of these problems, just doesn't have any of them.

1:12:32Like YouTube doesn't have to do anything to get the content.

1:12:36The content just appears at their door.

1:12:39Yes. Because and and I think I actually think that it the YouTube strategy for creators is the right one.

1:12:45Algorithms and not deals.

1:12:46I think that is the better system in the long run because us, right?

1:12:53We're not gonna work hard for Spotify.

1:12:55We're not gonna work at all for Netflix because they don't care.

1:13:00But we'll work at YouTube because maybe we'll break through, right?

1:13:04Mm-hmm. Because it is it feels like a level playing field because the the uh the algorithm basically just wants to give people content,

1:13:12right? That that's what it serves for.

1:13:14It's like if it can find people with the right content, it will just give it to them because that benefits YouTube.

1:13:19Where Netflix is like, well we w what we would actually like to do, we want to find the things that work for us and then we're gonna give them these people money and then we're gonna promote them on our page,

1:13:29right? We're gonna put them here, we're gonna put them there.

1:13:31It's the same for Spotify, it's the same for Netflix.

1:13:34Like that that doesn't it also it's also not healthy for the the podcast economy in general.

1:13:40Like it isn't because this is the same as when Spotify started writing huge checks.

1:13:46Now that Netflix is writing checks. Everyone is optimizing for Netflix video where before they were optimizing for Spotify, which was spend way too much money creating a scripted podcast,

1:13:57right? That because that seemed like what Spotify wanted.

1:14:00And now it's like, let's optimize for this like studio look that YouTube wants.

1:14:06And it's like but that actually is very expensive to do.

1:14:10And yeah. So I I have a lot of opinions about this because I am convinced that the Netflix approach to video podcasting is going to create another crash in the industry within twelve to eighteen months.

1:14:23Like the Spotify approach for buying exclusive rights to shows created a crash in the industry.

1:14:30Um I I uh but now we're completely off track.

1:14:34Apple's doing it in in a in a way that makes more sense to me.

1:14:37They're not deals. Sure. Right? They don't have an algorithm they don't have an algorithm like YouTube's, but it's like, look, this is an open system.

1:14:44You can just put your stuff here. It's like great.

1:14:46Like I like that as opposed to whatever it is that Netflix is doing.

1:14:49And Spotify will let you do that, but it doesn't feel the same.

1:14:51And you can bring your own audience with you.

1:14:54Yeah. And and that's I mean, we have a big audience in Apple Podcasts.

1:14:59You know, we have it in like in like Overcast, which doesn't do video, but we do an Apple Podcasts and and and it does have video, which is one of the reasons that we think that that that we would be a good fit there.

1:15:09And it is open. Uh I challenged you.

1:15:11You were like, there's a statement about the HLS being open and I was like, Show me another app that supports HLS video and then uh you said PocketCast actually.

1:15:21I actually found another two cents, but I've got to do it.

1:15:23No, no, I got I you already won.

1:15:25You already won. Um so so that's good, right?

1:15:29That means that if we do this, then if some other uh some other app wants to support it, they just they can get it.

1:15:34And I like that about it too.

1:15:36So it's it's all you know, I I I'll also say that the YouTube algorithm is pop uh is powerful.

1:15:43I mean, even for podcasts, and we saw that with Design in California, where very clearly people were watching episodes of Design in California who had no idea who we were or who John Syracusa was.

1:15:54No idea. They just were like there for the retro computer content.

1:15:58And that's the magic of that algorithm is you can reach an audience.

1:16:03Like podcast discovery has always been hard.

1:16:06So it's always been the hard thing. It's always been the problem.

1:16:09Right. And and the YouTube algorithm, guess what?

1:16:11It's good at this stuff. It is the literally the only thing that there has been since 2015 to help you find an an audience for free.

1:16:22Yeah. And I say since twenty fifteen 'Cessman Serial came along because it used to be that that iTunes was the way, right?

1:16:29That like if you if you could get enough plays on an iTunes, great.

1:16:32But since twenty fifteen there was a boom and then that doesn't really work anymore.

1:16:36Right. Um at least in my experience, but I'm sure it works differently for other people.

1:16:41Now it's like YouTube is the way I mean people are also trying to use like clips for this and clips can find you an audience in the places that clips exist.

1:16:53I'm not confident how well clips convert.

1:16:57Um Right, I like to see these guys' clips.

1:17:00I'm gonna subscribe to their channel on Instagram doesn't necessarily mean they're ever gonna be a listener to the whole podcast.

1:17:07I'm about to steal something from someone and so I'll say Neil I Patel is gonna be the next guest on Cortex and that's not gonna come out until December.

1:17:15But I'm about to steal something he says in that interview, so I'll just say it now anyway.

1:17:19Cause I asked him about this. He's very pro clipping for his shows.

1:17:22And I'm like do you think that it actually does anything?

1:17:24And he said, I do not believe that that that it creates new listeners.

1:17:28But he said, But what I think it does is it gets people ready that when they then see your face on YouTube, they'll click it.

1:17:37Because they've seen you on Instagram and TikTok hundreds of thousands of times.

1:17:41And you know, I know that guy hundreds of times so.

1:17:44And so like I was like, oh okay, that makes sense to me as like a a a reason for doing it.

1:17:49And similarly, design in California, we're finding more success with that than I have seen like on other projects before.

1:17:57Like we have some that go mildly viral.

1:18:00But like we had a um there's a a a a a clip of Bill Gates you talking about Stephen Levy's report of Bill Gates using the iPod for the th first time.

1:18:11And put that up over the weekend. It's like thirty five thousand views, all organic.

1:18:14It's like brilliant. Like that that's the thing that's now happened.

1:18:18Um I I can't say that it's done anything to the listenership of that episode, but that's not really the point of doing it.

1:18:24You're it's marketing, right? It's like putting our faces on a billboard, basically.

1:18:28It's like essentially maybe someone will come to find us.

1:18:30Uh but yes, the the Instagram algorithm I think is the best place.

1:18:36I have no idea what it's gonna be like to put Apple podcasts in Apple TV.

1:18:42Uh, and I'm and I'm very intrigued to see how that looks over time.

1:18:47Um and and kind of like if i if and how these things kind of like collaborate together, these two services or or maybe not all.

1:18:56So we'll see.

1:18:59This episode is brought to you by Fitbod.

1:19:01If you want to make changes to your personal fitness, getting started can feel really difficult.

1:19:06That's why I want to tell you about Fitbod because it is an affordable and easy way to build a fitness plan that is made for you.

1:19:12Because everybody has their own path through personal fitness.

1:19:15So Fitbod uses data to customize things to suit you perfectly.

1:19:19It is tailored to your body, experience, environment, and goals.

1:19:23Fitbod stores this information in your FitbudGym profile.

1:19:26It tracks your muscle recovery so you avoid burnout and keep up your momentum, but it's also adapting with you as you improve.

1:19:32Make sure every workout remains remains challenging.

1:19:35It pushes you to make the progress that you're looking for.

1:19:38And as it's mixing up stuff, right?

1:19:40So you're getting new uh you're getting new workouts, you're getting new sets, all this kind of stuff new rep schemes.

1:19:46As you're getting these new exercises, you can be sure that you're learning them the right way because they have over a thousand demonstration videos in the app.

1:19:52I love this because you know I see a new exercise, like I don't know how to do that one.

1:19:56And you can read some instructions, but it's like, but where does my leg go?

1:19:59And you can watch the video and it shows you exactly how to do it.

1:20:02And it gives me the confidence to then go ahead and do it.

1:20:05Fitbud tracks your muscle fatigue and recovery over time and it designs that well-balanced workout routine for you.

1:20:10Because when your muscles work together, you'll bet get the best results you don't want to overwork or underwork muscles, you'll see a a worse, a more negative impact that way.

1:20:19So they m they measure everything and balance everything.

1:20:23You can stay informed with their progress tracking charts, weekly reports and sharing cards so that you keep track of your achievements and personal bests and share them with your friends and family too.

1:20:32Fitbody integrates with your Apple Watch, your WearOS SmartWatch and other apps that you use like Strava and Apple Health.

1:20:38Personalized training of this quality can be expensive, but Fitbod is just fifteen ninety nine a month or ninety-five ninety nine a year.

1:20:45But you can get twenty-five percent off your membership by signing up today at fitbod.me slash upgrade.

1:20:50So go now and get your customized fitness plan at F I T B O D dot me slash upgrade.

1:20:56One last time, fitbud.me slash upgrade for twenty five percent of your membership.

1:21:00A thanks to Fitbud for the support of this show and all of Relay.

1:21:04Let's finish out with some ask upgrade questions.

1:21:08Tom asks Will the home view being the best in category play out the same way that the Apple TV has, or is Apple going to f uh is Apple finally going to stop leaving a ton of potential on the table because they don't need to bother in order to

1:21:22sell them. So the the the the conceit that Tommy's making is that the Apple TV is the best you can get and they've not really pushed it forward very much.

1:21:29If the home view is the best that you can get, will they just rest on their laurels or will they continue to push?

1:21:36Well I think they're gonna continue to push on the hardware.

1:21:38We've got stories about that. But I think the I think the answer embedded in this, at least in part, the way I read this is is Apple gonna be aggressive in trying to reach people?

1:21:47And like one of the ways you do that is by selling products for cheap.

1:21:52And I don't think Apple's ever gonna do that.

1:21:55I think Apple's goal here is to make a really nice product that's good, that you're gonna pay more for, not a lot more, but more than Google and Amazon.

1:22:04But um you'll get more and theoretically.

1:22:08And if you're in Apple's ecosystem, it's easy.

1:22:12And I think that's the that's the game.

1:22:13I will I will say I don't think they would be the between this and the fact that they've got a tabletop robot arm thing coming, it feels like they're more into this format than they are the Apple TV.

1:22:25Like remember, the Apple TV, the fact is streamer boxes have been shorn of most of their experience excitement because TVs have apps in them now.

1:22:35And so that market is much smaller than it used to be in many ways.

1:22:38You have to care enough to get something better than what's in your TV.

1:22:42And Apple still plays there and it is the best one.

1:22:45And And I am frustrated that it's $2.99 to get in the door, and hopefully they'll change that.

1:22:51But this market also kind of a weird niche market.

1:22:54But again, if you're selling iPhone accessories, which is essentially what the home view is, to it's a way to get more money out of people who buy iPhones and it's a way for them to get some uh advantages of being in the Apple ecosystem out in a different place in their

1:23:08home. So I I I it it the question is what does Tom think the t the potential is that they're leading on the table and and and what are they doing to bother?

1:23:18I don't know. How how much potential is there really on the table?

1:23:21It's a good question. How much effort are they gonna put into it?

1:23:24Uh but I what I don't think they're gonna do is make a a cheap home view that they can sell for ninety-nine dollars, right?

1:23:31That's not uh seem that doesn't seem to be a game they're gonna play.

1:23:34Dome says with the expansion of nanotexture to more and more Apple products.

1:23:40Do you think Apple will ever make the Apple Watch with a nanotexture display?

1:23:45I don't understand why they would and it doesn't make any sense to me.

1:23:49I think some people just don't want glare on anything.

1:23:52Okay. That's just the thing. I am not convinced with the nanotexture purists in general.

1:23:59Like I think I think people are going a bit crazy for nanotexture.

1:24:03Like they they want it on everything and I don't I'm not convinced that it actually works for everything.

1:24:08I'm not even convinced it works best on the duo at times.

1:24:11Um like bec there, you know, like I look at the the the inside display and look at the outside display and I'm like that outside display, it just looks so much better than the inside display.

1:24:20Like the quality of the image. I don't

1:24:25think I would make a choice to put nanotexture on anything myself.

1:24:28But I know that different people want different things because of different needs.

1:24:32And so maybe Dom is, I don't know, in under direct sunlight a lot and can't see their uh Apple Watch.

1:24:37No. Apple's solution to the Apple Watch is just to make that screen really bright so that you can see it in daylight.

1:24:42And that's ever going to be.

1:24:44That's my final answer. Carl says, I have been living with my with my partner for over fifteen years.

1:24:50My children each have their own Apple IDs and from Apple's perspective we're already a family.

1:24:55I'm considering adding my partner to our Apple family sharing group, but I'm hesitant.

1:24:59Whenever you podcasters talk about this, it's almost always horror stories.

1:25:05Well, podcasters love content and they love telling horror stories.

1:25:09There's no point in telling you sometimes, hey, I I every week, like my Apple family's still going great.

1:25:13Yeah. So this is a great moment. Let me give you a Carl, let me give you an Apple family update.

1:25:17My family is in my Apple family and it all works fine.

1:25:20Yeah. Well I set up an Apple family a couple of years ago.

1:25:22I actually think when Apple One you remember when Apple One came about and then they had the like family tier?

1:25:28I set that up, never looked back.

1:25:30It's fantastic. Like I th the thing is, it's like, yes, if someone has a it's a confirmation bias.

1:25:36I think it might be the phrase I'm looking for, maybe.

1:25:38Right? It's just like you th you may think that the Apple families are terrible because we only ever talk about when something goes wrong.

1:25:44It's like there it really isn't that interesting to for to talk about like my Apple family sharing group works great, but it does.

1:25:53And I think that once you set that up, the benefits only compound over time because more stuff gets added and you everybody keeps winning.

1:26:01Um I I'm a big fan of of Apple's family sharing system and and I I think it works really really well.

1:26:08And I think the integration with other parts of the operating system are great.

1:26:13Like find my gets so much better once you're in a family.

1:26:16Like because you can easily share devices with each other and you can see where things are.

1:26:20Like uh You know, they're obviously apps and subscriptions all share, which is brilliant.

1:26:25But yeah, I I I think that it is a great system and I really recommend it and I've literally never had one problem created by it.

1:26:33Agreed. In fact, we added my mom to our family at one point because she had uh she did not have enough iCloud space to back up her phone.

1:26:41And we just added her to our plan.

1:26:43So then now it's not a problem. She uses our storage space for that one backup and she doesn't use any other features of it and it doesn't matter.

1:26:50It works just fine. And I've even done a weird thing where like I have my testing device for my work on Widgetsmith.

1:26:57It's and I've added that into my family as well.

1:27:00So it it just benefits from from a bunch of subscriptions and stuff and I don't have to get a a separate um Apple plan for it.

1:27:07And yeah, no problem.

1:27:09Darren says, Do either of you think that the volume buttons and touch ID button on the iPhone duo should have been placed in opposing locations?

1:27:16So it's more similar to the original iPhones.

1:27:19So having the lock unlock button on the on the top and the volume buttons on the side.

1:27:24My opinion is that the button placement on the iPhone duo is extremely weird and I don't know how to make it better because I keep rotating it in different directions and folding it and unfolding it,

1:27:33and I don't know where the buttons are.

1:27:35Yes. So I don't have a solution.

1:27:37I hate saying this, but I don't have a solution.

1:27:40All I can tell you is buttons on the iPhone duo are kind of a problem, and I wish they were better.

1:27:48And I don't know where they are, and I can't find them.

1:27:52And I play the game where I'm like, I'm going to press the lock button now.

1:27:55I wonder where it is. I play that game with myself a lot.

1:28:00I don't think that there is a way to solve this problem if you have a problem.

1:28:03'Cause it's like you have to put them somewhere and the problem is the device keeps getting moved around in its orientation and so it I and also I see why Darren would suggest this,

1:28:14but then you're nev you're never going to have an easy unlock experience with touch ID.

1:28:20Like you can sometimes easily unlock a touch ID because you're you're a th a finger or thumb is just covering the device, like covering the button when you take it out of your pocket.

1:28:31If it's on the top, you're ne it's never gonna happen.

1:28:34Like you're n you don't naturally have your finger there, like just right on the top corner of the device.

1:28:39I hear this complaint and I understand it.

1:28:43I don't personally have an issue with the with the buttons, but I absolutely understand why people would.

1:28:51Because I do sometimes I'm sometimes holding my duo and I'm like Huh, it's upside down.

1:28:56Like I didn't know it was upside down.

1:28:58Yeah. Yeah. I kinda like uh I I kinda reach back there and I'm like, where's the camera?

1:29:02Where's the camera? To get some orientation.

1:29:04I don't whether this could be like an accessibility s setting or what, but like I almost want a really subtle indicator at the edge of the screen about where the buttons are.

1:29:13Like always. Like something a little bit more subtle but in line with like when they want you to use Apple Pay, right?

1:29:20And they they cut that little white line.

1:29:22Yeah. I I almost want a little subtle like light gray or whatever, a neutral kind of indicator showing me where the buttons are right now.

1:29:30I almost want that with the with with the duo because it's so i there's so many different orientations that phone can be in and you just lose track of buttons.

1:29:40This is why I don't camera control on the duo, is because it's another button that I can press and go, Nope, that's not the button I wanted.

1:29:46And uh I don't it it's a it's an issue.

1:29:49I don't like it. Oh uh next week's show we're recording a uh a few days early and one of the things that I wanna do on the show is kind of give a updated review on the iPhone Duo.

1:30:01Like now we've had more time with it. So if you have questions about the iPhone Duo and our experiences with it, how having had it for is it a month?

1:30:11Is it I think it's a month, right?

1:30:13It's about a month. It's a few weeks at least.

1:30:15Uh send them in. Um go to upgradefeedback.com and send in your ask upgrade questions and uh I've been saving some as well and and we're gonna talk about a bunch of stuff um on uh next episode.

1:30:27Uh final question today.

1:30:28Harvey asks if I recall correctly both of you are comic fans, so maybe you have an opinion on the recent news about James Gunn being fired from DC Studios.

1:30:37It seems to be a decision at least partially informed by the merger, uh the Skylance merger, the Paramount Warner Brothers thing, and the eighty billion dollars of debt that it's built up.

1:30:46A last resort for them could be selling DC to pay that debt.

1:30:49My proposal. What if Apple bought DC?

1:30:52They could let DC operate as its own studio and Apple TV would certainly benefit from having legacy.

1:30:58IP. I think if Apple if if DC was for sale, I think Apple would investigate it, as would Netflix,

1:31:07as would everybody else.

1:31:09My my my theory here, by the way, my my kind of like Galaxy Brain, where I think this is going, I think Disney are gonna buy DC.

1:31:17Yeah. And and I it seems unlikely that somebody's gonna be like hauling them into court saying they've monopolized superheroes.

1:31:23And because I think I think that the the only thing that I can unders can imagine is that Skydance want to get rid of D C because I don't know why you would get rid of James Gunn.

1:31:36Like it doesn't make sense. Oh, I know why. Go on.

1:31:38I know why. James Gunn contractually has to report to the owner, basically.

1:31:45So he would have to have a direct line to David Ellison and have nobody else in between.

1:31:51Yeah but what including all the new hired executives.

1:31:53Why is that that much of a problem? It's like or do I change the terms of the deal.

1:31:57Like why fire the guy because of that?

1:31:59You know? Like 'cause they don't 'cause they don't wanna they don't wanna change the he doesn't want to change the terms.

1:32:04And they don't change. I mean, I I think I think it is actually that simple that they are offloading a bunch of stuff and they probably have some opinions about his work and they're not interested in having,

1:32:15you know, him on speed dial and they're just gonna walk away.

1:32:19Um maybe I I don't know if they're gonna sell off some stuff.

1:32:22They might um I would propose what I'd love to see is maybe Apple should buy Star Trek.

1:32:27That's you would love that, wouldn't you?

1:32:30I would love that. Yeah.

1:32:31Uh but Disney buying D C would certainly be a wild idea in that the two greatest uh intellectual property uh in the in the comic book and superhero business would be together.

1:32:41I I do wonder, I don't how do courts work anymore, whether that would just be a problem because they would say, Yes, you're all that but it seems it seems so irrelevant in modern times Yes,

1:32:51I don't really think that that one's a thing. Like I understand it, but it's like it's who's harmed?

1:32:55Like who is harmed in that scenario?

1:32:57I don't Yeah. Right? Like it it doesn't really feel to me like a thing that that would happen.

1:33:03Because also it's like not even the comic book shops, because they're all done through distributors anyway, right?

1:33:08Like is it Diamond? Right?

1:33:10Diamond does the distribution for basically all the big comics, at least used to.

1:33:13And so like th this has always been an issue.

1:33:16I just feel like To me, it's like this is a thing that I think Skydance could let go of because I think D C just continues to be a problem for this entity.

1:33:28Right, like it's never worked in the way that anybody wants it to.

1:33:30It's definitely never worked, like the MCU.

1:33:33And if you're Disney, you know how you like really could could could pump this up again?

1:33:40What if you have Batman and Captain America fight?

1:33:42You know, it's just like, oh I wasn't gonna go to that movie.

1:33:47But the thing is in those days though, no one would really ever win because everybody had to save face.

1:33:51But if you own all of it, you can make decisions about all sorts of storylines.

1:33:55Yeah, okay. Well this is a fun thing. Thank you, Harvey.

1:33:58This is a fun thing on. Again, I'll just say, uh, sell Star Trek to Apple.

1:34:02That would be a thing they should do. This week on Designed in California is the first episode in our series on Steve Jobs being pushed out of Apple back in the eighties.

1:34:11Yeah. In the first episode, we set the stage of the crisis that Apple finds itself in that would lead to all of this unfolding,

1:34:21and exactly why the relationship between jobs and Apple CEO John Scully is set to be a disaster.

1:34:30This series has so much drama in it.

1:34:34It is the messiest of any of the series that we've done so far.

1:34:38It's full of big, bold, crazy characters.

1:34:44It's great. It's such a it's such a fun.

1:34:47It's such a fun story. Um so there's five episodes in that series, um, and they start uh uh this week.

1:34:54So check that out.

1:34:56If you'd like to send in your feedback or follow up for this show, go to upgradefeedback.com.

1:35:01Send us your ask upgrade questions there, especially if you have any questions on the duo.

1:35:05I want to thank our members who support us with Upgrade Plus.

1:35:08This week I want to talk about the next James Bond.

1:35:12Go to getupgradeplus.com.

1:35:14You can find this show by on YouTube.

1:35:16Where's a video mode on YouTube?

1:35:18That's where it is. If you want to see us, you can go to YouTube and find it.

1:35:21Uh I want to thank Fitbud, Scribe, and Squarespace for their support of this week's episode.

1:35:26But most of all, thank you for listening.

1:35:28Until next time, say goodbye, Jason.

1:35:30Goodbye from all boys in Virginia.