Podcast Search

The Talk Show

457: ‘A  Whoopsie Treason’, With Christina Warren

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00Christina, I I was thinking about having ya on the show and then I knew I had to have you on the show.

0:00:06You tweeted let's uh I'm scrolling.

0:00:08I'm scrolling. Oh no. Do you know which tweet I'm going to I I do, I'm gonna pull it up.

0:00:13It it it's a good one. I'm not gonna lie.

0:00:15I usually am not one to kind of all lower my own tweets.

0:00:19All lower case six days ago.

0:00:21Look, you can do a whoopsie treason and you can fuck a direct.

0:00:26You can't do both. Well, not the same scandal cycle anyway.

0:00:31I was like, boom, that's

0:00:35it took a it took it a little bit of time for to to like I didn't know if it was gonna pick up traction.

0:00:40I was like, oh man, at first it didn't really pop off and then the next day it did, and I was really glad because whoopsie treason I like I said,

0:00:48I'm not gonna I usually don't like to like tout you don't like to tout your own stuff, but when I did that I was like, Oh, I like this.

0:00:55I think this is good. Yeah whoopsie treason is a good coinage.

0:00:59We can get to this. Obviously, we are talking about Jensen Huang and Vidia.

0:01:04Now I wish I'd written it down.

0:01:06Somebody had a funny cause the other tweet you had too was about your mortal fear of pronouncing it Nvidia.

0:01:12Oh yeah, unvidia. Novidia.

0:01:14Navidia. It's funny because it this is like the world's colliding and I do not hold it me personally, John Gruber,

0:01:23I cannot possibly hold it against anybody for mispronouncing a name or word.

0:01:28That is it is my entire podcast shtick that I have a very large vocabulary, but a very small vocabulary of words I know how to pronounce.

0:01:39So I'm not holding it against them, but I don't know.

0:01:44Nvidia has been in the news.

0:01:46I've known of them for a long time.

0:01:48I'm not a gamer, but I've certainly known their graphics prompt Prowess and as somebody who follows Apple closely, it has sort of been the company that makes the better graphic cards,

0:01:59but Apple has a spat with them so they don't use their graphics cards.

0:02:03Exactly. It's always been that thing right?

0:02:05There's always been like the which is why initially with the Jensen stuff when people were like, Oh, Tim Cook should be the n I think Trump said that.

0:02:12Other people were saying that too. Oh, Tim Cook should be the next CEO.

0:02:14And I was like, Yeah, no.

0:02:16I mean the beef between the two companies is so legendary that, yeah, as Apple users, we've had to kind of pick sides and realize other than that one I think Retina MacBook Pro like 2013 that had the NVIDIA graphics,

0:02:30this hasn't been a thing that we've been able to experience.

0:02:33And it's always been a genuine trade off where, especially like in the Intel era, you could run the much better graphics cards on Windows.

0:02:42Sometimes they could get Mac drivers if NVIDIA was able to get access to them and then eventually Apple was even like, yeah, we're gonna let you sign these drivers anymore.

0:02:51So you can't run them in the latest versions of Mac OS, but you could run them if you had bootcamp.

0:02:55And so it was always this weird trade-off where it was like, okay, this this company makes These great graphics cards that we can't use for any purpose.

0:03:04Okay. So that's why it's funny to me people are like, Oh, well, Tim Cook should be CU.

0:03:09I'm like, Really? Really? The the beef started under Steve Jobs, but Tim Cook definitely kept it going, so I just looked it up too,

0:03:17'cause I what I remember was specifically there was a time where they tinkered with NVIDIA graphics cards and there was some kind of beef about a bug and the driver and whose bug it was and Yes.

0:03:31Nvidia It was a recall as I recall.

0:03:33Nvidia didn't want to fix it fast enough for Apple's liking.

0:03:37I don't know. But then apparently there was also a story where I forget I I it the details don't matter.

0:03:44But I guess it was early in the Steve Jobs return to Apple, like late nineties, not even the two thousands.

0:03:51And Jobs had a Apple and Nvidia had a meeting and Jobs accused NVIDIA of ripping off a bunch of technology that was innovated by Pixar.

0:04:03And an NVIDIA engineer said no, that it was Pixar who ripped off NVIDIA and then Jobs just pretended that guy wasn't the meeting for the rest of the meeting.

0:04:16That's such a that's such that's just that's such a great see Jobs.

0:04:19You don't even exist. You don't even exist.

0:04:22I'm not even going to acknowledge you for the rest of my time here.

0:04:24That's Steve Jobsism.

0:04:26And at the time, that would have been very, very, very early NVIDIA.

0:04:30They were just on the scene.

0:04:32And granted, Apple was beleaguered then, but was still a a better company than NVIDIA was at that point.

0:04:37Right. So in terms of size and awareness and everything else.

0:04:40So that's funny. It was all I think it was all a bunch of fragile egos at the time because nobody was very big, right?

0:04:47Nobody Pixar didn't make it as a technology company.

0:04:50Obviously they made it as a film studio.

0:04:53The whole next thing was still a bit of a you know, even with the acquisition by Apple, it was still an open question whether this was one sinking company buying another one et cetera.

0:05:04So I think it made the petty grievances all the more petty, right?

0:05:09It's forget whose line.

0:05:11I think it was Woodrow Wilson, but wire c college politics, college administration politics so awful because the stakes are so low.

0:05:21It's But anyway, that's how I know Nvidia historically.

0:05:27But even I know, even as someone who doesn't close is close You know how to say it.

0:05:31You know what's NVIDIA. Right. And yet in the last ten days uh everybody's calling it NVIDIA.

0:05:38And it's really bothers me.

0:05:41I feel like it really bothers me too.

0:05:42Even if I know how to pronounce something everybody should.

0:05:45I guess that's my take. Yeah, no, I mean and I kind of I am usually okay, I like to think, at pronouncing things, but we're all we all have our issues with it or whatever but yeah,

0:05:55this is one where I'm a little bit surprised.

0:05:58I can understand if you were just to read it for the first time, fine, right?

0:06:03Like John Mullaney on S N L.

0:06:05Yes. But like that that that I'll give a pass.

0:06:08But if you work on one of the major news networks, I am a little bit shocked, right?

0:06:12Like even if you're not doing the financial news, NVIDIA has been such a big story for the last couple of years.

0:06:18If you cover anything at news at all, I'm like, okay how do you not know how to pronounce this company's name?

0:06:23This isn't like Marissa Meyer or Marissa Mayer, which I never have had correct.

0:06:28And I will own that. I don't know what's the answer.

0:06:31I don't know either. I always forget.

0:06:33I do too. So that's what I'm saying. And and that's things but I promise you this, if that was my job to go on TV every day, I would have that down.

0:06:40And in fact when I did have to talk about her on TV, I would get it correct.

0:06:45Now I just can't remember it. But if that were my job, I know myself.

0:06:48I would learn how to say NVIDIA. So like I said, like somebody reading off of cue cards, like John Mullaney, fine.

0:06:55But when we see it like in the the rest of the press, I'm like, come on guys.

0:06:58If if we know, if if the Apple people know and we weren't even allowed to play with the good video graphics, come on.

0:07:04Yeah. So but I think your tweet, A, it's funny, but B, it honestly the reason I think it's so it resonates so hard is because A it's funny and B it's rude.

0:07:16Yes. Um I I've gotten not a lot, but I've gone to instead of the F word, I've used banged right from the start.

0:07:26And a few readers, not too many, were like, Hey, I think it's rude or uh Beneath you to be talking about this as him banging his spy or his subordinates at the company.

0:07:40And I very deliberately I worked in.

0:07:42I did not want to I was sensitive to the fact that Jensen Huang is a man and the three people who he had affairs with are women and I didn't want to insinuate wait that only a man

0:07:56bangs a woman and I in fact found a way very naturally I was gonna write about it anyway, to work in a mention of Trump and used that Stormy Daniels banged him and spanked him with a magazine with his

0:08:10face on the cover to show that it you c both genders can bang each other or can bang the same gender.

0:08:18Everybody can bang anybody. But that's I honestly feel in partly I think it's funny and I think it's a funny word and I also in all seriousness,

0:08:29think that euphemizing the sexual nature of the affairs is actually d doing a disservice to the coverage.

0:08:41And I get it that this NBC n nightly news at six thirty isn't gonna have the anchor say that he banged a tr suspected Chinese spy.

0:08:52But I feel during Daring Fireball can certainly uh go with that.

0:08:57And it puts the right context in the mind overall that this it is it's it's a dirty story.

0:09:04It is. It is. It's what a and the interesting thing is when you think about and this is why I kind of like sent the tweet that I sent about like you can ha you can have one or you can have the other,

0:09:13but you can't have both in the same scandal cycle.

0:09:15And if it was separated by enough time, sure.

0:09:18But like in the same scandal cycle you have to choose one.

0:09:20And that was honestly like at first I was like, Okay, maybe he's gonna make it through this.

0:09:24And then when the second story dropped and then the third, I was like, Oh, okay, yeah, no, this is over.

0:09:30This is uh unless you're a a company that's run in a completely different way than how his company had been run, this is just not the sort of thing that you can get through.

0:09:40But yeah, I mean I think that it's it it's interesting it's a it's a it's a dirty story, but it's also not completely unique.

0:09:47Like this when I was sending that tweet, like I said, like I had this thought.

0:09:49I was like, How many times has this happened?

0:09:51And it's a shocking number of times where the spy aspect, to be clear, is very unique.

0:09:57And that was I think like obviously like the initial reason why there was concern.

0:10:01I think that if it had just been like the subordinates uh story, I okay, I I don't know if we're having this if this is a discussion that we have on the talk show,

0:10:10right? But I think that like genuinely, like I think that like no matter what your code of conduct says, I I don't think that that's gonna necessarily get to that level.

0:10:19It's fact that it was with a spy and potentially doing some as as to to quote arrest development light treason or or or whoopsie treason,

0:10:27which is my kind of riff on that, is why this is a potentially like massive story.

0:10:33But there have been so many instances over the years of executives doing similar things just in terms of the affair stuff at tech companies,

0:10:42some of them have faced consequences, some of them have not, but it's it's like it's salacious, but this is a thing that happens.

0:10:49It's just I think is the fact that it was the two salacious things here.

0:10:53And the bigger thing obviously is whether or not that relationship in any way led to the that company getting preferred access and if they were in fact basically just funneling

0:11:06banned GPUs to the Chinese going against global trade sanctions.

0:11:11And I kind of feel like one of the weird aspects of this story when it first broke, and I have to admit I'm guilty as charged.

0:11:20I mean I don't follow the AI whole boom is not dead center of my lane,

0:11:29as it were, but it's certainly in there.

0:11:31I have to admit. I did not clock at all.

0:11:37I I d it's not like I think I forgot.

0:11:40I think a year ago it just zoomed right past the news cycle and I didn't even care catch it that the New York Times that's when the New York Times a year ago in October

0:11:54first came out with a story that Jensen Wong had a close relationship with Alice Huang of Mega Speed and that there were questions about Mega Speeds

0:12:08are they Singapore or Malaysia?

0:12:11They're Singapore. Singaporean acquisition of these chips and that the with the ultimate use being uh from i entities,

0:12:22let's say, in China, in circumvention of that you can't send the chips into China but the Chinese can use them if they're located in Singapore data centers.

0:12:32I the whole thing just missed missed it.

0:12:34And right from the get go of this one, when it first got run up the flagpole again by the New York Times again, but sort of re reiterating their own reporting from a year prior.

0:12:47When the New York Times says a close relationship, that's there's an insinuation there in New York Times Ease that if it's a man and a woman that if it could be read as if you wonder is the New York Times suggesting they're having an affair?

0:13:02If the New York Times wasn't suggesting it, they would use different language so that you didn't think they were.

0:13:08That if you if it even makes you think, is that what they're saying there?

0:13:11Is this the New York Times being the New York Times and being super buttoned up?

0:13:16That's probably what they're saying and that's what they were saying, clearly.

0:13:19But the new news this year but that that re inserted the story was the news that the State Department,

0:13:29Marco Rubio and the National Security, whoever else, they don't say whoever else, but presumably the CIA But US intelligence and the State Department both concluded that she was working with they use the word spy,

0:13:44but that somehow she's connected to the Chinese intelligence apparatus.

0:13:49And And that they had warned that the State Department it wrote this up in a memo, told Trump about it back in April or May.

0:13:58That that's why Jensen Huang curiously in hindsight oh, so that's why he wasn't on the plane for the delegation to China.

0:14:06They told Trump and apparently on the airplane, Trump was like, Ah, who gives a shit?

0:14:12And they landed Alaska to refuel and had Jensen Huang meet them.

0:14:17It was all very curious at the time that the plane goes off.

0:14:22Th he's not on the plane.

0:14:24It lands in Alaska and Jensen Huang took a private jet to Alaska to sink up.

0:14:30Right. Right. And I remember when that happened not under because at first we were like, Okay, well is he on the outs?

0:14:35What's going on? He's given so much money to the ballrooms, he's been so in pocket.

0:14:39Is this a sign that the administration has now soured on NVIDIA?

0:14:42That was kind of the narrative. And then he just showed up and it was like, Oh, okay Now he's joining the the convoy.

0:14:47Okay. But yeah, like you said, now in in hindsight it makes sense that the State Department and potentially the other departments were like, Hey, this is an issue.

0:14:56Our intelligence officers are telling us this thing.

0:14:59And then yeah, Trump just Overwrote them.

0:15:02Which okay. I mean, and again it c it kinda comes back to hey, how do you how are you a news anchor on TV and you don't know how to pronounce NVIDIA?

0:15:10They've been the they've been the biggest company by market cap in the world for for for most of the last two years, two and a half, three years.

0:15:17Exactly. And and in exactly a handful of years before that they were catching up, they were in the top five, right?

0:15:24If your company is a publicly held company and the valuation is let's say over a trillion dollars which is about I think where the top ten is you sh you should know how to pronounce the company's name.

0:15:37I mean Yeah no I agree.

0:15:39And it's your you as the CEO, if your business is related to the trip that the president's taking on a delegation uh delegation,

0:15:48you shouldn't be like, Oh yeah, we forgot about this guy midway through the flight.

0:15:53If you're right way down on the list and you're not even the CEO it's conceivable that someone would say,

0:16:01Yeah, we should have invited them.

0:16:03Let's see if we can get them to Alaska by the time we get there.

0:16:06I don't know. The whole thing was kind of suspicious.

0:16:09But for it to be the CEO the charismatic

0:16:15celebrity CEO of Nvidia, who's all in on pro Trump corporate,

0:16:23whatever you want to call it, photographed with Trump numerous times is big part of all of the various CEOs showing up for things at the White House type things.

0:16:35But unlike most of the others, just sort of all in on pro-Trump perspective, not just oh,

0:16:44because he's currently the president and just won an election, I'm going to stand in his direction of the political wind.

0:16:52It Jensen Huang was all in.

0:16:54Very curious. And yet nobody at the time connected it to the year ago story of this.

0:17:01It it just I I just think it nobody really thought That it it would be something like this.

0:17:07It really seemed to escape attention.

0:17:10Yeah, and I wonder if part of that is, and I say this to somebody who used to be a reporter, if that because there had been like I'd heard various things before about the the close relationship as you said.

0:17:22And I don't know if it was clear or I don't know if it had been reported that she worked for Chinese intelligence, but certainly it was kind of in the air that that might be a thing that was happening.

0:17:31But I I I wonder if it's one of those things where unless it has you have the concrete proof about it, if that's sort of allegation that the news media would be like,

0:17:40okay, even if we think that there's a connection here, unless we have our own very, deep reporting that would have to come from the State Department or Central Intelligence or something.

0:17:49That's the only place that they could be able to get that sort of thing from, would be to say we can draw the this conclusion together,

0:17:57right? I wonder if there are people who had an idea, but it's just is one of those allegations that especially for a company that has the highest market cap in the world that has the ear of the present,

0:18:09has all these things, you're just like, okay, this is a third rail and we can't touch this unless we actually have this, which I have to think is kind of what happened.

0:18:17And then as it became clear that there was memo that was being written by Marco Rubio and and others, and once that gets released and kind of gets into the ether,

0:18:26then maybe the other reporting pieces can come together more fully.

0:18:29And we still don't know in terms of and we probably won't because I don't think that anyone is incentivized to do a robust investigation into any of this what the nature of the relationship was in terms of was

0:18:43Nvidia, was he willingly bypassing sanctions with this company or was he potentially a rube?

0:18:50Or did nothing happen and and somehow, even though MegaSpeed was spending all these billions of dollars and and and having this big thing, none of their GPUs ever made their way to to Chinese companies who weren't supposed to have access to them.

0:19:04I think that the basic story is that I don't quite subscribe to it, but I've I'm such a fan of the movie Raiders of the Lost Ark that I don't wanna think about it too much.

0:19:14But there's whole theory that Indiana Jones actually didn't have any if you just if he ne if he never got involved, the whole thing would have played out the same way.

0:19:23They s the Nazis still would have gotten the Ark and they still would have opened it up and then the Ark would have shot the rays out and killed all the Nazis.

0:19:32I don't think that's quite true because I don't think you could argue that they wouldn't even found it.

0:19:37It was Indiana Jones who figured out that the headpiece to the Staff of Raw had two sides, blah, blah, blah.

0:19:42But it's an interesting theory.

0:19:45And I think in this case, there is the hey, what if he wasn't back banging Alice Wong,

0:19:53would this still be a scandal? And I think ultimately the real scandal is yes, that it's really about the hey,

0:20:04there was this whole big debate in the United States about what our policy should be about data center quality AI chips,

0:20:14which primarily at the leading edge means NVIDIA chips, right?

0:20:18That the That NVIDIA is why Nvidia became the b highest market cap company in the world.

0:20:24This is why in the re earnings report they just issued yesterday for the most recent quarter, their revenue was up a hundred percent from a year ago quarter.

0:20:33Yes. Right? I a year ago. And so were their profits.

0:20:35Right. Yeah. Yeah. Their profits yeah, their margins are like seventy percent.

0:20:39Their margins put apples to shame, which is really saying something.

0:20:43It just shows that it's pro a provable point that f at in this current AI data center m you ca I think it's a mania,

0:20:52a bubble uh to some extent, but whatever it even if it's not, whatever it is, Nvidia's position in it is unique and very profitable.

0:21:00But there's this debate of hey should we keep those chips out of Chinese hands?

0:21:06Because this is a national security issue.

0:21:09I'm fairly skeptical of to say the least about the hey AI has a ten percent chance of wiping humanity off the planet in the next few years.

0:21:19I don't I don't I think that's nonsense.

0:21:22But there's obviously s modern current AI technology is obviously accelerating fast and it does do extraordinary things.

0:21:32I think that's almost undeniable from a as a just a plain statement of fact.

0:21:39And therefore it certainly could be a national security issue, right?

0:21:44That and we know it's a fact that you can use AI to hack systems, disrupt systems, right?

0:21:52Cause financial havoc.

0:21:54You could disrupt the electrical grid banking, uh all sorts of stuff.

0:21:59And so it's not hard to make the case that it's a national security issue to stay ahead of China, who's our biggest geopolitical rival on the planet.

0:22:08You c and i the other case the other argument that oh well if we hold back the chips it's going to this is sort of my colleague on dithering Ben Thompson's argument that it's only gonna make China develop their own

0:22:22chips to rival Nvidia's they're going to do it eventually and then instead of the US owning the company,

0:22:30having the company that the whole world relies on for this, China's gonna flood the market with their own chips that are as good or better and that would be worse for the United States and the world at large.

0:22:44That's the argument. Both sides ca have reasonable I don't think the answer is clear.

0:22:49I don't anybody honest on either side could say they know with a hundred percent certainty that they're right.

0:22:55That's what makes it an interesting debate.

0:22:57But the side the n in the US national security circles, the China Hawk side won the argument and the bans were put in place.

0:23:06That's what happened. Ex That's what happened.

0:23:08And I think that becomes an interesting thing, like, politically within the Republican Party, right?

0:23:13Like it's funny because you've been seeing the people who were the most upset about Jensen, you know, having to step down, they're they're trying to turn this into like blaming it on Democrats as if this is something who it's like they haven't even taken office yet.

0:23:26They can't do anything about this, right?

0:23:27This isn't Congress isn't even seated yet.

0:23:29So what are you talking about, first of all?

0:23:31Second of all, it's no, like the it it was it's infighting within the Republican Party about like the to to to the two sides to your point.

0:23:39It's like, okay, are we gonna have the hawkish side or are we going to have the side that's no no no no this is really necessary for our economy for other reasons, right?

0:23:47So you know, that and which is why I I think it'll be interesting to see, especially since it seems like Trump was utterly uninterested in this,

0:23:56it'll be interesting to see if these congressional hearings go anywhere.

0:24:00And I doubt that they will because no one is honestly incentivized I think to look into this more broadly, especially now that he's stepped aside.

0:24:07It's just kind of okay, well, whatever problem there was, I guess we'll just pretend like it doesn't exist anymore.

0:24:13And but we did the thing i if if we need to show that we were serious about something.

0:24:17I don't I think the partisan angle comes to the fact that a lot of this debate happened while Biden was president and but there are numerous aspects.

0:24:26I would say the majority of the federal government ought to be mostly a part nonpartisan,

0:24:34right? National security, food inspection at the FDA, right?

0:24:40The people who are saying that the B. The beef is good to eat.

0:24:43Really, you should not be thinking of them as Democrats or Republicans, and that they should just be good people at d doing the job both bureaucratically and just the mechanics of actually doing the testing.

0:24:55And a lot of that did. It undeniably.

0:24:58Again, I don't think this is a partisan statement from me that Trump blew a lot of that upon taking office in January twenty twenty five with the whole doge thing of let's just fire people all over the place.

0:25:11I there d the best explanation that I've seen for the flight outage last week was that this is basically the result of firing four thousand people from the FAA that that maybe the initial problem might have

0:25:25still happened from the w the one router in Arkansas, but that the f amongst the four thousand people who got let go from the FAA were the people who would have quickly identified,

0:25:36Oh, this is where it's starting let's fix it and like instead of a couple of flights being delayed for an hour or two, you wound up with a whole day and four thousand flights canceled.

0:25:48And in national security, uh obviously there's a partisan angle t to certain aspects of it that elections are campaigned upon.

0:25:56But for the most part a lot of the expertise are people who stay in their positions throughout across administrations.

0:26:06No, absolutely. I mean and I again I think that's the interesting thing and you're right, yeah, there there a lot of these things did start under the Biden administration and and there's certainly partisan aspects.

0:26:14But I mean, it just becomes, I think, kind of clear now that there is and there has been infighting on on the GOP side regarding this issue and now it's kind of coming to the surface at this time and in the timing was is inopportune

0:26:28for a lot of reasons. Anthropic's about to go public, there are all these questions about the broader AI bubble.

0:26:34There's this idea I saw I saw your post today about them on the fifty yard line where you're talking about people are acting as if there's no one else who can who can do this this role and the entire economy is is incumbent

0:26:47upon Jensen staying in charge and I don't I'm not gonna make any sort of argument that is he the best person to still be leading NVIDIA.

0:26:55I'm almost positive, yes, but uh is it a tenable and realistic thing for him to be doing that right now.

0:27:02No, right? I mean, th it it's just not.

0:27:05It look it just comes down to as much as we have blown through societal norms and and corporate norms for things,

0:27:14there are still some for some companies that do exist for how much longer, I don't know.

0:27:19I was, I think, a little bit heartened in some ways just to see people say the quiet part out loud, which really comes down to if we deem you important and rich enough and important enough to enriching us,

0:27:29we don't care what you do. It doesn't matter.

0:27:32You can do anything, whether that's breaking codes of conduct or or the law or committing acts of treason.

0:27:37We don't care. And I don't subscribe to that personally, but I am at least kind of glad that people are honestly just being open about that, right?

0:27:46Can we all just have that conversation and not then act so surprised when the people get away with things?

0:27:51It's yeah, a a lot of people and not everyone, but a lot of people who are in positions of power just basically kind of take the position of, yeah, we don't care.

0:27:59If you're big enough, it doesn't matter and and I think that's actually kind of depressing, but I would rather us acknowledge that than pretend oh no no, we're we have so much propriety and we care so much about like morals and ethics.

0:28:10No, you don't we've proven time and time again over the last decade that if you are in a high enough position power and are viewed to be someone who can enrich others,

0:28:20then there are no consequences. And I think like everything there's trade offs when the trade-offs shift over time with the given moment and that any extreme position

0:28:35is pretty hard to argue for, but given the way things blow, one extreme or the other comes into vogue at a current moment.

0:28:44And we've we have as a society and culture whiplashed quite a bit over the last even less than ten years.

0:28:52But especially if we say the ten years since Trump first ran for president in twenty sixteen, it's gone back and forth quite a bit,

0:29:02right? Trump got elected, surprising the world in twenty sixteen.

0:29:06Then in twenty twenty, the whole George Floyd riots, the COVID madness, the Me Too movement,

0:29:14the word woke entering the vernacular.

0:29:18And At any given time in that era, just CEO is caught having an affair with a vice president who reports to the CEO,

0:29:29you'd get a very different reaction, right?

0:29:32That just the affair, if it happened in twenty twenty one, you're fired.

0:29:37If it absolutely happened in twenty twenty five, right after Trump took office, you're good.

0:29:43You're probably fine. Yeah. Probably, right?

0:29:46Those are two extremes that just automatically you're automatically fired because that's just uh no matter what else, there are no other circumstances,

0:29:55you're just out or nah, you it's all good, who cares, is also not good, right?

0:30:01And so there are things and that some people don't like I think don't like to hear it that it matters how good a CEO you are,

0:30:10right? If and how successful your company is and how correct hard you would be to replace and that if you're really hard to replace and really good at your job,

0:30:19there's more of a case to be made that you should be allowed to apologize and continue in the job than if you are middling and easily replaceable.

0:30:31Right. No, one thousand percent right.

0:30:32I mean I and I think that's why you have seen like when when Intel was for when their CEO was forced out, I think in twenty eighteen, there have been a number of other incidents too.

0:30:40That was deemed as I think part of it was that okay, well he wasn't seen as a particularly strong CEO, right?

0:30:47So it it makes it easier to go ahead and and make that move, even though at that time, especially because of all the Me Too stuff like that was just the only thing, even even with what was happening in that political climate,

0:30:58that was obviously what the what the response was going to be.

0:31:00Versus I think if that had happened to Intel in twenty twenty five, it's like, well, Intel has much bigger problems than who the CEO is is boinking, right?

0:31:07So but yeah, you're you're right.

0:31:09I mean I think that it those things all matter and sorry, go on.

0:31:13Well there's a time in Intel's history where the board might say, Oh, thank God he had a uh an affair, we can fire him.

0:31:19Right. Well that's what I'm saying right. They they they can use that as an excuse.

0:31:21They can go, Oh, okay, we'll use this as as our way of of trying, right?

0:31:25To get things on the right path. But yeah, no, I mean I think that you're right.

0:31:28And obviously I don't know, I look at these things and it just all seems like such unforced error, right?

0:31:34I'm just going, okay, putting the the treason stuff aside for a second, and I don't think that we should, because to me that's the the one that's actually egregious.

0:31:42I'm going but when I'm looking at the other stuff, I'm like, Okay, I know this is in your code of conduct.

0:31:48You know this is in your code of conduct.

0:31:50You don't even have to let everyone know that you are going to make a provision that says this does not apply to me.

0:31:58But just you're the CEO of the company and you're deemed the most important figure.

0:32:02You know what I mean? Just adjust the rules so that you don't run afoul of them for situations like this.

0:32:09I think the big thing too is that he lied to the board.

0:32:11And that was what was kind of coming out as it happened, is that is that he was not being upfront with the board when asked about things and he was also lying to the press.

0:32:20Now, there's nothing illegal about either of those acts, but if you are your board of directors and you are actually operating as a board of directors,

0:32:28which not all companies do that and now there are plenty of calls for board of directors to basically not act that way at all, provided the company has a high enough market cap,

0:32:36which is great.

0:32:38Then I don't know what other alternative you have when you have a history of of of deceit and there are multiple allegations and things that just candidly are going to be a distraction for your company in general,

0:32:49no matter what. This would be this is one of those scenarios where the only reason this I think is i is even in the ether of is this inconceivable is that for private companies or for companies that are run by people who don't have codes of conduct.

0:33:02I'm positive that Elon Musk does not have something like that.

0:33:05Or for companies that are structured in such a way that their boards of directors could not just oust them that it would be much harder to do.

0:33:13But NVIDIA's not that type of company and I and I think that's the important context here.

0:33:17What will happen in the future I don't know.

0:33:19But it also kind of struck me as I'm going, okay, what type of succession planning did you have at all?

0:33:25And it seems like you didn't. And I'm going, okay, well, if I'm the wealthiest company in the world, then granted the succession planning can go awry, and it doesn't guarantee that it's going to go well,

0:33:33right? Apple has I think throughout history the best succession plan CEO ever, right?

0:33:39With Tim Cook following Steve Jobs.

0:33:41But there are plenty of examples where even if you've a good plan in place, it's not necessarily indicative of whether the company will continue well or not right?

0:33:50It's just kind of a crapshoot. But it didn't seem like NVIDIA had anything.

0:33:53And I'm going, Okay, but what what if he has a massive heart attack?

0:33:57What if he's in a plane crash? What if some c something catastrophic happens?

0:34:00You don't have anything and you're the richest company in the world, that seems like a problem.

0:34:06Like where was the board on any of that?

0:34:08But that's completely, I think, all separate from the the real kind of ruse, which is this is salacious.

0:34:16I mean that that's part of why I think this has been like a a an interesting last ten days or so is that it's just like this is a salacious thing that's happening that is also having macro impacts on the broader economy.

0:34:27We're like, okay, I mean this is just Until we know anything definitively one way or another about the the spy stuff.

0:34:32I'm like well this is just I'm just kind of enjoying the scandal from the periphery.

0:34:37Yeah. And it spy is a loaded word, and I I wrote about this and I think it's pretty clear that she was not it's almost there's actually no allegation to the contrary,

0:34:47that she was not a secret agent who was trained by the Chinese to seduce him and infiltrate Nvidia's uh uh willingness to sell to a company associated with China.

0:35:01It she was a sort of hustler like and had worked in other fields like crypto and other things of whatever was hot at the moment.

0:35:11But got to know Jensen Huang and I think their affair started and the Chinese intelligence then noticed it and I think got in touch with her and like any Chinese national the Chinese government keeps

0:35:25tabs on you if you're a Chinese citizen and doing business abroad.

0:35:29Figured it out and was like it would be good if we got some of these chips.

0:35:33And it's like did he tell her secrets?

0:35:35What secrets could he tell her?

0:35:37Like the the right like the entire schematic for an H two hundred Nvidia GPU?

0:35:43No. But it's the fact that twenty plus percent of NVIDIA's sales apparently went to to to data centers that are either in you know chips that actually now are actually smuggled into

0:35:57China or just being used by Chinese entities in Malaysia through perhaps probably not a violation of the letter of the law,

0:36:05but clearly a violation of the spirit of the law.

0:36:09Right. I mean to the point that they used to report NVIDIA used to report how many how much of their I guess revenue was coming from Singapore and they stopped doing that.

0:36:17And it was it was uh approaching a very large percentage and and the the thought from some financial experts is that the reason that they stopped disclosing that was basically to kind of stop people from kind of asking questions.

0:36:30Okay, well well why is there this outsized percentage coming from Singapore and could that be used as, to your point, maybe not violating the the letter of the law but the spirit?

0:36:40And who's to say, right? And this is all stuff that if we had kind of a working government would be investigated in in proper hearings.

0:36:48I'm just not convinced that any of that is going to happen.

0:36:50And like I I really thought we could go Sunday when this was breaking, I was like, okay, if he can get out in front of this, if he can admit it, if nothing else drops,

0:36:58he's probably unless they have really, really strong conclusive proof that he was actively working with her to bypass sanctions and with this company to bypass sanctions,

0:37:09he's probably fine. It's just then when all the other stuff starts to drop too that that just becomes too much and too distracting.

0:37:16Yeah. But I think basically the real the and I think the NVIDIA board knows about this.

0:37:23And they du may not have know about proof, but the insinuation floating about is that Like what's the the official story is that it was Alibaba,

0:37:34the Chinese company, that was using these things.

0:37:37But the allegation is that maybe some of these chips were being are being were or slash are being used by the Chinese military.

0:37:45And if that again, is it true?

0:37:47Is there evidence? Is it a maybe?

0:37:49Or is it just something they're saying to drag him down?

0:37:53But if you're on the NVIDIA board, like and you're aware that's what's being investigated, there's you're not demanding his resignation and five days later with the Hey,

0:38:04bring him back. There's no way you're going to entertain that.

0:38:07It's your ass on the line. Exactly.

0:38:10Exactly. And look Everybody's gonna be looking for a fall guy in this.

0:38:13You know what I mean if the government has to find a fall guy, they are going to find people for that.

0:38:17And it's gonna be Jensen, we know that.

0:38:19I mean he's he's gonna do everything he can to not be the one who's gonna go to jail unless there's real stuff there.

0:38:25But yeah, if you're on the board and if you're any part of this other stuff, like you don't want to be tied into any of this nonsense.

0:38:29Yeah, that's a i it's it's a great point.

0:38:31And if these things really do show if there is a there there and that's what we don't know, yeah, there's there's no way that you can entertain the idea of somebody coming back.

0:38:39It's just It's completely illogical, but that doesn't stop people from like I said, just saying on to saying the quiet part out loud, which is to say we don't care.

0:38:48We're going to give up at all if we think this is going to enrich our personal positions.

0:38:52Yeah. And I think there's also this and again my understanding of it is largely I do read the New York Times and I do read World National Affairs,

0:39:00but a lot of my understanding of it does come from movies.

0:39:04Mm-hmm. But when you watch a Tom Clancy movie, there there is I I think it's actually yes, of course in the movies it's exaggerated.

0:39:15But I do think that in all great powers, I d I don't know of any country with a military to speak of where the national security security apparatus isn't extremely influential in terms

0:39:29of enacting compliance with their policies.

0:39:33Like when you work in national security and the rule is passed X happens and is enforced.

0:39:40And it's not ah geez.

0:39:42Hopefully too, like when you go out and you buy ninety percent fat free ground beef, it's not actually the eighty percent and they just put the ninety percent sticker on it.

0:39:52But it's like if that's what somebody's doing, well so what?

0:39:55But if it's national security, like the repercussions are real.

0:39:58And the idea of ah yeah, wink wink nudge, we're not supposed to sell these chips to China.

0:40:03But I think I personally, Jensen Wong Huang think it's nonsense and that this is actually a bad policy, so I'm going to do it anyway and just circumvent it in a way.

0:40:14The idea that the national security people are just going to shrug their shoulders and say, ah geez, he got us through this Malaysian loop loophole.

0:40:23No they're gonna go for the kill.

0:40:26And I think first the first step was the whole thing eight months ago where they went to Rubio and the State Department with the evidence and Rubio and the State Department obviously agreed with it too.

0:40:38And they're like, This is bad and we shouldn't be a s this A, it's wrong.

0:40:42And even if you disagree with that decision, it's like the whole country is not conscripted into the military.

0:40:49I'm not in the military. But there is a culture in the military where there is a chain of command.

0:40:55And if you disagree with the decision, you have your say or maybe you don't have a say.

0:41:00Maybe you weren't involved in the debate.

0:41:01But when you get an order, you follow the order.

0:41:04And when the national security policy is you don't sell these chips to China, that's the rule.

0:41:09And to tolerate effectively insubordination from a private company, even if it is the most successful at the moment private company in the world,

0:41:18it simply is intolerable. It has to come to an end.

0:41:21And the first way to do it was with a memo, give it to Rubio.

0:41:25Rubio tells Trump and hopefully Trump will say, ah yeah, we we can't have that.

0:41:30But when Trump's answer was who cares about that, they have to go to plan B.

0:41:34And plan B, I think clearly was bide their time, wait.

0:41:40I think again, uh I think if you're juiced into national intelligence, you kind of are juiced into politics and it wasn't too hard to predict that w from one end to another the US election this month was going to go

0:41:54the Democrats' way to some degree.

0:41:56Now it turned out to go their way pretty much maximally, right?

0:42:00It's hard to imagine how the election could have been better for the g Democrats at the state level, at the national level.

0:42:07But it at the lowest end, like if the polls had been wrong in the same d uh by the same degree but in the other direction, the House still would have flipped to the Democrats and the Senate would have been really,

0:42:18really close, like fifty one seats or something like that.

0:42:21One way or the other, Trump was going to be politically weakened after the November election.

0:42:27And so I think timing the release of this news and then t knowing that there was a sexual aspect to it, which is salacious,

0:42:36just puts it into the that's what made it national news, right?

0:42:40So it's not the important part. This isn't why from their perspective Jensen Wong had to go.

0:42:46It was oh he was so stupid to have done it this way because this makes it the front page of the new York Post.

0:42:53Exactly. Exactly.

0:42:55No, you're exact, right? The fact that we have to add the salacious part into it is what makes it then yeah everywhere versus it just being a okay,

0:43:04there was some underhanded business stuff going on.

0:43:06Now it has this extra component which yeah, just absolutely makes it uh go, I think much makes it a much bigger story than it ever would have been otherwise.

0:43:14Yeah, I think you're it's same way that what caused Richard Nixon to dis to to to resign wasn't the bungling burglary of a democratic political office in a Watergate hotel.

0:43:25But that's the story, the bungling burglary w was what made it a story and got everybody looking at the whole thing.

0:43:32And then they're like, hey, wait a minute look at all this other stuff that they're doing.

0:43:35Look at all this other stuff. Look at the cover ups. Look at it look at all these other things.

0:43:38Yes. Yeah. And so it's like, hey, him having uh extramarital affair with this woman who's just a Chinese citizen and has some relationship to the Chinese intelligence apparatus is what made it news,

0:43:52but then they're, Hey, wait a minute, how twenty percent of their sales are going to China and that's against the law.

0:43:58And not not like one of those things where there's a city in Iowa that says it's illegal to march a camel down the street.

0:44:05And it's like oh how'd that law get on the books in eighteen ninety

0:44:09exactly to your point, like this is a law that has been agreed upon By bipartisan groups across administrations to say, we consider this I mean, and you can disagree with this position,

0:44:18but but this has been the the position of of again a bipartisan position of people across administrations that say this is of national security importance and this is why we have these these things in place.

0:44:28And yeah, I mean and that that's what then makes it go, okay, well then this is obviously a problem.

0:44:34But yeah, I uh it's fascinating.

0:44:36Yeah, it really is. But and Twitter in particular has this weird culture, like it it's where the people who really honestly let's face it,

0:44:46mostly men who honestly believe nothing ethical matters.

0:44:52Right.

0:44:55And it's like uh and and you can look at things like hey, Trump's the guy who when it turned out that there's actual videotape of him saying that he grabbed women by their genitals and you can get away with it if you're famous.

0:45:09And he got elected president and it's like well that's there's a big difference there where and the difference is It's a violation of norms,

0:45:20but then ultimately it went to the American public and that's the way they fucking voted.

0:45:24And Exactly. Jensen Wong doesn't get to go before an election of men on Twitter.

0:45:31Nope. To raise their hands as to whether he should be allowed to stay.

0:45:35That's not the answer. It's actually the eight what, nine men and women on the NVIDIA board whose asses are on the line.

0:45:43That's who gets the vote. And they voted their way.

0:45:47They sure did. Yeah. He's not coming back.

0:45:50All right, let me take a break here and thank our first sponsor of the show.

0:45:54It is our good friends. They were here last year, this time of year, and they're back again uncomfortable common goods.

0:46:01Well guess why they're back? It's November and that means the holidays are coming around the corner.

0:46:07It is time to start thinking about holiday shopping.

0:46:10I'm the worst. I'm the biggest holiday shopping procrastinator this world has ever seen.

0:46:16Uncommon goods has thousands of one of a kind gifts for everyone on your list, all in one place.

0:46:22Perfect for the friend, the spouse, the family member who's got everything, the sort of people who are impossible to shop for,

0:46:30you can find something really weird and fun for them.

0:46:34If you wait till December, you'll be fighting everyone else for the same gifts.

0:46:38You can get go shopping now at uncommongoods.com slash talkshow, and you will be able to find gifts that will make people say,

0:46:47Where did you find this? I'll tell you, I said it last year, I'll say it again.

0:46:51One of my all-time favorite gifts that I got, my wife got it for me before they even sponsored the show, but she bought this for me years ago.

0:46:57They still have it. I checked before the show.

0:46:59It is an F bomb paperweight.

0:47:02Actually appropriate for this show where I dropped the F bomb.

0:47:05But it is a very heavy little paperweight.

0:47:07It looks like a bomb, like the old Mac circle with the fuse sticking out of it bomb with the letter F attached to it.

0:47:15I c I've had it on my desk where I write Daring Fireball for I don't know, years and years, but that's where we got it.

0:47:22Uncommon goods. They've got all sorts of other they have gifts that aren't profane too.

0:47:27But go check them out. They have all sorts of stuff for everyone, from moms and dads to kids to teens, book lovers,

0:47:35history buffs, or people who just love profane puns.

0:47:39Go to Don't Wait, cross off the names on your shopping list before the rush and to get fifteen percent off your next gift go to uncommon goods dot com slash

0:47:53talk show. That's uncommon goods dot com slash talk show for fifteen percent off uncommon goods.

0:48:01We are all out of the ordinary.

0:48:05All right. I have been told, is this true, Christina, that you have personal news?

0:48:10Yes, that is true. I do have personal news.

0:48:12So I just finished up my second stint at GitHub and I am now leading DevRel and GoTarket activities at a startup, at an AI startup called Macroscope.

0:48:21And so that's that yeah, Macroscope.

0:48:24So we do AI code review and and and cloud agents and stuff like that.

0:48:28And I'm excited. I'm also going to be moving to San Francisco at the beginning of of next year.

0:48:33So yeah, that's my personal news.

0:48:36Did you ever live in San Francisco before?

0:48:38I've never lived in San Francisco. This will be my first time living there.

0:48:41I lived in New York for a long time. And I've been living somewhere else.

0:48:44Yeah. I lived in New York for a long time and and I've spent time in San Francisco, but no, I've never but it's funny, it's like the NVIDIA collapse notwithstanding or or I'm missing collapse and and quotation marks.

0:48:54We we don't really know where things are, but this is for better or worse, like this is where everything is kinda happening in in tech and and it's kind of a moment and yeah.

0:49:04When you're still number three on the list of companies by market cap, you've not collapsed.

0:49:09But on the other hand when you've dropped two trillion dollars from your market cap Right.

0:49:16Well that's the thing, right? This is the hilarious thing.

0:49:18It's like you're still number three even after all that kind of turmoil.

0:49:21But yeah, it's like what does this mean? Everybody's Oh, there are bubbles or this or that.

0:49:25And like, maybe, right?

0:49:27I I'm not gonna say that that doesn't logical.

0:49:29I've also for the last five plus years, my my feelings on that is like logic doesn't apply to this current kind of age that we're and I know that personally at least when it comes to to code and developer tools and things like that,

0:49:42like AI has completely changed everything.

0:49:45It's completely disrupted the ecosystem at a really, really fundamental way.

0:49:49And so for my career and for what I'm going to be doing.

0:49:52That's going to be part of of what I'm doing and and I I really am excited about the opportunity with working at a a small place, kind of building something up.

0:50:01I think we're cool to get like a different perspective of what it's like to be at a startup in twenty twenty six,

0:50:09twenty twenty seven, which is different than it was a decade ago.

0:50:13Yeah. GitHub in some ways was sort of or it is still ground zero for the proof that AI has changed software development forever just by the massively.

0:50:25Right. The scale of Yes. Well, how many changes are being committed on a daily basis?

0:50:30And it's No, I mean massively so.

0:50:32I mean and yeah, to the point that GitHub's performance has had problems in the last year because it the the usage has gone many, many multiples up above what it was ever projected to be at,

0:50:42right? You're doing a whole year's worth of of usage in a month.

0:50:45You're doing ridiculous amounts of people are committing and pushing code in ways that the protocols weren't for, right?

0:50:52And so you can do all the planning you want in the world and and it's hard to scale that, right?

0:50:56And so I yeah, GitHub will I remains, I think, a really important place.

0:50:59And I I have nothing but fond memories of and nothing but the love and support of that team.

0:51:03This is just gonna be a good opportunity to to do new things.

0:51:06But yeah, I think you're exactly right. Like GitHub, I think more than anything else, you really see how that has just like how this It really the last year,

0:51:17I would say really we started to s we've seen changes a lot over the last five years.

0:51:20But really I would say since the the Opus four six model came out in November of of twenty twenty five and finally people went, even like people who were kind of like,

0:51:29I don't about this AI coding thing, right?

0:51:31I don't know if this is gonna be a thing that's actually gonna take off.

0:51:33I don't know how necessary this is, I don't know about agents.

0:51:37And then all of a sudden the code gets good enough, like really good, and it empowers people to do things that they wouldn't have been able to do before, or even the most grizzled engineers are going,

0:51:46actually this is pretty solid.

0:51:48It fundamentally we at GitHub saw the results almost immediately where our usage numbers just literally started orders of magnitude overnight and that has cascading effects on a lot of things and it but it's really interesting.

0:52:02Yeah. It's again, it's almost it's pros and cons to everything.

0:52:08And yes there are some cons to this, but it's undeniable that it is just a new world, right?

0:52:15And I know again, my my friend and colleague Ben Thompson is all in on building out his own little s suite of personal personal apps that he's got agents building for him.

0:52:26I see it I mean uh uh my inbox is just I I love it overall.

0:52:32Yes. Some of a lot of the apps I get press releases for on a daily basis now.

0:52:37Clearly AI coded, oftentimes clearly coming from people who've never made apps before and but a world where there's more native apps being made overall is a better world

0:52:51than one from just a a few years ago where there was so much talk of, Hey, I don't know if anybody's gonna build native apps, especially for the Mac anymore.

0:52:59And there's I and some of them are real winners.

0:53:02They are. There's there there's really cool new apps coming out on a regular basis from people who otherwise never would have made made them.

0:53:11I just wrote yesterday I think about Adam Engst over from Twitter.

0:53:15I was gonna mention I was gonna mention his app because that I I when I read about that on your site, like that sounds like such a great idea right?

0:53:21And something that I could definitely use because I've it's difficult sometimes to give some context.

0:53:27App what's it called? Uh Set Shot. Set shot.

0:53:29And it basically keeps a log of when your default settings change or when the settings change on your Mac because of an application, is that correct?

0:53:37Yeah. Well basically I uh I don't even know exactly how it does what it does.

0:53:41But z anybody who's used the Mac for a while knows the defaults command line tool.

0:53:46And that it it's kind of a little genius simp super simple when you really see how it works system that's inherited all the way from next step but where apps you don't have to you can write your preferences file however you want but if you do it

0:54:00the Mac way and it's now the iOS way is you use these APIs and you get a preferences file that goes automatically in the right place,

0:54:10like for your personal preferences in your home folder, library slash Preferences slash and then there's an identifier for you as an application.

0:54:21If I had an app, it would be net.daring the reverse comes from the Java world, the reverse domain name system.

0:54:27Net dot daring fireball my app name.

0:54:31And that way it's unique because I've got the domain name Daringfireball dot net.

0:54:37Nobody else could use it. So you have like zillions of them that are com dot apple slash or dash or period whatever.

0:54:45Set shot just goes through the whole system and logs them all and then when you do another snapshot it just shows you what's different between one and another.

0:54:56So Adam's original idea for this was to it was sort of the the sort of a conspiracy.

0:55:03I know kid the word conspiracy theory has such a negative connotation now because so many of the ones that have taken hold in recent years have been kooky.

0:55:11But But there are real conspiracies.

0:55:14They could be real. But the conspiracy theory that sometimes when there's a twenty seven point two point one update,

0:55:23Apple changes settings behind users back.

0:55:27For example, I think one that often they're accused of having changed behind users back is whether you agree to get software updates automatically or do you have to manually okay them.

0:55:41And And people think I never okayed that, but now I'm getting software updates automatically.

0:55:46I think Apple changed the setting behind my back.

0:55:49And I don't think that's true. I think what they've done is used what do you call those design styles, the Dark pattern design.

0:55:57Yeah, the dark pattern. Right.

0:55:59And that they made the button, it's like there's a big obvious button that just says okay, update automatically.

0:56:06And then there's a real small print thing that doesn't even have a button outline.

0:56:10It's text that's no, just download.

0:56:13It's like small text, doesn't look like a button.

0:56:16And that's what you need to tap to keep installing your OS updates manually instead of automatically.

0:56:22And at some point, one of these came through and you Tapped

0:56:31Right. So Adam made this app so that he could take a snapshot and then install an OS update and take another snapshot and compare the two and see if what changed.

0:56:42And it's useful for detecting changes that you make to anything, you know?

0:56:47Like you take a snapshot and a couple weeks later something's not working on your Mac the right way, open up Snap Snapshot.

0:56:55You think it's a preference setting but you don't know what it was.

0:56:58Open up set shot, take another snapshot, see what's different and see, oh yeah, it was that.

0:57:03I d I changed something in general s software update, whatever.

0:57:09But anyway, Adam is not a professional Mac developer, but he made a really cool Mac app that does this thing that scratches an itch for him personally.

0:57:19And I think it's useful to Mac nerds and a system administrators anywhere, he never would have made it before AI.

0:57:26I mean he's very clear that he used I think Claude in particular, but it doesn't really matter which one he used.

0:57:31It does matter, but yeah, e exactly.

0:57:32And I love that, right? Like I on I honestly think like that this is gonna be a thing that empowers so many people to build things that otherwise would not be built and and we shouldn't gatekeep how software gets developed,

0:57:44right? There there's been there's a whole history of that happening and then the barriers to entry being kind of barreled down and then and sometimes new gates being kind of built back up.

0:57:52But I think that this is can it be overwhelming?

0:57:55Does it mean that we might get a lot of kind of like unmaintained things that aren't gonna go the distance?

0:58:00Yeah, sure. Absolutely. Do I think that the trade-off is worth it?

0:58:04Right now, yeah, I do. I I think that the fact that someone like Adam, who is very smart and is very thoughtful and is thinking about things in a really good way and has a really good idea for an application that let's just be honest,

0:58:16this is so niche that it would be difficult for pre AI, even if you knew how to code, this would probably be like it would be a side project or be something that you'd really have to be committed to to wanna spend your your time doing this,

0:58:28right? And this is something instead like he can build and and enjoy that process himself and get use out of, but then make available open source to other people and it exists.

0:58:37And this might not be the sort of thing that otherwise you would make that decision to do and I think that's amazing.

0:58:44Yeah. It's it overall it is clearly so far a win.

0:58:48And I do I and it it's funny with Adam in particular, because Adam used to be a huge proponent of hyper card when tidbits first launched way back I I think nineteen ninety.

0:59:00I I forget what year tidbits debuted, but it was originally distributed as a hyper card stack.

0:59:06It there was no web at the time.

0:59:08Right.

0:59:14News on Usenet.

0:59:16I think that was the group Compsys Mac something.

0:59:19Or maybe Compsis Mac announce and then once a week there'd be an announcement of a new issue of tidbits and you'd download the stuff it file and you add a hyper card stack and you'd read it.

0:59:30And in some ways, ultimately it's very different technically and it is orders of several decades of orders of magnitude difference computationally.

0:59:40But ultimately it's the spirit of HyperCard where it was like, hey, you shouldn't have to be an expert in this.

0:59:45You should be able to use something like English.

0:59:50To be able to make software for yourself that you might be just for you or you might want to share with others.

0:59:56And it turns out that what peop what we really needed to get to really have that next level breakthrough was not like a programming language that is kind of English like like hyperscri Hyperscript?

1:00:08Hypertalk was the name of the line. Hyper T Hyper talk or Apple script.

1:00:12But actual just English.

1:00:14Just actually communicate with the system in the way that you communicate with people and have a back end this uh L L M system that can understand it and take action on it,

1:00:26it's awesome. It really is.

1:00:29Even as somebody who has as of yet not really done much with it personally, but n only not because I'm skeptical,

1:00:38but only because I d terrified that I've that I'll I've come out with a a twelve inch beard a month later and not I was to say Markdown might

1:00:52finally get an update. Right. Well that's possible.

1:00:54That would probably be one of the first things I w that I might use it for.

1:00:57But uh you know I've got other stuff to do is basically it.

1:01:01Including of just observing and trying all the things people are making.

1:01:05Yeah. Well, and what's so interesting again is just how much better this whole process has become and continues to become, right?

1:01:10Because I remember GitHub was really early on the AI assisted code stuff, I think GitHub Copilot was launched in twenty twenty one.

1:01:17This is a year and a half before Chat GPT.

1:01:20At the time that was more kind of code completion rather than things doing it for you.

1:01:23And then that quickly kind of moved into more agentic tasks.

1:01:27And then you saw things like Claude Code and Codecs and things like that kind of get better.

1:01:32But it like I said, when when the agent movement started and you could start having these things just autonomously kind of create their own tasks and sub subtasks and take care of things for you,

1:01:40that was really impressive. But the models maybe weren't there.

1:01:43And then when you kind of had the the kind of combination of both of those things together, it becomes really powerful.

1:01:48And then when you have you add things like computer use or if you're not doing development when on a a external server someplace letting it have access to your tools and do things for you that way.

1:01:58The power is enormous.

1:02:00The complications and the potential downfalls are enormous too, which is one of the reasons why Apple is is having to now be more granular about all disk permissions for the next version of Mac OS.

1:02:10I like I think whether approach is going to be there, but it's it's certainly gonna have some friction for people who are completely AI pilled on on their development schedule.

1:02:19But The the thing is is 'cause I've I've kind of gone both directions where I went from being kind of hesitant to how much control d do I want these things to have,

1:02:27which is typically how I treat my my personal Mac versus if I have a a a a cloud VM someplace or or a work machine or just another machine that I'm just kind of dictating I don't really care what you do on this go nuts.

1:02:40It's been interesting to kind of see, okay I see where all these things could go terribly wrong, but for the most part, they actually do things so well that it's kind of scary and you i it's kind of exciting too,

1:02:53like updating apps or building things for the first time for th the iPhone Duo, for example, and not having to necessarily deal with X code is great.

1:03:03Yeah. It's great.

1:03:05It's it's all fascinating.

1:03:07Let's circle back. Let's put a uh tack in that comment on the full disk access thing.

1:03:14And there's it 'cause of just going back to things I'm busy with other than using L L Ms to make software is reviewing products.

1:03:22Yeah, I was gonna say you've had so many products you've reviewed.

1:03:25Like And it's so many I haven't written about yet.

1:03:27It's unbelievable. And which is exciting.

1:03:29You know, I talked with Joanna Stern last episode about it.

1:03:32It's both of us agreed this is why we got into the racket.

1:03:35It's exciting, but it is busy.

1:03:38The home view is out.

1:03:40And I've got a review unit and boy, I I I guess it's just sorta not for me.

1:03:48I was gonna say I this was one where I was kinda glad I wasn't reviewer anymore for this one because I looked at this when this came out.

1:03:57I'm saying it's a bad product, although I I love Joanna's review and some of the the reviews have all I think kind of universally been like, this is not finished yet.

1:04:04The hardware might be great, but the the software still needs work.

1:04:07But even if the software worked Perfectly based on at least how Apple's vision of what this is supposed, like from their first ad, I looked at that and I went, Oh,

1:04:15okay, this is not a product for me.

1:04:17Period. And that's okay.

1:04:19Yeah. But I can see how it is for somebody else.

1:04:22And I've seen there's people argue it I there's so many products coming out, and the duo is certainly part of it.

1:04:31That it uh as much as I loved Siskel and Ebert, Ebert in particular whose opinions on movies aligned more with mine than Gene Siskel's,

1:04:42but their show was so good and their written reviews, both of them, they were such good film critics.

1:04:49But and they're best known for the whole thumbs up, thumbs down thing.

1:04:52But the show it was never like, oh, let's race through a bunch of movies and just give it a thumbs up or thumbs down.

1:04:58It was astute criticism and reasons why they gave it the thumbs up or thumbs down.

1:05:05But I think that and it made them famous.

1:05:08It was a great gimmick that that works so well on television.

1:05:12It really did. But it just it that sort of thinking Isn't it's certainly not what I do and it's not what any of the people whose reviews I enjoy reading and watching or listening to,

1:05:25depending on their medium. It's ultimately not just give it a thumbs up or thumbs down.

1:05:30It's tell me a story about it.

1:05:32Tell me who it's for. Or if you don't like is it actually a bad product?

1:05:36Sometimes it's Is it bad or is it just not for you, right?

1:05:38Because those are different things. Sometimes they're the same.

1:05:40Like I I I would argue the Vision Pro is one of those where I was like, This is a dud and I don't know who this is for.

1:05:45I can I can say that this isn't for me, but I think that this is a a developer kit that was kind of pushed as a fully realized consumer product.

1:05:52But that's a different thing than looking at something like at least for me, like the the home viewer.

1:05:56I'm like, okay, this is not for me if it has some of the core things fixed with it, it could be a great thing for a lot of people,

1:06:05even if it doesn't fit within my life cycle.

1:06:07Life lifestyle rather. I still don't know exactly what I think of it, but I guess ultimately what I think about it is compare Apple has you know and there's rumors that they might that Apple might go the other way and make a like

1:06:21a a wrist device that doesn't have a screen.

1:06:24I'm not quite sure I don't believe they'd ever put they'd make one for the wrist, to be honest, given that they sell Apple Watch.

1:06:32But they did make uh this is the company that made iPods with no screens.

1:06:37I was gonna say a after they had the success of that, I think that I would like to see them do that with the no screen and still have some of the health benefits of the Apple Watch ecosystem just because they're to me,

1:06:48they I think they could be complementary products.

1:06:49I don't know. I feel like they have enough of a lead in wearables Then like why not expand the pile a little more?

1:06:54You could make the same argument, like why are they selling iPads and touchscreen Macs and foldable phones?

1:07:00All these things kind of overlap in certain ways.

1:07:02Right. And I know Aura is a big company and a lot of people really like the Aura rings.

1:07:06I know friend of the show Craig Hockenberry has been talking about the ring being uh just to him a very interesting way to do a health tracking device for years.

1:07:16I think I think Aura existed but at the time but wasn't the big company that it is at now.

1:07:22But there it as a gen this is where I'm thinking though with Homeview, that adding a screen or taking away a screen from a product is an interesting way to do something right?

1:07:33So iPod, the original iPod, which we just had the twenty fifth anniversary fifth anniversary, right?

1:07:40And they came out with the fun web based uh So great emulator that even had the built in breakout game.

1:07:47Yes, perfect. What was the one called that didn't have the shuffle?

1:07:52The shuffle, yep. iPod Shuffle came out and they made various sizes of it.

1:07:57I really loved the one that was sort of like a clip on.

1:08:00I didn't like and ultimately they remember they came out with one that didn't even have buttons.

1:08:05It was That one was wild.

1:08:08Which in a way sort of exemplifies the best of Steve Jobs' Apple, which was that they would pursue an idea like,

1:08:16well, okay, we took away the screen and that worked.

1:08:19The first one was sort of like a pack of gum.

1:08:21It was like a pack of gum, yeah. Yep.

1:08:23And then the next one was just sort of like a lav mic.

1:08:27But it still had a play pause up down left right type thing.

1:08:31And that's the one I really liked that one.

1:08:34I really that was probably m my favorite iPod.

1:08:37Cause it really you could just you it could just dangle at the end of your your your earbuds and it wouldn't pull your earbuds out of your ear.

1:08:45The one with no buttons, it was I don't know anybody who liked that one.

1:08:50No, I think that was too far. And they would do similar things with the nano, right, where they kept changing the form factor of the nano every couple of years.

1:08:56They went from a being long and then being squat and then kind of being long again and then like the wrist and the fat nano, yeah, exactly.

1:09:03They kept changing the form factor on those things.

1:09:05But yeah, I think getting rid of all the buttons was a mistake.

1:09:07But no, the the shuffle was a fun product because it was cheap enough that you could like I used mine, frankly, as a USB thumb drive.

1:09:14Like a lot of things. Seventy bucks or sixty bucks?

1:09:17It might have been like forty nine ninety nine or fifty nine ninety nine.

1:09:20Yeah, it was it wasn't that expensive. And like it was like okay, I can basically use this as like some storage if I need to and it's also I can plug my headphones into it and use it.

1:09:28Yeah I forgot about that. The uh you could just use it as a w without it wasn't like oh, now it doesn't work to play your music.

1:09:36It's just like you could use some of the space to keep some files.

1:09:39But yeah but uh what I what I mean about that being the best of the Steve Jobs era though is that they by by putting the one out on the market without any buttons,

1:09:47it's like they proved where the border is.

1:09:51Okay, this is the this is where the border is of how many buttons it should have.

1:09:55And we proved it doesn't need a screen to be useful.

1:09:59And by putting the one out and doing the best they could to make it useful by being purely random, they figured out, okay,

1:10:07that's too much. Right? And the Apple hasn't put out a okay, that's too much product in a while.

1:10:15Ex maybe the i f the iPhone mini which I know hurts the people out there who are still clinging to their iPhone thirteen minis.

1:10:24But that it just did not prove popular enough, right?

1:10:27It's not I would say the the iPod shuffle with no buttons was just a bad product.

1:10:32The iPhone minis are were great products, but they clearly weren't popular products.

1:10:38It's great to see them try stuff like that.

1:10:40And I think effectively thinking of the home view, this is where I'm going, is thinking of it as a home pod with a screen,

1:10:48isn't that a great idea?

1:10:50'Cause it's got all the advantages of a home pod, which is a pretty good home speaker for playing music, and it has a screen that you can use for some things.

1:11:00So isn't that better? And it's I guess but for me I never I've I've had it set up in my kitchen f for I don't know,

1:11:09over a week at this point, and I never use the screen.

1:11:12All I all it is is a rotating array of photos.

1:11:15It's like the photo widget on my phone.

1:11:17And it's it's some of the sometimes some of the photos it chooses are photos I haven't seen in a while.

1:11:23For whatever reason it seems to be picking certain photos from my photo library that the photo widget that I love and have used for years on my second home screen on my phone hasn't turned up.

1:11:35And that's fun. It's fun to see old photos of my son when he was a a baby, or pictures of me and my wife Amy when we were younger,

1:11:45or just uh re even recent photos from recentish years of trips we've taken.

1:11:50It's like, Oh, I forgot uh we were there.

1:11:52Look at that neat picture. But that I don't know.

1:11:55I mean that's I I could I there's other ways that I could be reminded of photos than having a screen in my kitchen.

1:12:01Like I I don't know. It it's I find it more distracting than anything at the moment.

1:12:05And I never I really don't. I'm not trying to be a curmudgeon about it.

1:12:09But I still I it what I wrote when they k announced it and had their video.

1:12:14Why wouldn't I just use my phone?

1:12:15I just use my phone. Like I specifically in the context of this episode of this show, the other day when I thought I'm gonna uh see if Christina can do the show this week,

1:12:25I was like, I gotta look at my calendar to look at when I can do the show this week.

1:12:30I have a couple of things throughout this week that are I'm busier than usual or I'm more scheduled than usual.

1:12:36And it's like should I do it on the home view?

1:12:38And I'm like, No. Like I'll just open it on my phone.

1:12:41And I opened it by the time I even thought about it, I had Fantastical open in Weak View on my phone and I was in the kitchen.

1:12:49I just didn't get walk up and to where you didn't want to walk up and do it.

1:12:52Yeah. I mean and I th I think the thing too, and this is and it's not that it's a bad thing I think having the screen is is fine.

1:12:58It's just that how most of us have interacted with these devices for the last decade since the original Amazon Echo, even though there have been the Echo Show and whatever Facebook's one was called,

1:13:07there have been a number of of these things that have screens, but most people just interact with their voice, which is what what the original kind of home pod was.

1:13:14And I certainly don't grudge a screen existing, especially if it can be useful and you can interact with it in in useful ways.

1:13:21But I I do to your point, I think most people, unless you're doing very specific types of tasks, are going to just be better suited to having their phone be the thing that they look at and drive through.

1:13:32But that said, I do think it should be a product.

1:13:34I think Apple should just make it better, right?

1:13:36I think they should. I think I'm glad right?

1:13:39I was really worried when they dropped the original home pod.

1:13:43And remember it was it's one of the weirdest product life cycles Apple's ever had, where they stopped selling the original and people had determined there's a way to look at the boxes boxes and there's I forget what you look for on the boxes,

1:13:56but people outside Apple had f more or less figured that Apple made one but one batch of the original home pod,

1:14:04sold it till they sold out.

1:14:06The home pod two was I don't know, m the better part of a year away from shipping.

1:14:11And so they just had no home pods for like the better part of a yeah.

1:14:15And they had to make a weird announcement where they didn't say, We're coming out with a new one but it's not ready yet.

1:14:21But they didn't say we're never gonna make one again.

1:14:23I forgot. Exactly. I don't remember how they did it either, but it was weird.

1:14:27And then there was also a weird thing with updates. It was like, Oh, we're still updating HomePod OS or whatever.

1:14:32Um the OS has a future and it's like, Well, if the OS has a future, doesn't that mean are we getting new devices?

1:14:38Yeah. But no, when they got rid of the original home pod, well twice, right?

1:14:41'Cause they've killed that twice now. Yeah.

1:14:42That was worrying. I'm glad that they brought in the mini, I guess at least got an update or whatever and and it seems like this is the replacement for the big home pod.

1:14:50I mean, I'm a Sonos person.

1:14:52I did buy the original home pod and uh and I bought a Sonos at the same time and I That's that's looking like a good decision.

1:14:59Yeah, no it was. And well, I was able to get two sonoses at the time for the same price as the home pod and and I was like, Oh, this is the two of them together and in paired mode sound better than this single speaker if you have the room for it.

1:15:12I think that the support at that time for the various voice services was far better on on Sonos and you could use that with airplay and stuff too.

1:15:20And yeah, that's that that's basically where I chose.

1:15:23I was like, all right, my ecosystem is going to be Sonos based.

1:15:25I'm not gonna be a a a home pod person.

1:15:28But I am glad that they are still continuing to kind of release updates around that.

1:15:33And I'm glad that they have something in the home space, even if the home you isn't for me.

1:15:37I hope that we see more of it. I hope that they make improvements because Joanna's video was so funny and so good.

1:15:42I was like, okay, this is the stuff though that how do you ship like that, right?

1:15:46And I I know how you ship like that. I know deeply how stuff gets to market that way.

1:15:51But you just go, man, this this hardware was was sticking around for such a long time, they're waiting for a a serie AI to get good enough.

1:15:59Maybe it's close to being there, but but they've got to nail that final connective part.

1:16:05You you can't have it say, I don't have a camera when it has a camera.

1:16:08And I and I can't I can't unlock the garage door for you because of some weird, you know, permissions thing.

1:16:15I can't open it, yeah. Did you see her follow up video where she compared it to two thousand one and the opened up hot day Doors So funny.

1:16:23She was like, I can't believe I didn't think about that when I was on the show with you, 'cause she knows I'm two thousand one in particular.

1:16:29I was like, I didn't think of it either. That it was speci and it's specifically it's it can close the garage doors, but it just can't open them.

1:16:36But that's That's exactly the problem Dave Bowman had in two thousand one.

1:16:40He could Hal was happy to let him leave.

1:16:44He just wouldn't let him back in.

1:16:46Very funny. No, and uh that's also my experience over the last week.

1:16:50I mean I mean I'm trying to use it and the thing is two things are frustrating.

1:16:54Or at least two. One, Siri is just so friggin' slow on the thing.

1:16:57And I have not run into the hallucinations like Joanna did, but maybe 'cause I'm using it enough but that d thinks it doesn't have a camera when it clearly has a camera.

1:17:06But it's just slow. It is slower than Siri is on home pods.

1:17:11And I think that is sort of the hey, why there's like, hey, there's new Siri AI is rolling out to more devices and it's like,

1:17:19oh, it's Apple TVs now too, and it's oh that you think well that's good, right?

1:17:24New is always good. And it's like, uh maybe that's not good because new Siri is slow.

1:17:30And yes, it's ostensibly more capable, but it's also sometimes not good, like Joanna's video.

1:17:38And just the silly stuff that I do on Siri, it is slower on the home pod and or or on the home view.

1:17:45And for whatever reason, I don't know, I don't know if it's deliberate, I don't know, but it's not random.

1:17:52If you've got there's this whole thing Apple has done in recent years where when you say, Hey Dingus, and there's a whole bunch of Apple devices and in my house,

1:18:00there's always a whole bunch of Apple devices within audio hearing distance of the Hey Dingus command.

1:18:08They negotiate with each other and only one of them will take it most of the time.

1:18:15Sometimes, yes, two devices respond to the same command.

1:18:19But I f as somebody with a lot of devices, including uh in the this time of year, multiple phones, because I'm testing review unit phones and I have an iPad mini and a MacBook Pro a fifteen inch MacBook

1:18:33Pro up in the kitchen that I'm a review unit that I'm testing.

1:18:37And you for the most part saying, hey Dingus, only one of them will answer.

1:18:41But if one of them is the home view, it's always the home view.

1:18:44The home view is like, Well, I'm the home view, I'm the boss of Siri commands, I'm going to answer.

1:18:51But unfortunately it is seemingly the slowest.

1:18:55So it's like, I've got it, I've got it.

1:18:58And it's the slowest. And it's sort of I don't know, like you're running a restaurant and you've got a really well-meaning server, but you're really slow,

1:19:06and it's like you should not be taking the extra tables because you're slow.

1:19:11You should be deferring to these other devices and it's not.

1:19:15And so that's annoy- and I think that's it that's a problem.

1:19:18The whole device, the interface is serious.

1:19:20So when it's slow, they need to fix it.

1:19:22And then my other complaint is I am uh not in this I'm not in the Sonos universe.

1:19:29I'm in the home pod universe.

1:19:31And our living room has a pair pair of home pod twos as the audio system.

1:19:36It's I'm actually intrigued.

1:19:38I might try setting up now that the new I don't have the new Apple TV, but I might get one and try to set up two extra home pod minis before uh behind to get surround sound.

1:19:51I don't know. But I do I love having two home pods as the audio to my TV.

1:19:56They sound great. They're more than loud enough for however loud I want to watch things.

1:20:01And we have two home pod twos in our kitchen.

1:20:04A pair of home pods in our pretty big kitchen as a stereo pair.

1:20:10And when you want to play music in the kitchen, you can make it really loud and it sounds really good and the whole way that two home pods kind of sound like more than two speakers with the way that they coordinate.

1:20:23It's kind of uncanny and I like the way it sounds.

1:20:27The pain in the ass with the home view is you can't set up the home view with a home pod as a stereo pair.

1:20:35So I unplugged and there's only so many spots in the kitchen where such a thing can go.

1:20:40So I unplugged one of the home pods and plugged the home view in, but you can't say work with this home pod as your stereo pair for when you play music.

1:20:49It's it just doesn't.

1:20:51And that I get it.

1:20:52It's oh maybe it will eventually, but your Apple isn't that supposed to be the Apple story?

1:20:59Our shit works together. Well that that's the thing, right?

1:21:02Especially when you are like let's just call it spade, you are late to this market by years.

1:21:08Right? By by years. And then you come out and you're not ready to go.

1:21:12I'm very sorry. This is not a new category.

1:21:15This is not a new thing. Your hardware from based on reporting has been locked for quite some time.

1:21:20The fact that people have to do the updates because it's on such an old uh a firmware version or whatever speaks to that that yeah, that if you don't have it figured out,

1:21:29I don't know. I I'm not gonna say that they can't make fast follow improvements.

1:21:33I'm sure that they will. But again, this is not a product for me.

1:21:36So it matters to me less. But I I'm happy that they have it and I hope that they continue to iterate on it and make it better and better so that we can have other things.

1:21:43And and frankly, I hope it maybe even start to look at, okay, where can are there other things we could do with this space to could we uh bring this sort of view,

1:21:52right? This home view sort of thing to to an Apple T V or to something else.

1:21:55Where if I didn't want to have a the the screen just be this seven inch square, right?

1:22:00Would i i is that something that that's conceivable in the future?

1:22:03I don't know. Yeah.

1:22:05And I did lastly, I g I mean here's the thing for you as a Sonos user.

1:22:09Like when you if you bought a new Sonos product and you put set it up in your house, it would just work with all the other Sonos products.

1:22:16Yes. You'd somehow say I've put this in my living room.

1:22:19I would literally just add it to my to to the app, which granted the Sonos app has had issues, but they've gotten a lot better, right?

1:22:25But yeah, I would literally just connect it to my network.

1:22:28I would add it to my Sonos account on the app, and then it would just be part of the entire ecosystem.

1:22:32And then from that app I could either or from Airplay, frankly, you c you can do either.

1:22:36I would just be able to immediately send music or control how the sound works.

1:22:41I could either add it to an existing setup or create a a new room or whatever the case may be.

1:22:45But yeah, it would just immediately work with everything that's already there.

1:22:47Right. And whereas Apple is sort of going with a oh a home view is not the same thing as a home pod, and so you can't pair them together.

1:22:57And it's like well this screw you know Which makes no sense.

1:22:59It they're both speakers and they're both made by you and your company's middle name is integration.

1:23:06It's you s you f solve it.

1:23:07And Yeah, you figure it out.

1:23:09The whole I get it, right?

1:23:11That this the the backstory per Mark German, but I think it it's obvious now, was this was a product designed for Siri AI and Siri AI was eighteen months to

1:23:25twenty-four months late to market.

1:23:27And that's why it was sitting around.

1:23:30But hooking the part of it that would allow it to pair with a home pod or a home pod mini to make a stereo pair for audio,

1:23:38that's not related to Siri AI.

1:23:40Exactly. That should still be something that you should be able to just do.

1:23:43And it shouldn't be like it's weird to me that's not a thing you can do and just kinda pair them together.

1:23:47That that doesn't make sense. Yeah.

1:23:49I mean, 'cause that and that's actually been like the big thing with with Sonos, for better or worse, uh sometimes to the company's own detriment is that you can use their products for a really long time,

1:23:58even when they stop being sold or whatever, you can still use your new products with the old products in those ecosystems.

1:24:04And it just works that way. They they did eventually get rid of some of the oldest devices and th that aren't supported by I guess the S two kind of version or whatever,

1:24:13but those held on for a really, really long time.

1:24:16And you don't have to worry about that type of thing.

1:24:19And like that's the thing where I would expect Apple to be best to just say, okay yeah, we these are both airplay speakers.

1:24:25They can both be used, connected and paired together within the home app, regardless of one being a view and one being just a a a speaker,

1:24:34and we will figure out how to route things if someone comes up and taps it, then that can interrupt whatever the playback might be that was if it was it in channel with something else,

1:24:44right? That doesn't seem overly hard to me to be able to figure out and shouldn't require anything with Siri AI.

1:24:50Yeah. If anything to me it just seems like if they were waiting around for Siri AI to be able to deliver what it needed to deliver,

1:24:59in the meantime, they should have been adding awesome features.

1:25:03Yeah. Unrelated to Siri AI.

1:25:04It's like oh well,

1:25:07yeah, we don't have to ship in twenty twenty five.

1:25:09We're gonna have at least another year.

1:25:11How about we allow it to pair with home pods?

1:25:13How about we allow it to do this and that?

1:25:15How about we actually fix the home app on the f iphone so it makes sense.

1:25:20I don't know. How about we work on that other stuff?

1:25:23But they didn't do that. Another product I have been using, I did not get a review unit iPad mini, but I bought one and it's the first iPad I've bought for myself since twenty eighteen.

1:25:35Wow. Last did you get the iPad Pro twenty eighteen?

1:25:39Yep. I bought those the first eleven inch twenty eighteen iPad.

1:25:45Pro had an A twelve X chip.

1:25:48So it's so long ago that before they had A twenty and A twenty Pro chips, they had A twelve and A twelve X.

1:25:55X was what I think I don't think it's exactly the same difference, but it's how they said it's basically an A twelve with more.

1:26:02Mm-hmm. Something I don't mentioned it on the show, but one reason I've gone eight years, yeah, to the does the math in my head.

1:26:11Eight years between buying iPads is I don't use an iPad much, but one mood reason I've used an iPad less and less over time is I let this one got the update to iPad OS twenty six last year.

1:26:23And I was like, Okay, install. And I installed it and it was terrible.

1:26:28It was the the OS update that people when people say, Oh, don't install OS updates because that's they make your device slow to make you buy a new device.

1:26:39Well Well that's what happened with iPad OS twenty six on the eleven inch iPad Pro.

1:26:46Performance went i I mean bananas.

1:26:49I mean it was like there were times where it would just stop responding to touch.

1:26:54But But it wasn't crashed or frozen.

1:26:56I just needed to wait twenty, thirty seconds and then it would start scrolling again.

1:27:01Or other times I'd be reading an article and the scrolling, putting my finger to scroll the article would have like a second or two of lag,

1:27:10which d didn't happen all the way back to 2007 with the first iP iPhone.

1:27:16Remember that it would go to the checkerboard, it would show something so that even if it couldn't render the article in real time it would show a checkerboard scrolling until you let go and then it would fill it in.

1:27:26My twenty eighteen iPad went to hell with iPad OS twenty six to the and then I I f I reset it, I factory reset it and restored from backup and it helped a little but not much.

1:27:39And then I factory reset it and did not restore from my backup.

1:27:43I just set it up as a new iPad a couple months ago.

1:27:46And that actually helped uh to make it kind of usable, but it still was slow.

1:27:52And anyway, they didn't give it the t iPad OS twenty seven update.

1:27:56So I mean it's stuck on twenty six.

1:27:58And I th and I thought, uh but you know what I'm s I'm sick of this form factor anyway.

1:28:02I always like the mini and I want the mini.

1:28:05I'm gonna buy the new mini, even though it's OLED, and I bought it and I really do like it.

1:28:10But my favorite part about it was when I bought the iPad mini for myself, I thought well else let me see if I can trade in this twenty eighteen iPad Pro.

1:28:19I bet they only give me fifty bucks.

1:28:22Because it's A, it's eight years old.

1:28:24Exactly. B it runs like shit on the current iPad OS.

1:28:30But they gave me $180 for it.

1:28:32Are you serious? $180.

1:28:34Okay, because I'm not sure. And I got and I actually got the money.

1:28:37I waited to talk about it until I was like, let me wait until they actually put the money on my credit card.

1:28:42I got a hundred and eighty dollars. No, that's great to know because I have one of of those that my husband is still using because it was a great trade it in before it had listened to this podcast.

1:28:54I was gonna say, I was gonna say he would probably love an iPad mini and that would be like close to a third of what the mini would cost.

1:29:01So yeah, okay, I'm gonna look into that 'cause that's great.

1:29:03I love the iPad. I use mine more frequently, but I've upgraded I guess this is now the third time.

1:29:09I've had an 11 inch and and I I smartly, weirdly, managed to grow math myself like in May.

1:29:15I traded in my M2 iPad Pro, which was the last design of the kind of original iPad Pro thing so it still worked with my magic keyboard and Apple Pencil because I knew when they did the first redesign I was like,

1:29:29I'm gonna have to buy pencil, I'm gonna have to buy a new keyboard.

1:29:31That's so expensive. Whatever.

1:29:34Then when the M five version came out the trade in was was good enough, I went ahead and did it and I'm glad I did 'cause then they raised the price.

1:29:41So I weirdly I made a w a random justification for myself in May that wound up actually paying off 'cause I got a lot more for it and the it cost a whole lot less than it would have just a couple of months later.

1:29:53So I do use a a a a eleven inch iPad and I really like it.

1:29:58I have an iPad mini that is no longer receiving updates.

1:30:01I guess it's the the one from twenty twenty one or whatever, which is it's fine.

1:30:05I'm I'm not gonna get the new mini or at least I wasn't, but since I still have that original one from twenty eighteen, we might trade that in.

1:30:12That's yeah, that's I'm telling you, look, I cannot believe it.

1:30:15I mean I don't know, and maybe I'm idiot and there's a market out there and people are spending two or three hundred dollars on twenty eighteen iPad pros, but uh a hundred and eighty dollars to me felt like too good to be true.

1:30:26I was like, I'll believe that they put that on my credit card when they do it and they did it.

1:30:30And and I'll tell you, the thing I might have gotten it anyway I've I used to like the iPad mini and I forget why I I think it was w when my eyes got funny about ten years ago and I kinda had trouble seeing smaller,

1:30:43but now my eyes I I can read small text again.

1:30:46But would But what really got me thinking, I think I should just buy an iPad mini was my whole iPhone duo review where I did really love using it open.

1:30:56And I really loved it as a Kindle type and stuff.

1:30:59Yeah. I used to love reading on the iPad mini.

1:31:02This is forget about putting it in a keyboard.

1:31:05And I I know people like doing that.

1:31:07You have the I I've used my magic keyboard that I gave away to somebody else because they didn't trade it in was very well used for the iPad Pro that I had for eight years.

1:31:19But what I wanted from my iPhone duo time was I like using this thing that is roughly the size and bizarrely exactly the same weight.

1:31:30They're it's two hundred fifty five grams versus two fifty four for the new iPad mini versus the iPhone Duo.

1:31:38They're uh a bit more different in size than than you would think.

1:31:42The the iPad mini is actually quite a bit bigger, taller than an open iPhone Duo, but they're the exact same weight.

1:31:52And it is basically the same experience for reading and I just to me personally,

1:32:00having a regular iPhone eighteen pro that is my iPhone and an iPad mini that I lay around.

1:32:08That's like the perfect combo for you. That's the perfect combo.

1:32:11And the button is in y yes, it sucks.

1:32:14And the button is the space ID. But the button's in the right place.

1:32:18Yeah. I'm never turning it upside down.

1:32:21Exactly. So 'cause I honestly ever since reading your review, because I took took I didn't get my iPad do my iPhone duo until October thirtieth and so I had to I had to wait a week for for mine to come in and your review really kind of resonated with me and I was like,

1:32:34oh is this gonna be a scenario where I should probably just you know either keep my iPhone 17 or buy the eighteen and buy a mini, right?

1:32:42Because I'm not getting rid of my iPhone 17 Pro Max.

1:32:45I'm keeping that. And so I was like, should I just buy an i uh an iPad mini and and use that?

1:32:50I think that I'm gonna stick with the duo and just because I I do enjoy the novelty of it, but I completely agree with you with just like can in the abstract that I think that for most people it's probably a better decision.

1:33:04It it's a lot more logical to just buy an iPad mini and an iPhone and use whatever device fits whatever purpose you you have,

1:33:13right? Because the the trade-offs are still substantial, I think, for a lot of people, especially if you don't have multiple phones.

1:33:21I unfortunately have multiple phones, so I'm you know what?

1:33:24I'm I am enjoying the duo.

1:33:26But the mini has definitely would it like if I was a more logical person I would just have bought the mini.

1:33:33Yeah. And kept my iPhone. It's and it really did reiterate like I walked away.

1:33:38I remember thinking as I finished the iPhone duo review and I was like, I really stand behind this I was like, I really, really, really dislike using it closed.

1:33:47I really loathe the miserable fat little thing as I called it and still think.

1:33:52And I really love having this open, like sitting on the couch at night.

1:33:56This is really a great size and shape.

1:33:59And now that I've owned an iPad the new iPad mini for I don't know a week or so, I was right.

1:34:05I do love it, but I don't need it to fold and go in my pocket.

1:34:08But I understand why other people do, right?

1:34:10I it is the duo is super fun.

1:34:13Now that leads us to the twenty seven point three updates that came out this week, including for the duo,

1:34:22the rather surprising uh uh edition of unlock with the camera, which I think clearly Apple was not planning on doing,

1:34:33but also just as clearly is not something they ginned up with a gentic coding and

1:34:41it's not a good thing. No. They had a way to do this. And I think that was obvious from like the the home view, right?

1:34:45That like they could use these cameras maybe not like as a an authenticated way, right?

1:34:49They have to be very clear, like this is not face ID, but that they could do the recognition enough with just the cameras that are on it to be able to work with for things like unlocking your phone,

1:35:00right? And as long as you let people know, hey, this could potentially let someone who's not you into your device and then they still require the secure enclave for passwords and for payments and other stuff.

1:35:12Hey, I I think that this is I don't I haven't installed the beta yet.

1:35:16I'm I'm probably gonna wait another week, but I I'm excited about them bringing that out.

1:35:21Because I think that it's needed.

1:35:24They still let you set a four digit passcode if you want.

1:35:28Yes. You can set your passcode to one, two, three, four.

1:35:31And I think if you set it to one, two, three, four, it'll additionally warn you that even by the standards of a four digit numeric code,

1:35:39one two three four is a bad one, but it'll let you do it.

1:35:43What was Kanye's zero zero zero zero?

1:35:46Zero zero. Yeah. I think it was just four zeros.

1:35:48Yeah I think right. Yeah. He did it on camera in the Oval Office eight years ago or whatever.

1:35:55They'll let you do that.

1:35:57It and I think they should.

1:35:59I think they should with the appropriate warnings, they should let you use it with the sufficient level of security that feels right for you,

1:36:07even if it's a little risky.

1:36:09I think that the unlock with the face front camera on the duo is certainly better than a one, two, three passcode, right?

1:36:16'Cause the passcode is The key to everything, right?

1:36:20You could do anything on the device if you know the passcode.

1:36:22Right. And again, I know that they've mitigated that in good ways that have turned out to not be annoying and add security with the stolen device protection where certain things like if you change your iCloud password,

1:36:36you have to be on your home network or you have to wait twenty four hours or whatever so that there's time for a stolen device to be reported before it can be changed.

1:36:45Apple's managed all this very well.

1:36:47And yes, the unlock with the camera, it is nowhere near as secure as face I proper face ID.

1:36:53But I think it's great that they've added that to the duo.

1:36:56And now that I'm testing it again with it, it is uh you have it on your duo?

1:37:01It's it is I don't have it yet.

1:37:02I'm probably gonna wait until it comes if it's your main phone, I wouldn't think I was gonna say it's my main phone, so I'm gonna wait.

1:37:08If it was just my secondary, I would already be there.

1:37:10But I can't wait to come out because I do wear an Apple Watch, but A, that doesn't always work for everything.

1:37:16B I don't sleep in an Apple Watch.

1:37:17And so at night You have to charge it sometime.

1:37:20Exactly. I also I have the Aramez Apple Watch and I got like the fancy Grand H stainless steel band.

1:37:26And I love that, but like you don't want that scratched.

1:37:29So I don't sleep in that.

1:37:31And and even if I wasn't worried about scratching, it would be heavy.

1:37:34And so and I don't want to wear a second Apple Watch at night just so I can unlock my phone in bed.

1:37:39Like that's dumb. I'd much rather i if this is the case, 'cause the that's the scenario.

1:37:44It's okay, if I still need to use it for passwords or for other things, fine, right?

1:37:47I'll I'll figure it out. But more frequently it's one of those I'm just so tired of having to type in my passcode all the time.

1:37:52And then to your point, I actually do feel like this is more secure like as somebody can just be staring over my shoulder and just watch me enter in my passcode a dozen times as I'm kind of manipulating my phone at the airport or something.

1:38:04You know what I mean if I'm just getting into it to to unlock itself because for whatever reason touch ID isn't uh working fast enough or or my watch isn't fast enough.

1:38:13Okay, this is better than that. And I think that it it'll go a long way towards because that has been people have been asking me since I got the phone, what do you think about it?

1:38:21And my question for everyone has been, is this going to be your only phone?

1:38:25And if the answer is yes, then my answer tends to be for most people, wait for Gen 2.

1:38:31I think you'll be happier. But if you are going to have a second phone that you will still have around, either using iPhone handoff or just whatever your circumstances are.

1:38:38And if this isn't gonna be the sort of thing that's gonna be blowing your budget, I think that first I think that it can be really fun.

1:38:45But when people have asked what are your problems with it, yeah, the lack of face ID, which I was not expecting to be a problem.

1:38:51I was like, oh, people are blowing that out of the proportion.

1:38:53And then you realize just how often it comes up if you don't have a watch on.

1:38:58And sometimes even for me, if the watch if the connection isn't completely set and my watch somehow has become locked, then I've got to unlock my watch to make sure that it's communicating correctly.

1:39:07And yeah, anything to reduce that friction, I think, is great.

1:39:11And I'm glad that they that they did this.

1:39:13I think that it this is clearly something they have the ability to do and I'm glad that they I I don't think this was vibe coded or anything, but I think they probably did take directionally from just hearing the response from the users and going,

1:39:24Yeah, we have a way we can do this.

1:39:26We have a way we can make it.

1:39:28It's secure enough. Exactly.

1:39:30It's secure enough and we can make it clear to people what it's good for and what it's, right?

1:39:34And the fact that they're still going to be, like I said, locking off things that the secure enclave needs, that I think is the perfect compromise.

1:39:41I frankly at this point I wish that they would bring that to to the Mac, at least the new ones, right?

1:39:47Like Well, and why how about the iPads, right?

1:39:50Yes. Why d that's my big question.

1:39:54And it I say this as someone who just bought an iPad mini that if I could have spent Uhunno how many more hundred it would have cost to get an iPad mini pro that CAD with face ID.

1:40:04I would have I would have spent it because it my my single complaint about the new iPad mini is that I I still don't like using touch ID instead of face ID.

1:40:13And I'm still surprised on a daily basis.

1:40:16Even after having spent time reviewing the duo and making the lack of face ID a big part of my review and thinking about it.

1:40:24And even with the iPad mini having the button in a place where I know it is and it's a bunch better positioned for the button, I'm still annoyed with it.

1:40:32And now I'm thinking, well give me this face unlock on the iPad mini, right?

1:40:38Right. And why how about the Apple Watch unlock on on the iPads with Touch ID.

1:40:43There's a bit of to me marketing spite involved here where I think the answer of why those unlock with Apple Watch and unlock with the front camera if it does I mean that this just it's still

1:40:57in beta for i for the duo.

1:40:59Right. So g let's give them the benefit of the doubt.

1:41:03But presuming it doesn't come, then I think it's upsell to the iPad pros.

1:41:08No, I would agree. I I and I hate that, right?

1:41:10Because I'm like, okay, I understand doing that and even if you don't want to bring it to the iPad Air or the base iPad, I mean, I think that segmentation is dumb.

1:41:18But at the very least, yeah, this is your latest this is a seven hundred dollar iPad um that has an OLED screen.

1:41:25You're already capping the frame rates on it as as people have found.

1:41:29Just support, just let people do it.

1:41:31I I feel like the reasons that people get an iPad Pro should be beyond just, well this one has face ID.

1:41:38And a hundred twenty hertz display. Oh I it's I'm curious to see if Apple if anybody can get Apple to comment on it.

1:41:44But it to me is my frustration.

1:41:47And then that parlays into the the hey, this is secure enough Um sort of thinking with 27.3 to circle back to what you mentioned earlier with the full disk access and more

1:42:01or less accessibility control changes for Mac OS 27.3 in response clearly to the whole Hey,

1:42:10I gave my MetaMuse agent permission or I clicked okay to something and now all of a sudden it's reading my eye messages.

1:42:19It's like well yes. I like the changes they've made.

1:42:23I've I've installed it on a couple of on my MacBook Pro review unit, the fifteen with the f uh the new chip and the touch screen.

1:42:31I still have my MacBook Neo review unit and I put it on that so I could compare the difference.

1:42:36My only complaint with it, I haven't written about it yet on Daring Firewall.

1:42:40Maybe I will by the time this episode comes out.

1:42:42My only complaint with the new setup in twenty seven three beta two is when a an app with accessibility control is controlling another app,

1:42:53you get a thing in the menu bar and there's no way to turn it off.

1:42:57And apparently there's a hidden defaults command, a command line thing that you can use, but who knows if that's going to be supported.

1:43:03I think they need to rethink this.

1:43:05And in particular, on the new MacBook Pros with the Dynamic Island, they put it in the Dynamic Island.

1:43:13And so if you use any utilities, like I use one called Scroll Scroll reverser.

1:43:17It's a really cool utility here.

1:43:19I'll make a note. I use that is that the one that lets your mouse like your trackpad be one thing and your mouse be the other?

1:43:24I use that one too. Yeah. It's this great utility because I want to when I scroll with a trackpad, I want it to scroll the new way.

1:43:31Correct.

1:43:33Natural. But when I use a mouse with a wheel, I wanna scroll the old fashioned way.

1:43:39I have the exact same issue, yes.

1:43:41Scroll reversor is a long standing utility.

1:43:44I think it's free. I don't know if it is or not, but if it is I was gonna say I've been using it for a really long time, it's great.

1:43:49Right. And if you have it installed, it's all in twenty seven three, it's constantly got the the thing in the menu bar.

1:43:57And in on the MacBook Pro Pro in particular, it's in the dynamic islands.

1:44:01So it looks like you've got a live activity all the time, 247.

1:44:06I think that they that's the first beta.

1:44:08I think they gotta just backtrack away from that.

1:44:10Otherwise though, the actual scare

1:44:17Right. I I think there's a clarity to them that is good and appropriate.

1:44:23And I do think I had to go through I did a fresh install of a couple of utilities like keyboard micero that needs those permissions.

1:44:32I read through everything and I'm like, yeah, I this is what I'm agreeing to and I understand that I'm I trust this software with these things.

1:44:39Yes. And I do think it's the sort of thing that will give typical users pause for certain utilities because it shows you it's gonna have access to all of your photos and it shows you thumbnails of some of your photos.

1:44:53And it's Oh, I didn't know that this screenshot utility is gonna be able to read all my photos.

1:44:58Does it need that? I don't know. I think it's a good change.

1:45:02And I don't and it's it does not taking away any capabilities.

1:45:07Well that's the most important thing. Right.

1:45:18I think Apple has to do a little bit of CYA here too, because I'm sure they've probably been inundated with a lot of support requests for again, people who are have been fallen victim to to dark patterns,

1:45:28as you were mentioning before, allowing stuff to go wild on their systems and and not taking responsibility on that.

1:45:33And so you have to balance those two things.

1:45:36I I my hope is and maybe this will be a thing that that Adam Yinks' app will help us show is that they've done this before where you will give apps permission and then every update you have to do it again.

1:45:47I I that I will be driven crazy by, right?

1:45:51If I have to every single time I do like a a a Mac OS update, I have to re-enable the permissions for the apps that I've already access to,

1:45:59then I will be very annoyed. But No, you don't have to.

1:46:02If you just upgrade, it carries over.

1:46:04So if you've already granted like three different types of Sensitive permissions to a certain app, and all you do is upgrade to 27.3,

1:46:13those carry over. So it's good news for existing systems.

1:46:17Minimally invasive, except for this indicator icon, which I can't help but believe they will redesign

1:46:26it comes out. Yeah. All right.

1:46:28I'm gonna take a break. Thank our second and final sponsor of this episode, our good friends, at Work OS.

1:46:34Work OS, let agents sign up for your app without a browser.

1:46:40Look, an agent can't click through a sign up page built for humans a lot of the times.

1:46:46So give it something it can read instead.

1:46:51Publish an auth.md file.

1:46:55It's a markdown formatted file in a format that Work OS has published.

1:46:59It's an open standard that they've made.

1:47:02Here I am getting paid to promote the use of Markdown, an auth MD file.

1:47:07And agents can use that file to see how to learn how to register themselves as a new user without ever touching a a browser login.

1:47:18And the user never gets pulled out of what they were doing because they need to click through to answer the CAPTCHA or whatever kind of thing is in place on the web page to prevent non-humans from clicking through.

1:47:32If you want to allow agents to sign up for new accounts on your system, use auth MD and you can do it.

1:47:39With Work OS's authmd, you can enroll in the dashboard and auth kit, that's what their API is called,

1:47:46publishes the file. Agents read it, they register for your system, and they get scoped, short lived credentials that you control.

1:47:56Make your app agent ready today.

1:47:59Go to workos.com slash auth dash md.

1:48:05That's workos.com slash auth dash md.

1:48:10My thanks to work os for sponsoring the talk show.

1:48:13All right. Now this is the talk show, so we have to talk about James Bond movie news.

1:48:19We have to. This is amazing. And honestly, I was very pleased to see this news.

1:48:25I I give it a uh two thumbs up.

1:48:28Me too. Me too. Yeah. Like there were a lot of people who were un unsure about R.

1:48:32Pats being James Bond, but no.

1:48:34I some of us have been R Pats.

1:48:36That's his name, Rob Robert Pattinson, but he's known as R.

1:48:38Pats. And some of us have been fans of Penn like we've been Team Edward all along.

1:48:42And so he's slowly, like over the last nearly two decades, kind of gone from like this teen hearthrop who kind of rejected wanting to be the big fame thing to kind of doing it on his own terms.

1:48:53He's he m he's very, very good, but he's chosen weird projects and good artistic projects.

1:48:59He was in the Odyssey and in primetime this year and both of them are great.

1:49:02I think th the the Batman is the only good thing that D C has done in in years.

1:49:07It really is. Genuinely right?

1:49:09And that had nothing to do with with James Gunn.

1:49:10That was just Matt Reeves happens to be a a a good uh actually the Batman and I'll also say the spin off of sorts, uh uh Penguin on on on HBO,

1:49:19Max, that's also an excellent series.

1:49:21But no, I mean I like that a lot too.

1:49:23Yeah, yeah. So those have been only good parts of like the the the DC universe in probably a decade.

1:49:28But no, I mean I think that he's a great actor and he does have charisma.

1:49:32He's weirdo, which I like.

1:49:34I like that they like picked an actor who's a weirdo as James Bond.

1:49:38He's got the British thing going. I don't know.

1:49:40I'm I'm into it. I think it'll especially go well with the the director who is Denny Villanov or however you say his name.

1:49:46I don't know how to pronounce his name.

1:49:48I was hoping you would say it first. Yeah, so I probably butchered it, sorry to to the Quebecans in our audience.

1:49:54But I'm excited. I like I think that this is potentially a really good direction and like Daniel Craig was an excellent James Bond, but I think that this is a good pick.

1:50:04Yeah, and the knock against the pick, what's the guy's name from Slow Horses?

1:50:10People wanted Jack Louden.

1:50:12The problem with Jack Louden, and I love slow horses and I like Jack Louden and Slow Horses, and if they had picked him, I'd be like, ah, I'd give it one thumbs up.

1:50:21I'd be like, okay. But I don't think it was gonna happen because he's too much like a younger Daniel Craig.

1:50:28Yeah. Right.

1:50:37People were so mad that he's blonde. How dare you have a blonde James Bond because he didn't look anything like like Pierce Brosnan.

1:50:42Right. And it's like Who gives a shit?

1:50:45You know what I mean? It's I mean there's a limit, right?

1:50:48I w was not of or still am not of the opinion that you could cast a woman as James Bond.

1:50:55You can make a movie in the James Bond universe about a woman's secret agent.

1:50:59Right. James Bond is a man.

1:51:01Right. But like the the Idris Ilba thing, could James Bond be black?

1:51:06Well, yes, I definitely think so.

1:51:07Right. And the problem with Idris Ilba is simply that he's like fifty I was gonna say the problem is that we would have needed to do that a decade ago.

1:51:14And when it was first rumored to be happening, which would have been great, I think many of us would have been on board, right?

1:51:19Most people would have been on board. The only people who wouldn't have been on board were people who are are racist, let's just be honest.

1:51:25Because he's a great actor and would have been a great James Bond.

1:51:28But yeah, now I think he's aged out of that, right?

1:51:30Because the whole point and I think even at the time there was an argument to be made with Idris Alba that he and Daniel Craig are maybe a little bit too close in age,

1:51:38right? That would have been the only that would have been the only knock at him even a decade ago was like, okay, if the whole reason you're bringing a new guy in is to get younger generation,

1:51:49is this young enough?

1:51:52The time to cast him would have been for Casino Real in two thousand six.

1:51:56And it would have been a great choice. And I think the same movies would have been really certainly Casino Royal would have been amazing with him.

1:52:03It would have been great. But it's he's Yeah, and I just look Idris Ilba is four years younger than than Daniel Craig.

1:52:09So that's not impossible, but that makes it harder, right?

1:52:13So if you're looking at this young generation of talent, I will be honest, I did not realize because a lot of names were thrown around for a long time you mentioned Jack Clouden.

1:52:21There's the the guy from Challengers, Josh O'Connor, who I like.

1:52:24I don't I don't know if he necessarily has the charisma to do it but would be there.

1:52:28Jacob Alordi, who is beautiful and certainly would fit aspects of the part, Callum Turner aka Mr.

1:52:34Duo Lipa who which is in the right.

1:52:36Tom Hiddlest Tom Hiddleston was mentioned numerous times.

1:52:40Yeah Tom Hiddleston I think would have been actually a a really interesting pick and could have totally done it.

1:52:46But like Robert Pattinson, I only initially assumed that they wouldn't because I was like, well he's Batman.

1:52:51So they're gonna let him be Batman and James Bond.

1:52:53But you know what? Why not?

1:52:56Yeah. I agree. And I think uh in terms of well who else you know, this who are they gonna cast and who are they gonna get to direct?

1:53:04And the big name, the white whale for directing one of these would have been Christopher Nolan.

1:53:09Yes. And by I think ca again, you don't even ha need the inside gossip, but the the the the hold up is that Nolan now always gets always and only gets final cut.

1:53:22Right. And the broccolies weren't gonna give 'em final.

1:53:25They weren't gonna give now. And now even though the broccoli said, All right, fine, Amazon you take it, Amazon's not gonna give it amazon's not gonna give i everything.

1:53:33Yeah. I think there was a h slightly higher chance that Amazon would to get Christopher Nolan and I think if this one doesn't work out or whatever, if the I I think if they could get cr you know,

1:53:43there's a chance they would say, Okay, fine, you get final Oh yeah.

1:53:46But if they gave it to Nolan, I don't I think that it's very clear that Pattinson was his guy for Bond.

1:53:52Yeah, no, totally. And well th well that's the interesting thing too, right?

1:53:55Is that if they don't continue with this director for future films, but they you know, either because he has other projects and other things going on which makes sense right?

1:54:01He's if this were a thing that like Christopher Nolan wanted to come in and do, yeah, he's worked with Robert Pattinson, like he cast him in the Odyssey in the big kind of villain role where which he he did very well in.

1:54:13And tenet. Yes.

1:54:15Yes that's right. He was in Tenet as well.

1:54:17So yeah. So my son given this news, that's the next movie we're gonna watch together.

1:54:22We haven't watched it since it was in the theaters.

1:54:25And I I my take on Tenet was that it's just like my argument before about you can go too much to one extreme stream or another and like with the ch iPod shuffle with no buttons.

1:54:35So it's well that's that's too few buttons.

1:54:38Tenet is too much time travel.

1:54:41Right? I love memento.

1:54:43I love Inception. But I know Inception's not time travel, but too Right, but yeah, but it's time altering stuff.

1:54:49Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I liked Interstellar.

1:54:51I did. Interstellar's fantastic.

1:54:53Interstellar was kind of stretching the limits of the Nolan esque obsession with time and stuff like that.

1:55:00Tenet too much.

1:55:01Tenet is the iPod shuffle with no buttons.

1:55:05You need to pause this and make a diagram.

1:55:08But individually, scene by scene, it's really cool movie, and I did enjoy it because I'd watch Christopher Nolan's one of those directors who,

1:55:16if he made a movie that that they even said this is a movie Christopher Nolan's made of paint drying on a wall.

1:55:23I'm gonna watch it. I was gonna say there there's gonna be at least one good Yeah.

1:55:27I'm gonna watch a movie about paint drying on a wall if Christopher Nolan made it.

1:55:32But he also he loves he clearly loves certain actors.

1:55:35He likes working with them again.

1:55:37Yes. Robert Pattinson is one of them.

1:55:39And the Pattinson character in tenet.

1:55:42I remember thinking when I watched it in a theater, oh, if this guy ever does a Bond movie, this might be the guy.

1:55:48And in particular there's a scene I don't I only watched it once, so I might be getting into detail, but there's a scene where it takes place in the lobby of a hotel and just the th not that Pattinson was like Bond,

1:56:01but there's like a oh this could be a scene in a Bond movie.

1:56:05I could see it. And I think that whole hey, this guy's already a huge movie star.

1:56:09He's already famous. Yes.

1:56:11He's Batman. That's not who we ever pick for James Bond.

1:56:15It's like well some things have to change with the times.

1:56:17You know, and I d I do think this is one of them.

1:56:20One of them could be it's all he's already a movie star.

1:56:23Because one of the other things I think they have to acknowledge is with the exceptions of the ones who didn't work out, the w The actors they picked became huge movie stars.

1:56:33You if it's a good pick, you're going to be a huge movie star.

1:56:37Daniel Craig is now a huge movie star.

1:56:39Yeah. Kim Arsnan is a big movie star.

1:56:41Sean Connery became one of the biggest stars on the planet right.

1:56:45Absolutely. And he was already kind of on his way, but w was definitely helped insurmountably.

1:56:49And I would actually argue that I think Daniel McCraig helped a little bit here because he was already very well regarded before he was being cast as James Bond.

1:56:57Was he a a huge no name No, not to the extent that like James Bond made him that way, but he was very well respected and was like it was clear that he was on that trajectory,

1:57:07right? Like if he hadn't been cast as James Bond, I still think that he would have had an ac an excellent action career if that's what he wanted.

1:57:13And if anything he was kind of upset that he was beholden to this franchise and couldn't do some of the more artistic work he wanted to do.

1:57:19Uh but I I feel like that's also the interesting choice here with the director.

1:57:23If you have Denny Villanova again sorry to the people in Quebec for Matarina's name, but who's a a fantastic director did arrival and and and the Dune series and i is kind of I think like that really good kind of thing that at this point

1:57:37the best franchises are kind of trying to go after like if you can't get Christopher Nolan For Nolan, you get you still get an optor.

1:57:43And if you're going to reboot your franchise, rebooting with an autour I think is the right choice.

1:57:48And having him pick his guys y not that they ever could cast Chalamet anyway because he's not British, but you need somebody who has that type of charisma and Robert Patton and in kind of mix of I think being able to do the

1:58:01mainstream stuff and also the artistic stuff.

1:58:04And there aren't a lot of actors who can do that.

1:58:07And I think Robert Pattinson this year alone has shown that.

1:58:09I don't know if you've if you've seen Primetime, I have not.

1:58:12It's great. Basically he plays Chris Hansen essentially.

1:58:15And he's he's really, really good in it.

1:58:18And it's one of two excellent Lance Oppenheim films that has come out this year.

1:58:23And between that and the Odyssey, I'm like okay, this is a really interesting actor right now who's able to kind of pull in both these audiences.

1:58:30He can do the the big mainstream thing.

1:58:32He can also do the more artistic indie film.

1:58:35And I think that's gonna work really well hopefully with James Bond.

1:58:40Yeah, and it's like craft cocktails.

1:58:43A good craft cocktail still needs to taste good.

1:58:46And there's a whole direction that the craft cocktail world went and that's gone where it's like we're gonna make something that's really good but then we're gonna put something really weird in it that's gonna make it taste bad and that's what you're supposed to like as a hipster and it's like no

1:59:00it's supposed to taste good and the best craft cocktails and craft cocktail bartenders are the ones who never lose sight of the fact that this is supposed to be a delicious drink for the customer.

1:59:12Yes. And I feel like the the Batman is a perfect example of that.

1:59:18One hundred percent guy an actor who's really got some and the whole Craig run as Bond, right?

1:59:25He took it very seriously. But the Batman is hey, he's gonna go in a weird direction with the way that Bruce Wayne is tormented,

1:59:34right? And it's but it never lost sight of the fact that this should be a blockbuster movie right that people really like to see with car chases and fist fights and exactly gadgets.

1:59:45And so it's kind of crazy that the same actor but you know what I mean?

1:59:49Like uh but it works. I mean honestly, I think that there's an argument to be made like if we were to use Batman actors, for example, Christian Bale would have been an excellent James Bond.

1:59:59Yeah, without questions. Yeah, no question. He he was obviously too far into doing the Christopher Nolan Batman trilogy when that was cast, but he would have been an excellent James Bond.

2:00:08And and I think that twenty years ago he never even would have been considered and let's just say availability hadn't been an issue.

2:00:14It i it would have been. Let's just pretend that it wouldn't have been.

2:00:16I don't think he would have been considered and that would have been a mistake, right?

2:00:19To not even have him on your short list just because he played this other known character.

2:00:24I also feel like because now actor Actors are more frequently on multiple TV shows and and are playing multiple characters more, and it's uh you're not as stereotyped into being one thing.

2:00:34I think it'll be easier for people to be like, Okay, yeah, so he's Batman here, but he's also James Bond.

2:00:39Like I I think it'll be it'll be fine.

2:00:41But to your point I think that what he does in in The Batman and I I really do like this film like that film, I I I think Matt Reeves is excellent at what he does too,

2:00:50is that he brought a really interesting personality to that and but to your point you still knew that this is a Batman film and that this is a good time.

2:00:58And he was game for it, right?

2:01:00And and then I just have to say, like on a personal level, he's such a weirdo in his like press junket stuff that that's going to be so fun because he really does have a good time.

2:01:10He he la he's a pathological liar in his like press junket interviews.

2:01:14He will just say the most random stuff and then admits to like lying about things and he just he has a really funny sense of humor that I think will will resonate well,

2:01:22frankly, with people who are probably like your son's age and people definitely younger than me, although I appreciate the idiosyncratic stuff too, in in a way that like we haven't really had.

2:01:30And I don't think we can undercount that.

2:01:33I could also see that being a big part of his take on James Bond, right?

2:01:37Yeah. And it's not there in Bruce Wayne, right?

2:01:40Bruce Wayne really doesn't have a fucking sense of humor and he shouldn't.

2:01:43James Bond could absolutely should and has in the past.

2:01:48But it hasn't but it hasn't been there in a while, right?

2:01:51The Craig ones are really pretty serious.

2:01:54And there's some funny scenes, but there are but yeah.

2:01:57And there always are. But there are

2:02:00something a little more Roger Moore and Sean Connery in terms of the sense of humor and what do they call them?

2:02:07The bone moats, you know, the I I could see him bringing that.

2:02:11And maybe I this is just me if they wanted my notes.

2:02:14And again, I love the Craig run overall.

2:02:16I think it was gonna age very well as the decades go on.

2:02:20But if you want to make a shift, one of the things that in the Craig James Bond was that Craig's James Bond did not seem to enjoy being James Bond.

2:02:31No. Right. And Sean Connery loved being his James Bond He was a happy big James Bond.

2:02:39And Roger Moore, Roger Moore was like born as James Bond.

2:02:43Yes. Right? I always said the Roger Moore take on James Bond, it was as though on camera you knew that he'd read the script and knew he was gonna survive.

2:02:53So that he never really even got that worried when he was in the villain's death trap and somehow made that seem cool.

2:03:01'Cause it's like, Yeah, 'cause I'm James Bond, I'm Roger Moore, of course I'm gonna come out of this and my hair's still gonna look perfect.

2:03:07I'm not saying you go back to camp, but which I'd almost certain they won't do, but I think a little bit of that sense of humor it could definitely be something that Pattinson could bring to this in the right balance.

2:03:18So I'm very happy about it.

2:03:20One more thing, two things. Again, I'm not gonna pronounce his last name Denny Villan Villanouve, I think.

2:03:27Villeneuve. A movie of his that I love a lot and I think could sort of show the tone for a James Bond movie under his direction is Sicario with Benicio del Toro,

2:03:38sort of uh Mexican drug cartel movie from fifteen years ago.

2:03:42Really good movie, good action scenes.

2:03:44But here's the other thing I want to get your opinion on.

2:03:47I would love As a forty year old actor, that they just start and there's no origin story with this new James Bond.

2:03:56He's just already Jane just

2:04:00like Doctor No with Sean Connery in nineteen sixty or whatever year that was, sixty two.

2:04:05He's already James Bond. Fuck yeah.

2:04:07Who are you? Bond, James Bond.

2:04:09He's already James Bond. Right?

2:04:11Don't no origin story.

2:04:13He's forty years old. He's already the badass ass double O agent in the thing.

2:04:17He's already on M's shitlist for being a bit of a cock and cocksured.

2:04:23Just all just throw him right in a mix.

2:04:25I'm sick of origin stories. I yeah, no, I fully agree with you on that.

2:04:29And 'cause I don't think we need it, right?

2:04:30We already know who we Who he is.

2:04:32Exactly. Well, all we need to know at the a as the audience is what's his personality.

2:04:37Who is this James Vaughn in this universe?

2:04:38But we don't need to know how he got there. We don't you're already James Vaughn.

2:04:41We already know the the drill. Now we just get have the nuances of your personality.

2:04:45Yep. All right. I'm glad you're too.

2:04:48Thank you, Christina. What a great episode.

2:04:51Thank you so much for having me, John. Thanks to our sponsors, WorkOS and Uncommon Goods.

2:04:55And that's a wrap. Than