0:00:01what does your application have going for a brand was that a hideous icon that
0:00:05happens to include feet following following brands like a rebranding
0:00:13effort all you've got going for you is the fact that your icon had feet and so
0:00:17getting an Orange Julius icon has feet it's like like your own age you're
0:00:22you're owning the feet so but what if I don't really need to worry about brand
0:00:26recognition because only like three or four hundred people have ever bought the
0:00:29damn thing in the first it doesn't matter is not going they're looking for
0:00:33the feet that's what you've got his feet and you know I think being whimsical
0:00:37like that was your instinct that's what you brought to the application you do
0:00:40feed on that terrible icon you brought that they came from you that is your own
0:00:44personal creative input into the branding of this application if you got
0:00:47some other creative input put it in but don't like I wouldn't just throw that
0:00:50away you wanted to feed you got feet I kept his feet
0:00:55here's one from John dark spelled with an e at the end of dark it's pretty
0:01:02awesome name of the issue really haven't eaten his first name but he brought up
0:01:07an interesting point that I think of when we were talking about the Apple
0:01:11lightning connector and the upcoming USB connector that we don't know anything
0:01:17about other than it's not going to sock and it will be bidirectional wait we
0:01:20don't know it's not going to say well it's still very much can suck it I guess
0:01:24I suppose but they're saying all the right things about it and when we talked
0:01:28about that I was saying like it's hard to think of that connect your doing
0:01:31anything except for something like the Lightning connector not exactly but in
0:01:36reverse with that but the contacts on the outside and a solid metal thing
0:01:38instead of being like micro-usb mini-usb where it took a little bent piece of
0:01:42metal crap on the inside because that is very delicate and annoying and crappy
0:01:47and it seems crazy to me that they would make a new connector and make it like
0:01:52it's like micro USB on our server ssible that's not really great for that
0:01:57wouldn't be a very big improvement democracy right I suppose they could
0:02:00still do that but anyway this blog post says okay so say my speculation and
0:02:05being close to write and produce a connector that is in the style of the
0:02:11Lightning connector but isn't obviously not allowed
0:02:13connector and say that Apple eventually adopt that because it's a better
0:02:17connector than the current full-sized USB input in all their products and all
0:02:20that stuff you would end up with the cable like the one that's drawn in this
0:02:24blog posted open link yet actually read this post earlier that cable would be
0:02:29kind of a nightmare don't sugary cuz it looks like lightning on one end and they
0:02:34made a USB connector on the other that looks like lightning but not really like
0:02:37it's a little bit thinner and the context or longer and you lose all the
0:02:41advantages of the reversible capable of the new USB thing and everything and you
0:02:46know consumers would have trouble figuring out which ended which because
0:02:49they look so similar and you have a linear revealed in overtime but maybe
0:02:53even we were messin up of bleary-eyed in the morning trying to plug something in
0:02:57so that's kind of like the the curse of being first for Apple came up with
0:03:01lightning connector ball the USB guys kept screwing up their connectors making
0:03:05their crappy things and not for a while now I can see Apple's get these great
0:03:08connectors on their devices and of course the big fat ugly other end that
0:03:12connects your computer is you never get a computer lightning connector right but
0:03:16if the new USB connector look something like lightning Apple could find itself
0:03:19in a stranger uncomfortable situation and I don't think they can go USB on
0:03:23both ends because of all this you know planning they have a lightning connector
0:03:27and how it works with all their devices and how that's and change the insides
0:03:30will keep him that the characters and all that good stuff well first of all
0:03:34I'm guessing that the USB reversible
0:03:37to discuss calling it USB Type C as I do we have this unofficial name the type C
0:03:42plug
0:03:43thanks for the call in the thing that he likes for me
0:03:46good so we can go so if this if this type C thing ends up coming out be
0:03:52reversible and resembling lightning in its general design I would guess almost
0:03:58certainly it would be wider but by a substantial amount to accommodate all
0:04:03depends necessary do usb3 at a reasonable cost us money not the
0:04:08Lightning country has very very tiny little contact pads and the and then the
0:04:13port is required to have these little tiny pins all that signatures Asian I'm
0:04:18guessing might run afoul of USB his desire to be super cheap and and
0:04:24and to have pretty broad tolerances so that any idiot can make one of these
0:04:28connectors or ports and at work I'm guessing the connector would not be
0:04:33nearly as small as lightning and that alone would be a pretty big pretty big
0:04:36switch also lets you might realistically speaking here like how likely is it that
0:04:42the USB people are going to make aspect that's as good as lightning to be
0:04:46actually easily confused with it like I'm guessing to be in some way clunkier
0:04:51and I love you proven wrong and I hope I am wrong on that but I'm guessing you
0:04:55know looking at their history of how they had to do things when they
0:04:58prioritize I don't think what they make is going to end up being confusingly
0:05:03similar to like Apple's easy Appleby that no matter what the Kinect looks
0:05:06like make the plastic gravity in thinking on the Lightning connector just
0:05:10massive so that it's like the same size as the current USB connector on a
0:05:14lightning cable except maybe there's a little dinky thing so even if they made
0:05:17the connectors activism size Apple since it marlys controls the Lightning
0:05:21connector market or the people who want to use lighting connectors could dictate
0:05:24that the end is not lightning has to be this big fat chunky thing I think also I
0:05:29am pretty sure we can safely rule out the the latter two possibilities in
0:05:34John's blog post about either Apple basically killing lightning and adopting
0:05:39USB or Apple working together with the USB foreign people to to to make one
0:05:47better standard together I think we can pretty safely pull those things out as a
0:05:51very very unlikely though it up as motivation would be to standardize since
0:05:56they they love having their very own connector with their own particular
0:05:59attributes they can license accessory manufacturers and all I could see
0:06:04exactly because you know that they do make a lot of money off those licensing
0:06:07fees and and I think I think more than the money I think the money is a
0:06:11secondary concern for them I I think the bigger reason they do is control you
0:06:16know they love having control over what their devices can and can't do they love
0:06:22having control over what accessories can you can do how they interact with the
0:06:26device and then I think they also like that if you make a lightning port device
0:06:30it's not going to work on somebody's Android phone you know all these things
0:06:34really benefit apple and there's there's really no motivation to change
0:06:36and the best thing about it is finally Apple has found a market in a position
0:06:41in the market where this lack of compatibility with the other guys does
0:06:45not hurt them because back in the day was like whoa real keyboards and mice
0:06:48use insert connector here but Apple uses this crazy thing called ADB and so you
0:06:52have to buy special Apple keyboard attended by a regular keyboard and
0:06:56eventually adopted USB and moralistic and a USB keyboard connected either
0:07:01computer so during the whole Mac PC era the Mac was doing that every single area
0:07:05where it didn't conform to the rest of the industry now in the portable device
0:07:11basin you know the iPod space Apple so dominated the portable music players
0:07:15based at 30 pin became sort of the defacto standard and now in the phone
0:07:18market people might not buy an iPhone because it doesn't have a big enough
0:07:21screen or like some other things like that but I don't think people are saying
0:07:25well I was gonna get an iPhone but it doesn't use USB uses this lightning
0:07:29connector type thing people may still grab a lightning connector and the cost
0:07:32of it but it doesn't hurt them as much as I think all their special Apple
0:07:36specific weirdness used to hurt and this Apple always want to have its own weird
0:07:40thing but it was the negatives were not overwhelming but kind of must have
0:07:45annoyed apple now finally they have the portable device market place where they
0:07:51can do their proprietary stuff and only take a min demoted in the market for
0:07:55almost non-existent and people just grin and bear it he said that though but
0:08:00grouper made a post about this week or two ago about how the lightning cable I
0:08:05think it was something he was is the epitome of the difference in perspective
0:08:10between Apple users and Android users and actually pointed this out I sent
0:08:14this article to 100 loving friends and they were like yeah that's stupid why
0:08:19would you want a proprietary cable and man it's just to me that makes no sense
0:08:24I don't need to have a really clunky cable that I have three hundred of I'd
0:08:29rather have one cable that works very well all the time and it just struck me
0:08:35is so weird that that was the posters right about the difference in the news
0:08:40for those users who have already made their choice or who has some sort of
0:08:42like some allegiance to one side of the other regular people who have no
0:08:46I don't care or know anything different about them like they expect when you get
0:08:51a new thing nobody knew accessories that have to go with that I know people are
0:08:54enough people are like well I can't reuse my charging cable then forget it
0:08:58because across Android phones maybe you can reuse the same cables are the same
0:09:03charges they don't work as well it's it's not a big deal because they come
0:09:06with you no wonder two cables or whatever the iphone come with this guy I
0:09:11think the experience of using lightning cable like you said Casey for regular
0:09:16people is more important than the theoretical advantage of being able to
0:09:20reuse cables across bones that you're right we also got a lot of feedback
0:09:26about dual input displays because during the believe was last show we talk a lot
0:09:32or was it one tweet
0:09:34well I saw one to eat now pay people kept waiting and saying isn't it
0:09:38possible they just hooked up to cable right from two cables from your Mac
0:09:42grouchy reminder that does not solve the problem
0:09:45you know do you think Apple could do this do you think Apple will do this
0:09:48every variation so there were allowed to write but John you've put one specific
0:09:53tweet into the show notes do you care to expound upon that the slide from Apple's
0:09:58most recent presentation about the Mac Pro that showing the back of the
0:10:02machines as next-generation video up to 34 K displays single and dual input
0:10:07displays and I don't even know what that means I remember that being on the slide
0:10:11but I guess I just forgot about entirely I'm not even sure what they're getting
0:10:15ready they want you want to venture a guess
0:10:17well last unless we we talked about how it was going to be pretty impossible for
0:10:24them to ship a 50 120 pixels wide monitor what should be a perfect to exit
0:10:30the current 27 they would be impossible because it would use more bandwidth than
0:10:34wonderful 2.0 cable will support and now back in the days when these 30 inch
0:10:43Cinema Display first came out it was one of the first monitors in the market
0:10:46required dual link DVI and what dual-link DVI basically is is a whole
0:10:52bunch more D it's basically you know to regular DVI channels into in one cable
0:10:58that has
0:10:59ton of tens and it requires special video card that would support this and
0:11:04it was everything was very expensive and everything that was pretty much the same
0:11:08idea which is like you have the standard and forgiveness wrongly please email us
0:11:12actually from going from curious but it was it was you know this the standard is
0:11:17not fast enough to support all the resolutions that have basically as far
0:11:20as I know that they've basically divided the display and half logically in the
0:11:23controllers and just like how you can render one-half so by doing something
0:11:28similar if you could lay together say two Thunderbolt cables into one monitor
0:11:34that was made to handle this and the video card for me to handle this is well
0:11:37you could theoretically then have enough bandwidth to drive a 5120 pixel display
0:11:44the new Mac Pro and and doesn't the new actually at the open to that the new
0:11:52Retina MacBook Pro it also has the double to right now so far the only able
0:11:57to computer that shipping from Apple that has two ports on it as well and I
0:12:03don't know if it has this capability it might not I don't think they've
0:12:06advertised but it's it's worth noting that that does have two ports but this
0:12:10would be a way now so last last episode they were saying it's impossible to find
0:12:14office monitor now with the proof from this slide from Nielsen thank you with
0:12:20the perfect the slide actually shows that if a dual input display exists and
0:12:25that works the way you think it would which is being able to combine the
0:12:28bandwidth of both cables into one display like DVI cable but regardless if
0:12:35this works the same way is that that theoretical displayed now is possible
0:12:40again for the new member but isn't that what it means when it says dual input
0:12:44displays I'm not sure that what it means is a display of it has two inputs and
0:12:48you mean both inputs drive to display its native resolution it could just as
0:12:51easily mean a display that has two different inputs so you can switch
0:12:56between them sooo two different max could share the same monitor I don't I
0:12:59don't know what do input display means it's what I'm getting at night what
0:13:03value would I don't know I mean I've never bought like you know maybe this
0:13:07maybe there's something about produce played with this is a common feature
0:13:09what value would there be an apple advertising
0:13:13ability to plug into like a switch to monitor the has two different inputs for
0:13:16two different sources like I know it's one of those are getting out I think
0:13:18this in context were missing from people who produce video pros or something and
0:13:22I use this I'm sure we will get email from the people explain to us but busy
0:13:26put it on a slide with the expectation that everyone knows what it means and I
0:13:30hadn't heard anything about it meaning you know the equipment that you don't
0:13:34have been with the run the resolution you can learn to sew the overall of
0:13:38people asking is it possible to they could do this it seems technically
0:13:42plausible vaguely plausible because doing TV I wasn't a standard that Apple
0:13:46may I don't think it was part of the you know whatever the DVI consortium is
0:13:50never there were some of the first ones to use it right this this sounds a
0:13:54little weird you know especially since it would be 22 actual cables and they're
0:13:57like bundled together or something I don't know but it's within the realm
0:14:01father will Apple do this I think the costs of probably the cost of a display
0:14:06of that resolution is put it outside the realm of things that Apple will do even
0:14:11if they could definitely do it but I think the wild card is what did up on me
0:14:16and my doin puts players and teams like none of us know for sure so if anyone
0:14:20out there knows for sure exactly what happened but doing puts plays let us
0:14:24know anything we should point out right now is that we are recording this on
0:14:28Monday December 16th at night it is very very likely that the Mac Pros are coming
0:14:34out tomorrow it's very likely that by the time most people here this the new
0:14:39macros will already be out and if Apple is going to make any kind of display
0:14:44announcement at that time that might have already happened as well and other
0:14:48people might have already gotten these and tested them and we're saying all
0:14:50this before the new macros actually out so this all could be irrelevant in 12
0:14:56hours why do you say that tomorrow will be the day which would be Tuesday the
0:15:0017th because today they rushed out on a 10 91 update that supports the new Mac
0:15:06Pro and that's what this is one of the lender like to do this in Tuesday's and
0:15:10this is one of the last potential weeks them to release something and still be
0:15:15in December cos have Apple shuts down next week and this was the rumored date
0:15:19as of a couple of weeks ago
0:15:20right yes so it's it's I'd say I would say the 10 91 released today all but
0:15:25confirms it I would say it's almost certain that they're being released in
0:15:3112 hours ago and it hasn't happened are based hardware in the recent past where
0:15:36if you buy the new hardware you get a newer building the less than you could
0:15:39get an existing MAC I don't know where you are you get you know you can get
0:15:4410914 only to buy a Mac Pro and then a week later comes out for everybody else
0:15:48but they have definitely done things for you if you want about his new harbour
0:15:51you get it a newer build of iOS 10 than anybody else can getting you to wait
0:15:55until the next update yet that they definitely have done that so with its
0:15:59release imminent johnnie buying one tomorrow definitely come tomorrow now I
0:16:07have to wait even if everything was just right I want to wait until every people
0:16:10test that I wanna see gaming benchmarks you know as far as I know I don't think
0:16:15I'm going to buy one tomorrow unless they actually announcement over the
0:16:20display in which case I would I would buy both immediately but besides that
0:16:25and i think im also gonna wait and see
0:16:27I'm really curious to see from reports from people about how it compares to the
0:16:312010 Mac Pro in practice you know it has all sorts of the CPU improvements which
0:16:37are you know there there there but it's not really what you'd expect from three
0:16:42years of of CPU progress so besides the CPU appearance which are same moderate I
0:16:47want to know is a whole new version of this system architecture like this all
0:16:52PCI Express everywhere maximized for throughput and then these GPUs being
0:16:57super high power like I want to know is it how big of an upgrade is that in
0:17:02practice in regular use using not just you know 3d rendering absolute GPU the
0:17:08easy just general apps development apps photo audio production stuff you know
0:17:14that kind of stuff I would love to know how much of an upgrade is this really if
0:17:19you already have a 2010 Mac Pro with gigantic pci-express SSD in a dirty
0:17:25that's true well my highest is mediocre nothing like the disk throughput than
0:17:31quote-unquote discs through
0:17:33of of this solid state drives this thing are interested in that as well because I
0:17:38think that we'll have more of an impact on my daily life than the speed of the
0:17:42CPUs right exactly and in theory the way this is architected there's a lot of
0:17:49stuff missing from it and what various card slots and a few new faces a
0:17:55firewire one of the reasons they did all that was basically like devote all of
0:18:00the PCI Express lanes available in the chipset and from the CPU devote all of
0:18:05that to you know just maximum throughput for the core components and i wanna know
0:18:11can you feel that it is a noticeable we are sponsored this week by our friends
0:18:16at Backblaze it is unlimited and untroubled online backup planes and I i
0:18:23used by please personally I've used it for years long before they were sponsor
0:18:26and I did it just $5 a month for unlimited space it's really fantastic
0:18:32and you know I've used my views other online backups back places my favorite
0:18:37it can't be that price and other ones I've had problems with throttling that's
0:18:44why they say I'm thrown in there a treat I think this is a problem the industry
0:18:47where sometimes apparently some riders will throttle you after you've uploaded
0:18:53a certain amount per time period like you're going too fast it can handle it
0:18:57or discuss them too much to slow you down my problem with some of the other
0:19:00ones is not necessarily that but their servers are just too slow degas like I
0:19:05have this nice FiOS upstream of sixty-five megabits which is amazing and
0:19:10most providers can take the files that quickly back please I've never had that
0:19:15problem it is always rock-solid as always
0:19:18uploaded as fast as I was willing to send the files and Italy fantastic so
0:19:23they have is cool features too they have led to restore you can just pull one
0:19:27file off if you want to very handy if there was one time I took a vacation
0:19:34and there was a file on my home computer that I didn't have a Dropbox I just had
0:19:37some on the hard drive and I want to access that and I had no way to go back
0:19:42to my Mac worked for like a year and then stopped working
0:19:46kid 2011 so I haven't about my Mac working for years I couldn't pull it off
0:19:50that way back please I just logged in I was able to restore that file and get it
0:19:56and work on it was fantastic everything work exactly as you'd expect to have an
0:20:00iOS app you can also browse your files directly from their iOS app so it's like
0:20:05you have access to all your stuff where ever you are and back plz was founded by
0:20:09X Apple engineers it runs natively on your Mac and works perfectly with
0:20:14maverick's I i've had zero problems with maverick's so it's pretty much it's
0:20:18there no add-ons no gimmicks no additional charges $5 a month for
0:20:22computer unlimited online backup it is the simplest online backup program to
0:20:27use just install it and it does the rest
0:20:30gonna Backblaze dot com slash ATP and thanks a lot to our sponsor backless $5
0:20:36a month for unlimited none throttled back up at least dot com slash ATP
0:20:40everybody should have an offsite backup of some kind and online is the easiest
0:20:46and probably also the cheapest offsite backup you can get you we just received
0:20:50at least John and I received tweet from someone I don't have it handy
0:20:54saying oh my goodness I should have listened to John about backing up
0:20:57because I just lost twelve months worth of work because I didn't have a backup
0:21:02just installed a piece of software in five minutes and paid $5 a month which
0:21:06is not that much in the grand scheme of things just don't go out to lunch one
0:21:09time of month you're fine and it would have had all the stuff and some peace of
0:21:13mind
0:21:14yep it's it's really great it's also you know that this is a great thing to if
0:21:18you're like if you're visiting say your parents or grandparents and they have a
0:21:21computer like I i you end up for my mom because I I got her computer few years
0:21:26back she loves it she put everything on there but I know she's never going to
0:21:30manage time if you need a laptop at all over the house
0:21:33time capsules are unreliable I i dont even wanna mess with that I just wanna
0:21:36know that she has online backup and I can check in I can go online I can make
0:21:41sure her computer has been backed up recently and backless provides all that
0:21:45nice piece of mind
0:21:46fantastic for yourself and for setting up things for your for your relatives
0:21:51who you don't want to lose data should make it as a Christmas gift idea when
0:21:55you do the the annual visiting relatives in fixing their computer stuff just
0:21:58installed backwards on the first for casual users who are not downloading
0:22:02multi gigabyte things all the time and everything you say all did their
0:22:06internet connection not fast enough to use online back the initial backup is
0:22:10probably gonna take a long time on their terrible like DSL connection whatever
0:22:13crazy thing they're using but once they get through that initial backup casual
0:22:17computer users don't produce data that you know and that high-volume me back
0:22:21plz will automatically you know not backup stuff it doesn't have to write so
0:22:26you don't have to worry about all of it all their cache files from Safari when
0:22:30the new web browsing it's not going to back up that stuff that just gonna
0:22:33backup the data they their own data and casual users don't produce that much
0:22:36data so he will have no problem keeping their update their backup up-to-date
0:22:42practically in real time everyday once it gets caught up in it won't take that
0:22:45long so I mean my mom's entire backup set is 30 gigs and how much is a great
0:22:50day like you know that the daily the damn the daily turning that is probably
0:22:55like a megabyte or two no problem uploading that right and and I you know
0:23:00I can tell you to like me I have on my computer I have about 800 gigs and back
0:23:05lays my wife has about one and a half terabytes and back live and I as it
0:23:09reviews for years and never had a problem even with that much data we have
0:23:14a little bit more follow-up specifically around TV related things johnnie went on
0:23:18an absolutely fantastic ran last episode about your new TV and one thing in
0:23:23particular that that in the the dueling display idea we got a lot of feedback
0:23:29about so would you care to talk about how to calibrate your TV talk a little
0:23:33bit about calibration last episode how I was there's lots of settings and I was
0:23:37playing with all I'm trying to get it out and then I gotta
0:23:40a bunch of treats people asking about this topic including some tweets and a
0:23:44new jacket I just recently bought a Panasonic plasma television I was
0:23:47talking to him about it is making me realize how few people know anything
0:23:52about him even you guys who I calibrate my TV whatever you even talking about so
0:23:56I figured I wouldn't go over just a couple of basic things you can do to
0:24:01make your television look better almost anybody going to have a fancy TV doesn't
0:24:05even need to be a plasma TV you know you can make it if you like that and then
0:24:09basically what it comes down to is that your TV looks bad now and you probably
0:24:12don't even note so the first thing lots of people tweeted about was a
0:24:16calibration Appleton the App Store from the thx company Lucasfilm around and now
0:24:20I believe it's pronounced thanks John I thought you're better than that you know
0:24:28and it works if you have an iOS device and either an Apple TV so you gonna play
0:24:35to your TV or some way to connect the iOS device to your TV with HDMI cable I
0:24:41used airplanes my Apple TV ad that could happen sorry TMI but I don't know what
0:24:47the options are there in terms of Cape so anyway it's like $2 don't buy the
0:24:50application if you can't do one of those two things you can read read the
0:24:53description to see if you can I bought just out of curiosity because I already
0:24:58have a thx calibration thing that came with my Tivo that is basically the same
0:25:02tests as a little bit of integration with your camera which is only so-so but
0:25:07it's really simple really basic but even without that you can probably find
0:25:12somewhere where you can download some test patterns or something to adjust
0:25:17your television that thx out just happens to make it easy to do is that
0:25:21the tricky part is to get a picture on your television and you don't want to go
0:25:26through anything two screws at the picture so if you like
0:25:30got an image on your computer and try to use like AirPlay Mirroring on your TV I
0:25:33would worry that that would not be a good simulation of the images are you
0:25:38want to adjust your blu-ray player really you probably need something on a
0:25:42blu-ray to go out the Blu ray player and onto television
0:25:45that's not to say that you need to calibrate every single input of your
0:25:48television separately but it is possible that some devices you have to put
0:25:53different kinds of signals than other devices so be careful about that but
0:25:57anyway here's my quick tips for calibration first one is make sure the
0:26:02devices that are connected to your television are outputting what you think
0:26:06they're they're putting to your television set
0:26:08so for example if you get cable or satellite TV or whatever something like
0:26:12that it's sending you your television shows in a particular format and say you
0:26:18have Comcast and the television and comes over as 1080 I make sure that it's
0:26:23going into the back of your television as a 1080 i signal you be surprised at
0:26:28how many people have things get figured where their television shows or 1080 I
0:26:31but through the series of boxes are devices are inputs they're going through
0:26:35its being converted to 720p to be shown on the television or vice versa you have
0:26:39a 720p single and your TV could show 720p but it's up to show it has 1080 I
0:26:44most televisions and the boxes and receivers and things that will convert
0:26:48between 1080 and 7:20 p.m.
0:26:50you know and even 1080p they will settle down sample do whatever it takes you
0:26:55wanted to go through sort of natively whatever the need to visit the native
0:26:58720 heavier TV show at 7:20 the natives 1080 I have it show that way that's not
0:27:04even calibrations that this just you know look at all the settings and all
0:27:07the devices are you trying to make sure you're not impossible that sometimes
0:27:10easier said than done like all TV still available but different settings where
0:27:15you could you put out like the cable goes into your TiVo like television say
0:27:18no and then he comes out of your TiVo and say ok I can take the single coming
0:27:24in and I can convert it to any format you want and send it to your television
0:27:27or I could not touch it at all and just passing through and that's always the
0:27:30one you want these to coordinate ever whatever nowadays with the modern
0:27:34Tebow's I don't think they even have that option you have to know what the
0:27:36input signal doesn't match up for the outlets in particular is if you hit the
0:27:42up arrow button on the five-way selector it will change the format and if you
0:27:47have children in your house they will accidentally hit that up our selectors
0:27:50many many times and so you'll have everything figured that one day sit down
0:27:54your television and wonder why things look a little weird
0:27:57it's funny because when you get to the power there watching television and
0:27:59change the format should check that the second thing is about the size of the
0:28:04image on the screen and another I'm surprised that people know about if you
0:28:09buy television logo 1080p FullHD 1080 resolution right and if you know that
0:28:15the resolution I think it's 1920 by 1080 if you were to do in pixels and so you
0:28:20figure if you're watching a television show and that television show put up a
0:28:23test pattern image that showed one pixel wide rectangle that was 1920 by 1080
0:28:28pixels you would expect to see like around the edge of your screen that one
0:28:33pixel wide bordering states like a white white rectangular black background in
0:28:37reality on any television you by pretty much you will see nothing because they
0:28:41will cut off the edges of the screen as holdover scan or lots of other different
0:28:45names articles from the the CRT days where the images of the edges of CRT
0:28:50we're really low quality and they would cover them on television sets with like
0:28:54a plastic part of the best one everything and that someone is giving
0:28:59more historical context and why they did that but the bottom line was that there
0:29:01was a safe area where you can show an image or you were sure which opened
0:29:04everybody's television set and it was unsafe area which are most people tell
0:29:07them that would be covered by some other plastic trim piece there are no plastic
0:29:11trim pieces covering the edges of your television set you have ADHD television
0:29:15and it has 1080p resolution you can see all those pixels but all those
0:29:21televisions will take your television signal and zoom it so it's bigger than
0:29:24you television so you can only see sort of like the inner you know that will cut
0:29:28off the frame of things I just two things one to make the misinformation
0:29:31things that are outside outside of that area you won't see it all and the second
0:29:35thing is it takes all those nice native if you're lucky
0:29:371080p or 1080 pixels and it will stretch it is like taking a picture taking a
0:29:42desktop background picture of exactly fits your mantra and then making a size
0:29:45bigger by 5% you're missing part of the picture on the part you see is blurry so
0:29:50almost all televisions just a fancy ones have a setting somewhere in them are you
0:29:55can tell it don't do that don't turn off over scans and those that have dipped
0:29:59what size should be size one size to look in the manual for television but if
0:30:04you can't find me over television just google for your televisions model
0:30:08a manual pdf you'll find the manual vs online somewhere and find that setting
0:30:13because if you paid for 1080p television or 720p whatever you should see all
0:30:19those pixels at their native resolution to think of it in television parlance
0:30:23this these are these two steps in front resolution and the size of the picture
0:30:27two things that anybody can do you don't get an application to do it and they're
0:30:31pretty much know down to downsize to a some people are saying that if you do
0:30:35that you might see booms in the shot like a microphone booms because people
0:30:38expect every television to be over scanning not in my experience running
0:30:41television that proper size for four years now since I got my first HDTV that
0:30:46has not been a problem I have not seen a bunch of you know boom Mikes coming down
0:30:51from the top of the screen or things from the side but even if I did I would
0:30:54say that the problem of the show is not mine I don't want all my television all
0:30:57the images on my television to be assumed in and little bit blurry
0:31:01woodstock offer yet
0:31:02third item I would say that everyone should justin has renewed calibration
0:31:06thing is brightness and contrast that to calibration things that you'll look at
0:31:10indy this thx offer any other type of thing are one shows you a bunch of gray
0:31:14boxes going from white down to black and you would just your brightness until a
0:31:20certain number of boxes are visible will usually have it so you're not supposed
0:31:24to all the boxes like you shouldn't see the last boxes second-to-last box or
0:31:27whatever
0:31:28adjusting that level is important because it lets you see some shadow
0:31:31detail but you know not too much like the test images of you say you should
0:31:37see a person in front of the background and it looks entirely black to you your
0:31:40thing is is not dialed incorrectly and if it looks at ABC too much stuff on it
0:31:45then it's too bright so you should just until you get just the right boxes
0:31:48visible pretty easy tested do you need a special caught me just in your eyeball
0:31:52they'll say something like make it is dark and you can still see box seven
0:31:56that's nothing Anybody could do but looking at it maybe you want to do it in
0:31:59a polite rumor darkroom depending on your watch television and contrasts
0:32:04Emily the show you something like a series of four white boxes of this just
0:32:08looks like a big white rectangle contrast is too high
0:32:11turn the contrast down until you see actual four distinct white boxes of
0:32:15varying levels of great should be lines between the white boxes if you're losing
0:32:19line between the last two white boxes
0:32:21time to blend together you need to die or contrast those two settings plus the
0:32:26size and resolution will improve the picture on your television set not just
0:32:30make me more accurate to what it's supposed to look like but generally
0:32:34making things look nicer not look washed out not look too dark not look too
0:32:38bright and I haven't even touched anything having to do with color in
0:32:42terms of exactly dialing in the red green and blue and all that stuff
0:32:46adjust brightness contrast size and resolution will go a long way in the
0:32:49final thing I talked about this last show was turned off all the crazy
0:32:52affects every television has crazy facts that probably does you just need to turn
0:32:58them all off
0:32:59LCDs you might wanna leave motion interpolation on it looked weird you
0:33:03emotionally sweetie without it but other than that all the things about like
0:33:07vivid color an extra brightness and the title last episode billions enhancer
0:33:11often actually pasted into the show notes because I wanted to know these
0:33:15actual names that have in front of the last time he heard the actual names of
0:33:18the settings from my fancy new television set is not made up and these
0:33:23are not like gathered from several different models these are all in one
0:33:26television set
0:33:27caption smooth MPEG remaster motion smoother resolution remastered video and
0:33:32our C 80 s academic periods between letters photo enhancement vivid color
0:33:38color remaster black extension and automatic gamma control and all those
0:33:42things and explorations in the manual trying to explain what they do
0:33:46the bottom line is just turn them all off every single one of them turn them
0:33:49off what if I like cats cats and nobody know it like this they'd have terrible
0:33:55names to you look up what they do all they do is mess with the picture in a
0:34:00way they think might be helpful but generally is not helpful especially in a
0:34:04plasma television to doesn't have the problems that need to be compensated for
0:34:07by fax like this
0:34:09demotions move there is the one that really galls me in plasma and LCD
0:34:13television you'll have similar settings if you turn them all off and it looks
0:34:16like crap figure out which one or two you need to turn on to make it look like
0:34:20crap but do not leave them all on especially things like a vivid color or
0:34:25color remaster things are going to school with the colors those just make
0:34:28everybody look like
0:34:29sounds and make things look totally wrong so you don't need you don't need
0:34:33to hire someone to come into your house to do a professional calibration to to
0:34:37improve the picture television those four things just turn off the effects
0:34:42resolutions exercise and decorators in contrast it'll make a big difference in
0:34:46your life
0:34:47actually take a backseat yes ma'am I don't know I haven't read the manual we
0:34:54are also sparked this week by hover over as is high quality no hassle domain name
0:34:59registration for.com / ATP or use promo code ATP for 10% off however takes all
0:35:08the hassle in fact owning and managing domain names for smart easy to use and
0:35:13powerful Domain Name Management Tools however believes that everyone should be
0:35:17able to take control of their online identity with their own domain name and
0:35:21her makes it easy to do so they're part of two cows which is a company that's
0:35:24been around basically forever and they're one of the largest domain
0:35:27registrars in the world they offered tons of TLD the I dot net dot khou.com
0:35:32of course . TV all sorts country could and many more domain names and are
0:35:38always adding more you can get . just about anything so however does not
0:35:43believe in heavy-handed cross-selling or really you know aggressive up selling
0:35:47they don't believe in hiding functionality required extra payment for
0:35:51things that really should be included for free with the main names such as
0:35:54whois privacy subdomains and URL forwarding they also have their email
0:35:58service Gmail makes it easy and affordable to create a memorable email
0:36:02address and without having to use one of the impersonal forgettable web mail
0:36:07addresses that you can get for free elsewhere they also offer Google Apps
0:36:10for Business
0:36:11domain new or old and one of the best things about her is that they have
0:36:15amazing customer support so not only do they have excellent online help with all
0:36:20sorts of documentation and tutorials but they also have this awesome no hold no
0:36:26weight and no transfer fee telephone support policy so you can call this 866
0:36:30number
0:36:31Monday through Friday 8:00 a.m. to 8:00 p.m. Eastern and a real live person
0:36:36probably in Canada is there in Canada that means they're gonna be really nice
0:36:40of course
0:36:41cold maybe but really nice they're gonna be speaking to a live person picking up
0:36:46the phone almost immediately
0:36:48second ring maybe you make your way to the second ring but almost immediately
0:36:51and the person who takes the phone will actually be able to help you they will
0:36:55have the power to help you you want to be transferred to 10 different people
0:36:58know you call them up anytime during business hours 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. Monday
0:37:03through Friday and you are speaking to a person and that is incredibly unusual in
0:37:07pretty much any business these days let alone something that takes place mostly
0:37:11on the Internet domain name registration so go to hover dot com slash ATP for
0:37:16high-quality no hassle domain name registration and don't forget to use
0:37:19promo code ATP for 10% off any purchase you make a cover thanks love to show
0:37:25again at a couple more things on the calibration you yeah one is frequent
0:37:32suggestion by many people who have the same television here have other similar
0:37:36television they say they go into a forum seen as forums like this is ABS forearms
0:37:40has tons of websites but I don't have television television's on the web where
0:37:45people by television's calibrate them either professionally are sorted by hand
0:37:49by themselves and then they post to the forum group what their settings are
0:37:52different settings for brightness contrast color 10th gamma like tons of
0:37:57things you can adjust and they will just add to their liking or have it
0:38:01professionally calibrated and post those numbers to the forum and seen at the
0:38:05people to review televisions on CNN will also post their settings they we
0:38:08calibrate the television before we did our testing for a review here in the
0:38:12settings we use I tend not to just take those settings and use them like
0:38:17television because particularly with plasma each individual example of a
0:38:21particular model varies enough that you're not going to I don't think you're
0:38:25going to get like you know ten-point fifteen-point white balance adjustment
0:38:30of tiny minut degrees I don't think those settings that they use for their
0:38:36television sets are going to work for mine even if we have the exact same make
0:38:39model and year just because of variations than individual televisions
0:38:43and then on top of that there is aging where the televisions look different as
0:38:48used in Morgan particular class so I wouldn't blindly take any of those
0:38:52settings and apply them to your television
0:38:54back to you are seeing what they're seeing . I'm looking at them to give
0:38:57myself sort of a ballpark idea of what are people doing in particular look at
0:39:01the gamma settings to see you know what what gamma values they're using this
0:39:05lots of weird stuff especially Panasonic televisions where they had a bunch of
0:39:10preset tonight a custom setting and the if you pick one game level in the
0:39:14customers not the same as it did on the presets you have to look at all the
0:39:16details like they started with the same each week these things they started with
0:39:19that in this week those and is also the super duper professional mode where you
0:39:24can expose all the settings on television through some crazy interface
0:39:27by typing in weird cause in your remote to get even more settings are screwed
0:39:31those that level 13 doing that I would say don't do that hire professional do
0:39:35that but if you want to look at these these forms and to get an idea of what
0:39:39things to place setting for example if you did it visually like you do those
0:39:43tests with the book but the black levels and contrasting you got two numbers
0:39:46dialed in and then you go to a forum post you see seven different for
0:39:50different website and everybody has their contracts at like 6362 and you
0:39:56have your say twelve you probably did something wrong
0:39:58right now it's just like I said he checks I wouldn't say copy those numbers
0:40:01but that's a lot of people talked about that and asked me if I'd use the
0:40:06settings no I don't use them directly but I do use them to just check that I'm
0:40:10not entirely crazy thing that can be verified
0:40:13well you know it's supporting evidence against war against alright so everyone
0:40:19has been talking about raiding things so I think now is as good a time to any as
0:40:25any to save rate the radio show on iTunes now seem to do that now
0:40:30leader or not at all radar show well now or do you want to email us your negative
0:40:36thoughts right or do any reminded to rate us well in two weeks or how bout
0:40:42with every episode of the podcast will just ask you again during the show do
0:40:46you want to rate us
0:40:47yeah I realized how about halfway through that right down my throat so let
0:40:55me move on and say market do you happen to have any thoughts about reading apps
0:40:58and asking and soliciting users to rate ups ya don't
0:41:04moving on this topic we figured it out i mean this this was discussed at length
0:41:12in in last week's episode of John Gruber's the talk show with Dana jacket
0:41:17and it was a really good discussions so i don't think we need to rehash most of
0:41:21it they just have my position is really you know what we're talking about those
0:41:26in case you couldn't tell we're talking about the rate these the rate this app
0:41:31dialogues that pop up in many iOS apps big and small hey rate this app you want
0:41:38to go you know leaving creating an hour remind me later or never do it again
0:41:42they've kind of become this this like playing on iOS devices with a play with
0:41:47very minor effects that it is it's like slightly annoying everybody you know
0:41:55grouper started out about a week ago now saying like I've often thought about
0:42:00starting a campaign online to just make everybody rate one-star when they see
0:42:04one of those looks like his nice way of like kind of seating the idea without
0:42:08saying I'm telling you all to do this right now is a masterful freezing you
0:42:14know we've had a lot of discussion here in their various more people in the
0:42:18community about the pros and cons of of these great the staff dialogues and and
0:42:24the pros and cons of what would happen if the start of retaliating and and and
0:42:28let you know reading everything one star or or reading everything only three
0:42:31stars and a five or what we do whatever the case may be my position is not that
0:42:36you should necessarily take any particular action towards the absolute
0:42:39do this my position is really just telling developers you should not have
0:42:43this in Europe because it really and I think group had a really good plan to
0:42:49talk show about why this is so irritating is that a modal dialog box
0:42:55that pops up in your face we try to do something with an app like thats a
0:42:59Motorola box should be preserved for basically exceptions like in programming
0:43:03parlance like something that is not supposed to be the common case you know
0:43:08like there was some kind of weird server error and we can't do what you asked or
0:43:12you could try to authenticate and you couldn't login because
0:43:16refuse your password or like you're trying to do something right now and you
0:43:20can't do it because you turned off
0:43:22cellular data or location services or something like that you know that's the
0:43:26kind of conditions in which a modal dialog box is appropriate
0:43:29interrupting people to serve the developer like reading an app doesn't do
0:43:36crap for the people who are doing it it it doesn't serve them at all it only
0:43:40serves developer you're asking people to promote you or make you feel good about
0:43:44yourself either way you're asking you you do that you develop her are asking
0:43:48people to do something for you and your asking them that by interrupting them in
0:43:53the middle of them trying to use your app and probably trying to get something
0:43:56done you're interrupting them to say hey help me out here by 10 reviewing me and
0:44:02and you know pimping me in the store and that seems like a very inappropriate use
0:44:07of an interruption to your user like that you know I almost wonder if now is
0:44:12a decent time to expose Marco to corporate culture and what I mean by
0:44:18that is why I wonder if now is a good time for the five whys so Marco put on
0:44:25new or not so awesome developer hat and you're thinking right now about putting
0:44:32this into europe reaction let's say you just did put this into overcast for the
0:44:36sake of conversation what do I know you never would just try try hard and for me
0:44:42let me you're safer while we're on the topic I said in my post I am putting a
0:44:47thing in the settings screen that like a button to say leave a review for this
0:44:52happen historic up just a button there that is different if you want to make it
0:44:56easy for people who do want to leave a review for you if you want to give them
0:45:00a shortcut or suggest they might want to do that in a passive way like a button
0:45:05and about so that's very different than interrupting them with it with a message
0:45:10box in normal use of the app I don't have any problem with abundant in about
0:45:14that whoever you want their I don't care that that doesn't interrupt me and if
0:45:19I'm browsing in settings are about I might actually consider doing that
0:45:22because the unlike him I'm playing with stuff I am exploring this app but you're
0:45:27trying to do something
0:45:28interrupted by a modal dialog box that's the problem so I want to the distinction
0:45:33it's not that asking for reviews at all is bad or providing a shortcut at all is
0:45:38bad it's the way you're asking by
0:45:42by interrupting people in a modal right so you were writing overcast and you had
0:45:49a brain fart I know maybe add too much May one night and you've put this into
0:45:54europe why why did you put a video of a drunk featured
0:45:59right that's what that's when the best work is done
0:46:03why would you put a solicitation to rate your app into overcast if you were there
0:46:10kinda developer that would do that sort of thing the main reason why people do
0:46:13this and the reason why it hypothetical drunk me would do this and overcast if I
0:46:17somehow I don't know when I have a lot of shit I i dont get bad taste if I
0:46:26doubt I would argue for getting drunk on Sat May I think you're pretty good but
0:46:32in all seriousness to borrow money or phrases I think the reason people do
0:46:38this is very clear it works in this and in the definition of works where it does
0:46:44get you more reviews now I don't know why would you want more reviews the
0:46:48theory is I've heard different things obviously we know from just like a
0:46:53customer perspective we know that when we are browsing for apps usually we do
0:46:58read the reviews now or at least glanced at them or glance at the star rating the
0:47:02average star rating and it is there is a distinction between ratings and reviews
0:47:06you don't have to write a review TV star rating but I don't think for the purpose
0:47:10of this discussion
0:47:11matters so there there's one argument to say it when customers find it they will
0:47:18read the reviews and if you don't have a lot of reviews if you have a couple of
0:47:21bad reviews and no positive ones to offset them then that'll make unless I
0:47:25thought about that that I can't argue with that is true however I've heard a
0:47:31lot of people also say that reviews are correlated with rank and I don't think
0:47:37we have any evidence to confirm that in a couple people said that
0:47:41doesn't do that so that's all over the map I would love to hear from anybody
0:47:45who has actual evidence to support whether that's true or false or not as
0:47:50far as I know rank is all about sales volume and it's like sales volumes per
0:47:55time interval I don't think it has anything to do with with their reviews
0:47:59but that could change I don't know why do you want more
0:48:03why do you want a higher rank to get rich in the App Store will why would
0:48:08that make you rich in the App Store because nobody pays for the grinding all
0:48:14kidding aside line of questioning trying to lead you down is that and I believe
0:48:18that to some degree underscore David Smith talked about this in his really
0:48:22good blog post today but I feel like the end of the five whys of this
0:48:29conversation is that discovery is broken and if not discovery then finding a way
0:48:37to pitch your app in such so that I don't need to double check your work
0:48:43what I mean by that is if I throw up a bunch of really awesome screenshots and
0:48:48I throw up a really nice description it you're gonna want to double check from
0:48:53real people that I'm not all of it that I'm not lying and I think it's a
0:48:59combination of discovery and representation of the app that makes
0:49:03this sort of gross behavior necessary because if discovery was really good
0:49:11then I would be able to find out very easily and then once I found the app
0:49:16that I think I might want if if the selling of it the marketing of it within
0:49:21the app store was really good then say if we had a video for example or maybe
0:49:27if you had a trial and I'm not tryna go down that road I'm just saying
0:49:30hypothetically if you had like a one day trial or whatever then it wouldn't
0:49:34matter what the reviews are certainly what matters much with reviews say and
0:49:38it wouldn't matter as much with the ratings are but because developers have
0:49:43almost no levers to Paul in order to improve their performance to find
0:49:49performance everyone in the App Store this is only one of the only leverage
0:49:52they've got so dark
0:49:53they're gonna pull on it and that's what that was the exercise the five whys
0:49:57exercise I was trying to bring you down I think this is the reason this comes up
0:50:01at all like the reason is wondering fireball fireball whatever is not so
0:50:06much because doing things because I think the App Store has always been you
0:50:11know to america's thing from that guy was trying to run for president
0:50:16there's the two app stores this is the one that's full of crap we just ignore
0:50:21we being you know the Mac nerd blogger whatever people and there's the good App
0:50:27Store the attitude we like them or use and the reason this rate me thing comes
0:50:32up is because it's not limited to the crap out Store apps that we all like and
0:50:37use every day do this
0:50:39Instagram like our favorite Twitter client you know my favorite note-taking
0:50:44application everybody does it
0:50:47the super high-class well-designed well-regarded we love the application
0:50:51couldn't live without it everything about it is awesome responsibility
0:50:55releases bug fixes has a reasonable prices great application all-round even
0:50:59they have stupid to rate me dialog boxes on the not all of them but it's it's an
0:51:04infection of annoyance that has crossed over into our world and that's why you
0:51:08get someone like John Gruber saying well just gotta stop I mean I love these
0:51:12applications that use every day but they gotta get outta my face if there are
0:51:17tons of terrible things that happen only in the crap out story like blinking ad
0:51:21banners in your face and you know just all sorts of ugly you eyes and and
0:51:27things that are motile when they shouldn't be interested in this kind of
0:51:30crap applications we don't care what happens over there is it doesn't affect
0:51:33us because we know we feel like we're discerning and we talk to each other and
0:51:36say what the good applications are making recommendations and then we get
0:51:39one is good applications that we use every single day and thrust upon the
0:51:42written down boxes boxes it's like a betrayal it's like that's not supposed
0:51:46to happen here this is the good AppStore where I'll talk to my friends and
0:51:49getting my stuff like it's back to the discovery thing casey was talking about
0:51:52where if we had a way to look at an application it said something like I was
0:51:58getting on Facebook is scary but it's gonna be like a six-year friends use
0:52:02application they like it means so much more than waiting through
0:52:06hundred possibly paid for five star reviews from you know Mechanical Turk or
0:52:11whatever these developers to do is take it they're scammers using especially
0:52:14when you're going into an area that you not that familiar with in the App Store
0:52:18the sort of social proof that people who you know and trust have decided this
0:52:23application is good that's all you need to see like from three other people
0:52:27saying this is good or this is bad that you happen to know they were beaten it
0:52:31makes so much more difference than just his reign of you but there's no way to
0:52:35put that in that there's no way to you know we have the reputation the
0:52:38developer which maybe we know maybe we don't have a home interview that we
0:52:42can't even tie back to individual people even if we see a name that we think we
0:52:45recognize let me know that the name under which some friend of ours these
0:52:48reviews on the idea that we have no idea so the reaction to this in terms of
0:52:55putting up with things as what if we you know I've always I mean think about
0:52:57asking people to one star rate this is a weird way to suggest one-star rating of
0:53:01it it's in effect that's not the way to go about it the actual campaign
0:53:07suggestion of a way to the campaign to go about it but what we want to happen
0:53:10and what i think is going to happen is not that kind of one-star campaign but a
0:53:16socialization of the idea that putting upgrading the dialog box is unacceptable
0:53:20in the quote-unquote good app store and that's what we're looking for you know
0:53:24get that stuff out of the application is that we like the high quality will
0:53:28design application some good developers that we use everyday that really popular
0:53:31that we like we've already got this whole thing is like when an application
0:53:35goes badly people used to like 20 and then Twitter bought them and it was
0:53:39still ok and they changed it now it's crap and now nobody uses the official
0:53:43Twitter client r-iowa said they can't help it all that's an application going
0:53:47bad was good did conform to sort of are you know taste and social norm
0:53:52guidelines in you know the Mac nerd or I was in their community and then it
0:53:56didn't anymore we only kicked it outright but all these other
0:53:59complications is still doing this we need to socialize all the you know
0:54:04software reviewers developers consumers of people think they have good taste
0:54:09everything socialized the idea that you can't put up the dialog boxes otherwise
0:54:14we will look down
0:54:16when you in some way that's all you need to don't need to one-star ratings you
0:54:19don't need to attack people or to punish their applications if you socialize
0:54:25everybody involved in this good half of the ecosystem that putting a breaking
0:54:28dialog boxes unacceptable the problem will take care of itself because no one
0:54:32wants to be that out but the problem is that somehow we got to a point where
0:54:36that was deemed acceptable by almost everybody involved and I think this
0:54:40exercise is going to turn that around if we keep at it without any stupid
0:54:44campaigns to read things one star to retaliate or send e-mail e-mail yeah I
0:54:48mean that was that was kind of the main argument of my post is like yeah you can
0:54:52you can do this and and it works but at what cost to to quality and your
0:55:01reputation to your brew and you know if there's lots of things that work
0:55:06telemarketing and spam work but you know most reasonable people hate those things
0:55:11and said like and the telemarketers and argue well you know we're good we're
0:55:17calling you up and you know it's once a week maybe for two seconds and you hang
0:55:21up if you don't like it like I've gotten it so it's always good when you when you
0:55:26attack a portion of your own audience that's that's when you get the biggest
0:55:30feedback but I've gotten so much feedback in the publish my post about
0:55:36this from developers saying it's no big deal if you don't like those used to hit
0:55:40dismiss and you don't see it for a little while but that is a big deal
0:55:46that's like if you're annoying somebody slightly you're still annoying them and
0:55:52that builds up over time you you get the the image in people's minds the brand
0:55:57image of like of kind of being mediocre on quality on standards that matters at
0:56:04all adds up and I don't know my I'm torn on this because it's hard for me to talk
0:56:10about this because anything I say people jump down my throat immediately saying
0:56:15will you didn't have to do all that cuz you know you were popular or something
0:56:20forgetting that the read the way I got popular was be- cause of Instapaper
0:56:24not I wasn't properly before launching
0:56:28you know that that's so it's hard for me to say it again and for anybody to take
0:56:34it seriously in this regard because they just pulled that's fine for Merlin
0:56:36argument against me but I really I I can't I can't say enough how much those
0:56:43little quality decisions matter and they add up and that's how you get popular
0:56:48that's how you get respected as by caring so much about quality that you
0:56:52won't annoy your users for a split second every two weeks that really
0:56:55matters and I i don't know how else to tell people that without sound like I'm
0:57:00attacking them but it is annoying and it it doesn't matter
0:57:06let me take a quick break right before your next bigger point tell you about
0:57:10our final budget this week it is audible audible is the leading provider of
0:57:14downloadable audiobooks with over a hundred and fifty thousand titles in
0:57:17virtually every genre have a huge catalog its growing constantly if you
0:57:22want to listen to it
0:57:23audible has you can listen to audible audiobooks anytime anywhere
0:57:28iPhones iPads computers candles even old iPod if you actually have one of those
0:57:32still kicking around always offering ATP listeners a free audiobook along with a
0:57:3730 day trial go to audible podcast dot com slash ATP to take advantage of this
0:57:43special offer now Casey I've heard through the grapevine that you have
0:57:47recently listened to a book or read a book did I recently read in this was
0:57:53actually recommended by someone on Twitter few months ago when I was going
0:57:56to the beach and i wanted to have some books to read so I solicited
0:58:00recommendations on Twitter and somebody recommended machine man by Max barry
0:58:05varry I just finished reading it I did not read it on an audible but I read the
0:58:11book book it was extremely weird and I don't know if I like it or not but it
0:58:17was very different and for that alone or recommendation
0:58:20yeah exactly for that alone though it may be worth checking out in the the the
0:58:25TLDR version is I'm sorry the summary john is that there's a
0:58:31guy who's a PhD and he accidentally chops off one of his legs working in his
0:58:37lab because he works at like this big equipment and so he gets a prosthetic
0:58:43leg and then realizes well you know I could build a better one and so he built
0:58:47himself a better prosthetic leg and then realizes you know what this would be
0:58:51better as a pair instead of just one and I'll let you read the book to feel I let
0:58:57you read the book to fill in where this goes but it was very very very different
0:59:01and so I double checked and of course is available on audible and audibles been
0:59:06kind enough to sponsor ATP a handful of times and everytime I think of a book
0:59:11recommendation even if it's slightly esoteric I go to audible to see before I
0:59:16recommend it
0:59:17hey is this available on audible in every single time you answered yes so
0:59:21feel free to go to audible and get cases weird book recommendation was calling on
0:59:25the machine man it's called machine man by Max barry be Arry that he was
0:59:30surprised but I don't know I don't think so but it's a lot shorter than your
0:59:35recommendation questions
0:59:38less than sixty hours over 600 wasn't his night hours and 27 minutes on
0:59:44audible so there's a lot to audible once again for sponsoring our show good
0:59:49audible podcast dot com slash ATP and really quickly to build on
0:59:54not the book but audible you know we're going on a car trip to go to my family's
1:00:00soon and the best way in the entire world to kill time on a car trip other
1:00:07than listening to the show is to get a book on tape so get to get something
1:00:13from Audible and right now I mean they're offering you a free audiobook to
1:00:18fill in the case of this particular selection a 10 hour car ride how can you
1:00:22say no to that there's no reason not to go check it out or you can get john's
1:00:26pic which is the power broker and and fill your next three years of Cara
1:00:30alright so the party want to start before that breaks into this might be a
1:00:37little bit long so back to Apple and discoverability in search ability i I
1:00:42would take the position
1:00:44and I know this might not be popular but I think it's realistic that it's no
1:00:48longer Apple's responsibility and it might never happen but it's no longer
1:00:52Apple responsibility to promote your app in the App Store is just huge
1:01:00back in the early days of the web yahoo had this directory where they're trying
1:01:04to make a directory of every website basically and it worked in like nineteen
1:01:09ninety-five was a really small place eventually though that was abandoned I
1:01:15think I think it was abandoned because they were just got too big and a
1:01:21directory paradigm was was just there was too much data too much out there on
1:01:26the web just didn't fit and so that was pretty much abandoned in favor of
1:01:32searched and searched all sorts of challenges it has ranking it has fam
1:01:37issues but the directory paradigm did not skill and on the web
1:01:45you're on your own to get attention for your site you're on your own to get
1:01:49traffic it you know it's something that we merit-based if you can get good
1:01:51people to link to you but you know in general you're on your own and making
1:01:56something good enough is still on you anyway to get people into so I think the
1:02:01App Store has reached that point very clearly where discoverability
1:02:06is a word thrown around a lot with this I don't think it's apples problem I
1:02:11really don't I think they can have your editorial pics which will cover some
1:02:15discoverability
1:02:17to the to the whole store you know that's chances are you're not gonna get
1:02:21feature that often to matter you know you might get feature once or twice a
1:02:24good app chance I can be featured every two weeks or anything so
1:02:29discoverability through Apple's official editorial channels is going to help you
1:02:32occasionally if ever everyday discoverability is not a problem it's
1:02:38your problem it's you as a developer you have to get your own attention you to
1:02:42get your own traffic and whether you have to buy that traffic where you have
1:02:45to earn it whether you have to look into it if some influential person happens to
1:02:49use your happened you know lead to a talk about it or something you know you
1:02:52might get that but you have to do your marketing
1:02:56that's the right attitude from a developer's perspective because you want
1:02:59to be motivated to do the right things right I think that's the correct rate
1:03:01for a developer to think about it but in the grand scheme of things it is Apple's
1:03:05problem in that if they have a customer who buys an iOS device and they say I
1:03:10would really like an application to keep track of my shopping list and they
1:03:13search your shopping list on the App Store because they don't know what else
1:03:16to do like they shop you today the Google for shopping list app or they
1:03:20find the App Store luckily type shopping list into there and they didn't get the
1:03:24results and it does serve assault are filled with tons and tons of crap that
1:03:28the person looking at the screen says no way to determine whether they're being
1:03:32lied to with these are all automated reviews whether you know it just feels
1:03:36lost that's a bad experience of the customers like I just wanna shop in this
1:03:39in this is too many of them and I can't tell which is which
1:03:42and I think that's that's a problem for Apple because they want people to get
1:03:45their thing to be able to have a cool shopping list app and surely there are
1:03:48many cool shopping list app but the chances of them being anywhere near the
1:03:51top of the results for shopping list in the App Store slim I got so many people
1:03:55talking about you know we all know the handful of really great Twitter client
1:03:58apps out there if you search for Twitter whether a person like that in the App
1:04:02Store all the apps that we know and love
1:04:05debris think should be at least on the first page of results are somewhat near
1:04:07the top are very often are buried and you know is that a problem for its like
1:04:12the app developer cansao Apple it's your fault not so much stuff cuz I'm buried
1:04:16Arabia has to do their own marketing everything but from Apple's prospective
1:04:20they want everyone who buys an iOS device two types in Twitter app to end
1:04:24up with a good one
1:04:25like one that Apple agrees is good one that everyone agrees is good enough to
1:04:29sort through tons and tons of crap I think that's bad experience for Apple's
1:04:33customers not gonna on any individual based developer deserves to be at the
1:04:37top or whatever but just in terms of how satisfied as the user with that
1:04:40experience of typing in shopping list and finding a good job especially with
1:04:44no trials and just be another form of torture PCB like download trial delete
1:04:48download proudly download trial delete we want some way to like AC was saying
1:04:53to look at an application in to be able to tell is this going to be good and I
1:04:58being scammed am I being full of users cannot trust these people in these
1:05:02reviews right and you know that's why I think it's very important to
1:05:07draw distinction here that you know in air quotes discoverability that weren't
1:05:13alone that's not a problem
1:05:15search is Apple's problem and search ranking and you know so making it so
1:05:22that if you search for shopping list and the App Store and you know making it so
1:05:26that mostly good / popular apps show up on top that's important and their search
1:05:32engine sucks I there's no app store search has always sucked so you know
1:05:39that's that they they have tons of room for improvement and they really should
1:05:43be working on that however you're still mostly on your own you know assume they
1:05:49give assume they make good search you know let's let's say they fix it
1:05:53honestly it's probably not happening anytime soon but let's be realistic here
1:05:56but assume they actually did make really good search then and so it would be kind
1:06:02of Google life which is like the most popular generally the most like Valley
1:06:08popular things would generally ranked on top for for any given terms they can't
1:06:12use Google thing because Google is all based on the way other people linked to
1:06:14them but they web store is closed ecosystem and the problem with a closed
1:06:18ecosystem of the App Store in terms of searches you do what is your signal for
1:06:21determining what's good or not you can't use user activity is a simple because
1:06:26users are not like independent entities like because if you if you keywords spam
1:06:31you'll get boosted if you spam people breaking down boxes you'll get boosted
1:06:36up in terms of over 1000 that ranks but lots of scummy things that you can do
1:06:39and that's the only thing that affects the signals user activity so if you can
1:06:43convince tons of users to download the application and they'll give it one star
1:06:47reviews but you pay for five times more five star reviews are just random people
1:06:51around the world you'll be high ranked have all the signals the Death Star says
1:06:55good which is why their search algorithm put this crap near the top because those
1:06:59people have you know sort of game system to get near the top of that the only
1:07:02input signal then like apples at the mercy of its own rules that in every
1:07:07time it changes the rules people discovering people game and again which
1:07:10is why the top results for almost any category of APIs filled with crap
1:07:14applications and
1:07:16like one solution is to open up the ecosystem like the web where you know
1:07:21you have to do all the work of the SEO battling stop the Google does with a
1:07:27figure out when people make a link farms and combat that is a constant stream of
1:07:31battling but within a very narrowly defined App Store with no other similar
1:07:35coming into this you know like resembled a social networking type signal of I'm
1:07:40friends with this person therefore their opinions and ratings mean more to me
1:07:43than these random other people who I don't know or some other source of
1:07:46signal it's difficult for Apple to ever make a search that doesn't suck not
1:07:50because they don't know what they're doing but because any criteria that you
1:07:54choose to rent on will be gamed inside this little bubble oh yeah I mean that
1:07:59was always a problem with my first job was enterprise search and that was a big
1:08:03problem
1:08:04enterprise search even is like if your job as a search engine is to search
1:08:09through this company's intranet and they're like tens of thousands or
1:08:13millions of documents they haven't liked file stores and stuff there's no there's
1:08:18no Pagerank information they're like there's no helpful way to rank results
1:08:24of any kind of importance or or popularity there and if you do the if
1:08:28you do the sort of incompetent but not evil thing to say well as track activity
1:08:32and you could say well people search for vacations schedulers people search for
1:08:37the word vacation on the internet and you know eighty percent of the people
1:08:42search for vacation click on this link you must be really good will it means
1:08:45that link probably can't be at the top for whatever reason and everybody clicks
1:08:48on top and everyone goes to it is disappointed by it because it's like
1:08:51three years ago the schedule and as more people do that it gets higher and higher
1:08:56in the rankings and just get cemented as the number one matches everybody this is
1:09:00two years ago
1:09:01vacation schedule like that's that's an example where you don't have any other
1:09:04input signal so any errors that you have when you're out with them just become
1:09:08magnified by things that you didn't intend I totally see that
1:09:11the App Store on the topless workers out there like you know what is it the same
1:09:17expression I can remember this on the chat room where the rich get richer
1:09:20that's not it but it's like that anyway that's good we'll go with that but yeah
1:09:24you get in the top of topless and everyone sees you know topless made by
1:09:27you which makes you hire in the topless and when you talk about discovered that
1:09:30we're talking about is like say I'm not on the top list I'm unknown I didn't
1:09:35scan my way to the top
1:09:36I don't have a popular application how do I do a breakthrough how do I get
1:09:40people to know that I exist I believe I have a good application that's this
1:09:44quote unquote discovered billion that's where marketing you have to do your own
1:09:47market you can expect Apple to help you get in get in the face of you know get
1:09:52on the topless how do I break into the top results but you could do its gonna
1:09:55be stuffed apples hopefully battling for you have to do something else is not a
1:09:58problem to figure out how do I go from zero into the topless but it is not a
1:10:02problem to say look at the ecosystem of apps within any search term or any
1:10:06category as a handful of applications that we think are great and we can't
1:10:10editorially hand-picked you know every single category that we should have some
1:10:13kind of algorithm that will put up the applications that if you talk to anyone
1:10:18on the street that would agree are good you know our popular or high quality or
1:10:23not pieces and that's also a bit of exploration to you know this is this is
1:10:28hard for a lot of people to to even recognized as a possibility or two to
1:10:32judge or accept but it's also possible that you're a Peter isn't that good or
1:10:37is not compelling you know what if what if no one's buying your app because they
1:10:42don't really want it or they're really needed enough to justify the price to
1:10:45them there's a clock yeah I mean like of buckshot in the store now for $1 and it
1:10:52makes about two to four dollars a day sometimes one but usually 24 I don't do
1:10:59any promotion of it in fact mentioning here is the first time I've even thought
1:11:03about it besides using it in months and you know that's that's a good example of
1:11:09like an everyday app you know it's it's paid it's only a dollar though that so
1:11:13it's it's paid but really chief and there is no extra promotion of it except
1:11:19a link on my relatively buried link on my site that nobody ever clicks on
1:11:23and you know it does poorly less taxes the same way I get excited if I have one
1:11:30sale in a day and I would say you know every two or three days I do get a sale
1:11:35and I've actually had a really good run of three whole days where I had one sale
1:11:39but if I see more than once in a day that's like baby let's go to dinner is
1:11:44daddy's risk it all kidding aside it's it's very much the same for me but
1:11:49that's that's that's a symptom and you know that in the Buckshot sounds like
1:11:53that's a symptom of a lot of different conditions one of which in my case is
1:11:59late and probably your case too there's tons of competition has tons of other
1:12:03apps many of them free at do roughly the same thing and this is an area like
1:12:08Apple could do very well to improve how we were able to communicate what our app
1:12:12does like that there is a rumor couple weeks ago they then able to video in one
1:12:18apt description and the end people are thinking of what if they enable video
1:12:22for all apps in the future and you know and I suppose that comes with pluses and
1:12:26minuses the pluses are you could show off more of your app and it'd be easier
1:12:30to sell a paid app upfront if people who watch a video about it right there in
1:12:34the App Store and you can kind of show off how how good it is to me it's good
1:12:38but I'm downside is you'd expect to make a video which is time-consuming and
1:12:43potentially expensive so there's there's all sorts of plus or minus is there but
1:12:49you know the fact is the absence of very crowded place and if you're if your app
1:12:53is selling very badly especially if it's paid up front I mean Instapaper was not
1:12:57selling very well in its last year before so I mean it didn't sell that
1:13:02well because I was it was a paid app in a crowded App Store like people think
1:13:06I'm immune to all these effects but I'm not and look at buckshot it's it's out
1:13:11there for a buck and no one buys it
1:13:13you do this like popularity on the internet only take you so far and so the
1:13:21bigger problem here is not that that Apple has to improve discoverability you
1:13:27know in quotes it's the App Store is really crowded and maybe your app just
1:13:31isn't taking off in sales because it isn't that compelling for that many
1:13:36people
1:13:37or there is the need for that kind of app but someone else is doing it for
1:13:40free or had or is you know spending more on advertising or or is you know sending
1:13:47promo codes to all the people who are on the Mac blogs or something like that and
1:13:50other things you have to do to get noticed and if your app is really great
1:13:54even if used to a little bit of promotion it rapidly great it will get
1:13:58noticed it will spread people find it like that's how I know we all know what
1:14:03the good Twitter app so we could probably name all of them are even if we
1:14:05don't use them ourselves and the reason we know is because people who write
1:14:09about applications review iOS applications who are you a lot of I was
1:14:14applications who have popular technology blogs talk about their applications of
1:14:18their interview sometimes they ask what your favorite male application what's
1:14:22your favorite to do like people talk about things and you know just through
1:14:25word of mouth and old fashioned this is the author of organic marketing in
1:14:28addition to the regular marketing people doing advertising on podcast buying ads
1:14:32in magazines giving promotion code stay ready getting reviewed if you actually
1:14:36make a good application that most people who have you had given you know four or
1:14:40five stars or thumbs up a generally positive review you will eventually
1:14:45start to gain traction and the tragedy of that situation is where I made an
1:14:50awesome a patina crowded market but like mine is a popular one its IT people
1:14:54think it's interesting people think it's got a new take on the genre or it's a
1:14:58great example of the forum has lots of features and its high-quality
1:15:03application everybody likes it and people go to the AppStore and search for
1:15:06that with a generic term because they can remember your name
1:15:10remember your name they can't find it and then just under 10 the results of
1:15:14crap and that's where you're just being handicapped by the App Store you like
1:15:18unless they have a direct link to my product with the exact iTunes you're out
1:15:21if people search for me they're very likely to find a clone application in an
1:15:26unrelated application or just generally be distracted by crappy other
1:15:30applications that are not what they're looking for even if I get them to go
1:15:33there try to find my application that is terrible
1:15:36that's where you feel like Apple's actively impairing what would otherwise
1:15:39be a successor you have a great application it's you know it's the new
1:15:44version Tweetbot go find it
1:15:45people can't remember what it was they search for Twitter and tweet bodies on
1:15:48page 17 and no one ever finds me and you know there's obviously a lot I can do
1:15:53there but if your abs barely selling it is not because you don't have enough
1:15:58reviews that's that's not the reason and and let's say you had a bunch of you
1:16:04that putting in one of these stupid dialogues and then you're at your sales
1:16:08go up like you know 10% the next week or something how's it going to last and
1:16:13what else are you willing to do to keep that going and is it really worth it you
1:16:17know it the fact is like if your app is selling very badly
1:16:21chances are it's because it's not that necessary or not that compelling or not
1:16:25priced right or something like that and you to change something it's it's not
1:16:29about Lake juicing the sales you have it's about either dropping your price
1:16:35they got some other way to make to make money make make a free no doin a
1:16:39purchase or you know dropped to a buck and see if that helps
1:16:43after the market demands or find find your audience because like say you're
1:16:47trying to sell nursing clock and you've just been advertising on Mac tech
1:16:51websites you know you gotta find like where we're our new mothers hanging out
1:16:55maybe you know find the old days you've got to use Nikkor be posted then you get
1:17:00more sales from when you think of posting
1:17:02yeah I'm crossing the streams had used that existing its active thing at the
1:17:06same time that there anyway you have to find where your audience lives and
1:17:09advertised in that context what podcast they listen to what sites they visit
1:17:12maybe that's the problem maybe it's not the rap sucks maybe you just haven't
1:17:15found the audience and maybe there's an audience of people who want really
1:17:18complicated nursing clogs and yours is a simple find the people who want simple
1:17:22things like that you know it's it's the same product marketing thing is you know
1:17:26as any other to prague fine getting the right features of the right price and
1:17:30getting that message in front of the right people
1:17:32great writing applications are not the way to do that especially since I said
1:17:37if there really is no hard-and-fast evidence that getting more ratings or
1:17:43higher
1:17:43getting more ratings by bugging people is going to help move you up their rank
1:17:48in any significant
1:17:49well people say it works I I have no support this like I i treated the other
1:17:53day at like there is one version of Instapaper that that due to an App Store
1:17:57publishing bogus this is when when everything was being published broken
1:18:01signatures and they couldn't log online for like a day two years ago whenever
1:18:05that was that version of Instapaper once it was fixed and republished was not
1:18:10reviewable and it was in the store with no reviews for however long that was the
1:18:16latest version I forgot how long I think it was at least a few weeks maybe even
1:18:19longer maybe even a couple of months and it seemed to make no difference in what
1:18:25my average daily sales were like none at all and yes sure not every opportunity
1:18:28you know just like this they're they're obviously different editions on
1:18:32everything but that was just one day appoint a lot of people have given other
1:18:35data points saying like well one release I had no reviews and then I didn't sell
1:18:41that many in the next release had a bunch of using a lot more that could
1:18:45also be due to different factors like it's it's hard to run controlled
1:18:47experiments in the App Store so it's you know it's it's hard to really say
1:18:52whether it works definitively or not
1:18:55chances are a little bit the question is whether it works enough to make it worth
1:19:00it to you to have that quality reduction and and that that depends on what your
1:19:04priorities lie I think the reason that the big good app developers are
1:19:09resorting to their rating dialog boxes as a way to combat the the crappy
1:19:15developers like if you go to some crappy application it will have little
1:19:20histogram will have a huge number of five star ratings at base camp there
1:19:23with and then they'll be a bunch of like one started like you shape whatever if
1:19:29you make a really popular application that everybody loves especially since it
1:19:34doesn't spend its time writing reviews are reading applications what you'll see
1:19:37is a bunch of angry people who read it one star because of backlash because
1:19:41they read about it in seven different websites and they tried it and they
1:19:44didn't like it so like I read about these websites in their rooms I was
1:19:46great but i dont think its great once I wanna start when stark and all the
1:19:50people who love your application are not going to rate it and you're like geez
1:19:53this is not a one-star application or a two-star obligation I really think this
1:19:58is a four star in every place 23 viewed it and every person that's used it is
1:20:01said it's great
1:20:02why am I reading so bad and if someone does a search with their crappy search
1:20:05system and sees will this thing has an average of 4.8 and this one has an
1:20:10average of 3.2 3.2 1 month must suck in reality the four point eight one guy
1:20:15scandal is reviewed by paying people to rate it five stars or whatever and no
1:20:19one rated one star because no there are no legitimate users of that application
1:20:22because no one ever willingly downloaded to pay for it and the application that
1:20:26is actually good just has the backslash Nagar backs election backlash there you
1:20:33go
1:20:33is the word that backlash negative views and not enough positive ones maybe have
1:20:38some positive ones but not enough and that will bring this developer to feel
1:20:41justified in saying look I worked hard and supplication it gets great reviews
1:20:44every magazine and website that says good I know I have a lot of users whose
1:20:48people are buying it please can you go on rate my application I think this is
1:20:52what leads good applications to go bad good applications to throw in your face
1:20:56and I like box that says please read my application because they're fighting
1:21:00against that crap and that's another case where I think if Apple did
1:21:04something about the crap in the App Store these developers would feel less
1:21:08pressure and there would be less justified in saying well I'm just asking
1:21:13my happy users of my application it's popular to rate things I don't ask them
1:21:17in and all the crap applications do ask them to pay people to my application
1:21:22looks worse when people buy less and again the role that ablaze in this is
1:21:27due to get rid of the bad stuff is something you said earlier John kind of
1:21:31got me to thinking a little bit and I was wondering you know you had said
1:21:35something about like the facebook facebook if occasion if that's even a
1:21:40word which is now of the App Store and you know hey 12 of your friends are
1:21:47using this app or whatever kind of thinking that firstly imagine if on the
1:21:52App Store you could see that nato X number of your Facebook contacts or
1:21:59Twitter followers or or the people you're following on Twitter would
1:22:02probably an even better metric
1:22:04X number of those people have downloaded this app and then separately why number
1:22:10of that same group actually have this app on their device and that would be
1:22:15really cool and you know that would be a tremendous amount of data and yes it's a
1:22:19little bit creepy but if it was all can I miss you could never find out who
1:22:23those people were maybe would be ok that's when I said that Facebook
1:22:27application of whatever I was saying in a negative sense because that's a
1:22:30privacy thing where the facebook facebook does that but like I would not
1:22:34want the App Store to buy the fault show even even just counts for because if you
1:22:40see an application like if you know if you friend like two people right and you
1:22:46see the number on like your guide to getting a divorce application go up by
1:22:50one you know that's one of your friends and you know which one is like totally
1:22:54can't be the default it has to be totally opt-in it can't be like facebook
1:22:59but that's the reason Facebook and other things do it by default this because
1:23:02they can harvest lots of good signal from these relationships in these
1:23:07activities and I don't think I should do that but there is there is a place
1:23:12between what Apple is doing and what Facebook does even if you just look at
1:23:17something like more like when Amazon does Amazon stuff it's basically like
1:23:20the App Store in their reviews we're just a bunch of anonymous people most of
1:23:23whom were angry writing things that may or may not be true all what is Amazon
1:23:27had one tiny extra thing Amazon ads is the ability of other people to respond
1:23:33to reviews or write a big angry view and say I got this thing home and it didn't
1:23:37work as advertised and it is supposed to do this and it said it did that involve
1:23:40block just have one person respond and say oh you didn't see the whatever
1:23:44switcher you have to know that you have to look it up to the whatever and then
1:23:47it will do the thing that you wanted or if you had read the manual you would
1:23:50realize that you have to do this stuff
1:23:52thing that's it all they've added is just another level of sort of anonymous
1:23:56random garbage even that is better than the App Store just one big long linear
1:24:01listen if you're lucky you can scroll through twenty pages and find some
1:24:04person correcting somebody who said something totally bogus and bad that's
1:24:07one tiny step towards the direction of I see that seven of my trusted friends
1:24:12have installed the Senate launched in the last day which is totally creepy
1:24:14Facebook stuff it is creepy but nevertheless I could I feel like there's
1:24:19a way in which it could be only slightly creepy but very very useful and the
1:24:24actual point I was trying to drive ad is what if this is what topsy was for
1:24:29because top seeds of my limited understanding top season it was built
1:24:33for handling massive amounts of data and to me the only really massive amounts of
1:24:39data that happen probably cares about if not Twitter itself is their retail
1:24:45stores and the App Store in announcing the top see necessarily is going to do
1:24:50this weird thing that I just concocted about who me how many of your friends
1:24:53have this and how many of your friends have some devices but I could easily see
1:24:57it Missy topsy being used for either one of these things and the other popular
1:25:02thing that a few listeners have written about and I think makes sense is if I
1:25:05beacons are sprinkled throughout Apple retail stores perhaps aggregating that
1:25:11data in seen speaking of being creepy where people walking within an Apple
1:25:16store because at that point with enough I beacons and if you have the app
1:25:20installed on your phone
1:25:21presumably you would be able to maybe even know that much information usage
1:25:26data that's going through Google creepy at like you know what happened just
1:25:29tracks every time you launch an application and someone suggested
1:25:32demarco that you respond to your blog web they tracked how long you use an
1:25:35application which almost any metric you pick up can be gained as I think Marco
1:25:38pointed out with the how long the use of its punishing applications to get you in
1:25:42and out quickly
1:25:43the application is sufficient that you don't need to spend a long time and that
1:25:46application gets punished versus the one that keeps you inside the application
1:25:50because cumbersome to use like a metric you pick is gonna have some downsides
1:25:54but there are tons and tons of venues to get some other signal in here and you
1:25:59just have to be careful and how do you pick them but I think you need some more
1:26:02input
1:26:03have to get the closed ecosystem it's much easier to gain and if you have lots
1:26:07of different kinds of input that are more difficult to control like the App
1:26:12Store viewer you know the sky people can pay people to leave hafez all reviews
1:26:15and stuff they will have a much harder time they can't what they can't do is
1:26:19pay every single website that reviews iOS applications to give them a good
1:26:23review that's much harder than just a one-star review so that signal that
1:26:26external signal is harder to control the internal anything that just exist inside
1:26:31the App Store is going to be a lot easier to gain anything that involves
1:26:34all of us in the trick is to find some way to get useful signal from us in a
1:26:37way that's not creepy doesn't track every single thing that we do it doesn't
1:26:41you know violate her privacy but showing everybody which applications were
1:26:44downloading and using and win but just get this possum out I suppose tops you
1:26:49can be involved in looking at that would like any time by any company that you
1:26:53know they're not gonna tell us what they're going to do and we just have to
1:26:56guess that you can do that you know i i guess that primeSense company they could
1:27:01do that I have a sensor for the TV or for the next iPad for their next iPhone
1:27:05or for their watch or for a ring they're gonna do the classes or we'll see what
1:27:12the only one that was easy was Monday but was that called the child company or
1:27:17whatever they redid the store they bought the company that that but they're
1:27:21gonna use into the store and as far as I know yes they did and and and nobody
1:27:26likes a police feel guess right about what those before they were going to be
1:27:29doing with the company when they want them you know I wouldn't have high hopes
1:27:33for Apple doing meaningful things here i mean look at how they've improved the
1:27:38App Store since its introduction
1:27:42the crickets sound effect well they kind of its kind of shut things in one
1:27:49direction that it pops out there someplace else and they should be done
1:27:52over there and then anything pops out and so they're kind of doing stuff but
1:27:56it's all just like equilibrium you know the shift in one direction should
1:28:00packing other there's never any like big cleaning push into a whole new realm of
1:28:05wind it's always address whatever the most egregious problem is but actually
1:28:09caused another one in the address that want to cause another one kind of
1:28:12staying in the middle of a problem with the App Store during this whole time is
1:28:16during the time that they've been working on trying to tweak it and make
1:28:20sure it doesn't get too far out of line the volume has gone up like crazy and
1:28:23it's really difficult to do anything useful unless you get it exactly right
1:28:26when the volume is growing up so fast because a new kinds of problems are
1:28:29cropping up all the time in the solution that would have been perfectly viable
1:28:32and it was small is now useless and become of the new solution yet
1:28:36implemented in your gonna go up again and like Marco said if eventually you
1:28:40reach web-scale then this whole idea of having a directory where they can do
1:28:46they're like they're reproducing the web I guess Amazon does the same thing I
1:28:51Amazon Amazon I soon will always have more products in the App Store does and
1:28:56they managed to do better sort of searching recommendations is very rarely
1:29:00do I type something and Amazon and not find the thing I want I can misspelled
1:29:04it I can miss remember what it's called as long as I miss remembering in the
1:29:07same way that a bunch of other people I miss remembering Amazon seems to have to
1:29:10do a good job of keeping track but just like Google keeping track of not the the
1:29:15first day result the people click on but the first result that I should leads to
1:29:18like a sale or a lingering on a page or whatever they're doing over there at
1:29:21Amazon the company acquired merge with you know someone please help them Amazon
1:29:26well I mean who who sells out of things and make some discoverable and has a
1:29:32reasonable system for buying stuff that people tend to like Amazon right will
1:29:36hold on though but yeah you're right about that but you're also talking about
1:29:39physical goods and and and audio and things like that when i was just
1:29:44wondering is how is Amazon's Appstore for discovery and things of that nature
1:29:49problem is they don't have a lot
1:29:50perhaps no one uses it and nobody uses it but I mean even amongst the twelve
1:29:55people they use it isn't any better
1:29:57it may not be we've had a number of comments in the chat room during the
1:30:01show that apparently the Google Play Store is is really good about reviews
1:30:04and rankings and that makes sense if it's true that makes sense because
1:30:07Google is really good at search and ranking
1:30:11they they know how to do that well and they prioritize that they are probably
1:30:16totally not above keeping track of what every application is launched an Android
1:30:20phone and how long people all those stats and they get crackin on misleading
1:30:24however you know and then I try to do like but that is that's because that's
1:30:28what they do on the web they gather every ounce of signal they can on the
1:30:31web and try to block out every source of noise and gaming of the system they can
1:30:35for the entire web and that's what the whole company was founded on so of
1:30:39course the same tools on a Web Start course they're gonna do better that
1:30:43they're not see the the fireplace to talk about that but we talked about last
1:30:47week about someone saying why isn't anybody talk about this feature they
1:30:50didn't ship and whatever I was talking about the why isn't anybody talking
1:30:56about an angle but a lot of people were like I thought I did she buy just loaded
1:30:59in work and some people doing it as a joke but some people are kind of like
1:31:06half serious than I have to admit to myself like a lots of features that
1:31:11Apple shipped back to my back to my Mac feature which also has work sporadically
1:31:15for me if Apple ships a feature that has anything to do with the net it's very
1:31:22difficult to tell whether the future is missing entirely or just isn't working
1:31:24right yet because they hide all but the nuts and bolts from you so I'm back to
1:31:29my Mac isn't working if we told you that Apple removed back to my neck from OS 10
1:31:32two years ago versus oh no it's always been there to work for as far as you're
1:31:36concerned experiences the same you just it it doesn't seem to do what it's
1:31:41supposed to do and maybe this type checkbox for it but you know that's how
1:31:46far up as reputations and tree falls in the woods and it never works for anybody
1:31:50but so far upper levels reputation has fallen so far that if anything you can
1:31:55do it online people to see much it but it didn't work I mean I think App Store
1:31:59search you know because you know because searches such a hard problem
1:32:02and and you look at the different apparently very well it's not a surprise
1:32:07and Apple to the surprise I think this is the kind of problem that Apple will
1:32:12probably just never do that well like it's it's just not in their in their DNA
1:32:18to really do research and management of this large data said you know management
1:32:23of spam and Kim and everything else like it's just not what they do well and
1:32:28they've never ever shown an ability to do that kind of thing well nor a
1:32:34priority to really put a lot of resources into it and so i dont I would
1:32:38not expect the situation to change from there and before we leave this topic is
1:32:42one one more thing I want to briefly touch on which is the reason it always
1:32:44rains in here and here they are linking to your blog post about writing this
1:32:50happened and other responses to saying that Apple you said you can't ban the
1:32:56dialog boxes in the zone responded and he responded back to them this idea that
1:33:01the space mad the other one solution to this problem of the rating now I boxes
1:33:06that Apple could just say you're not allowed to put up a dialog box at Assam
1:33:09under a publication and you were saying you can make that religion can enforce
1:33:14it and you are going back and forth do you have anything more than that of them
1:33:17are you putting the blog but they're not really I mean a lot of people have
1:33:21suggested ways they could add a report button or something to get to a wooden
1:33:25actually work in practice like a few if they added a report as abuse or
1:33:31inappropriate or whatever
1:33:33button to every you I'll argue that obviously is very costly and other
1:33:38factors and then people to stop using your views
1:33:41think it's not that hard to write your own WAP overview like that looks and
1:33:46works like a dialog box and just as action as a subview of the window and
1:33:51you know what are they gonna do it but never UIView obviously they can't do
1:33:54that so there's really no like any kind of like a minor offense that lots of
1:34:01apps will do that will appear after a preview time such as spam push
1:34:07notifications which are also against the rules but they're very prevalent anyway
1:34:11I was gonna say that that's a perfect example because those already are
1:34:14against the rules you're not allowed to send people push notifications
1:34:17advertisements in it and yet many of us the push notifications which things with
1:34:22things in the look alike
1:34:23advertisements right all the time and it's for my post like it's very similar
1:34:29to that problem which is this thing already is against the rules this
1:34:32nation's already against the rules but it's really not enforced because unless
1:34:38the reviewer for a preview get this thing during like the five minutes
1:34:42they're spending with the app unless they themselves get spammed and notices
1:34:47against the rule
1:34:48they're never going to catch it really and once it's already in the wild after
1:34:52the fact like these are such relatively minor rule violations like it be
1:34:58differently if your app passes a preview and then you have a hard-coded like two
1:35:02weeks later it it becomes malware somehow that would get noticed and I
1:35:08would get shut down cuz that's like that really bad Developer Program whatever
1:35:13else fine but something like this like a minor offense like a push notification
1:35:18or write this after I like those are not major enough PR problems major enough
1:35:24offenses in the App Store that if it happened after review time Apple make a
1:35:30big effort to crack down on that and eliminate that it is not important
1:35:33enough to do everything else they have to do so realistically speaking it's
1:35:38very unlikely that Apple would ever ban these dialogues and if they did it's
1:35:44very likely would be enforced so my position on this is that I mostly agree
1:35:49with the difficulty of enforcing lewis also agree with the you know like just
1:35:53because it's difficult it can be done but I think that if if this agreement
1:35:58within Apple this is a new experience they don't want people to have that
1:36:03they're using their application and dialog box pops up in a separate
1:36:06applications they should absolutely added to the guidelines just like a
1:36:09thing that says you're not supposed to get ads and push notifications because
1:36:11Apple's decided that getting advertisements push notifications not
1:36:15the experience they wanted their phones
1:36:17enforceability I think should be not entirely separate but mostly separate
1:36:21from making the rules I think the rule against advertising pushing
1:36:24is a good rule kinda like the you know the the school zone speed limits which
1:36:29are usually set like super low it so that if if they want to they can get
1:36:33every single person's goes on a ticket gives you makes it so that like
1:36:37everybody is breaking the law and then you can you know anybody over but in
1:36:42this case I think it reasonable speed limit if you just put in a role that you
1:36:45can put up to rate me too I it's not like it's going to turn the mail what
1:36:48now we're how you gonna know that the distinct really put up a dialog box and
1:36:53who was it bad that blog post explaining like a big system of a sort of a social
1:36:58engineered system we're different people could report violations and then if
1:37:03their accuracy there reporting gives their reports a higher ranking and
1:37:06there's lots of systems that are possible
1:37:08yeah I wouldn't get too bogged down in details so that I would just say if this
1:37:12is an experienced it up things you shouldn't have put it in the guidelines
1:37:15and maybe it's incredibly spread we enforce almost never enforced the fact
1:37:21that it's there and I think it's probably easier to enforce them to push
1:37:25notification will be split over his income from like elsewhere the rate me
1:37:28think I guess it could be triggered by an external server based thing but the
1:37:31code to put the dialogue has to be in your application somewhere it's the type
1:37:36of thing where once it becomes a guideline that alone could push it off
1:37:40into the crappy section of the absurd that I was talking about before and all
1:37:44the good developers of the world applications that we all know and love
1:37:47and use all the time would comply with the guy buying because those people are
1:37:51willingly sending out push notifications rads either bases against the guidelines
1:37:54and so even you know just putting in that guideline even though it can't stop
1:37:59all the crap out from doing it just putting it there at all
1:38:03would give a position that the protocol good guys in the App Store would follow
1:38:08along with it thanks for the most part
1:38:10well but there's already like I think everyone for the most part knows that
1:38:15it's kind of not okay but most developers who are probably I'm planning
1:38:21it because they've they've with a trade if there had been a well I know it's
1:38:26kind of annoying to some people and it's kind of not okay but everyone else is
1:38:32doing it
1:38:33and I need all the help I can get myself so and that same rationale I think would
1:38:38would still be there but that cost benefit is gonna be way different if
1:38:42it's against the rules you would never knowingly put something on this tour
1:38:45that violated a kind especially it was a high profile guideline that came into
1:38:48being under circumstances like this for now Apple releases new guideline not
1:38:52allowed to operate me you would never put up an application that knowingly
1:38:55violate like it's not even subtle like it pops up and says please read this
1:38:59application your violin violation none of the good developers would willingly
1:39:04violet biggest suddenly the cost benefits like being kinda annoying but
1:39:07bubble block versus my app is going to be rejected or there's a chance my Apple
1:39:12gonna be rejected or as soon as somebody sees this I have all those backlash
1:39:16users saying you need to get this all the storied violates here but I read
1:39:19about on this website like I think all the good guys would follow you certainly
1:39:23would write you wouldn't put it up now but like I think of a guideline that
1:39:27able to come up with that you would willingly flout because you think it
1:39:30gave you some minor increase in sales you wouldn't you would just say well
1:39:33Apple's change the rules and made like my application unviable you go to
1:39:37something else you would not violate the rules and I think that does the
1:39:40functions of rules with certain not to eliminate the practice from really to
1:39:43further marginalize it and make it socially unacceptable
1:39:48agreed not to socially unacceptable but like the smart developers have a clue
1:39:52who don't plan registering new Apple IDs for the Apple Developer Program every
1:39:55two weeks to keep their business would say I can't you know I can willingly
1:40:00violate this you know something I was thinking and I know we should probably
1:40:04shouldn't get into the details of how to implement that kind of rating or to
1:40:08enforce I should say that kind of reading but it what's stopping apple
1:40:13from as part of the scan that they do for private API's what's stopping them
1:40:18from from looking for great a nap something that's passed into you I love
1:40:24you or you know just doing a string search within the within the compiled
1:40:28code for EO rate an appt only couple words away from each other and maybe
1:40:33they don't unilaterally rejected upon finding that
1:40:36but maybe that you know raises a warning to the reviewers saying take a look at
1:40:42this kind of heuristics they could pull off and again this totally not gonna
1:40:46stop anybody wants to do it but you gotta text data from a survey you can
1:40:49obviously did you know whatever but but yeah that's because more so than push
1:40:54notifications come from Ty Lee elsewhere her and I think you have a fighting
1:40:59chance it an automated tool that might bring up a flag on this you know and and
1:41:03even if the reaction to that was just that the reviewer would contact the
1:41:06developer and say you don't have a dog bites that pop up to say rate and then
1:41:12they have to lie to you to get through them so no it doesn't have anything like
1:41:15that and now you got them on records you know telling a lie and you know I think
1:41:20it would be helpful I think we're good thanks like two or three sparked this
1:41:25week
1:41:26Backblaze cover and audible and we will see you next week now the show they
1:41:35didn't even mean to begin
1:41:37it was accidental
1:41:44Casey
1:41:48because it was a depth and you can find the show and he was a team markle
1:42:31I'm so upset I missed the joke somebody the chaplain at the much better joke of
1:42:37its pronounced TX 10 that would have been much better I I wish I would have
1:42:43said that instead
1:42:47there was one other additional attack on the great thing to hear these dialogues
1:42:56work to kick you over to the absurd to review it is they call special URLs that
1:43:01wants the App Store app to particular pages and in iOS 6 and earlier it was
1:43:07possible to link directly to the review form for a nap and in seven that was no
1:43:12longer possible in seven
1:43:14the best you can do is linked to the apps page in the App Store one thing
1:43:20Apple could do to me to combat this in a way that would actually be more
1:43:25effective than policy is to make it stop working now they can't make links to the
1:43:31App Store lab stopped working but one thing somebody suggested on Twitter
1:43:36somewhere sorry I forgot who it was
1:43:38is that what if they make it so that if the App Store is invoked by a URL for
1:43:44their app don't allow the input of a reviewer rating that's an interesting
1:43:49point I can be frustrating from a user's perspective because I can rate the
1:43:57application and then it's like what did you get that window of their from a link
1:44:01from another and that they don't remember what that means it looks like
1:44:04their website is broken I don't know if he could that's like you know the people
1:44:10who try to punish their dog for pooping connect you yelling at the dog with the
1:44:14poopy made five minutes ago one of the things they could do that that I thought
1:44:18of also is so they have I believe this is an iOS 6
1:44:22it's at least here in seven where they have this this ability to show like a
1:44:27modal sheet for the App Store look for an app within your app without kicking
1:44:32over to the App Store app and so what if they were they removed the review input
1:44:37method just for those metal sheets and then made it a policy that you were if
1:44:43you were going to link to an app whether it's you or someone else if your gonna
1:44:45lead to an app from your app from your app you have to do it through one of the
1:44:49mobile sheets and you can you are not allowed to take over to the iTunes that
1:44:54would be an easier policy to enforce you can even like you know check for those
1:44:57URLs or or even make the URL stopped working
1:45:01the tution lysing be the idea of something that is triggered from
1:45:06application lets you rate the application of that like you almost
1:45:09think that if that's the like it has to be at should be on a springboard level
1:45:14type thing but no one would ever do that I can in an application you can
1:45:17everything's coming up that's why a lot of people are talking about the idea of
1:45:20making a new website you know sort of game of fire website where people could
1:45:26read applications outside of the App Store and outside of anything else but
1:45:30all you do is kind of re-creating a crowd-sourced review website in terms of
1:45:35websites to review iOS absence something that Apple people think about this at
1:45:41the same time as I do sometimes it's like just got entirely rid of ratings
1:45:45and reviews and everything and all they were was a directory of things you could
1:45:48download and they had a release notes that was it and they used signal that
1:45:53they didn't show you to rank the applications that was probably
1:45:57mysterious do whatever they do now but it would actually work in my search for
1:46:012010 best what our clients on the first page of results and I wouldn't care
1:46:05about the sort order but then people want reviews and people want all the
1:46:10things that Apple has signed up to do that and other kind of stuck with it
1:46:13said they had never had refused the left entirely to websites to review their
1:46:18stuff that would be a different story maybe that would be an acceptable thing
1:46:23to do but if you're probably asking them to do if you so kind of stuck at like 11
1:46:28you start censoring stuff now you're on the hook for anything that comes through
1:46:31once you start accepting ratings and reviews now you're on the Apple has not
1:46:36done that they win they want the control I don't think they'd like that the
1:46:41official source of whether a nap is good or bad is not controlled by them
1:46:45well you know the thing we didn't even talk about that every like everyone
1:46:51agrees that it should be possible for the developer of application to leave a
1:46:55response to review for both parties involved in that process up to that
1:46:59thing because nothing is more frustrating as developer having someone
1:47:02say I got your to-do application but doesn't let me defeat delete items
1:47:06one-star
1:47:08viewer right actually does like you do you have to swipe or something like that
1:47:12right
1:47:13it doesn't mean that the developers going to be correct or is official in
1:47:17any capacity but just simple matter of like this then you know you can edit
1:47:21your review in the people who are believed that nine Casey review all time
1:47:26are constantly adding you can edit your views of a good response they actually
1:47:29you can't sweat like you know when to turn into like arguing back and forth
1:47:33but if they just get they both have their one things as 11 review and one
1:47:38response from the developer the two of them could fight can continually
1:47:41updating their response to review if they want to I think it's
1:47:43counterproductive but a smart developer would leave in the third hit of response
1:47:47to the problems that were you know raised there and that would be that and
1:47:52I guess this year there is every single review having a contradictory sponsoring
1:47:59the developer and that would be annoying to read like a big giant argument but
1:48:03under something like that they have to have some way to have other people be
1:48:08able to vote down vote though not like all roads lead back to Apple Miller
1:48:13having to learn how to do social stuff which they don't know how to do as
1:48:16evidenced by paying debt situation for everybody I think what this boils down
1:48:20to is the need for reviews is to give to give more inputs when someone's browsing
1:48:27in the end they stumble upon your app to give more signal as to whether the app
1:48:33is good and works the way it should and if there's if there are more ways that
1:48:37Apple could could communicate that and a trial would certainly help for paid apps
1:48:42but I don't think we're gonna get trials it there were other ways if as I said
1:48:48earlier videos you know let people upload videos
1:48:51develop a response to comments are 22 reviews that is another way for
1:48:57developers to communicate their quality level like if if if a developer responds
1:49:02to every negative review in a really good way like in a helpful way to say
1:49:06like even if they're even if the person review something negative in their right
1:49:09and developers like you know sorry that we're working out for the next update
1:49:13you know and then you can diffuse on the invalid wants to see all actually exist
1:49:18here or the bug reporting is fixed in this version that's up now you know you
1:49:23can that's still a venue for you to communicate
1:49:26more signal to two browsers to tell them like this is an app that's worth
1:49:31checking out of this worth buying as a developer doesn't like everything about
1:49:35their responses because then it becomes and coming up on additional reviewers to
1:49:38say don't believe anyone develop responses they're entirely fabrications
1:49:42you know what I'm thinking that was a formalized structured system for doing
1:49:47the equivalent of blurbs in the back of the book thrilling adventure says the
1:49:51new york times or whatever and if you had a formal structured system so that
1:49:55where you had to link back to be actual source that's another way to pull an
1:49:59external signal back when you know macworld gives it five mice right New
1:50:03York Times New York Times review of this applications as Baba block link back to
1:50:08that article link back to the Macworld thing so that people can read it to you
1:50:13this is a well reviewed application in fact I can follow these links to confirm
1:50:16that they didn't make up these blurbs and I can actually read the review is
1:50:20and again that's how you gonna police that Mr think goes away and blah blah
1:50:24but these are all things that have worked in other contexts to give people
1:50:26signal that the thing they're looking at is this book popular to lots of people
1:50:31like this book you know and so it was like oh I hear about it on the news all
1:50:34the time and this is a very popular book arts here done monologues and a late
1:50:38night show whatever how to know that the Hunger Games is an exciting thing oh
1:50:42they're making a movie of it are you know all the other way is the single
1:50:46again unfortunately I'll have occasions have not reached that level I guess
1:50:50Angry Birds kind of maybe words with friends
1:50:53needed to that level that some people here are these things so that must be
1:50:56the application and i could even in that case you like oh well we're friends used
1:50:59to be good
1:51:00screwed all up and now it's annoying to use and how do you learn about that
1:51:05later
1:51:06it's not an easy problem and yeah people are people are inscrutable things that I
1:51:11think Apple wishes they they weren't