0:00:00by doing this podcast night like tonight why that's what I was going to do I said
0:00:03well you know I might be doing a podcast depending how late Marco you know his
0:00:07schedule whatever but if not I have a blog posted on 25 since like Dan Frakes
0:00:12thing about the macro is the Mac Pro many think I have my car and I i I have
0:00:17this week's blog post I need right that and I haven't stopped a chance to do it
0:00:21I try I wrote like two or three paragraphs of it while taking my son to
0:00:24swim lessons today while he was in the swimming pool of Russia Rodi my
0:00:28paintings inspired by Jason still do that wasn't actually wasn't that awful
0:00:31but he was still here and I started writing again and I said you know
0:00:36podcast on it so you are thwarting me from posting to my blog by continually
0:00:40like last night I had a podcast can blog about it tonight I got a hot again
0:00:44tomorrow talk about it actually was gonna talk about that particular topic
0:00:48in in the podcast last night that I was on one of the topics when the question
0:00:53this topic came up and I debated saying something but I said ok we'll hear this
0:00:57and I talked for like two and a half minutes that ok now just make a coherent
0:01:01and put it in writing my blog presents a challenge so yeah I mean many of my
0:01:08podcast discussions were inadvertently draft for blog posts are much better
0:01:14considered and that's that's what my body and you know talking it out
0:01:19rambling and then distill it down or whatever but but but you know what I
0:01:23should do it anyway because he liked that Pakistan last night is going up on
0:01:26like the 20th or something about how it goes up my blog post will have been up
0:01:29for weeks but this up tomorrow but anyway i dont wanna talk about the me
0:01:35broken sci-fi I have like I have every time I think of a blog was like it you
0:01:39just can't write a blog what's the matter of two paragraphs like all have a
0:01:42great to paragraph idea and it never comes out of it though it's like nobody
0:01:47goes out four pages and pages I look back at it like two paragraphs and its
0:01:51eight it was two paragraphs and it came out as fluoride be ok but aight I feel
0:01:55like there's something going wrong so I have one very simple idea that should be
0:02:00really three sentences but then I read the story sounds as I say if you don't
0:02:04already know what I mean you don't understand the reasons expand expanding
0:02:07expand until I feel like I'm bringing until I i feel like im bringing some new
0:02:11people long who don't already know
0:02:13i'm saying you don't already agree with me so what we gonna not talk about it
0:02:18that no I'm not going to talk about Marco just blogging this is now the site
0:02:25did that if I mentioned it all you decide yet everyone knows that stupid
0:02:28right to my blog post I think I think with the think everyone has been talking
0:02:34about what they could do with the Mac Pro every six months there's a way of a
0:02:39discussion about it and so many people think that it's kind of weird modular
0:02:45thing where you get a bunch of Mac minis and check them by a some mystery
0:02:48thunderbolts fast enough to do anything meaningful with the PlayStation 3 is
0:02:52gonna be like with the Cell processor runs together to make your games like
0:02:57better did you hear about that and it's just like it doesn't like all these fans
0:03:01who the people have about this in addition to having a lot of technical
0:03:05challenges mostly involving the speed and bandwidth of the connectors between
0:03:09the between the individual parts but it also just amazingly complicated really
0:03:16inelegant to set up like what I hate about the iMac is that once you have
0:03:24some kind of powerful demanded an iMac usually end up having to discover new
0:03:28hard drive enclosures and all these like all these bolt-on thing shutting the
0:03:31outside are connected to it that with a Mac Pro just put inside and and it's you
0:03:36know end with many advantages there so I feel any any move towards less internal
0:03:43storage less internal capacity for expansion any move in that direction
0:03:50really eliminates quite a lot of the Mac Pros appeal and a lot of people just you
0:03:54know they don't they don't really distinguish between the Z online and the
0:03:59regular consumers CPU line but that's also a very important distinction
0:04:02because like to see online means you can have two sockets and lots of RAM slots
0:04:07and you get all sorts of benefits like ECC RAM but she knows it just makes your
0:04:13computer a little bit more stable again a little bit less likely to have some
0:04:16problems down the road
0:04:17or it you know it'll crash in a little kernel panic like three fewer times in
0:04:22its lifespan but does not really matter to you if there's all sorts of these
0:04:25benefits that you get with this with the server great components with these giant
0:04:29expensive motherboards with these giant PCI Express slots at have really really
0:04:33high bandwidth you know if you have if you if you wanna do multiple video cards
0:04:37to have like six monitors you can do that with a Mac pretty can't do anything
0:04:40else so there's there's all these like this all these like edge cases that with
0:04:47the macro you can do all of them most people don't need all of them but a lot
0:04:52of people need one of them I feel like my blog post kind of made it sound like
0:04:59I that I thought that the iMac could solve these problems and and it can't my
0:05:03point with the blog post was not that I have the iMac is good enough for most
0:05:08Mac Pro customers necessarily but that it's good enough it's a good enough
0:05:13solution for Apple to release to address most of these customers not it not
0:05:19saying that and that's that's a weird distinction to make but like it's it's
0:05:23good enough for Apple to deal with them by just releasing this and you know as a
0:05:29user has lots of like that I as a user can say I would like as much and almost
0:05:35everybody has responded saying like I work in video or work in science or
0:05:39something like that I i working something where that would suck in some
0:05:43way and that's true but there's already tons of small markets that Apple doesn't
0:05:49address because usually cause they're too small and their relatives
0:05:51unprofitable you know if if a whole bunch of high-end workstation users had
0:05:57to switch to Windows but many of them already have four different video
0:06:00editing program since Apple pissed off all the video editors of Final Cut Pro
0:06:0310 like if if some of these people have to switch to Windows for their video
0:06:08editing needs i dont the Apple cares that much like if they can afford it
0:06:12easily they will but like I think that that's that's specialized market is it
0:06:19something Apple's willing to lose I don't be sad to see my tower with the
0:06:24server hardware go because I don't know if I can be attributed to it having
0:06:28server grade components in it
0:06:30this machine has been so incredibly reliable my 2008 Mac Pro it has been the
0:06:35most reliable probably the most reliable computer have ever owned BC of my
0:06:39favorite Mac ever the SEC 30 that had some reliability problems mostly related
0:06:43to the fact that I had a color video card shoved in it which is something I
0:06:46have never foresaw so some flaky issues there and had had a bum power supply
0:06:51early on but like this Mac Pro has just been a hundred percent champ like
0:06:55nothing has gone wrong and I think I had one bad game that went wrong when it
0:07:00went wrong it was so obvious that it went wrong you could still like the
0:07:03machine Buddha but I just had less RAM and a little thing and it show which
0:07:07bank wasn't showing up you know it was just like everything worked exactly the
0:07:11way it's supposed to put a million different hard drives in and I've added
0:07:15to the RAM never any problems with noise heat no fan bearings and gone bad you
0:07:20know just nothing like and I i cant imagine a machine replacing it being
0:07:26more satisfying than it was when it was new you know oh yeah
0:07:30in 2008 I can and it was cheap it was before they were like super duper
0:07:34expensive her crappy think its obvious and I i turnovers because it because
0:07:38he's here and is it because the CPUs are relatively under clock to what they
0:07:42could possibly the clock to is because the cooling of such overkill because of
0:07:45the case
0:07:46g5 you know like whatever it is about it is going to do said go are going to be a
0:07:53dick is not going to leave my house of course yeah man I sold my soul my
0:07:57version of a computer to Dan and a hundred and forty bucks to ship it to
0:08:02him it's you know it's it's a fact the Mac Pros a fantastic computer for these
0:08:10type of users like I like I don't ever see myself going laptop full time and
0:08:14being happy with it you know I did it I did it last year for a while and and it
0:08:19was ok but there are just so many downsides to it for me and so many
0:08:22little annoyances like you I mention a neutral that I like every to be stock
0:08:25and clean that's why he hadn't discovered and buyers hard drive
0:08:29enclosures like i dont i dont wanna have two full-time million different things
0:08:32to make my computer fast and stable and having space for what I'm using it for
0:08:36and yeah but couldn't you just get like one of those absurdly overpriced
0:08:43Thunderbolt docs not done well I could but you can't you can't you can't put a
0:08:49video card game behind right and you know there's a lot of people for whom
0:08:55that solves the problem like a lot of video editors don't use internal storage
0:08:59for their projects they use external drives in with you know raid 0 and then
0:09:04they have a fighting chance cards I mean a lot of them
0:09:07not not as the big production houses but like a lot of smaller shops and small
0:09:12individual video editors
0:09:13users like external og driverless vehicle that does the high-end
0:09:18enclosures are made of metal and just have to consume drugs and those you know
0:09:22I think most people like it's not so much that they need a Mac Pro is that
0:09:25they need a machine that's built with the philosophy of the Mac Pro in terms
0:09:30of like reliability like it's you know it's not they're paying for they'd
0:09:33rather pay more for something that would be reliable than pay less for something
0:09:38that's just as good but is made sort of two consumer spec right now and that's
0:09:42why I'm that way too I would like it my computer gets flaky that is a severe
0:09:47problem for me in so many ways you know it'd be a problem for this podcast
0:09:51podcast may be a problem with my work and my clothing if I have to be randomly
0:09:55rebooting every every few days for some weird issue for some weird reason that's
0:10:00a severe disruption that adds up and you know for people who who that really is
0:10:05attractive to it is worth it to pay more to get a high-end tower especially like
0:10:10any said these things last forever in your 2008 Mac Pro is still pretty good
0:10:14today by today's standards my you know my 2010-2010 Mac Pro is still the
0:10:24fastest Mac foremost single-threaded tasks and among the fastest max for
0:10:29anything paralyzed double
0:10:30I'm still playing games that are released this year even though I have
0:10:36you know the 8800 is not a good video card it's still you know it's better
0:10:41than what you get on a Macbook and maybe on anymore but but certainly for maybe
0:10:46not a MacBook Pro MacBook people by like when you get a
0:10:50get the laptop off to college they get a MacBook because the parent just wanna
0:10:54get the laptop and you can't play modern games not thing and Here I am with my
0:10:582008 computer and I can play them right i mean for us that's the kind of
0:11:01investment I wanna make I wanna that's why we want to get the biggest tightest
0:11:05asses but are they have to stick it in a box about the RAM slots may get reliable
0:11:09and give me internal storage and when you when you do want to get rid of the
0:11:14computer if you have a few if you if you saw the computer in the next year you'll
0:11:18still get like over $1000 for it I don't sell my children are you lease puppies
0:11:25into the attic I think it's something to do with this nineteen years later their
0:11:30star if it didn't take so much power output in the basement and make a video
0:11:34server something that was the problem with old with all hardware is like it's
0:11:37not worth the power or heat or noise if you keep my Mac minis like I would I
0:11:42would put it all back many in the basement if I ever had buyers Mac Mini
0:11:45but yeah she was a problem I have with the Mac Pro having never owned one is
0:11:50that it seems contrary to everything that Apple wants you know even within
0:11:54the laptop line now RAM is getting slaughtered on the board and and hard
0:11:58drives are getting slaughtered on the board but what I'm driving it is
0:12:04everything about all the consumer grade max even the MacBook Pros there for the
0:12:10purpose of this conversation and pricing that is consumer grade all of those are
0:12:13becoming more and more integrated to use the overly just to cite the overused
0:12:18word and in the Mac Pro is is contrary to all of them and that's if consumers
0:12:24don't want crap in their way they do not like the stars tell my sister and I
0:12:31convinced her to find your place or she had a sunflower iMac another little
0:12:35stand thingy and she was alright without one and then upgrade to get you know
0:12:41that the flat-panel ones and she was her favorite thing about the computer was
0:12:45that we put on our desks are to get us up she says where's the computer I said
0:12:48that's it that's all there is that's great because that's what I always
0:12:52wanted I just want to screen I don't want some other thing in my life the
0:12:57gets in the way of me doing something recognize that they need to screen you
0:12:59need something to look at
0:13:01mouse and keyboard but do I need anything else now and so that's why the
0:13:05iMac you know making the iMac go away
0:13:09consumers love that and the Mac Pro is the opposite of that because it's the
0:13:12opposite of going away it's humongous it's you know it you can't even fit on a
0:13:17desk is it all just dominate you and that's it
0:13:21anti-consumer because consumers did not want to see crap like that whereas if
0:13:26you're someone who needs a Mac Pro or someone who wants it for to play games
0:13:29or whatever you are the type of person who is willing to accept that intrusion
0:13:33into your life of this big space heater so much of the Mac Pro commentary that
0:13:38before Mike from tech blog and writers and stuff so much of the commentary that
0:13:43focuses on I wanted to get smaller I want to get sleeker that some people who
0:13:47have never owned one and the people who own them usually love them and usually
0:13:53don't care how big it is because it's it's it's it's out of sight League you
0:13:57talking away under the desk and you don't really like my MacPro got thirty
0:14:01percent thinner I wouldn't even notice I can stand for it I can see it like I
0:14:06don't see them because I wanna take up less room but I'm like you know what the
0:14:10author of the space for two optical drives and you know you convert some of
0:14:14the storage area to be taking SSDs instead of 3.5 inch discs and like that
0:14:20point maybe maybe you're wasting space maybe you can slam it down and some of
0:14:24it is also like fashion like I would be interested in seeing a new fashion
0:14:27iteration considering we've been with this case for a long time but it's not
0:14:31like I'm saying glom at all to the back of the LCD cuz i dont want to my way
0:14:34like this a dedicated spot on the floor where it goes I could put something
0:14:38slightly smaller there but I will be fine they kept the same way that's why
0:14:43we're desperate like bargaining please just give us a new one that's not crap
0:14:48but I like and also like you know a lot of the people who make arguments about
0:14:53it or have theories about it or who judge it unfairly don't realize how
0:14:57expensive Xeons are you know they'll say oh this thing is over priced actually
0:15:03surprised but not Apple's fault Intel exactly
0:15:08exactly like if you if you look at any other stage because like they charge so
0:15:15much money for what is like a piece of crap computer at this point that's an
0:15:19out apple sold the fighting is Intel still charges that bush for I know but I
0:15:24had enough like write something build your own Mac Pro ok so tell us by let's
0:15:29pretend we buy the process is it retail price which Apple does right and then
0:15:32attempt by the RAM retail price doesn't pretend about all the parts that retail
0:15:36you like boy that case must cost $1200 to make it does not add up no it doesn't
0:15:42add up but but it isn't as far off as a lot of people think and the add-on once
0:15:47you go to like okay I wanna pumping up to dual socket with a 2.66 hurts then
0:15:52look at the difference that cost like 1500 dollars extra what the hell and
0:15:55then you look actually Intel charges like $1200 more for the for the CPA but
0:16:02you know and I think it's it's just suck sure it is such a beast but if you did
0:16:10anything to really slim it down like if you eliminated a few drive bays or if
0:16:15you made it like single socket only we should see a lot of space in the bottom
0:16:18then you are you are limiting who will buy it like you are taking people who
0:16:24used to buy Mac Pros and and you are really significantly reducing their
0:16:28motivation by Matt Brogan and and that's why you think like I do hope that Apple
0:16:34keeps it around I do hope that the next revision has some kind of solution for
0:16:38retina on the desktop hopefully they will release some kind of retina Cinema
0:16:43Display and then there'll be some kind of insane video card in the new Mac Pro
0:16:48that can drive it for some insane price premium probably but you know I'm hoping
0:16:52that's where they're going with this
0:16:53it'll be the Apple 15 entering the cinema display just what you wanted
0:16:59right
0:17:00like traveling back in time and the thing that I can't reconcile it in my
0:17:05head is that to me as a non pro pattern on Mac Pro users can send on Pro Mac
0:17:11user because I'm laptop is sufficient for me it seems so obvious to me that
0:17:18the Mac Pro just cannot continue in any even vaguely similar forms the way it is
0:17:24now because everything Apple is doing is is going in the other direction I know I
0:17:28just said that but it's just like the like first of all it is a very high
0:17:34margin product they don't make a whole lot but it is high margin and they could
0:17:38they could even raise the price premium by another 500 bucks per case and we'd
0:17:41all still by the most may prove as we continue to buy them even if the price
0:17:46premium was even bigger so they saw it the profitability angle of them i think
0:17:50is probably covered I don't I don't think if they treat it as a unit of the
0:17:54company I don't think it'll be losing money but a lot of people say oh well
0:18:01you know doesn't sell very many they should just cut it out
0:18:04well there are some very many Macs relative to iPhones and iPads but no one
0:18:08saying you should stop selling max
0:18:10some people say that most people like it's it's not like people people tend to
0:18:19develop these rules in their head about how Apple works and how and how to make
0:18:24decisions and when I wrote about the iPhone + speculation and like so many
0:18:29people there are going to add another SKU that's not the way they do things
0:18:33you know that that is how to do these when it makes sense as the iPhone math
0:18:38market
0:18:40so so yeah like you know people have these all these theories
0:18:43armchair Apple com interview she has granted we all are but like the armchair
0:18:47commentators will have will come up with some rule that Apple will always follow
0:18:52and in practice there are very few of those rules Apple briggstone rules all
0:18:56the time and so many decisions Apple makes are inconsistent with previous
0:19:02decisions they've made in future decisions they will make that you can't
0:19:06say oh well they're gonna get rid of this Lanka's they sell any of them you
0:19:11know that that doesn't necessarily mean it should get rid of something or they
0:19:15were speaking of the iPhone plus we should start thinking now of how how
0:19:20Apple is going to be seen enough these presentations are what does that put up
0:19:24on the slides when they introduced the the iPhone with a bigger screen like
0:19:29what's the what's the how do you sell that I would say they're gonna put it
0:19:33right between the iPhone iPad iPod and they had like the iPhone and one side
0:19:38and laptop on the other like working going between these things right nor the
0:19:42competition which of course is all that site and then just say here's an iPhone
0:19:48here's an iPad you know we think there's room for something in the way steve Jobs
0:19:53was his his dirty way to do it would be kind of like we made the iPhone and we
0:19:59thought the size was just perfect and you know we decided that they would like
0:20:07a little bigger so we made it a little bit taller and you know if you want a
0:20:12bigger screen there you go again some people say they still wanted to be
0:20:15bigger and so here you like every time it's like what we what we made was
0:20:19perfect but you people just kept asking if we made at all if that wasn't enough
0:20:24for you so fine years like kind of a kind of way like that's one way would go
0:20:30the other way to go with this pretend you never said all those things in the
0:20:33past about the iPhone size being appropriately sized and just say here's
0:20:36the new iPhone got a beautiful display it's you know 4.5 inches or whatever the
0:20:41heck did and now and now they're not going to say anything about it and it's
0:20:46great and you know you don't have in your own presentation you are not
0:20:49obliged to address the fact that the previous ones had smores
0:20:52means yes and you know it's it's it's a new phone and it's great and here is a
0:20:58look at this beautiful display you know and not just give you the measurement of
0:21:02this play they don't need to mention that measurements larger than the other
0:21:05one of course it'll be the same Res
0:21:07whole nine yards if they continue to solve the old size as well then they
0:21:12might have to mention it I think it's all those because that's like with with
0:21:18the iPhone 5 vs 24 s like they're not gonna keep both of those sizes around
0:21:23forever you know once the 4 S's is out of the cycle of being a cheap phone you
0:21:27know they're not gonna keep that size going somehow but I think the iPhone 5
0:21:32size that will likely that the primary iPhone size or or one of the guys will
0:21:39always be that ballpark and if they have a bigger one it'll always be that
0:21:43ballpark also like the because you know you could the forests of the five is
0:21:48such a small difference in the outside dimensions of the phone and the five is
0:21:52is so much thinner and lighter I mean a lot of people with the for us look at
0:21:56the five and they're angry cuz they bought the for us not the five or
0:21:59they're angry that the the upgrade would be too expensive or something and they
0:22:02want to justify keeping the for us not getting the 525 suck that big keeps
0:22:07these houses around forever
0:22:09most people though who have who who who have owned the previous phones whoever
0:22:13picked up and held a five are like oh my gosh this is I want this and even that
0:22:19is not everybody can do that most people recognize that the five overall is
0:22:25better and that if the for us went away and the fire was the smallest iPhone you
0:22:30can buy very few people would say I want something smaller
0:22:34you know it's it's pretty great so you know but so that I see them keeping it
0:22:40around but if they only made the big one
0:22:42I think you have a lot of people to manage something smaller than I after
0:22:46after reading and easier reading and Android conversions to have it ready yet
0:22:50know but it's i've seen some clothes in it so it does seem pretty compelling so
0:22:54one of the things he brought up which I hadn't thought about too much as far as
0:22:57I i was a scene and ease and he's always going to the phones that he's testing
0:23:01right and you know since they're not they're bigger
0:23:05and one of the things I had noticed is a nicely using the underside of playing
0:23:09with him fooling around that he brought up the thing is not so much like the
0:23:12bigger screen is nice which is true and you know we know all the people who like
0:23:16bigger screens people who have vision problems people just like it bigger but
0:23:19that Android in particular does something with larger screens that I was
0:23:23probably going to have slightly more difficult to doing which is it uses the
0:23:26larger screen to actually show more information like the phone with larger
0:23:30screens have larger resolutions so you don't be absurd to show more stuff
0:23:36whereas we're also making a bigger iPhone is just simply gonna be alright
0:23:40same res but just bigger which is which gives you half of what a big screen can
0:23:44do but Andy saying what made him go over is not so much just as hard as I saw his
0:23:49mind right but that apps on that phone for the big screen showed more stuff and
0:23:55we're designed to have more stuff on the screen not so many like more items in
0:23:59list view but just like more context in the side and just more room for
0:24:03information it wasn't simply the same image you see in a small android screen
0:24:07may have larger because your vision is bad you know so that half of the
0:24:11equation I'm not sure when Apple can do that because all of its user interfaces
0:24:15and all the iPhone apps are designed for a thumb reaching around the screen like
0:24:19and by making it bigger
0:24:20yeah it's easier to see but you don't get sick advantage of the next room
0:24:24because you're keeping the rest seem to keep your you know the developer I
0:24:29wonder how high was 16 jurors auto layout which is way more capable and
0:24:35mature and flexible than the old auto auto sizing system they had in place so
0:24:40now like the the frameworks are are getting in place for iOS apps to be more
0:24:47flexible sizes and has always had that because Android phones have always been
0:24:52a wide variety of sizes so you know andrea is is like all the apps are
0:24:56designed least the good ones are designed to to be pretty flexible with
0:25:01the size that they're willing to render added and will work out just because
0:25:05they've always had to so that is definitely an advantage but you know I
0:25:09wonder like how Apple will do this in the future like that they're they're
0:25:11laying the groundwork with auto layout and
0:25:14and by having the iPhone 4 and the five dispute these two different sizes like
0:25:18they're laying the groundwork for a future where we can more easily support
0:25:24more sizes and and iOS developers expect that and do that but it does add so much
0:25:30complexity and it is so much harder to design apps that way that I wonder if
0:25:33they're ever gonna pull the trigger and and you know make things there a wider
0:25:39variety of sizes I think I think they'll be forced to eventually and I think the
0:25:42way they'll get away with it because the stumbling block is not so much going to
0:25:45be the absolute like assuming you know everyone gets on the auto bailout train
0:25:48and everyone's head to trial run with making their apps taller right which you
0:25:51don't necessarily need to adopt all that you do but you know it's it's pretty
0:25:54easy to write but the sticking block is always games right and what I think
0:25:58they're going to do with games you i think is designed for a fix screens guys
0:26:01I'm not using any real you I just a big OpenGL view right you know what I think
0:26:05they going to do with their with with games is what the same thing they did on
0:26:10the retina MacBook Pros which is like they did this intently there was no
0:26:15reason therefore systematic approach but they did they said okay well so you have
0:26:18native retina size but we also have a size it's even bigger than that and
0:26:22we'll just scale your whole freakin screamin and put it in the retina
0:26:25that's gonna look horrible and I'll see vietnam native res but it turns out if
0:26:28you make the pics are small enough it is not as horrible as you might think so
0:26:32what do you what do you do with the games that don't update on your big
0:26:36screen you just scale them and you would think it would look hideous and doesn't
0:26:40look as good as it could but because the pics is so small you are not incredibly
0:26:45sore that I can only keep the aspect ratio the same all this came as an
0:26:50update for the iPhone 70 doesn't show any new information all doesn't scale
0:26:54the one that used to run on the iPhone 6 you know it scales it horizontally and
0:26:58vertically in proportion and now fills my screen and maybe the game guide never
0:27:03has to go back and port and going forward we can make games that work at
0:27:06all the different resins natively but he never has to back for that and then
0:27:09everyone else just deals with the other layout issues and and try something nice
0:27:13one of the apps though is that designers have been accustomed to before the
0:27:19iPhone 5 came out
0:27:20designer really accustomed to having like pixel perfect control over the
0:27:24whole screen knowing that
0:27:25every iPhone every iPhone / iPod Touch app would always have a screen at
0:27:31exactly the shape example this physical size of this resolution so they could
0:27:35like they could design the entire app as like one bitmap basically and web
0:27:40developers used to make a web pages that of HTML tables with sliced up images but
0:27:44the right and so like you know now right now with the iPhone 5 they've broken
0:27:48that for a lot of apps and games and that this doesn't fit games to with with
0:27:53you I know not necessarily but the domain but the main with the main
0:27:58viewport of the game into the engine can be most can be different sizes in most
0:28:02cases without too much work but like the the you I usually can't so you know that
0:28:08that is challenging for games and apps alike but you know once they've got
0:28:14people accustomed to it but the iPhone 5 and you know maybe maybe now it'll be
0:28:18easier and people start adapting also stylistically like our what's in fashion
0:28:24right now and design is moving out of those extremely detailed picture perfect
0:28:30textures and into flat design which scales in two different aspect ratios
0:28:36way easier probably over by the way back to making everything look like the
0:28:43bottom would help now the thing that we're not on the same thought train the
0:28:50you guys you guys areare is everyone I've ever spoken to be fair is a very
0:28:56small sample size but everyone I've ever spoken to who's tried auto layout has
0:29:00not had good things to say and I think what's it been since I just posted
0:29:03something I think it's not allowed to demand that solo plus I B I totally
0:29:08agree with the bright side note I've seen that interaction with people try to
0:29:10do so because I can't figure out how it works in interface so I just don't use
0:29:16the old system gets it good enough for my needs so I guess maybe the answer is
0:29:22that we use the one is a visual format language or whatever we all start
0:29:25drawing ASCII art I think it's a bit of a learning curve and maybe maybe a bill
0:29:29that learning curve if you know the old system well enough that it's not worth
0:29:32it for you to climate but like I mean what brand said is like the way it has
0:29:36to be like when you lay something out
0:29:38with a GUI tool like auto layout is not going to leave leave in like sort of an
0:29:43open-ended question it's going to you had to have sort of it has to behave in
0:29:47a certain way to be deterministic so it's going to add the missing constraint
0:29:50that you're not yet specified and if you don't know what all those implicit
0:29:52constraints the detecting for you are you like why didn't have that constraint
0:29:56like well you need something there to balance the equation so the thing knows
0:29:59what it's supposed to do when you resize right and that can be frustrating but I
0:30:04think if you if you really really new auto me out he will be obvious to you
0:30:08what implicit constraints enterprise builder is adding and you wouldn't be
0:30:13surprised by when you lay something out that allowed interest builder and one
0:30:17constraint and see how it behaves because you know what all the other ones
0:30:20would have to be to fill it and like i mean there's still room for variation in
0:30:23there that I B could be adding things that you don't think it should close the
0:30:27equation in a different way or whatever but I think it's it's a it's a solvable
0:30:33problem in a politically on until they get something that works reasonably well
0:30:36also it's kind of a chicken and egg thing like right now most apps are able
0:30:42to adapt the iPhone 5 without significant changes because it just
0:30:46stretched vertically and and if any Apple has a scrollable like a vertical
0:30:51scroll content area in the middle of the table view our list app that was a
0:30:55really easy transition from us to make so it wasn't that painful to adapt the
0:31:01iPhone 5 once we if they would add a whole new resolution that was wider and
0:31:07taller you know that that was different both mentioned even if it's a different
0:31:10aspect ratio than that and even more complexity if if they do that then it's
0:31:18gonna be so much work to add a Pilates abs to it then maybe it'll motivate
0:31:21developers to convert to auto layout or to start using it for new projects
0:31:26whereas now the value proposition is not strong for it was like well the old
0:31:30system works well enough for so many cases and we already know it and we only
0:31:35have to support two devices and it's fairly easy to support them both now so
0:31:39you know it's it's it's a lot less compelling now do you remember I'm
0:31:44trying to remember the earlier demonstrably Dec to go to the session
0:31:46they did
0:31:47so like I'm trying to think of if they have the ability to do the same way like
0:31:52ok so now when they were showing on the Mac but like so now when you're when
0:31:56your window is little bigger suddenly new information and/or UI elements come
0:32:01into existence that weren't previously there sort of like responsive design
0:32:04when they have an application disappear in stepping up supporters that's because
0:32:08that's what you really need for like you know you're trying to avoid a situation
0:32:11where we have now is like ok I make my app for the iPod and the iPhone and then
0:32:16I have to you know if I'm going to do a good job I can do different you I forgot
0:32:20that is just so different in size you can't just take the phone thing scaling
0:32:23up well if you have a larger iPhone like getting back to Andy's point if you
0:32:28really want to an awesome job for those people USA ok now I have more room to
0:32:31put stuff I shouldn't really just take my iphone screen make sure everything
0:32:35like scales correctly
0:32:37fact they have room for another button here I have room for ancillary display
0:32:40with some other information you know like that's what the triple-a guys are
0:32:43gonna do and the question is if they're doing that these are allowed a factor or
0:32:48do they just make three different views that regular iPhone the bigger iPhone
0:32:52and the iPad and if it has the ability to simply let people say ok here is the
0:32:59iPhone wanted you make it a little bit bigger you know another control cousins
0:33:03of you and other like display thing and then also have to do another way out for
0:33:06the iPad I bet most good developers are especially good people good designers
0:33:13like most good developers will want to code those separately anyway because a
0:33:18lot of time is even if it's like it if it's ok we'll we'll show or hide these
0:33:22controls or rearrange them even then a lot of times the iPad interface probably
0:33:26should work even more differently than that and and so I think we're always
0:33:30going to have people who that's the idea saying from the small phone to the hell
0:33:35yeah and that's a smaller jump hopefully in and what what you want to be
0:33:40different so I could take care of that in a lot of cases I'm sure but I still
0:33:45think so many people are gonna wanna custom design things you know to to just
0:33:50be more different than what the layout engine is is capable
0:33:54writing and it has a car as the old curmudgeon syndrome like if you know how
0:33:58the rail out works is it worth it to you to learn how the art because then all
0:34:02you're doing is like you're going through an abstraction layer thus
0:34:05preventing you from just setting the things that you know you want to set in
0:34:08some cases are aware can do things that you would have to write code for and
0:34:11that's the kind of case we like my writing the stupid train layout code to
0:34:14recalculate the distances between these things based on their it's like you know
0:34:18springs and struts can't do it but our layout can all that is saving you from
0:34:22manually writing that coach just some stupid math on points to figure out how
0:34:26far things are and that's that's the type of thing that probably with Gemma
0:34:30well-lit areas you say if you didn't have allowed the amount of code you how
0:34:34to write for this would make you not want to use this feature and it would
0:34:38make it would make you not make your layout actress weblog how easy it isn't
0:34:41allowed vs like I could do springs and struts there's no reason for me to lay
0:34:46out its just getting in my way or the other thing that I find interesting
0:34:51about a layout is although I like I said earlier I haven't heard a lot of people
0:34:55sing its praises I certainly haven't heard a lot of people say this is
0:35:01supposed to work but doesn't
0:35:02iCloud you know if it doesn't seem like the technology is bad it's just a big
0:35:08learning curve like both you guys have been saying whereas iCloud seems to have
0:35:12somewhat of a big learning curve and it's a piece of crap so that you can
0:35:17learn anything it doesn't act news API and a framework on your system you have
0:35:22a fighting chance figuring out but when you're communicating to black box over
0:35:26the network and you can't figure out why it works the way it does just this it is
0:35:30a it does not converge on a solution will elect when Apple makes new API's
0:35:34and and frameworks and things like that you know they're they're solving a
0:35:39number of problems with these API's some of them appear to be designed not
0:35:43necessarily for everyone to use like as their new default of how they build
0:35:48things but for rapid development or 44 less sophisticated developers to get
0:35:53something working well and quickly so I think one of the biggest examples of
0:35:56this is our Christmas story boards like arc is a really great feature that they
0:36:03obviously want everybody to use its
0:36:05there's really very few downsides to it overall and and even power users you
0:36:10know even very skilled developers will get a lot of value of using arc with
0:36:15almost no downsides story boards are a very restrictive and limited structure
0:36:24that your app uses they can save a lot of time for rapid development or for
0:36:29less experienced developers they can save tons of time in and provide a nicer
0:36:34framework for certain things but there's there so limited that a lot of high-end
0:36:39developers really can't use them for much and and so you know maybe maybe
0:36:46auto layout is no not not quite to the level of storyboards and maybe it's like
0:36:51not quite to the level of Arc either it's you know it's there for for people
0:36:56to to use maybe sometimes or as they go forward maybe new developers learn this
0:37:00maybe it isn't intended to capture a lot of the other developers quite yet
0:37:04because you know maybe the value isn't quite that clear on it and certainly you
0:37:09know once you have one of those situations where you're laying out
0:37:13something with the old system that's really a pain to do it once you have on
0:37:17the situation then you start learning it but I think there's a there's very
0:37:21there's very little reason for developers to convert things to auto
0:37:26layout if they're working fine spring struts or delay or 22 absolutely vital a
0:37:31for everything in the next project like it might not make sense to do that yet
0:37:34maybe says the circles that we travel in the people who read but like the number
0:37:40of people who have a grumpy face about I B which is not like a fancy new
0:37:43technology comes from the next day is right there are like magic are just
0:37:48doing code oh yeah that's like it just shows that sometimes no matter how that
0:37:54was a big selling point in the next days like looking into rebuilding its amazing
0:37:57right you know some people just that I'd rather just do it in codon you know
0:38:03that's just what they would rather do and you're not gonna make it no matter
0:38:06how nice you make the tool if people don't want to chill it does that is not
0:38:11solving a problem they think they have there like
0:38:15auto layout even if they make it awesome and perfect just like and availability
0:38:19some people say I preferred just doing code and they well and Interface Builder
0:38:24I've always thought has been like comically unintuitive and like my
0:38:29background as Casey knows because he was there my my background was Visual Basic
0:38:34and you know Microsoft has a lot of things badly I got it got to give them
0:38:39credit for that they do so many things badly it's quite impressive however
0:38:43their development tools are really good and they're especially good at not not
0:38:51having a really huge learning curve to get started on something and Visual
0:38:55Basic and any now of course we were sophisticated with other new stuff like
0:39:00I started as a basic with version 1.0 literally visualize it 110 and even then
0:39:06it was really easy to use you dragged out of control and I double click it and
0:39:11there's the function like it so it was so easy to use that I could figure it
0:39:15out as an extreme novice like in 7th Grade you know who's really did have a
0:39:20great Interface Builder has so many weird little things about it
0:39:24weird behaviour that are necessary you know it's not like oh you're gonna have
0:39:30some advanced need at some point you might need to know this
0:39:33know it's like if you're going to use this to do anything at all you need to
0:39:37do is weird things about it that are very intuitive like and it's always been
0:39:41that way and they they keep saying it's getting better and in some ways it gets
0:39:45better and then head to new things that you need to learn some weird way so it
0:39:49really Interface Builder has never been particularly easy to use and Casey I'm
0:39:55curious cause you've come to this way more recently than John and I have what
0:40:00do you think of interviews builder like how you said you had those problems and
0:40:02and you have used the Microsoft stuff more recently cuz you are you were a
0:40:06Windows guy for so long at work and you still are kind of what do you think
0:40:10about this comparison i think for the most part I agree with what you said I
0:40:17don't have any heat for Interface Builder and I think that largely comes
0:40:21from the fact that a I haven't done you know years upon years of iOS development
0:40:26and be
0:40:28all the development of done is tended to be with reasonably simple and
0:40:33straightforward user interfaces I i dont I do agree though that it is not
0:40:38intuitive like when you were talking about how you drag a button on 24 min
0:40:43and current Windows Forms parlance apartments have you pronounce that word
0:40:47et cetera regardless you just drop it on a formidable clicking there's your
0:40:53messages like you're saying whereas with Interface Builder as you're describing
0:40:57this and thinking well how does that work in interface bode well you have to
0:40:59have something on the header or perhaps the the code I'm file that is an idea
0:41:06action and I be out late will wait what's the difference between the two oh
0:41:09well you see I B action as a function error message in an IP outlet is where
0:41:14you just want to have a reference in its already it's like oh my god shut up so I
0:41:19don't think it's terrible I don't have a problem with Interface Builder but I
0:41:22would agree with everything you said about the Microsoft Developer Tools
0:41:25really are good and it's funny because i've been teaching a co-worker Objective
0:41:29C and cocoa and whatnot and he's really enjoyed it and got over the ugly ugly
0:41:35ugly syntax a lot quicker than I did but one of the things that it's hysterical
0:41:40to watch is when he's trying to figure out what the right method is to do
0:41:45something like for example to make a string lower case rather than go to the
0:41:49documentation what does he do it
0:41:52yeah he uses his windows a student at like that like that's the programming in
0:42:01anything done it for the first time you can all you need to know is the first
0:42:04word system is still system yet so yeah like you can you can know nothing about
0:42:11the language of programming error dat idea program against Alize language of
0:42:15course I was thing but you can do nothing about the FBI of her game
0:42:17against and just typing system . and just start there and you will probably
0:42:22find unique yeah you're absolutely right and that's the funny thing is watching
0:42:27him use Xcode crummy intellisense I note I called intellisense for whatever they
0:42:32call it and it's gotten better like I remember everyone freaking out at WWDC
0:42:36they were so excited when they when somebody announced that
0:42:39when you start typing an assss rather than what was streams yeah I was just
0:42:47trying to remember what the what the bad match was I can do is it was an extreme
0:42:51right or SAT maybe I was trying to form the great for I was going to type
0:42:56NSString and as steve Beshear he's annoying as prime minister yeah whatever
0:43:02it was it was dessert because they finally got the autocomplete to the
0:43:07point that it sort of made sense but it's not a great documentation browser
0:43:11where is done and you could you really never need to kick open any
0:43:15documentation exactly you can just sit there with intellisense and you'll find
0:43:18what you like if I'm working index could I have to have an organizer window open
0:43:23and I have to have a documentation tab and I'm going over there and searching
0:43:26in the search field like every five minutes or something like that
0:43:30any kind of built-in you know pop-up automatic documentation is usually not
0:43:35enough for what I'm looking for
0:43:36and no more I don't know looking for exactly and you know i cant are
0:43:40completed or or the autocomplete is freaking out because of something that
0:43:44it showed on a hundred lines up that I don't know about yet and it's not
0:43:48working in its
0:43:51snappers I am writing on my code the old-fashioned way I don't have
0:43:55auto-completion I just memorize every single freaking function its name and
0:43:58then the argument that's because it was all my back ends are still in PHP that's
0:44:05why I write back I'm running it on text made which doesn't really have like you
0:44:08know and tell us on skype features or if it doesn't know how to activate them and
0:44:13please don't email me I really don't care and you know I can write that way
0:44:17but it's so nice we don't have to and it really is a major productivity booster
0:44:22to have things I can tell us a sense that it you know what doing that well
0:44:27makes a really big difference to coding especially when you're new to a language
0:44:31or an ATI you're upset and i think is the part of the part of the problem
0:44:36might be there to see such a proposed language and you know method names are
0:44:41string by replacing occurrences of string with string with whatever the
0:44:45hell it is I forget what it is
0:44:47that's one letter in progress
0:44:50well let's be honest all of pearl regular one of them I think we should
0:44:58talk about that at some future package at a certain point the host names do not
0:45:04help understanding everything except once you do get familiar with Apple's
0:45:09crazy API naming style then you can start guessing the names of things
0:45:14before you know them and you can usually gets correctly at least a point where
0:45:17the Nautica you that's you know it to begin with because once you learn like
0:45:22the words for the event handlers for a will and did you know all that stuff
0:45:27like then then at least you have a fighting chance on the prefixes but the
0:45:30words that come after the prefixes that's this kind of like people writing
0:45:35all I see is that the order they put like the the adjectives and verbs and
0:45:40where the with comes in the
0:45:42like that there's a rich history of scrambling up the primary things that's
0:45:49a solution to never do this but like give give a pic cereal named parameters
0:45:53that order doesn't matter anymore you know
0:45:56be great that would be that would be too much would be different and it's funny
0:46:03the market because just today I was tryna remember for the I was working
0:46:07with my coworker who's learning the language in the API Nostrand remember
0:46:11wait how do you get a lowercase string it's not to lower thats dotnet no that's
0:46:16not how it now you know what I bet Apple would do lowercase drink it sure enough
0:46:22that's according to lower case I don't say it's true
0:46:28early today I was I had an array and I wanted to join with with a string and
0:46:34enjoying all the components this trend and so I had the array nicer and I
0:46:38started from the Erasmus having strength by AM pretty sure that was corrected
0:46:42stream by joining components with string something like that and you know because
0:46:47I I am familiar enough with Apple styles able to guess that method without
0:46:51looking it up and I was right and so once you it's and Interface Builder is
0:46:57actually very similarly
0:46:59once you get it then you can see oh ok I can see why they thought that made sense
0:47:06and now it makes sense to me and now I'm past it but don't want her to see dick
0:47:12euless rule so I understand that there were both naming thing that someone who
0:47:16has never seen Objective C before can look at that and guests that you are
0:47:21taking a string and joining a bunch of other strings with some of the string
0:47:25and they can tell which is which
0:47:27like you know me but the visual the mental visual space that that call takes
0:47:32up as compared to like as equals a dot join and then single quotes the joining
0:47:38string like maybe someone doesn't know what that means but once you know the
0:47:42language and no little bit about the basics of the API it's just that that's
0:47:46why people that's what people are literature for both things not because
0:47:49we're loading so much bad but because there's a there's a limited common
0:47:52vocabulary that people feel like should not be that verbose because it happens
0:47:56so often right and that's why a lot of Objective C code looks like a lot of
0:47:59visual stuff like squint a lot of black on the page for doing operations that
0:48:04you know in some higher-level more dynamic language like Java Script even
0:48:09or a pro review Python would just be so much sup take up so much less room and
0:48:15be so much faster to scan because you wouldn't have to read I mean like it's
0:48:19just joined map grab still there
0:48:22replace substitute instead of the big English sentences with stuff paying off
0:48:27although English sentences are substantially easier to read if you
0:48:34aren't familiar with the API they're calling a trip outside like this there's
0:48:38a there's a subset of like really super common functionality so I guess maybe we
0:48:42would have a language course I mean I don't think it's reasonable they call in
0:48:47Huffman coding where you take the things you are common and make them concise and
0:48:52as you get more esoteric you get more verbose so you know the built-in stuff
0:48:56is super duper short lowercase SLC right but there really more esoteric things
0:49:01like creating a socket with timeouts and a binding parts of that is proposed in
0:49:06this big name parameters and everything's long spelled out right
0:49:09whereas in Objective C and not the language but the API the cocoa
0:49:12foundation guys everything is your vote even like basic string functions even
0:49:17like things dealing with numbers and formatted like everything is hosted
0:49:20don't say okay people are going to change a string to lowercase way more
0:49:25often than they're gonna like set up some sort of handler for some event or
0:49:30whatever set up an ass notification center right so shouldn't one of those
0:49:34be shorter because it's gonna be more calm to be fair to learn key string
0:49:37method is one of the shortest into the long right and substitution durang
0:49:44running regular expressions matches and substituting like you know parole
0:49:48thought it was important to put syntaxin language right so did sort of JavaScript
0:49:53kind of put syntaxin language for in a couple of things too but you know ok so
0:49:57finally just received the language but the API for things that deal with
0:50:01strings are now don't have any recognition of how come they're like
0:50:04they are just as her bosses everything else although in a string is monolithic
0:50:09as hell as well as so many different we are two methods like four paths and
0:50:14getting like doesn't have data type things related to URLs and like you know
0:50:19it's like a string what do you have to do with your else well I kinda know yet
0:50:25is that there's a whole lot why do you know about euro corps the core of useful
0:50:30Foundation Classes like strike in a string and as data as a really there's
0:50:35so much a weird like ok I want to convert this to this which which object
0:50:41has that class has a method which classes and a lot of times it's not the
0:50:45one you expected to be it's not you gotta do like it you know and it within
0:50:48the past the NSString or do you call american on a string the returns from
0:50:52yeah its string to data gets me every time I always assume the wrong one has
0:50:58the method I need and I always have to spend two minutes looking for
0:51:00documentation I P string to data that's it and I P dated a string which is also
0:51:08a very common one like when dealing with Web services you get back data to get I
0:51:14use those constantly I also have a whole string category the mistake on my
0:51:19stirrings there is i i stole XPath string functions so I have some stream
0:51:25before substring after contains and few other little things like that but you
0:51:31are strings and check the news it's just even contains it's a cool way more
0:51:35compact syntax and it's not found does not equal strength range of string and
0:51:41so much more complex I'll definitely a helper for things like that I do very
0:51:47commonly URL encoding the the default method of extreme with by replacing
0:51:54percent escapes using incorrect that that big one method to convert a string
0:51:59to your own coding doesn't do it right 40 off there is that there's some
0:52:03there's a few characters that that method doesn't include that whatever RFC
0:52:08requires does require you to be encoded so I have my own IP URL encoded string
0:52:14methods and you end you know so I have weird that just save me time and the
0:52:20whole idea of having categories on classes is awesome that you can but you
0:52:23can extend the built-in system classes I think that's also love Rubio monkey
0:52:29certainly can be done badly and also haven't you heard its three letters
0:52:36please for third party using a stick with IPB never completed anything having
0:52:42to do with the technology exactly I don't understand why there are no
0:52:48namespace I mean I understand be with the runtime I know I know but
0:52:54spaces like baby steps like all these problems are talking about we solved
0:52:59that just nice high-level language but you know you know he's been bitching
0:53:05about that for you this year's gonna be type in France right so yeah it was
0:53:10lurching toward something but all that crap with the strings and the data in
0:53:15like dealing with stuff like that it's just a completely goes away if you have
0:53:19a language that has I don't need of streams and you know a little more or
0:53:23less a faire attitude about data types are you can trust you know things around
0:53:27and not worry about if it's a floater injury number I you can't do that
0:53:31language is useless I know I know all the reasons ejector seat is living on
0:53:35its way more efficient and stalin to let you know every must have their cake and
0:53:39eat it too so right now the top of the cake I honestly I like I'd like to see
0:53:44and and all that stuff with it I mean it's not perfect at but you know I think
0:53:50I think if you if you think any language is perfect you don't know it well enough
0:53:53or you or you don't have enough experience as a programmer honestly like
0:53:57and everything that has problems and shortcomings and the nature of these
0:54:03it's not really possible to design a perfect language and certainly there are
0:54:07you know I've yet to see it has a lot of ancient baggage that still carrying that
0:54:12it can probably never get rid of because of the kind of language it is but I was
0:54:17doing some pretty awesome stuff with it like a even simple things like they did
0:54:21reduce a whole lot of that boilerplate last year when they introduced compact
0:54:27syntax for you know array access dictionaries to fight that you know the
0:54:31compact primitives like they they they introduced a lot of that stuff that you
0:54:35can that they are making real progress you know making sympathize optional
0:54:40you know stuff like that like they go get rid of the double double name stuff
0:54:44with the type of answer your own have to declare the variable being of type
0:54:48whatever
0:54:49right you know then call the class method to give you a new one of those I
0:54:53don't know I just write that name of course of course that's the class that
0:54:58i'm gonna call the method on to instantiate one of those guys that the
0:55:00type of the variable I can you know so that's my next guest over what they're
0:55:05going to add but like I still feel like at a certain point you can at like eight
0:55:10of us plus a certain point you can't keep adding crap or fixing crap are
0:55:13trying to make it better
0:55:14certain point you need to do as long as it's like a sea-based language you're
0:55:19always going to have that there's gonna be a pretty pretty hard limit on a lot
0:55:23of these modern niceties that you can add to it but I mean like the transition
0:55:27I C you know putting some dead or until apples at a business is that like you
0:55:32know now you have core foundation which is just great see and you've got the
0:55:35objective CA Viz never got to deal with core foundation API's like lower level
0:55:40and it doesn't have a list of what I you know if they come up with something
0:55:45higher level than objective seat which I think high-level languages is much more
0:55:48appropriate for most of the stuff you do
0:55:51catching events figure out when they click this button bring this view
0:55:54interview like that crap does not need to be in a sea-based language just like
0:55:57just like monkey work of connecting up things and you are but there are there
0:56:01will always be parts of it that need to be in a lower level language so then you
0:56:04have like 10 you like most of my coat and whatever this high-level languages
0:56:08and then some portions of an objective CBC so much more efficient and then
0:56:11presumably some portions a stolen car foundation like it's a layer cake of
0:56:14like alright well the OpenGL crap you know still a straight capi guess that's
0:56:19really probe insensitive and then somewhere in the middle of something
0:56:21that's like it's not like high-level you I dealing with but you know it's a
0:56:26little bit lower level and then at the top you rewrite overall structure at
0:56:29most the time writing this very huggable language I could see them going to
0:56:33something like that I think those are very well though in the Indies like
0:56:37early years of of mobile computers because he knows so well that they've
0:56:43they've benefited so much from just the sheer efficiency of these of the
0:56:48sea-based languages with the things that things that benefit them early suddenly
0:56:52become right disadvantages late exactly then suddenly everyone else is less
0:56:55efficient language like the TPS ketchup and it's like all of that but that was a
0:56:59great advantage you back then
0:57:01but now not so much right now it can now that it that advantages in significant
0:57:05if not know if webOS came out five years from now it would have a better chance
0:57:11the market because it would knock slow every every wouldn't be complaining
0:57:16about its terrible battery life in 10 terrible performance you know it
0:57:20wouldn't be that big of a difference from anything else that was out there
0:57:22and I can drive in dramas disgusting right but like it in Tennessee it is
0:57:29using high-level language and it was slower for a long time and you know
0:57:33arguably Iowa still has the performance events there but the gap is really close
0:57:37at you know hardware is getting better there's more memory that the there's
0:57:41more stuff to indulge jobless foibles and if you if you believe that the
0:57:46things you don't have to worry about in Java like you know segmentation faults
0:57:50and crap like that are an advantage then suddenly Android platform in this
0:57:56particular respect becomes more attractive development you know to doing
0:57:59your development so you don't have to learn about arc you don't have to learn
0:58:02about our appointment for crying out loud is weird start for a variable names
0:58:08that new program I have no idea what they're there for nearly breaks when
0:58:12they forget her apple and the continuum of things that make someone go on a
0:58:17platform or not the crappiness is language is very low on the list as
0:58:21evidenced by the fact that all these bazillion people suddenly learning
0:58:24Objective C because that's where the money exacto alright we'll learn your
0:58:27crazy ass language with square brackets just got to my way and that's always how
0:58:31it's been accepted the web on the web you can write in pretty much anything as
0:58:35long as you can find some service offered to run it so the web has has
0:58:38tons of great languages to choose from and it really matters when you're
0:58:42writing but on a native platforms as always been like one language that on
0:58:47every end and one framework on every major native platform where like you
0:58:52really should be right things in there
0:58:53that and you know windows for a long time with has been C++ and then more
0:58:58recently it's moving into dotnet stuff you know s10 has always been Objective C
0:59:04IIS injector seal their heads for the framework so you know there's always
0:59:08always like that that that pushed if you want to help on this platform you should
0:59:13really be doing in this language everywhere except the web so if I agree
0:59:21with that is a very interesting point my my question for the to you gentlemen is
0:59:25it if you pick the lab if you were to pick the language today that would
0:59:29replace or or supplement Objective C what is it
0:59:33john has all you my water my criteria like what what what realistic bounds to
0:59:42have to stick with it here it has to be language that exists today which by the
0:59:47way I don't think Apple would necessarily play by that rule it and it
0:59:51has to it has to prevent John Siracusa from continuing to bitch about what
0:59:57languages are available from the possible platforms
0:59:59no no choices will get him to complain as little as possible which is a
1:00:07extremely lofty but theoretically plausible this is a good question
1:00:11because it makes me realize all this time I've been talking this I've never
1:00:14been pushing for Apple to adopt any existing languages have always been
1:00:18thinking the day will do their own thing like pretty much as they have been like
1:00:22Objective C at this point is their own thing like it may have started out as
1:00:26the old like at this point but whatever whatever crazy taken version number they
1:00:29apply to language they've changed it so much they completely fearless about
1:00:32changes I always imagined what everything replaced it would also be at
1:00:36their own invention exactly tailored to what they need a language too and no
1:00:41language like there's no language out there that I like well enough to say
1:00:46they should just do that one like and I and I think you're right and I think
1:00:49they would do their own thing but then that John Siracusa guy would continue to
1:00:53complain about the fact that everyone has to learn this we never complained
1:00:57about learning I've never made a single complaint about you gotta learn this
1:01:00language well here's an idea what if they are doing it already let if he also
1:01:05similarly how Objective C in its first implementations was basically a macro
1:01:12language on top of see is that accurate I've always heard that in a C++ ok I
1:01:17don't think so I think it was see anyway plus plus was was see with classes and
1:01:23it was this yes that is also true but I think Objective C started at the same
1:01:26way I don't always have to have a runtime right i mean it wasn't just
1:01:29macro library of CO 2 dunno somewhere Objective C message that had to be
1:01:35written content library to call me anyway so Objective C started out as
1:01:41like a bolt on top of C and it has matured a lot since then and you know
1:01:45the series are still all there but now he know the tools you'll never get to
1:01:49see the compilers for all native Objective C rivals riding like you know
1:01:54they're they're doing you know that is the language now what if their next big
1:01:59language is what they're doing with Objective C now that's moving towards it
1:02:04and then at some point in the future they enable some kind of new syntax mode
1:02:09where it adds a lot of stuff that we want it adds a lot of the complex stuff
1:02:14it hides pointers and things like that don't want a lot built on top of
1:02:19directive see temporarily or version one and then over time is at least you have
1:02:25to drop into that syntax to use some low-level API is but most of everything
1:02:30will be available right there like I think I think they're moving if they
1:02:36were going to replace this language in five years I don't think they'd be put
1:02:40in as much effort into it now you know they're doing radical changes to that
1:02:45the the the Objective C without the C thing seems to be the path are going on
1:02:48but this is not entirely satisfied me I'm sure they're taking into account
1:02:51with their plans but they are you listening right now you know the people
1:02:57who are making decisions on what to do disagree with me about the about what
1:03:03the ideal situation but I think they would be perfectly happy to slowly
1:03:06evolved as a QCD eventually bifurcated into abject receiver that the C part
1:03:11where safety is much more
1:03:13County then it is and you could have an unsafe you know sort of realm and then
1:03:17most people eventually get most people doing their coding in the safe part
1:03:20where you can't scribble your own memory where you just calling to Objective C
1:03:25API's and just use the escape hatch for the other stuff but I really like I
1:03:29mentioned I really think that ideally and of course you can have the idea but
1:03:33ideally a higher-level language with more safety guarantees and less
1:03:38fussiness about types wouldn't just me know we got that language are all set it
1:03:42would also necessarily imply different API like in a language with built-in
1:03:48strings you don't NSString doesn't exist is not you don't stand she had a class
1:03:51to get a string in a language that has native strengths and in a language that
1:03:55has you know language level support for regular expressions that's not like a
1:04:01library or call but not like as things get pulled into the language you
1:04:05necessarily change the way API works whole whole concept of API's change
1:04:09based on what language support so you that's why I like these bridges are some
1:04:13terrible like if you have Python have some amazing you know pythons high-level
1:04:18language but you just call the same for you guys and they don't they don't mess
1:04:21it seems like quite know what ever write a pipeline a parent like this it's so
1:04:25clear that I'm calling into an Objective C API not just because of the new
1:04:28inventions but just because of like you know you know right out
1:04:31error parameters are you pass in an error and its gonna write back to it
1:04:34like that like that doesn't happen in high-level languages cuz you know I mean
1:04:39you could you pass references and language reference but it just doesn't
1:04:41that's not how you design the API and like some hole and a string wing of the
1:04:47language just disappears and you know and then like maybe like Ruby have all
1:04:51the strings be objects and methods on them which is not the same thing I'm not
1:04:54really I could say new strength and putting
1:04:58I just feel like the language in the API are our match set and you can't change
1:05:04without changing the other if you change language sufficiently if you keep
1:05:07evolving this language to the point where it starts to become a higher level
1:05:11and more safe and less work for the developer it will be a shame if the API
1:05:16still looks like oh why is a powerhouse well used to be was just the sea-based
1:05:21language and this is the way everything will see that that I'm not sure I agree
1:05:25there because everything you just described as dotnet early still my ears
1:05:30and and I it's weird because I have no love for Microsoft but I do think don is
1:05:34actually pretty cool language and in to a.net developer you generally speaking
1:05:40can use the win32 API without ever touching C C++ or C because dotnet
1:05:46consumes all of that and access the bridge and I don't even when I'm calling
1:05:51into these API's I don't need to worry about pointers on hand but i dont need
1:05:55two generals piano need to worry about any of that crap because dotnet has
1:05:58encapsulated all of it in and is putting a facade in front of its own have to
1:06:02worry about that that being said if I have an old capi that I wanna call C++
1:06:07API wanna call i campi invoke into it and I can say hey there's a deal here
1:06:11here's the structure of the method I need to call in and I can even do it on
1:06:15safely and I have an unsafe keyword where I can manage my own memory and all
1:06:19that crap so everything you just described believe it or not is done now
1:06:22I am I dot net and I think a.net is way far ahead of where Apple is
1:06:27technologically speaking maybe not necessarily AP Iowa's because Microsoft
1:06:32seems to have more trouble figure out what it wants out of an API sticking to
1:06:35it I remember what what iteration of you know how you use this tool kit for you I
1:06:40say they have no problems there but like the CLR and the whole idea behind it
1:06:47that is a foundation that if Apple had that foundation now and it was
1:06:50performing the need to put as much time into it is Windows had they would be in
1:06:54a much stronger position to say look everything is common language runtime
1:06:57and we have all these cape hatteras run safe and we can put new languages on it
1:07:01and you know a python the CLR is just straight up Python you write your you
1:07:06write your Python functions having a private party money be I have two
1:07:11bridges but hopefully they don't just two straight bridges they do you know
1:07:13rappers are different than British rapper is like I wanted to hide all the
1:07:18stuff that's irrelevant high-level language and rappers have a cost in
1:07:22terms of performance but there is more better semantics than than bridges yes
1:07:27absolutely and that's what I'm used to seeing a bunch of rappers and facades
1:07:31that that under the hood are doing p.m. folks all the nasty crappy things
1:07:35I have to do but to me i'm just calling system . whatever that whatever the
1:07:40thing like this event has that the API that it's wrapping is much more
1:07:45disgusting
1:07:46like 132 as compared to like our foundation it's not real it's all so
1:07:52that they there does wrapping rappers of rappers because in the very bottom is
1:07:56this is terrible slime the New Orleans a touch it's true but you don't answer my
1:08:01question if you were to pick today at language today what would you pay to get
1:08:05the pic prospects even though it doesn't really exist kind of sort of it's kind
1:08:09of a cop and if you don't really know what's so bad about it yet
1:08:13well I mean I know what's so bad about the language I just don't know what to
1:08:16do better on the implementation language existed suspect is just no i didnt like
1:08:21it doesn't really exist the last half implementation or whatever but like
1:08:26language wise I think process is the most exciting language that sort of kind
1:08:31of almost exists I dislike pile on more than I just like Ruby so I would
1:08:38probably bring in the result I really really do dislike several things about
1:08:44Ruby pretty vehement Lee because I feel like they should have known better but I
1:08:49i just like Python more I definitely just like JavaScript more so I guess I
1:08:53would have to go through be as much as it pains me to say that as much as I
1:08:56have not a fan of Ruby really just totally distasteful to me and JavaScript
1:09:03is just just informative
1:09:06nothing about Apple modernizing Objective C and eventually adding this
1:09:11new syntax layer on top of it if that's what their plan is that doesn't preclude
1:09:15them from also modernizing the ATI's along with that and I mean that they
1:09:20would have to wrap them they were well temporarily but you know compared with
1:09:24the bridge to bridge when it wraps things I agree with everything you said
1:09:27a bridge sucks because you get these weird you know API is that obviously are
1:09:33not written with that new language in mind but that's because bridges usually
1:09:38written by people who aren't the API platform owners like Apple would make
1:09:43a new brand new the Java bridge was something that was that was doomed but
1:09:47you know if Apple decided this is the new thing this new language Larry built
1:09:52on top of just to see now on its back by Victor see this now this whole different
1:09:56language layer on top this is our new thing this is the this is the way
1:10:01forward then within a few years they could have all the replies modernize to
1:10:05it are these all the one people actually use on a regular basis are some of them
1:10:09I mean like what you when you would hope is that like I guess you would hope the
1:10:13bottom layers roll up eventually like kind of like the assembly assembly has
1:10:18been basically rolled up like the original Mac operating system tremendous
1:10:21amount of assembly and the amount of Assembly in operation that anyone has
1:10:26two writer deal with or call arranged things just shrug up to the point where
1:10:29now it's like a couple device drivers in the current Olin library for doing math
1:10:33right that's it
1:10:34like it too low and curls up and it's just gone from the operation of the
1:10:38operating system the things dealing with the GUI you know like you would hope
1:10:42that eventually see part thanks to roll up to now the Objective C fiber let's
1:10:46start with the C part that like ok well now the sea is only like in the current
1:10:50online and device drivers or whatever like and it used to be every everything
1:10:54used to be C you know everything you know if you can't inject you see is it
1:10:57like I would like to see progress of the high and also rolling up a long visit
1:11:02you're not you don't do that all you're doing is making putting more layers and
1:11:05layer cake and that you know it at a certain point like them are now or what
1:11:10kind of performance here this is a great article that someone should put in our
1:11:13nonexistent shown us but at a certain point no matter what kind of performance
1:11:16you get from the hardware if you keep putting layer upon layer cake
1:11:19performance won't be a problem it'll be like latency the jury that article from
1:11:23John Carmack talking about latency of your head sets no but that's that sounds
1:11:27good
1:11:28is like we have amazing technology with GPUs and we can do that amazing texture
1:11:33fills and cute you know shader operations operating on like millions
1:11:36and millions of pickles like 15 times per frame we can do is amazing frame
1:11:39rate and none of that matters because if you can't react to me turn my head
1:11:43within 20 milliseconds and get a new image in front of my eyes it's like
1:11:47motion sickness inducing until all those great technology we have actually
1:11:50impairs the ability pieces so many layers and layer cake of like this goes
1:11:54through this that goes to the the USB thing there and then goes to the did you
1:11:59know that the input system and then goes to the OpenGL and how to the graphics
1:12:03card comes back down has to be displayed like all the layers we've had two layer
1:12:07cake you know for this amazing performance skills latency so this is
1:12:12not a direct analogy designers latency the API stuck with the same ideas that
1:12:15we can't just keep adding layers and layer cake you have to curl up the lower
1:12:18ones to you have to pop off the bottom as you had once at the top so that's the
1:12:22kind of progress I'm looking for my lifetime thing you get on that and I i
1:12:27think they're doing that you know we haven't really seen the next big step
1:12:30yet but it looks like like based on the actions that we have seen i think thats
1:12:36a plausible prediction of where they're actually heading they're not going in
1:12:40the wrong direction it's not like we're you know it's just it's just like
1:12:43quibbling about the details like and the and the pace you know mobile set
1:12:47everything back a decade or two so trying I understand that you know it
1:12:52makes perfect sense right but like you know I would like to see more MORE
1:12:59advancement in the high and more coming up to the lower end is just like the
1:13:02road they're taking to it is perhaps more security and slower than than I
1:13:06would like
1:13:07especially when I see things like CLR existing position long time it's like
1:13:10this technology was there and you know yeah your entire stock is still better
1:13:15than Microsoft's now but like would like the mile thing with this is not
1:13:20something you can do overnight and if you're going to try to do incremental in
1:13:24pieces I think he will end up running into a barrier where there has to be a
1:13:27discontinuity somewhere and if there isn't your gonna end up with the sort of
1:13:30mongrel at the end of it like age of us plus where you just took the salt thing
1:13:34and slightly modified a bit of time but never sat down to say okay like what is
1:13:38this new thing we want you know me it's like it's like ViaWest just an
1:13:42incremental revision of slowly adding mobile site features the Mac OS 10 it
1:13:45wasn't they you know they start over conceptually from the UI perspective
1:13:49right I I'm a fan of a kind of clean break and I worry that slowly creeping
1:13:55up on deck to see without the sea will result in a language that no one can
1:13:59really
1:13:59love it may be that will never hurt Apple set aside a big deal as long as
1:14:03you're doing great marketing everything but that's what appeals to me so I think
1:14:07it's like a philosophical difference and I'm obviously I'm probably more
1:14:11idealistic you not being the person whose job is to make the decision for a
1:14:16big company in the world or whatever and you can also question I think it's worth
1:14:21considering like is it too late to do something like that like are these
1:14:24systems so complex are are these devices an API is so feature rich and so mature
1:14:31it like is it wouldn't be too big undertaking for that and never it's
1:14:37never too late never two I mean if if anything I would say when is the time
1:14:42that you should be thinking about this it's when you're like at the height of
1:14:45your power because you try to do it like on your way down like promise like ways
1:14:48I could borrow a Sox we should make an all-new on like too little too late
1:14:54rammed into me likey you got it so whatever their plan is like they have a
1:14:59plan like if it takes some longer and they do it in a small series of steps or
1:15:03whatever but like you know that if the company will go out of business or the
1:15:07day will come when they need to have this better higher level thing and
1:15:11they're either going we'll have arrived at through a series of small steps and
1:15:14perhaps ended up at the destination is not quite as pretty as if they had made
1:15:17a larger disk discontinuous jump but you know I doubt there I think I think the
1:15:24only the only thing I wonder is perhaps we should pay a little more attention to
1:15:29any mentions of LLVM in claiming it at WTC because it seems to me they were
1:15:34going to sneak in a new language or somewhere new framework or something
1:15:38like that I would suppose that we would see traces of that their first like
1:15:42archive believe was if I'm not mistaken was a building built off of the static
1:15:48analysis that was in one of the two of these guys in and I'm opening up a whole
1:15:51new can of worms I don't open but I am just curious to see what LLVM inclined
1:15:56are doing over read lately and what the what will be announced that really just
1:16:00type inference because it's like a natural progression of what they're
1:16:04doing they pretty much almost have the metadata in there for a stock analysis
1:16:10combined with you know the knowledge required to make our quirk that makes it
1:16:15seem like they could do some reasonable time it may be is not enough bang for
1:16:19the buck maybe this occasion we could do Thai beverage but it's not such a big
1:16:23win to be worth the confusion so we're just gonna bail but assuming they
1:16:26actually think it's worthwhile it's an obvious next step of things they can do
1:16:30to make it easier to type less crap but you're not really changing the language
1:16:33like you know it's not change its language really just like how you know
1:16:38the type you must also know you do like auto or bar where the hell were they
1:16:42used to indicate that you know it's it's clear from the code just you know and
1:16:48then and also I think the pace of those improvements has increased dramatically
1:16:52in the last few years
1:16:53yeah what they want they got totally free of GCC right now we're seeing this
1:16:57explode like received like this past year that are all those little shortcuts
1:17:01in so many little benefits like just in one year
1:17:04you know and they still see full-size 11 kind of weighing them down like they got
1:17:09out from under GCC but they still need to do a lot more to like fully support
1:17:13the monster language that is C++ though like that that probably still absorbs a
1:17:17lot of their time like finally nailing down all the little crazy as C++ is that
1:17:24even possible
1:17:26like the point is the GCC GCC much like C++ compilers that have been compiling
1:17:34productive last for a long time are still ahead of her claims evils of
1:17:39support was as if like a year to go maybe they've closed the gap now but
1:17:42like it's a lot of work and it's it's kind of annoying work was like Apple
1:17:45barely uses C++ compared to like how much for example and so we gotta makers
1:17:52to become policy but we know we don't care about this language really like we
1:17:55have enough support for our stuff what it was like alright but if you want
1:17:58trying to be a popular widespread compiler and you have to you know make
1:18:03it supports if even that much and enemies all the stupid esoteric readers
1:18:08because you can't build
1:18:09important stupid projects food bill Brewster whatever they don't have that
1:18:14problem now but they did early on and if you can't support the new vehicles 11
1:18:18landers and also the crap you know that's that's still in the background
1:18:25like ketchup stuff to do before they can grow totally fly free C++ oxtails thing
1:18:32when it would have meant that that's what became his was 11th in it I don't
1:18:36know why I don't fall to sleep in all I try not to but even