0:00:00They'll say they funny now that's a really good that's a really good ending sort of sending funny
0:00:04and you know it's sort of the beginning of the show. That's true.
0:00:06Time has no meaning in podcast Marco you are the master of time and space.
0:00:13Some follow up if you want to talk about Flappy Bird
0:00:15and get in an argument again I I would just like to say that I think most of the feedback sided with me that flappy
0:00:23bird is actually a good game not a great game
0:00:26but it was that it got most of its popularity at least initial popularity boost that got it into the top charts which
0:00:33then made social element really take over.
0:00:35I got a lot of its popularity simply because of its merits
0:00:39and even though it is not it is not what you know it's to me it's like a McDonald's hamburger of games not even without
0:00:46Michael when he's number and like it's like you know you shouldn't like it it's terrible.
0:00:53It's complete junk However it's good. That's that's McDonald's Wendy's is good.
0:00:58McDonald's is not good except breakfast. Breakfast is going well or whatever people eat with all that actually good.
0:01:03Is there anything there that you have to make the burgers or not but breakfast is good.
0:01:08I actually found it like a long car trips where I have to like stop at a rest area some were in the middle of nowhere
0:01:13to eat.
0:01:14I would if I have to pick between the major fast food chains
0:01:17and you're really somewhere in the middle of nowhere I would go with McDonald's because they're they've always been
0:01:24extremely good about quality control standards and so it's you know you're guaranteed to get the same crap everywhere.
0:01:31Whereas Wendy's I like Wendy's better in an ideal case
0:01:35but I've had a lot I like I've had a much wider range of Wendy's quality.
0:01:39Where do we stop on the way back from South Carolina that we started
0:01:42when we did that was in a fairly populated area I'm talking about like if you're stopping at the Pennsylvania Turnpike
0:01:48or something you know really you're really in the middle of nowhere and you're and you have like the Roy Rogers
0:01:53or the mic. Oh God I remember. Or like the T.C.B. Why you know you know this is this is our new.
0:02:00This isn't so John what do you think about the Flappy Bird follow up I think the feedback was it's hard to tell
0:02:06but are especially because of course I only see the replies that I had mentioned me
0:02:10or you know like people mentioning just you to say they agree with you.
0:02:14I wouldn't see those or whatever but I think the majority of the feedback was that they agree with you
0:02:19and that just goes to show that the majority of people are often wrong about things like that.
0:02:26As is often the case in this part Guess where I don't do any preparation like we sort of talk about things in the
0:02:31moment right
0:02:32and then after the podcast I think of like how you know how I could have approached to better explain things better
0:02:39or maybe just the next I want to summarize stuff whereas I do have some actual fault that it by the notes about this
0:02:44but like you I have a vague outline here of kind of what we said the last time
0:02:51and the heading ever is the two sides of success
0:02:55and we barely touched on one of the sides maybe we should talk about it more.
0:03:00The first side of success is like
0:03:02when you're very successful you get a lot of attacks from people who don't think you should be that successful don't
0:03:09think you deserve your success or just because you're very popular you get a backlash effect.
0:03:15We've all experienced this to one degree or another. It's scales.
0:03:18Fortunately with your success if you're massively successful
0:03:20and everybody knows what you are you're going to have a portion of the larger backlash
0:03:25and that would be mentioned at the very beginning the last show maybe
0:03:28and I tried to point out that like I didn't think it was a terrible game because it's not it's not terrible it's not
0:03:35completely incompetent it's not non-functional it's you know it has high praise.
0:03:40Right so what I'm saying my people are there and I don't think it's a terrible game no it's not a terrible game
0:03:45and yes you have to recognize that because it's so successful do you see this crazy backlash against the game the
0:03:51concept of the game people who enjoy the game and that is one of the sides of success
0:03:58and I don't think we spend enough time focusing.
0:04:00Now because I think a lot of the people saying I agree with Marco it's not a terrible game I don't think anybody said
0:04:04it was a terrible game. Nobody thought it was terrible.
0:04:06You know I said it was not a good game
0:04:08and it's like oh it's good versus mediocre versus you know I would call it a mediocre game I would not call it a good
0:04:13game but certainly not terrible right.
0:04:16And of course as many things about it that make it be successful in the marketplace
0:04:20and I'm drawing distinction that a lot of other people don't.
0:04:22Between the quality of something like it is a good game a bad game or whatever
0:04:26and how successful it is in the market sort of like the is the McDonald's hamburger good hamburger
0:04:30or bad hammer versus how many McDonald's hamburgers are sold every year that type of distinction although I draw that
0:04:36line much more harshly than most people do because most people will say that their favorite movie is the best movie
0:04:41and I would never say that about my favorite movie
0:04:43or you know I can separate those two more than most people like to separate them.
0:04:48What is this movie at the hall the pod cast.
0:04:52I would say Marco what is best in life and you would say What are you talking about
0:04:55and what the second side of success is over I mean if you could just guess at least we're consistent.
0:05:08So I reach out to have a serious conversation here.
0:05:10Up this is not that long but do you think there's going to be some flapping So there's going to be some flapping
0:05:17and some birds Second Sight of success is the idea is the opposite side of the coin of like everyone attacking the
0:05:25thing is successful and that is people deciding that the successful thing is a success based on its merits
0:05:32and trick about that is choosing the merits that you think seem fair
0:05:37or admirable So that means diminishing the role of chance in this and minimizing or diminishing less attractive merits.
0:05:44So for example if you think it's admirable to be a successful game because of the code it's in the game itself because
0:05:51because of what's on the screen and how it works you elevate those elements
0:05:54and if you think it's not admirable to be successful because of a genius marketing campaign.
0:06:00Or like a very well made television ad or something or whatever you decide is sort of less fair or less you know.
0:06:09If you're deciding what your merits are most of us kind of agree like the game itself of the code that ships is good
0:06:15and the game is successful that is fair and there's Adam BOWEN We should all look up to
0:06:20but if something isn't successful because they take the other end of the spectrum someone you know paid to get a bunch
0:06:25of fake reviews we all agree that's not admirable.
0:06:27What if they had a really good ad campaign and they wrote the ad copy themselves and they made the art
0:06:31and they didn't want to. What if they had a really good strategy for viral marketing or whatever we decide.
0:06:36Well those aren't creepy or anything but they're not as admirable as the game.
0:06:40So as being in the game itself when I'm talking about like success based on the merit a lot most people
0:06:46when they see a big success will decide that the thing is successful based on whatever they think are the most
0:06:51admirable aspects of that success
0:06:56and I think that was I was taking a last podcast was that the merits of the game itself
0:07:02and that's the thing that I find I would find an admirable reason for success is like what's in the code what's in the
0:07:07binary that ships the people and all the other stuff I consider less less directly connected to success
0:07:14and in terms of like is the game good versus the marketing campaign good versus you know that the popularity of our
0:07:21When discussing that a lot.
0:07:23I mention in the show that there are plenty of other games that have similar attributes
0:07:27and as we were talking about was
0:07:28when Mark was saying the attributes of the game to its excessive playing those attributes were probably necessary for
0:07:34the success because of it's a terrible game on going to want to play anything
0:07:37but they're not sufficient because lots of other games have those same attributes and they're not successes.
0:07:42So you're saying that they were necessary
0:07:44but not sufficient implicitly one of trying to get here is implicitly we're discussing that all of us kind of agreed
0:07:51implicitly what things we're talking about we weren't talking about the ad campaign
0:07:55and we weren't talking about you know any other aspects of the.
0:08:00Again we were talking about essentially what's in the binary like the app itself
0:08:04and we did need to establish up front because I think like we're on the same page in terms of
0:08:10when you're talking about the game that's what we mean
0:08:12and I don't think that that's necessarily a valid viewpoint from all perspectives because if you were in the
0:08:17advertising business for example if you read Ad Age and I like our you know big into the advertising world.
0:08:23Of course you would consider the ad campaign part of the success of that you know the things like that so important
0:08:28fact it's more important in the binary that you created I was going to stab us in the like we are there are some things
0:08:33that we don't state that are definitely informing what it is that we're talking about so much so that we didn't even
0:08:37need to call them out last time and most people who are responding that's all that need to call them out
0:08:42but I think it's worth thinking about other perspectives on this.
0:08:46And anyway so they said that about you know their aftermath star having these characteristics of course people came out
0:08:51of the woodwork and said show me these tens of thousands of games that have these other characteristics
0:08:57and that's kind of a sucker's bet because a you know how many games are there in the App Store one hundred thousand two
0:09:03hundred fifty thousand are any more know how many games there are
0:09:05but no one has played them all so it's pretty much impossible to exhaust a very fine woman
0:09:09and it is some sort of statistical sampling of games to try to find games of these qualities.
0:09:14Couple people posted games or they thought here's this game from five years ago that I was in college or whatever
0:09:18but the reason I say it's a sucker's bet because whatever game anyone was to cite someone will say well that one is not
0:09:26alike enough because there's always some extra nuance
0:09:29or Flappy Birds has this game doesn't have the down to the fact like well that doesn't include birds in flappy birds
0:09:34includes birds and do the history of the App Store with or as a call Angry Birds and tiny wing that birds
0:09:40and selves you know therefore fly the birds was this perfect thing you know and it would be impossible.
0:09:46There was I see that little nuance that I point out this game has a neck
0:09:50and doesn't have you know extra levels all on one screen doesn't scroll doesn't matter where you tap on the screen to
0:09:55some like the always be some difference treating the game that you cite in that game
0:09:58and say See that's why flappy birds.
0:10:00Yes and his other game wasn't and that's why I think flappy bird itself is the best example.
0:10:06Which is why I gave the time travel scenario on the show which is like OK go back in time to before it was created.
0:10:12Bring the Flappy Bird diary with you submit it to the App Store across you know provisioning profiles would never let
0:10:17you do this but anyway.
0:10:21And and you'll see that it doesn't sell and flappy bird itself is on the App Store for months and months and months
0:10:26and it didn't it didn't sell right
0:10:28and even then with this example I imagine someone will say well there was some minor gameplay tweak that happened just
0:10:33a week.
0:10:34It took off and that was a minor game which gave gameplay tweak that made it happen all of this is true or not
0:10:39and of fighting for its gameplay was updated all between the time it was released six months ago now
0:10:43but that's what some would say
0:10:45and the reason I bring up these hypothetical you know people's complaints that they would have if you were trying to
0:10:50say earlier games or if you were trying to say flappy bird itself which I did frequently on Twitter
0:10:54and say what about fly the result was over six months was not successful.
0:10:57Like well you know understand it was it was you know it had to be it had to be in the store gestating for six months
0:11:03because of how long the ramp takes for viral whatever you know there's always something you can say
0:11:06and this is the point I really wanted to get at on this part of cast and that I didn't bring up the last one.
0:11:13It's the second side of excesses people seeing something through festival
0:11:18and then working backwards from its success to determine why is why it was successful it's kind of this fatalistic
0:11:24everything happens for a reason mindset where you see something successful
0:11:27and decide that every attribute of that thing that you find admirable has to be in exactly that position for it to be
0:11:32set otherwise how could it have happened.
0:11:34Right and this I think even applies to really good games and most other things in life where you look at the success
0:11:42and even the really admirable awesome things about it. You'll say that's why it succeeded.
0:11:46And also every other detail of that thing because how could it have been any other way you know this is what happened
0:11:51so it was written so it shall be done.
0:11:53Be married to the perfect game because it is massless it has no other games that were not five birds were not
0:11:57successful therefore you must be like flappy birds. Nothing but flappy bird could have been together also and so forth.
0:12:03And to address this friend of the show Kieran Healy put a blog post he's the sociologist
0:12:09or does he play on the Internet I think is a real sociologist and teaches sociology.
0:12:13He's really smart he teaches it do you believe that's true and if that's not true when I go and he's actually U.N.C.
0:12:18or Something I'm being real deep trouble.
0:12:20He posts something where the sociologists are interested in this phenomenon of like how do things become successful
0:12:25and the angle they were taking on it was why can't record executives and stuff predict like hit songs
0:12:31and ideas like don't you guys know anything about their business how come they have such a poor track record a perfect
0:12:38hit song some songs hit some songs don't
0:12:40and if you asked executives beforehand they would be totally sure the song that was going to be a hit and it was
0:12:45and other people say the song is going nowhere and becomes a mega-hit. Why can't we predict that.
0:12:49So trying to figure out this phenomenon they ran a series of experiments where they had a bunch of songs in this case
0:12:54and had people listen to them and download them.
0:12:58It was like fourteen thousand different people
0:13:00and in some situations the people could see what other people were doing.
0:13:04They could see how many downloads a song have.
0:13:06And in other situations they can see how many songs how many times a song is downloaded.
0:13:12So it's basically trying to move the slider on social influence from like zero all they have to maximum
0:13:19and what they found an experiment was that increasing the strength of social influence increased both the inequality
0:13:25and unpredictability of success.
0:13:27So as they made the social aspect more relevant like as they show the download numbers more primally as they sort of
0:13:32buy downloads or whatever the difference between the most only successful became much bigger.
0:13:38The difference you like the winners of the races which you kind of expect because like this a piling on effect of like
0:13:42once everyone recognizes a winner everyone's going to download it
0:13:45and losers want to download it all versus if you had no signal from what other people are doing there would be you
0:13:50wouldn't see this runaway success. But the other part of the thing was that the predictability of success went down.
0:13:56So in general the best songs never do really bad. On the worst songs.
0:14:01Never did really well but almost any other result was possible I'm quoting from his blog post there.
0:14:07So basically once you add social signal to the mix amongst the games amongst the songs that were kind of in the good
0:14:14category as the social signal increased which one of those songs would be that it became totally unpredictable
0:14:20and he when he wrote he first wrote this blog post I was like oh this is one point I didn't make
0:14:25and I'm excited to make it on the on the pod cast next week but only updated his blog post making my additional point.
0:14:31He told me I could still make it because we're both right so I will use the phrase that I was going to use here I had
0:14:38to come up with different wording to that I want to copy is right exactly the way he's trying to explain the reluctance
0:14:44of people's reluctance to agree that true unpredictability is a real feature of markets like this like people don't
0:14:49want to believe that there is that unpredictability as you increase also saying NO among the top they want to believe
0:14:54that the one that came in number one was always going to be the number one
0:14:57but these experiments prove that in a totally different set of people with the same set of songs.
0:15:01Run this experiment to different times amongst the sort of good enough to be good songs as you increase a social signal
0:15:07a totally unpredictable and people do not want to believe that so he says.
0:15:11Psychologically people are often predisposed to believe in some version of a just world hypothesis where people are
0:15:16fundamentally get what they deserve and that's trying to get it
0:15:19but the fatalism thing people want to believe that the world is fair and just
0:15:23and that what happened deserve to happen especially with something like well I like this game
0:15:28and it's the number one game.
0:15:29Obviously it's number one because it's a good game
0:15:31and if you try to tell them that it's number one for reasons other than just it being a really good game you're saying
0:15:36this game is terrible or you know you just don't understand why this game is good or anything like that.
0:15:43Here
0:15:43and even cites the other example that I was hoping to bring out which is you see this all the time in books about how
0:15:48to succeed in business but what happens basically in the eighty's
0:15:52and I guess in the ninety's probably today as well as some.
0:15:57Some rich white dude had a very rich white dude who shows in a row.
0:16:00Some are trying to you may or may not people there where if you pay
0:16:02but the eighty's becomes amazingly successful for whatever reason and besides I now know everything.
0:16:10I'm a mass of the successful I need to write a book telling everybody else what I know and they don't
0:16:14and they write these books about like here's what I do like every morning and have cornflakes are right
0:16:19and then make sure you drive an American car
0:16:21and we get into work early like they did they just take every detail from their life
0:16:25and they say because I am successful.
0:16:26Everything I do in my life must have led to the success there for all of you people should do this
0:16:30and you're not successful so who are you to complain.
0:16:33Again working backwards from success in every business is like that like we did this in our business
0:16:38and we're successful therefore you can do this.
0:16:39Seven Habits of Highly Effective People
0:16:42or whenever we get the software methodologies about in the future show I'm sure talking about this is a year where it's
0:16:50like we did something we were successful therefore this methodology should work for everybody
0:16:55and all the business book in particular love to just that the winners come and tell you here's what I did
0:17:01and if you do that you'll be successful because otherwise to think otherwise would be to think that your success is
0:17:07derived from something other than the merits you consider admirable if your success is derived from like you know the
0:17:12fact that you had rich parents
0:17:14and got into a good school because their legacies the fact that you were in the right place at the right time with a
0:17:20product that was merely satisfactory and
0:17:23and you know you decide it's because of your great business AQIM in really any monkey could have run the business
0:17:28and would have been just fine and had the same result.
0:17:30No one wants to believe that happenstance or things that you don't consider admirable contributed to your success
0:17:36but I think in general that is more often the case.
0:17:41Anyway this link to Karen's article but the results and links to the papers that no one's going to read
0:17:45but he has a really good summary of it with some grass and then encourage everyone to read it.
0:17:50I agree Marco that most people that agree with you
0:17:52but I think all of them are suffering from the symptoms described in Karen's blog post or well and also.
0:18:00I think one other valid point to make here.
0:18:03I'm not going to even try to address all that because I'm not qualified really
0:18:08and I have to save my words tonight so I don't and I'm coughing all night. But that's science.
0:18:13Yes and I and science is always right.
0:18:16So I think another thing to consider here is
0:18:21when trying to apply lessons learned from someone else's success to two general cases
0:18:27or to your case during the the great Gruber and Marilyn South by Southwest.
0:18:33Oh nine Talk what your was at a nine car rolled up in the show.
0:18:40It's one group Merlin talks and it's the titles like how to supercharge your blog
0:18:44and that's of course as I cast a title and it's a fantastic talkers audio recordings of it
0:18:51and it was two thousand nine hundred fireball it's not really going to work because we already have a Daring Fireball
0:19:11and Daring Fireball got big in an environment that didn't have a Daring Fireball and so
0:19:20and the environment back then was different and then he succeeded in that environment.
0:19:24But if you try to do the same thing today you're in a completely different time with different set of conditions
0:19:30and you know the same lessons don't always work more than once because they they have this context that let them work
0:19:37or that or that they thrive with and so like everyone's going to make all these flappy clone games now
0:19:42and try to replicate this but this succeeded you know in part because of the environment and the time
0:19:49and the fact that something like this hadn't really done this before so it was this novelty you know all know something
0:19:55like this or something like this. Hadn't done it before that people had seen.
0:20:00And it's why people thought that the interesting thing but like that.
0:20:02That's why
0:20:03when people brought up the Flappy Bird clones like you know lots of those a lot of debate that sort of mention me that
0:20:08I didn't participate in on Twitter
0:20:10and some of them were like well just look at all the flighty Bird clones why are they succeeding all that is obvious
0:20:15you know like they're just whatever is already exists like that that's the reason I came for the time travel scenario
0:20:20you can't you can't say Welcome make a bird just like bloody birds now
0:20:23but better doesn't succeed therefore you know what I was describing.
0:20:27That's that's not a valid example you know by the way the Flappy Bird clones are succeeding.
0:20:31Well you know they think the same way that the mains water succeed you know typos
0:20:36and the wonders of the App Store search ensure that far outweigh don't look at the pop charts like the Clones are still
0:20:43happening.
0:20:43Well you know it's also the fact that now you can get flappy bird so it's wide open for Flappy Bird clones
0:20:48but you know what I mean like they're not none of those cones is going to be flooded roads because flooded roads
0:20:52already so that is that's not irrelevant to talk about.
0:20:58We are sponsored this week by our friends attending Tang is mobile that makes sense. There are no B.S.
0:21:04Simple to use mobile service provider from the people at two cows the company behind hover ting is a reseller of the
0:21:10Sprint network in the U.S. They have a great solid network behind them. It's going to a special U.R.L.
0:21:15To learn more A.T.P. Ping dot com It's a very simple take it has great rates.
0:21:22There's no contract and there's no early termination fees.
0:21:25You own your device out right from the start and then you just pay for what you use every month so here's how it works.
0:21:32You get any compatible Sprint device you can get through them you can get it new you can get it used you can buy
0:21:38yourself on e Bay
0:21:39or whatever you can you know ask a friend if they have an old Sprint device including the Sprint i Phone So check check
0:21:46them to see exactly which models are compatible they have all the stuff up going to A.T.P.
0:21:50That can not come to see so anyway you get your phone somehow doesn't really matter how any kind of any spring
0:21:55compatible phone that they list in their site and then you just pay a base price of sixty.
0:22:00It's a month to get connected
0:22:01and then on top of that there's all these buckets for there's a bucket set for for data buckets for talk minutes about
0:22:08get set for S.M.S.
0:22:09and Use pay for whatever you use whatever bucket is the cheapest that will accomplish what they use they pick that one
0:22:14needle you for and there are a few bucks each so you can see.
0:22:17So for example you know if you use use one hundred megs of data this month on a device you'll just pay for that bucket
0:22:24if you use a gig next month you'll pay for that bucket next month
0:22:27and the next month after that if you switch was back down but right back down so you never really pay for it.
0:22:33You don't have to remember to like you know go to their site or call them and get it increased when you go on a trip
0:22:38and then get it decreased when you go back home. None of that you just pay for what you use.
0:22:42Simple as that their prices are actually recently even lower.
0:22:46They discounted a bunch of their data presence bestially So five hundred megs twelve bucks two gigs is just twenty nine.
0:22:54So really really cheap data here that it includes tethering too.
0:22:59So really great so you can see how much you can save by going to tango eight A.T.P.
0:23:04To come check out the savings calculator you can enter in your last few bills from a carrier
0:23:09and they'll show you based on your usage how much you will save with Thing
0:23:14and over time they can show you OK well let's say you go to buy a device up front.
0:23:18Then you'll pay for it in three months with the savings or whatever it's a really great stuff here.
0:23:24They also have this cool program where if you're stuck in a contract with someone else
0:23:27and have to pay an early termination fee to get yourself to Tang.
0:23:30They will even give you twenty five percent of that early termination fee in service credit up to seventy five dollars
0:23:37to help get you over the ten years with this possible. They have great customer support just like cover.
0:23:43No hold no wait. Telephone support during the business day so you can just call them between A.T.M. and Eight P.M.
0:23:48Eastern and a human being will pick up the phone who is ready and able to help you.
0:23:53No waiting on hold for Evernote transfers two million different departments.
0:23:57Great set up here and they have tons of features only one time talk about.
0:24:00They they have you can pull devices to manage a fleet of devices all this crazy stuff great stuff here.
0:24:06It's also really good for developers if you want test devices on different platforms like Android you can get a test
0:24:11device have it connected with the great data plan you can even buy a Nexus five from the Google Play store at a great
0:24:17rate and bring it over to saying great stuff here sort of find out more. Going to A.T.P.
0:24:22Tang dot com and I believe that's it I don't think you have to enter coupon code or anything.
0:24:28Yep that's a good thing that come
0:24:30and learn more about this great company Thanks a lot to take in for sponsoring the show once again.
0:24:36So powerful very birds brands that at least I'm continuing to refer to this as flappy birds when it's singular.
0:24:42I was not going to correct you on that. Everyone's doing this by the way.
0:24:45Yeah I know I know I
0:24:47and I have the opposite problem with tiny wings where I feel like I always want to call tiny wing
0:24:51but it wouldn't make no sense that there was just one wing anyway all these birds
0:24:55and then a series of other things I was there is another thing with the birds like things that contribute to this.
0:24:59Flappy Birds I have to think somewhere in the list of things that contribute to this is us is the fact that it features
0:25:04a bird.
0:25:05Absolutely yeah I mean
0:25:06and the fact that that birds are you know common in the App Store there's been a lot of hit games birds
0:25:12and their cuteness games about flying and it's had good artwork I mean it's there's no question that was part of it.
0:25:18Like in terms like your inherent experiments that he cited in his blog like what is the thing that caused the Angry
0:25:25Birds to hit or go go back in time why the bird games are associated with mobile devices angry it was anger
0:25:31but it's the first one was it building on something else like it's such an incredibly complex situation which I didn't
0:25:37think you could ever devise an experiment to try and isolate the things that I saw it in this experiment
0:25:41but even this experiment is much simpler than the actual app store because songs are sort of I guess they have titles
0:25:46and maybe that contributes to but they don't have artwork
0:25:48and I guess they have the entire history of music behind them
0:25:51but it's kind of like you don't know what you're getting into you click on the thing
0:25:54and then you listen to it like what determines as they increase
0:25:57or which one becomes a hit it's one of those ones in the.
0:26:00But which one and likely run the experiment a million times and it keeps becoming incredibly important to Bill.
0:26:04Which one will be the runaway success there are it is a runaway success
0:26:07but you don't know which one out of the good group it is
0:26:09and I think they'll be the next phase an experiment trying to figure out is it really completely random
0:26:14or what other variables contributing towards increasing
0:26:18or decreasing your stance your chance of sort of being the lottery winner among the games that have these among the the
0:26:25songs that have these qualities to put them somewhere and a good group and a flapping.
0:26:32So we had the kind of monumental moments over the last week and our member exactly when it was the image I was wrong.
0:26:42I'm going to choose to not engage on that one but I think you have to choose K.C. Mommy or daddy.
0:26:54Right so we're professionals.
0:26:56So we had an interesting moment over the last week wherein we actually got a bit of not complimentary feedback about
0:27:05John of all people which never really happens this is very rare that's not true that it doesn't come to the show comes
0:27:12directly to me and believe me it exists. MEIGS Yes but Hand on heart.
0:27:18I've seen maybe five less than complimentary things about John
0:27:22and about five hundred for Marco on about five thousand for me.
0:27:25Well that Marco gets a lot of them directly to do with what they know like where they can reach you they don't need to
0:27:30go through the show feedback form to say mean things to you usually get on Twitter.
0:27:34The email is mostly stuff since I pulled my email address off of my site. It's all hard to figure out.
0:27:38Yeah well anyway So John do you want to address what this what this person said.
0:27:45Yeah I didn't put it in there because I was such a big deal that you know I get hate mail because if I get a mail right.
0:27:50But because I thought well a couple aspects of it were interesting
0:27:54and I'm going to read a paragraph of it here not the whole thing it's sent from that what they put in the feedback.
0:28:00When was goofball Jones purchased fake name obviously
0:28:02and it says a throwaway accounts not really looking for this to be read on air
0:28:06and it probably won't so there are some good reverse psychology there like you know
0:28:09when they say I don't expect a reply I don't expect this to be read on air
0:28:14and if I say that I'll read it in there that's not why I'm reading out of there but in effect it works.
0:28:19Oh you plan also before you get into it that somebody criticize urine
0:28:23and as a result our notes file now has fifteen links in it for this topic.
0:28:28I'm going to put all of them into the show not continuing.
0:28:33I can take a listen to this part guess anymore I mean I know it's artistic is not like anything after all his old
0:28:38podcast was called hyper critical and it wears thin after a while the guy complains about everything.
0:28:42Well it's OK once in a while it's all the time all in caps. It's not even funny anymore.
0:28:47It sounds more like a miserable person just whining about his miserable existence.
0:28:50What are we to do with this does it really offer any insight to anything are people actually entertained by this on a
0:28:56sustained level Now the reason I bring that the show is to put this in the shows two reasons one.
0:29:02I'm fascinated by the idea that this person put in a fake email in the feedback form
0:29:08or that use like a throwaway account
0:29:10or whatever like I don't even know because I think that the real I mean why would you create a fake.
0:29:15Can't you just type anything in the email field it doesn't make you confirm that your email is real right.
0:29:19I don't think so yeah I think you can just buy anything there.
0:29:22And like why wouldn't you put just put your regular you like either put it either put like X X X X dot com
0:29:28or something or just a made up thing
0:29:29or put your real email in like is there is there a downside to having a really male like I'm going to harass them by
0:29:34email or tell people their email I don't know
0:29:36and that that confuses me as as does NOT using their real name who cares like if you don't like it you know put your
0:29:41real name like it's not talking about you and me anyway.
0:29:47So want to put in the show nuts because you are a whole bunch of links to me being not critical about things
0:29:54or talking about things that I mostly like or that like a lot. Yeah.
0:30:01And like I put these in here not to convince anybody of anything because I just want to provide context
0:30:07and I have a preface by saying that if your state of being requires some elaborate explanation there's already a
0:30:12problem. This person is never going to like how much contact so I don't know you don't understand.
0:30:16Here's the context maybe complaining about things like Oh yeah.
0:30:19Now I find it much more enjoyable like I'm not letting this person over those persons not wasn't the target anymore
0:30:24or whatever
0:30:25but I thought it was worth talking about because it's easy for me to assume an easy for all of us assume I think that
0:30:32everybody already knows where we're coming from that they know all of our conduct so they've read our blog for years
0:30:37they've read everything we write on the web and all our old podcast they know everything about us
0:30:43and that's just not true.
0:30:44We can kind of feel like you know of course everybody knows who these people are except for Katie obviously
0:30:49and you know and where they're coming from and what opinions they've had before
0:30:55and what other part because they've been on things they like one things I don't myself like that I mean I find myself
0:31:00doing it too.
0:31:00Like I assume that you know everyone who listens the show has listened I have are critical
0:31:03and I find someone who listens the show and as never heard of hydrocortisone I'm surprised and I shouldn't be right.
0:31:09So I think it's worthwhile providing contacts to the people who do actually enjoy the show.
0:31:15I think they would enjoy it more understand it better with a little bit of context to that into the main thing I object
0:31:21to in this person's emails not so much they don't like the show.
0:31:23Fine you know like you know like whatever you don't like me you know like me that's fine
0:31:27but the idea that I'm a miserable person
0:31:29and I have a miserable existence that's easily refuted by a long list of pod cast I've been on where I talk about
0:31:36things that I almost you know unabashedly love almost everything about and I put tons of links
0:31:43and they're not going to read off what they are. Marco will copy and paste them into the show notes.
0:31:48But suffice it to say that I talk about some podcasts I mostly just talk about things that I like
0:31:54and the one link that I want to put in here for the people who want to kind of this is the original thing that I posted
0:31:59the.
0:32:00In two thousand
0:32:00and nine with the title hypercritical which is sort of my explanation of my shtick as he put it like what's the deal
0:32:05with a guy who complains all the time.
0:32:06Here is my attempt at explaining it again this explanation is not going to convince anyone that they are all not
0:32:10something I like hearing complaining all the time you know obviously if I go when I went over
0:32:14but I think it does provide context and again I always assume everyone who reads my blog
0:32:18or listens to this part of death or help I guess.
0:32:21Of course they read this article How could they be listening to this you know that would know where I was coming from
0:32:25but that seems to not be the case.
0:32:28So anyway and also we didn't have a sort of a dippy by the way where we talk about how we deal with criticism
0:32:33and all that stuff which again some new listeners may not have heard so there will be a cornucopia of show notes links
0:32:40this week for people who want to hear me liking things you know I think the most obvious example of this which is the
0:32:50first one you listed is you
0:32:52and Dan Benjamin doing your five by five movies is that still the only edition of five by five of the movies.
0:32:58Now I think the second one and you know what the point is there's not many.
0:33:02And this this podcast which which you did with Dan if you don't know listeners in you should listen to this.
0:33:13Dan and John took the movie Goodfellas
0:33:15and you literally spin something to the order of one hundred fifty percent of the length of the movie discussing the
0:33:23movie I remember you being extremely If you save and
0:33:27and it it's how do you spend three hours talking about a two hour movie.
0:33:31You know if you love it like that that to me is just a seminal example of you being extremely positive
0:33:39and if you set about something I mean it's one thing to spend an hour talking about a two hour movie
0:33:43and liking it it's another thing to spend two hours talking about a two hour movie and liking it.
0:33:47But you sent something to the order of three hours discussing this two hour movie
0:33:51and how phenomenal it was in every frame.
0:33:54And that's pretty darn complimentary and I loved it and I love Goodfellas and I've seen them.
0:34:00Movie thank you very much and I'd seen it before you'd done that pod cast thank you very much.
0:34:05I know you're proud of the truly that podcast is wonderful
0:34:10and in you know it it reminded me a lot of the really fantastic ones that that John Gruber
0:34:16and Dan did about the Bond series but either way the point is it was extremely If you say that
0:34:21and to me one of the things I love so much about the work that you do
0:34:24and why I'm so lucky to be on the show with you is because a lot of the times
0:34:28when you tear something apart it to me it's so clearly out of love not out of hate and
0:34:32and that's that's what makes it so enjoyable because if it really was negative I wouldn't want to be on the show.
0:34:38Now as the saying goes the opposite of love is not hate it's indifference.
0:34:42And if I'm indifferent
0:34:43or something you don't hear me talk about it all the good example that I was that well you know it is
0:34:46but we did the incomparable covered the first three Star Wars movies which I really like
0:34:52and we did two episodes on each movie set six total episodes of the original trilogy of Star Wars
0:34:57and of course the video game that I could not stop talking about you know since it was released
0:35:02and for having talked Ernie we did an episode of Being comfortable about that as well.
0:35:05So anyway there's tons of me liking things if you want to hear that which you may or may not.
0:35:12I was expecting a much better rant
0:35:14and a little disappointed now because I sent a NIAM to Margo a couple that we get there to now saying hey man if you
0:35:20look at the show notes lately because you're in for a good show of history I don't want to write like this one I'm
0:35:25going to try to convince someone who doesn't like me that they should like me like this.
0:35:29The section was not for that person who presumably is not listening to the show anymore
0:35:32but for the people who are listening and do enjoy it and might enjoy it more with more context and background.
0:35:38Right now I'm a little disappointed.
0:35:41It's OK You know we're also sponsored this week by our friends at square space the on one platform that makes it fast
0:35:48and easy to create your own professional website or online portfolio for free trial
0:35:53and ten percent off going to squarespace dot com and use offer code. Casey that is see.
0:36:00Why in case no one knows how to spell Katie's name like all the people who e-mail us square spaces always improving
0:36:06their platform with new features new designs and even better support.
0:36:10They're beautiful to learn to start with
0:36:11but then you can also customize them with all their cool tools online that are really easy to use
0:36:16and also if you can inject custom H.T.M.L. C.S.S. and Javascript if you so desire.
0:36:21They also have mobile layouts for all their sites they're fully response of layouts so they're great on any device any
0:36:28screen size.
0:36:29If you need any help doing all this stuff they have an amazing support team with over seventy employees right here in
0:36:35New York City.
0:36:36They works twenty four hours a day seven days a week on support their customer support team has won numerous awards as
0:36:42have their designs and many other things about square space because they are just that awesome.
0:36:47Just eight dollars a month and includes a freedom eighty percent for a whole year up front.
0:36:52And they're doing they have a couple new things for the same read over
0:36:55and over again because they sponsor the entire pod cast a sphere which we love them for of course they have a couple
0:37:02new things so they're this new thing called square space logo in addition to build a new Web site they now have this
0:37:08thing actually lets you create a logo for your side business cards shirt whatever you want you can go check out
0:37:14squarespace dot com slash logo.
0:37:16Also every square space plan now includes that they built this cool commerce functionality
0:37:21and before it was limited to only certain accounts.
0:37:24Now all accounts include the commerce functionality so you can have you can now have you can make your own store online.
0:37:32Online goods or offline goods if you want to like sell shirts or anything
0:37:35or if you want to sell like you know e-books anything electronic
0:37:38or physical you can sell through their store full integration full you know store front carts all this crazy stuff they
0:37:44have all this built for you comes with every square space player now at no additional charge.
0:37:50And a really cool thing now is if you want to work at square space. So go to be a part of it.
0:37:56That's squarespace dot com be a part of it. They are hiring and they are really rolling out the red carpet here.
0:38:03If you have you for an engineering
0:38:05or design position before March fifteenth they will invite you in your partner to be New Yorkers for a weekend.
0:38:10They'll fly you out to New York put you have one of the city's best hotels
0:38:13and give you a long weekend of checking out some of their favorite attractions cultural icons
0:38:17and restaurants in the city. And Squarespace picks up the tab for the whole thing.
0:38:22They've been voted one of New York City's greatest places to work for two years running.
0:38:26So put them on your short list if you're looking for a job they're looking to hire thirty engineers
0:38:30and designers by March fifteenth. So go to be a part of it that's where Space dot com to learn more about that.
0:38:37Anyway thanks what a square space for sponsoring our show.
0:38:40Once again good scripts based are commies offer code Casey for ten percent off.
0:38:44Thanks a lot to square space for sponsoring the show again.
0:38:47Do you have any thoughts on what's app what's up on even I don't freeze this I don't really to be honest this is kind
0:38:55of unimportant and boring to me which I know is making friend of the show Ben Thompson pulls hair out
0:39:02but I don't to me it's just very unremarkable other than the cost because it doesn't mean it doesn't mean anything to
0:39:10me I've never seen the app outside of a screenshot I think of one on one of St T. Cories posts.
0:39:17Nice This is matter to you too.
0:39:20I think what's interesting is that we don't know that much about it
0:39:22and it has been right you know I think this shows more than anything recently that you know there were there were
0:39:28always you know there's the consumer tech stuff that we all see
0:39:32and there is there was always like the kind of business side of enterprise tech stuff that was mostly invisible world
0:39:37to those of us outside of it that you know we don't really care like if s.a.p bought Oracle it would be a major deal to
0:39:45a lot of people but consumers wouldn't know who these people are and wouldn't care.
0:39:50This I think shows that the consumer tech world is now so big you know what SAP is as far as I know and I.
0:40:00I know very little about I really shouldn't be talking about it but as far as I know it is huge in lots of places
0:40:06but North America is not one of them.
0:40:08And so as far as I know at any rate it's really massive were everywhere else at least
0:40:13and so I did a lot of Americans aren't familiar with it you know
0:40:18and the fact is it's it got so big to be a major threat to Facebook and Facebook also you know so.
0:40:27So what's app is is basically a replacement for S.M.S.
0:40:30and There's a few other apps that do this like there's a line and there's a couple of
0:40:34but I think I think this is the biggest worldwide I think I'm not sure about that.
0:40:39But what this really shows you know S.M.S. Is extremely valuable and Facebook want.
0:40:44Facebook has wanted to own that they want to they want it when you say it's the messenger
0:40:48and not everyone use Facebook Messenger
0:40:50and I think that's pretty much the reason for this that Facebook saw this major market.
0:40:56This is worth a ton of money because it replaces S.M.S. For so many people.
0:41:00And Facebook wants in on that and Facebook is not a part of that and it's not some kind of standard protocol like S.M.S.
0:41:07Was then they're kind of locked out and it could actually work against them to not own this in the future.
0:41:13You know if all the socialization ister is happening on something that someone else controls
0:41:17and that someone else could lock up
0:41:19and to keep Facebook out of that's pretty bad for them so I think this there's no question why Facebook would want this.
0:41:26That is very no question that that is that is clear.
0:41:32As for the finances I have no idea people who are more no more knowledgeable about the stuff than they seem to seem to
0:41:38think this is actually not a terrible price for this
0:41:42but I think it just really shows the tech world is so big now that it's such a massive collection of multiple
0:41:51industries even though this isn't even just want to scream
0:41:53or it's so big that extremely major things like this can happen in it and most of us don't know anything.
0:42:00About it
0:42:00and you know the idea of having like a tech show that comments on everything in the world tech is completely outdated
0:42:05now because the world tech is too big and like one show not only doesn't have time for that kind of thing
0:42:11but even the host on the show like you can't you can't get enough hosts on a show taping experts all these areas were
0:42:18big news is happening anymore.
0:42:21You know I agree the only reason I think that maybe we don't understand this is how many how many friends do you have
0:42:28Marco that you communicate with on a regular basis regular enough that you would desire to send them text messages that
0:42:36do not live in the United States. Exactly how are you John.
0:42:42Well we don't we live in the United States
0:42:44but if you lived in a right on trade be communicating with different countries.
0:42:47Well but the thing of it is is that the United States lives in a very kind of sheltered the right word
0:42:54but we we live in our own little igloo insular. Thank you.
0:42:58That sort I'm looking for and so we're looking at Europe for example Europe.
0:43:03In Europe it's very easy to go to another country because all the countries in Europe are the size of Rhode Island
0:43:09and only it's a did just email Marco.
0:43:12But anyway the point is the point is locating a side is that there's a lot more international contact in Europe
0:43:20and from everything I've gathered anyways
0:43:23and so it would not be surprising to me if if it was a much more important thing to have international text messaging
0:43:33between countries and I know I have a friend that lives in Wales and he happens to be American but he lives in Wales
0:43:38and about a year
0:43:39and a half ago maybe two years ago he begged me to install Viber which was some equivalent to what's happened that
0:43:47would let us exchange text messages for free and that was before i Message
0:43:51or it was around the time that I message was the thing
0:43:54and I know that I wouldn't talk to for example my curly nearly as much as I do it wasn't for the fact that he you know.
0:44:00Can I messaged back and forth and I message was doomed to never be this thing because you couldn't do it on Android.
0:44:05Yeah exactly.
0:44:06And the advantage of what's happened all environ all these other things is that they are cross-platform so by by virtue
0:44:12of them being international
0:44:13and being cross platform which are two things that don't matter that much to the three of us the cross-platform part
0:44:20anyway
0:44:20and certainly don't matter that much to us in the international part I don't think we were ever really in a position
0:44:27that Americans would understand this plus most American cell phone plans.
0:44:32It's a feat to get unlimited text messaging
0:44:35but nearly everyone paid everyone that I know pays it in fact I was one of the big holdouts to not get an unlimited
0:44:43text messaging plan and even I eventually caved. I don't know three years ago four years ago something like that.
0:44:50So it's it's not surprising to me that Americans don't understand it
0:44:55but it's also not surprising to me that it is a pretty big deal.
0:44:59I still have an unlimited texting plan which will surprise you don't you don't really have a cell phone.
0:45:04I know very well I don't have one either because I've been holding on A.T.M.
0:45:07To the one of the reasons why everyone has these on them in a plant in the U.S.
0:45:11Now is because the carriers have removed most sensible options to force you to pay to pay more money.
0:45:18It's just like the triple play deal that every cable company
0:45:23and file is pushing extremely hard anybody who doesn't have all the services you know that is similar with protest
0:45:29plans where I'm still using this grandfathered like five dollar a month for a few hundred text message plan because I I
0:45:37just don't need anything more than that
0:45:39but you know if you had to start a new line today your only choice basically is like no texts
0:45:44and pay for each one which usually ends up being a lot or unlimited like in the U.S.
0:45:50There's almost no other options right now that this whatsapp thing assists.
0:45:55When I look at it it looks like more sort of kind of useless churn.
0:46:00In the market for things that like we all know that people want
0:46:04but that we can't seem to get an A in a nice pleasant way like more people want to talk to each other like the
0:46:11telephone was a nice way for people to talk to each other but it had both real
0:46:15and artificial barriers the real barriers where that you know the power of the president to be there
0:46:19when you call them
0:46:20and then international calling it like of course I can delay for you know the distances traveled that was weird for
0:46:26real time
0:46:27and then the artificial barriers Well no kind of real to it like a long distance fees because all costs more money to
0:46:32call for their wages to pay for the infrastructure to get there
0:46:35but in the long distance fees scaled up on a scale that wasn't a portion of the cost of making the call that was all
0:46:40kind of weird but people want to talk to each other
0:46:43and so instant messaging with the advent of the Internet is like well you know now we don't need to pay long distance
0:46:47fees I can talk immediately to someone in another country this is a paper you can do e-mail you know the one that kind
0:46:52of sort of worked out although you know that terrible secure decisions lead to spam
0:46:57but at least there's only sort of one email but instant message there was tons of instant messaging client
0:47:01and it was all surrounding us wanting to talk to each other in real time
0:47:05and all that stupid churn between I think you and I am in Yahoo Instant Messenger and M.S.N.
0:47:09and Skype and like all these different networks each Sometimes getting critical mass
0:47:14and nothing will ever be as big as I think you and I remember my C Q number till the day I die
0:47:18and then it just goes away and the name is big and everyone the name and all my friends are on AIM and then S.M.S.
0:47:23Comes
0:47:23and everyone's texting like all these things are churning around the basic desire we have to communicate to each other
0:47:31in more or less real time with maybe a little bit of asynchronous stuff allowed like
0:47:36but you know shorter than an email not a phone call text to and from each other
0:47:42and Whatsapp was taking advantage of I go as I messages are a feeling where they charge you ten cents for the stupid
0:47:47things that they're piggybacking on analog cell signals anyway back in the day you know I was like it was free for the
0:47:51carriers and they would say we can charge people ten cents we think we'll make a mint and they did
0:47:55but that was an artificial back that people start to realize I was out of it was no reason to hate our son.
0:48:00As it always struck me as like you were charging money for something that should not cost much
0:48:03but people found a valuable so they paid and then as soon as people could bypass that with Whatsapp and vibe in line
0:48:09and I message
0:48:10and all the other apps we have access to the public Internet over the data network the same cell providers give us a
0:48:15why would I pay ten cents
0:48:16or paper a texting plan well because all my friends aren't actually the room texting each other whatever well whatsapp
0:48:22and the other apps like it got enough people to say hey come over here it's cheaper or free
0:48:27and we don't charge attendance for message and you can do it across countries
0:48:30and we can eliminate all these other artificial barriers and everything will be good
0:48:34but really that was just another private company now being swallowed up by another private company like I don't feel
0:48:39like we're making progress there is just shifting around us just like this this big you know it's like a pile of chips
0:48:45on the table and we're shoving the chips toward this corner OK now towards that corner for that corner
0:48:49and it never is it landing in a place where if you like is there a sustainable way that we can all talk to each other
0:48:53in semi real time we're on the same network and we can all take some each other
0:48:56and it's you know it may be it's not free
0:48:59but it sustainable over some pricing structure it's on a standardized protocol
0:49:02or anyone can implement it like it's so hard to get to even a solution is crappy the malware we kind of all agree on
0:49:09the protocols even though the protocols of terrible need to discourage of spam even that sometimes I think well at
0:49:15least we got an email this this is one emails us
0:49:17and we don't have to deal with every single day every single you know decade
0:49:21or so some new e-mail service coming up like oh I can't tell you now because I'm on the G.
0:49:26Mail email
0:49:27and you're on the Hummel email we can send him across because an email to a cello competition for the front end client
0:49:31and everything but the back end is all you know interoperable
0:49:34and we have not achieved that with ways to send little bits of text to each other
0:49:40and I think Facebook buying whatsapp doesn't bring us any closer to that goal which makes me sad.
0:49:46And there's also you know I think I mean I've been beating this drum a little bit recently
0:49:51but I think this is kind of creepy or like just kind of negative news to me.
0:50:00Because it's such a massive acquisition like it.
0:50:02It looks to me like Facebook is just like taking out a competitor like that.
0:50:07That's all this was is Facebook got freaked out and has now neutralized a competitor
0:50:13and that which they've done before and that's an Instagram was
0:50:17and it just seems like the more like these the Web Giants are so giant these days that they can afford to buy pretty
0:50:25much anyone else besides one of the other web Giants.
0:50:28Even then sometimes they can do that
0:50:30but they can afford to buy pretty much anybody who ever becomes a threat to their business
0:50:35and this has to be limiting the amount of true innovation
0:50:40and progress that we're seeing in our industry because you know it's pretty much impossible at most most big tech
0:50:47startups who are doing very well are going to have a really hard time turning down a multiple billion dollar offer of a
0:50:54buyout.
0:50:56And so this basically give it basically gives Facebook and Google
0:51:01and you know if you watch anybody who has enough money
0:51:06and willpower to buy a multi-billion dollar company it gives them all assurances that they're not going to really be
0:51:13messed with by anybody.
0:51:14And occasionally something will break out
0:51:17and not take that route like Twitter did that most recently where they just went for the I.P.O. Instead. So far right.
0:51:24Yeah that's a good point.
0:51:25But you know I guess I can't I can't help
0:51:29but be sad at what this actually does to the big picture where there is so much less competition in progress.
0:51:37Once everyone gets so big they can just buy one who's a threat.
0:51:40If your business is based on like everybody being on your platform like if you're trying to be a protocol like e-mail
0:51:46didn't have a company behind it but Facebook is a company behind it
0:51:49and so many people on Facebook that it's like their their goal is you know everyone should be on Facebook.
0:51:54And so if they perform well in their business plan it's like we have stuff.
0:52:00Find the other thing that is going to get enough critical mass that we can never compete with it no matter how good we
0:52:07make our product and buy it before it gets that critical mass and become so expensive
0:52:12and I think they waited a little bit too long
0:52:14and what because they always what they want to buy it like they want to be sure that it would be something that they
0:52:19couldn't compete with like look you know Instagram's got too much mass like no matter how good we make pictures
0:52:24features we're never going to pull that Instagram people where they've gotten too big.
0:52:28We need to snap them up now and maybe they will do a little bit along and Instagram too
0:52:32but they don't want to buy all these companies like oh my god they're a threat they're going to buy them for like five
0:52:35hundred million dollars and they never would have been a threat they never would've done anyway it's so hard to tell.
0:52:39Again getting back to the unpredictability of success once you cross some threshold of value
0:52:44and Whatsapp like it's that type of situation where it's like look how big they are
0:52:49and there's no way Facebook messaging is ever going to pull those people away like they've got the critical mass in the
0:52:54same way that we did. We've got critical mass.
0:52:56Our only option is to buy them because that's you that's what you do you know that's the final play
0:53:00and you would hope that they would go for that from there again from the perspective of the strategy.
0:53:05If they're doing well they do that before they cost sixty million dollars
0:53:09but it's actually worse to say well they're too big now I'm not going to basics team billion dollars let's just let
0:53:14them go because they're never going to you know they're never going to make a messaging product that dethrones whatsapp
0:53:20once that'll be thrown by something else but probably not Facebook So yeah the strategy
0:53:24when you go this money is we may be too long
0:53:28but late is better than never because if we just ignore them then no they'll be there on doing like one of my space I
0:53:35don't you know the timing has worked up a lot of my space had the wherewithal to offer a newly born Facebook before it
0:53:43was anything another money to live in is better. We'd all be talking about My Space by about that now.
0:53:49Those darn monkey those darn butterfly wings laughing but anyway you get the idea.
0:53:54Like that's the strength of your one of those companies were like are the only way we succeed is if we get everything.
0:54:00Birth in the world like if we offer a feature that's the future that everybody in the world that they use for that you
0:54:04want to summary pictures and tell them about your kid's birthday you have to do it on Facebook
0:54:08and of someone who is in something other than Facebook to do that
0:54:11and those somebody's there are hundreds of millions of somebodies. We've screwed up we need to buy that company.
0:54:16And yeah that's from a consumer's perspective a terrible But if you are acting as Facebook that's that's their strategy.
0:54:25Our final sponsor this week is Lynda dot com L Y N D A dot com When the dot com health
0:54:32and human learn creative software and business skills to achieve personal
0:54:35and professional goals they have over two thousand high quality engaging video courses.
0:54:40Top by industry experts with new courses at it every day.
0:54:44These courses span huge range of difficulty and complexity and skill levels from beginner to advanced.
0:54:51The videos are very well produced.
0:54:53They have animations and diagrams
0:54:55and then they even have as Katie pointed out last time they even have like the scrolling transcript on the side so that
0:55:00you can see what's being said.
0:55:02You can scroll around and you can even click on a point the transcript will seek to that point in a video.
0:55:06Really cool stuff.
0:55:09Here's the deal you pay twenty five bucks a month flat rate for unlimited access to their entire catalog over two
0:55:16million people worldwide are doing this and it's really great.
0:55:19So the teachers of these things are experts in their field working professionals not just like some random person on
0:55:25You Tube They're actually working professionals in this field that are experts and can
0:55:29and know what they're talking about
0:55:32and they have all sorts of stuff that they tell you about business strategies all the way down to like you know you
0:55:39know management and then all the dental development stuff you can learn. I was development web development.
0:55:44You can learn creative cloud apps if you want to brush up on Photoshop learn how to use in design stuff like that basic
0:55:51office stuff you know advance stuff in Excel
0:55:54or how to use Quick Books how to use Power Point effectively even media production stuff.
0:56:00If you know videography pod casting photography all this sort of stuff.
0:56:04They have an amazing course library here you know I I went on there
0:56:08and learned a lot about how to use logic better to edit the show
0:56:11and just kind of you know get better at this whole feel that I've never had any training as an audio engineer
0:56:18and will now I have kind of.
0:56:21So check out when the dot com L Y N D A dot com They really have an amazing range of video courses here
0:56:28and again twenty five bucks a month get you access to the entire catalog
0:56:33and what's best is that you don't even have to pay up front to see if you go to L Y N.D.A. Dot com slash A.T.P.
0:56:40That's Lynda dot com slash A.T.V. You can get a seven day trial for free.
0:56:46So before you pay anything you go there when the cons less A.T.P.
0:56:50and Star seven to trial and watching videos you know anything. Browse the whole catalog.
0:56:55You will be you'll be shocked how many videos they have. It's really quite impressive.
0:57:02So once again check out Linda dot com When the dot com slash A.T.P.
0:57:06Thanks a lot to Linda for sponsorship once again they are really a great service and and I personally have used them
0:57:11and recommend them.
0:57:12You know I looked at them a couple weeks back when they first sponsored I saw this really long list of videos
0:57:19and I was like you know that's a lot but not overwhelming.
0:57:23And then I realized I was only looking at the new videos area
0:57:27and out come to find out there were eleven good Jillian videos waiting for me I just hadn't navigated away from the new
0:57:35video section yet. If you just look at any of the categories.
0:57:40You know like pick an application will learn how to use better or pick a permanent widget you want to learn
0:57:45and you can see like it's it's pretty pretty.
0:57:49Their pricing plan a certain life because
0:57:51when you have a huge selection like that if you had to pay like even like a dollar video you'd worry like oh is this
0:57:57the right video out of the umpteen you know you like a pickle.
0:58:00Even it was just a dollar video you can spend all the time fretting this is a flat fee just like sit there
0:58:05and watch videos. It doesn't matter how many you watch.
0:58:08Exactly right so we put this off last week
0:58:12and I think we should talk about it this week before it becomes so stale that it's not worth talking about.
0:58:19It seems like it's that time of year and it's that time of year
0:58:22when everyone in the eye less development community says oh objectives he's objective see sucks
0:58:28and we really need to get over it we need to get away from it. We need to move on to something better.
0:58:32Apple Why won't you help us.
0:58:34And this was originally Well in my exposure originally posited by John's piece called Copeland twenty ten
0:58:43and I guess John would you like to describe simply what Copeland twenty ten was saying would can you summarize that for
0:58:51us. Yeah I think I don't have a link in here but one that I read that two thousand and five or something.
0:58:57The stone ages.
0:58:58It was a long time ago when it was before twenty two
0:59:01and the point of my blog post was that I was I was worried about what Apple was going to do with its language in A.P.I.
0:59:09and Going forward because it seemed like all those competitors were moving to sort of memory manage higher level
0:59:14languages and Apple was not they were sticking with the C. Base language Objective C. This is all.
0:59:19Yes two thousand and five this is all before the i Phone and for all the stuff or whatever.
0:59:23And Copeland is a reference to one of Apple's many failed attempts to get a next generation operating system they had
0:59:29the classic macro S.
0:59:30Which is a really old to go operating system where any application can write any part of memory including the parts
0:59:36that are used by the O. S.
0:59:37and Everything like that
0:59:38and so which meant that badly behaved app that started writing memory to a bad pointer would just scribble over random
0:59:45parts of memory and bring your whole machine down and that was just archaic
0:59:48and everyone else was getting protected memory and pre-emptive multitasking where the O. S. Could take the C.P.U.
0:59:53Away from a process that wasn't true on the old mac operating system less the process yielded so it had these technical
0:59:59problems with.
1:00:00So I could not figure out a way to get a next generation operating system
1:00:04and Copeland was the highest profile failure I have a book on my shelf to my right that Goebbels going to America was
1:00:10eight and it's called Macca was a revealed
1:00:12and it's a book published by Apple with an Apple logo from Apple Press describing the next generation.
1:00:18Frank Sesno will be macro S eight
1:00:19and you know Copeland basically that operating system never shipped Apple cruise ship something called Magaw was eight
1:00:25but it was not Copeland.
1:00:26There were other failed attempts and other weird partnerships and this is all the dark times of Apple's existence
1:00:32but the Copenhagen thing was me saying If Apple doesn't get its act together
1:00:37and come up with whatever it's going to plan for its next generation programming language an A.P.I.
1:00:42You could find itself in the distant future like the year twenty ten you know our founding of two thousand.
1:00:48I've read artist Clark as a kid so crossing a point
1:00:51and if they don't get their act together they could find themselves in a situation just like they were with Copeland
1:00:55where everyone else has something they don't have it
1:00:58and they don't have a viable plan to get it because it's not so easy to snap your fingers
1:01:01and get a new modern language runtime and an A.P.I. To go with it.
1:01:07I also wrote another article in two thousand and ten called Coban Point Henry visitors explaining what I got wrong
1:01:13and why about you know about people about the year twenty ten because people say Well here we aren't trying ten apples
1:01:19not having any problems because they don't have a memory and language an A.P.I.
1:01:22and There are lots of other reasons for that
1:01:25but in general the the major failings like any time you try to break if you just pick some round number in the future
1:01:29that seems so distance then really it's only five years away and that's just you know bad thinking
1:01:33and economists take when trying to deal with the future. But anyway.
1:01:37OK so the comp topic came back up again and I'm not sure why it came back up again
1:01:41and I'm not sure what people are saying about it's different than what's been said before maybe you can enlighten me.
1:01:46Well there were these two post there was one by one by Steve stress a little put in the show notes
1:01:52and basically with the you know just saying we have to see and with a few a few things that we need there. We better.
1:02:00And then our friend Guy English wrote a post in response to these that basically said
1:02:06and forgive me if I'm butchering the argument that basically said like it's easy to like can we even say we need
1:02:11something better. But we need more specifics like what exactly needs to be better and how would that work.
1:02:19Like you know it's easy to just say oh well we need something that's higher level.
1:02:25OK Well it does that mean garbage collection of that mean you know reference counting in a different way like you know
1:02:30like that me in a dynamic type does that mean like all these all these decisions about higher level languages
1:02:38and it seems like not a lot of the arguments contain answers to questions like that it's just like oh we have to have
1:02:44something that's newer and that will by default be better which I think is itself a flawed argument.
1:02:52Yeah it seems like you know it's tough because I have tremendous respect for for Ashley and for Steve
1:02:58but it seemed very hand wavy and this argument tends to go around regularly in the West about in circles
1:03:06and it seems like every year or two everyone gets all upset about the fact that we're still writing in Objective C.
1:03:14but This is a problem that guy seemed to have and I concur with it is OK That's lovely that you think that Objective C.
1:03:22Is bad.
1:03:22Tell me what's bad about it or tell me why we need something new
1:03:27and you know before our automatic reference counting and before Grand Central Dispatch in blocks.
1:03:34I would have probably said the same thing
1:03:37and I probably would have said that you know not having closures in twenty twelve twenty thirteen that's a problem
1:03:44but I don't remember when blocks became a thing but it was I want to say twenty twelve
1:03:49but so up until twenty four that I probably would have agreed.
1:03:51And in some way there were a couple of really big advancements really big
1:03:55and important Vance events in the last couple years that I really think brought objective see.
1:04:00Two position where it's it's relatively modern in its arcane it's own archaic ways
1:04:09and so I don't I don't really see what's so terrible about it and I can sell you that cocoa
1:04:15and cocoa touch which are the frameworks. They are they are unbelievably good.
1:04:22They're truly amazingly good and I love me some C.
1:04:26Sharp I really do but the done a frame work while very solid is nowhere near as good as Coco and Coco touch
1:04:32and so I don't really see what the urgent burning need is to get rid of Jack to see that I have had the urgent burning
1:04:41need to get rid of a victory in two thousand and five that I still feel and really what I was writing there.
1:04:50The audience that was not so much developers trying to tell them that the language they're using is bad or something
1:04:54but it was really apple
1:04:56and I think that by the time I was getting a little bit panicked about this whole part of it is kind of like you know
1:05:01how someone who grew up in the depression is always panicked about money and worried about not having enough food
1:05:06and stuff like that.
1:05:07If you live through the whole Copeland disaster obviously going to be a little bit more panicky about oh oh my god what
1:05:13is what is Apple's plan for a Texan aeration whatever because I don't want to see that thing that I'm you know the
1:05:17Apple today is so different in the apple than that it's a little bit ridiculous
1:05:19but a lot of that is that's where that's coming from someone who experience there that you know a company that they are
1:05:25mired in thought should be successful almost die because they failed to think about stuff like that time
1:05:30but as the years pass I don't get more relaxed about this.
1:05:34Just you know if I continue to worry about it
1:05:36and my point would be like if I was in charge of Apple I would have had starting and like starting basically
1:05:43when javac say you do it or totally asleep at the wheel and Java comes on the scene.
1:05:47I would have had multiple teams multiple small teams of the fanciest you know computer science Ph D. Whatever.
1:05:56Maybe these teams don't know about each other maybe they're on different continents you know.
1:06:00Whatever working on the next generation language runtime an A.P.I.
1:06:05All those things and most of those teams I imagine would fail and produce nothing useful
1:06:09but you know you're Apple you have all this money the empire the modern apple budget you know like maybe maybe the old
1:06:15Apple could only afford one or two teams of the few people who aren't that good.
1:06:17But at this point Apple could have ten teams with you know the ten best people money can buy all working on this
1:06:23and the reason I bring this up is not so much. We need to replace Objective C. Next year.
1:06:27W W C twenty sixteen Apple doesn't replace coke or Objective C. They're doomed Of course not right.
1:06:32It's because doing this making a new language and A.P.I.
1:06:36It's so incredibly difficult and takes so long to wring out
1:06:39and you have to bring it out not just in these little these little labs in these competing teams
1:06:43but then you actually have to build real absolute Didn't you have to sort of like it's just so hard to do this
1:06:47transition so hard to make it harder to make the language and on time people focus on the language and runtime so much.
1:06:55But that's kind of like you know that's mostly just picking from you know what do you want what features do you want
1:07:00and they can do experiments that making the A.P.I.
1:07:02That matches up with the language because I've always said that you can't just have a new language you have to have the
1:07:06A.P.I.
1:07:07and Languishing with it and cocoa has been in development basically since like the eighty's
1:07:11and it's taken that long for a cover to get from where it was in the eighty's to where it is now.
1:07:15So assume whatever thing you're going to make to replace cocoa is going to take at least as long to get at least as
1:07:21good you know in terms of rail routes you know. So you're not going to jump from OK Objective C.
1:07:26Is done everyone try this new language in this new A.P.I.
1:07:30and It will be better than Coakley it won't be out of the good will be worse in the beginning just like it was ten was
1:07:34worse think like a classic macro as in almost every respect.
1:07:38For years you know and it took years to develop
1:07:41and it was false starts with the whole Rhapsody project every like that.
1:07:44I know how long it takes to do this I know how badly wrong you can go I mean like.
1:07:49Think of every other company that's tried to do this even Microsoft C.
1:07:52Sharp
1:07:53and a common language runtime which I would say is the biggest success story hasn't been a clean win in terms of getting
1:07:58rid of win thirty two.
1:08:00All you know now when sixty four if you want to call that all of the stuff
1:08:03and that also took years to be adopted widely for developers.
1:08:06Yeah and it just and they put tons of money and tons of like you know you can't wait you can't say like Objective C.
1:08:13Is fine now it's going to be fine for five years therefore we need to do nothing.
1:08:16Assume that it's going to take you ten fifteen years to get this crap figured out
1:08:20and assume you're going to fail a couple times before you do because I think those are safe bets.
1:08:24Someone in the chat room posted oh maybe to Apple's is holding its cards close to his vest. That's entirely possible.
1:08:30As with anything in Apple you have no idea what the hell is going on over there.
1:08:33They could have seventeen games
1:08:34or people who they kill after their three years are up of they don't produce something and they hide the bodies
1:08:39and we have no idea what's going on.
1:08:41That's where I'm coming from with this not so much from the perspective of like I'm developing today
1:08:45and I think this is ridiculous I do think a lot of stuff is ridiculous
1:08:48but I feel like I understand how incredibly hard it's going to be to make something that's better than this
1:08:54and the second part of this is I think a lot of people don't want to sign up for a maybe is not relevant to them is
1:08:59that this day will come
1:09:01and I think a lot of people are either are of the opinion that this day will not come in their lifetime which may be a
1:09:07very safe bet in which case you know they feel justified in saying look I'll be dead or retired
1:09:11when this happened so I don't have to worry about it so it's not on my radar at all.
1:09:14And how it may be the current leaders of apple think I'll be dead or retired but on this happens
1:09:19but I'm I'm thinking longer term. Like yes I am I and everyone know I'm going to die.
1:09:25But if Apple wants to live on our as humans want to live on there will come a day
1:09:28when it isn't acceptable to have a pointer that you can scribble all over the memory.
1:09:32Yes just of your own memory of your own process Sure but that's barbaric. That's going away.
1:09:37We all agree it's going away it's just a question of the timing
1:09:39and a lot of people think well the timing is not in my lifetime therefore I don't care about it
1:09:44but someone's gotta care about otherwise Apple's going away
1:09:46and if you don't care about who goes away you know then fine
1:09:49but someone an apple presumably should care about Bill goes away even if they're retired Well I don't know maybe maybe
1:09:55I'm thinking too long term maybe this is not how human beings think and I just have to accept that.
1:10:00Apple's going to go under in seventy five years because they're never going to get away from Jack to see
1:10:04and someone else is going to replace them and that's the way of the world and I should just be OK with that.
1:10:07But that's where I'm coming from with this
1:10:10and that's why I think calls for like what specifically do you want to whatever as many people pointed out that's what
1:10:14Apple's supposed to figure out it's not our job to come up with Apple's next generation language
1:10:18or our time it's their job and how do they do it.
1:10:21It's going to take on a whole bunch of tribes and it's going to be really hard
1:10:23and they should have been started working on it two decades ago
1:10:25when it was obvious that this is the way that the world is going
1:10:28and it should have always been obvious is the way it always goes to higher level languages so that's what I'm fretting
1:10:33about and it's kind of an esoteric concern that no one really cares about but the rank
1:10:37and file people have to Jill exactly see every day they see what other languages are like
1:10:42and those other languages have peakers that everyone agrees are good that they wish they had an Objective C.
1:10:47and It's like well you can't just have that feature you can just have the you know the native regular expressions
1:10:53or nicer strings or you know memory protection action you know management Imrie
1:10:58and not having pointers of I guess you can just pack them on right.
1:11:03That's what they see them in other language they see them in contemporary languages that are doing similar things
1:11:08and they say well everyone agrees that's good why did I have that here.
1:11:11And that kind of discomfort is maybe how this type of stuff begins
1:11:15but this is not something you can begin from the outside it can be a bunch of developers complaining about Objective C.
1:11:20They can't be developers leaving the platform because they don't like to see it wasn't going to happen as long as they
1:11:24continue to sell apps. It has to be from within.
1:11:26So this is something that Apple needs to undertake and that's always been my my thrust with the whole Copeland point
1:11:31and thing it's not telling developers what to do.
1:11:34It's trying to tell Apple what to do and we know how successful that usually is right
1:11:38but the problem is is that as someone who has a leg in two worlds there are definitely things about Objective C.
1:11:45In cocoa that I that I wish I had when I do my day job of writing C.
1:11:50Sharp like Grand Central Dispatch is a great example.
1:11:53It is unbelievably easy to just throw things on to random cues and to throw.
1:12:00Things on to the main thread without even having to think twice about it
1:12:03and you'll see sharp has gotten better with that over the years but Apple did a great job.
1:12:08Now granted the syntax is unbelievably bad and there is an entire website whose U.R.L.
1:12:15I can't mention without having a horn go off
1:12:18but there's an entire website based on the syntax for how to write a blog how to write blocks properly.
1:12:24And that's probably not a good sign but the
1:12:27but nevertheless there are things about Cocoa this antiquated language that we all want to throw away.
1:12:33That framework
1:12:35but there's things about object of seeing cocoa as a as a pair that is supposedly science equated that I would love to
1:12:42have an Objective C.
1:12:44and It doesn't mean that you're wrong John
1:12:47but I don't see the urgency that perhaps a lot of other people see I concur that it needs to be being worked on
1:12:56but I don't know that we are at the day where they need to flip the switch
1:13:00and then I don't think you're saying that either but it seems like it's still a little bit down the road to me.
1:13:06As long as there's continued improvements to both cocoa and Objective C.
1:13:14Which there are well like the urgent they should be at Apple and I understand for enterprise N.T.
1:13:18Pattern they're defending against is if you spend all your time worrying about your stupid next generation thing then
1:13:23you take your eye off the ball which is people making Objective C.
1:13:26Better people working on KOGO like Apple
1:13:27or so about focus I can fully understand though that's that's a sucker's bet you'd not want to spend all your time
1:13:32coming up with these crazy new A.P.I.
1:13:34These crazy new languages you're taking your eye off the ball you should be making the product that you have now better
1:13:39like what they're doing with object is the an el of the EM like us exactly what they're supposed to be doing
1:13:43and any effort they spend so they might think any effort they expend on like what is the next generation pie in the sky
1:13:49architecture astronaut crappy thing that we're doing that is just like that's not in our D.N.A.
1:13:54We don't worry about that or whatever. And I understand the urge not to fall into that.
1:14:00But the other trap is we will never have to do that we will get there by increment starting from C.
1:14:06Pointers forever until we don't and that will somehow make that transition like. How do you get from point A to Point B.
1:14:11Like it's kind of like what they tried to do with the classic macro us Copeland was like we can try to keep kind of
1:14:16some kind of compatibility and old style mac apps will be able to scribble all over memory
1:14:21but will make these new style absolute run on this new kernel that are protected from each other
1:14:26and eventually all the old Absolute go away I'll be able to translate it was an idea to transition into protected
1:14:32memory
1:14:32and pre-emptive multitasking maintaining backward compatibility with existing classic apps by allowing them to still
1:14:37have free reign of memory.
1:14:39But just like the device drivers and new apps wouldn't like it was it was a hybrid type incremental solution
1:14:43and they could never pull it off
1:14:44and it's not to say they can pull off because it was incremental is just to say that it I think history has shown that
1:14:51the thing that the next generation thing will be very different from the previous thing it won't be the previous thing
1:14:59just improved in small increments.
1:15:00It will be something entirely very often something entirely different from a different company which is not what you
1:15:04want. Apple managed to do it to itself by saying Well sort of like we sent our C.E.O.
1:15:08Away and I did a five and he made another company and he made no new O.S.'s and we're just going to bring that back
1:15:14and that's our newest convenient that was all secret plan all along he says.
1:15:17Very clever anyway it was a complete replacement. Like people jacked it on Twitter.
1:15:21I was citing like I was ten as a complete rewrite of the mac operating system from the perspective of the app it is a
1:15:28different operating system it has a compatibility layer that was you know you know virtualize for Classic apps
1:15:34and everybody but holy cow is it different than Classic MacOS Unix for crying out loud. So incredibly different.
1:15:39I know that was the thing that was the thing that worked right there
1:15:44and most often the thing that replaces it was radically different and also from a different company.
1:15:48So Apple doesn't want that to happen if they don't want the next thing to be radically different
1:15:52and also for a different company.
1:15:53They need to balance their desire not to take their eyes off the current ball which I agree with with the reality of
1:15:59that. Like eventually got to come.
1:16:02You got to where we are away from pointers not this year not this decade like
1:16:05but it's like whenever you think it is in the future I don't think I've never met anyone who says no pointers are going
1:16:09to be forever seven thousand years from now he'll be writing programs
1:16:12and if they DRAM is a bad pointer they're going to scramble her memory like that if you're not going to have them write
1:16:17an apple begun then it is not like I guess it just depends on what time horizon you consider fruitful to think about
1:16:24and I'm thinking about time horizons that I myself would have to say are perhaps not for me for me to be thinking about
1:16:30but that's that's those are the type of things I think about I think someone an apple somewhere should be high minded
1:16:35enough to realize this is a concern and to start doing something to help that.
1:16:42See I'm I'm a lot less convinced that this is inevitable that that a progression like this has to happen even within a
1:16:50time span of like you know twenty years thirty years about two hundred three hundred pick your time scale everyone
1:16:55agrees is going to happen right. Well sure but you know I think so he does argue over the number that's it.
1:17:02I think Objective C. Monetarist of C.
1:17:06and The tools that we have for it have are so much more advanced than where it was five or ten years ago
1:17:14and you know I think that we I don't think modern Objective C.
1:17:19Is as far away from what people want as they think when they write a blog post like this.
1:17:24Like if you look at a lot of the complaints are a lot of thing people say it needs a lot of them are our A.P.I.
1:17:29Is not part of the language a lot of them are like really fairly minor cosmetic details almost And you know a lot of it
1:17:37it already has
1:17:38and you know looking at looking at the history of programming languages there's there's this assumption that you've
1:17:44said that most of these posts are based on which is that everything always moves higher higher level higher you know as
1:17:49time goes on but that's not necessarily true. Stuff moves higher level at the beginning.
1:17:55It's true with bumps obviously it's not a straight line but it's true. The trend line. Sure.
1:18:00There are certain things the kind of settle in and become and become kind a locked in
1:18:04and I think one of the one of the greatest examples of this is see you know see has has been around for ever.
1:18:12Is no part of it is new except blocks and it you know no part of that in general use is is really that modern
1:18:21and yet it's been around forever and it's everywhere and any and every language usually languages are written in C.
1:18:29Usually you know languages have tons of C.
1:18:31Modules that can be added on anything that high performance is required is usually written in C.
1:18:37You know there is I would not historically I would not bet against C.
1:18:41but but You have to you know it's going like it's not going to go away the same with some wouldn't go away
1:18:45and tell you the machine go didn't go away like people running game console someone's writing some hexadecimal numbers
1:18:50then Norma Jean got right by and saw me feel like a layer cake but C. Will lose its primacy eventual E.
1:18:56The same way assembly lost its primacy is the way you program computers the same way the machine code it sees as having
1:19:01a much longer life than a C. Had a longer life in assembly.
1:19:04I'd have to look at the numbers to see
1:19:05but certainly assembly had a longer life than writing machine go because it was so incredibly unfriendly
1:19:11but like all you're arguing about a timescale you think like oh this is a long plateau you're right it is along the
1:19:16plateau how long it'll plateau going to be
1:19:18but I think the the systems that we have now that do use higher level languages are out there enough to sow a little
1:19:25discontent even then just the regular rank and file people who find it like so much less verbose.
1:19:31Like the sort of the same operation done in a higher level language like Python or Ruby
1:19:34or something like Boy after so much less typing
1:19:37and it's so much more clear what I'm doing it's just is just more concise it's a higher level
1:19:42and I can do more with less typing.
1:19:44I could be more clear with my intent that even things like go where you know implicit parallelism
1:19:50and other other abstractions that allow you to express yourself in a way that would not be possible in C.
1:19:57Even in a language that's not particularly hard. Evelyn see because go is very similar to C.
1:20:02but With like better libraries and buildings
1:20:03and stuff like that because of all the existing high level languages that people do other kinds of development
1:20:08and it allows them to see what the future might look like even if we're not quite ready for it today
1:20:14and I think that's I mean that's that's the beginning of the writing on the wall for C.B.S.
1:20:19Languages and you know you say I wouldn't bet against sea
1:20:21and it's locked in like those are all relative terms like you
1:20:26and I start throwing out big year numbers eventually you agree with me.
1:20:30But like you don't want to read them in any year number that you can envision either being alive during or
1:20:35or in vision like anyone you know being alive during And that's maybe that's just human nature
1:20:39but like everything just depends on what the time scale looks like
1:20:44and their discontinuity is where suddenly you make a great leap forward because some reason because you know an
1:20:48earthquake wiped out Apple and Google and some new company has to rise from the ashes
1:20:51and it bases everything on Erling or something and we enter the new Erling age
1:20:55or I'm trying to think of a crazy language but I think your or your desire not to think about anything beyond C.
1:21:04May be well founded because for your entire career you'll never have to think about that but your grandkids probably.
1:21:09Yeah I mean
1:21:10and I think I totally agree that given a long enough time scale you're right that given a longer time scale this will
1:21:18have to be replaced
1:21:19but I think that I think it's pretty likely that by the time that happens Apple might not be that relevant
1:21:27or we might not be running the same or less even you know like well they don't listen to me of course they're right.
1:21:33Like you know I think you know there's a lot of things that that keep Objective C.
1:21:39As it is in power you know and part of it is you know that there's the whole tool chain that kind of requires And
1:21:46but even know the reasons why things that are compiled down to get to see various toolkits
1:21:51and stuff haven't really been huge is mostly because you know here to see as I said before it's it's close enough in a
1:21:59lot of ways.
1:22:00What people actually want and you know you can say oh look the brackets are ugly
1:22:05and you know that's mostly people who are unfamiliar with it who say that
1:22:08and then once they get familiar with it it just as mattering because you know every language look we have been familiar
1:22:13to you and
1:22:15and I think so I think it's close enough to a lot of what people want I think a lot of the alternatives are not clear
1:22:23cut like if if you say OK well you shouldn't even to think about memory ever again OK well then you know which memory
1:22:28management model do you pick and then that's not an easy question.
1:22:32You know the question of types and how they are implemented that's not an easy question.
1:22:37But also we've got this this great like reset with the rise of mobile where efficiency is certainly a lot more
1:22:45important than it was in two thousand five thousand five your billion desktop app.
1:22:51You know then the new C.P.U.'s are so powerful back then for desktop apps for most types of use that you could do
1:22:57anything with the language you have a language having tons of overhead and tons of dynamic safety stuff and it be fine.
1:23:03Whereas in Mobile that was a great reset and obviously mobiles getting faster it will it will keep getting faster.
1:23:10And you know eventually this will this will become a lot less of an advantage
1:23:14but it sure has helped Iowa so far that most of the after people use are written and a very little of the language
1:23:22or these are compiled down to a very low level language so that they have a lot less overhead than say Android apps you
1:23:29know and there's different things like just in time comp compilation that have been very advanced in recent years
1:23:33but still the compiled C.
1:23:37Based language that is mostly static and fast has a lot of advantages in Mobile
1:23:44and what's different in mobile is that the power budget is so much tighter that it actually matters not only for speed
1:23:51or for battery life and so this will continue to matter for a while and you're right.
1:23:57Eventually it will over a longer time scale but.
1:24:00I think I'd say we probably have a good ten years at least where this will continue to matter
1:24:05and where it would be unwise sticking around numbers I think we have another seven point two years.
1:24:11Yeah I know I know it's the same thing and they're trying to end the revisited article I felt like in two thousand
1:24:16and five when I didn't see coming two thousand and five was you know the i Phone I mean who did right.
1:24:20But like the prominence of Mobile right and that I wouldn't call it a reset.
1:24:24It's a delay and if it could be a massive laughing at what I said
1:24:27and I read it as an article I give that a twenty year delay it adds at least a decade you know because yeah all the
1:24:32things you Senator with mobile being low level such a massive advantage in mobile like that why Apple was able to do
1:24:39this type of evidence of the i Phone was fake because you know you can't do that.
1:24:42They were like the java apps that are running on the stupid smartphones then there's no way you could just I got a nose
1:24:47job like you would you need to have a crazy desktop powered C.P.U.
1:24:50In there well if you have a language that's more efficient than Java on your phone you can do pretty amazing stuff
1:24:55and yet so this this is been an advantage
1:24:58and it's a sustainable advantage in Apple's investing in that advantage in making Objective C.
1:25:02Better in everything so I don't know how long that delays things that delays things for a long time you're right.
1:25:07But on the other side of the like yeah it's going to happen eventually
1:25:11but not in my lifetime I always think about like it we're just talking about whatsapp
1:25:15or think about any you know think about My Space.
1:25:18Things move faster and industry than than most of us are comfortable with.
1:25:23Like even just reflecting I was every time I see like the timeline of something that like oh this happened a long time
1:25:30ago way back in two thousand
1:25:31and four like you know before Facebook even existed how many years ago how old it is Facebook even how old is Instagram
1:25:37all this Twitter like all these things to be accepted institutions how old is whatsapp that just cost sixteen billion
1:25:43dollars like in some respects things have a lot of momentum
1:25:47and mobiles going to going to keep us to keep Apple's advantage of actressy relevant for a long time
1:25:53but in other respects that's what I'm about discontinuity like the graph is not smooth as long plateaus for nothing.
1:26:00There's a big spike we're crazing strange
1:26:02and you never know what's coming down the pike so it could be that we are all stuck with C.
1:26:06Based languages for our entire lives and careers.
1:26:10But it could be that twenty years from now something dramatic happens that we didn't predict
1:26:16and suddenly all sea based languages are swept under the carpet because big mazing new company that is becoming to
1:26:22prominence uses a language at super high level that everybody loves
1:26:25and everyone looks down at the barbaric people flinging pointers
1:26:29and relegates them to writing device drivers for whatever.
1:26:34Well you know I was really upset at Marco because I was going to make the same plucking Tapout mobile kind of resetting
1:26:40everything already made of the revisited article on twenty eight Then I now I know well OK some of Sapper did it first
1:26:45time but set it both of you then but the other thing to consider is if this suppose it I watch is really a thing.
1:26:52I mean that that kind of does this whole being near the metal It makes being near the metal
1:27:00and a huge advantage all over again.
1:27:02Well I think the power constraints of the watch are that much different than a phone. I mean probably like two X.
1:27:09but Maybe not ten X. Less I don't know your but do you think you do you think you're being.
1:27:13You'd be in a position that running a just in time compiled or or
1:27:18or a Common Language Runtime kind of set up is really going to be a good call on a watch.
1:27:24I don't think it's as big a delay as going from a laptop or a desktop to a phone.
1:27:30Think there's a smaller jump going from a phone to a wearable that's probably true.
1:27:34But yeah like you are they continuing the continuation of mobile
1:27:38and battery powered stuff is going to be a substantial delay in making any kind of high level language
1:27:42and may end up being a disadvantage to anybody who doesn't have a C. Based language but it already is.
1:27:47Talk to talk to the windows so I mean it's hard to say because it's again it's kind of like the you know working
1:27:55backwards from successes like well the i Phone is so awesome. And yeah.
1:28:00I could've existed probably without this type of language
1:28:02but if Microsoft had not been so incompetent its mobile strategy and had come up with an O. S. Like you know I O.
1:28:10Us years before the i Phone using C.
1:28:13Sharp it would have had terrible performance and been like everywhere to look at
1:28:19and said Why the hell are you doing this you're making everything so slow C.P.U.'s can't handle this.
1:28:23There's no mobile G.P.U. They can sling as many pixels it's embarrassing and it would've reminded me of O S ten.
1:28:28All that was one hundred percent true voice ten ten point no a composite of gooey running on the C.P.U.
1:28:34It was slow as balls you couldn't even scroll windows full of Texas like this is your next generation operating system
1:28:39I can scroll a window full of text without it stuttering forget it
1:28:43and Apple's like no no no we think this is the right way to do things.
1:28:46Eventually the heart will catch up and it did so.
1:28:49If Microsoft had had fielded you know sort of Windows Phone seven
1:28:53or of the whole number there up to way back in the day or done something like i O. S. On C. Shop and it was slow.
1:28:58That may have you know and they became successful they became you know the i Phone because they did it first
1:29:03and they got in and they made this amazing product and you know eventually got good enough.
1:29:08And Apple was like the you know Johnny come lately.
1:29:11You wouldn't be able to make the argument that like oh well the only way you can do this type of thing is with a low
1:29:15level language. I think something like C.
1:29:18Sharp in the common ground time now are good enough to make something kind of fast on a phone probably would've taken
1:29:25longer to be as fast as the i Phone is and it would have been as good
1:29:28but who wouldn't have the i Phone to compare it to so we would be like oh this is good as it can possibly be like.
1:29:33That's what I like the whole the whole idea that the way things currently are going where they could possibly be a very
1:29:38very big objection to that and it's human nature to just assume that's the case.
1:29:43So while I think that objective has been such a big advantage to Apple I don't think you say well you can never have a
1:29:48phone type device with C. Shop because the shop is not that slow no slower.
1:29:54You know but like I mean how people can do amazing things with stupid javascript just crazy lately.
1:30:00We have those classic mac emulators and stuff inside a browser window
1:30:03and javascript are about a slow language is not designed to be fast at all so I'm I'm not convinced that that Objective
1:30:11C.
1:30:11Is the only way that we could have a i Phone like devices in our lifetime
1:30:14and I think even the current state of Windows Phone which as I know uses code that you know Concord native code to do
1:30:20with things that have to actually be fastened same thing with Android with its native code
1:30:23and I understand all these these things that they have to do to be faster
1:30:27but I don't think the shop is necessary to have you know smartphones for example
1:30:32or objective third a smartphone right out of the game is making that argument.
1:30:36I think it's more that you know if you if you can have something that's this fast in this efficient it's an advantage.
1:30:42It's not a requirement but it's an advantage for sure
1:30:44and as time goes on it becomes less of an advantage proportionally but still you know it still is significant now
1:30:51and you know again I just think like you know Casey even knew you were very qualified to talk about dot net You know
1:30:59and that's I would I would say like C.
1:31:01Sharp in that framework are very good example of the kind of thing that would that we might be moving towards although
1:31:07we probably go you know hopefully another evolutionary step to that's now you know fifteen years old or whatever
1:31:12but you know based on what you know with dot net
1:31:16and what you know with with modern literacy development are they really like is Dot Net really that much easier to use
1:31:24for mobile app development.
1:31:26If you had asked me a year or two ago maybe two three years ago actually I would've said yes it is considerably easier.
1:31:32Ref counting is not that conceptually difficult
1:31:35but it's still a lot hell of a lot more difficult than just writing the new keyword all over the place.
1:31:42But given the advantage the advances of are given the advances of having closures in Objective C.
1:31:51No I don't think it's really that different in the end that's kind of what I was driving at earlier.
1:31:57You know there are things in Objective C. That I love. In that I miss when I write C. Sharp.
1:32:02There are things that are in C. Sharp that I love that I missed when I write Objective C.
1:32:08but If I were to like the first thing that jumps to mind of something that I really missed an Objective C.
1:32:13That I enjoy so much in C.
1:32:15Sharp is something silly like reflection
1:32:18or introspection which really is not necessary in is completely ancillary to the conversation we're having.
1:32:26Like that it's been a lot out there to say you know you know what is there
1:32:30but it's no it absolutely is there just a comparatively a royal pain in the butt compared to how easy it is in some
1:32:35trouble
1:32:36but it changes the way the right programs like it mean think of think of writing an action actual very high level
1:32:41language it's not just like us. Incremental stuff.
1:32:45If you have those features in there kind of built into the language in a convenient way it it informs how you write
1:32:51A.P.I. Spelling Absolutely. Think of all like the ruby people writing this to be a D.S.L.
1:32:55So making a little you know because it's so easy to just add methods to classes
1:32:59and throw that like extending the number of classes they can put like one dot times in three days not a go at all this
1:33:06like now I'm saying all this stuff is good but like language features change what the A.P.I.
1:33:10Looks like and another thing that change will be a palace like success
1:33:14and I think a lot of the sort of the narrowing gap between objective seen tea shop is based on the success of the
1:33:23companies that shepherd them the relative success over the past decade of Apple versus Microsoft.
1:33:28It's pretty stark contrast now though Microsoft has been improving the shop
1:33:32and everything they have not had the dominant thriving big new platform as a tractor to pull their language A.B.I.
1:33:40They have had the kind of fizzling out really doing well in the mobile market platform
1:33:45and the old legacy Windows platform and a bunch of other confused the eyes you know point along
1:33:50and so yet the gap is narrowing because Apple's fire and also owners with objectives
1:33:55and Microsoft is another DON'T was a shock but what will you say that. But I mean C.
1:34:00Sharp is making considerable strides on a regular basis and what the language yes but yeah I do that's fair point.
1:34:08The U.P.I.
1:34:09Has done a little better with like parallel programming for example I would argue it's not as clean
1:34:13and simple is as Grand Central Dispatch but it's better. But C.
1:34:18Sharp as a language I really really really really like it a lot a lot a lot
1:34:25and I'm not saying I love Microsoft I mean Microsoft has its own woes but C.
1:34:29Sharp as a language is really truly incredible and I really really like it and some of the things you can do in C.
1:34:35Sharp like someone brought up in the chat a minute ago link link language in the query you can do some of that with
1:34:41predicates in cocoa but it's not as nice it's not as easy and
1:34:47and like I said reflection earlier some of those things are really incredible into having easy access to introspection
1:34:53having easy access to writing seek will ask queries against objects.
1:34:59It makes the way you write code very different just like you said John in so I see both sides of this coin
1:35:05and it's so tough I want to be more definitive and come down with a particular perspective
1:35:11but I don't know I don't know I don't know what I would do if I was Apple other than put some really big nerds on it
1:35:16and see what they come up with I think the link is a good example because there's this whole thing of like you know
1:35:22higher level language with manage memory in these other features and native strings
1:35:27and all of those things from a high level language that we think we want
1:35:29and in providing you the ability to like let's try to you know link link isn't yet another attempt to sort of make it
1:35:37easier to deal with big buckets of data in a language that you want to get the data out
1:35:41and we want to get the data into like variables essentially in our language so we can deal with
1:35:45and we want to take whatever structures we have in our language with objects or something else
1:35:49and put them into some other big bucket of data probably a database like how many times have we taken a run of this
1:35:54problem with object relational mapping and direct sequel queries and link with the another example and it just goes.
1:36:00Show that like the features of language that we're talking about being a higher level will become a necessity it will
1:36:06be necessary to be to you know dream memory manage to not be able to have a site fall to have things that we all expect
1:36:13to have like you know name parameters native strings and maybe regular expressions
1:36:17and native implicit parallelism baked into the runtime and all these things.
1:36:21Those will be necessary
1:36:23but they will not be sufficient to be a better language because I think many people Lincoln many people hate because
1:36:29they like you know everyone hates or around this right but then link people like oh this is a great idea
1:36:33and then you link throwing like links not that great either
1:36:36and some people go back to writing the sequel queries like just because you have these features doesn't mean you're
1:36:40going to make an awesome A.P.I. G.C.D.
1:36:42Is a great example the people who made that had a better idea of what would make a good easy A.P.I.
1:36:47For new pals and they sure are going to just see for crying out loud right.
1:36:51You know it just because you have married doesn't mean you're going home with A.B.I.
1:36:55Was good is easy doesn't mean that you're going to come up with a way of dealing with databases that's better than a
1:36:59link that's better than or ends better than writing direct queries like it doesn't automatically make you the winner
1:37:04but it will eventually be necessary
1:37:07and eventually you get to the point like Apple was with Copeland where no matter how good your stuff is if you don't
1:37:14meet this in the bar you do not have every protection you become a nonentity you it's like you can't play in the game
1:37:21anymore no matter how awesome your stuff is in like oh look at this we have this
1:37:24and we have done our new I know I saw it I was like I'm sorry you spent a long time over there dicking around
1:37:30and the bar has moved and now you are just and not a player anymore and that's the scenario that trying to avoid here.
1:37:36It doesn't mean that if you make a memory management which then it will be better than Objective C.
1:37:40In fact chances are very great that it will not be and your A.P.I.
1:37:43Will not be as good as cocoa That's why I was saying make seventeen teams put them against each other don't tell them
1:37:48each other exists like it's going to be difficult to do is not even guaranteed that you're going to be successful
1:37:52but if you don't try you are guaranteed long term that you're doomed. Yeah I agree it's just.
1:38:00It's it's so tough in one thing I should point out is that link is about more than just hitting databases I mean what's
1:38:07what what's really powerful about link is if you have a dictionary
1:38:11or a hash table in memory you can write really expressive queries against that half sure that dictionary
1:38:20and you can do it either in a format that that smells a lot like sequel literally within code you can you can write you
1:38:27know from a dictionary where blah select blah or you can do it in a more traditional way but
1:38:34but link is extremely powerful and it's things like that that make me think you're right
1:38:40but I don't know I think the most the most pressing thing you said was that it takes a long time to develop a really
1:38:48solid A.P.I.
1:38:49Of a really long time and I don't think that done it very much there
1:38:52and I would take I would say Coke over the Dot Net framework as much as I would miss link as much as I would miss
1:38:58reflection in the easy peasy form that it is and net I would probably take took Ko-Ko over it and that's saying a lot.
1:39:05Even if you have an awesome A.P.I. and Even if you have an awesome language and every agrees A.B.I.
1:39:09Is better than everything else in the market never degrees your language has been
1:39:12or the market is not attached to a successful product that will also do middle health like the things that have to come
1:39:18to get like that's how we end up with like see an objective.
1:39:20It's like in the end like it no matter how great a thing you make in terms of the underlying thing that doesn't get
1:39:26attached sessile product it's gone
1:39:28and whatever it is it has a successful product provided to meet some pretty low minimum bar of suitability.
1:39:34It will be wildly successful
1:39:36and will be still be stuck with the decades for decades anyway so that's the other you know again the theme of the show.
1:39:42Like just because it is ever
1:39:45and uses it to Natasha successful products it doesn't mean that it is the best thing that we could ever possibly have
1:39:50and its success you know like Objective C.
1:39:52Would be nowhere paddled in by next right is it because I had no object is the is better in many many ways than a lot
1:39:59of its contemporaries. Languages but it would be nowhere if Apple hadn't bought them and so like that Apple has.
1:40:05When you have a successful product
1:40:06and you have the ability as Microsoft sort of had to try to to try to prevent yourself from becoming irrelevant by
1:40:13revving your technology stack trying to good at the same time is also making successful products on maybe it's
1:40:18impossible maybe Apple maybe Apple's life time is limited by the lifetime Objective C.
1:40:22Of it's institutionally uncapable capable of ever making anything good enough to replace it.
1:40:28Then it will be Apple the company will live as long as it takes or Objective C.
1:40:33To become like a disqualifier where now just like memory protection was like memory lack of memory to action preemptive
1:40:39multitasking became a disqualifier for the desktop P.C.
1:40:42Market and Apple had to do something
1:40:44and then most went out of business well that if that's Apple strategy if we ever get Tim Cook on the shelves I would
1:40:51ask him this super esoteric question is like this I think this is like you know it's probably pet he'll be retired
1:40:58but he doesn't have to worry about this.
1:41:00Like personally
1:41:01but I wonder if your SEO company if you ever think about things like this like three C.E.O.'s are now that guy might
1:41:08have to worry about this do I care at all and if I do my planning for it now
1:41:12or my discontent to say we're going to make competing proving objective as long as hard as we can ever never becomes a
1:41:18disqualifier success Well that's the end of Apple but that'll be so long from now nobody alive cares. Good job.
1:41:24So my what I keep wondering is right around the time that I think all of us were getting completely fed up with the
1:41:33fact that we needed to to perform our own reference counting in Objective C.
1:41:38That's when Art came out and at the last possible moment the biggest issue that all of us had
1:41:44or I would say the biggest issue all of us had with Objective C. Suddenly wasn't an issue anymore.
1:41:49If Apple continues down that road
1:41:51and at the eleventh hour finally fixes whatever the current issue is is that it is not a long term plan that'll work do
1:41:59you think.
1:42:00It took them two tries to do that because the first try was garbage collection right and that
1:42:04and that was a multi-year effort that ended in failure because like it wasn't while they got the by anybody something I
1:42:11think they made Xcode guys do it I forget who they had dog food the garbage collection
1:42:15but like it didn't work out because it wasn't nicely compatible with the sea place language they found a better
1:42:19solution that had better characteristics it was a better fit for their language that is more of a compromise in many
1:42:25senses than garbage collection but is so much better fit for a C.
1:42:27Based language and also garbage collection has many disadvantages
1:42:31and mobile that arc doesn't have the ark was the right solution at the right time for Apple.
1:42:35No question but it's not really the right solution.
1:42:38If you're ever if you're going to try to incremental lies your way from where we are now to a higher level language.
1:42:44I guess if you're phenomenally successful you can use that to extend your life for a really long time
1:42:51but eventually we're going to get it kind of get to the point where we are like with age of us plus where there we go.
1:42:56Where you kept attacking stuff on to something for as long as you possibly could
1:43:01and as long as you're still successful you know hailed as i Phones There is a response on there must be pretty awesome
1:43:06right like you can keep adding features for pretty long time if you have an excess of products you're just really
1:43:11delaying the inevitable though
1:43:13and I have a hard time seeing a path from something like object to see like how the transition of the transition is
1:43:20when do the pointers go away.
1:43:22That's the really hot like there's always like a chasm that you can keep making things better improving the syntax dot
1:43:27notation string literals object literals like you can do lots of awesome things especially with L V M The new compiler
1:43:33infrastructure like they have a lot of runway out in front of them they can do lots of awesome things again long enough
1:43:38probably for everyone who works at Apple to get old retire and die.
1:43:41But eventually the runway does run out
1:43:43and you're left with this crazy ass mongrel like the runaway I think is run on each of us plus that is just you can
1:43:48tell has had tons of stuff modified and tacked onto it
1:43:52and some other successful product will come along will be successful not because of the language
1:43:56but just incidentally also happens to have a language where you can express yourself.
1:44:00Concisely you know in that summer's nicer manner that people will in addition to saying I'm going to write for the
1:44:07whatever contact lens O.-S.
1:44:09Because that's awesome in the year twenty whatever and by the way the programs are awesome
1:44:14and you know how do you know if you're going to say square brackets a gang of us all be able to see the stupid syntax
1:44:19you know it's not the most important thing.
1:44:21But yeah there there will be a better way to program
1:44:25and it will be attached to some other product if Apple doesn't make it.
1:44:29Yeah and I think this conversation is the conversation of like Oh Apple needs to do this.
1:44:36I think if you're going to make that point I think it needs specifics
1:44:38and you know it's easy to say oh well Apple needs to do.
1:44:44They need to move in this direction in general terms
1:44:46and I agree that they did need to move in the direction of higher level of Angele
1:44:50but there's a big question mark there of what exactly that means
1:44:55and you know you said earlier John that you think it's Apple's responsibility.
1:44:59I don't necessarily think that's the case and I think they should have to turn the thinking
1:45:03but I think it's up to it's up to like the world of developers really to to to figure out what the heck we want
1:45:12and that I think is a much harder question you know if.
1:45:17I definitely think that the whole platform
1:45:21and all developers benefit substantially by their only really being like one conical language that you write apps for
1:45:28these platforms that there's one language with it with the officially by
1:45:33and yeah you can there's there's fringe efforts to you know languages
1:45:37but I think I think overall everyone benefits from there being like want to greet upon default language so the question
1:45:43is is something's going to replace that that language. It Like what.
1:45:48What changes and what decisions are good enough to replace it.
1:45:52Because if you if you try to have it both ways try to maintain both you know you had a whole show you had two of the
1:45:57shows on bridges that you know it doesn't really work very well.
1:46:00So what you know what choices would they make right now Objective C.
1:46:05Is pretty good at most stuff really good at some stuff and really rough it some other stuff
1:46:11but overall I would say it's pretty good right.
1:46:14And I think overall people who are familiar with that are enough to look beyond the brackets would probably agree with
1:46:20that it's pretty good. So what.
1:46:23What new thing would be at least that good to at least as many people or or a clickable to as many circumstances
1:46:32and I think that's a really hard question
1:46:35and you know this is this is like a design question this is not this is not as much a technical question.
1:46:40This is a design choice and design is hard because a lot of times with these quick questions there is no good answer.
1:46:47It's a lot like politics like there is like no good policy in some cases where everyone's going to be happy
1:46:56or to Universal winner or even everyone can agree that it's a net win at all and so I think Objective C.
1:47:02Replacements are going to face a big problem there which is like there's this huge A.P.I.
1:47:07That has to be you know poured over or core converted or rethought.
1:47:11There's a huge installed base is all these developers know what it is
1:47:14and it works for the most part it works really well like all the problems of of C.
1:47:19That make it hard to use or or clunky or hard to maintain. If it's badly written Objective C.
1:47:26Tackles a lot of those and severely reduces the impact of a lot of those
1:47:31and so it like a lot of the a lot of the problems of C.
1:47:34Aren't really problems an object to see or are so much more that it's you know it's basically irrelevant.
1:47:40And so to make something that substantially better is.
1:47:44Technically yeah you're right a lot of work it can take a lot of time
1:47:47but I think the much bigger question is what is just deciding what exactly that should be and how it should work and
1:47:53and all that. All the decisions that go into designing a language and the associated framework.
1:47:58But you know just the tech.
1:48:00That's a really big question
1:48:02and I don't see any consensus forming among developers who are suggesting that it should be different.
1:48:08I don't see any consensus forming to say like oh it should be it should move from where it is to X.
1:48:14and You know what exactly X.
1:48:16Is a little bit of consensus because of all the other high level languages there are other because so much development
1:48:21these days is done not on you know native platforms going go you know server side programming like there's always a
1:48:26language like Python Ruby and even P.H.P. and All you know all the stuff out there is giving P.
1:48:31and Javascript giving people a taste of the things they don't have a native languages
1:48:34and there's some consensus on things of the day I think everyone agree that a modern language has to have a.
1:48:39I'm thinking more like you mention a transition before it transitions can be terrible because you can't just wake up
1:48:46one day and say OK everybody right new A.B.I. and If you language go like.
1:48:50But luckily Apple has some experience in this area. It transitioned everybody from A C C plus plus you know A.B.I.
1:48:59System for reading that whether it's next to a box or power plant
1:49:02or whatever it transition them from that to a language it almost looks like a lateral move to Objective C.
1:49:07Also sea bass but totally different totally different language.
1:49:11They manage that transition perhaps not as well as they could have but for a long time they had things like carbon
1:49:16and cocoa and you make a new control is control only available in cocoa
1:49:19and it's one thing carbon people would complain why can't I get that control I want to draw
1:49:22or my carbon up in the head Quickdraw still in there in the course like it was a hairy mess
1:49:27and that move was such a tiny move like you're saying you need a language it's so maidenly betterness confesses was
1:49:33there consensus that objective seeing Coco is better than carbon.
1:49:36Definitely not among old school mac developers doubling out among like Adobe and Microsoft and stuff like that.
1:49:42It's I'm not going to say it's going to be easy
1:49:44but I think the the carbon to Cocoa transition is evidence that it is possible to do that in a way that doesn't totally
1:49:53destroy your platform which is not I don't think was a given that I don't think any one of the ripple of a transition
1:49:57like Microsoft still hasn't managed I think to pull it off.
1:50:00With the shark now desiderata a mac app you're writing a cocoa out.
1:50:04But nowadays if you're writing a windows app are you writing C. Sharp app and whatever the hell A.P.I.
1:50:08They're pushing these days for the good. Like who's running Windows apps. Yeah I mean that's a question too.
1:50:13It's going to be really difficult and the transition is almost a little
1:50:17but I think the thing you're transitioning to I don't think you need all that much consensus
1:50:22and I don't think it needs to be that fantastically better Big Apple's kind of shown that you can do it sort of by
1:50:28Fiachra and eventually people will come around to the thing. If the things that you can program in Objective C.
1:50:33Are popular enough like the i Phone and you know that you will you don't you managed to bring along like Microsoft
1:50:40and Adobe eventually kind of kicking
1:50:42and screaming like I was the first cocoa version of Photoshop like to version of the go or something like that.
1:50:47It's taken a long time but you manage not to lose them
1:50:50and they've basically completely transitioned if you're writing an application for Apple's platform you doing it
1:50:56objectives the echo despite the fact that they're not all that different from C.C.
1:50:59Plus plus A P I's that preceded them.
1:51:02What I don't see though is Mark
1:51:04or you said a minute ago you know it's up to the developer community in order to kind of I don't dictate is a strong
1:51:12word to kind of help figure out what the what the way forward is I mean how do we do that as a community do we just
1:51:18write blog post we write our own coffee script kind of equivalent that trains compiles into Objective C.
1:51:24You know what how is it up how to hell can we influence that change.
1:51:29I would say that that's exactly it it's you know we do it by both discussion and by example.
1:51:36Again though I think the biggest challenges that this is a really hard problem.
1:51:41It's a really hard question to figure out like what should be next
1:51:45and you know like you know the most of the posts have said that you know no one no one saying oh you should switch to
1:51:54python like. Like no one is putting like with like a specific language in place to say this.
1:52:00This specific thing is what you should switch to.
1:52:04It's just you know very hand we'd be like oh well it needs to solve these criteria or it needs to change.
1:52:11This list of my personal nitpicks about the language and and you know
1:52:16and as I said earlier like you know a lot of the things could be solved by A.P.I.
1:52:19Changes not not language changes and and a lot of those things do require language changes
1:52:25but are like superficial like the brackets and so I don't to be just too much of the ground further
1:52:31but I just think that one of the biggest reasons why we don't have something like this yet is because what what that
1:52:42next thing should be is really not obvious to anybody as far as I can tell
1:52:46and no one's clamoring for something specific that is widely considered a good idea.
1:52:52Well there's never going to be consensus outside Apple unavailable for consensus to form that consensus would take
1:52:58would be all their developers leaving to develop for a more popular platform
1:53:03and then the only thing Apple could take away from that was well everybody leaving to develop for whatever the new you
1:53:08know pinky ring platform is that's become very popular and then they would decide whatever the hell
1:53:16and language of the pink platform uses that's what they should use in on even though that would be the case because all
1:53:20it would mean is they just moved to a more successful platform the same way that people would say Objective C.
1:53:24Is the best language ever because look at all these developers who one developed
1:53:27and it's not really because the language they learn the language because of the way they get out of the i Phone so that
1:53:32signals from outside as well you can get from any kind of is like a big fuzzy noise.
1:53:39If you wait for a clear signal the clear single will be a sign that you waited too long and you're doomed
1:53:44and it's probably not a good signal anyway because you were to get a look at the thing that they're moving to
1:53:48and say that's what we should have done not necessarily You could've been something entirely different ten years ago
1:53:52and been and prevented this from happening but you didn't
1:53:55and so now you've lost the opportunity to dictate what the next language an A.P.I. Is going to be. That's why.
1:54:00I think Apple has to do it because they they have to do it now
1:54:02when they're in their position to be masters of their own destiny.
1:54:06If they were never going to be consensus outside them all they can look at is sort of the buzz of noise of high level
1:54:11languages and pick and choose the features they think like what one of the biggest pain points.
1:54:16I mean the kind of doing it with ARC and everything now
1:54:18but like how can we transcend those pain points not just patch over the not to make them a little better not just find
1:54:24a solution to those things it's a better fit for our current language than for example garbage collection was
1:54:28but so what is the next leap in languages.
1:54:31And I have to look at everything across the entire world all the different ways you can write software
1:54:35and maybe come up with some new ideas of their own it's a big responsibility but
1:54:38when you're the biggest technology company in the world that's what you have to do. Thanks a lot.
1:54:44Two or three sponsors this week King Squarespace and Linda dot com and we will see you next week.
1:54:53Now that's accidental. John thanks again today.
1:55:24And you know it says to that list and I don't know if anyone else enjoys it but I freakin love heard out like that.
1:55:58I think we do that all the time. It beats.
1:56:00And I would hate to show software methodologies because I know one of these things is going to be an even longer show
1:56:07one of these days we'll talk about why link and our arms are not solutions.
1:56:12Nice to see you keep associate yngling with with link to sequel which is one piece of land I know I know I know I
1:56:19didn't realize I can create my database using X. Path will be awesome.
1:56:24Nor did I bring up of the database drivers for in memory things in common separated files all the good stuff the pros
1:56:32doing decades ago. The opportunity memory operated the first program. Now I think Link is awesome.
1:56:40I think it's amazing. I just think that like the ability to try something like that is the important thing.
1:56:46Actual success like was once you tried you're like well I have strengths
1:56:50and weaknesses versus all the other things we tried before and then someone else tries again
1:56:53but you can even try something like a link if the language doesn't provide support for it.
1:56:57So you know we will keep trying.
1:57:00Like I don't know what the solution is to turn to the problem that link and or EMS
1:57:04and everything else who tried to use you know people here.
1:57:07Again he keep shooting link with or EMS and it's so much more than that. I know but it's a way to get a date.
1:57:13Doesn't have to be in a database it's basically a way to bridge the world. Like I want to get this information.
1:57:19It's in some place like to be able to view everything through a certain lens.
1:57:23What if I could query a dictionary the same way I can query a database now they're unified under the single A.P.I.
1:57:28And yes that's a much better way of looking at it. Their advantage to that. And then sometimes like.
1:57:33But that's not really a good fit for this type thing.
1:57:35Maybe I want to get in a different way
1:57:37and in the same way that people that say I don't want to view my database as a database I want to view it as a bunch of
1:57:42objects and I don't like at all. I like R.M.
1:57:44Better or maybe I don't object database because in a database I actually will be like the objects
1:57:48and I'm getting with an object database is going to keep trying to figure this out.
1:57:52As you know I give it full marks for being an interesting and novel way approach to familiar class.
1:58:00It's aided by the abilities of the language.
1:58:03Yeah that's the thing that I love so much about link is I use it against objects constantly
1:58:07and not just dictionaries you know use against a raise you know gimme gimme all the items where such
1:58:12and such a property is greater than such and such value give me all the people where age is greater than twenty one.
1:58:17And yeah that sounds a lot like a database query.
1:58:20And that's where link got it started but I can do that against an array of memory
1:58:24and that's what makes it so powerful and I very very rarely in fact almost never use link again sequel.
1:58:30I almost exclusively use LINQ against objects and it's so powerful again you can do a lot of that with an S.
1:58:36Predicate
1:58:36but it's not quite so clean it's not quite so transparent although perhaps I'm saying that because I'm just used to
1:58:43link that you would love Perl Perl is the big thing about Perl is that like your come you're comfortable speaking in
1:58:50that sort of you know not dialect but like I want to get things out of an array
1:58:54and I think of it I can think of it in the same way that we think of getting out of a dictionary it's cultural.
1:58:58Yes Perl is the poster child for giving you a way to express the same sentiment in whatever way you're the most
1:59:05comfortable thinking about it so if you're more comfortable thinking about getting information about a re is phrasing
1:59:10it in that way then that's a way that will work
1:59:12and you know like not just more than one way to do it in more than one way to say and what I like.
1:59:17People would argue why do you want to save me through different ways will sometimes people's brains work a certain way
1:59:22and they think of it in this matter knows how his people brains think of the same as I passed in a totally different
1:59:26way with everything switched around in a different order. They should be able to express that as well.
1:59:30That does make sense.
1:59:32I also want to bring up one more quick thing that's famous last words and that's concurrency
1:59:38and a lot of a lot of the the posts
1:59:42and thoughts about the new the next big language revolve around concurrency which is a valid concern the problem is
1:59:49that what a lot of people seem to want is for concurrency to be like hand wave the way.
1:59:54Oh it'll just always make everything concurrent at the language level and noodle little.
2:00:00And currency easier and the reason why concurrency is hard is not because of the language.
2:00:08My concurrency is hard is because it's complicated and it's so there are language aspects of it
2:00:14but I can relate to something like her language if you design the language around the idea of concurrency.
2:00:19A lot of the code that we have to right now to do things safely
2:00:22and concurrently like implicit concurrency where I mean go has a little bit of this
2:00:26and you know other things that where you can express something in a high enough level way where not only do you not
2:00:32care about the details of how it's done you don't have any control over the details of how it's done
2:00:37and there are invariants that are provided by the language in runtime that you can guarantee.
2:00:41All that does is just move your set of problems up to a higher level if you like
2:00:46but at least it gets rid of like the super low level concerns in the medium level concerns
2:00:50and now you deadlock on much higher level concerns think you are right
2:00:54but that's progress you know because like you don't like you want to have some sort of primitive like semaphores
2:00:59and you know atomic operations I.C.P.
2:01:01Usenet let us stop thinking about that particular problem think one level up and it's never going to be easy
2:01:07but what people want is like look I'm tired of thinking about concurrency at this level I would love it if simple
2:01:12things I could do simple concurrent operations on sets of data where I didn't care about the power of them
2:01:17and there was like built into the language I was sixteen implicitly expressed something like doing all this on all
2:01:23these With goes away towards that worth it I don't want to worry whether the details of the language itself can provide
2:01:30lots of ways of worrying about things at a slightly higher level concern
2:01:35and I think everyone would see that as a big win and that's what they're mostly talking about concurrency.
2:01:39Maybe they have fantasies where like there's not going to be a problem that really they're just going to reduce the
2:01:43number of deadlocks or deadlock and higher level things but again isn't.
2:01:47I mean so many of these of these wish list items This included in this much more an A.P.I.
2:01:53Problem than a language problem
2:01:55but it can be a language problem if you design a language with parents in mind even if it's.
2:02:00Part of like the standard library to go to know whether they're concurrently things are part of the language
2:02:04or there is a library that comes in the language and that that line is fuzzy to begin with I mean like Objective C.
2:02:08Technically is basically a C. Library it's not like it's there in Objective C. Language with C. Runtime which is a C.
2:02:14Program that runs your you know what I mean like it's a fuzzy line but I think Erling and Haskell
2:02:19and other kind of things where you express operations in such a high level that there's no way to control any sort like
2:02:26the parallelism may either be nonexistent or like pervasive
2:02:29and you just you know you know sort of the preconditions in the post conditions in a language you guarantee you that
2:02:34and you're not concerned with how outperforms of things if you can get that kind of implicit parallelism built into the
2:02:40language whole classes of problems that people
2:02:43but that regular sort of run of the mill programmers are afraid to tackle with concurrency now even though they totally
2:02:48have the tools to do it. Become open to them in the same way the G.C.D.
2:02:52Has opened up parallelism to people who otherwise wouldn't try have been part of this great library G.C.D.
2:02:58Previously able to run on the main thread but it's so easy for me not to run the main thread out of throw it off
2:03:02and those people learn that actually you can screw yourself doing that too you know.
2:03:05But like it's it's all about lowering the bar to whatever powers in the my willing to attempt
2:03:11and feel confident is going to work and if you can bake things like that into the language
2:03:15or into a library that's so much a part of the language it seems like the language.
2:03:19It lets more people do parallels and more you.
2:03:22Yeah I don't know I guess I'm I'm much more of an optimist that there are still tons of room for improvement with
2:03:29libraries an A.P.I.
2:03:31With the same language in that you don't need to throw out the entire language and the entire existing A.P.I.
2:03:36To get progress in a lot of these fronts people are asking for
2:03:38and I think that's you know you're right that if you if you make it like part of the syntax
2:03:43and part of the native way of doing things then it certainly can go deeper
2:03:46but I just think there's so much more we can do and I think it's one of the reasons why Objective C.
2:03:52Has stuck around all this time
2:03:53and probably has a pretty long future because there is so much more you can do with just libraries and.
2:04:00Changes and maybe a little help from the editor and the tools are written in very a court date.
2:04:05Speaking of like Link and R.M.
2:04:07In all other ways a court date is yet another way to try to deal with like large troughs of data that you can rummage
2:04:14through
2:04:15and they had to have a different model of its kind of like go around not really like a link like you don't call the
2:04:21database you mention as predicate it's an object store it lets you know that probably didn't run at many different
2:04:28times never I think at the language level I think maybe link is closer to God even though it's not language levels like
2:04:33flies on language features but it's language integrated. That's what it says in the day you know.
2:04:39But is it language and if I don't you know I know it's like yeah.
2:04:44Problems here having more tools to run
2:04:48and a problem having a language help you in that regard can let you try new solutions those solutions may not be better
2:04:53or worse than what came before but at least opens up the door
2:04:56and I think I don't know enough about these highly parallel languages to know like we're given an early expert on here
2:05:01they would explain what it is specifically about her lying that makes it so much better than doing the same things in
2:05:07any other language because the language was designed with concurrency in mind
2:05:12but I'm convinced enough from what I have from things that I read about language that that is the case it's just that
2:05:17or lying is so much worse that everything else that people want to do with programs that it hasn't really caught the
2:05:21world on fire but who knows if the if the pinky ring program but only in Erling
2:05:26and everyone earth bought ten of them then we'd all are alike.