Podcast Search

The Accidental Tech Podcast

54: goto fail;

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00You're under some fall. OK sounds great. There's hardly any is there any kind of not really.

0:00:09Yeah I'm lumping something that probably isn't by the strictest definition follow up in the follow up

0:00:15and that is after our discussion about what comes after Objective C.

0:00:21A lot of people have come out of the woodwork

0:00:23and said hey guys have you seen this wall from language thing that's going to be the next big thing that will replace

0:00:28Objective C. and It's not. So anything else it is pretty cool.

0:00:34Oh it's cause hell I have no idea what I would use a floor if anything I think I'm not smart enough to use it actually

0:00:40but every day all kidding aside it is very very cool but it's serving a completely different purpose

0:00:46and I don't see a mechanism by which that's going to be the way in which we build apps

0:00:52and of course somebody will will say to us.

0:00:55Oh well but didn't you watch the whole video they had sliders on there another U.I. Elements and blah blah blah.

0:01:00Yeah but that's not that's not really the point.

0:01:03You know it's not it's not the sort of thing you'd build an app with it's the sort of thing that you would do some

0:01:08really impressive and very cool data computations with

0:01:14but for some heat build an app with the the money you don't have to use Mathematica in school I did

0:01:19and I've long since forgotten all that I don't know I use Matlab I'm sorry about that Mathematica I think I was

0:01:26and still more from Mathematica is to him the max is the Stallman basically like separating this crazy person who made

0:01:36an environment where he can where he can sort of fill his dreams of computation has just added to it over the years.

0:01:43Only well for me as a little bit more successful a little bit more determined and not quite as afflicted with R.S.I.

0:01:49and They hired a bunch of other people to do things that I had a business that made money to let him indulges his taste

0:01:56to this type of thing so he's built this amazing thing for him self that works the way they want to.

0:02:01That is basically like start with Mathematica and just expand out to fill the universe

0:02:04but it it's I'm going to tell you about this like oh it's just a

0:02:10and insert word here because it's not just a anything like what it does is very impressive it's like it's a life's work

0:02:15and it is very interesting in a present

0:02:18but I think it's an application an application that you can program with more than a programming language regardless of

0:02:26what you think it can apply to everything and that demo shows that it's good at doing the stuff in that demo.

0:02:33But Apple of course would need a language it's going to doing the things that I'm going to do and what is happening.

0:02:37Do they need to let developers write applications they need to write applications themselves

0:02:41and they need to write in the US and for all of those purposes this language is not useful.

0:02:46Right and you don't don't let me you know kind of shrugging it off as a replacement for Objective C.

0:02:53To take away from the fact that you're absolutely right it is unbelievably impressive that things can be done with it

0:02:58but it is serving an entirely different purpose

0:03:00and that's the only point I'm trying to make I'm not going be writing the next you know Instapaper killer.

0:03:06It will from language.

0:03:08Yeah one of the aspects that it has going against it as the fart computer languages that leans heavily on it like that

0:03:15like in the sort of cloud of what are you closer to that sort of start grouping towards the math side of things while

0:03:22always very interesting and powerful tend not to.

0:03:26Thus far I mean doesn't mean it can never happen

0:03:28but so far the ones that tend to be more math like have not caught on as much as the ones that are less math like

0:03:34and you know I don't know why that is the only you know for example Haskell as another of those languages that looks

0:03:40more like you're doing math or is more math like are you even sort of like Lisp kind of sort of

0:03:47and this definitely is towards the math side I mean it's all intervals with it like language with all the symbolics I

0:03:54mean start from Mathematica now going to be math. But yet so far. Language is like that.

0:04:00I haven't caught on with the masses no matter how cool they are for the people who use them for the things they're good

0:04:04at.

0:04:05One problem I think I'd have trying to trying to use this for anything is that kind of similar in this one only one way

0:04:14to Apple script.

0:04:15I think it would be hard for me to get started into this and to even know the kinds of things I could do

0:04:22and you know you can do so much and in that way it's pretty unfocused.

0:04:29It's very broad and you're presented with like here's here's this shell basically this command shell

0:04:35and this interactive prompt you can do whatever you want with but

0:04:40and like the demos that he was showing off in the video look amazing really cool I don't know that is really how useful

0:04:46it would be for me but they are still amazingly cool.

0:04:48But I was looking at the kinds of syntax he was using the kinds of commands using the kind of structures he was using

0:04:54and I don't even know where I would begin with something like that

0:04:58and I had a same problem ever using will from Alpha as well where every time I've tried to go from Alpha I've I've

0:05:04tried phrasing things in a certain way and every I never guessed the correct syntax and never does what I want

0:05:10and I can tell there's a lot there

0:05:13but it's really hard just to get started it's really hard to know like OK what can I do here

0:05:18and how do I ask it to do that.

0:05:21I think like a list I think the language itself is probably super simple I figured only a few things that exist you

0:05:26know the royal like tuples in some sense X.

0:05:28or Function calls

0:05:29and a couple other symbolic things to write math in ASCII to convert it into symbol representations that is the

0:05:36language

0:05:37but the language is pointless like if you look at the big paging through those page after page a little rectangle

0:05:43underneath one of those has a vocabulary which is basically like a library.

0:05:46You know I wonder what functions can I call what things can I type that's not part of the language per se.

0:05:51None of those are key words like if and you know the loops and function declarations like the language syntactic loop.

0:06:00Very simple to its discredit I think it would be both be very cumbersome to do anything remotely complicated

0:06:06but the whole the power of the thing is look at all these basically libraries that we have look at all the different

0:06:11functions we have to look at what the options of those functions are look at how those functions can be composed with

0:06:16each other and so it's it's kind of weird to call it a language other you know it's more like an application

0:06:23or a set of libraries in the set of what we look huge like that.

0:06:26Surely there is some function that does the thing that you want to have the operas that you want

0:06:30and if you can't find it exactly you can build it by composing it out of other really powerful pieces

0:06:33and put it all on a web front end and get it through web services A.P.I.

0:06:37Lots of cool stuff in there but I think it's more like an application it's more like an A.P.I.

0:06:45Then it is a language and whatever it is it's not to write their operating systems for phones or desktops.

0:06:52So I had the same thought that this would be in a potentially extremely powerful add on or you know processing unit.

0:07:01But I guess like a dynamic library for first something in Objective see if you could get some sort of interface into it

0:07:09but I don't see it replacing Objective C. or Anything like that. Very cool though very very cool.

0:07:15So what else is going on. You want talk about this as a sell bug go to fail.

0:07:23All right so moving on now it's getting ready to take aim premium

0:07:29and I love the good to fail dot com was actually available not for long

0:07:34and it was useful once it was once it became a thing. I don't know if I have all that much to say about this.

0:07:42I'm not sure I concur Marco with your tinfoil hat reasoning.

0:07:47This was a deliberate act happy for you to convince me that I am wrong but I'm not saying it is it wasn't deliberate

0:07:55but it to me didn't recall of being deliberate like you seem to think you want to. A recap.

0:08:00What leads you to believe that I'm sure I mean I think I'm not saying this was definitely an N.S.A.

0:08:12or Security breach where you know my my theory that I think is is potential

0:08:19and I don't even know if I would say the most likely

0:08:22but I think it's reasonable to look at these events that this one a duplicated line was inserted into this as a cell is

0:08:34a strict verification code

0:08:36or a common name checking Paro than it it was that the step the checks of the common names match

0:08:42and it skips over that step.

0:08:43I believe so it was some part of the verification step so that you can make sure that the S.L.

0:08:51Server that you're talking to is who they say they are

0:08:54and not I'm in the middle who you know like mannitol attacks I mean even qualified to explain them in all their you

0:09:01know everything properly but somebody who could like intercept your network traffic and I a spear

0:09:09or a wireless router in a coffee shop

0:09:11or whatever the case may be your school your workplace somebody who could intercept your government somebody who

0:09:16intercept your your network traffic normally as a cell's designed if everything's done right so that to so that the

0:09:25server and you can talk securely and you know

0:09:28when you connect to the server you can verify it through the series of cryptography steps you can verify that the

0:09:33server you're talking to really is who they say they are

0:09:35and nobody else in the middle is listening in a way that they can decode your data.

0:09:40This this bug broke that assumption. And so that somebody could have been listening in and breaking S.S.L.

0:09:47and Watching your traffic and the operating system was just skipping that verification step or part of it.

0:09:53So the way this was inserted in the file and the file. There are open source.

0:10:01Not every revision is open source but you can see like the version that shipped in ten

0:10:07and the version that shipped in ten nine and you can see the difference there.

0:10:11So the difference not entirely convincing because there could have been a lot a lot of intermediate revisions between

0:10:18you don't know what happened between those two all you see is the getting point and ending point.

0:10:23But if you look at the Do Not a lot in the file has changed between the two releases.

0:10:29There is this context parameter to some of the security calls that was removed. Basically it was at the A.P.I.

0:10:36I just changed mine early so that you know this one argument and I want to say or something like that.

0:10:41So most not even some of the calls had this very this very basic change to them that just like remove this argument.

0:10:49There are almost no other changes in the entire function

0:10:52and then this one extra goto failed line inserted in the middle

0:10:59and so if you look at this if you just look at the death looks pretty bad like it looks like wow there like no edits

0:11:05happen in the surrounding lines between these two releases.

0:11:09Just this one line was inserted kind of the middle of nowhere and it looks pretty bad.

0:11:15Of course you know that said though you can't rely only on that.

0:11:18I think what what worries me and what makes me think that this could be this could have been the Ferias

0:11:26and I'm going to

0:11:27and I want to say to my tweets I don't necessarily believe that that Apple itself you know officially knew about this

0:11:33or introduce this intentionally or was working with the N.S.A. I think it's much more likely seeing how the N.S.A.

0:11:39Works knowing that they have a program where the New York Times reported hard to find the link

0:11:43but I believe it said they had an annual budget of two hundred fifty million dollars to go do things exactly like this

0:11:49where basically the N.S.A.

0:11:51Will kind of get to an engineer who works who works at one of the tech companies or they will.

0:11:58They'll have people sitting on.

0:12:00In standards bodies trying to argue for different standards to be subtly weakened or have have these back to just

0:12:09or the people who work in tech companies will you know become an essay. I don't know.

0:12:15Supporters Asians whatever they're called. So we know that that kind of thing happens.

0:12:21We know all that from the Edward Snowden leaks and from these from the associated important common sense

0:12:24and all of that you know that's that's not that's not like artifice

0:12:28and tinfoil happing that think that kind of thing does happen.

0:12:33And so for this bug to be inserted in this file at this time and so

0:12:38and again another little piece of circumstantial evidence this bug was inserted in I believe it was fall of two

0:12:46thousand and twelve. It was like a it was the month before. One of the N.S.A.

0:12:51Slide decks claimed that Apple had joined the prison program in some way

0:12:57and that timing is really suspect as well so you can look at this

0:13:01and we don't know yet at least we don't know what happened and we probably will never know what happened.

0:13:06It could have been an innocent mistake an innocent you know blind patient of a buffer or a weird merge artifact

0:13:13when the files are merged. Who knows right.

0:13:16You know we can't tell exactly but normally

0:13:20when you try to rule out a kind of Farias tinfoil hat conspiracy theory kind of thing you do it by saying well the

0:13:26simpler more likely explanation is honest reason X.

0:13:31and I think in this case looking at the environment we're in looking at the kinds of things that we now know go on with

0:13:37the N.S.A. and What they do with tech companies.

0:13:40And you look at exactly I mean for a one line bug like this this is a hell of a line to take.

0:13:49Like if you look like what I did in the way it did it was so subtle it was subtle enough.

0:13:55If you think about it it's perfect. It's subtle enough that.

0:14:00It would pass a lot of any kind of internal review they had

0:14:03and we can talk about that they probably had insufficient review and sufficient tests

0:14:07but any kind of internal review it would it might it might skip by because it looks it's it blends in.

0:14:15It's not obvious it's not even obvious that it is a bug once or even once you spot it.

0:14:20You kind of have to notice and oh wait a minute like you think about it for a second.

0:14:24Oh that's that's wrong

0:14:25and it could be explained away if somebody was caught inserting it it can be explained away by saying Oh I must've hit

0:14:33you know hit paste wrong or merged wrong so there's like a plausible explanation if you get caught and it's

0:14:39and it's exactly at the right point where it wasn't breaking all S.S.L. It wasn't making all S.S.L.

0:14:46Validate but is making this one particular class of thing validate that the N.S.A. Has been known to do so.

0:14:55It's just a little too convenient in so many of these ways. The timing the kind of thing it is.

0:15:01The perfection of like exactly the right part of the file to cause a very convenient backdoor for the N.S.A.

0:15:08and In a way that looks really subtle and hard to find and hard to blame for what you do find it because then they can.

0:15:16I'm sure they can look at their version history and they can see which employee in sort of that

0:15:19but again it's there's a plausible reason.

0:15:21Oh it was much of a mistake during the merger some might that you know so it's just a little too convenient to be a

0:15:28dumb honest mistake in given the given the context given the time it happened.

0:15:33What it did the results it had and what we now know about what our government does.

0:15:39So that's why I think again like I wouldn't say that it's definitely the N.S.A.

0:15:45but I would say it would be naive to brush it off and say Oh it probably wasn't that.

0:15:50I think the chances are better than that that it was that you know like I can't really argue with any of that

0:15:57and I don't know I just.

0:16:00How I guess I just want to believe that people aren't jerks like that

0:16:04and that our government doesn't do things like that

0:16:07but to be honest that's me to keep my head my head in the sand so I don't John what do you think about all that for the

0:16:14timing thing I think that just is reasonably explained by saying the N.S.A.

0:16:21Knew that this bug was in there and joining the program basically means the N.S.A.

0:16:25Now has the capability to intercept traffic to Apple devices because of this bug that it knows about

0:16:29and how would they know about the bug well through its own testing through trying to do man

0:16:34and then all attacks perhaps having someone working at Apple who look at the code before its release to tell them of

0:16:39this isn't there. So that would explain the timing and that doesn't require the N.S.A.

0:16:43To have caused the bug to be entered in any way.

0:16:47So the timing I think of the wash for it if I had to put money on it I would bet that it's a merge error

0:16:54and it was accidental and that doesn't mean the N.S.A.

0:16:57Wasn't exploiting it to do what they do because it seems like they knew about it based on the timing

0:17:03and that they knew about it I'm sure they would be exploiting it.

0:17:07The reason I think is a merger is because I don't think it's all that subtle I think if they were going at the N.S.A.

0:17:12We're going to intentionally plant on like this they would do it in a less discoverable way because once a disco is

0:17:17discovered to get patched and the N.S.A.'s goal is not to be discovered.

0:17:22This is not a you know it's if you glance at it you might miss it you know casually visually inspecting it.

0:17:28But it's a type of thing that will be found both in terms of the code

0:17:32and in terms of the massive effect it has like if they planted one you would hope they would plant one that isn't so

0:17:38easy to find because this is like a I can spoof a certificate

0:17:42and it just accept everything like except any garbage it skips that entire Like if I carefully constructed a

0:17:48certificate with a particular thing early you know like it's not exploding in subtlety it's the type of thing it's

0:17:53amazing that it went underscored for as long as it did because of apparent Apple's apparent total lack of testing of

0:17:59their security camera.

0:18:01So that I think argues against it being intentional

0:18:03and the thing about plausible deniability this is the really creepy part is that I can imagine that Apple has automated

0:18:10merge tools for bringing bills together so if you were to find a commit that did this I I would imagine there's a good

0:18:16chance that it could be attributable to an automated merge too and then how do you blame. Right.

0:18:21Bio phone was really clever and set up the series of dominoes such that they knew and

0:18:24when we did this merger that merge and that merger would mess something up.

0:18:27And if the only validation of a marriage is a human being visually inspecting

0:18:31and signing off well yes you know in this.

0:18:34Or if the validation emerges it compiles

0:18:36and passes are apparently clearly inadequate test suite then that will let it go here too.

0:18:41So I think we all agree that it's it is entirely entirely possible that the end as I did of the government is because

0:18:49like Marta said that something this is something they do

0:18:52but I think this is a this would be below the level of competence and sneakiness that I would expect from them.

0:18:59So I give it a less than fifty percent chance that it was done intentionally.

0:19:03More than fifty percent chance that it was done unintentionally at almost a hundred percent chance of the N.S.A.

0:19:07Both knew about it and exploit it.

0:19:10I mean you know overall I agree John like I agree that that these things like all of these factors could be explained

0:19:18away in reasonable you know plausible explanations.

0:19:23It's just like what you

0:19:24when you add it all together the end again like it's sort of happened a year ago before we knew so much about you know

0:19:31from the Snowden leaks before we knew all this stuff a year ago I would have looked at this

0:19:36and thought oh well it's like somebody made a stupid mistake.

0:19:39But now that we know that this stuff happens and

0:19:43and because of how convenient it would be you know yeah you're right that that was you know disabling his entire steps

0:19:49of S.S.L. Verification are pretty handsome.

0:19:53However you know they got it through and it was there for over a year right. So.

0:20:00I think I'm sure they don't just try one thing and maybe the other things they tried got caught or didn't chip

0:20:10or are still there. Yes thanks.

0:20:13Sleep well tonight or are still there and and you know I'm sure they don't just leave themselves one option you know.

0:20:21So again I think by by looking at just the the fairly you know broad strokes of this bug used I wouldn't for the same

0:20:32reason that you wouldn't rule out the timing because there's you know there's always like I wouldn't I wouldn't rule I

0:20:38wouldn't rule out the possibility of I'm doing this just because of how fairly hamfest it is because in many other ways

0:20:45it's quite elegant in how innocent it looks and how hard how hard it was to catch

0:20:52and I'm sure they tried many things and some of them are handwritten and some of them are really clever and the

0:20:58and the really clever ones maybe didn't work for me they're still there but this one we happen to find.

0:21:02Well none of the ruling it as if you're over fifty percent for thinking it was intentional and I'm under.

0:21:07But that's basically it we're all around the middle you know. Yeah and I'm like I'm not too far over fifty percent.

0:21:13I might say sixty percent you know

0:21:15but normally conspiracy theories really well there are just too many coincidences to believe your conspiracy theory.

0:21:22You know too many Clintons would have to happen.

0:21:24You know this I think it's I think it's subtly the other direction it's theirs.

0:21:29You have to ignore a lot of a lot of Clinton and says that did that

0:21:32or the case to believe that this was totally innocent.

0:21:36So you think Apple will ever say anything publicly about the investigation that undoubtedly is taking place inside the

0:21:44company to determine the cause of this. Oh I really doubt that.

0:21:48And the second question is will they use their disclosure canary thing you know like where the previous disclosure they

0:21:55said we have not been contacted by government agencies to blah blah blah blah blah for you with the word.

0:22:00But as someone in the chat room a look at up but they put that in there so they can so that

0:22:04when you see that message disappear you will know that they have been contacted by the government told not to say

0:22:11anything about it.

0:22:13So that's I guess the thing we can actually watch

0:22:15or that's actionable The next time they do one of those security disclosure statements.

0:22:19If the whatever canary statement is not there again we can't directly connected to that incident

0:22:23but at least you know for example if we see the statement again we'll know that Apple is investigated internally

0:22:30and that I don't see if it was the government

0:22:34and they have been forced by the government to disclose it was the government.

0:22:38I don't see why they wouldn't make that public because the base will be saying hey in essence you know our government

0:22:45hacked us.

0:22:46You know they'd be angry they'd talk to Congress about it all sorts of stuff like that if that if they determine that

0:22:52to be the case but if it was just an internal error they probably won't say anything

0:22:57and if they're little canary statement is still there. Then we also know that N.S.A.

0:23:01Is not the one making them not say anything she wants all to the Canary statement was more about getting user data.

0:23:10I thought that the canary statement was something about how we you know we haven't been

0:23:14or we haven't received any requests from the N.S.A. To do crap. We didn't want to do.

0:23:19I know but this will be a request to you're not allowed to say anything about the N.S.A.

0:23:24Mole that you discovered in your organization like that.

0:23:28I guess you're right it's different categories thing like we've never given them user data and blah blah blah

0:23:32but it was it was fairly wide ranging statement

0:23:36and like they can't they can't to state what they may be forced not to say anything about it

0:23:42but I would imagine they would remove that they would just simply not put that statement in there because it's not an

0:23:47admission of anything it's just a cell phone of the Khmer you just remove it

0:23:50and that's their sort of signal to the outside world that government people have come

0:23:55and told us not to say anything and we can legally just simply not say anything and you can interpret.

0:24:00As a as a sign that we're being told not to say something about something. Yeah maybe but it is two different things.

0:24:07It says you know I have it here the very last line of this is thing from Mattapan Serino the very last line of Apple's

0:24:14report today states quote Apple has never received an order under section two fifteen of the USA Patriot Act we would

0:24:20expect to challenge such an order if served on us which to me sounds like something separate than what we're talking

0:24:27about.

0:24:28Well I mean that's a look at what was Section two fifteen of the Patriot Act says doing a very good actor Paul because

0:24:33the government can do whatever the hell you have no rights and some something some sort of vague language as broad

0:24:39but I mean that's all we've got like they can go back in time

0:24:42and put in a canary about what we've never been infiltrated by the N.S.A.

0:24:45Never added bugs or code intentionally

0:24:48and honestly I don't know how they would ever determine it is like Marco I said if the best case scenario that it

0:24:53actually is an individual developer What are they going to waterboard to God like knowledge on a stake.

0:24:59They can ask him did you put that there intentionally

0:25:01but if you did intentionally of course he's not going to tell you that he did and you can't force him to tell you

0:25:06and you just you'll just never know because it is one hundred percent plausible as a bug like people are abuzz all the

0:25:12time right.

0:25:12Just you know the winds get pasted twice like Marcus that like there is no literally no way to force someone to.

0:25:19You'll never know that I thought you could talk to him to death and he dies and he never said that he did

0:25:25and you still don't know whether he was lying or not let me tell you a story

0:25:29and then maybe Marky can tell us about some sweet in my first job I wrote. Bingo.

0:25:36Biggest slot machines which is a weird and odd story that's not worth explaining right now

0:25:42but this was done in DOS using the Wacom people's past compiler

0:25:47and because it was done in DOS The bugging in the traditional sense wasn't really a thing.

0:25:54So you basically had to put out a bunch of print out a bunch of log statements and so on and so forth.

0:25:58Well the machines. That we built in the software that we built.

0:26:02Basically it had a menu and then a series of different slant Slot Machine Games

0:26:08and what we were noticing all of a sudden is that after some arbitrary amount of time of going into a game you go into

0:26:15them and you go on to the game going to them and you go to the games on the menu at like thirty forty fifty times.

0:26:20All of a sudden you get a hard crash and we couldn't figure out what it was and we had some really really good C.

0:26:28Plus plus developers there the team at that point was only twenty people.

0:26:31But there are some really smart guys there now I'm straight out of college so I don't know what crap I'm doing.

0:26:36But after a while it was on me to try to figure out and a co-worker actually to try to figure out.

0:26:45Where's this crash coming from why is it happening

0:26:48and you know some of my room much more experience much better coworkers had looked through diffs they'd look through

0:26:53check ins nobody could figure out what it was and eventually I figured it out I can't recall if I just spotted it

0:27:00or if I looked through the version history of some of all the files that have been changed lately

0:27:06but it ended up being was a fall through in a switch statement and in the switch statement

0:27:14and in in each case we were instantiating an object that was fairly big I forget exactly what it was

0:27:21but is big so what that means is we would create this new object and allocate a bunch of memory for it

0:27:28and then there was an accidental fall through that we didn't mean to have and so we would create another one

0:27:34and that first object all that memory got leaked and it took us for ever to find it it took it seriously.

0:27:43I believe it was two weeks of myself

0:27:45and a co-worker just digging through code for two straight weeks trying to figure out what it was.

0:27:50And I bring this up because it looked statically.

0:27:53It looked very similar to this go to fail issue there was what appeared on the surface to be.

0:28:00Perfectly valid switch statement

0:28:02and it just so happens that we had forgotten to put the word brake with a semi-colon after it.

0:28:07We were leaking memory and after thirty to fifty times going back out to the menu.

0:28:12That's because the air they've got instruments you wouldn't know that because you couldn't run the little graph that

0:28:17shows the memory was in the league.

0:28:18You're absolutely right and I know you're slightly being snarky but that is absolutely true

0:28:23and that's part of the reason why I think none of us are necessarily that excited to get rid of a check to see.

0:28:28But I bring this up because here was a situation where we had a handful of really good C.

0:28:33Post plus developers now we didn't have a lot of process you could say our methodology was not very good

0:28:39but regardless you have a lot of process.

0:28:41But nevertheless we had some really bright guys and girls going through the stuff

0:28:45and nobody could find it because it wasn't something that was visually almost a static Lee obvious

0:28:52and I see this as being a very very very similar situation.

0:28:57Now just food for thought is examples of language misfeatures that lead to bugs the language you cite is the fall

0:29:04through

0:29:04or you need a break statement language misfeature I think in this bug was you know that you can have single single

0:29:10clause conditionals without the braces and then make it slightly less obvious

0:29:13and some people say the language misfeatures the white spaces significant in the by them people tell you others will

0:29:18never happen in Python.

0:29:21I mean all the talk about whether this is intentional

0:29:23or not like bugs happen all the time that aren't security related to displaying bugs and cause things to crash

0:29:30and the language features do lead to more or fewer bugs

0:29:34and I don't I would love to see some stats on like bugs that are attributable to human error that it could potentially

0:29:44have been influenced by language feature so that the single clause if they had that is probably probably pretty high up

0:29:50in any language that allows that type of thing.

0:29:53This is just so easy and I feel I put a line underneath it or to indent things wrong in a misleading way.

0:30:00The break and the fall through for K.

0:30:02Statements for getting the break I mean I can't count how many times I've done that I like it I do it.

0:30:07You know usually it's so obvious because there's nothing works at all but if you get on like enough

0:30:10and things happen to sort of appear to work you won't notice it because you just write it out

0:30:15and the looks is all invented the way you want to be news forgot the put the word on who doesn't forget to put the word

0:30:19that's like a rite of passage when you learn the things you will forget the put in break

0:30:25and you know your things don't work right. Man I found a nasty bug this week in my P.H.P.

0:30:30Framework in my in my sort function so I have you know my model class

0:30:35and I have a couple of community model sort functions to do common things and

0:30:39and one of them is if you have your your way and P.H.P.

0:30:44Arrays are all hashes slash dictionaries it's all like you know arbitrary key to value it can be strings or numbers.

0:30:52So the idea is if you have an array of numerically indexed models

0:30:55and you want to do instead be indexed by one of the values on each one like say go ID to object instead of just like

0:31:02zero through and add a function to assign the key of each object to be that that property the specified

0:31:12and I hadn't worked on the array in place loops see the problem.

0:31:17The speech we have defined semantics for what what the cars trucks allow you to modify the thing you're into writing

0:31:24over and place and which ones don't. He's not really P.H.P. You can generally modify things as you read over them.

0:31:32Most of the time it usually works. Not reassuring.

0:31:36Kind of a problem that I have to say most the time and usually they are.

0:31:40But yeah so as a result I was and I'm going through you know going to be in the numeric indexes

0:31:47and I would say All right well I have this property value of this one so unset in America index said that it was that

0:31:53and set it to the string index. Cool so what happens when the value of one of those things is like what.

0:32:00Happens at the value of the one it was previously an idea zero is two then you go to ID one do that your ID to it

0:32:09and that one gets on set and so the resulting a ray can clobber certain elements to base an error value

0:32:15and can actually have fewer elements in it than an input of what I was getting I will say you pulled off the first one

0:32:22and its id value a seventy seven and you shoved it into seventy seven

0:32:26when you were later on fine years of iterating over seventy seven because the iterations I now see the new entry down

0:32:31the seventy seven I think so

0:32:33but it's a fact that I can't I don't even know that for sure is a problem with self modifying code here

0:32:39and you can in theory get yourself into like an infinite loop of credit where you think his keep getting shoved to the

0:32:44end and make a new entry that you then enter eight over the cause and to be shown to the end of the end

0:32:48or sources telling us yes yes it's crazy

0:32:50and so yeah that was an obvious like if you looked at the code it looked reasonable legal of course

0:32:56but you know until you thought about it I'm like oh wait a minute

0:32:59and I this was this was a utility function in my framework that's been there for about seven years.

0:33:06Like I wonder how many bugs that I don't use a function a lot though I do use it

0:33:13and maybe all the time to use it so far I like most of the time it just never it never had a situation so I didn't

0:33:20notice it. Yeah that was a problem anyway.

0:33:24We're sponsored this week our first Bonsor thirty minutes

0:33:26and our first sponsor is picture life now we talked a while back many times about posting your pictures online photo

0:33:35storage photo backups stuff like that so picture life is the one up you need for your photos and videos.

0:33:42Starting with seamless backup and deep integrations into i Photo an aperture picture life auto organizes your photos

0:33:49and gives you the power to view and quickly search through them on any device.

0:33:53Picture wise private sharing that you easily control who sees which photos and their editor works on the web and I.

0:34:00No S. Plants are just five dollars per month and A.T.P. Listeners get thirty percent off for life.

0:34:06So I have a picture Life dot com slash A.T.P. They've never done this before so I really give this a shot.

0:34:13Make them make them love their sponsorship with us. You save thirty percent on the monthly fee for life.

0:34:19That's awesome

0:34:21and so they have all sorts of cool features they have a deep search it's very very powerful you know use of the face

0:34:28detection all that other stuff is really cool these days. They have apps for the mac apps for i O. S.

0:34:34Also even support Windows and Android Android just launched in December and is very quickly coming up to speed

0:34:40and you know this company was founded by people who really love those they love creativity and love technology.

0:34:48Founders of this include Charles foreman who I actually know.

0:34:51Charles foreman of Pop Jacob the heart of Threadless and Nate Westheimer of the New York Tech Meetup I know him too.

0:34:59And that is backed by our V.C. Friend that Spark Capital and I know them too they were the main P.C.

0:35:04Behind tumbler so I'm very familiar all these people they're really good people anyway.

0:35:08Picture life is the one after that your photos really needs so you can back up the search edit and share on math

0:35:15and i O. S. Going to picture Life dot com slash A.T.P.

0:35:19and You can get thirty percent off for life thanks a lot to picture life for sponsoring our show

0:35:23and if you don't want them to go away like ever pics. Sign up.

0:35:26And unlike every book they don't have unlimited storage things over there have a more viable business model of where

0:35:33you actually pay for what you use. Yeah it seems that way.

0:35:36Also Charles foreman that guy is a machine like member draw something that was the big thing that was like their big

0:35:42thing

0:35:42but he he had a site before that that I was I was socialized them a bit while he was working on that through David Karp

0:35:49a Tumblr we were all we would go out to dinner a few times here and there and that guy.

0:35:53He's incredibly smart and he's just like a coating output machine.

0:36:00Like I rarely see anybody be able to produce as much as he does

0:36:05and he really really knows his stuff so I would I would certainly trust us right now to go back for him before the

0:36:11sponsor break it would it would be wrong of me not to mention that in Objective C.

0:36:17I'm sorry non-objective see I've been writing a check to see today which I'm all confused in C. Sharp.

0:36:23There are interesting language features that would prevent both of the bugs that Marc and I are talking about.

0:36:29Firstly you can't have a full through in any case in a switch statement unless that case is completely empty.

0:36:37So you would literally have one line case one Colin the next line case to call one

0:36:42and if there's anything in between without a break statement that's a compiler error

0:36:46and the other thing is if you try to modify pretty much any

0:36:49and numerable collection in place you get a I believe that's a runtime error not a compiler error.

0:36:56So that's just really nice ways to protect you from yourself

0:36:58and that I really appreciate that I have to tell you that pro are protective

0:37:02and they think they were just Simla now doing a crawl requires braces on single statement if it doesn't let you do it

0:37:10without them. The numbers intentional to avoid this feature because the people who wrote Perl were writing Perl in C.

0:37:16and Hated that and there's no switch they principle solve there

0:37:20or there is a terrible deprecated one it's part of a sea pen model

0:37:23but counts up our language well as modifying sets if you integrate over the keys of a ray you can actually modify the

0:37:34array because they get sick us out of time and doesn't make reference to the thing.

0:37:40Unfortunately you get the keys and values that it does the good old P.H.P.

0:37:43Way where you know this is madness but there are other reasons not to do.

0:37:48They should just deprecate getting the keys and values the same time anyway because I don't go to Perl details

0:37:54but suffice it to say that it's not. They have to give it a value on a per very.

0:38:00Basis and that just leads to more madness.

0:38:02So that should be deprecated but I think that this is one of those things too like you know the go to fail bug.

0:38:09There's actually a compiler warning that warns on unreachable code blocks

0:38:15and so if you have a function that contains like you know return zero

0:38:19and then a bunch of lines of code below it will those those lines will never be reached because that return statement

0:38:24unconditional return will execute and then everything else in the function will never be reached.

0:38:29Go to fail thing again.

0:38:30It's if you have this unconditional goto statement which is what the bug line was that skips over that big block of the

0:38:36function then that that code is unreachable and so compiler there's a warning for that. In honor of his in G.C.C.

0:38:43but It's at least a V.M. and The problem is it's not part of the W.

0:38:48All option that that a lot of nerds use it's not part of the all mornings default set because I think I was reading a

0:38:56little of this I think the main reason why is because there's a lot of like you know libraries

0:39:01and stuff that that it would fail on for various reasons

0:39:05and so in that's you know it's always it's always a tricky balance of warnings and

0:39:09when you're striking that like I recently in my P.H.P.

0:39:11Framework I I always had for the last few years I've used what I call trick development mode which is

0:39:20when you're in the development Vironment everything even the notice the lightest level of P.H.P. Warnings.

0:39:26Everything became an exception because I don't want my code to ever emit a notice

0:39:30and I don't care if it's going to be littered with with is set statements all over the place.

0:39:35I don't care everything there should be no errors in development

0:39:38and I recently even a couple weeks ago I think it was a recent So you know why.

0:39:43Why should not also apply to production.

0:39:45If I'm if I'm throwing exceptions on

0:39:47and on any minor error in development that for I think good reasons why should I be more lenient in production.

0:39:54In reality if things are failing anywhere I want to know about that so I can stop it so I can fix it.

0:40:00So I can do the right thing. So the reason it shouldn't apply in production.

0:40:02If you don't control your own service which a lot of people don't like this sort of deploying to they have some

0:40:07baseline they need to support for their deployments

0:40:10but they don't control every single detail like they don't have their machines basically they're not the one who

0:40:14installed P.H.P.

0:40:14For example they're not the one controlling Apache in the upgrade cycle stuff like that

0:40:18and you don't want to run with all the warnings turned on especially with warnings turn into fatal errors in that

0:40:22situation because someone will do a minor point upgrade to Apache P.H.P.

0:40:26or Some other thing which will suddenly cause warnings where once they were nine

0:40:29and then your production is down because of something you didn't do.

0:40:31But in your case since you control all of the you control the version of everything is not going to get upgraded behind

0:40:36your back.

0:40:37So it is slightly more reasonable to do that I think I would disagree on that I think I think I will I will want that

0:40:42to break because that's a problem that you should know about immediately

0:40:46and if the if the people who are controlling the servers do any kind of testing like if they you know maybe deploy it

0:40:52on film and server or if if you deploy to production you know with stuff like P.H.P.

0:40:58Update at least like you do it on one server first and see what happens if you give it that Fluffy you know

0:41:03and if you like in all those cases I'd rather the app actually crash

0:41:08and burn immediately you know it's like to fail early and completely or often whatever the statement is fail

0:41:14or the warnings are always going to be something like this language feature is going to be deprecated sometime in the

0:41:18next two years so you should stop using it

0:41:20and it's like that should not cause your app to go down in production like that did it you'd be mad that it went down

0:41:26to you be like that's not important enough for production to stop working

0:41:29and you'd be mad because you know they upgraded something and it broke your stuff or whatever

0:41:32but like historically in my working career the reason warnings get turned off from production is privileged to the

0:41:38series and even sometimes

0:41:40when we do control the entire stack merely because a different department in the same company controls like the upgrade

0:41:46cycle and stuff like that

0:41:47and the other department doesn't want that department possibly screen them up by you know changing something that

0:41:53causes a warning that is totally bogus and immaterial and stupid and really does not have any.

0:42:00Do with a functioning application is practically like the developers is like waving at you

0:42:03and saying we made a new message here look at our message Hi How you doing message a message

0:42:08and you're like I don't want my program to stop working because of that.

0:42:11I'll see it finally go to patch up that things that doesn't emit the warning any more like it'll be invisible

0:42:16but turning it into a fatal error in production is usually a bridge too far.

0:42:21I still disagree I see your point I don't think that's a good enough reason.

0:42:26Well it's when you want to throw a one man shopping controls everything yeah that's fine

0:42:29but things get much more complicated as the organizations get bigger

0:42:32and things get farther away from the control of the people writing the code.

0:42:37I completely agree with John and I think that comes from the fact that John and I have real jobs

0:42:43and it's just you by yourself so it's not easy it's not easy to deal with those sorts of issues and even consulting.

0:42:53It's an even finer line because a lot of times you know myself

0:42:57and my team will build something handed off to the client and then walk away.

0:43:02And so in many cases the company for which we've built something may

0:43:09or may not really have the talent in the house to figure out when some esoteric warning happens

0:43:15and what to do about it and we're not necessarily contracted with this client anymore so they're on their own

0:43:22and not to say that we you know silently squash or exceptions or anything like that

0:43:26but for non-fatal things oftentimes it's not in our

0:43:30or our client's best interest to cause a ruckus over those sorts of things.

0:43:35The Sutil chain is better about doing this as a bridge is basically why miners wall doesn't print so many areas because

0:43:42whoever defined wall way back when.

0:43:44Now no one can change it because if you did you like all this compile cleanly

0:43:47and how Doesn't your compiler's broken right that's why there's everything.

0:43:50Because the wall is not you know historical baggage like that whereas in the much looser higher level languages in the

0:43:58fancier tools people.

0:44:00No problem throwing out the next version the next minor version of like Ruby or node or something like that

0:44:05and adding a bunch of warnings because because they're trying to influence the people who are using the language

0:44:10because they're trying to warn about deprecated features because they think they've decided that this could potentially

0:44:14be a problem like you know because their warnings like we don't know this is wrong otherwise you wouldn't have compiled

0:44:20it.

0:44:20But there might be something you might want to look at here

0:44:23and this may be a new warning so you don't have the statement above

0:44:26or that says don't worry about that they like you were saying with the like a lot of other legally put pragma as an

0:44:31lexically scoped warnings restrictions they look I know normally and more warning would be emitted here

0:44:36but I know what I'm doing let the thing go past me to write that right into the code.

0:44:40Well you can only do that for the for the warnings you know about

0:44:43and oh you see compiler is not going to suddenly add a bunch of things to minus wall.

0:44:48Lots of other languages and open source projects that are newer

0:44:51and moving much faster who have no problem adding crap like that

0:44:54and eventually just the fatigue of the organization keeping up with these things is like you know politically speaking

0:44:59they'll be like Can we just not make the warnings into exceptions and production and just look at the logs

0:45:04and we've seen or expects them that will very quickly go through once production is down a few times and bosses

0:45:09and bosses bosses are yelling down development asking why production is down

0:45:13and at that point Marco have a much harder time explaining to his boss

0:45:16or his boss's boss why it actually really is good a good thing that production went down because now we know right away.

0:45:24I think this is a lot like ending a Lisp program with a bunch of clothes in parentheses just you know just in case you

0:45:28make a mistake which was actually the recommended thing for in my eye com site you will want to run every class

0:45:34when we were learning list.

0:45:35The professor actually instructed us to just put a bunch of these in the file to make it easier for her

0:45:41and he might have been joking

0:45:43but from a profit from a practical perspective if your company is a twenty four seven online company

0:45:48and they you they lose let's say five thousand dollars in revenue for every sixty seconds your servers are down.

0:45:54It is much harder to make the argument that Margo is made like it really depends on the situation and some reason.

0:46:00Stupid like institutional reasons where there's you know kingdoms within the company that are fighting each other

0:46:06and the developers are distant from the code

0:46:08and they don't control the deployment like those are sicknesses within the company

0:46:11but then there are legitimate reasons like will say it is a company where the Embry works together

0:46:15but you know you lose X.

0:46:16Amount of dollars for every minute the server is down and going takes

0:46:20and only takes one night of that happening to go

0:46:23and develop a salary that they could have had you know from thousands of dollars

0:46:27and lost the service being down during that time

0:46:29and so yeah like sometimes you just you just practically speaking don't have the luxury of turning all warnings into

0:46:34exceptions I think this is everything you've just said like you know like really critical that it is having production

0:46:41is a really big problem.

0:46:43That's all the more reason why you shouldn't be recklessly playing updates in production to your critical code like

0:46:49your language interpreter like the hip if you're deploying a new version of P.H.P.

0:46:54To your production servers that you've never tested your code on development

0:46:58and you have the kind of situation where you're going to lose tons of money every minute that your site is down the

0:47:04middle of the night because you updated in the middle of night

0:47:05and like any of the weight of your programmer like that's to me that's that's like a pretty there's a number of things

0:47:13wrong with that and it's not it's not your warning level that languages can

0:47:18and unexpected warnings not just because they're going to the version of the anagrams interpreter

0:47:22but simply because they could bethen have coverage and you know it's like the runtime they're basically runtime

0:47:27or things like that that exist as a thing in the hammock language especially for web programming that if you don't

0:47:33execute that code path that warning will never be admitted

0:47:36but if you have a warning to me they become fatal exceptions

0:47:38and in production someone Apple actually hits that code path.

0:47:41No one upgraded anything but your server still you know died because

0:47:46and because that turned into a fatal exception there's there's always between you know with with any kind of non error

0:47:55any kind of warning or notice there's this balance that you're striking between.

0:48:00You know convenience of easiness and tolerance of edge cases versus trying to be correct all the time

0:48:10and it's you know kind of like security it is like it is a balance between convenience and easy and ease

0:48:16and like the right thing

0:48:18and you know if if you're to the point where you're permitting lots of warnings to happen in production unexpectedly I

0:48:26think that's a sign that something is wrong that well you know you're not permitting them you just don't want to be

0:48:31fatal errors you'll address them as soon as you see them because one of the could be data driven for example value

0:48:35comes in and it's undefined and how I was value undefined it OK for it to be undefined

0:48:39but there's some warning that if you use an undefined value as one function it says this is unexpected

0:48:44and you totally thought it should be expect that someone forgot to

0:48:46but please don't give me warning about undefined values I pass them because OK for it to be undefined

0:48:51but you never get that coding testing and it gets like warnings aren't necessarily.

0:48:55I know people like to turn them on development so they can just get things clean because it's that much easier to

0:48:59verify that there's nothing there because once you let any leak through then you just it becomes an avalanche

0:49:03and you start an argument but in production like

0:49:08and Mabel ing these things isn't necessarily saying we are telling you there's something wrong with your code in fact

0:49:12almost all the time it's not telling you there's something wrong with your code

0:49:16and it's just really hard to be at the whim of these messages that don't actually tell you anything useful about your

0:49:22code in production turning him into pillars leave them on a production log them immediately address each one of them so

0:49:29that you get the volume of those warnings down to zero again but turn them into fatal exception.

0:49:34Like I said I think that's too much but you see I think that

0:49:37and people have also suggested like you know you can you should just log them

0:49:41and then you know have a policy to deal with them.

0:49:43I think in reality that's much more likely to just get ignored

0:49:47or well it only happened if you know it only happens once a week for a few hours

0:49:53or we've only ever seen this message five or six times so we'll just ignore it

0:49:57and I think that's the wrong approach for a law.

0:50:00Situation you don't need to if you don't need an hour you'll know exactly what line it came from you can get a stack

0:50:04trace a bit like you like it's usually so easy to address because your media look at the warning look at the line of

0:50:10code and say Is this an acceptable condition out of as an accepted condition

0:50:13and you just put in the pragmatist don't emit that warning from this line anymore. Done and done.

0:50:17If it's not an acceptable condition in Congratulations you've been alerted to potential bugging you need to change your

0:50:21code.

0:50:22Both of those situations one of these are dispensed in two seconds and so there's not a barrier to entry that

0:50:27and the second one is you found a legitimate bug I think developers will want to fix that as well I don't I don't think

0:50:32people will ignore them especially if you're running all development

0:50:35when the fatal error is mode because that will ensure that their volume is zero in development it's just

0:50:39when you get to production that you want to crank it back one notch to basically to make yourself not go down to reason

0:50:45that you would want to be down

0:50:46but again I guess I think the human behavior like the reality of of human nature is such that if you tolerate those

0:50:55warnings and production even if the policy says you shouldn't.

0:50:59In practice that's going to lead to a lot of messy code staying there indefinitely.

0:51:03Whereas if it actually breaks it forces you to fix it.

0:51:09They were innovations are going to one thing it's making policies annoying policies so I actually have more faith in

0:51:16the large corporations ability to make a stupid policy that requires their who are not stupid

0:51:22and to be able to make a policy that people don't like following gives us human nature to not want to deal with those

0:51:26things and to enforce it.

0:51:28I mean it goes the other way like the policy that says you gotta have all warnings on when you

0:51:32when you build your application a lot of individual developers won't like that because they find it tedious to go

0:51:37traced and all there is there is like that

0:51:39and indie developers tend to have to psych each other up to say I know I should be running with everything but I'm not.

0:51:45And like they can have to encourage each other to do that because they know it's good for them

0:51:48but it's human nature not to want to do that.

0:51:50Like flossing an organization you have someone to levels up

0:51:54or does not touch the code can just force everybody do that and make it

0:51:56and make it a policy like I think if Casey has said this many times in the past.

0:52:00It's true of any works of the companies.

0:52:02Whenever anything goes wrong it's almost like a positive event of a rabbit again which eventually leads to a gigantic

0:52:08web of policies that paralyzes the company makes them stupid and dumb

0:52:11but like I said that's the one thing they are good at is this bad thing happened.

0:52:15Make a policy sort of happen again like they wouldn't deposit we must have zero warnings by the Tuesday after the build

0:52:22all warnings must have tasks assigned for them with due dates

0:52:25and like that that is I think something that they were they are good at right now I think.

0:52:30MARCO What would your maybe losing sight of is that as a lot of times going to having a production failure it just

0:52:39isn't an option even for seconds and and John was alluding to the surlier

0:52:43but you were you're coming from the position as you should of someone who is not only V.P.

0:52:50On coder but is also the boss and so if if overcast is out in the wild and it goes down who do you have to answer to.

0:52:58Everyone will know why now. Yeah exactly.

0:53:02Default time zone said well you know you're modifying other collection monitoring over these know that you shouldn't

0:53:09use my framework if you have the situation right

0:53:13but you don't I mean like you have to answer yes you have to answer your customers and that is kind of crummy

0:53:16but your customers can't fire you.

0:53:18They could walk away and OK we can go and we can go down that rabbit hole if you really want to

0:53:22but in a direct sense they can't fire you they can't not give you a bonus that year they can't impure Rickly hurt you

0:53:33and it's very different for I think I speak for John and saying it's very different for he

0:53:36and I because if we make some sort of decision that we think that dying in production is better somebody many many many

0:53:46rungs up the ladder from us may not agree with that and I guarantee you the bigger the company the more.

0:53:54Well in my experience the bigger the company the the happier they are to find a head to chop off and what role.

0:54:00Well the big thing is you will not be able to convince them even if you're one hundred percent right because there are

0:54:04many situations where you really are right and this was like

0:54:07nor where they were talk about warnings like this was a legitimate reason it is actually better that this happened that

0:54:12it not happen.

0:54:12Good luck convincing somebody three levels up in the org chart of that even if you were just so right

0:54:17and everybody who has a sibling to you in your time below you agree that they all signed a petition they all got on the

0:54:22parking lot and they were right. The C.E.O. or The C.T.O.

0:54:26and Certainly you will not convince them

0:54:29and that's the harsh world that we live in you know let me let me challenge our listeners here.

0:54:33I honestly curious I would like to know if you work at a company that has a big important online infrastructure.

0:54:45And isn't google stuff like that you know big important companies that where you do things well online

0:54:52and it's really important that they stay up.

0:54:54I'm curious what is your policy what is your company's policy

0:54:57and you can write us on the feedback form honestly you can use the early Twitter accounts.

0:55:02We don't need this to be like you know on the record I'm just curious to know what what do the big companies do in

0:55:08reality where this stuff really does matter and where they are technically.

0:55:13Generally you know well run companies I think at that scale it's kind of different I think Google and Amazon half

0:55:20and Netflix although it has a design for expected failure so they have to have basically instead of an organism that is

0:55:26like clean running they have to make one where X.

0:55:28Cell death is expected and they just have little busy robots going through cleaning up the dead cells

0:55:32and stuff so that isn't that a little bit different

0:55:35and I'm thinking of like of the medium term ones where you're not that big every human in the world is not hitting your

0:55:40server but it has to be up.

0:55:42It just absolutely asked me like stock trading or banking things whereas only a few computers in this network

0:55:47and they're directly connected by crazy optic wires

0:55:50and into I forget the trading are they doing something about doing bank transfers but these three

0:55:55or four computers have to always be up otherwise people whose millions of dollars you know.

0:56:00But he can like that's more reason why you should be really careful what code runs on them

0:56:04and why you probably shouldn't ignore a warning.

0:56:07Well you're not you're not ignoring what is going around circles it's like the question of do you want something that

0:56:11shouldn't that doesn't necessarily have to be fatal to be fatal

0:56:13or to cause a piece of work to be put into someone's been to fix that with a deadline because that's the policy

0:56:18and so on and so forth.

0:56:19But anyway if people defend a feedback on what are they the policies I think you'll be horrified to find that people

0:56:24don't enable warnings period even in development.

0:56:27Military innovation

0:56:28or even they're not even enabled like if we just took a mass survey what we'd find out be like warnings now we turn

0:56:34those authors unless you're absolutely right you have the right the other thing I should point out is that you saying

0:56:40Marco that you only care.

0:56:41Well I shouldn't say that the way you phrased the question was if your livelihood your company's livelihood is based on

0:56:48some sort of online service or website or whatever.

0:56:51But what you're losing sight of is a lot of times my clients at the job in which I work.

0:56:58We often times but not always do like a corporate Internet you know same sort of thing that igloo does

0:57:03and a lot of times we're told this cannot go down when in reality nothing will go broke in.

0:57:12If the internet is down you don't I mean so a lot of times from on high they say this Internet will be up always

0:57:19but really it doesn't matter.

0:57:21And so we have to make decisions because as consultants based on the requirement from the client even if we think it's

0:57:28ball and I think that John was alluding to that earlier and so a lot of times even if you could say

0:57:34when it doesn't matter if this goes down.

0:57:36So a lot of times clients will say well it's better for going to be up or work come in and call on you guys

0:57:41and we're going to be asked and I hope you know you want to tell me about some cool yeah.

0:57:46And before that so that I think that you're right that for your situation where you know if if it's consulting a

0:57:56consulting gig where you have to build some system for somebody and then.

0:58:00Effectively it's going to have a zero maintenance for a while whether that's weeks or years

0:58:04or decades like then I think that's

0:58:07and that's a different environment where you expect the software to just tolerate existing

0:58:12and whatever upgrades happen on its server which probably won't even be a whole lot honestly.

0:58:16But in reality let's be realistic here.

0:58:19But you know this thing has to operate with no programmer intervention indefinitely. Right.

0:58:24Then it's a different story. Right.

0:58:26Then I completely agree that you know you're already doing something that's by software development standards pretty

0:58:32bad. If you're going to have and maintain software in production use for a long time right.

0:58:39But in reality that happens all time

0:58:41and so you're right that like you know in practice in a lot of places you have to accommodate for that

0:58:45but that's typically not the kind of place as you said it's not the kind of place where it's super important that there

0:58:52wouldn't be no technical errors. You know all the time.

0:58:55So anyway we are sponsored and sorry we are sponsored as we also once again by our friends that help spot.

0:59:04Are you still using email clients for customer support Casey. I do customer support. I mean yes yes I am.

0:59:12You're probably losing track of important take its I bet I am trying to use mark as unread as an organizational tool

0:59:18and I am in co-workers to see who's working on what. That's ridiculous. It's time to get organized.

0:59:24Most helpdesk software tries to be all things to all people. Infinite feature creep.

0:59:28These huge complex messes help spot is focused. It deals only with customer inquiries and self serve knowledge bases.

0:59:37There's no built in asset management or password resetting or other unnecessary features to get in your way

0:59:42or require complex integration work with your application or your infrastructure.

0:59:46How the software is also usually really expensive.

0:59:49A lot of them are like around six hundred dollars per user per year which is really high helps

0:59:54but is just to ninety nine per user. Once you own it for life it's not.

1:00:00If it is to a twenty nine per user one time you own it for life and there's no lock in.

1:00:05You can download the software and host it yourself or you can have it hosted for you either way.

1:00:10Even if they host it for you you always have access to the database that you can directly Querrey export

1:00:16and take elsewhere Helspont is not some new startup they've been available for nearly a decade and is that

1:00:22and they've been adopted by thousands of companies organizations customers from single person startups to Fortune five

1:00:27hundred companies all use helps to manage their support teams so you can start a free trial today go to help spot dot

1:00:34com a slash A.T.P. and Then when you went to buy it if you use coupon code A.T.P.

1:00:39Fourteen for the year of fourteen code A.T.P.

1:00:42Fourteen will save you a hundred dollars off your already very well priced purchase.

1:00:47So thanks a lot to help for sponsoring our show once again. Member go to help spot dot com slash A.T.P.

1:00:53and Use coupon code A.T.P. Fourteen for one hundred bucks off.

1:00:57So here's the thing that we're kind of dancing around and I think it might be time to pull the band aid off.

1:01:03No I want to do this thing that was I thought as you were talking about the perfect example you're just talking about I

1:01:10know what he was he was this our mentality is here with us we kind of touched on it a little bit less time for script

1:01:16notes you know to save it to Africa.

1:01:18The second sponsor John was happening I had to break into it happen and I listened.

1:01:26Nope I guess for nothing but I also know I have a follow up today.

1:01:30Just just to make sure I had it done for this episode gentleman the last this is the way it's going to have to be.

1:01:36Daddy Casey has spoken.

1:01:37Where I don't want to this week by squirty going to I don't even see all one platform makes a fashion easy to create

1:01:44your own professional web site or on one chord going out for a free trial

1:01:48and then for that after a square space dot com and use offer code.

1:01:51K C Yeah hey Squarespace is always improving their platform with new features new designs

1:01:57and even better support their view.

1:02:00If you're to start with and all the style options you need to create a unique website for you or your business.

1:02:06They have to over twenty highly customizable templates for you to choose from.

1:02:10They've won numerous design awards from prestigious institutions and it's incredibly easy to use

1:02:15and customize if you want some help.

1:02:17So if it has an amazing support team that works twenty four hours a day seven days a week with over seventy employees

1:02:23right here in New York City all of this starts at just eight dollars a month

1:02:28and includes are free to make any kind of for a year

1:02:30and you can her free trial today with no credit card required it's a real free trial.

1:02:35No credit card and when you do start to sign up

1:02:39and use offer code Kacey for ten percent off to show your support for our show as well.

1:02:44And one more cool thing to Merkel is actually you know what I'm going all out for three more cool things.

1:02:51Square is based introduces a new thing called square space logo.

1:02:54In addition to building your website you can build your own logo for your site business cards or whatever you want.

1:03:01Also all square space plans now include the commerce functionality you can have a store where you sell physical

1:03:06or digital goods. Also it's a great integration there it's so easy to set up.

1:03:11You can finally have your own online store with very very little effort it's really amazing

1:03:15and every square face plant now includes the commerce functionality at no additional charge.

1:03:20And finally Squarespace is hiring.

1:03:24If you enjoy it if you interview for an engineering or design position before March fifteenth they will invite you

1:03:30and your partner to be New Yorkers for a weekend.

1:03:33It will fly you out to New York put you up in one of the city's best hotels

1:03:36and give you a long weekend of checking out some of their favorite tractions cultural icons

1:03:41and restaurants in the city square space will take up the entire tab for this awesome trip to New York.

1:03:46They've been voted one of New York City's greatest places to work for two years running so really put them on your

1:03:50short list. They're looking to hire thirty engineers and designers by March fifteenth.

1:03:55So going to be a part of it that squarespace dot com That's be a part of it. That's great.

1:04:00Based on com to learn more about the school offer thanks a lot to Squarespace for sponsoring our show once again.

1:04:05So but this Christmas episode Don't even start with me.

1:04:08Are you really going to be that if you really want me to abandon software my set all Jews even though it perfectly fits

1:04:14the thread of this episode. Then we can move on. John what do you think about this. He changed so much.

1:04:23CAVE You know yourself you know I thought I would say though that over the time I think it deserves to be kind of like

1:04:30in the prime spot with more time. I leave it up that I am abstaining from this vote.

1:04:34So it's Casey versus Marco decide we're going to talk about X.

1:04:39I'm prepared for both I kind of feel like that already has a big enough topic that we would want to jam into the into

1:04:45the show. But I'll go either way.

1:04:47I actually am going to agree with John's non-vote it was actually IS OF A

1:04:51but I'm I'm going to agree with John's non-vote and say that I am not trying to avoid it.

1:04:56I do think it deserves more time.

1:04:59You know you're probably right

1:05:00and God help you trying to edit this episode because now I've turned it into a complete cluster.

1:05:06But oh this is all in just one horney to that's it.

1:05:09It's all and I'm excited about that this is this is what Bill Clinton for Casey this is this the show right.

1:05:16So we should probably catch people up on script notes

1:05:19and curse this topic internally even though it actually is very interesting.

1:05:23So a lot of people came

1:05:26and told us oh you should really was in the script episode in script notes is a pod cast by two screenwriters

1:05:32and I can even tell you who they are off to my head. John August and some other guy.

1:05:36I think that's what I do too but I was yeah.

1:05:40And I only know John all this is because he was another part guess that I listen to

1:05:44and once I have I've seen his movies and I like them and I'm like oh he's the guy who did that.

1:05:49But yeah I don't know that guy sorry. But now that other guy knows exactly how I feel anyway.

1:05:56So there's this podcast about screenwriting and.

1:06:00Apparently the defacto industry standard for screenwriting is called What what is called the final draft.

1:06:08Thank you I have wanted to say Final Cut final draft and so it's a screenwriting application

1:06:12and it is like I said the industry standards.

1:06:14So from what I gather the screenwriters John August and Casey will call him.

1:06:21They don't particularly care for Final Draft and his name is Craig Mazen.

1:06:25Thank you so John and Craig don't really care for final draft

1:06:29and they actually I guess I complained about it in prior episodes

1:06:32but this past episode at the time we recorded this they had actually had the C.E.O.

1:06:38Of the company that makes final draft as well as what a proud duct managers I write product

1:06:44or project I don't know the difference I live in my own little world here with some other guy would just call that

1:06:49person long suffering employee right. So so that other guy.

1:06:57So the two of them came on the show which I really respect because it was clear from the get go that this wasn't going

1:07:03to go well for them.

1:07:05And so John and Craig had these two other guys on the show

1:07:09and started telling them all the things that they don't really like about Final Draft

1:07:14and why they feel like they've been wronged by not only the high purchase price of what two hundred fifty boxes are

1:07:22right.

1:07:23Some like that some with two hundred fifty bucks or so for final draft but also the slow updates

1:07:28and it was a really fascinating view of both sides of the coin of software development both as the company

1:07:39and the people who create software and the people who consume it

1:07:43and how they don't entirely understand what we go through in the same way that the C.E.O.

1:07:50and That other to the long suffering employee don't really understand what their customers go through either

1:07:55and I have some takeaways from this but let me let me open the floor to you. You guys and see us.

1:08:01MARCO What did you think about all this. Well first I think. So I I listen to the podcast.

1:08:09I made my own opinions of it and I've made a whole post about it

1:08:14and all that was before I had read this follow up article from there's a guy named Kent Testament who writes a

1:08:23competing product called I believe called Satan here we go.

1:08:29And and he he's been a long time critic I gather of Final Draft

1:08:34and that's one of the reasons why he started writing his own because he hated soundtracks so much so he started writing

1:08:39his own.

1:08:40And and he's clearly you know a programmer tech guy but also a film guy and

1:08:47and he he put down here I'll put Lincoln a general view.

1:08:50He broke down exactly some of the problems with with final draft technically like for instance that it still doesn't

1:08:58support unit code.

1:09:00Like really like a major major shortcomings

1:09:04and that one of the reasons why why they had so much trouble going Retton was not necessarily because it was using

1:09:11carbon if you can do right now with carbon it's because they were using a quick draw which was deprecated what twenty

1:09:19years ago ten years ago a long time ago at any rate they thought of quite some technical debt.

1:09:27And so there's there's some problems there.

1:09:30Basically seems like they wrote this application you know in the eighty's and ninety's and have not

1:09:37and have been kind of sitting on it and not doing the really hard migrations and not modernizing all this time

1:09:44and then all of a sudden they were forced to by the customers with things like retina

1:09:48and they were forced to sell it as quickly and it became a really big thing.

1:09:52And so it's a pretty typical story of pretty severe technical dead being. No word for way too long.

1:10:02I think what I got out of what out of the C.E.O.'s comments attitude was that you know he wants to make all of his

1:10:10problems your problems

1:10:12and this is something you know the reason why I think it's important for developers to hear this is because you can you

1:10:18can see both sides of it you can see the C.E.O.

1:10:22Arguing the business side and the difficulties of the business side

1:10:27and then you can see the customers arguing that well you know your business stuff is your problem

1:10:32and it's not serving us at all and you're kind of treating us badly in your product needs a lot of work

1:10:37and it's really stagnant and I think it is.

1:10:39So you can see both sides of it and you can kind of see like as as a as a programmer or as a as a.

1:10:45So she has you know a company owner if you own your own company

1:10:47or make your own products you can see how you could become that C.E.O.

1:10:52and It should scare the crap out of you because that's a plausible outcome for somebody software developers.

1:10:58I think developers should listen to this because it's people with technical knowledge of both sides of the software

1:11:04industry or people who like was in the spot Gaz or just mac nerds

1:11:08or into the into development thing will have the unique experience of listening to a podcast with two camps of angry

1:11:14people both of whom are just massively wrong at the fundamental level about the major points of their arguments like

1:11:20the customers are wrong about like your products should be free

1:11:23and how hard is it to do this is like you know from the outside they think everything is easy

1:11:27and I think everything should be free

1:11:29and Apple gives away the Oh as for free why can't you give away final referee like that just so I don't feel like you

1:11:34know where they're coming from but it's like man they have no idea whether I was a software and as Mark I'm going out.

1:11:40The C.E.O.

1:11:41Is being defensive in ways that are not appropriate for his job as it's all like it's his job to figure out a way to

1:11:48keep your software up to date. So you know don't.

1:11:51Those are all your problems you have to figure out a way that's that's called being a software entrepreneur.

1:11:55Like you have to print stuff out you can't throw it back in customers faces and say you don't realize.

1:12:00It is really hard to do this and it's clear that the C.E.O.

1:12:02Doesn't have a lot of technical knowledge so he doesn't even know the detail things like I thought I want to jump into

1:12:07the podcast and explain to each one of them why they want why they're both wrong new customers.

1:12:12But things can't be free in your crazy let me explain why you're reading the wrong

1:12:15and you see you know you don't even know why this is hard but it is really hard if you had a clue how hard it was.

1:12:20You want to start on these transition years and years ago and yes they might have discerned your company

1:12:24but like look how many other companies have been left in the wake of like not being able to keep up with the changes

1:12:28and I was ten and I was like that's your job but you want to you want to be a big boy in the software world.

1:12:33It's not easy like the I think there was something which started in classic macro us

1:12:38and it had to go through some of these attacks that had to go through all these things.

1:12:41They had quick draw they had to get rid of that they were carbon they had to find a way to you know go on modern Then

1:12:47they had to adopt unit code they had they went through like you know these are like at sui and like or taxed

1:12:53and whatever the hell they've gone through multiple different underlying text engines you have to do that otherwise

1:12:58you're dead and you know some other nimble competitor who doesn't have your legacy concerns makes a new application

1:13:03and the only reason you think the sessile is because you're an entrenched interests

1:13:06or whatever like we've all seen this play out a million times so those two guys those two camps of people were just

1:13:13both angry both talking past each other

1:13:15and is both fundamentally wrong about about their complaints about the other person

1:13:20and you know you can't have an app that has a code base that you can't write an app in one nine hundred ninety

1:13:28and still be around in twenty fourteen

1:13:31and not have to have gone through a few really painful transitions in that time unless you coast on like well we're

1:13:37just so entrenched where the big really we can afford to like even if you do that your time you have a longer time

1:13:41or but still a timer because like Eventually you're after the launch anymore

1:13:44and you're like Well now I guess is the time we have to move quicker it's like nope sorry too late now you dead.

1:13:49Like I don't think final draft is in that situation yet because they are such an entrenched interest.

1:13:53How look at Adobe Look how long it took them we mentioned the look last show look how long it took them to go.

1:13:57Coco The only reason they can get away with that is because there are.

1:14:00Photoshop you know we are Photo Shop we are the image editor we ate up all the other ones you know we bought Macromedia

1:14:05were like and even then like Eventually the O.

1:14:08Us is like no seriously you got to be sixty four but you got to be Cocoa right.

1:14:12Like even then they're forced upgrade but yeah the final cut didn't understand.

1:14:18Doesn't seem to understand what his what his company does or should be doing.

1:14:23Like what how does what is your company do.

1:14:25We sell and maintain a software application like that's a dynamic business you can't just keep making the same thing

1:14:32and like expect.

1:14:35I don't know expect everyone else to do your job for you

1:14:37and to make it so that your have to your company doesn't have to do the hard things and I don't know.

1:14:43Yeah and there were some quotes in this.

1:14:45Only a handful that I'd like to quickly go over that that just really stuck out to me.

1:14:52So one of them in actually John your T. Quoted it was.

1:14:56Well this is John and Craig will will give us an entire operating system away for free.

1:15:03No that wasn't them that was the C.E.O. Citing that as I was a problem that they had.

1:15:07Yeah now I think it was think it was the C.E.O.

1:15:10Pointed out to them that they make money from selling the phones

1:15:12but I think it was the the complaining customers who are saying it wasn't us it was something about like look how cheap

1:15:19software is like software has been devalued therefore your thing should be one dollar it's like selling it telling

1:15:25Adobe that for a shop should be free or like ten cents because Angry Birds are things

1:15:29and well to be fair they were not complaining that final draft is not free.

1:15:36From what I gather they were complaining twofold both that it is not a high end of quality product to be worth the high

1:15:42price anymore

1:15:44and that the upgrades are not worth the upgrade price because of how little progress is made relatively speaking in

1:15:51each upgrade that would that seem like they're bigger complaint not that the app should be free or very very cheap.

1:15:56It seems like they be very happy to pay two hundred fifty dollars for the. If it was a better app.

1:16:01Well but even then they want to pay two hundred fifty dollars ten years ago and never pay again and just

1:16:06and continually have the app updated

1:16:08and I didn't get that impression I don't I definitely got that impression that that's like yeah I did not that they

1:16:12would that I think that I had the impression that they would have hated to spend two hundred fifty dollars way back

1:16:17when and then I just want that app to work forever and continue to be updated with the O. S.

1:16:21and To get written

1:16:22and to get Unicode support never They all for free like they seem to have an entitlement complex that was not not

1:16:29proportional to the value of the value that they're deriving from the software

1:16:33and it was kind of like compounded by the fact that this is crappy software that hasn't been updated so they feel

1:16:37burned by any amount of money to put towards it.

1:16:40I guess mostly because they have it revenge like they feel like they have to have this program because like everybody

1:16:45uses it I think that's that's the core of their dissatisfaction is like it's like an abusive relationship with like

1:16:51well you have to get final draft everybody used graph and then you're already better at this thing

1:16:56and if it's not the most amazing program that does everything perfectly and then you just can be pissed

1:17:01when anything is wrong with it

1:17:02and they seem to be a lot wrong with this program I think Marco's is right though that I don't think they were

1:17:08embittered necessarily about paying for it it just seems that they they thought that it was an order of magnitude too

1:17:14expensive and I'm making numbers up I'm putting words in their mouth

1:17:17but instead a two hundred fifty dollars it should be one hundred dollars up front for the first release.

1:17:21And like twenty bucks for every supplementary release

1:17:24and additionally I think they were extremely embittered that these upgrades

1:17:29or updates whatever they call them were a heck of a lot of money

1:17:32and even I would probably agree to this a heck of a lot of money from really not that much.

1:17:36Update right now it was cited several times I think it was one hundred dollars for the retina upgrade update whatever

1:17:43was like eighty bucks or something and like maybe I'm crazy

1:17:45but who is that there's an application that I use for my livelihood I would pay eighty dollars for an upgrade like I do

1:17:51I wouldn't blink at that because like I say you use Photoshop to do your work you're a graphic artist

1:17:57and authority that comes out and the only upgrade. Is that the U.I.

1:18:00Is rotten and like all bug fixes

1:18:02and at eighty dollars the upgrade I mean I would pay it would wouldn't any of you pay it.

1:18:07Yeah I mean I suppose I was like maybe we have different I guess we probably value software differently because we kind

1:18:13of know what goes into it but like

1:18:15but it's not like it's like fifty grand I mean it's not you know it's not a site license the CAD program like they just

1:18:24don't know.

1:18:24Like that's why I think they just they're getting used to the world where everything is like cheap or free and

1:18:29but it's like. But this is part of your livelihood.

1:18:31You make money

1:18:32and I think it all gets back to it's because they don't like this till they feel like they're forced to use it if they

1:18:36had their choice they would use something different and better and it's like if you're going to force me to buy it

1:18:41and then and now suddenly I'm not happy about like say you hated Photoshop

1:18:45and you needed it for your work like this like say you hate Microsoft Word you have to get it because you deal with

1:18:49people

1:18:49or they insist that you send him everything in doc format right then you'd be pissed that the only you going to do like

1:18:56an eighth grade office in the only change was that it was red and incompatible with Mavericks then you'd be best

1:19:02but it's mostly mostly just because you hate words so much that any money you put towards continuing this charade of

1:19:07having to use this program to have other people like that's where I feel like they're coming from you I think it's that

1:19:13but it's also that what was once a decent product has stagnated the impression I got and I've never used final draft

1:19:20but the impression I got was that it was at one point a good thing like what they were saying about how based on the

1:19:27length of the P.D.F.

1:19:29or The printed document you could take a guess at about how long the script was that was very quote apparently

1:19:34something that the C.E.O. Seem to think that that was unique to them. Twenty ways.

1:19:39The product started pretty solid and pretty good but kind of never really went anywhere and

1:19:45and these these two guys John

1:19:47and Craig were for example really I'm bitter that it took so long to get retina support in there

1:19:53and then on top of that they got charged for and so they were saying the C.E.O.

1:19:55You knew this was coming you knew this was coming how did you not figure this out how did you not do it.

1:20:00At first I was like well you know it's hard I still have my fast text update for I was seventeen I'm a slacker

1:20:07and I have better things to do with my time but you know I can understand that well then the C.E.O.

1:20:11Says there's another my quotes.

1:20:13You know we're forty people and I think to myself OK so how did you not get retina done with forty people

1:20:21but then later on he says well but ten fifteen percent of us are programmers.

1:20:25What the hell is everyone else in sales and marketing in the best part was

1:20:29when he said well you know how we learned about Iran.

1:20:32Someone brought him brought a computer into the office

1:20:35and showed it to us if that's how you learn to read then shows you're not engaged with the platform on which you deploy

1:20:40your software or even trivial. You don't even subscribe to MacWorld like you do nothing.

1:20:45You know forget about going to see which of course you should do if your if your job is that you write software product

1:20:50for the mag for crying out loud. Right. Yeah this is kind of pressing like the C.E.O.

1:20:57Like he did it himself and his company disservice by coming on this program

1:21:01and saying oh it seems because every word out of his mouth was like Mark I said it's like the answer to every single

1:21:06one of his comebacks was like that's your problem. That's not my problem.

1:21:10But you know I mean it may be the natural way of things is that you've now painted yourself into a tactical corner

1:21:15and you must go out of business

1:21:16and it will be a blessing for the industry because we can all give our money to the other hungry

1:21:20or developers who if they're on like people go through exact same cycles you get big become popular not update their

1:21:25software for a decade to crumble under their own weight and the cycle will continue.

1:21:30But like that's not your customer's problems in any way shape or form

1:21:33and so like it's I don't I guess he doesn't have people telling him don't go on to a program

1:21:38and tell even what your customers are actually wrong about like everything should be free

1:21:42and you know it's not like you can click onto a program and and tell them about all your woes and

1:21:47and they're going to all

1:21:49and now it's like I guess maybe he was hoping for empathy like that they would put themselves into his shoe as the

1:21:55non-technical C.E.O. Of a company that made terrible strategic decisions for the past.

1:22:00Did and go all in

1:22:01and I feel bad for you it's all right if I hear software I mean one of the one thing I noticed case you have this in

1:22:07the notes and bring it up now.

1:22:10One of the one of the more interesting parts of of this dynamic I thought was that the C.E.O.

1:22:17Opened the conversation basically by saying that they've done surveys

1:22:22and I believe it was ninety two percent of the of the people said that they are very happy with Final Draft

1:22:28and therefore they think they're doing great.

1:22:30And like that's flawed in so many levels and they and and John

1:22:35and Craig briefly mention like well you know that's like that only people who responded to the survey which is

1:22:43obviously going to be mostly people who like you

1:22:46or you know like it's that's so not a random sample of what people think of your product.

1:22:52And the C.E.O.'s entire attitude seem to just be that well we keep hearing from people who like it

1:22:59and therefore everything's fine

1:23:02and we don't have to like his attitude from the very beginning was we're fine because some people like us

1:23:07and therefore we don't need to make any changes at all and it's so easy for people to fall into that trap.

1:23:13You know if you select what you're listening to and I've been I've never seen this app

1:23:20and even I know everyone hates it.

1:23:22Like I know I've heard about this app for four years now about how much people hate this random you know Edge

1:23:28conversations here and there and not even being in the business I know people hate it.

1:23:34Obviously that's a pretty widespread problem

1:23:37and it's so easy it's so easy to surround yourself only by the the inputs that you want to believe.

1:23:44I'm sure there's a term for that like there's it's so easy to fall into that that this guy honestly I think he honestly

1:23:50thinks that everything's fine and he's in complete denial of any major problems

1:23:55and therefore that's I think why he was so we're.

1:24:00We defensive

1:24:00and aggressive in his response I don't know if I really believe that he was sincere that he really believed that

1:24:06but like it's possible the Nile is pretty strong but I think the reason you heard about it

1:24:10and I have as well even though we're not screenwriters is because we travel in software development circles

1:24:14and anybody who knows anything about software can look at that location

1:24:16and you can you can smell like death on it you know even if even if you don't know if you think you're like oh jeez

1:24:23this program has not been updated for a while you see old I began I don't know years works

1:24:27but I bet we could pick up like it's using older controls that should be using newer ones like maybe for a long time

1:24:32the text wasn't properly and the alias

1:24:34or looks like was rendered different exists Quickdraw unlike you know we could tell that that there are problems with

1:24:39it

1:24:40and the reason I think he may be right if you took a random sampling of their customer base is because their customer base

1:24:46are not technical people and they view this as kind of like especially since it's such an institution.

1:24:51They view it as if you want to become a screenwriter. This is what you get and this is the tool you deal with.

1:24:57And everyone complains about it

1:24:58but like you know you might as well complain about the weather because to do your job you have to use Final Draft in

1:25:03the same way that you might say you have to use Photoshop if you're a graphic designer

1:25:07and you just you know there's no no other choice out there

1:25:10but they're non-technical people so they're not equipped to to understand what's wrong with this program and why.

1:25:15And they're more willing to accept it like whatever's wrong just the way it is what can you do so in that respect they

1:25:23may have good server responses

1:25:25but the thing that makes me think of in the worst case scenario is I will bet you in two thousand

1:25:29and seven two thousand and two does nine maybe even two thousand and ten.

1:25:32If you were to survey all Black Berry users they'd say they love their Blackberry.

1:25:35Doesn't matter black rim is still doing right

1:25:38and you can thank all the people have Blackberries love it it's like yes but the time has passed that by

1:25:43and customers may have it and may love it and may be Stockholm Syndrome or the maybe not know better

1:25:48but like from the outside we all can see Bob Iger.

1:25:54Yeah I think I found interesting about this and it's the only other quote that I that I want.

1:26:00Bring up is apparently there was a feature called they called a collaborator which I guess was some sort of

1:26:06collaborative writing thing where you can work on a screenplay two people can work on screenplay at the same time

1:26:12something like that. Yeah that's a very that's a very good analogy.

1:26:17And so they said and this should be pretty much for beta collaborator was built

1:26:22when it was on a peer to peer technology with no security. It would still work like that.

1:26:27Today what they were saying was

1:26:29when they built this feature that was designed to be used between two people probably not colocated they did it without

1:26:38even thinking about firewalls and I mostly wrote it in ninety six. Are you kidding. Like how is that OK.

1:26:47And that just completely sealed the deal in my mind that screenwriters don't have firewalls care if you think they have

1:26:52mighty departments there.

1:26:53There are lonely people in their apartments with internet connection slaving away in the next great script

1:26:59and every router since nineteen since two thousand and one hasn't included a firewall in it

1:27:04but he wouldn't know about this stuff anyway. He was talking about it but.

1:27:07But yeah

1:27:09and that's the thing is even if that is such an obvious technical hurdle that you would have to get over to do that

1:27:16kind of feature and they shipped it at least for a little while

1:27:20and I guess they've pulled it since they shipped it without even thinking about that like how is that possible.

1:27:26It just reminds me that there are terrible software developers out there

1:27:30or if these developers are good just on believably indescribably out of touch management or both.

1:27:36If I was on a podcast I would have also brought the MET a point which is that the screenwriting format is ridiculous

1:27:43than anachronistic and really deserves to be destroyed and torn down

1:27:48and it is held aloft by the collective you know by tradition basically this is the way it's always done this is what a

1:27:54screenplay looks like. Let me tell you about all the great qualities of it.

1:27:57Oh you can always tell exactly how long the thing will be in minutes by looking.

1:28:00Number of pages always or number of pages every day. Everyone knows it.

1:28:03Like it can continue to be held aloft by that like sort of oral tradition and indoctrination of new people

1:28:09and it is true that this is what a screenplay looks like. But the format is dumb it is not like it's my space font.

1:28:15It's formatted crazily lots of things are in all caps and everyone who enters the industry and I really get used to it.

1:28:21Come to like it and will not accept any other format

1:28:24but bottom line objectively wipe out all the people who've ever seen a screenplay.

1:28:28Show them this for a show the new people. This format they'll be like is like it is it is not of this time.

1:28:33It is of a different time of a time of typewriters and one is based on an all caps and not you know it's dumb.

1:28:40So what are the best.

1:28:42The ideal thing to happen for the entire industry would be to not only for a final draft to be disrupted

1:28:46but for the entire screenplay format to be replaced by something better.

1:28:50I have dim hopes of that ever happening because of that.

1:28:52Any group of people who is not not raring for you know amazing disruption innovation is screenwriters

1:28:59and entertainment is true they just want their format they want to be the way it is.

1:29:01They just want slightly better tools to work on and they will consider that a big victory

1:29:05but from the outside it's clear that the screenplay format is stupid.

1:29:09Well and to be fair in the fall of episode of their pod cast John and Craig did address that a little bit

1:29:15and talking about things like how the one paid for minute thing is this kind of elementary assumption that you know

1:29:21it's like three paragraph essay you're taught in middle school it's you know it's like it's a very basic thing that you

1:29:26know in practice once you get once you're a real professional It doesn't really it's not that simple

1:29:32or it's not necessary to rely on things you know assumptions like that are these tenets like that

1:29:37and there's also this thing called Fountain which from what I gather is like a markdown like

1:29:42or markdown based plain text format that doesn't weigh with manual pagination or stuff like that

1:29:48and it doesn't what they are actually moving forward

1:29:50and the problem really seems to be that that final draft is not his final draft has this this position.

1:30:00Our right now where you know

1:30:03or at least they have to date where they were the standard of they have their own file format

1:30:08and there they are like you know they're relying on these invariants that OK well pagination matters above all else

1:30:16and all of the stuff and the reality is the industries being disrupted.

1:30:22Just like so many other technical industries where now there's a whole lot of other apps coming out some of them cheap

1:30:29and terrible but some of them good that are doing things more in a more modern way

1:30:35and that's the problem like you know just like so many other industries.

1:30:41I don't think it's going to be I don't think final draft is going to be disrupted

1:30:45and replaced by one thing I think is going to end up being diverted and replaced by a few standards

1:30:51and then a few different apps they read the reader write the standards

1:30:54and it seems like this fountain format is probably going to be that standard

1:30:58but again I think by now all three of us are talking us and we all know nothing about

1:31:04and we're going to get all the e-mail people explaining the various features of the screenplay format that were created

1:31:09intentionally for a specific reason and like

1:31:10and I'm sure like the formatting in the layout Everything has had a purpose originally

1:31:14but some aspects of it are really just artifacts of the technology that was available at the time specifically you know

1:31:20the all caps amount of a spot.

1:31:22The layout being done basically by serious spaces of the model space finally all those things are done because that's

1:31:27what you had that's how you know you were going to typeset it like a book because that's not efficient for the

1:31:32production process you need people to be able to type these things up.

1:31:34It's kind of the same way that you see like the the opening parentheses used to make ASCII art to make the little boxes

1:31:40on the front of legal documents Mark along with this

1:31:43but I don't like the fact that so it doesn't really matter as much in legal arguments like whatever lawyers everything

1:31:48they do is all made up and crazy with their legal language.

1:31:50But screenplays could benefit from a farmer that took advantage from of modern technology keep all the good stuff about

1:31:56the old format in terms of visually blocking out things with whitespace.

1:32:00So making it easy for actors to read

1:32:01and you know all I don't I'm just making up what the features may be of the four

1:32:04and there are probably good things about the former

1:32:06but the bad things are just being carried along like those parentheses on legal documents

1:32:11and they just they just ridiculous at this point. OK thanks lead to our three sponsors this week.

1:32:18Picture life help spot and square space. And we will see you next week.

1:32:25Now this it was accidental accidental because it was there until today. Except that the Michael Casey.

1:33:27So I cannot believe I let you railroad me. Well that's good notes and timely.

1:33:32But now I am saying you

1:33:34and Margo could have we're going to months you know Casey had insisted I would have gone along with it.

1:33:38He didn't really and stain I did I'd say I gave my thing about abstaining from the vote.

1:33:44I was what I was trying to convince Casey was that not getting it done today does not mean it will never get done

1:33:50and in fact it may be done better in the future but he still kind of insisted and I would not have opposed him.

1:33:54What would you do next week will say right now next week we saw from mental methodologies and nothing will happen.

1:34:00Old statement when I went out of I've Been Turned out we won't talk about it all.

1:34:05God Now you've changed it and will never talk about it ever.

1:34:08This pod cast will

1:34:09and if it results in Apple buying Nintendo you're your sacrifice will have been noble you are you saying that we will

1:34:19do it next week. Whether or not you're serious has pretty much absolutely prevented that from happening ever.

1:34:26That's that's the equivalent of saying well this will be short show. If Apple doesn't send.

1:34:34And there's no John Syracuse a podcast to talk about it didn't really happen on this my third part cast in like three

1:34:42days comparable to command space now we're doing this as a how to just take a rest.

1:34:48The it really for the unknown handsomest. I hate you too.

1:34:54I know that we didn't even talk about driving with glass there was not another remark

1:34:58or topic yeah I mean why it is that much more to say on it.

1:35:01I just want to say that I have looked into the zero amount as is my way for the show but what I assumed

1:35:07when I saw the headline about storing flying blind Twitter was that they were only lobbying to allow you to wear it in

1:35:12the car like for example if you get it with prescription lenses

1:35:15and you need them to see to drive they didn't want they want to make it illegal so you didn't want to be illegal for

1:35:20you to merely wear them.

1:35:22I didn't think they were lobbying for it to be legal for you to to have it turned on and using it

1:35:27but since I didn't read any article that is there I don't know did you know did you read them

1:35:30and you can tell me I don't think we I don't think we know that much to that much detail.

1:35:36Hell my little justice here I've merely heard mostly support of my position

1:35:44and brief in my position is that for Google to to lobby to actively lobby against states that want to prohibit glassed

1:35:53use while driving. I think that's incredibly irresponsible by Google and you know it.

1:36:00I think it's you know pretty much all reasonable people agree that texting while driving is dangerous

1:36:06and should be prohibited. And certainly avoided.

1:36:11People will do it anyway but I think I think even people who do it know that it's unsafe

1:36:15and wouldn't really argue that strongly that it that it was safe and I think texting while driving

1:36:21and using Google Glass are pretty close.

1:36:25Like I don't think there's a huge difference in safety in a car between doing those two things I don't think one is

1:36:32dramatically more safe in the other.

1:36:34It's both like it's engaging your visual attention in a way that like us like interact with like a multi-step process

1:36:44with a computer system where you're not looking at the road

1:36:46and well actually now that I've thought about it for the five minutes they've talked.

1:36:50What about if they are envisioning something like that why don't your in five there in arguments that people have made

1:36:57that say things like well this is just like looking at an afternoon or it's just like looking at a heads up display

1:37:03and I think the difference is that you know a net first of all natural

1:37:08and heads of displays are designed very very carefully and conservatively to be like maximally safe

1:37:15and also to minimize how long you have to look at them in ideal cases some of them go as far to be like you can even

1:37:23like some of them or even let you enter an address in navigation if you're moving for instance.

1:37:27There's all sorts of safety things that that car systems use to either prevent

1:37:32or discourage you from using it very responsibly things like you know how D.V.D.

1:37:37Players like sometimes there are be these D.V.D. Players that will complete video in the front seat.

1:37:41But you can only totally play while you're parked and yes some people will will pack then disable it

1:37:45but like there's all these things in place for for things that are installed in cars especially things that come stock

1:37:50from the manufacturers. There's all these safety in place to to try to make them as non distracting as possible.

1:37:58And like. A heads up display displaying your speed.

1:38:03Well that's you know that's no more distracting than a speedometer you don't have a lot of reasons to like stare at

1:38:08that for a while.

1:38:09Well what are the heads up display in your glasses showing now overlaid on the street in front of you.

1:38:13If that is what it's showing that's fine

1:38:16but I think again this is like a human nature human behavior kind of thing the reality is like we've banned in most

1:38:25places we've banned handheld use of cell phones.

1:38:28Now you could also say well what if you're using the cell phone in your hand looking into navigation screen

1:38:34and that's in place where hand-held cell phone use is banned that spent

1:38:39and I think is one of those cases where you know the reason why that's banned is that yeah maybe you might be doing

1:38:45that

1:38:45but there's also a very good chance that a lot of people who do that are also going to like you know sent a quick text

1:38:51just take a second

1:38:53and there's all this all this potential for these multipurpose general computing systems like smartphones like glass.

1:38:59There's all this potential for misuse and misuse is so easy

1:39:03and so common that they should probably ban it out right because they know that like you might be using for navigation.

1:39:12But there's a pretty good chance you're not

1:39:13or there are so many other things to do with it there are navigation that you know in reality people would like be

1:39:19reading a text message or dictate they're taking a message

1:39:22or reading Twitter reading e-mail just came in are like like they're like there are so many potential abuses there

1:39:28and is so it is so much more distracting than in the car systems because you're interacting with a computer at that

1:39:35point like you're like it's a multi-step interaction.

1:39:38You're like visually engaging in a way that it's non-trivial and

1:39:41and takes more than a split second of your attention and so I do think there's a significant difference there.

1:39:47And and

1:39:49and some people also said like oh well what of glass is you know what if you can where you have to keep it off again.

1:39:56Same thing like how you can tell from the outside whether it's. On or off.

1:40:00So a lot of people just sneak by

1:40:02and say oh well you know I was going to leave it on because you know I'm responsible I'll be OK

1:40:06and that's a problem too.

1:40:07Well that's why I'd like to know what Google was lobbying for like basically where they're lobbying for you're allowed

1:40:11to wear but has to be offices you're allowed to wear it and use it like I'm pretty sure was the latter

1:40:15and I'm pretty sure they didn't distinguish between on and off that they just want you to be able to wear.

1:40:19Yeah well like I think Google's bet and I think they're right in this

1:40:22but is that augmented reality as they call it is probably the future of more or less everything

1:40:26but I think you're right that if that is the future thing we are unfortunately going to have to wait for it to be built

1:40:31into cars because then it will be more or less single purpose

1:40:36and even if it's the exact same technology the exact same kind of display were like overlays that have on top of the

1:40:41street in front of you

1:40:41and shows you where you should term of the wire like you can imagine lots of really cool features like this I think

1:40:45that is actually safer than

1:40:46and looking down at an ab screen like to see the little arrow in your little picture of your car going if you could

1:40:51just continue to look out the window and just look like a little red line was painted on the road turning to the right.

1:40:56That's safer and I think that is definitely coming.

1:40:58If that comes from your glasses though chances are good even if you have like a driving mode

1:41:03and that the glasses have to be certified by a like the Highway Association like it's so much safer

1:41:08when it's built into the car

1:41:10and because car technology moves so slowly that they're super conservative everything sucks there anyway

1:41:14and B if it's built into the car the car maker is extremely motivated to make sure that you can't read text on it right

1:41:20like in the car the car maker could not ship that they're more liable with that kind of stuff like like you could you

1:41:27could plausibly sue the car maker for designing a very threatening system a lot more easily than you could sue Google

1:41:32for making you know. Right.

1:41:34Built into the cargoes going to say you shouldn't have been doing that while you're driving

1:41:37but you're like if it's built into the car you say you put it in the car.

1:41:41Exactly and that's why that's why you can do the address

1:41:43when you're moving because the car makers like we allow them to do this they will they'll crash

1:41:47and also us for what it's worth I can actually read text messages on my i drive in my B.M.W.

1:41:53Like on the screen but usually crashing as a means of B.M.W. Get their car.

1:42:00Just want to point that out real quick I'm sorry Mark I'm going to act.

1:42:03All right so part of my position on this was was a pretty severe condemnation saying like you know if Google Google is

1:42:11actively lobbying for something that I believe is pretty clearly very unsafe for driving

1:42:18and car accidents are are no joke like it's a really car accident or a serious problem.

1:42:25So many people get injured or die in car accidents.

1:42:29And for the most part you know things that we pay a lot of attention to like plane crashes

1:42:34and terrorism like that end up killing way fewer people than car crashes car crashes are a big problem.

1:42:41It's a really big deal and car safety should really be taken very very seriously and not at all lightly

1:42:48and not at all recklessly.

1:42:49And so for Google to actively lobby against car safety basically to actually lobby for their own self interest in a way

1:42:58that's that pretty clearly unsafe in general use for cars like people are probably going to die as a result of that.

1:43:07And if Google Glass becomes really popular which you know it probably won't in all honesty but I suppose it does.

1:43:15Imagine how big of a problem that will be

1:43:17and how many people might unnecessarily die because Google fought safety legislation.

1:43:23That's a really that's that's serious. You know that's not a joking matter at all.

1:43:27So a lot of people said well isn't Apple at fault for people texting while using their phones and crashing and.

1:43:35No that's a completely different situation because Apple has not to my knowledge actively fought against anti texting

1:43:42laws. And if they have let me know I mean I would love to know that.

1:43:47But that is not at all the same thing and is not comparable.

1:43:52You know it's obviously manufacturers on both sides of this political debate.

1:44:00When both sides can potentially do more to prevent people from using their phones while driving.

1:44:06You know now you can you can think OK Well Apple has this new M seven processor that can supposedly detect

1:44:12when you're in a car.

1:44:13It probably can't tell whether you're driving or passenger but if you take

1:44:17when you're in a car make you show some kind of warning or something you know there are things they could do

1:44:20but they're not like actively fighting against safety legislation

1:44:26and that that I think puts a very different type of action.

1:44:30Like who is doing I think is actively harmful whereas the inability to try to prevent people from texting in a car is

1:44:40you know like like inaction is is not as bad as like actively harming safety actions I think.

1:44:46Well Google also in a position to potentially bring the largest safety increase in car transportation ever which is

1:44:52through their soft riving cars assuming that continues apace and does not fade away

1:44:56and there continue to be successful with it.

1:44:59I'm not saying that balances out like Therefore you're allowed to do something is going to kill more people now that's

1:45:03a bad idea but but it's like historically speaking.

1:45:07If history goes out every More forget that briefly they killed a bunch of people less I think what they're thinking is

1:45:15on the glasses that they also believe that all humans in reality is the future just look at their crazy whatever there

1:45:21was that thing with the phone thing the maps out there

1:45:23and they're in like the tech for doing that are going to realize stuff is getting better

1:45:26and better all the time it's going to be everywhere

1:45:28and Google is like if we wait for the car makers to do this it will take forever to get here it will be crappy

1:45:32and all that is true

1:45:34but I think they just have to like the alternative is they should either make their own car with this built

1:45:39and say buy Tesla go nuts like you have have a go at it

1:45:42but trying to put it into a general purpose computing device that you wear in your face

1:45:47and you have to get everyone to wear the stuff in your face

1:45:49and be like they would have they would have to sign up for all of the sort of liability type concerns that the car

1:45:55makers do in terms of regulation and everything and like it there.

1:46:00If they want they want the freedom to do whatever the hell they want

1:46:03and just don't bother us because eventually we're going to get to this awesome auger into reality it's coming

1:46:08eventually anyway and we're going to get there first because we can move faster but that's playing a little bit fast

1:46:13and loose with with people's lives I agree. And that also that also seems like almost a childish and naive.

1:46:21That's Google for you.

1:46:22Exactly I think that's a problem it's like well that's what that's what we love about that's what I love about Google.

1:46:27Like the self-doubt in cars is the same type of thing that's what we love about it

1:46:30but in the same time it gets them into that like that's why I always think of Google's corporate mindset not as evil

1:46:37more as like a naive hacker type of you know like Dan is in a Reddit like technology is cool we can do cool things with

1:46:45technology and I just go do that cool things because it's cool and let's not think too much about the consequences

1:46:50or whether all make money or anything like that you know that's what we love both love and hate about Will.

1:46:57Titles go to fail the house the title might go to fell some put in all caps this isn't basic. Have you seen the code.

1:47:06Oh yeah that's one point we didn't dress about the goat isn't that on your dress. All the people who've never seen a C.

1:47:11Programmer Unix C. Programmer like goto who uses that if you are a C. Programmer and you come from the.

1:47:19Just look at the source code to your favorite you know look at B.S.D.

1:47:22Look at Linux or wherever you find go to everywhere because they didn't really have exceptions

1:47:27and the control flow necessary with lots of nested it's to get you out of an if you end up having to make like Flag

1:47:34variables and really contorted logic.

1:47:37Go to is actually the cleanest solution in those situations where you want to get out of the normal flow of the program

1:47:42and go down to it you know or you can do set jumper

1:47:45or any of that whatever you want to go to is is the idiom that believe it or not

1:47:48and the only thing you've heard about programming is the GOTO is evil because there's a paper that you never read that

1:47:53got passed around the Internet ten years ago. But look at any real C.

1:47:57Source code and go to is there and it's use for exact.

1:48:00There is purpose and it has all the same problems and this is not what the paper about goto was against really

1:48:05but you can see goto does contribute to this anti pattern

1:48:08but you know that's why newer better languages have exceptions.

1:48:13Yeah and you know and like the GOTO is like there's things like break

1:48:16and continue in a loop that I would argue break

1:48:19and continue especially break like that's really not a whole lot cleaner than goes here like if you think about it like

1:48:26it's a lot

1:48:27but you knew like if you had like a very contorted logically condition a condition a condition you want to break all

1:48:32the way out of it then you even break doesn't save you then you didn't have a flag variables

1:48:36and it makes the code in comprehensible to the people who read up the functional a bit

1:48:40and saw the type of the variable status.

1:48:44Pretty sure if you knew what that was you were not surprised to see the go to the flick that's that's like you know if

1:48:49you've if you've been around old C. A.P.I.

1:48:52As long enough you know you've probably seen that

1:48:55and it's you know it's a little thing words like you call a bunch of A.P.I.

1:48:58Calls and if they return zero everything's cool.

1:49:01And if they return non-zero something bad happened

1:49:04and so if you want to do that's like you know eight step process Recall is a different functions

1:49:09and you have to have Eric check in code around every single one of them if any of these return non-zero fail that's

1:49:15what this was that's exactly what this was and and and fail in this case but the fail label didn't mean it has failed.

1:49:24The Fair Labor was the destination of where to jump to if it had if it had failed looks basically like go to the end

1:49:31like go to the end of this logic block that's what it was.

1:49:34That's another object to see a thing that we could have talked about and I hope and point and shows the convention

1:49:39and basically cocoanuts want to receive a Coke which not use exception exceptions for control flow is that correct.

1:49:46Yeah yeah I mean except like injective see objections like bye bye like policy and. And like the A.P.I. Norm objects.

1:49:57Exceptions are not meant to happen in.

1:50:00In running code most of the time like it's not meant to be control flows easily gets They're meant like you're probably

1:50:06not meant to catch an exception I got to see and it's not like so much a language feature as it is an A.B.I.

1:50:12Convention

1:50:12but still that that type of thing leads you to these like the tedium of of you know you know write parameter conditions

1:50:22you know where you passed the an address to some error thing is going to fill out

1:50:24or return values where at some status of others or a status

1:50:27or any other type of thing that type of thing is frowned is seen as slightly barbaric in languages that do allow you to

1:50:37use exceptions.

1:50:38Do expect you to use exceptions for flow control

1:50:40and then of course there's the pathological case of like you know checked exceptions and all the java crap

1:50:44and like it can go too far in the other direction as well

1:50:46but I would I would put down a list of things that Objective C.

1:50:49That other languages do differently that people find cumbersome tedious and error prone

1:50:55and lead to these type of situations where you find yourself needing a go to as far as I know it might get to see code

1:51:02written so far. Instapaper buckshot. The magazine and overcast of the ever written a try catch block.

1:51:09I think I've always made exceptions global thing.

1:51:12Yeah because in Cocoa they're not you're not you're not supposed to like exception is supposed to be exceptional like

1:51:16that that policy is there not for control flow it's not just to get me out of this mess that block it's like something

1:51:22has gone wrong and maybe you can put up a dialog and exit your app or do something like that

1:51:26but you're not supposed to use it as a form of flow control even if even though I assume you can if you want to.

1:51:32It's more like an assertion failure.

1:51:34Yeah I think that's how the tire more supposed to use it like if I think certain failures might even throw exceptions I

1:51:39don't remember exactly when. Anyway all right title title. Go to Phil's obvious I'm not against it.

1:51:49A lot of contests I think are going to have the title as we close

1:51:51and I want to avoid it so we can be cool so we can be cool. I added ish. Everything is relative.