Podcast Search

The Accidental Tech Podcast

55: Dave, Who Stinks!

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00In certain music here. Are you going to play for me. I won't give them. You think I'm not happy here.

0:00:04Dammit man who for the first item in follow up is when we talk about Final Draft

0:00:13and the script notes podcast Last week we got a lot of feedback on that. Also directly from the two hosts of that part.

0:00:21And as it turns out I definitely am perhaps also Casey missing tributed to the two hosts statements which were not

0:00:27there in particular discussing their stance on software pricing at closing the park as I was under the impression that

0:00:35they thought that they thought software if not should be free should definitely be much lower priced

0:00:41and I cited an example in a podcast of them saying well of Apple's operating system is free.

0:00:46That was not the host of the podcast that said that that was Joe Jarvis he was the product manager from Final Draft who

0:00:52was on the podcast.

0:00:54Now I know people feel when they say they can identify our voices and never think for the first time

0:00:59and you know fifteen twenty minutes into it you lose track of who's speaking.

0:01:03I didn't lose track so I think Katie said the last show and I said that a marker tried to correct us

0:01:08and none of us could remember for sure at the time.

0:01:10But Mark it was right I could tell you where you are and all that exist

0:01:14and I was that I did I thought that was them in case I thought that was them doing you said I thought it was them

0:01:18but none of us had the pocket in front of it.

0:01:20And speaking of that there is actually a transcript of this pod cast which Michael put in the show notes that will give

0:01:27you a text version so you don't have to listen to the podcast.

0:01:30People sometimes don't want to listen to audio and scrub to the park.

0:01:33You can just look at the text version which is much faster to read and find the discussion of this topic.

0:01:37So I apologize to both of those guys for making it sound like I thought all software should be free

0:01:41and in fact John all the cells and software are his own and so he is not just a observer of the software industry

0:01:47but is also a participant on the other side of the coin.

0:01:50Yeah yeah I definitely was part of screwing that up

0:01:54and I will say that I was completely in love with listening to that particular episode.

0:02:00Part cast because was it is it Mark. Mad Nick is that right here. Who is the C.E.O.

0:02:05and Co-founder final draft to my ears was straight out of New York I can tell I could tell his voice from the other

0:02:12stuff

0:02:13and so that's what that was going to say as he was the only one I could I could without question definitely place who

0:02:18is to everyone else I was I was taken shopman dark you know we got a lot of feedback about like from from people who

0:02:26are in talk about the screenplay format and people have many alternate apps for screenplays

0:02:31and it looks like that ecosystem is actually pretty vibrant

0:02:34and seeing some new life in terms of like alternate applications and alternate formats for writing screenplays.

0:02:41So it's actually much more lively than than it might seem if you just listen to this

0:02:46and think everyone is stuck with final draft that the young

0:02:50and upcoming people are seeking adult I was photographed in those alternatives exist

0:02:54and in fact there's a format kind of like mark down that you can use to produce a screenplay

0:03:00and any application like mark down any application I get is that a text that format

0:03:04and you can convert from that format to the quote unquote real screenplay format so that's really opened up feel to a

0:03:10lot of other editors which I also mentioned during lunch.

0:03:15Eventually by name

0:03:16but I didn't know what the name was so I didn't know if you had said it like Mark Denver screenplay sort of in like may

0:03:22be said that this is where you can insert the clip of you saying that you had only I thought I think I'd give one

0:03:29sentence about mentioning this fountain format

0:03:31but yeah otherwise otherwise the follow up is I was right I would get someone that's not so true.

0:03:39Don't you know there has been plenty but you were there if you had been more insistent like Kate

0:03:44and I both got it wrong who said that and you're like I don't think it was the other guy.

0:03:47You weren't sure it was the other guy either.

0:03:49Or sure enough to say no it totally was and I guess I think I did

0:03:53but that's OK are you going to turn back let's say you know I was just trying to give you places where you can insert

0:03:58audio. There were parts in there.

0:04:03The other part of it is that the Craig and John did and various times say things like and we know the price is off

0:04:11or is going down and things that used to cost a lot cause more

0:04:13but they were saying it as a sort of a offering up of the idea that they understand where the founder of guys are

0:04:20coming from. Not that these are positions they agreed with.

0:04:23So if you look if you read the text it is much more clear that they are trying to provide like trying to say that I

0:04:30empathize with your situation I understand that in the software market software is apparently being devalued

0:04:34and then they would say but and then go on.

0:04:36I think Craig is still closest to to walking that line in saying that he doesn't think great just oregano should be

0:04:42worthwhile

0:04:43but again again it gets back to the specifics of this one program that they don't like that hasn't been updated for a

0:04:48long time and not a general statement about all software.

0:04:52Yeah

0:04:52and I think that that specific complaint about retina being the thing that should have been free I don't I don't agree

0:04:59with them on that.

0:05:00I agree you know if they if they want to complain that the updates in general to final draft haven't included enough

0:05:07new features to be worth their price that's a different story and charging for what is really a bug fix.

0:05:14That is also a different story but retina is actually like you know supporting new hardware

0:05:20and that's that's not necessarily quote a bug fix

0:05:23and you know it's like it's like if you have to support a new version of the U.S.

0:05:26You know you don't you don't get everybody for free if they're already really old version.

0:05:29But you know I think it's I think this is all I think they're probably this is all tied up in the overall problem a

0:05:36final draft being crappy and not really having any kind of development pace for a long time.

0:05:42All right so the other bit a follow up that we have is regarding whether

0:05:48or not it's wise to treat warnings as errors in production code

0:05:55and I believe this came from the go if you feel conversations are right it was kind of a separate.

0:06:00Actually yeah it was a separate topic but. But yes you know there is the culture of of using the W. All flag or W.

0:06:09Everything flag or the various permutations thereof that specify the really. As for Terra carriage in C.

0:06:16or Easier to hear because you would say.

0:06:19And that kind of morphed into you know my my position of with my well development now I'm doing my P.H.P.

0:06:27Framework such that all warnings

0:06:30and notices in production even are treated as exceptions I was doing development for for the last few years

0:06:36but now even in production all warnings and notices are exceptions

0:06:40and I asked the listeners during last week's show because John John in case you guys severely disagree with that saying

0:06:47that in practice to paraphrase your arguments I feel if you'll prove in practice that in a production environment once

0:06:55you get you know beyond a one person operation that gets really tricky you might have other people deploying you know

0:07:00P.H.P.

0:07:00Updates to the server and you know breaking the site into the night

0:07:04and you know maybe it's not that important to break the site for some minor reason it's not worth it

0:07:10and it's better to to keep everything up as much as you can and just log the warnings.

0:07:15So I asked the listeners what if they worked in a big organization that it is known for having that either has a really

0:07:25important web presence or is known for being really good at tech like Google or Amazon.

0:07:31I asked them like you know what's your policy in your organization and you know please let me know the feedback form.

0:07:36And boy did they go my God And I think it's pretty safe to say that not only did I lose this argument

0:07:46but I'm pretty sure I actually lost it unanimously.

0:07:49Well it's not there's no winning

0:07:51or losing based on what people say a bunch of people sending feedback doesn't mean anybody want to last anywhere.

0:07:56I've been thinking about it I think I can frame this the reason.

0:08:00I disagree with you on the reason we had a disagreement last show as it was all about the framing of the thing it was

0:08:04the thing I put in the show no special talk about at the end

0:08:06but the major framing of the topic was that in the beginning I like the topic came up in Yuma

0:08:14and you mention something about it and the beginning both Casey

0:08:16and I stipulated that there are certainly situations where it is both feasible

0:08:20and the right thing to do to elevate boarding stairs in production

0:08:23and we give example of you like you have to control everything about it.

0:08:26Your one man shop you're doing the client server side like you know you're not running a bank like you know for a

0:08:34podcast up and you know it's like it's reasonable based and then

0:08:38and then you stipulated there they're institutions in which it is unfeasible to do this because of something about like

0:08:45it's a different department that controls that are the developers are too far away from it

0:08:50or think you know things have to be up all the time and that's the most important thing

0:08:55and used to be elated that it was some sort of ailment in the enterprise that company it's also a practical concern

0:09:01that you might have to do that but every time Casey

0:09:04and I tried to come up with a scenario where it wasn't just like something you had to do because of real world

0:09:09practical concerns that are such a shame

0:09:11but that it was actually the right decision like not because of some sickness in your organization

0:09:16but actually because the arrangement of things in this perfectly healthy organization are such that this is the correct

0:09:21move. You would say oh I don't know.

0:09:23Basically you kept creeping towards an absolutist position him whenever we tried to cite an exception you would say I'm

0:09:28still not convinced so I think despite all the feedback is all the feedback you can dismiss

0:09:32and say well all those people belong to organizations that have some sort of sickness which most of them probably do

0:09:36let's be honest I'm trying to organizations that have some sort of organizational sickness that requires the requires

0:09:42them to do this you know isn't that a shame yes I understand it's a reality in your life but it's

0:09:45but it's not really the right thing to do

0:09:47and what I was trying to convince you of last time that I think is still the case is that there are situations where it

0:09:53is actually the right thing to do not to elevate warnings to exceptions.

0:10:00Action

0:10:00and the difficulty if you continue that I think has a lot to do with like us not this is kind of a tangent not sort of

0:10:06being on the same page ahead of time as to what the heck is a warning what do you mean by a warning like we got to it

0:10:11from like the warnings like the compiler that I was you know were talking about because that's like

0:10:14when you're compiling the program before you've deployed it there is no you know there's a different kinds of warnings

0:10:20and I was trying to think of a way to like who gets to agree on what warnings are

0:10:25but that's almost impossible to do you have to talk about specific technologies involved and where they come from

0:10:29and I thought of like the most extreme example is like imagine there was just a random number generator in your code in

0:10:35point or one percent of the time on this particular line it would have made a warning

0:10:38and you know that to an exception in production

0:10:40and you'd like of course I'm not going to turn that on because I'm just signing myself up for downtime.

0:10:46That is pretty much what exception what warnings are like in many situations in libraries that you didn't write that

0:10:51you have no control over in languages are runtime pass through code you can emit warnings

0:10:57and I think in that situation that absurd situation obviously you would agree that if something randomly elevating

0:11:01things to exceptions now you wouldn't want to turn those

0:11:04and warnings about he wouldn't turn them into exceptions going into signing up for downtime

0:11:08and lots of other people who wrote in who belong to these organizations that have these problems that cause them not to

0:11:13be able to do what you think is the best practice.

0:11:16Describe why they think it was the right decision but I don't think any of them were convincing.

0:11:21That would have convinced your should have convinced you that really is the right thing to do.

0:11:26So I'm wondering if reading all those things were you convinced that this is actually the right thing to do to not

0:11:32elevate them to exceptions in some situations and not just merely that it's something that poor suckers have to do.

0:11:38Now wait before you answer that market let me jump in there's there's a couple of quotes just three quotes that I'd

0:11:44really really like to read really quickly that I think really kind of nail this home and I and I

0:11:50and surprisingly I agree with everything John just said. The three quotes are from Alex tall and tall was in all caps.

0:11:56In practice the C. Whatever C I O C E O It's a. Doesn't give a flip about anything but their own agenda.

0:12:02In the end Marco has the correct idea.

0:12:04But outside of small and extremely well structured organizations the practice falls apart

0:12:09and I think that that that that's exactly what John

0:12:12and I are both saying that yeah you know in certain cases all know that that the guy is an organization that has

0:12:16problems.

0:12:17You know he's he's admitting that his organization has has problems that cause him to have to do what he knows isn't

0:12:22the best practice because you know such a shame like that's not really what I'm saying.

0:12:26OK but I guess the way I read that was Marco's idea is absolutely right it's just not always a political.

0:12:35No I don't think it's idea that we railed on that's what I'm that's what I'm saying.

0:12:38Like So here here's what I just said here is you know kind of like you going radio the feedback isn't enough so the

0:12:46other two were.

0:12:47Secondly there were two different engineers from Amazon that wrote in

0:12:51and I'm paraphrasing kind of the mutual message that that both of them said.

0:12:57And so this is no not verbatim but they said I get why Marco says what he's saying but

0:13:03when you deal with this kind of scale something is always broken.

0:13:07And so in the example of Amazon there's so many moving parts that no matter what you're doing no matter what happened

0:13:15there was always going to be something that isn't quite right and so you kind of have to plan for that

0:13:20and there's not a lot you can do about it.

0:13:22And then finally anonymous said we don't guarantee up time with code quality we guarantee up time by having an

0:13:30institutional strength in reacting to problems and this is kind of getting into a different tangent

0:13:35but I just thought it was a very interesting point as well that even if your code has no smell to it whatsoever that

0:13:41doesn't necessarily guarantee up time

0:13:43and really guaranteeing up time is more about just being able to read it react to issues that are saying those are the

0:13:50three quotes I have so I apologize Marco or John Feel free to carry on.

0:13:53Well before Marco has to respond I want to give what I thought was the strongest argument sort of buried in our.

0:14:00Feedback and that that many people have offered

0:14:03and it gets back to kind of like going to the final draft thing with the C.E.O.

0:14:07Found Rafa's coming up I guess and trying to make all his problems your problems

0:14:11and a lot of the people who are discussing the problems with their baby

0:14:13or evasions that that that make this unfeasible also said basically and you know more or less

0:14:19and even if we could do this it's essentially making your problem

0:14:22and your problem is basically I want to ensure that my code is morning free

0:14:25but I think it will produce higher quality code.

0:14:27It's turning your problem into your customer's problem because you know once once you turn that warning fatal in

0:14:33production you have some sort of you know avoidable downtime that causes you to you know while I'm sure we're going to

0:14:40go fix it now because once there's downtime everyone runs around like their hair is on fire

0:14:44and that will make sure that we don't let human nature go through

0:14:47and if we merely log the errors maybe you'll just ignore them

0:14:49and build up in a log so this is a way to guarantee that we have code quality

0:14:52but the way you're guaranteeing is at the expense of your customers.

0:14:56Someone just wrote in the chat room I was the name I think it was or was it something

0:15:00and it was some of those are in the chat room. Enjoy this downtime I didn't trust myself to take the warning seriously.

0:15:06Like message to your customers and what I would say the strongest argument

0:15:11and in this vein is that by elevating warnings to errors in production

0:15:17and making your problems your customer's problems if that's the only way to ensure that you stay in warnings clean.

0:15:23That in itself is a sign of an unhealthy organization and help the organization would have a policy to log warnings

0:15:30and have them addressed in a timely manner was suggested and shown a lot of people wrote in

0:15:33and they said this was the policy so I think if this is the only way you can you can avoid the pitfalls of human nature

0:15:40and make yourselves address these things.

0:15:41That's a sickness that's worse than the sickness that lets you not do that because of a lot of these people who are no

0:15:48relation to did seem very compensate we have a policy a warning it's logged it makes it take someone who deals in a

0:15:54fixed amount of time and they can execute and that policies that's their stopgap against human nature or not.

0:16:00Putting it on to their customers and causing a problem.

0:16:02And that's why I think there are actually situations where it is the correct move not just the pragmatic one not just

0:16:08the unfortunate I'm sad I had to do this one but actually in the correct optimal you know

0:16:12and if their butts about it policy Mostly I'm not going to argue this anymore because I've clearly been proven wrong

0:16:20and I can see a lot I don't understand and accept a lot of the kind arguments have been put up.

0:16:26Just to clarify though what I'm talking about warnings in production like the kind of morning that I see on my apps are

0:16:34usually things like my skew Well truncated value because I passed one that was too long

0:16:40and my application code is not validating that for lanes properly or or you know something else with my S.Q.L.

0:16:47Like the connection was dropped in the middle of a transaction and my library didn't reconnect

0:16:53and those that that kind of thing that's both the kind of thing that I want to know about

0:16:58and so I think you're right John that yes making it your customer's problem is not ideal.

0:17:04And yes if you have the structure in place where if warning just get logged in a database somewhere

0:17:10and then you're required to act on them.

0:17:13That's great and if you have that kind of discipline within the organization that's awesome

0:17:18but I think so many organizations don't have that.

0:17:22In practice you know there's there's always there's like there's the bigger organizations that can have procedures like

0:17:28that and they don't always

0:17:30but you know they usually usually bigger they are more likely to have some like that where this tends to fall apart

0:17:36and where this you know where a lot of software methodologies fall apart

0:17:43and a lot of discipline falls apart in our industry is in the small and medium sized shops

0:17:47and in that kind of situation where you don't have a lot of procedures in place you don't have a lot of infrastructure

0:17:53in place. You don't have giant different teams doing different parts of it so you know maybe you have.

0:18:00Between two

0:18:00and twenty people in your organization you know that that federalization That's a lot of times where discipline is at

0:18:06the window and if you get a bunch of logged warnings in production you might not fix them or humanity can see them

0:18:13and so I do think there are a lot of a lot of situations where enforcing this in forcing it's blowing up production

0:18:21with warnings as a disciplinary tool to combat human failings I think there's still a place that I I will I will yield

0:18:31to the counter argument on this being the right idea for everybody

0:18:35and even for a larger organization I think the thing that's been proven that that's probably bad

0:18:39but I think I think you can apply this kind of rule of crashing production on everything to more than just me.

0:18:49I think there's more of a place for it's not just you

0:18:52but you like I stipulated there are situations where that's valid in all cases we're trying to find the correct

0:18:57solution is the one the plays to the strengths of the particular situation the strengths of a small shop or one

0:19:03or two man shop a shop working on something that doesn't matter if it's down for a little bit like a game

0:19:08or you know something it's not super critical that is not to say strength

0:19:12but like that is that the shape of that beast is that you know you can take advantage of this.

0:19:19Since you're a small shop

0:19:20and doing something on essentially you can take advantage of this to make sure that you don't ignore the Vieira's

0:19:25because you know you're you're basically you're hacking is one of the self acts like

0:19:29when you do something to remind yourself to exercise all the time and now it's all of the life hack things or whatever.

0:19:34But on a small scale and that makes perfect sense and then in the larger organizations they have different strengths

0:19:40and one of the strengths of a large organization they have the ability to have policies to be imposed on people it's

0:19:45very hard to have a policy imposed in a five or ten person company because who's going to be the big guy because

0:19:50when the policies are going to be your friend who sits next to you

0:19:52and you're not going take it seriously like that's a weakness of Smorgon of the strength of a big one so you have to

0:19:56pick the solution is appropriate for you and we think it's not.

0:20:00Just for Marco but for other organizations where it may be possible that this may also be the best solution.

0:20:05The tricky part and gets back to what I wrote in the show notes which is what is the nature of warnings

0:20:11and warnings so just like without agreeing on that it's like it's very hard to have a discussion about this because you

0:20:15know transactional border devalue truncated like everyone would agree that I mean regardless even like you know value

0:20:22truncated I think that should be elevated to an exception in almost all situations

0:20:26but the warning about like you sure you want to use this function because a lot of times people use this function

0:20:32or really they mean that function and that happens at runtime because you never had that code path

0:20:36or a particular value

0:20:38and your total like yes I use the write function don't want to that's why I get back to the random number generator

0:20:42like that's the extreme thing is like some code that you didn't write in some library that you don't control.

0:20:47Decide they want to send you a nice friendly message depending on if it gets the you know the data value was over five

0:20:53and it's past three pm on a Tuesday

0:20:55and the system clock past the year twenty ten which at the end it decides to emit a warning like I would consider that

0:21:01a problem if you didn't plan for that and catch it.

0:21:04No

0:21:04but I mean like if the warning is like Are you sure you want to call this function maybe you meant another one like it's

0:21:08advisory it's guessing like you did your not that you were if you could find the person who wrote this morning you'd be

0:21:13like Stop writing no warning like because they're human beings writing these warnings in the words they have nothing to

0:21:19do with any kind of erroneous or unexpected situation but merely giving advice right and advice is fine.

0:21:26In situations like you can't get back to the random number generator a lot of times warnings to me feel like they might

0:21:32as well have just been my code was running fine and

0:21:35and some random number some random number generator decide I'm going to send you a friendly message right now that had

0:21:40nothing to do with anything that was not useful in the only reason I have to react to it is to add whatever I need to

0:21:44make that warning go away if I can't because sometimes you can't get it to compile Libre the use that you don't control

0:21:50it's not acting in a way that is unexpected or wrong but then that author decided to give you advice about something

0:21:56and that is the worst kind of warning the worst kind of runtime.

0:22:00Even driven warning that you don't control and that's why I think a lot of people didn't position this because

0:22:04when they think of warnings it's like oh it's something I have to react to and

0:22:08when I think of warnings often think of the only reason I have to react this is to shut this person up because they

0:22:13don't know our code or they're trying to be helpful and give advice

0:22:16or suggest a different way that we could do things

0:22:18and it's like I don't what you're suggesting now at runtime you know I need to blank that out of the logs because I

0:22:23can't get rid of it and it's not telling me anything useful.

0:22:27So as with most things we were discussing

0:22:29and trying to like agree on the premise like authorities are talking about a specific technology

0:22:34or a specific version of something

0:22:36and then you kind of say here's the set of warnings that come out are we OK all of the things all two exceptions

0:22:40and then you have to look inside your innovation all of the stuff

0:22:43but if you just say warnings in general everyone's got a different picture in your head of what we're talking about.

0:22:48All right we are sponsored this week by something pretty cool something pretty new here.

0:22:54It's called influx and this is a music album from brave wave productions that highlights the diverse

0:23:01and ever changing nature of music. It's a blend of chip Tunes rock electronica and more.

0:23:06And it features diverse musicians from around the world.

0:23:09Brave ways music is dedicated to exploring the interplay between video games music

0:23:13and the style you might know them from their previous world one two albums influxes theme is collaboration between the

0:23:19composers of the east

0:23:20and west featuring original music from Manami might sue me to McCord of Evanescence cagey young McGee she Akira Yamaoka

0:23:29say Henri Kobayashi and more get in flux today on i Tunes Bandcamp

0:23:34or their online store at brave Wave dot net to go to break away the net for more info now rather than keep talking

0:23:40about this music for another ninety seconds.

0:23:41I asked them if we could just play a couple of samples from the album and they said yes.

0:23:45Here are some samples from influx showing off two different styles in the album there's a lot of different styles on

0:23:50here. All right that was from influx by brief wave good a brave Wave dot net to preview more of it or buy a copy.

0:25:12Once again that's brave Wave dot net and the new album is called influx two words.

0:25:18Thanks a lot to brave way for sponsoring our show.

0:25:21You know always have a soft spot in my heart for Chip tunes because it's straight out of childhood.

0:25:25You know that's when even I cared a lot about Nintendo and things of that nature.

0:25:30And now I'm not that into gaming but I'll still occasionally stumble upon a chiptune album like this one

0:25:36and just absolutely love it if for no other reason for than a stodgy factor you want to give me the bleeps in groups

0:25:43theme song but will accept them. Yeah. Do you want to sponsor John. I heartily endorse the bleeps and boops.

0:25:56All right so I guess we should talk about soft mode algebra first I want to talk about.

0:26:00Any of these new bugs that have come out or Apple by Nintendo. What else happened a lot happened this week.

0:26:06Car Play we're not going to that they foresaw from a little car play right.

0:26:10Car Play was interesting but we get we can do software that all of this first if we want to explode.

0:26:18Well you know what I'll tell you what do you hear the fans for my MacPro I do not exactly where to set your new MacPro

0:26:29white one and God They came today. Oh my God Are you serious are you.

0:26:38I don't even know what to say right now I am so serious you need to say something about software methodology now it now

0:26:44is your time. OK it's called.

0:26:47It's pretty good by the way I don't know how stop you so much all right so a long time ago. Yeah it's fantastic.

0:26:55I posted this here here's a picture you can actually see just to prove just as proof you you waited just for just for

0:27:03this very moment didn't you. I did. I've kept it off the Twitter all day. The government that algae.

0:27:13I was going to say if this is the longest roll either half of me admires it

0:27:17and half of me is about to get in the car and drive to that town in which you live in murder you.

0:27:23But

0:27:25and this is why I kept it up Twitter all day for you our listeners to hear Casey's genuine reaction because he really

0:27:31didn't know that I had it and I hate you so much.

0:27:34All right so a long time ago in a galaxy far far away on a podcast very similar to this we talked about we touched upon

0:27:44the idea of talking about software methodologies and what we mean by that is you know how do you write software.

0:27:51How do you do that especially in a group atmosphere which means Marco probably doesn't do this very often anymore

0:27:58and hasn't done it in a long time.

0:28:00When I haven't prepared anything specific about this so I'm just kind of going to kind of ad lib.

0:28:07But a lot of a lot of my time my professional time has been spent pretty Actually all my professional times been spent

0:28:15working in teams.

0:28:17And I found over the years that there are very very very many different ways of going about authoring software.

0:28:25And I should say right now that if you're not the kind of person that really gives a crap about how to write code then

0:28:32this might be a portable to you anyway because many of these things that we're about to talk about are actually

0:28:38political to just about any project. And so there's a lot a couple of different.

0:28:44Well there's many many many different ways of going about this but a couple of very very obvious ones.

0:28:49And the way that I wrote most of my code in my career is by using a technique called waterfall which is to say you do

0:28:59all the planning up front

0:29:01and so that means you do a lot of planning up front you do a lot of thinking up front you have a lot of meetings up

0:29:09front and you pretty much do everything you can before you write a line of code and you do that all first

0:29:16and you do no code until you are ready to pretty much just thrown it in because you've specified almost everything up

0:29:23front.

0:29:24And the alternative to that are the most obvious alternative to that with something called agile which is to say you

0:29:31just kind of fly by the seat your pants and see what happens.

0:29:35So it's they they're very very different and there's pluses and minuses to both.

0:29:42But before we dig into that John what do you use in your day to day job today.

0:29:49I don't use any method

0:29:51or methodology depending on what you think is an actual word that you could name with a proper noun with a capital

0:29:59letter. If we use some vocabulary from the world of agile but it's kind of pointless and there's no real.

0:30:09We have a system and we have processes

0:30:11but we don't have we're not we're not following any kind of methodology from a book or a paper

0:30:16or even within the organization of the processes that we have are mostly methodology agnostic so I would not put it

0:30:26into any one of these had been in past jobs lived in fact never been to the company that has it here due to a

0:30:34particular system for doing software development that I could do that I could name with a capital letter.

0:30:40So let me instead answer that well OK I'm sorry I should ask Marco What do you do.

0:30:45MARCO What did you guys do a tumbler. The answer to both of those is the same which is a long awkward silence.

0:30:57All right. So so I have had the benefit and and detriment of using kind of a little bit of everything.

0:31:08I've used agile in a strict sense of ease that on a not so strict sense of you want to form a strict sense waterfowl

0:31:15not script in the strict sense.

0:31:17And what's interesting is that there's a lot it doesn't really matter what methodology you use or method

0:31:25or whatever that you use a lot of it falls down to the team and what the team is comfortable with.

0:31:31And so I've had a lot of experiences where I've tried to use agile and in doing so in client work.

0:31:42In my personal experience is going to be made or bridge broken by the client so the way I had to work.

0:31:48And I probably was being a bit flippant earlier

0:31:51when I said it's all about flying by the seat your pants it's really not at all the way it works is you spend a little

0:31:57bit of time a front planning the next couple of weeks. Or the next sprint as it's called.

0:32:02And so you spend that time figure out what are we going to do for next couple weeks.

0:32:05And the way that typically works is you come up with something called user stories which is to say you know as a user

0:32:13of this online banking system I would like to make a deposit and somebody will

0:32:18or you as a team will decide how how long do we think that will take

0:32:22but not in terms of hours which is a typical consulting way of doing things

0:32:26but instead in terms of something called points and points are not arbitrary but not really defined either

0:32:33and so what that means is typically you'll say OK of all these user stories we agree that the positing a check is for

0:32:39whatever reason a one point story that's very very very simple.

0:32:43And so we will say that we will judge all of our other stories based upon the difficulty of this story this one point

0:32:52story.

0:32:53So in the beginning you do sprint planning

0:32:56and you say OK for the next two weeks we think we can cover twenty points worth of effort.

0:33:01And so what do we think we're going to do.

0:33:04And so what you'll figure out of these are the things that we're going to put in the current sprint

0:33:11and then we'll have a backlog of things we'll get to if we can.

0:33:15And a nice box of things will get you way in the future if possible and you do your sprint usually for two weeks

0:33:21but not always and you do spend for two weeks

0:33:23and you try to figure out you know you try to get all these things done

0:33:26and at the end of the Sprint you'll see OK well we didn't we didn't do as much as we wanted.

0:33:33So actually we ended up only doing eighteen points worth of work

0:33:37and will consider eighteen points our vote last city for the next sprint.

0:33:42And this is all very boring on the surface

0:33:45but over a couple of sprints you get to figure out what is your team's velocity

0:33:51and your team's velocity can get you to a position that you can actually plan how much work you're going to do in the

0:33:58future. And that's the path.

0:34:00Our of Agile is when you've gotten a couple sprints under your belt and you've gotten your velocity

0:34:05and it's relatively repeatable and reliable.

0:34:08And then at that point you can you can predictably figure out OK given all the work we have left to do then why how

0:34:16much how much how much time will it take.

0:34:18And so I've done agile several times all but one of the times it failed spectacularly.

0:34:27And the reason they're Well there are many reasons to fail spectacularly

0:34:31but in my personal experience the reason the most obvious in hugest reason that a fail spectacularly is because our

0:34:39client didn't really get it. Which probably falls down to us not really explaining agile properly to to our client.

0:34:49But the one time it worked well our client really got into it and really understood OK P's point.

0:34:55Things don't really translate to hours and if you don't they don't really translate directly to anything specific.

0:35:04But these points are kind of like currency.

0:35:08And if I decide out of the blue that I really want some new feature

0:35:15and if I ask the team are right how long do you think this will take and they say well it's going to be three points.

0:35:21I know as the as the product owner I know was the client as a product owner that I'm going to need to take away three

0:35:30points worth of effort if I want to shimmy in these new three points that I've just come up with.

0:35:36And when it got to the point that we and the client both understood that points are currency

0:35:43and really had faith in the system it worked on believably well.

0:35:49But generally speaking out of that happens instead what you end up with is from a fall which is you do a bunch of work

0:35:55up front have stand ups every day say you're working in agile and none of it works since complete.

0:36:00That's basically are just about the sounds awful. This is this what working with other people is like. Which part.

0:36:07I'm I am asking honestly which part sounds awful all of it to the point it sounds condescending the points I mean

0:36:14whatever.

0:36:15I mean it's like I said it just sounds and I mean there's been so much said and written and experimented with

0:36:23and tested over the years about how to organize

0:36:26and manage anger nearing tasks like this sorry programming task start of the real engineers out there

0:36:34and most of these systems boil down to the ways that are easily exploited for laziness or personal gain or and

0:36:46or ways that are just very obvious gated and potentially condescending

0:36:51or infantilizing And I think I would have a hard time with some of this like vandalizing it just having a boss I know

0:36:59it sounds the same from your perspective. I have someone else tell me what to do I'm not a baby yet.

0:37:07So what good is there a specific thing

0:37:09or things that you take issue with because your reaction to be honest is not unreasonable is especially knowing the

0:37:16frame of mind you're coming from. It's hard to explain.

0:37:20I think just the whole the whole setup sounds like it sounds like a lot of people need something to do with their jobs

0:37:29who aren't necessarily programming all day whether their managers or whatever you want to call them

0:37:35and managers have a role.

0:37:38Good managers are very very helpful but there's a lot of managers out there who aren't good at hand.

0:37:45And so much of this stuff sounds like the creation of mediocre managers trying to occupy their time

0:37:53and prove themselves a worthwhile by coming up with some kind of system some kind of you know procedures and.

0:38:00And frameworks and abstractions over people doing work and the the process of building software

0:38:07and it may be one of the reasons why these things often fall apart

0:38:11or don't work very well is because like you just said OK well this feature if you set a night in ideal case you can

0:38:18take the points of people part of it and you can say OK well this feature will cost three points.

0:38:22That's just that's all it is estimating time right.

0:38:24And we're always our entire industry is myself included is horrendous at estimating time.

0:38:29And so like is it really any different to say oh that'll take two weeks or they'll take you know thirty man hours

0:38:36and are any of them even accurate.

0:38:38It's not really estimating time is as much as it is estimating difficulty and that's the key difference

0:38:43and if I were you I'd be kind of sucking air through my teeth and being like What is there really a difference there

0:38:48but there is because you're saying relative to other things.

0:38:53This is either a little bit more difficult or a whole lot more difficult.

0:38:58And so a one point story we all agree as a team including Q.A.

0:39:03Including everyone we all agree is a team this is not very hard where as an eight point story

0:39:08and usually use of technology sequence so what is it one two three five eight sum like that you know there's a point

0:39:14story is many orders of magnitude more difficult than that then that other one point story.

0:39:21And so it's less about estimating time and then it is difficulty in the theory as you take time out of the equation

0:39:27and that's what that velocity is all about because over a couple of friends you realize OK we bit off forty points

0:39:33worth of work but holy crap we only did twenty.

0:39:37So realistically we shouldn't sign up for forty points anymore Sprint's we should sign up for twenty

0:39:43and over time things become a lot more predictable

0:39:47and the other thing that you said which if Which makes perfect sense

0:39:50but I think I'm doing a pretty crummy job explaining scrum

0:39:53and agile is that all it's all about giving manager something to do or not all about

0:39:58but in part about giving managers some.

0:40:00And to do

0:40:00and in fact it actually to some degree neuters the traditional product project manager in that you're no longer

0:40:08beholden to a Gantt chart which is possibly the most evil thing ever created and instead the whole idea of scrum

0:40:16and agile is the team is the one in power and if there is a pride project manager their job in life is

0:40:25and to be honest it is what I think it should be which is to get obstacles out of the way

0:40:31and the best products project managers I've ever ever ever worked with do two things. Well three things actually.

0:40:37Number one they get obstacles out of the way.

0:40:41Number two they advocate on behalf of the client to our team so they are the client's representative.

0:40:49Whenever the client isn't around and sometimes even when the client is around

0:40:53and number three they advocate on behalf of us to the client.

0:40:58So if the client is like Dude you guys gotta be able to do more than twenty points in the sprint really I mean come on.

0:41:03This stuff is not hard.

0:41:05It's a product and project managers job to kind of step in and say well know whether

0:41:09or not you think it's difficult the fact the matter is history shows us data shows us that we can only do twenty points

0:41:16a sprint. So this one is going to have to be and to think anything else would just be impractical and irresponsible.

0:41:23Does that make any sense at all.

0:41:24It totally does but I like what what bothers me about systems like this is I look at this

0:41:29and I say well why do you call them points. Why does it have to be this concept of this of this currency or this this.

0:41:34Like why does it have to be another level of indirection

0:41:36or an abstraction above what it really is which is people working you know man hours.

0:41:41It's you know that's like why this this to me sounds a lot like the culture of Java and which has infected P.H.P.

0:41:50As well of like making tons and tons of deep class hierarchies and class and upper classes inheriting from classes

0:41:56and factories an abstract factory and all this crap. And when you're really trying to do some.

0:42:00It's a lot simpler than that it doesn't need all of that and so when I

0:42:05when I look at some of these things like it's it's easy for me to to get turned off by it

0:42:10and honestly there's probably tons of value here that I'm not seeing because I'm an idiot in this regard I've never I

0:42:17am completely inexperienced in following any kind of from methodology in in all my programming jobs even when

0:42:22or even

0:42:23when I work with the people we never fall in the methodologies closely we would you know we would kind of like what

0:42:29John said earlier we'd like borrow occasional things and Michael will try a few weeks with this

0:42:33or try couple of months with this and

0:42:35and it would never stick so I don't know I don't know what I'm talking about in this area so that in mind I mean

0:42:40normally I don't know I'm talking about with a lot of things

0:42:42but this time I'm actually admitting it so that should mean something.

0:42:46You know what your your questions are completely reasonable

0:42:49and so to answer one of them you know why points why that level of indirection Why not just speak in ours

0:42:55and it's because of exactly what you said which is that the developers are unbelievably indescribably bad at coming up

0:43:02with accurate estimates

0:43:03and so the whole idea of points is like I was saying earlier it's an order of magnitude of difficulty

0:43:08and you can kind of construe how many hours a point will be after a few sprints

0:43:14when you say OK well Sprint is two weeks. Casey has done ten points worth of work every two weeks.

0:43:20So that's about five points a week.

0:43:22So you know you can you can extrapolate that out to figure out what ours is

0:43:26but the idea is to take away any sort of measure of time and just argue about difficulty and track difficulty.

0:43:36So that time kind of falls out of that equation.

0:43:40I'm not sure I'm doing a great job describing it there's a lot of reasons why that will not at all it is B.S.

0:43:45And I think I have my own cynical take on hung on agile and other matters as well

0:43:51but I want to get to a link that someone put into the chat room whose name I will get this time because I froze my

0:43:55scroll back. Wonder Matt put in the link the thing that I wanted to mention which.

0:44:00His

0:44:00and maybe another uses the Greek software company introduced this thing as part of a product as part of I guess a click

0:44:09a link to find out.

0:44:10But scheduling it was Bugs a while ago I think it was for some five or something it was a while ago.

0:44:16Yeah and it's a similar take on this

0:44:19but it's like it's even more kind of data driven in that on an individual developer basis they asked that individual

0:44:24developer to estimate how long something will take

0:44:26and you basically each individual developer gets a sort of a reputation within the system of how could they heard about

0:44:32estimating how long things are going to take for them to do

0:44:35and it is an easy weakness to pick out of an adult system that uses points in the way Casey described.

0:44:40It's that programmers aren't interchangeable parts

0:44:43and you're you're crappiness at estimating difficulty of a tester in one sprint probably has very little bearing on

0:44:49your crappiness of estimating the difficulty of an entirely other task another sprint so you may think the entire team

0:44:55has a capacity of twenty points

0:44:56and really Person A has a capacity of fifty points on its own if you're doing a feature that involves like O.C.R.

0:45:02but If you're doing a feature that involves pull down menus. His point about that is much lower.

0:45:07But he's able to estimate both of them really well so you think you'll be able to oh we should be able to you know

0:45:12figure out exactly how many points we have but the points vary wildly.

0:45:16Being able to estimate the difficulty who you estimate for difficulty for the team difficulty for you who is assigned

0:45:22to such a big difference.

0:45:23That's why a lot of these things fall down

0:45:25and evidence based cajoling is trying to say what can we do to take the human element out of the equation

0:45:31and say Let everybody Lyall every really crappy

0:45:34but even then you don't have like OK they were crappy about estimating for this type of thing

0:45:38but what about that everything maybe they're better estimating then you're hoping it's going to home in on some kind of

0:45:42average but I have a feeling that unless you find yourself doing the same kind of task over

0:45:46and over again which would be super boring

0:45:47and most good programmers don't want to do it'll be difficult to get something really predictable out of that system

0:45:55right so Marco do you want to tell us about something else that's really excellent and then John I'd like you to.

0:46:00Part all of the arguments are just because of that sure thing.

0:46:03We're also sponsored this week by our friends attending once again. KING Is mobile that makes sense. There are no B.S.

0:46:10Simple to use mobile service provider from the people to cows the company behind hover good or special U.R.L. A.T.P.

0:46:17Dot King dot com to learn more. They have great rates and there's no contract and no early termination fees.

0:46:25You own your device out right and then they have a pay for what you use pricing model.

0:46:29So here's what you do you pay a base price of six bucks per month per device

0:46:33and then whatever you use on top of that in minutes texts

0:46:37and data they will just Bill you whatever cheapest bucket they have that fits that number so for instance if you use

0:46:44one hundred megs of data this month and a gig next month

0:46:47and the next one after that you've gotten back to like you know two hundred megs each month you'll pay a different

0:46:51price just whatever you use to pay for that so you don't need to guess what you'll need an advance you don't need to

0:46:57like raise your data cap before you want to be trippin and lower when you get back

0:47:00and of course you'll forget until you have two more months of paying a higher rate that you don't even use.

0:47:05You could pay for the use they believe for the cheapest bucket the fit and that's it.

0:47:10They even have new lower prices if you if you check them out in the past check them out again because they even just

0:47:15lowered their rates so for instance two gigs of data is just twenty nine dollars five hundred megs in just twelve

0:47:22dollars or so to see how much you can save a thing. Go to A.T.P.

0:47:26Dot com

0:47:27and check out the savings calculator you can enter in your last few bills of whatever your actual usage was from your

0:47:33existing phone carrier and it will show you how much change will save you on average and over time

0:47:39and if you're stuck in a contract with someone else

0:47:43and if you if you if you supposed to pay no if your nation fee to yourself to Tang.

0:47:48They will actually give you twenty five percent of it back in service credit up to seventy five dollars.

0:47:55So like coveting has great customer support there's a no hold no wait phone number you can.

0:48:00All them up any time during the business day and a human being. Picks the phone.

0:48:05Who is right there waiting to help you.

0:48:07It's a really great system great customer support

0:48:11and you know we can think of various ways you can use it you can look at if you're a developer you want some test

0:48:15devices that you know you want to be activated on cell network if you don't want to pay a lot of money

0:48:20or if you're just a regular user

0:48:21and you're tired of paying a really high phone bill for a lot of capabilities are not really using.

0:48:25Check out tango to A.T.P.

0:48:27Ducting dot com they're compatible with any sprint phone because there are sprint and the ENO here in the U.S.

0:48:33And if you have a Sprint phone bring it over if it's compatible. Go to their site to see the list.

0:48:38They also will sell you a new or used phone for pretty great prices so check it out. A.T.P.

0:48:43Ducting dot com Thanks a lot for sponsoring the show once again.

0:48:48They should have a song with peeps and groups with a name like Tang. Or just bells. That's true too on the nose.

0:48:57Goodness.

0:48:58So really quickly before John destroys all of the points I just made a friend of the show David Smith said earlier in

0:49:03the chat and I'm quoting from Slash addles purpose is to attempt to try and extract a consistent

0:49:09or predictable performance out of an uncontrollable situation.

0:49:12It is better than nothing

0:49:13but it is no replacement for talented motivated developers who can get things done in Anita Vironment methodology to

0:49:19help reduce the impact of individual talents on the overall outcome and I think that that really makes a lot of sense.

0:49:24And I completely agree with that.

0:49:26But with that said John Jeremy apart now it's not you it's like the it's the overall concept of having a particular

0:49:35method by which you develop software like the reason Marco has a sort of is a reaction against that

0:49:41and I think most programmers do

0:49:43when they're in the type of environment is that if you spend any time programming you whether on your own

0:49:48or in even just a small group just one

0:49:50or two other people especially in small groups where you kind of like get a feel like this is what it's like to make

0:49:55software this is you know this is what the experience is like here.

0:50:00I learned that you learn kind of what works

0:50:04and what doesn't in terms of getting the job done independent of any schedules and stuff like that

0:50:11and what works is having a bunch of talented people who are motivated

0:50:15and excited about the thing that they're doing right.

0:50:17And so all these methodology is in some respects are attempts usually good hearted

0:50:23and sometimes vaguely effective attempts to take for example mediocre programmers

0:50:28and making them into great programmers or to take great programmers who don't care about something

0:50:32and make them care about everyone wants like what we want is what happens

0:50:36when you get a bunch of talented people working on the same product who are good at their jobs who are excited about

0:50:42what they're going to do and large companies say well we can't do that because we're too big

0:50:47and people are excited about our stuff and it's hard to get that many people who are talented

0:50:51or even if you could get a many people who are Tampa they don't get along with each other

0:50:53and they can have group so we need some sort of method to arrange all of this so that we so that we get some sort of

0:51:00somewhat predictable performance out about what we've got what we've got is maybe we'll get really talented people

0:51:05we've got not so down to people maybe we got people who are excited and people are excited.

0:51:08People disagree about how things are going to go

0:51:10and we have a whole bunch of people telling them what to do so they don't even get to decide which direction the

0:51:13product goes in and they have we want them to do that in a consistent manner

0:51:16and so if you're in this environment you're like you start to feel if you does not this alone

0:51:22and got rid of Dave who stinks like and then we would get this thing done

0:51:26but instead we have to go through these stupid steps of this methodology in these user stories in these meetings

0:51:31and these points in the going through those Nothing it was like look I'm a software developer I know what made you

0:51:36think they are good software it just put me in charge of the world and I'll tell everyone exactly what to do

0:51:40and just me my three friends would like everyone to get back to that thing whereas if you want a couple friends in a

0:51:44room working on your program which which is how lots of great software is made

0:51:48and all this methodology stuff seems like it's pointless busy work and doesn't actually make anything better

0:51:54and I think a lot of times it is pointless busywork doesn't make it any better

0:51:56and the only thing that it makes better is that as people point to.

0:52:00Chat Room people higher up on the org chart can point to well we've been following this methodology

0:52:05and it has predictable results and look at our things to say we have we know how many points

0:52:09and our velocity involved was so kind of like covering your ass that so you're not going to get fired because what we

0:52:13have a methodology in this is what we do.

0:52:15But in effect everyone in that organization might feel like the stupid methodology is making us less efficient less

0:52:22happy making us do worse work than we would if we just again Fire Dave because it stinks

0:52:26and we have got three of us go off for a week

0:52:29and it will solve your freaking But like that's how programmers feel like the cowboy coder like to stand aside I know

0:52:33exactly what I'm going to do.

0:52:34Like that's the tension between the sort of feeling that any experienced programmer has that if you just let us do what

0:52:41we need to do we could get it done you know and the reality that if you're on a large project you can't do that.

0:52:49This is where this tension is and some people are trying to apply a methodology to to make order out of this chaos

0:52:54and the people who are contributing to the chaos always feel like anything you impose on me is making things worse

0:53:00and they get grumpy about it and so some people look at religion and say oh I'm going to get into this process

0:53:05and I like

0:53:05and it's predictable like bottom line is you know a large organization is ever going to achieve the ideal of a handful

0:53:12of talented like minded people communicating well and even like

0:53:16and that article open the show it's like of why software mythologies don't work even if the ideals like all of us focus

0:53:21on communication to make sure we have personalities

0:53:22but to get like those solutions are not scalable to organizations of hundreds of people like him no no way for people

0:53:29to do a job together

0:53:31and you know at at peak performance is scalable to hundreds of people because inevitably personality conflicts is going

0:53:36to be disagreements and that's why you inevitably have to fall back to some kind of method.

0:53:40Now for things that are regularize which isn't point out a million times like building a road or building bridges

0:53:46or things people have been doing for hundreds of years that are very simple you know very much success

0:53:52and failure was the need to be spent over the course water needs carry this much weight a need to the stand these

0:53:56conditions need to last this long. We've done this twenty times before.

0:54:00Our We know exactly the steps that are required to take still things can get screwed up

0:54:02and we can try new methods they might mess up

0:54:04but in general it is way easier than even the simplest software product where no one has made a specific thing before

0:54:09with the specific requirements people don't even know what the requirements are

0:54:12and they're going to change a million times like software is so much more complicated than pretty much anything else

0:54:17humans do except maybe parenting impossible to predict you know what's required to go into it

0:54:24and so we're willing to accept essentially a massive reduction in peak performance just for some Grassman like can we

0:54:31get some predictability of that even if it means that are you know they're working slower like that's part

0:54:38and once you get a certain size in a public company like I don't care how much crappier it makes us as long as we're

0:54:43still still able to stay in business I want everyone to follow whatever methodology A.B.C.

0:54:48India whatever processes even if I know that this is going to send the best programmers out of the company because they

0:54:53don't want to work for us anymore

0:54:55and we're not going to get the peak performance that we were just better than the unpredictable cast because if you're

0:54:59not one of the programmers

0:55:00but you're one of the people in charge you could very quickly feel like you're nobody's in charge nobody's at the wheel

0:55:05you're does up there and you just like Whisper down to the person

0:55:08and say well hey guys you think you could make a program do this

0:55:12and then you just wait to hear reply with your fingers crossed like that's not a way to run an organization so these

0:55:17rules always have to apply but they're always going to feel like they're making things work

0:55:21and in many respects they're there wishful thinking that you are going to somehow convert the correct process to turn

0:55:27this huge team of people into the equivalent of seventeen rooms full of five people who are really motivated.

0:55:35You know the funny thing about everything you're saying is and this was pointed out to me on Twitter by Chris each

0:55:42and he's right is that the origin of agile. Why do you try to get away from oversight by management.

0:55:51And so the whole idea of scrum

0:55:54and agile is that you self manage as a team the team is self-governing you establish a team norms.

0:56:00So you know we're always going to be on time to meetings which never actually happens.

0:56:03We're always going to pay attention during meetings which never actually happens.

0:56:07And you're trying to get everyone to get along in agreement like that's you

0:56:11but you can't do that like that's not how that's not how human human relations work.

0:56:15Like if we just all agree they will be friendly and motivated

0:56:18and work well together then we will not follow works like you can't from.

0:56:24It's like coming from the outside and saying it would be nice if all the interaction with other groups were this way

0:56:31and then if you say that to each other that doesn't make it so.

0:56:33Like these two people still hate each other always going to these two people disagree strongly about this technical

0:56:38issue there you know telling them that they shouldn't disagree is not going to work like it's kind of like shifting the

0:56:45things around on the table like OK well we don't want people who are programmers telling us on sure if we just let all

0:56:50the programmer sort out they'll do fine no you just move those those dynamics to a different group of people a

0:56:54different even more passive aggressive group of people.

0:56:59So I take it John that you've never been in a situation wherein you feel like the math improved the product processes

0:57:09sometimes improve the product and I like that for large organizations you have to have processes

0:57:14and you have to have methods because if you don't it's just wildly unpredictable

0:57:19and depending specially with your mix of people like the herd is like if you have a bunch of great programmers

0:57:25and you can listen to it

0:57:26or the one your be awesomely successful if you have a bunch of mediocre programmers you need to apply you know process

0:57:32the methodology and if you have a bunch of crappy programmers you need massive methodology application to them.

0:57:38And then in the end of it all those situations you end up with a product of similar quality what I don't know if I

0:57:43believe that and I don't know which one of those things is better

0:57:46but most most companies are a mix of those type of things and it's just there. I don't think there's any avoiding.

0:57:52With something as complicated

0:57:54and unpredictable software I don't think there's any avoiding that dynamic that small groups of folks really smart

0:57:59people can do great.

0:58:00In short periods of times things that larger groups of less motivated less experienced less talented people can never

0:58:07do like is not like OK we'll take these five people in the room a year to do this but if I have three hundred people

0:58:12and three years I know you will never equal them with three hundred people if you don't have the right five for example.

0:58:18It's because it's not a predictable thing because it's not something you can systematize some of the chairman saying oh

0:58:23c'mon there's plenty of things that are more complex than software.

0:58:26Plain natural things not not plenty of manmade things like I would say some forty seven I mean the consequences of

0:58:32errors and forty seven are much greater but software is much more complicated the consequences easily stupid

0:58:37and pointless and nobody cares which is why we get away with this.

0:58:41Software is insanely complex in terms of you know what.

0:58:45What number of states can can this thing be end

0:58:48and how how many transitions from one state to another going to go through the friggin halting problem we can't even

0:58:53reason make basic reasons about arbitrary programs that you're going to consider it.

0:58:59Programming is is different by nature than most things that people do it just so happens that the consequences are

0:59:04usually not that serious.

0:59:05That's when you see a program where there is real consequences like you know missile control systems or things

0:59:09and planes hopefully they have a massive process applied on them like they're willing to sacrifice productivity

0:59:16and you know job satisfaction

0:59:18and not have the smartest people to say look we have crazy requirements about how everything must be done in the most

0:59:23conservative fashion possible and it's like some people look at and say it's a miserable existence

0:59:28but like that's our only tool to say we would like to make a program but we'd also like it not to fail. Like ever.

0:59:34And so we're going to apply the methodology nucular bomb or nuclear if you are not a crackly to this problem

0:59:43and we're going to make it miserable for like no one would sign up for this like you can't use these features you're

0:59:48not allowed to ever allocate memory we have the system system for do it like for the space program it's not like that.

0:59:53That's our only tool like method

0:59:55and that's what our tool is for for trying to make it so that you know we can minimize.

1:00:00Dog to make it reliable

1:00:01but it destroys productivity you can use that same methodology that you use like the Mars rover software you can't use

1:00:06that to make like Whatsapp like you know he'll be out of business it's not you know you can you can even use them a guy

1:00:13Wes for crying out loud like you would they would never produce a product you know.

1:00:17Think how many years and they would never get the people who want to work on it so it's.

1:00:22That's how I think that's the place of methodology like it's it is an evil that is necessary to the degree to which you

1:00:30would demand predictability of the software

1:00:32and even then you have things going out of orbit because of unit conversion errors

1:00:35and this bug you know like we're never perfect so I feel for the people who want methodologies to make things better.

1:00:45But I mostly see it as like the only tool we have to try to fight against the inherent chaos of writing software in it

1:00:52as per usual.

1:00:53I think you've hit the nail on the head in Coincidentally I was about to bring up that there are instances where

1:00:58waterfall which among software developers is considered to be evil in almost all cases there are instances where

1:01:04waterfall is absolutely the correct answer

1:01:08and in fact as I kind of hinted at during the debug that I was on with Guy and Rene as plug

1:01:16and if I do what I can to get accidentally half way through the thank you I say yes it is

1:01:22when I was working on some stuff for where failure was not an option.

1:01:28We had pretty much everything that was waterfall a lot of planning up front a lot of meetings up front code reviews

1:01:35and all of these things

1:01:37and that was in order to prevent exactly what you describe John you know it was to prevent a poor poor unit conversion

1:01:45or something along those lines

1:01:47and in that situation it was absolutely necessary it was absolutely necessary absolutely the right answer

1:01:52and absolutely the right way to get that project done. The problem was is that as a developer especially one who tends.

1:02:00Two want to sling code

1:02:01and rather than talk about slinging code it was incredibly neutering to me is that a word it doesn't matter anyway it

1:02:09made me it made me feel like I could never get anything done because I just had to talk about getting things done

1:02:15and it was very frustrating

1:02:16but I don't begrudge my then employer for doing things that way it was absolutely the right call.

1:02:22It's just it wasn't the right call for me.

1:02:25Waterfalls like almost impossible with anything that's reasonably complex because nobody knows what the correct line

1:02:31for it is no matter how much you talk about it like you could you could talk for three years to come up with a design

1:02:38and once you start implementing it on a third day you're going to go with us wouldn't think of that like the running

1:02:44program is too complicated for ever

1:02:46and to keep in their head unlike what happens at that point is do you bravely plow forward with the waterfall design.

1:02:52Do you you know go back to the drawing board and start all over again or do you just make some little tweak

1:02:56and then like you end up with this thing of kind of misshapen It's like putting the other piece of furniture in one

1:03:00piece of wood is like Bent Barely they fall the plan right and slot and have be it. Yeah yeah.

1:03:09In consent only Marco to bring him back into the conversation has dealt with a lot of that lately.

1:03:13Not as many wonderful stuff but not as much wonderful but but you've dealt with the reality

1:03:21and realization that you know what maybe I need to throw away a lot of work I've done and and do it all over again.

1:03:28Oh yeah I mean that's I mentioned in the after show about four episodes ago I think it was about a month ago

1:03:36and I don't I think I even cut it out of the final edit.

1:03:40But the lead listeners probably heard me a month ago to say that I was rewriting the overcast sync engine because I

1:03:47discovered some sync shortcomings and I was we were in the engine to be much better and everything else

1:03:53and at the same time I was doing of course you know you can. In hindsight I can see why this is a bad idea.

1:04:00While you're in the sync engine on the whole the whole protocol with which it's saying to the server.

1:04:04I also took the opportunity to break up the data model for some of the for for the two key models of the apertures pod

1:04:13cast and episodes.

1:04:15I broke I broke off parts of those that were that were use or parts of them in several models

1:04:20and this required such massive changes to the code on both sides server

1:04:24and client at the same time I was I was also changing the same protocol

1:04:27and trying to make it generic so I could use like you know the one master super class flash library functions to sink

1:04:34anything and the result was I lost a month basically.

1:04:41And last night I decided you know as I was staring in there with with the parts of my of my applique on the floor still

1:04:51and as I was trying to rework the changes you know still back into the app

1:04:57and I realized I was throwing away so much working behavior

1:05:03and so much like nuance complicated stuff especially in the I.O.'s app that depended on the old model.

1:05:10Meanwhile this whole time on my carry i Phone My main i Phone I was using the old version of the app for a month ago

1:05:18because this whole time I couldn't put a new build on yet because it was broken and for the whole month it's been fine.

1:05:24It's been working great

1:05:26and I've been sitting here using this build for this supposedly like unshockable alpha software.

1:05:31I've been doing the same build for a month every day heavily and it's been perfectly fine and I realize you know what.

1:05:37Now that I'm like you know two thirds of the way into this massive sink change I realize now that even if I get it all

1:05:44back together it's going to be too complicated too fragile and not at all maintainable

1:05:52and so even if I finish this the result will be worse than what I had before I was wrong

1:05:57when I thought it would be better. In practice it's not better.

1:06:00So therefore I decided to go back to what I had

1:06:06and I spent today basically reverting back to the old version from a month ago and merging in a few.

1:06:14Basically cherry picking by hand a few of the improvements I made that that will fit in the old system just fine

1:06:21and so I've I've lost.

1:06:23I wasn't doing this home when I was doing stuff I could keep but I would say I probably threw away two

1:06:29and a half weeks of work because the result is actually better the old way.

1:06:35I think you're only on step one of four of the Brent Simmons thinking developed because I think at this point now you

1:06:41have to also throw away this one again and try the other one

1:06:44and then you have to revert back again to the previous year following the Brinson

1:06:48and Vesper think a diary plan of thinking software development you've got a long road ahead of you.

1:06:55And to be fair you know to bring this very briefly back to methodology.

1:06:58No methodology would have fixed that in my in my estimation you know what I mean it take longer.

1:07:04Yeah you're absolutely right like Agile would have

1:07:07or would have forced you to ship something you didn't want to ship because it home

1:07:10and in areas where there are constraints like that that's what I was getting at is like that a lot of timed

1:07:15methodologies are seen as the way to solve your problem

1:07:18when your problem really might be your one software you have working on a sync system is not written a sync system

1:07:23before and there's no methodology that's going to make that go faster.

1:07:27Make it come out better like there are lots of practices that week that you can adopt him it is not like saying oh we

1:07:32should just be the Wild West like for example practices that should be imposed on people that I think everyone agree on

1:07:37like you know I don't pick a language or try to like Javascript but the stupid use strict token

1:07:42or if you decide that's a reasonable thing to do

1:07:44and I think it isn't it it doesn't affect your compatibility to say everybody's got

1:07:47but the javascript script defined deciding on your compiler flags having some sort of common naming convention

1:07:52and indenting style I wrote all the easy things that people can agree on that stuff counts and it helps everybody but.

1:08:00People say that's good. Coming up with agreement on the standards helps.

1:08:04If we come up with agreement on even bigger more sweeping changes surely will get a proportional benefit

1:08:09and you don't like you you get I mean that you start talking about testing I think as that testing is definitely

1:08:16something you really need and it's great

1:08:18and testing taken to its logical conclusion a tester in development is certainly better than having no tests at all

1:08:25but you can't just keep cranking that dial until it's like now just everything will be perfect all the time because of

1:08:29a little bit of testing help

1:08:30and a little bit more testing is great that if we have one hundred percent code coverage everything testing we've

1:08:34solved the problem of software development and you haven't.

1:08:38And unit testing is something that I think is a little bit kind of taboo is the word I'm looking for

1:08:44but not a lot of developers that I know are really into it

1:08:48and I would argue that test driven development is taking it a bit too far in my personal opinion but.

1:08:54But writing writing comprehensive unit tests is all the same sort of thing as code reviews where first I was like oh

1:09:03god really this is a thing we have to do every want to sort of my code and try to tell me why it's wrong

1:09:09and they don't realize that I'm actually right now I've got to convince all these people.

1:09:13But in the end it actually worked.

1:09:14Code reviews were extremely extremely interesting

1:09:18and I always learn something from it even if I never change my code and most times I did change my code.

1:09:23Unit testing is a summer thing words like I don't really need regular test for all these things.

1:09:27I run it a few times I give it a few example inputs and that should be enough right.

1:09:32But unit testing is an unbelievably awesome way to make sure that not only that what you've written works

1:09:39but also that it will stay working and that's what's extremely powerful about it

1:09:46and you can take it to the nth degree which is tested in development or you can use it where appropriate

1:09:50and one of the things that that I need to explore more in Objective C.

1:09:55Is looking at like Xcode unit testing framework has never really played with it but there is great.

1:10:00Frameworks

1:10:00and Java in Dot Net like any unit for example in him actually Microsoft has their own copied version of that

1:10:08but that would allow you to know of course if that allow you to do those sorts of things

1:10:12and I agree with you John that that you know having these unit tests is or is a really valuable thing.

1:10:18Every methodology has something about it that you can take away from it that's good like waterfall has some good things

1:10:23about it as in like I think about we're going to afford to have agile and some good things about it I can you know.

1:10:27Let's take smaller steps because if you if you don't know that if you describe something as one big giant step you have

1:10:32no idea what's involved in and they can break it into smaller steps than you have

1:10:35and I think that's from the Gantt chart as well but also you get that experience agile tester in development.

1:10:40Lot of developers left to their own devices won't do test so if you if you try to indoctrinate them into this crazy

1:10:45cult of test driven development then they'll learn to write tests

1:10:48and I think I think Petron realm is actually not that far off from something that everybody should do it's just that

1:10:53it's so far off from what people would do on their own that it seems crazy at first

1:10:59and I'm I'm a big proponent of massive amounts of testing what you run into eventually with test your Novell man

1:11:05or any kind of testing thing is that tests are also code like it's not like another fallible person comes

1:11:11and writes the tests right and it doesn't mean you shouldn't write test that doesn't invalidate it

1:11:15but it like that's the limit that you get limited you hit a certain point is that your you know tests

1:11:21or code you're not infallible when you write them either

1:11:23and the more of them you write the more difficult changes become both in good and bad ways

1:11:27and like so every one of these things if taken too far can have problems

1:11:32and that's what we're looking for is like oh just if we got those two

1:11:35or three guys who really kind of know the doing

1:11:37and have had experience with each of the things they're going to be doing and have done something like this before

1:11:41and can kind of get the balance

1:11:43and just you know firing on all cylinders in the project small to fit all in all their heads collectively

1:11:48and then you know they're super geniuses

1:11:50and make this great one point no product with this great potential future they handed off to another group like we're

1:11:54all trying to go to get to recapture that it's like it's like trying to recapture you like.

1:12:00You're never going to get there again you're never going to be like you were when you were sixteen years old

1:12:04and I guess we can just apply the series of constraints

1:12:07but there are like there's wisdom in every experience that you had that you want to apply

1:12:11and in some respects it doesn't matter if you're in an organization it's like you know whoever the Chargers things are

1:12:16that all of the way we go over the chart of things as we go to test driven

1:12:19or we have to pair program we have to if you like someone's leaning heavily on whatever button or dial

1:12:24or accelerated I think is the best thing in the end what matters is like the people in the group the dynamics within

1:12:31the people their motivation for what they're doing and their skills

1:12:34and experience how they done something like this before

1:12:37and almost any minute ology you apply to them will appear to work because they would have been fine in any situation

1:12:43and those same people you know would choose to to write test because they know it's good like that because no

1:12:49methodology that omits tests entirely because I've been saying there's no methodology that omits any planning up front

1:12:54because we hit waterfall like this there's always there's always something some piece of every one of them like you no

1:13:01matter what methodology you apply to a bunch of good people and they will pull all the parts from each one of them

1:13:06and the problems only come in when it's like you know and how long ago it was like no silver bullet written

1:13:10and you know the red brick stuff like that's not so long ago as we've known this for so long as people keep reaching

1:13:16for that for that brass ring and saying This time I've got and every time is like you don't have it

1:13:20but you've discovered something new that maybe we can take away from what you're preaching and move forward.

1:13:26So in summary you know methodologies can help.

1:13:29But really they're not going to fix anything and it's all a bunch of hocus pocus.

1:13:33With that said we should say just wishes you are no sponsor was going to say that both of us should convince Marco to

1:13:39write way more tests than he's currently writing which is to say more than zero.

1:13:43I don't know what that number is I was going to say I'm just saying which is to say more than zero.

1:13:49Yes I would suggest that I would say what I really want

1:13:52but anyway Marco what else is really cool these days it is once again our friends at square space square space is the

1:13:58on one platform.

1:14:00I make it fast and easy to create your own professional web site or online portfolio for free trial

1:14:05and ten percent off the square space dot com and use offer could now you have no it's a new month. January was Marco.

1:14:12February was Casey march off a cliff or Squarespace is critical. Nice everyone else got the name.

1:14:21I just get my credit card one of my old hot star Iraq if they were going to start better than my name I hope maybe

1:14:28maybe critical is your identity. I was going to say that's so critical of you right then and there.

1:14:33It's hypercritical too long to fit in database context

1:14:35or the coupon codes for a maybe they'll throw a warning at the thought of their whole app Squarespace is constantly

1:14:42improving their platform with new features new designs and even better support.

1:14:46They've been beautiful country to start with and all the style options you need to create a unique web site for you

1:14:51or your business.

1:14:52There were over twenty highly customizable templates for you to choose from

1:14:56and these templates of won numerous design awards from prestigious institutions.

1:15:00Now square space is very easy to use if you need any help.

1:15:04They have an amazing support team of over seventy people in New York City that works twenty four hours a day seven days

1:15:10a week and even they have won numerous awards so Squarespace started just eight dollars a month.

1:15:16Now they have this cool feature called square space commerce where you can build your whole you can build an online

1:15:21store that sells physical or digital goods

1:15:25and it's this whole storefront capability built into square space so it looks like your site you can theme it you can

1:15:32customize it and you don't have to build a shopping cart that the tracker for all the inventory

1:15:36and all that crap they do all of that for you. Building a store with a lot of work they do it all for you.

1:15:42And squareface commerce is included in every square space plan.

1:15:45So if you want to use it great notational charge if not you want to make a site put a portfolio whatever the case may

1:15:51be you can do that too.

1:15:53All this started at eight dollars a month you get a freedom a name with that purchase for a year up front and.

1:16:00You can start you can start a free trial today. No credit card required for that free trial.

1:16:04It's a real free trial you don't have to like give him a credit card

1:16:07and you know hope that you remember otherwise you get charged nothing like that.

1:16:11Real free trial at square space go squarespace dot com and use offer code critical to learn more

1:16:18and to start building your site today. Now one more thing if you hurry up.

1:16:22If they are they're interviewing designers and engineers because they want to hire thirty designers

1:16:29and engineers before March fifteenth Now right now they have to be released on March sixth.

1:16:34So you know hurry up basically But if you interview for an engineering advantage

1:16:39and before March fifteenth they will invite you and your partner to be New Yorkers for the weekend.

1:16:45They will fly you out put you up when the city's best hotels

1:16:48and give you a long weekend of being a New Yorker going to restaurants attractions etc

1:16:53and they will pick up the whole tab for it.

1:16:55They've been voted one of New York City's greatest place to work for two years running. So put them on your short list.

1:17:00They're looking to hire again thirty engineers and designers by March fifteenth so hurry up. Going to be a part of it.

1:17:05Square Space dot com to learn more

1:17:07and apply to things like this Chris has once again member offer code critical if you have been hearing Squarespace ads

1:17:15on podcasts for months

1:17:16but not going to the site to sign up as a time to do it with my code to show the other two I wonder if I can get them

1:17:23to tell me like you know in a couple of months which of our codes one yet it's too late for you to use an ivory body

1:17:29pile on my code so in markets of information I'll be the overwhelming winner.

1:17:33Well I don't think our code stopped working.

1:17:35I'm pretty sure the code still work it just you know another that would be bad because then like you whoever the first

1:17:41code would have the accumulation of the you know the months of of user signing up anyway. Everyone is Micah.

1:17:49Casey was the. After all this time was the methodology used to talk on the show everything you hoped it would be.

1:17:56Now actually really wasn't. I think it's over though. Are we done.

1:18:02Are we I don't know we don't have to be

1:18:04and we don't have to be I don't really have so much more to say To be honest after all that.

1:18:07Well I have a question for each one of you. I mean we are going to have nine of us at the follow up.

1:18:13Maybe Marco going to stay in but like which one methodology or part of the methodology. Have you found to be.

1:18:22Make the biggest improvement in how and how you feel about coding or how you write code.

1:18:28So Marco do you have an answer for that. I don't have to be like a formal wonders anything you've done.

1:18:32You know honestly what has improved my code the most by far has been open sourcing it

1:18:40and not necessarily because of the contributions I get which are good but I look at a whole lot of them.

1:18:45It's mostly that if I know I'm going to be open sourcing it I hold myself to a higher standard and I

1:18:51and I kind of reconsider my decisions more and so by by editing myself more

1:18:57and by by pushing myself to a higher level discipline for these very important modules that I'm open sourcing that that

1:19:05has helped me to radically and you know as a defensive helper there is you know I don't really have a code review.

1:19:13I don't have pair programming.

1:19:14You know there's a lot of of methodology type stuff that I just can't do as one person

1:19:21and a lot of the stuff I could do like having tons of tests I could do a lot of that stuff.

1:19:26But it's it it would take so much of my time it would slow me down so much that it might not be worthwhile or

1:19:33or practical for me to do that and so I don't do a whole lot of stuff

1:19:38but certainly yeah open sourcing by far that's that's helping with anything so for me I would say that I think scrum

1:19:50which is to say the thing where you get together either physically or on the phone for five to fifteen minutes each.

1:20:00Day and talk about what you've done and what you're doing and what stands in your way.

1:20:04That sounds wonderful in theory and in practice never works.

1:20:13Even in my company where we take agile extremely seriously

1:20:18and of course all the people who think I'm wrong about everything are laughing right now

1:20:22but we do take Advil very seriously and whether or not you think I am.

1:20:26I know what I'm talking about I show you that they do and so they they take scrum very seriously

1:20:30and we have scrums every single day

1:20:32and even though we take all this stuff so seriously describes never last the fifteen minutes are supposed to last

1:20:39and they always go on to tangents that they're not supposed to go in

1:20:43and so scrum is never help however that one project where we had that perfect storm of willing

1:20:51and capable developers willing and capable keyway willing and capable pm and willing

1:20:57and capable product owner slash client when all of us really went all in on agile and really bought into it

1:21:05and really believed in it and really took it seriously.

1:21:09It was fantastic because it allowed for us to roll with the client's ever changing requests which to be fair they were

1:21:19actually very good to us and didn't really change things that often but

1:21:22when they did the product owner the client would come to us and say oh I really want to do this thing.

1:21:28How much will how many points is that and we'll go and talk for a few minutes OK it's eight points.

1:21:34Man All right let me figure out what points I want to get rid of and I'll get back to you.

1:21:38And we didn't have to argue with them. There was no scope creep there was no.

1:21:44Well if you'd like this to happen you're going to have to take some other stuff.

1:21:48How much other stuff we don't know you just have to take out of the stuff I did so much.

1:21:53None of that awkward conversation happened.

1:21:55They took it upon themselves to realize well you know what you've told me that.

1:22:00That that this thing that I really want is eight points

1:22:03and so I know that I need to take away eight points from what's currently on the docket.

1:22:09And oh my god it was so wonderful I mean I genuinely It was so wonderful

1:22:14and I think this is exacerbated by the fact that in consulting you have this client versus one of vs necessarily the

1:22:23you have the your client in your own team and sometimes that can be an adversarial relationship but when you

1:22:30when we were on the same page with agile it was so wonderful because we were truly honestly partners in getting this

1:22:36project on and it was great and so to answer questions on the one of the ten

1:22:42or so years I've been working the one time that agile really really really really stuck. It was incredible.

1:22:50But to be fair I've tried agile many many other times and it hasn't really worked out that well.

1:22:55And at best it was a distraction and at worst it was a hindrance.

1:23:01Yeah I would say for me it's hard to pick because a lot of things like a lot of steps

1:23:07and things that I've done that for the better

1:23:09and I recognize Marco's thing with open sourcing stuff like me having a lot of my Coby open sores all in my career now

1:23:15is super embarrassing.

1:23:19That really helped you know for all the reasons Marcus I like you just feel the pressure to make it better

1:23:23and especially when you're young developer working on your own.

1:23:26Like I was under slight you know random open source stuff. You need some kind of external motivation.

1:23:32You don't have a boss telling you to do it

1:23:33or maybe you don't have other experienced programmers trying to get you to stuff

1:23:36but I think the thing that has made the biggest impact on me in terms of how I develop software was as I started to do

1:23:44more and more testing

1:23:47and not in any particular thing not particularly test driven not particular even unit test versus integration does

1:23:52or has five sets but is the idea that testing is not like eating your vegetables and I know I had turned a corner

1:23:59when I think.

1:24:00One

1:24:00or two jobs ago at some point there was some fairly complicated project that they wanted with like you know this big long

1:24:08description of how it's supposed to work written entirely by non-technical people so of course they have no ideas about

1:24:12feasibility or anything like that and they needed in a super short time frame

1:24:17and they're like you know this is super important we know it's really complicated

1:24:20but like him you know we have all this meeting about it like what's going to take to get this thing done.

1:24:24And my reaction to being put in that situation to be like the you know the lead guy on this project was immediately to

1:24:34to revert to kind of like you know not test driven entirely

1:24:36but like to say I'm going to need a massive amount of tests more testing than my tests have to be great

1:24:41and I have to be awesome

1:24:42and I have to really constant I think because that's the fastest way to get this thing done on time with the fewest

1:24:48bugs so on and so forth

1:24:49and the fact that that was my reaction shows that I had you know sort of learned through bitter experience that testing

1:24:56is not like eating your vegetables is not like a luxury you can get that you can afford to do like if you had the extra

1:25:02time or whatever but rather when you're under the gun is when you really need to pull that out of your back pocket

1:25:07and not be you know you know religious about it

1:25:10and say like oh yeah I'm not going to take a step until I've got a failing test

1:25:14and all this other stuff like not that crazy

1:25:16but just like for me to feel confident that I can move at my fastest pace I have to be sure that the code I have I'm

1:25:22writing is correct and in the code that I've written remains correct.

1:25:25During this entire development process and I've never been under quite the same constraints before

1:25:30but now like that's an example of a turnaround methodology I think people do pair programming have the same feeling

1:25:36sometimes or it's like I'm not going to do that all the time as the most extreme thing but

1:25:40when push comes to shove I know which styles I can turn to myself to get my best performance

1:25:45and I will choose from those things and I think testing is the one that probably I don't even know how.

1:25:51Probably you know because the test Urban Development like you know hype and everything

1:25:54but I would not have thought of that on my own to be the thing that I should do when I was young programmer but event.

1:26:00So they came to have it as one of the tools in my toolbox and I have a now and I try to prejudge other people

1:26:06but I say I like it. It should be something that you do from time to time to know how it affects your work.

1:26:12Yeah and I agree and it's funny because the formal unit testing is something

1:26:17and also formal integration testing is something that I find often gets punted if you're running out of time or budget.

1:26:25Additionally performance testing is another example of something that gets punted if you don't have a lot of if you're

1:26:31running out of time running on a budget.

1:26:33But all of those things are extraordinarily important to give a deliverable that you're really truly proud of

1:26:40and it's a hard thing man when when when somebody is looking at you being a project manager

1:26:46or a client saying oh my goodness you really really really need to get this thing shipped in you say no my test classes

1:26:55aren't complete yet so there is not enough code coverage so you need to leave me alone.

1:27:00So hard thing to sell and it's a hard thing to say

1:27:03but so often if you don't get that right up front you don't pay for it later. Same thing with performance testing.

1:27:09Oh well you know we don't need to worry about that we shouldn't have but five users at a time.

1:27:13And something weird happens next you know you have five hundred users at the same time

1:27:17and your Web site comes to a screeching halt.

1:27:20The key thing is to recognize when each tool is appropriate for the example that I cited.

1:27:25I was handed a big giant you know card documentaries

1:27:28or documents of this complex system not written as a program expect by any means that merely written as like like you

1:27:36know a fantasy scenario would be cool if and what about this

1:27:40and this would do this in the sort of the really complicated stuff it involves tables

1:27:43or whatever it was kind of like an intentional waterfall where it was like a big idea of a complex system that is just

1:27:50now in the kind of like blue sky ink stage

1:27:53but there needs to be needs to be shipped this software in like a very short period time like less than a month. Right.

1:27:59And. That's a case where you can say look if you agree this is how this is.

1:28:03This needs to work and you think you've got it all down.

1:28:06It's the fastest way for me to do this is to lean heavily on testing because there are so many complicated scenarios

1:28:14that I need to run through

1:28:15and it's not like I'm going to get one hundred percent coverage is not going to test every possible iteration of input

1:28:20but at the very least this document here describes many different situations and how they interact.

1:28:24And I can test every single one of those things.

1:28:27It's the only way I'm going to be able to ratchet my way through this code

1:28:30and that's different than a situation of like well we're not quite sure what we want to make it

1:28:34but it's an economy like this

1:28:35and in that case writing all these tests would just be like pinning yourself down the spider webs while you're trying

1:28:39to to move to an unknown destination.

1:28:42So you have to recognize like when do I have enough information to really pin this down the test right now.

1:28:47Or when do I have to do kind of a more fast and loose agile type thing of all this get something up and running

1:28:51and we'll look at it will poke around that it will see how it like in that case you're wasting your time to writing

1:28:56and changing writing and changing tests for something you're not even sure how it's supposed to work.

1:28:59So in all these cases like you can't you can't use the same tool for all different situations you have to know like in

1:29:07Margot's case when he's doing the U.I.

1:29:09I like this look over there how does this transition look maybe this button should be over there maybe is actually

1:29:12shouldn't be a button it should be a slight error let me try this with a gesture like writing tests for all those cases

1:29:17would just slow them down it would not help whereas for example the sync code which can be largely faceless is like an

1:29:24eye

1:29:24and very complicated in many different states is an ideal opportunity to do a very complicated series of data driven tests

1:29:31and maybe even some fuzz testing to be a consonant of this tiny little kernel of stuff that you've made works the way

1:29:36you expect it.

1:29:37Oh yeah and one of the reasons why I don't write a lot of tests is because most of the code I write

1:29:43and especially most of the most of the difficult tricky code I write is the form which is it's you know U.I.

1:29:51Stuff it's much harder to test and write tests for and maintain those test I changed things

1:29:56and you know either refine the design of a you know add buttons and.

1:30:00Here's a list of around like it's it's much harder to test for I don't know I don't end up writing a lot of the like

1:30:05easily testable faceless module math that's that's very unusual for me to write a lot of that

1:30:11but you gotta know you've got the F. Something devious not to see it at C.

1:30:16Model

1:30:17and somebody else wrote Chester that this is why open source is great like that that's something that's another thing

1:30:23an open source does because most open source cultures have a culture or I'm going to say most in our culture vulture

1:30:28but I'm always depressed and I when I download something on target and you know run configure make an error

1:30:34and make tests and it says no make That's not what you're talking about and like but

1:30:39but yeah most most of the newer software culture is in dynamically reasons than Amy jobs from stuff like testing is

1:30:46part of the culture if you really something as open source you're kind of expected this social pressure to say where is

1:30:51the test suite. How can I tell that this works on my system I want to immediately you know run the test suite.

1:30:57Perl is super crazy on the testing thing where you want to even install modules

1:31:02and they don't pass their test unless you know the secret incantation to tell it don't bother running the tests

1:31:06and that runs into all the N.T.

1:31:08Parents I talk about like well tests or software too

1:31:10and the people who wrote them aren't infallible so a lot of times the model won't stop because the test won't pass

1:31:14but the tests are wrong and because they were written by another fallible human and you know it's you go too far

1:31:20and that direction as well but overall it's it's a good idea to do you know test until it hurts basically and then

1:31:29and then back into the goodness right so we good.

1:31:37Thanks a lot to our three sponsors this week influx by brave wave King and Squarespace and we will see you next week.

1:31:49Now that's a dental accidentals. Because it was that this was banks and then and she was sitting in the first place.

1:32:18It sets to that list and Michael.

1:32:49Gentlemen thank you for letting me have my moments and you know I want to talk about too

1:32:53but I think the promise of home of the knowledge is too big a topic it's like software development right to discuss

1:33:00software What do you think guys in the other thing is occurred to me that I was describing my experience with agile

1:33:08but I know that we're going to or I'm going to get much e-mail

1:33:15and is all that's not how it all is so you're calling scrum agile and agile scrum

1:33:18and you don't know what you don't get on that. I'm not looking forward to that at all.

1:33:22I'm just glad because last week when when I asked people to tell me what they were in the nation that about warnings

1:33:27and production I don't think I have I don't think we've ever gotten that much feedback and it was like seriously.

1:33:33Every time I check my email all day long there be three more and they were each five paragraphs long like it was.

1:33:40It was actually a lot to keep up with

1:33:43when you solicited like Tell me about the problems that you have it your work people will say we didn't solicit

1:33:47feedback on the show about her methodology.

1:33:50But when we get to things like if you were doing it right like you can put the butter in the coffee

1:33:55or whatever like that although I knew I'd like this kind of like you know you don't understand my.

1:34:00A religion is the true religion and you're doing it ever so slightly wrong

1:34:02and I give only you didn't eat shellfish you'd be fine like it that's what I was trying to get at the beginning of like

1:34:09the whole point to soften analogies like to take to attempt to impose order

1:34:14and to make things better than they could ever possibly be like. No software methodology can possibly do this.

1:34:19Like there is there is no the Silverball there's nothing you can do to make it as good as it can possibly be.

1:34:25You just have to decide what is the appropriate level of annoyance for the given task at hand

1:34:30and then there are many things to choose from and some are better than others and people write and tell us that

1:34:35but I don't think we're getting the absoluteness who are like you know pair program is the only way to do programming

1:34:40and we're not doing pair programming is doing it wrong

1:34:43and there's no way anyone who's not doing pair programming can be as good as some of doing pair programming.

1:34:49Well I don't think they will because they will listen

1:34:52and the thing is like that's the thing because he was like unless you have a time machine you can't beat us these

1:34:58things because software is like you know it's always different like you have to get the same exact people solving the

1:35:03same exact problem the same exact combine with the same exact knowledge about the Dome of the product they have your

1:35:08knowledge and you can find people who are identical who have this like it is impossible to validly A.B.

1:35:12Test because everything software engineers engineers do is novel in some small way.

1:35:19Yeah that's one of the problems with a lot of these things like you know

1:35:22and this I mean this is a problem in so many fields and so many so many actions but like

1:35:28when you can't really scientifically test the stuff very easily if at all then you know you might do something in your

1:35:37methodology and ascribe your success or failure to that thing when in fact it had little to do with it

1:35:42or nothing to do with it

1:35:43and that's why I look at some of so many of these things a skepticism like OK you did it this way and it worked.

1:35:49But if you did it some other way would it have also worked and it didn't work because of the way you did it

1:35:55or did it work because of the people and the conditions they were in. And there's all these.

1:36:00And he's like like I recently got into the the world of high end headphones

1:36:04and I mean the audio file world is comical in the things that it believes in and and I go on.

1:36:12On the head of fire the biggest headphone enthusiast forum

1:36:16and I have trouble relating to the people there because they're all talking about how they upgraded the cable to this

1:36:22new cable and how they can hear all sorts of things that cables can't actually make you hear

1:36:27and that all cables you know cables don't vary that much and it's all psychological

1:36:32and you're spending four hundred dollars on a headphone cable

1:36:34and like I can't understand these people because I know scientifically like what their what their thinking is invalid

1:36:43and what they're saying is wrong and and they're wasting their time

1:36:46and money doing things that are that are just totally placebo

1:36:50and I wonder how much of the methodology stuff is that same way wears what you wear you know you just you can't really

1:36:57say that helped you.

1:36:58Yeah I think I think individual people can tell what parts of the methodology they're using is helpful to them.

1:37:05Basically by by gauging their own performance that like I've gotten similar problems like this in the past

1:37:11and I've performed this way on it and it's take me this long and I've had as much difficulty and I know

1:37:16when they told me to do this I felt that I was going to have difficulty with it but I did a new thing this time

1:37:21and it helped me do it better and like that's like on an individual basis like I decided to use testing

1:37:26or I had a friend look at my code before I checked it into going to very informal code reviews

1:37:30or I clarify the requirements like that's you know becoming becoming a programmer and having experience

1:37:36and you learn what all those little things are.

1:37:38And that's also part of the frustration is if you're put into an organization where you're told to do X. Y. and Z.

1:37:43but Not this thing you know that helps you and you're like oh well you know I really I really do better

1:37:48when I'm pair programming or I can't stand pair programming it makes me unable to work.

1:37:52But the organization like it wants to have rules for everybody.

1:37:56They don't want to just do whatever the hell they want because then they felt like a man.

1:38:00That's that's the difficulty of the situation that's like even without A.B.

1:38:03Testing I feel like individual programmers can get a feel for the things that help them

1:38:07and want to repeat that you know as appropriate. The filling up of the cherub either at the audio file.

1:38:14Yes Dalton post about that today and he said he couldn't tell whether it's a joke or not either

1:38:19and I can tell you that or I can think about this but it seems like it's got to be but then you never know.

1:38:27Anything that is made for audio files promises better sound quality that has no basis in science has no basis in a B.

1:38:34X. Testing and cost a lot of money.

1:38:37It's probably not a joke that's that's the the loss of audio file crap out there is like yet some it's out there.

1:38:43They're serious and people are actually buying.

1:38:46Probably not a lot of people but enough people to make it worth selling a thousand dollar six foot cable.

1:38:51Yeah that is absolutely ridiculous but it works out to be a joke.

1:38:54When do we want to do a quick accent on neutral incorporated we want to save that for next week.

1:39:00We can do it honestly I really don't think there's much to say about it.

1:39:04I think why do you even say that you know others go. Now that's a top tier equivalent of how hard can it be.

1:39:11Exactly yeah I mean we knew about what they were calling I was in the car last summer

1:39:18and we knew this was in the works

1:39:20and there's some stuff in the Iowa seven point one S T K that's in beta still there's some stuff in there that that

1:39:27looks like it's probably related.

1:39:29And so this is not really a huge surprise

1:39:33and then even even like a month ago I think it was Steven transmit one of the one of the good I was hackers was leaking

1:39:40like screenshots of the simulator running with this thing with the card play interface anyway so it's not big news that

1:39:50this is happening.

1:39:51The important news I think is that it is twofold one that Apple's actually kind of working with the car manufacturer.

1:40:00Just to give a variety of input methods the Ferrari one that was demo was resistive touchscreen.

1:40:05The Mercedes one used to control wheel in a scream wasn't stuck screen at all

1:40:09and then some other one used to touch screen and so there's like they're showing off.

1:40:13There's a variety of different screen

1:40:14but which is important because if you look at the car screen control landscape as we've discussed many times it's all

1:40:21over the map and not everybody including our beloved B.M.W. Dailies touch screens at all.

1:40:28Lexus also stopped using them recently I believe that will probably still turn that filter to Toyota if it hasn't

1:40:33already.

1:40:35Whereas he's like a little remote dangles of some sort the remote knobs

1:40:38or pointer things are being very was more safe than touching the screen and certainly works a lot better.

1:40:43So it's nice that Apple is kind of adapting to what's out there to a degree.

1:40:49It's also not surprising that what they want is and what what this what car place seems to be is literally airplay.

1:40:58Basically it's like it's I.O.'s is creating the entire interface as a video

1:41:03and streaming it to the car's engaged system and taking over the video screen to weigh or play with a simple yes or so.

1:41:11So it's basically airplay video output at least so that Yes So Apple is taking over the screen so it's not surprising

1:41:20they're doing this.

1:41:21It's not surprising they got a few car manufacturers just to say we will do this in what will be news in the rest of my

1:41:28post but what will be news is

1:41:30when a lot of cars have shipped with this because that's still up in the air that could still not happen

1:41:36or they could still take a long time to happen

1:41:38and you know if if if if a few car makers introduce it on a few of their high end models for model year twenty fourteen

1:41:47and the future and let's say the chart like you know B.M.W. Has a thing called B.M.W.

1:41:52Apps if you want that in your car you can pay extra money in most cases on most of the models

1:41:57and so if the other manufacturers.

1:42:00Off a car play but it's a five hundred dollar option or two hundred dollar option

1:42:04or if it's an option roll it cost extra money at all and it's only on certain models.

1:42:09How long is it going to be before a lot of cars actually have this in the road and that could be a while.

1:42:16So there's you know there's two sides as a user if you buy a car with that that's great it works for you as a developer

1:42:21I think it's potentially a lot less interesting for a while unless it gets a meaningful installed base.

1:42:28I was kind of depressed by the announcement

1:42:29but it showed me is that like television thus far this announcement proves that cars are another area where Apple's not

1:42:38going to be able to make things better.

1:42:40As much as we want them to like television they have the little park and it does some things

1:42:44but it doesn't solve like the whole television problem

1:42:46and you know I go I was really hoping Apple would is go in there and solve everything like music but they're not.

1:42:51And cars same thing there.

1:42:52They come into we know like television it's all scripted you ation

1:42:55and everything there is forever like oh god apple please save us from these terrible car interfaces

1:42:59and they can't they just can't.

1:43:01Like what they're doing is saying you know please let us have access to your existing screen will you run your existing

1:43:08software and let us take over it briefly

1:43:10but that's not the way that's like saying please Johnny I have a design the i Phone four S.

1:43:15but All you get is what's on the screen.

1:43:17We're going to tell you what's surrounding it whether there's any buttons what they look like how big it is how much it

1:43:21weighs what the battery life is.

1:43:23But make a great product for us and as we've discussed some hits guys that are current here is was the neutral

1:43:28or on the show I remember it was neutral like the things that make a car interior like it's a holistic thing it's it's

1:43:35everything about it from the driving position and the visibility to how many physical controls large

1:43:41or how many virtual controls to how they interact with each other to the software the hardware it like it is one big

1:43:46whole thing

1:43:47and it's like unless Apple can design that entire thing they're not going to be able to ever really solve the problem

1:43:52and they can't design

1:43:53and hire them because they're not a car maker the same way they can't fix television because they don't know all the

1:43:56programming and they don't know all the television sets and you know.

1:44:00I guess they're doing the best they can in an ideal scenario.

1:44:03The integration required for this will shrink to some ten cent ship just like everybody has in their cars

1:44:10and they use that same chip to do interaction with Android and whatever else and it was like Well

1:44:14when you buy a car in the future whatever smartphone you have which was called phone because all phones are smartphones

1:44:19by this point we'll be able to throw up with you on the screen and make something out of it

1:44:24but that interface is always going to be less satisfactory than it would be if there was one.

1:44:30One design thought for the entire thing.

1:44:31You can't just make some rectangle on your car and say this is the rectangle or smartphone stuff happens

1:44:37or maybe there's some buttons on the steering wheel that activate

1:44:39and do stuff like you're never going to get the right really good interface with the interaction of everything

1:44:45and less someone designing the whole thing and I believe car manufacturers are not thus far capable of design

1:44:50or thing and Apple is not allowed to design the whole thing so we're kind of stuck with this crap for now.

1:44:55I guess you know the thing I've noticed is I had a heated

1:45:00but friendly debate with Dave nany in who writes the excellent software super dooper which if you don't have you should

1:45:08and he was extolling the virtues of the Tesla interface and I have not interacted with it myself

1:45:17but he was saying that it's it's extremely good and it's touchscreen done right

1:45:23and I knew it in neutral I am quite the humanly set I hate touch screens in cars and and I stand by that to this day

1:45:31but I've not seen the Tesla interface and Ne Ne and among others he was the only one

1:45:37but he was an example of somebody came out of the woodwork saying oh my god really the Tesla interface is so good in

1:45:42this is so bad and he in in a series of tweets that this might of been a direct message between the two of us

1:45:47but he said to me it's like back O. S. On the phone. Do we want that. Or another example is i O. S. On the Mac.

1:45:54Is that really what you want and whether I'm not sure if I agree with him or not because.

1:46:00Although I really don't like the name Car Play screens I saw I liked but his point is absolutely interesting

1:46:08and worth thinking about. Like is this really is this really the right answer.

1:46:14Yeah I think the right answer has to involve more than just that screaming.

1:46:17Just look at the little home button like the U.I.

1:46:20Home button Why isn't there because they can't make a hardware home button like because they're confined to that little

1:46:25screen

1:46:25and like it said that their interest is probably going to be better than the i Pod integration the car makers have been

1:46:30shipping for years simply because like look it's not rocket science people can see disintegrate we gave you this

1:46:35interface to integrate with our you know i Pods I've got it in my hand like we can you can show the track name you can

1:46:41go next in previous track but you still did a bad you got the details wrong so just give us a screen and will do

1:46:46and I thought and you know will the Syrian to Gratian

1:46:48and like in many respects as many people pointed out there are advantages over the existing systems because like now I

1:46:54can upgrade my phone and I automatically get something better with car play and all that stuff

1:46:57but if for example you your car has a really slow U.I.

1:47:02and Car players like a lag

1:47:04or if you buy your two hundred grand Ferrari is going to reduce the touchscreen upgrading your phone's not going to fix

1:47:09that with a touchscreen upgrading from not going to add a physical button

1:47:12and if your car you why has one touchscreen and they use that touchscreen for climate controls

1:47:17but then you have the car play thing out you have to get out of car play just to change the temperature

1:47:20and you wish that it had a knob. It's not going to fix that either.

1:47:23So I really I really wish there was like sort of a single minded holistic approach in the race

1:47:29and that's why I think Dave likes this tussle so much because that's a case where the car maker does do the whole thing

1:47:34and they do concentrate heavily on touch screen type interfaces

1:47:37and it does come together in a manner better than most other cars

1:47:40but I mean the Tesla For example I think it should have more physical controls

1:47:44and it's definitely a version one point software and it's kind of snappy as like an actual i Pad is

1:47:48and it's like we see the technology for all this is there is just not like the correct arrangement of the people with

1:47:54the technology and the people who make the cars to to make it happen. Yeah.

1:48:00I'm very very intrigued by this I think it has a lot of potential.

1:48:05One of the things I've noticed is that to me the look of Iowa seven made a lot of sense

1:48:12and on screen I don't know why but I'm not that's not to say I don't that that I dislike it on either vices

1:48:19but I actually really really really liked the look on the Ferrari a Mercedes

1:48:26and vile involve a video demo the bar is low I think I think there was you know I I mean I guess I should show you the

1:48:32screen shots of my Honda view I look like if I go web page one hundred ninety five

1:48:36and I could make my favorite part of the Ferrari video was when the Apple raffle was demo ing it.

1:48:43She's showing that you can switch back to the Ferrari interface easily well if you want you can to happy years switch

1:48:50to the to the F.-F.

1:48:52Interface but will just go right back for a second and it just looked awful and this is a brand new Ferrari.

1:49:00The interviews with her renders

1:49:01and then switch right back to this nice clean Apple world because like that's not Ferrari's expertise is not in user

1:49:08interface design for the touch screen cars like that is not where their strengths lie

1:49:12and it's never going to be unlike in this respect I'm afraid like oh finally someone could take over some of the stuff

1:49:18but but still it's like you have.

1:49:19Not everyone's going to have a phone or plug it in so you have to have an interface there

1:49:23and just the standard is so low for these for these interfaces that you know they're I don't know what the solution is

1:49:31like. Again Tesla at the very least they're taking it seriously and saying we're going to have a different U.I.

1:49:36We're going to take ownership of it we're not just going to have some sort of generic touchscreen

1:49:41and we're going to have some third party write the software

1:49:43and put like our logo above it into different background color and call it a day.

1:49:47I know other companies do much more than that

1:49:49but like it's a difficult problem it's difficult on many levels to figure out what the best balance is between physical

1:49:54controls and touch controls and all the modern features people expect an integration of their devices so I think.

1:50:00Our play is a step forward but it's a small one like Apple T.V.

1:50:03Was a step forward too but it's a small one I think it's worth asking what problem this solves for everyone involved.

1:50:12Now you know to me a lot of the audio functions of it are solved perfectly well by Bluetooth

1:50:19and Bluetooth is extremely convenient because when done right

1:50:22and it's usually pretty well in cars surprisingly because there's not much to it.

1:50:27When done right I can I have you know overcast on my phone and if I'm in my house and half of a washing dishes

1:50:34or whatever I'll play a pod cast and then if I go to my car to go to the store I get in the cart in the car on

1:50:40and just are driving and a few seconds later my podcast are playing to the car speakers when I turn the car off.

1:50:46It pauses and sees my position and then when I go back inside I can resume it and play inside

1:50:53and all that works without having to plug the phone into the car without having to wait but I mean to launch anything.

1:50:59It just I get in the car the phone happens to your pockets always in my pocket and it just works.

1:51:04You have a way to pause the audio yet through the car's built in wheel controls

1:51:08and stuff because you know because the car using the built in protocol the car can can signal basic things like play

1:51:14pause you know track forward packs of like that can you change playlists

1:51:19and stuff this is like the simplest possible scenario that you're describing where you're in the middle of an audio

1:51:23and you know you like what you're playing.

1:51:24But like I don't agree that is that's a step up from what you would have heard of them before

1:51:28but like even a slightly more complicated snare like I'm going on a trip and I want to hear this song

1:51:33or this playlist that's a place where car play would have your back because it's like I know how difficult it is to you

1:51:39know using my stupid onscreen control even if I have my i Pod plugged in to find the playlist I want to select it to

1:51:46you know enable

1:51:47or disable shuffle to you know to do all that stuff with a touch screen with a touch screen with them

1:51:52but my stupid control is terrible and serious probably also kind of terrible but it's better.

1:51:57I would rather shout something out to my car.

1:52:00They don't want to play the new nothing the Bluetooth doesn't solve that at all because look it doesn't give you like

1:52:04here that here's a visual interface to like all your playlists are all your songs now go find the one you want right

1:52:10it's merely like a wireless version of an audio cable

1:52:13and so card play I think is a step up from that even if it lacks the seamlessness of you to be able to get into your

1:52:18car.

1:52:19Oh yeah I mean for podcasts I think the difference is a lot smaller because you tend to listen to one pod cast for much

1:52:25longer and then you listen to one song

1:52:26and you tend not to have to do serious navigation to find the Podcast you want to hear at this moment like Generally

1:52:32you put it on whatever's on you keep listening to the hour and fifty minutes long. So it's not a bigger problem.

1:52:38Like as music I agree you're right and obviously a lot more people listen to music than park asked

1:52:44but you know this just just pointing out that Bluetooth Bluetooth convenience is pretty severe competition for this at

1:52:52the start for audio functions and Bluetooth also everywhere already.

1:52:56Look at this in so many cars now it's you know so many new models include it.

1:53:00It's been around forever so there's so many cars already on the road with Bluetooth that it really does solve all these

1:53:04problems in a pretty limited but very effective way. So where where car play I think will really shine is navigation.

1:53:15In theory but I think in practice this is still i OS maps I.O.'s navigation and trying trying to replace a car system

1:53:26or either trying to you know sit on top of a car system that's being ignored or be present in cars that have screens

1:53:34but don't have now which is not a ton of them. But you know certainly there's still there's still some.

1:53:41And is that really what you want I mean usually a car's built in nav is not that bad

1:53:47and it's also all loaded all offline all you know built in ready to go it has the high precision G.P.S.

1:53:53Transmitter on the air receiver on the car and like in my opinion the G.P.S. That's built in.

1:54:00Two cars that have never been is usually way better and more consistent. No one the one in Iowa City.

1:54:07Well I mean maybe in an M five that's true

1:54:09but I think the big advantage it has is that as your car ages assume you keep it for a while your phone will get better

1:54:15and the navigation presumably will get better you know what I mean whereas whatever navigation your car came with

1:54:19that's an avocation is going to have that in my experience is what happens when I get into someone's car

1:54:23and it's like an eighty year old car.

1:54:25They're not a geisha is a gross looking at they bought a modern car better

1:54:28but I think the key is that to do navigation Well you need to integrate with the rest of the car like Marco said from

1:54:34the antennas that you're getting the signal from instead of having a tiny little device inside an arm rest plugged into

1:54:39a cable underneath a big steel roof all way up to like you know eventually we're going to they are going to realize

1:54:45that you're going to want to show stuff on the hood you're going to want the navigation is no maybe areas we want to

1:54:49know the speed from the speedometer and angle of the wheels instead of having to get that info from G.P.S.

1:54:54and Then reckoning like there's so much more you can do when you did navigation built into the car than

1:54:59when all you get is to be.

1:55:00I'm a phone I don't have a Geisha

1:55:02and I can project my image on to the screen like it's it's such a weak solution to come to a common problem that cars

1:55:08have been solving for years on their own.

1:55:10Well the other problem is Markos navigation in your brain U M five is excellent

1:55:15and the navigation in my twenty's eleventh Street series is pretty darn good.

1:55:19I'm actually very glad I got I got a car with navigation because I was in the plan

1:55:23when I went looking for for use three series.

1:55:26However even though I think the build date on the car was December twenty ten in the three years since the car's been

1:55:36built the local area has changed quite significantly and so if for no other reason even the you why left alone.

1:55:46There's an extreme advantage in having your phone do your navigation because the maps get updated

1:55:53and I'm not talking like the you why I'm talking the actual data gets updated and I'm working right now.

1:56:00How much it would cost to get my maps upgraded from B.M.W.

1:56:04and I need to pay for a forty dollar in ninety cents US speak he said that just gets me to keep on top of that I need

1:56:12to pay two hundred four dollars and eleven cents for the actual maps themselves.

1:56:17So I'm in two hundred fifty bucks to get an update for the nav on my car

1:56:23and one of these days I'll probably pony up for it because after three

1:56:27or four years it gets to the point that you're you're really in need of it because a lot of the streets I go to I

1:56:34shouldn't say a lot.

1:56:35Some of the places I go to they just don't clean don't exist on the navigation in my car so that's a bummer.

1:56:45Additionally traffic lately as mentioned by David T.

1:56:49Moves in the chat traffic lately is way better coming off the phone than it does my car in my car does accept

1:56:55or does receive traffic and it's good but it's certainly not foolproof.

1:56:59And the with the advantages that ways brings among other things with the kind of crowd sourcing traffic reports.

1:57:07It's almost always going to be better navigation on the phone so yeah right now your M five is wonderful

1:57:13but I'd be curious to see if you said that in three or four years.

1:57:17Another example of your car aging and not doing well with the tech

1:57:20but like I think the root problem is right now it's unacceptable for someone's home to not have an internet connection

1:57:27but it's a couple of a Karsten out emanation there is

1:57:29and I was like I don't want to pay for two wireless build out on my car to have a separate connection like that's a

1:57:34symptom of the market the shape of the market now like what we would want is as time goes on as cars get better ones

1:57:39like inevitably cars need to have network connections in cars need to auto update their maps

1:57:43and they need to not charge like your car is old so it doesn't do this

1:57:46and modern cars still don't have internet connections but they can get one through your phone maybe

1:57:49or actually we're doing the reverse here and saying no car you still can't have an internet connection

1:57:53but my thing that I have that has an internet connection it's allowed to spray it image up on your screen you're

1:57:58allowed to send it in but standard.

1:58:00Like you know not too far in the future if we ever get the stupid carrier stuff sorted out

1:58:05or like we have a better wireless that like cars need to have internet connections just like homes need to like what

1:58:11mine does. Even my twenty ten built car does and if I subscribe to like the Super Bowl or B.M.W. What is a B.M.W.

1:58:19Assist which kind like On Star I can do basic Google location searches from the car

1:58:26and certainly up until Google freakin ruined Google maps recently I was able to send addresses from Google to my car

1:58:36which sounds silly but oh my god it's the most wonderful thing in the world.

1:58:39And so my car has some modicum of Internet connectivity

1:58:42but that doesn't really terrible software right in the end you to be honest you're on a kind of different point which

1:58:49is it should be able to do a lot more with that Internet connection than receive extraordinarily small packets of

1:58:56search results and addresses.

1:58:58Yeah they were we see all the pieces we know what i Pads like we know what i Phones like

1:59:02and we know all the things that could be useful to cars

1:59:05and it's like we have this tech it's not that expensive compared to the cost of a car.

1:59:10We know people know how to write software to do this but they're not at the car companies

1:59:14and like it was going to get these guys together

1:59:16and that's kind of like you know we're hoping in the Apple announcement

1:59:19or something like maybe they will get together maybe Apple by Tesla and be able to do the whole experience

1:59:23but they're they're still so far apart in the things we know today are technically possible to do they're out

1:59:29financially feasible or just not organizationally feasible like we can on vision.

1:59:34You know like why is the car the separate realm where we can have the nice things that we know exist.

1:59:40Why do we have to choose between navigation and integrated with our car.

1:59:44But it's crappy in other ways and that is you know fast and responsive and can respond to voice commands

1:59:51and get its maps updated all the time but is not integrated with the current anyway.

1:59:55You know I don't see where it goes for sure. Now I'm going to be very jealous when my car can't do it.

2:00:03Cops have to give me one three the only answer I wonder to like like how how much of Car Play will will fail to be

2:00:12useful to people who aren't totally bought into the Apple ecosystem like there's a whole lot of features in Mavericks

2:00:20and Iowa seven where like if you don't use a far as your browser for instance then that doesn't work right for you

2:00:27or if you don't use by clouds reminders or calendar or whatever

2:00:33and so you know how much of that do you think will apply to Car Play where obviously it's very much based on SIRI

2:00:40and actually in you know one topic is third party apps integration with it

2:00:45and Apple as far as I know they have not clarified whether anybody will be able to make an app that uses this

2:00:53or whether this is partners only like Siri and it sure looks like its partners only to start at least and

2:01:01and so you know to what degree will this be limited if you choose not to have a not to use Apple services for

2:01:13everything or Apple's apps for everything.

2:01:16Yeah Google Maps and I was having for example like what if I don't want to use up all that maps on whom. Right exactly.

2:01:23Yeah I don't I think we're going to have to limit it probably you know if you realize like safety legal reasons like if

2:01:32you're allowed to you know we always wrote about like you can even enter the destination of where you're going to your

2:01:36car is not moving in the car manufacturer but that into their navigation right.

2:01:41What speed is it safe to play flappy birds on your airplane if you're you know it's only one tap it we can send that

2:01:47over to our playwright that's really the input that'll work with the i Drive not just hit the knob the flap of the

2:01:53cover they have the case he was having the Dave in the Twitters was I recall.

2:02:00It's growing like touch growing like it is now.

2:02:03That's not quite as natural as you might think it would be

2:02:06when you're in a moving car versus a button the resulting in a battle like the resist a touch screen of the Ferrari as

2:02:11it has that punters this terrible right.

2:02:13But like it even without that constraint you know what's the easiest way to find something in a long list

2:02:20when you're in a moving car.

2:02:21Because like scrolling through a list is great when you're looking at your phone your hand is looking with some

2:02:26but your eyes are on the phone the whole time when you're

2:02:28when your eyes are supposed to be on the road you know if you flick

2:02:32and look back at the road look back down you're past that like maybe that's not of us

2:02:35and are very That's why I keep going back to Syria is what I keep telling Syria because that's what you want you want

2:02:39to.

2:02:39Eyes on the road but still get done what you want to get done and that's one of the strength also of knobs

2:02:44and dials as if they have little things you can feel them clicking you know how far you're going

2:02:48or you can feel so much in the ON

2:02:49or OFF position you don't have to take your eyes off the road it's a different environment

2:02:53and the things that work great and i Pads and i Phones U.I.

2:02:56Wise don't necessarily work the same way on the phone that's why I think carpet looks so different

2:03:00and it is so like sort of Spartan unlimited

2:03:02and they keep them going serious like they don't want to say oh great now it's exactly like mounting my pad to my

2:03:08dashboard mounting your i Pad your dashboard is dangerous in terms of like what you can do to distract yourself

2:03:13and car play I think is trying very hard not to be that dangerous so that's why I would imagine it's not going to be

2:03:20open season

2:03:20or if it is open season the things that third party apps are allowed to do through the interface is going to be so

2:03:24limited that it's not going to allow you know before he burned up there are you know play a movie

2:03:30or something in the front of your car right now actually. So the new stuff that's in the Iowa seven point one S.T.K.

2:03:38Looks like it would be a way to be

2:03:41and whatever I can say it looks like it would be a way to have arbitrary apps be usable from the screen

2:03:49but only present like a structured menu kind of like your i Pod that would be you

2:03:55or your entire interface could be the structured menu and you have a few limited things you can do.

2:04:00But you're not you know you know just given an arbitrary view that you can do it if you want with it like put a game

2:04:06and I like those menu items

2:04:08or bespeak a bowl like you'd probably put in some it is say if they say this that's what they mean like if they had

2:04:12boys and you know they wanted to be simple interface you can do some crazy thing

2:04:16and also ideally you would have touchscreen and all that you could like activate the app

2:04:20and say you know like they were showing you know play a song name whatever or if you open a menu of options.

2:04:26Pick an option which is send text

2:04:27and then you know Katie that would send a text it was you know like that type of integration and that's what I mean.

2:04:34It's kind of boring if you look at it you know like oh it's like it looks kind of like a car you IOW it's a bunch of

2:04:39items

2:04:40and the thing is sometimes it's not even it's not even a response of the expected to be because of whatever the crappy

2:04:46host operating system of the host hardware is so it's still a far cry from the performance that experience of having an

2:04:53i Pad in the dashboard. But you probably wouldn't want to have that anyway in terms of the U.I. The U.I.

2:04:58Has to be simpler

2:04:59and different because it's not the same as knowing I've been using it by the way I should mention that what was news to

2:05:06me anyway I believe news to everyone was that car play will support things like the drive controller which I consider

2:05:14to be a tremendous win despite Dave maney and flow for touch screens and cars

2:05:20and I'm still of the opinion that having a physical control is a much much much better way of doing things

2:05:26and so having having some amount of integration with things like the I drive controller I think is very important

2:05:34and a very welcome bit of news that I didn't know before.

2:05:38Oh yeah definitely and that's me too like when I

2:05:41when I saw that the you would expect knowing Apple that easily do things you would expect they would say aren't

2:05:47everything that we that we support has to be a touch screen period like enraged dictate that

2:05:52and then you know to manufacture and sign up and no one else will.

2:05:55And maybe that's why we haven't heard of it I was in the car for almost a year. Maybe they were.

2:06:00One plan was to dictate that and they could get enough supported them

2:06:02and slowly backsliding finery that at that screen there and find you can do the job

2:06:07or put the home button on the screens as you guys can find a spot for it on your dashboard is not going to change your

2:06:12dashboard for are you like

2:06:13and they were probably all saying We also want to be able to do the same with Android so nothing you do can preclude

2:06:19someone playing in their Android phone to do whatever the hell they're going to do for that. Right exactly.

2:06:25I think the new stuff and seven point one It doesn't say it's work or play

2:06:30and it doesn't say much of anything actually there's not a lot of documentation for but the new stuff

2:06:35and seven point one sure looks like this is what it's for

2:06:39and it's a way to create a hierarchy of menus for things that could be music or could be anything.

2:06:45So that would mean that both overcast and fast text would in theory work over car play

2:06:53and whether it's integrated with Siri is a different story

2:06:55and they could be might not be might be limited in who knows. But that's that's a different story entirely.

2:07:02We are very interested interested to see whether they do something you know he's connected apps where you have to be a

2:07:11blast partner in order to get access and be interesting.

2:07:17Rights can long titles menace macro's good save that action now you get to suffer and you get to hold back

2:07:24and wait till next weekend.

2:07:26Well the funny thing is there's not that much to say about it really it don't know don't ask don't go there.

2:07:31This is going to be a short topic. Don't go there.

2:07:34The biggest thing I noticed so far is it is noticeably faster not by like an earth shaking amount as what I had before

2:07:42was already fast but it is noticeably faster the I was definitely faster.

2:07:47What is most noticeable by far besides how cool it looks is how much quieter it is I mean that's like it's shocking how

2:07:55quiet this thing is and I have always been of the opinion the mac pros were always pretty high.

2:08:00Why you know compared to what they were doing to any other tower P.C. That you would have.

2:08:05They were always pretty quiet

2:08:07but now that I have this in the same room with an across through most of his old MacPro it's a big big difference in

2:08:14the noise and John if you want of getting one of these things which you probably won't and probably shouldn't

2:08:18but if you do of getting one of these things that I think is what you will notice first just so it's such a big

2:08:24difference.

2:08:26OK one eventual simming the song cycle is one of the cheese grater inevitably elegantly I want yes I'm looking for that

2:08:32in the size like a thing of there on your desk like Next your water glass practically being the size of your house like

2:08:37this is going to be set I mean I'll have more leg room.

2:08:39Presumably they'll be a few were cables draped from the top to the bottom of my desk. You know I mean ice.

2:08:46Yeah it is really cool.

2:08:47So titles

2:08:48and I'm actually I'm not touching the case because I've seen take a lot of people that are like you know the covered in

2:08:53fingerprints.

2:08:54So I pick it up by Philip goes through from the top

2:08:58and I set it all up I didn't touch any part of the case at the very part

2:09:02and I wiped that off with a microfiber cloth and this new that you hear that's a stain.

2:09:09But you would if it was playing you know that there are the never mind titles titles.

2:09:16I know this is one of my suggestions

2:09:18but I kind of like it because who suggested it Dave who thinks we just invite underscored here

2:09:23and Smith I didn't mean another think about it it's funny and I think that's a title that will be difficult to guess.

2:09:31Well I guess if you know the software itself that you can guess

2:09:34but I find that once I didn't get it how close it is hell is other people I was held other people's code.

2:09:42I guess that's why I was amazed

2:09:43when someone buys a software product like Mars that people buy like other apps that companies don't want anymore I'm

2:09:51like that's like my worst nightmare getting someone else's pile of code done by under me

2:09:55and you know we're going to see it before and it will be like that. You know here you go.

2:10:02You paid a lot of money for this hope you can make a good go of it.

2:10:05Hope it's not too crazy if it came with the other person and they were my flavor of the rest of their lives

2:10:10and I'm like What do you mean by this is what I'm doing way what is the purpose of this class.

2:10:14Described to me you know

2:10:15and if they didn't know I couldn't beat them around them so you never thought about what the Bourbons glass was that it

2:10:20just does stuff.