Podcast Search

The Accidental Tech Podcast

56: The Woodpecker

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00Given your musical taste I bet you like Coldplay. I do like a play.

0:00:04I prefer Radiohead but I like

0:00:05or play I prefer energy that's probably a perfectly reasonable joke that I just did not get. No you got it.

0:00:17So John tell us about the found format.

0:00:19There we mention this in the show we talked about script notes fountain is that markdown like format they used to write

0:00:26screenplays.

0:00:28And at the time that I brought we were of the second time I said it was invented by John August

0:00:33and someone tweeted me to just clarify it was created by John August and you said he

0:00:38and Stu mash with so three people created not just on August don't want to just give credit to the one guy who happens

0:00:43to have a podcast that we listened to and talked about and are still talking about.

0:00:47They go into I mean like this is the thing about the correction that that small. Like I think it's worth correcting.

0:00:53But like you have no place to correct for it except in the follow up so like if I just read about it I had to remind

0:00:59everyone of us has a park has also follow me on Twitter some progression has been on the podcast no way around it

0:01:03usually thought this this minuscule I exclude But I think crediting is worth putting in.

0:01:10Right so software complexity

0:01:12and you guys remember what I said about software complexity last week it was a second only to parenting something like

0:01:19that.

0:01:20I you know as always I relisten to the show I was like I don't want to make sure that I remember what I said

0:01:26but of course I relisten the show so long ago that I've since forgotten

0:01:29but I personally got a lot of feedback about this I don't know if all of you guys did

0:01:34or didn't come to the Form a little bit came to the feedback from but I got a lot of tweets a lot of snarky angry

0:01:40and questioning tweets.

0:01:42Oh that's right because I saw Dr Dre call you out on it and you said that you would correct him in my words not yours.

0:01:50You said you would correct him and the next episode

0:01:52and I'd forgot about that now I'm very excited to hear where this is going. Yeah so it was like an offhand comment.

0:02:00The fact that a software is the most complex thing made by humans or something similar that you know right after

0:02:06and parenting at the end is a joke

0:02:07and it was imprecisely worded because I thought I was referring to an idea that everybody knew like I was referencing

0:02:14something that was shared knowledge with me in the audience and we all knew about it

0:02:18and most of us probably agreed so I could just you know say something vague

0:02:23and be like oh he's referring to that idea and then put the joke about parenting at the end you know whatever.

0:02:30But that like that was not an expression that's not a complete expression of what I meant

0:02:34and which is not surprising to me that so many people heard that

0:02:36and misinterpreted it because if they don't know what the heck I'm talking about the words I said were not as Actually

0:02:42what I meant.

0:02:44So did you see what you saw darting during being about her but what did you guys think I meant

0:02:51or think I was referring to or did you know what I was referring to.

0:02:54I did not I thought you were being genuine I didn't think you were being.

0:02:57I thought you were being playfully snarky like you were you're trolling in a in a not jerky way in a funny way.

0:03:05You're going to make me go off on a tangent about the definition of trolling because I have a fairly precise definition

0:03:12of trolling which is intentionally saying something you don't believe to get a rise out of people.

0:03:17That was not what I was doing.

0:03:19People use trolling to mean just like saying something that gets people angry

0:03:23but if you really believe it you're not trolling you are expressing your actual anyway. Forget about trolling.

0:03:30So here's what I was referring to I think I can sum it up reasonably concisely

0:03:33and I'd just like ramble a lot at the end until every second of the topic

0:03:39and I had to look this up because it was another thing that assume everybody knows that they don't like saying that I

0:03:46can remember seeing like for decades I don't know where it came from

0:03:48when I google for it I got attributed to some name but not a timestamp

0:03:52but the last place I can be sure I remember seeing it in the first place I can be sure I remember seeing it on Usenet

0:03:58and signatures.

0:04:00It was an everybody got sick kid or that's a guess and it's the thing and you tell me if you've heard this before.

0:04:07If builders build buildings the way programmers write programs the first woodpecker that came along would destroy

0:04:11civilization have you heard that one before now.

0:04:15Very popular saying back in the early days of the internet it was of that segues.

0:04:19I'm sure predates the internet because programming certainly does.

0:04:22I founded credited to General Weinberg but I don't know if that's accurate.

0:04:28I only did five minutes of looking up his muscles doing research.

0:04:31All right so good boy so this is the that saying what it's trying to get at is like the first premise behind the idea

0:04:39that I'm getting at is that software has more problems than other seemingly similar things like other forms of

0:04:46engineering and construction

0:04:47and stuff like that that's what they're saying is like well the people who build buildings if they were as crappy as

0:04:51programmers woodpeckers would destroy civilization. That's that's idea number one like that.

0:04:56There are always bugs in software and sometimes they're super really serious bugs not just minor ones

0:05:03and soft even software written by the very best programmers of various practitioners the entire field.

0:05:08Those have big problems too right.

0:05:12And I think everyone can agree on that if you write software a living you know bugs are a fact of life it's not a

0:05:17default when I get really good programming I'll stop writing books that never never ever happen.

0:05:21Actually your bugs become harder to find.

0:05:24And that the quality of software I think we would all agree like that saying it's funny about the woodpecker destroying

0:05:29civilization because there is not just a grain of truth but a serious amount of truth behind that.

0:05:34Like people in other professions that seem similar certainly seen a hell of a lot more confident like the average is

0:05:41better

0:05:41and in programming particular does not like no matter how good you are you're never going to achieve a level of competence

0:05:48that you know that even close to the average of these other professions.

0:05:52All right so the second premise of behind the idea that I was referring to is that assume you agree with the fur.

0:06:00One is another big chain of things like if you disagree with me at any point they're not going to connect after kind of

0:06:04like if you said you have to kind of all the whole chain and if you disagree at any point well then oh well so

0:06:09but if you agree with the first bit the second bit is this the the first bit about software being crappier

0:06:16and the woodpecker thing.

0:06:17It's not because software developers are dumb

0:06:19or lazy like that is not because we haven't thought about programming is not because people haven't tried to figure out

0:06:27better ways we might be able to program is not because programming is super young that we've been doing this for

0:06:32decades and something that I think most programmers

0:06:37and most other people would agree with is that this nature of software that was discussed that have been crap revert

0:06:42things is because software is different in those other things and not because of any lack of effort or knowledge

0:06:48or skill or or you know the biggest because programmers are stupid or anything like that.

0:06:53We've had decades and decades of research and hard work

0:06:56and they have not really led to any big reduction in sort of the number of bugs per line of code

0:07:02or whatever whatever stat you want to put up like a programmer today versus a programmer writing something on punch

0:07:08cards error rate wise are probably pretty similar.

0:07:12And it's not for lack of trying to sound like well we've never really put an effort in trying to figure out how to

0:07:16write software that are you know we put a lot of effort into it and it's seems I'm I can say it's intractable

0:07:20but so far we haven't cracked it.

0:07:24And like the Fred Brooks things that I mentioned I want to show you know the mythical man month how adding manpower to

0:07:31a late project makes it later that is not true.

0:07:33You know building a bridge if you double your manpower you can probably build a bridge faster or you know

0:07:38and anything any sort of more scalable physical endeavor or building a skyscraper you got one guy building a country

0:07:43or boys can take forever. If you're running late if you add more construction workers up to point obviously I mean.

0:07:50But like this The Mythical Man Month is famous because it's such a counter-intuitive finding for software in particular

0:07:56and you know Fredricka there was no silver bullet.

0:08:00This is my mother's one hundred seventy five no syllable one hundred eighty six.

0:08:04Programming's been around since you know in its current sort of modern form since the fifty's sixty's right.

0:08:12So these are people trying to research what we can do to get better know so we're brought was that we've looked into

0:08:16this

0:08:16and it doesn't seem to be anything we can do that will really make us better programmers by like an order of magnitude

0:08:23used in the correct sense for all the people who are potentially correct and gave you about that.

0:08:28And these two sort of seminal works in the in the world in the software field are fairly old

0:08:34and I think most people accept them that like that.

0:08:38This this all comes together as like programming is for some reason we're really crappy

0:08:42and we can't figure out how to get that much better and it's not for lack of trying.

0:08:49And so that's that's where I'm coming from in this

0:08:51and the lots of silly misinterpretations of what I said which are probably accurate if you were to look at the words

0:08:57like should have been dismissed.

0:08:58This is something

0:08:59when you look at them really like give them the benefit of doubt assume they're not like really dumb because it's so

0:09:03easy as I have the exact words you said would only make sense if you meant you know mean this

0:09:08and that's a stupid idea instead of saying well you must I meant the stupid idea most about something else

0:09:12and it was not their fault my fault for saying the wrong thing.

0:09:14But so they misinterpretations that I'd like to dissuade people from now is one that programmers have the hardest

0:09:20profession in the world that's obviously silly pretty much any other job in the universe is harder than than

0:09:24programming at least like physically

0:09:26and emotionally like it's very hard to think of a profession that is easier than programming maybe you could think of

0:09:31some that might be easier mentally

0:09:33but that really depends on what kind of mental state you have if you have the type of brain that itself if it isn't

0:09:39going to be something to do then actually being a checkout clerk is harder mentally than being a programmer.

0:09:45But you know any any job is hard to physically almost all jobs are harder emotionally like it's trivial to think about

0:09:50a job so that's not what I meant.

0:09:52Software is the most complex thing in the world that is obviously also silly but there are some nuance I don't get to.

0:10:00Bit

0:10:00but like just to give an easy example the human body is obviously more complicated than any software we will probably

0:10:05ever write and people deal human body all the time in many forms not just doctors and all of us stuff.

0:10:12So here's what I did mean based on all those premises that I just described about software being the most complex

0:10:18things made by human.

0:10:21I just want one more sort of foundational thing you have to understand

0:10:25and agree with me what it is that software is written on top of an abstraction

0:10:30and that traction is what we call the hardware

0:10:32and it's an engineering task to make the hardware so I guess someone somewhere is responsible for making essentially a

0:10:38machine with the you know chips or transistors or whatever that provides an abstraction

0:10:44but software work in the world of ones and zeros.

0:10:46It's the hardest job to figure out the ones and zeros you know we are including after industry C.P.

0:10:51Use clocks you know phase loops power supplies all that stuff that's running hardware that is all to make an

0:10:57abstraction where it's like OK from this level up it's ones and zeros.

0:11:02Sometimes that's traction is leaky to use your parlance but that's not what we're talking about

0:11:07when we're talking about books.

0:11:08If only holding most of our bugs were attributable to hardware problems were the ones

0:11:12and zeros breakdown like that is not what causes most of our software bugs the hardware for the most part of a really

0:11:18amazing job of maintaining that ones and zeros

0:11:20and direction in our software bugs are not caused by that abstraction leaking are not caused by all of what actually

0:11:25took to a zero and that's what caused the bug no one caught the bug in your program with you writing bad code.

0:11:30There are hardware bugs and that's but that's not what we're talking about almost all the time in fact it's so novel

0:11:35and it's a hardware bug it's like an exciting story right.

0:11:37Whereas if you just make a software bug happens every day and above the ones

0:11:43and zeros layer we human beings we software people are responsible for everything

0:11:49and we have to write everything ourselves because you have libraries and O. S.

0:11:52Isn't free and works like we've built up this gigantic tower of stuff on top of those ones and zeros.

0:11:57But there is an expectation.

0:12:00And I think the founded expectation that every single thing in the giant tower of crap that we've built is

0:12:05understandable to a programmer the idea that software is for the most part pretty much nearly one hundred percent

0:12:13knowable by humans I mean to have it all in their head doesn't mean any human being fits the entire Like knows every

0:12:18single thing is happening the problem

0:12:19but it is unknowable understand what you want to look up what's happened you can find out all the way down to getting

0:12:24like the manual for the C.P.U.

0:12:26and Figure out what the machine code is and disassembling it like it is knowable doesn't mean you know it.

0:12:31But it means like the only thing stopping you from figuring it out like you have some super hard bug you keep digging

0:12:36down down down eventually going to get down to ones

0:12:38and zeroes in those one hundred zeros are noble you know Casey would know

0:12:41or any other gun person has done any kind of a thing where you build a C.P.U.

0:12:46Up from logic gates

0:12:47or if you learn how transistor works then you know how logic works a million to the world the one who the earth

0:12:51and you can very easily build a C.P.U. From those logic gates and work your way up. It's noble from top to bottom.

0:12:56Every single piece because we're building on top of these ones and zeros

0:13:00and I mentioned human body before which is way more complicated than a program

0:13:05but humans don't create the human body not in the way not in the way I describe everything we do

0:13:10but not like assembly going to be sometime so.

0:13:13So let's think about something like a bridge a bridge is also more complicated than any program we will ever write.

0:13:18In fact bridges are so complicated that we can't even like reason about them as they are we have to use approximations

0:13:24and models and stuff like that to figure out whether they're going to work right.

0:13:27Everything we do and that's have engineering has to be based on these models that are not reality

0:13:31but they're hopefully close enough and we refine them

0:13:33and everything like that because they're they're fiendishly complicated.

0:13:37That's another good thing you know you're saying the programs are so complicated What about a bridge like a pencil is

0:13:42more complicated than a computer program if you look at it at the atomic level so I think we can all agree that bridges

0:13:52are generally more reliable than software like actual bridges like bridges fall down dropping the cars into the ocean

0:13:58much less often than saw. Where just totally craps the bed and does the equivalent.

0:14:03And granted we've been building bridges for a long time

0:14:05but I don't think the Head Start really explains this because of you know the acceleration of technological advancement.

0:14:11So the analogy I would say is like programming is like having to assemble a bridge starting from subatomic particles

0:14:18and you're not allowed to know the current laws of physics and use them as a reference you have to invent everything

0:14:24and so you you build on the equivalent of libraries

0:14:27and frameworks of the equipment of librarian for I was in the bridge world it would be like

0:14:30but what if there's a bug in the gravity library What if the guy who wrote the steel molecule framework that left some

0:14:37corner case unchecked

0:14:38and at some point all the steel would turn to liquid at room temperature of a certain kind of car travels over the

0:14:43bridge that's what we're doing in the world of software and it's because the entire stack is both created by humans

0:14:50and noble by humans there is no sort of like well that's the way things work

0:14:54and will build models to you know to sort of approximate what's going on

0:14:59and using these here is actually going to be something reliable.

0:15:02Every single piece of it from the top of the bottom is no noble and changeable by the programmers.

0:15:06And so these things

0:15:08when I say software is the most complicated thing created by human I just made it more I could say software is the most

0:15:12complicated thing wholly created by human because it is wholly artificial.

0:15:16Like once you get above the ones and zeros all that ones if you're with us

0:15:20and there are no rules except the rules we make there is no gravity there's no laws of physics there's no you know

0:15:25physical properties there's there's nothing there is only what we make of it in every single layer that layer cake has

0:15:31bugs and nuances that are knowable to us but are not known to us

0:15:36and so that you know the higher we build the more chance there is that we don't understand something about cocoa that

0:15:42we think we understand and this thing ends up being like on allocated in the time we tried to access it

0:15:47or that there's a bug in the local library

0:15:50and it's revealed in some very strange corner case like nothing all bugs to do both in frameworks

0:15:53and everything like that all the way does turtles all the way down it's all humans writing programs you know that are

0:15:59no.

0:16:00But unknown and that's the world we're living in

0:16:02and that I think is describes the unique nature of software as being the most complicated thing that we make from top

0:16:08to bottom because it is completely artificial.

0:16:11The human body is not knowable because we do company

0:16:14but we're we don't make it we you know we're not responsible for no one expects you to know could you tell me what the

0:16:19electron in this atom in this person's eyeballs doing right now of course not

0:16:23but if someone asked you Can you tell me when this value is going to change. A You can actually tell them and B.

0:16:28You can understand what is happening

0:16:30and if you had a bug related to that little electron you should be able to figure it out.

0:16:34So I don't know if this is convincing as a bee as I keep piling on the assumptions I think most people were going to

0:16:39let on that software is bad and that it's not bad because programmers are lazy

0:16:43but I think most programmers will agree that the unique nature of software is essentially that it is really complicated

0:16:51in the realm of things that we make ourselves and every single part of us every single part of it is created by us

0:16:57and in theory noble but noble bias.

0:17:01We are sponsored this week by our friends at square space the on one platform that makes it fast

0:17:07and easy to create your own professional web site or online portfolio for a free trial

0:17:11and ten percent off go to squarespace dot com

0:17:14and use offer code critical square spaces constantly improving their platform with new features new designs

0:17:21and even better support.

0:17:23They have beautiful designs for you to start with

0:17:25and all the style options you need to create a unique website for you

0:17:29or your business you can start with over twenty highly customizable templates that have won numerous design awards

0:17:36and then you can modify those you can inject code you can use graphical adjustments any possible thing you can think of

0:17:42to change these things with C.S.S. or Custom field values and everything else you can do all that stuff.

0:17:47Very very easy use if you need any help with this though.

0:17:51They have an amazing support team that works twenty four hours a day seven days a week with over seventy employees

0:17:57working full time right here in New York City.

0:18:01Eight dollars a month and includes a freedom a name for a whole year up front and every every design.

0:18:08Not only is very customizable but it also has a response of mobile interface so your site looks like your site.

0:18:14Any device you can connect to your social accounts Twitter Facebook Linked In Pinterest Instagram google many more web

0:18:21and social services. They also have commerce functionality.

0:18:25You can build an entire e-commerce store right into your square space site comes free with every plan you know

0:18:31notational charge.

0:18:32So go to squarespace dot com today start a free trial and it's a free trial with no credit card required.

0:18:38A genuine free trial starts on the Web site see if you like it for free trial and ten percent off.

0:18:44Go to square space dot com and use offer code critical.

0:18:47Thanks a lot to square space for sponsoring our show once again.

0:18:51Now you guys want to get off this topic

0:18:53but I want to get both of your take on this realm which assuming you care I don't Casey.

0:19:00I I sort of do so as as someone who claims to be an engineer which is to say I went through an engineering program

0:19:08and had a relatively large university.

0:19:11I I feel like I can be extremely snobby about engineers vs non engineers for example.

0:19:20I think that Marco got an inferior education simply because his education was in computer science not computer

0:19:25engineering.

0:19:25So I wouldn't call it inferior I would just say that as a someone who also has an engineering degree the one thing I

0:19:31think we can rightfully get to do is lord it over the people who took what we considered to be easier majors. Yes.

0:19:36Is it inferior education.

0:19:38I don't know

0:19:38but is it harder to go in general is it harder to go through an engineering degree than it is to go through a computer

0:19:45science degree I would say in general for most people yes.

0:19:48And so that's the one little thing that we can hold up with some tiny amount of profit.

0:19:53Please e-mail them please e-mail us. Furthermore like you were saying earlier the difference to be between can.

0:20:00Engineering or science all kidding aside is that in principle when John

0:20:05and I graduated if not today we should be able to like John said follow software at a high level language like object

0:20:14of C. or or C. Sharp or or even Perl or P.H.P.

0:20:17or Whatever the case may be we should be able to follow that all the way down to NAND gates and so and so on

0:20:23and so forth within a proper even transistors within a processor.

0:20:26Just like John said

0:20:27and I think what's interesting is I can see why people like Dr drang who is air quote traditional engineer could be

0:20:37offended by John or me or anyone saying that the sort of thing we do is extremely complex

0:20:43or even the most complex as other thing we do it's thing we create and write right.

0:20:48The thing we create and so I can understand both sides of this and to me.

0:20:53I think the thing that makes the most sense is that for us by comparison

0:20:59and John you touched on this our our our industry our engineering discipline is so much younger so much younger than

0:21:09most of these other disciplines.

0:21:11You could argue that mechanical engineering for example has been around for a really long time hundreds of years at the

0:21:16very least if not many many many more than that

0:21:19and so because of that I think the reasonable argument for software being terrible

0:21:26and for us not being good at our jobs is that we're very we as a as a race as a as a race I guess you are just very

0:21:37ignorant and we're kind of amateurs at this.

0:21:40I don't buy that argument because of the accelerating pace of technology you're right that it's so much newer than

0:21:45structural engineering for example

0:21:46but technology if you like put any graph of like technological advancement after like the industrial revolution like

0:21:52the rate of change is accelerating so even though our thing came in much later in the timeline it came in after the

0:21:59bend in the high.

0:22:00So we've had the equivalent of millennia of technological advancement in software

0:22:05and yet we're not getting better at these things.

0:22:09Learning I don't buy that like and I think that contributes to it somewhat

0:22:12but I think I think the thing we're making because it is so wholly artificial and knowable

0:22:17and complicated that unique combination of factors like I spent a little while trying to think of something that has

0:22:23similar properties.

0:22:25I can think of science fiction things that have similar properties like you know building living beings from like you

0:22:33know doing D.N.A.

0:22:33Programming or stuff like that or building nanobots or maybe that or self

0:22:36or up like everything I think of that is that would be worse has some kind of place where we decide it is not knowable

0:22:44anymore like genetic algorithms or things were like well just let it go run off on its own

0:22:49and we'll do a some tiny simulation of kind of like what how life evolved.

0:22:53But we won't understand the reasoning or the functioning of all of us hope that the end product like works right.

0:22:58Can you think of one that has the combination of like totally made by humans also very complicated

0:23:07and no help from any pre-existing anything to start with like ones and zeros.

0:23:11Well no

0:23:12but you can argue that you know we're building on more building on physics as well just as much as a bridge builder as

0:23:18well but I think there's a clean break like.

0:23:20Yes the engineers who build the hardware Yes that's all physics obviously like that's here

0:23:24but I'm saying like there's a hard layer behind like that's the hardware

0:23:27and they do a great job with that because like it's there they're you know doing approximations based on the natural

0:23:32world and laws to tend not to change and everything.

0:23:35But once we get about that the ones

0:23:37and zeros we draw a hard line there we say look if anything happens below that that's not our problem isn't our fault

0:23:42that's not a software bug

0:23:43and in practice that's not where our that's not where our problems are like yet it does happen hardware fails right.

0:23:48But nobody blames the software gosh that people blame the software guys for all the other times something goes wrong

0:23:53then the hardware is functioning perfectly fine. Yeah I mean I don't know I did stuff because like I said I see this.

0:24:00Both sides

0:24:00and I understand what Dr Treng is offended by also a lot of pretty much no one surprisingly agree with everything you

0:24:06just said so we can move on from this summit to to see us in the chat room the ones that complex math.

0:24:14Yeah maybe that qualifies Although yeah kind of a lot of math to analyze that

0:24:20but what matters a little bit different in that it's less built and more discovered.

0:24:26You know it doesn't it doesn't do anything

0:24:28but you know everything is like you know you're discovering properties that were already there

0:24:34or you're building you know you're building new ways of expressing things that are already there

0:24:38and proving things that already work like it's a little bit different in that you're not like you're not as much a

0:24:44building up these whole systems of things that could be like three quarters wrong

0:24:48or you know would only work in you know eighty percent of the possible cases like usually math is a little more well

0:24:54grounded than that and it's more provable

0:24:56and you know kind of built more slowly over the years so that it's one hundred percent for a boy.

0:25:00That's what the find it like

0:25:01but like it's not you're not building a little machine to do something like math is a pleasurable to every machine that

0:25:06we make of course but like

0:25:07when you're doing math you're like you're not concerned you're not trying to make a thing to do something you're trying

0:25:12to you know sort of explore the nature of truth you know the only real truth we have some better make the

0:25:17mathematicians happy and other people suggested music and storytelling.

0:25:21Lots of things that human do is like love is more complicated

0:25:24but like it's much harder to define a bug in storytelling and music and stuff like that

0:25:31and those things are those are kind of executable where you can play them like the music doesn't like the music isn't

0:25:38isn't meant to like if it makes one person center than another that's not a bug if one person finds it boring one

0:25:44person finds it amazing that's also not a boat like it's not yeah it's difficult.

0:25:49Like again tons of things that people do are harder

0:25:51and more difficult more complicated than per se what what we make is programmers because it's so completely artificial

0:25:58and also so complex and. No no a thing.

0:26:01Nothing to stand on like it is the world of one of the theories that we have collectively built up

0:26:05and it is you know woodpecker would destroy it if it was made of wood

0:26:09and doesn't take it would take dust motes can kill floating there in the wrong spot

0:26:14and again like all the steel turned to liquid and when the yellow car runs over it and it would make a move on please.

0:26:20Really quick real time follow up Firstly it is math not maths.

0:26:24You people that are hailing from the British Empire are crazy and I know we have to but at least we got that right.

0:26:31And secondly when I said race earlier it's not about race I meant the human race last the species of humans.

0:26:38So before we get a thousand e-mails actually it's probably too late.

0:26:40So let's talk about software methodologies

0:26:43and do a little fault on that because Marco isn't already bitter enough a lot of people wrote in

0:26:48and said hey you got agile totally wrong and to some degree they were right

0:26:54and I should say that agile began as a manifesto and that manifesto all kind of get to you in a second

0:27:01but it was more about here's the things we value

0:27:05and less about here's the steps that you should take in order to do these things and what I had talked about

0:27:12and I think all of us had talked about was more hey when you're when you're a soldier on the ground so to speak

0:27:19and I mean that very very figuratively when you're when you're working developer this is what agile

0:27:26and scrum tend to mean and it tends to mean things like stand ups and stories and points and so on so forth.

0:27:33So those of you who wrote in about Agile being more about a series of ideals rather than a series of steps you're

0:27:42absolutely right and I should have specified that.

0:27:45Additionally a lot of people have written in and pointed to a post that was very pressure

0:27:50and worked out how the timing was great post by Dave Thomas not the Wendy's guy but the agile guy and his post is.

0:28:00Agile is dead long live agility and the T.L. D.R. Of that is.

0:28:05Hey agile in the sense of a series of things that you need to do really is kind of B.S.

0:28:12Again agile is really about here's the values that we have.

0:28:17So he says and I'm quoting from this article look again at the four values

0:28:21and these are the this is the Agile Manifesto that I mentioned earlier.

0:28:25We value individuals in interactions over processes

0:28:27and tools we value working software over comprehensive documentation.

0:28:32We value customer collaboration over contract negotiation and we value responding to change over following a plan.

0:28:40So that's the ideal. That's what agile really really is.

0:28:43So Dave goes on to say you know how to do it to prescribe standups to prescribe scrum to prescribe stories to to

0:28:52prescribe any of that is really B.S.

0:28:55So let's get back to the basics and he says here's how to do something in an agile fashion what to do.

0:29:01Find out where you are. Take a small step towards your goal.

0:29:04Adjust your understanding based on what you learned and repeat. And here's how to do it.

0:29:08When faced with two

0:29:09or more alternatives that deliver roughly the same value take the path that makes future change easier

0:29:16and I'm continuing to quote. And that's it.

0:29:18Those four lines in one practice encompass everything there is to know about effective software development.

0:29:23Of course this involves a fair amount of thinking in the basic loop is nested factoring inside itself many times as you

0:29:28focus on everything from variable naming to long term delivery.

0:29:31But anyone who comes up with something bigger or more complex is just trying to sell you something

0:29:35and to be honest this is pretty much right.

0:29:39This is true

0:29:40and I stand by our last episode I stand by all the things I said not on all the things that we said because agile

0:29:46and scrum as they are perceived today boils down to those things

0:29:50but if you really really try to break it down to what is the the genesis of all of this it's really programming

0:29:59or developing. With agility and that's what David's talking about.

0:30:02Yeah I read this thing to do

0:30:04and what it reminded me of is the idea that we see it played out many times that any idea whether it's a reaction to

0:30:13previous ideas are entirely novel new idea about how someone might do something better.

0:30:20Inevitably falls victim to the sort of innate human desire for simple answers like you know Fred Brooks no silver

0:30:27bullet. Everybody wants the silver ball right.

0:30:29And so if someone has an idea like Agile where it's like well you know I reaction to it like if you say the opposite of

0:30:36all those points like let's let's you know do a whole bunch of planning up front take big steps instead of small steps

0:30:41let's let's get a full complete understanding of the problem before we start instead of like getting the next any human

0:30:46to like their opposites of each other and in many ways agile as a reaction to methodologies that have come before it

0:30:50or you know systems of working that have come before

0:30:54but once you put it out into the world it does not take long for it to snowball into like the Silver Bullet people get

0:31:00their hands on and the books come out in the seminars and the courses and the consultants

0:31:03and like that is inevitable any idea doesn't mean the idea is wrong or dead or bad.

0:31:07Any idea you put out there

0:31:09or even any technology will be absorbed into the gigantic culture of things that that you know sort of give people what

0:31:16they want.

0:31:16People want to know that you can hire a bunch of consultants fell swoop in teach everyone in your organization how to

0:31:21do X. In the new way whether it be like six sigma or all those things that your dad could tell you about from the I.B.M.

0:31:28Days and you know quality first in the stack like someone's always selling Here's a new way you're going to work

0:31:34and it always gets perverted from what the original intention was made into a caricature

0:31:38and just becomes a money machine for consultants and other people

0:31:42and I don't think that they thought of the original ideas and it's kind of a shame

0:31:46but I think it's a natural life cycle of any idea about how people can do things better.

0:31:51So agile has traveled that path

0:31:54and so you know we see technologies travel that powerful time as well you know every technology everybody has somewhere.

0:32:00On a continuum and sometimes they wrap back around to get a second run out and change

0:32:03but it doesn't make me think any more or less or agile.

0:32:07I just think that I feel I feel a bit more comfortable with agile now now that it has sort of run through its first

0:32:14kind of burst onto the scene. Everyone has to do this.

0:32:17Actually it's not that great a backlash settling down to like yeah it's just one of those other ideas out there that's

0:32:23in the mix.

0:32:24And now we can refer to it our collective knowledge of it is enough in sort of a vague sense to say that's our

0:32:31counterbalance against you know waterfall or whatever like it's it's another idea that's out there

0:32:37and hopefully this point.

0:32:39We all know it's not silver bullet a mortgage we've gone through the back slapping backs backslash.

0:32:44My God give it back to last year just what the hell backlash the backlash phase

0:32:50and we're on to sort of the steady state now we're just waiting for whatever the next popular ideas I mean to do the

0:32:54same thing with extreme programming and pair programming like I like that life cycle I think it's valuable.

0:33:01I think just maybe like people who sort of come of age

0:33:05and like whatever ideas the first idea like that that they see they may drink the koolaid

0:33:09and think this is the one this is we're going to change everything but like if you've been through six

0:33:12or seven cycles that you're like oh well that's just the next new popular idea.

0:33:17Wait for it to sort of settle down and then we'll get the value out of a tester in development the whole nine yards.

0:33:23One thing that always also tends to happen with these ideas or methodology is like you know how when you

0:33:29when you try to explain something to someone who is really new at computers he try to explain or do something

0:33:34and the way they remember to do it you know they don't remember save the document.

0:33:39They Remember click on the File menu click on Save.

0:33:42You know like they remember the steps before they before they conceptualize the concept

0:33:47or you know it's probably very similar to how people in foreign languages

0:33:50but you know from from like translating in your head every word to becoming fluent.

0:33:54It's a difference between following procedures and really understanding and internalizing it.

0:34:00And you know agile was seemingly started by a group of people who really understood these concepts who really deeply

0:34:08got them and what once it started becoming this this procedure and you know steps that you could follow

0:34:15and you know part of that was their manifesto part of it was what everyone else added afterwards.

0:34:21You know then it loses the understanding and it started becoming like a manual a series of steps a procedure

0:34:28and it needs to be because in order to generalize that to a big organization this is where the difference is that we

0:34:33talked about last week between a small organization the big organizations.

0:34:38Once you generalize this past a very small group it has to be a procedure it has to be code a fighter has to become

0:34:44instructions.

0:34:45And inevitably Not everyone involved is going to be able to rise above that you know the letter of the law

0:34:52and figure and just and gain a complete understanding.

0:34:55And over enough time I think that's what kind of ruins these things because that happens on a on a grand scale to

0:35:02almost everyone involved in it.

0:35:05People don't want to understand the philosophy they just like just tell me what do I care what they want they want they

0:35:10want this over a book like it's not even to that they can't grasp it

0:35:13or like it they don't even want that they're like all right so you've done all that thinking.

0:35:16Now tell me what to do and it's like no you don't understand.

0:35:19Like in the future mentation understanding the ideas that led me to these practices will be much more helpful to you

0:35:24than the practices themselves and that's not something people want to hear.

0:35:29All right do we want to cover this question from Paul today or would we rather shelve that for another day.

0:35:35I'll bring it up because I actually was on the one on one added it so all right so a guy named Paul sent us a feedback

0:35:40form thing saying I'm a computer science professor

0:35:43and I'm always curious what particular things that we teach turn out to be useful in the end you would ask each other

0:35:49last week what one thing you would take from software methodology.

0:35:51My question is What are the one or two things from your C.S. Education that you find the most useful when coding.

0:35:59I mean for me.

0:36:00I would say it student I would say one is the operating systems course where we went all the way down into deep

0:36:08explanations

0:36:09and some some playing with like little seekers mostly people of what an operating system does in lots of different

0:36:16problems memory management scheduling interrupt stuff like that like you know the basics of what US is doing.

0:36:23That was very helpful to us because it gives me a major understanding of things that we have to deal with every day

0:36:30things like concurrency things like threading and locking

0:36:32and everything that it it really helps that memory management really helps to know that that sort of thing

0:36:38and the second thing for me is it you know at my school you know

0:36:45and I think this is common everywhere they were as they were a couple of like intermediate level courses where you

0:36:49basically just did like a new programming language every week for something

0:36:54and so we get to explore all sorts of different languages.

0:36:57Briefly shallowly but we get you know if we get some experience

0:37:02and the basic concepts of lots of different types of languages

0:37:06and that's the kind of thing that in the real world it's harder to get because it's harder to justify work harder to

0:37:11find the time for you know it's easy to fall into the trap in the real world which I'm certainly guilty of myself of

0:37:17you know just going really deep on whatever you do work and not really exploring lots of new things.

0:37:22And certainly there are so many new things coming out these days it's almost impossible to explore them all.

0:37:27But in a calm side to cation they at least they get when they kind of forced you to.

0:37:33And so like I know the basics of languages I've never used in the real world like lisp like I know the basics of Lisp I

0:37:38don't know if you sat me down in front of you know a list codebase until Mr working I would have some trouble it would

0:37:43take me a while to get back into it but like I know the basic concepts

0:37:46and you know stuff like that like there's that was a very a very valuable thing to me to to force me to experience a

0:37:54lot of new concepts that you wouldn't really ever have time or reason to in the real world most of the time.

0:38:01I would say that I actually exchanged a couple emails with John because I didn't realize that this was going to be

0:38:07covered in the show in action and I blamed John for heading into the show notes Little did I know it was you Marko.

0:38:12But what I had said to him was the thing that I think I value the most from my education which is going to sound really

0:38:21ridiculous but I stand by it.

0:38:23Is learning what a pointer is because pretty much all of the development that I've done professionally in C.

0:38:32Plus plus in C. Sharp even in Javascript and certainly an Objective C.

0:38:38All of that all of it comes down to it some point or another truly understanding what a pointer is and C.

0:38:47Sharp is a great example because any time you have a class.

0:38:49So if you don't have a struct here

0:38:51and you don't have a primitive type if you have a class it is always always always always passed by reference so you

0:38:57whenever you're dealing with a class you're always dealing with what is under the hood a pointer.

0:39:03But I have dealt with so many C.

0:39:05Sharp developers many of whom I would actually classify as very good developers that don't.

0:39:12That fundamentally do not understand that concept. And so in C.

0:39:18Sharp when you pass a class instance into a method or I should back up

0:39:24when you pass anything into a method you could say you can explicitly state that you would like to pass this by

0:39:30reference. So for example if you have a string that you might manipulate in a method.

0:39:34Dot Net has call time passed by reference. One of P.H.P. Is worst features are they finally removed recently.

0:39:40Yes and it has it.

0:39:42Yes Wow And it has always had it and so a better example would probably be like an integer so I have an integer

0:39:48and I call a method and I'd like that method to be able to modify that energy

0:39:52or what I can do is I can say that I am passing this by reference and thus I am I am passing basically a point.

0:40:00Here today an integer.

0:40:01Well all classes by default are pass by reference you know you're just throwing pointers around so many times the same

0:40:07way that you would say I am I am specifically passing this integer by reference.

0:40:13I will see people use that same key word which happens to be wrath

0:40:17or yeah I will see people put wraps in front of a class which is redundant because you're always passing a class by

0:40:23reference and so they clearly just fundamentally do not understand what's happening here

0:40:31and I think that that's true not just of C. Sharp clearly it's true in C. Plus plus clearly it's true in Objective C.

0:40:38and I would argue it's true of many many many other languages as well.

0:40:41Even say Javascript you have to understand what's going on under the hood

0:40:44and so truly honestly understanding what a pointer is I think is the thing that I am most not proud of

0:40:51but most thankful for for my education.

0:40:55Right

0:40:55and you know it helps to understand what's going on under the hood even if you don't have to deal with it because it

0:41:01lets you it lets you make better decisions up top like at the level you're working at even if you're working at a very

0:41:06high level. Even work in Java Script a very high level.

0:41:10You're still by knowing what actually is going on all the way you know and all the levels all the way down.

0:41:17It does enable you to make better decisions for all your high level coding.

0:41:21That's exactly right that's exactly the point I'm driving at John for me I think I mean the easy ones. The sort of C.S.

0:41:28Professors I think the easy ones are like just like the basics the stuff you learn like a big O.

0:41:32Notation and algorithms and data structures like it's boring but I think you have to learn it like that.

0:41:38That's type of thing that if I did if I was in a formal class atmosphere I probably wouldn't have gone off to learn

0:41:45that stuff on my own.

0:41:46But knowing it like it's not like you need to know it every day and you can just look it up

0:41:50but just even having known it like this point I cannot implement a red black tree if you ask me to

0:41:56but I know red black trees exist have a vague idea of how they work and if I were to look up an.

0:42:00Well taken I would be like oh yeah. Versus being like red black tree what the hell is that what's a treaty or Big O.

0:42:05Notation one of those letters mean in the US like that. That's the basics of a C.S. Education I think of my C.S.

0:42:11Courses like that's that's what you need to know

0:42:13and like you build on that because if you don't have that foundation everything just seems like just like like a

0:42:20product like you learn a language

0:42:22or like I'm learning this product you wouldn't even see the generalities underneath it and you know some algorithms

0:42:27and data structures definitely were very useful

0:42:29and I don't know if this was since I was a computer engineering it's like electrical engineering with a few C.S.

0:42:33Courses I don't remember if this was technically a C.S.

0:42:35Course but the one I found the two I found was one the class where you build your C.V.

0:42:40Up from from logic gates which I had for probably isn't C.S.

0:42:44but Like that's like is that like the course you have to have I mean like maybe in your class you didn't do like the

0:42:51I.S.I.

0:42:51I might lay out the chip in like you know we didn't manufacture the like you know doing the electronics design

0:42:56and everything like that

0:42:57but you know all we have to stack like it helps to come from that perspective you know I'm never going to make my own

0:43:02C.P.U.

0:43:02Just because like look that is the best way to prove that you understand it actually do it

0:43:07and then the other one is the courses I took where I had to do assembly programming I don't even know if they make

0:43:13people do this anymore because again maybe this is anything like the reign of microcontrollers and stuff

0:43:17but just thousands and thousands and thousands of wind

0:43:21when the only reason the thousands because do anything in assembly to expand and Thousand someone can family

0:43:27and that

0:43:28and in particular one of the presses I remember who was doing my course were doing one of the microcontroller courses

0:43:36for assembly.

0:43:37He was from A to the telecom background

0:43:38and he was like I'm going to show you a structured assembly which is what we use in the telecom industry too so we

0:43:43don't go insane and you know like it was like seeing the primordial ooze of C.

0:43:48Where it's like we have to know everything in assembly

0:43:51but we know if you just do whatever the hell you want an assembly it's chaos

0:43:53and so we we've imposed some you know it's been like this the system of conventions

0:43:57and structures to allow you to Proxima.

0:44:00What you would write

0:44:00and you start to see the sea because he retook was on the course after we'd done seeing such a be like oh like I can

0:44:05see you basically are like a human compiler like when I write it conditionally I always do it in this form

0:44:09and I always use this label when this type of thing so that

0:44:12when I squinted someone's code I can if I squint just right.

0:44:15That gigantic block of incomprehensible assembler turns into like an F in a while in a break

0:44:19and continue you know like that that was very instructive

0:44:23but mostly just like the thousands of lines of the sound because there's no way to write thousands of lines in assembly

0:44:27and not understand pointers like when I pointed to them from C.

0:44:30but

0:44:31when I see someone who doesn't understand pointers It's like our job just to seeing your point is they probably won't

0:44:36but if you make them understand assembly they'll get it hundred percent guaranteed.

0:44:40Yeah I remember I did a course that out that required a lot of assembly you know like the Mits assembly that everyone

0:44:45else had to do.

0:44:46Around that time and one of the hardest things about that course probably the hardest

0:44:51and had to do was during the final exam we were given a block of roughly you know one printed page

0:44:57or so of MIT's assembly uncommented And the question is what does this do.

0:45:02Stuff

0:45:03and it was it was like I was sat there for like a half hour like basically like basically compiling it back to see in

0:45:09my head and I make a little note.

0:45:11Here's a little loop here and I think I think I would have ended up doing was like finding duplicate substrings

0:45:17or something like you know some kind of basic string processing thing

0:45:20but it was surprisingly hard to figure that out but that's why

0:45:23when you're looking at it if you actually literally have to translate it to see to understand it it's kind of like

0:45:27translating the language into English you know so you can understand it right.

0:45:30Venture like that's what structured assembly does is let you start to look at the assembly

0:45:33and recognize you know the assembly chunks as like the equivalent of an F. but You don't have to translate C.

0:45:39To see what it does because there's a regular ization of it you know you don't have to like execute every line in your

0:45:44head like visualize the registers in your head and how they're combining

0:45:48and keep track of all them on a piece of paper so you can say you know I mean like it starts to take on a form itself

0:45:53but the structures algorithms assembly and C.P.U. Design basically just take the whole core.

0:46:01You know I hear a lot from people who say that C.S.

0:46:05Degrees are useless flash inferior slash not giving them what they want because they're not being taught you know X. Y.

0:46:12and Which whatever language is hot at the time at the time

0:46:15and you know nothing nothing that we all just mentioned had a lot to do with a particular language that was in

0:46:22when we went to college you know if if my college taught me a language

0:46:27when I was there they would have taught me Java and in fact in the intro they do teach

0:46:31and they pretty quickly abandon it because it doesn't really it's first and then

0:46:35when they go to see it in it's have kind of mattering when I would use

0:46:37and like for some of the later classes you're already just pick whatever language you want and do your project

0:46:41and that which And at the time I was there I was very upset that they weren't teaching me Windows A.P.I.

0:46:47Programming like like Net stuff and had which had just come out about halfway through my college career and

0:46:56and like it I wasn't learning C.

0:46:57Plus plus during college and stuff like that I was so mad

0:47:00and what they told me at the time which I'm sure everyone's heard from there comes I professors is it doesn't really

0:47:06it's not really their job to teach you the language

0:47:08and they're not really doing you a big favor if they spent a whole lot of time teaching you a particular language

0:47:13because chances are your education will go out of date much sooner if you spent half of it learning whatever language

0:47:20was popular at the time that you went to college and.

0:47:24And in reality like all the stuff you do learn in college or in a good C.S.

0:47:28Department all the theoretical stuff in the basic principles

0:47:31and everything there's really never a time in the field where you get to learn that like there's really not in the real

0:47:38world in the real world workforce there are a lot of opportunities to sit down

0:47:41and you know learn bigger Taishan stuff like that and and so and a lot of

0:47:47and you don't even know what to look for you know if you didn't get that back

0:47:49or you don't even know what to look at them with P.T.O.

0:47:51or What what to look up on land or whatever else and so you know part of part of C.S. Is teaching you things that are.

0:48:00Are timeless and there are fundamentals and it's hard to see that at the time that you're there.

0:48:04But once you're out for a while you appreciate that OK Well yeah now I know the fundamentals.

0:48:09It isn't that hard to learn a new language when I have to do my job I can learn language and you know a week or two

0:48:14and be pretty good after six months or a year and you know it's it's like you wouldn't want to spend your entire C.S.

0:48:21Education on a language that's going to be out of favor five years ten years later as I like the language has got a

0:48:27favorite just like in higher ed like they look down their nose at like teaching practical skills that they were not a

0:48:32vocational school places not apex tech and get your own tools like they want to teach you the concepts

0:48:39and I never had a desire for them to try to teach me like any specific technology and they certainly didn't.

0:48:46And also I kind of got the sense that a lot of these professors like we're better mathematicians than they would ever

0:48:50be programmers in especially department like they're not programmers like it

0:48:54or would want to teach you I think if they would teach you the wrong things

0:48:57but what you learned sort of through osmosis is in every class like they just expect you to do OK

0:49:03and our exercises are going to be in you know sixteen bit assembler or a C. Plus plus or you know plain old C.

0:49:10or Mathematics are like that it doesn't matter like what you're you know or Matlab

0:49:15or like every teacher had some tools you need to use or

0:49:18and do this this will let you work through whatever it is until you know they'd be teaching you concepts

0:49:22and algorithms and stuff like that

0:49:24and the tool used to work through them like every class was like oh whatever this professor is like whatever their

0:49:28hobby horses they want to do everything in Jolliffe while they're in job

0:49:31when you learn the programming language doesn't matter like it as you go like it's an infantile detail of you doing

0:49:37your actual job your actual job

0:49:38and school is like doing the assignment to understand the concept in your actual job in real jobs is you know making

0:49:44the product or whatever

0:49:45and it's like well you know if you've never used before you take this class this professor mated excise

0:49:50and Java guess what you're going to learn of Java to do the exercise which will probably be actually end up being a lot

0:49:55of Java surprisingly but that's not where the teaching in the class like yours expect to be able to pick that up.

0:50:00And that is good training for the real world because in the real world Yeah you're just expected to pick it up like

0:50:04never done before. Read about it. Buy a book. Figure it out because you need to do your job. Exactly.

0:50:11All right our second bunch of this week is our friends once again a transporter at file transporter so file transfer is

0:50:18a really cool device.

0:50:19It's basically a networked external hard drive

0:50:22or a little little puff that you get that transforms one of your hard drive to a networked hard drive that you own

0:50:28and control this hardware so you have a hard drive sitting in your house your office you own it you control it it's all

0:50:35your data sitting right there on that drive your data's not up in some cloud service it isn't on some of the company's

0:50:39servers. It is all right there on your hard drive but it gives you features that are similar to what Dropbox offers.

0:50:47So it has if you have more than one of these things let's say you and your friend each have one or you have one

0:50:52or home one at work or one of your parents house or whatever.

0:50:55You can have them automatically sync and replicate to each other so you can have either part

0:51:00or whole so you could do like a shared folder.

0:51:03You could do like a backup automatically like a sync keeping these two drives entirely in sync so you always have an

0:51:08offsite backup to the shared folders greater collaborating with a team if you want to share big files that may be

0:51:14limited me don't fit on Dropbox or maybe buy some kind of regulatory compliance you can't have them and Dropbox

0:51:19or you know maybe you just don't want to have your files in a cloud service you know for various privacy

0:51:23and security reasons.

0:51:24So transporter is this great device it allows to do all these cool things they also in addition to the sink

0:51:31and backup nature of these things.

0:51:33They also have i OS apps

0:51:35and mac apps that allow you to access the files from wherever you are so your transporters could be sitting in your

0:51:41house and you could be somewhere else you know in the next city or the next country over with your i West device

0:51:47or your mac laptop or whatever the case may be

0:51:49and you can access the files on your home transporter without doing any kind of crazy network set up it does all that

0:51:54for you. You know that's as good a relay service to do the connection set up but then the files are off the cuff.

0:52:00I'm from your transport of the trip the hard drive sitting in your house and so it's never going to be a cloud service.

0:52:05It's never the date is never out of your control.

0:52:07All the transfer of the CO over the internet are all encrypted

0:52:10and they don't have the keys your devices have the keys on both sides and that's it.

0:52:15So really there's there's quite a lot you can do with these things.

0:52:20It's their software is always getting better they recently updated the mac software

0:52:23and have even more Dropbox like features now they can even do so do things like automatically sync to

0:52:29and from the transporter and all your other devices automatically sync special force such as your desktop

0:52:35or say your music for your pictures for her.

0:52:37So these don't even have to be on you know in some special location

0:52:41or store just on the transporter they will automatically Cindy's folders from your from your computer between your all

0:52:47your other computers which is really nice from the dropbox even do so how do you get one of these things.

0:52:52Go to file transporter Store dot com and you can see these things are very reasonably priced.

0:52:57The best thing about this there are no monthly fees.

0:53:00You buy the hardware once upfront and you own it

0:53:04and then there's no monthly fees after that which is a huge savings over cloud services especially if you have a lot of

0:53:09data. So how do you get one of these things this is great one time purchase no monthly fees.

0:53:14The transporter sync which is a little thing that you it's like a little park and you plug in any U.S.B.

0:53:19Hard drive you already have and it has a network putting aside and automatically double these things for you.

0:53:23Transporter sync is just ninety nine dollars.

0:53:26There's a five hundred gig transporter with a built in hard drive five hundred gigs for one ninety nine one terabyte

0:53:32for two forty nine and two terabytes for just three forty nine

0:53:35and you can save an additional ten percent off of all those prices at file transfer of COM save an additional ten

0:53:42percent by using coupon code A.T.P. So go check it out.

0:53:46File transporter Store dot com see how these things can really help you have the feature set of these things is

0:53:51incredible and it keeps getting bigger and bigger as they update the software and do all sorts of cool stuff.

0:53:56So thanks a lot to file transporter for sponsoring our show once again.

0:54:01So Marco last episode

0:54:04and a half hearted attempt to derail me from my beloved software methodology so that was full hearted in her mouth.

0:54:12You announced to the world on the show that you had received your trash can.

0:54:17I'm sorry your new computer you know as a trash can it's pretty crappy.

0:54:22We have like that top or so of actual volume in there

0:54:25and if you put a bag in there then the fan can pull the air out so it's kind of a bad trash can out you know typical

0:54:31typical Apple overpriced.

0:54:34Can you put one of those blow up men like they have in front of a car dealership

0:54:37and they're like well you have the arms.

0:54:40What's the line from Family Guy like the crazy inflatable or waving guy or whatever.

0:54:44Why do you waving inflatable aren't willing to make. Somebody has to make one of those for them.

0:54:49I'm sure I'm sure it's going to happen.

0:54:51You know leave it up to like I don't know but if you see somebody is going to make one of those. But yeah I don't.

0:54:59Yeah I mean what you want to so I give a little quick thing at the end of last show during the after show

0:55:03and you know basically there's not that much a talk about it's faster which I knew going into it from benchmarks

0:55:10and there is a certain nuance to the faster ness.

0:55:17So my previous macro I had gotten one of those but if you see Excelsior cards which is basically a P.C.I.

0:55:24Express card with two little S.S.D. Would two little serially D.

0:55:29Cards in RAID zero controlled by the card and then it shows up to the system as just one drive.

0:55:35So one of those you know cheapo software it kind of things I imagine

0:55:38and so that you know there's a lot of wires of intricacy there are a lot of translation layers a lot of lot of

0:55:45components on the new one the S.S.D.

0:55:48Is not only a higher grade higher you know higher speed flash

0:55:52and presumably a more advanced controller than what these were using because it's just simply newer

0:55:57but also the new S.S.D. Is P.C.I. Express native. And I'm not entirely sure on the intricacies of how these work.

0:56:03But as far as I know that requires fewer levels of translation fewer bridge in-vitro chips along the way.

0:56:10So what it what it is compared to the old MacPro It is simply more consistent

0:56:16and it feels like there are fewer bottlenecks and this is all very hard to measure at this my are holed up in this.

0:56:22This might be like audio file cables like this.

0:56:24This might not hold up to which I call upon a lady

0:56:27but if I say pano pano I don't know I thought it was pronounced piece of crap. It will say that.

0:56:35So how do you pronounce it in a triangle.

0:56:39So it's faster and it's faster not only you know like I've done a bunch hand-written code since I got it

0:56:45and so then they are so you know at least fifty percent faster then you know just just on the frame rate to hit that

0:56:53handbrake reports I'd say fifty percent on some one thing that I think bench bears that out.

0:56:59So it is faster but it also feels more consistent.

0:57:02It feels like there are fewer little bottlenecks little hiccups here and there the Excelsior

0:57:07or not I'm not sure I'd recommend it because well first of all it's now a dated now you know the era of P.C.I.

0:57:14Express card aftermarket cards is pretty limited now

0:57:19but I'm not sure I recommend it simply because you can now get one terabyte it has eased into the half inch bays for

0:57:27like five hundred bucks or so.

0:57:30So it's not as necessary and B I always it always felt a little bit inconsistent in its performance

0:57:37and that could just be in my head I don't know.

0:57:39Beyond that with the new one it's it's a lot quieter and I really it's a dramatic difference.

0:57:47Like I always thought the macro was quiet but man this is this is even quieter I would say it's quieter in most use.

0:57:55Then my MacBook Pro and not you know not the math of procreating it's manner highly. Quieter than an Apple Pro at idle.

0:58:02To my ears but again that could just be that that isn't a precise measurement I haven't taken on but I do have an S.P.L.

0:58:08Meter I should try to but anyway. If you've ever go anyway. So overall it's fantastic there.

0:58:16There's not that much more to say though it's it's just fantastic. It is not you know four times faster C.P.U.

0:58:24Wise than my old one but it is faster and it is really really nice and it looks awesome

0:58:33and look even better once again as we've gotten top So yeah overall I give it a thumbs up.

0:58:38What are you doing with your old macro is that getting the queen's to TIFF.

0:58:43If so what's happening to Tess will tip has the identical model.

0:58:47She actually got hers back in twenty time when it was new so she is.

0:58:52I'm going to what I'm saying is tentatively I'm assuming that in roughly a year maybe a little bit less than a year.

0:59:00The next mac pro will be out that'll have the has well E.P.

0:59:03Chips and that will unlike this one that will actually come with a per clock performance gain.

0:59:10So we should see a nice single threaded jump there the same way we do now with Leno.

0:59:14That's that's the whole reason why the IMAX

0:59:17and Napa pros now are occasionally in some measure much faster than the new pro in single threaded stuff because they

0:59:23have the has well cores and they have a little bit more efficiency peroxide on how much they can get done.

0:59:28So those that have not come to the on line yet so that is not in the new MacPro

0:59:32but it will be in the new MacPro probably a year from now so I'm guessing a year from now I'll buy one of those for

0:59:39myself and I give this one the test of a great her she really wants one too it's so much quieter and so much smaller

0:59:45and that it physically will help a lot in our office like the like I still have my old one sitting below my desk here

0:59:50but it's going to having this little tiny cylinder on top of my desk instead of the tremendous tower below my desk is

0:59:56going to allow me to like totally rearrange the physical space here. And same thing on her side of the office.

1:00:02So there's a lot of genes there that are not just you know the specs

1:00:06but just the physicality of it you know the the size the noise the cables.

1:00:10Stuff like that So overall a plus one thing I noticed

1:00:15when I restored to it so I I haven't been doing this Clunes recently which I think is a mistake I'm going to start

1:00:21doing that again.

1:00:22I've been relying on a combination of Time Machine and online backup and so I so when I got this new

1:00:29and I did a restore from time machine over the network and with post on this analogy box I don't have to have

1:00:35but I stopped covered harddrive enclosures

1:00:37and Time Machine restorer worked great except that certain things aren't backed up time machine and it's annoying

1:00:45and i took me and I still haven't quite figured out what overall has been executed. You know the data is all there.

1:00:53The apps are all there

1:00:53but like certain apps lost their preferences certain key chain things although not all of the key chain mysteriously

1:01:00certain key chain things aren't there and I had to reintroduce that sort of stuff.

1:01:03Certain apps like losing losing entire configurations of some apps and I don't know why that is

1:01:10but it was not a perfect clone and so I so I I want to get back into the cloning business again

1:01:16and I haven't quite decided how to do that I'd rather not have a desk with harddrive enclosures on it so I'm thinking

1:01:23maybe of trying I suppose you with the phonology but I suppose he requires a kernel extension

1:01:28and that's uncomfortable so I don't know I'm actually curious to hear from listeners like if you do I skuzzy does it is

1:01:36is it a pain in the butt basically like with oh S.

1:01:39Upgrade is a pain

1:01:40but it's a bug is it weird why do you need to use I tell you I'm sure to stew a super duper clone to a disk image

1:01:46Honor's analogy I suppose I could do that

1:01:49but then how do you restart from that same way just as you were just you know I guess you got the whole thing to boot

1:01:55from but they just need their own super and you get into a state where you can run super duper and then clone from.

1:02:00The disk image back onto your drive.

1:02:02You need like kind of an in between a drive to be like your your way station because you can't clone onto a drive that

1:02:08you're booted from but that's not I mean that's not hard to do if you do that on a U.S.B.

1:02:12Cable like assuming you can boot from it.

1:02:15One thing I have a thought about actually was was just just getting a bus powered two

1:02:20and a half inch hard drive enclosure that was like a one terabyte disk

1:02:23and therefore it will cost substantially less than the I scale the software for it for me

1:02:30and I just like you know zip tied to the bottom my debts when you can see it

1:02:34but I'm not sure I wouldn't hear it I'm assuming it could be put to sleep if you were near

1:02:38and I have a bus powered one terabyte and it's even black just like a macro is already there.

1:02:43Oh it's like the Dr go to sleep you would leave it on mounted most of the time and you'll never hear it.

1:02:49Yeah I think I think I might try that first because that's that's just so much easier

1:02:53and then the other thing is I actually one of the reasons they were trying to ask but.

1:02:57But I might also do the the drive strapped to the desk method instead.

1:03:01Is that back please does not backup network drives and they've made little hints here

1:03:08and there that they might consider in the future but it doesn't seem like they're there in a big rush to do that so.

1:03:15And I mention in previous shows that the other options like a crash plan just don't work very well for me with various

1:03:22issues so I would love to have I have this like four terabyte share on my phonology that is storing with all my large

1:03:29archive files and I right now I use arc on the mac to back it up over the network to Glacier

1:03:37and I don't love this set up.

1:03:40I don't love that it's on glacier and it's kind of hard for me to get to anything

1:03:44but it's too big for us to do a price so I might I don't know I might go back to enclosures

1:03:51and just kind of like hide them under my desk somewhere so I can't see them

1:03:55and figure out ways of unmounting tricks so they don't hear them.

1:04:00So I want to give John a chance to interrogate you

1:04:03but really quickly you kind of haven't answered the question So what is your old cheese grater doing just collecting

1:04:08dust.

1:04:10Well actually it has stopped collecting dust because the fans aren't running into any more sucking dust through it.

1:04:15So right now it has pause it's dust collection as well of all of its other activities

1:04:19and it's just sitting under my desk in its old spot just as I have been too busy to move

1:04:24and I took a trip this past week and so I've been I've been very very busy just organizing things and then

1:04:30when I get back.

1:04:31Disorganizing things so I will let you know soon how it's going to like I still haven't even rewired

1:04:39or unwired like I'm going to one of the standing to finally clean out all these old wires on my desk

1:04:44and like take a bunch of news of ties and Recep Tayyip within the gather and I'll stuff

1:04:47but if you use a little Velcro things are better than the guys I have some of that I have about twenty of those.

1:04:54Problem is that they're big they don't hold very tightly and they themselves collect tons of dust.

1:04:59What's big about them they're like they're like a centimetre one at the widest it compared to is a time that's a pretty

1:05:04big number that you're spraying away though I found they were very raw just kind of read of the back of my T.V.

1:05:08when I got all the T.V. and Tivo and everything and I do those things and I was skeptical.

1:05:13They look like they're crap but they worked really well and not a single one has come off your stuff

1:05:18and I want to wrap it around enough times

1:05:19and I love the fact that I can undo them really tired it's like I can get in there with a needle and undo it

1:05:24but I really don't want to. So you just end up cutting arm and that's dangerous.

1:05:27So I'm like I'm a convert to the to the soaker things maybe it depends on the brand that I remember where I got it was

1:05:33just what I was highly rated Amazon they were super cheap.

1:05:36Oh yeah I got a bag of thousands of ties in two thousand and four

1:05:41and I have I still have like a quarter of the bag left so I don't like I just cut them lever

1:05:46and it changed it's no big deal and you're afraid to actually cut the cables.

1:05:49No you like you notices are under in such a way that it can't cut the cable and now I'm here.

1:05:58So for now it's just sitting.

1:06:00Mayor but are you eventually offloading your macro onto Dan or is it going to be a charity case he'll give it to me.

1:06:08I thought you hated that stops I don't want to macro you kid me that's stupid. Exactly who would want an old one.

1:06:13I desperately need an S.S.D.

1:06:17Hintin tinting my new video card is awesome but like spinning disks on this macro like just it's becoming unbearable.

1:06:24If you want the Excelsior

1:06:25or I will I'll give it to you for a very very good price because I just want to get rid of it because I have no use for.

1:06:31Well you're not you're not selling very well as a kind of weirding system performance not take.

1:06:37Well yeah I mean I just I have no idea how to use that like it for me to eat free if I want to keep using that I would

1:06:43have to buy a thunderbolt a P.C.I.

1:06:45Express enclosure which is like three hundred bucks an hour you can use it a new hard drive a new S.S.D.

1:06:51Of the same size is five hundred bucks

1:06:53and is going to be probably faster because it's new now so I don't know I'm not like

1:06:59and it's a problem if the new two and having to drive is five hundred bucks.

1:07:03Look I really sell this one for you know I mean this one might be faster because it's in the slot but I don't know.

1:07:10Anyway this is all boring so let's move on but yeah basically it's awesome.

1:07:15There's not that much to say about you know there's I don't have any software as far as I know that takes advantage of

1:07:20that of the dual G.P.

1:07:21Used to do computations of like that so it really isn't that interesting it

1:07:25but right now it's just a really awesome very fast extremely quiet workstation which is what I wanted

1:07:33and so I'm very happy.

1:07:35John no questions I was going to say and Mark already touched on this

1:07:39but it's kind of a shame that machine is so expensive because of the sort of life change that it brings about is going

1:07:44to be such that like once you have that astrology is great it's your house

1:07:47and you've had to go off on this for a while you're going to like see the cheese grater at someone else's place

1:07:52or something and be like people used to have those things under a desk

1:07:56or the size of the idea you made a fire is like it's going to be seen as going to seem absurd.

1:08:00Just because it's such a you don't realize how small these things are until you see them in person like in one of those

1:08:07pictures online showing an X.

1:08:08Thirty four cube which was like oh my god they put the whole computer into a cube probably smaller like it's skinnier

1:08:15or similar heights. It's just it's it's an unbelievable change in the size of things they were forced to live with.

1:08:24It really got people interested in the macro again who weren't interested for years I mean the MacPro is for the first

1:08:30time ever it was even even when the cheese grater one first came out in two thousand and six.

1:08:37It was never like a hot item.

1:08:40Now this new one is a hot item they made it cool again

1:08:43and that's almost almost completely because of physical you know superficial things but that matters.

1:08:48Yeah I mean that's part of the product where it matters to innovation.

1:08:52You know social is ask any more like it matters to all these things and

1:09:01and it got people interested in this in this relatively boring out of reach product again and that's really great.

1:09:08I mean it makes people wish and makes me which will you know the X.

1:09:12and I dream of him I was like damn if it only wasn't so darn expensive like a new one G.P.U.

1:09:17and Set it to use a cheaper chip like I mean I guess they kind of can a thought the point of the product

1:09:21but you like that form factor is so great that if you just take that form factor

1:09:26and change the guts keep the schooling system everything

1:09:29but just change the insides to be you know hell even I'm at caliber size just to be able to get like a separate screen

1:09:37or like a better G.P.U. A new computer and I could have a desktop G.P.U.

1:09:40In there and Apple never do this

1:09:42but it is really nice those fantasies of like I love that form factor so much a person should never need to be bigger

1:09:48than that in fact they don't need to be as proved by the amazing power that's in this one.

1:09:52So why is it that the only way you get one of those is to you know get two giant G.P.U. That are never going to use an.

1:10:00Super expensive server chip to be fair the the four and six core chips are actually pretty competitively priced.

1:10:06The eight and twelve cores are ridiculous but the four and the pricing on the forensics is actually pretty good

1:10:12and not that far above regular intel consumer Seaview pricing I was not before.

1:10:17I mean this is like the other expensive uses out for what you can't. What if I just want one.

1:10:21Tough tough luck you know. Yeah exactly. So you know but overall it's an even use stuff they like.

1:10:29So I for for large expensive things like this where it's practical to I keep the boxes around the shipping boxes

1:10:35and the internal boxes so that when I go to sell them three to five years

1:10:38or whatever down the line I can put them back in their box and it's easier and it saves them money

1:10:43and everything else and I know it's relatively safe.

1:10:46So in my basement I have two giant mac pro boxes from the from mine and saves old ones

1:10:52and this one the box is like the size of a bookshelf speaker but even that is an improvement

1:11:00and I just you know you never think about but it all adds up. I think about it as I have.

1:11:06Indeterminant are much larger than to a number of those which is great about this

1:11:11and they're ridiculous like they're massive They did get smaller a time where they're not but only slightly.

1:11:18Member when I when I sold my old one to Dan Benjamin they cost me over one hundred dollars to ship it.

1:11:24They That's how big these parks and how every day I mean it's just just incredible.

1:11:28So anyway talk to me how you are going to give us new for good price anyway.

1:11:33We're also sponsored this week our final sponsor before we move on to more macro to find discussion.

1:11:38Final part of this week is taking once again ting is mobile that makes sense. There are no B.S.

1:11:44Simple to use mobile service provider from the people at two thousand the company behind hover thing which is a

1:11:49reseller of a Sprint network in the U.S. They have great rates and there's no contracts or early termination fees.

1:11:56You own your device out right from the start there.

1:12:00True pay for what you use pricing model so you pay a base price of six dollars per month per device

1:12:05and then you're automatically billed for the actual amount of minutes messages

1:12:09and megabytes that you use each month above that.

1:12:12So this is great for if you have fluctuating usage which let's face it most of us do.

1:12:16Let's say you have like one hundred megs of usage one month

1:12:19and data next month you are traveling you use a gig it doesn't matter.

1:12:22You pay you little bucketed rates for those two rates.

1:12:25You don't have to remember to like call ahead and raise your cap and then call ahead and you know do it again

1:12:30when you get back

1:12:31and lower back down to build next month for the high level just automatically you get billed what you actually use each

1:12:37month and no more.

1:12:39And their prices are even lower so five hundred gigs sorry five hundred megs of data is just twelve bucks

1:12:45and two gigs is twenty nine. So go to A.T.P.

1:12:49Ting dot com

1:12:50and check out their savings calculator you can see how much you can save by entering in your last few months of usage

1:12:56from your cell phone

1:12:57and they will still show you this cool graph will say All right well if you continue your average look at that this

1:13:03most months you're going to save X.

1:13:05Per month roughly with us

1:13:06and then over time you can see well after a year you've saved this much you know you will save.

1:13:12You know you have to buy your device up front but you'll pay that off in say six months or whatever.

1:13:16Great thing the savings calculator on A.T.P.

1:13:19Ting dot com They will also pay your early termination fee up to twenty five percent back in service credit up to

1:13:26seventy five dollars you get to go out of your existing carrier.

1:13:31That's little help there for you

1:13:33and also you know with thing there are no contracts there are no service fee there interation fees so they'll be the

1:13:39last and the raft right.

1:13:40So like cover taking has great customer support they have a no hold no wait phone support policy so you can call them

1:13:48in time between eight A.M. and Eight P.M. Eastern and a human being takes a phone who's able to help you.

1:13:53So going to take dot com to hear some big news for a while there was this kind of elephant in the room.

1:13:59What about the i Phone.

1:14:00You know for a while Tim didn't didn't support the i Phone I couldn't get it on a couple months ago they finally got so

1:14:06there I was there on the Sprint network so if you get an i Phone four or i Phone four S.

1:14:11That is for the Sprint network and you can get it on e Bay you can get it on Amazon you can get on glide new

1:14:16or use whatever whatever the case may be and a compatible Sprint device so the i Phone four and four S.

1:14:21Have a compatible for a few months now. Big news they just added the i Phone five.

1:14:25So get your hands on a sprint i Phone five through them or anyone else and you can use that one thing as well.

1:14:31Once again check them out. A.T.P. Dot dot com And thanks a lot for conjuring the show all right.

1:14:38So my dad listens to this show and my dad is a bit of an amateur Stereophile audio file whatever you want to call me

1:14:47and I'm in this weekend where I know we can go down the road of cable still mattered cetera et cetera

1:14:53but he's been giving me a hard time for a while because John had mentioned in the past that he is either seeking

1:15:00or had found a new avi receiver and my dad has also just found a new A.V. Receiver and I don't recall what it was.

1:15:10But regardless was very interested to hear how John landed or is intending to land on the A.V.

1:15:17Receiver of his choice and my father whom I love dearly has been giving me grief every week asking

1:15:24when we're going to get to this topic so Dad This one's for you. John tell me about A.V.

1:15:29Receivers and only reason I was even looking for an A.V.

1:15:32Receiver is because as I think I explained about all I first talking about my T.V.

1:15:36Is the number of H T M I pour it on T.V. It seems to be going down even on the super expensive ones of my new fancy T.V.

1:15:43Had three H T M I am but I think compared to like four or five a mile one and I remember the exact numbers

1:15:49but anyway Les and I I had devices I didn't have any place to plug them in so I needed some kind of solution

1:15:55and a receiver is one possible solution but before that I tried to just get an H T M.

1:16:00I switch

1:16:00and I didn't actually buy any because every time I read reviews of them there was always like a good ten fifteen twenty

1:16:06five percent higher stories about how terrible they were.

1:16:09Every single one like didn't matter the brand

1:16:10or whatever they wanted in our story views were super high end like installed by value added reseller kind of one

1:16:18thousand dollar boxes

1:16:19and those didn't have any better uses than of any reviews because sites like that don't people who made reviews

1:16:24and I was in

1:16:25and I like that much any receiver so I resigned myself to getting it received as far as your dad is concerned I don't

1:16:31think what I have to say will be useful because this is just a general

1:16:36when people ask like what kind of action I buy the more you know about a topic the more you're just inclined to say

1:16:43Well it depends on your needs. But that's so true because like for A.V.

1:16:48Receivers when I'm reading product reviews I know what I want like I'm basically getting the world's fancy's H.D.M.I.

1:16:56Switcher and I have specific features that are specific features that are super important to me

1:17:01but that may not be important all the other people and on the reverse the features that most A.V.

1:17:06Receivers use talk about what kind of speakers they can power how clean an audio signal they get all

1:17:11or all that I don't care about because I'm going to have crappy speakers. They're not going to sound good.

1:17:16I'm not buying this thing as a sound system. I don't care about Internet radio I don't care about music playback.

1:17:22All these things that are you know may be the primary most important features of a lot of people who are buying A.V.

1:17:28Receivers so the one that I bought is probably not important because my needs are so weird like what I wanted was a

1:17:34huge number of H.D. My ports the ability to switch the H.D.M.I.

1:17:37Ports without turning the device on I mean like on on I know they're always you know you know what I mean like without

1:17:44having to think powered on all the time because I'm turning it on and off

1:17:49and the ability to hook up all the devices I have like I have I have component video devices like the Playstation two

1:17:56and my we in the Game Cube and I have composite input devices. The Game Cube.

1:18:00We're going to have composite or component for that

1:18:02but I well I have all sorts of legacy devices that once again on the back of my new T.V.

1:18:06There's no place to plug them in because you know that's one of the one of video ports no composite video port you know

1:18:11all that stuff I want to play stuff

1:18:13and we're getting a gigantic receiver box that's got a million plugs in the back of it.

1:18:16I'm I will find one that fits all my devices that are tons of A.C.I.M.

1:18:19but They can switch in standby mode

1:18:23and I don't care about almost anything else so I don't think the one I ended up with this particular useful I ended up

1:18:28with a Yamaha. But this is our X.V.

1:18:33Six seventy three I should look this up

1:18:34and anyway something like that that even the particular model number is interesting because

1:18:39when I was looking through the reviews I spent a long time reading reviews about this.

1:18:43Again ignoring almost everything that's important to me is looking at the few features that I'm interested in narrowing

1:18:48it down.

1:18:49There's a newer version of the Yamaha receiver with a slightly higher number like six seventy five instead of six

1:18:54seventy three but the features they added I don't care about any of them

1:18:59and all of the features that I do care about are identical.

1:19:02And there's this thing even so there's a thing

1:19:04and I chose it with sort of I run the programmer's bias towards new models like if you write software for a living

1:19:11or if you're a software afficionado I may be just me I find myself strangely compelled like I have to get the new

1:19:18version of everything

1:19:19and the reason why is because it's like empathy like I can empathize with a program you know how good you feel

1:19:23when you deleted that massive amount of code is no longer needed to replace it with simpler code even though does

1:19:28exactly the same thing even though you may have actually introduced a bug because the old code worked

1:19:31but you feel so much better about oh god I can't leave people out there using my old version the new version I deleted

1:19:37like seven hundred lines of code is just so much cleaner.

1:19:40I got rid of this flag variable you know like you just feel so good about you like please stop crying I came believe

1:19:46people in executing that whole program I'm so terribly happy running a new one right.

1:19:50So in summary this is a new version of his software.

1:19:52I feel that way like I feel that way for them I feel like of course the idea of the new version.

1:19:57I can only imagine how much better this new version must be.

1:20:00Even if it looks functionally identical on the net a single feature and it's the same speed.

1:20:03I just know it's got to be better in the code like I know that feeling well I have the same feeling about like well six

1:20:09seventy three

1:20:09and six any thought of course you know six seventy five like why would you give the six hundred three it's crazy I'm

1:20:13sure they fix tons of bugs and six seventy five and maybe that consolidates of chips and it puts out less heat

1:20:18and I can come up with those elaborate fantasy scenarios about why the six seventy five should be better

1:20:23but I was good this time and I made myself say no you don't care about like they added better Pandora streaming

1:20:28or some other crazy thing where you can plug in and I don't like I'm not going to use those features

1:20:33and the six seventy three with a one hundred bucks less than Amazon so I bought the like basically last year's model of

1:20:39a receiver

1:20:40and it does all the things that it said it would do now the reason I put this thing in here is because despite the fact

1:20:48that I was able to shop based on feature stuff one of the things that people don't talk about in their use for the most

1:20:54part is how terrible all consumers are in terms of the user interface and how they get together

1:21:01and I was thinking about like it's not that hard if if if a programmer is a design A.V. Receiver.

1:21:06Like when I conceptualize it and in fact in a lot of the manuals you'll find a big like truth table or grid

1:21:12or it's like if input is from this device video input is from this device in or do you put it in that device

1:21:18and audio output can be on this output unlike the like a truth table of a matrix of a given these inputs

1:21:24and outputs what combinations are valid or much combinations aren't

1:21:28and right away this kind of pressure I am sure there are physical you know limitations of like well if you have video

1:21:33coming in a composite and you don't have something converts as you can output the video to your television H.D.M.I.

1:21:37Unless you have a chip to do that not you know I understand the limitations to define it

1:21:42but ideally you'd want look I could take anybody O.

1:21:44Source any audio source and put them any any inputs and send them out and the outputs.

1:21:49Any combination of obviously that's you know again optimistic there's hard work in trying to stop from you didn't ever

1:21:54that's what you'd like is the ideal but within the realm of the things that you can do these inputs.

1:22:00Some no doubt but for whatever is valid

1:22:03and all the other settings you can have you know the feeling things the balance of the speakers

1:22:07and the surround decoding moment

1:22:10and if you're sending it out to the seconds on an old like a million features a receiver is better if you visualize all

1:22:17those all those settings the bare minimum I think any programmer would do is say give me an ability to save all of the

1:22:25current settings under a name and let me select that name and have to change all those settings for that name

1:22:30and I've never found a receiver that even does that. They all want to be like.

1:22:34Well when you say the setting what you're really saying is when you change this input we implicitly change that

1:22:38but you only have one set of speaker level settings or if you have two of those that's a separate scene

1:22:42but the scene doesn't affect the inputs and the impulse on effect the surround mode

1:22:45and this dialog delay is independently adjustable

1:22:48and is not tied to the input of like if it's the most Byzantine mess of crap

1:22:53and it's harder I think it's harder for them to do that it like the stupid simple thing is every single setting under a

1:22:59name. Whatever the current state of the machine is right now.

1:23:02Save the owner name

1:23:03and then any time you go back to name everything assigning an entire machine back to that's the stupidest better woman

1:23:09you have subsets Here's one set for free speaker level you know.

1:23:13Here's one set for input combinations Here's one something like And then you can combine those sets like

1:23:17and that's the type of thing

1:23:17but I'm not even talking about the just like the stupidest thing a programmer could think of as I have a billion

1:23:22settings.

1:23:23There's only certain valid states set every cell in the way you want it save it all under name

1:23:27and none of them do that.

1:23:28So you're basically resigned to say look I basically have to choose one set of speakers else because this this thing

1:23:34does not have a choice of a way to change because levels based on inputs or if it does it's a complex

1:23:39or some other features I have to resign myself to just pick it

1:23:41and compromise there because I'm never going to go into these menus

1:23:44and like turn out the Centre Town just a little bit

1:23:47when it's on this point because it's just too cumbersome Summers got the kind of a happy medium

1:23:51and then for these other features I know these are tied to a preset

1:23:55when I change this piece I have to remember to change the other thing because the other thing doesn't follow it with it

1:23:59and why. I'm not going to the Blu ray player but the sound coming back from the T.V.

1:24:02I don't want to come back on the only return channel because then it's only two channels because of some insane reason

1:24:07so I think the OP is out of it I have to but they all do it

1:24:09but to be a before that only want to go into the speakers

1:24:12and it's like the amount of Basically bottom line is to get to the point where I can work it

1:24:18but anywhere else in my family tries to use the television.

1:24:20It's too complicated and no a single learning remote won't solve all this because of the timing delays

1:24:25and how long it takes. Turn things on and off and it gets into where it states and you really want to disable its T.M.I.

1:24:30Control or A.T.C.

1:24:32or Vieira caster

1:24:33or whatever the hell they call that thing where the mind of an end where you devise a control each other a say Michael

1:24:38hundreds more problems to the next in your best bet is just turn that off so you're fighting chance of managing it.

1:24:44So in general I think I picked the right receiver for me.

1:24:48Probably not the right receiver for everybody

1:24:49and everybody who makes receivers should just be like I say taking a shot

1:24:53but let's just say given a stern talking to about how our software could do to help them because I feel like they're

1:25:01trying to help they're trying to be like you can be like you're in an opera hall this

1:25:04and it's like just start from the basics save everything or studying under sail name that interface sucks

1:25:09but still better than what you have now and then work your way up from there.

1:25:13You know what you're describing it almost sounds like you want the apple approach to the receiver

1:25:21and please don't email me because I haven't thought this through because I didn't do any research Libya new category it

1:25:28would be a new category though

1:25:29and I'd to be honest I don't think it's really in Apple's interest to do the sort of thing but.

1:25:33But maybe we need like a nasty you know a bunch of X. Apple people or just smart people doesn't have to be X.

1:25:40Apple to come in and say you know what here's a receiver done right and we will we will be an omnivore

1:25:46and consume all these different inputs and give you one or perhaps more than one

1:25:52and for whatever reason output that makes sense.

1:25:55Well the they would NEVER provide what I'm asking for which is let me change every single feature.

1:26:00I mean save them as a set because that's a terrible interface for most people

1:26:03but I like that they would never do that they would just say oh we've decided all the settings for you

1:26:08and you don't have to change them which is fine for what you want but my big complaint is they give you the settings

1:26:13but then they're like some of them are global some of them are semi local Some of them are local only and

1:26:18when you save a preset bike you're saving some weird subset of that and it's just terrible.

1:26:24So when you're making your own you need to see them like that.

1:26:28That's what I keep thinking about it like it's going to be I would be OK Well no no I'd like in terms of it's find

1:26:35people Bennett's offer like we're also used to you know car makers and everyone is not going to solve

1:26:39or an interface is ugly and they look like the silk like M S Das or they used to be like you're excited

1:26:43when they've had onscreen control the U.C.S.B.

1:26:45Buttons and everything but it's like Isn't it easier to do it the dumb way.

1:26:49Like it's almost it's almost like they are

1:26:50and it's the worst products through software like the easier to implement solution is still insanely unfriendly

1:27:01but it's still so much better than what they're offering because this is no way any regular person is going to

1:27:06understand the even with the giant table of valid Commission's input output.

1:27:10They don't explain like what settings are linked to each other which setting can be changed independently

1:27:15and which like you have to send in the source code for like to figure out like when I change this

1:27:20and save a cent of the setting

1:27:22but I change to a different setting which settings change wrenching change in which setting says same

1:27:26and it doesn't depend on what the settings are and what things are turned on of the timer like.

1:27:31Seems like the stupidest thing you possibly think of would be better than what we have now

1:27:36and then working your way up and

1:27:39when I think we like nester Apple like Nest is trying to not have you the nest thing is like all people know how to do

1:27:44is turn the dial hotter when they're hot.

1:27:46When they're cold and cold or when they're hot

1:27:48and that's all we should expect them do will do the right thing which is a noble goal and it's good

1:27:51but I don't want that on my receiver I just at the bare minimum I want let me you have a million settings.

1:27:57Some of them are about some of them. Some combinations of.

1:28:00Now some are trying to make everything about as possible I don't want to hear him put on H.D.M.I.

1:28:04One you can only output over a she my three Y. Y.

1:28:07All the hardware reason I'm sure there is

1:28:09but like my ideal device would be a the most complete metrics possible for inputs and outputs.

1:28:15Put whatever chips in there you have to do it every option configurable and just let me save all those options off.

1:28:21Then you'd spend three days setting it up make all your presets

1:28:25and you'd be done now is like always a mystery of like which settings about the Change menu with a changing this thing.

1:28:32I'm I'm really glad that so far I have made decisions

1:28:36and I've I've kind of accidentally fallen into limitations that prevented me from ever actually needing a receiver

1:28:44and I've intentionally kept it that way because I have many of the same concerns that you did before getting one of

1:28:51trying to avoid this world of complexity and

1:28:54and I think the result of getting one has confirmed that those concerns were valid aren't dead.

1:29:01And you know like it sucks that T.V.

1:29:03Don't have more inputs

1:29:04and the reason tv's are more inputs is because I guess I assume because most people who would fill all the inputs on

1:29:12the T.V.

1:29:12and Need more probably also have a receiver because it's like the thing to get to advance your set up to the next level.

1:29:18But to not have that device would be so much better and so many other ways like.

1:29:25And I'm one of those weirdos like I don't even have surround sound and I'm very very happy with stereo sound.

1:29:31I'm like I had for a while in college I got the speaker set off of the bay that was a pretty suspicious.

1:29:38Sounds like it fell off a truck.

1:29:40I really like thinking back on it on the way to minute

1:29:45but anyway so I had this like integrated powered speaker set from Sony that like just one of the speakers contained all

1:29:52the amplification for the other ones and it was a five point one set

1:29:56and for the first couple years a colleague actually brought all four.

1:30:00Point one speakers with me and sucked in is a pain and I had all these wires everywhere

1:30:05and I just eventually stop burning the center on the rears and just brought the left and the right

1:30:09and just put it in story mode and left it there

1:30:12and I realize that once I didn't have surround sound I didn't miss it at all like it was so unimportant to me for for

1:30:19what I actually use and when I actually cared about it didn't matter one bit that I didn't have surround I had left

1:30:24and right and so I was able to keep the set of simpler the whole time

1:30:28and ever since then I've kept kept her very simple

1:30:31and just have never had surround sound again because it just turned out to be this given that I don't actually care

1:30:35about.

1:30:36So in the same way I wonder like could you John like could you give up any of these inputs

1:30:42or could you find some of the solution to remove your need for this receiver.

1:30:47Well I was in the same camp as you for the longest time

1:30:49but I care less about sound that I do about picture that's why I have a super expensive relative the one

1:30:53and all the oh by super expensive T.V.

1:30:56and You know no speakers at all for the longest time

1:30:58and I love having all the inputs on my television because it did make it simple enough for anybody in my family to use

1:31:03all my devices were connected.

1:31:05They're all labeled you could pick any of my game consoles by name and switch to the input

1:31:09and you can you know it was straight forward there were three boxes you had to coordinate

1:31:14but once the tv's came with your inputs I think well that ship has sailed

1:31:18and so if I have to get a receiver anyway now is the time

1:31:21and this is basically the first you know surround you know five point one system that I have now diving into that

1:31:26previously I had an old analog receiver on there but I only had two speakers a couple kind like you

1:31:31and I would almost never use them because they were terrible speakers so I bought the cheapest possible

1:31:36and the smallest possible five point one speakers because my room is not set up for a five point one is really hard to

1:31:40find a place to put the speaker there then but you know I did the research

1:31:44and I found one of the best cheap flights on once and you can get

1:31:47and I don't think I would ever use it which is why I figured I'm going to get the thing about to get the speakers

1:31:51anyway but I don't want to spend less money while they'll be off all the time I assume just like my old speakers

1:31:56and that's why I wanted a receiver that I could change the inputs on without turning.

1:32:00Not

1:32:00and Canada works great like you can you know I can I can change inputs without having to turn the big thing on it all

1:32:05lights up and you know sort of like the features that I pick for work great

1:32:09but I find myself now to my own surprise watching almost all of my television in five point one because pretty much

1:32:15every perm I want is five point tradition activists five point one Netflix stream so I pull on Apple T.V.

1:32:20Five on movies that you know of course Blu rays and stuff like that.

1:32:23They all put out five point one and my speakers again are crappy but the speakers

1:32:28and flat panel televisions are super crappy So just having like a reasonable base

1:32:33and a center channel those are the two big Forget about surround like very few things actually use the back channels

1:32:38that much anyway but just having a real low in sound which you can get from flat panel speakers insides to the T.V.

1:32:44and A center channel so the dialogue can be understandable

1:32:48and loud enough without like you know blasting a lot of like kids I am a convert to watching even on terrible five on

1:32:55one speakers watching television

1:32:57and movies like that versus Washington the other thing so that's that's kind of been like the big surprise for me that

1:33:04even though I am so much more visually oriented than auditoria Leroy on ever be oriented I find myself using the

1:33:12surround a lot more than I could I guess it goes a long way you know the fact that because I got guest they're terrible

1:33:16in the grand scheme of things

1:33:17but they're way better than like that crappy stereo speakers I had like there's a couple hundred I've spent a couple

1:33:22hundred bucks on speakers

1:33:23but basically pretty much the same price as the receiver itself on speakers which anyone who knows any of our you would

1:33:28say No I actually just spend way more money on speakers than you should on the receiver because they're much more

1:33:33important but you know again and care.

1:33:35So it worked out well for me I'm very happy with the receiver I got

1:33:38and very glad I didn't buy the Sony receiver that I was looking at that as the forty page nightmare threat of the Sony

1:33:44support forms with people having problems.

1:33:46A research pays off you know it's funny I'm in a similar boat so Marco I used Well I still have a five point one set up

1:33:54but I only have the subwoofer in the center in the left and right speakers.

1:34:00On rare installed right now

1:34:02and that's mostly a laziness because I didn't have a really good way to wire up the rear speakers without drilling

1:34:08through the floor drilling to the ceiling and I just didn't want to deal with any of that and such never did.

1:34:13We've been in the house since two thousand and eight started on it

1:34:15and there are times there are absolutely times that I miss it without question

1:34:19but just having proper non built into the T.V. Speakers and a subwoofer makes a world of difference.

1:34:28And even just having that is enough to keep me happy

1:34:32and here I am I wish I had the rear speakers are time to watch a movie that that is designed to be particularly

1:34:39immersive don't it.

1:34:41Movies aren't in general and I can think of a great example

1:34:43but you know a movie that clearly you you want to be in the middle of an out of the action

1:34:47and all miss those rear speakers but generally speaking I'm fine I'm perfectly happy with just the left right

1:34:54and I do have center but you know left right and sub the I think centers even over rated like so.

1:34:59So my sort of now is I just have these pair of paradigm out of bookshelf speakers which is a really nice book just

1:35:06because but just left and right

1:35:07and it's like this is it this is a good way to buy speakers it is the the absolute cheapest model from a really good

1:35:14specialty speaker company and so they were like three hundred bucks for the pair or something like that.

1:35:20And and so I have those speakers powered by this little tiny new force I think it's called the U. DAC or isn't it.

1:35:33It's one of it's some kind of little like new force ant thing that is very buggy and horrible but Powers them

1:35:42and it's like the size of like two alkaloids tin So it's a little tight in the power speakers

1:35:46and so all I have is left and right

1:35:49and there's little tiny thing power in them that has a little tiny remote even smaller than the Apple T.V.

1:35:54Remote and it's fantastic it's great like the difference between. T.V.

1:36:00Speakers and these lesson write with no centers just different between T.V.

1:36:03Speakers

1:36:04and Means is just that you know what John John I think this I think is an address you need just from how to center

1:36:09shall like you're able to hear what's going on the T.V.

1:36:14Better at lower volumes because the speakers are larger They're directed more at you.

1:36:19They're better quality and so you can understand things a lot better without having to crank it up

1:36:24but it's not it's not the speaker quality it's the mix like

1:36:27when they mix five point one they put out they put the dialogue mostly in the center

1:36:31and louder on the center channel is actual separation a five point one

1:36:34and a good five point one mix with so you can you need the center channel speaker because they're not going to send the

1:36:38signal to the stereo

1:36:39and in fact the more a signal leans toward that the less you can hear the dialogue because there's almost no dialogue

1:36:45in the left and right almost all dialogue is in the center. That's only if your receiver is terrible.

1:36:51Every signal like almost everything Blu rays D.V.D.'s almost everything has a stereo mix

1:36:57and things things that only have a five point one mix will be down next.

1:37:02I know but I don't want them to know their hearts this around modes that will take it take the stereo signal

1:37:07and send it out to the centers and saw in like a or just to the stereo mix

1:37:10but I want I want to trust the person who did the five point one mix to properly makes it between left right

1:37:16and center I find them because I've I've done it the other way yes you can do I can just you know I can just power on

1:37:20the left and right speakers and put on a stereo mix

1:37:24and compared to what it's like with the five point one of the center channel

1:37:26and I think I think I spend more time on the five point one mixes

1:37:29and I think I find them you know better than than the stereo mixes.

1:37:35Well regardless so I have in my opinion a very very close approximation to the value of a full system a full five point

1:37:42one But which of these two relatively small bookshelf speakers that are each about eighty two inches taller than the

1:37:49new MacPro and about twice the deep and serious about the no that's because I hate external subs.

1:37:56I absolutely hate subwoofers. I've never had it.

1:38:00One system that I cared about for good reason because I don't like the way they sound.

1:38:04I don't like the imprecise kind of the source of where it's coming from you know wherever that's you tucked it behind

1:38:11the T.V. or Whatever it doesn't it never sounds right.

1:38:14I like speakers that are big enough to do their own sub offering so these you know bookshelf speakers for T.V.

1:38:20Is a perfectly fine

1:38:20and for low volume audio it's perfectly fine to if I if I want to get a lot more volume I would go with force

1:38:27and like you know the full floor height speakers.

1:38:29I really really hate actual subwoofer they didn't they do not sound good they never sounded good.

1:38:34Well there are always there is configured terribly people houses like if you've only heard them in stores

1:38:40and people thousands there are just massively miscalibrated over Boston just super terrible I hate them because they're

1:38:45gigantic I mean there's no getting around the fact you know you have you have this gigantic thing

1:38:48but other than that like

1:38:50when correctly calibrated in most of the good receivers these days have some usually pretty crappy were way better than

1:38:56nothing calibration or you can just put a you know a directional mike where your head would be

1:39:01and it just runs test tones that adjust the levels

1:39:04and I was amazed at how how low level it put the sub like this guy was like is a sub working at all.

1:39:09I didn't you didn't hear that annoying kind of where is that rumbly think coming from the propre level for subs

1:39:16according to the judgment thing

1:39:17and I tell you live now is basically like I can hear it at all it just sounds like my speakers have more bass

1:39:24and in the few movies that really just you know thunder that out with an explosion it works well there.

1:39:29But otherwise you should basically not hear it just make you know my crappy tiny even smaller than bookshelf speakers

1:39:34feel like oh they actually have low end it's a miracle of science but really it's like that.

1:39:39That's like you're not even sure and turned on but this we'll see if you need that little of it

1:39:45and then I think you know if you know your speakers are smart that's that's a different story

1:39:49but like you know if if I'm going to have bookshelf speakers even compact bookshelf speakers I think that's big enough

1:39:55you know the you know the woofers on them are big enough to provide How big is the.

1:40:00How big is the biggest cone or whatever you use including the rubber gasket around it's five inches across.

1:40:12Yeah that's probably I mean five or six inches is probably quite a bit my speakers are super tight

1:40:16and I was one of my requirements right speakers is because you've seen the room that they're in like I have no place to

1:40:19put speakers on like well he's just they could kind of be really small so I can tuck them in you know they get a lot of

1:40:25the pictures on my mantle.

1:40:26One of the surround speakers is like there amongst the pictures so it has to be pretty much the height of a picture

1:40:31and conspicuous as possible you know. So I defined it is about those otherwise it would just be you know nothing.

1:40:38My biggest con is like three NEVER four inches and they're you know I also I greatly you know as much as I can alter

1:40:45and of course you know the influence of my wife

1:40:47and I want to keep the house reasonably looking is is a different impact as well

1:40:51but certainly as I get older I value it more and more having fewer smaller things you know

1:40:57and less complexity in the set up like.

1:40:59That's another reason why I don't want to receive it like just and why I don't want five point one

1:41:03or seven point one surround like I'm so happy just having a decent left right speakers. If the T.V.

1:41:09Could power them that would be one more thing that I could remove

1:41:11but it can't so a well I just I'm very happy just keeping things as simple as I possibly can and then you

1:41:18and I had a kid.

1:41:21Well hey that now there's less for him to wreck or pull down or you know pull the wires out of or eat or anything else.

1:41:26So it's all good.

1:41:29They saw two or three sponsors this week transporter King and Squarespace and we will see you next week.

1:41:36The show is over accidental. And you are sitting on the current system that can live and so I went on this trip.

1:42:41Did you survive it. I did I think the trip was my my my friend from my friend from high school is getting married.

1:42:49I'm the best man and for his bachelor party he want to do the ski trip in Seattle

1:42:54and one of the things that we we also had the idea you know what let's try a leg in because we we were the two that

1:43:00always start all the land games back in high school and we had games of total annihilation and then later on me

1:43:07and more recent games mostly total annihilation.

1:43:09So we thought you know we we would have like Apple laptops

1:43:12and if you if you the other guys were coming on the trip also were part of this group

1:43:16and also had laptop so let's let's just try to set up you know basic when game.

1:43:21OK You would think in this day

1:43:24and age this would be easy that we're trying to run a game that came out in one thousand nine hundred six.

1:43:30How hard could apartment twenty seven to me. How hard could it possibly be to run this game in twenty fourteen.

1:43:37And so I first tried a few things I tried like you know what would be easiest is if I can get it running in virtual box

1:43:44because virtual boxes free and then I can just copy the V.M.

1:43:47Between anyone's computer that needs it and just launch it

1:43:50and we could be guaranteed to have the same set up in everyone's computer isn't just copying a V.M.

1:43:54That would be the best.

1:43:55Well first of all what version of Windows do you run well if you want to pirate from or do you want.

1:44:00Like you know you know how do you deal with copying if it's activation all this crap then I settled on I was going to

1:44:06get the version of Windows eight point one that Microsoft is offering for a developer preview right now for free

1:44:11because that you can download it there's no activation and it only runs for ninety days

1:44:14but that's all we needed to meet we needed to run for so fine right.

1:44:18So I get all that and try installing it in a virtual box and the game just does not run right.

1:44:27Virtual Box You know we want to play three games total annihilation movies commander

1:44:32and if possible Supreme Commander which is much newer and higher higher needs.

1:44:37So we want to run those three games and you know virtual box just doesn't or doesn't run right.

1:44:43We tried parallels I've heard of before I got there.

1:44:47Parallels are supposedly the best one of these things of gaming disaster by the way.

1:44:52Really annoying like parallel that like the crap installs that asking you is really of noxious really.

1:44:58Yeah I want to recommend a V.M.

1:44:59Ware but they can see parallels that are the games they only say because well I'll try that next year.

1:45:05There was always my choice because it was always the much more professionally made of the two

1:45:11and you could feel it like in in all the different variants and just seemed like the more adult version.

1:45:17So I try to V.M.

1:45:18Ware also didn't work right for these games

1:45:20but OK well I guess I can try boot camp so I tried to camp Everything works great now I get everything set up

1:45:28and I in order to try to mitigate having to mess with computers for hours on exam knew we wouldn't have time

1:45:35or motivation to do that on a ski trip where we you know we would get home from a ski resort get home from dinner

1:45:40and just want to like try to start a game in ten minutes

1:45:43and play you know if it takes more than ten minutes to set up once where there were no was no want to do it so let's

1:45:49make it simple so that our boot camp I know that even the most recent version of Windows bootcamp works great

1:45:56and I bought the steam versions of these two games.

1:46:00Because people like Moon base

1:46:01and sub come about the steam versions so they were there so chiefly the social games a total of eleven dollars to buy

1:46:07both of them so I said All right so he mailed everyone I said are here for you to do if you have a P.C.

1:46:12Laptop bring it install the steam versions of these two games. Here's the links.

1:46:16Able to see only eleven dollars please install them now before you get here that way when you get here.

1:46:22Everyone has the same version of the game ever has the same games everyone has the same maps everything's updated.

1:46:28No one has to deal with cds or CD checks or CD cracks

1:46:31or any of that crap to deal with trying to get my games going we were teenagers. So this should work perfectly.

1:46:37So I get there. One guy doesn't have a dimple camp it's only in V.M. Ware which doesn't work and can't boot it.

1:46:47One guy had installed one of the games the other game

1:46:49and hasn't launched even while serving us to update on this like satellite connection in the woods that we have the

1:46:54disc.

1:46:55We spend probably a good forty five minutes trying to get one game started of the simple as possible thing passing

1:47:02U.S.B.

1:47:03Keys back and forth copying all this crap between the two computers having steam launch and failed

1:47:07and not going to the Internet in the not

1:47:09and then want to update itself not have the updates of course of course nobody had actually done what I said

1:47:13or they didn't half of it or they don't you know a half assed job of the thing they didn't say

1:47:17and finally we get the games both launched both running and can't see each other over the network.

1:47:24Emmett is like Screw it.

1:47:25Let's get some bourbon and that then I became a bourbon one instead of a video gaming night

1:47:30and this is like I tell this here because this is the this is still like the state of trying to get a land so I mean in

1:47:42the end of the day though your evening became better because it involved bourbon instead of old P.C.

1:47:49Games to be fair it probably would have ended in Bourbon regardless but at least that way even after the games

1:47:56or maybe during you know halfway through the games. Yeah.

1:48:00They should have brought in tennis sixty four you could hook up the T.V.

1:48:02and Play God

1:48:02and I know a man I want to work that actually does that we'll be able to get a lot of that too that we're actually

1:48:08living better the whole time I was thinking like of course we all had to be like the difficult nerds

1:48:13and like these weird P.C. R.T.S. Games like why couldn't we all just like an X.-Box game and be so much easier.

1:48:19No no we had we had to be difficult for a little while anyway.

1:48:22Pretty soon you're not going to plug in Tennessee or into the back of a T.V.

1:48:25Because the you know nothing we have composite parts but in some crappy hotel was probably there for a while.

1:48:31You probably can get some sort of like cheap a converter box to have has H.D.M.I.

1:48:36Out on it you know that's more thing you got to bring like you know a couple laptops take up less space in a bag than

1:48:42in sixty four

1:48:42and a few controllers I know that in their divorce like you control that that's that's the flaw in your plan which

1:48:47we're relying on other people to successfully do something you like well I've done the hard work

1:48:51and you know what you guys need to do or you know right now is execute on the simple plan

1:48:54and that was you know that's the downfall of like here if you want to work you should have been like calling each

1:48:59person on the phone a week before three days before a day and say hey I don't want to set up.

1:49:04Have you launched a ham not running in a V.M. Are you I know you might be doing that.

1:49:08Boot camp means you reboot the whole computer

1:49:10and you just say Windows No it's not going to you know like you have to like nag them to death until you confirm

1:49:15and then I do test games very good you know to make sure you can see each other than that we're going to have different

1:49:19theme ideas in your blog.

1:49:22You're connecting this team for the first time from this computer please grant your password Oh I don't know what it is

1:49:26like there's so many there's so many places you can go wrong it does not surprise me that you were unsuccessful.

1:49:31Well and another idea I had was to use rent like four laptops before I got there

1:49:36and because you can rent labs from some from some places including tech serve here in the cities

1:49:39and like you can just rent a laptop like let me just configure them before even go

1:49:42and bring my own bring a stack of four like thirteen inch map with pros pre-configured to work exactly the way I want

1:49:49to but that would've cost a thousand dollars

1:49:52and didn't I thought you know everyone will have laptops in a way that would be wasteful.

1:49:57But you know let's see let's see what we can do I'm sure.

1:50:00It's so easy to install any version of Windows install the steam versions of these games

1:50:04and bring your computer that's it.

1:50:06No that's not at the thought that this is the good version like Steam is just you know is that the mirror the modern

1:50:12miracle of P.C. Gaming is that it makes it so much easier you know right.

1:50:17No serial number of none of that crap ever of the same version it's always updated like come on.

1:50:21Nope can't even do that.

1:50:23Sounds like fun although you know I'm a little disappointed that you didn't try to bring all these computers through

1:50:29neither gate checked or through baggage claim or whatever because there's no reason why that should be a problem

1:50:36but there would have been a humongous problem with that. Oh yeah like you know why does one person need four laptops.

1:50:42Clearly you're trying to hack the N.S.A.

1:50:45but What else could you be using for laptops for all you know what I was gonna buy the pano thing there's not much to

1:50:52say about pano I wrote a thing about it a few months ago into it again tonight I think.

1:50:58But basically it lead to an article by my favorite writers Dan Rather of Dan's data

1:51:04and he wrote this big thing basically debunking the whole collecting a whole bunch of debunked this in one place

1:51:10debunking the whole thing about how you know it it turns out you can't hear the difference between you know over forty

1:51:17four point one kilohertz files and over sixteen bit resolution

1:51:20and you know all the all of the supposed benefits of this like high bit rate high you know high sample rate high high

1:51:28density music.

1:51:30I definitely music rather you know there is a real thing with remastering

1:51:35and you know you have like the loudness war making music sound terrible the way it's released on CD and stuff

1:51:41and then a lot of these a lot of these high definition releases that are like it you know one hundred to kill or hurt

1:51:47or something like that twenty four bit thirty two bit flow whatever it is a lot of them will have a better more more

1:51:55even less F.M. Radio like mastering so that they will sound better just because.

1:52:00It's like they were mastered love better and they were you know crushed and compressed less in the dynamic range.

1:52:07So there are lots of reasons why some of these things sound better

1:52:09but none of them are the bit rate of the sample rate above a certain point and that point is pretty much CD quality.

1:52:18And so you know these things like pot I mean a guy could talk forever about audio file stuff and I won't.

1:52:24But let me quickly interrupt you for those who don't know.

1:52:27Pano Pono pony cone the whatever it's called is this thing by Neil Young where it's supposed to be a high fidelity

1:52:37portable music player and I'm assuming there's a store associated with that is that correct.

1:52:43You know it's a it's basically trying to be like a high definition version of i Tunes So it has the device plus the

1:52:51music store that goes along with a device

1:52:53and this will you know this it's a whole new ecosystem that is I believe funded on Kickstarter shortly

1:53:00or about to be fun to kick start or at least it will be put on Kickstarter.

1:53:04Sure if it will succeed but it's already like funded like double funded like a one of a hundred grand

1:53:09and they've got one point six pledged already. Yeah that's not good.

1:53:12Well

1:53:12but I think that is good I'm rooting for the ecosystem to become vibrant because that what it means is that we'll be

1:53:17able to get like you know two fifty six kilohertz Lossie rips of all of their well mastered tracks

1:53:22and part of the time.

1:53:25Yeah I mean that's like you know this is one of those things where it would be nice for you know mastering engineers to

1:53:34have like a market force to make things better.

1:53:36Unfortunately I think they're already do I think you know the general drop in the Rev In the relevance of radio helps a

1:53:43lot. I believe Apple's called mastered for i Tunes.

1:53:47Yeah they're better but

1:53:48but opening up an audio app it's still kind of like a wall of like it there then I am a great range as best we were

1:53:54looking for the like you know from the loudest sort of quiet is that you just look at the wave form of the waveform

1:53:59looks.

1:54:00One big screen goal that's that that goes the full height of the thing all across that's that's your problem

1:54:05and there are the massive Rogers ones are better in that regard

1:54:08but they're nothing like if you look at like the levels on like vinyl

1:54:11or whatever where there was the quiet sections were really little ripples

1:54:14and then the loud sections just started to go close to touching the edges all I can to graft on a line where the next

1:54:21you know amplitude over what I think I have faith in the mastering of these people are going to do with their crazy

1:54:27high bit rates

1:54:28and everything that that mastering will be more aggressive in terms of the manic range than even the master tried to

1:54:33and so that's why actually I was serious I really do look forward to if I can get you know some of my favorite songs as

1:54:40as a six kilobit rips of those last was crazy high bitrate ones that I'll be able to experience a song in a new way

1:54:49with a much bigger dynamic range and even better than the Manson tried to write I mean

1:54:54and that's that's all very valid

1:54:55but like it's like you know it's not like the placebo effect is like well you can argue that it works

1:55:02but it doesn't work for the reason people think it works.

1:55:04It's like they've been the kind of thing like these these tracks might sound better

1:55:08but it's not because of any of the technical things that they have on a platform it's entirely because of the input.

1:55:15You know how the media has mastered going in like that that would be why they sound better.

1:55:19You know if it turns out if you do

1:55:21and there's a there's a number of sites that offer this like man I forget if I have them our complete Yeah this is

1:55:27really cool if you go to M.P.'s three or not dot com This is this is hilarious.

1:55:32So it lets you play to play basically automate an ab X. Test.

1:55:38So an A B X test in brief and please people of science on the part of the from messing this up. And A B X test.

1:55:46So Eve heard about a beat try try one thing and for another thing and see which one you think is better

1:55:51and the problem with that is what the problem is that but it's easy to like hear things that aren't there

1:55:56or perceive things that aren't there and you don't really know so a V.X. Test.

1:56:00Is you have two unlabeled inputs or even label doesn't matter to inputs A and B. and Then you have this X.

1:56:07and You say here's a here's B. Listen as much as you want. Here's X. He's a little as much as you want is X. A or B.

1:56:17and So M P three or not this size is an example one of these things. So it says All right so you have you know A and B.

1:56:23Like a is a high bit rate and B. Three B. Is a lower bit rate M P three. What is X. Is it the is it the three twenty K.

1:56:30or The one twenty eight K. and P. Three.

1:56:32And I tried I tried the site on my set up which I currently have

1:56:37but many people would argue with the best headphones in the world.

1:56:40I could not tell the difference between these two I have I failed.

1:56:44I got it right about half the time which means that I'm failing.

1:56:47You know that's that's you know random guessing so I could not tell the difference reliably on this site

1:56:54and you know people there's always more things you can blame you can blame my lack of sophisticated years you can blame

1:57:01some other part of my setup you can blame the fact that these are both M P three S.

1:57:04and Neither one of them is a loss of file or whatever the case may be.

1:57:08But it's one of the things like hearing the difference here is a larger psychological with a lot of these things

1:57:16and if you add in a lot of the a lot of the possible upgrades and enhancements and fidelity

1:57:22or hardware advance notice in the audio world a lot of them don't seem to be accessed including things like fancy

1:57:29cables or even fancy apps a lot of this just does not hold up

1:57:34and you know the reality is most people even even the audio files who own and buy

1:57:40and talk about these things usually even they have a pretty hard time in a B.X.

1:57:44Testing tell the difference between things like M P three bit rates fancy cables

1:57:48and fancy amps for every three bit rates a lot of it depends on if the actual specific song they're playing to you

1:57:54happens to hit one of the areas that M B three encoding is bad it's encoded like this pathological case.

1:58:00It's like you know you get that M P three sizzle

1:58:02but only for certain sounds with a certain cadence in a certain frequency so if you play some song that does not have

1:58:08any of that noise in it you won't die.

1:58:09That's what people are going to look at the artifacts like it's fine

1:58:12when you know you're not running into one of these areas where the way the N.B.A.

1:58:15Three cheats end up becoming visible

1:58:19and so I could it's like you know just I don't even know the sort of like sort of middle of the road classical music

1:58:23was sort of like nice tones and it's not like high frequency high pitched drumming

1:58:28and cymbals where you might start to hail here a little bit those artifact the sizzles

1:58:32but that's basically what I have better still if I was trying to listen for something of what I'd be listening for

1:58:36those artifacts and I know those are in fact from the days of like you know ninety six kilobit

1:58:40and all the rigs you know super overcompressed like those same artifacts like oh in this part of so I can totally hear

1:58:47all this fuss keep cranking up the bit rate around one twenty eight pretty much almost all that fuzz goes away

1:58:52but there's maybe a little bit left to fifty six.

1:58:55I can't hear anything in three twenty Certainly I can hear any difference

1:58:58but what I do hear definitely from you know as I have lots of copies of the same music bought on remastered on CD

1:59:04and stuff like that in the original on CD and in the crappy original CD release I hear differences in the mix

1:59:09and that's more important to me than the bit rate at this point.

1:59:13Yeah I definitely notice older like I still live pretty much my entire music collection from whenever I start first

1:59:22started amassing M P three S.

1:59:24So ninety six something like that and the empty trees that were ripped way back then when our tools weren't as good.

1:59:33Nobody knew what settings to use arguably nobody does today but certainly more do than ninety six.

1:59:39I can absolutely hear compression artifacts particularly with symbols especially there I can I can hear a lot of

1:59:46artifacts but compare that to anything ripped in the last five to ten years

1:59:51and I agree with you that once you hit for me it's about one hundred to over one hundred two I don't think it makes a

1:59:57difference I feel like one twenty eight maybe it's. But I feel like one twenty eight.

2:00:01I can still hear the artifacts one ninety two is all I need now I'm happy. So titles.

2:00:07Let's go to the ticker All right let's go to bed.

2:00:11Well I will say that I am very close to releasing the Iowa seven update for fast text

2:00:17and I really need to do it well in the next six months so I didn't overcast.

2:00:21Can you put a foot a feat based Easter egg in there for me to figure something out

2:00:27and if you don't beat overcast you should really feel ashamed because of the relative complexity of the that locations

2:00:32is not damaged John don't you sell fast tech shortly.

2:00:35No such I just set myself back a month you should be able to beat me pretty easily.

2:00:39You know I've been working with a designer Jason Jacob's Ladder and he's been very good

2:00:44and on a wildly unrelated note I've been playing with no J.S. What I really like it. I kind of feel dirty.

2:00:52That's good man that you're actually doing something more recent than anything John

2:00:55and I will probably ever do think about it I do know it's awful to seriously makes me hate javascript even more.

2:01:05Web Developer united capital times I was kept at the fact of life. Sad sad fact of life.

2:01:10Well yes

2:01:11but doing javascript in the browsers in many it's a far cry I know it's not the browser writing real programs with

2:01:19javascript which prevents the what in your web developer is doing at this point you're not just like those the way for

2:01:23me to script the browser that age path long ago were writing real programs and jobs covenant and

2:01:27when you had to write a real program in a language that's what makes you really hate it because you like it if I had to

2:01:33speak your language this wouldn't be so stupid.

2:01:36For a start it not a little balls and all the things that are like still kind of half built and still immature

2:01:41or even just like every time I do that a distressing manipulations like you were so close you had all the features I

2:01:46find access stupid. Of course a Perl programmer would complain and moan about string manipulation.

2:01:51Anything I'll take a pic in a language P.H.P. Ruby said awk anything has better more time and more convenience.

2:02:00String manipulation than javascript every time I got to do like you know string dot match

2:02:05and then wrap the whole thing in parentheses

2:02:07and sub script off the first one because it was the original strain going for some insane read like I just it's not

2:02:14that it's not huffman code to use Perl parlance the most common things are not short and simple.

2:02:19The most common things are just as stupid as the complicated things you are so bitter

2:02:24and cheated in the old money with no notice

2:02:28and now it is a fun way to have a trial that goes thing that's speaking of a nice note to look at what Ghost it's like

2:02:35what he called that would change his blog to it I heard about it from him.

2:02:39It's a way to run a blog and they have a hosted version that they charge an arm and a leg for but it's open source

2:02:44and you can just download and run on your system

2:02:46and it's just a node based blog engine it's like well that's exactly what I'm writing right now because you didn't

2:02:51Marco didn't I didn't want to be left out dammit I did not make a blog an engineer made a way to produce the H.T.M.L.

2:02:57Files that I are sent up to anyway.

2:03:01But yeah I like and I said mine is not it's not a system at all but a ghost is

2:03:05and if you're making one yourself download ghost and just look at the source because it's eminently understandable

2:03:12and it's a neat little app like I don't like it particularly I wouldn't use it as a blogging engine

2:03:16but seeing it's kind of the first like example because Open Source of like here you go here's the whole thing.

2:03:22Run it yourself if you want and it's small enough you can understand it here but then that defeats the whole purpose.

2:03:28But then I could just use Tumblr now.

2:03:30No just look at it to get like ideas of how this structure things is like I thought it was a protest vote was ample of

2:03:36how do you write a modern inode based web application without including umpteen billion for a mark so they do install a

2:03:44lot of other modules but it was pretty straightforward when you have to consider that.

2:03:49I'm way too self obsessed to do anything smart like that.

2:03:54Plus I'm way too bad it note and I'm sure if I looked at this which I will and I would look at this code and be like.

2:04:00I don't know what the hell's going on now. You will find it completely understandable.

2:04:04Like everything is extremely straightforward and I think fair enough.

2:04:08Well my blogging engine which is barely an engine that basically just regurgitates markdown and as a couple

2:04:13and builds an R.S.S. Feed and does a couple other very small things. It is sitting at three hundred nine lines of code.

2:04:19Him By that I mean there's three hundred nine lines in this file some of which are comments a lot of which are

2:04:24whitespace etc So there's nothing much to it.

2:04:28I'm really enjoying it for basic stuff I would want to do it for you I would want to use note for anything serious

2:04:34or complex but the basic stuff is pretty nice.

2:04:37No if it were rails you could build the entire blogging system in one line of code.

2:04:41I've never done rails actually

2:04:42nor Ruby ever I've done I've dabbled with Python I've done like Basic Basic Basic Python and basic basic basic P.H.P.

2:04:49Which is to say I've never done object oriented neither.

2:04:54And go to school in Java scripting so bad makes you think about things differently which isn't much time to me

2:05:01and I'm glad you agree. Jerks.