0:00:02Having always knowing this son of a man. Excellent track excellent track.
0:00:09Yeah that was that was my that was my first cassettes that I ever bought was MC Hammer. Yeah I was.
0:00:15Please hammer Don't hurt him. Did you end up having him sign that cassette when you met him many years later.
0:00:21No I did not have it with me in Manhattan and poor planning when he was promoting dance.
0:00:26Did not I did I mind I was promoting tumbler yet is that still thing is dancing I'm still saying I have no clue.
0:00:33I don't I've never even even that day I didn't even look it up. Dance Jam has come to an end.
0:00:39Thank you all for the participation over the years but dance Jam has come to an end.
0:00:44I guess they sunset their brand their with their line and their visions of us with their platform umbrella.
0:00:50I'll just stop just stop you're hurting my ears. John let's talk about how you can sell tickets quickly.
0:00:58Yeah last show we talked about whether how they would sell their very few take it this year of course in the grand
0:01:03tradition of our Wednesday recording of our Friday show Apple announced how they were going to sell tickets after we
0:01:09had a record of the episode so that was fun.
0:01:12So one of the options is a lottery that's what Apple ended up doing and or something back and what are some insane
0:01:19or they didn't think that that was really difficult to do a system that won't crash due to the onslaught of people
0:01:27wanting to buy tickets.
0:01:28And on the previous show I had said that you know this is a bounded problem it's not like Facebook where in theory
0:01:33everyone in the earth with an Internet connection could get an account.
0:01:37There is limited interest
0:01:38and really see how we are trying to think how many people could there possibly be maybe one million is an upper bound a
0:01:43crazy upper bound for the conference or five thousand people
0:01:45and I said Surely someone could design a system that can handle the onslaught of thousand people
0:01:51and basically serve them in on a first come first serve basis.
0:01:55No guarantees you may still get blocked out but it's a way of potentially increasing your odds. Versus a lottery.
0:02:02A truly random lottery where there is no way of increasing your odds doesn't matter
0:02:05when you enter you know doesn't matter what you do you're just one of another.
0:02:09Whole pile of people
0:02:11and so someone said well that's what Google did too because apparently even the mighty Google couldn't put up a service
0:02:17for their I O.
0:02:18Conference so it was stand out so they did a lottery instead I don't think Google did a lottery because they couldn't
0:02:23provide a service that withstood the onslaught.
0:02:25It's conceivable that Google did the same that was made we're underestimating where the demand would be
0:02:30and put a wimpy system out there and it would be system fell down
0:02:32but I think it is entirely within Google's technical expertise to make a system that would allow a million
0:02:38or so people to try to sign up for a conference. All the same time.
0:02:43And as evidence of this someone on Twitter pointed me to Shmoo con I hope I'm pronouncing it correctly yes it could be
0:02:49schmoo can't write as in short for schmooze.
0:02:53From the description on their website it's an annual east coast hacker convention hell bent on offering three days of
0:02:58an interesting atmosphere for demonstrating technology technology exploitation bubble of anyway
0:03:03and it's you know biotech Nereids for techno it's presumably it's a small conference
0:03:07but they did pretty much what I described on the previous show which is like well just make something simple
0:03:12and straightforward with their I think fancy unit and have a system whereby every just floods it all at once
0:03:17and everyone you know first come first serve and that's all there is to it and it's not a guarantee
0:03:23and you could still be the very first person to click the button so I get a ticket because of the vagaries of the way
0:03:28servers work but at least you're increasing your odds in a service don't fall down.
0:03:32And this shook and I was a small
0:03:33and that what they did is they did a series of rounds where they would release six hundred fifty tickets at once like
0:03:38you know and I don't know how long the rounds were separated by maybe an hour whatever
0:03:43and then if you get your as if you reserve your spot then you have like five minutes to check out
0:03:48or something like that and if you decide not to buy the ticket it goes back into the pool
0:03:52and everyone who didn't make it into didn't get a reservation gets put in a queue for anything that's coming you know
0:03:57that any tickets to people don't buy and they do a series of. Sounds or whatever.
0:04:01So anyway I'm I'm you know the person who was haranguing about this on Twitter was telling me that you know in a
0:04:08slightly condescending tone that is no what I was talking about.
0:04:11I'm I'm pretty sure after what twenty years of doing web development I know what is
0:04:15and isn't possible in web development
0:04:17and it is possible to make a system that gives you slightly increased odds of getting a ticket if you if you are one of
0:04:25the first people willing to click the button again.
0:04:28No guarantees is not going to be perfect but you can make a server that doesn't crash under this kind of load.
0:04:32And apparently these people have done it and I was you know they were going back and forth
0:04:35and what about this there was a lot of goalpost moving and hemming and hawing
0:04:38but the bottom line is that I think Apple and Google both had slightly more financial
0:04:43and technical resources than Shmoo con so eventual calm is doing six hundred fifty ticket rounds so you could see Apple
0:04:52could just use the schmooze on technology which is probably one Linux server
0:04:55and one programmer they could use that technology to do like seven or eight rounds and Philip
0:05:01or you know they could use a little bit of the billions of dollars they have
0:05:04and do something similar anyway regardless of you know this in the previous show at a lottery is by far the best system
0:05:12for Apple and Apple tends to do what's best for Apple
0:05:14and they did what was best for Apple so the law kind of moot point
0:05:17but I want to bring it up again because there is an actual example right down to the sort of very simple text only not
0:05:23very fancy looking stuff written I think by one one or two people who were there were saying this is on Twitter.
0:05:29So it can be done.
0:05:30Honestly I would love the chance to try to write something like that just because like I would take it as a just like
0:05:36the Whenever there's a big key note that is not live stream that everybody clogs the hell out of the various blogs that
0:05:45have live chat transcripts of what's going on.
0:05:49I think I was trying to be cool to attempt to design one of those things
0:05:51and see like how how much is to have to remember all those things crashing Ars Technica have the same problem because I
0:05:58kept trying different vendors.
0:06:00They hired someone named Lee who was a programmer
0:06:02and he by himself wrote the new Ars Technica system for handling live blogs
0:06:06and they've been using it ever since with no problems one person probably a couple months of development.
0:06:12So there you go.
0:06:13Oh yeah I mean it's like if you if you custom tailored to exactly your needs and no more
0:06:19and you do it right taking advantage of things like you know S three and CD ends to alleviate a lot of the load
0:06:25and you know the spreading out the load stuff like that you can you can do it they can be really cool anyway so like I
0:06:32think this kind of thing like I would love the chance to design this kind of system
0:06:35and see like how like couldn't handle the rush from a five thousand ticket conference of you know fifty thousand people
0:06:42trying to get into it
0:06:43or whatever whatever the number might be if you were in a class like a college course about this topic that this would
0:06:49be one of like your homework assignments or one of like your mid term project
0:06:52or whatever you know design a system that could withstand X. Y.
0:06:55Never had like a test harness that was subject your system to the stresses newbie you have some given amount of
0:07:00hardware that you had to use efficiently
0:07:02or whatever like it's it doesn't get much more straightforward than this like you know so you don't have to do the
0:07:07purchase part just to the reservation part like that is almost the simplest possible problem you could have no big red
0:07:12I didn't like. Let me try using no J.S. Let me try using a no S.Q.L.
0:07:15Database let me use a relational database let me try it with flat files on which I would share a memory like you could
0:07:20I think of using a database at all you already lost.
0:07:22I mean my solution would be cash
0:07:24and using it in the atomic operations within memcache cleverly to to make it basically an all them cash illusion that
0:07:31the exercise would be like within a given set of hardware all these different technologies.
0:07:36How do how well do they take advantage of the hardware or don't they you know
0:07:39and you probably don't like more harder than you need
0:07:41but like you would have to have something that scale the horizontal it like it's a good object lesson because it's it's
0:07:46a very simple thing that you're trying to do actually talk about how they have scaling way down the road.
0:07:51But anyway continuing for a little bit quick topic right in then do you want to talk about.
0:08:00How anything else regarding the sign up process specifically like the follow up area.
0:08:07I don't know yet but we have to say how we all did in the D.C.
0:08:11Lottery but I don't have any more follow up on this plan thing.
0:08:13We are sponsored this week by our friends at transporter the transporter is a special extra hard drive that you own
0:08:19and control like any other external hard drive but it has these awesome cloud a network features
0:08:25but it's all private it's a private cloud that allows you to have a sharing and sync
0:08:29and a whole bunch of other cloud benefits without the files actually being stored on the cloud the files are stored on
0:08:34this drive it's in your house or in your garage or in your closet or whatever
0:08:38and you only control that drive so like Dropbox you can access your files from any of your computers or your I.I.S.
0:08:45or Android devices all your transport of files are available from anywhere that has Internet access assuming your home
0:08:51connection is online of course you can get to it you can share individual files
0:08:55or folders with web accessible share links no matter how large those files are.
0:09:01If you have multiple transporters or if you have one and your friend has one
0:09:04or a co-worker has won multiple transporters can replicate each other you can set to replicate the whole thing
0:09:09or just a folder.
0:09:11This is a great way to collaborate with projects
0:09:14or to provide an easy off site backup like if you have you can have one at home want to work want to friends
0:09:19or your parents' house or whatever the case may be.
0:09:23So if you want to sync just one folder for instance you and a friend or a co-worker
0:09:27and you collaborate on one folder
0:09:29and collaborate on a project in those files always I mean think about how big they are.
0:09:32You know minus time it takes to actually transfer them.
0:09:36So your data with transporter is secure it's never stored on cloud servers you know you don't have to worry about like
0:09:43you know if it's your own Dropbox and Dropbox has access to it
0:09:46and you know maybe government stuff might get in the way with transporter your data is stored on your hard drive it in
0:09:52your house
0:09:53when data is transferred is transferred directly between transporters end to end encryption is used so there's no.
0:10:00But in the middle who can read it all the let's talk about the Hartley by going to few minutes
0:10:03but I'm pretty sure Hardy said they were not vulnerable to that.
0:10:07So your data is very secure a transporter so how do you only see things go to File transport
0:10:12or Store dot com They have a handful of models here you can get five hundred gigs for just one ninety nine one terabyte
0:10:19for two forty nine and two terabytes for three forty nine
0:10:22and they have this other model called the transporter sync which is a little ninety nine dollars almost like a puck
0:10:27kind of thing and it just has a U.S.B. Port on one side and a network port on the other and so you plug in any U.S.B.
0:10:34Hard drive you already own
0:10:35and then against all the features of a transporter with harddrive you already have at the transporter sync for just.
0:10:41ninety nine dollars and all these prices take another ten percent off by using coupon code A.T.P.
0:10:47Now Best of all once you buy it. That's it there are no monthly fees.
0:10:51Unlike almost any cloud solution you can think of.
0:10:54You buy the transporter upfront
0:10:55and that's it no matter how much data you store as long as it fits on there that's it you're paying no monthly fees
0:11:02and if you look for example you know let's get the to Terra by model if you look to see how much it cost to store two
0:11:08terabytes of photos on a cloud service you're going to pretty quickly see the benefits here.
0:11:12So go to File transporter dot com for more info and if you go to File transport
0:11:17or Store dot com to buy these things don't forget to use coupon code A.T.P.
0:11:21To get ten percent off thanks a lot the transporter for sponsoring our show once again.
0:11:25All right so we should probably talk about D.C. Tickets and what came of that.
0:11:32So all three of us registered for tickets we were registered for the opportunity of spend sixteen hundred dollars.
0:11:40Marco did you get a ticket.
0:11:42I won the chance to spend six hundred dollars and I took that chance there
0:11:47and I too want a chance to spend six hundred dollars
0:11:51and thankfully since I'm gainfully employed Unlike you I used works money to spend six hundred dollars.
0:11:58John how did you fare. I did not get a golden ticket.
0:12:02I got a set of e-mail an hour
0:12:03and a half after the Suppose a deadline that unfortunately you cannot win a chance to spend six hundred dollars.
0:12:09Try again next year.
0:12:11This genuinely makes me extremely sad
0:12:13and I know this probably doesn't come across as genuine because I am very excited to have gotten a ticket
0:12:21but I almost not quite
0:12:24but almost wish that of the three of us you are one to get the ticket because I think it takes the most encouragement
0:12:30for you to get out there justifiably I should add.
0:12:33And so I feel like the universe has kind of wronged all of us by not allowing you to win the lottery.
0:12:40I wish your work was paying for my ticket
0:12:42and the I also you know because because I mean you know you look around at the at the rate of people you hear from on
0:12:51Twitter people you follow it at the rate of how many of them got rejected.
0:12:55I would say roughly speaking I would guess maybe one in ten got in.
0:13:03Of people that I follow or heard about or from yeah I would say the same thing
0:13:07and it's funny because before the tickets went on Survivor before the lottery ended I had plucked out of thin air
0:13:14and you know I betcha it's about fifty thousand people because I knew a lot of right and I should say a lot
0:13:18but I knew a handful of people that I didn't think or they didn't think that they would go if they got a ticket
0:13:24but what harm is it in throwing your name in the hat. You know there's no there's no penalty for that really.
0:13:30And so I would agree that of the people I saw it was about one in ten
0:13:36and given that it's about a five thousand person conference even I can handle that math says it's about fifty thousand
0:13:42people. What did you think John.
0:13:43Right after the announcement it seemed to me like it was you had a fifty fifty shot because I would say roughly half
0:13:49the people in the twenty three were saying I got one and didn't
0:13:51but then later on I start hearing about like Whole blocks of people who are like oh yeah everybody in our ten person
0:13:56company applied and none of us got tickets so that started.
0:14:00Now that I knew beforehand if you were to ask me I would say like ten to one or twenty to one
0:14:04but then afterwards I was thinking maybe it's only like two or three to one.
0:14:06But it's so hard to tell
0:14:07but I don't think we have a good sample size because you don't know everybody who's in maybe only the winners are
0:14:12saying yea they got them instead of being set or they didn't. I'm not even sure Apple will give us numbers.
0:14:17I suppose like in the W.E.C.
0:14:20Keynote in the beginning they're big part
0:14:22but they talk about all their numbers that they're proud of will be like welcome to have you received so popular the
0:14:26blah blah blah. You know maybe they'll throw something out there but in the end it doesn't matter too much.
0:14:31I think I mean like if it was like a hundred
0:14:34or a thousand to one I think we can ballpark it you know it's somewhere between you know two to one ten to one twenty
0:14:40one but I would be really surprised if it's hundred one. It seems like it's much lower than that. Yeah I mean it's.
0:14:48I feel kind of sad for everyone who didn't get one
0:14:51and that's why I didn't say anything on Twitter about whether I got one or not.
0:14:55And really the only reason I even agreed to talk about it here is that everyone's asking us
0:15:00but I feel guilty that I got one not guilty not to not take it. So if I ever is guilty.
0:15:09Do people ask me for the show that if I want to talk about whether I got my
0:15:12or not because there are two things at play one is that some people who got the chance to buy a ticket take it chose
0:15:18not to know people who did that because I was asking them if they could somehow transfer their ticket to me I don't
0:15:24think there's a way to do that I think if you got the chance to buy a ticket
0:15:26and you choose not to buy it well then you choose not to buy those tickets go back into a pool somewhere
0:15:31and presumably Apple will disperse them to people who didn't win the lottery the first time.
0:15:35So there is that glimmer of hope for me
0:15:37and the second part is the glimmer of hope that someone inside Apple knows who I am
0:15:40and says oh we should get that guy take it and some people might give me a hard time about that
0:15:45or some people think that I should feel bad that it somehow because I have this amount of fame from writing these
0:15:50reviews or whatever that someone inside Apple recognized my name
0:15:52and say I'll give him one of our pool tickets to be reserved or whatever
0:15:56but I think that's perfectly valid because for example like what. Why do.
0:16:00Certain journalists get tickets and other ones don't depending on your publications
0:16:04or because of your readership is it because of your fame is because the wife you Apple just chooses which people in the
0:16:09press that they like and give them press passes to the Keynote
0:16:12and we're going to get a process of the keynote of course
0:16:14but for many years lots of other people didn't get press passes and then they did get them
0:16:17and then they didn't get them and it's like it's whoever Apple takes about the likes of you
0:16:22and people inside Apple like you you get nice things from Apple if they don't like you
0:16:26or don't know you don't get nice things.
0:16:28I have limited control over that and hopefully you know over doing writing reviews that people Apple might read them.
0:16:34I might they might know who I am or whatever
0:16:35but you know it's not I don't feel guilty if I get special treatment because of that for the same reason.
0:16:41You know John group we shouldn't feel guilty that he gets a press pass so I go oh you've got a press guys who you run
0:16:46during final Yeah that's why he got a press pass like you know it makes perfect sense to me
0:16:50but also to point out what the press pass is which is important.
0:16:55Like
0:16:55when Gruber gets a press pass those press passes are only good for the keynote they're after the keynote that's it.
0:17:01They kick you out.
0:17:02So the press even if you had a press pass it wouldn't really help for your purposes because your purposes are you
0:17:08actually go to the sessions the whole week to learn stuff for your review
0:17:12and if you had a press pass from you know via ours
0:17:16or for either means for the keynote that really wouldn't help you at all because it would only be for that morning
0:17:22which you can watch anytime and anywhere anyway and most of the stuff that you would talk about
0:17:26or you know going to the lads asking questions talking to the engineers the press pass wouldn't lie to do any of that
0:17:31stuff.
0:17:32Yeah if I had to choose like you know I mean the president was I'm not I'm not being press of the king you know talked
0:17:39hours about
0:17:40and I told ours like if you get a press pass use it for people who are going to report on the keynote because I'm not
0:17:44going to report on the keynote and you can use that's what you use the press test of the process is useless to me.
0:17:48I need the pass to the entire conference I go to sessions every single day for the entire week.
0:17:54So you know while Ovi fund to go to the Keynote and be in there or whatever you know.
0:18:00A press fair I would never take a press pass away from someone who's actually going there to report.
0:18:04Whereas people like oh you're taking a pass away from a real developer.
0:18:07I feel like I'm going to just as many sessions of the quote unquote real developer and I'm paying attention
0:18:13and I'm taking notes and I'm using that information to do something what I'm doing is not writing a program
0:18:18but I don't think it's any less of a practical useful thing for me to go to all those sessions
0:18:22and take all those notes
0:18:23and synthesize all the data so I feel no guilt in sort of oh you're taking a pass from someone who's a developer if
0:18:29somehow I managed to get a pass.
0:18:31You can be sure that I'm going sometime between taking that thousand going dollars sessions like Asia do.
0:18:36If I don't know well what can you do. Yeah I think you know there's always every year we even thought it was last year.
0:18:42Every year you look around and you talk to people there and
0:18:46and there's always people who get in who you can be pretty much after five minutes talking
0:18:52and you can pretty much tell like yeah they didn't really need to be like people who just really aren't into it like
0:19:01into macro US development and also don't want to be into it
0:19:05and they're just they're like because their company was willing to send them in they happened to get a ticket
0:19:09or something like It's like you know you shouldn't feel bad about it like if you're if you're at all interested in this
0:19:16world of of these ecosystems if you're at all interested you should not feel bad taking it take it for it because
0:19:23there's you know yeah there are a lot of people who are interested who don't get tickets but like you
0:19:27or you're not the one person keeping all those people out.
0:19:31Yeah
0:19:31and I honestly like the videos really do help like if I don't get a ticket why it's not so bad this year not calamitous
0:19:36to my review hopefully as a disseminator announce that they released eight of us ten is like a week after seeing which
0:19:42case we're all screwed.
0:19:44They released the videos in a timely manner now so it's not so bad for me to not be there to sit through the sessions.
0:19:50Now it depends on what they announce in the year
0:19:51or so for example in certain past years they've announced technologies
0:19:54and stuff that I've spent multiple hours talking to that's just. People about ad W W D C.
0:20:03That really heavily informed my review and helped me make it better
0:20:07and those are some of the you know like from the outside if you look at my reviews like maybe it looks like all this
0:20:12one sort of one undifferentiated soup of information
0:20:15but I know the president of nation that I never would have known had I not been physically had received
0:20:19but now I'm not physically there.
0:20:21The sessions have tons of information too so it's not the end of the world from our view.
0:20:25There are always the end of the world my view is always about the now it's for the release date because that tells me
0:20:29how much time I have to write the thing but you know it's fun to go out there for a week it's fun to see people
0:20:34and I like being in the sessions like there's something about being in the room even for things like the State of the
0:20:38unions in the keynote being in that room gives you a better idea of like what the vibe is than watching the videos
0:20:45because the videos are so now that either they're manipulated
0:20:48but they're post processed in a way that like it doesn't feel like it does in the room in the room you can get a sense
0:20:52of what people really think about the going on for good or bad and any of these announcements
0:20:57and POTUS talk whispering to the people next to you
0:20:59or whatever like it's a whole it's whole thing I'll be really be sad if I don't manage to get a ticket
0:21:03but again what can you do. Yeah in the videos they dig first of all they don't show the presenter.
0:21:09Like the old it's just the pictures only of the slides
0:21:14but they also cut out like if there's any any periods of applause or laughter.
0:21:18They'll actually cut that out for a time because they try to make them faster right.
0:21:22Yeah but it's like being there live gets you all that stuff. No question and that's great and if there is Q.
0:21:29and A which there really rarely is these days but if there is Q.
0:21:32and A That's almost always cut out of the video as well
0:21:35but the videos have the advantage of being able to skim through being able to rewind to be able to play it faster than
0:21:41one expiate because the actual pace of the presenter speaking is very slow.
0:21:46So everyone can get it and you know even if even if your English isn't that great
0:21:50or even if you're even if you're a slow note taker you can still follow along which is very nice
0:21:55and accommodating of them. But it really is nice once you get home and you can.
0:22:00Videos to be able to skim through and play them like one point five X. or One point six X.
0:22:04and and Get through a lot more a lot faster or you can skip over sections that you already know about
0:22:09or sections that aren't relevant to you.
0:22:11Stuff like that you know timely release of the videos is so much more important than getting a ticket in terms of you
0:22:17know getting the information out to me very views because
0:22:20when they weren't timely I had to be in there taking notes like a demon because as soon as they change that slide I was
0:22:26never going to see those words again for God knows how many months
0:22:29and so like this is my only chance to type that literally like transcribing the slide the many times I took pictures of
0:22:36the slides like I can't come because I was going to take a picture like it was a bad situation now like for the past
0:22:41two years when they've been so good with the video it's like to relax you know because you know
0:22:44when the slides are going to be a look at those lives in a couple days anyway you'll be fine.
0:22:48And it's just so much nicer
0:22:49and then you can write down what you really should be writing down is like your thoughts that you know your synthesis
0:22:53of the information you're receiving or points that occur to your question is you want to ask and even if there's no Q.
0:22:58and A There's always the bunch of nerds gather around the presenter at the end of the thing
0:23:02and if you really have a pressing question you you know take note of that presenter
0:23:05and hunt them down later in the week or just go up there and stand
0:23:08and try to ask any question after the session is over.
0:23:10I mean that's actually one of my if one of my tips for them to be seen
0:23:13and I start doing myself is even if I don't have a question I'll just go up there and stand there
0:23:18and listen to everyone else's questions
0:23:20and the answers that they get because a lot of times like the the mob presenter at the end answering questions from
0:23:27crazy people you can get a lot of information out of that that is useful that you know maybe there are some questions
0:23:33you didn't think to ask but it actually is useful information.
0:23:36So I always end up there is listen even if I don't say so what do you guys think will happen this coming Monday at five
0:23:44Pacific which is when the deadline is for those who won the lottery to actually commit
0:23:50and reward Apple for their winning the lottery with six hundred dollars you know what do they do with those excess
0:23:56tickets to the start doling them out to John Surtees So like we all hope.
0:24:00Do they do a second run lottery like they've never said anything about a waiting list what do you suspect is going to
0:24:05happen. Let's start with John.
0:24:06I assume they're going to do another random disbursement
0:24:09and if you're one of the lucky few you will get an e-mail that says I know we told you before you can go take it
0:24:13but one is available if you'd like to but you have until X.
0:24:16Date
0:24:16but I don't think they'll send out more negative e-mails like that I won't get a second email telling me a bunch of new
0:24:21tickets I really want to be I wouldn't bother but you don't just want to be there later.
0:24:26That would be so cruel that would be amazing.
0:24:28That's that's what I suspect that the lucky people kind of like what happened in that year
0:24:32when everyone is like have purchased things in their car like they just went to those people
0:24:35and said hey it looks like you tried to buy taken didn't get it if you still want to like it
0:24:40and I think that makes sense for the way they would do this.
0:24:43Well so last year and the year before like you know when they've sold out rapidly and probably before that too
0:24:50but Apple's developer relations people have always had some tickets to give away.
0:24:57Like if somebody really important
0:24:59or really deserving didn't get a ticket they could like email their friends at Apple
0:25:03and like hey would you consider me and sometimes that works sometimes it didn't.
0:25:06So there's always been this pool of tickets that that might be given away you know as the developer relations people
0:25:13you know at their discretion or to like important corporate clients or whatever the case may be
0:25:18or you know good you know good stories from students or young people or whatever else so that my guess is when
0:25:27when the number of tickets that are unclaimed becomes you know established if I'm really really really high like over
0:25:35you know I mean there's about five thousand tickets if let's say that number is over a thousand if over a thousand of
0:25:41them are unclaimed. That weren't already reserved to be given away at their discretion.
0:25:46Maybe they might do it in the RAM drawing
0:25:48but honestly I would assume that whatever pool is not a claim to the random lottery that just gets added to their pool
0:25:58of discretionary tickets that they can give.
0:26:00Way say I thought I figured they had their discretionary pool was already pretty big
0:26:03and that's why I thought they would do this a second random thing is that I thought they already had a discussion April
0:26:08that was never even put up for possibility and there are saving those like.
0:26:11I mean again this is why the system is great for Apple we have no idea how they distributed tickets was a truly random.
0:26:17Did they pin down like OK we got to make sure these X.
0:26:19Number of people from the Microsoft Office team get in there and these people from Adobe
0:26:23and like you know the people who who have business relationships these people for me have to go I can imagine of
0:26:29everyone who got shut out like I don't see that happening right.
0:26:32So surely there you know
0:26:34and like it could be that the entire thing was like that like that was like a large portion of the pool could have been
0:26:40discretionary so they pinned down all their discretionary first and then to everybody else random
0:26:44and that's why I think if these people don't buy again they will have already made sure that the people they care about
0:26:49got them and then just do a second random thing. But none of us know that's the beauty and beauty of the system.
0:26:54Apple can do whatever they want and from the outside reaches all have to assume it is entirely random and fair
0:26:59and from what I've seen like it's always you can always do pattern matching in kind of a conspiracy theories like Oh no
0:27:05nobody from rogue amoeba got one not all Apple doesn't like Rogue Mima therefore they're they're being shunned
0:27:10but until we know what the total number of people trying to buy tickets was like What are the odds that all seven
0:27:16people from Rogan who didn't get it. Probably pretty good.
0:27:19I mean you know like
0:27:22and you know I don't want the other I think I think we're probably like in the show the two of the three of us got
0:27:26tickets and I don't think it was because someone was trying to give people or maybe just us the luck of the draw.
0:27:32So someone is better at probability than I am can calculate the odds that any specific group of people all didn't get
0:27:38tickets but I have a feeling that it's impossible to tell from the outside of whether it was truly random.
0:27:44I mean I think that at least some part I think the part that's been given away so far was random because you know not
0:27:53only looking around and just seeing it totally what we see around us
0:27:55but they use the word random everywhere they used it on the site.
0:28:00If they use it in both e-mails confirm
0:28:01and reject like they use the word random so many times it would be really weird to say random so much if that portion
0:28:09of the tickets was not given only randomly You know Apple's way is not to lie.
0:28:14It's just to withhold
0:28:15or not specify so I would imagine this was actually random Now they could have randomly given away thirty five hundred
0:28:23and kept fifteen hundred for themselves for discretionary use who knows. Yeah and I feel like it.
0:28:28It leaves some portion has to be random because how else do you explain away me getting a ticket and not John.
0:28:34As much as I'm excited about it I think it's pretty safe.
0:28:39There's a pretty simple argument that the community at large would be better seeing a better O.-S.
0:28:43Time review then if I am able to go and talk about it on A.T.P.
0:28:47So I then it seems clear to me at least a portion was random
0:28:50and well like the other weddings they could use for example like here's a things I'd imagine if they were going to do a
0:28:56non-random dispersal any randomly you know pseudo randomly where they use the built in rand and put a defiant seed in
0:29:01or something
0:29:02but anyway I think there's many things that can weigh in there which could be like have you seen before if you have
0:29:08your odds go down if you haven't your odds go up because they want some portion of the people to be like new people do
0:29:13you have an app in the App Store. He does I don't right.
0:29:15How long have you had a developer account how many bugs have you filed like all sorts of criteria you can imagine
0:29:21coming up with this crazy algorithm to cut away to try to like we want some percentage of new people.
0:29:26Some percentage of people who are long time developers we don't
0:29:28but if you just want to give someone else a chance like you can imagine trying to cover the algorithm
0:29:33and just getting that into the engine and letting it spin
0:29:35and saying you know it's not deterministic it's just waiting your chances based on the criteria
0:29:40or it could be entirely random like again we don't know. But like it seems like it's pretty fair.
0:29:44Like I don't see any rhyme or reason to the people who got them good and got them
0:29:49and I think anything that I am seeing
0:29:50or can try to convince myself of it's because like you know the jewels were produced pattern matching machines
0:29:55and I'll try to apply whatever you know or try to apply a narrative to anything through.
0:30:00And it will always be some patterns that we see in the noise
0:30:02but yeah I'm I'm pretty darn certain that they have a reasonably large pool of discretionary ones that they are sort of
0:30:10pinning down on the people they definitely want to come and I am not receiving on that group nor do I expect to be
0:30:15nor should I be I was hoping that I can you know you got one of the dregs but people through than to buy tickets.
0:30:23I think also I mean I haven't heard of anybody getting a discretionary ticket offered to them yet they're probably at
0:30:28least waiting until this timeout period ends so they know how many they have which is one of the reasons why I think
0:30:35why these aren't going to be really randomize that there that's going to be added to the discretionary pool.
0:30:40Well I mean like used to go to transfer them like there wasn't like a reservation a purchase that used to be that you
0:30:45could buy them but then you could transfer it as an asset within your A.D.C.
0:30:48Things over in past years there was lots of sort of horse trading going on of transferring these things around from one
0:30:52person to the other. But that's not possible here as far as I know overall are you guys.
0:30:59Obviously you know because we had different results.
0:31:02Our opinion of this is probably biased but overall how happy are you with this system that they did.
0:31:10I don't love it but I can't conceive of a better system that isn't me selecting all my friends
0:31:19and giving you know like I don't.
0:31:22I wish there were something that worked out better selfishly in the sense that you know I wouldn't.
0:31:28I'm very happy I got to take it and I'm happy you did but I wish John did
0:31:32but if you look at the bigger picture I can't I can't conceive of a system wherein I think it's more fair
0:31:39and also more agreeable to Apple as John has said many many many times.
0:31:44I think a lottery or even a lottery with some allotment on the side is about as fair as you can get.
0:31:50Yeah I also I mean again like I was picked this time.
0:31:54So it's kind of I don't know how valid his opinion is but you know that's why.
0:32:00Said last week
0:32:00when we were speaking about what they would do I said this is me be my preferred system even if I didn't win because I
0:32:09think this is again it's like you know you can think of all these different ways to try to alleviate the problem of way
0:32:15too many people wanting to be in a conference that really can't and probably shouldn't grow larger.
0:32:22But I really do think this is the best way that they could have done it
0:32:25and it worked flawlessly I got to give them credit.
0:32:27The weather service was perfectly fine possibly as a result of the E. Mail delivery pace.
0:32:33The check out process was lightning fast and fine like everything the whole thing worked fine.
0:32:41It worked exactly as they designed it it seems and I don't know.
0:32:46I really think they did the best they could and it worked. It worked as well as it could have.
0:32:52My opinion last show
0:32:53and it's unchanged I like the idea that people who are more enthusiastic about going can somehow increase their odds
0:32:59not guarantee themselves a spot not block out other people but you know like
0:33:02but just like increase their odds slightly that whole thing of ever and sitting around waiting for a coffee
0:33:08and clicking on a button.
0:33:09Maybe that's not the best way to allow people to increase their odds
0:33:12but it's a reasonable way because you are expressing your maniacal enthusiasm for wanting to go.
0:33:17By doing that and you are slightly increasing your odds by doing it
0:33:20and so system that Apple controls entirely You don't have a good way.
0:33:26At the time of purchase to increase your odds the only way you can increase your odds is by you know doing something
0:33:31over the course of two decades to put you into the good graces of Apple which is much harder to do. A day before.
0:33:35So you know.
0:33:38I would've said it even if I got to take it this time because I like you know it's sort of the powerlessness of like
0:33:44you know all I can do is put my little ticket into this hat and then just wait.
0:33:48And I guess you know there's no way for me to to express that I want to go to this more than somebody else
0:33:54and surely I want to go to this more than at least one or two other people. So there's no way for me to to.
0:34:00My God I find I find it like a controlled setting an apple I'm sure if I have a lack of control delicious and lovely
0:34:08but I do really quickly before Marco tells us about something cool.
0:34:14So John what I think you're saying is in a perfect John Syracuse take a distribution world Apple would do what they did
0:34:24in the first few years of me going anyway where they randomly out of the blue I guess so that was last year was years
0:34:33prior.
0:34:33Out of the blue they just let the tickets go and everyone has to jump on and stomp on their servers
0:34:39and try to get in before the servers crumble so no no that was that that was no good because of the people who live in
0:34:46time zones and stuff like you know our enthusiastic you are to AM where you are is not fair.
0:34:52OK So so what would you say then saw what I was going to say was let's assume the servers can handle that kind of
0:34:58impact which I know was laughable to begin with.
0:35:01Assuming the servers can handle it you would still do like twenty thirteen where they pre-announce What time is it.
0:35:06Pre-announce the time
0:35:07and date I mean someone's going to go through it anyway because it's going to be three in the morning
0:35:11and somewhere on Earth one thing goes over it a bit like you have to pick a time.
0:35:14I mean you can even do it by region by time if they want to be fair
0:35:17or like this this hemisphere this time zone release tickets in blocks like they have a ways to control basically you
0:35:23know what time I was going to be
0:35:25and you express you express your desire to go by being there hovering over the button at the exact moment
0:35:30and even if they all saw it in five seconds if you were one of the people who put that button within that five seconds
0:35:35and you got lucky because again it's not a guarantee you know due to the magic of concurrency
0:35:39and everything at the very least you increase your odds versus someone who just rolled in thirty seconds later
0:35:45or forgot about it or sent a reminder
0:35:47but didn't get a chance you know I mean like it's not great it's not a great way to express your enthusiasm it's not a
0:35:51perfect system but it is a way to increase your odds and the only thing you need is like that you've never been.
0:36:00My boy I have never been to see I keep hearing about it sounds really great I really really want to go.
0:36:04All you gotta do is make that decision sometime before the date that they announce and sit there
0:36:07and your mouse button and click your little thing to your point and that doesn't make sense.
0:36:13So why don't you tell us more about something that's cool
0:36:15but I'd also like to get you guys thinking is W W D C The way it is today.
0:36:20The right way to accomplish what they're trying to accomplish.
0:36:23But before that new relic is an all in one web app performance management tool it lets you see performance from the end
0:36:30user experience through your servers and down to each line of your server side code.
0:36:35So our friends a new relic asked us to take a minute
0:36:38and say a big Thank You to all you data nerds out there building all this great stuff that we all know and love.
0:36:44They're sending a shout out to the developers software geeks the code jockeys to those brave few who see things
0:36:50differently. High fives to all you rule breakers and disruptors.
0:36:54Here's to working nights to wear an oversized concentration enhancing headphones hey you know they got me there upon
0:37:00your furrowed brow as I don't know from furrowed that that's like when you're like tense angry looking right
0:37:05when a brother opens in the middle. You know I'm not usually for but I do always wear giant headphones.
0:37:11New relics thanks to the entire Internet. Thanks you.
0:37:15Nowadays there aren't any business you're in the software business.
0:37:18Software powers are apps runs our databases manages our accounts and runs e-commerce sites and e-mail programs.
0:37:24When software breaks everyone loses new relic helps improve your software performance so your users have a better
0:37:30experience and your business is more successful. That's a win win right.
0:37:35So a new relic monitors every move your application makes across the entire stack.
0:37:39They can show you what's happening right now you can zero in on problems quickly with transaction tracing S.Q.L.
0:37:45and No S.Q.L.
0:37:46Performance analytics application topology mapping and deployment history markers
0:37:50and comparison than even half the things are but they sound really cool. Just signed up a new relit dot com slash A.T.P.
0:37:56For a thirty day free trial. So here's.
0:38:00Do you deploy their agent other agent is a has native support right built in for Ruby P.H.P.
0:38:06Java dot net Python
0:38:08and even node has a meter on there on the ball here that's all the cool stuff all the cool kids using one of those
0:38:14languages except P.H.P.
0:38:16Little surplus mediately
0:38:18and you can quickly see inside your app to start finding hotspots bottlenecks you can surf it fixing issues
0:38:23and optimizing your performance. Once again new relicts dot com slash A.T.P. For a free thirty day trial.
0:38:30Check it out thanks a lot to new relic for sponsoring our show so work I am not involved with our application
0:38:37performance management group but we do have one and we use several different tools
0:38:43but I can sell you with my hand in my heart that new relic is one of our favorites
0:38:47and although I've not used it personally I know that my my guys and girls at work who have used it really do like it.
0:38:54So you should check it out.
0:38:56So before the break I had asked you guys are cute you guys up to ask how it is going to be do you see the right answer
0:39:02for for accomplishing what Apple is setting out to accomplish with the conference and if not what should we do
0:39:11when I bring this up because I've gone to a couple of Twitter discussions about how out of D.C.
0:39:15Is fundamentally broken
0:39:16and this shouldn't go on they should make it so much bigger other Mosconi have much more space this is terrible oh my
0:39:23god level and I just don't see how he would be the same anymore if only anything changed about it.
0:39:31So I don't I don't love the system the way it is but I don't begrudge it either.
0:39:37Marco do you feel like it's OK the way it is and if not what would you do.
0:39:41There are ways they could improve it certainly
0:39:44but I think overall there's a reason why it pretty much hasn't changed in years.
0:39:50You know it's in many years I've been going since two thousand and nine
0:39:54and I know it was different you know various points in the past before then but since I've gone in.
0:40:00From two dozen nine forward.
0:40:01It's been pretty much the exact same the entire time they've you know they've they've had minor improvements to certain
0:40:08things the last year of the Odwalla flavors changed and that to me for a loop.
0:40:13I can have the ones that banana in them and so every year there's like one flavor I can have and
0:40:19and say that that sucked because they remove the good one last year besides that they also patrolled it a lot more.
0:40:25Did you notice they didn't release the Odwalla refrigerator as often. Exactly which was too bad.
0:40:33Exactly but you know besides you had while flavor changed the Great a while flavor changed twenty thirteen
0:40:40or the worse I might add it was for those of Pan allergies
0:40:44but besides that you know they're trying to alleviate this with things like releasing the videos really really quickly
0:40:52and make them available to everyone not just ten days which there are a couple of things to change I think a few years
0:40:57back and and having the tech talk all around the country for free that are like you know like one day many devotees
0:41:05and what's interesting the tech talks they split up into game and non game tracks
0:41:11and so that's one thing you could do maybe is people you know have have basically two parallel conferences
0:41:18or two sequential conferences one focused for game developers and technologies they use
0:41:24and one focused on Abdel verse because that that actually is a pretty pretty effective bisection of the market not just
0:41:31because you know so many apps are games and so many apps aren't games
0:41:35and the like there's enough people on both sides to pack those conferences full and it's a pretty good division
0:41:40but also because there's there's good subject matter division there that there's a whole lot of stuff like almost all
0:41:45of the interface U.I. Stuff widget stuff like game developers almost never use those things.
0:41:51So you know so much of that like so much of the like if if if I was we should actually have an I was eight.
0:42:00Action slash wishlist segment at some point but probably before Debussy would be nice
0:42:05but you know like if if they had something like better in or after an occasion
0:42:09and sharing features like the like the Windows contract to the end or intense
0:42:13or vice versa whatever whatever the match is up there if they had something like that then that's again game developers
0:42:19probably wouldn't use that. Game developers need a lot more stuff about media and G.L.
0:42:24and There's some things that are common like networking frameworks that that's common you know memory management
0:42:29profiling tools stuff like that. Most of that is coming between the two worlds but there's so much stuff that isn't.
0:42:35Whereas if you if you took pretty much any other division like you know Macs versus I.I.S.
0:42:41Even is a pretty bad division these days because there's not that much stuff exclusive to one
0:42:47or the other anymore that at least that's worth talking about at the B.B.C. So there's all that.
0:42:55But then you know what if they do something like what if they announce an i Watch or some kind of new platform.
0:43:01You know do they do that at the conference or the game conference
0:43:03and you know do you know which one covers which you can see there or there are problems with that approach as well.
0:43:10So I don't really know what else they could do.
0:43:12I think they're already doing what they can which is you know sells man tickets as they can
0:43:18and try to reduce demand in slightly meaningful ways like I know a lot of people.
0:43:25And this this began a little bit last year but this year I'm seeing it more a lot of the people I know
0:43:30when I was a community didn't even try to get tickets that they just like I will you know what I'll just I'll save the
0:43:38six hundred dollars I'll go out there anyway.
0:43:40I have all the social aspects and all the you know business meetings and networking you know.
0:43:45Most of it that you get that I can do and I'll just like you know hang out with some friends every day
0:43:50and watch the videos that come out every day
0:43:52and I think by having the videos come out like right then rather than you know only a couple years ago the videos
0:43:59coming out.
0:44:00A week after the conference was revolutionary because it used to be months that they would come a month after the
0:44:06Congress to come out and in a couple years ago it was a week and then last year it was like half a day
0:44:13and that changed everything I think because now it is totally plausible to go out there
0:44:20and watch the videos during the week in the in the week of the conference while you're out there without actually
0:44:26attending it and I know a lot of people who chose to do that even before the new with the I think they didn't even try.
0:44:33So I think they're doing an OK job of managing it.
0:44:37So I have one problem with what you just said which is how do you acquire these videos if you're not sitting in the
0:44:44cafeteria area at Moscone because they're pretty big and hotel life I socks
0:44:50and you don't want to be downloading gigabytes of video over and L.T.E.
0:44:53Connection unless you're somehow you know rich enough to afford a ninety gig connection that I I have I don't know what
0:45:01people do with that you know I assume.
0:45:04I mean I sure wouldn't do it in the past I've never done a lot of stuff until I've gotten it I have to hear it for the
0:45:11exact reason because I was contemplating going even without a ticket before I knew whether or not I would get a ticket.
0:45:18And the one problem I had with my grand master plan grand master plan was I could spend the day watching the videos
0:45:28and thus it wouldn't really be last time.
0:45:30But I didn't know how to get the videos because I put a wife my socks always even in a place like San Francisco where
0:45:37you would assume that half the internet runs through it some way somehow.
0:45:41Hotel life eye is still terrible so I would wonder if there was a way to do that
0:45:47or maybe maybe one of the answers to make them more livable is to allow people into the cafeteria area during not
0:45:55eating times I know there's a million logistical issues there but my point is give give.
0:46:00The John Surtees of the world not to pick on you John but give you a way to get these videos with a quickness.
0:46:05Without having to download them over you know to life.
0:46:09Well they just need to extend their wife I don't work outside a thing like I think you can can you current wife IMO
0:46:14chairman of the why find the big giant lobby but it seems like the sort of the exterior walls of the building.
0:46:20Stop
0:46:20or if you if I was like in line with my i Pod Touch could I get the wife I that's in there is the password as always
0:46:25you know you get the password from someone you know is it you see and then get on the beery see why fine at work
0:46:30and presumably that will suffice for you to download a bunch of idiots
0:46:33and go in on the hunt a couple cares that you did
0:46:36but well they often will block big download files like always they always block the betas that that that they make the
0:46:43blood has been down the river why fight because they don't want the wife a clogged up or they're going down
0:46:47and he's like to get files so they I think they might block the videos as well
0:46:51but I mean if you know someone who's going to be in there the easiest solution is to just have them down with
0:46:55everything onto a U.S.B. Stick and hand to you it's a really good point.
0:46:58Yeah I mean it's like there are ways to do it
0:47:01and there's always some place where you can find my file just because we don't live there and hotel with wife I sell
0:47:05but it doesn't mean there's no why fine San Francisco like so I don't know someplace there has I mean the worst case I
0:47:11mean like for us again so I could you know like we go to the Macworld office
0:47:14and mooch off their connection could that you know there's always something you can do especially with all these
0:47:18alternative conferences popping up or whatever I don't think that that
0:47:22and I was going to same thing Marco said that I know a lot of people who have gone in many past years both this year
0:47:27and last year we just chose not even trying to buy a ticket because they figure the value they're going to get for
0:47:33they're going to get from you know the socialising in the videos
0:47:38and a lot of them already know a lot of people inside Apple
0:47:40and they're like well I'll see that person outside the conference I don't need to be in the conference to go talk to
0:47:45that guy because I don't like how all the time and I'm going to talk to him in person
0:47:48and doesn't have to be at the beach every see the videos being moved up it is a big win.
0:47:54and the tech talks are also a big win because what you get out of W.B.C. Is like the M.
0:48:00The ration disturbing that everybody who's raised a developer in a timely manner covers that interaction with Apple
0:48:06people.
0:48:06Tech talks kind of cover that
0:48:08and I think that's the part that's most difficult to scale because for every moment those Apple people are talking to
0:48:12developers they're not doing whatever it is that they're supposed to do in the drop is a lot of times people give these
0:48:17presentations are like you know the lead architect for the whatever system is going to go up there
0:48:22and give a presentation about it it's not like a you know custom trained P.R.
0:48:27Guy who just ten generally knows about the topic like these are subject matter experts so you can have that.
0:48:32Touring the country for a year telling you about core data because someone needs to go work on core data like they
0:48:37really need to work in court.
0:48:38So so there's that tension is always going to be there
0:48:42and there's probably always going to be more demand for that face to face time with Apple employees because who
0:48:49wouldn't want to like every single person or to think of any platform like I write Playstation games
0:48:53and I would really love to talk to the person who works on the disk subsystem for the Playstation four.
0:48:58Can I get some face time with him or her you six hundred dollars ball.
0:49:01Every Play Station developer can have face time with that guy he's a busy guy you've got stuff to do you know so that
0:49:06tension low is be there and there's nothing about having a better conference or better conference schedule
0:49:10or more confidence that will ever solve that tension. It just doesn't scale that way.
0:49:15There are too many developers for any popular platform to each one of those people to have personal contact with the
0:49:21engineer engineers who work on their resources and they're most interested in are what's most vexing them.
0:49:25That's life you've got to figure it out yourself.
0:49:27You know in some way having as much contact as we do is especially precious in the Apple community because Apple is so
0:49:33close and tight lipped and like this may be your only chance to talk to these people in an official capacity
0:49:39and we all know it's true.
0:49:41People inside Apple are more forthcoming in the environment to see you know talking about topics that they would
0:49:48probably never even email you about but they'll talk to you in person about it.
0:49:51Every see that revealing super secrets
0:49:53and telling you what the next holographic eyewash levitation device seem to be tell you like you know well that A.P.I.
0:49:59Is the way. It's because of X. Y.
0:50:00and The story and I will give you some insight into how it works and let you work about it
0:50:04but then maybe they would have sent over an email because unlike Eric Schmidt to understand that e-mails will leave a
0:50:08paper trail quote unquote
0:50:10and they should probably not do that like they're just more open so I think Apple is doing not the best it can
0:50:17but it has made tremendous strides in the past several years with the tech talks in a time they release a video so I
0:50:22give them full marks because they used to drive me nuts that I wouldn't I wouldn't be able to.
0:50:26I couldn't go to every city because well I couldn't go I didn't want to go there you see because I didn't go travelling
0:50:34if I didn't go
0:50:35but I did get the videos I mean like To my right here I have a big metal ten two thousand three hundred
0:50:40and it's filled with D.V.D.'s that used to be the way I went to W D C N A You become a month later in this terrible so
0:50:47we're so far from that still think there are things that they should improve
0:50:51but I would not scale this conference up any more the way I would try to scale up the How Do developers get face time
0:50:59with Apple engineers as I would just have more concerts spare like there's more concerts more conferences spread around
0:51:06like tech talk or maybe too Davide really sees because of the third thing I didn't talk about it.
0:51:09Apple has chosen this time to announce their a lot of their big products but I think you could have another D.C.
0:51:18Like maybe two of these a year in a different location maybe different content where you say there's not going to be an
0:51:23announcement there's no keynote no pressure for Apple to come out with something big It's just like this is the the
0:51:28rerun of the same sessions
0:51:30but if you couldn't attend there you can attend this one it's a little bit bigger than a tech talk longer than I
0:51:35thought that's probably the limit of how they can scale it up.
0:51:37I would rather do that than to double the size of this one.
0:51:40And here's an idea what if they did a second one in China every year I was going to say for the app for the games
0:51:45and whatever track in the games one they should have a slide to go really slowly
0:51:49but if you pay more money they'll go to the next slide faster
0:51:51and you can go to another session right after you've gone to.
0:51:55But again if you pay more money you can go to two sessions directly in a row without having a meal between..
0:52:00If you do stuff like that. Love it. Write anything else about the B.B.C.
0:52:07No I think that's what I really do think that you know they reach what's basically an equilibrium here where you know
0:52:14the event changes very little year to year the ticketing I think will probably change very little year to year from now
0:52:20on I think it's going to be like you know they've they figured out what works as best as it can for them
0:52:26and you know for the world
0:52:28but mostly for them because you know like as John mentioned like you know if you like these you know libraries like
0:52:35core data and auto layout stuff like that ideas are written by like two
0:52:38or three people usually these are very small teams at Apple
0:52:42and so they can't really afford to have all these engineers taking weeks and weeks and weeks beforehand to make
0:52:52and practice and refine these presentations and then you know and then a week not even being at the Apple campus
0:52:59but a week staying up in San Francisco putting on the event answering questions going to labs
0:53:05and everything like it's it's a pretty big drain on Apple to put this conference on so that I don't I just don't think
0:53:15there's a better way that they can really do this.
0:53:17You know there are there are some small things they can improve here and there
0:53:20but overall big picture I don't think we're going to see big changes here because I don't know I think they reasonably
0:53:25can or rather I don't think it was worth it for them.
0:53:28Him I should also mention really quickly that last year I believe it was somebody I don't know who was in charge came
0:53:35up with all to see what was happening right around Moscone or during W D C.
0:53:41And this year they're doing it again it's called all the cons and I believe it's free donations accepted.
0:53:49And if I didn't have a ticket I would very strongly investigate that because I suspect it's going to be pretty good
0:53:57and I heard very good things about it last year.
0:54:00And so that's a nice way for the community to kind of come together and fill in a gap.
0:54:03Yeah I saw Will French tweeted during the giveaway day and ideas you just have to see.
0:54:13Run Run apparel a conference one day behind the real one in Vegas at some giant thing that holds like thirty thousand
0:54:19people and just play the videos.
0:54:23And obviously you know Apple which has a down pretty quickly
0:54:26but I think this is you know now that Apple is making it is available I think organizing probably a large number of
0:54:35small conference small like you know convert alternatives that that might be the way to go.
0:54:42You know if you get to Big Apple probably have a problem with it but if you could have a bunch of small gatherings
0:54:47and they're there informal and noncommercial
0:54:50and everything you know I don't think Apple's really going to go try to police all of them. So that's the way to go.
0:54:56Anyway our final sponsor this week is our friend the back please once again
0:55:03and I'm pretty sure all three of us use that plays right.
0:55:07That's true I do not but I know I know but I mean your take it to John.
0:55:13Yes Seriously I'm pretty sure my dad had ended up on back boys actually so I sort of do buy so Shushan clothes
0:55:20and well most of us he's been tackling this is unlimited unthroned old simple online backup.
0:55:32So it's five dollars a month
0:55:34and there's not a lot they give in this really short trip here because you know they knew I would just talk forever
0:55:40about my own stuff with it. If you don't have online backup you really you really need to get on this.
0:55:48It's all my backup is an amazing insurance policy and complement to
0:55:54or replacement for a local backup for me it's a compliment to like my my favorite kind of backup is I have.
0:56:00Time machine locally and that's for factory stores
0:56:03and historic you know pulling files that I might have deleted an hour ago
0:56:07and then rose oak wrap actually still mean that when we get that back that Time Machine is great for that
0:56:13but time machine you know I've had some issues with in the past a lot of people have it's it's not incredibly reliable
0:56:18it works most of the time but it's not included reliable so it's good to have something else.
0:56:23And back places gravy is because the files are not stored in your house.
0:56:29There's a whole class of problems like fires floods electrical issues power surges lightning strikes theft all sorts of
0:56:38issues where if you just have your computer with an internal or an actual time machine drive
0:56:44or a time machine drive plugged in that's always plodded next to it are in the same outlet as it or whatever else
0:56:49or in the same house as it has all sorts of environmental
0:56:52and people problems that could happen there that will take out your computer and your backups at the same time.
0:56:57That's no good online backup solves that problem
0:57:00and gives you if you had a little nicety So for instance that place is a pretty slick I.O.'s app that lets you access
0:57:06and share your backed up files from anywhere that you are you can just logon to your back place account from your i
0:57:12Phone or your i Pad
0:57:13and you can access your files right there you can restore your files selectively so you know if you just need to pull
0:57:21one file at the backup you can do that and that place keeps it very very simple.
0:57:26There's no add ons no gimmicks no extra charges for different services it's five dollars per computer per month that it
0:57:34could even be less actually if you buy the annual or or bi annual summer biennial plans.
0:57:41But five dollars per month per computer gets you unlimited unthroned old online back up it back please.
0:57:47It's simple use the app is nice it's developed by X. Apple engineers it's very Apple friendly.
0:57:53It's always a different way so as of now I'm running it for I think three years now I've never had a problem running on
0:57:58any version of O S ten. It's fantastic. Go to back Blaze dot com slash A.T.P.
0:58:04Once again back with unlimited untrodden online backup for just five dollars per month. That leaves icon's last A.T.P.
0:58:12So we should probably talk about this bleeding heart heart bleed thing. This is this is pretty uncool.
0:58:22This is probably the biggest security story of the year
0:58:25and I don't think it has I don't think it has yet grown to be its final size.
0:58:31I think I think we're going to be having fallout from this
0:58:36and realizing the problem might have an even bigger than we thought
0:58:39or that you know important stuff might have been taken during this window that this was open.
0:58:44I think we're going to be seeing fallout from this for a long time. It's a big big problem.
0:58:50So in brief what this bug is is it's a bug an Open S.S.L. Which is the S.S.L.
0:59:01Powering layer for lots of different software usually stuff that runs on Linux on Linux servers usually
0:59:08or where we were hearing about and for instance if you have a website with a view to be S.
0:59:13Enabled and you're running Apache or engine X.
0:59:18As your web server those use open as a cell on their back ends to power the S.S.L.
0:59:24Component so it affects a lot of things
0:59:27and the bug is actually introduced into the software in twenty eleven so even like I run sent to us on my servers which
0:59:34is it's a free a free distribution of Enterprise Linux basically.
0:59:38I know that's not technically correct pleasing OK see that it's close.
0:59:41So send us the reason why you sent to us is because extremely conservative and generally very secure by default.
0:59:48You don't really have to be a security expert to make sense to us reasonably secure you can pretty much leverage the
0:59:53default and be pretty good. So send us in it's.
1:00:00Latest distributions six point five
1:00:02and a few other a few other Linuxes that have you know roughly similar release schedules like the bug was so old that
1:00:10it was actually in the versions that were shipping with the latest literature reasons from a few to a few of these
1:00:15things so that was enterprise one X.
1:00:18Center one of the uban two servers and a couple or so it was it was very on very widely used things so that's Helens
1:00:28but was there and it was only very recently discovered and then it was basically patched immediately
1:00:32but what the bug allowed is for a very maliciously formed T.L.'s request you were able to have the server respond back
1:00:44to you with sixty four K.
1:00:47Of arbitrary memory from its process space and if you kept making requests you get a different sixty four K.
1:00:55and A not sure of the details beyond beyond that level of like exactly how you requested
1:01:00or you know what exactly what memory you were given or why but it was a bad problem and blah blah.
1:01:07It would read the wrong memory and output it back to you.
1:01:10Now the problem is what is in the memory space of the Open S.S.L. Process is the entire web server that's running.
1:01:18So anything process local the web server traffic the like the the biggest problem is the S.S.L.
1:01:26Keys like the private key that the web server is using on its end to encryption decryption the traffic the private key
1:01:33could have been sent back in the response of the to the to the attacker to say hey here's a perfectly so the attacker
1:01:40could Querrey a bunch of servers basically get all these random memory contents back and just dry a bunch of them
1:01:48and try a bunch of the segments from within that as a key
1:01:51and see if it decrypt the traffic because you already have the public key from
1:01:54when you make the connection so it's it's pretty bad. A pretty bad thing now.
1:02:02People are saying you know like there is you know you'd only be life if you get the private key if the server had
1:02:07recently been restarted or something and you know again I don't know the details of all that
1:02:10but the the part that matters is that you could get the private key back plus anything else that was going to the
1:02:16observer process the time including the traffic and if if your application ran in the web server process
1:02:24but I think I think Apache when it runs like my P.H.P. I think it does that fast C.G.I.
1:02:28Should be immune that's a different process anyway. All that was potentially exposed.
1:02:34And so an effect you know because it was in these conservative distributions that are often run on servers because
1:02:42they're conservative because the bug was sold.
1:02:46This was on so many sites I mean they release tools that you could test for
1:02:51and I ran on a bunch of well known sites mio and other people then went on site
1:02:56and I would say about about a quarter of them were actually vulnerable like the morning after it was discovered like we
1:03:02had most of a day to fix things in the patches for all the Linuxes were already out the day before
1:03:09and the next day they were still the major sites that were still vulnerable I mean it's
1:03:13and it isn't just servers it might be appliances it might be if you have a load balancer
1:03:17or if you have a router that runs imbedded Linux
1:03:20and that version of embedded Linux has has this flaw in it like there's all sorts of places this could be it could be
1:03:28on your home right or it could be on your home NES anything that run them bedded Linux
1:03:32and embedded open to sell could could have this
1:03:35and it's a pretty big deal so I don't think it's really hard to know how bad this will be so far
1:03:45but the potential you know we we know that the potential was really bad.
1:03:50What we don't know is how much it was exploited before these holes are are being closed
1:03:54and how long it will be before you told her so.
1:04:00Government and on this is actually pretty bad too because the usefulness of getting the private key.
1:04:07Like at this point is not that useful unless you have a big gigantic catalog of intercepts of encrypted traffic from
1:04:13the past. Because if you have that in theory if you get the private key in that private key was the one that was used.
1:04:19Previously you had these encrypted intercepts of sort of data going flying by that was useless to you
1:04:24but suddenly potentially becomes useful to you because I know I've got the private keys now I can go back
1:04:29and decrypt stuff from the past.
1:04:31And again this this exploit has been out there for a long time so maybe they were integrating it in real time during
1:04:36that
1:04:36but the only kind of party that's likely to have historical encrypted intercepts is like oh that sounds like something
1:04:41the government would do right.
1:04:43Like an individual's not going to do that
1:04:44but the other angle on this is that the other thing is likely to be in memory is post stated from the last post you
1:04:50know what I like on encrypted you know data from forms admissions like passwords
1:04:54and so a lot of people did like let me just run this against yahoo dot com like their mail thing for a couple minutes
1:04:59and you just see people's passwords like crazy because they're you know these crazy strings like in memory query string
1:05:04clearly identifiable as like password equals plaintext password because that was sent in the post data as part of an
1:05:10S.S.L. Forms of measurement someone enter their password to log in the mail.
1:05:14And although the private key may move away from the memory that is the acceptable.
1:05:17People are constantly logging in and so that's constantly in memory there.
1:05:21And what is basically means is that everyone should change every password in every single service they've ever you like
1:05:28if you want to be safe that's the only way to do it.
1:05:30Basically catalog every service that you have a log in for over they all have unique passwords.
1:05:35Check each one with the vulnerability site to see if it's still vulnerable.
1:05:39Once is not vulnerable go to it and change your password
1:05:41and make sure by the way the place they send you to change your password is the same your reality check before
1:05:46but sometimes they send you to a different site to change your password bottom line is all their passwords
1:05:50and every one of our services could now be compromised like that is not not an exaggeration of like that is a plausible
1:05:56worst case scenario that every single web site that was going on.
1:06:00Well someone has your password now on it so you should probably change your password
1:06:04and you know for example like this are affecting you know was vulnerable to this for a short period of time as well.
1:06:10Every single person our tactic has changed all their passwords.
1:06:12I mean you know you just have to like we should all change our passwords as well
1:06:17and not just that you don't actually know whether a site that has close a vulnerability whether they're still using the
1:06:24same private key
1:06:25or not because you can regenerate it if I mean well I guess you could you could if you were a real nerd you could
1:06:30figure it out.
1:06:31This I'm looking at the search you know details but what you really have to do as a site operator
1:06:37or a server operator to to fix this is you have not only close the vulnerability
1:06:41but then you have to you have to revoke
1:06:44and regenerate yourself a ticket from an brand new private key you can even use the same signing request
1:06:50and renew it like in the usual way.
1:06:52People usually really think you have to do a completely new private key because that could have been compromised
1:06:57and I bet a lot of sites just close a vulnerability and haven't replaced their shirts
1:07:03and they might never replace their shirts or they might do it the wrong way
1:07:06and reuse the key you know because it's easier.
1:07:09So there is this actually this could be the repercussions from this could go on for a while they were saying in that is
1:07:16that there is a question so out there I don't know the answer to as to which software
1:07:21and which platforms honors like checks for revoke certificates.
1:07:25A lot of I think the default on a lot of mac browsers
1:07:29and even the key chain like people are tracking like what is my default chrome configured to check for a certificate
1:07:34revocation.
1:07:35Go to your parents now
1:07:36and check maybe it is maybe it isn't if it isn't is it because you change it that way was because that was the default.
1:07:40Same thing with an apple key chain is a thing about checking for Certificate revocation if the client software doesn't
1:07:47check to see if a certificate has been revoked then you're basically open to men in the middle attacks by someone who
1:07:53exploited you know got the private key for a certificate that you know and that web site did all the right things
1:07:58and got a totally innocent of it. With a totally new key and everything is brand new.
1:08:02But that old certificate is still out there
1:08:04and your client software doesn't check whether the certificate you're dealing with is very broke they can still man in
1:08:08Italy.
1:08:09Yeah and you know
1:08:11and you couldn't so many ramification of the this is why I'm saying like I don't think that we have fully seen
1:08:18or realized what this is going to cause yet because OK So yes so far you know people who are on the ball have have
1:08:26almost all patched by now and hopefully they're reissuing their stuff gets and keys.
1:08:30But there's there's going to be people who are vulnerable to this for a long time
1:08:37and if you know Suppose suppose the N.S.A. or Other creepy government agency supposed they didn't know about this.
1:08:44Now there's a very high possibility did
1:08:47and this is one of the reasons why what they do is so destructive to society because security works best
1:08:56when everyone shares their research. If you have these like little fiefdoms of like secrecy like the N.S.A.
1:09:04Which has tons
1:09:05and tons of really advanced people working on really events things basically trying to find holes like this obviously
1:09:14benefits all of society.
1:09:17If when they find a vulnerability they get it fixed they publish it and they you know work to make a patch
1:09:24or they publish their findings for God's sake.
1:09:26You know in in the accepted ways in the security community but they don't do that.
1:09:31They have all this talent all of this potential to help the world
1:09:35and they're instead using it to hurt the world for their own personal gain.
1:09:39That's probably illegal and certainly immoral. I mean that's why what the N.S.A.
1:09:43Does is so offensive to especially to me as a nerd.
1:09:47Also me as a citizen and me as a programmer
1:09:49and me as a human being I mean it's it's so destructive for them to have those resources at their disposal
1:09:56and not help the rest of the techno community.
1:10:00To work together to make more secure systems because Morsi has the systems actually hurt their efforts to spy on US
1:10:06illegally so that you know part of the rant
1:10:10but that's that annoys the crap out of me that they might have known about this but we have no way to know
1:10:16and they could have been exploiting it forever now regardless of whether they knew better already.
1:10:20They sure as hell know about it now. So anything that you know any any thing the N.S.A.
1:10:28Wants to hack that was previously encrypted with it with you know S.S.L.
1:10:33or Anything else they now have a very good chance of being able to intercept that traffic as we know they're able to
1:10:38intercept traffic through various points on the Internet various data centers I.S.P.
1:10:43Cetera that they that they have partners with or whatever
1:10:47or hacked into so we know that they have access to the traffic the raw traffic.
1:10:52Now they came in the middle attack everybody without even knowing.
1:10:55And that's pretty bad I mean before they could do it through other weaknesses now they can do it with the private key
1:11:02as long as they you know as long as they can they can get it now through this whole ability
1:11:07or they already have gotten it so that I think is one of the reasons why this is so so bad is because now you know it's
1:11:14find out that most of the big sites patched already and are going to do it are going to do their their cues correctly.
1:11:20But there's going to be so many smaller sites hardware vendors you know embedded systems developers so many people who
1:11:28aren't going to patch for a while that are now just wide open for being spied on.
1:11:34Yeah and I looked into this bug a little bit
1:11:35and it's not as super obscure as you by I think it is like it's not some kind of exploit where some carefully crafted
1:11:42machine code that only executes on a certain C.P.U.
1:11:44and Chipset causes something to trigger some bug in the way it's not like that type of thing it is entirely
1:11:49straightforward from what I saw on the site I was explaining it's the old story of you know you got some kind of packet
1:11:56that has its length in coded in the packet and.
1:12:00The program is taking that length
1:12:02and using it as an argument to the meme copy command to say OK well they sent me a packet it said you know my
1:12:09information is in the next sixteen bit value my information is in the next bite and and bites
1:12:15and you know do a meme copy from the thing into those areas basically you're taking you're letting users apply data
1:12:20like over H.T.T.P.
1:12:22They send you a number and you read that many bytes into a buffer
1:12:25and you cross it is it over for good like this make that number all ones and then you read sixty five K.
1:12:29Of information when in reality there's not that much information there
1:12:32and you've got your typical buffer overrun like it's straight forward.
1:12:36You can look at the code and say you're taking a number that came from the Internet
1:12:39and using it as an argument to meme copy don't do that it's very bad
1:12:43and it's basically the opposite of buffer overflow.
1:12:45Yeah it's but it's like it's not it's not obfuscated in any kind of way you can you can look at the variable
1:12:51and say wait that just came from the network
1:12:54and here you're using that number two how much remember you're going to read that seems ill advised like it is nothing
1:13:00you know there's no sanity checking on that or anything like that.
1:13:04This gets me of course back to my you know Copeland twenty ten thing is if you had a memory safe language like a lot of
1:13:10people ranting about this is like look humans are never going to be able to write secure software if you have arbitrary
1:13:17access to memory even if it's arbitrary just arbitrary just your own memory space because like it doesn't make any
1:13:23sense it's not it's not a buffer kind of it's not like if you had it done in a memory safe language you wouldn't be
1:13:31able to just run off the end of whatever variable or data structure you had.
1:13:35There's no meme copy command that just says you just give me a starting address and a length and I will just read
1:13:39or write that memory and I don't care what Senator what's there I'll just go run right over it.
1:13:43That doesn't exist in memory safe languages so a lot of the people in the security community like we need to get the
1:13:50base infrastructure that we do our security stuff in off of languages to give your richer access to process memory
1:13:56because we're never going to be perfect like it's impossible to say how does one do that.
1:14:00We all know not to do that or how long to the sit in code open source code how long it has been there
1:14:04and who knows how many of these things are in the closed source code out there it's like we're just not capable of
1:14:10writing programs that are secure in languages that have this feature on the wall I think it is proving it to ourselves
1:14:17and what do we need to do you know we can we can get rid of an entire class of problems not all problems
1:14:22but we know this is definitely a big class of problems that a lot of security exploits.
1:14:26We can get rid of that class of problems with technology that we have now
1:14:29and I guess move on to the next class of terrible security exploits
1:14:32but you know like we hope we can make some progress there.
1:14:36One of the thing too is that this was a bug in the heart beat feature of T.L.'s or protocol or method
1:14:43or whatever which apparently is very rarely used
1:14:49and many of the servers were not vulnerable because they couldn't support it
1:14:54and many of the patches to initially fix it quickly while everyone figure out you know.
1:14:58But what it will eventually be the final fix.
1:15:00Most of the very early patches just turned it off
1:15:04and nothing happened like nothing bad happened because nothing uses it
1:15:08and so it's worth asking why that was unable to roll.
1:15:11Obviously this rarely used feature was going to get a lot less attention from researchers because you know it didn't
1:15:17really come up a lot so it obviously had a stance on it for a long time
1:15:21and this is why this bug was existed for like three years if anyone figured it out.
1:15:26You know what this this should inform decisions about you know why should Apache or engine X.
1:15:35In even unable to spy default Why should Open S.S.L. Even support this.
1:15:39If it's been around for a while nothing uses it.
1:15:42You know this should really impact the default choices that library and application and server vendors make
1:15:51and maybe it maybe it's time you know like one of the ways that you can make an S.S.L.
1:15:57Server more secure is by requiring.
1:16:00Better ciphers and better settings from from connecting clients
1:16:04and one of the ways you can do that would be to like cut off if you kind of support for I E six
1:16:09and some ancient you know client libraries that no one use anymore.
1:16:15If you cut off support by default you can make security better for everyone basically by requiring higher standards for
1:16:21everyone and you can close off on a lot of avenues for attack that way.
1:16:26But it requires cutting off support for really really all things which I guess you talk about X.P.
1:16:31If you want to but you know that that's been a culture in the Apple world for a while.
1:16:38Yeah you know it will be tough supporters I mean it's three years old because I was a little nuff doesn't matter.
1:16:43I think there's some of that server can take as well
1:16:46and obviously they have a more conservative because you know the value system is with the different requirements
1:16:51or could be different environments are completely different
1:16:53but I think they can take some value out of that like it's it's probably not worth enabling something at all that is
1:17:02used by almost nobody anymore.
1:17:04That could be an avenue for attack easier solution for this in that we just need to revisit the specs are they the
1:17:12R.F.C.'s
1:17:13or there are protocols that we use on a regular basis to trim out the features that are in use because like this tons
1:17:19of features that H.T.T.P. That but it's the common browsers and server software don't support them.
1:17:24They just like our half heartedly support and they just don't get used
1:17:28and after a couple of years that are a decade of that it's like looking nobody uses this feature of this protocol.
1:17:33Make next revision of this protocol remove that feature because people keep the feature like I know I have to be
1:17:38compliant with whatever the R.F.C. Is.
1:17:40I support all the features but if nobody ever used that feature just sits over there festering
1:17:45and that's like the perfect place
1:17:46but corrects posters like it's not use an ever increasing fact it's almost never used so we support it because
1:17:50technically part of the protocol and if we want to be compliant and get our server cation
1:17:54and say we fully support the bottled water article we have to do it.
1:17:57So revise the protocol cut out the part so we decide OK.
1:18:00Well use that people just don't do that anymore like even the spec is also it's a little terrorism there from the you
1:18:06know they just don't get used to the common practice that you could cut out headers formats for a start you know old H
1:18:12T V one point no feature is like there I think you can make I mean they're already are working
1:18:17and others are basically a bit like you drop the features that nobody uses
1:18:20and that hopefully lets people finally drop that code that wasn't being run that was possibly riddled with bugs.
1:18:27So also in the news. Dropbox did some stuff today. Time moving on.
1:18:35I totally missed the dropbox story I saw I saw the carousel thing is that is that is are you talking about.
1:18:40That is part of what I'm talking about so they announced a few things firstly they announce the Congolese a race is now
1:18:46on the board and I'm not joking. I saw that as weather and I thought it was a joke.
1:18:51The first thing I asked myself was what why
1:18:55and I guess I read the summary I don't recall where my down Tech Crunch thanks to Panzer but anyways.
1:19:02Somebody theorized Well it's to get them better international relations which I guess because I don't know in what
1:19:10other way she could possibly be qualified to do anything useful for Dropbox
1:19:14but I mean she's a smart lady so maybe I'm underestimating her.
1:19:17Well I mean first of all keep in mind Al Gore was an apple's boardroom. I don't know if he still is but he was.
1:19:23And second of all the president for like one of the politicians to be on tech companies boards for some reason that's a
1:19:31good point but you know and we're pro all of us are over the work people are all talk about this but drop boxes.
1:19:39Biggest competition is Box dot net which has a very very strong position in the enterprise but not
1:19:48and not a very strong position in the consumer world that I think is and it's obviously
1:19:54but that's the universe of Dropbox where Dropbox has huge presence among consumers.
1:20:00As in the business world Dropbox is often used but often blocked
1:20:06and not supported because it's not it's actually pretty funny like in the business world.
1:20:10They use Dropbox constantly which usually is violating their I keep policies as the file store and somewhere else
1:20:18and it's not enterprise probably certified encrypted friendly than a president
1:20:24or the case may be half that's probably B.S.
1:20:26but That's a perception
1:20:28and so Dropbox like it solves such a common so many common problems so well that you know similar to how the i Phone
1:20:37kind of broke in the enterprise from the ground up. That's what Dropbox has been doing.
1:20:41Box dot net has been contacting the opposite problem which is trying to be enterprise friendly as as much as possible
1:20:48and trying trying to get in from the top side and they've been pretty good job of that
1:20:52and so Dropbox I think with you know with a lot of their moves towards business stuff
1:20:57and maybe kind of these arise is more about you know reaching that community look better the role of big business an
1:21:05enterprise that we my guess as to as to her or her importance there
1:21:10but Dropbox probably is reaching for that world as much as they can first of all to defend against Boston at becoming
1:21:18so big that they start encroaching their their consumer business.
1:21:21And second of all because the the enterprise business is just so profitable.
1:21:25If you can get into it I don't think drawbacks of anything to fear from box reaching into the consumer space let me
1:21:31just say that as a user of both third go that is it is definitely enterprise.
1:21:36And I saw a couple stories recently about a box of young some I.P.O.
1:21:39or Some some sort of thing where financial statement came out about the company
1:21:42and Bach spends a tremendous amount of money on like getting into the enterprise on sales and marketing huge amounts.
1:21:50Some people say unsustainable amounts and that's not always a good thing.
1:21:55It's never a good sign when you're spending just tremendous amounts of money to try to grow rapidly.
1:22:00As working to get enterprise contracts we use it at work and everything
1:22:02but the product itself is not is going to drop box. My question about Condi Rice is who came who came to whom K.Z.
1:22:12Like you did.
1:22:13Did she approach the company because you know she's out of her you know government job
1:22:17and she's just looking like you know be on boards or like begetting invest in something
1:22:21or you know I mean like people do that
1:22:23when they leave one career where that was her high profile like I'm going to become a venture capitalist I'm going to
1:22:28get in technology or whatever and they just got to go that way or did they seek her out
1:22:32and saying we need someone with government ties because you know people with those kind of connections in government
1:22:37are extremely useful for all sorts of things I'm sure you know Al Gore
1:22:40or whatever that is like who it would be great to have you on the board you have these connections we think who can
1:22:46help us in our business. Ever is wigged out about like she's a back history defend the N.S.A.
1:22:52and Her whole role in the Bush administration on the Iraq war and now our data is going to be moved by the N.S.A.
1:22:58and It's like I don't think her being there makes your data any more or less likely to be seen by the N.S.A.
1:23:04I think the bottom line is that the N.S.A.
1:23:05Once they don't draw back they probably already have all of it feel any better or worse
1:23:11but it's you know it's not I don't think it affects things one way
1:23:16or the other I don't think she is personally given the N.S.A.
1:23:18and He used any kingdom I don't think she has the kind of access I think she's merely there to provide that private
1:23:24connections that she has in the government world and I think that's mostly a non-story.
1:23:29That's fair impulse if the N.S.A.
1:23:30Really wanted some sort of into Dropbox he think they would use it as an obvious aroud is kind Lisa Rice joining the
1:23:37board. I feel like they would be a little smarter than that.
1:23:39Now they just took us three of us were drawbacks but all stayed and they had everything
1:23:43and I'm sure they already have access to every bite of data in a three if they want to.
1:23:47Fair point the other thing they did was they announced a new app I guess you could and it's an app called Carousel
1:23:56or in this. It is. Firstly it's not a good name.
1:24:02It's like some folks here in Richmond that Marco you know mobile locks they already had an Instagram app for ten called
1:24:11Carousel and the trademark for it and you don't.
1:24:14Yep sounds like it's a great name than someone else already had that great name.
1:24:21Funny how that is I did not really sells a trade module that's exciting. They might be really wealthy soon anyway.
1:24:28But be that as it may it's so it's it's sort of kind of but not really at all in ever Pixy sort of thing for Dropbox
1:24:37and I didn't stall it
1:24:38and it was funny because the first run experience for me went from really really cool to kind of terrible immediately
1:24:48the really really cool part was they have you know an opening screen
1:24:51and you're supposed to slide from bottom to top to get to the next page
1:24:57and the way they had done this one is there were a series of photos on the bottom of the screen kind of just strewn all
1:25:07over the place and as you swipe up words those photos align themselves into an ever pick style like very
1:25:14or quicker style for that matter varying sized grid.
1:25:17So it's kind of implying Oh we're going to organize all your photos I just thought it was really well done.
1:25:22So after they did that my options were a checkbox should've written written down what it read
1:25:30but it was something like backup all my photos to Dropbox and it was a check box and a button that said get started
1:25:37or sign in or something like that.
1:25:39So I don't necessarily want all of my i Phone pictures going to my Dropbox and thus I did not write I wish it's a son
1:25:48or No I that's not the way organs my photos so.
1:25:51Q Bradley chamber so anyway so I I didn't want to check the checkbox and I hit the tap the sign in button and then it.
1:26:00Did a little expand contract to the checkbox basically implying the only way that I can carry on is to go ahead
1:26:08and say All right back up all my pictures to Dropbox I did the exact same thing as you uncheck the checkbox I tried to
1:26:13get the new I realized no I can't use this application unless I let it do that thing that it wants to do which already
1:26:19kind of turns me off. They are asking their telling.
1:26:22Yeah yeah and the reason by the way that I check the check box and then
1:26:26when I do it's because I know in my Dropbox situation is like in like the camera feature I had enabled for a little
1:26:32while when I was playing with it
1:26:33but like I know if I did that I know how many pictures are on my i Phone I don't know many of us pictures are not in my
1:26:39Dropbox pretty much all of them checking that box was going to add gigabytes of data to my Dropbox and I'm almost all.
1:26:46So I did indeed click the checkbox and neither is
1:26:50or was your will be uploading all my photos to my Dropbox So you're presented with what looks sort of like the camera
1:26:57roll and I O. S.
1:26:58Including with the grouping that I believe in or just I was seven there whenever they introduced it so by location
1:27:04and date which I like
1:27:06and on the bottom they have like a old school radio don't actually know what it looks like it looks like the
1:27:11speedometer from an old ozone deal where you have like all the tick marks across the bottom
1:27:15and then like a little needle. So it's like a horizontal speedometer you know what I'm talking about.
1:27:19Totally you know anyways so that's like your date picker thing and what you can do is you can select an entire event
1:27:27or series of photos and you can share them and it shares them in
1:27:31or they imply that they're going to share them is really nifty like ever pics looking kind of way so I thought well let
1:27:38me test this out I want to test this out with myself so I says I shared from my Dropbox account which is that which is
1:27:44associated to my personal email address to my work account
1:27:47and they send this really lovely picture email to my work account
1:27:52and then it says Casey Liss has shared seven hundred photos and videos with you on Carousel
1:27:58and you know you're allowed to put in a little mess.
1:28:00It shows some of them what is a snob I know of them and I go on my computer to you know click on these pictures
1:28:11and basically it says tough melodies get the app so there's no web component whatsoever
1:28:19and I bet if you if you have the app those pictures would be added to your Dropbox counting towards your quota despite
1:28:25the fact that I drop boxes content addressable storage in those photos are not stored more than once which drives me
1:28:30nuts and I believe that's right.
1:28:32So my initial impression went from great to see you to want
1:28:41and so now I'm probably going to leave it to some sort on talking about it I don't know who has so few pictures that
1:28:46they can afford to host them on Dropbox because as we point out many times the transfer at Dropbox mass storage is very
1:28:53expensive like it's not meant to hold terabytes of your data.
1:28:57That's a tremendous amount of money forget about the freakout freakout is enough pictures for you to like take pictures
1:29:02for a month and then your for if you want to live your life
1:29:05and take pictures of your children as they grow over the years you're spending like a huge amount of money per month in
1:29:12Dropbox fees if this is your solution to cameras like people presenting it as an ever picks like solution.
1:29:18It's just not financially feasible or smart to pay that much money. Stories are in my my photo library.
1:29:23You know if we say I got my first digital camera
1:29:26when my son was born he's nine years old as I've nine years little photos they're currently in a five hundred gig drive.
1:29:31Right how much would it cost for me to get five hundred gigs of storage on Dropbox and pay that month after month
1:29:38and it's just going to grow I meant deleting their baby pictures or they get older.
1:29:41Like it's going to grow
1:29:43and I keep getting keep getting cameras that you know take a larger images I'm not I'm shooting RAW is just a peg right.
1:29:49I don't think this is a tenable solution for photo storage units and it works so nicely
1:29:55and easily that it's almost like a trap like I mean I can see why Dropbox likes it like you know people get a free
1:29:59account.
1:30:00Dr act like it's great every picture taken my phone is here I can share with my friends than ever at the start of the
1:30:04myth and you're like Oh well I got to get out of the paid account
1:30:07and then you get your next argument oh I get to pay for the next year in a certain point you just start getting angry
1:30:11bitter Dropbox like Apple with the free i Cloud stuff that's just not enough storage to back up your entire device like
1:30:17it's worse it's worse than if they just charge you a fair price up front for what they want to do
1:30:21and I don't think Dropbox is economical for any mass storage like this like if you ask me what do you keep in your
1:30:27Dropbox you keep like a small set of your important files
1:30:30or your current working set no one uses Dropbox is like their long term archival.
1:30:35All my anything if not all year it's not all your anything I mean it's probably not even all those people text
1:30:40documents or on Dropbox or maybe who are doing that
1:30:42but I think this is not a good solution for the photo problem I think it's a great way to get more people to hit the
1:30:49drop box stores on its way to paid accounts which is probably why Dropbox like yeah.
1:30:54So it's basically yet another photo sharing unthinking solution that is almost but not useful.
1:31:01Pretty much
1:31:02and the other thing is the one place that I think you could potentially Shine is a you know John you have your family
1:31:10over for your son's birthday and everyone has their camera phones or cameras
1:31:16and everyone wants to share each pictures with each other so potentially you could use carousel in order to do that
1:31:23but in my experience I've been happy although not overjoyed with i Cloud photo album sharing whatever it's called
1:31:33and that works sufficiently well as long as you're not sharing it could Julian pictures
1:31:37and I think carousel would do better with sharing a good Julian pictures
1:31:40but for just an you know a handful of really good ones that you know everyone in the family took you can make a shared
1:31:45photo stream album thing. Again I'm getting the terminology wrong.
1:31:49That will get the point across and accomplish what I need.
1:31:53They're for sharing what you always want is you don't want you don't want to impose on the people that you want to
1:31:59share that.
1:32:00As with which basically means that no matter what other cool features you're sharing as there has to be some way with
1:32:05some person with a web browser to see your things no matter what else is like it may be cooler in the app maybe you
1:32:12have photo stream you see a push
1:32:14or whatever there has to be a web way to do it which is you know you have to be able to send someone a euro they have
1:32:19to be able to tap that your eloquent that you're aware of they are and see pictures not install
1:32:23and have not changed their or style S.
1:32:25Not sign up for i Cloud they need to see pictures of you know the magic of Facebook it's like the bottom line is
1:32:30there's a Web site called Facebook you can go there you can see pictures that some people share because we just want to
1:32:35see pictures we don't want to do any of the stuff so I think it's great to be held as integration fact photo stream
1:32:40works really well for my family because of the push notifications
1:32:43and if they're on there I was devised a little notification guns and they swipe it
1:32:46and they're looking at pictures two seconds later.
1:32:48But if I want to send us pictures of someone who doesn't have
1:32:50and I was that I thought an OK first step go to the Apple store like it's not going to happen you need to have a web
1:32:55interface stuff and the fact that as far as Casey was able to turn
1:32:58and that's not the case for Dropbox seems especially terrible because like you can make Public Links from like things
1:33:04in your public folder on Dropbox and those are whether it's as simple
1:33:07and that is just a way to see a thing in Astoria
1:33:09but that seems like an obvious gap in their functionality even if we know the storage limits.
1:33:14Yeah I completely agree so basically all of these announcements today.
1:33:19Give it one tremendous me there was one other relevant thing yesterday I believe that a deal be announced light room
1:33:27for the i Pad and I should disclose that I was on the beta of this
1:33:33but a month ago so obviously I'm a little bit biased because they think I'm special not to put me in the beta so you
1:33:42know I do we've had an interesting set of attempts.
1:33:44You know their their first attempt which was originally called Carousel was Adobe rebel
1:33:51and rebel was like like a sinking sharing kind of collaboration editing kind of service for photos I think are still
1:33:59running it but it seems. Like they've kind of given up on it.
1:34:02Lightroom now has an i Pad app
1:34:05and a sync service so now you could you can use white room to sync between your computer and and i Pad sort of
1:34:16but the reason why didn't you very long is because it's pretty limited.
1:34:21It's it's obviously designed much more to be more like you know working on working on a project in Lightroom on the go
1:34:30that you start on a desktop like you manually move things over
1:34:33and then you might work on your i Pad a little bit then you come back your computer and your editor there whatever.
1:34:38It's not really about your whole library because one of the biggest limitations of it is that first of all the
1:34:44interfaces and the infrastructure of the app or clearly not designed to have tons and tons thousands
1:34:50and thousands of photos being sent.
1:34:52But the biggest problem is you can't sync a smart collection which is like their version of a smart playlist you can
1:34:59only see and you can sink your whole collection.
1:35:01You can only think like basically you know folders that you have to manually move photos made on the photos into so
1:35:11it's not particularly useful because you have to like manually select every photo that you want to be available for
1:35:17sinking in Lightroom before set up on your i Pad which is kind of a fatal deal killer for me.
1:35:23So you again think it's like yet another option for photo thinking
1:35:28and share one that I'm not really sharing with photo sinking between your devices yet another option that kind of
1:35:34but doesn't work the way that most people want and need it to.
1:35:38Every time we talk about those people write and tell us the things that we've talked about
1:35:41and again mention a few of them to someone just email before the show it's created flicker in case anyone still doesn't
1:35:47know flicker are as you apparently one terabyte of storage for free
1:35:51and you get unlimited for a storage if you're grandfathered in with the fire broke out which I think I should have been
1:35:56pretty sure I had a flyer program but who knows.
1:36:00Do you drive from Google gives you also one terabyte of storage for ten dollars a month
1:36:04and the person who tweeted this that's the same the same money run Dropbox if you one tenth the storage.
1:36:12So there are many other more economical options to store to try to store sort of all your photos
1:36:17and I think at this point one terabyte is probably enough if you're not a professional photographer for anybody who has
1:36:24a kid who's not a teenager yet.
1:36:27You know you start from like when you're if you start when your kids are born or if you start with her
1:36:31when digital cameras were popular US But that's again this is going to go up people it's accumulate photos I mean not
1:36:35everyone's as much of a pack rat as I am
1:36:37but like renaming talk to people as an entire like how my feeling about a place which a place like this video is in
1:36:42there too and it's not that I have a lot of videos but one or two videos in ten A.T.P.
1:36:48That adds up really fast even though they're compressed
1:36:50and everything so yeah I mean the people who are sort of selling premium price storage like you know Dropbox
1:36:58and Apple I guess but how much is a cost per gigabyte of stored data on their servers.
1:37:04There is going to have to adjust their prices like things are going to you know storage will keep going up
1:37:09and companies will try to not lower their prices in proportion to that to make their margins a girl over time
1:37:14but this all needs to readjust because we all have lots of digital data
1:37:18and the amount of visual data we drag around behind us and don't want to be specific with pictures
1:37:22and videos I would imagine it just just keeps going up over time so we really need better solutions to this.
1:37:29All right I think we're going to be all right thanks a lot two or three sponsors this week. Back please.
1:37:34New relic and transporter and we will see you next week John.
1:38:03Today during her sister that the Iraqis have two pieces of salt one for each of you already.
1:38:44These are not fought for our podcast.
1:38:46So that's why I didn't go in the fault section there's a fault for other podcasts.
1:38:52Of course one is for Marco So you're tweeting and you are saying that in most of your errors
1:38:57and your programs are from exceptions and bad A.P.I. Calls are not from site fault.
1:39:02No we're going to get into this just like I don't know I mean that's your experience understanding what my experience
1:39:07was
1:39:07but what I want I want to do with double check my experience because it sure seems like all my crashes are due to bad
1:39:13memory actresses.
1:39:14So I just went through my crash logs which is you know which I don't think I've deleted scenes like ten point like
1:39:19they've just been kind to anyway. I went through.
1:39:22Let's see what is three thousand three hundred sixty five crash logs
1:39:26and seventy five point nine six percent of those are due to bad memory access.
1:39:31How many of that was within the last year I don't look at the dates on them.
1:39:37My my theory is that over time the percentage of these things that are that are you know better access
1:39:42or sites all of these things is going down over time because they do a regression analysis.
1:39:50Yeah well because it like my theory is a lot more code that's in application the people are using in writing today.
1:39:56And when you talking about new languages and the need for a new. Language or new A.P.I.
1:40:02That specifically talking about the benefits really is for developing new software so I think like you know you might
1:40:08want to rule out something like Photoshop
1:40:11or Microsoft Office where like that's that's probably there's probably a lot of old coats all around there.
1:40:17I would say look at recent applications the things that have been written with modern A.B.I.
1:40:22As modern stuff
1:40:23and recent crashes to any application so the reason I was looking at all the dough is because if you make a change now.
1:40:30Eventually if you fast forward ten years after that change the steady state will be like this you know I mean like
1:40:36Eventually you will pass through this portal
1:40:38and you will be into the like we are now with memory protection like we now pretty much previously.
1:40:43Very few things American action now pretty much everything does your phone as in every rejection your your I watch is
1:40:48going to have you know I mean like.
1:40:49And so you venture to get into that same steady state and I think what this my crash logs for the X.
1:40:54Number of past year is a reflection of the current steady state.
1:40:57You know even if it's getting better now
1:40:59and I don't have to see it like a graph of like Ode to the frequency go down like it's hard to tell it as one person I
1:41:04was basically checking my own thinking maybe ten percent is it fifty percent seventy five makes me feel like my gut
1:41:10feeling of every time I see a crash log and that feeling hasn't changed over time but like I can I can check
1:41:15and see if I sort them by date.
1:41:17Does the frequency decrease but it could
1:41:19but it was a single person's date it could just be like I stop using the program is crashing all the time
1:41:23and you know doesn't show up anymore
1:41:25or like how many what was the what was the recent encoding bug in the max tax frameworks that somebody likes and you
1:41:33and I am with a bad go to Caribbean it would take I don't like I probably have like a dozen of those in the recent
1:41:38things growing up the average as well
1:41:40and I don't think there is a better memory because I'm not sure probably was because it's probably like overflowing
1:41:45some stupid buffer somewhere probably.
1:41:47Yeah but like you know my theory is basically that over time even even within the same language as libraries
1:41:55and as hardware get better people generally tend to move up a little.
1:42:00But in traction like even like life when I wrote the very first version of the paper for i OS app I wrote all the S.Q.
1:42:06Lite calls directly against the escalate C. A.P.I. and I know the press and I correctly I don't care.
1:42:14And then like within a year I had written it to use more Objective C.
1:42:19Stuff where it stayed for the whole time I owned it and then when I started the magazine is Corday
1:42:25when I started overcast I used F M.T.V. and C.
1:42:29Model so like I I was I've been moving up the stack as time went on because the benefit of writing directly against the
1:42:38C. A.P.I. Was so small on modern hardware and it was so much more code and so much more low level C.
1:42:44Code that had things like worrying about lines of buffers and everything which like I don't think overcast
1:42:51or some audio stuff that has to do that
1:42:53but the vast majority of its code doesn't have to deal with like buffer lanes at all.
1:42:59Like there's nowhere where I'm calling mem copy there's no way I'm calling you know any kind of like anything where
1:43:06that would even matter.
1:43:07And so I think
1:43:08and I think I think it applies to so much software especially in the world that we're in with the Apple world
1:43:12and all this cool mobile stuff all these great frameworks
1:43:14and libraries that are there are building up over time I think there's so much even even though we can do these things
1:43:20in C.
1:43:21and Some maybe maybe an app might have wanted to see calls or
1:43:25or you know I use I had to add key chain support circuits or the log in token securely
1:43:31and rather than writing I just got a really nice cocoa pod called black box that just does it for me
1:43:39and wraps it all in this widely used well tested and pretty honestly pretty small simple A.P.I.
1:43:45So that's like here's here's a chance where I had to use a C. A.P.I.
1:43:49but Instead it has used this already well developed already proven wrapper for it so that's yet more sea buffer
1:43:55checking her I didn't have to write well but some Someone had to write it or like it.
1:44:00Moving a problem down like looking at sector our factor was are these crashes due to something bad that someone wrote.
1:44:05Dealing with memory or do they merely trigger a bug because that you know who wrote F M.T.V. F.T.V.
1:44:10Is written in a line with us for access to memory like at certain point you get down.
1:44:13Yes you need direct access to memory to write like this. The G.P.U.
1:44:16Drivers in the kernel and all the good stuff
1:44:18but like framework code that deals with like putting of the user stuff like you would want at a certain point you would
1:44:25want to not only do you not to have to deal with that stuff
1:44:27but also the framework you're calling because it's easy to to trigger a bug in the framework by you know doing
1:44:32something silly with an A.P.I.
1:44:33and You didn't mess up anything with pointers and you weren't doing anything with range checking
1:44:37or whatever you just use an object to see if you had been passing messages
1:44:39but it just so happens that the combination of perfectly benign information and your senators A.B.I.
1:44:45Triggered a memory location air inside it because it is written in Objective C.
1:44:50You know you keep going down eventually have to get on the low level code
1:44:53but what you want to do is have everybody using C.
1:44:56Code so not only can you not screw up
1:44:58but all the frameworks are calling cancer up until you go down to like OK well this point it is now appropriate that
1:45:03you need direct access to memory
1:45:04and we were saying earlier in the show that life even open as a self like well it's got to be fast it's encryption we
1:45:09have to write that in C. Some part of that probably has to be written in C.
1:45:13but The entire thing like you know it's really you know I would like rust
1:45:16and everything that they're trying to say like we will go you know we're trying to be memory safer or C.
1:45:21Like languages.
1:45:23Even if you're not going to jump all way up to something where you have complete memory safety
1:45:26and I just I just one I did the check I figured it was worth bring up on the show it doesn't mean anything is just one
1:45:32person's thing. Everyone can go look at the crash so I can try to figure it out themselves.
1:45:37I think it's also worth honoring arc a little bit here.
1:45:41In your in your debug it was said that we're talking about we can only think we mentioned we're talking about
1:45:45but we're talking about YOUR percent of people do you know so you kind of glossed over Ark saying it wasn't a big deal
1:45:52I disagree I think it was a very big deal.
1:45:55Well it is a big deal I wrote all about it I think it was a good thing but for this particular issue.
1:46:00Like again getting back to second or facts a lot of those bad memory accesses.
1:46:05I bet a lot of them are attempting to do something on an object that is then either whole they are partially
1:46:10deallocated you know like you know I mean right exactly.
1:46:12ARC helps with that
1:46:13but it's still possible in an arc system to screw that up because of all the like oh are you calling it a C.F.
1:46:18It's different and you got an A to things right when you're writing a block and you forgot to weaken that thing
1:46:22and although you know like or you didn't realize you had a copy of that in the block
1:46:26and you forgot to retain it for the block implicitly retains that thought you didn't have to retain it here
1:46:29but you do like it makes it way way better but it is still possible
1:46:35and it's like in some respects it's more complicated where it's like
1:46:37when I was Emmanuel retain relief you know we see where we thing was now arc is doing tons of regains releases Phormium
1:46:42blocks and a complication if you think you don't have to worry about it you will get bitten
1:46:46and you will never really end up sending a message to a half the allocated object
1:46:50and you will have a memory access area.
1:46:53Well
1:46:53but in the failure mode is is much more likely to be a leak usually through retain cycle through not doing the weak self
1:47:01dance which I love you thing of calling it wealth by the way.
1:47:03Me too I don't know what is everyone else calling it it's just right there it's right in front of its wealth the ETS is
1:47:11right next to the W.
1:47:13I mean all these things all these things do help like arc does help in everything
1:47:18but it's like arc is a great example both like how much benefit we can get from automating some of this
1:47:23and also how you're never going to get all the way there because like anyone who does lots of Arc code it's like in
1:47:30many ways it's so much simpler
1:47:32but it's not the type of thing where you can tell a beginner you don't have to worry about anymore it's like in reality
1:47:36in fact you have to have a complete understanding of retain release because
1:47:39when the time comes for you to develop this weird arc situation you're not going to what the hell is going on unless
1:47:43you understand what arc is doing for you
1:47:45and then once you have that foundational knowledge we can explain to you this obscure education what's really going on
1:47:51because without that then it just becomes like doing you like a Visual Basic Basic programmer no offense to Visual
1:47:55Basic programmers just flailing wildly ingoing like when I type this it works but now a day.
1:48:00Isn't And I don't have a foundation to understand why you still have to understand retain release in order to release
1:48:06arc just saves you a tremendous amount of typing it makes it so much easier to not you know it takes away a lot of
1:48:10drudgery and makes things way so for most people but you're never going to get all the way there.
1:48:14You're never going to get to. If it's like fault it's not your fault and that's that's what I'm trying to do.
1:48:20So totally is just my my insertion in the tweet which I don't think we actually even said the beginning of this
1:48:24diatribe.
1:48:25My assertion your assertion basically is that the vast majority
1:48:28or the majority at least of of crashes are bad memory accesses or through corruption or things like that
1:48:36and my assertion is that in my experience I'm seeing that that's not really a problem.
1:48:42Language has this I have to solve as much as you seem to think they do because the vast majority of the of the crashes
1:48:48that I see in my abs and other apps that run on my stuff are things like assertion failures and I got exceptions.
1:48:54Things that like every language has exceptions like every language has error conditions
1:48:59and if you if you read if you make a new language instead of having a C.
1:49:04Based one Make it is a new language that succeeds that you're still going to have exceptions that are uncaught to have
1:49:09problems in apps like your stuff.
1:49:10Just like a different type of error humans have to write those assertions
1:49:14and the reason humans writer's assertions in languages with the free reign of memory is because they didn't put that
1:49:19assertion there they know that six lines later you're going to scribble in our memory.
1:49:22So that's why they put these aren't there
1:49:24but if you have got to put the assertions there guess what you're scribbling all over memory.
1:49:27And yes an end even in a high level language with memory protection you put a surgeon to make sure your sanity checking
1:49:31your stuff
1:49:32but there's no danger that if I go I forgot to check that assertion to make sure this value is greater than
1:49:36or equal to zero so I don't end up with a negative number.
1:49:39There's no chance that in subsequent lines a negative number will cause you to scribble all remembering
1:49:43or send the contents of your web service process out as the response revealing your private key or anything like that.
1:49:50Now before you skewer me on whatever you're about to skewer me on probably vinyl Where would one go to check one's
1:49:57crash logs if one was so.
1:50:00And I went to the console app
1:50:02and along the left side were on the consulate you can find all the different directories that have the word crash
1:50:06and the whole bunch of like it there
1:50:07and slash library there until the slash library is like I don't read like some some of them are an application specific
1:50:13log directories I just you know found a bunch of directories
1:50:16and recursively grep through them for the various current access failure expected I might just look through them
1:50:22and you'll find one of them
1:50:23and you'll know what the grab for it if I don't go to look at there is do I I would imagine that the error is that you
1:50:30counter well developing app may be different in the areas I encounter when using apps
1:50:34and so there may be something that distinction as well
1:50:37but it's worth checking I just wanted to grasp that distinction is important however
1:50:41when you're talking about the need to make a new language I would say the helping developers during development avoid
1:50:50things like we have memory errors often very hard to find and fix it helping avoid that might be more.
1:51:01Develop an app once more or less.
1:51:03Millions of people use it all over the place would you rather have the openness is openable had something that happened
1:51:07during the development or the something to help the people who had deployed the programming obviously you want both
1:51:11and they're probably like they're tied to each other in various ways
1:51:14but I would much rather have the developer suffer and have the end users not experience crashes than the reverse.
1:51:21I with cases.
1:51:23He got it he knows he knows what he did in the vinyl he knows what he did I just never saw it today
1:51:29and I could not believe he just kept digging yourself in deeper
1:51:31and deeper let's provide context which we didn't do last time apparently.
1:51:34OK so I was on IRA talk with faith in Jason for second time which I am not at all going to gloat about how I was
1:51:43invited back before you were invited back because I'm too much of a not all for that.
1:51:49In any case I was invited on in the comedy of this is I didn't actually hear the episode until after I was on wherein
1:51:57faith and Jason kind of got into a tiff.
1:52:00About head to intuitive about vinyl and Faith had asserted
1:52:06and she is correct that vinyl does indeed sound better on an appropriate stereo then a CD does this stop this stop
1:52:15digging yourself. That's already gone it's already scientifically rock very good if I finish it. Finish your summary.
1:52:22So she had said to Jason No it sounds better and they got and they went back
1:52:26and forth though at the time I didn't know this when I recorded with them they went back and forth
1:52:30and Jason actually summarized it really well after Faith was so far into the rage deep into that I was surprised he
1:52:38didn't plop it in any case what Jason said was Oh you just feel like it's more full in complete sound in Faith said
1:52:45yeah that's pretty much it. Obviously I'm heavily paraphrasing her it's all right.
1:52:50So hold on so so what I had said was Hey Jason I didn't hear the background story all I saw was a few tweets fly by
1:52:59between my cue and faith or faith and Jason and I wanted to weigh in somewhat ignorantly given the context
1:53:06but weigh in and say that having grown up with a really really really good stereo
1:53:12and a house with a father who has just a shed load of vinyl I would completely agree science be damned.
1:53:22That vinyl legitimately does sound better and maybe it's a placebo.
1:53:27Maybe it's all my darn head but I don't care because I believe it in my heart that it sounds way better
1:53:33and faith is right.
1:53:34All right so I have two cables to sell you over here are going to try to try to give a reasonable summary of this are
1:53:39you guys going to attempt I think I mean first of all let me start by saying I'm not an audio expert
1:53:44but I don't think you need to be an expert to get a handle on this topic I think that the main problems on the original
1:53:49of this are between faith and reason which will put in the shadows.
1:53:52Was that as usual they didn't sort of define the boundaries of their discussion in their terms well enough that they
1:53:56were just talking about each other. Here's how it started so like.
1:54:00They were talking about the stupid Pono thing that we talked about of the high quality music from what is
1:54:05and you know young or whoever and you know and you know
1:54:08and Jason asked her if you'd be interested as she said if I you know if I want to if I was after that it's like Oh
1:54:14wouldn't you want us to listen to higher quality audio is like a high I want to higher quality audio just listen to
1:54:18vinyl and that's how it started
1:54:19and I think there's a sort of a foundation as you can see how through the game of telephone you end up with that type
1:54:25of opinion it devolved into like oh you think vinyl is better than this that the other thing there's many many factors
1:54:31at play here
1:54:31but I can start from like again I can get like I don't I can't get specifically technical about this you can look up
1:54:37all the stuff that you want to mark are going to add later but here's here's I think I'm going to bottom line
1:54:41and I think the bottom line is reasonably accurate.
1:54:43When you when instruments make sound like when people play music live right and you capture that sound
1:54:51and you try to take the sound that was in the air when people playing instruments
1:54:54and put it somewhere such you can get the most back from what you heard in that room like the actual sound of his
1:54:59produced CD even just plain CD is more able to capture
1:55:05and reproduce accurately the sounds that are in that room than vinyl.
1:55:10I'm pretty sure
1:55:11and Mark can confirm you want that is just a more less undisputable fact due to the limitations of the medium. Confirm.
1:55:17So that's the problem with a gun and they were talking about vinyl CD of stuff like just ignore everything else
1:55:25and if they like their sound in a room you want to capture that sound
1:55:28and put that sound back out in the world somehow if you want to capture that information.
1:55:33Vinyl has limitations in terms of frequent frequencies that it can accurately reproduce
1:55:37and how well it can you know capture what was in that room.
1:55:40That CD doesn't have right so that I think and you can google that
1:55:45and do all the stuff you want to see what what kind of frequencies can vinyl reproduce and what are the limitations
1:55:49and what is the top and then the bottom end and how well can it produce high for exams versus low frequency sounds
1:55:54and and distortion this is even before you get into like every time you play a vinyl record you're damaging it
1:55:58and all its other things.
1:56:00I'll make a little grooves in wax in illustrating like that fact sits there
1:56:04and flies in the face of all of the discussion of like a vinyl vs C.D.C.
1:56:08Vs mine of his when you're talking about a medium that's different.
1:56:10Now why why could normal good reasonable thinking people come to the conclusion that you know why did they think that
1:56:17vinyl is the highest quality. You know if I want to listen to music with a higher quality than than M P three S.
1:56:23or Cd's always goes in the vinyl why why did you come to that conclusion because there is much more to what music
1:56:29sounds like than just how well it is the medium able to capture sound right and we've talked with some passion.
1:56:37There's a stupid loudness more where they mastered everything for CD
1:56:40and kept cranking up the you know the whatever I don't know the term for it
1:56:44but like if you look at the way inform the way room slowly fills the entire thing the dynamic range between the quiet
1:56:48sex and loud section disappears in the whole song as loud that sounds like crap.
1:56:52They didn't do that in the era
1:56:53when most vinyl was made so vinyl sounds quote unquote better so if you hear the same album on vinyl
1:56:59and CD in the CD one is over compressed and cranked up
1:57:03and the final one is not of course the violin going to sound better
1:57:06but that's not even the same song anymore it's different audio.
1:57:09So that's one reason the vinyl could sound better like legitimately really sound better because it was mastered
1:57:13differently in the early days when they were making vinyl.
1:57:16From what I've read since vinyl has a different frequency response than C.D.'s they would master it as if they were
1:57:21standing at the vinyl like they were over boost the treble
1:57:24or whatever frequencies of Binah would have trouble reproducing they would have to crank those up because they know a
1:57:29lot of those who get muffled by the vinyl and they just take that same master and put on CD
1:57:32and it would sound terrible because she didn't have those limitations I can reproduce the sound accurately in this its
1:57:38a more linear range between them you don't have to say well this travels going how do you know his trouble whatever
1:57:43this trouble's going to get swelled to really need to crank it up or don't worry
1:57:46when we're going to carve the little grooves into the vinyl disc of all sound good.
1:57:50Again if you take the same album from the same master all the CD sounds terrible the vinyl sounds good it's because
1:57:55vinyl is swallowing up half of the things that are there and it's you know the master was made. Your vinyl.
1:58:01All these things can contribute to the idea that vinyl sounds better because in a particular album
1:58:06or a particular song the vinyl recording may be better master
1:58:09or you may simply prefer that those frequencies be attenuated the way they are on vinyl.
1:58:15So and what happens if you don't have all the background and all these handy gritty details.
1:58:21Your experience your lived experience will be when I hear the song on and B three that sounds like crap
1:58:26when I play it on my fancy vinyl things it sounds awesome.
1:58:29Therefore vinyl sounds better and it just game of telephone that over
1:58:32and over again in Austin in the hipster community as is accepted fact that vinyl is higher quality than CD and
1:58:38when I see you can jump through like you jump from something that has a basis in reality all lead to a conclusion that
1:58:45has no basis in reality in fact and you can't say vinyl is better than CD because it is not.
1:58:51Well OK I understand where you're coming.
1:58:55Well it's not where you're coming from I understand what you're saying and by and large I do agree with it
1:58:59but it's more than just I think playing it off as a game of telephone for for both faith
1:59:04and I is not really being fair because both of us have legitimately experienced really good setups in the homes in
1:59:14which we lived at some point or another and in I don't know if I can speak for faith
1:59:19but I know I have listened to a CD and then the exact same song from the exact same hour
1:59:24but you don't know is exact the sort of thing you don't know with the same song you know it could've been mastered
1:59:29differently and there's nothing I can say to you to refute
1:59:33or dispute what you had said about different mastering absolutely could be right about that.
1:59:38But one way or another I can tell you that I've listened to C.D.'s and I've listened to vinyl and be at the mastering
1:59:43or be at the medium and yes the medium is kind of inherently flawed in cracks in the hisses and the pops and whatnot
1:59:49but I don't but now and then the frequency response
1:59:53and in the things that it can in the things that it can reproduce there was sound in the room
1:59:57when people played that music. How many of those sounds can.
2:00:00The recorded and played back by vinyl it is a smaller subset of sounds than CD
2:00:05and I haven't looked at any of the research because market would let me hear very well could be true.
2:00:13I find that a little harder.
2:00:15You got into this on the show as well that you're trying to think of like things that sound reasonable to like oh well
2:00:20it's inherently like analog then stick signals and systems in a school.
2:00:23Yes but that was no analog versus discrete signals.
2:00:26Marco has a good video that you can see about it like I watched that the sampling like it's not here.
2:00:32If you if you still subscribe to it even after seeing the math
2:00:36and taking say dozens of whatever if you don't if that perch you don't find that approach convincing although you
2:00:41should because it's true and an alternative approach.
2:00:45Think of it this way when you take sound
2:00:48and you translate it to carving a little valley in plastic you are inherently taking an analog signal like it you know
2:00:56the music you're recording directly about how it works
2:00:59but so you're recording directly into the grooves in the while you're taking something
2:01:03and you're encoding that signal in a groove in plastic. What do you think has a better resolution.
2:01:10Those samples and bits that you're taking or the variations you can make precisely in grooves in plastic.
2:01:16Like Talk Talk about quantizing in like you know if you if you subscribe to a theory like oh it's inherently continuous
2:01:22function you're sampling How can you ever reproduce there is no single That is B.S.
2:01:25You totally can but think of what you're doing when you're making a groove in vinyl.
2:01:29Do you think oh that can completely accurately encode this information because we can so precisely control how we wage
2:01:36these atoms out of the way
2:01:37and that is vital to make this little valley I mean look at under a microscope is not a precise trail that's been drawn
2:01:43there is nothing more precise than sixteen bit samples and forty four Gilberton No it is not
2:01:48and that's borne out by what kind of frequencies you can get out of that let alone the variations in an individual
2:01:53stamping or carving of vinyl it's it's insanity to think that vinyl as a medium is better then.
2:02:00Digital things mastering is what it's all about.
2:02:03Here's here's how you make things sound good you listen on a really really good system which is usually systems that
2:02:14are like you know really good inexpensive are usually only by upper middle class men in their fifty's
2:02:21and up like my dad right.
2:02:25And these are middle class men in their fifty's and up probably listen to music from the sixty's and seventy's
2:02:32and music from the sixty's
2:02:34and seventy's if you have a CD version of the same thing was probably one of the old crappy cd's that was mastered back
2:02:41when cds were too young as drummers discussing and a lot of the masters were really bad
2:02:45and a lot of the translation to CD were really badly done.
2:02:49It's also possible that you were you know comparing it to things like M P three that were encoded in the late ninety's
2:02:56injuries were new and M P three encoders used to be really really bad
2:03:00and now they're really really good as always are factors now the way you make things sound good is you listen to well
2:03:06recorded music
2:03:09and there's a good chance that old fifty year old men with you know a lot of money with big stereos they're probably
2:03:18listening to pretty good music.
2:03:20Honestly music that was probably recorded better was probably never going to music that was that was played with more
2:03:27real instruments
2:03:28and less artificial tweaks to the sound less electronic instruments if any you know there's there was a lot more there
2:03:39like of substance that you could detect on gets area you know compared to like the very artificial clean sound of
2:03:45modern stuff. So they're listening to stuff that sounds better at higher resolution and higher detail.
2:03:51They're listening are really good stereos
2:03:53and they're making an event out of listening there this is the most important part by far they're paying attention
2:03:58when when you are told. This is why a B. X. Testing is so important when you are told.
2:04:05Listen to this this is going to sound amazing and it's played on a great stereo
2:04:10and you are expecting it to sound amazing he's been told it will sound amazing
2:04:14and you want to say it's an attractive idea of the old the romantic the analog being superior to the new crazy things
2:04:21the kids are doing these days. That's a very nice attractive idea people they want that to be true.
2:04:25So you're being told going to sound better you're in an environment where it looks impressive you're probably in front
2:04:30of an impressive looking stereo. And maybe it has some like old crazy things like tubes.
2:04:36Or at least I mean hell record players themselves are you know pretty crazy analog things especially the really
2:04:42advanced ones that are probably in these events that have like the electrically moving arm
2:04:45and all that sort of stuff so you have you're told to expect it.
2:04:49It looks impressive the system looks impressive it looks exotic and old and romantic.
2:04:56And then the music starts playing and you pay attention to it.
2:05:00This is critical you're you're not just putting music on.
2:05:03You are listening to the music
2:05:06and you're trying to hear your you're paying attention to what it sounds like you're listening for details you're
2:05:11trying to hear details you've never heard before
2:05:13and then you say oh my God I'm hearing details I've never heard before which is probably true
2:05:20but it's not because of anything inherently awesome about any individual component of that necessarily to the exclusion
2:05:25of its alternatives. It's because you're paying attention.
2:05:29Your mentor says in the event you're making you're telling yourself to enjoy the event so you're enjoying the event
2:05:35you're telling yourself it sounds good and the input you're getting from other factors like its appearance
2:05:41or the setting or whatever people are telling you about all these symbols are telling you this will sound great.
2:05:47So then when you listen it sounds great.
2:05:51And that's not to invalidate the experience because who cares if you're enjoying it and it sounds great
2:05:55and it works like this if the work basically got all the money you spent like give it making you happy. Right then.
2:06:00Then everything worked and another possibility is that people who have grown up with
2:06:06or even if they haven't grown a bit like you may simply prefer the sound of an accurate reproduction of live music.
2:06:13You may prefer those those frequencies to be tamped off.
2:06:16You may prefer that they're sort of an underlying noise to be underneath all that.
2:06:19That may sound better to you is better is subjective like that may sound better to you like that's fine to say I like
2:06:26the sound of vinyl better than CD because I like those things like it may be inaccurate because again you have to say
2:06:33OK fine we'll get you the same stereo will take the same song master the same way you do controlled experiment play
2:06:38while vinyl A See if you can tell which one is which and B.
2:06:42If you can tell them to say which one you prefer because once you can tell you May so I prefer the vinyl one.
2:06:46Whatever doesn't matter whatever you prefer is going to be refer.
2:06:49Where this goes wrong is when you say higher quality because I asked that you could say that subject a do
2:06:54but like Hark why we're talk about audio it's like the definition I gave the beginning
2:06:58when this music was played there was sound in the air. We want to take that sound put it somewhere and bring it back.
2:07:04What which way can we do that so we lose the least amount of information
2:07:08and CD winds over vinyl I mean that that's that's it like that to the foundation of this entire thing.
2:07:14Everything else you can say is you may say you prefer one thing or the other one thing makes you happy
2:07:19or so makes you happy
2:07:20or find you prefer one thing of the over of the other you can still be challenged say OK I will give you a double blind
2:07:25test R.N.A. Be accessed.
2:07:27Let's see if you can even tell which is which you probably can't
2:07:30and if you can tell maybe you're not sure which is which
2:07:32and then you've sort of punched a hole in your own kind of well I prefer that over the.
2:07:35Maybe you really don't prefer it
2:07:36but whatever you wouldn't subject yourself to that test unless you're trying to ruin your fun.
2:07:40If it makes you happy to listen to vinyl fine but where people go crazy about this
2:07:45and where you start to get into all of audio file tell Terry is where you start really truly believing the vinyl is the
2:07:50highest quality reproduction of music available it may be the best mastered version of that song available that may be
2:07:56true and that's why I said like porno might be better because it'll get better mastered versions of it.
2:08:00And you can say that if you think that's true.
2:08:02But that's where I'm going nuts over this thing is when you get into like oh it sounds fuller and richer
2:08:07and it's analog and all that other stuff that's that's what drives me face it.
2:08:12Nerds only you know everyone else just enjoy their music so maybe you could just look in the media like in the way you
2:08:18want enjoy it and not worry about it
2:08:20but I guess don't go on podcast with you're going to try don't talk about vinyl of the CD I have the floor please.
2:08:26You may or you too Don. Probably not but I doubt it. I'm stone sober and I'm so angry right now.
2:08:33OK There's a few things.
2:08:35Firstly I should make it plain that when I came to the conclusion that vinyl was better and I cannot speak for faith
2:08:46but
2:08:46when I came to the conclusion the vinyl was better in the limited experience that I have it was because I was playing
2:08:53modern recordings.
2:08:54One was Dave Matthews which Marcus McGraw you want but they are well recorded the first time
2:09:08and the other was Soundgarden I forget the name of the album but it was the one with I played
2:09:16or my dad played there's a vinyl or the CD and picked one of the songs and immediately played the other.
2:09:24Immediately after yes I know I knew which one was which.
2:09:28Yes I was predisposed are arguably predisposed to like one better than the others.
2:09:33So yes from a purely scientific point of view you could say that this test was flawed.
2:09:39Yes you could say that the dramatic difference that I heard which is exactly how I would describe it was all in my head.
2:09:47It very very well could be I have no kind of volume.
2:09:51Yeah in fact it's been shown that like in blind tests people overwhelmingly prefer an input that's like Point one.
2:10:00Sibyl turned up more than the other one even if the heart was identical.
2:10:03Yep that is slightly slightly louder and you'll sound better anyway.
2:10:08So regardless of whether or not it's based in science I can tell you that I definitely heard a difference
2:10:18and I'd definitely prefer preferred vinyl I will be the first to tell you that yes the medium is inherently flawed.
2:10:24You're screwing it up every time you use it. You're gonna have to get over hisses and pops and crackles and whatnot.
2:10:30Yes most of my father's record collection was bought in the fifty's sixty's and seventy's.
2:10:35But yes he does have a record cleaner specifically designed to clean L.P.'s that he uses almost every time he plays a
2:10:43record. Yes his CD player is so ridiculously out of control that it's actually what he calls it a transport right.
2:10:52Yes Thank you it's a transport and it's a digital analog converter I believe uses tubes because at some point
2:10:58or another that was the trendy thing to do and people believed it sounded better.
2:11:02Though in many communities that's still the case by the way.
2:11:04Yes you could argue that all of this is just one placebo on top of another on top of another
2:11:09but I think it was one I don't know which one of you that said it but one way or another.
2:11:15Let's assume I'm wrong
2:11:16and let's assume for the sake of conversation that I'm just completely full of it even if that's the case.
2:11:22The experience of going to a shelf full of vinyl
2:11:27and finding alphabetically the particular LP you want removing it this humongous disk that's like a foot wide
2:11:35or whatever it is removing it placing it on the cleaner putting the little solution on it having the little turntable
2:11:42cleaner thing spin and vacuum up the solution as you shimmy it across the record moving that something else.
2:11:49Don't you get me started about a party. All right so anyways move the record over to the turntable.
2:11:57You guess you three can guess where.
2:12:00There it is the song you want to play starts and you're probably going to be wrong
2:12:04but you can look at the little smooth ring not only aren't doing the work you can and I know and I know
2:12:09and dad who's done this for thirty years is much better at it than I am.
2:12:13All of this adds to the experience and I forgot to mention all the album art when that was still a thing
2:12:17and still fricken mattered. All of that taking picking the record out of the out of the sleeve gingerly.
2:12:24All of this adds to the experience and makes it more enjoyable for me.
2:12:30Don't forget chucking the disc of the base the what is that some right we didn't have a reference guide to throw in a
2:12:37night I'm glad he has a quota for you Marco to sit here and tell me I need a B.X. Test and blah blah blah.
2:12:45When's the last time you may be axed your coffee versus Starbucks. He didn't tell you you needed the A.B.A.
2:12:51Test like all the stuff you satisfy no one is arguing against like the tea ceremony sort of thing you have going to
2:12:55that like again I said whatever makes you happy then go for it like there's no reason to subject yourself to the
2:13:01scientific test if there is going to make you enjoy life less like that right.
2:13:05But
2:13:06but you also then can't make claims like vinyl is the highest quality source of music available because in that sense
2:13:13you didn't say what I really mean is that when the mass
2:13:15or things are vinyl they have more dynamic range in my preferred like you didn't say that you said vinyl and like it
2:13:20and you end up talking about the medium and then
2:13:22when you stray off into well digital can't capture all the nuances because it's discrete instead of giving this like
2:13:28the you're just off into the weeds and that's what people yell at you
2:13:31and it's like stick to your actual you know argue with you
2:13:34when you say you really enjoy the ceremony of Dylan if I don't know who are you with me
2:13:37when you say come on this is the Internet somebody will argue well I know but like they have a leg to stand on
2:13:42and I played the song on vinyl and the song entity specific songs
2:13:46and I liked it better if I don't find you like what you like you get into trouble
2:13:49when you go into like categorical you know scientific statements about capturing audio waveforms
2:13:56and reproducing them and that's where it all goes off the rails and that's where I think like it.
2:14:00In that kind of committee long enough where everyone reveres vinyl as the sort of thing to do.
2:14:03Eventually it just becomes like everybody knows vinyl sounds better and it just becomes accepted wisdom
2:14:08and that's not you so much more faith like it says we don't like in your circle of course vinyl sounds better than C.
2:14:14Everybody knows that I think an obvious fact that came believe you're arguing with me about it
2:14:18and that's what infuriates people inside that community.
2:14:22This stuff just wraps around on itself again
2:14:24and again until eventually it becomes accepted within the vinyl is better than CD which is not a true statement in
2:14:29and of itself and the nuances are now lost
2:14:31and it just becomes like that that's why I like a game of telephone where it's like a generation of people who don't
2:14:36know or care about the technical details and know they like the sound of vinyl better but they don't know why
2:14:41and their conclusion they come to is is false.
2:14:43See if you can take issue with the entire city of Austin believing the finals better as long as you put an asterisk at
2:14:49the end
2:14:50and say accept things in the same thing with me because we have come to this conclusion from personal experience there
2:14:57is no game of telephone for us now.
2:14:59Every other person on the planet that claims line is better fine telephone no no because it's bigger than her initial
2:15:04reaction was like well I would just listen to a CD on vinyl history out there like of course everybody knows that like
2:15:09it wasn't a controversial statement when she first made it and I think that's why she was taken by surprise by like
2:15:13and she's you know she backpedaled and tried to more narrowly divine or whatever
2:15:17but like that's what I'm glad I listened to the a little bit of a so if you haven't already I have I have sinned since
2:15:22I recorded.
2:15:23She threw it out there like as if it's like well everybody knows that in my circle so it's like if it wasn't that
2:15:27wasn't a topic the topic wasn't buying over there things like well I would never buy the stupid triangular player
2:15:31because of actually really cared about high quality music I just listened to it on vinyl and then Jason was like What.
2:15:36You know like he's he's not coming from that same environment where that
2:15:40and then she had to think about what I mean by that like if it's excepted wisdom in your circle of friends you don't
2:15:45think about what I mean by that is that they have to do with the mastering is vinyl actually better able to you know I
2:15:50mean like and maybe that has been thought through
2:15:52but I don't think that she was intending to make a declaration about the world as much as I probably was.
2:15:58I think she was more trying to say.
2:16:00This is what I feel
2:16:01and this is what I think I don't think she was trying to be the representative for Austin Texas last hipster Ville USA
2:16:08I can't speak for her but I'm pretty sure that that wasn't the intention. For me I was more going for a global.
2:16:14You are and you should listen to yourself and watch the video the market sent over and over again
2:16:19and do exercises in your same old assistant book until you convince yourself that it's B.S.
2:16:23but They were like the reason I brought it up on the show
2:16:25and in the after shows because I don't want to bring it up on our own talk of I already had an episode where I harangue
2:16:29them and faith does not need to be arranged but if you could you could take some Hering who will thank you
2:16:33and I still want to go back for you.
2:16:35I I do not understand how a man that spends an unbelievable amount of time fussing over a drink that's inherently
2:16:43disgusting and not helpful can throw stones at me because I want to enjoy music in my own little way.
2:16:49How wonderful if I knew maybe X. Tested your coffee.
2:16:52I would love the opportunity to solve the problem the problem of coffee
2:16:55and stuff like that is that there's no like it's not like capturing audio waveforms there is no original
2:17:00and a reproduction.
2:17:01So there is no sort of objective criteria by which you can judge it all it's all like how does this tasty Oh
2:17:06and then you can test the disabled this is really taste better.
2:17:09Maybe the special beings
2:17:10but like it's all subjective so you know like every city really replaces specially made coffee with K.
2:17:17Cups for a week and see if you notices but he would not.
2:17:20I mean hey if you want to if you want to orchestrate that I will gladly participate because I don't I don't like at all
2:17:27to be around.
2:17:28Well the market biggest market was trying to find like he's although he does all these fussy things I think what he's
2:17:34like.
2:17:34If there was some way that he could like snap his fingers and instantly have a cup of coffee with no mess
2:17:39and no muss I think it tasted good to him I think he would do it like he's not going out of it you know going out of
2:17:44your way to find the most complicated way to make coffee.
2:17:47No in fact making making coffee in my way I don't think actually takes more overall effort than using like a regular
2:17:53drip hardly ever use for years it is a little more effort than using a cake up machine
2:17:57but it's like I use an arrow for us. And I don't even do a super first year press and a roast their own beans.
2:18:04So that kind of thing that cranks up the fuzziness meter if you were to buy roaster invented outside of your house of
2:18:11the village smoke and figure out how to use the roaster it takes fifteen minutes every ten days.
2:18:16Iris I like the point is like the reason you're doing that is because you're trying to find the minimum like a coffee
2:18:21that tastes good to you but it also doesn't absorb your entire life in making it right
2:18:26and the reason why I've been doing all this audio research recently is because I also am an audio file.
2:18:32But I'm I'm not a ridiculous one like I'm really really super into good headphones
2:18:38and speakers I care a lot less about that I don't have a lot of opportunities to work on speakers right now my life
2:18:42but I'm really into really good headphones and I have now what I consider pretty ridiculous equipment.
2:18:50But getting here involves a lot of research and finding out like what mattered to me and what didn't
2:18:57and what what matters to science and what sense of to A B X test and what doesn't
2:19:03and it's all about striking a balance between practicality and cost and quality
2:19:10and vinyl you know your vinyl crazy Tea Ceremony is the exact same way like you're looking to get something out of that
2:19:17and you get it out of that if it's worth it to you fine.
2:19:20I agree with John that you know that you can't just go
2:19:22and say Oh well actually better than why you know if you're not saying well I enjoy the procedure of X.
2:19:28More than I had to have the procedure and experience of why
2:19:32but you know the reason why I pick on this sort of stuff in the audio world
2:19:37and in the coffee role even is because people do a lot of wasteful stupid things that actually don't have any effect
2:19:45and again if they enjoy them that's fine but the problem comes in when they start telling other people.
2:19:51If you do this it will be better. Or if you buy this it will be better. That actually gets destructive.
2:19:57But that's what you do with coffee. That's exactly why. Do a cough you die.
2:20:01Sure I could google a post where you told us about how roasting beans is the only way to do.
2:20:06Actually every time I've mentioned roasting my own beans on my site I say you shouldn't do this.
2:20:11Well I guess I guess if you're back to taste being subjective like it's not as not as now I go anywhere we have a way
2:20:16of here is the original And let's see if we can reproduce in that unlike the generally accepted level of quality in
2:20:22audio is like we want to reproduce the original as accurately as possible and like
2:20:25and I don't even think that necessarily makes people feel as good because the original It's not just the way form it's
2:20:30like where you're sitting in the room and vibrations coming through your seed
2:20:33and oil like the so many things about live music that are different than normal.
2:20:37So again you could be a hybrid that I prefer when when the
2:20:41when the original single is reproduced in accurately in these ways in fact in particular the way that vinyl tends to
2:20:47accurately reproduce it that's what I like better.
2:20:49Fine you can like it but our standard for audio is compared to the original.
2:20:53There's a standard for coffee if you like McDonald's coffee Dunkin Donuts coffee cake up like whatever you like is what
2:20:59you like you can say well that's not how coffee supposed to take us and this is all subjective
2:21:03and Marco has particular tastes in coffee and to his tastes. Starbucks is gross and what he makes is good.
2:21:09Someone may love Starbucks and hate is coffee or whatever
2:21:12but there's no easy yardstick except for like I guess some things like damages your body by drinking
2:21:17and we can all agree that you probably shouldn't have that although maybe that's a bad choice for coffee.
2:21:22Well no I but I think Coffee does damage your body in before Marco interrupts me what I mean by that Lance doesn't.
2:21:27What I mean by that is part of the reason I don't ever want to learn to like coffee is because I don't ever want to
2:21:35rely on having something in order to get my day going.
2:21:38I can go weeks without a diet coke but I like to now but I don't and I don't run my life based on whether
2:21:45or not I've had my lunchtime Diet Coke and maybe Marco isn't this way although I feel like you are.
2:21:49But most people I know like that I work with for example they go in
2:21:54and they don't want to be talked to until they've stuck a cake up in the Keurig and they can't.
2:22:00They feel like they can't function until they've completed that stage of their mourning
2:22:05and that just sounds positively frickin terrible to me it really does.
2:22:09Well Mark has already said he doesn't like that aspect of coffee drinkers
2:22:12and I mean if he is a capping addict you know I am a Cappy addict in that if I don't have coffee I will get a headache
2:22:18by about four pm or so. But when do you think I have my first cup of coffee today.
2:22:24Oh well you probably work up a new ring.
2:22:26I woke up at about a third of that that I was totally give you know her know her a thirty I worked all morning I have
2:22:31my first cup of coffee at about two thirty. How are you going about eight thirty.
2:22:36Your wife is a saint and I give a separate area thirty to thirty though your child the saint
2:22:44and saying you should not you should not share that widely to the point of driving at is less about the time
2:22:51but more about if you do not consume a cup of coffee during the day
2:22:55or equivalent caffeine something is amiss in your world.
2:22:58Could you live with it perhaps but something is amiss and I just don't want that in my life.
2:23:04Agreed so then instead you listen to vinyl which involves washing things and sleeving them
2:23:08and wiping the wash off the sleeve he doesn't he doesn't even have a record player right. I never do.
2:23:14The only time I was in the finals when I met my mom
2:23:16and dad's which up until two months from now they lived in Connecticut so I was in the final two
2:23:22or three times a year
2:23:23and you know what maybe that's why romanticize it so damn much maybe it's because I grew up with it there's a million
2:23:28reasons why
2:23:29and I will concede that I should not have said that it is the be all end all better mechanism for listening to music
2:23:38but I will not concede that in any experience I've ever had I prefer it be a placebo or otherwise.
2:23:45I still love you guys even though I want to kill you both. Marc about follow up do you know it.