Podcast Search

The Accidental Tech Podcast

61: Perfectly Neutral

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00So your tweet about us having thin topics like oh there's a lot of stuff we didn't get that for wearables

0:00:04but after that you read them are topics I didn't want to know I guess it was a popular item

0:00:10but just one last week we were talking about how if you have some sort of service that deals with your photos

0:00:17and lets you share them no matter what cool features you have you've got at least also have a way to send a link to

0:00:23somebody they can view and any web browser and we also talked about photo stream an I O.

0:00:28Us integration and stuff like that.

0:00:30And although we didn't come out

0:00:31and say it directly the implication was that sort of stream did not have a public euro

0:00:35but for a stream does that public your all you can make a little yourself

0:00:39or a website that you can share with somebody that lets them see the pictures in your photo stream.

0:00:45I use mostly with my family and my family has I.O.'s devices

0:00:47and the great thing about that is it notifies you on your phone or on your i Pad And

0:00:52when you get the notification you need to swipe and see the pictures immediately.

0:00:55It's of much superior interface for viewing pictures but you've always got to have that web interface underneath all

0:01:01and this came up in the kind of Carousel which I think he said they didn't have a way if you could just get an easy web

0:01:06link that was my experience that's correct.

0:01:09So I emailed what was to Carousel a completely random e-mail address that wasn't associated with a Dropbox account

0:01:18email address in fact it was my work email and

0:01:20when I received the e-mail from personal mean I'm doing that in air quotes to work me the work e-mail basically said

0:01:27hey you need to install carousel if you want to do anything useful and I think it did have like six

0:01:32or seven pictures in it.

0:01:33Little little thumbnails of the pictures and I'd actually selected so was like stock photography or anything like that.

0:01:39But with that said it didn't it didn't do anything and there was no Web based link it basically said go to the app

0:01:45or get the hell out of here that we have anymore follow up in any case if you feel like you need to follow up at all.

0:01:52I mean topics from last week you know you did Casey do you want to tell us all what you did post. No I don't know.

0:02:02I'm I'm a little not bitter little frustrated with the feedback from last week

0:02:09and I was debating talking about it in since you've prompted me I'll go ahead and do so

0:02:15and just make my world even worse for myself.

0:02:18And the thing that frustrated me about the feedback we received is that there were a few instances

0:02:24and Mark at words is from the Django Django I was Prancer on I'm so sorry Mark.

0:02:30But anyway he wrote a relatively long missive that he put up as a just a guess whatever on my thing

0:02:37and I just thank you and doubted myself anyways. Mata whack.

0:02:41So he put up a jest

0:02:42and then he explained as someone who used to do this sort of thing for a living why vinyl is basically the most evil

0:02:50thing in the world and well I don't entirely agree with what he said.

0:02:56I can't really factually debate it and so things like that

0:03:01when Will will put a link in the show notes that was actually welcome and useful

0:03:06but I got a lot of feedback we got a lot of feedback

0:03:08and I got a lot of feedback which basically amounted to I read something on the internet once. It must be true.

0:03:16You're crazy and stupid

0:03:18and that kind of bothers me a little bit because it was oftentimes not really based in fact Or sometimes it was

0:03:27but never ever ever based on experience and I'm not going to try to rehash the argument

0:03:32but suffice to say I put a lot more stock

0:03:34when I receive feedback from someone who has had the experience of listening to vinyl on a really nice set up over

0:03:42someone who has just read some things or seen some stuff on the Internet and swears that that's true.

0:03:48Now yes there's a lot of science behind it. Yes I understand that. Yes I'm probably crazy.

0:03:53All of that is fine I agree I understand it it was probably silly of me to say that the fidelity of.

0:04:00I know it was better than the fidelity of C.D.'s but

0:04:03when it comes down to it something I said on Twitter which actually is fairly proud of myself I'm patting myself on the

0:04:09back is that it's very kind of cliché but life is what happens between one and zero in my eyes and whether

0:04:16or not the accuracy of the reproduction on vinyl or CD is better.

0:04:21I just happen to prefer the feel

0:04:24and to some degree the what do you call it the T something I already forgot ceremony

0:04:29and I think the ceremony you know I'm I know what you mean so I prefer the tea ceremony of it

0:04:35and the only thing I will say to defend myself other than come at me once you've had personal experience you damn nerds

0:04:43you know me other thing I'll say is Why is it John that you choose to drive a manual transmission in two thousand

0:04:51and fourteen that's not even close to a fair comparison.

0:04:55Oh no I was going to let you slide but you kind of you come back at me with this

0:04:59and you just like that what I was going to let slide is the time that thing with life is what happens

0:05:03when you want to zero that like that vaguely allude to terrible illogical reasoning behind crazy you know like I know

0:05:12you know I thought we did getting it at all.

0:05:13Like I understand but the fact that you chose to use one and zero is like another nudge it like that.

0:05:18C'mon guys we all know that digital stuff is not a feeling and you know I mean like this is an I did I do that

0:05:26but then you came like I found the feedback frustrating as well

0:05:29and you would think I wouldn't want to be that pressure because I think that most of the feedback agreed with Marco

0:05:32and I but I found the bag very frustrating because I mean this is a common phenomenon of the back for the show.

0:05:38Very often we will get feedback and I don't want the topic

0:05:42and past shows everything where someone will be I mean it's not bad feedback is good for the shows

0:05:46and some you know some of the big fan of the show right in

0:05:49and this is in some ways this is the best kind of feedback that whether we like listening to your show maybe think

0:05:55about this and here is what I think about it and they'll present a bunch of ideas about the topic.

0:06:00But what I find frustrating is a lot of the time the ideas they present are things that we talked about on the show

0:06:07and you don't want to write back and say you know we talked about that this exact thing going on the show

0:06:13but then it sounds like you're not valuing their feedback

0:06:15and it's good that they're enthusiastic about a sometimes it's frustrating to see like I fail I obviously failed to

0:06:19communicate this idea because it keeps coming back to me as if it's information that we're missing

0:06:24or if it's new information or new insights

0:06:26and like we talked about for fifteen minutes we said almost these exact words

0:06:30and it's like sometimes it's people sometimes people sending feedback in real time where they listen

0:06:35and then I guess they cause it or whatever and then they write their you know three page missive

0:06:40and then they start playing again.

0:06:41You know as I haven't gotten into the pod gets I realize we addressed the point

0:06:44and I happen to tweet you know obviously it's fine.

0:06:46Some of that happens with us too

0:06:48but a lot of the feedback was like presenting points back to any of us me Marco you that I thought of because where we

0:06:56covered on the show like we talked about these exact things and it's like maybe we're not communicating effectively

0:07:02or are just like we're talking past our audience

0:07:06or something in the same way I saw a lot of arguments directed both Casey

0:07:10and US that I thought we talked about on the show and address all different sides of coming back at us you know

0:07:16and the arguments that I thought I had you know refuted

0:07:21and settled down arguments the case he never made arguments that we never made decisions that we never staked out to

0:07:26say you know the whole nine yards like this is obviously a very fraught issue

0:07:30and I think the problem you're still having with it

0:07:32and I think you know continue to have with that is that you just got out like you have to just make it clear what it is

0:07:39like you know like in a world in an underwear like moving the goalposts the enemy clear what everybody's talking about

0:07:44to this point I think everybody on this part of us all agrees it's just that you keep wanting to put the goal posts

0:07:49over there and that's what we're talking about I mean I'm going to put the goal posts over here in Britain this is

0:07:54and and and and original and I'm trying to give them kind of where the original thing was which was the whole idea.

0:08:00An R.L. Talk where Faith said I'm not going to buy a device that purports to have high quality music and you're right.

0:08:05Fidelity is a better word is point out to us by Dr Dre

0:08:08and we should've been using that word which could be part of the communication problem here.

0:08:11But anyway I'm not going to buy a device like the PO now because if I want high quality meaning high fidelity music

0:08:16I'll just listen to vinyl

0:08:18and that I think is a clear you know a clear implication that like we're talking about the pano in the whole big deal

0:08:25with that is like there is you know there's more information in the music

0:08:28and it's like it was I want more information in the music of I want higher fidelity if I want to more accurate

0:08:33reproduction of sound I will go to vinyl and you seem to fall down the trail

0:08:38and my objection America's objection is that like you know vinyl is not good at reproducing sound not as good as CD

0:08:44and although some I think are great for us to talk about

0:08:46and it's good to define the boundaries of what we believe in everything that I like you should be happy with that.

0:08:51It's not as if we like it it's not as if you should you shouldn't cling to that idea like that fidelity thing

0:08:58and that's not what you're talking about then. Fine then you agree with us there and we agree with you.

0:09:02However the tea ceremony and everybody's happy

0:09:04and that one of things that he keeps getting thrown back in is like I like to read like to reframe the arguments in the

0:09:12popular one is like I said look if I'm really interested in High Fidelity images I'll go to Instagram.

0:09:21I get that the effect of the argument they're making like you know I don't need a full frame camera with with a really

0:09:27great sensor and lots of megapixels.

0:09:29If I'm interested in photographing for the ality I will look at a camera phone picture of a nice night joints a gram.

0:09:36I guess the argument that many people are making

0:09:38and unknowingly that they're making that they're completely combining what they think looks good which may be like a

0:09:44super grainy Instagram filter.

0:09:45And the concept of fidelity which is a straight forward thing that can be measured talked about in objective terms

0:09:51moralist and young people coming back.

0:09:53What I love to bands

0:09:55and everything like that you know instead of digital it's like that's not what we're talking about.

0:09:58Like whatever whatever it is do you. Think sounds good.

0:10:00All we're talking about is given that sound that I probably made a mistake in the live insurance because I had to deal

0:10:05with all the people who are going to live music. Give them something even some sound that you think is awesome.

0:10:11What is the best way to transport that sound through space and time to reproduce it elsewhere.

0:10:16That's all we're talking about it has nothing to do it whether you like to banter saws they bands they like six tring

0:10:21to bars or five string whether you like someone sing into a paper bag

0:10:24or whatever the sound is you've produced a sound a song live recorded whatever you want to get that across space

0:10:30and time to someone else you want to put it on something so that that sound that you love can get to them exactly as it

0:10:35is to have whatever that sound is. Master however you want to where you want how do you get that sound.

0:10:39CD verses while that's what we were talking about everything else is like immaterial I don't care if you like the sound

0:10:46of silence singing through a paper bag

0:10:49or another no not talking about bio I don't care if you like Tom Waits I don't care if you know what kind of music you

0:10:55are listening you have it you have something there

0:10:57and then live music was easy because like oh I hear that now you just want to put that on something so it could be

0:11:02played back elsewhere and if your choices are CD and vinyl

0:11:05and you care about the fidelity of the reproduction you should pick a CD instead of vinyl and that's it.

0:11:10And everything else people want to talk about.

0:11:12It's so hard for them to maintain focus it was hard for us to maintain folks who have drifting

0:11:16but it's a difficult topic to talk about I think and I think you're right

0:11:20and I think I think you're right in saying that we all agree that if if a deli is truly the issue that I can get behind

0:11:28the science even though I give it a little bit aside I never saw last I can get behind the science that says I'm crazy

0:11:34and that digital mediums are the better hire the daily method of reproducing music

0:11:41but just as you said I actually happen to prefer the tea ceremony the emotion behind like I was talking to my wife Erin

0:11:48about it she said well you know you have to consider you grew up with final

0:11:51and this was something that had that carries a lot of emotional baggage I think John one of you guys might have said

0:11:55that last week. Anyway it carries a lot of emotional baggage that for most. Humans especially in this day and age.

0:12:02They don't have that emotional baggage.

0:12:03And I say baggage actually in a good way in this context I'm sure you probably think of it that's a bad thing.

0:12:08But nevertheless I know one thing I learned from this

0:12:11and I'm really being serious is that it is very frustrating to say something which admittedly is a bit contrarian

0:12:19and admittedly I did kind of pick this fight so admittedly I kind of made this head for myself

0:12:25but man is it frustrating to say something that you truly believe

0:12:29and then the whole of the Internet decides to come out

0:12:32and tell you how wrong you are in that in of itself I can deal with that that's fine I've been wrong point times will

0:12:37be wrong plenty of times again

0:12:39but it was very frustrating for me to receive a whole bunch of feedback from people who had perhaps never even heard

0:12:46vinyl before in their lives yet decided to take the time out of their day to explain to me how wrong I am

0:12:54and I actually want.

0:12:56I'm twisting this not

0:12:57and I don't want it to sound like a complaint what I want to sound like is I learned a little bit that I think I do

0:13:04that to people sometimes

0:13:05and I can think of a great example other than maybe snickering at somebody pulling out an Android phone for example

0:13:10but let me get that for you here.

0:13:13I don't I don't want to be that guy and I think I am that guy

0:13:16and it so was a very good learning experience for me that I need to stop being that guy. Does that make sense.

0:13:22Yeah I think I don't know I mean you know we're always going to get the guy so much more to say about this

0:13:28but I'm trying to resist.

0:13:30We're always going to get you know people who disagree with what we say we always do every week I mean we get to give

0:13:37listeners some idea. We get probably I would say twenty feedback e-mails a day. These days it's a lot.

0:13:46I'm shocked how much feedback we get from the show.

0:13:49And I should quit very quickly interject and say I can't speak for you too

0:13:53but I try very hard to read every single piece and at worst skim every single piece of feedback that we do.

0:14:00Yeah me too and it's he really does like when you only get like a couple a week. That's easy to keep up with.

0:14:07Now it's getting hard to keep up with my kids.

0:14:09It's getting we get so much out it's kind of difficult because some of them you know some of them are a few lines

0:14:15and that's great.

0:14:16Some of them are like six paragraphs six dense paragraphs at that

0:14:20and those like it takes some serious time to get through it.

0:14:24But anyway you know I think we we are expressing our opinions in public.

0:14:30Lots of what we say is going to be argued with. That's just the nature of putting yourself out there. Right right.

0:14:36I like I mean I've I've been putting myself out there in my and my often rash or incorrect

0:14:43or badly stated opinions out there online for the better part of a decade now pretty consistently

0:14:50and whenever I say something that everyone jumps down my throat for for being totally wrong or off base

0:14:57or are misinformed or just just not very well stated.

0:15:02I learned something from that and I appreciate that because most people don't expose themselves to that much criticism.

0:15:10Most people don't have an audience to tell them when they're wrong and who actually will tell them

0:15:16when they're wrong and an audience that's big and diverse and smart enough to notice when they're wrong

0:15:21and to be able to express that in any kind of useful way.

0:15:25So most people tend to be terrible arguers have narrow world views etc etc And it's hard to get people to change their

0:15:34mind when they spend their whole life thinking that they're right and no one has really ever challenged him on that.

0:15:40So I'm very thankful that we have the opportunity which most people don't have.

0:15:44We we as pod cast or as anyone else who's a pod cast or a blogger or any other way that you can put yourself out there.

0:15:51We are lucky that we have the opportunity to be criticised by a massive worldwide audience. Even if your audience is.

0:16:00Twenty five people.

0:16:01That's still twenty five random strangers who don't care as much about how you feel as your family does

0:16:05and who are willing to tell you when you screw something up and you know as the audience gets larger It hurts more

0:16:12when you screw up because you have more people telling you that you're an idiot.

0:16:15But I think it is useful and it's useful

0:16:19and so like in your case you know as John said like in your case you have you know with that with the vinyl thing like

0:16:26you expressed valid opinions there.

0:16:28However you word of them in a way and you made a generalization that you couldn't support

0:16:35and so the feedback kept beating that into your head. And this is true and it's you know it certainly was not.

0:16:44Certainly was not probably easy to read everyone saying that you were wrong although by the way there are a lot of

0:16:49people who agree with you.

0:16:50I should point out but like your main your main point was that it sounds better because it sounded better to you.

0:16:59A solid argument would have been you like the sound better right and I do

0:17:04and I think I fell on my face because I painted it like John was saying

0:17:07and like you're saying now I painted it as a universal statement

0:17:11when I really shouldn't have that it was factually better that it it was superior to C.D.'s

0:17:17and while I might prefer the experience

0:17:19and in the quirks of the sound I don't think that I should have gone as bold as I did

0:17:25and as one of the feedback things actually couple people did us like for that if if we could just take that sound that

0:17:31you love and recorded on to see the

0:17:33and play it back to you in a way that you didn't know whether we were playing back the vinyl

0:17:37or not you you would not be able to tell like we would be exactly accurate if you're producing that vinyl sound that

0:17:43you love with every nuance to the help of you know what I mean like.

0:17:47And that that's gets to the heart of the matter and we're all for you liking whatever sound you like

0:17:52but like we're talking about when we talk about mediums

0:17:55and we just say the word vinyl you're not talking about his song or a sound you're talking about a medium and that's.

0:18:00And that's a different alphabet so many different ways to try to come at this trying to get people to understand what

0:18:04is keep going back to whichever side they're on where they're like No way and then vinyls awesome

0:18:08or like vinyl is always evil like people just don't want to define the boundaries of what it is that they're saying

0:18:15and it's impossible to come to any sort of agreement or disagreement if

0:18:18but if no one is defining the boundaries of what they're saying a lot of like the special between frankly you can't

0:18:23blame it's hard to talk about this in a single tweet fell victim to that both you know on all sides of the debate are

0:18:29the best ones where they say I like tweets on any topic of us I I agree with Casey about this I agree with Mark about

0:18:36this I disagree with John about this

0:18:37and they will ascribe to all three of us opinions that like that fifty percent time we didn't take

0:18:43and I think you know I agree with Largo that that Starbucks coffee is great I agree with Casey that all cars should be

0:18:50black and I agree with John the pearls is terrible language you know that's a silly example

0:18:54but it's like you put our names in a tweet and you've expressed your own opinions

0:18:58but you have by implication the scribe the opposite opinions to us and I don't think we ever anyway.

0:19:04But if the excitement of feedback I agree with Mark getting of the feedback as I've said many times is very valuable.

0:19:10We're lucky to get a lot of it you too can get a lot of it as well if you just go to online communities

0:19:14and whatever topic you're interested in

0:19:16and just start you know I guess out of usenet in my past where it wasn't it wasn't a big audience as we have here

0:19:22but doesn't take you know only takes like four or five Mean people to put you in your place for a couple years

0:19:26and you know you'll get better.

0:19:28Yeah

0:19:28and again I don't I don't mean to complain necessarily about getting feedback I don't mean to complain about all of the

0:19:35Internet or my head thinking I'm wrong.

0:19:38That actually doesn't bother me what was frustrating was people who really didn't have to be blunt.

0:19:44Anything that constructive to add just coming out of the woodwork and saying you're wrong

0:19:49and you're wrong because I read something once that's just not helpful were something that Mark did which he said OK

0:19:55From personal experience let me take you through why you did. If you're wrong.

0:20:00That is infinitely valuable and extraordinarily valuable I'm very thankful for that.

0:20:05But the other people are expressing their enthusiasm like even if they're there they're doing it in a way that makes

0:20:10you feel bad.

0:20:11They're there saying we listen to the show and B we are enthusiastic enough about it to seek you out on Twitter

0:20:17and send you something. So there are there is even good in that I think.

0:20:20Yeah I agree and that's why even on the e-mails that I want to reach to the computer and back

0:20:24and whoever wrote even on those e-mails I try always to force myself to do an e-mail in such a way that

0:20:32when I write thank you for listening

0:20:34and thanks for your feedback that it's taken is genuine because I do mean it genuinely even if I want to freaking kill

0:20:40whoever I just replied to.

0:20:43So I don't know maybe this is too inside baseball this might be boring maybe we'll cut it I don't know

0:20:47but it's just the point I was trying to get to was that it made me look at myself with a bit of a critical eye which

0:20:56again is even more reason why even the feedback that I'm moaning is actually valuable in its own way

0:21:03and to point out also I actually.

0:21:06So I've been in this high end audio world for a lot recently

0:21:10and I've found that like so the reason why I don't like vinyl

0:21:16and a lot of analysts is all the same reason why I had a chance to to have a tube amp in my house for a couple of weeks

0:21:23to try out and I didn't like it and ended up not buying one. The reason why people like vinyl sound.

0:21:32Not everyone

0:21:32but the reason why the people who do like it like it in addition to all the things you talked about last week about the

0:21:37tea ceremony and the romanticism of it and how hip and awesome it looks and everything a slow an artisanal a manual.

0:21:45In addition to all that crap it does sound different and it sounds different in various ways that people find pleasing.

0:21:56Now as. But you know that wasn't the argument the drums making against.

0:22:00You however that was what most people thought when you know what for they are going about vinyl siding better than CD

0:22:06or whatever.

0:22:08You know in my own purchases and what I found in my experiences with high end audio stuff what I like is neutrality

0:22:18and in most cases.

0:22:20So for instance I don't use a tube amp because I use sensitive headphones

0:22:24and sensitive headphones you can very easily pick up the noise introduced by two bands.

0:22:29You can also occasionally get like a little pop if a piece of dust hits the wrong way

0:22:33or something like that like it's just not it is it's it's almost like like records you know.

0:22:39It's almost like vinyl it's not.

0:22:41You're introducing distortion you're introducing noise so I try to get very very nice digital stuff so everything is

0:22:48solid state there's there's you know no moving parts with a volume knob.

0:22:52There is as little noise introduced as possible

0:22:57and there is a little you know total imbalance introduced as possible and I actually took a little too far.

0:23:05So my my current set up is I have a sunrise or H.D. Eight hundred headphones plugged into the shit.

0:23:12Asghar two that is actually its name and shit by frost DAC and it looks amazing.

0:23:21These things all look fancy and also they sound great.

0:23:26The main reason I like the shit amp and that is because they have like zero noise

0:23:30and I can hear anything that I have that's not because they're the shack and the name helps too

0:23:34and they look pretty awesome and they're they're small and they are reasonably priced

0:23:39and I like to be the super neutral now. The Sennheiser H.D.

0:23:42Eight hundred headphones the best I can say about them is that they are the most neutral headphones ever heard.

0:23:48The downside of this is that they actually sound a little bit boring on certain things like certain types of music.

0:23:56I actually like the distortion by things like amp.

0:24:00Following the high end that you hear and some biodynamic models or

0:24:05or the more the bigger base I have on my clothes headphones the one hundred

0:24:09and certain things I like that distortion now throughout through up all my research

0:24:14and findings haven't actually I tried a few other models I ended up returning or selling in the meantime

0:24:18and I found people's opinions vary dramatically on what they considered sounding good.

0:24:25So one of the most popular lines of Sennheiser H.D. Six hundred six fifty.

0:24:29Those actually have pretty muted high end and I didn't like that sound a lot of people loved it

0:24:37and similarly certain people don't like the biodynamic super strong high end and I like it

0:24:44and what I found is that you know keeping everything neutral up until the point of the actual headphones.

0:24:50Well I mean that choice gives me flexibility like you can simulate all the other so you can simulate vinyl with digital

0:24:57plugins and equalizers and stuff.

0:24:59Please email Dan

0:25:01and you can simulate most of the most of the effects of what people like about these things electronically artificially

0:25:09if you want to just like Instagram.

0:25:11You know can you know can simulate the distortions of certain old processes or things that you know or like idealized

0:25:19or enhanced versions of old processes and old distortions that used to exist in the analog world

0:25:24and that produces more pleasing looking photos just to a lot of people.

0:25:27So it's important to recognize like you know I like I like everything to be digital and pure and clean

0:25:34and neutral up until the point where I have my headphones I can make that choice

0:25:37and say either I want to listen to something with a lot of bass with this pair of headphones

0:25:40or I want to listen to something that's neutral with this pair of headphones

0:25:43and I reckon that's a crazy set up however that's how I am and that's how I did it

0:25:46but you know none of that like the argument John was making last week is that C.D.'s are are better at being neutral

0:25:55they're better accurately and neutrally replicating the recording.

0:26:00And that's that is correct that is one hundred percent right and most people though

0:26:06when they're arguing about what sounds better or worse or what is better

0:26:09or worse they don't put it in those terms of personal preference or of like the difference between neutrality

0:26:16and pleasing sound because that's of those there's a very different things perfectly neutral sounds boring to a lot of

0:26:22people like when I ended our podcast with perfectly neutral. However my Listen to phish a little bit more bass.

0:26:29So

0:26:29when I listen to fish I put on the other headphones you know it's it's very important to distinguish those things personal

0:26:35preference or more pleasing versus accurate and neutral and I think you're right

0:26:41but I don't know this is probably getting a bit old now I want to talk about something that's cool I would love to.

0:26:47It's our friends at P.D.F. Penn once again this is P.D.F. Pen for i Pad P.-A pen for i Pad lets you edit P.D.F.

0:26:55Anywhere you are as long as you have an i Pad with you that happens to be running P.D.F.

0:26:58Pen However anywhere you are with one of those things you can edit P.D.F.

0:27:02You can sign contracts you can fix a typo you can actually edit the P.D.F.

0:27:06Right there on your device you can correct a price list you can fill out a form while you're on the go

0:27:12and you can take P.D.F.

0:27:13Document with you anytime add notes highlighting add mark up during your mobile down time you can sync P.D.'s with

0:27:20P.D.F. Pen for O S ten using i Cloud or Dropbox is P.D.F. and Is for a left hand and you can grab an SES P.D.F.

0:27:28Using Dropbox Evernote Google Drive box.

0:27:31I guess it isn't called Boston anymore that right they dropped the dot net now it's a box.

0:27:36Anyway you can say P.D.'s to that or from that even web and F.T.P. Servers and anywhere you are with P.D.F.

0:27:44Ten for i Pad You have the complete feature rich mobile editing power of P.D.F.

0:27:48and It's available in the App Store now a lot of talk

0:27:53but there's a lot of apps these days haven't even Iowa seven yet they're not native you know the kind of ignored P.D.F.

0:27:59Pen is. It is always updated.

0:28:01It is native to Iowa seven

0:28:03and there's tons of they're always making tons of improvements performance improvements everything else they're

0:28:09fantastic and it seems like your stuff once again.

0:28:13They even support a few of the pressure sensitive pens on the market.

0:28:17The most popular ones they support the jock touch the Pogo connect and the Jaja

0:28:22or Haha I'm not sure which one is that is but it's J.J.

0:28:25That one which is either Joshua or ha ha or maybe John or Hodge who knows but they support that one. So check out P.D.F.

0:28:33Pen for i Pad going to smile Software dot com slash A.T.P. That is smile Software dot com slash A.T.P.

0:28:41Thanks a lot to P.D.F. Pen for i Pad for sponsoring our show once again. I'll tell you I I use P.D.F.

0:28:47Penitence has I use it more in the math on the i Pad Just so that's where I am most of the time

0:28:51but it's boy it's an amazing piece of software and it saves my butt pretty frequently. So thanks a lot to P.D.F.

0:28:57and For i Pad once again we didn't get a chance to talk about last week because we were too busy arguing didn't get a

0:29:05chance to talk about this trial with Samsung between Samsung and Apple

0:29:10and there's been some interesting things coming out of this

0:29:13and we've gotten to look at some of the behind the scenes at how Apple does stuff how they get their jobs done as a

0:29:23result of a lot of the discovery during the trial so I know John you have any thoughts on this.

0:29:29Yeah I picked out I'm taking on not so much of the tales of the trial

0:29:32or whatever because there's no one how to do it patents through and pay attention but you know I think about patents

0:29:37or whatever but yeah because as part of the discovery process

0:29:41or some other legal term that I don't know really internal documents from Apple

0:29:47and it's great because Apple is what's great for us and I know it's great for Apple.

0:29:51That's all the discussion but we get so little insight into what goes on in Apple.

0:29:56We just see their public face and their public face is so incredibly controlled.

0:30:00And I think it's even more control now than it used to be said many times before and the good old days with Steve Jobs.

0:30:06Yes Apple's message was controlled but Steve Jobs had the ability and often took it to just go off book

0:30:13and do have the hell he wants and say whatever the hell you want

0:30:15and whatever way you want that I'm sure he was you know controlling Calvin as well

0:30:19but you never quite knew what he was going to say.

0:30:20Tim Cook you're not going to make him slip up and say something you're not going to get something exciting

0:30:25and so far it seems like he is very on message and very controlled strategic leaking things

0:30:31and saying this sort of way in choosing his words very carefully.

0:30:34But the Steve Jobs felt like it was a chance he might you know either act like he's just suddenly caught up in the

0:30:40moment and saying something spontaneous or actually do that.

0:30:44But anyway these documents are internal Apple documents

0:30:47and from the outside a lot of people to Apple's arrogant Apple's out of touch they don't know they use really want to

0:30:52whatever

0:30:53but these internal documents make it very very clear that that is not the case that that is merely their external face

0:30:58that they control so well but internally this is the fiscal year twenty fourteen planning offsite slide deck

0:31:05and you can see some of the slides.

0:31:07If you haven't seen them overdoing the Seante to check them out

0:31:09but I'll I'll read off on the sizes of the first slide it says they're talking about i Phone sales

0:31:15and it says growth rates are slowing and they show a graph that shows growth rates going down down down down down.

0:31:20Apple of course would never show a slide like this in public.

0:31:24Why are they going to you know that puts them in a bad light

0:31:29and again something as simple as this showing growth rates long yes you'll see stories about Apple about that

0:31:34and if someone actually gets in touch with Apple Masson by that they'll say some you know blah blah blah kind of well

0:31:40we think we were you know on the right track in mobile or work you know they'll say some stupid P.R.

0:31:44Thing but here they are saying when they're talking to themselves like here's the graph growth rate is really slowing.

0:31:49Next lie they say So what's going on

0:31:51and they have a little section here is as strong as the man is coming from less expensive

0:31:55and larger screen smart phones carriers have strong interest in capping.

0:32:00I Phone due to one or more factors high share the subsidy premium unfriendly policy unfairly using

0:32:05and quote lack of alignment so they're basically saying cut customers want cheap fronts a bigger screens.

0:32:10Carriers carries don't like us that much

0:32:12and they don't like us we're going to reasons because we are more demanding of them because we in these unfriendly

0:32:16policies that we have are subsidies really high a lack of alignment with you know our interests are aligned with the

0:32:23carriers you know that they're really laying out the carriers don't like us that much

0:32:28and competitors nature little Android competitors have drastically improved their hardware and software software

0:32:33and their ecosystems and the spending obscene also in scare quotes amounts of money on advertising

0:32:39and carrier channel to gain traction which is a Samsung things laying out like here here her problems we're going to

0:32:45get there but it could mean there is you know people want and this is a tile the site is great.

0:32:50Next what consumers want what we don't have getting right now is Apple saying that in public what we don't have

0:32:57and so they show like the market share growth they said where did the growth come from

0:33:03and this I know I wish there was a better breakdown of maybe there was the same way to the growth in the industry come

0:33:08from shows the growth in IT SAYS I don't can't do the percentages here

0:33:13but more than half the growth came from phones there are less than three hundred dollars

0:33:17and the rest of the growth came from screens that are more than three hundred dollars

0:33:21but have screens that are bigger than four inches.

0:33:23The real objection I have to this graph is OK great you identified that that the majority of the growth is coming from

0:33:29phones that are less than three hundred dollars.

0:33:31I think break that down more because if you take that piece

0:33:36and say OK well out of that growth actually ninety nine percent of that growth is coming from phones there are less

0:33:41than five dollars that is way different than saying OK well most of this coming from how much less than three hundred

0:33:46dollars break it down is it as if you know what the average house what the distribution in there without knowing that

0:33:52you don't know what to do.

0:33:53But anyway this is the high level slide so I take him they have broken it down in turn

0:33:57and I just again I would like to see that broken down.

0:34:00Didn't And all this reminded me of a book I'm reading now which I recommend everybody will point in the show notes.

0:34:06It's a cat most book called creativity Inc It's not really a memoir manifesto it's more just an exploration of the

0:34:15early history of Pixar and what Catmull and the rest of the company has done to to make that organization function

0:34:22and be successful.

0:34:23And a big focus on the book is being clear eyed about your own problems and candid about them internally

0:34:31and I don't think so it's not Apple I don't know if the jobs didn't have nearly as much involvement in Pixar as it is

0:34:36an apple.

0:34:37But I can't help

0:34:38but see parallels between you know the things that are in this book in the approach Apple is taking here.

0:34:45Apple is very clear eyed in the slides they are not sugar coating it better not like Rob Rob like yeah we may have

0:34:51problems that we still have the best known is in his office the slides are just you know there's not a lot of them

0:34:56but they're essentially unrelentingly negative towards Apple and you know that's how they have to be that's

0:35:01and that's how Apple improves so I felt better about seeing these lives

0:35:05and it made me think that at least some of the culture

0:35:08and strategies described in that excellent book way Catmull are alive and well Apple's Well yeah I think it is.

0:35:17It's fantastic to see that Apple knows its own problems it knows its own shortcomings

0:35:23but I think that's not really that much news necessarily.

0:35:29To me seeing all these like I see all these trial documents and like the e-mail of Phil Schiller

0:35:33and everything it really just says to me that this company is you know by being as private as they usually are they are

0:35:42saving us from the boredom. And there can be the relative routine in this that's actually in their company.

0:35:50This is these are like the only big surprise here is these people are actually acting somewhat human

0:35:56but they're all you know they're saying not that surprising things.

0:36:00There something boring business emails for their advertising agency that doesn't even capitalize anything which is

0:36:04apparently a thing

0:36:06or help out with that with all other things like that that fell short like this article was supposed to be sensational

0:36:10or whatever

0:36:11and so one of the things they show over the email where Phil show is being angry too is that initially what I took away

0:36:16from that exchange was how incredibly low the bar is

0:36:20and see like it's like this is your I didn't see you you're the biggest country in the world

0:36:26and these jokers are doing your ads. Boy that's just the pressing I got.

0:36:31Not everything can be up to the standard of Avalon Pixar I guess

0:36:34and that's just yeah yeah I mean what I what I really just found that these with these documents is like wow this is

0:36:41all really boring stuff that I like like because very little of newsworthiness here except that you know Apple usually

0:36:50does a really good job of keeping what comes out.

0:36:54Interesting you know keeping their public image interesting and secretive and and well edited

0:37:01and you see you see now on the inside that yeah it's it's a big company dealing with big company problems

0:37:06and doing things the big companies do.

0:37:09And my not seeing the novelty of it I compare it to I mean I work for a lot different companies

0:37:14but the one people may have heard of that for for a time I work for Palm

0:37:17and I didn't I wasn't very close to the leadership of the organization but internal to the company

0:37:22when I worked for Palm I got presentations from you know some of the big leagues came to visit us because we're in a

0:37:27different location and gave us a presentation on the state of Palm and what their plans were for the business

0:37:32and their slides were not candid and didn't accurately identify the problem they're facing.

0:37:36They were much more kind of like we're actually still doing pretty good in the P.T.A.

0:37:41Space and the phones are coming on but we've got these trio things

0:37:44and like it was like even to me inside the company I'm like you guys are in denial of these That's why we're showing

0:37:49this internally.

0:37:50We're showing these lies to ourselves internally we're not being honest with ourselves about the state I mean you would

0:37:56hope that they would you know we saw it and we felt that maybe they held it.

0:38:00Just didn't feel as honest and straight forward and like if you if you don't think these Apple slides are novel

0:38:05or interesting like I don't have that much experience in big tech companies but I have seen it from big and small.

0:38:11Most companies are not this candid about themselves

0:38:14and are not are not this accurate like you know are not able to exactly pinpoint where their weak points are

0:38:20and nail them in that way and I guess that shows you know competence internally and skill

0:38:25and if they weren't that skill they wouldn't be where they are today so I think there is something to it it's not we

0:38:29can just accept that every company does this because I think many of them don't.

0:38:34The other thing that we didn't talk about last week which we could have is some guy that apparently I was supposed to

0:38:40know but didn't know.

0:38:42He's leaving Apple and that guy is Greg Christie

0:38:45and did either of you two heard of him before I'm assuming John that you had but

0:38:49but Marco Have you heard of this gentleman before last week. No I still don't even believe this is really a story.

0:38:56Well there was there were stories about him.

0:38:58He was featured in recent stories before the he was leaving Apple story so even if you weren't aware of him before that

0:39:03you want to send Duncan a name before it's like yes like two weeks ago.

0:39:07You did see that name when it was I think someone did a story about the early days of the i Phone and he was heavily.

0:39:11Yeah.

0:39:13So that's why you might be aware from the other's looks a lot like kind of a gossip story like people arguing inside

0:39:18Apple and then one of them leaves I mean that happens all the time in every company

0:39:22and then you know from some people have we don't know what's really going on here

0:39:28but there's at least one reasonable design denial from this map

0:39:31and you know the details of this big breakup are not as dramatic as they seem

0:39:35but the reason I think it's interesting is forget about how we left our wire after whatever. Like who cares right.

0:39:43The what it highlights what all the stories highlighted is it's time for them to talk about kind of oh Johnny Ives

0:39:51organization because he is in charge of much more than he used to be in charge of anything that happens in that

0:39:56organization people coming people going or whatever. With him remaining the top.

0:40:01In some ways like not that it reflects on him

0:40:04but it makes us focus on him so what the story's made me do is think more about how Johnny I was doing in this position.

0:40:11And yes part of his vision is retention or whatever but not so much in this particular thing

0:40:15but what got me thinking about was what what our Johnny Ives weaknesses in his new role as a software designer I've had

0:40:23you know decades to think about was weaknesses are in hardware design

0:40:26and previously was unknown what is be like in software

0:40:29but his organization I guess you know i OS seven is the first big product of his software organization

0:40:35and we've all had a long time to live with it and I think his weakness is a software designer are more glaring

0:40:43and obvious than they are Harbor may be and in fact they're very similar

0:40:47and so any time anything happens within the organization it makes me sort of like dwell more on how he's doing in his

0:40:56new role as a software designer. And I think that's a useful avenue of thought for me.

0:41:03So you're not pleased with how things are going then with Johnny film.

0:41:07Well like when somebody leaves like that even if it's on good terms bedtimes

0:41:12or whatever like you have to think that it's not I've been sleeping right people under him are going to leave it there

0:41:18and you have to think like maybe there was someone who used to be more in charge than they are now right.

0:41:23He used it like he was largely responsible for a lot of the early I thought I knew why

0:41:28and surely his power to make changes in decisions has decreased now the Johny I have has come in above him

0:41:34and you know to me like that's the whole thing with Johnny Ive is given has been given much more power

0:41:39and that means the power of the people he used to have the power of had it taken away.

0:41:42And if there's any sort of disagreement about what to do John as you know when as he should because he's in charge

0:41:48and what that means is that whatever his strengths

0:41:51and weaknesses are are imprinted even more strongly on the organization because he is not just one voice anymore he is

0:41:56the voice either as I think it will do one point he's in the full.

0:42:00Sugar I'm your moto mode where Memoto designed in ten flagship games like Omarion Donkey Kong and many other things

0:42:07and slowly climbed the ranks of the organization until essentially he was the buck stop with him for all issues related

0:42:14to software design and all of Nintendo and possibly several aspects of hardware design as well.

0:42:19Like once you are in that position of power whatever your strengths

0:42:23or weaknesses are are magnified I mean it was true with Steve Jobs his strengths

0:42:27and weaknesses were magnified through the whole organization

0:42:29and so now I that's why I'm going on what I was like a software designer because these other voices weren't whether you

0:42:34agree with them or not Scott across all Greg Christie all the other people their voices

0:42:39and their ability to you know affect change within the organization are necessarily modified by the larger

0:42:45and larger footprint of this one fallible individual. For better or for worse and so that's what I've got mine.

0:42:52Yeah that's interesting I mean I you know the problem is I I think you're right that that is something to watch

0:42:59but I think everything we've ever been we've heard about this about great Christie's particular departure makes it

0:43:05sound like maybe you know maybe the problem had nothing to do with Johnny Ive And you know like we see like the the

0:43:13crazy rumor site saying you know there was some kind of friction there

0:43:16and then you see people like John Gruber who have generally better sources on these kind of things saying oh this is

0:43:23actually you know in the works for months and he didn't even it wasn't even recent

0:43:27and there was no bad blood he just was retiring and as the story gets older we're hearing more that it's not a story.

0:43:38Then the very minute that it broke in the news that said it was a story.

0:43:42So that's probably the reality it probably isn't a story itself now.

0:43:45Again you're right that this I mean you know Johnnie I've having a lot more power than he used to

0:43:50and becoming so powerful that he's able to get bad decisions through that is something to watch.

0:43:58No question and I always say.

0:44:00Evan is a great example of some of those things you know I think Iowa seven really showed that.

0:44:07Johnny I was wanting to make a big a big change in a lot of very important stuff on I.I.S.

0:44:14and He did and he went a little too far in a lot of those changes.

0:44:17But even you know as we saw last summer even from Beta one to what was released at seven point zero There were a lot of

0:44:25changes to rein some of that back like that the biggest one being the super thin font was replaced with a more

0:44:30reasonably thick that missed one more reasonably waited.

0:44:35You know things like that if they were in the lock screen having modifications to make it easier to realize that you

0:44:41have to swipe right and not up things like that you know there were a lot of.

0:44:47Or is it left out of the way there were a lot of changes made.

0:44:50You know he went too far and he dialed back

0:44:53and I think I was seven is great I think the design of it is great it is not perfect but it is great

0:45:00and it is a massive improvement over six so and this is going to you know what we want from I was and I guess

0:45:06but I don't know if we even have that as a topic.

0:45:10But I think this is going to watch for you know watch for Johnny Ive getting enough power that he can get bad decisions

0:45:16pushed through. And for him to think that these decisions are good you know those things are a problem together.

0:45:24But other than that I don't really think this is much of a story like on this bigger story doesn't like I was going at

0:45:29it doesn't matter how

0:45:30or why Christie left it only matters that he was somebody who was there for a long time who was responsible for a lot

0:45:38of like it was senior person. Right.

0:45:40He wasn't just some other president he was another voice whether he agreed with Johnny Ive

0:45:44or not at any point if if you were like the last the last the you know Godzilla standing like all the other big guys

0:45:51have left all the other people who were there from the beginning who strongly influenced the original i Phone You know

0:45:56I mean like that's what I say about like.

0:46:00Your army a mode of life you need to have those voices that you that you will listen to because you believe like that

0:46:05they are valuable and have experience

0:46:07and even if you just left because you just like retiring right that's that's a loss.

0:46:11That's that somebody that you don't have any organization with a wealth of experience for you to bounce your ideas off

0:46:16of and you know I mean like I go back to be accountable to them

0:46:19but they have a whole chapter on the brain trust which I will put a link to this because I think that an excerpt on

0:46:24some website somewhere where they will get the people the sort of the oldest and wisest people together in a room

0:46:31and have them all tell each other what's wrong with their with their projects.

0:46:35Just about ideas are to be will respect each other and they all have a lot of experience

0:46:39and any time a senior person leaves in you know in the similar role like the senior software designer for Iowa in the

0:46:48past that is a loss for the company and that's why I like it doesn't matter who cares why he left.

0:46:54He's not there anymore and that will only serve to magnify the good

0:46:59and the bad about I've And I would rather see him surrounded by say more senior people that he respected too.

0:47:08You know that's a temper his output

0:47:10but perhaps even to enhance the parts that are good about it I have to disagree with him maybe they should more

0:47:14vehemently agree with him in certain areas where he's touting himself like that dynamic is what I what I think is lost

0:47:19when you see your people leave you know the other thing that I'm a little concerned about just based completely on

0:47:27theory is Johnny getting spread a little thin and I would hope that he has his trusted minion slash you know Cers

0:47:37or whatever to to take a lot of the day to day off of his plate.

0:47:43But based on no facts and just a bunch of assumptions it seems to me that Johnny is a fairly hands on guy

0:47:51and if he's a hands on guy and then presumably already had a full plate with hardware alone I just can't imagine.

0:47:58And now adding all of us.

0:48:00Where on to that already overflowing plate

0:48:03and still being able to be good at your job go to not only your existing job of hardware

0:48:09but also good at this new job of software which really in the strictest sense he doesn't have any real experience

0:48:16or education in so that kind of concerns me a bit that he'll be spread too thin over over the next few years.

0:48:23Well that's I think that distinction if you were to ask Johnny I'm going to play Jai I've now because I wrote a book

0:48:28about him once we had on the part of guess what he would say is this distinction between hardware

0:48:34and software is an artificial one that has no bearing on the experience of using the product it's all one part of the

0:48:39same product and it makes perfect sense for them to be under the same umbrella because that that separation

0:48:45and that sort of arguing between them I guess there is a tension technically

0:48:48but that doesn't matter to the end product that has to be one thing.

0:48:51I think it's perfectly valid to have that that approach the holistic approach of the product Apple has always had it is

0:48:58just a now it's literally embodied within one person.

0:49:00Yes is a danger of that and that maybe there was healthy tension between hardware and software

0:49:03but I don't worry about him being spread too thin because I think he is fulfilling sort of the Steve Jobs type role of

0:49:10set the direction be tastemaker give thumbs up thumbs down he's not in there draw new eyes in

0:49:16and you know one of the time or whatever.

0:49:18Well you know I mean he's got a staff of the people who do that but in the end the buck stops with him

0:49:23and if he really wanted to be a super skinny font on a white background that's what it's going to be

0:49:27and like Margo said it's not you know if you have to dial a back line in many ways it's better to go to go to big

0:49:34and then scale it back then to be too timid you know I mean so I'm not giving in like a bad grade

0:49:39or anything I'm just I'm just watching it because I would rather see ideas have to fight for their life as hard as

0:49:47possible and find out all

0:49:48and only the best ones make it out then to sort of slide towards a situation where there is not enough.

0:49:55There's not there's not enough people with skills even close to Johnny I have for him too.

0:50:00Do good work in the software ie like an harbour. I don't know what's going on back there we don't know those people.

0:50:04Well I think he has trusted team that doesn't have a lot of turnover

0:50:07but the software is often lost Scott forestall went through what we think actually was a disagreement

0:50:13and great Christy is now gone like I would I would be happier both those people were still there

0:50:19and working in concert with Johnny Ah but you know what I do.

0:50:22Well you know maybe the harder stuff will be a lot less work now because that you can just look at like what H.P.

0:50:27and Samsung are making into just disciplines like that right. I think if the opposite doesn't work either way.

0:50:33You know the other thing that I should point out and I am not through listening to it yet but on Guy Englishes

0:50:40and Rene Ritchie is really great pod cast debug on Episode thirty three will put a link to that in the show notes they

0:50:47had Ken Ferrie on who did apparently was kind of the primary guy behind on a layout

0:50:52and I'm only about two thirds of the way through the episode but it's really really good.

0:50:56And one of the things that Ken talks about is kind of what it's like to get an idea through Apple.

0:51:04You know so he I don't I didn't hear the all the lay out specific part yet

0:51:08but just for the sake of argument you know I go in there.

0:51:12I come up with the idea for auto layout and apparently he basically only has to convince his immediate supervisor.

0:51:21Or at least that's what I gleaned from it

0:51:23and I just thought that was really really interesting that it's not very bureaucratic It's not that you have to

0:51:28convince three thousand people all the way up the chain and I'm sure that that's that is the case sometimes

0:51:34but generally for for some things you can just convince one man or woman

0:51:40and that's all it takes I just thought that was fascinating.

0:51:43We're also sponsored this week once again by a new relatively new relatives

0:51:47and on one web application performance management tool is an acronym for that and it's A.P.M.

0:51:54Numeral it lets you see performance from the end user experience through servers down to each line of your server side.

0:52:00Code new road assets take a minute

0:52:02and say a big Thank You to all the dinners out there building all this great stuff that we all know and love.

0:52:08They would like to send a shout out to developers software geeks code jockeys to the brave few who see things

0:52:13differently.

0:52:14Here's to working nights to wear an oversized concentration on Hansing headphones upon your furrowed brow as new relic

0:52:20thanks to the entire internet thanks you.

0:52:23Nowadays if you're in any business you're in the software business software powers

0:52:27or apps runs our databases manages our accounts and runs e-commerce sites and email programs.

0:52:32When software breaks everyone loses new relic helps improve your software performance so your users have a better

0:52:38experience and your business is more successful. How's that for a win win.

0:52:43New relic monitors every move your application makes across the entire stack.

0:52:47It can show you what's happening right now in your app you can zero in on problems quickly with transaction tracing

0:52:53S.Q.L. and No S.Q.L.

0:52:55Performance analytics application topology mapping and employment history markers

0:52:59and comparisons go to new relics dot com a slash A.T.P. and You can sign up for a free thirty day trial.

0:53:07Then you all do it deploy their agent on your server it natively supports Ruby P.H.P.

0:53:12Java dot net Python and even no J.S.

0:53:15It will start collecting data immediately

0:53:17and you can quickly see inside your app to start finding hot spots fixing issues and optimizing performance.

0:53:23Once again go to new relic dot com slash A.T.P.

0:53:26To start monitoring your performance today and fighting all your issues and fixing them all new Really dot com flash.

0:53:32A.T.P. Thanks a lot. So one quick remaining thought on the Christie thing which I came up with.

0:53:39We said Christie had been there since the beginning.

0:53:43But let's suppose hypothetically that he was pretty well lined

0:53:47or pretty chummy with forestall then wouldn't it make sense for him to either choose to leave or be asked to leave.

0:53:58And and.

0:54:00Those quiet rumblings I've heard are that that's exactly the case that he was kind of an forestalls camp

0:54:10and maybe the person who is replacing him is someone who likes to argue a little bit more.

0:54:16If that's the case I'd consider that a wonderful thing.

0:54:19I think it's very smart of people who are in a position of power to have someone around them that argues because it

0:54:27forces you to really be really vehemently believe in your own opinion

0:54:33or change it if the case maybe the best example of that from the Steve Jobs history is the you know being adamant that

0:54:40i Tunes was it wasn't it was the i Pod should be available for one night in storage and give over windows

0:54:46when you're going to help me out is not remembering that anyway.

0:54:49Yeah I'd consider Windows a chat room set so I'll trust them

0:54:52but anyway whatever it was it's something that eventually came to pass and was enormously positive thing

0:54:57and Steve Jobs was dead set against it

0:54:59and it was just all of his most trusted the tenets were constantly on him arguments they could not give it up like

0:55:05we've got to do I don't know I'm never going to do it in any event they warm down it like fine do friggin i Tunes

0:55:11or windows whatever you want like that sounds like an unhealthy dynamic

0:55:14but I think that is that is actually a company I mean it's not it's not the healthiest It could be better if again it

0:55:22was something more like the Pixar brain trust.

0:55:25But in many ways it was similar because like the brain trust thing it's a bunch of senior people.

0:55:32You know I'll tell you what's wrong with you thing. But none of them have the power to tell you what you have to do.

0:55:37Like they can make you change your movie in the case of the very latest tell you like we think this is wrong that's

0:55:41wrong maybe just Lucian's but they have no authority to make you do any particular changes

0:55:46and in the case of Steve Jobs it was and it didn't have the authority to make him put i Tunes on Windows

0:55:51but because he respected their opinions

0:55:53and because they were so insistent on eventually you know he went against his own better judgment

0:55:58and said you know what am I even paying these people.

0:56:00For if not to advise me and they are so strong

0:56:02and unanimous in their in their you know insistence of this is a good idea.

0:56:07He was kind of a baby about it that find whatever stupid thing on Windows if accounts are to be believed

0:56:13and that that might sound like him but in the end you know this is the worked.

0:56:17Yeah and that's exactly my point and so I mean whether

0:56:21or not Christie was forced out depending on who is replacing him it could be a really wonderful thing.

0:56:27So was like All right so we have a few other things that we can talk about

0:56:33and something that we've had on the show notes for a while that I don't think I completely understand yet

0:56:39and I'd love to hear Jon you explain it to me is what is this P selfing all about good you know I get to explain other

0:56:46thing that I don't know the details of but I do think I know enough.

0:56:49I do know enough I think to do explain that you know the broad strokes in the broad strokes are actually interesting.

0:56:56So P.

0:56:57Sellers from the parliament is the same I think inventor of one of one of the original inventors of quick time he also

0:57:03did the On Live for mode gaming service and is another one of his babies

0:57:07and he has a little bit of reputation as kind of a genius crackpot sort of like Stephen Wolfram undeniably incredibly

0:57:14smart and doing amazing things

0:57:15but also prone to like presenting his creations as the best thing since sliced bread in kind of magic

0:57:22and that's a difficult piece L.

0:57:24As I think of the original name for a cause

0:57:26but it's been rebranded to be so it's presented in a way that doesn't that doesn't explain how it works unless you

0:57:33already know the Orcs

0:57:35and so it seems like magic it's like you have all these problems with cell phone reception because there are so many

0:57:41people with cell phones and so many towers

0:57:43and so much interference this week signals a strong field you can have the cell towers too close to like he's basically

0:57:47describing what we all know about current So for reserve he's like one of that could all go away

0:57:52and you wouldn't have any problem in every single cell phone user would have the full bandwidth of the entire tower.

0:57:57And like possible are you talking about.

0:58:00It sounds like a parental motion machine

0:58:02and you're trying to dismiss him out of hand unless you already know what it is in which case you think oh I know what

0:58:08that is and then it becomes boring

0:58:10and those are the two extremes like this sounds like magic I'm going to be like the only person on earth that's like as

0:58:15if I have a whole cell tower to myself and then you find that really works if you haven't

0:58:19and if you are in this field it's not anything novel or or amazing

0:58:23or new with certain aspects of it that are that are interesting from an engineering perspective

0:58:28and you're like oh it's that OK well now now I think I'm less excited about now that was my experience as well.

0:58:34So here's what it is what do you see in the demonstrations were you talking about as having cell towers

0:58:41and you can't put them too close together because they make indifference to each other

0:58:43and of course every single cell phone is trying to communicate with self our cell tower is interfering with the other

0:58:48cell phones that are communicating with a cell tower in as many different strategies that we use to allow multiple cell

0:58:54phones to talk to the tower and you don't need to know the details of all of them

0:58:57but like you know like you know let us all take turns.

0:59:03There's different ways of multiplexing our signals with frequency division where we charge up into different channels

0:59:09on different frequencies our code division multiplexing where we send the signal that each thing can decode to figure

0:59:14out which part of the signal is relevant to it.

0:59:17But it all has to do with just a big shared space and all those techniques interferences badly screws up the signal.

0:59:22Each thing is sending out a receiving one piece Ellis trying to do is make it so that all the cell towers are aware of

0:59:33where all the cell phones are and they're where what signal is being put out by all the phones

0:59:38and all the other towers

0:59:40and they do a whole bunch of really complicated math to figure out OK We know what we want to send everybody here we're

0:59:46going to output something such that our interference overlaps with each other in such a way that it sort of forms the

0:59:54hotspot right in the target area where all the combination of the interference from all the signals we're putting out.

1:00:00I'm up to exactly what we want to send to that phone

1:00:02and then all the interference from all the sales we're putting out something that's missing in our approach to the

1:00:06other phone that's why it's like you get all you get all the bandwidth because it's a bunch of things working in

1:00:11concert to figure out exactly what they need to send out so that the sum of all their crazy interference exactly equals

1:00:17this the exact clean signal they want to send to that particular phone I'm massively simplifying it obviously

1:00:23but this is this is sort of the upshot of how it works

1:00:26and the innovative thing they have is like well how do you do that how can you have all the cell towers figuring out

1:00:32exactly what they need to put out sort of in real time you know all the signals that are being sent

1:00:37and received to figure out what they have to put out to make the interference overlap to hit every single little cell

1:00:41phone that sounds crazy how could you do that well that's part of the engineering breakthrough in that they claim to

1:00:45have a way to do that with like fiber optic cables or whatever running through his cell towers

1:00:50or slower links if you're willing to allow for a little more slop in the system

1:00:54and to be able to have a computing in each one of those locations that scales linearly which is a topic on top of the

1:01:02negatives on scaling the scale linearly.

1:01:05So it's like well OK so it's easy to do for two receivers

1:01:07but is it ten times as much before it is like how does it scale cycle we have a way if you want to handle fifty people

1:01:14on a tower then you need one computer if you want to have one hundred people you need two computers you know two

1:01:19hundred eighty four computers.

1:01:20Like it's scale linearly with the number of people

1:01:23and that is an interesting engineering breakthrough assuming it works as advertised.

1:01:27But there are limitations

1:01:28and certain First of all you do have to have all the time I was talking to a significant without doubt

1:01:32but you do need fast connections between the towers

1:01:36and if you make slower connection in Towers what you're giving up is essentially how fast the receivers can move.

1:01:43So for example if you were in a car

1:01:46and that car goes over something like seventy miles an hour by the time all the cell towers figure out how to

1:01:51constructively overlay all their crazy overlapping signals to hit where you are you've moved too far

1:01:56and it won't work as well so there are speed limitations of this which are not you know there is.

1:02:00He limitations that you moving around a cookie affects everything but affects the system more than others.

1:02:05So you know if you're in any sort of car trying to you know use your nav system whatever and this is the Most News.

1:02:09If you're going over seventy maybe you wouldn't be able to keep up with you if you only had microwave links between the

1:02:14towers and everything but the idea and even I think Apple's routers

1:02:19and you know regular just walk around to the so called being forming or whatever the idea is an interesting one

1:02:24and it's great when an idea that was you know worked in labs for years

1:02:28and years suddenly becomes feasible in the real world do you know engineering expertise which is essentially what

1:02:33they're trying to bring as a company to this

1:02:36and the theoretical benefits are there in that if you could get a system like this you can make a much more effective

1:02:41use of bandwidth and you can put cell you know small cell tower type meters receivers everywhere

1:02:48and don't worry about how they overlap because it'll be just fine that would you know that would make they would make

1:02:54for the ability to support more users in a congested you know urban environment

1:03:00and the other trick we have from engineering perspective is they didn't want to change all our phones so they found a

1:03:04way using the existing features of like L.T.E. Four G.

1:03:07That are in the existing protocol so such that an unmodified plain old i Phone five S.

1:03:12or Any other plain old cell phone can participate in this like they don't need to have a special chip in the phones

1:03:17or special computing in the phones or whatever

1:03:19and that again is another engineering type of breakthrough where yeah this was fine in theory

1:03:23but you can just go replace all the cell phones in the world these magic ones that work like what we found a way to get

1:03:27this to work using existing protocols with existing unmodified phones with all the smarts on the other end.

1:03:32So I think it is an interesting engineering achievement assuming it works as advertised.

1:03:38He still faces go to market challenges in terms of getting this technology into all the cell towers

1:03:42and was going to be the first person to roll it out and how will it co-exist with other things

1:03:46but in the end it is not magic it's just science it's not particularly new science

1:03:51but the engineering is where the interesting parts are there was a really neat video that I watched that showed I

1:03:58believe it was a bunch of like. Laptops or tablets or whatever that work quipped with L.T.E.

1:04:03Radios and they'd shown probably get the details wrong but they had shown what happens when you move around

1:04:11and they turned off the thing where it senses where you are. So basically they concentrated this beam of L.T.E.

1:04:19In a specific spot

1:04:21and just for the purposes of the demonstration rather than allow that beam to move around with the device.

1:04:27If they kept it stationary

1:04:29and you could see as they moved just a couple of inches that the throughput would just plummet

1:04:36and then they would put the device backwards started and it would come back to like full each D.V.D.

1:04:41or Something like that and then

1:04:43when they had it working as it's designed which is to say you will follow the device as it moves.

1:04:48You would get this full H.D.

1:04:49Signal as the dudes like you know just moving these devices around in the room with a reasonable quickness not seventy

1:04:57miles an hour but a reason and it was fascinating to watch

1:05:00and really really impressive in some ways it's like engineering at its best because what engineers do very well as

1:05:08opposed to you know scientists like this there are you know two sides of the same color as the scientists will come up

1:05:13with something already theories or whatever

1:05:15but it's the job of the engineers to be able to figure out you know what that theory was useless to us ten years ago

1:05:22twenty years ago fifty years ago.

1:05:24But computing has advanced so much or technology or material science

1:05:27or whatever has a bit so much that crazy theory that no one ever paid attention to you know that you know if I Well

1:05:32that's not feasible obviously you can never do that starts to enter the realities ability

1:05:37and mirrors are rewarded by getting the jump on error

1:05:40and say you know what I think I can do that now I think I can do that crazy beamforming thing you know across huge

1:05:45urban areas to people traveling up to seventy miles an hour with a girl who's I think I can do that now likely to get

1:05:50there first right.

1:05:52I mean the mentally when technology comes along

1:05:53and it's like well now we have you know every More realize we have the computing to do you know an algorithm that

1:05:58wasn't feasible before compression.

1:06:00Technique that used to be too computationally expensive but now is trivial on phones right.

1:06:04Like and this is an example of that like he seems to be out ahead of people in terms of I think I can do that now

1:06:10and here is my proof and here's my implementation.

1:06:14And whether

1:06:14or not a fly is kind of like on my bike I think I can make people have video games where the video gaming machine is in

1:06:19a data center and there are miles and miles away. I think gaming can work like that.

1:06:24It did kind of work I have on live I've watched it I've played it it's not great

1:06:28but it's as a technology pro concept it's interesting

1:06:31but there are you know as an elf The engineer is only one small part of the battle of being successful in the market

1:06:37but as as non-magical as it might be I do like what he does because it kind of like Elon Musk he's he's figuring out

1:06:48what is feasible with current technology and getting there just slightly ahead of everyone else

1:06:52and that's that's great engineering.

1:06:54Yeah like I said it was really impressive to me whether

1:06:58or not it's just the combination of a bunch of things we've known how to do for a while it looked really cool.

1:07:06That's all Apple does too right.

1:07:07They take things you know we've had touch screens with a capacitor does screens that you know user interfaces of

1:07:12buttons like you know bring it all together figure out that actually we can make a phone like that now

1:07:16and do it just a little bit ahead of everyone else. There's a big reward if you get all the parts right. Exactly.

1:07:22We're also sponsored this week by a glue software igloo is an Internet.

1:07:27You'll actually like now most people think of internets as over the internets this is interim that's the old boring

1:07:34thing right.

1:07:35The old still terrible places that the corporate overlords make you go when you just want to use Dropbox

1:07:41or weren't present something easy that helps you get your work done that actually works.

1:07:44Igloo brings the ease of use

1:07:46and familiarity from consumer software into your corporate environment by using familiar apps like shared calendars

1:07:51Twitter like microblogging file sharing and more.

1:07:55Every piece of content in your a lieutenant be social with comments and like buttons and.

1:08:00Each team in your company can figure their own workspaces so that's if you're users but what if you're in charge of I.T.

1:08:06Well Lou handles the security hosting a management for you.

1:08:10Igloo is sock to type two compliant and they host data securely in stock to type one enterprise solidities in Canada.

1:08:18That's right Canada us everything is polite and C.D.R. Of cost too much on their own servers.

1:08:23It will offer two hundred fifty six bit as a cell and they are not vulnerable to heart bleed.

1:08:28They offer backup disaster recovery single tenant

1:08:30and shared environments integration with many authentication in sync systems including Sammul services and elder

1:08:36and more. It will even work with hip pocket client organizations.

1:08:41You can also customize everything inside your Italy with the ability to add C.S.S.

1:08:45and Javascript globally across one T.'s face

1:08:48or even on a single page you can see all this on the Web site which is actually built on their platform.

1:08:54Learn more in a glue software not com slash Casey over Software dot com slash K.C.

1:09:00Where they made a funny winning page about why Share Point sucks and how iglu is better.

1:09:05Thanks a lot once again to a Lou for sponsoring our show I wanted to ask about scaling servers because we've had this

1:09:11on the show in the show notes for a while. Yeah I love this.

1:09:15So on the topic list there's just a simple bullet point it just says scaling servers like you might as well had a

1:09:20bullet point said computers.

1:09:24I wrote it there

1:09:25and it was actually a reaction to a particular blog post that Brent Simmons put up very mention scaling and passing

1:09:32and it's not I don't get into a big thing about it is just like every every time I see this come up

1:09:36and we do it ourselves.

1:09:37People are sloppy with their analogy like it's so important to keep reminding yourself like you know definition of

1:09:44terms like what what we should be talking about

1:09:46when we talk about scaling as we use it as an umbrella term to talk about everything

1:09:49and I kind of alluded to it in the piece L.

1:09:51Thing with like my only point is like the old saw about the difference in performance

1:09:55and scaling so much of the time when I see people thinking they're blogging about scale.

1:10:00All their blogging about US performance which is fine interesting a topic of itself sending us scaling

1:10:05and so I just you know I put it in there as a reminder myself to throw it out So in brief performance how fast you can

1:10:11make something go if you've got a computer

1:10:13and you've got a test to be done I can do a task in five minutes I need to increase my performance now I can do the

1:10:18task in three seconds. You've increase your performance. Scaling is I've got one task to do and I've got one computer.

1:10:24What if I give you ten million of those tests to do.

1:10:27Can you do them in the same time if you just use ten million computers.

1:10:31That's scaling it doesn't matter how long it takes even takes your computer a year to solve the problem.

1:10:35If I give you two of those problems you say no problem or just buy another computer I can do both of them in a year.

1:10:40OK One of the three by three computers as a linear scaling by three computers I can do all three in a year

1:10:46but if I give you three million three million computers I can do all three million of those problems in a year it's not

1:10:51about performance scaling in performance although they so often seem related are not the same concept.

1:10:57The failure to focus on scaling when you talk about scaling and performance

1:11:01when talking about performance leads to all sorts of sadness.

1:11:04Oh yeah I mean scaling is is not how fast your system is

1:11:10but how easily you can make it take on more of something usually more traffic more users more data whatever the case

1:11:18may be.

1:11:20How easy is it to take on more and how many changes do you have to make to your software into it to its architecture.

1:11:26Two to add that capacity because you know it's with almost everything it is not nearly as simple as I'll just add more

1:11:33servers because you might have like all right well let's say you can add more web service pretty easily have to a point

1:11:39because web servers like you know you can distribute the calls to any of them with a little bounce

1:11:44or as long as you don't use like weird shared sessions

1:11:46or anything you can attribute calls to any of them there are in any call coming in gets assigned to a web server sixty

1:11:51seven and was web server sixty seven does whatever need to do a response back. OK great.

1:11:56However web server sixty seven probably has a.

1:12:00Access a database to do something and how do you organize the databases

1:12:04and that's usually it's the data layer not the web serving application layer that's usually the hardest to scale

1:12:12because that's when you have things like globally shared storage you have things like limits on disk performance

1:12:20and on on how many how many rights can a single server even write per second if you're you know if you if you scale the

1:12:28way all the reads and and given reads to all these like you know replicating servers How do you know that's fine

1:12:33but can they even keep up with the rights how many rights as a master do

1:12:36and then if you split the roll up like that into really hard issues like All right well how do you cache data.

1:12:44Can you be sure that the data that you have read off of the read sleeve is up to date.

1:12:49Otherwise you can't really cash it because you might be clobbering something in a cache that is newer

1:12:54or you might be caching old data when new data is available.

1:12:57All these like really hard problems to go along with that that makes scaling such a complex interesting topic and

1:13:03and and why why it's such a hard problem and that's why

1:13:06when I see a blog post about like how to make a data structure smaller aquarium more efficient

1:13:12and then the word scaling is the same conversation it's like a performance you're just talking about performance like

1:13:17you know if you talk about the Web here like sense that you know it's stateless because scale the horizontal forever

1:13:22like nothing's scale even the web here.

1:13:25Even the web here is not like that one to once again allow you to my example if you ever get there you have reached the

1:13:31Golden Rule you know that you will be busily in there even just getting there even on the web here it's like well bored

1:13:36by different data sets and geographical load balancing

1:13:39and what about never a connection like the nothing nothing skill perfectly

1:13:43but you're right like you know the first thing you do you run into it as a state

1:13:46and you get in the cap the Arum of you know consistency partition tolerance

1:13:50and availability like this is well trod territory lots of people constrain

1:13:56and scaling Google knows probably the most about it of any company the entire world given this guy.

1:14:00While they operate at Microsoft seems to be learning a lot about Apple not sure with like scaling a super hard

1:14:05performance performance a super hard and I mean from the outside.

1:14:11This is all like sort of Soteris stuff but even for people who are just working on a small system

1:14:18and like it doesn't matter you're not going to have you know going to have Facebook level users right.

1:14:22But even on a very small system ten users one hundred users one thousand two hundred thousand even then you should be

1:14:28thinking about both performance and scaling and keeping a clear head about which one you're concentrating on

1:14:33and don't concentrate too much on scaling and not enough on performance

1:14:36or too much improvement on a scaling just keeping a clear head about what the individual tasks are

1:14:42and you will eventually find yourself even in a small system.

1:14:45Reading all those papers about the theory behind it

1:14:47and making your tradeoffs about you know consistency veil building a partition tyrants like you what you have to make

1:14:54decisions about if you don't make decisions the software you choose will make the decisions for you

1:14:57and you'll be sad about it so like that's all part of learning process

1:15:01but it's not all I I don't want to pick on a particular blog post I love reading those Brent Bozell love watching him

1:15:09think a lot about what he's doing

1:15:10and he's a great example of a great software developer like sort of you know showing his showing his work as he works

1:15:17towards a product and everything like that is just that.

1:15:20I have since I've dealt with server side software my entire career I have a particular.

1:15:24It's when I see the word scaling and that's not really talking about scaling I may be understating P.

1:15:30Dense right Casey. That's right that's right.

1:15:34Well

1:15:34and there is there is something to be said for performance optimization to a point you know it's it's very similar to

1:15:42the premature optimization wisdom in the world except and Brent even addresses

1:15:45and in one of his posts on an essential dot com which we should mention he even dressed like you know what you talking

1:15:51about. Server side design like for client side stuff. Premature Optimization is is considered a bad thing because.

1:16:00We have such fast hardware we have so much memory these days on client side devices and desktops

1:16:04and everything we have so much we have so many resources that it's just it's just not really worth doing super Mycroft

1:16:13imitations everywhere. However on servers things are different on servers.

1:16:19You are paying for what you use basically

1:16:22and if you're apt get popular at all even for a for a minimal amount of that of users relatively speaking to like

1:16:31something like Facebook like you know if you get one hundred thousand users using a web service that's going to that's

1:16:38a substantial need for the hardware

1:16:41and depending on what your service is doing that actually could need some serious resources

1:16:48and so that you know you could be you could be talking the difference between hundreds of up a hundred dollars a month

1:16:55or thousands of dollars a month worth of hardware or even more than that.

1:16:58And and so you know if you really make or break your whole economics it can it can make you busier

1:17:05or not is very like one of the best things to happen first for servers

1:17:09and scaling in the last decade has been S S D S because for a long time for a lot of lamp type applications one of the

1:17:17biggest limitations was the database the disk speed

1:17:21and like like a time where I was able to replace I think it was about nine

1:17:25or twelve read slave servers with one with S S D's and you know nine or twelve servers that had fifteen K.

1:17:35S.A.'s disks in RAID ten being replaced with one as a DB a server and the

1:17:39and those were those were old intellects twenty five says these are you know they've come a long way since then.

1:17:45That unit it now modernise is easier even faster than those and you know it's like when

1:17:52when you can make a big you know order of magnitude type jump if you can go from from ten database servers to one

1:17:58database server. You know that.

1:18:00It's kind of difference actually matters

1:18:02and is worth doing that that is something where performance has a direct impact direct measurable feel of all impact on

1:18:10scaling optimization for performance to a point actually is useful because in practice in practice most people most

1:18:20most people who make use of services make absence of it that most people are not going to get his biggest Facebook

1:18:25and Google. Most people are not even to get as big as you know small things that we've all heard of.

1:18:30You know it's most people are lucky to get a hundred thousand users to their web service you know

1:18:34and so by making decisions that favor high performance you can often keep you know that can often be the difference

1:18:45between being able to run everything off of the cheap easy to easy to Mr V.I.P.'s

1:18:50or a fully managed cloud service at a reasonable price and running a whole bunch of dedicated servers or running

1:18:57or paying tons of money for a cloud service or one of these things like that could make that big of a difference.

1:19:02And so it is you know on the scale inside this community from between you know needing just one fast database server

1:19:09and needing a multi server setup or being able to fit all on one server

1:19:13or having to share the database which is really complicated and adds a lot of maintenance

1:19:18or having to use a different type of tool entirely like a sender which is a world of hurt.

1:19:23It's just so incredibly not worth using.

1:19:26And

1:19:27and so you know performance does matter to the point where having a high performance system has a very good chance of

1:19:36keeping you from ever needing a difficult to scale system successful.

1:19:42Well the actual business that people don't understand the business people who don't understand technology

1:19:47and don't want to will apply both of these pressures to you because they will apply pressure for you to increase

1:19:52performance because they don't want to pay a lot of money for servers right.

1:19:57But they will also apply the pressure you for scaling because they will say.

1:20:00My business plan says we're going to grow fifty percent year over year for the next five years.

1:20:04So you need to be able to say OK we have five customers now in in five years we're going to have five million customers

1:20:12so I you know whatever multiple That is I don't want to pay if we if you have a greater than linear scaling is likely a

1:20:18one customer cost us ten bucks but two customers cost one hundred dollars.

1:20:22You've got a scaling problem immediately because they want the business to grow

1:20:25but they want to grow less than linear they want they want to double their number of customers

1:20:29but not double the harbor cos anywhere you're telling them as well.

1:20:33That's not how scaling works if we double our customers I need to weigh more than double our hardware cost that's like

1:20:37how much more how close are you to perfect when you're scaling and so they they want both.

1:20:42They want to you know it's too expensive every time we get another client we need to buy X.

1:20:46Amount of hardware and cost so much money

1:20:48and we're making only certain amount of money from each individual client we had.

1:20:51We can't afford to add that much harbor so increase your performance

1:20:53but year over year over year is like look we're going to quadruple our customer base can you quadruple our customer

1:20:58base you know like you know we can we go one database server were already buying the biggest machine we deposit that

1:21:03money can buy for a database server or we need a strategy for scaling in and then you end up charging

1:21:08and you know what about people in the parts of the country then you have all of that.

1:21:11If they're in charge how do these people interact with each other

1:21:13and it's like it's in some ways it's easier for software where it doesn't matter like Facebook where you're like the

1:21:19message shows up here a little bit sooner than it shows up there it's not it's not a banking system or whatever

1:21:24but not everyone's that lucky sometimes it really has to be you know that's where you're going to be kept there

1:21:28and again we have to pick your trade offs.

1:21:32And it's difficult and even no matter how bounded your problem is even it just doesn't scale everything down.

1:21:38If you're like oh I want to stick to you know V P S's

1:21:41or something really cheap I don't want to buy dedicate like you're playing in the small leagues

1:21:45but it still matters for your company when you when you're going from ten customers to ten thousand.

1:21:49It's the same exact thing playing out is just a smaller scale versus companies that start off from day one buying mass

1:21:55a dedicated hardware and the only difference in the high end game is that the.

1:22:00People are more likely to get into the situation where they are buying the most expensive computer equipment that money

1:22:04can buy from anyone in the entire planet. When they get to the end of their scaling rope and the like.

1:22:09Well I like we've increased performance as much as we can go we have no matter how much money we wave at somebody we

1:22:15cannot get a bigger single machine to do task X.

1:22:18Like now if you wait a bit longer think about scaling you have a serious problem because you've you've hit the

1:22:24performance that and like if your optimizer software

1:22:26but like yeah it's the same it's the same story it's just you know it's the fractal of itself it just just depends on

1:22:32how many commas there are for the decimal point and the invoices

1:22:38and that's this is one of the reasons why I really prefer to do things at a relatively low level

1:22:45and to do things that are fairly standard because you know even if you don't need scaling you know in quotes even if

1:22:51you don't think you need that today.

1:22:54Like knowing how to scale something or knowing knowing the steps that you take

1:22:59and the hurdles you will face is useful when writing anything even before it needs to be scaled.

1:23:05So for instance I set a number to unnerve Cajuns I never write database joint's ever joins our joint basically put a

1:23:15lot of work on the database server which granted it is very optimized to do.

1:23:20However I prefer to split up the joins into two calls like one to fetch the list of ids

1:23:25and the second to fetch from the target table you know which ones you get and stuff like that and design the schema

1:23:31and the code to do that.

1:23:33And that's for two major reasons one is to make that to give the database a little bit less work both through injuries

1:23:40and one give it a bit less work because database C.P.U. Power database resources are expensive and hard to scale.

1:23:46The second one is caching.

1:23:49Maybe you can cash that first where you know maybe you can cash a list of ideas you need

1:23:54and then you know only fetch the records or vice versa only fetch the ID

1:23:57and then fetch the records from cache things like that.

1:24:00In the third is that then that also gives me the ability later on if the service gets really big to say you know what

1:24:06the users table now has to have its own database.

1:24:08This gets hit so often

1:24:10and it's such a drain on performance that we should split this up into its own database cluster entirely so users is

1:24:18now on a different avi's then you can't do a join because I live on the same server any more so even like even with

1:24:24overcast I'm not running a joint I'm doing the same way I've always done it because it's not that much harder

1:24:30and it's you know just in case in the future that'll be fine i'll be set up for that upgrade to go sit you know the so

1:24:38many other things like very careful use of indexing.

1:24:41One of the most useful books I ever read on scaling was high performance My S.Q.L.

1:24:48and I read I read the addition before the current one and I liked it a lot the current one got a lot longer

1:24:54and the reviews weren't as good so I'm not sure if the current one is great I didn't actually read the whole thing

1:24:58but the previous one was awesome. So maybe give it a shot.

1:25:02But you know I think it's important it's important to make decisions like if you're writing. Suppose you're writing C.

1:25:09Code for an app and you're calling something like str when in in the loop to iterate through a string

1:25:16and calling Sterling the Durlan string if you know about performance at all you're in a look

1:25:22and say wait a minute you know that's being involved in every single call you you get this mentality that makes you

1:25:29make small decisions like that better.

1:25:32And in the course of a whole project that adds up

1:25:35and the end even though any one of those calls probably won't matter

1:25:39when you make every decision with a certain mindset in a certain sensibility

1:25:42and a certain wisdom about what will happen in the future or what the cost of this will might be or might add up to

1:25:49when you make all those small decisions the right way. The sum of all of that is different and does matter.

1:25:56Same thing applies to scaling when you make a bunch of small decisions to say.

1:26:00No You know what I can put a little more work on that on the database here

1:26:02or you know this doesn't need to be that optimized even you know the index isn't quite right to do this index only or

1:26:09or you know this is going to scan a bunch of rows to get these results

1:26:12but that will be a right you know it's how often do you going to do that once you get into the mindset of thinking OK

1:26:20what's going to happen when I have to do this thousands of times a second.

1:26:25You'll probably never have to

1:26:26but if you think about that from the beginning you can make better small decisions along the way that will add up

1:26:32and that will make scaling easier for you. Can we go back a step.

1:26:37You're saying that you would rather make round trips to the database than do something that the database is

1:26:43specifically designed to do that I mean I think what he's saying is that he doesn't want to use a database right.

1:26:51I know you don't like this is the newfangled key value storage things or whatever

1:26:54but if you're not going to be joined and I'm not saying that's the right or wrong decision

1:26:58but if that's the route you're going there are probably places you could store your data that would give you better

1:27:06performance for the same kind of usage pattern I imagine the reason you would like them is because there are newer

1:27:12and less mature

1:27:13and you know you're used to the features of being able to you know back up by people into easy replication

1:27:18and those are all important features and the reason is stick with it

1:27:20but you're kind of using my single in a sort of a degenerate state like you're using it as a really bad performing poor

1:27:26man's key value storage with some basic filtering doing your own joints client side we're just trying to get you get

1:27:32the other benefits of your familiarity easy backup easy replication reliability

1:27:37and you know that's why you're avoiding you know you that's why you're not another mom going to be you know nightmare

1:27:41story.

1:27:42Yeah I think you know obviously I know as as you

1:27:45and as the chat have said I'm going to lot of e-mail about my my no joint stance

1:27:50but the fact is first of all you said my school is WAY slower than some of the system and that's probably not the case.

1:27:58Certainly it is not always the case.

1:28:01The reason I use my skew well even though I'm not using some of the you know relational database type features like

1:28:07joints.

1:28:09You know I don't use stored procedures either out on the thing where you know that's just asking for trouble I don't

1:28:12use triggers things like that you know the reason I do this is because my S.Q.L. Is just frickin awesome.

1:28:21There's no other way to say I've I've heard so much crap about my fuel from people who don't use it

1:28:26and are prejudiced against it whatever and I know you know I don't use Postgresql.

1:28:30I don't use Oracle have I don't have an experience though so I can't tell you how it compares to those

1:28:33but I can tell you most of the criticism I have heard about my few well is wrong or at best outdated

1:28:40and only applied to my eye Salmon not the more recent in a D.B.

1:28:43Storage engine which at this point is not even recent And so if you use my S.Q.L. Within a D.B.

1:28:50As your storage and for all tables it's amazing. It is awesome.

1:28:55It's and I say I said this in a post recently and I you know the gravity of this I don't want to overstate this

1:29:01but it's hard to overstate this in all time the tumbler Instapaper all that time. Now overcast I've used my S.Q.L.

1:29:10A lot

1:29:11and you know a tumbler it was under extreme stress first for the entire time I was working there it was costly under

1:29:17extreme stress I have never seen my S.Q.L. Crash once. I have never seen my school corrupt data once. That's amazing.

1:29:26Look at any issue you've never seen a corrupted data I have never seen a corrupted I've never seen a crash.

1:29:32That's my skills actual functionality could be argued to be a corruption of the document going to have you look it up

1:29:40in the doc says that's exactly what it's going to do is not it's not wrong it's not a bug

1:29:44but like that's that's a philosophical difference

1:29:46and then you like a real database people have with my sequels like the documented behavior

1:29:51when it performs a documented behavior database people do you think get angry at it and I'm kind of one of them.

1:29:58I have that.

1:30:00We're talking about However if you look like Are you sure you're talking about you know modern versions of those.

1:30:05I'm like no no like we're weird coalitions of data types

1:30:09and cases where columns that are marked as not know can actually have no and weird things with empty strings

1:30:14and you like it they're all Dr Nagura is my if you're got your pages and just read through them

1:30:18and you know in terms of performance though like now that I'm saying you should switch to a different thing

1:30:23or something

1:30:23but like because most of the things that have massively better performance have much much less of the other things you

1:30:29describe like stability and reliability.

1:30:31But performance wise if your data model is kind of simple and never going to have joints

1:30:38and if you care about getting more government that you may or may not there are lots of other databases

1:30:42and that do go away faster than my sequel.

1:30:46Especially with energy because like it's the extra overhead of that of that storage engine you know most of the new

1:30:54hotness is basically people do almost everything in memory like it's you know it's not it's not like memcache

1:31:02or there is like a persistent memcache thing

1:31:03but a lot of them are like look we can involve disk in the operation of our thing here and you can imagine

1:31:09when you do almost everything in memory you go way faster than my sequel trying to diss of with the.

1:31:15Oh sure will and you know and there's ways you can you take advantage of that with caching already you can do that

1:31:19and probably my skill does already catch a lot of memory but you know certain And of course the O. S.

1:31:24Will catch a lot of the disk blocks memories of it but you know certainly you can use my S.Q.L.

1:31:29With predecessor memcache or any of the any a cache of some that are out there

1:31:32and I mean most people do it's fine you know that's like people there's this big it's a cool thing to use a different

1:31:42storage engine these days but the fact is a storage engine is oh boy here we go.

1:31:46A storage unit is like a file system is you know you don't want to change that very often

1:31:51and you want to be extremely conservative and extremely focused on data integrity

1:31:56and my if you will is so incredibly like Battle test.

1:32:00Good it is so solid and yeah I get that it might not have always been that way back in the olden days of mice

1:32:05and all the crap but those days are well into the past now and modernized.

1:32:11My school has been rock solid I would say for at least seven or eight years and that's why Google use it very heavily.

1:32:18They still do

1:32:18but they at least did I know you lots of major major sites use my sexual Twitter use it for a long time

1:32:25and probably still do. There's a reason why it's really really good and it's people.

1:32:32There's a great blog post a few years back when a Friend Feed existed T.V.

1:32:38Some idea and it was a blog post called how Friend Feed uses my S.Q.L.

1:32:41To store schema less data and how to find it but in the show notes

1:32:45but there's a lot of good stuff in here Friend Feed was a weird project that was run by incredibly good engineers

1:32:52and it's basically got a lot of the stuff like My S.Q.L. Even if you don't use some of the database the features of it.

1:33:03My fuel is still an amazingly fast solid low needs low maintenance storage engine that has tons of tools a huge

1:33:12ecosystem tons optimization potential there are so many reasons to use it

1:33:18and if you look at one of the newer systems it's you know and you know things like Mongo

1:33:24or you know all these like new no S.Q.L. Type systems.

1:33:27If you look a lot of those you know they have some benefits but if you don't necessarily need those benefits

1:33:32and what you really want is fear database to be like a file system to be basically bulletproof.

1:33:38My skills a great choice and I feel like I get ignored because it's old.

1:33:42This comparison is kind of harsh so I don't mean it the way it's going to sound

1:33:46but it's it's as close as we can align in the forest along a few things here again in the world of databases what is

1:33:53the P.H.P. Of databases it's kind of My S.Q.L. Is way better than P.H.P.

1:33:57Don't get me wrong but if you have to map onto it like that's what ends.

1:34:00Then like what's the Python of databases that's probably post-arrest you know like that that's that's more

1:34:05or less how things line up and like what's what's a C.C. Plus plus of databases of like Oracle you know.

1:34:11And what's the Ruby it's like you know the B. or Something like. But to align things I say is very clearly P.H.P.

1:34:17My skill at the P.H.P.

1:34:18Databases and that sounds terrible I know because it is not as bad as being a tree do not get me wrong P.H.P.

1:34:23Is terrible

1:34:24but it has many of the same characteristics in like that it's everywhere it's a known quantity it's reliable

1:34:30and has idiosyncrasies but once you know that you think these are they don't bother you that much

1:34:34and the thing about using it for schema less like that's why people do that because they like

1:34:38or have a tool that I know is reliable.

1:34:40I know what it's capable of

1:34:41and I'm going to use it like you said in a degenerate kind of way like I'm actually going to use it for Scheme in the

1:34:46state I know it's not a scheme Elice database system I know there actually are schemas

1:34:49but I'm going to find some table with columns or keen value and version number and some other crap in and it'll work

1:34:54and it's like you were taking advantage of a system that works in a way that you're comfortable with that has all the

1:35:00features you need and is reliable and your building something else on top of that

1:35:05and all I was saying with the other database type things is like if you care more about performance there is these days

1:35:10much more performance to be had if you're willing to trade it for less reliability and more unknowns you know

1:35:15and I'm hoping that that sort of younger section of the of the data storage world matures in coalesces

1:35:21and we get some sort of equivalent of My S.Q.L.

1:35:24or Even best case on a quilt in a post press where it's like a tried

1:35:28and true known quantity within that realm right now we don't have now right now kind of the Cambrian explosion over

1:35:32there I'm not sure how it's going to shake out

1:35:34but it's still it's still worth keeping your eye on because if you know twenty years from now you're still using I seek

1:35:41no joins there will be either a great failure of the no sequel world to come up with a useful product for the long term

1:35:48or a great failure due to keep an eye on what's going on.

1:35:51Possibly but I have two questions firstly what is the role of database and strong

1:35:57and I was trying to think about I don't know. Maybe maybe an S.Q.L. but Neither one of you remember that.

1:36:04There is really is no problem there is I don't know what it is it's probably one of the one of the newfangled databases

1:36:11and that I was not familiar enough with the thing that has kind of like there's nothing that has the same combination

1:36:16of like a precursor to all of the better known ones now with lots of weird quirks like I don't I don't know that is

1:36:23but it's it's not bicycle definitely isn't it just some academic paper that swears that it's academically flawed as

1:36:30that. That's part of the prospects you know thing in their database that can be written but not read. P.H.P.

1:36:37Look just like Perl you can to make a call.

1:36:40Let's I got out there or can we still back up to you just spent Marco five or ten minutes explaining how

1:36:46and how my sequel is amazing and reliable and does what it's supposed to do really well

1:36:51but you don't trust it to do a fricken join like that I can't get past that it is an issue of trust.

1:36:57It's an issue of leaving yourself open for future scaling options.

1:37:01It's about being able to say you know what my database server is going to at some point be split off from my web server

1:37:07once a month I have my service has more than five users and this is going to have its own server

1:37:12and it's going to be harder and more expensive to increase database hardware resources than to increase application

1:37:19or web hardware resources.

1:37:20And so you might as well have the application and web stuff do more of the work and make the database easier job.

1:37:30So things like you know reduce the number of queries to put the number of queries that go to it that you know make them

1:37:36access fewer rows make them access fewer tables make you have to do a C.P.U.

1:37:40Work but it's more about Io you know let the database do only what the database is required to do

1:37:47and let your other servers take on as much work as they can.

1:37:51OK but you'd rather ping away at it and do a good zillion round trips to avoid these joints like I.

1:38:00I've been through a tumbler I've been bantering Instapaper so I'm doing that thing which I told you I don't want to do

1:38:08in the beginning of the episode where I'm saying that seems weird

1:38:10but genuine question Have you ever done anything to imperiously prove to yourself like have you used a new relic to

1:38:17prove to yourself that this is legitimately the right way to go you can do it on paper that you've given yourself a

1:38:25massive market

1:38:26but I'm sure the answer that is yes because any server that offer quickly realizes the part that has all the state is

1:38:31the hardest part to scale I mean he basically just laid it out like you can just do it on paper.

1:38:35There's a certain amount of work that needs to be done. One part of your system you can scale really really easily.

1:38:39One part is really hard to scale you want the hard to scale part to do like the same whatever operation does the most

1:38:45efficiently primary key lookups maybe have a do that same operation over and over and over again

1:38:51and have everything else you can do put on the easier to scale parts like you know there's lots of ways you can do the

1:38:56math to figure out you know how it works but like just I think you even if you just think about that logically

1:39:02and reason through it

1:39:04and that's not even to get you a linear scale we're just trying to keep our heads above water with a step a strategy

1:39:09you always want to push the the work out to the system that is to scale

1:39:14and so I mean it's kind of the Google approach

1:39:16or like a big table where they went to the extreme where like their their data store was like really annoying to deal

1:39:22with and unreliable and applications had to retry and figure out how to resolve conflicts and it was just like

1:39:28and made it incredibly hard to replicate and stuff like that was the price of scaling early on

1:39:32and they've made strides in that way

1:39:33but basically you're trying to move the work to the systems that are easy to scale

1:39:37and web servers are ways you know to scale and not not performance scale

1:39:41and again your computing performance in that you know you have that goes round trips you're going to cross it that work

1:39:46in making multiple queries like that's performance we're talking about scaling it's fair point

1:39:52and I did that literally forever it's worth you know we're putting a lot of your putting a lot of weight on these round

1:39:59trip.

1:40:00Run trips to a database server or to a meme kasher or that's you know in the same rack

1:40:06or at least of the same data center as they are coming from point you know we're talking about a lot of time here that

1:40:12I don't think you know all of this depends on the kind of application you're writing how much data you actually crating

1:40:18like to build the page you know or to build the A.P.I. Response that you're talking about.

1:40:22How many database called do you actually have to do is it seven or eight. Is it fifty like.

1:40:28Is it more that like there's what you're doing matters a lot and you know it's infinite

1:40:34or was fairly easy to scale because it was never as big as tumbler

1:40:38and I was using I was using Tumblr style techniques at Instapaper So of course it was way overkill.

1:40:45Which is great which is why which is why I was able to afford to run it and not go crazy and not go broke.

1:40:50But you know a time

1:40:52when we face things like to give you one example how do you display the list of posts on somebodies dashboard so you

1:41:01have to figure out who they follow and then other

1:41:04when they follow to find enough posts from those people to make twenty of them an order them properly.

1:41:10There are so many different ways to do that

1:41:12and there are there in the naive ways where you do if you joined then you have any do a big sort

1:41:17and it's all fine you know the naive way does not really skill very well just because you start dealing with hundreds

1:41:24of gigs of data pretty quickly and that and the database having to scan you know millions of rows

1:41:30and that starts performing very badly so a lot of times what you think is the most like good naive approach.

1:41:39Actually in practice it does not is not useful it is not.

1:41:43It doesn't scale well enough you know becomes too expensive or becomes completely impractical

1:41:48or impossible to do it scale.

1:41:51So you start having to do weird little hacks

1:41:54and so you know one of the hacks we get a tumbler early on was actually something that I learned from.

1:44:00Unrolling a loop

1:44:00or doing some setting up some big bunch of setup stuff to do a bunch of you know simply operations on it like it gets

1:44:06longer

1:44:07and get uglier looks like you're doing more is like the Seems like it's more work you know in the same way like my head

1:44:12is my screen they've got me all day and I wanted one big self consistent blog but this nice join query

1:44:17and replacing it with these multiple queries

1:44:18when I just dated together myself like that it's longer How could that be better.

1:44:23I mean I guess is not a fully accurate in the US case like you're actually increasing performance.

1:44:28And here like Marco said you're you're protecting yourself for future scaling although in some cases even in the deep

1:44:34dark world of databases human is stored procedures or if your query planner is not your friend.

1:44:39Like say if you use Informix.

1:44:41Speaking from experience that sometimes if you want to get a massive amount of data it's better to write a stored

1:44:46procedure procedure

1:44:48and essentially be the query planner yourself do it all in a database you know all right on top of the thing that they

1:44:53look. When I give you this join you can do something dumb.

1:44:55So let me run this great this great this query join the master results together put them in a tent table index with a

1:45:00temp table.

1:45:01Joining is that temp table with the second mate like

1:45:03and like how could that possibly be faster than just running the query you want is like well the creeper

1:45:07and I made some very unfortunate life choices when we send in a matter of fact.

1:45:13Doing this crazy stored procedure like I mean once you're creating temp table index I mean like there's no way that

1:45:17could be fast in the rain a query like.

1:45:19Well you know let me show you like databases are funny things

1:45:22and the more you can treat them the way Mark was treating treating them the less headaches you'll have about them

1:45:28and I think the more you should think about whether you're sharing the using a database

1:45:32but that's you know that's a competition.

1:45:34But anyway the idea that the sort of client side code of the consuming code gets longer and uglier

1:45:41and more complicated.

1:45:42That is not outside the realm of normal programmer experience

1:45:46when just increasing the performance of your regular you know compiled code that makes sense. Yeah and it's a balance.

1:45:52You know it's a balance you have to strike.

1:45:54Obviously you know if you're having severe problems and severe scaling challenges you're going to have to.

1:46:00No more in that direction of more complex code.

1:46:03That and I'll be more bugs you'll have things like weird caching bugs and you know things like replication delay

1:46:09or eventual consistency bugs.

1:46:11I didn't even know what your book structure using and that's all hard that's all complicated

1:46:17and certainly you shouldn't do that sooner than you have to. In most cases. But again it's a balance.

1:46:24Just like you shouldn't waste all your memory as much as possible when you're writing a C.

1:46:28Program already program for that matter. You know it's either find a balance and with servers and scaling.

1:46:35I would lean a little more just because the nature of you know using someone else's vast resources on their computer

1:46:41versus expensive shared server resources.

1:46:44I would lean a little bit more towards a little more complicated but way more scalable. I make sense then.

1:46:52Far be it for me to argue with you Mr tumbler. Thanks. They have functions this week. P.D.F.

1:46:59Pen for i Pad new relic and a glue and we will see you next week. Now on this show is over.

1:47:13It was accidental accidental was accidental and you learn today learn from as I said that can live tomorrow.

1:48:08I'd like to tell you about why I hate my car now.

1:48:10Wow Is it because I didn't get there early Finally it is actually relatively dirty dirty at the moment.

1:48:18Aaron and I decided this past Saturday to go to the local drive in movie theater

1:48:24and if you have a local drive in movie theater I cannot suggest enough that assuming you don't have small children

1:48:30which I guess that definitely limits mark on probably limits drawn in this particular context.

1:48:36If you don't have small kids you can escape the kids go to a drive in movie it's really cool.

1:48:41Instead of the way the Goochland drive in theater works which is between Charlotte on Richmond is you poll

1:48:48when you pay something like eight dollars a person in your car and you get a double feature

1:48:53and you get the audio for the Double Feature by tuning to a F.M.

1:48:58Station that the that the theater broadcasts

1:49:01and it's a really cool experience especially in a really pretty night like this past Saturday was planned.

1:49:07We have been several times in the past although not for a year or two and

1:49:10when we've gone in the past I've taken my car which at the time was my Subaru. What color was that that was white.

1:49:18We'll take an Aaron's car which was and is still a Mazda six which is a great silver and we've never had an issue.

1:49:26Well this past Saturday I had just washed and waxed in leather conditioned and vacuumed Erin's car

1:49:33and so I thought well my car is dirty because yes my car does get dirty It just takes longer than forty nano seconds.

1:49:40Unlike Marco's car. So we decided to take the B.M.W. The B.M.W.

1:49:44Has a pushbutton starter and it has an accessory mode and so I figured self there would be no issue here.

1:49:53What we'll do is we will go to the drive in theater I will put the car in accessory mode by turning it off

1:49:59and then press.

1:50:00Thing the push button once and we will listen to the movie on the stereo

1:50:04and it will be wonderful I will turn off the i Drive display I had to figure out how to do that because I completely

1:50:09forgot and I will turn off the i Drive display and everything should be good and right in the world.

1:50:15So that's what we did. And after ten minutes I heard the B.M.W.

1:50:19Chime that you might remember from neutral and it was telling me that my battery was dying.

1:50:25What after ten minutes of having the radio on does the car have two batteries or the smartest

1:50:30or something Marcos car does does it.

1:50:34Now that I know of are those cars like ten batteries

1:50:36and I thought it only had one you couldn't you couldn't find the one battery that one guy was partially filled with

1:50:43that I don't they're always on the passenger side in the trunk.

1:50:46Now if we went through this anyway I thought his car had two batteries and I thought I thought I was a common B.M.W.

1:50:50Thing but what do I know. For all I know.

1:50:54But anyway now it could be that I that the battery in my car's original I believe it is

1:51:00and it was purchased originally and I think December twenty ten.

1:51:04So now we're getting to the point that maybe this is all a battery issue that I'm misconstruing to be a core issue

1:51:09but what I can tell you is that the radio at least once turned itself off because it felt like it was tired of being on

1:51:18and thought that I'd left it on.

1:51:20Not deliberately and I'm like in a keyed car where you physically put the key into accessory mode

1:51:26and a push button car it's just being told where you put yourself an accessory

1:51:31and I guess we'll hope that you don't turn yourself off and it turned itself off

1:51:35and then I turned it back on in like I said after like another ten minutes

1:51:38or something like that it started digging away about how the battery was dying so we ended up watching only the first

1:51:42of the Double Feature by lowering the windows which by the way used a whole lot of juice because you are moving a motor

1:51:48is a heck of a lot harder than moo than to having an F.M.

1:51:52Radio on but I did that we lowered the windows

1:51:54and we listened through everyone else's because my damn car wouldn't stay running in.

1:52:00I was afraid I wouldn't be able to crank it

1:52:01and the other really interesting thing is even though they have whittled jumpstarting boxes at the theater I was so

1:52:08scared that it would get so dead

1:52:11and the jump starting boxes would take so long to trickle charge it that I wouldn't even be able to push start the car

1:52:16because it wouldn't be able to engage the push button ignition into run mode to get the things I could for can push

1:52:22start it so it sort of ruins our entire movie going experience

1:52:26and granted we're talking about a sum total of sixteen dollars but if you really really really annoying.

1:52:30So now if we take my car to the movie theater again if for no other reason than the auto disable

1:52:36or you have to take a frickin stereo for like a boom box with us

1:52:39and keep it quiet so we can listen to the stupid movie.

1:52:43You know you're already got her to marry you because they were not pressing your date on this night.

1:52:50OK Two things One the fact that you can solve this problem by you know like a twenty dollar bill in box makes it a lot

1:52:56less of a problem. True too.

1:53:00Do you think anybody who designed this whole like you know electronic pushbutton start in accessory mode

1:53:06or not I'm a turn off.

1:53:08Do you think any of those people involved in those decisions have ever been to a drive in movie theater. Certainly not.

1:53:14But it's still very annoying.

1:53:18You know some of the reason i Pods that have interest in them like the old i Pod Nano see how do those high end

1:53:23but they have a fountain I you know we could do that out in advance what are actual hitech really ridiculous

1:53:28but it could work.

1:53:29And also you should get a new battery carcass ridiculous

1:53:32and yes batteries do go bad sometimes suddenly after many years. So you do it replace them.

1:53:36Yeah

1:53:37and actually the more I think the more I think that may be the issue in terms of the warning about there's actually there's

1:53:43some the pops up in the I drive it's increased battery discharge because gets very upset that the battery got as low as

1:53:50it did

1:53:51and so the next time I take the car in which will probably be for the N fifty five recall that everyone just real

1:53:56or that B.M.W. Just announced I will certainly ask them.

1:54:00Either replace it or double triple check that it is healthy as they claim it is.

1:54:05But man what a stupid problem to have I mean maybe this is the biggest first world problem ever it probably is

1:54:12but what a frustrating silly problem have because an errant car which has a key like most normal cars.

1:54:18None of this would have been an issue.

1:54:19And I also wonder if part of the problem was because the i Drive is a whole frickin computer.

1:54:25I wonder if the whole damn computer was turned on with a little twelve or fifteen gig harddrive spinning and so on

1:54:33and so forth.

1:54:34Even though the display was off in other words there's not like a short circuit if you will just for the F.M.

1:54:39Radio to keep that on a no freakin nav

1:54:42and everything was powered on just like it was in the radio do you think you could have brought the soundtrack to the

1:54:47movie on vinyl and maybe played it on a gram phones them easily to any power at all and we don't hear it and we don't.

1:54:58I hate you.