Podcast Search

The Accidental Tech Podcast

70: The Endgame Is Omnipotence

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00Right so the show bodies up again so far as you know on that last you still centering the titles comma K.Z.

0:00:08One what's wrong with that. What's wrong with that. Yeah. Besides it's like daggers in your eyes.

0:00:14Impossible to read that other than that no one can how did you like the flat forms crazy shapes that mean nothing if I

0:00:24turned the entire thing into a jar rush hour test with a man with a hat looking at me.

0:00:31Is this person's name actually Jason discount Not only is this person's name Jason discount but I knew this person

0:00:37when I was a kid. So you know this is actually his real name. Yes it is his real name.

0:00:41I think it was in Australia now but he used to live like you know a town over from me so his name is Jason discount

0:00:48and he's e-mailing us about repressing discounts. Yeah finally a legitimate reason for him to have that name.

0:00:55He's been waiting his whole life for this moment when a podcast said something wrong about discount price.

0:01:00It's not wrong this is that I don't think any of us brought up this specific scenario

0:01:04when complaining about the confusing bundle pricing as a way to do upgrades

0:01:09and he gives the example of what's a US release application at six dollars

0:01:13and then you work on your second version of the application and you want to sell them for six dollars two

0:01:18but you only want people to build upgrade from version one for two dollars.

0:01:22So his strategy for this is if you reduce the first version to four dollars

0:01:26and make the bundle price of both of them together six dollars if someone actually buys the old app it still only cost

0:01:32them a total six dollars to buy the new app

0:01:34and of course anybody already has the new app can buy the bundle to complete this bundle to get it for two dollars.

0:01:40I don't think it's entirely solve because one of somebody has the old app

0:01:44and actually buys the new out for six dollars then they're out four dollars

0:01:47but oh that's a whole other angle you're right yeah because there's nothing like you can't like there's nothing

0:01:53stopping them from individually buying the absolute full price theory right unless the store was like detect they

0:01:59bought one only. For them to complete their bundle.

0:02:01Right

0:02:02but the idea of lowering the price of the old one that you have to keep on the star so that if anyone actually buys it

0:02:10there you know it they they're not

0:02:12and they've paid the same price anyway if they actually buy a bike I'll just buy the bundle then you can get the new

0:02:16one for the same price you would've paid for if you bought it individually

0:02:19but they still the full price new one out there lurking is a problem with this whole thing is around about

0:02:24and trying to explain it is confusing and that's why it's a bad idea but I still think people are going to try it.

0:02:30Will say I still maintain that it's a terrible idea

0:02:33and that nobody should do it because at best it's fairly confusing for your customers.

0:02:39At worst if you do things wrong cost them extra money and then extra money that you can't easily refund them

0:02:45and they will be angry about

0:02:46and leave you want star reviews about like the thing with the one star reviews like it only takes something angering a

0:02:53very small percentage of the user base.

0:02:55In order for them to suddenly become the dominant voice in your reviews because very few people review things even if

0:03:01you get even if you show them one of those annoying pop ups still a very small percentage of people actually review

0:03:06your apps

0:03:07and so it doesn't take much like if you if you cause an issue that really really angers a tiny fraction of user base

0:03:14that will become disproportionately influential in your ratings and reviews

0:03:17and all the discussion about your app on line and that's really not good.

0:03:21People are much more motivated to actually sit down and figure out how how you go about leaving your view

0:03:26when they're mad about something.

0:03:28Whereas if they love your app they may briefly think you know the person who made this happen.

0:03:33Nice and I want to do something to help them write help like that that thought goes away quickly

0:03:38and I go back to their life.

0:03:40So quick side note one of my favorite things to do which I immediately don't do very often is if I for some reason have

0:03:46to call it safe arising or something because there's an issue which almost never happens

0:03:50or if I have really a really really great server at a restaurant occasionally I like to ask for their manager just to

0:03:57say something really nice because I feel I could put some good.

0:04:00Army in the world and maybe the karma will come back one day he said you asked to talk to their manager

0:04:04and they feel I go what I do.

0:04:06Yeah that's the best part is to kind of know it's not the best part you just talk torturing these people.

0:04:10No but then but then usually a but then I'm extremely If you sieve about how wonderful they are.

0:04:15Now that's that's like calling condemned the principal's office randomly and you know freaking him out

0:04:19and saying I just want to say hi to you has your day go.

0:04:21Well sometimes a lot of times I'll say you know I'd let you know that this was really awesome Can I tell manager

0:04:26but sometimes I don't Sometimes I like to mess mess around and you know you're mad with power Casey Casey.

0:04:32We need to talk.

0:04:36Fine you know I'm just going to be quiet for you trying to say something nice about if you had a you know that's a good

0:04:45you know if your motivation is good the thing you're trying to do is that the way you're doing it is not great.

0:04:49Which sounds a lot like the show but you get that you know that practice makes perfect right. Are games movies.

0:04:58All right is there going to give the spoiler so I need to go away again because I genuinely honestly did not listen to

0:05:03that part of the show it's not going to be.

0:05:05Well it's not a bad journey it's about the whole is Apple said to disrupt Microsoft

0:05:10and Sony in that all conversation we had lots of people tweeted about that I know there was a whole podcast about it

0:05:15that it in my queue but I haven't yet listened to that features. Ben Thompson who wrote that article.

0:05:21A bunch of the people that live in that yet

0:05:24but the thought that occurred to me after we finish the show because of course I want to talk even more about the topic

0:05:28that we talked about forever anyway because I like talking about games.

0:05:32Was are are video games more like apps or more like movies

0:05:36and I mean this in one specific respect that I don't think we touched on.

0:05:42Although we didn't bring this up in the show specifically the whole computer Personal Computers are like trucks

0:05:51metaphor that has been discussed that I think Steve Jobs wrote up many years ago

0:05:55and that you know people don't need a mac pro to post to Facebook and. Three Web sites and check your e-mail and stuff.

0:06:02Despite the fact that the macro does all these amazing things they're probably not going to use them like that.

0:06:08They're the amount of technology we have in the features available far exceed what any person is ever going to want to

0:06:13do with it

0:06:14and that's what I say is it like apps like where I mean if it is like a computer where we know a person computer

0:06:22technology is available now that is far beyond the needs of what regular people want to do with computers.

0:06:31And I'm comparing that to movies where movies.

0:06:35The technology available to make movies has just gotten better by leaps

0:06:38and bounds if you compare like a blockbuster movie if you look at it could take like even the crappiest blockbuster

0:06:43movie like Transformers or some crap like that.

0:06:45Back in the time back in time fifty years in show it to somebody they would not have on first viewing they would not

0:06:52have been able to compute how terrible the movie was because they would just be amazed at the visuals because they were

0:06:57like This is magic I don't understand where this came from this must be like an alien artifact because they wouldn't

0:07:02understand how we close this is on a screen and I think in movies anyway.

0:07:08The mass market appetite for increasingly amazing things is not satisfied it's not like well you know once we can do a

0:07:14reasonable practical facts like Raiders of the Lost Ark that's all we ever need.

0:07:18There's no upside to making a better people don't need the MacPro of movies they get by perfectly fine with the IMAX so

0:07:24we'll just leave you know stick with the feature set that develop on Raiders the Lost Ark. No need for Jurassic Park.

0:07:29No need for you know it masses in C.G.I. We have today no need for like all the C.G.I.

0:07:33That's used in television shows to do backdrops and stuff. Sets are fine.

0:07:37We've pretty much got the set I don't think that's the case

0:07:40and it's not like the only people who care about just more features more technology more amazing stuff are the people

0:07:47who are super into movies and the casual moviegoers alike. I don't need to practical effects are fine with me.

0:07:54I think the appetite is essentially unlimited for amazing visuals and movies you know.

0:08:00Things on the stupidity of scripts and all the other stuff that have always been the same.

0:08:03It's not as if movies got good enough and people like now you don't need to improve them anymore

0:08:06and they keep trying to prove they don't mean everything they do to improve them is better three D.

0:08:09Is an attempt to improve it and they may not be better maybe you don't like that higher frame rate same deal.

0:08:14High Definition Television I think that's an improvement.

0:08:16People do say yes we like that better than the standard that's good enough.

0:08:20I'm not I'm not a power user of television I don't need high definition television standards now so you see I have this

0:08:25you know I go to that old saying we want a new thing and the question about video games one of them or like them

0:08:30or like the P.C. Where increasing power is like nah I don't really need that.

0:08:35Or is it more like movies where there is a seemingly infinite appetite of the mass market for making them better in

0:08:42ways that involve technology and money and I think for video games so far I don't this will always be true

0:08:48but for video games so far that seem a lot more like movies to me and that any time I could will think what about

0:08:54when a pocket of Pavel's Playstation for them are all set right.

0:08:58No because people will still want the power that the Playstation five or six offers.

0:09:02Like why will they want that well because they always want that because their appetite for better games

0:09:06and better graphics and things you know more power can do is unlimited

0:09:10and it's not like a computer where it's like you don't need all that technology in that macro you just want to check

0:09:14your email. Games are different.

0:09:16If you could have a vast fully realize realistic looking city with amazing draw distance is an amazing physics

0:09:22and I think people want that they don't know

0:09:23or care how it works they're playing the game it's much different than using the the computer to do something so that

0:09:30is a factor they didn't articulate the last time we discussed this

0:09:32or that I think is definitely in play here with games in that I don't know I don't know if the appetite is

0:09:40inexhaustible but I know we haven't exhausted it yet

0:09:43and that's why I think a lot of people who are saying oh you think that now but what about

0:09:46when the wind park is a star of the Play Station four then it will then they'll be no more market for four hundred

0:09:52dollar gaming device.

0:09:52I think the reason we people keep buying for underdog game things is because their appetite for better visuals.

0:10:00Better gameplay and better physics and just you know better games period is insatiable.

0:10:05It is not satisfied we never get to the point where games are good enough and then it just stops and stays that way.

0:10:11There's always something more you can do you just first tutti John written stuff like that you can always do something

0:10:16more with more technology with more memory with more centers and more you know who knows what.

0:10:21So that more than anything I think is going to keep the four hundred boxes alive for much longer than I think people

0:10:27think. I see I'm not so sure. As an example. So we have a forty inch T.V.

0:10:33At home and we need it does support anybody

0:10:37but the difference to me between seven thousand nine hundred eighty is I think I can tell I can tell the difference

0:10:43between four eighty whatever standard def is and seven twenty or four eighteen twenty

0:10:49but I can't tell the difference tween some twenty nine hundred eighty

0:10:51and I know what's going to be different because it's not a film it's it's something that's been created

0:10:56and so I do think you're right that it will always we always seek for more clarity better better better more polygons

0:11:01etc but I don't I don't know of anyone that buy games that that needs that latest

0:11:09and greatest system specifically for the best graphics except people who generally like self describe as gamers.

0:11:16So for me I don't really care about games very much and if a new system comes out better graphics cool

0:11:22but it's not it's not just better graphics that's the whole problem of first of all I would say that yeah maybe only a

0:11:26self described Amer's care about this and parts on it but there's enough of them to stay in the market.

0:11:29Right we already established like this generation grew but there's enough of them to sustain the market right.

0:11:34But for for everything else as the technology increases new types of games become possible kind of like you couldn't do

0:11:42live action Lord Of The Rings without computer effects.

0:11:45You just couldn't film that like you could do with with puppets maybe or people in costumes

0:11:49but it would just not have the kind of appeal and you don't need to know

0:11:52or care anything about the technology involved in making that to appreciate Lord Of The Rings.

0:11:56Right and so it's not going to happen like that. High def vs.

0:12:00It's what's on the screen you can do different kinds of things if you were to take any current game developer

0:12:06and say What if I gave you one hundred thousand times the memory the band with the whatever.

0:12:12What could you do they wouldn't just make their existing games with more polygons

0:12:15and highrise textures like how it was that I can make a different kind of game like I can make a hiking simulator that

0:12:22people will love like I mean sort of when you get to the holodeck.

0:12:24Different categories of games especially with physical materials because a lot of things you do in games like

0:12:29everything feels like a set where it's just sort of a rigid polygon or with some sort of predefined destructive things.

0:12:35Once technology gets to the point where you can do like real arbitrary destructibility hold to people who aren't so

0:12:41interested in games before will suddenly be interested if they can realistically take a baseball bat through like a

0:12:46showroom of super cars

0:12:48and it doesn't just feel like you're triggering a bunch of destruction animations to rethink cities.

0:12:54Now just different categories of games you can have in the hiking simulator thing is a joke I had from

0:12:59when I was a kid I bet there probably is a hiking simulator now like we've gotten to the point where there are with the

0:13:04visuals in games

0:13:05or enough that people are only interested in visuals would never been interested in sixteen games in any As games

0:13:11and pondering but suddenly

0:13:12when games start to look such pass some threshold the realism whole new categories of people become interested even if

0:13:17it's only like the you know the deer hunter simulator type things those people were not interested in playing to Mary

0:13:22about it

0:13:23but once you can simulate deer hunting in a way that they find appealing suddenly you open up an entire new market so I

0:13:29think the insatiable appetite for better technology for games isn't because people know or care understand

0:13:34and acknowledge it's the same as the insatiable appetite for increasingly ridiculous visuals just again Transformers

0:13:40despite the fact for the rest the movies terrible people go see these movies because the visuals are amazing

0:13:45and you throw out they're amazing now

0:13:47but they can't get any more amazing surely ten years from now that it will be exactly the same

0:13:51and no person will ever go into a movie and be wowed.

0:13:54I don't think that's the case I think people will always want to see something amazing out of people I think people

0:13:59always want to.

0:14:00Something amazing I think increases then technology will only open the market because you'll be able to do different

0:14:05things not just the same things we're doing now but fancier.

0:14:09Yeah I think the big risk though is you know typical disruption where the big risk is not people stop caring about

0:14:17things being more and more advanced.

0:14:18As we get new technology capabilities the bigger risk is that other factors come into play that you know the kind of

0:14:26thing where somebody or somebody gets a think like OK well I could buy this new game system for four hundred dollars

0:14:33but instead I can have this other thing where you know maybe it's an i Phone with an i Pad maybe to Nintendo you know

0:14:41D.S. Seven Whatever the case may be.

0:14:42You have these other devices that come in where somebody can say I don't care about the graphics because X.

0:14:48or I don't care about the technological inferiority because X. Where X.

0:14:53Can be some kind of really compelling reason whether it's an extremely different price point you know a completely

0:14:58different portability class or you know it's always with you

0:15:00or it's built into something else you already have it so it's kind of free things like that.

0:15:04That's what caused the big problems and so it's not the market for super powerful game boxes is going to disappear.

0:15:12But I certainly think there's a lot to suggest it's going to be marginalized

0:15:16and continue to be marginalized over time

0:15:18and you know you can look at movies are actually a pretty good example of this where box office sales are actually kind

0:15:26of crappy relative to what people expected for this time period because there's a lot more to do besides go see a movie

0:15:34these days. And so it's not that people stop caring about movies getting better and better.

0:15:41It's that now they have a lot of other stuff they can do it during times with which you know in the ninety's they're

0:15:46not going to see a movie and so I think that's the big risk here is kind of a splitting of attention

0:15:52and increase in disruptive factors that are different from the things these boxes do best not the people stop caring

0:15:59about what they do best. No you just don't you just put placeholders in for the things that are going to cause it.

0:16:04I don't think you can name it because all the things you named already exist

0:16:07and still haven't killed off the mark I mean spreading attention is one thing no one can help that suddenly just too

0:16:12many other things going on

0:16:13and you know it's if people just get spread too thin like that could happen right that could have anything out of T.V.

0:16:20Movies like that

0:16:22but the one thing video games has going for it is as a concept essentially if not into the specifics of like a box that

0:16:29you buy that connects your T.V. but Conceptually games are camped out in the end zone waving like the wrong analogies.

0:16:37A sport not a good sports analogy but games are basically at the end of the line tapping the foot

0:16:41and patiently saying you guys can do all whatever you want T.V.

0:16:44Movies live theater music although the stuff but it will be here in the end

0:16:49when you're all gone because our logical conclusion is the holodeck which will sort of end humanity because once you

0:16:55can realistically simulate anything

0:16:57and have you not distinguish it from real life will all just be dead in our little virtual sensor tubes within ten

0:17:03years right.

0:17:03That's that's the end game the end game is you know on that

0:17:08but it's the illusion of omnipotence know everything do everything indistinguishable from reality.

0:17:14That's going to come out of gaming is not to come out of television is not going to come out of live theater is not

0:17:18going to come out of music.

0:17:19Gaming is trying to get there and so it's likely that there are lifetimes here

0:17:23but way out thousands of years in the future.

0:17:26Games are the only form of anything and eventually destroy the entire human race.

0:17:29So I don't think gaming has that one good thing going for in that it's not going to go away

0:17:36and if we do get spread too thin because of other factors it'll come back because it's it's the end zone is the wrong

0:17:43thing it's the end of the line waiting for all of us.

0:17:47Well our first out of our first punch of this week is a new sponsor and a close friend of the show.

0:17:56If you ever listen to bio Nick you know the other half of it.

0:18:00The fake British guy who used to be British but now is a man.

0:18:04Matthew Percival Eduardo Yes Alexander he started a company and that company is called need that need it within

0:18:14and not the cave version of it.

0:18:15It's need lifestyle dot com Come check us out so need is a refined retailer and lifestyle magazine for men.

0:18:24So each month they get this nice curated collection of some like you know nine ten items

0:18:30and it's all from the world's top men's brands and they offer it to you at a special price in the special collection

0:18:38and they're presented in the form of this monthly editorial that's built around a theme

0:18:43and they always you know they support local photographers

0:18:45and have you know local photographers photograph all these things local models beyond clothing they also have coffee

0:18:51literature furniture.

0:18:53It's it's like a men's kind of you know cool fashion magazine it's for people who are not you know it's for people like

0:19:01me basically people who are not that good at making these decisions on our own.

0:19:06You can go to knead and you can see what is cool because I sure I certainly can tell you

0:19:11but this stuff is pretty cool I've gotten some of the stuff

0:19:13and it's really really good stuff you know the man has a really good really good eye for the stairway trousers.

0:19:20They also plan to localize to different cities around the world.

0:19:23The first of which will be London of course because he's almost British and so take a look good

0:19:28or need lifestyle dot com They just released Volume seven today which is built around the theme this month is

0:19:35summertime commutes vents and weekends with friends.

0:19:38So they're into a special deal for our listeners because Matt likes us

0:19:41and he's a cool guy even though he's half British.

0:19:44Anyone who places or with need

0:19:45and was sent from us send them an e-mail at hello at need lifestyle dot com with the subject line.

0:19:52World's Greatest pot cast if you do this if you e-mail Hello. Need less style with a sort of one world.

0:20:00If you place an order with them they will throw in a bunch of free extras of those orders things like you know magazine

0:20:05field knows no books socks scarves you know the kind of extras that a cool hip men's magazine has line around.

0:20:11They will also if you do this you will also then get twenty five percent off your next order.

0:20:16This is pretty cool I know this is kind of like you know haphazard last minute because neither of us knew how to write

0:20:21an ad for this it was very it was kind of a last minute book in a kind of save our butts here so need is great.

0:20:25Matt is great it's really a friend has a company Re my fantastic people thought I can really say take a look.

0:20:31Need lifestyle dot com for all of your cool stuff needs need less Style dot com Thanks a lot the need once again went

0:20:40to once again this is the first I'm a sponsor Thanks what's the need for sponsoring our show.

0:20:45I just love that they're having now be so shaded with the World Trade greatest pod cast in my defense.

0:20:51Matt wrote that line I didn't we would have but we did.

0:20:56Yes So it is not to blame if you do not think that we are the world's greatest pocket.

0:21:01Either way if you order from this company just so you can then email him get this cold it can get the free socks

0:21:05and scarf and stuff and then tell him why brother was going to talk us talk about a few more things on the D.C.

0:21:12Hit list

0:21:12or do you want to jump straight to the fire phone with the Fire Phone happened today so that's the best thing we do is

0:21:18when it when an event happens the Daily Record and we know nothing about it there was talk about it.

0:21:22Why not before anyone has reviews or even has a thing on their hands.

0:21:26I read Twitter when the press conference was going on to that count.

0:21:29That's not all I did and I reacted to things I read on Twitter.

0:21:35So so what this thing is it's basically what you'd expect

0:21:39when I was on making the phone based on what they've done with the Kindle Fire tablet line it's a phone that runs

0:21:46Android. It has pretty decent specs to gigs around some kind of C.P.U.

0:21:51I'm not familiar with I don't know that so I'm sure Indra people know it.

0:21:55Most of the innovation and it comes from software tweaks I think but I think what's most interesting you know it.

0:22:00If you would have asked people including us a few months ago like you know hey am isn't going to make a phone.

0:22:04What do you think we're going to do.

0:22:06I think almost all of us would have guessed that they were going to do something disruptive or creative

0:22:11or different around pricing because everyone's thinking oh you know Amazon's all into getting things really cheap

0:22:16and maybe maybe they could like revolutionize the phone business by giving you a phone for free

0:22:23or include you know for free supported by ads or include with Amazon Prime or

0:22:28or something like that somehow subsidize the phone to make it very very cheap or free.

0:22:32And what they what they gave us instead was a phone that's priced almost exactly like the i Phone

0:22:38and other smart other high end smartphones because Interesting so you know it's two hundred bucks on contract six fifty

0:22:43without There's a few things that make it a little better value there's like the thirty two gigs of storage is the base

0:22:48storage sort of sixteen you get a year of Amazon Prime if you buy the phone

0:22:55and if you already have it you get your membership extended for a year for free.

0:22:58So there's a couple things that value there

0:22:59but for the most part it's still a six hundred dollars on subsidized phone

0:23:03or a two hundred dollar onto your contract phone. Iran's only on a T.N.T. So far only in the U.S.

0:23:09So it's honestly it's kind of boring.

0:23:12I mean there's a couple things to talk about with what they've done with some of the software and hardware

0:23:16but I don't think we're even going to be talking about this in like two weeks. Yeah probably not.

0:23:24Some of the things that were very interesting.

0:23:25The most interesting thing to me which is gotten less interesting as more information came out.

0:23:30What is one of the slides they showed during their keynote

0:23:34or announcement whatever you call it was unlimited photo uploads to Amazon Cloud Drive

0:23:40and so there wasn't a lot of information that I could glean on it

0:23:43but John Gruber has said that there's only only unlimited photo storage for photos taken with the phone itself.

0:23:53So notably that that completely eliminates videos which are the things that take up the most space and.

0:24:00Additionally anything else is apparently subject to a five cap

0:24:04and I'm not sure the mechanism by which they're deterring is another just you know reaching into X.

0:24:10If data or what have you but.

0:24:12But yeah that that's a somewhat no worthy difference although to be fair the two cameras that we have in the House are

0:24:20two i Phone five S. Is.

0:24:22So in a parallel universe when or where Aaron and I both have Amazon one of what we call ins a fire fire found it

0:24:29when we both have fire phones that could be fine for us because that is all our photos because that's the only cameras

0:24:35we use but I know amongst this crowd we're probably quite the anomaly.

0:24:39Well you know so if you look at look at

0:24:42when Amazon overcharge the Kindle Fire the the first their first Android tablet one of its biggest selling points by

0:24:49far was it was really cheap compared to other under tablet

0:24:53and it was it was like the best two hundred Eleonora tablet you could get for a little while

0:24:58and it was just pretty terrible cause it was a it was pretty bad

0:25:01and the new the newer fires from want to hear are better I haven't actually used them

0:25:05but the newer ones are supposedly better but anyway the big reason people bought it was because it was so damn cheap.

0:25:12And the fire phone doesn't have that So my question is one of the major things this offers above

0:25:20and beyond something like a high end Samsung

0:25:22or H T C phone like if you're obviously it's the same price that everything has an i Phone like you know you get a

0:25:27little bit less of the i Phone for the same price but most people are not going to care. It's close enough.

0:25:32So you're going to two hundred bucks.

0:25:35Either way two hundred bucks on contract for this phone so it's not cheaper than an i Phone It's probably not going to

0:25:41have much if any presence in phone retail stores which is going to really hurt sales and you know why.

0:25:50It's going to be limited in certain ways like all the Google services it doesn't get it is not as far as I know correct

0:25:56me if I'm wrong anybody but all of Amazon's.

0:26:00So far like it doesn't get the Google seal of approval doesn't have to do a play store as far as I know it doesn't have

0:26:06Google Maps Google Now all that cool integration you get on officially you know blessed Android phones.

0:26:13So there's there's a lot of downside to this the upsides are you know it has some Amazon integration with some of their

0:26:19stuff it has some some store integration where you can like pointed at some things

0:26:23and scan stuff to talk about than a minute

0:26:24but I'm kind of wondering why why people are really going to buy this in any significant numbers.

0:26:30Because I don't I don't see the appeal if it was really cheap.

0:26:33Maybe if it had the full Android experience plus Amazon stuff maybe but I don't see I see and

0:26:40when people want to get an officially license Google blessed Phone

0:26:44and i see i Phone are sticking with their i Phone So I'm I'm kind of missing the point of this

0:26:48and I was on kind of like the new Microsoft but only with hardware.

0:26:52You just have to assume now whenever Amazon enters a market with a hardware product just wait until their third try.

0:26:59Right yeah I mean he mentioned that the they can Delphi or tablets

0:27:03or whatever just forget about the first one second one you know like it's going to take them a while to get it right so

0:27:08there's the learning curve there

0:27:10and I just had a thought while you were describing the phone is that phones are kind of like P.C.'s now used to be

0:27:17and that it's no longer a novelty that any company with a reasonable pockets can make one like back in the day if you

0:27:25you know if you're a company technology Haven't you had a lot of money you can make a P.C. Like you buy the C.P.U.

0:27:31As your men tell you buy a motherboard chipset possibly from Intel puzzler

0:27:35and someone else you buy a hard drive from someone you make a plastic case you put a power supply

0:27:38and put a screen on it you know you make a P.C. A lot of people did it was tons of P.C.

0:27:43Companies back before you know consolidation all fell apart.

0:27:46These days it doesn't seem like a big deal for anybody to basically you know build your own i Phone like smartphone

0:27:53Amazon went to all the vendors and people are making all these parts

0:27:56and the phone they made looks I mean if this in phones.

0:28:00I had come up for the i Phone we fall over selves to say how amazing is

0:28:03but now it's you know many seven years later it's not so mazing now it is just a fairly straightforward thing to say.

0:28:11Yeah we can make a phone that looks like a smart phone that has a good C.P.U.

0:28:15That has memory has a life so much as a result battery life as a couple other little features.

0:28:19That's no longer a big deal

0:28:22and obviously it's not quite as easy to make something as good as the i Phone on your first try so we're going to give

0:28:27Amazon three tries to do this or whatever

0:28:29but I guess it's just it's interesting that phones used to be this amazing thing in only amazing Apple can make a smart

0:28:40phone like this and now they're basically like P.C.'s If you want to make one you can make one.

0:28:44And so Amazon is making one I don't know if this is a good move or not

0:28:46but Mark also mentioned disruption of the beginning Lego hope they would do something with pricing to try to disrupt

0:28:53the phone market.

0:28:54I think Amazon it's a problem of the word disruption like

0:28:58when they did that with the tablets they sold the most out of at cost

0:29:01or possibly at a loss certainly not making big profits

0:29:04and undercut everybody like Amazon would give you a nicer screen and more storage for less money than Apple it

0:29:11but I don't think you can.

0:29:13It's kind of weird to call something disruption before it has disrupted anything you could say in attempted disruption

0:29:19but ever wonder says Oh Amazon disrupt the tablet space by selling their product at

0:29:23or below cost as far as we all know because Amazon doesn't tell you sales figures

0:29:28but as far as we all know from sort of just like walking around

0:29:31and how much Amazon is touting things they haven't disrupted the tablet space that much right I mean it's not like

0:29:39because they priced in so low all the incumbents who make a profit on their tablets were put on their heels

0:29:45and said what we can handle this soon were our market share is shrinking Amazon is stealing all our customers.

0:29:51My impression is that that has not happened so their attempt the disruption with that pricing strategy with tablets

0:29:57didn't work I guess they could have done more and say the real problem.

0:30:00If we didn't we weren't radical enough with the price we'll pay you to take and take one of these phones right.

0:30:05But instead there were no directions that are right. Obviously that strategy did not buy our way into the tablet space.

0:30:11Let's try the more conventional strategy of making money by selling things at a profit with subsidies

0:30:18and so that's what it seems like we're doing with the phone I don't think there's any particular reason to favour the

0:30:23stone over the best Android phone you can find or an i Phone and there's many reasons not to.

0:30:29But to Amazon's credit they did of these try to differentiate I mean again it was a version one product assume this is

0:30:35going to be a stinker just like the version on Kindle Fire was

0:30:38but it has interesting things in it you know the multi camera thing in that silly depth perception the parallax

0:30:44and you know the thing for scanning things to buy them on Amazon the Amazon Prime in America listed all the stuff

0:30:51that's way more differentiation than the average crappy Samsung phone has and Samsung felt like crazy.

0:30:57So it could be again like the P.C.

0:30:59Space that all you really need is to pass a minimum threshold of like if we get a C.P.U.

0:31:04We got a hard drive we got memory we had a case of the kind I said we have a couple of differentiators or reputation

0:31:09or a connection with a brand that you like or franchise that you like or whatever and again in movie parlance

0:31:14and that's enough to become a player in the space.

0:31:17I think that's sort of an Amazon game plan is not to rock the market

0:31:22but just to try to be part of the conversation the same way all those P.C. Makers were like hey we're part of the P.C.

0:31:28Market we sell P.C.'s will pick our stripes on them because I was gay way for two thousand and nine

0:31:33and our names will never actually reach that year I got my first computer and it came in the catalogs

0:31:38and it was awesome. Maybe maybe someday we'll have retail stores anyway. That's how I see Amazon's entry here.

0:31:44And so I'm I'm not for or against it.

0:31:47I like more competition in the phone market I don't know what the long term odds are better wake me up

0:31:53when they're on their third phone. I'm guessing a big part of it might be as as weird as the sound I mean.

0:32:00Probably didn't spend much money on us like this

0:32:02and I'm sure they continent they contracted out the even hardware design to somebody else who definitely counted had

0:32:08the manufacturing I think D.C. Made it for them right. Yes So you know they didn't. I didn't invest very heavily in it.

0:32:16I'm guessing the main purpose of this is just like all the other hardware it's just to use Amazon sales

0:32:22and one of the things that this will do if they can get a big presence in the phone

0:32:28and tablet market you know they're already probably there with tablets maybe

0:32:31but if they can if they can if they can get enough of a market presence everybody who develops an Android app will be

0:32:39forced to put their app and Amazon's Android app store.

0:32:43And as far as I know this only works at the answer unless you go the no download if you Kaizen

0:32:48and able to create the setting

0:32:49but I think for the most part you have to have things in an answer because there's no the Google Play Store on this

0:32:54please correct me if I'm wrong chat but.

0:32:57So you know if they get if they get even you know ten percent of the market then it would be pretty unwise for Endor

0:33:02developers to to not develop which not to put their stuff on Amazon asked or

0:33:06and then I'm going to take a nice cut of you know any kind of money flowing through Android apps not theirs

0:33:12historically to hold up but you know there are people that that adds up now

0:33:16and you know there's also the other factors there's four for all of the reasons that Google wanted to make Android

0:33:23and kind of had to make Android the main reasons why were that Google was threatened by by the possibility of somebody

0:33:33like Apple

0:33:33or Microsoft dominating the phone space in a way then than they could like lock out Google services from working on

0:33:41their phones.

0:33:42So Google kind of defensively had to make Android to to give themselves a place for their services to live

0:33:47and thrive so they couldn't ever be locked out of a dominant phone platform

0:33:51or so they tell themselves anyway yesterday so I think Amazon has a similar goal here in that Amazon wants to.

0:34:00Make sure that none of their digital services get locked out of their physical services are probably fine everyone's

0:34:04going to keep buying you know their shampoo from Amazon it's no big deal I don't think Apple cares to interfere with

0:34:11that but it certainly is a risk that that you know maybe Amazon's bookstore or a video store or music store.

0:34:20You know those kind of services could easily get locked out of future eyeless and Google blessed Android

0:34:28and so I think I think they kind of strategically thought this is this is a good idea and

0:34:34and I'm sure I'm sure they'll make enough on it to justify the probably minimal investment they put into it.

0:34:40Maybe but it doesn't need to set the road on fire to succeed you know. Sorry yeah.

0:34:48It you know it doesn't it doesn't need to sell extremely well.

0:34:51It would be nice if it did I'm sure they would they would appreciate having the extra margin to play with because they

0:34:56don't have a lot of margin on most of the other stuff

0:34:58but the reality is I don't think this really is that important for this to sell well

0:35:03and I don't think it will sell well there and it's the I mentioned in passing earlier

0:35:06but it's definitely worth retiring this is also US only mostly because most Renaissance services are still U.S.

0:35:12Only or at least very limited outside of the U.S. And so as long as this is U.S.

0:35:17Only it's going to extremely limited its market share especially since it is actually in price in the U.S.

0:35:24As a lot of much better phones.

0:35:25I think it is a good idea I mean don't you you said you know whether this is good I think it is a good idea it is a

0:35:30good idea for it was a good idea for Amazon to make tablets. It's a good idea for them to make a phone.

0:35:34I mean despite the fact that I guess I don't think the tablets are really tearing up the charts.

0:35:39Again we don't know for sure give them a lot of like to release numbers

0:35:42but I think it's a good idea for them to make a phone because because it is like P.C.'s

0:35:46and now I want why shouldn't they have a phone why shouldn't they have a tablet Why should it's part of their ecosystem

0:35:50they sell they sell you things you can consume on that tablet so it's good to have a tablet.

0:35:55They also sell you things that you can consume on the phone

0:35:57and you can use both of those devices to buy things from the.

0:36:00Physical store they have a cohesive story around these things

0:36:03and I think it was a good idea for them to develop it because I think this was more

0:36:07or less the right time where they can just you know put it together out of off the shelf parts and some innovation

0:36:12and I think it probably didn't vest in it because I think they you know it makes sense for them to have these pieces of

0:36:18the package

0:36:19and not rely on other people for these because it makes sense for their business not totally out there like they've

0:36:23decided to make you know self driving cars or something.

0:36:26Yeah but I still think like it was a good year for them to make this no question

0:36:31and since they were already making tablets an argument in the SO S.

0:36:34I'm sure there's a lot of shared development resources there anyway

0:36:37but I'm sure they are most definitely spent way more on software development and harbor development

0:36:42and they can probably use most of that in their tablet effort.

0:36:45The difference here is you know phones

0:36:47and tablets are very different markets as a lot of people have found that over the last few years especially most of

0:36:52the early attempts at Android tablets on this it's a very very different.

0:36:56These two are very different markets and what works in phones doesn't necessarily work in tablets and vice versa

0:37:02and was on was able to break in the tablet market by being extremely aggressive on price.

0:37:07Nobody was buying the Kindle Fires

0:37:09and still today nobody's buying the Kindle Fires because they're the best tablets because they're not they're certainly

0:37:15better than they used to be but they're still not the best habits.

0:37:17People buy them because they're cheap and they see them promoted like crazy on Amazon.

0:37:21This phone is going to be part of the creation Amazon fine

0:37:24but it's not cheap it's cheap though I mean especially for people who are using the i Phone right.

0:37:32But when people are shopping for Android phones

0:37:34and anyone is willing to pay two hundred dollars for the same for phone shops this two hundred dollar phone to get any

0:37:39competitive two hundred dollars phone assume they're not going to buy an i Phone because they're not in that market at

0:37:43all speculative and feature wise.

0:37:47This compares favorably with any with the of that with another two hundred dollars Android phone

0:37:52and I think that's the big conversation they're trying to win they're like oh we're not going to be with people who are

0:37:57shopping for an i Phone because this is the ecosystem the cache. No the apps like we're not there for get it right.

0:38:02But there's tons of crappy Android phones and I mean you look around.

0:38:05Mostly what I see is people with i Phones or people with a huge menagerie of crazy are going to Android phones.

0:38:11That's that's the jungle where the phone is stalking

0:38:15and it's got a nice screen it's got a lot of RAM It's got a fast C.P.U.

0:38:19Got crazy has cameras that are going to impress people in a demo somewhere

0:38:22when they see someone who has one the camera is pretty good right like it's got all sorts of stuff

0:38:27and the crazy things

0:38:28or the tilt scrolling in the parallax reminds you of the stupid crazy features like in the Galaxy S five that no one's

0:38:33ever going to use that track your eyes when you close your eyes the video stops

0:38:37and you know how to touch the screen like that. People go for that crap.

0:38:40And so this it in that crap show

0:38:43and even though it's not super cheap it I think it compares like it compares favored to the i Phone Let's put that way

0:38:50in terms of pricing and specs and I think they're going after the people who care about gee whiz features

0:38:55and also the people who care about stupid number specs not against the i Phone or no one cares about the specs

0:39:01when they buy an i Phone They're buying an i Phone have an i Phone and to buy into that whole system.

0:39:05You know what if you are living not near family members and you really want to smartphone

0:39:13and your family members that live nearby that are really good with computers.

0:39:18So your family members that are really good with computers don't live nearby

0:39:21and you feel kind of all in your own little island and you want something that you know you can get help with it

0:39:27and maybe you don't live near an apple an apple store.

0:39:30This made a thing I'm fairly surprised that the Mayday in the tablets hasn't made more waves

0:39:38and I could very much see like say my grandmother for example who is fairly computer savvy especially for a woman that

0:39:45is not terribly young but she lives near no one in terms of her family members that are good with computers

0:39:52and so I can absolutely see her wanting this if nothing else for the maybe feature so she knows within fifteen seconds

0:39:59she can have. Oh and I can see that as being very powerful.

0:40:03That's a clever use of Amazon strength because their strength is like physical logistics.

0:40:07Having a human being on the other end of a phone is a physical matter it's not a matter of software or servers

0:40:13or whatever.

0:40:14An Amazon does it all the time and they're all about people and physical things

0:40:18and managing things that are ridiculous scales.

0:40:20So they were wise to bring to bear the skills they have from their retail business on the phone the same way Google is

0:40:26wise to bring to bear all of its great assets like you know it's really you know good maps and

0:40:31and driving directions and their server capacity

0:40:33and all their web apps like everyone is bringing their best stuff to the table you know I think this does make sense

0:40:39and I don't think this will necessarily like if you were to buy this phone.

0:40:44I mean maybe it has nothing to compare it to wouldn't matter

0:40:46but I don't think experience to be that great this is version one and Amazon in my mind I try to tweak this

0:40:51but I can figure out a way to tweet out a tweet in a way that would express myself so I'll try just by rambling here.

0:40:57Unfortunately my perception of Amazon now whenever I think of them

0:41:02and I think of Jeff Bezos surveys us like Glenn you got to tell me how to pronounce a name I don't know up on the stage

0:41:08is Amazon has a really good demos and everything they show is much crappier in real life.

0:41:13I got another tragedy not getting that impression but like after several of these demos feels like

0:41:18and sometimes they're OK In real life like you know the Kindle Paperwhite really was more

0:41:22or less like what they showed but like all of their Fire tablets and now the phone

0:41:26and a lot of the Kindles they've demo they do really good keynotes

0:41:29and you look at them like wow I can't believe Amazon pulled this off they've got the features they've got the specs

0:41:34they've got the design everything is amazing when you see the actual product

0:41:37and it's like well you know if you like we could pull the wool over your eyes

0:41:42and that's the reputation they're getting in my mind so much so that I'm kind of tuning out the what are very good

0:41:47presentations and fairly polished and like you know not thing to say in the Steve Jobs file

0:41:51but obviously you know in the post Steve Jobs presentation world adding their own twist.

0:41:55But now I'm just starting to write though that that's a tech person type thing but anyway right.

0:42:00Well you know going to know what their presentations are like

0:42:02but I feel like real people once they get them will be like the same way they

0:42:06when they get the Alex a Galaxy S five like you play with a little with the features that you're never going to use

0:42:10again in the end you have kind of a crappy ugly phone. The river after two years.

0:42:14See but what makes you think that anyone would find it to be crappy

0:42:19and ugly because on the surface especially if you don't have something as well designed as perhaps modern Android

0:42:26or certainly an i Phone if you like you said if you don't have anything to compare to then how would you conclude that

0:42:31it's not crappy. The Samsung say it's crap.

0:42:35I think I think the Amazon's industrial design is better as ridiculous as the original Kindle Fire was in terms of size

0:42:42and weight and everything.

0:42:43Industrial Design is not bad like it was you know pleasingly shape that made it to the power buttons are in the wrong

0:42:49place. We all know that but like that they have rubber parts in the right spot.

0:42:53I am of the UN is the head we had really great screens.

0:42:55The problems of course are in software and ecosystem in kind of using the devices not as wonderful

0:43:00and magical as you would expect that they miss on a lot of the details like well you can have an amazing screen

0:43:05and a quad core G.P.U. and Twice the RAM of any i OS Apple device please Apple fix this place.

0:43:12But it doesn't matter if

0:43:13when you click the scroll it's jumping like how did you jump you got twice as many cores we had twice as much ram.

0:43:18It's like it takes a lot of effort and coordination between hardware and software to make all that come together.

0:43:24You know how can Apple get away with having half as many choruses the top and Android phones

0:43:29and yet it still feels faster and does things quicker.

0:43:32That's where those guys can compete and that's what I mean by like that.

0:43:35I think compared to fine but once I go into an Apple store and start looking around on an i Pad or.

0:43:41And i Phone I think even pressing a bit like oh my my thing doesn't feel like this.

0:43:46Well I'm going back a sec to Mayday.

0:43:49I do think that that's probably Amazon's best feature if it even works half as well as the demos.

0:43:56That's an amazing feature and that will win over a lot of people.

0:44:00Especially people like us who are possibly in the position of buying the phone for someone else that we don't want to

0:44:06have to tech support.

0:44:08You know that's that I can see I can see the benefit of

0:44:10but there's also the other side of that which is made they can only help you with problems that involve the phone being

0:44:18able to boot and show the screen contents

0:44:21and going to say I like the comparison as I like to tell people the Apple stuff because then if they have any problem I

0:44:27say just go to the Apple store.

0:44:29Exactly and that's a thing like you know maybe well maybe as great as long as the phone can boot the screen works

0:44:36and it can connect to a data network or wife I.

0:44:39All of those things has feature and that will solve a lot of problems no question.

0:44:43But there's also a whole class of other problems that people routinely hit with their phones that may they won't be

0:44:49able to solve or want what they want they will access it and

0:44:52and there is immense value in Apple having this giant network of retail stores

0:44:58and in being able to walk into like an A.T.M.

0:45:00To the store with your Samsung phone that you bought there

0:45:02and you know get some help there like there's there's a massive massive value in in being able to go to a physical

0:45:10place and get service and you know in the case of you know the phone network stores aren't that great about this

0:45:15but in the case of an Apple store you could walk out of there with a replacement like you could go to your phone could

0:45:21break in the morning.

0:45:22You could go to the Apple Store at lunch

0:45:25and if there's not too big of a line you can walk out of there with a replacement in a half hour.

0:45:30And that's something that Amazon can can approach that they can you know they can have you be able to call them up

0:45:36and then they can overnight you a new phone maybe you know maybe we'll see about that

0:45:39but that's still a very that's a very different degree to very different kind of experience

0:45:42or to talk on the phone to somebody who need to talk them through the problem

0:45:46and then Amazon has to decide whether to send you a phone and send you a phone that arrives the next day

0:45:50or by drone later that day who knows.

0:45:52But it's still it's a different it's a different problem

0:45:55and there's just such immense value in having those retail stores there now.

0:46:00Now granted there's also a whole class of problems where like you might just live with it like if you're somebody who

0:46:06doesn't know the technology very well and you're like oh well for whatever reason you know my mail is all blue

0:46:12and I don't know why

0:46:13but it's not really worth going all the way to the Apple Store for that well maybe you know on it's on the kindle thing

0:46:18maybe you would you know hit the media butt

0:46:19and say hey why is this all blue can you help me change this back you know so there's you would be able to get better

0:46:24help with a lot of small problems like that using Mayday But you know phones

0:46:30and those are even more so than tablets phones get carried around people so phones have a lot of hazards happen to them

0:46:34in a lot of things that are weird that break and

0:46:36and so I see that being a problem for Amazon people what you're not considering is that both of you are taking a

0:46:43completely myopic North-Eastern view of the world because the nearest Apple Store to like half of Virginia is either in

0:46:53another state or easily two hours away. I mean I'm lucky in that there happens to be an Apple store in Richmond.

0:47:00But outside of Richmond like let's take Charlottesville for example which is an hour west of where I am.

0:47:06You can either come here to Richmond or go two hours north to D.C.

0:47:10and Charlottesville Zay not small city I mean it's Virginia classifies it as a city.

0:47:16Well OK you can be all the smog in Miami because you live in the northeast.

0:47:21The look of the population of Charlottesville

0:47:23and save it for the larger than the population of where I went to high school and perhaps it's not

0:47:28but I think you're way way overselling the utility of Apple stores because if you're lucky enough to live near one.

0:47:36Yes you're absolutely right. But most of the country doesn't and beyond that most of the world doesn't.

0:47:43So that's wonderful that you guys have forty four Apple stores within a ten minute drive.

0:47:47But I've got only one option

0:47:49and if I lived an hour away it would be an hour drive to get to the nearest Apple store an hour drive maybe in my

0:47:56busted assed car that can barely get up the highway. I mean.

0:48:00I'm being a little dramatic but my point is Apple's retail footprint is really consequential.

0:48:05Now this is where you would say well there's one thousand nine hundred foot print

0:48:08and yes you're right about that eight hundred He's a lot more stores we're not going to get the same level of service

0:48:12and repair it in one thousand nine hundred or that you would have an Apple store.

0:48:15So I think you're grossly overselling like yourself are body bags I said I was going to say Apple Store is the best

0:48:20case scenario but leave Apple Store aside normal people get their phones the quote unquote phone stores

0:48:26and they're everywhere in every strip mall probably even in Charlottesville.

0:48:30And those are not a great place to bring your phone back to

0:48:32but it's still a place to bring a phone back to his once Grandma gets that phone from Amazon.

0:48:38She doesn't know where to take that when it doesn't work

0:48:40and then every volves especially tech support calling someone on the phone

0:48:43and try them in Amazon is generally good at that maybe that's also going down on strengths

0:48:47but Amazon for all their physical It just takes is not in the retail if the physical brick

0:48:52and mortar retail store business for what I think are obvious reasons of sort of the opposite of what Amazon is so

0:48:58they're going to sell you physical product it's all about them trying to make the experience really good like I can I

0:49:03can do text chat I can do email

0:49:05or I can call someone on a phone to arrange for me to return this thing to them in a package.

0:49:11Either I shipped myself or they sent me a box and they ship it back and all that other stuff

0:49:16and that has to compete with going to the phone store at the strip mall that's five minutes away going to the Apple

0:49:21Store the nearby me if I live near a big city if you live don't you live near anything then maybe Amazon is the way to

0:49:29go but I don't know.

0:49:31It's the maybe Peter I think is is a good selling point and Amazon was smart to put it in there

0:49:39but it's competing against those those other possibilities for getting help

0:49:43and as someone said in the chat room mom can get tech support in fifteen seconds too

0:49:47but it's a Face Time call to me that if you are calling you on the phone

0:49:51and that's that's what we're waiting as the technically savvy people with relatives who are waiting like what do I tell

0:49:57my relative or my non tech savvy friend.

0:50:00Get so that they don't call me in the middle that I because they're having a problem or when they do call me.

0:50:05I don't have to debug it I can tell them. Just take your phone back to the store.

0:50:08Just go to the Apple store or just go to the web page and Amazon and decide whether you want to call them e-mail them

0:50:15or text them

0:50:16and they'll arrange for you to return the thing that's really all we want to not be bothered with certain people.

0:50:20We want we want them to get a solution and we're not going to try to debunk it remotely.

0:50:24Maybe we can go over their house and try to figure it out over and over

0:50:26but once that's happened it's all that I think May Day in the cases where everything is working.

0:50:32It's great just to have another human there to talk to who is who is getting paid to help you with your thing

0:50:37and that will help you not send a Face Time request to your child.

0:50:43It's also very smart of Amazon to do this because the kind of thing that their competitors really can't.

0:50:50Microsoft probably could

0:50:52but Apple really can't because it would just be way too big of an operation because they way too many people have i

0:50:59Phones It would be a nightmare to support and scale that and at the at the i Phone sales volume

0:51:06and Google kind of can't because well first of all they they hate people and don't understand them

0:51:11and second of all like how would Google like how do you even pay for that.

0:51:16The way androids whole model is set up like they have a hard time supporting that really

0:51:22and you know even if they were in the business of applying lots of human powered things which they're definitely not

0:51:29Microsoft could maybe do it for the same reason Amazon can do it which is they don't sell them any phones like Amazon

0:51:34actually lucky

0:51:35and a lot of these things that like for example one of the reasons why they were able to do you like certain screens

0:51:42and some of the Kindle Fire H.D.X.

0:51:43and Stuff like that is because they're at small scale they can use components that don't have very good yields that

0:51:50aren't being produced in very high volume because they can't be things that like for Apple put something in an i Phone

0:51:56They're going to need one hundred million of them in a month like they can't you know.

0:52:00They can't do that and so this is this is a very smart move from Amazon of doing doing something that they can do

0:52:08and that and that kind of only they can do.

0:52:12So anyway let's move on to our second sponsor before we forget too it's been almost an hour our second sponsor is a

0:52:18return sponsor.

0:52:19It's our friends at hover hover is the best way to buy and manage domain names you know

0:52:26but simply a man ignore the three page three pages and you know I'm not very good with paper but Thanks Marilyn.

0:52:33Yes So however is it I mean because rather than suck basically they have all sorts of features all sorts of plans all

0:52:41sorts of products you can buy hosting you can by e-mail you can buy domain names

0:52:46and I can speak to the most with I do use their email service it's great it works for some of the mains

0:52:54and mostly I use them as a demeanor to star and that's I think their main business

0:52:58and you go there they have tons of T.L.B. Is very very very complete inventory of T.L.B.

0:53:04That they support you can get pretty much anything.

0:53:08Even the stupid new ones they support although all those that are out so far they support all those so it's a great

0:53:14start and they don't try to screw with.

0:53:15They don't have all these like big add ons and gimmicks

0:53:18and like you know boxes that say like you know uncheck this to not opt out of not being billed for the privacy blocking

0:53:26protection service and like what what is what is that do I have to check this am I going to get charged for this.

0:53:32They basically have seen defaults to well designed. They also have amazing support.

0:53:37They have a no holds no weight no transfer phone bill phone support policies so yeah you can e-mail them if you want

0:53:43you can fill it up or take it.

0:53:44They have knowledge bases online if you want but you can also just call them

0:53:48and if you call during business hours a person just picks up the phone and talks to you and they can help you.

0:53:53There's you don't have to wait on hold.

0:53:55You know what to do one of those annoying push button menus or even the more annoying talking menus.

0:53:59Boy do I hate those. You can either call them and a human being picks up and talk to you. Hover is fantastic.

0:54:06I view them myself watchable use them there's a reason why they sponsor tons a podcast of their cool First of all

0:54:12and also because they know that you guys value the stuff you know the audience values services

0:54:17and products that aren't trying to rip them off

0:54:18and they're actually brought in good service good quality so good over dot com

0:54:22and you can get ten percent off your first order by using the new coupon code this month. Let me get that for you.

0:54:31What I knew you wouldn't get it. I got nothing. You'll get it later anyway. Go to her and use coupon code.

0:54:40Let me get that for you for ten percent off and we'll see if anybody ever gets that this week.

0:54:46Please you know Casey if you do know don't e-mail me oh my god.

0:54:49Let me get that for you all one word all lowercase no spaces no punctuation.

0:54:54Thanks what a hover for sponsoring our show once again.

0:54:57So I'm looking at the I'm still frustrated with you two I'm looking at the Boston metro area

0:55:03and there are by my count one two three four five six maybe seven Apple stores within what is this one twenty eight

0:55:11that runs around Boston.

0:55:12But one thing I'd like to know based on your race here so yes by by geographic area Apple Stores don't serve a lot of

0:55:19people but what percentage of the U.S.

0:55:22Population is within driving distance of an Apple store

0:55:25and then also what percentage of the population most likely to buy an i Phone is within driving distance of an Apple

0:55:31store.

0:55:32Well the second the first one I'll give you the second one I won't even let me finish my thought real quick which is to

0:55:36say that the Boston metro area has six Apple stores the entire state of Ohio has six Apple stores it also has less

0:55:44people than the Boston metro area probably does

0:55:48but if you don't live on I seventy one is this that runs from southwest Ohio to northeast Ohio then kindly piss off

0:55:54because there is no apple store near you. So anyway so the point is it's there's a lot of there's a lot of them.

0:56:00Like the entire What is Nebraska South Dakota North Dakota Montana Wyoming like none of them have an Apple store.

0:56:09They do i missed it.

0:56:10Those are all green states in any case and your point about population density is fair

0:56:16but I also wonder like what do you think Apple Store popped up in a larger city in Wyoming.

0:56:23Assuming such a thing exists which I'm sure it does but I can't think of any

0:56:27but anyway let me cap off the geography thing that I just bothered to look up.

0:56:30Well us were discussing where stores are in the United States population.

0:56:35The Charlottesville is apparently about forty four thousand people it should be some really if the population of

0:56:41Smithtown New York or I went to high school is one hundred seventeen thousand people.

0:56:46So just cut I'm surprised you have a fair point I'm surprised ruthless that's not how you know that as well if you look

0:56:53at Richmond the Richmond metro area not Richmond itself a virtue metro area I think is a couple million

0:56:57and we have a Apple store but you have an Apple store anyway.

0:57:03Thank you so Margaret said a while back about taking advantage of the fact that there aren't a lot of them like they

0:57:10can afford the fancy screen because their volumes are low and they can afford to do maybe a prison because

0:57:15and I guess a lot of these are the very least they're starting from zero so the be a growth curve isn't like Apple

0:57:19where on day one you're going to tend to send sell ten million of these things where they sell

0:57:23and then you've got a big problem with Mayday right you just can't handle like passenger without working up to it

0:57:29and this gets into the the problems with the concept of unlimited A lot of people are tweeting about

0:57:34when they're talking about the unlimited photo storage in case you already noted what Gruber tweeted about it not

0:57:38really being unlimited is like all is going on that if you take them on the on the phone if you have an existing

0:57:43library pictures then you know you have subject to five you could buy cap maybe the charge you above that

0:57:49and you get the second homes gosh and we always have where it's like I just want someone to take care of my crap and

0:57:55and then you hear about it you know like well that would take care of my crap and you know details

0:57:58and there's always weird rules.

0:58:00You've got to remember this NIE I remember that in this is free and this is for paying us for that thing

0:58:04and a lot of people aren't going to are saying this is a problem is unlimited It's like it's pointless it's never

0:58:10really give me unlimited if you ever see the word unlimited run the other direction it's just for people who who used

0:58:16too many resources and it's not like the way things should be

0:58:20and I think that's too extreme a reaction because I think the thing that we all want someone to take care of our

0:58:26pictures for us can be done and will be done eventually.

0:58:30It's not the unlimited part that's bad it's the complexities of like someone who wants to put a limit on the sly

0:58:35but doesn't want to commit commit to that right and it's not like oh you're going to get something for nothing

0:58:38and a great example is our frequent sponsor back plays where it's unlimited but they charge you a monthly.

0:58:45It's a low monthly fee and they figured out how to.

0:58:47Presumably they figured out how to run a business where we charge people low monthly fee.

0:58:51We give them unlimited really is unlimited

0:58:53and the way it works out is that most people don't have a lot of data in the average works out so that we're able to

0:58:57make money. We're also sponsored this week by Bakley how serendipitous really actually most of it is now.

0:59:06Backless is five dollars a month unlimited

0:59:09and uncomplicated online backup you can try it for free with no credit card required.

0:59:16Literally it's five bucks a month. I'm an online backup. It's very very simple they have a mac native client.

0:59:21It's actually founded by X.

0:59:23Apple engineers so they're they know the mac sensibilities their software is really nice

0:59:27and you can actually access your files from anywhere they have this cool I less app where you can you can access any

0:59:34files backed up on back plays from anywhere you are so if you're like you know on vacation somewhere you want to access

0:59:39the files on your home computer as long as you're back on tobacco is that files there

0:59:43and you can do it you can get to it right there you can also get email notifications for peace of mind to know that

0:59:49you're being backed up

0:59:50and to know if for example if something is not being backed up for a certain time they can email you

0:59:54and tell you that which is very nice to know. Bakley is by far the simplest on a backup.

1:00:00Use use install it and it does the rest.

1:00:02And really like I have a lot of data in back plays

1:00:06and I've had trouble with other services not accepting it fast enough because I have a print of three I'm here with

1:00:11finally getting fires.

1:00:13I waited my whole life to live somewhere that has files and I finally do and it's glorious

1:00:18and I some of the services I couldn't they wouldn't accept the uploads quickly enough.

1:00:22But back please I don't have that problem.

1:00:25BAKLEY except the others as quickly as I said it to and you can send it to you know be kind to your connection

1:00:30or you can set it to just decide for itself how much it should use

1:00:33and I've never had a prob that I've never had a problem and it uploads quickly and I have between me and my wife

1:00:40and my mom. We probably have a total of about four and a half terabytes worth of stuff there and it's fantastic.

1:00:47Five bucks a month per computer. Unlimited space. Simple as that. Go to back Blaze dot com slash A.T.P.

1:00:54and You can get a free trial no credit card required. Thanks a lot to back please.

1:00:59You really need online backup if you are not backing up online

1:01:02and you have the option to pass it in the bandwidth to do it. You really really really need to do it.

1:01:06I know some places you don't have good get upstream

1:01:09or you have will ban with caps that's fine you are you are kindly excused

1:01:12but everybody else you should really be doing this.

1:01:15There are so many backup problems that this can be a nice safety net for things you know things are going to happen to

1:01:20your house if you have you know just your computer

1:01:23and Time Machine drive put into it then like electrical problems fires floods that all sorts of crazy stuff water

1:01:29flooding from the apartment above you like all sorts of crazy this can happen that can take out all of your copy of

1:01:34your data if it's only in your house so really you are also back up and back which is in my opinion is the best one.

1:01:39Go to back please dot com slash A.T.P.

1:01:41Thank you very much

1:01:43and I think the backplate has going for it is that they get to use the word unlimited which takes away the stress from

1:01:51from anybody really

1:01:52but from certainly from high capacity like high demand users you don't want to know is there a limit am I going to hit

1:01:58the limit to do I had to wear red.

1:02:00And even casual use issue if there is a limit they may not have any sort of conception of how much data they have likes

1:02:05of like do I have that much data. How much is a gigabyte. Will I had that much data in five years I doesn't matter.

1:02:10That totally never going to reach the cap if they don't understand that it can cause them hesitant so unlimited gets

1:02:16rid of that anxiety of like I don't have to worry about how much stuff I have

1:02:20and then the only job you have to do after that is make the financial arrangement both attractive

1:02:26and easy to understand

1:02:27and this Amazon arrangement is not easy to understand I would never have guessed that only the photos taken by phone

1:02:32count or the limit of the five gigabyte cap maybe I can buy stuff

1:02:35and going to import my existing for a collection of all

1:02:37but it's already too complicated you know back places we charge a fee per month it is a small fee.

1:02:43People are willing to pay it.

1:02:45The average data stored by our customers is enough that we make money at that price it's easy to understand.

1:02:50Five dollars a month unlimited something like that.

1:02:53For photos it doesn't have to be we'll star all your photos for free.

1:02:56Unlimited doesn't mean free and unlimited just means you know more anxiety about

1:03:01but what about these photos boy about those photos I take here what about my existing stuff

1:03:05but will you keep the rose at full resolution will you downsampled them is there a thirty day window is there like all

1:03:11that crap and anxieties to go away

1:03:13and then the company just needs to find some way to pay for that whether by charging a reasonable monthly fee

1:03:18or incorporating it into some other service or subsidize the river

1:03:21and so we were all briefly excited by the Amazon thing.

1:03:25Now we're all on excited about it it's just another solution that is too complicated and too weird

1:03:29and it's going to leave people in situations where they're not sure their stuff is safe

1:03:33and where in reality probably won't be safe.

1:03:35All right so I actually if we if we have the time Jesus will permit me I would actually like to talk now about

1:03:42continuity and I think it plays into some of the sort who were just talking about.

1:03:47So continuity is a feature during the keynote of the demo where between your sanity and i O S nine and.

1:03:54or eight yeah I was eight and now apparently possibly even the Apple T.V.

1:04:00There are features where you can for example start doing something in an app and one of these devices

1:04:04and then go to another one of your devices and pick up where you left off

1:04:08or do crazy things like take a phone call on your mac and stuff like that or tree

1:04:13and transfer to an e-mail as you're writing it between your phone or your computer.

1:04:17All these different things that involve basically passing off tasks from one computer to from one computer

1:04:22or device to another one seamlessly and one of the reasons I think this is smart you know this one of the theory

1:04:30or one of the themes where Apple tends to not do so well and this this doesn't actually apply just Apple

1:04:38but were Apple terms

1:04:39and not do so well is trying to go past what they're good at trying to do a really big new project in an area that they

1:04:48are really really not good at.

1:04:49And so one of the best examples of this obviously is maps where you know maps of the kind of area where Google is

1:04:55really good at the at the at the kind of like Big Data Integration massive scale data collection

1:05:01and resolving conflicts between different sources of data and ranking things and and finding relevance

1:05:07and Google is really really good at that kind of problem.

1:05:11And so when Google tackles that kind of problem they can do it very well and very few others can.

1:05:16Apple tried to tackle the problem with maps and i O. S.

1:05:18Six five six six and and famously did not do very well at it and it's certainly better than it was

1:05:26but it's still not to Google level of quality and honestly probably never will be.

1:05:31And so you know you can look at things that you can see are these are kind of areas where where Apple's weak

1:05:37and I mentioned right before the pre

1:05:39or before last topic how I thought it was very good of Amazon to recognize one of their strengths

1:05:47and do something in it made a do something that the other people kind of can't do in the business can't or won't do.

1:05:55And so what Apple has done with continuity I think.

1:06:00Is the same kind of strategic thing where continuity is the kind of thing that Apple actually can do very well.

1:06:07Yes it uses i Cloud but I think it mostly actually is a local networking I think it would use a Bluetooth L.-E.

1:06:12To do some of the initial handshaking and probably probably doesn't go over the network

1:06:16or over the the LAN with it has to so I think to jump in my recollection of the video I watched was it negotiates over

1:06:26Bluetooth Ellie and then it did the amount of data you can send back

1:06:31and forth is like the State of the world is almost non.

1:06:35So it it stablish is proximity using the truth Ellie

1:06:38and then you have to use some other mechanism of your choice including a stream that I believe they can open between

1:06:45devices actually that might be over Bluetooth as well

1:06:48but anyways by some other mechanism you have to establish like What the crap is you're working on

1:06:52and what you're doing

1:06:54but the proximity awareness bit is due to selling in this is freakin terrible for me because both of my Macs are late

1:07:01twenty Levon Macs and they don't have political energy and I'm very sad.

1:07:05Don't worry though they'll eventually be replaced inabilities those cool stuff

1:07:09and said no no just talk to any macro owners in the last few years who ever had to use airdrop

1:07:15and realize they can't do it because of the NIH proas sold anyway.

1:07:20So this is the kind of thing this involves you know local networking with high end ran New controlled hardware

1:07:26and passing around the Internet. Very small bits of information in very large volume.

1:07:33That's what push notifications are that's what I message is that's a kind of Apple is already doing this stuff at scale

1:07:39and doing it very well.

1:07:40Most of the time and so like this and it requires a very deep you know top to bottom integration of the hardware

1:07:50and the software and the services it requires people who buy multiple devices from the same manufacturer

1:07:56and who actually keep someone up to date. Casey did. So you'll have it'll be cool.

1:08:03And so this is the kind of thing where not only is Apple really good at this sort of thing

1:08:10but only Apple can really do that if you look at you know Google you know

1:08:14and group are a big thing about only Apple is really good

1:08:17and I was I was I was kind of hoping to be more about this when I saw the title.

1:08:22He touches on this but other people are more into it.

1:08:25You know Microsoft can't do this because they don't sell any phones really.

1:08:30And even the computer sales are not doing that great

1:08:33and they can't you know they have this massive their bevy of hardware to contend with

1:08:38and you know what percentage of Windows computers have Bluetooth low energy and what version

1:08:43and all this crazy stuff that they have to do that they have to contend with that Apple doesn't who can't do this

1:08:48because nobody's buying computers and even their tablets are pretty weak

1:08:53and they're also the similar issues of hardware diversity. Michael don't go can't do it now.

1:08:59They'll be able to eventually Apple can do it first so that only Apple can do this.

1:09:02Now it's important qualifier because eventually everyone will be able to do this and they will.

1:09:07Well the direction that that these various companies markets and products and strengths are going.

1:09:13I don't I don't see a future where nobody else can do this really well I mean like if it's a useful thing to do they

1:09:20catches on all the other players will develop some kind of open standard for doing it

1:09:24and eventually all the hardware will catch up in many years and like it the same thing with everything else.

1:09:28Only Apple can make the i Phone one but today Amazon can slap the other a phone that essentially looks

1:09:34and behaves to a regular person's perspective like the I thought of one.

1:09:37Hopefully maybe a little bit better for you but maybe not wealthy

1:09:41but you know I mean like there's a big lead time Apple has an advantage

1:09:44but it's mostly a temporal advantage not a qualitative advantage ever and it will eventually be able to.

1:09:51So yes this is just about what you'd be doing doing the things that they can do before anyone else can do them because

1:09:55they have more control than ever else and even Apple is kind of in the in Congo situation was like pork.

1:10:00So you know you got to have a new ish Maggie because the chipset needs to do whatever

1:10:03and you got to have a device with a lightning connector you sorry i Pad three users like me and you know all this.

1:10:08There are other even even with Apple's world

1:10:12and how fast they get everyone upgraded everything there is like the strength of Apple is doing it to centrally as soon

1:10:17as they possibly can

1:10:18and will see if this feature is like a killer feel like that's what you need if this is a feature that people really

1:10:23want.

1:10:23Then everyone else will eventually copy if it turns out to be something that's kind of OK

1:10:27but maybe not important enough for the other guys to go through the effort to copy then oh well

1:10:31but Apple has will have the advantage of the first mover advantage that it so they like to have.

1:10:35Yeah I think really ultimately this is the kind of thing that Apple is going to be the only game in town that really

1:10:43does it in any effective widespread way for the foreseeable future I really don't see that change anyway.

1:10:49I also worry too a bit like when networking is turn to the next is I agree with like devices and hardware

1:10:55and software just on those devices.

1:10:57Apple that happens we'll house but once you get anything involving the network I just have bad flashbacks I mean

1:11:03and like messages which I've been using much more lately because you see everyone's using messages

1:11:08and I was you know I guess last year I was doing it to maybe use messages way more

1:11:13and I kind of I'm still using it I've been using Mars in space this is my wife got.

1:11:18Maybe the i Phone five that she had before us

1:11:20but anyway I find myself using messages on the mac I find myself using it on my i Pod my kids via message account so I

1:11:26use them to talk to them on their various i Pods and i find the program maddening.

1:11:31Like it doesn't fill the basic function of writing text box I can type in do it's

1:11:35and now having a massive shop somewhere else some absurd percentage of the time it says not delivered

1:11:40and they are there to do is tap the exclamation point to try again and it says not delivered. Why is not delivered.

1:11:46Will it ever work sometimes I just have to delete that message and send the same message again

1:11:49and that will work I have no idea what it's failing on a basic level so I really hope continuity doesn't actually

1:11:55involve the Internet or any of Apple servers I hope it does ad hoc wife I like airdrop.

1:12:00I don't have to involve internet stuff either

1:12:01and I'm out of the net stuff it screws up I mean just today I thought we'd my time line someone said on one device I

1:12:07had a phone number another device had to lead to the phone number. Now neither device has their phone number.

1:12:13Thanks I like those like stuff like that.

1:12:15Some I know think is hard

1:12:17or whatever I'm just saying like that is outside Apple's still is outside Apple's So I really hope continuity only

1:12:24involves like the airspace and hardware and software that within my arm's reach

1:12:29and does not involve any servers anywhere I know push notification does better

1:12:33but I don't know I haven't I haven't tried it yet so we're all just hoping it will be good there is a potential You're

1:12:39right that potentially this is something that is right in Apple's wheel house.

1:12:42If it's outside it is not very far outside of just you know I get nervous.

1:12:47Yeah I mean that's that's certainly fair

1:12:49but I I really think the people give them a hard time with stuff like i Message weirdness but

1:12:54but you know if you look at things like i Pod key value store push notifications

1:13:00and really most use of my messages I'm message most use of my message I think everything works great

1:13:07and there are these there are like you know the fringes where things fall apart

1:13:11but the I think the bar the bar is low and I message though I could just text like I'm not asking for the world

1:13:17and not sending gifts like Katie is like I'm just just axed and like here's my fallback like in these times

1:13:25when I'm frustrated I can send a message and it's frustrating. I launched a G.

1:13:28Mail app and I send that they send that message as an e-mail

1:13:31and you know I sent every frickin time every second time I send the email

1:13:35and email if I have an internet connection could send the email every single time it has never said could not sent it

1:13:41has never failed. If I have a network connection and that it's tough to compete with that.

1:13:46Like when I find myself going to the G.

1:13:47Mail app

1:13:48or maybe even Apple's own mail app like I going to be if I use Apple's Mail I would have gone to that I message still

1:13:55angers me greatly. Thing is funny because I actually don't have any.

1:14:00Normally she's with i Message I occasionally get like a message failed to send.

1:14:03I only get like either time shifted message or something like that

1:14:09but maybe nine percent of the time I have no issues with my message

1:14:14and so it's so weird to me to hear that you have a ton of problems

1:14:18and you're not the only one that you have you've had to fail to send what is that mean what does that mean failed to

1:14:22send I don't understand what it's probably like I would like an error message.

1:14:25I'm thinking it means that the thing that it tried to send didn't send you I don't like why you have it with a server

1:14:33and I respond like I am not that I'm saying I need the details of like intellectual curiosity I wonder what it is that

1:14:39is not going to be like here's what I would want out of a thing like OK so you can't connect the dots for whatever

1:14:44reason

1:14:45or maybe there's a legitimate reason like some time to think maybe the phone like if their phone is rebooting cannot

1:14:50send this message like this some sort of like they want to show me the delivered message

1:14:54and it say there the phone with everybody can possibly be delivered because you know there's nothing to receive it like

1:14:59maybe that's what it is

1:15:00but even if that's the case which I think is ridiculous by the never really catered to be store

1:15:04and forward like most other I.M.C. Systems are like a Google talk or whatever.

1:15:09Even if that was the case it should be the job of the software.

1:15:12Just say I'll just keep trying don't don't don't worry about it all I won't say it was delivered like a lot to you

1:15:17but you don't have to keep getting the explanation point to try again I'll eventually get sent

1:15:21and want to really be a store and forward like e-mail

1:15:23or like Apparently every other I am message like going on a movable talk

1:15:26or whatever if someone is not on line of all their computers are turned off I can still send a message

1:15:30and the next time it's either the service or turn on one of their devices they'll see my message right.

1:15:34Like that's all I'm asking for it's not it's just tax man. Thanks a lot.

1:15:38Two or three sponsors this week needed need a lifestyle dot com hover and back please and we will see you next week.

1:15:49Now it was accidental. Until you're sitting on the scene and it says to that list and the mighty titles.

1:16:50Did you survive I saw you yelling at the people in the gyro.

1:16:54But right now I want to be bitter and angry and say I'm just not bringing it back but that's immature.

1:17:01So problem this time. So the problem this time was somebody decided to.

1:17:07So I guess web sites may have been a poor choice.

1:17:11It's actually a technically sound choice for the problem is it's not very obvious skated.

1:17:16And because well I guess I could like you know be sixty four and code everything that andare of obfuscation

1:17:21but what was the problem.

1:17:22So the problem was that somebody decided to run a loop of voting for every possible ID

1:17:28and I.D.'s are in a church because I guess it wouldn't be because why do you need a grade

1:17:32or something super complex for an idea. You need any throttling is a defense against an out of service.

1:17:39You don't have any you like there's no I guess the problem is because you know the state to account for what you can do

1:17:46you can keep it a memory I mean like whenever it whenever I've done a great limiter in the application layer I was

1:17:50doing them cash because it's just it's quick it's easy it's like way I know it's fast and

1:17:54and if you if the if you hit the application consists only of launching your you know getting your.

1:18:00Back up to the controller level and you firing off a meme Tasha read Norman

1:18:04and then catching commander other I didn't even get a single process.

1:18:07You know yet if he could just keep it in a way that's the thing though is that well there's two problems one.

1:18:14I mean I'd have to do this all by hand because this is a raw socket to the server by definition that's what a website

1:18:20is and she was the I was the other one was.

1:18:24I realize that vote double vote prevention was totally borked

1:18:28and I it took me a few minutes to realize that all of the votes submissions were coming from ten dot X.

1:18:35Addresses which can't be extorted for a year to notice things exactly like it was like a mini web bootcamp for you my

1:18:45girl cause them with how to make a web.

1:18:47No it's just it's funny because so far abstracted from all of these things that you guys I guess have somehow

1:18:53or another had to worry about but somehow or another by writing web apps.

1:18:57No it's not it's just experience is just the same way you learned all the stuff you learn writing fast X.P.

1:19:03You didn't know before about how to write and I was up.

1:19:05Well there's a different set of things you need to know for web apps it is more fun when you're doing them publicly

1:19:10and it and this can be a whole series of a graduate school for Casey and Web ads just every week.

1:19:17You'll try you'll try and every week the chat room will educate you on something that you didn't account for

1:19:22or didn't do correctly and then the next week you can fix that and you can get a new problem.

1:19:28Well in this thing if like I write web apps for a living which at this point probably sounds like I make a terrible

1:19:32living but the thing is it's so much of it is abstracted so far away from me that I never have to worry

1:19:37but I've also heard for Internet's right not exclusively but generally yes.

1:19:42I've done some public face and stuff

1:19:44but I like things that aren't a target like basically you survive because like there's not people now we have a PA gas

1:19:50and it's a fun little game to target your things so it's fun for them.

1:19:53Just think of how I just think of how incredible your thing will be when forged in the crucible of.

1:20:00By the end of it it will just be completely hardened shell.

1:20:02Unlike so many other crappy things where someone writes a little web app and put that up and get up

1:20:06and says Here you go and then some poor sucker runs that and use it for something really popular

1:20:11and then it falls under the lower your ISP will be battle tested I guess.

1:20:15Or dead one of the battle tested it not ever sitting standing here now actually I feel like just murdering it forever

1:20:22more. But that's very mature of me so I will lick my wounds.

1:20:26I am well I will put bandages on them

1:20:28and I will take another stab sometime maybe next week I had to limit myself in the chat room for like half an hour

1:20:35though because not only was it distracting

1:20:37but I wanted to murder all of them you just need to like for all these things right like failing test cases for all

1:20:43them write a little test for denial of service to test your throttling write a little test

1:20:46or duplicate voting to have you know like do everything that is done to you turn into a test case

1:20:51and so that you'll know that your future changes don't regress and you know blah blah blah.

1:20:55You're right

1:20:56but the thing that that for us that's frustrating about it is this is a box of record votes for the chat room

1:21:04suggestions and votes for the challenges just titles like why am I having to go through all this like why can't we all.

1:21:10Why can't we all just act like an adult or act like adults and behave.

1:21:15But oh no not this crowd I'm wondering what the heck could like you know twenty people in the chat room due to bring

1:21:22down no J S How. Like I've seen the code it's not that complicated.

1:21:27Not going to bring it down that is writing an infinite loop and he's got no throttling end of the Nile virus right.

1:21:32Well I think what happens is at some point actually might be when wraparound like Brent was talking about way back

1:21:39when but anyway there is no way they're making enough requests to make a fifty three bit

1:21:44and it's a wrap around in twenty minutes when I WILL IT.

1:21:46Today the issue was they were just incrementing the idea in trying to place a vote for every successive ID number

1:21:54and eventually that did piss it off and make it fall down you know the.

1:22:00What the hell that are you know there's an acronym a wasp. Yes they do over open web application security products.

1:22:08Oh W A S P as like a list of you know common vulnerabilities and web apps and empty the list every year

1:22:13and you have hit several of them already one of them is exposing your internal ids to the outside world if you know

1:22:19what it's called the some snappy name for it and that's the one with people

1:22:23and command number to try to guess your ids.

1:22:26Well that's what they do but I mean here again like I did conceptually know that many of these things could

1:22:33and probably would be problems but I was perhaps too sore maybe just stubborn

1:22:39but I didn't think that I would need to write like ten thousand lines of No to prevent the chat room from being a bunch

1:22:46of balls and as it turns out I'm going to need to do that or just give up on it

1:22:51and will rely on Brad showed through all the great winter slash Brad set up there is in the package a note that's like

1:22:57a simple rate limiter and stuff like that.

1:23:00Well there is but again because I'm using web sockets not so simple

1:23:03but there's probably like a website its wrapper library that has a rate limiting parameter that you can you know many

1:23:09of the receiving end of your socket you're not going to have a sending

1:23:11and it's all going to be the receiving end that's the thing is I don't have to write my own rate limiting I did a quick

1:23:16cursory search to see if there was anything and I didn't see anything

1:23:20but I did know what thirty second search that tomorrow or some point

1:23:24when I'm less bitter about it all then I'll have a proper think on it.

1:23:27Not that it matters for her show bout or whatever

1:23:29but realistically speaking like for the people who are actually web developers and are

1:23:33and are listening to this this type of thing where a bunch of people are just intentionally attacking the Zap I go I'm

1:23:40glad the app that I'm doing doesn't have that problem.

1:23:43That's I mean you may luck out there but really what you're saying is my app is going to develop an add features

1:23:50and become important in the Central to the people who are using it

1:23:54and then some person is going to stumble across it

1:23:57and break it because it doesn't mean your application is not burnable to the.

1:24:00All will never experience these it just means that if if it's if it's not going to happen now it's going to happen

1:24:07later

1:24:07and later it's going to be worse because you want you want the stuff that if the stuff is ever going to happen in the

1:24:12lifetime of the app you want to happen early because it's not.

1:24:14It happens when the app is been deployed for six months and the entire business relies on it

1:24:18and then some piece of malware or bought or whatever stumbles across your thing or wiped off the face of the earth

1:24:23and that's a much bigger problem when your whole company now relies most after you have millions of customers

1:24:27or whatever you have.

1:24:28Then it would have been if during the early development of this app it had a bunch of jerks attacking it

1:24:34and major harden it again not really relevant to a show bot

1:24:37but I like it is relevant to people building a real app it's like don't stick your head in the sand with everybody get

1:24:43hit by one of these eventually and if you don't and you just you're the lucky

1:24:47or you never got popular enough to be noticed but even if you're not popular just this malware that scans

1:24:51and just you know forces its way into everything and so eventual every web app will be a victim.

1:24:57You know that's the thing is that I had thought since this is a controlled audience which I had assumed were all well

1:25:04behaved I didn't think I needed to do a lot of the things that I would have otherwise done in in my real world in my

1:25:12job world and I just took a lot of shortcuts because I thought well we're all friends here it will be OK.

1:25:18Parent Lena

1:25:19and by the way I know an apology too I think it's Adam Kearney who is already actually quite a while ago put up a pull

1:25:27request on get her because accidental but isn't there

1:25:30but a couple requests to fix an unrelated small issue that we discovered during the show about not refusing titles that

1:25:38are too long and that is the appropriate way to behave not if you didn't break it that's fine

1:25:42but through Throw me a pull request man.

1:25:45Did he submit the source code change as a very long title and hope that that would be funny.

1:25:49That would be the best way to do it but in a persistent so you would never see it

1:25:54and that's on the list is that I'll probably have to set up like some like no sequel.

1:26:00A vase or something just to stuff this in a renowned snuff school case

1:26:03and whatever just because well it's actually in a perfect world I would never need it because the darn thing I'll never

1:26:09crash

1:26:10but well I'm still how how did this take down a note instance this is this is either the worst ad in the world for Heroku

1:26:21small instances or the worst ad in the world for no good or my code

1:26:25but to be honest like like you said this code is pretty straightforward.

1:26:29I mean I don't know I really don't know because I've survived a couple of a couple of links from your site which proved

1:26:38as far as I could tell some pretty serious traffic we talked about that in the past in an Hiroki like us in the past

1:26:43reach out to me and said Oh yeah that was nothing like you your your diner was good to go cruising at like

1:26:49and here they said it was like under a third C.P.U.

1:26:51Usage bandwidth usage your throughput is cetera so I dunno if it's my code if it's the fact that its website gets

1:26:59something as weird as the connection limit on the website could layer somewhere it could be I'm not aware of one

1:27:06but it certainly could be I mean there are so many only submit so many port numbers but I can imagine that's the issue.

1:27:11Well it could be you could guard against him whenever So yeah so but what if I told Michelle about it works

1:27:19and he has been meeting today.