Podcast Search

The Accidental Tech Podcast

71: Security By Guilt

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00If you know me but feed on a fast fast

0:00:02when you're there what of in your ticket to finance you know what you know it's obvious now that Casey There was making

0:00:11fast techs have too many features fitted just simply sent the word you know to everybody who did nine

0:00:15or now Little did I know you thought too big I go I gotta have a way to configure different messages

0:00:20and send them all in but you know just send the word you know push notification done and done.

0:00:28Seriously how can the valley take themselves seriously

0:00:30when I mean what that was a product of the valley I assume right.

0:00:34Mark I was on had departed nine dollars homepage nine a homemade still wins because that venture capital money like he

0:00:41has to actually spend that a trial like grow the business

0:00:43or whatever the million dollar home page I just got the money and it has free

0:00:46and clear like he does not have to invest it into a business he is not expected to hire employees to get off the place

0:00:51like the venture capital money this guy got comes with massive strings attached

0:00:56and he will never be able to fill the what these people want because he's stupid

0:01:00and his business is stupid so the millionaire home page guy still wins for the best business plan of any business in

0:01:06the entire universe and I continue to try to think of some equivalent.

0:01:11Many have tried like the smartest person in the world.

0:01:19Casey had the idea you were trying to do a web site when I went to work for just the web page

0:01:27but that you get your financial investment.

0:01:31Even

0:01:31when he didn't like in one hundred ninety five like his total financial investment in a static web page like hosting it

0:01:37and paying for bandwidth. She must've been like let's say one hundred dollars.

0:01:44Again it's on the millionaire income do we make this the intro. Oh I was already planned doing that yeah.

0:01:51Guy man even if the answer was like five minutes long before we actually get to the real show and I'm OK with that.

0:01:56Yeah when I was a million dollar home pages.

0:02:00These days they can look it up for God's sake it is not hard to find it is still up I hope.

0:02:06It was guaranteed to be a sort of at a time right. So up it's still fast selling posters of it genius. Yeah it didn't.

0:02:16It probably doesn't lose all that data if the server crashed yesterday. Home mean to me.

0:02:21My goodness I have the MS is one aspect of that I guess he had to do something assuming he didn't program this he would

0:02:27have to put in the pixels that they paid for in their places right.

0:02:30I'm pretty sure he did it manually because otherwise it's kind of a layout issue.

0:02:34The box packing problem right right so there is some small component of labor

0:02:38but I have to be sure the the bet of money he was laying on made that labor more bearable.

0:02:45Well this is all and he had to make the image map and links to it I guess. So had he had the right H.T.M.L.

0:02:52and Click buttons in an image editor. Oh yeah this is long before anything more useful than that.

0:02:57You got a mouse over that it was an advanced technology he really put a lot of time in ever not only so I just expanded

0:03:05the I did inspect element on safari

0:03:08and I expanded the map element I think I just crashed the best part of you got like fake kill tips for I guess the days

0:03:15of our brothers didn't do automatic updates and you see the fake one

0:03:18and the real one like the fake one solve the cursor but the real one like it sounded

0:03:21and how many hits a day do you think does get I mean the only bad thing is that a yes he thought kind of small because

0:03:27million dollars doesn't last that long.

0:03:28I'm sure he's already gone through this money or whatever

0:03:30but it's a hell of a start for like starting your adult life at twenty whatever years old he was

0:03:35and so unfortunately he's now in the same situation as rest the world is like I need another idea it's like that if he

0:03:40had done ten million dollar home page he would've been a lot more comfortable.

0:03:42Wait so you see this play out

0:03:44and you see how it's like all loud because he didn't control who bought you know so it's like visually very loud right

0:03:51now but it looks like the web in the ninety's really yeah. His new web his new venture com dot com.

0:04:00If I spent a million dollars and I don't mean as Spurs Twitter account he is the founder and C.E.O.

0:04:06Of calm but is not moving as quickly as the million dollar.

0:04:10No it isn't maybe just like take it down with three simultaneous request has got a little water background

0:04:16and now I'm seeing a cloud background or prepare for your two minute session.

0:04:20Choose your preferred major something or some B.S.

0:04:23Relaxation thing you know the day idea was better and makes people send him money.

0:04:31The site was guaranteed to be online at least through August twenty sixth two thousand and ten.

0:04:36However the aim is to keep the site online forever or as long as humanly possible.

0:04:41Have a host of at the sold out banner.

0:04:42Yeah right if you want to still want to buy things sold out and the minimum purchase was ten by ten

0:04:48or a hundred dollars because a dollar pixel that says I was his only thing is I thought a little bit small because

0:04:54anyone who bought this like I guess he probably did get some private individuals

0:04:57but mostly it's going to be businesses

0:04:59and businesses are willing to spend way more than one hundred dollars on vs boondoggles like this.

0:05:04Even back then where they go yeah definitely.

0:05:07Like I mean I'm not saying you going to got thousands but you could have got you know three hundred

0:05:12or five hundred easy because one hundred to one hundred is under the petty cash threshold even to most businesses in

0:05:17the ninety's you know type of site pixel advertising is on Wikipedia

0:05:23or there are many as opposed to non pixel advertising so see Click on pixel advertising and it's

0:05:29and you end up back on the million dollar home page redirected from pixel had.

0:05:38Marco but I mean I'm three and I let me do some extraordinarily quick follow up the show bought us back

0:05:46and if I was more prepared which I'm not because the show is accidental.

0:05:51I've had some people contributing to it and I know Jeremy banks put a lot of work into it.

0:05:56Kyle Cronin Cronin did and Brad showed. Who runs the show but that actually works.

0:06:03He is also contributed and I'm probably forgetting some people here and there and for that I'm deeply sorry

0:06:07and I really mean that because I didn't pull up the I didn't pull up get her before we started

0:06:12but yes the Shabat is back.

0:06:15We've And by we I mean everyone but me has made some pretty good improvements to it will see a long it lasts.

0:06:22We are currently about two minutes into recording and it hasn't quite died yet

0:06:28but it's been a really good inside it's been a really really cool thing to see people issuing poll requests only bad

0:06:35thing about putting something that's semi popular on the internet and open sourcing it is that unbeknownst to me

0:06:42when people actually pay attention which I'm not used to you actually have some sort of implied time commitment to like

0:06:48look at poll requests and figure things out

0:06:50but that that's a good topic for a show do you have an implied time commitment to do you feel.

0:06:56Obviously you think you do but do you actually that's not for today's topic

0:07:01but I was going to say we could use the standard a standard consulting term

0:07:06and we could put that in the parking lot for now. What wait hold on. That's a real thing.

0:07:11So I spent all day in meetings and I'm about to cry. What is wrong with you people.

0:07:16I'm I regret to say that I do know about the parking lot on the market doesn't the OH MY GOD WHAT.

0:07:24You've already broken my brain like the rest. I said I'm done I can say in the Google I O. Didn't do it.

0:07:32Know that you can prove my brain more than Google I O. Did. That's really saying something.

0:07:36You're welcome you know you should have been doing all this time and you haven't figured it out now.

0:07:41I will give you the hint to help you along that path even though you're being dragged down by the people as it is you

0:07:46had the chat room filled with people who were attacking your bot and everything

0:07:49and how it's going to help improve it and help you improve your code and be educational

0:07:53and entertaining for everyone involved. You should've immediately tried to enlist a faction of people who.

0:08:00For it on your side because it's very easy to get programmers on your side

0:08:03when presented with a problem like a bunch of other people are attacking this program. Help me make it stronger.

0:08:10At least half of the people who are attacking probably would've said I'd like to be on the defense side.

0:08:15In this game you know I mean and gaming parlors do are the attackers or defenders.

0:08:18You haven't done that it's been happening to you people have been saying here let me help you out with your bot

0:08:22but I think you would have been successful even in the very first show saying I know people are going to attack this

0:08:28and if you want to be on the defense side join me and then you can be a power dynamic going

0:08:33and I bet it would be a much more fair fight.

0:08:37Well in that's true but we've had like I said some volunteers come out of the woodwork

0:08:42and make some really excellent changes a couple of them have started we're looking at putting like memcache in front of

0:08:49it or some equivalent thereof I haven't had the time to look into the specifics of the more invasive

0:08:56but I mean that in a good way.

0:08:58And it's sort of been made to the show

0:09:00but I know there are there are automated test now which I also didn't hear yet but one of one of my cronies

0:09:06and again I mean that a good way has added automated testing

0:09:09and at some point I plan on turning that on so that is things get checked into Masters in pushed into Master

0:09:17and so on automated tests will run.

0:09:20We did have somebody contributes some red jacks

0:09:23and specifically call you out in say in a happy way saying well I don't know this is up to you John quality

0:09:29but nevertheless I did something it was around the suggest checking checking for this. The exclamation point.

0:09:36Yes but would you go see bang asked or would you say exclamation point.

0:09:39What is a direct it's just two characters that always are the same.

0:09:43Well

0:09:43but it could be it could be exploration point answer could be explanation point suggest if they both begin with escalation

0:09:49point.

0:09:49Well that's the way I looked at it

0:09:51but apparently if you feel if you find yourself in the presence of anyone who's ever touched parole in their lives then

0:09:58their hammer is made of Reggie.

0:10:00It's an everything looks like now you want to be permissive in what kind of input you take in because humans are

0:10:04writing it so you have to love a variable not the spacing

0:10:07and inevitably you have to extract the part that is not the command and that is the title

0:10:11and you're going to want to do things with a title like normalize it for purposes

0:10:14and then turn on a little space runs to the official version that you display and all that good stuff.

0:10:18And that's exactly what regular expressions are for. If you're a C.

0:10:21Programmer and you're stepping to the strand character time I feel bad for your son as they say.

0:10:28Now I have two questions with with all these improvements to the show but Question number one is it rate limited.

0:10:36Yes Somebody added some modicum of rate limiting.

0:10:39I've been I haven't been paying super close attention which comes back to what John said we should put in the parking

0:10:45lot or what I said we should put the parking lot.

0:10:47But anyways there is a modicum of rate limiting and there is still no persistance so

0:10:53when this inevitably go that was question number two this inevitably goes down we're going to lose our title so I hope

0:10:59the actual show is still around.

0:11:02BRADSHAW It's show but anyway

0:11:04but it's an ad so I've I've turned a new leaf friend of the show Chris Harris from originally from the other media now

0:11:10it's with Glyde publishing.

0:11:13He wrote me a very nice email saying in so many words yes it's annoying

0:11:17but it makes for good programming so you know deal with it.

0:11:21So I'm going to try to put on my happy face when the show

0:11:24but inevitably goes down in like ten minutes on the probably end up really ticked off again.

0:11:28But standing here now I'm going to put on my happy face.

0:11:32So I bet the guy who wrote you in with like the your I am ing about a particular known bug that could take out the show

0:11:38by very quickly the person who wrote in to you about that probably now feels bad about exploiting it and won't say.

0:11:44So you've sort of got that person on your side to this is no fun anymore to like because if you know about the bug

0:11:49and he told you about the bug

0:11:50and he knows it's not fixed it's not as fun to exploit it to bring the thing down great security by guilt someone on

0:11:57the chair and said well oh it's hacking it.

0:12:00It's more than fun and fun than defending that's like level one level two is that defending is more friendly

0:12:04and came to the attacking the attackers all think they're hot

0:12:07but really if you're a defender that shows you're better than all the attackers You know it's the white hat black hat

0:12:12thing and I feel like white hat is the next level from black

0:12:17and because everyone wants to be black at all going to crack into things

0:12:20but to be a white you are saying that you are better than any potential black cat which is even more both a state

0:12:27and we died gone that was it.

0:12:29Let me see if it doesn't mean that other people didn't also know that that known bug and weren't on your side.

0:12:35Let's see where did I see a stack trace. Unspecified apparently there was just some sort of error in the web socket.

0:12:42You guys stall why put up a just so people who actually know what the crap they're doing can can diagnosis our first

0:12:48Pons for this week isn't well timed or yeah right.

0:12:51I'm getting good at this sometimes maybe occasionally our new sponsor this week is raised labs are A I Z L E B S raise

0:12:59labs they are a full service development firm with offices in Boston and San Francisco.

0:13:04They've been around for about ten years now

0:13:07and they've been crafting great mobile products for a variety of companies big and small.

0:13:11It's from well known brands like Macy's and Bloomingdale's and B.H.

0:13:15Photo video to local startups like some Sprite the creator of the first solar powered personal sun exposure tracker.

0:13:21The company got a start by shipping one of the very first several hundred amps in the abstract called Run Keeper it's

0:13:25actually been there since the beginning. Boston based G.P.S.

0:13:29Fitness tracking app anyway raised labs wants to change the world with great software they care about crafting quality

0:13:35products and they are looking for others that share this mentality.

0:13:38See the sponsor it's actually a job listing they're actively hiring for experienced mobile developers i OS

0:13:44and Android in both Boston and San Francisco to engineer beautiful apps

0:13:48and influence product direction for well known Fortune five hundred companies

0:13:52and exciting new startups they're also looking for talented designers to help craft a memorable experience for users as

0:13:58well as product manager.

0:14:00Yes you'll be working with enthusiastic and supportive peers in a trust based work environment.

0:14:05I wonder if they have a parking lot. If it plays an have a parking lot it can they still use that phrase.

0:14:12Sure there are major metro areas they might even have a parking lot because they know their intent there anyway.

0:14:18Well we'll just assume they'll use that phrase with good people.

0:14:21So you'll be working with enthusiastic

0:14:23and supportive peers in a trust based work environment they also have unique vacation and referral programs.

0:14:29Their vacation policy is unlimited unmetered it can be summed up in four words in team we trust.

0:14:36How much time you take off is up to you.

0:14:38They also have this referral program where anyone who refers a town's individual to raise labs will receive a four day

0:14:43all expenses paid vacation for two and you can learn about that and raise up a dot com slash trip.

0:14:48They also have hacked days every two weeks.

0:14:50The only requirement is that you must devil or present whatever you've learned

0:14:54and they're involved in the I was community with sponsoring events such as all cons

0:14:57and drinks on tap so check raise labs they're looking for good people if you want to work there. Get in touch.

0:15:03Raise lads R.E.I. Z L E B S dot com slash A.T.P. Once again that's raise with his E. Rays Lab dot com slash A.T.P.

0:15:12Thanks a lot to raise last response on the show

0:15:14and check him out if you want a job all right so Jeremy banks in the chat is one of the people who are dedicated not in

0:15:22significant amount of time to improving the show bought and apparently one of the many branches

0:15:27and poll requests that is out there that I haven't had a chance to look at fixes this problem which is to say that I

0:15:33wasn't catching or handling errors and web sockets and of course I probably shouldn't have been in the first place

0:15:40but eventually that exceptions bubbled up and brought everything to its knees so that I believe is what happened.

0:15:47But it's event driven right and scalable.

0:15:50This is how it scales well what circuits are a little bit weird but your point is not unreasonable.

0:15:54But anyway we could. We don't need to talk about any more. It lasted what ten minutes.

0:15:58That's not power not even is an improvement. It's getting worse every week.

0:16:01Last fifteen let's you know yeah you're right I did my best trying to stall for time by getting people to not bring it

0:16:07down. So I worked as a law.

0:16:11Do we have any actual other follow up I'm in we have like this you know four pages worth in the document

0:16:15but if you read this or I thought one item at the very top

0:16:19and it could be a topic to us as I figured we would talk about Google I O.

0:16:22but Then Casey said he didn't even watch it on the show will talk about today but I had one apple D.C.

0:16:28Sort of related topic so it's kind of follow up.

0:16:31Well you know the follow up is the essence of experience design the strength of our actions our inflection point to

0:16:38transform the whole design their emphasis mix core functionality immediately apparent

0:16:43and provides waypoints for the user it's not the worst one though they were the one that the tweet is I think that was

0:16:50because I read that like six times and I'm like this.

0:16:52There's not even their verb in the sentence anywhere I was just as well for what it's worth I did at least look a

0:17:00couple of recaps to see the general gist of what was said

0:17:03and I watched one of their like what is this silly term they have for design material based design

0:17:10or something like that of material metaphor is the unifying theory of a rationalized space and a system of motion.

0:17:17Our material is grounded in tactile reality inspired by our study of paper and ink yet open to imagination

0:17:24and magic the thing that scared me

0:17:27when he tweeted that because he's to the table something like Apple has you know some high high minded knowledge

0:17:35or you know B.S.

0:17:36Language essentially in their copy sometimes but this really takes the cake

0:17:39and I'm like That's from an Apple Web site that he was saying that they have some crazy stuff sometimes a lot of this

0:17:45is the worst thing they've ever done and I was looking at I'm like what what web page could that possibly be from that.

0:17:51That can't be from an Apple site and I was relieved to learn that it was not five but it was from a Google site.

0:17:58Yeah knots.

0:18:00Great no but I will say that literally two or two

0:18:03and a half minute video that they have on their new design site where they don't really say much of anything I don't.

0:18:10think but they show the kind of idea behind the look and feel of what is this Android L.

0:18:17But anyways that actually looks good to me in a lot of it looked a lot like I.O.'s and some of it didn't

0:18:22but I thought it was good.

0:18:24I thought the Apple video there a little interest for our seven look better

0:18:28but it's not like we could talk to the whole show talking about how Google is worse a giving keynotes an apple

0:18:34but really it doesn't matter that much how good the keynote is or how I guess how good the copy

0:18:41and marketing on our side matters a little bit more because that's persistent.

0:18:45But in terms of like why do this thing why do this material you why Google has been trying for the past several years

0:18:54to address its perceived

0:18:56and I think actual shortcoming in user interface by saying it should look less like a bunch of programmers slap

0:19:02something together and more like they were designers involved and it's been a slow long process

0:19:06and this is the next step in it to try to you know unify Google's user interface across all the things that have you

0:19:13and is your interface to give a family resemblance or whatever. That's that's a good idea.

0:19:19I mean you can argue whether it should be unified across everything from watches to televisions

0:19:23but Apple kind of has a common design language across everything that it does even if they're not as as similar as this

0:19:32material U.I. Supposed to be.

0:19:34Yeah I mean I definitely think it's they're going in in a good direction they're going a direction they need to go

0:19:39and a lot of the things they talked about while they were full of this you know blowhard in the cloud language

0:19:46and who knows what they were sniffing over there when they came up with some of this

0:19:49but the design the actual design below all this B.S. Looks pretty good to me. But it's easy.

0:19:55You know it's we can't really judge. It's way too early.

0:20:00Just because we don't really know how this will be in practice

0:20:03and the three of us will probably never know because I'll probably never use it regularly to even see it

0:20:07but you know it's easy to say it's easy to give a good demo. Well is it easy. Is it easy to give a good fair pocket.

0:20:18It's like there's going to be some challenge of this like every like every design language like every especially every

0:20:22like trendy looking design language.

0:20:24One of the things I noticed immediately was it seems extremely reliant on fairly undiscoverable gestures

0:20:34and you can say that about a lot of Iowa stuff as well but it seemed like this was especially so in that direction.

0:20:39That's a little bit scary to me from just from a usability perspective anything that revolves around like oh well you

0:20:44can you can just pinch this out and drag here and move this thing around.

0:20:48Well it has to be pretty clear to people you know what can move what can what is drag Well what CAN'T of this if

0:20:54there's something like a picture or a drag that can expose pretty good functionality How do you ever figure that out.

0:20:59That that's always tricky with gesture based interfaces and that's going to be a challenge here too.

0:21:05That being said I again I think it's too early to tell because anybody can well almost anybody can make a good demo.

0:21:13It's even easier to make good video.

0:21:16It's much harder to actually predict how this will be once it's integrated through the whole system

0:21:21and once after integrating it

0:21:23and none of the three of us know enough about Android to even know what the main problems these days are not having is

0:21:29it is not a reason for it to not pick up things they don't like about it.

0:21:33So I do things they complain about from the first two players actually complain about all the recent visual redesign

0:21:42things is that I was does the you know Google's doing or does everybody who does some sort of U.I.

0:21:48Refresh feels this need to peer pressure

0:21:52or is it just like you know this is not new to computer interfaces I guess this is always been there.

0:21:56They want some kind of theme or metaphor.

0:22:00Our to anchor their design which is a common thing but in the end user interfaces on mobile devices

0:22:05and stuff like the metaphor the glue used was Don't think of it as a bunch of pixels think think of the pixels not just

0:22:14having X. and Y.

0:22:14Coordinates but also as the coordinates

0:22:16and down to the point where in the demo there like in your you are you also actually gives the the layering to all of

0:22:22your things and then our user interface library will make them look like they have the layering by applying shadows

0:22:28and rendering them realtime L.-A stuff or whatever

0:22:30but that metaphor like that you need this metaphor that's like pieces of paper and they're stacked and they have a Z.

0:22:36Index or like Apple or it's like translucent thing sliding past each other and it's a layered thing.

0:22:40Those metaphors are important in that they inform the user interface

0:22:44but it seems like maybe I don't know who is worse about this Apple or Google.

0:22:50Like they take their design

0:22:51and they go beyond just having this be a way that humans look at the screen can understand what supposed to happen

0:22:57and they they just get lost in it and think that everything in their user interface has to inform

0:23:04and reinforce that metaphor for the sake of the metaphor not like it flips instead of the metaphor being this is how

0:23:10we're going to get people to understand how to use our device.

0:23:12It becomes the metaphor is the goal and every part of a user interface has to reinforce

0:23:17and build on that metaphor right down to being clever expansions of that metaphor

0:23:21and doing stuff like that if they lose the forest for the trees.

0:23:23So every time I see one of these videos that explains what the underlying thing is

0:23:27and then spends the rest of the video showing how everything fold into the don't align thing I'd rather have them show

0:23:32me how the metaphor makes the interface more understandable to people

0:23:36and said show me how every part of user interface conforms to the metaphors but that's one thing

0:23:40and again you can't tell until we use it

0:23:43but I can tell from the presentations of this is this is how the presenting their U.I.

0:23:48and The second thing but as a second I feel like lots of them go for a third thing

0:23:53but I can't remember the second thing and I mean the second got I'll get it as I go.

0:24:00So they only spent about the first forty five minutes or so talking about new stuff that was going into Android.

0:24:07Right we have roughly where

0:24:08and then like the rest of it was some of these new initiatives like the Android where Android T.V.

0:24:14Android in your vehicles whatever the entrant Carender driver to go into auto Android is that right. Yeah.

0:24:20Android on the way.

0:24:22OK it seems like you know sort of first forty five minutes here's what's new in Android basically good.

0:24:27You know that's if you're into Android that's probably very relevant

0:24:29and I think what what got people to say it was so boring because in the first part of it everybody was quite interested

0:24:35in all that and you know as I was watching it live I was watching the Twitter response

0:24:39and yeah the first part of it was seem pretty strong and then they get into this you know hour

0:24:44and a half more two hours more of talking about various new hardware integration and initiatives.

0:24:53What's what's bad about that is that none of these things are actual product yet or very few of them are

0:24:58and it's all about like the promise of what you can maybe do this in the future like

0:25:02when Apple you know Apple unveiled the health book Health Kit thing home kit

0:25:10and didn't even mention carful if they did it was very quick in this keynote because you know I think it was didn't

0:25:18launch last year and it didn't initial in NASCAR they last year anyway but they had a Ferrari right

0:25:26but they didn't give it a whole a time that you know because there's not much really to say yet.

0:25:30It's hey we have this new thing we're getting you know we hope people make devices for it basically

0:25:35and we hope you make apps for it once these devices exist.

0:25:38Good luck with that and you know moving on

0:25:40and that's what they did this year with help getting home because there really was not much to say.

0:25:45Google devoted three quarters of their keynote to that

0:25:48and so I think that's why it was so boring because like you know it's like a C.E.O.

0:25:54Ask you know at that point you know C.E.O.'s cancer like famously you know like Microsoft give them our age.

0:26:00Here whoever they really be famously full of vaporware always be like this this crazy stuff that kind of maybe sounds

0:26:07interesting during the demo and kind of sounds possibly impossible

0:26:11or stretching the limits of what consumer products can be or can do realistically

0:26:15and then you know six months later they get canceled and they were never released or they you know they come out

0:26:21and they're really disappointing and they flop in the market because they were nothing like what they were

0:26:25but they're going to be like in the keynote and it's hard to look at Google's rest of their keynote

0:26:33and not make a parallel there because it seems like almost everything they announced after the first forty five minutes

0:26:39was like here's a bunch of new stuff that in the best case scenario might come out fairly soon it might be kind of cool

0:26:46but we're depending on a lot of other people for that to happen

0:26:49and in the meantime here's some pretty terrible smart watches to tide you over.

0:26:54I think that's a little bit harsh because I mean a this is Google's part of the strategy is that they they make a

0:27:00platform that other hardware makers other people can build products on like that's their thing I mean you can say you

0:27:04know like I think as much as Apple thing but that is certainly there are things so to expect school to come out

0:27:09and have products behind every single one of these things that their software platform provides is probably expecting

0:27:17to be too much like Apple

0:27:18but the things that they are the things that they show like the idea that we've got this platform the platform works

0:27:24obviously in phones and tablets. Here is how the platform works on television. Here is how I work my work on a watch.

0:27:31I didn't like the watches either but it is showing that their platform works there and the T.V.

0:27:36Stuff looked pretty good to me.

0:27:38Certainly they have shown an ability to have a single platform that spans all those devices better than Apple has.

0:27:46Steve Apple has its platform it's got its desktop platform in its tablet and phone platform in its T.V. Platform.

0:27:52And there's no unified story that includes all of them.

0:27:56I mean it and you can you can say well we don't want to be unified.

0:28:00Just the MAC and I was devices which is fine but the T.V.

0:28:04Thing already run by us

0:28:05but don't run apps like they're not extending the platform out there so I think that Google is out ahead of Apple in

0:28:11terms of having a unified platform across all their products just so happy that they're not responsible for making all

0:28:15their prices their whole deal is a lot of the people build them and so on and so forth but the T.V.

0:28:19Stuff that they showed that was a whole lot better than Apple T.V.

0:28:22Why don't you guys think you know didn't see very much of it.

0:28:25But one or two images I saw looked very good in the Apple T.V.

0:28:29Is starting to look a little dated but to go back to Step what's so bad about these watches.

0:28:34I'm I don't know I mean I'll tell you what's bad about the watches.

0:28:38Let me not finish my thought

0:28:40but I genuinely would love to hear what you have to say because I'm looking at these pictures that are on the verge of

0:28:45which one is a smaller three sixty and I don't see an issue with the circular display I gained at the around one right.

0:28:52OK will hold.

0:28:52Yes it's around

0:28:53when I hold on now the one thing I was going to say is I have the tiniest wrists that any man has ever had in in the

0:28:59history of mankind and so I think this thing would look ridiculous on me.

0:29:03But let's assume for a moment that I didn't have a little teeny tiny wrists I don't see what's so bad about this I

0:29:08think it looks OK It looks a lot better than a pebble.

0:29:11We're also sponsored this week by our friends at square space they are back once again now we're in this a little

0:29:16different this week Squarespace recognizes that they have supported lots of pod cast big and small.

0:29:23They really fund a lot of them and we all find them very much for that.

0:29:27They want to be in the forefront of helping this medium reach the next level.

0:29:31But for this had really wanted for something different something fun.

0:29:33Our friend Jonathan Mann also on a sunny day man Jonathan Mann who wrote our theme song which you've possibly heard

0:29:40before if you are looking at the end of our show or let's be honest the middle of our show.

0:29:45If you've ever listened so John to member awesome theme song.

0:29:49He also recently he was tired of hearing the same Squarespace reads over

0:29:53and over again so he wrote a Squarespace sponsorship song.

0:30:00Well you know you know when you start a free trial with no credit card required start building your website today

0:31:21when you decide it's on a particular space. Make sure you go to squarespace dot com and use the offer code A.T.P.

0:31:27To get ten percent off your first purchase and to show your support for our show. Once again use Google A.T.P.

0:31:33To get temper sent off thank you very much to Squarespace

0:31:35and Jonathan Mann thank you for sponsoring our show Thanks John of the man for being awesome Squarespace a better web

0:31:41starts with your website. Now John why do smart watches suck.

0:31:47I don't know what smart watches in general but the ones they showed this cool thing

0:31:51and I didn't watch all of the smallish demo but I watch enough to see what they're doing essentially.

0:31:56I just talk about how I was a good idea that Google had a platform that span.

0:32:00And you know little screens the big screens out of the strength of them

0:32:03but I remain unconvinced that the correct way to do a smart watch is to take your user interface that you have on your

0:32:10phones and your tablets and your T.V.'s and continue to shrink it until it's on your wrist and then tap

0:32:14and swipe your way through a series of you eyes that are custom made to fit on a very tiny screen.

0:32:18Because that just was not a good time for me it doesn't look like something that's useful you have to compromise

0:32:24certain certain U.I.

0:32:25Elements and staples just don't work on a small screen like table views and stuff start to become ridiculous

0:32:30when you see two items at once

0:32:32and you know it's just I don't think that's the right solution for a screen that small in the same way that the right

0:32:38solution for a screen the size of a television isn't merely like a tablet U.I. Made larger right.

0:32:44It's something entirely different to mine the uniting touching it it just doesn't seem like there's enough room down

0:32:48there.

0:32:49I'll just I'll just take my regular Android O S and just make it smaller

0:32:52and I'll keep the elements same size of the still touchable.

0:32:55But I don't you know but if there's not room for a particular helmet I just won't put that on there

0:32:59and others have you know small things when you're swiping your tap swiping

0:33:02and tapping on something that small just just looks like a non-starter to me

0:33:06and I have had the you know the small i Pod Nano is with a little touch screen and everything

0:33:09and you know it's just not it doesn't work for me.

0:33:12So I'm I think there is another solution to things that big maybe doesn't involve screens at all if it does maybe they

0:33:19behave in a different way maybe just a matter of putting different U.I.

0:33:21Elements on that screen that don't exist in any form on any of the larger screens.

0:33:26So that's that's why I think these watches are hard to some extent I can see why Google pushes this whole like one

0:33:34interface scalable to every device size thing because they have to because that's that's the environment of Android

0:33:39hardware. They kind of have to do that.

0:33:42In general I do agree though it's going to be a pretty painful approach for developers to try to try to actually

0:33:50fulfill the promise of that

0:33:51and try to actually make like one interface that magically scale to all the different sizes

0:33:55and doesn't suck on any of them. I think it's I think it's custom U.I. For the phone I'm just saying like.

0:34:00The elements that are involved.

0:34:01Buttons regions that you scroll controls for doing things I mean I guess that I've text into pieces of the speech

0:34:07or whatever but just I'm assuming that you have to write a custom U.I.

0:34:11For the server they have custom controls very certainly for them like a circular screen all that stuff

0:34:15but it's just that the elements that are involved in the user interface things that you tap things that you slide

0:34:22things that you scroll through.

0:34:23I don't think there's enough room for that type of interface and I think that small

0:34:27and I'm basing this both by using a touch screen i Pod to have the very small touch screens.

0:34:33It just doesn't feel good at that size.

0:34:35The big problem that we've seen with almost all the smart watch lists come out so far from the pebble to these new ones.

0:34:42It's all about the screen and the screen is never big enough to be useful

0:34:48but never small enough to make for a good watch

0:34:51and that's why I think that really the whole idea of a smart watch might not it might not be possible to make a good

0:34:58one. Certainly not with today's technology but maybe even ever.

0:35:02Like there's this fundamental limits of like the ideal watch does not have a giant screen.

0:35:08But the ideal touch screen is big

0:35:10and so it's very hard to to rectify that conflict design wise you know it even if you could make it like infinitely

0:35:18thin and light and give an infinite battery life you still have the issue of you know we need to somehow maximize

0:35:24but also minimize the size of the screen

0:35:25and I don't know if you're right about that because so I have a couple of friends that that are watch collectors

0:35:32and I think I probably would be one of those people if a I wasn't cheap

0:35:38and I didn't have the tiny wrists that we spoke about earlier

0:35:42but like for example a Rolex is a relative the average stereotypical Rolex is fairly large

0:35:49and like my one friend really really loved Panta Rhei watches which I'd never heard of until I spoke to him that up

0:35:55there very pretty I believe Italian watches and they're huge they're freaking ignore.

0:36:00I'm missin like Clarkson and Hammond on top here.

0:36:02If memory serves are both big into watches and typically where these physically very very large watches.

0:36:08So because Tapia presenters are the fashion leaders of the world.

0:36:12But that's the point though that there are all these people who are wearing these watches are wearing them for fashion

0:36:18reasons not for utilitarian reasons and they don't.

0:36:21How long do they spend looking at the face of those watches you know let alone pawing at the face of those watches in

0:36:26the zero time pawing at the face of the watch is very short Mouse Hunt looking at the face of the lodges they're mostly

0:36:31wearing them as a as a piece of jewelry as a fashion accessory not as utilitarian thing.

0:36:37So these none of these things qualify as fashion accessories because they're ugly.

0:36:40Especially the square one looks terrible circa one looks humongous I guess if you're if you're a giant person it is

0:36:45proportional to you and but then you'll have equivalently giant sausage like fingers

0:36:50and I'll be able to use it anyway

0:36:51but the idea that anyone going to spend any amount of time turning their restored themselves

0:36:54and staring at their rest and pawing at it with their finger to get stuff done.

0:36:58It's like just you know turn their respect

0:37:01and take out their phone like you know a decade ago people in the street weren't holding a rectangle staring out over

0:37:08their head.

0:37:08Now you walk around a city street a little rectangle down the stereotypes that is the change in behavior so it's

0:37:13conceivable that a couple years from now instead of everyone holding little rectangles everyone is staring at the rest

0:37:17as if they're trying to tell what time it is but all can't tell time.

0:37:20Like Boy I can only talk on the stereo and their study

0:37:24but really what they're doing is like reading Twitter on their wrist.

0:37:26I guess that's conceivable

0:37:27but it still seems to me that that's not smart watches not just a phone strategy rest smaller I think that is the wrong

0:37:35solution for smart watches and no matter how good technology gets what if we can make it if it is a piece of paper.

0:37:40If it's still watch size I don't want to be holding up looking at him or point out it with my finger.

0:37:44I think there is a role for something smart that's on your wrist.

0:37:47I'm just I just don't think the role is like a tiny little phone on your wrist.

0:37:51So maybe maybe the solution then you know because I think you're right.

0:37:55This may be the solution really is not to leave the interaction to the walk.

0:38:00To leave the watch really has to be like a very as small as possible a just a display it's a beat up a device for

0:38:08and for notifications open late for my meeting or you know voice input quickly

0:38:12and then it would start sounding off directions to your Bluetooth headset to tell you where to turn as you walk.

0:38:16Like there are there are uses that I can see for nothing a smart watch is done the smart watch is a good idea says that

0:38:21what these guys keep making is a tiny phone on my wrist right whereas if you like if you if you give up on the idea

0:38:27that you should be pulling your watch all the time.

0:38:31If the watch is primary purpose is to give you information and a quick glance

0:38:36and then you leave the interaction of two taking the phone in your pocket which is

0:38:39but you know better suited for the job.

0:38:40In all in almost every case anyway then you can make the watch of stench really simpler

0:38:45and you can make this play much smaller

0:38:47and you can you can then I mean it doesn't even need to be touchscreen on again

0:38:52or you have arrived at I don't have a watch.

0:38:58Well that's true of the three of us I'm the only one who actually wears a watch on my I were watching middle school I

0:39:04wore a watch up until around the time I got an i Phone and then I stopped wearing a watch

0:39:08and I just recently started again. I remember my second thing so good.

0:39:12Tell us about your second we're also smart to the purely so I read the material you are talking about the metaphor

0:39:22taking to much prominence both

0:39:23and I think the second thing is that you need to go to the shop for the material thing that I showed a little bit of it

0:39:29was that they've decided to do something that I thought more Touch user interfaces would do

0:39:37and the fact that no one has done it that much until Google download it is surprising to me

0:39:43but maybe everybody knows something Google does

0:39:44and that thing is showing feedback for your touch as a matter of course as a matter of like.

0:39:52But with the expectation that when you touch

0:39:53or do anything in Uniphase the interface response let you know you've done it.

0:39:57Now that type of feedback is really important in. Regular user interfaces with you know a mouse and everything.

0:40:03Because it's indirect in a way.

0:40:05So you put your cursor of a button click the button you want the button to highlight

0:40:08and you wanted to highlight on mouse down

0:40:10and you want to do something different on mouse up like you want to feel like you're pressing into the you know these

0:40:15are three D.

0:40:15Type interfaces with a button but puffy in early versions of Windows and mac and even today to some degree as well

0:40:22and it lets you know that you were successful at something was happening.

0:40:26If you decide to use events where there are buttons and you click them and nothing happened

0:40:29and then eventually a dialogue going away you might not be sure which button you clicked the same thing with the menus

0:40:34are coming down the mac when you select a menu item on the original mac the menu item you selected would flash on

0:40:40and off a few times before the menu went away because they want you to know.

0:40:43Yeah you were trying to get that menu item.

0:40:44You did get them anyway in fact it was adjustable in the original not to be like one flash to fashion three lashes

0:40:49or whatever visual feedback what's going on.

0:40:52Touch elements do the same thing like an Eye us when you touch a button and invert or whatever like that.

0:40:57But the mature U.I.

0:40:58Seems to go much farther in that it's almost giving you the kind of thing you see on a screen in presentations where

0:41:04they want you to show where the person is touching you can't see their fingers if they're using a device

0:41:07but the device the screen is being projected so they have like the little circles like that appear in the Iowa simulate

0:41:11or whatever but this is part of the OAS that you get a little circle with like little Ripley lines coming out of it

0:41:17and then

0:41:18when you select an element a little ripple goes across the element to show that it selected very heavy handed feedback

0:41:24to let people know that yes I registered your charge.

0:41:27Yes It touched this item and here it is not just like individual items of buns

0:41:31but if they touch almost anywhere they were shown on the dial pad you see the little ripples appear where you hit the

0:41:35dial pad not just like the one button ripples

0:41:37but where your finger touch of you touched in the upper left of the one a little ripple appears there

0:41:42and I can't decide if this is brilliant or terrible.

0:41:47Part of me that makes you think it might be brilliant is I've seen a lot of people use touch interfaces

0:41:52and not be sure whether their touches are doing anything a grand most of the time it's because they're using a touch

0:41:57device that is not as responsive as.

0:42:00And I always device like say some crazy Android thing where the interface is slow and they'll stab at it a few times

0:42:07or hit the same button multiple times or try it and then pick their finger off

0:42:10and tried again because it didn't register that time that that could not be frustrating for them so if Android is the

0:42:16O.-S. Of choice for underpowered devices would not respond to the U.I.

0:42:19As having having really heavy handed visual feedback to let people know when their touch was registered

0:42:26and where where they where the device thinks they touch and what thing they just selected might be an excellent idea.

0:42:32But on the other hand I think would drive me insane because the whole point of a great a great touch interface is that

0:42:38it should feel like a manipulating like a physical thing scrolling should stick to my finger touching the button should

0:42:43immediately highlighting it like it should be it should be direct manipulation I don't need this indirection

0:42:48but the indirection there because everything is too slow.

0:42:50Then maybe this kind of interface is a good idea

0:42:53but it makes you think is that the world of Android users get used to this eventually in four years whenever he hears

0:42:59interface.

0:43:00They will find a device that does not even have a device a super responsive to be inferior

0:43:05but they were like oh I like the one that shows me where I touched.

0:43:08Does that sound crazy that that would be something that eventually people could latch onto and think is great.

0:43:13No I mean that's I think what we're seeing this year we saw a lot from Apple

0:43:17and I think what Google is has always been doing to some degree and is continuing to do like this.

0:43:24We're seeing the platforms tried a different turn to differentiate themselves further so that they lock people in more

0:43:32effectively because you know not a lot of people Levi less for Android but a lot of people have left

0:43:37and right for i OS and certainly Google wants to stop that

0:43:41and certainly Apple wants to make the reverse less likely to happen in the future.

0:43:45And so you know we're seeing things like like you know Apple building up a whole bunch of hype around things like cloud

0:43:52care

0:43:53and the cloud services you know the things that don't appear in Android Google doing similar things with you know the

0:43:58levels of integration they can get you know what. They can bring up developers to do and now from like that.

0:44:02Certainly it could be it could be if you teach a thing like that it probably probably wasn't I mean it's probably like

0:44:09I'm sure somebody thought about that after they came up a bit

0:44:11and said oh this also has a side benefit of being you know some potential lock

0:44:15and I want to view it as a lock in it just like it's if it's a feature that people like

0:44:20and they come to associate it with like that category of product right in the same way that essentially people came to

0:44:27associate a rectangle with a screen on it as what a smart phone looks like

0:44:31and everyone else had to make rectangular screens on this because as a people thought of a smartphones it I found

0:44:35define the category.

0:44:37Giving people something that they react too strongly that makes them feel comfortable the device makes a device

0:44:43and makes them feel comfortable using device makes if you're familiar

0:44:45and friendly it's not lockin like oh I wish I could leave

0:44:49but I can't because the other devices don't have this feature.

0:44:52It's they like it and they try to go to something else

0:44:55and say I miss I miss that thing I miss the ripples that makes me feel like that they're meant to be able to articulate

0:45:00it.

0:45:01But like it's weird because I like it I think I would hate that feature but I think a lot of people might like it

0:45:09and I think Apple would never do anything like that never never that heavy handed

0:45:13and so Google may have just done something brilliant or people hate it and then Google will like turn it off

0:45:18or no absolute ever use the new you are for the five things that Google makes

0:45:22and it will continue to be crazy fragmented world over there will say I think you're reading way too much into this.

0:45:27Aaron had a touchscreen phone with a slide out keyboard which is not a smartphone it wasn't a Blackberry

0:45:33or anything like that it was just a phone that had a touch screen in a slide out keyboard this is right before she got

0:45:38her first i Phone around the same time I was begging her to let me get her an i Phone

0:45:43but she didn't think was worth it. That's a different discussion for another time.

0:45:45Anyway the point is that thing had tactic feedback in in so far as I think that's right we're going anyway it would

0:45:52vibrate a little bit when you touched it

0:45:54and I believe it like I had a little white spot on the screen where you touch the screen.

0:46:00And she didn't think anything of it

0:46:03and soon as she got her I found that neither of those features air quotes were there

0:46:07but that was so long ago that that phone must've been so awful

0:46:11and so in response of in the vibration is just pointless because of not telling you anything because that plane where

0:46:16you did it

0:46:16but like that's that's a bigger leap from like from pre-i Phone smartphone I have on yet no matter what the old ones

0:46:21had eventually even the physical keyboard to pigeonhole people hold on for the longest time.

0:46:25Eventually it's like I just give up it's you know no more physical keyboards I'd ever was one over there

0:46:30but I think the gap between a modern Android device

0:46:33and a modern i Phone is small enough that this is life especially with all things they kept showing you know they says

0:46:38every year

0:46:38but hey look we made a user interface more responsive venture it's going to be true just because hardware gets better

0:46:44and better and these things everything that showed look pretty darn smooth.

0:46:47So I'm thinking that the gap is small enough that differentiator is like this if they prove popular may be a problem

0:46:57for Apple in terms of getting people to come over just like the big screens are in the same way like the big gigantic

0:47:02screen that we thought oh I don't want everyone is going about people love them they love the big screen.

0:47:06So Apple's essentially forced to field larger screen phones we all assume this fall because that's what people love.

0:47:13You know you're right it's going to be just like the Black Berry keyboard in the millions upon millions of people that

0:47:17are clinging to that.

0:47:18Also real time followup to

0:47:20and I think I might have said tactic I meant haptics of things to the chat room for correcting me.

0:47:24And thank you for the thirty five people that are listening to this after the fact in a verty emailed me to correct me

0:47:29I thought you meant tactile. But anyway that's who I think I think I kind of combine those on my head.

0:47:34But anyways we're also sponsored by our friends at Lynda L Y N D A dot com Going to Lynda dot com slash eighty P.

0:47:42To learn more.

0:47:44Lynda dot com helps you learning keep up to date with your software pick up brand new skills

0:47:48or explore new hobbies with easy to follow professionally produced video tutorials.

0:47:53What you want to learn new programming language create a graceful user experience for your website

0:47:57or do your first could have been running with Dick to see.

0:48:00When the dot com offers thousands of video courses

0:48:02and a variety of topics they have over twenty four hundred courses they're taught by industry experts

0:48:07and they add more every week. They have courses for all experience levels whether you're beginner or advanced.

0:48:14They have general and specialty topics and you get all of this for one moment the price of just twenty five dollars.

0:48:20Now because you unlimited access to the entire Lynda dot com library just twenty five bucks a month for unlimited

0:48:26access. So they have all sorts of things. They have things like programming languages. You can learn P.H.P.

0:48:31If you really want to. I would advise against it but you can do it because it's much easier than the node K.Z.

0:48:38Because my P.H.P. Shabat stayed up.

0:48:40It's easier to create something functional it's not even something that's not actually learned. OK.

0:48:47If you want to learn note you can do that too. You can even learn Perl if you're completely crazy.

0:48:51And if you otherwise you want to learn the applications you can learn some of the Adobe Creative Class apps you know do

0:48:56we get released updates to the Creative Cloud so if a new with new versions of their apps like Photoshop

0:49:01and Illustrator and stuff like that.

0:49:03Lynda dot com works with software companies to get you updated video training the same time that the updated versions

0:49:08are released so they probably I haven't checked

0:49:10but they probably already have all the new Adobe stuff up there already.

0:49:14You can also learn Final Cut Pro Logic Pro

0:49:17and you can learn video editing learn audio editing to make your own podcast.

0:49:20Go into the logic stuff and see it's really cool they have

0:49:24and they even have a stuff on podcasting if you don't want to use logic they have a huge library so these courses are

0:49:29produced by professionals at the top of their field

0:49:32and you can watch them anywhere you can watch them on on your computer on your tablet your mobile device

0:49:37and they're broken into these bite sized pieces so you can if you only have fifteen minutes at a time to watch

0:49:42something you can do that you can watch a fifteen minute chunk as you're watching the transcripts close by on the side

0:49:47and you can click to different point in the transcript it will jump to that point in the video.

0:49:51So it's very easy to find what you need to skim to pause to slow down to go back.

0:49:55If you miss something or you want some clarification that's the presentation here is simply.

0:50:00So check it out you can get a seven day free trial by going to L Y N.B.A. Dot com slash A.T.P.

0:50:07That is Linda with a wider consular A.T.P.

0:50:10Thanks a lot to Linda for sponsoring our show once again we need to get Apple to send Linda dot com because I would

0:50:16love to be able to click on the spot

0:50:17and a transcript of Apple's got the transcripts right I'm Is that guy who took the transcript I made that ASCII W.D.C.

0:50:23Site where you can search them.

0:50:24Yeah I just need to put it all together Linda spyware the transcript on the left the video on the Right Whale The click

0:50:28on the trends for brevity. This by the video that would make my life so much easier.

0:50:31Oh yeah like I was thinking I would have been like noodling in my head.

0:50:35Another idea never can do I would love to just make an app just make like probably a mac app that it would be like

0:50:41you're watching videos and it would you know you could like you know Star the ones you want to watch.

0:50:45It would keep track of the ones you did watch. You could search you know search for topic search for A P I's the W.

0:50:50Everything.

0:50:51Now but yeah the official app keeps track of what you want to keep track and playback position across devices.

0:50:56You know really well I guess only if you watch in the app I don't ever drive. Yeah.

0:51:00Crap I will not make it but it doesn't do the transcript thing as I'm saying as an ex that.

0:51:05Yeah like why why can you take command and go right to something like you browse the titles

0:51:11and figure what they call the you know the ability section this year like one of the call that you know that's one note

0:51:16taking is still a big thing for me because the slides have like seven words on them

0:51:20and the person onstage speaks important information that's not in the slides

0:51:24and it was a particularly bad this year I thought where all the real information misspoke

0:51:28and it wasn't even like hinted at in the slides the slide would have like one word on

0:51:32and then a guy would talk for ten minutes like oh this is the stop so I had to write that that you can't run I can't

0:51:37for research purposes I can't go back to the video

0:51:39and watch it in real time to visit takes forever I have to have the notes budget of into the one thing that's extra

0:51:45really valuable with watching these videos is the variable speed playback in quick time player seven

0:51:51and I'm probably like we'll see everything else but I think with time X. Does not do it.

0:51:55But so you can you know it just like just like a podcast you can play these videos at like one point five.

0:52:00And it helps a lot because the B.B.C.

0:52:02Sessions are pretty slowly paced because you know they want everyone in a room full of people many of whom it was not

0:52:08their first language.

0:52:09They want everyone to understand it and to keep you know to keep up and you know in a giant room

0:52:14and that's very different than watching a video at home

0:52:17and especially if you're like if you're like looking for something specific

0:52:20or waiting something specific that you know the mention of that you can be might have mentioned you want like skip

0:52:24around a bit and play through sections fast and it's it's so nice to be able to do that.

0:52:30Member the Earlier I said I wasn't making fun of Google's inability to presentations is not a productive avenue

0:52:37but since we're talking about the most obscure out of the way in the tiny little room in the corner of Moscone about

0:52:44some A.P.I.

0:52:46and Framework that nobody uses except ten people that person's presentation

0:52:50and demos were better than everything in Google I O.

0:52:53Is there an engineer who is not a professional presenter

0:52:57and you see at the very least goes through some sort of regime where they make them make your slides comprehensible to

0:53:02the point where they work on everything they say where they make sure the demos are tight or they get them done

0:53:07and it just amazes me how the Google I O. Presenter is for the most part did not even get the basics right.

0:53:14The Ramble the slides had too much stuff on them they tried demos that didn't work well even of the demos had worked

0:53:19well they weren't be demonstrating anything worth demonstrating it was not a good showing.

0:53:24I mean I don't think that's important except for in the sort of you know fun giggly Twitter snark type nature of the

0:53:30thing but it's at a certain point Google should get better at that. Do you think they really care.

0:53:36They do they're trying or you can tell the early part of the presentation I thought were together like

0:53:41when there was a name Sunday are I can't remember the last names of the P.

0:53:45when He was up there talking about Android the slides had bullet points that were important he would address each one

0:53:50of them that wasn't too much going on like it was it was straight forward and to the point

0:53:55but it just started meandering and things started going wrong.

0:54:00I guess that even if every demo that he got wrong began perfectly I still don't think those are the right demos to have

0:54:04especially not making out a real time follow up from Sam the geek in the chat room apparently quick time player X.

0:54:13Does have variable speed playback.

0:54:16It's in the discovery of the discovery of this in of option clicking the fast forward button.

0:54:23Yet how does anybody even know that I have no idea I saw underscore do it on the plane

0:54:27and I was like Wait how did that just happen

0:54:29and they had to show me that because like you said I had no idea what it was for template X.

0:54:33and Have the most important feature which is get the freaking control over my video of the most important feature not.

0:54:43missing. I've got time player seven installed and that's what I still use. Is there anything else on Google I O.

0:54:49They say sixty frames per second this year. They also say this year is the year of desktop Linux.

0:54:55Right and Duke Nukem Forever finally came out. You actually do it and then Android T.V.

0:55:03Iteration nine is here and so that's going to set the world aflame.

0:55:07I mean eventually they're going to have to you know get those and some T.V.'s I mean. Man the previous Google T.V.

0:55:14and Somebody in a chat I'm sorry I forgot who it's too far to scroll now

0:55:17but some of the chap pointed out like it's kind of confusing with the branding between likely What's Google what's

0:55:22Android what's Chrome you know they have

0:55:25and you know John you mentioned earlier that Google is better at having this like cohesive cross device experience

0:55:31and honestly I don't think that's the case I mean if you look at things like you know the chrome cast and crew books

0:55:37and versus Android versus Google services like it's pretty fragmented actually the naming of the things is bad

0:55:44but first of all if you're just comparing it to Apple which is what I'm doing. They went on T.V.

0:55:47Because Apple doesn't have a way for third parties to do anything on T.V.

0:55:50So the who wins by default right even if you're not going like that I think also Google's interface is they showed on

0:55:55the television a better than I believe want to dabble T.V. Is not a platform for anybody except us.

0:56:00So I have or selected a partner so they were in there and the second thing is Apple.

0:56:04Google's big thing is web apps and stuff and so that's their you know that's their platform

0:56:08and they are likely making it about to better.

0:56:10But they're working hard to make you know like this new you why for example is available to web apps at sixty pamper

0:56:16seconds in Chrome

0:56:17and chrome runs on all of their devices from the chrome books to you can write it on your phone you can run your tablet

0:56:22it runs on your television. Like that's their unifying force.

0:56:25An android runs on most of these things half of the chrome books

0:56:28but their whole thing is where the native app doesn't matter it's going to look at same with comes from Google were

0:56:34telling you that we think is going to perform the same as if the French was like an animation.

0:56:37That's their strategy

0:56:39and I give him the win over Apple because Apple has nothing on television except for this box that only does like to do

0:56:46things

0:56:46and they don't just don't have that unification across levels like I said the I was always ten split is going to get a

0:56:53lot better in Yosemite and Iowa State but that's not quite here yet.

0:56:56But even there that split is much larger than the split between I think the Chrome OS

0:57:01and Android simply because Google is a web company and their whole big thing is whether apps

0:57:06and they shouldn't they shouldn't be second class citizens to Native out they continue to be

0:57:10but Google is really hammering on making that not be the case

0:57:13and if it's going to be the case somewhere in the first place is going to not be like that is on Google's platforms

0:57:18because it was highly motivated to make web apps feel

0:57:21and look just as good as native apps you know something we skipped before we leave Google I was apparently G.-Mail has

0:57:28a rest for A.P.I. Now. Yeah I put I put them in the notes because I was freaking out about it.

0:57:33Everyone's freaking out saying that this is going to replace I'm mad and I'm very I'm the first person to say that.

0:57:40Yeah I would not I would not assume the G.

0:57:43Mail I mapped support will be there for very much longer in fact I made a prediction.

0:57:47I forget exactly what time interval I said I think within two or five years I was pretty sure that that cow there

0:57:53and you know I'm Apple both be discontinued or sunset or whatever whatever phrase they would use but

0:57:58but they say I know.

0:58:00With this particular case of the dream I know that Google has actually explicitly said this is not supposed to replace

0:58:05I map exactly right of course they can they can say whatever they want

0:58:09but I think in this case they're probably telling the truth that they probably don't attend didn't send them to replace

0:58:13him.

0:58:14What this probably will do though is maybe hasten the the ability from the suit to see new map in a in a marketable way

0:58:25because they hate our map access they really do they they I'm sure they can't wait to get rid of it.

0:58:30I mean there's really like if you think about every all the ways that that that Google operates makes money innovates

0:58:40in G.

0:58:41Mail and I Matt have never gotten along very well it's not supported even though it's been pretty flaky

0:58:46and unreliable and slow

0:58:47and very limited because a lot of e-mails features just don't fit in the model of what I map is

0:58:53and how a map has to represent the mailboxes and everything and those like the hack of like the messages mailbox

0:58:59and all sorts of crazy stuff that just it just causes problems.

0:59:03And so you say all that and I know that there's some amount of truth there but I used a Google Apps for my domain

0:59:11and I use i Map and maybe I'm just not a G. Mail power user but I almost never have any problems.

0:59:18I really don't

0:59:19and I agree with you that that it's contrary encounter to the way they make money which is for me to be on the Web site

0:59:26looking at their ads but I'm never on the Web site. All I very rarely on the Web site anyone the G.

0:59:32Mail web site because I have no particular need for it.

0:59:35I don't particularly fancy the web interface I know either Last I heard John I know you do and that's fine

0:59:41but I am just fine with the I.R.S.

0:59:44Mail app I'm just fine with mailbox on the mac and I do use I'm after constantly for Google Apps

0:59:51and I really don't have any big problems.

0:59:55I think like Margo said I'm out as never been a good fit for the way Google does email I'll search.

1:00:00So like when I first saw his A.P.

1:00:02I was excited because of what I thought it meant was that cool if I get a ring of I'm up

1:00:06and I think the reason Google should get rid of my map like

1:00:09or you know slowly phase it out is not to like cut off third party clients

1:00:13or whatever in fact that's the reason they'll probably have to keep it around forever just if they want to continue to

1:00:17support like you know customers and clients and use I'm up

1:00:20but just because it's a poor fit for their for their mail service their mail acts in a different way than I.M.F.

1:00:27Expects mail to act and I like the way G.

1:00:30Mail acts I was like All right well so fine keep I have around for the legacy clients make a new fancier A.P.I.

1:00:35That works the way G.

1:00:36Mail works and you know they thought make it faster make it not just a better match semantically

1:00:41but make you feel to do things with you know higher performance like search or bulk operations

1:00:46and all this good stuff but then I would have documentation

1:00:49and in the first couple paragraphs a diagram they had says no to the G M L A B I should not be used to replace I'm out

1:00:55for a full fledged email client access so that's straightforward right there in the very first thing in the nation.

1:01:02If you're writing what they consider it what they call a full fledged email client don't use this you sign up so that's

1:01:08a shame like the now just like oh this is just a way for applications that want to do something with mail to be able to

1:01:13send mail through your G.

1:01:14Mail account it is nice because you can only you can only ask for permission to send not to read

1:01:19and then you can send out through G.-Mail using his A.P.I.

1:01:22Instead of doing you know like I think it's a good idea to have his A.P.I.

1:01:25but It becomes much less interesting

1:01:27when they're saying right out it is not for making an email client so that that alone means that I'm out has to either

1:01:32I'm happy to stay around for a much longer time or eventually Google phaseout I'm out

1:01:36and says no you have to go through the web U.I.

1:01:38but It's I think it would be difficult for Apple for Google to go back

1:01:42and I'm out at this point you know this is this is kind of a left turn here

1:01:46and I I hadn't thought of that you thought the other day you look at things like you know the proliferation of apps

1:01:55taking over from web sites for where modern interaction and computing is really happening. These days.

1:02:01Combine that with Android with its intense Windows eight with its contract

1:02:05and now Iowa with its extension system our A.P.I. Is necessary anymore. Yes Why.

1:02:17Because I mean for Web services if you if you want to interact with something that's not on the same device as you are

1:02:24like you could be the eyes for things like everyday reading Twitter posting to Twitter getting email

1:02:32or any of the existing native code systems for allowing one application on the same machine to communicate to another

1:02:39don't apply to I mean like that's the unifying principle of Google is that they would instead say the opposite.

1:02:45And like everything should be like a web app

1:02:47and everything should communicate to restfully be eyes even its on the same machine

1:02:50and really it shouldn't matter where you think it's hosting it everything should all be the web and blah blah blah.

1:02:54That's obviously not the path that Apple is going down or aura or Google that matter for Android

1:02:58but if you guys are definitely still a thing both remote and local.

1:03:03Well think about how many of those others just mentioned certainly you know there's going to be some that that can't be

1:03:09done this way but think about how many of the things you just mentioned could be like rather than call in the P.R.I.

1:03:16Just you know the user will probably have a G.

1:03:18Mail app on their phone because they used e-mail so just because of the G.

1:03:21Mail app and have it do something and then you know keep back to you or whatever. What is the G.

1:03:24Mail app do it calls to him politely I can see mail servers are on the other side of the connection.

1:03:29Well sure I mean public A.P.I. Is obviously like public web service A.P.I.

1:03:33As our you know our do really need to be a major thing anymore like you know could you possibly launch a new web.

1:03:40service today where you know that has some kind of social everything without an A.P.I.

1:03:46I mean people do all the time but like how far can you go without having a P.R.

1:03:50And are we at a point now where having an A.P.I. Is the exception not the rule.

1:03:55Because you know five or ten years ago everything had to have an A.P.I. That was what people do.

1:04:00Then you wouldn't you wouldn't become big if you didn't have an A.P.I.

1:04:03As of yet still true though like Twitter is a great example which got big based on an analysis

1:04:08and a cut everybody off from it. But they wouldn't of gotten big without the A.P.I.

1:04:11So I don't know I think that avenue to getting big bike I think is still required to get big.

1:04:16No if you if you if you have some great thing that you say but there's no A.B.I.

1:04:21but We've made selective private libraries that use an A.P.I.

1:04:24That you're not allowed to use and you can put those libraries

1:04:26or apps on your devices in kind of like I don't think you get big like that.

1:04:29It would be like not being free in the beginning and charging everybody down to money.

1:04:34I think the tractor to get big is to try to at least make a show of look where part of the community

1:04:38and you can enter operate with us may have this great A.P.I.

1:04:40and Really encouraging people to build on your yeah sure if you've got a service

1:04:44and we've got a service we can to our servers you talk to each other we should integrated be great we'll have these

1:04:48great synergies and then when you get bigger and you can start turning the screws and cutting everybody off

1:04:51and charging money for a guy accessing all those wonderful things that we love to hate.

1:04:56So are you saying Marco that let's take an example that you're in a Twitter app

1:05:01and let's take Instagram perhaps you're an Instagram and you want to tag a photo with a location

1:05:08and you want to do that using the Foursquare A.P.I.

1:05:12Rather than have some sort of a view within the Instagram app you could dump out to the Foursquare extension that lets

1:05:23you search and then the Foursquare's extension will take the location you've selected

1:05:27and punted back to Instagram is that sort of what you're in visioning.

1:05:30Basically yeah like I'm looking at this from the perspective not of you know what's best for everybody technically

1:05:37but what's most likely to be best for everyone business wise and one of the most likely to do

1:05:41and you know you can look you know John you know what you just said about how if you have a kind of requirement for a

1:05:48good growth I'm not sure that's true anymore I mean look at look at big servers of that of launch like in the last five

1:05:54years. Many of them don't have an A.P.I. Many of them launched without one and now.

1:06:00Have one that's kind of half that half assed Arab

1:06:02or even like extremely restricted like even Google Plus Google phone service I mean that's not a good example because

1:06:08you know kind of failed but even Google plus launched with a very limited read only A.P.I.

1:06:14and If it didn't even didn't even have that first. Anyway I know when they launched the A.P.I.

1:06:19What it was at launch not when they launched the A.P.I.

1:06:21Was read only and I think it might still be Instagram pervert example got huge and they had a very limited A.P.I.

1:06:28That I believe was usually read only for almost everybody.

1:06:31The beginning

1:06:32and it's easy you know if you guys have a big problem this is the problem Twitter faced which is it's becomes very hard

1:06:39to monetize.

1:06:40If you become a dumb pipe unless you do you know sometimes you can do creepy things

1:06:45but for the most part like if you if people if your A.P.R.

1:06:49Is mostly an accessory to your service and people still keep coming to you and using your apps

1:06:54and your web site for the primary interaction with your service that's fine but if the A.P.I.

1:06:59Becomes your service and people are really only interacting with you through the A.P.I.

1:07:03It's very challenging to run a business that way for certain biz miles and certainly anything for you to add based

1:07:09and so you know I think we can look back at the Golden Era of web as in like the mid two thousand

1:07:15when everything had an A.B.R. and Everyone was talking about them as being like the big requirement.

1:07:20We can look back at that time

1:07:21and we can say you know actually in retrospect that was kind of a problem a lot of the work that used to be like free

1:07:29and naive are now like super lockdown unlimited

1:07:32and it's pretty easy to see that that was kind of giving away too much of a farm whereas now I'm sorry from the mixing

1:07:39metaphors there.

1:07:40Whereas now we have this other way where you the service provider can have these apps on these different platforms the

1:07:48only you don't need to cover that many of them you can't is actually different platforms that all have these ways to

1:07:54kind of offer A.P.I. Like services to other apps without actually giving up the farm or actual.

1:08:00It's not much control and

1:08:01and you know we're keeping everything locked down in private for the most part behind the scenes.

1:08:05Well there's a line between not having an A.P.I. and Having and becoming an A.B.I. Only pipe.

1:08:11Again we see that we see a Twitter

1:08:13and that continues in the beginning was like yeah sure everybody builds on Twitter everyone make your own crazy clients

1:08:18we want all sorts of different clients we want you know any place you can talk to where you are at the I'll do

1:08:24and then they you know becoming the most people interaction with Twitter was not through anything as what are

1:08:28controlled. That's one extreme but the other team is not having won it all. Twitter still has an A.P.I.

1:08:33Right at the very least they would have some kind of A.P.I.

1:08:36For like embedding tweets and putting little controls and buttons I mean the you know I thought maybe the public A.P.I.

1:08:41Put this mark down on your page. Supposed to this U.R.L.

1:08:45Make these buttons run this javascript like there has to be an A.P.I.

1:08:50Just doesn't have to be like you want to encourage people to integrate with your product.

1:08:55You don't necessarily want to encourage people to become your product and so I think the A.P.I.

1:09:00Use people have learned you know like you said don't become Don't become a faceless A.B.I.

1:09:04Given you become app that net right.

1:09:06Don't let everyone else to find experience of using your product it's the same way as like Apple you know taking

1:09:11control instead of tools.

1:09:12Don't let code mentor works in code

1:09:15or you're in power plant become the face of your platform because then you've lost control

1:09:18but I think you have to have some kind of web based A.P.I.

1:09:22If you want to interoperate with the wider world because you're never going to hit every platform

1:09:26and realistically speaking the little libraries

1:09:29and apps that you make for all the different platforms are going to have to be hitting A.P.I.

1:09:32Anyway and if they can hit it then other people are going to hit it.

1:09:34Do you really want to get into some kind of son of security war about having secret A.P.I.

1:09:39Endpoints that people have to figure out how to hack into and so this is going to use a lot

1:09:42or something anyway anyone can do it you know it's just a matter of getting an A.P.I. Key in an extract.

1:09:48I think a P.R.S.

1:09:49Will still be here but I think you're right that the lesson has been learned by several people in a painful way.

1:09:55Don't make your A.P.I. The only thing you offer because another people will become your product for you.

1:10:00But it's not so bad I mean they're sponsored posts and Instagram and Twitter and whatnot.

1:10:05I haven't seen them pushed on me and tweet about for example

1:10:08but there's nothing stopping them from being pushed on the right I think we're in the minority of people who are not

1:10:14using the official crazy as it is for us to drink about.

1:10:17Now you're right that we don't use the official Twitter app

1:10:20but I bet it would you say Were you think most people who use Twitter at all use the official Twitter app

1:10:25and a lot of alliances. No question. And like we are an oddity because we were there early.

1:10:31We don't look at Twitter that way

1:10:32and Twitter started to his credit has been like OK you know they shut the door on us we are in a little room together

1:10:40with our limited A.B.I.

1:10:40Talking from the address they were there in the beginning and no one bothers us

1:10:45and they just don't have to worry about us

1:10:47and all our growth is with those other people they could have said you know what third party stuff is turned off now

1:10:52you have to use these official client

1:10:54and I don't think it actually would have hurt them that much because all of us would have left in the past.

1:10:58Maybe the problem is all of us might have like hold on that thought an addon actually made that a viable platform

1:11:02or something but in the grand scheme of things we don't matter

1:11:05and so I'm glad that Twitter is not shoving stupid crap that Arthur our throats

1:11:09but I'm kind of sad that like we're never going to get like multiple images or these are the features they're adding

1:11:14and now I think that that really gets into the country

1:11:17but not as I thought it was even available to third party clients you could view multiple images

1:11:23and if you can post them now or anywhere they they're adding features

1:11:26and they don't care of third party if it's available for their places they're already won

1:11:30and so it doesn't surprise me that they're not making us choke down ads because who cares about us for often a car

1:11:36somewhere and it's probably the best move them not to anger us anymore and US Laos to stew in our

1:11:41and our little private third party Twitter clients.

1:11:44All right anything else we need to talk about there's a little bit of talk that we kind of skipped over about swift an

1:11:51apple I think Johnson's mostly your do you want to touch on that.

1:11:55Actually I want to talk about art briefly first before the swift thing of art was.

1:12:00When the thing Art is not a new thing it's something that the interesting Kit Kat

1:12:04but now it's official for their new US This will be their new runtime that they're using instead of the previous dial

1:12:09the virtual machine. This is them refining. I mean not the them saying this is their answer to swift and i O. S.

1:12:18and The A seven all that stuff

1:12:19but they're feeling pressure to have a more performant less battery sucking engine underneath their platform so that

1:12:27the language they use is Java for development they had their own job of virtual machine that they wrote themselves

1:12:32but just kind of novel called Tao that they've had for many many years.

1:12:36This new one is a new virtual machine that is better about memory management

1:12:41and has fewer stalls for garbage collection shorter stalls for garbage collection produces better code that runs faster

1:12:48on all the C.P.U. As they target I think that arm X.

1:12:51Eighty six and MIPS and they showed a bunch of performance figures showing how this is better.

1:12:56So I'm glad to see that Google is making progress on sort of the fundamental lowest level of that platform to make

1:13:04their applications faster

1:13:06and it shows the advantages that they have of you know having a merry face language in a virtual machine in that this

1:13:13change just really radical change under the cover does not require any changes.

1:13:18And anyone who wrote their application using Java you know if user a guy wrote thing you don't have to know

1:13:22or care about it they just major runtime faster whereas compare this to Apple which is made the object of C.

1:13:27Runtime faster.

1:13:28Many times over but you know we had the reeling your app against it

1:13:32or use certain features like faster numeration you had to change your source code to use them.

1:13:36I guess you know the name because you must send every gets a benefit when they re compile against new libraries

1:13:41but then it was only available six or seven blah blah blah.

1:13:44Anyway I'm glad to see Google making progress there mostly because I like the idea of virtual machine based languages I

1:13:52guess I'll probably have more to say about that

1:13:54when I do this with a section of my Osteria Hauser coming back away slowly. So is slowly and painfully.

1:14:03Thanks a lot two or three sponsors this week raise labs Squarespace and Linda dot com and we'll see you next week.

1:14:14The show is over to be an accidental accidental death was accidental

1:14:34and she is now sitting on the screen as it says to that list and that said they were going to for this one thing

1:15:14and be for the song. You know you can tell how unprofessional we are because here it is I Q Up John to talk about a.

1:15:22He talks about B. and Then before we get back to a can if in the after show you can be like follow down.

1:15:30I mean I just as a reward for the people people are things just on topic but hey you've made it through the song

1:15:37and here we are on the other side. This is your.

1:15:39Yeah it was something I was been thinking about since the Via really see about how Apple is being more open with things

1:15:47and I've seen things from apples and stuff that I had not seen from Apple in years and years

1:15:53and years maybe not ever in the second. Steve Jobs are like after ninety seven and that.

1:16:00There is the phenomenon of Apple employees saying in a more

1:16:06or less official capacity something that Apple is going to do in the future.

1:16:12There we saw that today which I think you're about to bring up right and not just today I've seen it many many times

1:16:18and studied every see that one just and I keep seeing it was blowing my mind.

1:16:21The one today was like my gas did a blog post about Swift.

1:16:24Chris Lander responded to the blog post

1:16:26and said that thing you were complaining about were going to change that which is basically talking about an announced

1:16:32product

1:16:33and I've seen that multiple times about you know nerdy technology is not like oh we're going to watch like going to

1:16:38going to say that red button of about thirty technologies only developers care about the developers are willing to say

1:16:43like oh yeah that idea doesn't exist or whatever but we're going to make it like we're going to do is that before G.M.

1:16:50or That feature you asked for. We're doing that right now. Not sure when it's going to be done.

1:16:55That's you know Apple does not come in a future products

1:16:57but apparently Apple now comments on future technologies being open and you won't be able to watch the videos

1:17:02and actual Apple engineers saying that you know this is not exciting

1:17:07or surprising to anyone who deals in the company of Apple

1:17:11but historically Apple engineers would never say that even like the most obscure little thing like I think this

1:17:18argument of this method should accept no and it shouldn't be an error and you just have to sit there

1:17:23and wait until venture like your bug was closed or just a release comes out and that's in the release notes

1:17:27and said Today Apple and Apple engineer will say yeah we're in the process of doing that it will be in the next build.

1:17:34I guess that has happened to some degree like on the day of forms and pass bills and stuff like that

1:17:38but this is about something big like Swift is bigger than just one obscure A.P.I.

1:17:41So if there's a whole language

1:17:43and on the deformed For example people are complaining about missing features in a Swiss language

1:17:47and people you know who are writing so if they're coming in today for them saying You write that feature is missing

1:17:52we're adding it now it will be there soon.

1:17:54Like talking about future products is blowing my mind this is happening at any second acts like a black.

1:18:00Helicopter to come in and like close the thread and delete the post and nuclear we think

1:18:04and you know so let's form sort of acting on it N.D.A. Which I wasn't a violent talk about details.

1:18:08This is on a public blog post if it was a thing that he was talking about

1:18:12and there was a race of medics being crazy which they are I mean it was vague it was like we know they're crazy.

1:18:18We're going to try to fix it.

1:18:20Jake thumbs up say without that part of the world

1:18:22and you know like if we don't mix it is ever going to go on I was well I totally expected you to fix the crazy race

1:18:28semantics when you saw that comment on a blog post

1:18:30but you didn't think that I hate you Apple like that's that that's the thing they're protecting against

1:18:34and I suppose that can happen if you're seventy ships and I was eight ships

1:18:38and so if there is a manifesto crazy pants then people are going to like site that blog so we can't trust you after you

1:18:44say things with and don't do them I don't know I just assume they're just going to do it and everything will be fine

1:18:49but it is definitely weird to see that and definitely change for Apple. So what's the downside to it for them.

1:18:57I just said the downside downside is if they don't do this thing then crazy people be O'Grady

1:19:02but is that really why they didn't do it for all this time I mean.

1:19:06Yeah because you can't predict the future you don't do across time because if they say something

1:19:10and they're not able to deliver it it breaks trust so they just say nothing I guess

1:19:16but to your point about like developer tools that are coming years like I just I don't I don't really see the need for

1:19:26all the secrecy up until this point I applaud the opening up that they've been doing lately

1:19:32but I don't know it just seems like a pretty weak reason to be so unbelievably secretive.

1:19:37It seems to me like the reason they were secretive is because they felt like it was cool to be secretive if you're

1:19:42secretive about products you can be secretive about everything it's not just about the cool factor

1:19:47but it's you know someone is put in the child room under promise

1:19:50and over deliver it's it's the safe bet you will have you'll not disappoint people you only surprise them because you

1:19:58only disappoint somebody said by so.

1:20:00When you're going to something and not doing it if you never say anything and you don't do it.

1:20:03You don't disappoint a member they should have had no reason to expect that you were going to do something

1:20:07but if you say you're going to something and don't do it then people are disappointed.

1:20:10But is that really true I mean Martin I know the market isn't really the best judge of anything.

1:20:15However you know any time Apple doesn't release a T.V.

1:20:19Viewers are watching the market has a fit about it and they've never said anything about doing any of those things.

1:20:25That's I think a counter-example because can cook up saying we're going to enter a new product category so yes it is he

1:20:29says that like a year ago every time Apple does anything it doesn't enter a new product category.

1:20:34You know people's use center a new product category and you did something anything

1:20:39and the thing involved in that did not enter a new product category therefore age you know Apple who cares like this is

1:20:46more of the larger the feature the less you'd want to say stuff like this like you know if you're talking about like

1:20:53this this A.P.I.

1:20:54Is is available but it's Iowa seven only

1:20:59and if someone from Apple were to say Actually we're going to back port that is Iowa six to people that like oh yeah

1:21:04that's awesome I can't wait until that happens my app will be able to run and I was six and seven uses cool new A.P.I.

1:21:09and Then like the O. S.

1:21:10Comes out and says Sorry we didn't get time to back or that I was six and now we're never going to.

1:21:14People would hate Apple that all you said you were going to I plan my business around you.

1:21:18You know destroyed my livelihood zone or if they just say nothing

1:21:22and they say file bugs you like to see them as I was six

1:21:24or whatever you know they don't make any promises they just don't say anything you say.

1:21:28If you every time you ask them a question I say the same developer I was seven.

1:21:31But it's going to be on I was six guys available or I was seven I guess the old Apple way

1:21:35and there are serious upsides to that but at a certain point becomes ridiculous as you get tinier

1:21:41and tinier like are you going to fix a typo in the documentation.

1:21:44It's no skin off Apple's back to say yes we're going to fix that type of documentation in fact I'm fixing right now you

1:21:49should see it in the next build like that's always been under the line like no big deal

1:21:53but once you move from typos up until you know A.P.I. Features A.P.I. Availability language.

1:22:00Teachers that's starting to get into some serious territory and you know this is this the new Apple i think

1:22:06and I applaud it and I think Marco would say one of us had said break before D.C.

1:22:13That we didn't really know crap about what was coming when we knew Health Kit which we thought was health book

1:22:19and there were like one or two other things but certainly nobody knew Swift was coming

1:22:23and that made it so much more enjoyable I'm not saying Apple shouldn't be secretive about like product launches I'm

1:22:28talking like your like you are John about this and I mean you sure but perhaps it isn't

1:22:34but stuff that for the most part really isn't going to make or break anyone

1:22:38and yes you know you just you just had an example of where it could break someone

1:22:42but I don't I'm I'm surprised it took this long for them to open up the continuum like the one I think I'm also a sixty

1:22:48four bit carbon which they said they were going to have and then change their mind on

1:22:52and that's like a bummer like it wasn't it wasn't like they didn't have it almost all done.

1:22:56Is my understanding and it was like that and plan on doing it. They did plan on doing it.

1:23:00They did say they were going to do it but they changed their mind the next year

1:23:03and that did really seriously affect people

1:23:05and you know secrecy would've saved them there because I was sort of sort of like they said they said that they're

1:23:11going to have over us ten ten ten and I was eight.

1:23:14Those are speaking about future products

1:23:17but we assume those will actually arrive that they want to you know never mind about I was eight.

1:23:21Like that seems like a safe bet

1:23:23but technically it's exactly the same things we do not have this for you now it is not completed but we will

1:23:28and making a comment about a feature and like saying we we agree that the race semantics are stupid

1:23:35but we are working on them

1:23:37and we plan to have the better version of them available before any of our whatever operating system ship.

1:23:43That's a pretty concrete statement about something that's going to happen.

1:23:46It's probably not much more concrete than saying Iowa State is coming in we're going to ship it

1:23:51and here is the rough time frame

1:23:53but it is definitely a change like Normally they would just let the blog's all complain about stuff and swift and.

1:24:00I secretly be over there saying all these people are complaining about you know feature X.

1:24:03Whereas we know the project has been checked in two weeks ago and we're just like testing it out now and it'll ship

1:24:09and exceed among those people who pleasantly surprised but now those people who actually go on to the Internet

1:24:13and tweeted the people like I just totally did that don't worry it's coming.

1:24:18And what else going on I think there's a M three at the local dealer I haven't actually gone by

1:24:25but I was not because my car's actually gone on Monday anyway so I'll see it on and then I'll probably steal it

1:24:32and get arrested not only the end of A.T.P. We keep doing it with you in jail.

1:24:37All I know is I want to them through that. Sorry Luigi follow only the Ferrari.

1:24:44What I didn't do my pop culture references I stuck it in the bin. Now that's in the movie a million.

1:24:52Margot has children and soon Casey will too.

1:24:55A million times I know every line in that movie because I've seen it a million times you want to scream it from the

1:25:02tops of those very high you see I was going to say that.

1:25:07How could that movie possibly get old but I know enough to know that any movie can break

1:25:13and well it's actually a pretty good movie I mean that's that's that's that's one of the reasons why adults love Pixar

1:25:18movies so much is because if your kids are going to make you watch the same movie every single day for three months it

1:25:23will be a pretty decent one. Yeah you know you don't know how bad it can get.

1:25:27Like I mean you're probably protecting yourself from it I thing is like cars people say is not one of the better Pixar

1:25:33movies and maybe I kind of agree there

1:25:36but lots of people who don't have kids dislike it much more than I do because now in retrospect the memory of course is

1:25:41entirely tied up with the memory of my son when he was young in Washington movie a lot

1:25:45and I think the same thing will happen to Marco

1:25:46and that that gives the movie a fondness that it would have had if you had just seen it on your own.

1:25:51Just wait until now to get older and he remember when he was a little peanut and he would watch the movie over

1:25:55and over again. I love cars cars two was freaking terrible though I haven't seen cars.

1:26:00Two because I heard it was terrible so I I'm just like I'm not I'm not even buying that an Apple T.V.

1:26:04and Is leaving it off don't do it and the worst part is Michael Caine isn't it.

1:26:09And I love Michael Caine but the movie was still terrible.

1:26:12Well it's not terrible I do you don't know terrible until you see him like Dora the Explorer

1:26:16or something like that I mean terrible does the whole other thing the movies just says there are right now.

1:26:21That's right let's put that one in the parking lot for you know exactly where you want two titles on one of the

1:26:27functional shoebox which means not mine. Yeah I have put that in the parking lot for now.

1:26:33Confess that this is a business speak terminology but I can't.

1:26:38Like what planet is everyone on Marco to put things in perspective. I went to a client today at what time was it.

1:26:48About nine for a ten o'clock demo that demo lasted half an hour.

1:26:54I spent half an hour dealing with security related things because it's a new client so I had to get fingerprinted.

1:27:03I had to go swear that I had antivirus on my computer that I needed to prove that I antivirus on my computer.

1:27:10Then we spent from eleven thirty five in consecutive meetings talking about the work that has been done in the work

1:27:20that needs to be done.

1:27:22My god that was from eleven thirty until five in the evening

1:27:26when the screamer fall standoffs happen is actually the end of.

1:27:31So it was a retrospective which is part of agile and then it was Sprint planning which is part of agile.

1:27:37But the problem is this is for a large government entity

1:27:40and I don't think most of the business people in the room that these are our own internal business people have had a

1:27:47lot of experience with like doing strong agile software projects.

1:27:51And so it's really kind of scrum or fall at best and that's just bad. But anyway so. Back to titles.

1:28:01Did they have a parking lot.

1:28:03No not today actually but a basement is there do you like put things in the basement

1:28:06and over you know just a parking lot but you know back behind the dumpster like is there.

1:28:11No the alley is there an alley even though you can't like throw something at the fire escape.

1:28:18No Marco you got the same metaphor that I was developing basement U.I. You know speaking of basements.

1:28:23Same same stuff the hamburger basement metaphor.

1:28:26Exactly the same exact thing why is that terminology OK with this terminology is not because we are right now that is

1:28:33most market statement ever heard in my defense I don't like the hamburger basement metaphor

1:28:37but you use it because it's a way to communicate with other people a shorthand.

1:28:41So exactly when buzzwords and lingo are supposed to do that you can say this

1:28:44and then be sure that everyone who you're talking to knows what you mean without you having to explain it the long way

1:28:49and there was there was some time where it where I mentioned hamburger basement on Twitter a few months back

1:28:54and I got the best responses from people who didn't know what that was and there

1:28:59and there they were filling your role now saying is there now only Bubble Ball Game.

1:29:05I actually liked breaking bots I think that's I don't think it should necessarily be a show title

1:29:09but it's pretty funny. I'm also a big fan of I'm not getting one.

1:29:13There's actually two of the moment a period

1:29:15when without If you combine the ratings for even better so you get you get up the working show about features by doing

1:29:21better normalization and getting rid of trailing periods.

1:29:26Fair enough I'll get to that as soon as I can keep the thing running for more than ten for ten minutes.

1:29:30Hugo and Marsh OK So this is like that that old web site give up

1:29:36and use tables with a timer for you to try to do things that going to battle days of C.S.S.

1:29:41when You can do lots of of a sea of us you know one more show and then Marco

1:29:46and I are going to force you to stop using web sockets and enforcers after that you go to use Perl.

1:29:51Although if we realistically speaking

1:29:54when we should stop your news events are good for you started using them for a shoebox because there's no reason to use

1:29:59Linux.

1:30:00Protect our curiosity so we give you an hour we'll give you a couple weeks say OK you just want to do is really just

1:30:04playing with things you want to go fine go ahead

1:30:07but a certain point to say Look just make it work stop using website at

1:30:11but if you think about it it's the right answer for it leaves no it is not a persistent connection to the clients of

1:30:17like no it is not the right answer.

1:30:19Well it actually is useful because it gives you the immediate feedback of the new stuff comes in you don't need

1:30:24immediately people staring at the show I need to see what someone has changed a vote right now if you don't the latency

1:30:30unpeople looking at show voting does not need to be real time this is not like a game

1:30:36or a simulation where we need feedback like it's not they perpetrate Knology for this purpose.

1:30:41You could have a fifty five minute refresh interval and it would be fine it's just a show but not a real time three D.

1:30:48Application.

1:30:49John the last time I said it's just a show but it was about hardening said shoebox and we also have that end

1:30:55but the Web sites are fighting against you and that area like they're making it worse.

1:31:00It's a technology that it either is not mature enough

1:31:03or I mean it seems like the library for dealing with are mature enough because if they were you wouldn't be having all

1:31:07these problems.

1:31:08I just can't imagine what the heck is going on behind the scenes here that's causing even the worst crappiest slowest

1:31:17of B.P.'s in the universe to overload and crash not overloading is a store an exception that nobody catches

1:31:22and they killed it.

1:31:23Most of them will then once I get around the problem

1:31:25but this is because the inception of the coming from within website gets exactly as a third party libraries during

1:31:31exception that I guess you didn't expect I think over the specifics of the bug

1:31:34but that wasn't a bug in the actual website it's library I just repasted the jest

1:31:38and it's very they where the actual problem is. But that's right and C.

1:31:46Sharp have exceptions case you just not accustomed to having to catch exceptions

1:31:49and deal with them you know there's no need to be cruel to him like she says the whole thing in try catch

1:31:56and always keep the thing from going down. Well generally.

1:32:00I would prefer for this situation to die violently and tell me exactly what's going on

1:32:05and I think actually we got a pretty big fight with Marco about this yes

1:32:09or no it's like I said turning that into yes turning that fiddlers you're not turning warnings into fatal errors.

1:32:16You're not doing anything with fatal errors

1:32:19and I think it's fine for example to have multi-process mild to let your apache child die because it had a fatal error

1:32:24because the whole service doesn't come away and then there's where you lose all your data.

1:32:28The parent the parent will just spawn another child and it will go on but I want to single process

1:32:33and you're not catching exceptions.

1:32:35And one comes along you're saying a process goes away and that's what we agree we agree

1:32:40but my point is just that if the error was something more specific like oh somebody tried to send ten thousand bite

1:32:48thing over over this Web site that then I could take action on that

1:32:53and thus harden a system a little better that what I'm going to do however since I didn't get useful feedback is I'm

1:32:59going to add a you know a try catch if you will or at least handle this error message error vent

1:33:06and then call that call today because clearly I'm not getting anything useful from it.

1:33:11Well it's like when I maybe any web server if the client sends invalid you know invalid method type

1:33:16or whatever like you could you can make the pier that's malformed

1:33:20and your server should handle Yeah garbage client connected to me he sent me something of a kind of like trying to be

1:33:24rigorous but I actually was invalid because the method I use doesn't actually exist in this header

1:33:28or it sent this method but it didn't have the required headers

1:33:32but it claimed to be one point one like either your library

1:33:36or if you're not your library they'll use your app has that has to be resilient to people sending you garbage

1:33:41and you would think that would be the job of the library like you're writing something on you know patchy platform

1:33:46or using my P.H.P. or Something like that.

1:33:48Your sim in the pageant going to handle like crazy in doubt

1:33:51or question Is everyone going to get to the point where I get your P.H.P.

1:33:54Does that Patty's going to return to five hundred error and tragedy

1:33:56or pay Tantlinger wherever you want to do before it even gets to your thing but.

1:34:00The Web site his library is not doing that for you

1:34:01and we don't even know if it's because people are sending mail form website

1:34:04or requests it could just be a bug in the library and people are sending perfectly valid website requests

1:34:09and this is choking out.

1:34:10Either way it's not good for your server and if you just did everything the old fashioned way with a T S B

1:34:16and Ajax you would be having this problem.

1:34:18That's possibly true

1:34:19and I would like to address something from the chat somebody said I don't understand how Casey could be a professional

1:34:25programmer

1:34:26and I think it's important to realize that I am working in technologies that are not typically used to working in a so

1:34:33in so far as noting web sockets but B.

1:34:35and More importantly this is something I threw together for fun in not a lot of time.

1:34:40I'm not being paid to do this and I'm not doing this for my job.

1:34:46I'm doing this just for grins and giggles and just to learn

1:34:50and a lot of the things that I'm fighting like people deliberately being malicious are things that I don't often run

1:34:56into in my day to day work

1:34:58and so I would have put in a crap load more time being defensive in my programming instead of being defensive right now

1:35:07and making sure all of these things were considered in taking care of and things of that nature

1:35:13but I didn't say I didn't spend the time on it B.

1:35:17I still don't think I should but the chat room is a bunch of pains my butt

1:35:21and see this is not like my normal job my normal job I'm paid to consider all of these possibilities

1:35:28and to spend the time to to get all this right and this is something I threw together in the sum total of like three

1:35:35or four hours.

1:35:36So it's a very different I would I would say let's not pretend this is not the way that the person who said that

1:35:41comment strikes me as someone who is not a programmer because that's not to pretend this isn't the way that all

1:35:45programming happens it just may not happen in public but this is how you write a program guys.

1:35:50You try it you find out how it's broken you fix it like this in the process of programming it just that he's doing it

1:35:55sort of in public. The writers normally also be happening on your local computer.

1:36:00As you write it and try to use it and it crashes and you write something else and you try to use it and it screws up

1:36:03and like that's called programming.

1:36:05Do you think it would work better if you were running an a virus software on your mac.

1:36:10You know that antivirus thing like I mean I understand why people do that

1:36:14but that's so insane to me that like people would insist that you have antivirus software in your bag I wonder if the

1:36:20same requirement applies to i Phones you have antivirus software on an i Phone I'm sorry it's not it's not qualified to

1:36:25can we can use that.

1:36:26Well I mean again this is a government entity

1:36:28and I don't know if you Well John you should know better than even that government entities are things that are

1:36:34associated with the government they tend to have just piles and piles and piles and piles

1:36:38and piles of red tape much of which is not understood by the people that enforce it.

1:36:43Yeah but they do change like my wife works in a place that has crazy requirements

1:36:47and it used to be that you couldn't bring any device that had a camera anywhere you know you can bring a camera

1:36:52anything that had a camera on it and then one phone started have cameras you can bring any of the cameras.

1:36:56Then he phones with cameras and because that's a camera right.

1:36:58But a certain point all phones have cameras

1:37:00and then it's untenable to tell people I'm sorry you can't bring your phone to work

1:37:05and so they had to change the rules

1:37:06and say OK well it's obvious that we can you know be like well Blackberry makes a special model that doesn't have

1:37:12phones in them for enterprise and that's what we're going to force everyone to use whatever

1:37:17but now it's like you know even the government has to eventually recognize you know and so they did

1:37:22and they said OK well there's certain areas where you can't bring your phone

1:37:26or any camera because we assume your phone has a camera but you can bring your phone to work and send

1:37:30and receive phone calls with it.

1:37:32So eventually you know they'll catch up but they don't require you to have antivirus software on your i was device

1:37:37but I bet in two thousand and seven they sure did and were sad when you told them that makes no sense

1:37:43but places I worked that did a lot of government contracting for a long time the official stance was you may not have a

1:37:51camera phone and this is right when you just like he said one phones with cameras started becoming prevalent

1:37:56and I believe they changed the policy. But yeah it's.

1:38:00It's a tough thing it's a lot of stuff that market isn't have to deal with and probably doesn't have the patience for.

1:38:05And sometimes I wonder if I do it.

1:38:08Yeah I don't think I've never been in the job that I had that have laid my internship at Nationwide

1:38:14and all these other I have never been in the job because like I've always been at the small companies where I can

1:38:21pretty much have whatever I want on the computer.

1:38:23Well that's the thing is for my company it was I found it extremely agreed just

1:38:28when they instituted a you have to change your password every ninety days policy

1:38:33and I'm not trying to get into a security discussion about why that's important or good

1:38:36or bad I'm at sixty days Casey right now. And in two thousand and fourteen. Right so the C.S.O.

1:38:43I was really upset when when that happened but I mean my computer it's wide open I can do whatever crap I want with it.

1:38:49It's the problem is is that because I do consulting when we work for

1:38:53and with clients we have to generally speaking not always we usually roll with their rules and their rules

1:39:00when you work with either large government entities

1:39:03or large financial services companies as my company tends to do have tremendously strict

1:39:09and difficult rules so it's not that all the real world is bad markets to some parts just the parking lot just the

1:39:17parking lots and we don't have any. Yes So by I mean I'm three let's go back to the important stuff they were around.

1:39:27You know also suffers all suffer through black just for you know one of the color would you pick.

1:39:34Mustard mustard yellow Fishel taluk mustard efficient German color of yeah I think that's a that's a B.

1:39:41The deal is if I if I get to buy you a history I get to pick the color and you have to drive it. Oh no that's fine.

1:39:47Just give me the right transmission for christ sakes.

1:39:49That is by the way and and speaking of the most recent car

1:39:52and driver more stuff for your case it was that there were thirty cars under thirty thousand dollars section I don't

1:39:56know if I've gotten this one you look at the white white car snob.

1:40:00Thirty thousand to thirty thousand to cover the hot hats back story was on the cover. Nothing interesting.

1:40:07But anyway my car is right in there and thirty cars under thirty three but they say they love it. Now they're wrong.

1:40:14I think we call it nearly perfect. Definitely not even you agree with that.

1:40:21I thought I said nearly all right I've built my M three I think is it like seventy five grand.

1:40:29Seventy five to fifty mark.

1:40:33Too many options on a stand of use how do you like there are choices for anything so it's like well I guess I'm getting

1:40:39this interior color and this is like looking at these leather colors trim colors and B.M.W.

1:40:44Individual other interims like I don't know what combinations look at this the promise of a car is that you pick

1:40:49everything because they're going to handle if you're anywhere in Japan you know half a million dollars.

1:40:52But I'd be like I don't know what looks good together it's your job to decide what colors in the interim look good

1:40:57together in the end it will read people just pick and like the random combinations

1:41:01and you know you've got to have a million dollar car with nothing to match isn't it right now that I'm depressed

1:41:06because I don't want to spend seventy three thousand eight hundred twenty five dollars

1:41:09or nine hundred sixty dollars a month on a three on the go to bed.

1:41:14Also you would never actually pay their their list price you can negotiate way lower than that now so I just Marco go

1:41:23ahead

1:41:23and buy one for me I'll drive in black I don't care I might even I might even accept it if it had the stupid D.C.T.

1:41:29That's sounds like you're changing your mind a little bit on the D.C.T. That C.

1:41:32That sounds a lot like not be willing to suffer through is what I'm saying I would not choose it myself.

1:41:39I'm saying that that sounds a lot like you know this fish isn't really that bad I kind of like that one song.

1:41:44Sounds like you're changing. Finally like I'm winning you over there.

1:41:48I'm proud to tell you that I continue to not know

1:41:52and I have never known the title of any fish song would not recognize any of her songs if I heard them

1:41:57and despite you toots continuing to discuss for a song. By title.

1:42:00Now I also do not remember any of this is I don't one by title I have I wouldn't recognize if I heard them on the radio

1:42:07I did not know a single title of the sales of Dave Matthews unfortunately another few of the Top forty is new You've

1:42:14mispronounced Fortunately it's my curse.

1:42:18What this perhaps unfortunately you know and knowing the day Matt and knowing some of the.