Podcast Search

The Accidental Tech Podcast

7: The Forecast For iCloud

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00it's interesting at all I'm bored what we're talking about tonight is anything

0:00:07to talk about the summary thing I know I thought your post about david was really

0:00:13interesting this is obviously mutual admiration society but I thought it was

0:00:19very it was very person in in impressive that he was smart enough not to reveal

0:00:25his age and then made in hoops and and like you said suddenly every article

0:00:30about amber became about his age rather than the fact that number was really

0:00:33well done right and that's too bad but I've never used some least I don't know

0:00:38if it's any good apparently you say it's not good I i was i mean I don't know

0:00:43what they did in the last six to nine months they they had they have their

0:00:50whole app that was the whole news browsing thing that all came about

0:00:53fairly recently before all that is when I tried it so i didnt trying to do stuff

0:00:57so I can't really speak to what it was but the originally the whole

0:01:02summarization engine I was really not impressed by

0:01:07I think it was a reasonable idea to try to do something like that but it wasn't

0:01:15that compelling like something like that we're okay so the idea of this thing is

0:01:19to take any web article news article whatever the case and summarize it into

0:01:25like three little $0.01 bullet points and so the idea that you don't have to

0:01:30read everything well first of all somebody who likes reading things that's

0:01:33kind of missing the point but OK to some uses for that I can see that the problem

0:01:39is the summaries were so bad I'm not you know occasionally would get maybe one

0:01:45and a half of the three bullet points would make sense but that wasn't the

0:01:49best Irish I do so it was a way to poorly summarized news stories sometimes

0:01:57and so to me i just don't have anywhere that fits into my life and probably

0:02:03don't remember this because you didn't start using that until recently but back

0:02:06in the classic Mac OS two is Apple made a big stink at one point in it

0:02:10sad decline in the nineties about system wide text summarization service where

0:02:16you could select text and asked to summarize it and it would summarize it

0:02:19down to a couple sentences the sound familiar yet and this was classic macros

0:02:24and that feature might still be in there should go back and I caught him in and

0:02:28see if there's a summarized tax thing with that but it predates Pakistan my

0:02:33recollection and yet not that feature did not set the world on fire and you

0:02:39know I don't know what the state of the art is with with natural language

0:02:42processing doing summarization I'm sure this probably good stuff out there but

0:02:48the thing with lots of natural language processing or or AI type algorithms is

0:02:54that a lot of times the best they can ever do is like an 80 percent job and so

0:02:59there's a lot of cases in the rubber that's useful but usually when you're

0:03:04like directly between the data and the human and you're trying to do like just

0:03:08as one smart thing that involves language and and concepts and a very

0:03:14subjective difficult complicated things it's it's not usually good idea to to

0:03:21expose the ASAP addressed to people whose usual it's like let's say it's 95%

0:03:26good 5% is still pretty often you're looking to hit that a lot you know so

0:03:31like John you talked a lot about speech recognition software you use it a lot

0:03:36and dictation software you know what what do you think is like the the most

0:03:42the highest acceptable error rate that you would still use it for summarization

0:03:48of her speech speech recognition in the area is pretty high and I'm I think I'd

0:03:56be willing to put up with a much higher rate than I currently get in fact I

0:03:59think I'd be willing to trade correctness for responsiveness because

0:04:05when you're trying to speak you don't want to be waiting like that the

0:04:09building technician dictation and I was 10 is the worst case because you

0:04:14activate a little thing and then he's a little blinking cursor funny you think

0:04:17you talk then

0:04:19you have to activate the thing again to say okay take what I just said and do

0:04:24something with it and then you started the blanket thing and then a whole bunch

0:04:27of tax comes on screen and that's when you find out whether it is been totally

0:04:30off the rails whereas if it had exactly the same area but did it were to time in

0:04:35a kind of Syrian the Google you know I was talk speech searching thing

0:04:41responsiveness i think is more important than than correctness this obviously was

0:04:45you know seventy percent error you'd be annoyed but I think being responsive is

0:04:50more important than being psychic correct because the dragon is really has

0:04:54really really good actually really high accuracy but still frustrate me

0:04:57sometimes when I'm talking faster than the taxes appearing and I had to stop

0:05:00and maybe I don't have to stop but I do stop to wait to see the last you know

0:05:04fifteen words come splashing out on the screen usually all at once to say that

0:05:08it's on the same page because you don't do that if you just like close your eyes

0:05:11and talk it will do an amazingly good job but every once in a while to get

0:05:14something off and I'll go back and I'll be but what I do know what are called

0:05:17wrote by speaking and I have no idea what the hell I was saying and how do I

0:05:21look at it and try to think a comment and say now like which word that sounds

0:05:25like the words on the page because when you make your own typos it's like I was

0:05:29typing the right word and I scribbled out what it was you said but when you do

0:05:33like speech shows where it transcribes the wrong thing it's it could be so far

0:05:38off semantically and I've literally had times where I sit I have no idea what

0:05:42the heck I was trying to say here business sense actually makes no sense

0:05:44whatsoever know all the words are spelled correctly in english words they

0:05:47don't make any sense another remember what I was saying and I gotta like say

0:05:50the word as written out loud and closed my eyes and think about it sounds like

0:05:54what I mean I don't think anyone many people would choose to use speech

0:05:59recognition for this way like I wouldn't be using it if I didn't have our side

0:06:03things with typing right that I think that's why you'll know

0:06:06speech recognition has really arrived when people who can already type very

0:06:11quickly

0:06:12shoes to use speech recognition instead because it's like if he is fast or you

0:06:19know it's so accurate that is why would you bother putting your fingers around

0:06:23know that right now it's not a a group activity what I mean by that is if

0:06:30you're working in an office cubicles like john i presume you do and how I

0:06:34certainly do if all of us are talking to our computers that's going to be a bit

0:06:40allowed to say the least and furthermore you know doing the sorts of things that

0:06:45all three of us do which is right code which is a far cry from regular pros I I

0:06:52never imagined nor tried to do speech recognition for writing code but i John

0:06:57I can't imagine you're writing pearl and regular expressions which is basically

0:07:00the same thing using speech recognition is not the same thing and no and a good

0:07:11role I i do my best if you like you know there's this place is for the stuff like

0:07:18a lot of people have said that you know first of all there are there

0:07:23opportunities for anything that could be considered an assistive technology for

0:07:28people like dictation is great for people who can't type and RSI is you

0:07:33know a usually mild but still a handicap and so if you if you can't or would

0:07:40rather not use your hands to type then it's great to have alternatives but you

0:07:48know the place for the stuff is in other contexts you know people who don't

0:07:52permanently have a specific disability but who might temporarily have one for

0:07:56example when you're driving you really shouldn't be typing so when driving also

0:08:02theoretically hopefully partially blind to your computing device so that's why

0:08:08things like voice commands and audio cues can be so useful in a mobile app

0:08:14that they are expected to use while you're in the cards like serious great

0:08:17for that but you know syria is not good enough for me to dictate everything that

0:08:22way you know as john said like it when you have alternatives will take them but

0:08:26it's still good to have this thing when you don't have alternative motives or

0:08:31worse I'm trying to look up to a text summarization service in class

0:08:35and i cant find it all I can find to the references to it existing a Mac OS 10 so

0:08:40maybe I miss remembering the time I could have sworn this was like from

0:08:43michael has paid or whatever but anyway if you want to just fired txt Edit now

0:08:46in Pakistan's put it past the budget ax in there from an article

0:08:50select the tax code of the Services menu summarized will be in there if you

0:08:53didn't deactivate it in your profane and you get a little slider that lets you

0:08:56you know cracking down to you know one sentence if you want so I gotta

0:09:02understand how I don't know anything about this only thing except except what

0:09:06i've read his blog and like two other news stories and summarization is not

0:09:12the whole thing was like it would you know it was going to let you consume

0:09:16news without you having to look for all the news you try to give you a condensed

0:09:20version but not you know I am I getting this right but not any human do it

0:09:23having the computer do it and summarization would be a part of that

0:09:27but if it's the summarization part of their excited about like you know this

0:09:32feature is always existed for a long time but there is a classic Mac OS not

0:09:35knowing cares that it's there is it patent encumbered is it like I I still

0:09:40don't understand why they pay $39 I don't understand it all that will answer

0:09:46that and that's what a lot of the debate has been about is you know first of all

0:09:50it's cool to say Yahoo is being stupid because I who's had some pretty bad

0:09:54decades so everyone's like a look at how stupid yahoos being again but I don't

0:09:59think that's I don't think it's them being stupid you know usually if you

0:10:02think a company's being stupid usually you are looking at the whole picture or

0:10:07they're there something that you're missing or you know there's some better

0:10:09reason for what they're doing that's better explain then they're idiots so I

0:10:15think you can look at the company is grim now called blackberry anyway that

0:10:22they actually are idiots but for the most part everybody else you know when

0:10:25when the explanation is how they're being stupid is usually more to it so I

0:10:29think in this case a lot of people have suggested so it so here's the deal day

0:10:33they bought some Lee the the product and part of the staff for thirty million

0:10:39dollars most of actress cash I think they said 10 percent woodstock but all

0:10:43the numbers are actually

0:10:45door from inside sources unnamed the numbers were not officially made public

0:10:48but everyone saying thirty million dollars mostly in cash and so the end

0:10:53and it's a classic textbook

0:10:54higher the product is immediately shut down and Yahoo paid for this I started

0:11:01at a relatively modest sum for basically for three people were the three most

0:11:08important people by their definition to work for Yahoo for a minimum of 18

0:11:13months so basically they've paid like 10 million ahead for these key people and

0:11:19that's that sounds even more crazy now that you're telling me more about this

0:11:22I'm thinking it's crazy that I thought so they're shutting down the stupid

0:11:26product that summarizes stuff so it's it's gone it's they pulled from the App

0:11:29Store and i know i dont standard like there's no way those three people over

0:11:35thirty million dollars this know that some people are saying that that the

0:11:42technology was actually license from ESRI the the parent company of Syria

0:11:46before up about it that that the the speech recognition or the natural

0:11:51language processing technology was actually ESRI's and it was licensed from

0:11:54them that simply didn't develop that but then the Somali people are denying that

0:11:58so that's it's unclear what what is the truth there but at least what Yahoo but

0:12:03at least we know that he bought was they paid thirty million dollars for these

0:12:07three people one of whom is the 17 year old kid Nick got it should not

0:12:12references last name do you start of the alloy CEO and EtOAc oh I'm sorry I'm

0:12:21probably sharing that Nick D hehe but not make done this is tough anyway

0:12:30Nick D lolz oh sorry he started this company was 15 now e17 so now he's a

0:12:37seventeen year old tech whiz kid Millionaire which of course the press

0:12:40loves to bang on that angle so much

0:12:43and and I i kinda rip them apart yesterday for that as as you're saying

0:12:47the top of the show about how that was originally a problem a tumbler with

0:12:51david was so young but you know so all the stories are about how young this kid

0:12:58is or about the tech press freaking out that why the heck today by this and why

0:13:03they pay so much but to bring us back a little bit we had a couple weeks ago we

0:13:09had a question from Bobby Becker he suggested an interesting topic he said

0:13:13what if Apple bought Yahoo and the idea there was like Apple needs to buy or

0:13:21Apple needs good server side and services talent and Yahoo might have

0:13:26that an apartment this topic for a little bit Yahoo is is still very

0:13:31popular among especially among non geek demographics like normal people as we

0:13:37like to say in the world which is probably condescending or somehow weird

0:13:41but sorry about that I don't know what the right term is none do you think is

0:13:46fair but I think Yahoo is for the most part of resting on their previously

0:13:52previously achieved laurels and I don't think they've really done a lot in the

0:13:59last decade maybe two to really get new users and to really grow the company and

0:14:03that's why everyone has had a bit of trouble and that's why isn't it was

0:14:07interesting when they brought a Marissa Meyer CEO from Google that that was

0:14:10interesting but either way this company this company that needs to make a

0:14:14comeback of some sort they've also in the last decade gone through a lot of

0:14:19layoffs a lot of very talented people have left or gotten fired or laid off so

0:14:26it they i don't i don't have any inside sources Yahoo but I have to imagine they

0:14:32probably have a talent shortage and because if you're really good you

0:14:38probably have you probably were not happy working Yahoo in the last decade

0:14:41you probably left or didn't go there in the first place because they just lost

0:14:45so many good people over the last year or so and they have some good properties

0:14:50like Flickr that we've just seen just

0:14:53languish and and stagnate as all the good people of left north or so

0:15:00Yahoo talent wise I have to imagine is not in good shape so the other angle

0:15:06people are discussing with the summly deal is first of all nick de le CEO

0:15:11again I'm sorry he he might be a really good product sensibility person and

0:15:19that's that's what you know that's the kind of person that that in one way

0:15:23steve Jobs was it's the kind of person certainly the David Karp visit tumblr

0:15:26having believe me he is he's definitely kind of person and and that that's a

0:15:32very valuable kind of person to just short short handed called products

0:15:38people product people can make or break a company because they make the

0:15:43decisions about what products should be and they have the sensibilities to know

0:15:47what people will like and what will work so if Nick DLB CEO is a really good

0:15:53product person then it would be valuable to bring them onto Yahoo because Yahoo

0:15:59needs people like that

0:16:00not thirty million dollars from sole reason that you pay $39 and his when I

0:16:06come up with is not too great and based on information one there's a bidding war

0:16:10you're not the only one who wants to buy these people if you pay with the market

0:16:13demands of you want the more than someone else has gone up in we get them

0:16:16in and two is intellectual property they have some stuff there would you know it

0:16:21would cost you it's a huge selection of properties would cost you more to let

0:16:26someone else cooped up in the UFC licenses from them long-term those the

0:16:30only two things I can think oh well what I'm thinking is there there are two

0:16:35factors here that could have driven the price up artificially one is that Yahoo

0:16:42is again not in good shape and you know that you could argue that having a

0:16:50really good product person is very valuable to the company you could

0:16:54counter argues that while he's only obligated to stay there for 18 months so

0:16:58they are you good urs

0:17:0118 months one thing and the second thing is unproven show me your a product is a

0:17:06great product was the thing that we just can then known as really interested in

0:17:08cause I think gramm even Steve Jobs and get thirty million dollars a day he

0:17:11arrived at Apple in 1997 he had to kind of sort of a kick out the old CEO and be

0:17:16kinda sorta prove myself before I like they're like okay well you know i mean

0:17:20he did come out the gate and CEO Steve Jobs wonderful you're gonna me to let

0:17:24you take over and give you tons and tons of money and showered with praise of

0:17:27Steve Jobs has to prove himself this kid has to as well I guess is not you don't

0:17:30pay thirty million dollars for a couple of employees no matter who they are even

0:17:34if they literally on the best employees in the entire world you don't you just

0:17:37how much money for well you would have to you could get those employees for

0:17:42less money if there if they didn't know like they obviously know they have

0:17:45something or think or know they have something that actually worth much more

0:17:48than they were

0:17:49would be individually as employees you know maybe Yahoo can't get them for less

0:17:54Yahoo again they yahoo has a problem because if you're really good in this

0:17:58industry do you want to work at Yahoo

0:18:01probably not that's a million dollars ahead for 18 months would do it so

0:18:06anyway so you know one thing I I think they can justify the high price by

0:18:09saying well we're Yahoo

0:18:11we need people we need good people the other thing is Nick doee CEO again I'm

0:18:16sorry is extremely relentless and really really good at self-promotion this guy

0:18:24there is there is a link to this gizmo article which is really kind of

0:18:28tasteless honestly I felt bad evenly on Gizmodo really here because when you

0:18:37know this guy keep in mind this is a teenager or at least he was 18 I guess

0:18:41or seventy whatever but this is a teenager like if I started a company

0:18:47when I was a teenager and got a whole bunch of publicity and got all over the

0:18:50press and was able to email

0:18:52people who were important in the industry I don't know that I would have

0:18:55had that much better honestly cuz when I was a teenager I was an idiot and I i

0:18:59guess im probably going to look back at this time in 10 years since I was an

0:19:04idiot now but I at least feel like I'm way less of an idiot now than it was

0:19:07announced a teenager so I gotta gotta give this kid the benefit of the doubt

0:19:11that ok you know he he was 15 when he started all this stuff

0:19:14and when I was 15 I was an idiot so anyway but he he emailed the motor

0:19:23reporter relentlessly like every day making up all this stuff like oh my boss

0:19:29is getting on my back and you don't put my app in the hall of fame or something

0:19:32like that and everything was marked urgent so I didn't see that story when

0:19:35it came out but Nick gave me a similar email Mirage about six months later

0:19:42trying to get me to integrate some lean to Instapaper and I mean the email she

0:19:49sent where I don't want to be mean to the kids but I mean it was ridiculous he

0:19:54he he he would have multiple times a day from some of these days everything was

0:19:59marked like super urgent even though it wasn't urgent which is just kind of a

0:20:03rude thing to do and he he he would impose artificial sense of urgency and

0:20:10and everything had to be done quickly right now oh my god

0:20:13a lot like high pressure car salesmen you know like really like high-pressure

0:20:17manipulation I would say end and really I was not left with a very good

0:20:23impression of nixon these emotions because I felt like I was being

0:20:25manipulated and and badgered and an annoyed so this included you know

0:20:31because you the exact same thing that somebody else I have to imagine this is

0:20:33just part of his personality where he can imagine the crap out of people until

0:20:37until they do what he wants and and so is his company his company has some

0:20:45fairly prominent investors he had a video promotional video done with

0:20:50Stephen Fry and among other other people did a few things with two and like he

0:20:56has a lot of connections obviously and I don't know if he battled his way

0:20:59interfere earn them or what this kid is really really good at getting people on

0:21:05his side and badgering people into paying attention to him and doing what

0:21:09he wants for his product so it's very possible that just Yahoo's desperation

0:21:15and that could have been the only two factors that made this price go WAY

0:21:19higher than we think it probably should have that seems highly unlikely to me

0:21:22you didn't get these kids emails I saw I read the articles I guess he's annoying

0:21:28but like this there's obviously something there that we don't know I

0:21:33don't have information about the something bidding war its intellectual

0:21:37property it's not it's obviously not the product is they can that the kids out

0:21:41that the product of a user base that transferring now be there has got to be

0:21:45gotta be some thing else had less than 2 million downloads and no revenue think

0:21:50about like if you're running a company you can't you can't hire superstar

0:21:53person for you know ten million dollars head all your existing people who are

0:21:58lightweight and I superstar water night at ten million dollars for it doesn't

0:22:02you just can't do that doesn't gotta be something they're worth money to the

0:22:06company as human beings I I think it's clear I think you're right that we we

0:22:11don't know the whole story here because obviously this still seems ridiculous

0:22:15but I don't think there needs to be that much more to it for it to be

0:22:20understandable or or plausible like I don't think they had some kind of

0:22:25awesome super duper natural language processing technology the Yahoo now owns

0:22:30I don't think that's it all because I saw the technology that wasn't a

0:22:32compelling but I might just be patents and intellectual property is actually be

0:22:36awesome it can be super duper dominance act is the best kind of patents the

0:22:40Superdome path I don't think they were in business longer to get a patent

0:22:42issued patent everyone's got a pet when I read somewhere today and I wish I

0:22:48remember where I read this so this is probably fall since I barely remember

0:22:52where I read it but somebody said that it wasn't even there tack that they it

0:22:57was like quasi Siri in that they license the text from someone else and just

0:23:02putting you in front of it called it there's so I agree with you john that if

0:23:07it's not the people than it should be I P but supposedly the IP isn't there's

0:23:13anyway so what gives

0:23:16I don't know why I think I think you know johns right there is there has to

0:23:22be something else here that has not been reported one if its the desperation of

0:23:27Yahoo something that I've heard and read a lot about lately is how desperate

0:23:33Apple is so how far as Apple from being in this position and I know that's kind

0:23:36of ridiculous and absurd thing to ask but it's also kind of a legitimate thing

0:23:41to ask I mean is Apple really where the super incredible mega nerds want to be

0:23:48these days that's a very good question i've i've heard a lot of things

0:23:52rumors and some things from people in Apple that they have a lot of problems

0:23:57retaining good talent getting good talent mate Mitt may be getting to town

0:24:01they still ok with that retaining good talent that they're having a big problem

0:24:05there it makes sense that they have trouble retaining because I like the way

0:24:10Apple works is if you are a really smart you know great performer lots of talent

0:24:16but can do lots of different things you're not going to go to Apple and get

0:24:22to do what you want to do because the company does so few things like it's

0:24:25focused right so you can help contribute to what may be a big deal but you're not

0:24:30going to go you know I have this really great idea for this thing and they

0:24:35should I every month I do like the only very very few ideas actually get

0:24:38implemented so eventually after work done one or two things that that Apple

0:24:43decide to do and you were important contributing to them or whatever you

0:24:47will inevitably say well you know but now I want to actually do the thing that

0:24:50I was thinking of that i think is cool there's no way for you to do that inside

0:24:54of Apple so you inevitably have to leave and it's not like the faulted Apple for

0:24:59doing this because they have to be focuses the company but the really smart

0:25:04multi talented people you can't keep them and find a place where they can

0:25:10only contribute to the one or two or three things that are important for a

0:25:13blue do they will want to go off on their own even if it's just like you

0:25:16know like I just wanna go often and make make letterpress or something like it

0:25:20you know Apple's not interested in Napa maybe you are and you can't do that with

0:25:24an apple and so you like right well you know

0:25:27I worked on this I worked on that they were great it's really important work

0:25:30lots of people use it but i just want to do my thing so I think I think it's

0:25:34inevitable and also you know you can you can kind of get some idea that you know

0:25:39most of the people I know and maybe this is just the people i've i've observed

0:25:42cause to I follow on Twitter or whatever but most of the people I know who have

0:25:46left Apple have gone too much smaller companies often times they've they've

0:25:52gone to start a startup and I think it's it's part of what you said John is part

0:25:56of you know them wanting to do something on a much smaller scale where they can

0:25:59have a bigger role or make a product that Apple would never make but I think

0:26:04part of it also is that Apple has created this entire environment this

0:26:10entire ecosystem of small start-ups being able to succeed and one person

0:26:14shops be able to succeed on the App Store and and their people being in

0:26:20charge of of the stuff for working on the frameworks are or working in this

0:26:24photo released being surrounded by by other developers who are working in this

0:26:28world that has to be very tempting for people who work inside of Apple to be

0:26:33looking at all these other people making probably way more money than they make

0:26:37their job at Apple and and doing really cool things and and making products from

0:26:41scratch and having no boss you know to watch that from from the inside and not

0:26:49be able to participate that has to be very tempting and I bet that pulls lot

0:26:54of people out of Apple but isn't the converse is also true in the sense that

0:26:58lets say I was a middle of the road

0:27:01self employed iOS developer and I have a few apps or maybe just one app in the

0:27:08App Store that's popular but not see it it's barely self-sustaining and an apple

0:27:13says to me hey why don't you interview with us I can't imagine it would be like

0:27:18no I really like being my own person and it's hard for me to fathom what it's

0:27:24like to be self-employed because I've worked for the man my entire life but I

0:27:28guess what I'm saying is if if I was not a superstar if I was just a regular Joe

0:27:34who is trying to to do his own thing in the App Store and Apple said hey we've

0:27:38seen what you do

0:27:39we really liked it and we'd like you to interview you got to imagine I'd be

0:27:43thrilled that that opportunity would be so moved to California that I do you

0:27:47feel about it now

0:27:49well and that's a very very fair point and didn't do the telecommuting thing

0:27:53really and that's not a limiting factor you want to work for Apple you gotta

0:27:57live in apple and living in apple and is expensive and maybe that's not where

0:28:00your family has maybe that's not where you want to live and if you live out

0:28:03there you have a lot of competition for that job or other people have a lot of

0:28:08competition for employer like if you live out there already

0:28:13then you can go work for any number of big tech companies plus an infinite

0:28:17number of small ones and that's a really good point it really honestly is and I'm

0:28:23hypothesizing I don't know what any of this is like but I guess what I'm saying

0:28:28is as much as Apple is arguably pleading talent I i cant imagine that it's that

0:28:33hard for them to find new talent that being said a revolving doors clearly not

0:28:38a sustainable approach so you know it's it's it's an odd thing to talk to think

0:28:43about its not just think it's not just the people who like go there are a

0:28:47superstar do something awesome like you know design the UI for the original iOS

0:28:52iPhone OS as it was then launched the original iPhone may be due on to other

0:28:56projects and say right well now and I feel like I have all the all the towns

0:29:00under my belt to do but it is basically whatever I want and I want to be the one

0:29:03in charge you can only have so many chiefs you know I gotta be Indians

0:29:06especially at a company like Apple going to limited number of things only a

0:29:10limited number of people who is an h1b reference for native americans mark I

0:29:16don't know for allowed to call them taking a turn so I get there is there's

0:29:23that feeling that you want to like I want to be the guy who calls the shots

0:29:27right and so that those people go off and do that but it's not just the people

0:29:31who like when I came in at the bottom I learned some stuff and now I'm able to

0:29:33go off on my own you know I like you said you can make more money my friends

0:29:36are making these hit applications making tons more money than I am I can be a

0:29:40part of my own business I could have you know unlimited income limited only by my

0:29:43success not by like a review process and the cost of living raises and bonuses

0:29:46and

0:29:47like maybe stock options are lucky think about but run for transfer Leigh who was

0:29:53one of the guys in charge of making presumably tons of money he didn't leave

0:29:57Apple because he didn't get to be in charge of stuff i mean he wasn't Steve

0:30:03Jobs but he was like two or three runs down there anyone you know very few

0:30:07people have that level of power and he certainly wasn't you know I'm so bitter

0:30:12that these people making money in the App Store he just wants to go and do

0:30:14something different and no matter where you are

0:30:18except maybe if you're the very very top of that pyramid if you have an itch to

0:30:22go do something you can't do with an Apple if it's not something that Apple

0:30:26wants to do and so he left to do whatever his secret startup is right now

0:30:30he didn't retired like you know sit on the beach and you know county's money

0:30:35and watch the waves come in he won he said he had an intellectual its and he

0:30:40wanted to do something and so he left to do it and that's that's never gonna

0:30:46happen in a company where you hire people who visit you wonder how many

0:30:50people who could be the Steve Jobs of their own company but you want to work

0:30:55for you and is anyone I kind of like get them as long as you possibly can and get

0:31:00hit when you can out of them but I don't think Apple is better than they go off

0:31:03and do things on their own if anything it's like it if we have an employee who

0:31:07couldn't leave Appling go off and do better for themselves maybe we didn't

0:31:10make the ride higher like that's you know that's that's the calculus there

0:31:14they want all people who could do better outside of Apple they want to keep them

0:31:17for as long as they can you know get the best workout of them I guess I think

0:31:22it's interesting maybe to distinguish you know they were talking about how

0:31:27Apple's having trouble getting talent but that seems to be mostly at the lower

0:31:31levels of the company and the mid-level the company at the upper levels of the

0:31:34company they seem to have for the most part pretty strong loyalty and pretty

0:31:40long running people there and so maybe executives I mean can can a middle

0:31:47manager Ken a middle manager go off and do their own thing

0:31:50and be as successful as far as apple now has a certain point when you get high

0:31:53enough I get a fair trial is an exception because he was an engineer

0:31:56relation but there are people who just managers and if you're a long time and

0:32:00you can be making lots of money maybe you don't care that you don't have to

0:32:03tell the company when the company gets to do like there's room for middle

0:32:07management everywhere

0:32:08those people are gonna leave voluntarily yeah I guess that's true but I mean if

0:32:13you look at other companies I think Apple is pretty good at retaining the

0:32:16upper yeah people and so I guess the question is like you know the upper

0:32:21people obviously like a frequent changes there would probably be way more

0:32:25disruptive to the company then frequent changes at the lower levels of the

0:32:29company are frequent changes at lower levels

0:32:34really something that they should be worried about or should I just keep

0:32:38trying to make the best stuff and and keep keeper day like the other people

0:32:42and just kinda hope that a lot of people keep coming in fashion going out I think

0:32:47they probably need to figure out some way to prolong the really smart people

0:32:53stay by giving them some way to flex their independence and desire to do

0:32:58something like it's it's totally against Apple's ammo to do you know the computer

0:33:02called a concept cars or have something like Google Labs or 20% time those are

0:33:07just not in Apple's culture but Apple culture so far in the other direction if

0:33:12you can just give people some outlet within that structure to say you know

0:33:17there is a slim chance however some like the lottery however slim that you may be

0:33:21able to get us to do your crazy idea like I think of the original Xbox right

0:33:26so he was jailed hard and maybe one other person had the idea to do a gaming

0:33:31console and they were not like vice presidents when they came up with this

0:33:34idea they were you know pretty much rank-and-file employees had been there

0:33:38for a while but we're not not in a position to say we should make a game

0:33:42console but they were able to take that idea and pick it up up up the ladder and

0:33:47eventually convince Microsoft to make a game console and became a big part of

0:33:51that process so good to be upgraded to go back and tell know they became you

0:33:55know

0:33:55bigwigs in charge of that project that can happen inside Microsoft released

0:34:00happened once there are plenty of people in lower positions and Apple whose ideas

0:34:04come to fruition and become a big type of thing but I'm not sure they go with

0:34:09those ideas up the ladder so if you could just give make some sort of form

0:34:13within the company for these independent people to come up with something that

0:34:16it's possible to pick its way up and become the next big you know killer on

0:34:20the story even if that only happens like once every 10 years or something I don't

0:34:24know how not have a set of her work for Apple

0:34:26just speculating on the outside but it but it might be like but I think that

0:34:31type of bike 20% time however BS it is the Google these days and Google Labs

0:34:36type things that ended pre Google+ days let's say before Google tried to become

0:34:40a nightly focused that was a lot of the reason I think a lot of really smart

0:34:44people stayed in Google because whether it actually hit anything actually came

0:34:48to fruition not there was the idea that it was a bunch of smart people doing

0:34:51lots of interesting things and all sorts of directions and why would you leave to

0:34:55go anyplace else because here they give you a nice salary they feed you they

0:34:59take care of you you have health insurance it's a nice job and you kind

0:35:03of sort of get to do whatever you want to know is that thing whatever you want

0:35:05to become the next gmail email came from night or the next Google Reader before

0:35:10you know that an hour within the Google that environment within Google the pre

0:35:15Google+ Google I think that served as a magnet to pull people into Google and to

0:35:21keep people into Google may be the wrong kind of people that maybe not the kind

0:35:24of people Apple ones but Apple needs just a little bit more than a half now

0:35:29and I think that would help them keep people for I say six months longer but

0:35:36yeah I think that's that's a wise thing I think I agree with everything you said

0:35:43what what's hard to reconcile is if you look at the big players in california

0:35:48and lemme hedge heavily by saying i'm an East Coast I've only been to California

0:35:52handful of times my life and in fact at least half of them were for WWDC I don't

0:35:58understand what the what the culture and when what

0:36:00the technology sector looks like out there so I apologize for getting all the

0:36:04following wrong email Marco but if you're if you're really bright engineer

0:36:09and you're really passionate about writing code where are your options I

0:36:15mean you can go to Microsoft but most people would perceive that is just

0:36:19corporates to chill and you can go to Google which means your entire purpose

0:36:24in life is to sell ads you can go to Yahoo which means you're the only bright

0:36:29star in a cloudy sky which some people might like but is not my cup and see

0:36:34where you can go to Apple and and at least Apple is devoted to pleasing

0:36:40customers as opposed to telling customers they're out to please them in

0:36:45actually in their eyeballs for advertisements that doesn't make sense

0:36:50like I i I don't see why anyone else would be compelling with the exception

0:36:54as you guys mentioned of startups but I don't know I guess I'm so risk adverse

0:36:58that that doesn't seem that compelling to me either but that's one of the

0:37:02reasons that I think the seniors I could have stayed as well as big especially if

0:37:05you're a senior executive like it's the you know you want to sell sugar water

0:37:08for the rest of your life becomes mean change the world like those those

0:37:11executives really feel like they can have the biggest impact on the world by

0:37:16being a regular good old middle manager in Apple then being a regular girl

0:37:22minimal manager Coco large Mr Proctor and Gamble because they don't feel like

0:37:26they're likely to go to parties and I work probably a very important person in

0:37:30my body like that that there's also some angles that but it really is a chance

0:37:37that same thing for engineers to do something that you think will have an

0:37:40impact that used to be Microsoft that was certainly Google probably still is

0:37:45cool but you could say you work for Google in that like you know job

0:37:49satisfaction feeling like your job is important and can change the world

0:37:53you're not just toiling away and I think Apple is just as much a corporate

0:37:56student jobs Microsoft or any other player is a big corporation it's like

0:37:59it's it is what it is it doesn't it's not a it's not crazily different than

0:38:03any other large corporation like say valve or something where it's totally

0:38:07outside their own expectations they have

0:38:08managers and employees and teams and there may be a couple things that are

0:38:12different about them is certainly at the top level the company behave very

0:38:15differently in terms of focus on everything but two employees I don't

0:38:19know maybe it's naive of me but I feel like Microsoft's purpose in life may be

0:38:26up until recently but Microsoft's purpose in life was to please other

0:38:30companies and Yahoo's purpose in life is to buy cool things and ruin them and

0:38:37condemns purpose and Google's purpose

0:38:39things and runs into that's true and Google's purpose in life is to sell

0:38:44advertisements and and at least Apple's building cool stuff right i mean

0:38:49corporates to job and I think John you're right it's apples more corporate

0:38:54Studi than I care to admit but if you get to choose a corporate student job on

0:38:58the left coast is Apple not the best option

0:39:03it also depends on the kind of person you like is that the problem we were

0:39:07talking about you know that Apple and its services right to say you are

0:39:10someone who does something on the server side datacenters infrastructure type

0:39:15software you know you don't want to go work for Apple because Apple has not

0:39:20shown that it values those people that part of its business just wanted to work

0:39:24doesn't want to hear about it and like this

0:39:26the smartest best service i'd people are not going to go when they don't want to

0:39:30work at Apple because they want to be valued if they if they go working Google

0:39:33they're practically god's you get to work on like you know GFS version 3 over

0:39:37to our spanner whenever these are things like those are like serious business

0:39:42like that's the whole company right but Apple you're just like they don't want

0:39:46to hear your know who you are anything about you know we have here is that

0:39:50you're screwing up and just make it like the people who get the Gloria I made the

0:39:54iPhone interface so I'm so I am excuse of hardware I work on the opera is

0:39:57nobody's getting any glory or any claim or any recognition putting anything in

0:40:03open source a contributing anything it was working on service I did Apple

0:40:06forget it so Apple I think cannot hire those people we're talking about like oh

0:40:10if you're if you're a client-side program or as your designer yeah

0:40:14designers wanna go to Apple client-side native app people want to go to Apple

0:40:19but if you're a web developer services

0:40:22person you don't want to go to a problem that's not entirely true I i think

0:40:27that's mostly true but if you happen to be one of the six people on the planet

0:40:32that knows how to do web objects I think you can think of all the other side they

0:40:37countered at Sequoia programmers and when you're right you're right but I

0:40:41think that the six people that do web objects in the world and in a quaint of

0:40:46a friend of a friend of a friend does web objects in actually lives nearby to

0:40:51where I live and he works for Apple because you know or at least that's my

0:40:57understanding I could be totally wrong but my point is if you're if you do one

0:41:02of the things that Apple doesn't nobody else does like web objects you can pay

0:41:07your own way that's why Apple is having trouble hiring the people they need to

0:41:12make their service and stuff better because hiring a bunch of web objects

0:41:15programmers is not going to help them make their stuff better right they want

0:41:18the people who are taking the jobs elsewhere gonna come for the next big

0:41:21thing early spring have up-to-date with like 10 years ago decker I hand out

0:41:25there so far behind so out in the weeds on this they just want to get good

0:41:30service i'd people to do their stuff and it's and I bet like it's not just that

0:41:35maybe they can get the good service I V 12 good serviceable get there on the go

0:41:38like the first thing they do is like we got to get rid of this web objects crap

0:41:42what the hell you guys doing and they'll find out like the culture is like no

0:41:45obvious who runs the iTunes store that sells twenty million songs every three

0:41:50seconds and you can't break it and you know you're not gonna rewrite it

0:41:53something else just just help us get better but don't change anything like

0:41:57that type of attitude that is totally you know talk about corporate jobs like

0:42:01that's that's the way it is I became in their realities that have to be dealt

0:42:05with you can't come anything like the Apple Store of that should not be

0:42:08written that way you just gotta get rid of it replace it with something else

0:42:11that's not a big you know what's with the payoffs are willing to risk

0:42:15destroying our entire you know multi billion transaction business to from

0:42:20what's the benefit of the end of that we differ on by WWF Seattle and give you a

0:42:24pass authority you'll be able to get so hard to sell this type projects right

0:42:28people go there and like realize that they're not going to change anything and

0:42:34then leaving

0:42:35Java Facebook and that's true until you have somebody like the verge writing an

0:42:39article about how crummy iCloud is that's not their service I guess not

0:42:45no no let's we'll get to that in a minute before that let me give our

0:42:49sponsor break here this episode is once again sponsored by Squarespace

0:42:54Squarespace is just an awesome way to make a website and have hosted and

0:42:59designed and managed for you it is fantastic it's a website hosting

0:43:04platform you can put up your blog you can put up a store a portfolio site for

0:43:08your business

0:43:10a site for your music whatever you want to do you can put it up on Squarespace

0:43:14plans start at just $10 a month and really I mean it could not be easier

0:43:19they have a whole bunch of great templates designed by professional

0:43:21designers and if you if you want to jump into customized all the CSS and HTML and

0:43:27JavaScript you can do all that our site is hosted their ATP Titan you can check

0:43:32it out that's totally Squarespace site with minimal hacking involved and if you

0:43:38don't wanna miss the hacking you don't have to you can just go there and sign

0:43:41up and move stuff around drag and drop everything is hosted it is it is just so

0:43:46low needs an awesome I really can't can't overstate this enough hosting

0:43:54websites where space is just so ridiculously easy it's where I tell

0:43:57everybody in my life who asked me over how do I make a site where should I

0:44:01whose could you help me with this I say yes I can help you I will tell you to go

0:44:05to Squarespace and that's it

0:44:06go there that's it and it's like it's like telling people who want tech

0:44:10support I tell them to get a Mac cuz you know you can given that directive and

0:44:15they won't come back to you call you every five minutes with some problem

0:44:18making you fix the computer Squarespace is that for web hosting and web site

0:44:22construction trust me it is awesome

0:44:25go check out Squarespace you can use our coupon code ATP 34 accidents suck

0:44:31podcast in the month of 383 use that code at checkout to save 10% and get a

0:44:38plan for a $10 a month you can you can even sell stuff you can do commerce I

0:44:41can't I can't even fit everything they do and 21 outbreak

0:44:45believe me is where space is great you can host any kind of say you want a

0:44:49beautiful sight and you don't have to worry about hosting you don't have to

0:44:52worry about designing everything from scratch

0:44:55it's all done for you it's fantastic go to Squarespace dot com check it out

0:45:00today and thanks to our space for supporting us once again so is already

0:45:04on the verge called why does an iCloud just work and it's getting a lot of

0:45:09attention and I think this is worth a little bit of discussion here and there

0:45:13was a great follow-up from Brent Simmons that will get 24 in a little bit but

0:45:18what do you think about this article like it basically cites a lot of a lot

0:45:23of users and developers visibly all saying like we tried to build iCloud

0:45:28sync into our apps and it just didn't work and we had to cancel it

0:45:31problem I had with it was very few of the developers were named and I don't

0:45:36blame them because if it were me I wouldn't want to be named I have

0:45:39tremendous respect for I think Pasco from black pixel was named Justin

0:45:46Williams was named and I have tremendous respect for those who were named but I

0:45:51don't think the the message was unfair or invalid everything I've ever heard

0:45:57from both prominent people whom I follow on Twitter for example and even friends

0:46:02whom do this locally or who did this ugly lol yeah I know you saw that

0:46:09feedback to me anyway the people who I know they do this locally everyone is

0:46:14universally said it's it's crap it's in the same way that auto layout is either

0:46:19crap or so impossibly difficult to get right that it's effectively crap it's

0:46:25all crap at it really is but I mean so at what point is this wheel speaking up

0:46:34for Apple to really fix it and can they fix it I know Johnny talked at length

0:46:37about how you're skeptical whether they can get this is a tradition that's why I

0:46:41said that I cloud core data thing and it specifically what we're talking about

0:46:44here is it's not so much the service I PeopleSmart service I people have danced

0:46:49on the server side stuff being flaky or whatever but as far as I can tell from

0:46:55listening to all the same developers and talking to someone

0:46:57in person and reading all different articles on their blogs it's a it's a

0:47:01design problem it's it's you know high-level box level design and also an

0:47:06API design problem like with the high level designers like is there a way to

0:47:10have seventeen different devices with just with a bunch of you know related

0:47:14objects stored in local databases and get them all to sing together without

0:47:19having without doing like what Google does but just like ok well google has

0:47:22your mail your emails on their servers and that is the one source of truth in

0:47:27the entire world and when you put up in your web browser not like synchronizing

0:47:31the state on your web browser that thing is just like this one central source of

0:47:35truth everywhere and everyone synchronized with that in all their

0:47:37actions like modified this is a bunch of local things to modifications and they

0:47:41all try to synchronize with each other later sort of in a peer-to-peer type

0:47:44fashion and I'm not sure that conceptually and algorithmically they

0:47:49worked out how that's supposed to work for arbitrary object models because your

0:47:54car did you make up your own object model and make your own relations

0:47:57between things and you know like it's it's not it's not a fixed schema time in

0:48:02its its not skinless but it's not like they don't know how your application

0:48:06works at trying to make a general-purpose system for any sort of

0:48:08you know tree of objects that you can modify any sort of way and that later go

0:48:15to another thing that has its own tree of objects in a different state modify

0:48:19that one and then have to reconcile themselves with each other and have that

0:48:22actually work like sometimes you don't know what's supposed to happen so that's

0:48:26the first promised a compromise looks like the API design that's on top of

0:48:29this conceptual thing doesn't give the developers nice ways to do the things

0:48:34they want because it probably so complicate like one of the ones they put

0:48:37their arms like what someone you know takes my app starts doing stuff with it

0:48:41builds you know essentially built an object model for their data and then

0:48:44they signed iCloud and and their icon account they had previously saw this

0:48:48application elsewhere and they had a bunch of big data from from there how do

0:48:53I reconcile like to erase everything I have replaced it with what's version of

0:48:58this thing I try to merge attitude not related at all like it is just a

0:49:03nightmarish type problem and I think conceptually like ignore bugs and North

0:49:07are available nor service speed ignore visibility of anything I just think

0:49:11conceptually they don't have something that is nailed down that will work under

0:49:16percent of the time in the layer on top of that oh you know there are bugs and

0:49:21their API is that there's no hope for me to say hey tell me when this thing

0:49:24changes and sometimes gets corrupted it gets wedged and you can't tell what's

0:49:28wrong cause I have no API to query is a thing available is it not available as

0:49:31new data comment as did not commit like it's just failure on top of failure on

0:49:36top of failure is not just one thing so that's why I think like get the best

0:49:40service I've people the world's not gonna save the assistance of seven of

0:49:43the layers of things that have gone wrong with this specifically and I think

0:49:47the conceptually simpler ones like the key-value storage and document storage

0:49:50because that the sound design and they're like well last update when so I

0:49:56can keep you think you values that something when is it something a little

0:49:58more specific document it's very simple conceptual model then they can put an

0:50:03implication of that which may or may not have a few bucks but it's okay and

0:50:06there's enough visibility into and you get stuff done like we were all

0:50:10developers you know what it's like when you start programming something and you

0:50:13didn't think it through conceptually to begin with there is no amount of typing

0:50:16you can do after that to make it better you have to just go away like what the

0:50:19hell am I doing here this is never gonna work when I haven't even started through

0:50:23yet I can't just start blindly typing in putting in weird cases and try to make

0:50:27this work and that's a situation I think they're in with iCloud korda yeah and I

0:50:31think from what I've heard in front of seen from the developers I I haven't

0:50:36done much like loud I should get up front I the only thing I don't like

0:50:38Cloud was a very basic feature of syncing your position and currently read

0:50:43article in the magazine which which works sometimes

0:50:47value because it's way easier and literally just storing like answering

0:50:54article positions in the article at small and I'm sorry I want you to tell

0:50:59me what article you currently reading that's it but you know that the main

0:51:05concerns I've heard have been what you said that the core data saying we should

0:51:09I have this whole database of objects in my app and in when I was unveiled I

0:51:16believe steve Jobs was was doing this part of the presentation

0:51:19he even said like and it works like or did you just you know you guys think it

0:51:24just works I never would think that kind of huge applause because he was really

0:51:33really cuz that's a really hard problem with that sexy and so you know we work

0:51:42we were promised that this would work and so developers Core Data Sync that

0:51:47I've always heard has been a complete disaster but I think that any key-value

0:51:52store is fine everything documents I don't know a lot of developers who've

0:51:55used to document model because I recently everybody just added a quitar

0:51:58your core data if they could well there are there enough things to do not intend

0:52:03to be to be fair to be good to be unfair to the server side people like back in

0:52:07the iOS 5 days like almost nothing worked right like evaluate obviously the

0:52:11simplest and thats has mostly on and document storage mostly work but had

0:52:16some kind of nine bugs and quirks in that can be a little bit weird so all

0:52:20these things are slated to begin with but is just like the reason the reason

0:52:23is coming to head now is because I write these things that had time to still

0:52:26iCloud didn't come out three months ago right this dark cloud is not brand

0:52:30spanking new all these API's like we gave them like the one major version of

0:52:34iOS to mature the one major version that goes into mature and now they like

0:52:39devalue storage and documents seem to be following the typical path of Apple

0:52:42API's and core data is not like getting better at the biggest problem I have

0:52:50heard that the court is part is you know the most unreliable part of of the

0:52:54iCloud sync stuff but I think the much bigger problem with you

0:52:58breezed past little bit ago is that everything is tied to the Apple iTV is

0:53:03currently signed in and that people sign out of Apple IDs in two different Apple

0:53:08IDs on their devices fairly frequently you know not everyone doing every day

0:53:14but there's a good number of people who do it regularly

0:53:17yasser that they have APIC like oh and you're gonna keep in mind that when you

0:53:22launch you may not be in the same app ideas when you're stuck with me then you

0:53:25may get his car back that means they changed Apple IDs and like they've made

0:53:28their where this gonna happen but they do I kinda shoving her into the car

0:53:31of the programming site and you'll figure out what to do when that happens

0:53:34like what am I supposed to do you know in some cases like all the pre-existing

0:53:39data gets deleted like there was in your local directory like it you know I'm

0:53:42what if I hadn't synced bad and like it's gone now like you don't have it

0:53:47it's like it's like you know throwing an exception if you can't you know the

0:53:50discus for something and I'll catch except when you gonna do about delete

0:53:54stuff but sometimes you can't there's no saying recovery or there's nothing like

0:54:01the case absolutely not like like all we have a call doctor when they change

0:54:04things and and will automatically count all the old and you're ready to go again

0:54:07on my way to second like from you should check like what if you want to do

0:54:12something different with you I tell people this is happening that they're

0:54:14gonna end up deleting all the local data and like I just don't think it's been

0:54:19thought through this is all I called data like with the frustration over

0:54:23jackals like we talked to happen they don't tell scarce and like their WBC

0:54:30they're gonna come out with like you know the API for one of the apology

0:54:33mouse from New York we're sorry for the puck luck on your children and your

0:54:39chair there's a same database thinking you know like that come out of it's kind

0:54:44it's kind of a decision gives me some hope you like MobileMe was a disaster

0:54:47and had to change the name you get iCloud but they have had at least one

0:54:50instance where they had something that was a disaster and they cannot with a

0:54:54much better awesome version of it didn't change the name that's file fault 4501

0:54:59was just a mess and 512 kept the same name but is totally unrelated other name

0:55:05and it did the same function and is awesome so far but two is awesome

0:55:08following this terrible so if I cloud core data syncing at this is considered

0:55:12a soft like something else comes out that's different and the same as this

0:55:16new thing just forget about the whole thing they can still call it like latkas

0:55:18iCloud is an umbrella term that already covers on 10 different things and why

0:55:22not just keep changing out the scope is like and they have the advantage of not

0:55:26having this user base like wait what about all the successful applications

0:55:30built on a club in CoreData sinking they'll have to rewrite know there are

0:55:33many don't work and I think you're right though

0:55:37conceptually this is a problem like what it like the biggest problem being

0:55:44usually that you know people who sign in and out of different Apple IDs what is

0:55:48the app supposed to do about that like I don't think that's the kind of thing

0:55:51that could necessarily be fixed with a revision to the API or a new service ID

0:55:57back end because it's like like member like a year ago it was a whole debate

0:56:00about the guy who's iPhone alarm went off in the symphony and and the whole it

0:56:05was the whole thing we know what should the behavior of the of the alarm be with

0:56:09overriding the sound switch and back then about it and you know my theory was

0:56:15you know this is a hard problem because you've told the phone

0:56:20wake me up at this time no matter what and you've also told the phone don't

0:56:24make noise right now and so you've given these conflicting directives I was a

0:56:28problem with how 9002 conflicting directives and no matter what choice you

0:56:35make it going to anger some some portion of the user base that's non-trivial and

0:56:38and so it's kind of that's kind of a problem with the user at that point well

0:56:42with this you know what I cloud syncing

0:56:45you've made the system where your data is tied to the to whatever Apple idea

0:56:52signed in in all your apps like that's your latest tied to that and then but a

0:56:57lot of people have different Apple IDs some people like a couple will share

0:57:00when Apple IDs they don't pay for apps twice to be in both of their phones

0:57:04some people have different Apple idea for their for being a developer versus

0:57:07being a consumer like there's lots of reasons why people have different Apple

0:57:11IDs and an apple does not make it easy to to merge them or switch them or

0:57:16anything like that so it's a very common thing and you know if your app has its

0:57:21own sync platform then it has some kind of concept of being logged in to that

0:57:27and so if you change your Apple I D

0:57:29system wide to go use a certain app or do a certain thing and a new launch you

0:57:35know my note taking app whatever ext cloud plus then

0:57:40then you know i i don't lose that sink Association from rapidly because I'm

0:57:47using my own custom sync thing that you've logged into and if you actually

0:57:49go into my appt and want to sync with a different thing you have like going to

0:57:55my apt and logged out explicitly of that account and presumably that stuff is all

0:57:59storage server side and then you can log into something else like it it's a

0:58:02deliberate user action whereas if you're using iCloud syncing users might not

0:58:07realize they probably almost never do realize that if they log out system

0:58:12modify cloud then the data in XYZ is gonna be blown away and the worst part

0:58:17is that it that they may be blown away and that they may never have made it to

0:58:21any other device

0:58:22never been sick rises actually got like the app is any way to tell that well I

0:58:28mean some of these things you get to sleep at like say it's a the existing

0:58:31API strongly bug free and like and you got these callbacks and you were given

0:58:36an obligate add new API's like oh we're about to change rapidly may be there to

0:58:39have this you have an opportunity to save the stuff off the side of whatever

0:58:42you still end up in situations where like what if I do these three changes

0:58:46this device to these four changes not divisive completing before changes not

0:58:49device to conflicting more or less simultaneously had turned these two on

0:58:52then turn those too often turn the third one back on like to try to figure out

0:58:56what the state should allow modifications to continue what about

0:58:59when I turn this to backup Mike reconciling is all without a single

0:59:03central source of truth like Gmail where the just everyone communicated to the

0:59:08server and model makes a lot of kids they're allowing you to make the local

0:59:11modifications in trying to resolve that into it like a a replaceable transaction

0:59:15log their results in some sort of consistent thing you can make something

0:59:18that's like provably like you it will it will have a deterministic consistent

0:59:22result but the odds that being the result being what the users expected it

0:59:26to be

0:59:27are probably zero because the users will inevitably issue a series of conflicting

0:59:31instructions and when I think synchronized no matter what the stuff

0:59:35packs it's sometimes it's not going to be what they wanted because they gave

0:59:39conflicting instructions there is actually no right answer so that's

0:59:42something like the model they're using for a coordinated you know arbitrary

0:59:46object graph sinking is never even if it's a hundred percent bug-free is never

0:59:51going to to look to users like them

0:59:53magical hey everything just works because it's you know that they will

0:59:58they will issue conflicting demands with their actions on the original devices in

1:00:02Windows devices synchronized even assuming zero bugs and perfect

1:00:05performance they're going to be sad that they're going up quote-unquote losing

1:00:09data even if you were to say let me say you not to lose data because here's how

1:00:14we reconcile things and you see these series of collecting fans can only do

1:00:17one thing you can have this and have that well but I want the other thing

1:00:21actually I really want to merge of those too but with me manually picking like it

1:00:26can't know that you know so that's that's never going to make people happy

1:00:30and i cant im not sure what this solution there is except for maybe

1:00:34having I mean you can't do it but Google does you can't have every single changed

1:00:39your application sending commands up to a server

1:00:42you know i mean Google+ gmail too but I think like they've the reason I think

1:00:49it's because they have a defined data model that is not as complicated and you

1:00:53know its application but with messages and labels stop its not arbitrarily

1:00:59structured interrelated data objects and Objective C that you get the right

1:01:03yourself and this is a good segue to the brink Simmons response article did you

1:01:09read this yet it's called why developers shouldn't use iCloud sync even if it

1:01:13worked I read it as well and then I was gonna bring this up in as well because

1:01:20and forgive me for a kind of interrupting your tangent but one of the

1:01:27things that I find very interesting about iCloud is that Aaron and I shane

1:01:30is to share the same Apple store I D so we can share the same apps and so on and

1:01:37so forth we have different iCloud ID's and if we had say a shared grocery list

1:01:43we can't share grocery list if we're using Eichler that app is using iCloud

1:01:49the background in Brent talks a lot about this

1:01:53iCloud is very personal and not very social and I hate social because that's

1:01:57about as

1:01:58as big a buzz word is brand but but nonetheless I feel like there's some

1:02:03amount of truth to that and brand Brent brings this up in our presume market

1:02:06you're about to recap what some of the other things he said that's one of them

1:02:11I mean it's exactly true and and and if I were to write I've thought about

1:02:18writing a a very very simple shared list keeping appt so that area and I can

1:02:25share grocery list are packing list or eighty Home Depot or Lowes list but I

1:02:30can use iCloud for that because we can't share it because we're on different I

1:02:33cloudy now actually is wonder list which I'm not a tremendous fan of but it does

1:02:40the job a lot of people I know use Google Docs for that and we use Google

1:02:45counter to share counters and we do use Google counters one of the reasons we do

1:02:49that is because I don't think it's been caught up in this kind of deep level but

1:02:54the reality is that we never worried about Google document saying in sync we

1:02:59never worried about Google Calendar staying in sync with our various devices

1:03:02because we always know when we're making changes we are directly manipulating the

1:03:05state of something on a survey and where and it's just it's always in sync you

1:03:08know like it's never it's never not in sync because there's no it's not like we

1:03:13don't use any offline modes right the downside of course is that we can

1:03:17actually make modifications to our calendar for offline but thus far that

1:03:21has not come up not only doesn't for that scenario is going to be less and

1:03:26less likely to like that

1:03:28conceptual simplicity of how does how does document sharing with a Google

1:03:33document work live in real-time always synchronize that's how it works and I

1:03:38like and you just you just don't think about it and just like that model very

1:03:43difficult to do well and bug free and fast and all that stuff but conceptually

1:03:47it's understandable to people and they they come to trust it whereas no I'm not

1:03:52even developers of applications can have any idea how things are working even 10

1:03:56bucks and I like that the bugs as a couple things I read about iCloud

1:04:01courted a stop some of it

1:04:02unpublished as yet hopefully it will be published some point in the future

1:04:05somewhere

1:04:06the worst part of any of these type of things when you add on top of all the

1:04:10stuff we talked about the type of bugs where there's nothing you can do to help

1:04:16your user there's nothing like Apple can do to help your user just like things

1:04:20get wedged in a way that that even a developer can be expected to figure out

1:04:24on their own let alone individual user and that's what they're talking about

1:04:26the verge articles like a support time suck because sometimes things just get

1:04:30the wedged in don't work and there's no visibility of that does not even

1:04:34visibility to the developer and less like a cessation to machine guns are

1:04:38digging through like you know supposedly hidden directories containing big binary

1:04:42blobs and daemon processes that are hung they're not putting the binary blob in

1:04:46the right place and just like is the worst nightmare of trying to debug Elise

1:04:50when you're debugging service I stopped at least you have access to the server

1:04:53and you can see what's going on there this is like the worst of all possible

1:04:55worlds like every single person literally does have their own little

1:04:59server on their local machine there on the latest or in their machine and you

1:05:03can't see any of that and talk about the services you also can't see all of which

1:05:07have bugs none of which code you wrote you don't even have the source code

1:05:09foreign and good luck W that so I'm sorry interrupted you you were gonna

1:05:16bring up the social aspect and you said your gonna bring up something else

1:05:19yeah and the other thing is that you know brian says you know keep in mind

1:05:23that iCloud is Apple only he says you may think you'll never want an Android a

1:05:28browser-based version of your app but are you sure really well yeah I'm pretty

1:05:36sure but but now I think you know this is a very good point that you know if

1:05:44you're if you're in the iCloud platform business if your app realizing that then

1:05:49sure you know that's fine if today you only have an iOS platform but if you

1:05:56really invest heavily in that you have to be really sure that your only ever

1:05:59going to have an iOS platform and I don't think that's that's a very safe

1:06:03assumption for a lot of things these days

1:06:05best but the best part was when he brought what about a Mac App is not so

1:06:08to the Mac App Store cuz you can use iCloud there either

1:06:11forgotten about those forget about member was like oh well they're putting

1:06:15iCloud only in the Mac App Store that'll be like that's to lure you into the Mac

1:06:18App Store now it's like three like another repulsed air it's the opposite

1:06:22effect it's like saying well I really don't wanna be a Mac App Store but only

1:06:27the Mac App Store apps that uses awesome new iCloud AP I guess it is kinda like

1:06:35it so its own credibility if you choose iCloud not only you just using Apple's

1:06:39platform but you choosing also their sales channels like irrevocably yeah

1:06:43exactly and so i think you know obviously I was making iOS app euro we

1:06:49stuck in there and and that's fine but I just think it's unwise to limit yourself

1:06:55necessarily like it's it's one thing to say i'm only going to have an iOS app

1:06:59right now but it's a whole thing to say I will never have anything but an iOS

1:07:04and Mac App Store app like that that's a very very limiting thing and changes of

1:07:09policy decisions they could say hey guess what we have a Web API with a

1:07:13JavaScript library now you can use iCloud API's from your web app that you

1:07:16write yourself that would change a lot i mean it if Apple ever open up to two

1:07:20service cider or website interaction that would open up tremendously but I

1:07:24don't think they ever will understand the word no and there's no immediately

1:07:31obvious benefit to them to do that and and so I don't I don't think they will I

1:07:34think that would be a big giveaway

1:07:36you know they wanted they want to lock down to their devices in their stores

1:07:39and you know part of its just for control and part of it so they can make

1:07:43sure that nobody goes crazy and abuses it through the API's and everything but

1:07:46you know whatever the reason I don't think that's ever gonna happen so I

1:07:51think it's you know it also points out that for most apps needs before sinking

1:07:57it really isn't that hard to write your own server and to run your own server

1:08:00and it really isn't that expensive and it really isn't that complicated and you

1:08:05know you can you can design server side stuff to make it to make your life

1:08:09really easy in in two key ways you can make it really cheap to run in scale and

1:08:14low needs and you can design the absurd that if the server is not reachable the

1:08:19apt is still useful you know and obviously depending on what you're doing

1:08:23with the server

1:08:24how useful it can be will vary but like with Instapaper it was really easy for

1:08:29me to do this because Instapaper is made to be used offline so if the server is

1:08:34not reachable the app things it's offline it was still works just fine he

1:08:40just can't load new stuff into it but it still works everything to use up and

1:08:43once it gets can actually get work so like Instapaper server goes down for an

1:08:48hour which is a pretty major downtime for a web thing I'll hear about it from

1:08:53a few people but not nearly as many as you would think because everyone else is

1:08:59still using the app just fine although there is a big advantage to these type

1:09:03of one Apple wants to happen this does happen a lot where like it easy for you

1:09:09to talk about it as you have service I didn't even experience but what if you

1:09:11just a client's I got like maybe you just want someone to take care of that

1:09:14other stuff for you and I mean those type of API's allow developers who would

1:09:20otherwise not be able to make these type of products to make them or would

1:09:24otherwise need more people you know some examples might be okay so Lauren Berger

1:09:28genius programmer great app designer but he is Gabe said he doesn't wanna write

1:09:32that crap and if it works

1:09:33kind of sort of didn't work when he launches game but you know like if it

1:09:36eventually sort of works he doesn't have to do matchmaking he doesn't have to do

1:09:40accounts at the moment he gets to just write the game part you with newsstand

1:09:44mostly monetary things get the money and everything is like you couldn't have

1:09:48done that but hey you know you can make an application the descriptions that

1:09:53does something that native application wouldn't do by using Apple services

1:09:56right now you did the web thing yourself anyway because of course you can but

1:09:59that's just an extension of the App Store model where maybe don't wanna run

1:10:04the store you don't want to figure out how to sell things to people and getting

1:10:08the downloads are hosted do other stuff will take over that for you and Apple

1:10:11wants to take over all those things and provide these infrastructure services

1:10:16and that's all great when the services actually work and are things that people

1:10:23want done and I think I cloud is is all those things except for the working part

1:10:29and may be right up to the part where like if you design your own like if you

1:10:33design your own service to synchronize your stuff you make design something

1:10:36like a value story

1:10:37and you might design something like I clubs documents in the clouds and you

1:10:40might decide something like you know Game Center whatever those functions you

1:10:44can imagine what would you to undertake on your own to say you know what I need

1:10:48to provide arbitrary server-side synchronization of coordinated across

1:10:51multiple devices I don't think individual developer would would buy

1:10:56that off they would think of something simpler like the simple know what is

1:10:58that when the simple notice oversight baby I like when third parties who

1:11:02created these services they've looked more like traditional more like modern

1:11:08web services and less like what I call for data thing with because they can't

1:11:14do that they can have little demons running on everyone's machines they

1:11:17can't they can make a diamond processing I was that does all this stuff like they

1:11:20would be forced to do something that is it to be endpoint that their

1:11:25applications talk to you know me like they wouldn't be able to do all this

1:11:28crazy stuff that Apple did i think im just bit off more than it could chew in

1:11:32this case I mean this is kind of a problem as we discussed two episodes ago

1:11:36or last episode about I clouds model to the users that it it is the certain

1:11:43simplification of hiding the file system and and and doing these things but still

1:11:46limited I mean this is kind of like it sounds like Apple bit off more than they

1:11:51can chew with a lot of parts of iCloud not just like oh it doesn't work

1:11:55reliably but like this was a bad idea

1:12:00wanna know if it was a bad idea but I just don't know if it's if it's been

1:12:05executed well and in when John when you were talking minute ago I feel to some

1:12:10degree you're describing me in that I have experienced and I have service and

1:12:15experience but the thing is I've server-side experience in in Microsoft

1:12:19technologies which are expensive and if I was to write say a grocery shopping

1:12:24list that I could share between multiple people like Aaron and myself what are my

1:12:29options I can't use iCloud because it's tied to a single iCloud I D so what am I

1:12:35gonna do I could do you like parole and be like John or I could you PHP and be

1:12:40like Marco I could do Python and B

1:12:43you know what terrible according to you too I could do real well you know me I

1:12:49don't know but but if I was going to learn something else for the web backend

1:12:52stuff I would learn Python you can email Marco but the point I'm driving it is

1:12:56what do i do and interestingly and I think brent talked about this in a

1:13:00different post maybe I would go to a sure and maybe I would do and and that

1:13:05doesn't necessitate using C sharp St using.net but from what I've gathered

1:13:10having never played with this as yours are pretty pretty decent way to get some

1:13:15sort of quick server-side or cloud database without too much effort with it

1:13:21with an Iowa CPI and that's just not a place I don't think that's position

1:13:26Apple wants themselves to be in it maybe they don't care I don't know what

1:13:29they're doing and I've seen people do like this is that this is a low-tech

1:13:33solution to like client-side people who don't wanna write big service ID service

1:13:37but they know they need one and the like are by just like the grocery list like

1:13:40like Dropbox Dropbox was something like what am I just like shavon JSON files

1:13:47onto s3 and have the thing put down and Ike reconcile it because it's just a

1:13:52grocery list how I possibly could go wrong worst-case scenario I get superset

1:13:56of a bunch of changes in this an extra items that you don't want I can

1:13:58duplicate you know like when you have a confined problem domain you can get away

1:14:02with just the most ridiculous simple possible solutions s3 would be enough I

1:14:08into something something other something not the mind of I something not the

1:14:12device was something in this third place that's always available and i dont wanna

1:14:15make it was available and that's annoying and that's really all I need is

1:14:19some market share that's always available and I'll do everything else

1:14:22myself in client-side code because I can because it's a grocery list that I got

1:14:25some people end up doing that's annoying they would like to not be able to do

1:14:29that if their needs are satisfied by key-value store in like oh my god I

1:14:33cloud and I know where it's coming out Friday and I'm storing like you know

1:14:37like Marcus things like your your last read position and like it's really easy

1:14:41to reconcile

1:14:44non-critical its tube it's a date if i dont have a good throw it away and it's

1:14:48like no big deal or like worst case I can just pick the lock the later one too

1:14:51soon

1:14:52you read from top to bottom like not having to do that and saying I can tell

1:14:56you stories that just like makes people smile like a weight I don't have to do

1:15:00any of that crap I just want to store number somewhere and I could do that for

1:15:04me and you know it's like it's like keyless where can I go again came out

1:15:09and have a proper lets people using them for everything was like well I didn't

1:15:13need to design some stupid like to see structure ministerial I zip code or in

1:15:18this case like this store like a list of values like I just a little bit crazy

1:15:23and then you end up like trying to make appeals into your entire database and

1:15:27that's bad but not if you give developers a little tiny bit of cool

1:15:33infrastructure that makes them happy but if you keep cranking out the side you

1:15:38know we're basically going to do everything for you and don't worry to

1:15:41work in a doesn't then you know people scale back and say you know i maybe I

1:15:44should go back to uploading Jason Powell says three cause that I'd at least I I

1:15:48can have some guarantees about it working in a predictable way that's

1:15:52predictable it's mostly reliable and to some degree it's a known quantity I

1:15:57completely agree with you

1:15:59yeah and and again like you know if if you have simple needs you can write your

1:16:03own sync stuff and get another not everyone's going to get their sink stuff

1:16:06correct but again like if it's a grocery list and you have to sync stuff like you

1:16:10know what's the worst that can happen is not correct you can fix because of all

1:16:14the source code you were the worst part is like it if it's going wrong in like

1:16:19the you know the demons running on your local matter or wedged in or not

1:16:23synchronizing or notify your applications like you don't control that

1:16:26code you doin you're not making it run you don't have the source file bugs into

1:16:31the black hole and just wait patiently the next major version but in the

1:16:34meantime your customers just want their stuff to sink and it has been pointed

1:16:38out to an article in so short you to read it before you put the whole thing

1:16:42but you know this stuff and doing the server side stuff is real has really

1:16:47gotten so easy in the last five years as so many tools come out to make it really

1:16:54easy really chief you have to write so little custom code these days there are

1:16:59great frameworks there are great services there there are there are

1:17:03companies will automatically scale up and down

1:17:05everything there are a lot of things that are more complex that will require

1:17:10cuts to work but but for the most part for simple needs for most developers

1:17:14needs you don't need anything bigger than like a lineout instance or you know

1:17:20paying paying by the by the cycle on something like Heroku or as your or s3

1:17:26or a PC to and the things that use easy to like for most developers needs one

1:17:33virtual server somewhere will cover it and you can write something and whatever

1:17:37framework you find that is understandable to you and as Brent says

1:17:42it was a very good point has been says like if you could learn Coco you can

1:17:47learn this stuff you know

1:17:49cocoa industry so obtuse in so many ways like web programming to somebody who's

1:17:54who does iOS programming web programming will seem easy by comparison pointers

1:17:59and type stuff is that part of the articles say it's not so much that it's

1:18:05so much easier than it was before your summary of its dead it used to be that

1:18:11for for a given amount of effort you get a certain result now if you put in it

1:18:15sam nunn effort your result will be so much better

1:18:18like the base the base level has risen so much is still going to be complicated

1:18:22lots of stuff to learn and stuff like that but previously if you put in like a

1:18:26week into getting a service and stuff you'll end up with like something that

1:18:29looks like someone who had been just doing service for a week but now you

1:18:33have such an incredible like up with all these instructions if you put in the

1:18:37week your end result will be you're standing on the shoulders of giants who

1:18:41created all the infrastructure for you not staring at a blinking cursor on a

1:18:46bare you know Linux machine and saying okay now I guess I start writing a CGI

1:18:51script there something like your see you have such a leg up so it is really

1:18:55complicated not that people stay away I mean when it's like anything else if you

1:19:00are service I develop you take a lot of stuff for granted but a lot of clients I

1:19:03people are starting from basic knowledge that doesn't really help them that much

1:19:06but they can follow tutorial to get some sort of rails thing up or even like

1:19:10noting just get some sort of note instance

1:19:13and you know put a little tiny snippet of code like a coaching strained back

1:19:16and you can run that instance on a virtual machine that you can scale up

1:19:19you are so far ahead of where expert service I did offers were in 1993 with

1:19:26your stupid little 19 ekhono program right like the things that things can do

1:19:30the scalability performance and reliability of that are just worlds

1:19:34beyond expert level knowledge from two decades ago so that's that's even one

1:19:38decade ago that's why I think like you know that's what he's getting at is like

1:19:41even though you don't know anything about this you'll be able to get

1:19:44something else that has good performance scalability and reliability even if you

1:19:49have almost no idea what you're doing you just put it a little bit of time and

1:19:52that was not true

1:19:53many many years ago and also remains not true if you want a 500 million users

1:19:57which is libelous crude but you're not gonna have 500 million users and if you

1:20:02do presumably you can hire me look like Instapaper runs on about 10 servers does

1:20:08it it does a lot of stuff for a lot of people but the magazine runs on the

1:20:13cheapest VPS outline erode its $20 a month the entire service runs on that my

1:20:19blog market or get service number of patients these days that runs on the

1:20:24cheapest VPS outline erode again because it's like the stuff that we can get

1:20:30today is so advanced and everything is so fast hardware so cheap to rent and

1:20:36then with the so cheap

1:20:38I've never bought damn with separately from any of these things like with all

1:20:41the bandwidth is pooled from other servers and I've never exceeded that

1:20:44pool adjust to whatever whatever each server comes with its all pull together

1:20:48and I've never need to buy more than that and that's a pretty big with

1:20:52intensive app like you can do so much now with so little money and so

1:20:58relatively few servers and and and yet using one of these crazy host of things

1:21:03you don't even have to deal with the individual servers directly its you can

1:21:07just do so much and the fact is most iPhone app developers are gonna need to

1:21:13do some crazy ridiculous complex thing during life their app should finish

1:21:18quoting but I assume going by memory here is an article from the very bottom

1:21:22part about

1:21:23how r maybe this wasn't someone else's commentary Apple thing about how they

1:21:26want to control all the important part is that part yeah well anyways I can't

1:21:33find the exact part but he says you know here he said Tim Wood of the Omni group

1:21:38treated the tweeted the phrase own the wheel

1:21:42here's the thing is that this is Brent Burns words here here's the thing

1:21:47have to Miller evolution is about designing and building apps for

1:21:49smartphones and tablets

1:21:51the other half is about right on the web services the power those apps how

1:21:54comfortable are you with outsourcing half of the year after the company

1:21:57gerber's commentary that I was remembering is it was so don't take

1:22:02Bransford reconsider Tim Cook stock that's relieved that we need to own and

1:22:06control the primary technologies behind the products we make you know if you

1:22:10want to make a great product you want to have certain things under control

1:22:12obviously you're not you don't control everything you know the App Store you

1:22:16know control kokou during the source code for that in most cases unless it's

1:22:20like you know something is part of Darwin like so many things are out of

1:22:23your control and this is what's frustrating I think you know good

1:22:27developers with iCloud is there they've accepted the things that are outside

1:22:32their control the platform the store the other language the API the compiler and

1:22:36lots of things are outside their control but they always felt like I can wrangle

1:22:41the things that are within my control to make sure our customers have a good

1:22:44experience in this club thing is like there between a rock and a hard place

1:22:46because the customers think they wanted and are demanding that they want to sync

1:22:49features and they specifically a strike called by name because good PR and they

1:22:54can't make it work and that's that's an uncomfortable situation to be in my

1:22:58brain to never promise last board because they control that side of it was

1:23:02on it was on them to make it work and they could make it work because they

1:23:05controlled everything top-to-bottom they never were gonna hit a barrier where

1:23:08they like this isn't behaving in a deterministic way it's buggy and I can't

1:23:12fix the bugs like that was never going to be you know it's a blocker right they

1:23:16never had those bloggers who wasn't working right they were tweaked their

1:23:19service offering if you really want to you know control your destiny to the

1:23:22extent possible in a lot like Prince article said why would you give up

1:23:27control over half of your application and less and less like giving up control

1:23:32is one thing the other thing is like not having to worry about those details so

1:23:36Lauren gave up control of his application to Game Center if that had

1:23:40not worked out for him that would have been very bad and a lot of problems I

1:23:45know but like it like eventually it sorted itself out of scaling problems

1:23:49caused no news gave center for letterpress and bug in weird right but

1:23:53he didn't want to write that stuff himself is not one interested him I had

1:23:58to

1:23:59that's the tradeoff he he made there maybe he regretted maybe who went second

1:24:03time he would do the service I part himself right but that uncomfortable

1:24:07situation where you know you're giving up control in exchange for you hope not

1:24:12having to do that and if it comes out well you like hey look at all that work

1:24:16I said that was really smart and you know I got featured on the App Store is

1:24:19amusing game center in the seventh of the fringe benefits to using you know

1:24:22Apple's API's right if it doesn't work out you can't keep your application here

1:24:26adding it for the night time then you're sad and you like that happen again from

1:24:30now on I'm ready everything from scratch like Lauren Berger who doesn't use you

1:24:34like it

1:24:36Center at the so what's gonna happen in June or whenever WBC is with regard

1:24:43specifically to iCloud I mean is they gonna have a new API are they going to

1:24:47say oh man everything is finally fixed and if so is it gonna be real there's

1:24:51gonna be a bunch of baloney mean what do you guys think of everything is all that

1:24:55the new filesystem Casey aw I walked in the Smart TV not a circus will be so

1:25:02happy

1:25:03no but seriously I mean do you guys think that they're going to be a big

1:25:06push for iCloud repentant for it are they gonna say oh no really for our

1:25:11first for sure I promise this time its facts I don't know if they have enough

1:25:17time he'll apps for them to be able to you know they know they need to do

1:25:22something I don't have enough time has passed them to have actually done it I

1:25:25don't know if they can come to me and say here is the thing and we have a

1:25:30solution to fixing it is scrapping and replacing is something in between like I

1:25:35don't think there's enough time has passed for that to happen all I think

1:25:39they can do when they show up there is hopefully engaged developers

1:25:44acknowledged the issues and have something for them that improves their

1:25:47lives in some way

1:25:48while also acknowledging the like this I don't think they gonna come out it's not

1:25:51like to think about 14 get that existed as another thing it's awesome it works

1:25:57great

1:25:58you will forget 501 ever existed and people go oh wow that's awesome and then

1:26:03they just forget you know I don't think there's enough time has passed because

1:26:05maybe maybe a pessimistic but like in the very story think they said they like

1:26:12for people working on iCloud stuff or whatever Apple has anyone thinks they

1:26:17have right and I know how much work

1:26:20handful developers can get done in like a year's time I just I'm not optimistic

1:26:24but I'm coming down from the mountain with new stone tablet and saying we have

1:26:29some of your problems you know not because they don't want to hurt or

1:26:33negligent but just because not enough time I don't think that might my theory

1:26:41is that is entirely but I thought is that I i think there's problems in both

1:26:44the AP the ABIM limitations and problems with just the user conceptual model of

1:26:49iCloud and I love you know where your data is in your apps how it's tied to

1:26:54the Appellate it signed into the device I think they're they're such conceptual

1:26:58problems there that I'm not expecting iCloud as it is named today to ever be

1:27:04fixed I'm expecting it to happen more like MobileMe which is like some next

1:27:11generation they will come out in a few years to replace or upgrade iCloud and

1:27:17work differently for the users not just the developers I think it'll it'll have

1:27:21to be conceptually different for the user to keep the name now I don't think

1:27:26they do the name change

1:27:29be able because it already is an umbrella term in there are parts of

1:27:32iCloud work ok like you don't have to scrap key-value store just don't it's

1:27:37fine right under the umbrella of iCloud so when you say that iCloud is

1:27:40conceptualized there's no such thing as iCloud like iCloud CoreData stuff is

1:27:44conceptually bankrupt and needs to be replaced or modified in iCloud

1:27:48conception of

1:27:49hey when you signed out we dump all your data that was linked to it like that

1:27:52whole connection between your Apple ID DRI cloud thing and the data and

1:27:55applications like that can be revised it all day thing can happen over the course

1:27:59of several years without ever having to have a MobileMe to iCloud type

1:28:04transition I like I think they can keep the name because it is an umbrella term

1:28:07that really has no relation to you know like why is key value storage and

1:28:14documents in the cloud on the umbrella of I got no reason they don't share the

1:28:18same service that this setback and might be written by entirely different teams

1:28:22be entirely different code the friend an API is also entirely different teams

1:28:25they can be entirely different languages for all we knew they'd like to see that

1:28:28one could be like are found like they're so there it as unrelated at anything

1:28:32else except the network services market decide they're going to be under the

1:28:36umbrella I cause I think Apple has plenty of runway in the room to totally

1:28:41change everything about iCloud well still calling iCloud and just making it

1:28:45look like over making it better

1:28:47yeah I think but I think they like they're gonna have to do something

1:28:51that's that's changing the way you know the whole portion of iCloud that is AB

1:28:58storage the app storing their own data and having that sink somehow they do

1:29:04multiple uses and I S III just think that whole concept as we talk about

1:29:09being in another episode about about the the file storage thing not necessarily

1:29:15making a lot of sense or or being too simple and not really addressing the

1:29:18problem domain well enough I I think the entire iCloud data model for apps has

1:29:24that problem

1:29:25the entire I thought data model is too simple to limited doesn't really address

1:29:29the real life problems and usage well enough for a lot of apps and I think

1:29:32we're not going to see that get fixed with the part that we currently know

1:29:37today as I cloud over the section of it what we will probably instead see is

1:29:41people will start following instructions of you see fewer and fewer ads relying

1:29:46on iCloud especially from big developers who who who know better and have the

1:29:50resources to do not use it and under a tree and and I i feel like just like the

1:29:58both of you said key-value storage I think that'll carry on I think

1:30:02documents and iCloud will probably carry on I feel like core data sync iCloud

1:30:08will go the way of garbage collection and no matter how you look at it the

1:30:12forecast for iCloud it's cloudy we have to end the show now I did that just

1:30:18really you're not allowed to keep talking up to that I do that was

1:30:24terrible but I restrained myself see that scans your professional and we

1:30:31should have an awesome song by Jonathan man how awesome was at stake now the

1:30:41show they didn't even need to be in a dental

1:30:51John

1:30:52Casey

1:30:56because it was accidental

1:30:59and you can show no see a team markle

1:31:39did you see his follow up like a second version better he made a second version

1:31:45yes I said the song he made was nice but it didn't it didn't like the magically

1:31:52whatever it didn't seem right for the show and he said well what would sound

1:31:57right there shows and books or something he made some moves which is also awesome

1:32:07the accent down for the day

1:32:39that I did not see i no idea I'll have to pay as one of the men and will give

1:32:48will give him a good link in the show notes and thanks to Jonathan man that

1:32:52the song a day guide you to for doing this so I I love I lost my junk when I

1:33:00saw that in the sense that I don't believe that a good way in the good way

1:33:03in that I can't believe that somebody on the internet would care enough about the

1:33:09city it's particularly me to to include me / us in a song that I was beside

1:33:15myself excited that I'm good enough and gosh people like me

1:33:39cyclist don't want to have to do something it'll take at least a hundred

1:33:47episodes don't you nobody's gonna be sick of us has an artist I always wonder

1:33:53if like if you know mark on I we had our progress where are we getting to Union

1:33:57people are we getting the intersection for the people who can who could

1:34:02tolerate me and can tolerate Marco is the sum of our parts less than you know

1:34:10I think you guys are confused really on the big draw in you too or just writing

1:34:13my coat tails yeah that's what your job is is to make all the people who hate

1:34:20both me and Marco have someone like Apple / John sorry there are those

1:34:25people and you know I want to start months Casey starts getting haters of

1:34:29his own then pulled them out problem it's only a matter of time and you can't

1:34:32do a podcast for that long and not getting very likable very likable that's

1:34:37true not just like we are so have we met

1:34:43what did you see somebody wasn't earlier today tweeted about how ugly we all are

1:34:46ya when am I gonna argue