0:00:00Why did you become stupid game you should play this ball while rocking. Get an infant in your arm.
0:00:06Yeah you can do it one handed one arm baby holding rock balance walking tap tap tap tap tap tap tap tap tap.
0:00:17All right so in the post show from last episode we can have a potion of neutral and I was talking
0:00:23or I thought I was talking completely hypothetically about cars for Aaron
0:00:28and myself you know now the Declan's around
0:00:30and I don't know if I made it clear that that entire conversation was completely hypothetical
0:00:37and of course what with this being us everyone came out of the woodwork to give car recommendations
0:00:43or car ante recommendations you know never buy this car it's terrible.
0:00:47SUCHER which is which is certainly appreciated
0:00:49but I don't think I made it clear that that it was all just hypothetical I mean neither of us is going to get a car
0:00:55anytime soon and I still love my B.M.W. and I plan to keep my B.M.W.
0:00:59For at least a couple more years if not longer than that and as I think I said on the show Aaron loves her Mazda six
0:01:05and I think she'd probably rather give me up in the car just and you know who can blame or so I didn't mention that.
0:01:11Additionally a lot of people came out of the woodwork to say the goal of our wagon is a thing
0:01:16or if you're not from the United States the state believe that's right and saloon is a sedan is a right
0:01:23and you still think golf apparently to golf golf whatever I just want to add that it's not even an accent is it do you
0:01:31or G G O L F Yes So it's golf or yeah Is that why does everyone think that's brawn.
0:01:38You keep things like the Gulf of Mexico. Now why whatever. Anyway that the G.R.
0:01:46Point being I know that's the thing the reason I didn't bring it up is because I don't suspect that will get it in the
0:01:53United States
0:01:53and yes I believe it was in Los Angeles briefly for the purposes of the Los Angeles Motor Show auto show whatever.
0:02:00But the likelihood of that arriving in the States is slim to none.
0:02:03Additionally people have suggested various Subarus including the outback also known as the B.M.W. Three G.T.
0:02:10As well as the Subaru Forester and I owned a Subaru in the past
0:02:17and that car had its entire drive train replaced over the course of the sixty or eighty thousand miles that I had it
0:02:23and although I drive like a jerk I don't drive like an animal so I don't think it's my fault
0:02:27and the likelihood of me getting another Subaru is not good.
0:02:31So thank you for all the recommendations for the cars that I'm not buying
0:02:34and that will be enough of the car talk for now. You notice three G.T.
0:02:37Has not had any parts on it replaced actually going quite well in fact we use it for our Thanksgiving trip this past
0:02:42weekend and it was glorious I love all the luxuries of having you know like all the little hooks
0:02:48and stuff in the trunk and I'll leave a little latch points
0:02:50and little things that can move around plus the giant torn space to begin with It was quite quite pleasant.
0:02:54And yeah I think I think we're going to sell you an errand on one of these. Next time you'll see you'll see.
0:03:01You say you're denying it now but I bet once you once you actually see it and give the chance
0:03:08and once errancy didn't give it a chance I bet we can convert you guys.
0:03:11That's not likely you could probably you may be able to get me me but there's no chance of getting there
0:03:17and because she isn't. I think she thinks it looks too much like a wagon which she doesn't like.
0:03:22And beyond that I don't think she particularly want to be M.W. Much to my Should chagrin.
0:03:27That word I'm thinking of it's France shall grind much to my dismay let's go with that in no small part because all
0:03:34B.M.W. Drivers are jerks myself extremely included and she is one associate with them.
0:03:40There are enough of the Car Talk you want to talk about something that's cool I would love to.
0:03:44In fact this week we have a fourth sponsor and it's a holiday miracle.
0:03:49It's definitely not because of a clerical error last week it was definitely a holiday miracle that the reason we have
0:03:55four sponsors this week are sponsor our first ponder this week.
0:04:00Is studio neat once again with a whole bunch of cool stuff. So if you go to Studio neat dot com slash A.T.P.
0:04:09They've made a really cool A.T.P.
0:04:11Holiday cocktail guide for us
0:04:14and they've made you have to get a page I mean first of all the page looks incredible because they have incredibly good
0:04:18design skills or where they're going to studio neat dot com slash A.T.P.
0:04:23and They have actually made custom drinks they've made the case you list for John Syracuse So the Marco Arment you can
0:04:29tell they actually listen to our show and actually know us.
0:04:32So the case is of I could drink the John Syracuse is not the halakhic
0:04:36and is based on Sprite that made me laugh so hard what I what I what they show this to me when Tom and
0:04:42and studio in each of the Sammy the John Surtees it was far away my favorite. Well because I was a little concerned.
0:04:48I saw this you know when we weren't on the air when I saw this and
0:04:51when I first saw they made rings for the three of us I thought Oh well I don't know of I don't know of John's going to
0:04:56want to be associated with an alcoholic drink and oh no it's it's bright. John is that is that a correct assessment.
0:05:07I was happy that I'm in college but I'm not a big fan of mint actually like this one
0:05:15but if it were a boy body may more than be a drink that I like then I don't know maybe the combination of it might work
0:05:23I've never I haven't tried this so I can't say whether or not it works as a drink.
0:05:26Well similarly I don't know if I'd like a mask emule I mean if you look at the constituent ingredients say it seems
0:05:32like something I would enjoy but I don't know the red ones like I know I hate old fashions
0:05:37and much to the dismay not sugar in my curly and Marco but this sounds like it would be all right.
0:05:45I think it's funny and my mind is like of course a coffee based dessert drink which sounds pretty good.
0:05:52If I can say I think it's even better that John has a minor complaint about his. Yeah like.
0:06:00It wouldn't be the John Syracuse if the real John Syracuse A didn't have a minor complaint about it.
0:06:04Well I haven't I haven't talked about my Vegas like of mint things on the show before so they can be forgiven for not
0:06:10knowing this tiny detail about me. Would you like to talk about that now John I would not.
0:06:15Would you talk about that now John. We don't need to we can move on. Well we're still in the sponsor.
0:06:23I'm very sorry my bad.
0:06:25Know what we're going to come back to that some point maybe not today maybe not tomorrow but some day.
0:06:30Anyway this is all studio neat dot com slash A.T.P. You gotta look at this page it's hilarious.
0:06:36They also have made a cocktail tool guide cocktail tool Guide dot com and check that out as well.
0:06:44They collected a whole bunch of gear some stuff they make some stuff that that they don't make
0:06:48and you know they don't care if they make it
0:06:49or if they make it they want you to have the best year for making cocktails at home
0:06:53and some of the stuff is really cool and finally they have this new thing called the simple syrup kit
0:07:00and it is exactly what it sounds like it is a kit to help you make and store simple syrup and honestly
0:07:06when they first announced as I was a little skeptical because I've made simple syrup before it sugar and water
0:07:11and I thought what do you possibly need a kit for to make this like couldn't you make this in anything
0:07:16and I haven't for years I've been making my own simple surf usually for ice coffee recipes
0:07:21and the fact is making simple Sarah by yourself even though it is incredibly simple it does have like two
0:07:26or three potential spots for annoyance and I watched the video and I found simple circuits and I
0:07:31and I actually that fixes those annoyances. Like I got ahead of these guys.
0:07:36I thought there was no room for a dedicated product in that space but they made one and it looks pretty good.
0:07:43I mean these guys really have a knack for taking taking things that you didn't make maybe you didn't think you needed
0:07:50and then once you have that you're like wow this is of course I knew this this is a great how do I care I live without
0:07:54this studio and you go you gotta look at their cocktail tool guide. As well as the studio neat dot com slash A.T.P.
0:08:04Where they create these awesome cocktails for each of us and really they are. They're really funny I got a say in it.
0:08:11Page is a beautiful video they shot is beautiful the simple circuit. Check him out there. They make great stuff.
0:08:17As I mentioned last time they have the cars or not they have the glyph.
0:08:20They have the ice kit all this great stuff they make the studio neat dot com slash A.T.P.
0:08:25Yeah and as a final quick dent into that Tom and Dan are the two guys that run studio need
0:08:30and they're they're friends of ours
0:08:32and they're super super super awesome awesome people so if you're going to throw if you go through a little bit of
0:08:38money their way there.
0:08:40Well deserving and in the stuff they make is awesome and why don't we mention
0:08:44but I get ten percent off if he's a Cody T.P.
0:08:46and Forgive me if we already talked about that but yes forgive me for not talking about that that's very important.
0:08:51Use coupon code A.T.P. For ten percent off anything even the studio neat store.
0:08:56So thanks a lot to studio neat once again.
0:08:58All right when we talk about tonight there's not so much going on all right well that was good show.
0:09:05Thanks a lot for sponsor them. Marco makes his own news right. Yeah you could say that.
0:09:13Marco what's been what's what's been to be in your bonnet these days.
0:09:16Well I have a thing about about the push notification I had which was I don't know how much of a topic that really is
0:09:24it's really a topic post about a tweet about it all day so it was ever you making your own news that could have come
0:09:32and gone but you felt like you needed to chime in about it and say you wrote a big long blog post about it
0:09:37and then argue to the people on Twitter about it it was one hundred ninety five words most of which are not about that
0:09:42particular one. Really I thought it was longer.
0:09:45No there was an image in the middle of my to turn you off make use of your song and put a link in the show not so.
0:09:53So basically the other day Apple sent out to push notifications advertising the red.
0:10:00Apps or promotion from the App Store Apso if you if you had notifications enabled for the App Store
0:10:06and if I remember correctly I don't think I ever actually enabled those I don't think I was ever asked to.
0:10:12Maybe maybe you'd like the first time I launch the app store app on some of us version maybe that's me
0:10:16and I said yes but I don't usually say yes to things and mine were unable to so I don't know what that was about.
0:10:23If it was actually if it actually enabled by default and it never asks you up front that's kind of crappy
0:10:30but I can't say for sure whether it was that way or not.
0:10:32Yeah I was only wondering why I didn't see this
0:10:34and now that you mention this I realize that the whole time I was reading your tweets in your post I was like well I
0:10:39didn't get I guess I don't have an i Phone right.
0:10:42But I realize I do have an i Phone and then I have an i Phone Why didn't I get that
0:10:46and I realize the reason I didn't get it is because any time I set up an the I was device I go to the notification
0:10:51screen turn everything off
0:10:53and then selectively turn on like the two apps that I want to allow her to tell me notifications which are I don't know
0:10:59like messages and is there another one hundred messages. I can't think of anything offhand but certainly not apps.
0:11:09Well anyway so regardless of whether it was somebody's fault even worse but regardless what I was pointing out
0:11:16and it kind of got the idea kind of got muddy a little bit because the message they sent was promoting something for
0:11:23their project for the Product RED charity thing which is
0:11:27and I don't honestly I don't know the details of how the product RED Corp works I think it's not technically a
0:11:33non-profit in there some kind of stuff I don't have that it doesn't matter.
0:11:35And please don't email us of it really is a matter for the conversation.
0:11:40A lot of people took took issue with me complaining about a push notification that is for this.
0:11:45There's good cause and
0:11:48and the fact is I'm not taking issue with an avocation I'm taking issue with a red I'm not taking issue with the
0:11:54content of it. I'm taking issue with the fact that Apple sent a promotional.
0:12:00Put on a vacation and there is specifically a rule in the abstract Allen's rule number five point six
0:12:05and the rule says you can't.
0:12:07The apps cannot use push notifications to send I think the exact wording but it's something like marketing
0:12:12or promotions of any kind.
0:12:14This rule is if you've ever had any absinthe
0:12:16or on any i Phone Ever And you've ever said yes to push notifications to anything besides messages John if you if you.
0:12:22You almost certainly know that after violate this rule constantly apps always send push notifications for advertising
0:12:30purposes always like hey come back to our game new bombs are fifty percent off today only like crap like that
0:12:36and it is so incredibly common and it's really unfortunate
0:12:39and so my post was basically saying this is really unfortunate how common this is that it is against the rules
0:12:45and Apple doesn't really enforce that rule and to some degree they kind of can't enforce that rule
0:12:50and we have with us a little bit before and now it's even worse that Apple itself doesn't follow that rule.
0:12:58And so that's my main complaint here.
0:13:00After all this preamble that yeah it was a little thing yeah it was you know essentially for a good cause.
0:13:06Yeah it was only to push notification sent in one hour on one day.
0:13:11But this is really setting a bad example it's setting a bad precedent
0:13:15and it's showing once again it's this is not that different from the you two album being shoved into our libraries this
0:13:21is not as bad as that I don't think.
0:13:22But it's this is this is this is Apple showing that they don't respect
0:13:30or they don't see that this is a boundary that they shouldn't cross like
0:13:34and advertising push notification to me is really offensive.
0:13:39And I you know I would I totally understand why like you know the target app or the Kohl's app
0:13:46or some kind of crappy news site.
0:13:48Yeah I think they will do it of course they'll do with their crappy retailers
0:13:51and they're shameless because most retailers have to be shameless to survive.
0:13:56And certainly news sites generally do as well. So that.
0:14:00Find if somebody with really terrible low standards with no with no self respect
0:14:04and who doesn't respect their customers either wants to spam people that's not a surprise
0:14:09but those are not usually terms used to describe Apple or their products
0:14:12and especially things that are there to default in their products
0:14:15and so what worries me here is that not only that will setting a bad example that this practice is OK by doing it
0:14:22themselves but also that it just shows that Apple is like their stuff getting through.
0:14:28And you know Apple is not one person.
0:14:31Apple has lots of people maybe some of them you know don't follow the same standards
0:14:34or make mistakes sometimes that's fine but it's a worrying trend.
0:14:39First we had the U two album that somehow got out
0:14:41and that like nose able to stop then say you know what this is this is kind of a bad way to do this
0:14:47and now we have this mess again and again.
0:14:49It's a little thing but we're starting to see a trend here
0:14:52and that that worries me it worries me that Apple doesn't seem to respect this boundary
0:14:56and doesn't seem to think this is a problem. I think my issue with it is not so much.
0:15:01Everything you said about a person on occasions and boundaries in the U two album and everything.
0:15:06It's part of a pattern of behavior with Apple
0:15:11and the App Store where if this was the only thing that happened it probably wouldn't bother me that much
0:15:16but it has been a silly aside.
0:15:18But this is happening in the context of an apple with an app store
0:15:23and a long history of really weird arbitrary nonsensical enforcement or Hafen Forstmann of some rules
0:15:32when they feel like it
0:15:32but not the rules like if Apple didn't have that pattern of behavior where an apple we finally apps over three years
0:15:38and then get polled and Apple polled and put in after a bunch of stories appearing Web sites you know
0:15:43or felt rejected for reasons that don't seem to make sense or be fair you know like that whole history
0:15:51and the fact that all of us are kind of close to people who write applications
0:15:55and come in contact with those sort of weird arbitrary rules and all that stuff over the years.
0:16:01That makes this thing more egregious because it's like it's like they're rubbing it in our face.
0:16:06Yes we know the rules don't really apply to Apple as they run the store like we're aware of it
0:16:11but it's like are they for me anyway my my sort of bitterness
0:16:16and anger by proxy to learning to have an app in the App Store but I know a lot of people who do
0:16:20and I read the stories and like this person did everything right.
0:16:22They made a great app they tried to do something it seems I would never predicted they would have got a pose not a
0:16:27borderline thing seems like it's exactly what I wanted
0:16:30and the app gets pulled for some crazy reason Apple doesn't care and it's this person's livelihood
0:16:34and they spend all this time on it and they could not have predicted at a time that this would have been the result.
0:16:39And yet now they could be potentially out all the time
0:16:42and money they spent to develop in the application now may be wasted for reasons that don't make sense you know we all
0:16:50sit out here
0:16:50and try to divine what is Apple's motivation what kind of store they're trying to to make sure it's not going to tell
0:16:56us like that with all these rules but they don't say why.
0:16:59And their decisions you look at them
0:17:01and you try to figure baseness vision they trying to not have a store where junky apps are on their nose playing drunk
0:17:07after they trying to not have a store where apps have advertising know it
0:17:10or not have free apps they don't want to have to really make any sense.
0:17:15With the exception of some simple stuff like no porn apps like you know that kind of thing make sense
0:17:20and they've been consistent on almost everything else I can't figure out what it is that they're aiming for what why
0:17:25and force this rule not that one.
0:17:27Why come down here
0:17:28and not there what kind what is the shape of the App Store they're trying to make by these rules of just seems
0:17:33arbitrary and in the context of all of that then doing something like this just seems egregious
0:17:39and it's not it's not the incident it's that it's the surrounding you know sort of sadness
0:17:44and the reason is infinite so going you put the text of the the Rule five point six in your your thing in case people
0:17:49think there's some big legal ease thing or whatever. Here's the full text of this rule and the apps or guidelines.
0:17:56Apps cannot use push notifications to send advertising promotions or direct them. Marketing of any kind.
0:18:01That's it that's the whole thing. There's not like twenty paragraphs of stuff. That's it and it is not ambiguous.
0:18:06Advertising promotions or direct marketing of any kind.
0:18:08This is clearly if there is an advertisement or it's a promotion
0:18:11or it's direct marketing it's certainly one of those things like that pretty much covers all your bases.
0:18:16And so they do this one little thing like we were already kind of upset that you know they don't catch all these ads
0:18:21that are spamming us with the you know come back to our store to buy as an app purchase.
0:18:25And then
0:18:25when they do it themselves it's for me it's not so much about fashion of occasion which I never even saw it's about
0:18:32like someone an Apple had no problem doing this.
0:18:36It's like just rubbing it in your face
0:18:37and that's maybe that's like transference like it's not fair to come down on whatever this one little incident was.
0:18:43But really it is it's about it's about everything else that has to do with the App Store
0:18:47and it just being focused on this one.
0:18:48Maybe for Marco it's also about the push notification
0:18:51but for me this is just you know the flash point of a much larger sort of sadness about the App Store.
0:18:59Do you think that people who aren't in our little circle of techno people know
0:19:05or care anything about this specific notification.
0:19:08I get they don't read sites that covered it as news that remark was blog they don't follow me on Twitter.
0:19:13But the notification did come on their show on their phones. Did they even take note that it was they even notice.
0:19:19I mean I would imagine most people who have any reason the number of apps
0:19:24and stalled probably get regular spam notifications like so many apps send them especially like you know big retailer
0:19:33and publisher apps or games. Game free to play games are the worst. Yeah.
0:19:38Like all of those apps there it is so incredibly common that this is also imposes about abuse of this of the system
0:19:45and directly breaking this rule is so incredibly common that I would imagine most people who have a reasonable number
0:19:52of apps and stalled are accustomed to seeing push notification ads all the time.
0:19:56So they probably didn't think anything of this one. Maybe even the.
0:20:00All who run the app store promo team like maybe the people at Apple who sent this ad aren't even aware that it's
0:20:06against the review rules these are different teams. They probably have.
0:20:11I bet the people who sent that don't even know about this
0:20:15and maybe on their phones maybe they see enough push notification ads from other apps they just think it's a normal
0:20:20acceptable thing to do.
0:20:21Well that's what I think I think it is a normal acceptable thing to do for for other people I guess.
0:20:26So I'm going back to the theory that it's our closeness to people who make
0:20:30and sell apps on the App Store in the history of Apple dealing with the App Store rules
0:20:34and those people that makes us in any way sensitive to this whereas I think other people who don't know anyone who
0:20:39makes apps don't care what it takes to make apps don't care what the rules are for the App Store.
0:20:43This totally disappears into the noise noise that is mostly not of Apple's making maybe just of their negligence of not
0:20:49enforcing this rule on other applications which as you pointed out somewhere maybe in the blog.
0:20:54It's really hard to enforce this
0:20:56and Apple historically has not been good sort of crowdsourcing this kind of enforcement because basically
0:21:01when you're reviewing the app if your view of the app
0:21:04and you never get an ad push notification you can't determine whether the ad will never send a push notification.
0:21:11The added day after the day after the proved it goes into the store
0:21:14and then here come the first notifications to be applied like it's very really easy to do that so there needs to be
0:21:19some mechanism whereby people can report notifications I think is as you also said like you can't how do you you don't
0:21:25put that in the U.I.
0:21:26To say report this notification is spam or something of that kind of mucks it up
0:21:29and it's like it's got the maps thing all over again where people are trying to send corrections were an Apple had
0:21:34things in the wrong spot
0:21:35and Apple was not good at integrating those corrections at least initially into improving the map data this is not
0:21:41Apple's forte.
0:21:42So if they are going to have a sort of very clear unambiguous rule against push notification ads they also need some
0:21:48mechanism for enforcement independent of of them sending it themselves which I
0:21:53and I were told by our market is that the people who sent it either didn't know this was a rule or didn't care.
0:22:00Both I think are equally likely
0:22:01but again I think the only reason that he is talked about in our circles is because of our former contact with the app
0:22:08store and just poisoned us on this entire issue.
0:22:10Everyone else doesn't care at all because their entire life is dismissing stupid notifications about come back to the
0:22:15game now because you're seven sprouts blossomed and you need to pluck them and you can get the fifty gems
0:22:21or twenty percent off whenever we shouldn't just accept that.
0:22:25Oh well this role is violent all the time so we might as well not even try to enforce it like that's not good enough to
0:22:30me that's that I've heard a few people say that like oh well this is too common who cares it's one of occasion
0:22:36and the fact is it isn't just one of occasion and the entire experience of your phone of using your phone changes
0:22:43and in a pretty important and non subtle way.
0:22:47If you routinely get ad notifications like that's the head is not a small thing.
0:22:53Just wait until they start showing up on your watch. Right like that that is not a small thing.
0:22:58Notifications should matter you know
0:23:00or you should at least be allowed to treat them as if they matter what he did they were not another story
0:23:05but like it is an interruption to you it is literally pushed you don't ask for it is literally pushed to your device at
0:23:14any time.
0:23:15It alerts you it is meant to interrupt you to show you something that you care about seeing an ad is never going to be
0:23:22one of those things and it's it like the idea that you say that oh well Apple can't really enforce us very easily
0:23:29and lots of people break the rule so we don't we don't need to even try to enforce the rule.
0:23:34No that's that is not good enough and that is not like Apple shouldn't think that's good enough.
0:23:40And what worries me is whenever there's any sign that maybe they do think it's good enough
0:23:45and I think that's that's why this that's why this irritated me so much.
0:23:50Thing is even though Apple's bad at this sort of crowd sourcing type of thing that can't be done an app
0:23:55or view really do so with this argument it has to be sort of done in the field
0:23:58and they have to collect that information.
0:24:00Right and most people don't realize that Freeview only spends a few minutes with each app.
0:24:05Yeah so the other alternative is to collect all the information and that Apple is not good at
0:24:12but the other part of it they're in such a powerful position to if they can get any kind of collection they're in such
0:24:18a powerful position to enforce it because all they have to do is kind of have a sort of you know I don't know three
0:24:24strikes you're out of some sort of the merit based system where you know the first time
0:24:27or so you maybe didn't know about this rule maybe you didn't see this in the gut by the way after Bellbird we noticed
0:24:32that a lot of people reported your absenting push notifications maybe confirm what they have developed
0:24:37or is this the case or these people I don't know you determine authenticity is it so easy to fake this like
0:24:41or whatever
0:24:42but in consultation with the thing they had you know not an automated kind of You Tube is taking down your movie
0:24:48because someone is playing copyrighted music in the background right.
0:24:50But in a human to human way which I think they can afford to do with the Felber relations Hey we got a lot of
0:24:55complaints about your app sending an ad somehow somehow collect those things
0:24:59and said of the present you know you're not supposed to says this guideline OK My bet that's one struck in the second
0:25:04time they do it is a like you know hey we told you about this before and seems like you're still doing it.
0:25:08You really need to stop doing that because if we get more reports of you doing a game
0:25:11or to pull you out from the store and then you know whether it's three strikes because it's a baseball analogy
0:25:15or something entirely different like they are totally in a position to talk to the people about something if it's a
0:25:21willful violation it's not like oh accidentally use something that calls a private A.B.L.
0:25:25Like those things happen or people aren't doing that intentionally.
0:25:27There's no accidental push notifications for as happening maybe once you don't know about it maybe twice.
0:25:33Oh you didn't quite get it worked out but like three or four or five times
0:25:37or maybe it resets after a year whatever they are in such a powerful position to tell anybody in the App Store you need
0:25:42to stop it and they don't need to be perfect they don't need to catch every single one
0:25:45but it has to be there has to be repercussions right now people are terrified to make it
0:25:50and we'll talk about it maybe the next thought of how to make notification center which is the stuff
0:25:54and I was because they're afraid they're going to get pulled but nobody's of raises and pushed out of the gate
0:25:58and because there's no repercussions.
0:26:00Apple has all the power they can at their leisure whenever they want to go into whatever schedule they want to put the
0:26:05fear of apple into every single developer and say you know we may just pull your app if you keep doing that.
0:26:10But they don't there's no consequences they don't like this data.
0:26:13There's no three strikes policy it's just you know it's completely foreign to the graphics.
0:26:18Well that's the thing and you hit the nail on the head enough there in forcing the wrong stuff there.
0:26:23They're tearing apart all of these today widgets which maybe we should take a pause
0:26:27and talk about that rather than rather than going after all these ridiculous push notifications
0:26:33and you know a lot of people have called for
0:26:35and I think they're right you know like I think one of you just said this
0:26:38but having some way of reporting I mean I think it was Paul Her dad had said you know if you do what is it a right to
0:26:45left why did I get the correct
0:26:47and here it doesn't matter if you do the swipe the one direction to take action on the particular push notification you
0:26:54just got Will lets you swipe in the other direction to like Report for spam or something along those lines
0:27:00and I don't think it's a bad idea
0:27:01and I don't think most regular users have any idea that you can get pretty granular with your push notification
0:27:09settings more so than almost anything else I can think of in the last.
0:27:13And and so I think a lot of people just live with all the spam
0:27:16and that begs the question you know if there's this much spam coming on to their phones at what point did people start
0:27:21feeling like that degrades the experience well I love my i Phone except that it's constantly buzzing with weird
0:27:26messages that I really don't care about and I wish I could make them go away.
0:27:30You know no mockery on tell us about some of the score.
0:27:33We're also sponsored this week by Harry is go to Harry's dot com R. Y.S. Dot com and use the promo code A.T.P.
0:27:40Holiday special on this week A.T.P. Holiday all one word to save five dollars off your first purchase.
0:27:46Do you know someone in your gift list it's impossible to shop for that guy in your life who has everything.
0:27:51Holiday shopping for these people in your life can be stressful time consuming and frustrating.
0:27:55The last thing you want to do is go to the mall try to find something you consider gifting razor.
0:28:00How about a Harry's razor razor not typical gift.
0:28:03You never go to a drugstore and pick up a razor as a gift because drugs for reasons are flimsy tacky
0:28:07and really nothing special.
0:28:09Harry's came out with a limited edition line just for the holiday starting at just fifteen dollars including free
0:28:14shipping. They have this one is really nice.
0:28:17It's called the Winter Winston set and the winter Winston says only thirty dollars for a sleek chrome razor.
0:28:22Three high quality blades and they were made in foaming shave gel or shaving cream.
0:28:27It's already gift wrap and shipping is always free and is a special holiday offer.
0:28:32Harry is giving our listeners five dollars off with perma code A.T.P. Holiday. That's right.
0:28:37Even those of you who are already loyal Harries users will get five dollars off a winter Winston set with promo code
0:28:43A.T.P. Holiday. If the Rays are three quality blade and cream for just twenty five dollars shipped. That's amazing.
0:28:52Harries dot com started by two guys passionate about creating a better sharing experience for all men.
0:28:57We talked with them before I like Harry's razor stuff I think I said before I would say it is comparable to a fusion
0:29:03cartridge in shave quality but I but it cost half as much and the handles
0:29:10and the cream are awesome the handles are way better than fusions nice like heavy weight the metal handles
0:29:16and they just look really classy it's like you know nice classy old style.
0:29:20Harry has also the gift that gives back Harry supports the community by donating one percent of sales and volunteer
0:29:25and one percent of all employee time with a community partner.
0:29:28City Year the Heart Is there a time for thanks and giving and giving Harry something you can feel good about.
0:29:33Go to Harry's dot com now and get five dollars off a winter Winston set with the code A.T.P. Holiday.
0:29:39That's right a special limited time offer for the holiday.
0:29:42Here is getting all new and existing Harry's customers five dollars off the winter Winston set.
0:29:47That's Harry's H A R R A Y S dot com and enter coupon code A.T.P.
0:29:52Holiday at checkout for five dollars off the winter Winston. Harry is good enough to gift you know.
0:30:00I like best about the Harrys handle the shaving handle thing. It's not shaped like some part of a transformer.
0:30:07Yeah like I'm holding a tiny skinny robot in my hand I don't know when that started maybe I think it started
0:30:12when I was a teenager the razor handles had to look like Transformers to make any sense. Like make it comfortable.
0:30:18I'm not supposed to say hey to the British people understand what I'm saying even
0:30:21when I spell it out the way they complain about.
0:30:25However you probably should have a R R Y as dot com hirees I tell you what talk about today which it's because as if
0:30:34this episode wasn't grumpy enough what's getting grumpier.
0:30:37So one of the friends of the show Greg Pearce writes in Iowa called drafts
0:30:41and he had a pretty cool today which is from what I gather where you can there are several buttons that will let you do
0:30:48several different things including start a new draft in the app.
0:30:53And apparently he was told by Apple was it today
0:30:56or yesterday recently that if he wants to continue to have his app in the App Store he needs to take away those buttons
0:31:04from his today which it which was effectively the entire today widget so here it is he's getting told you cannot have
0:31:11anything really interactive and today which you act that's not fair.
0:31:14Anything that involves like creation is I forget how he phrased it on between front of me because something along the
0:31:19lines of it's for viewing data only.
0:31:23Right well so and I think we need to be very clear on this because a lot of the tweets
0:31:26and stuff on around have not been and Greg clarified this too but it's
0:31:31and it's important that if we're talking with us we're talking about the right thing.
0:31:35So it appears and unfortunately it seems to be constantly shifting
0:31:39but it appears that the reason why Apple is not letting him have those buttons in the ad is not because they are
0:31:45buttons necessarily it is because they launch the app from the widget to complete a task or to do a task in the app
0:31:54and that is what Apple is saying you can't do whether you agree with that or not we will we can talk about it.
0:32:00What it is.
0:32:01Apple is not saying you can't have buttons they're saying you can't launch the app from the extension to complete a
0:32:08task was that something that was known beforehand or they just decide that now or seemingly make it up.
0:32:13They seemingly made it up.
0:32:14Yeah I heard and yes
0:32:16and you know Monte underscore underscore in the chat room is saying that Evernote does that exactly Marco I know that
0:32:23and there are other apps that do that.
0:32:24This is as John was saying earlier part of the problem with app review that a lot of times the rules are not enforced
0:32:29consistently and a lot of times like Evernote might have been approved
0:32:33and they made like a little note to their boss saying hey we might want to consider the the the policy
0:32:39and what they can do this or not and then you know eventually they make that decision and then get hit by a
0:32:45and then maybe Evernote will get hit by you know in the future next and they try to update
0:32:48or maybe Apple will send them a pleasant phone call.
0:32:51Who knows but the point is these rules are evolving and it's really a bad scene for for all parties involved.
0:32:59I think Apple is obviously you know Apple is never going to say these are the rules they are set in stone
0:33:05and they're complete They even say in the rules document I think it says in the intro that it's like a living document
0:33:10and it will be changed over time and and they're going to change their mind
0:33:13and rules are going to they're going to figure out new rules that the fact they change over time like we've been
0:33:18expecting a change or time to be change in response to changing markets to be refined and made more specific
0:33:24and clarify things that are unclear.
0:33:26That's why it's so important to do the thing that Apple seems not to do that well which is explain the motivations
0:33:32because if you say here's a set of rules and what we're trying to do with these rules is
0:33:36and then explain their motivations because the motivations let you say well the rule doesn't say anything about the
0:33:41specifically
0:33:42but it doesn't violate the spirit of the law we have the letter of the law we don't necessarily have the Spirit.
0:33:48Is there a good chance that this is like borderline might get rejected
0:33:52or you know usually you can tell if you're trying to skirt a rule like you know you do in there
0:33:55but sometimes you just like the example just going to show it is..
0:34:00James Thompson's Peacock very made a pig out of a calendar application on the Mac.
0:34:08And he made a little calculator in in the today which is you know just about a number pad
0:34:14but the plus minus you know it's a calculator.
0:34:16Right
0:34:16and that the whole time he was making that he's like boy this is a perfect example of a today widget because it just so
0:34:23happens that in an extremely simplified version of the functionality of my application fits within a today widget
0:34:28because you know the count to the big calculator app is very complicated and it's got a customizable keyboard
0:34:32and you know a tape and scientific notation and programmable functions like.
0:34:36But I can give you a simple add a bunch of numbers together thing here and he got rejected
0:34:40and I haven't talked about this so I don't know whether this is the case
0:34:45but from from seeing his tweets about it it seems like he spent the entire times
0:34:49and studied over the seasons I was it was announced until now working on this widget.
0:34:55Never in a million years thinking this widget is going to get rejected because you're not allowed to have calculators
0:35:01today which it just didn't even occur to him because looking at the rules there's nothing from what he could divine
0:35:06from the spirit of the rules that said this type of thing would cause it to be rejected.
0:35:11Now I'm pretty sure this is fairly quickly reversed and I think it's back in the store now or never.
0:35:15That's correct
0:35:16but it was it was reversed after we all loudly publicized it through all you know because he's he's a well known
0:35:21developer a long time Apple developer there was lots of stories that why it got reversed.
0:35:26Maybe maybe not maybe it was just a mistake or whatever
0:35:29but that type of experience where you where you think you're doing exactly what Apple wants like you can you're coming
0:35:34home from everything you're like boy I'm totally on board with this thing I'm going to make a great I'm going to take
0:35:40advantage of these new baby eyes you made like that's what he's trying to get to do here is here's this new software.
0:35:44Here it is new you guys know go out there make something great with it and you do it
0:35:47and just like nope rejected me like What do you mean rejecting you know you have no recourse you know the appeals
0:35:53process but like it's so difficult to talk to someone
0:35:56and you just don't understand you say I didn't think I was skirting a rule I didn't think I was. Close to any line.
0:36:01Nothing in these things would indicate to me that I would ever get rejected any just get rejected
0:36:05and would have been reversed if he wasn't such a well known person
0:36:08and the opportunity maybe maybe not to you never getting an explanation of why it happened or least public one
0:36:14and there's nothing in there you know what are you trying to do with it what are you trying to direct you haven't
0:36:20you're launching other applications putting advertisements in there no you putting a tiny little game
0:36:24and I don't know it's just it's exposing some functional your application.
0:36:28It's like it's exactly what you think you're supposed to do so that type of stuff.
0:36:32You know again frustration by proxy I don't have an afternoon after that doesn't affect me
0:36:36but it just makes me it makes me upset.
0:36:39This happens it's like mismanagement It's like especially
0:36:43when is it immediately reversed it's just bad blood for no good reason
0:36:46and I think you know what you just said about like he was like putting a little game in there anything like I think
0:36:51that should be allowed to like I think what we're seeing here is Apple is is obviously still trying to figure out what
0:36:59the rules around this are and I think the rules should have already been decided for the most part
0:37:04and should be pretty clear to them
0:37:06and I think they are exerting a lot more like nanny state level control over this than is warranted because you know
0:37:13from there and secondarily maybe the reason they don't want apps to launch themselves
0:37:19or other apps from notifications or from their view maybe there's a security angle on that.
0:37:25I don't know if there is a security angle on that. Apple should fix that security angle and allow it. That's stupid.
0:37:33So you know maybe maybe this is security thing and that's the reason we have been told that.
0:37:37But regardless you know that's something worth fixing and then
0:37:40and then allowing I think what we're seeing here is Apple saying here's this great new system we've made very powerful
0:37:48but we're going to be extremely cautious so that we don't allow users to make a bad experience for themselves that that
0:37:55is Apple's typical M.O. However the way they've done it here is first of all.
0:38:00Like in the process of adding a today widget to your to your today view is pretty deliberate like it doesn't like you
0:38:07don't just install an app and all of a sudden it's automatically
0:38:10and you should a view like that that doesn't happen you have to manually go at it
0:38:15and it's a process that I would imagine most users don't know how to do.
0:38:19Don't care do
0:38:19and are certain are going to be able doing accidentally too many times not even knowing how they did it
0:38:24and it's considerably harder than say accepting push notifications for an app right.
0:38:29Yeah I like the app can just present a button that does this.
0:38:31Like you have to actually go into your today view and go to only to the area whatever it is
0:38:37and at it like you have to deliberately put these things there because of that.
0:38:43So you have chosen to download this app you have chosen to add its widget to today view I don't think Apple needs to be
0:38:51as protective of what's there because the user has chosen to put this here please I am Want This is so important to me.
0:38:59I want this in my today because today view it doesn't scale well to having tons of crap there like you're going to be
0:39:05picking a small number of things to put there in all likelihood.
0:39:08So Apple's concern if I had to guess it's about keeping that simple and lightweight
0:39:14but they don't have to do that because the process of adding those things already so deliberate and difficult
0:39:19and it doesn't handle having a lot in there just design wise already that I think anything that an app is allowed to do
0:39:27in itself it should be allowed to do there too I don't think Apple is is doing itself or its customers
0:39:35and its developers any favors by trying to say well you can you can put things here and it's a U.I.
0:39:42View you can enter into an ever you want and you can have buttons and stuff
0:39:47but we only want to be for these quick glance kind of tasks like that's a really hard line to draw we're seeing the
0:39:53problems with them trying to draw that line and I think it's it's just it's a bad idea to even try it.
0:40:00On that line I think if somebody downloads a game let's say it's a game that puts palm in your notification center it's
0:40:06a punk game and you can install the pond today widget and you can play upon in your today view.
0:40:12That's you know that's not a great idea for a game but something to do it
0:40:16and make a billion dollars I will take my royalty later
0:40:19but if you want to do that as a user why does Apple have to say no you can't do that that's not what this is for that's
0:40:27you have to go to the app for that like you chose to get the app you chose to put it in notification center.
0:40:31You chose to bring it into play pong with it like this is not something that I see ripe for abuse from developers if
0:40:39you let them just do whatever they want within their little view there.
0:40:42Do you suspect that after he was part of Federico his organization if I had to guess I would say Schiller's because a
0:40:49threat part of developer relations I think which is part of Schiller's Right I agree.
0:40:53Well could it be something as simple as you know as far as Engineering's concerned it's it's the Wild West in a good
0:41:01way not a bad way but Schiller's group is like that's no good.
0:41:07But Short Well all right so very Q Is the app store guy right there in the App Store
0:41:12and so peek out the great thing with peek out as status now plan a chat room that pickup was accepted Peacocke was
0:41:20promoted a bit like the big banner in the App Store at the big art we're going to rethink except in the App Store
0:41:24promoted and then rejected it was rejected while it was in the promotion.
0:41:28Right so people who are responsible are saying hey here's an application to demonstrate like this is a great I.O.'s out
0:41:34the shows a developer using our new A.P.I.
0:41:36Bubble blah whatever like they choose what to promote That's chillers organization maybe but E.Q.
0:41:42Runs a store it's road I don't understand how it's working
0:41:44but it's it seems entirely plausible that one hand know what the other hand was doing on the one hand some people are
0:41:50picking out applications they think are ready to go to the App Store
0:41:53and on the other hand someone else is rejecting peek out because I think you should have a calculator thing that saves
0:41:57and then eventually those people got together and maybe two.
0:42:00And then the app was under rejected but it just it it's not it does not inspire confidence in the organization
0:42:06when stuff like that happens because like guys talk to each other figure out you know what's going on here
0:42:11and especially because again we're trying to divine the motivations are like could we have forseen this is there
0:42:18anything in what Apple has ever said from any public public
0:42:22or private communication about today which it's that would indicate to you before hand that this thing was even close
0:42:28to any boundaries of something they didn't want to have because it's not you know as much as your spirited defense of
0:42:34the pong game right.
0:42:35Because of the way today center with its work I think anybody doing that could have a reason I expect ation that you
0:42:40are outside the bounds of what does a center which it is supposed to be because it's so far out of the bounds of
0:42:44anything that Apple has shown.
0:42:46But Apple has shown things that are exactly like a calculator and I got a small degree interactive graph
0:42:53or some information that you can swipe to do something
0:42:56or a couple buttons you can press you know it's adding numbers for crying out loud I mean I know there are technical
0:43:01limitations on today's center webpage just in terms of like today center whatever the hell these things limitations on
0:43:09like when your abs going to be instantiated how quickly you're going to be torn down
0:43:13and like you know you're not you can't cram in you can take a long time to initialize you that you don't have a long
0:43:18time to tear yourself down you're getting pulled out like there are limitations and putting in
0:43:22but if you if you're working within that context you know something like a procedurally drawing punk game
0:43:28or a calculator that have numbers it's perfectly fine.
0:43:31So it's not just in the make any sense and so when Apple does that I go to the bad blood I was talking about
0:43:37when stuff like that happens you know like it's not a big deal but it gave one developer a lot of stress for a day
0:43:43or two and doesn't make any sense
0:43:45and it makes it look like Apple is an organization that doesn't have its stuff together you know.
0:43:50Yeah and it also it does have a chilling effect on other development.
0:43:54Like there's a lot like I mean I don't have any plans for today which I don't think makes a lot of sense for ever.
0:44:00But if I had planned for it I would certainly be reconsidering them now because I don't know like as a developer like
0:44:07should I invest a few months into doing something that will very possibly get my app rejected in the future
0:44:13and have to pull it out like that's it's such a big risk.
0:44:16There are so many
0:44:17and you know especially for apps like draft like Peacock where it's a bigger undertaking it's it's a bigger selling
0:44:24feature.
0:44:25I don't know that I would be developing for an innovation center which is right now it's not it's just not worth the
0:44:29risk and I was shocked about something that's cool that maybe will make us a little happier than this fiasco.
0:44:36Have you ever built a Web site Casey you know once or twice.
0:44:40Building Web site used to take a long time you to set it all up yourself manually spend all day troubleshooting ran
0:44:46random errors and stuff if you ever had to edit the site to be pretty easy to break your links
0:44:50or even break the whole site break the layout put in like a space in the wrong place and break your P.H.P.
0:44:55File some of you just changed the font color be a huge headache.
0:44:59Now we have square space and you can build beautiful websites with
0:45:01or without a sweat if you Squarespace check it out today.
0:45:05If you can hear a square space for a long time
0:45:07but now there's more with the brand new square space seven square zero seven has a whole bunch of really new features
0:45:13including a redesigned user interface and integration with Google Apps for your domain.
0:45:18You can have like your scripts based a main register there you can have your apps there you can e-mail spreadsheets
0:45:22documents all that set up through square space with demand it's hosted by them
0:45:26and they also have a new partnership with Getty Images so you can get forty million high quality photos for your site
0:45:31when you probably don't need all forty million
0:45:33or something in there that you need you need an image for your site if you've ever tried to buy like a you know stock
0:45:38photo or officially commercially license photo from somewhere else.
0:45:41It's usually very complicated to get the right license it's very expensive.
0:45:45I didn't for the magazine and I know how expensive that can be and how complicated that can be.
0:45:49They worked out a great partnership with Getty so that you can pick eighty forty million forty million high quality
0:45:54photos for a post for a header image for a background image whatever you need for just.
0:46:00Ten dollars an image it's really a fantastic deal
0:46:02and they take care of all of for you browse right in the square space interface is really great.
0:46:08Anyway they also have fifteen new design templates what's crisp a seven Eva Green feature called cover pages.
0:46:14This is basically you can if you like an intro page for your full site
0:46:17or it can be your site you can have it like a nice single one page site you can put it up temporarily or permanently.
0:46:24You can do it it's like a splash page to have promote promoting a sale you're having are promoting a special
0:46:29or promoting a new post you did or a new video you made.
0:46:32We're going to have a nice trendy intro page to your full site they make it beautiful to make it easy
0:46:37and I've seen this myself.
0:46:39It is really quite impressive and those kinds of used to be really hard
0:46:42and now it's really easy with square space all this very simple very powerful beautiful designs you can customize it
0:46:49was much as you want you can be a nerd like us and actually inject H.T.M.L. C.S.S.
0:46:54and Javascript right into the template.
0:46:56Or you can use their drag and drop wizard and it's all very easy is great I love using square space
0:47:02and there's so much there that like I you know our site for the show is built on Squarespace I built a square space
0:47:09safer for my kids' preschool I mean it's so just so easy to use.
0:47:13There are so many use cases for that you don't have even if you know how to build websites.
0:47:17You don't have to build every Web site you make
0:47:19and this is I would recommend using space for so many things that previously you try to do yourself
0:47:25or you try to install some hosted C.N.N.'s somewhere
0:47:27and anyway you can start a free trial today with no credit card required.
0:47:31Start building your own site when you decide to sign up. Plants are just eight dollars a month.
0:47:35If you prepay for a whole year front you can get a free domain name for that.
0:47:39Anyway go to squarespace dot com and use offer code A.T.P.
0:47:43To get ten percent off your first purchase and to show your support for our show.
0:47:47We thank Chris bass once again for sponsoring our show Squarespace start here go anywhere do you want to go totally mad
0:47:53and talk about pod casting because people love that. So our friend Alan Pike steam clock software I wrote a great.
0:48:00Post that will lead to in the show notes.
0:48:02They basically considered and started researching the possibility of making a pod cast double and or recording app
0:48:10and in the post they go through the rationale for why they wanted it there at the Wireless think it was a market
0:48:16and as they did more research into the market
0:48:18and rents numbers they realize they actually shouldn't make it because there just aren't enough Pod casters to really
0:48:26support it like financially. The market is just not big enough for it.
0:48:30So our friend Rob Reiner Martian craft wrote kind of a follow up maybe a counterpoint argument to it.
0:48:36That was really good.
0:48:37Basically saying you're targeting professionals you know somebody who uses an app to make their ticket to do their work
0:48:45basically to make their job possible or easier or better.
0:48:48Amateurs and professionals it's easier charge more money
0:48:52and so maybe so he was saying maybe there is a way to charge more money to the to the small number of pockets which you
0:48:57might use such a thing and fund it that way.
0:49:01What do you think of these when you read them I thought they were both really really good posts.
0:49:06What I loved about Allan's was that here was someone who actually put a little bit of thought into what he was doing
0:49:13which if you know Alan is of no surprise whatsoever.
0:49:15But he actually crunch numbers like you were saying Marco
0:49:19and really thought about OK is this a viable business which is a much better way of going about things than just
0:49:25throwing something against the wall and seeing if it sticks.
0:49:28And I thought it was a really great post
0:49:31and then Rob Reiner's was equally great because he was saying well if you spend it one or two other ways that you may
0:49:40or may or may not have considered Alan there may be something there.
0:49:44And certainly both of them have built successful businesses by making intelligent business decisions
0:49:52and I think Martian craft is quite a bit bigger than steam clock so you could make an argument that Rob is coming from
0:49:58Definitely a place. It of knowledge and experience. Not that Alan isn't.
0:50:03But you know I think both of them make excellent points and whether
0:50:06or not you care about how the three of us make our podcast it's still an interesting thought process with regard to
0:50:15entering a new market.
0:50:17When I read the original post about hey we're thinking about making this particular thing up which is something I think
0:50:22we've talked about on the show before about the weird hodgepodge of things we used to do the podcast
0:50:27and how one app that put it all together would be nice if we always had the same thing as around in this thing well an
0:50:33app to put all the other be nicer but the total market for people who need this app is small
0:50:38and you know probably those those people even if you sold every single one of them is probably still not a viable
0:50:43business which is what these two posts are about.
0:50:45But that the real the real thing that I think about
0:50:47when reading the original post about this app is just how incredibly hard it would be to do this apple Well because it
0:50:54encompasses so many other applications that are in themselves complicated hard to do applications and
0:51:00and connecting things together is I think even harder than making a good audio editor a good audio recorder you know a
0:51:07good you know Skype type application where you want to call those voice communicate like trying to either integrate
0:51:15multiple apps or build those things in have them all work together is just incredibly hard to do a good job
0:51:22and I think that just the development job on this would be I'm not going to say it's harder than voters office
0:51:28or a shop is a very full featured application but it's part of the forest up one point now I can tell you that right.
0:51:33To do all that all the things that all the things that we do with the separate applications as well as we're able to do
0:51:40them with separate applications in the first verse because that's what you would need to be like especially for techno
0:51:46type people think well we get the job done now but it would be nice if we didn't have these hassles.
0:51:51But how much you know how much money I willing to give up for that and that's what that other fellow post is about
0:51:57but also how much quality am I willing to give up. For integration.
0:52:01Well if I got this application and the pricing isn't a problem but I get better results
0:52:06when I use the seven different applications that I'm already using.
0:52:09So is the downgrading controller quality or whatever for the one point overs as products.
0:52:14You know it's it's a tough sell even for the people who you know. Money's no object we don't care about the pricing.
0:52:20You can make it really expensive.
0:52:21What are you giving me that is an improvement over what I have and especially just out the gate.
0:52:27I just can't don't see how it's going to be as good as whatever system everyone's using.
0:52:31If you going to sell to new people hey you don't know how to use the seven applications
0:52:35and I guess it's really annoying if you don't want to have to deal that stuff or learn all that sort of witchcraft.
0:52:41Get this one application then I think you'd have a better shot at selling them because they don't know what it's like
0:52:46to use logic and Marco's weird audio aligner and Skype
0:52:49and all the things that we use to sort of make this all work together. They don't know how to do all that.
0:52:55So you're giving them a shortcut to getting up and running.
0:52:59But that market of people who want to do podcasting
0:53:02but don't want to learn all the other applications like how many new podcasts are coming on the scene at this point
0:53:07and how many of those people have Macs and you know the whole idea of like where you build the sentiment to link
0:53:13and download an application a little hook em into the zapper never like man I would not want to try to make the first
0:53:20version of that application at any price even if there was a huge market.
0:53:23So this application terrifies me from a development perspective because I think it would be really really hard to do
0:53:31and I still think no matter how you price that the market is really small now.
0:53:36One good thing it has going for it is there for not for integrated applications
0:53:41but for sort of expert level applications there is a market for a really really difficult to use tool that is really
0:53:51capable
0:53:52but is also like full of bugs in the vendor is annoying like there's a long history of applications where you can think
0:53:57of some whatever application you use not like logic. Good logic you know.
0:54:01Even Photoshop to some degree is like those things exist so that must be a maybe that's less possible today than it was
0:54:09but I still think those those type of applications exist but I don't know if people want to be in that software.
0:54:15Even something like not Final Cut final draft is actually kind of a weird example of that where you know most of those
0:54:22journalists like us really there's one application that everybody has to use They've got entrenched
0:54:27and the vendor is not the best vendor and people kind of have this love hate relationship with it
0:54:31but it's like it's the thing that everybody uses.
0:54:34Someone else suggested Pro Tools like that that is a thing that happened.
0:54:38That's what kind of like a dysfunctional customer
0:54:41and software vendor relationship I feel like so I wouldn't I wouldn't want to go into that.
0:54:45Even though it appears to be a viable business work experience is another example to kind of eventually went sour right.
0:54:50So I think that that is what I see as a way to make a business out of this
0:54:55but I wouldn't want to go in I wouldn't want to be in that business
0:54:59and the other side of it I was talking about like hey make it easy to use integrated my first pod casting out that will
0:55:04not give you as good a result as using the dedicated expensive applications in this mishmash with Mark a special custom
0:55:09code like it won't give you those kind of results it will be buggy and weird
0:55:13and really hard to pull off that I think is less viable because I just think there are fewer people trying to do
0:55:20podcasting That way if anything I think the only way you get entry of app like that is to target I us
0:55:25and not the MAC and somehow get an audio interface and there were like the U.S.B.
0:55:29Connector or some something like that. But then my head hurts just thinking about this.
0:55:34Yeah I mean that's like the there's a number of big problems with trying to make an app or about casting
0:55:40and you know you nailed most of them it's like like the first of all having to work with everybody's set ups is not
0:55:47trivial because this is a world where there's a huge variety a huge range of diversity of of hardware
0:55:57and hardware types hardware setups.
0:56:01You know logical setups of like you know what are you do you have four people together in a studio recording onto a
0:56:06multitrack mixer Do you have four people on Skype who are all trying to talk at the same time do you have
0:56:12or are you recording church sermons and putting that out as a feeder you're recording off of a phone.
0:56:18You have one person or a phone in Australia where three people are in the U.K.
0:56:22Trying to talk without latency like there's so many variations there.
0:56:27There's also the huge variations in budget a lot of these are a lot of pod casts are produced in radio studios
0:56:33and a lot of them are produced on people's laptops and there's everything in between.
0:56:38And all of that you have applied to what really is a very small number of producers you know overcast entire directory
0:56:46every feed I know exists. I think I have a little over two hundred thousand of them.
0:56:52What I've heard I've heard rumors about the size of i Tunes a directory being somewhere around the five hundred
0:56:57thousand number
0:56:59and if I look at the number of so over Catherine I had about one hundred eighty thousand users of those only about I
0:57:07think something like forty thousand pod casts actually have any subscribers.
0:57:11So obviously not everybody uses overcast
0:57:15but I think that's a that they can give you some idea of like roughly how many pod cast how many distinct pod casts are
0:57:22even listened to by more than a couple of people and so I would put the number around you know fifty thousand maybe.
0:57:31So you think about how many producers is that not you know not not every one of those fifty thousand that has listeners
0:57:37is produced by a unique producer.
0:57:39There's a lot of people who produce many shows radio stations Park has networks so you know how many how many people
0:57:47actually edit pod cast that are listened to by more than a couple of people that numbers are getting smaller
0:57:53and smaller
0:57:53and yes as you go to the step the search area well how many people might how many people could even use an app I make.
0:58:00And I would say generously the number of unique pod cast producers is probably less than ten thousand possibly a lot
0:58:10less than ten thousand how many of them would be even willing to use my app because a lot of these people have their
0:58:16own workflow.
0:58:17Like when this is like
0:58:18when you can sleep the pro content production of like you know the pro software markets you got to fight with people
0:58:24who used to work flows so you have to say Well look I I probably wouldn't use an Apple because I you know I that I had
0:58:31at the show and I use logic and logic is not perfect but it works
0:58:37and it's only two hundred bucks I think are three hundred two hundred so it's only two hundred bucks.
0:58:43It works and I know there's a fairly decent chance
0:58:48and I the only person using it since I know the number using it for public housing the small
0:58:53but like the number of people using this is going to be big enough that if there's a major bug it'll probably get
0:58:58caught and fixed before it hits me and
0:59:01and I know that like you know I can buy this knowing that it's going to probably work on the next version of macro S.
0:59:07Tense I will I won't be like stuck after an upgrade. It's probably maybe going to be maintained in the future.
0:59:13Like all these like you know fears that you know no one ever got fired for buying I.B.M.
0:59:17With that kind of thing like you don't want to be conservative in your choice of Pro Tools.
0:59:23And so a small app would have to fight against all of those factors for the chance to possibly win a small percentage
0:59:32of a small number of people's business.
0:59:34The worst thing for the other app competing in this area is that the other applications that people are using just have
0:59:42to add a few features to their existing mature applications like so audio editing outright.
0:59:47There's plenty of the stylish audio editing applications.
0:59:50All they have to do is add one or two
0:59:52or three features focused on podcasting say if they built in your audio alignment thing for multi-track stuff it's like
0:59:58Oh well like.
1:00:00Each one of each one of constituent apps that you use for each function like a Skype add some features focused on
1:00:05podcasting of logic if you just sort of pod casting it like you know square space already has features focus on
1:00:11podcasting like the integration of like all the different pieces that we put there in the gather.
1:00:15If they just kind of say oh yes Pike has a thing is a thing now
1:00:17and I make an audio editor so I should have a template for a podcast I shot
1:00:21and tools that are useful for people who do large multitrack podcasts and Ike And that's it
1:00:25and then it's like well now why am I using your app
1:00:27and it was so easy for them to do because there are already a great audio editor there are already a widely used
1:00:32application for talking to people over the Internet.
1:00:36It's just so hard to compete in all this said like someone did an amazing job on an application I guess even if you
1:00:41didn't do everything in-house even if it said you know edit audio an external advert
1:00:45and threw you into logical that I give it like if it didn't do the whole thing
1:00:48but just kind of integrated stuff together.
1:00:51Even that I think we would all be willing to try because we would like it to be easier so I don't think it's not like
1:00:59the idea of the application is bad it's just that the the environment for polling
1:01:02and the degree of difficulty is really high
1:01:05and I maybe maybe someone just did it for free out of the goodness of their heart
1:01:09and was an amazing developer it would be a benefit to the world but as a business it's it's tough right
1:01:15and worth their fine two point one There is an app for editing called Hinton Berg look H.
1:01:22Underscore underscore be mentioned they had actually tried this once.
1:01:26I kind of found the name distasteful because that's kind of a treasure that killed people
1:01:29but anyway so it's it's a it's a dedicated like radio journalism part has journalism kind of Abbott's made it's made
1:01:36for radio journalist to produce that that's not a podcast it is three hundred seventy five dollars to use commercially
1:01:45and it was a logical half the price.
1:01:49So they're fighting that battle already like they have to
1:01:51and I'm not so much to charge less because I don't think they could charge less
1:01:55and make enough money to survive because a number of purchase customers are so small here.
1:02:00So that's another thing to consider like there are alternative editing apps and they I don't know anybody
1:02:07and in Berg and I mean granted I don't know a lot of radio journalists but I'm sure they have users
1:02:11but that's that's a tough sell to a lot of people.
1:02:15Second
1:02:15and clarify is that you know Alan Pike's potential product was not an editing product it was just something to do the
1:02:21double ending recording
1:02:23and the number of people who do that style of pod cast production is even smaller than the number of producers.
1:02:28That's like that's a fairly rare way to produce a punk as where everybody records there and
1:02:33and then an editor combines them all and that's that's what we do here.
1:02:36That's what a few of the shows do that we know but most shows that have remote guests just record Skype
1:02:42and it's fine and you know it's not the best audio quality
1:02:45but then you avoid sync issues you avoid trying to get the person to select the right input for that for the program
1:02:51that's recording the thing or having them having them have to buy piazza or call recorder
1:02:57or something like that like it avoids a lot of issues to just record a Skype feeds that's what most people do.
1:03:02That was that was one of the big pitches of this is like the difficulty of getting guests like so if you're going to
1:03:07have a podcast where you have guests
1:03:09and you know you don't want to limit yourself to guess you know how to do pod casting you have to have some way to say
1:03:15hey can person who probably owns a computer but knows nothing about podcasts.
1:03:19Do these simple steps
1:03:20and you will be able to talk to us over the Internet in a way that you will be participating in a live podcast
1:03:25and appear recorder podcast
1:03:27and it's kind of like the same problem like concrete copal is trying to solve a radio you need to screen share with
1:03:33your relatives to help them with their computer problems.
1:03:35It's difficult over the phone to you know get them to initiate screen Jerrine So here he just send them an email has a
1:03:42link to click the link because three buttons and your you're connected to them right.
1:03:47That's a very difficult problem
1:03:49and I think that problem is easier than the problem of hey do these simple steps person who's not too familiar with
1:03:55computers and you are now talking live with me and possibly recording your own locally on your.
1:04:00It's going to surely fast enough to keep up with this and you want to like it just
1:04:03and your audio input will be through the right stuff
1:04:05and it's just doing that part of it just the guest application even that is really hard to do. Co-pilot.
1:04:12I don't know that's the thing I've tried to use it a few times the mac version did not go well for me.
1:04:18Kind of I kind of sort of got it to limp through what it was I paid for it like many times like they had abysmal
1:04:24or you pay someone you can use it for like an hour or something.
1:04:27In desperation I've tried it it's a good idea but it was not smooth sailing at all
1:04:32and so even that's not a solved problem many people have tried including Apple with the i Chat stuff
1:04:39and podcast until it has a certain degree of built in complexity like you're dealing with microphones
1:04:44and people's random computer's random environments and random internet connections.
1:04:50There's a reason why I like you know if you have a regular show with regular guests like the three of us it's worth it
1:04:57whether for the three of us to have like you know each recorded separately because we're always the same people all
1:05:03three of us were willing and able to buy a nice microphone and have a quiet room where you record
1:05:09and you use software that records it and we tragically able to do that and to do it reliably and
1:05:16and all of our net connections we know are solid enough
1:05:18and we even live geographically close enough that it's not usually a problem.
1:05:21So none of these things are problems for us. So that's why we choose to do the show that way.
1:05:25But again like like if you're if you're having a new guest every week that's a tough thing to coordinate
1:05:31and it's you know it's hard enough getting them a microphone to even use Skype properly
1:05:36and you know to add in the complexity of are you recording the right thing in going to send me your file that's you
1:05:42know that's it's not worth it in the market for that it's is extremely small
1:05:47and it's not in the way the big shows do this by the way the way the big shows do the how do you get a guest up
1:05:53and running in everything as they throw humans that like so someone will contact you the day
1:05:57or week before they will they will mail you a maggot. Phone in the mail.
1:06:00The person will contact you and make sure your setup is correct
1:06:03and walk you through laboriously over the phone over video over whatever they can do to make sure your setup is correct
1:06:09so that when the actual show goes you have a set up that is known
1:06:13and validated to be working by one member of their staff that is incredibly expensive as a way more expensive than
1:06:18buying a three hundred dollar application or a five hundred thousand or application
1:06:22or one hundred dollars a month application
1:06:23but that has a lot higher chance of success I think than the application will take care of it for you probably still
1:06:30going to need that human to walk the person through these supposedly so simple set up because of physical factors not
1:06:36even the software you know software is perfect
1:06:38and beyond all that like if you go to take Rob Reiner's approach of saying like well they charge more money like this
1:06:43is where the people beyond all the problems of it being a really small market of people who are producing these things
1:06:49and want to try your app is also some severe budget problems for most people like most people you know podcasting is a
1:06:56podcasting well are using high quality stuff is already a tough sell because you're already asking people to spend a
1:07:03few hundred dollars on it on a decent mike in some kind of setup there may be a pop filter maybe anti-shock thing like
1:07:09orbits are mounted all the stuff that I'll call record as of the thirty bucks
1:07:14and you know something like maybe logic that of two hundred dollars
1:07:18or maybe garage band the program keeps getting worse for pod cast
1:07:21and each new version like it's you're already asked me to spend a lot of money.
1:07:25Already most people are not willing to do that most pod cast are not produced that way.
1:07:29Most pod cast are produced from people's built in mikes and headsets
1:07:32and I fill in my stuff like that like it's there you know they don't sound very good
1:07:35but a lot of people like you can ask like you know maybe maybe some church recording it's sermons
1:07:41and everything they don't have maybe the money to buy logic you know like there's like there's all this so many
1:07:46processors out there who are not going to be spending hundreds or thousands of dollars on software
1:07:53and gear to do this and that's like that will always be the case that is always going to be most produce.
1:08:00There's we're going to be doing it as a hobby or on a low budget and you have to account for that and so that's like.
1:08:06I agree I agree with Rob Ryan that you that a professional app should be priced accordingly
1:08:14but I don't think there's enough pod cast producers to ever support something like this any time soon.
1:08:20In defense of Rob's post if you could snap your fingers
1:08:23and make the theoretical application like come into existence that is awesome
1:08:27and all the stuff it does everything is high quality the integrated is relatively bug free like that really provides
1:08:32the benefit.
1:08:34Then all his various pricing strategies could probably work out
1:08:38but the prerequisite is you actually have an application that helps people make money like that.
1:08:43That is more convenient for them that produces better results
1:08:46and less time that has fewer bugs that its features that would be difficult you know like they can replace a fractional
1:08:52portion of a staff or that you would need right then it may be viable and
1:08:57but even then it's borderline because you don't have the benefit I think it was another Joe article like the different
1:09:03kind of software you sell the cheap free stuff that random for
1:09:06and by the the street the sort of consumer applications that you can sell to an individual who's going to buy you know
1:09:13application for like you know the buy for shop for themselves or whatever and then
1:09:17and that's like a hundred bucks a couple hundred bucks
1:09:19or maybe like a small monthly subscription fee then there's a gigantic chasm and then your starting price thirty grand.
1:09:25Right and that's like and and I write software you're selling it to a business to business.
1:09:30This is such an essential part of their business that thirty grand
1:09:33or you know let's use the Oracle pricing model how the percentage of revenue has that feel to how much money do you
1:09:39have not profit revenue yet contact us for pricing that is just a huge a huge gap between like a couple hundred bucks
1:09:47maybe pushing a thousand and then up into the multiple thousands and there's not much in that middle ground there
1:09:52and I don't know park I think is not at the point now where it can be sold as enterprise software for the most part
1:09:58there are enterprise that are doing it made. Kind of like I don't know maybe like Twitter or T.V.
1:10:03Network is trying to a podcast like The Daily Show
1:10:05but even those I think of like to go shop I guess is not you know you can sell them thirty grand Pike I think they're
1:10:11just putting stuff together
1:10:12and I don't know if that market will ever exist for sort of enterprise level sales because even in the entertainment
1:10:19industry like you know my or whatever is a couple grand but it's not sixty grand.
1:10:23Whereas Oracle you know helps the businesses and their their checks have a lot of zero.
1:10:29So well in the end all the proposed casters who were doing it like from studios are as part of bigger companies they
1:10:34already have their workload established like you're going to get them with a with a new tool at this because they
1:10:39already have their already set up with how they do things was started on core intuition semi recently that Daniel
1:10:46jacket was talking about how I think this may be fast Cripps is that his as I write a script a little description using
1:10:53the keyboard circuits and so he had written it in had like Percy licensing model or something like that
1:11:02and then he got approached by some company and they said we want to buy it for the entire company
1:11:07and I forget exactly how we phrased it
1:11:10but I parent he came up with some number that he thought was so ridiculous they would basically laugh at him
1:11:14and that's what they paid
1:11:16and that's kind of what you guys are talking about is you know you find there's eventually at a time
1:11:21when a company will pay just absurd amount of money in order to get this app
1:11:27but I agree with you that finding podcasters to do this is going to be challenging.
1:11:32Yeah and maybe someday there will be enough Pod casters to make this a viable market.
1:11:36But today there are there is just simply are not that many
1:11:39and they were so far from that like it's not like there were that many.
1:11:44They're going to be that many next year
1:11:45but I'm even making this app like we're pretty far from there being enough to support things like this.
1:11:51So in conclusion somebody make this awesome apps we will buy it and tell you what's wrong with it
1:11:56and you out of business then I probably wouldn't buy it. I already have our workflow.
1:12:01We would totally get it to make you buy a parka.
1:12:05We would send one of us to go get it probably Marco Marco try to not use it because he doesn't like things that other
1:12:11people make. And additionally as a good son as a good summary.
1:12:16Moreover on top of that we are meeting you John but certainly Mark
1:12:21and I are of an age where we grew up trying to find ways to acquire things without paying a lot of money.
1:12:30And well I think I speak for all of us and saying we're willing to spend money here and there when it's appropriate
1:12:38when we think it's reasonable.
1:12:39If we have a workflow that works that is not something that we necessarily that's not a problem in a surly want to
1:12:46throw money at.
1:12:47And and that's what I think Marco is saying is that we have something that works
1:12:51and if it's a lot if it's just way easier then OK but if it's just a bit easier.
1:12:57Whenever I've been afraid to describe seven that's free.
1:13:03Our Final Fantasy exactly title of it is Lynda dot com Lynda dot com is an easy
1:13:08and affordable way to help you learn with high quality easy to follow video tutorials instantly three
1:13:13and thousands of courses created by experts on software web development graphic design
1:13:17and more going to Lynda dot com slash A.T.P. To see for yourself as L Y N D A dot com slash A.T.P.
1:13:24when The dot com is fresh new course at a daily they work directly with industry experts
1:13:27and software companies to provide timely training.
1:13:29Often the same day new versions or releases hit the market so you can always stay up to speed there for course
1:13:34and all experience levels whether you're beginner advance or anything in between.
1:13:38Ariel in the dot com courses produces the highest quality does not like the inconsistent homemade videos on You Tube
1:13:44courses are broken up into bite sized pieces so you can learn at your own pace and learn from start to finish
1:13:48or to find a quick answer.
1:13:50They have searchable transcripts as they place you can jump around you can see what's being said you can skip you can
1:13:54skip around by clicking parts in the transcripts. Their play lists they have course completions.
1:14:00If you can publish to your Linked In profile you can even learn
1:14:03when you're on the go with the dot com apps for i Phone i Pad
1:14:06and Android wondering about one of the icons I like a lot is that you can watch whenever you want with no pressure
1:14:12or commitment because you don't pay per video.
1:14:14You get one low monthly price
1:14:16and they give you access to over over one hundred thousand video tutorials at just twenty five bucks a month unlimited
1:14:22access to their entire catalog. This is great you know if you're like me you like to know little about a lot.
1:14:29When the common this is where this ties into what we're just saying when the dot com was a big help to me
1:14:33and learning how to use logic to edit this podcast and to make the audio sound there were things like compressors
1:14:38and the cues and limiters and stuff like that.
1:14:42I really like this phase and like you can just biologic spend twenty five bucks a month or one that I come and
1:14:50and learn to do all this yourself with those tools and you don't need to buy anything else anyway.
1:14:56When the dot com also offers an annual premium plan you can download courses to your i Phone i Pad or Android app
1:15:01and watch them offline. You can also get sample files of the premium plan and practice law instructor.
1:15:07Anyway if all sorts of course you might like to mention creative tools like logic they also have software development
1:15:13productivity apps programming languages web apps native all this crazy stuff you can you know learn Creative Suite you
1:15:21can learn final cut. You can even learn soft skills like management and negotiation. When did I come in so useful.
1:15:27Thirty percent of colleges universities
1:15:29and most of the Ivy League schools offer Lynda dot com subscriptions to their students and faculty members.
1:15:34Anyway check it out there's a lot of great stuff there I like them a lot going to Lynda dot com slash A T P L Y N D A
1:15:41dot com slash A.T.P.
1:15:42and You can get a free seven day trial with access to all courses really a fantastic deal go get your free trial
1:15:48started today and watch as much as you can the next week when the dot com slash A.T.P.
1:15:52Thanks a lot to learn that I convert sponsor our show once again.
1:15:56All right John tell us about the video games on the i Phone. One that you've been playing lately.
1:16:01Just one game which I think Marco's blathers I guess you haven't seen the game is cross the road.
1:16:07Everybody's playing it's very popular these days.
1:16:09I like the name until I realize that it's probably an attempt to cash in on the flappy bird
1:16:16and you made that connection with your I liked it so much better before I mean I still think it's a good name anyway
1:16:22the game is like kind of like Frogger if you remember that if you know you can do it like in there far as I want to
1:16:29talk about this game what I talk about is the monetization strategy of this game.
1:16:35Purges simultaneously confusing and depressing
1:16:38but maybe I still don't quite understand the way things are working these days.
1:16:42So it's a it's a popular game it's really well done.
1:16:46I think we could have easily sell different on United sense but they didn't decide to go free to play.
1:16:50Fine that's but you know that people are doing these days.
1:16:54But to cross the road is either really bad at free to play which makes it a good or
1:17:02or I don't understand how that stuff works so most free to play games have to find some way to get money from you
1:17:09somehow in the game by buying things that help you in the game or showing you ads or both
1:17:14and cross the road has both of those things
1:17:17and has characters that you can use in the game you can buy different character starts off of the chicken you can buy
1:17:23all sorts of other characters as in game currency that you get that you can find is that a coin
1:17:27and you get some currency
1:17:29and you can use that currency to redeem him kind of like a gumball machine that gives you characters for free
1:17:35and the time base mechanic where you get a free gift based on how long you plan to get all the things you kind of an
1:17:39energy mechanic how long do you have to play how much longer until I get a new for you to tell me coins I collect
1:17:44and you buy the players with actual real money you know ninety nine cents each or whatever
1:17:50and it seems like a reasonably good monetization strategy
1:17:52but the characters don't make the game any easier for you so they don't give you extra powers they don't give you extra.
1:18:00Lies they don't give you any time that in fact a lot of the characters make the game harder for you instead of easier.
1:18:05So the only motivation to buy them is kind of like buying hats and counterstrike
1:18:10or whatever like you know it's a frivolous thing
1:18:13and that has worked in the past so maybe I'm not quite understanding it
1:18:16but they're not pressuring pressuring you to buy things in the game you can play it and you don't have to buy things
1:18:25and they have a little put thing where you can see an ad
1:18:27and they just present you like a little icon shows like a little movie which I don't think.
1:18:32Yeah same for Chris too sorry Charles correct me where the hats were they were I was going to have a book
1:18:37and they're not really there are thirty nine or a little movie strip
1:18:42and then a low calling to him over ever saying hey if you watch this movie we will give you points of course as an ad
1:18:46if you tap on that it shows you nad for some other game you know they get some money of that Adam
1:18:50and you get this in game currency that you can eventually redeem in little gumball machine for random characters you
1:18:55can get These are the same characters that you could buy otherwise free to point it out of might have been Jason
1:19:00and his thing I was writing about Christ he wrote that the fundamental problem with their monetization strategy from
1:19:05the outside it from some is playing is I think it's more fun not to pay any money to play this game.
1:19:11It's more fun to play the game itself is fun getting coins in the game it's fun.
1:19:17Redeeming them a little gumball machine for a random guy is fun
1:19:21and you don't feel like you're missing anything to feel like boy if I could pay the ninety nine cents I guess I get the
1:19:25power that lets me like walk on water for two steps and I would really help you or like there's none of that
1:19:29and so it isn't entirely like for the most part friendly to the user not in your face it does prompt a couple times say
1:19:36hey do you want notifications when the century our energy meter runs out and you can see
1:19:40when you should come back to the game and play again.
1:19:42But you can say no like it presents an end game may be presented a few more times than it should
1:19:46and maybe little kids like watching my kids play it.
1:19:48They will watch the ads they have the coins because they want to get the other characters so I guess they're getting
1:19:53some ad revenue for that but I just look at this game and like boy I wish I could give you some money for this game
1:19:59but I don't want any.
1:20:00The characters like I've got all the ones I got I got it was more fun for me to get them for free
1:20:04and now I have them and they don't make the game any easier anyway so I'm concerned.
1:20:08But two things I would start across the road is the development of a millionaire right now is swimming in a bathtub
1:20:13full of money saying that's great good you tell me how I should run my business
1:20:15but it's puzzling to me because it seems to do everything wrong like from the perspective of the evil free to play
1:20:22games like learns to extract money from people.
1:20:25So I guess what I'm saying is you should all go out and across the road it's a great game
1:20:28and I really hope the developer is swimming in a bucket full of money
1:20:32but I just don't figure out how they would be unless everybody is looking to build them and it wouldn't surprise me
1:20:38and I'm trying to look around trying to look at the after DO YOU KNOW WHERE place is on the top grossing list.
1:20:43Oh I don't know I don't look at those things because it's number four on the top free list
1:20:49but it would not surprise me if it actually if you're right that it actually isn't making that much
1:20:53when I don't even when you were describing. I only played a handful of times you know.
1:20:57Thanks yeah i literally have all times I don't I don't I don't like the kind of game but like I forgot like
1:21:03when somebody says oh my God This game is great you have to play it.
1:21:06I'll go and buy in the App Store and I will forget what the up front price is whether it was free
1:21:10or not I just want to remember. Because it's like OK so cheap it's a dollar Who cares.
1:21:15Or three and so I didn't even realize this was a monetization scheme.
1:21:19I played the game a handful of times like you can probably expect many people to have done who have downloaded it I
1:21:26didn't even realize that's how it was monetized I like that's a problem.
1:21:31He might make it up in volume though because this is a super popular game
1:21:34and like I said Little kids do want to see the ads
1:21:36or maybe all the money is made by showing ads little kids to buy other games that
1:21:40and I think people will buy the other characters but I mean to give my other yards they go so far.
1:21:45My son who was sent an undisclosed amount of money I spend an undisclosed amount of money on Clash of Clans
1:21:50and the amount is large. Well that's that's very different though. But he is susceptible to not purchase.
1:21:55He has not asked me once to buy him one of these sets.
1:22:00It is not fur is not he's not shy about asking me to you know press this button in a way that I can read tweets on the
1:22:06day about someone who woke up and found their kid slowly trying to move their finger on to the Touch ID
1:22:11and phone call they were asleep to try to do any purchase so you know watches get like he's not shy about asking
1:22:17and he has not asked once that shows me that as whoever it is who wrote this again maybe Jason it's more fun to play
1:22:25the game to unlock this stuff for free than it is to buy that is more fun so why would you have the other thing is less
1:22:31fun you're paying money to have less fun. I mean like it would not surprise me if this really isn't doing that well.
1:22:38Like others that like so I just think the whole if I couldn't find the top one hundred fifty top grossing so I don't
1:22:43know where it is but it's probably not high.
1:22:45Somebody said this adds another incident where you said you can you can click on a little thing that says look at this
1:22:50Adam will give you you know twenty coins or whatever
1:22:53but it's not even showing the ad during a game play with the way the burden whether they'd put up a dialog box puts a
1:22:59dollar mark here are your options if you have more than one hundred coins you can redeem a hundred of them right now on
1:23:03the gumball machine if you might have a free gift on the time base mechanic which will give you one of those things you
1:23:08can buy because even playing for a long time or press a thing will show you how to give you twenty points but like
1:23:14but as a player like when we even need to do that like one of that you never need to do
1:23:18and what one of the things one of the things that I got from the gumball machine was five hundred points which is
1:23:23basically like five three characters like it's an understand.
1:23:27So I just opened up to to see like you know how this is and like so so far playing this game
1:23:34and I'm seeing no ad I'm seeing no solicitation for buying these coins are doing it go die
1:23:40and you'll see a little things as free gift and if you have over a hundred Corell Yeah you know I sort of did before
1:23:44and I had no idea what that was
1:23:46and that's why so like the little icon that shows the filmstrip I don't know if kids know what film looks like the
1:23:52value lawyer but the little notches so
1:23:54when you do an icon like the old telephone handset icon much I guess kids are kind of socialized to know means phone
1:23:59because the icon.
1:24:00Our phones
1:24:00but whatever it is cellular filmstrips with the little holes in the edges I don't know if people know that anyway.
1:24:06There's a little symbol looks like that and it shows clients Oh here's this Kumble thing L. Case I'm seeing this now.
1:24:12I saw this once before I had no idea I could even pay anything and here I thought it was literally a free gift
1:24:19and I just get this you know this weird cow or something you have and you can't pay there you can go.
1:24:23Like when you start the game
1:24:25when you start the game there's a little thing where you can change your character in the lower left
1:24:28and if you scroll through all the characters have ninety nine cents underneath this is the worst monetise popular game
1:24:33ever seen.
1:24:34Well that's one thing I don't know if it is like we're on the outside we don't know how much my Again this person could
1:24:38already be a millionaire We have no idea what's going on
1:24:40but it's on so I feel that has developed because whatever they're making they could be making a lot more.
1:24:45Yeah I would have paid five ninety nine for this game is an amazingly well done game I mean granted this is Frogger you
1:24:50know he didn't make a frog or whatever but execution wise and like fit for you know for input method
1:24:56and viewing contracts and retina screens
1:24:59and everything it's it's beautiful it's amazing I mean even if they were just and I had on the top
1:25:04or bottom like just like a bird and that would annoy me and it would make the game less fun.
1:25:07Well and you can pay a dollar to to hide it I would have to pay that instantly.
1:25:11Right like that that itself I guarantee you whatever monetization they're doing with this app with this weird pointing
1:25:18I guarantee you what I just said with an eye and a dollar to hide it would have done at least ten times better.
1:25:23But you wouldn't have done that because you would have felt bad about it happen like that.
1:25:26This not if you buy all these characters that are ninety nine cents a like twenty of them I think you could spend like
1:25:31twenty or thirty bucks on this game. But even but as you said look there's really no reason to.
1:25:35Well I mean again maybe it was just in my experience and in my kids experience it seems like there's not.
1:25:41But maybe other people again with buying the hats and Team Fortress two
1:25:44and all that stuff like maybe go on horse armor there's another gaming reference where you like maybe people do want to
1:25:51buy them and don't want to unlock them and just can't live unless they have a Dark Lord as their character.
1:25:56Characters are cool and they do change the game they really need you know I can't help.
1:26:00But feel like we spent the beginning of this episode talking about how the spammy push notifications are really
1:26:08cheapening your product and it's a terrible way to go
1:26:11and now we're ending the episode by saying oh you should put ads on this thing you would made a fortune.
1:26:15Thanks a lot of people. They can but I tell you what.
1:26:22Everyone go down this game for free play it for five or ten minutes and if you think it's worth something.
1:26:27Pay ninety nine cents for the favorite character dress and by the way I said they changed the
1:26:31and they changed the graphics and again they don't change the gameplay only to sometimes make it harder
1:26:35but for example if you buy the penguin spoiler makes everything else snowy it's adorable.
1:26:39Just what even like what you said what you said like like the whole idea like oh I got this game for free I'm enjoying
1:26:47it so much I want to give the money I forgot how much you pay for the game.
1:26:50Days after buying it and it was free maybe you thought you had given us the money but you didn't. Well exactly.
1:26:56So many people I bet like they don't like you know a lot of people only buy free stuff or download free stuff
1:27:01and that's fine.
1:27:02But there's a lot of people like me who are like you'll pay a dollar for a game without really thinking about it.
1:27:08And so like if you see a game that has no ads
1:27:11and no obvious spam to try to monetize I would assume I prepared for this
1:27:16and not even think about giving the Mormon in the future. All right. I think we're done.
1:27:21Anyway thanks a lot to our four sponsors this week studio neat Harry's Squarespace and Linda dot com
1:27:27and we will see you next week. Now to be as it was accidental accidental found because it was that was accidental.
1:28:03Yes he was accepted that scandalous and I should both give this game
1:28:33and I think I'm friends with all of you have this game and all point more.
1:28:37I just played it on the air I can't like this is we had a punk that's where pod casting fall I play in cross he wrote
1:28:41on the Air Force test over it really.
1:28:46My favorite feature of the game which I feel better most point of and you see it it's just really really well done.
1:28:52Is that your game center friends that when they play of course it records a score and you can see a leader board
1:28:57and all that stuff but
1:28:57when you're playing the game you'll see the name of the person written across the farthest distance that they've made
1:29:03it their highest score you know I was I was the Marco Arment on like you know thirty
1:29:07or whatever your pathetic score is the ground so you literally hop over their name when you're beating their score.
1:29:13It's brilliant cool
1:29:15and I was trying to I kept trying to contact Jason I think he left I sent him private messages I sent to my AMS What I
1:29:20was trying to do is send a friend request from my son's game centre account to his because Jason has the highest score
1:29:26of anyone on my friends list but my son I think has been him
1:29:30and I want to give my son motivation to beat somebody score so I said if they could just get him to be friends Jason
1:29:34then he would have you know I did because when Jason in the second place.
1:29:38All right so I have an I haven't got an app for years now figures lets you browse other apps rankings.
1:29:43So I'm showing you know the rankings pretty consistent.
1:29:47It is if you look at just free like on the free chart it is in the it's in the top five most of the times across the
1:29:56road is really in the top five and I look at it like what category looking at.
1:30:01It's and it's in the top one through Ford and games.
1:30:03Oh it's number twelve overall new number thirteen you know we look at.
1:30:06So we're talking like this is like this is the number twelve most downloaded free app in the App Store for for the last
1:30:12you know while. So that's a very very high rank probably tens of thousands of installs per day.
1:30:18Now if you look at the top grossing in i Phone top grossing is around the two hundredth place.
1:30:26So it's placing number fifteen of top downloads.
1:30:30Number two hundred top grossing and i Phone and i Pad It's like number three hundred.
1:30:35So it's even worse an i Pad That is I mean I'm sure I'm sure the developers are making decent money on that
1:30:42but the money they're making is not proportional to the downloads they're getting at all.
1:30:47Like it's like that's a very bad ratio for how popular this game is how popular it has been for the last couple of for
1:30:53the last week or two
1:30:54or where they have a lot of been out that is not generating a ton of money for for that level downloads
1:31:00and I think it shows like just getting a bunch of people if you have some kind of premium monetization scheme like this
1:31:08you have to also say like the pain point of what you're paying for.
1:31:13You have to set that with with some thought as well they just had to be smart business you know ranking in the four
1:31:19hundred in the abstract I'm guessing atop my head I'm guessing that's five thousand dollars a day
1:31:24or less for a game this popular that's not great.
1:31:27That's that's really like that help of getting really ripped off and it's basically.
1:31:33But by their own creation here by by not giving enough of a reason for people to pay and also not putting an ad in it
1:31:40or not putting a price on it like it
1:31:42and I guess I feel bad for whoever made this because it's it's clearly like the world is getting a lot more value out
1:31:49of this than what they're being ultimately paid for.
1:31:52So real time follow up I am playing this game and it's weird but I'm looking at my leaderboard and.
1:32:00It's going from bottom to top me with twenty eight. My friend Eric we lander with thirty four Marco is forty three.
1:32:09Adam Swindon with sixty three John Surtees a one fifty seven
1:32:12and then SALIE Dan provost of studio need three hundred eighty four.
1:32:18Wow yeah I haven't really broken through in this game yet.
1:32:22You know you're on that John I mean we don't stand a chance
1:32:24but you you might find a problem with that with the control scheme
1:32:28and like I have my own sort of energy meter in the game where I'm just serious cases now if I play if I play it more
1:32:33than two times my I have diminishing returns in the controller know the computers cheating Marco it was a computer
1:32:40error.
1:32:40Now the ultimate I mean like obviously the tap
1:32:42and if this is one of those games where the ultimate interface I feel I could be if I could hook up a D.
1:32:48Pad
1:32:48or a joystick to this early the game would be a minimum time of course to learn part of the game is like yeah you know
1:32:55part of the game is the control scheme is not quite that they used to have to go forward
1:33:00but swipe for the other three directions and frequently I will initiate an action
1:33:05and get the wrong action like basically it'll hop for when I really meant to be a swipe back to left
1:33:10or the right because the controls are not that precise but that's all part of the game you know anyway.
1:33:16Really what I do best is when I'm not paying attention.
1:33:19Like I just I just sort of look absent mindedly the screen around the algorithm
1:33:23and I find myself crossing into the hundreds and on there are some crossing two hundred good service and die
1:33:26but there are only two or three games and then I you know go back to the desert golfing or something.
1:33:33Yeah I've actually been playing a lot of desert golfing it's amazing desert golfing cross the road is a better game
1:33:40and as a governor of a great concern. I spent a lot more time as a governor.
1:33:44Time now I believe it
1:33:45but that's not I don't think it's I'm currently on a whole two hundred seventeen farther than that
1:33:50but my Of course my Doesn't golfing score is not good as a governor is brutal.
1:33:56I'm at the seven hundred forty three structure being a hole to seventy in my school.
1:34:00It's just terrible because like it's a whole game section.
1:34:04Does does or golfing it's punishing in that like it's brilliant
1:34:07and pure in that you watch the game you start playing that's it
1:34:10when you realize the game puts you back to where you were.
1:34:12That's it no saves no loading screen no menus no one do you can't even reset it can you know start you can and start
1:34:18and you can start again.
1:34:19Like that's it the game is the game the best thing would be like if they actually Stuart Stuart it's what your score
1:34:24and i Cloud so that you couldn't even research right now is no
1:34:28but then you need to have like it would be like singing
1:34:29and everything is just brutally like this is the game you are now playing the game of didn't like that stroke you would
1:34:35never get it back.
1:34:36There's no mulligan there's no undo there's no resetting anything going from left to right
1:34:43and terrible physics engine that is just filled to the brim with B.S. Because I cannot leave.
1:34:48However they programmed me. YOU PLAYED IT market like oh you're not going to roll down that hill.
1:34:54That doesn't make any sense.
1:34:55It just like stops in the middle of one hill but any other hill or down the entire thing slow it right
1:35:00and even just the physics of bounce thing like the angle of incidence does not equal the anvil angle of reflection in
1:35:07any universe forget about sense emulation this is not even if you had a rigid body physics is B.S.
1:35:13In this game and yet I play it because you just launch it and what you do when you get in the ball in the hole
1:35:18and you quit whenever you want and you come back to be right where you left off.
1:35:22And yeah I did sixteen strokes not Hulk it was pissing me off for the next one I got on my me just keep going.
1:35:27Yeah I love.
1:35:28In fact speaking about Pike on his on his video game I believe is called up up down down there right now anyway.
1:35:35He interviewed the creator of this sometime recently and I love the guy
1:35:41and said like you know like the first time you get a hole in one you expect like some kind of like congratulations
1:35:46and just nothing happens like you get it goes to the next hole. That's no different than any other score.
1:35:52A lesson about life this is really not the next game we need to get General Honore to play although I think about
1:35:56probably bounce off of it but if he ever comes out of his three stupor.
1:36:00There's a golf thing does or golfing can teach you something profound about life I think.
1:36:04Kind of in the same way the Demon's Souls can I absolutely love it.
1:36:08Mark real time follow up I now have forty sixty
1:36:10or forty three so I can put the game down to hop over the named engine was not fun I didn't like his name it looked
1:36:16like gobbledygook and I think you've never actually played Frogger
1:36:20or had heard of it before I mentioned it here I had heard of it you big jerk but no I never played it.
1:36:24However I did see I think I've even seen the segment on Seinfeld. I didn't even watch Seinfeld.
1:36:30That's where you know right from here. Anyway this is better than for a lot of them hard now.
1:36:37Now I can construct a plain stupid game I hate you too. Just installed us forgot it will calm you back down.
1:36:46Those are golfing. Does it go.
1:36:48Yes sorry does or golfing like according to the Gulf Do people are going to search for the name to find it.
1:36:52Then does their golfing as you pay money for it
1:36:55and at that you pay money you get the game this is the game was it a dollar
1:36:58or two you are now playing the game I remember it was I have gotten so much enjoyment of the game because I
1:37:02and I know how like how abusive it is and yet I keep playing like it is satisfying
1:37:08and I think I was saying it like like there are so many games it just it just like a constant like showering you with
1:37:15praise and with rewards.
1:37:18Anything you do anything you're amazing here's some fireworks you get a bonus coin for your cow it's like this is
1:37:24there's none of that like you just play the game and
1:37:28when you succeed in doing each hole you just move on to the next hole.
1:37:31That's it and again and the game is cruel and arbitrary an anchor incorrectly programmed
1:37:36but you love it just like life the only thing that makes you mad about this game is that I didn't make it to this is
1:37:42like I've always kind of wanted to make a game and you could've made this.
1:37:47Yeah and there's not a lot of games that I'm technically qualified to make and I totally could have done this
1:37:52but I just never thought of it.
1:37:54The trick in the tricky part is the procedural generation with a twist of the levels I think that is the.
1:38:00Because the genius of this game is it just goes on and on and on like how can I go on
1:38:04and on to the human layout all these levels know it's procedurally generated but not just is it.
1:38:08Yeah it is an article about Xander view it's a pretty large area
1:38:11but not random so there is human influence over it somehow that like particular holes have certain attention paid to
1:38:18them I don't know the details he didn't really have but it's for the most part procedurally generated
1:38:22but with a human touch to you know when you're stuck on a hole that is particularly difficult.
1:38:27I always see the you know the touch of the human you know scoring with you there. Right.
1:38:31Like there's been like a like a big ramp up to the hole on both sides.
1:38:35You instantly roll off of anything and we're in little ledges
1:38:37and so if you can see kind of see the human touch there
1:38:40but there's so many levels you know that you can get up to the cactus yet I don't know where that is because a cactus.
1:38:45Yeah I well I mean I actually enjoy this game it's crazy like I was I took so many friggin screenshot that I can't say
1:38:56I knew it was coming in there are other things out there in the distance too
1:38:59but I don't want to I don't want to ruin what it says it's not frog fractions which you've both never heard of
1:39:04but trust me that's an apt comparison.
1:39:06So it is not frog traction
1:39:08and there golfing is the opposite of progress action applying that the funny thing is in the lake nothing the little
1:39:15thing will full of game development I've done one of the things I've done is a procedural terrain generator for a
1:39:21scorched earth style game which is this stuff I actually already have an algorithm to do that
1:39:26and I don't have the things that like you know make sure that the hole is reachable in some reasonable way.
1:39:31Yes that's one thing like procedure generally dangerous because you can get on a little ball specially with this B.S.
1:39:37You get on one of the holes you have to be careful and
1:39:40and the other thing is like so you precision are generated you hope you have rules so you don't make them in a hole
1:39:44but you have to play through them all to make sure and that's the worst punishment of all.
1:39:49We so so like is my whole two or three the same as your whole two or three.
1:39:53Yes yes it's determined if they were the seed and ever in the levels that with him although he said he might change.
1:40:00A future and might change some of the later levels I won't tell you what later means but you'll be depressed.
1:40:06Like over a thousand.
1:40:08Just just trying to go
1:40:09and I was really trying to think of like if I never uninstalled is game out I'll run this until it doesn't run on my
1:40:16phone anymore.
1:40:17Just keep going like the numbers will keep going up the ball keep going in the hole I will keep getting angry at the
1:40:21physics for was a huge on the tweeted about how you has to go sixty four bit now because again I'm stuffed.
1:40:28Yeah well I retreated somebody that's notably the same thing and if you can I mean wow.
1:40:33They're using sign thirty two bit like animals now.